liberi v taitz appellees opposition-objections to doff's rjn doc 45-1
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
1/25
H`xk A{iekux: 00);632< `am 00);606=
'Hoaxodlm`}km Fkeu{`u| 8$ 5305,
[AL]KM X]@]KX HO[U] OF @SSK@DX
FOU ]GK ALA]G HLUH[L]________________________________
DLX@ DLEKUL$ k} `d$
Sd`la}lffx/@sskddkkx
vx!
OUD\ ]@L]Z$ MKFKAM O[U
FUKKMOIX FO[AM@]LOAX$ LAH!$ k} `d$
Mkfkam`a}x/@sskdd`a}x
::::::::::
:::::
Oa @ssk`d fuoi }gk [al}km X}`}kx Mlx}ulh} Ho{u}$Hka}u`d Mlx}ulh} of H`dlfoual`$ Xo{}gkua Mlvlxloa
H`xk Ao! 7:00)hv)33=7;Goaou`edk @amukr B{ldfoum
@SSKDDKKX OSSOXL]LOA/OEJKH]LOAX ]O MKFKAM O[U
FUKKMOIX FO[AM@]LOAX$ LAH! UKP[KX] FOU J[MLHL@D AO]LHK
@AM ]GK ]GUKK ^8Y KWGLEL]X @]@HGKM ]GKUK]O
Sgldls J! Ekub$ Kxp{luk 'S@ E`u Ao! 3
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
2/25
l
]@EDK OF HOA]KA]X
S`bkx
]@EDK OF HOA]KA]X!!!!!!!l
]@EDK OF @[]GOUL]LKX!!!!ll)vl
L! X]@]KIKA] OF F@H]X!!0)=
LLL! @UB[IKA]!=)0;
L! @UB[IKA]X am KVLMKAHK SUKXKA]KMfou }gk FLUX] ]LIK la ` UKSD\ EULKF `uk
R@LVKM `am I[X] ek X]ULHNKA!!!=);
LL! @SSKDD@]K HO[U]X OAD\ HOAXLMKU }gk
UKHOUM EKFOUK }gk MLX]ULH] HO[U]
oa @SSK@D !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!;)7
LLL! ]GK MOH[IKA]X MOFF lx UKP[KX]LABJ[MLHL@D AO]LHK of `uk ao} X[EJKH] }o
l! MOFFx Kwglel} 0$ MA =2)5 }o }gklu UJA
fldkm @suld 83$ 5305!!!
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
3/25
ll
]@EDK OF @[]GOUL]LKX
H`xkx S`bk'x,
E!N!E! v! I`{l Sodlhk Mks}!$526 F!8m 03
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
4/25
lll
]@EDK OF @[]GOUL]LKX ) Hoa}la{km
H`xkx S`bk'x,
La uk Dkg}laka$ ;6= F!8m 03;5$ 0360 a!= '
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
5/25
lv
]@EDK OF @[]GOUL]LKX ) Hoa}la{km
H`xkx S`bk'x,
S`mbk}} v! Rulbg}$ ;72 F!8m
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
6/25
v
]@EDK OF @[]GOUL]LKX ) Hoa}la{km
H`xkx S`bk'x,
[al}km X}`}kx v! Kdl`x$
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
7/25
vl
ALA]G HLUH[L] DOH@D U[DKX
S`bk'x,
U{dk =6)508$ 0=
U{dk =6)5'`,!08
FKMKU@D U[DKX OF KVLMKAHK
S`bk'x,
U{dk 530!!!7$
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
8/25
0
@SSKDDKKX OSSOXL]LOA 'OEJKH]LOAX, }o @SSKDD@A]X IO]LOA
fou J[MLHL@D AO]LHK 'UKP[KX] fou J[MLHL@D AO]LHK,
@sskddkkx Dlx` Dlekul$ Dlx` Ox}kdd`$ Bo Kwhkd Bdoe`d$ Sgldls J! Ekub$
Kxp{luk$ `am }gk D`r Offlhkx of Sgldls J! Ekub ossoxk `am oejkh} }o @sskdd`a}$
Mkfkam o{u Fukkmoix Fo{am`}loax$ Lah! ^MOFFY$ ou ^@sskdd`a}Y$ Io}loa fou
J{mlhl`d Ao}lhk 'Ukp{kx} fou J{mlhl`d Ao}lhk, ^UJAY `am of }gk }gukk ^8Y Kwglel}x
`}}`hgkm }gkuk}o! @sskddkkx `uk `dxo `xnlab }glx Ho{u} }o X`ah}loa @}}ouak| fou
MOFF$ Oud| ]`l}z$ Kxp{luk$ `am @r`um @sskddkkx @}}ouak| Fkkx am Hox}x!
X]@]KIKA] OF F@H]X
@sskdd`a}x @ssk`d lx fuoi }gk Mlx}ulh} Ho{u}x Mkal`d of }gklu @a}l)XD@SS
Io}loa!
@sskdd`a}x fldkm }gklu Oskalab Eulkf oa Mkhkieku 0 Oa Fkeu{`u| 8$
5305$ @sskdd`}k Hoiilxxloaku Sk}ku D! Xg`r hoaxodlm`}km @sskdd`}k H`xkxDlekul$
k} `d v! Mkfkam o{u Fukkmoix Fo{am`}loax$ Lah!$ H`xk Ao! 00);632< fldkm e| Oud|
]`l}z oa ekg`df of MOFF> `am Dlekul$ k} `d v! Oud| ]`l}z$ k} `d$ H`xk Ao! 00);606=
fldkm e| Jkffuk| H{aalabg`i$ Kxp{luk oa ekg`df of Oud| ]`l}z!
@sskddkkx 'Sd`la}lffx, fldkm }gklu Hoaxodlm`}km @axrkulab Eulkf oa I`uhg 0
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
9/25
5
rglhg rkuk ukjkh}km e| }gk Ho{u} `am Oumkukm ukfldkm rl}g houukh}loax! Oa }glx
x`ik m`}k$ Oud| ]`l}z$ Kxp{luk ^] l}zY oa ekg df of MOFF `dxo fldkm `
Hoaxodlm`}km Uksd| Eulkf `am }gukk ^8Y Kwglel}x la H`xk Ao! 00);606=$ MAx 8;)
0$ 8;)5$ 8;)8 `am 8;)=$ mkxsl}k }gk Ho{u}x Oumku Hoaxodlm`}lab }gk @ssk`dx!
MOFFx fldlab r`x `dxo ukjkh}km$ `am Oumkukm ukfldkm rl}g houukh}loax!
Oa @suld 83$ 5305$ MOFF ukfldkm l}x Uksd| Eulkf `am ` Io}loa fou J{mlhl`d
Ao}lhk of }gk }gukk ^8Y Kwglel}x }g`} g`vk ao ukdkv`ah| }o }glx @ssk`d> `uk
{a`{}gka}lh`}km> `uk gk`ux`|> `am `uk x{eil}}km fou }gk flux} }lik rl}g }gk Uksd|
Eulkf of MOFF!
Oud| ]`l}z g`x @e{xkm }gk Ho{u}x Suohkxx$ fldlab ` xkhoam`u| Hoaxodlm`}km
Uksd| Eulkf$ rl}g `ub{ika}x ao} u`lxkm la MOFFx Oskalab @sskdd`}k Eulkf$ ao}
sukxka}km }o }gk Mlx}ulh} Ho{u} ukb`umlab }gklu @a}l)XD@SS Io}loa$ `am `ub{ika}x
}g`} g`vk `exod{}kd| ao}glab }o mo rl}g ]`l}zx `am MOFFx @ssk`d! Oud| ]`l}z oa
ekg`df of MOFF `dxo vlod`}km }gk u{dkx rl}g }gk fldlab of }gk }gukk ^8Y Kwglel}x$ }g`}
xgk lx ukp{kx}lab }glx Ho{u} }o }`nk J{mlhl`d Ao}lhk of! Oud| ] l}z oe}`lakm Kwglel}
8 }o gku Ukp{kx} e| fu`{m{dka} `am mkhks}lvk ik`ax!
@sskddkkx lahousou`}k e| ukfkukahk `x lf f{dd| xk} fou}g gkuk `} dkab}g$ }gklu
Io}loa }o X}ulnk MOFFx Uksd| Eulkf `am }gukk ^8Y Kwglel}x0 `am }gk Mkhd`u`}loa
0 MOFF la }gklu oulbla`d Uksd| Eulkf `}} hgkm }gukk ^8Y Kwglel}x$ }gk x`ik }gukk ^8Y Kwglel}x }gk|`uk aor `}}kis}lab }o g`vk }glx Ho{u} }`nk J{mlhl`d Ao}lhk of!
H`xk: 00);606= 3;/3=/5305 LM: 706=
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
10/25
8
of Sgldls J! Ekub$ Kxp{luk la x{ssou} of @sskddkkx Io}loa }o X}ulnk fldkm @suld 5=$
5305$ LM 70;0368$ Mohnk} A{iekux ^MAY 87)0$ 87)5$ 87)8$ 87)=$ 87);$ 87)6$
`am 87)2!
]`l}z {xkm }gk Ho{u} `x ` s{edlxglab buo{am fou gku Sukxx Ukdk`xk }o
s{edlxg sulv`}k hoaflmka}l`d moh{ika}x xgk fu`{m{dka}d|$ {amku f`dxk suk}kaxkx$
oe}`lakm fuoi ` Ho{u}5!
]gk Moh{ika}x MOFF lx ukp{kx}lab J{mlhl`d Ao}lhk of mo ao} p{`dlf| }o ek
J{mlhl`dd| Ao}lhkm e| }glx Ho{u}! MOFF mokx ao} ikukd| `xn }glx Ho{u} }o
`hnaordkmbk }gkxk moh{ika}x$ e{} hl}kx }gk hoa}ka}x }gkukof fou }gk }u{}g of }gk
i`}}ku `xxku}km }gkukla `x suovlmlab kvlmka}l`u| x{ssou} }o MOFFx Uksd| Eulkf
`am }glx @ssk`d! Xkk MA 8; `} ss! 57)83!
5 ]`l}z$ ho{axkd fou MOFF$ g`x ` glx}ou| of oe}`lalab moh{ika}x e| fu`{m{dka} ik`ax `am fldlabi`a{f`h}{ukm$ `d}kukm `am foubkm moh{ika}x `x bka{lak$ la o{u Fkmku`d Ho{u}x! Xkk Ugomkx v!I`hMoa`dm$ 623 F! X{ss! 5m 0868 'I!M! B`! 533 Dlekul$ k} `d v! ]`l}z$ k} `d$ [!X!M!H!$Hka}u`d Mlx}ulh} of H`dlfoual`$ Xo{}gkua Mlvlxloa$ H`xk Ao! 7:00)hv)33=7; @JB '-5;3!33X`ah}loax fou f`ldlab }o `elmk e| }gk Ho{u}x J{ak 0=$ 5300 Oumku$ MA 552,> E`uak}}$ k} `d v!Oe`i`$ k} `d$ [!X!M!H!$ Hka}u`d Mlx}ulh} of H@$ Xo{}gkua Mlv!$ H`xk Ao! 3 x{esoka`x `am Ki`ldx fldkm `x bka{lak e| ]`l}z,> `am ]`l}z v!Ilhg`kd @x}u{k$ [!X!M!H!$ Mlx}ulh} of Hod{iel`$ H`xk Ao! 00)=35$ Mohnk} Ao! 8
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
11/25
=
Fou }gk uk`xoax o{}dlakm gkukla `am la @sskddkkx Io}loa }o X}ulnk `ssk`ulab
`x MAx 87)0 }guo{bg 87)2$ MOFFx UJA i{x} ek Mkalkm `am X}ulhnka> ]`l}z
X`ah}loakm> `am @sskddkkx `r umkm @}}ouak| Fkkx `am Hox}x!
@UB[IKA]
L! @UB[IKA]X `am KVLMKAHK SUKXKA]KM fou }gk FLUX]
]LIK la ` UKSD\ EULKF `uk R@LVKM `am I[X] ek
X]ULHNKA:
@sskddkkx rkuk ao} `ffoumkm }gk ossou}{al}| }o `mmukxx }gk akr kw}kamkm
`ub{ika}x$ la rglhg }gk| `uk {xlab }gklu lisuosku UJA }o x{ssou} `am dkam
hukmleldl}|$ }g`} rkuk ao} sukxka}km }o }gk dorku Ho{u}$ ao} u`lxkm la }gklu
@sskdd`a}x Oskalab Eulkf `am `uk u`lxkm fou }gk flux} }lik la MOFFx Uksd| Eulkf$
MA 8;!
L} lx }gk doab godmlab of }glx Ho{u} }g`} moh{ika}x sukxka}km fou }gk flux} }lik
rl}g ` Uksd| Eulkf rldd ao}ek hoaxlmkukm! Xkk Nokuaku v! Bulb`x$ 857 F!8m 038
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
12/25
;
lxx{kx u`lxkm fou }gk flux} }lik la ` uksd| eulkf!,: Bu`vkx v! @us`lo$ 658 F!8m 03=8$
03=7 'Kekudk v! Hl}| of @a`gkli$
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
13/25
6
oad| }gk ukhoum ekfouk }gk }ul`d j{mbk rgka glx mkhlxloa r`x i`mk 'kisg`xlx la
oulbla`d, Nluxgaku v! [almka Hous! Of @ikulh`$ 7=5 F!5m 032=$ 0322 '
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
14/25
2
kvlmkahk `am `uk dlil}km }o rg`} r`x x`lm `am la}uom{hkm `} }gk oulbla`d
suohkkmlab! Lxx{kx$ mkfkaxkx `am `ub{ika}x ao} u`lxkm `} }gk Mlx}ulh} Ho{u} h`aao}
ek u`lxkm la }gk @ssk`d! ]glx Ho{u} ukvlkrx }gk dorku Ho{u}"x `ssdlh`}loa of }gk
d`r }o }gk f`h}x `x sukxka}km!J`akx v! R`d)I`u} X}oukx$ Lah!$ 52< F!8m 778$ 772 '
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
15/25
7
MOFF fldkm l}x UJA of Kwglel}x 0$ 5 `am 8 la `}}kis}x }o x{ssou} }gklu
akr `ub{ika}x `ssk`ulab la }gklu Uksd| Eulkf o{}dlakm `eovk rkuk r`lvkm e|
MOFF ekh`{xk MOFF mlm ao} sukxka} }gki }o }gk Mlx}ulh} Ho{u} ukb`umlab }gklu
@a}l)XD@SS Io}loa `am }gkukfouk$ }gk| i{x} ek X}ulhnka! Xkk Sk}kuxoa v!
Glbgd`am I{xlh$ Lah!$ 0=3 F!8m! 0808$ 0850 'Fkm! U!
@ss! S! 03'`,> `amNluxgaku v! [almka Hous! of @i!$ 7=5 F!5m 032=$ 0322 '
H`xk: 00);606= 3;/3=/5305 LM: 706=
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
16/25
ou '5, h`s`edk of `hh{u`}k `am uk`m| mk}kuila`}loa e|
ukxou} }o xo{uhkx rgoxk `hh{u`h| h`aao} uk`xoa`ed| ek p{kx}loakm! FUK 530$
x{em! 'e,! ]gkxk o{} of Ho{u} x}`}kika}x hoa}`lakm la }glx Lavkx}lb`}lvk Uksou}
mo ao} ikk} }gk mkflal}loa of `mj{mlh`}lvk f`h}x$ `am `uk }gkukfouk ao} suoskud|
x{ejkh} }o J{mlhl`d Ao}lhk!
U{dk 730 of }gk Fkmku`d U{dkx of Kvlmkahk mkflakx gk`ux`| `x ` x}`}kika}$
o}gku }g`a oak i`mk e| }gk mkhd`u`a} rgldk }kx}lf|lab } }gk }ul`d ou gk`ulab$ offkukm
la kvlmkahk }o suovk }gk }u{}g of }gk i`}}ku `xxku}km! Gk`ux`| lx ao} `milxxledk$
`exka} `a `ssdlh`edk kwhks}loa! FUK 730! Ao soxxledk kwhks}loa }o }gk gk`ux`|
u{dk `ssdlkx la }gk lax}`a} h`xk!
F{u}gku$ Kwglel} 0 lx luukdkv`a}$ lii`}kul`d$ lisku}laka} `am g`x `exod{}kd|
ao ukdkv`ah| }o }gk skamlab `ssk`d$ aou lx l} ukdkv`a} }o }gk @a}l)XD@SS Io}loa ou
}gk {amkud|lab h`xk `am }gkukfouk h`aao} ek hoaxlmkukm! Xkk H{kdd`u v! Jo|hk$ ; X`a}` Ioalh` Foom Ao} Eoiex
v! Hl}| of X`a}` Ioalh`$ =;3 F!8m 0355$ 035; a!5 '
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
18/25
00
Su`h}lhk `am Suohkm{uk 0875$ `} 236)32 '0
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
19/25
05
]kug{ak$ 80; F!8m 0037$ 000= a! ; ' 80@ H!J!X! Kvlmkahk$
;7 'J{ak 533;,!
F{u}gku$ Kwglel}x 5 `am 8 uk luukdkv`a}$ lii`}kul`d$ lisku}laka} `am g`x
`exod{}kd| ao ukdkv`ah| }o }gk skamlab `ssk`d$ aou lx l} ukdkv`a} }o }gk @a}l)XD@SS
Io}loa ou }gk {amkud|lab h`xk `am }gkukfouk h`aao} ek hoaxlmkukm! Xkk H{kdd`u v!
Jo|hk$ ; X`a}` Ioalh`
Foom Ao} Eoiex v! Hl}| of X`a}` Ioalh`$ =;3 F!8m 0355$ 035; a!5 '
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
20/25
08
hd`li fou ukdlkf ou }gk mkfkaxkx eklab sdk`mkm!% ; Hg`udkx @! Rulbg} & @u}g{u U!
Ilddku$ Fkmku`d Su`h}lhk `am Suohkm{uk 0875$ `} 236)32 '0
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
21/25
0=
`am x}`}k mlxhlsdla`u| `bkahlkx rgka }gk Ho{u} mkkix x{hg ao}lhk }o ek j{x}lflkm!$
Xkk Hluh{l} @mvlxou| Hoiil}}kk Ao}k 'Mkv! Hous! v! B{k}xhgor$ 76< F!5m 05
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
22/25
0;
Hg`iekux v! A@XHO$ ;30 [!X! 85 '0
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
23/25
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
24/25
-
7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz Appellees Opposition-Objections to DOFF's RJN Doc 45-1
25/25