liberi et al v taitz et al - plaintiffs memorandum in opp to reeds msj doc 500

8/2/2019 Liberi Et Al v Taitz Et Al - Plaintiffs Memorandum in Opp to Reeds MSJ Doc 500

1/34

i

ZCOFK NA BNEZKEZR

Tcgkr

ZCOFK NA BNEZKEZR%%%%%%%i

ZCOFK NA C[Z@N_IZIKR%%%%%%%%%ii-q

I% IEZ_NJ[BZINE%%%3-?

II% _KKJ JKAKEJCEZR KQIJKEBK%%%?-2

III% RZCZKMKEZ NA ACBZR%%2-7

IQ% RZCEJC_J NA _KQIKW7

Q% C_G[MKEZ%0-?;

C% EKIF RCELKYR JKBFC_CZINE%%%%%%%%0-9

O% Z@K _KKJ JKAKEJCEZR RNFJRNFJ TFCIEZIAAR _KTN_ZR Z@CZGNQK_EKJ OY Z@K AB_C%9-?;

QI% BNEBF[RINE&%%%%?;

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44-3 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk 3 na ; Tcgk IJ"83?;;7


2/34

ii

ZCOFK NA C[Z@N_IZIKR

Bcrkr Tcgk(r)

Cjcm q% Fkpi Ekpi _i l ! Iean% Cecfyzib Grn{t& Ieb% &BIQ%40-:740 (_MO.LW)&?434 WF 392332; (J%E%H% Mcy 3?& ?434)%%??

Bcmorijgk Kfkbzrneib Bnrt% q% MGC Kfkbzrneib & Ieb %??7 A%_%J% 232& 2?3 (B%J% Bcf% ?44:)%%%?

Bcrfzne q% B`nibktniez& Ieb%&BIQ%40-;779(_OL.LMW)&?449 WF :3?7;:1 (J%E%H% Enq% ?2& ?449)%?2

B`k zkr q% T{rqi &?14 A%R{tt%?j 733& 737 (R%J% Iej%?442)%%%32

Bnmkc{p q% Ornwe ! Wifficm ne Znocbbn Bn% &93; A%?j 3?1:& 3?72-7: (9z` Bir% 3994)%%?4

Anrrk z q% Rkb{rkj A{ejieg Bnrt %& 4;-B-32?:&?447 WF 03070 (K%J% Wi % Hce% 0& ?447)%%%??

AZB q% T{of'g Bfkcrieg @n{ k& Ieb%&34: A%2j 3310& 3373 (9z` Bir% 3997)%7

Ie z`k Mczzkr na _kkj Kf kqikr& Ieb% cej Rki iekz Ieb% Bnrtnrczine &AZB Aifk En% 4;?-249:& Jnblkz En% B-:??1%%?2

Iejiqij{cf _kakrkebk Rkrqibk Grn{t& Ieb% q% A%Z%B%&3:; A% R{tt% ?j 1& 20 (J%J%B% ?443)31

Lekb`zkf q% B`nibktniez& Ieb%& BIQ%40-;430(_OL.LMW)&

?449 WF :3?2?7; (J%E%H% Enq% ?2& ?449)%?2

Mcrribnek q% Kptkrice Iean% Rnf{zine & Ieb%&49-BQ-33?2& ?449 WF 2?:;:37 (K%J% Tc% Nbz% 1& ?449)%%%?2

Mkejk q% J{e ! Orcj zrkkz& Ieb% &174 A%?j 3?9 (9z` Bir% 390?)%?4& ?3

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44-3 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk ? na ; Tcgk IJ"83?;;0


3/34

iii

ZCOFK NA C[Z@N_IZIKR - Bnezie{kj

Bcrkr Tcgk(r)

E{ekx q% J{ebce & ;93 A% 2j 3?37& 3???-?2 (9z` Bir% ?434)%7

T`iffit q% Grkejc f & 23? A%2j 2;7 (0z` Bir% ?44?)%30

Tiezn q% Tcbiaib Brkjiznr C 'e&14; A%2j 11;& 17: (9z` Bir%?434)32& ?:& ?;

_noie q% Rtnlkn& Ieb%& BQ34-4;241 NJW CG_P&

?433 WF 379222: (B%J% Bcf% Mcy 33& ?433)%?4

Rcakbn Ie % Bn% na Cm% q% O{rr & ;;3 [%R% :7& ;? (?447)3?& 32& 37& 30

Rkfa-Ie % Ie z%na Cmkribc& Ieb% q% Rnazwcrk cej Iean% Iej{ % C 'e%&?40 A%R{tt%?j 34;0& 3411 (B%J% Bcf% ?444)%?

Zrce [eine FFB q% A%Z%B %& ?9; A%2j :? (J%B% Bir% ?44?)%31

Zrce [eine Bnrt% q% Akjkrcf Zrcjk Bnmme &?:; A%2j 049& 032 (J%B% Bir% ?443)%30

Zrce [eine Bnrt% q% Akjkrcf Zrcjk Bnmme &03 A%2j ??0& ?23 (J%B% Bir% 3991)bkrz% jkeikj& ;21 [%R% 93; (?44?)30

[%R% q% B`nibkTniez& Ieb%& Bc k En% 41-bq4390& AZB Aifk En% 4;?-2419%%%?2

W%O% Bnrfky q% Cff zczk _kcfizy C nb%&

?434 WF 292114? (E%Y%R{t%)& ?434 E%Y% Rfit Nt% 2?747%%7

Wifficm q% Fkpi Ekpi _i l Mgmz% Ieb%&BIQ C 241BQ?:3& ?447 WF ?:29:12 (K%J% Qc% C{g% ?2& ?447)%%?2

Wizrinf q% Fkpi Ekpi Grn{t & B4;-4?29? MHH&?441 WF :7?;732 (E%J% Bcf% Ako% 34& ?441)%?2

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44-3 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk 2 na ; Tcgk IJ"83?;;9


4/34

iq

ZCOFK NA C[Z@N_IZIKR - Bnezie{kj

Bcrkr Tcgk(r)

Yceg q% Gnqz Kmtfnykkr Ier% Bn%&3:1 A%2j 32?4& 32?: (33z` Bir% 3990)%37

AKJK_CF RZCZ[ZKR

Tcgk(r)

3; [%R%B% 3103 kz ks%%%31

3; [%R%B% 3103(c)(:)%%%%32

3; [%R%B% 3103c(o)%%%3:

3; [%R%B% 3103c(b)%%%3:

3; [%R%B% 3103c(j)(3)%%%:& 31& 37& 30& 39& ?4

3; [%R%B% 3103c(j)(3)(C)33

3; [%R%B% 3103c(j)(3)(O)%%%%%33

3; [%R%B% 3103c(j)(3)(B)%37

3; [%R%B% 3103c(a)%?& :& 3?& 3:& 31

3; [%R%B% 3103c(t)3?& 32& ?;

3; [%R%B% 3103c(w)%3?& 3:

3; [%R%B% 3103o(c)(2)(C)%33

3; [%R%B% 3103o(c)(2)(O)%33

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44-3 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk : na ; Tcgk IJ"83?;14


5/34

q

ZCOFK NA C[Z@N_IZIKR Bnezie{kj

AKJK_CF RZCZ[ZKR

Tcgk(r)

3; [%R%B% 3103o%%%39

3; [%R%B% 3103o(c)(2)(B)%33

3; [%R%B% 3103o(a)%%%32

3; [%R%B% 104?%%3;

3; [%R%B% 104?(k)(1)%%%3;& 31

3; [RB 3103b(c)(3)-(;)%%7

BNJK NA AKJK_CF _KG[FCZINER

Tcgk(r)

31 B%A%_% 232%3;(c)(;)%%31

31 B%A%_% 133%?%?;

AKJK_CF _[FKR NA BIQIF T_NBKJ[_K

Tcgk(r)

Akj% _% Biq% T% 27 %%%?

Akj% _% Biq% T% ;1(b)%%7

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44-3 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk ; na ; Tcgk IJ"83?;13


6/34

Fiokri& kz cf& Tfcieziaa Mkmnrcej{m ie Nttn izine zn z`k _kkj Jkakejcez % MRH 3

3

?

2

:;

1

7

0

9

34

33

3?

32

3:

3;

31

37

30

39

?4

?3

??

?2

?:

?;

?1

?7

?0

Tìfit H% Okrg& K s{irk (TC I%J% 9017)K-mcif8 tìfhokrgDgmcif%bnmFCW NAAIBKR NA T@IFIT H% OK_G;;; Cejnrrc Gfke Bn{rz& R{izk 3?Fcacykzzk @iff& TC 39:::-?;23Zkfkt`nek8 (134) 0?;-232: Acp8 (134) 02:-71;9

Czznreky anr Tfcieziaa

[EIZKJ RZCZKR JIRZ_IBZ BN[_ZAN_ Z@K BKEZ_CF JIRZ_IBZ NA BCFIAN_EIC&

RN[Z@K_E JIQIRINE

FIRC FIOK_I& kz cf&

Tfcieziaa &

q %

N_FY ZCIZX& kz cf&

Jkakejcez %

8888888888888888

BIQIF CBZINE E[MOK_8

0833-bq-44:0;-CG (CHW)

TFCIEZIAAR MKMN_CEJ[MO_IKA IE NTTNRIZINE ZN Z@K_KKJ JKAKEJCEZR MNZINE AN_ R[MMC_Y H[JGMKEZ

Jczk na @kcrieg8 Mcy 3:& ?43?Zimk na @kcrieg8 34844 c%m%Fnbczine8 Bn{rzrnnm 34J

I% IEZ_NJ[BZINE8

Tfcieziaa Fi c Fiokri \ Fiokri]& Fi c N zkffc \ N zkffc]& Gn Kpbkf Gfnocf

\ GKG]& Tìfit H% Okrg& K s{irk \ Okrg] cej z`k Fcw Naaibk na Tìfit H% Okrg

\ FNTHO] oy cej z`rn{g` z`kir {ejkr igekj Bn{e kf `krkoy {omiz z`kir

Mkmnrcej{m ie Nttn izine zn Jkakejcez _kkj Kf kqikr& Ieb%& Fkpi Ekpi & Rki iez&

Ieb% j.o.c Cbb{riez \ Cbb{riez]& Fkpi Ekpi _i l cej Ieanrmczine Cecfyzib Grn{t&

Ieb%& Fkpi Ekpi _i l Rnf{zine AF& Ieb%& B`nibkTniez& Ieb%& Fkpi Ekpi Grn

bnffkbziqkfy \ _kkj Jkakejcez nr Jkakejcez ] Mnzine anr R{mmcry H{jgmkez

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk 3 na ?; Tcgk IJ"83?;2?


7/34

Fiokri& kz cf& Tfcieziaa Mkmnrcej{m ie Nttn izine zn z`k _kkj Jkakejcez % MRH ?

3

?

2

:;

1

7

0

9

34

33

3?

32

3:

3;

31

37

30

39

?4

?3

??

?2

?:

?;

?1

?7

?0

\ MRH]% Z`k grn{ej anr rkfika bizkj oy z`k _kkj Jkakejcez acif c c mczzkr na fcw%

Z`k rktnrz nfj oy z`k _kkj Jkakejcez bne ziz{zk c bne {mkr rktnrz c jkaiekj oy

z`k Acir Brkjiz _ktnrzieg Cbz \ AB_C]& 3; [%R%B% 3103c(a) cej z`k _kkj

Jkakejcez crk c Bne {mkr _ktnrzieg Cgkeby gnqkrekj oy z`k AB_C& w`n kff

bne {mkr rktnrz & z`rn{g` iezkr zczk bnmmkrbk anr mnekzcry akk % Jkakejcez crk enz

imm{ek arnm ficoifizy anr qinfczieg z`k AB_C% Z`krk crk {aaibikez acbz ie ji t{zk

z`cz R{mmcry H{jgmkez m{ z ok JKEIKJ%

II% Z@K _KKJ JKAKEJCEZR KQIJKEBK8

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez aifkj z`k Jkbfcrczine na Fi c Rimmne \ Rimmne ] wiz`

Kp`ioiz C& O cej B czzcb`kj z`krkzn cej z`k Jkbfcrczine na Fi c Tnfibc zrn

\ Tnfibc zrn] ie {ttnrz na z`kir Mnzine anr R{mmcry H{jgmkez% Tfcieziaa aifkj c

_ks{k z zn Rzrilk z`k Jkbfcrczine na Rimmne & Tnfibc zrn cej Kp`ioiz C& O cej

B zn z`k Jkbfcrczine na Rimmne ne z`k grn{ej z`k _kkj Jkakejcez ekqkr ijkeziaikj z`k k zwn \?] wizek k cej ekqkr trnqijkj z`k jnb{mkez ie ji bnqkry&

cfz`n{g` Tfcieziaa rks{k zkj iz ie ji bnqkry% C c rk {fz z`krkna& z`ky m{ z ok zriblke

t{r {cez zn Akj% _% Biq% T% 27%Rkk Bcmorijgk Kfkbzrneib Bnrt% q% MGC

Kfkbzrneib & Ieb% ??7 A%_%J% 232& 2?3 (B%J% Bcf% ?44:)


8/34


3

?

2

:;

1

7

0

9

34

33

3?

32

3:

3;

31

37

30

39

?4

?3

??

?2

?:

?;

?1

?7

?0

Kpìoiz crk `kcr cy cej Ekif Rcelky jnk enz `cqk tkr necf lenwfkjgk na z`k

acbz %

R`n{fj z`k Bn{rz grcez Tfcieziaa _ks{k z zn Rzrilk cej Nohkbzine & z`k _kkj

Jkakejcez Mnzine anr R{mmcry H{jgmkez m{ z ok Jkeikj& c z`ky jn enz `cqk

cey nz`kr {ttnrzieg kqijkebk%

III% RZCZKMKEZ NA ACBZR8

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez bfcim z`k rktnrz nfj zn Ekif Rcelky& Znjj Rcelky cej

Z`k Rcelky Airm& Ieb% \ Rcelky Jkakejcez ] wkrk nfj oy I_O kcrb`& FFB c c

rk kffkr anr Cbb{riez \_[A& En% 2?& ::& ;2]< z`cz z`k Rcelky Jkakejcez jij enz

nozcie Fiokri Rnbicf Rkb{rizy e{mokr& jczk na oirz`& mcijke ecmk nr tn{ k

ieanrmczine arnm I_O kcrb`& FFB nr Cbb{riez \_[A& En% ;;-;9]& wìb` i w`nffy

{ezr{k c kptfciekj `krkie cej ie z`k Jkbfcrczine aifkj bneb{rrkezfy `krkwiz`% Cey

wcy yn{ fnnl cz iz& z`k _kkj Jkakejcez wkrk z`k a{rei `kr na Tfcieziaa bne {mkr

rktnrz %

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez bfcim enek na z`k Zcizx nr Rcelky Jkakejcez `cj

cbbn{ez wiz` Cbb{riez \_[A En% ?9]& wìb` i bnezrcjibzkj oy Znjj Rcelky

Mnzine zn Wiz`jrcw Cjmi ine & JE :91-3 cz tt% 0-9& b& j cej k%

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez { k bnezrcjibznry zczkmkez rkgcrjieg Cbb{riez cfk na

Rnbicf Rkb{rizy e{mokr \_[A& En% :1-:0]< cej z`cz enek na z`k _kkj Jkakejcez &

iebf{jieg Cbb{riez& iebf{jk nr bnezcie mcijke ecmk \[A En% 31]% Z`k k zczkmkez

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk 2 na ?; Tcgk IJ"83?;2:


9/34

Fiokri& kz cf& Tfcieziaa Mkmnrcej{m ie Nttn izine zn z`k _kkj Jkakejcez % MRH :

3

?

2

:;

1

7

0

9

34

33

3?

32

3:

3;

31

37

30

39

?4

?3

??

?2

?:

?;

?1

?7

?0

crk {ezr{k< Rkk Tfcieziaa Ji t{zkj Acbz \ JA] En% 34-3?& 3:-30& ?4-?;& 2:& :0&

;;-;1& ;0-;9]%

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez cjmiz z`cz z`k rktnrz z`ky kff anr c akk crk tkr ne

tkbiaib rktnrz z`cz z`ky brkczk cej iebf{jk z`k iejiqij{cf ecmk& oirz` jczk& `nmk

qcf{k& cqkrcgk n{ k iebnmk& ip \1] fkqkf na rkfcziqk ieanrmczine& iebf{jieg cff cfic

nr nz`kr ecmk { kj oy z`k rkfcziqk & wìb` iebf{jk mcijke ecmk & tn{ k

ieanrmczine& cjjrk k (trkqin{ cej b{rrkez)& zkfkt`nek e{mokr (iebf{jieg {efi zkj

cej {et{ofi `kj)& mcrricgk rkbnrj & brimiecf rkbnrj & h{jgmkez & kzb% \JA 34-3?& 3:-

30& ?4-?;& 2:& :0& ;;-;1& ;0-;9]% Cff na z`k anrkgnieg wìb` bne ziz{zk bne {mkr

rktnrz c jkaiekj oy z`k AB_C& 3; [%R%B% 3103c(j)(3) cej 3; [%R%B% 3103c(a)%

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez t{rb`c k ieanrmczine arnm zìrj \2 rj ] tcrzik & gnqkremkez

cgkebik & bnmmkrbicf kezizik & aiecebicf ie ziz{zine & Jktcrzmkez na Mnznr Qkìbfk &

brkjiz rktnrzieg cgkebik & wìb` iebf{jk bneaijkezicf ieanrmczine& kzb% \_[A En 34-3?]% Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez & iebf{jieg Cbb{riez jkqkfnt cej brkczk z`k rktnrz arnm

z`k jczc z`ky rkbkiqk cej kff z`km anr c akk zn z`kir b{ znmkr z`rn{g` iezkr zczk

bnmmkrbk%RkkOkrg Jkbf%& t% 7& ?3& Kpo% ;& t%34;& _ks{k z En% ?%

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez rka{ kj zn a{rei ` Tfcieziaa z`kir rktnrz w`ke Tfcieziaa

rks{k zkj z`km% Rkk F% Fiokri Jkbf%& t% 34 ?2-?:& Kpo % 0& 9& 34& tt% 3:;-

F% N zkffc Jkbf% tt% 2-; 2-:& Kpo % ?- 33& tt% ??-79< Jkbfcrczine na Jr% Arc

N zkffc \ Jr% N zkffc]& t% 2& 9< cej Jkbfcrczine na Orkez Fiokri \ O% Fiokri Jkbf%]&

1& 32< cej rka{ kj zn bnrrkbz iebnrrkbz ieanrmczine& zikj zn Tfcieziaa oy z`kir oirz

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk : na ?; Tcgk IJ"83?;2;


10/34

Fiokri& kz cf& Tfcieziaa Mkmnrcej{m ie Nttn izine zn z`k _kkj Jkakejcez % MRH ;

3

?

2

:;

1

7

0

9

34

33

3?

32

3:

3;

31

37

30

39

?4

?3

??

?2

?:

?;

?1

?7

?0

jczk cej Rnbicf Rkb{rizy e{mokr& z`ky mciezcie ie Tfcieziaa aifk F% Fiokri Jkbf%& tt

31-?3& 20-:2& Kpo % 3 cej ?& tt% ?:-342< cej nfj Tfcieziaa rktnrz zn

{ec{z`nrixkj z`irj tcrzik cej rk kffkr & iebf{jieg z`k Rcelky Jkakejcez cej

I_O kcrb`& FFB& wiz`n{z c fkgcf nr tkrmi iofk t{rtn k cej wiz`n{z z`k tkrmi ine nr

lenwfkjgk na cey na z`k Tfcieziaa nr z`kir tn{ k % Rkk F% Fiokri Jkbf% t% 3;& ?

2;& ::< F% N zkffc Jkbf% t% 7& 9< O% Fiokri Jkbf% tt% 1-7& 3;-37< cej Jr% N

Jkbf%& t% ;& 3:%

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez bfcim z`kir jczcoc k bnezcie ieanrmczine arnm c wijk

qcrikzy na n{rbk & iebf{jieg brkjiz `kcjkr ieanrmczine cej brkjiz rktnrz \_[A t% 2&

33]% N zkffc cej Fiokri t`nek e{mokr & iebf{jieg bkff t`nek wkrk {efi zkj cej

{et{ofi `kj e{mokr % Rkk \O% Fiokri Jkbf% t% 0& ?4-?3< F% Fiokri Jkbf% tt% 2-:

F% N zkffc Jkbf% t% ;& :< Jr% N zkffc Jkbf%& t%1& 39< Fiokri jnkenz nwe rkcf k zczk nr

z`k trntkrzy ie w`ib` `k rk ijk & O% Fiokri Jkbf% tt% 0-9& ??% Tfcieziaa `cqk okkentzkj n{z na trnmnzinecf naakrieg wiz` kcb` brkjiz rktnrzieg cgkeby& Rkk F% Fiokr

Jkbf% t% 31& 21< O% Fiokri Jkbf% t% 0& ?3< Jr% N zkffc Jkbf% t% 7& ?3< cej

ekqkr rkbkiqkj cey enziaibczine arnm z`kir aiecebicf ie ziz{zine z`cz cey na z`k _kkj

Jkakejcez & nr ceynek kf k& wkrk kklieg z`kir ieanrmczine& F% Fiokri Jkbf% tt% 3;-31&

2;< O% Fiokri Jkbf% t% 0& ?3< F% N zkffc Jkbf% t% 33& ?3< Jr% N zkffc Jkbf%

?4%

Z`k _kkj Jkakejcez cjmiz z`k jnb{mkezczine z`ky rkbkiqk crk aifk { {cffy

trktcrkj oy brkjiz o{rkc{ & z`cz trnqijk {b` ieanrmczine c iejiqij{cf ecmk & ecmk

Bcrk 0833-bq-44:0;-CG-CHW Jnb{mkez ;44 Aifkj 4:.39.3? Tcgk ; na ?; Tcgk IJ"83?;21


11/34


3

?

2

:;

1

7

0

9

34

33

3?

32

3:

3;

31

37

30

39

?4

?3

??

?2

?:

?;

?1

?7

?0

qcricez & b{rrkez cej anrmkr cjjrk k cej Rnbicf kb{rizy e{mokr % \_[A t% 2]%

Z`k kcrb` bnej{bzkj oy Z`k Rcelky Airm& Ieb% ne Fi c Fiokri z`rn{g` Cbb{riez wc

r{e wiz` Fiokri ecmk cej cjjrk % Z`k kcrb` arnm Cbb{riez rkz{rekj c fi z NEFY

tkrzcieieg zn Tfcieziaa Fi c Fiokri& cfneg wiz` onz` Fiokri nfj cej ekw Rnbicf

Rkb{rizy e{mokr %Rkk \JA En% ;2]< F% Fiokri Jkbf& t% 2& 7& Kpo% 3& tt% ?:-?0

Jkbf%& t% 3;& 27& Kpo% 9& tt% 371-304%

Z`k bnmtrk`ke iqk bne {mkr rktnrz nfj ne z`k Tfcieziaa zn z`k Rcelky

Jkakejcez iebf{jk z`kir ecmk cej cff ecmk kqkr { kj& iebf{jieg mcijke ecmk

liberi et al v taitz et al - plaintiffs memorandum in opp to reeds msj doc 500

Documents