l:hmal:ioaoria toy aormatol: en thi apxaia. · pdf fileus 'av8peou @eo361pou k e cj> a...
TRANSCRIPT
lHMAlIOAOrIA TOY AOrMATOl EN THI APXAIA XPIlTIANIKH
KAI TH E2QXPIlTIANIKH rPAMMAlElA vno
ANAPEOY 9EOAQPOY V$HrHTOV 9EOA lXOAHl nANEOIUHMOY A9HNQN
HPOAErOMENA
Exono( Tijl peTa xei(aleayaaa( ftpwp elvat va naeaaxn evaVVOnTOV 8xOsaw TWV JWtXAWP alpaatwv ll( qJeaet 6 Beor bTe Tfl xetaTtaVtXfi xat Tfi xetaTtavtwij YeappaTelq Tfjr TeAevCaar CavTYr avaqJ8-fopevf)( eMtxwr elr yaappaCela1 Cif ampexata( ftvwP8VY( ExxAf)atar
bullH e(evva Cfjr aYpaawAoyta( COV MypaCo( xa-ra eno-xo CavCYJI xtxCY7at 3aavCtCa xal aYpaatav Coaovup PUAAOV xafJ BaOl Co Mypa fmoCeAovv oVatav Cifr aWCYeuMovr aAtoetar Cijr Oelar ampno-
ampnoCeki avyxeowr xat TO avnxetpBVoV Tij eeeVvfJ( Oepe-Atw5wv pa()IIla-rwv Cifr fJeoAoytar rjC04 TifraCoe(ar CWV LJoypaCwv xat Tfit LJoypaTtxifrmiddot HMv COVTOVmiddot ft ampnd tnolpewr peUTI TOV fJepa-TOr naeovataCu xat Breaar nkveur xaO 8aOl GVpfJaAk-Tat elr Tifr TOV MypaTor XaTa psyaAtv xat
nee(o5ov Tifr aTO(lar TWV Aoytauov xat ofiTw l5VvaCat va aen nCzQeepYJVetar xat naeexlioxar Tijr evvotar aVTOv aiTwer 18-
AevTalwr tpqJtAOXWeOVaat tvwxov tv Tep Tfit Oe()oM$ov Aortar 1
evxope()a 8nwr ai5TY elt 8XTeVBaTeear l(yaata( xat xat xaO AYV peMCar TOV MypaCor alCwer fJft()ovaat naea Colr ()eoMrotr nae ftpiv elvat avvnaeXTot
Hedr GVaTYpanxwT8fJaV Ifevvav TOV fJepaTor ftpwv lJAfJV AtV eir Teta ueqJaAata rjTOt a) elt peUTIv Toil MrpaTO( tv Tfl dy reaqJfi (3) Bv -rf y(aupaulq xat y) lv Tfi yfappa-Tetq Tifr ampexatar xa(JoAxifr ExxAYatar
1 II M 3J ( a T G t JJ T 0 v HbvoUl foii Bv efi geoioyl(h b laquogeoAoytlraquo 1957 (J 510 nB
9EOAOrlA T6j1OS AA TeOXos A 10
us Av8peou eo361pou
K E cJgt A A A ION A
TO 80rMA EN TlI ArLi rPAcJgtlI
1 IT OC AOC oc 11 OC 0 1p( Ij
To 86YLoc ev T1i IT mocOepwlt U1tO T1jv rijlt 1ociijlt 10U 10U vOLou 1013 1jJI)qgtEOfLlaquo1olt rijlt ltX7CoqgteXOecgtlt l7Co
toc6-njv ev 1iIgt 101) (213 laquo)(OCl tO 36YLoc xocl OtOOqgtOL ltX1tej(1ampvvovton 310 laquo(11) ipoundOl)xoclt 8oYfLlaquobullbullbullraquo 329 laquoXOCamp h6gt 86YLocbullbullbullraquo 43 laquo)(OCt
eLo1) etampOl) 36yJocraquo 68 laquo1131 001 Ot1jOov 101 xoct t)(Oelt ypoc-61tcgtlt 10 86YLoc IIepOwv XOCL 69 laquo101e (
10 8oYLocraquo 610 laquoKOCL eve-1ampYI) 10 36YLoc n 613 ( amp1tO 1WV ulwv 1rjlt OCLXLOCAwOpoundoclt rijlt Iou-80c poundocc OUX u1te1cXYl) 1iIgt 8oYfLlaquo1pound Oouraquo 615 laquoyvwfh to 86YLoc
)(oct IIepO(xLltbullbull raquo 626 laquoh 1tpoO6gt1tOU iJOU t1tel) MyiJ(X 101)10 ev 1tcXO() ltxpxn rijlt Lou raquo) yEVetOCL A6yolt 1tepL3LOC1OCYLeX1cgtv twv At(UV xoct 8ocpepoundou ev tilgt tou
(2026 laquo)(OCt (xU1oult tv toilt36yfLlaquoOLV (XU1WV tv tilgt peueOOocpound Le 7Ciiv g1tcgtlt ocqgtocvpoundOw (xU1oult) x(Xl ev 1n 11pound171 tWV (13 laquo)mepov 3amp toc V6iJLiJ(X xoct 1WV 1toctPpoundwv 30YLcX1wV raquo) lve(X mo 1tcXtPL(x 36yiJ(Xtoc 01)
LOCEVOV1OCL tv 1n (Xl evtoA(xL tOU v6iJou 1tpolt to 3 6 y iJ (X mo T1jv 10U evttA-
WO(XU1CgtC )(OCL to prjiJoc 3 0 Y iJ oc 1 e v Olhwc 39 laquoet 1iIgt amp1tOAtO(xL
(XU10UCraquo) 2 Mocx)( 108 3s iJe1OC XOLVOU 7CPOOtcXYiJoctOC xocl 1jJ1jqgtL-0fLlaquot0lt 1tocvmiddotd tiIgt 1WV Iou3oc(cgtv leVeL raquo) 1536 laquoX(xL i30yiJcXtLOOCV 1tcXvtec iJe1OC XOLVOU 1jJI)qgtLOLOC10lt L1j3ociJwlt eiiO(xL oc7CocpoccrljLOCV10V T1jv 1 E03poc 633 dyfu 8(Xpei0c 3 e 3 0 Y iJ eX 1 LX OC e1tLiJeAWc X(x1OC 1(Xihoc
1 Ev T(l Iou3c()eii yplXJJIXteq t0 36yJ1X 17ltlXVttt xupcu ltlXP 1(0)-XIXL ltIgt(ACUW t iigt Iou31Xcp - Olthcut I IwOIJnot teX 3amp3iXyJIXt1X toov EaOlJvoov XIXPIX-
wt 86YJIXtIXDe bello zud IIU2) 3e ltpot to ampaov3etov nAij60t toov tptAOOOqgttxoov 30YJat(o)v 11)1 lv Myott xlXl iJ6t1)t1X tijt McuOIXtKij
86yJIXtIX ampAAtX xlXl ltlXpamp300tV KIXttX tOv Iwa1]ltov I lou31XIXOt AIXOtampVS-x1X6ev l1Cijpe ltpoaxeuroxoAA1JlltvOt elt ttXt YPlXtptXt iou XIXa 0001 l6ewpet tIX6tIXt w aoy[JlX-t1X eoO ampttVIX bepateL aelltotE xotl Oltep TooV 01tOlOlV kO[JoXlXl va ampltO-
I 402) m Iou8lXioL 8e XIXUXWVtIXt 86 XplXWUI1L IIamp XaAAtOtIX toov 80Ylla-
ill7
2 K ocL VYj a Loc 6 x 1)
middotEx t1j II Yj My[1oc xocl iJ1to t1j Kocw1j gv6oc terPOCXLlt ILev croctpamp 01t0 t1jlt t Ji A ) 1 t L t t - n VO[10U tO ouxoc laquoeyevstO ev tOCL 1)ILepocLlt exeWOCt ecY)lvev
6 Y IL oc 1t oc p ltX K oc ( cr oc p 0 lt A uY 0 0 (J t 0 U OC1toypoctpe06oct 1trlOocv tYjv 177 laquoXOCamp oihoL 1tltxvteurolt oc1teVocvtL tampv 0 Y IL oct W v K oc ( 0 oc po 1tpoccrcroucHV (3ocOLMoc Ittepov Myovte eVOCt IY)Oouvraquo 164 laquo6gtlt tltXlt 1t6AeLlt ocuo1lt tpUAOCOOeLV oc 6 I-lL oc t oc tltX xexpLILevoc U1tO tampV OC1t00t6AWvraquo 0 A6yolt 1tepl t1jlt OC1totpocOewlt tiilt ev IepoOoAOILOLO OC1tOOrOALX1j 1tept tampv e6VLxampv ellt XPLOtOV 1tpoOL6vtwv) xocl Ef3p 1123 3ev etVocL f3ef3oc[oc tOU
ypOC1ovto laquot 0 3 6 y IL oc tou f3ocmMwltraquo sepwv )ILWlt ypoctp6vtwv tOUf30t0LAtWraquo (XPLt Nestle 16 31lt 3e ev ij6txj evvo(q
1tpo tampV 10u3ocmiddotx()v eVtoAampv 1)tot EtpeO 215 laquotov v6ILoV t()v ev-tOAampV ev 3 6 Y IL oc 0 L xocl KOAOOO 214 to xoc6
Xetp6ypocltpov t 0 1 lt 3 6 Y IL oc 0 tV () 01tsvocVttov TeAO ev ti K xocl to p1j[1oc KOAOOO
220laquoEt oc1te6ocvete cruv XpLOrltgt OC1tO t()v otOLXetwv tou x60[1ou tt 4 tv x60ILltr
XV 136 AAACt xed Itlt1(PCt IDtAM ((JJ Iou8cdCjl b My(Joc XPY)at(JOltOLet(OGt ltoAMxLlt (xOG(Ct (01 ltLVOCXOC (Ou Leisegang ampltOGvtij 140 qlopamplt )O()-rw YpoundVe(OGL MYOI mpt (ampv 8oy(JtX-
(Wl (ampvaoqlLO(c)1 (Vit Mos 2 212) XOCt(amp1 XocA8OGLWl ampcrpoMywI (Abr 82) 1tept amp1-flPW1tLIWI 80y(JtX(wI bJ dVOGql0Pij ltpOC -rljv KOGI 8LOGlpeaLI (OU Xp61ou (Fuga et inv 57) ltept Etwtxamp1 (IIOGlOGL(Lou XIXI B01)flou De aet mundi 76) KOGI IIAOG(wleLwI 80y(JtX(wI (De aet mundi 17) 01 (J61ol 8t liAM XIX( mpt 80y(JtXtwI (01 Mw()Oewl amp(LIOG aUIaY0l(OGL 8t tVA1)yoptxijl iJEfl68ou (De opif mundi 25 leg alleg 3194 sacrif Abelis 19 post Caini 38) QaOGU1wl YLIe(IXL Myol mpt fleLWI XOGI xy(wv 8oY(Ja(wI ltEpL 80yJamp(wI ijlt OOqlLOGI xocL ij TCt My(JOG(OG ij alXqlamplt 81)AOUot
(ou x6a(Jou (Damp opi mundi 172 lH ltepL (amp1 t7j f)e(IXC ouOlOGlt 8L-alXOXIXA[OG amp1tO(EAetxOGtCt (01 ID(AWIOC 86y(JOG amp1OGYxOGL6tIX(ol atCt (00 omxaOOtijt qlLAO-OOqlLOGlt (Cherub 85)
1 0 iepolt Xpua60(0(Jolt (Ct xwp(OG (OGUtIX wt 36y(JIX(OG 8bJ dlt08qetOGL xltAc) -rltXlt (ou MwOccixou 16(Jou Ett(o KOAOO 2ill ltOGpiX(1)pet laquo(otlt 86y(JOGoL ql1)OIIopoundoLlt 86YiJlXaL tij 1t(crltL OXOUI apxei m(f(EuaOGLraquo (PMGr 62340) mt at t0 EIPea 215 1tIXPIXiJEveL amp(Jql[pP01to laquoT[ ea(LI tV 36y(JOGOL 1) Tl)V 1t(a(LV 0151 ql1)O 86y(JOG IXUTI)1 XOCAc)1 1J TI)I ltOGPOGYyeApoundocl XIXf)wt ItAeyev 6 XptO(6t eycb at AeyW U(JLI (J1] OPYLOfl7jlIXL (SAwtlIPMGr 6239 )- QaOGU1wc xOGi I 0e08ampgtpY)tot et (Jtv to KOAOO 2H 00lt 86y(JOGtOG ampltOaqe(OGt tamplt e6OGyyeALXamplt tV1)fleLOG tCtt amp1OGyxOGpoundoclt elt OCJltI)p[OGII laquo8w-xe at tCt e6OGyyeALXCt 86Y(JOG-i-OG tv tn (olhwl qlUAlXXn TI)1 Ow(1)piOGll tltlXyyevoc-(JevoCraquo (PMGr 82 612B) Et at (il EqleO 215 ltOGpOG(1)pei laquoa6y(JOG(OG ae tijl euOGyye-ALX1]I 8L81XOXOGA(OCl sxwcrevraquo (P MGr82 52ttB) sv OXecreL (JtVLa(oc ltpolt (amplt e6OGyye AtXCt
148 Av3peol) so3cfpou
Ex truvC6[Lou CIXt1ljlt lted)6[Le61XlhL 86y[La Ce
Cn xlXl tii K Cijv COU v6[Lou tOU cXlto(lcfaecult
ev tii evvo(q tampv euoeyyeALxampv
KEltIgtAAAION HI
TO 800rMA EN TII EEOXPUTIANIKII
Ev tj yplX[L[LIXCepoundq Co 86y[LIX ocltlXvCii llltO 8uvlaquo[Le6IX va
) 0E - I - 1IX V t n e v VOL q C t) ( It 0 (l IXI 0 e cu x p 0 cu t i t)-(l t 0 [L IX C 0 8 t) [L 0 (i t 0 u Ev t7i tvvo(q ClXotn O[LtAOUOLV 0 II A laquot (j) v
ev tiil M(VlO IXUtOU 314B Htt ouv amp1 CoU-ccuv tov v6[Lov ellIXL t a 8 6 ( [L IX C IX ClXtltlX XlXt tJt)(ltO[LIXCIX e[Lo( ye 8oxei 8061111 lOLxe COV v6[L0m 0 E e v 0 (l amp v ev Cn Kopou bull6411 laquo8 6 y [L IX bullbullbull 6IXvlaquoCltp IXUCO 1t)[LLou061XUgt 335 dx too-Ctiu e86xeL cnplXCt)yotlt elvlXL 8 6 y[L IX It 0 L 0 IX c 6 IX L Cov lt6Ae[LoV eVIXL) xIXl 6627 laquo1jv yap Campv cnPIXtLCUtampV 8 6 Y [L IX
8t)[L60LIX elvlXL Ca At)(l6tVtIXraquo) OOIXU-cCUlt O[LtAOUOLV b II 0 A U L 0 lt 2046 laquo[LIttamp KOLVOU 86y[LIXC0lt 4264 XOLVOU 86y[LIXtop) xo16132 ev6x ypoundveCIXL et3Lxamplt 7tept Campv tJt)(lLO[LlaquoCCUV C1llt HOU-3e[LtlXv 7tOLeLV ot t1X[LtiL 8UYIXVCIXL Campv 8oy[LlaquoCcuVraquo o 8ot) [L 0 0 6 e v t) 7tepl tJt)(lLO[LlaquotltOV 18154 155 laquo86y[LIXCoc A[L(lLKCu6vcuvraquo 0 A l cr X U A IdCL8elt 601 laquo81)[LoU M8oxCIXL tJt)(l(0[LIX-CIXraquo 0 Hpco8LIXlOlt 7105 (jIXOlALXIXilt 8La 86y[LIXtolt IXUCOUlt ex60[Lt)Oevraquo XlXl d tLlt
E I t n b v 0 (q t 0 U v 6 [L 0 u 8 L IX C IX y [L IX t 8 L IX-C IX Y -ij lt Ev Cn evvo(q tIXU-cll Co 86y[LIX cXTClXVtii 7tIXPa IIAIXCwvL Oikcult 6
O[LLAei ev Cn IIoALCtpoundq IXUCOU (320 p 414 H) 7tepl Campv 80Y[LcftCul
149
36ytLoc 3 ampvOPW7t(Jv qJPOVt[J(Jv t7tocv6pO(J[JIX 3e rWV EXOUOt(Jv XIX ampXOUOL(JV [JIXptY)[Jampr(Jv 7t6Ae(J Ouv(1)xtj XOW1)xIX6 1)1 rot tv
7t6AWl WX 0 IT )0 U r IX P X 0 Mor 742D dv re 36y[JML xIXl
bull I re xIXl O[JOAoytIXL xIXl )orepoc 1(IXt
-repIX r(JV 7tP(JrtVraquo
y) E v r 1i cent v v 0 ( r Y v W [J tj () 7t 0 A1)1jJ e (J IX 0-6 e v r L X 3 L oc 0 Xoc Apoundoc amp L W [J r 0 qJ LAO 0 0 p L X 0 uO e-[J e A L W 3 0 u amp p X Ev tLev r1j yevLx1j lVW[Jtj fmoA1j-
amp7tocVr(f ro 36yVA 7tOCPO ITAOCr(JVL 7tX 265C laquorij) WV 7tOAAWV MYtLOCrL Xo p1j[JXtL XPWtLEVOLraquo (B) XIX N6[Jou 7 797C) 7tepl tWV 30y-fLampr(JV 3L3ocOi(OCALWV qnAoOoqJtOC ypound Myo eoU-repo O)r(J 0 KLxeprov 7tepl rWV 30Y[Jampr(Jv OOptoc rWV xeuroXrtjtLfv(Jv xGpo aeO-[JeurLxov 3La rOO amp7t03eX0[Jevou IXOramp 7tIXpIXtY)pet laquoSapientia quae neque de se dubitare debet neque de suis decretis quae philosophi vocant 36y[JIXtoc quorum nullum sine scelere prodi poteritn (Academ priorum 2 9 27) Ev rij) U7tO ro (VO[JIX roG rOCAtjVol) qJepo[Jevltp f3L-[lAtltp De historia philosopbi 3LOCXp(VOVrIXL rEOcrlXpe xeX(JpLn[JevocL qnAoM-
xIXreu60vaeLI 6lV [JLIX ruyxampveL (ltlt[JLOCV tLev t1)V 30y[JIXrL-middot X1)Vraquo)) ExampOrtj oc(pecrt lxeL ra t3LIX My[JXrIX xocO 500v IXtpetn rt 30Y[Jampt(Jv etc rtjrOC OIvocY0[JevtJv laquoxocr lvvOLllv 3e 80y[Jampt(Jv 7tOAlWV 7tpOC I1AAtjAOC Ou[JqJwv(Jv 7tpOC pound1 reAo ampvoccpepovr(JVraquo (Diels Doxo-graphi graeci Berolini 1879 p 6045 6042) ITept 3t oi) APXeOLAOCOU AeyerOCL iSrL xocrt1 rO cpMv6[Jevov [Jampv oxe7trLx6c tv r1j 7tpocy[JocrLx6rtjrL 3 ([J(Jc laquoXocta 8e ampA1j6etocv 30y[Jocrtxo (Ritter und FreIler Rist pbilos graecae Gotha 1898) n 539oc p 440) ITepl
t b 7tAeL6tepoc 3 bApLOroreAtjC (ltPuOtXa 42 )xIXl 7tAetOrOV 7tampvrtJvmiddot 0 ITAOUtIXPX0
Mor14E laquora 7tepl My[JIXtocraquo Mor 797B laquoXIX Myot tWV Mv XIX 7tOALrtXWV ampv-3pwv XIX XPIXt1jO(JOLmiddot v6[J(Jv MVIX[JLV 7i xoc ITAOCt(JV et 7tAeUOeV ta 36 y [J IX r IX v6[Jou xad lpyoc 7tOL1jOetV centv ror 7tpampy[JIXOLVraquo iOOOD laquoxoc MYOL ptjt6p(Jv xIX13 6 y-tL oc r IX 0 0 qJ t 0 t WVraquo 1062E laquolStIXV tLampv ouv [Jtj3evol tWV [JOCXO-[Jev(Jv ampAAO 7tampVr1X o[Jo)oyetV XIX tL6evocL 6eA(JOt 7tOV OOt 301(OUOL Oocu-fltXOt(J) tv r 0 r I 6 y tL oc 0 L O[JOAoytIXv De repugn stoic 1033A t1)v rWV 3 0 y V- amp r (J) v O[JOAoytocv tv torc [ltOLC 6e(JpetaOIXLraquo 1034 B laquoltt 3 6 y [J IX Z 1j V(J) V0 totLV tepa Oewv olxooo[Jetvmiddot lepov
N T It lt - -l l yocp [Jtj-7tOIlOU OCtoV XIXL OCYLOV OUX litltLV Oli IPYOV XOCL IXVOCUO(JV
150 Av3peou
ouSev 1tOAAOU Colot 1 laquo(1tept tOU gtL xltgttamp twv ttMCiJV qnAo-06rplttlv S 6 Y L ltgt t ltgt ooSe tatW)) 0 H 9CiJ S L ltgt v 0 lt 124 laquorpLAOOOrpLotV
lJ0 R oe OU JOYOLlt ouoe oOYJltgttCiJV yVCiJOem OeLvep 0 fjVeL XotL OCiJrppOVL tJLep E1tLOtCiJ-erltgttOraquo - OLOLCiJlt XotL Mocpxolt ( amplt MYLlXtot XotL 6eLeALwSeLlt ampAY)6e((tlt rpLAoerorpLotlt laquoetlt e(tutov 23 )-
IIoAMxLe tamp rpLAoerorpLXa totUt(t MyJltgttot Leta tOU ov6-L(ttolt tOU etGY)YY)tou tCiJV O)tCiJe ( t0 ampOWL(ttOV thlV 6ehlV X(tpot-
we t0 laquoXUPLWt(ttOV thlV II U 6 (t yo P x hl V 30YLoctCiJV)) (IIpotpe1CtLx6e 21 n 21 H Pistelli Leipzig 1888)0 APLGtO-teAl]e 1tept thlV ampypocrpCiJV SOYLoctCuV tOU 11MtCiJvoe (ltPuerLx 42 p 209 14) OLOLlttle xotl tOU r(tAl)VOU rpepeL tov tEtAOV laquo11ep1 thlV I1t-1tOxpamptoue XOL 11AamptWVOe ( KLXepCiJV Lvl)L0veueL tOU Ax(t-aweLxou MYJ(ttoe amplt 6eJeuroALWaOUe IXOA1jlt xe-Xtl)t(tL xupoe u1tOxpeCiJtLxov X()L SeOLeutLXOV SLa toue o1t(t30ue laquoAn-tiochus ad istum locum pressius videbatur accedere Quoniam enim id aberentAcademici decretum (sentitis enim iam hoc me SOYL(t dicere) nibil posse percipi non debere eos in suo decreto sicut in ceteris rebus fluctuariraquo (Acadpr 2 9 29)
a) E v t fl h v 0 (q t 1t P (t X t L X e amp p x 1i e X (t-V 6 v 0 e p U 6 L E 0 Vt 0 e t amp e 1t P amp Le t 0 U amp v a p W1t 0 u Ev tn eurovvoEq totutrJ t0 SOYLot XUPLCiJlt 1totpa toLe ItCiJmiddotcxore OtltCiJe ( E1tL-Xl)tOC SLotGteMeL ta opaa amp1t0 thlV rpltgtUACiJV aOYLamptCiJV ((et opaa SOYL(ttltgt IpoundxeLe X(tAhllt et rp(tUA(t XciXhleraquo 3 9 2 Schenkl Lipsiae 1916 cr 2605) AV(tAOYCiJe thlV exampGtou aOYLcltCiJV ampPZhlV XpEVetotL TroLOtY)e x(tl tOU ampvapW1tOU (3212) To MYLltgt we X(tL tOU xextl]t(tL terxuv xotlxupoe X(taOALXOV xoc1 ampxMvl)tov laquo1t(tVt(tXou yap toXupov t0 a6WIX ampxEVl]tov t0 SOYLotraquo) (316 8)
K(tL totUt1X Lev yeVLXhle 6erov de to a6YLot euroV tn yplXLL(tteEq AeuroyoJeurov IhL ev otut7j to MYL(t GlJJltgtEVeL amp1tOrpotULV
mpl thl1l 1tp(tYLcltCuV 1ELe X(tL taeuro(te 3e tou rpLAoerorpLxou 1tdHou rpLAoerorpLXa SLMY[J(ttot e1tL elte Xota6AOU xocl xotl e1t OV6LottL thlV etGY)YYJthlV (tUthlV (tu6ev-tLXa IXOAhlv tl1tOXpeWtLXamp 3ta taLeAl) (tUthlV euro1tl tou 1tpotXtL-
te XOLVW-VLXOV thlV ampvapW1tCiJv OtL OtOLXerOV Xott yvwpLerLot tOU MYLottoe
a - f f 1l1 x(t ot1toter(te erxeovv otutou tote UfeLe eLVotL to otVCiJtepov X(tL 07) (tVtLxeLLe-VLXOV xupolt otUEleVtEot elv(tL 1tepLttOV XOI1 va
us Av8peou eo361pou
K E cJgt A A A ION A
TO 80rMA EN TlI ArLi rPAcJgtlI
1 IT OC AOC oc 11 OC 0 1p( Ij
To 86YLoc ev T1i IT mocOepwlt U1tO T1jv rijlt 1ociijlt 10U 10U vOLou 1013 1jJI)qgtEOfLlaquo1olt rijlt ltX7CoqgteXOecgtlt l7Co
toc6-njv ev 1iIgt 101) (213 laquo)(OCl tO 36YLoc xocl OtOOqgtOL ltX1tej(1ampvvovton 310 laquo(11) ipoundOl)xoclt 8oYfLlaquobullbullbullraquo 329 laquoXOCamp h6gt 86YLocbullbullbullraquo 43 laquo)(OCt
eLo1) etampOl) 36yJocraquo 68 laquo1131 001 Ot1jOov 101 xoct t)(Oelt ypoc-61tcgtlt 10 86YLoc IIepOwv XOCL 69 laquo101e (
10 8oYLocraquo 610 laquoKOCL eve-1ampYI) 10 36YLoc n 613 ( amp1tO 1WV ulwv 1rjlt OCLXLOCAwOpoundoclt rijlt Iou-80c poundocc OUX u1te1cXYl) 1iIgt 8oYfLlaquo1pound Oouraquo 615 laquoyvwfh to 86YLoc
)(oct IIepO(xLltbullbull raquo 626 laquoh 1tpoO6gt1tOU iJOU t1tel) MyiJ(X 101)10 ev 1tcXO() ltxpxn rijlt Lou raquo) yEVetOCL A6yolt 1tepL3LOC1OCYLeX1cgtv twv At(UV xoct 8ocpepoundou ev tilgt tou
(2026 laquo)(OCt (xU1oult tv toilt36yfLlaquoOLV (XU1WV tv tilgt peueOOocpound Le 7Ciiv g1tcgtlt ocqgtocvpoundOw (xU1oult) x(Xl ev 1n 11pound171 tWV (13 laquo)mepov 3amp toc V6iJLiJ(X xoct 1WV 1toctPpoundwv 30YLcX1wV raquo) lve(X mo 1tcXtPL(x 36yiJ(Xtoc 01)
LOCEVOV1OCL tv 1n (Xl evtoA(xL tOU v6iJou 1tpolt to 3 6 y iJ (X mo T1jv 10U evttA-
WO(XU1CgtC )(OCL to prjiJoc 3 0 Y iJ oc 1 e v Olhwc 39 laquoet 1iIgt amp1tOAtO(xL
(XU10UCraquo) 2 Mocx)( 108 3s iJe1OC XOLVOU 7CPOOtcXYiJoctOC xocl 1jJ1jqgtL-0fLlaquot0lt 1tocvmiddotd tiIgt 1WV Iou3oc(cgtv leVeL raquo) 1536 laquoX(xL i30yiJcXtLOOCV 1tcXvtec iJe1OC XOLVOU 1jJI)qgtLOLOC10lt L1j3ociJwlt eiiO(xL oc7CocpoccrljLOCV10V T1jv 1 E03poc 633 dyfu 8(Xpei0c 3 e 3 0 Y iJ eX 1 LX OC e1tLiJeAWc X(x1OC 1(Xihoc
1 Ev T(l Iou3c()eii yplXJJIXteq t0 36yJ1X 17ltlXVttt xupcu ltlXP 1(0)-XIXL ltIgt(ACUW t iigt Iou31Xcp - Olthcut I IwOIJnot teX 3amp3iXyJIXt1X toov EaOlJvoov XIXPIX-
wt 86YJIXtIXDe bello zud IIU2) 3e ltpot to ampaov3etov nAij60t toov tptAOOOqgttxoov 30YJat(o)v 11)1 lv Myott xlXl iJ6t1)t1X tijt McuOIXtKij
86yJIXtIX ampAAtX xlXl ltlXpamp300tV KIXttX tOv Iwa1]ltov I lou31XIXOt AIXOtampVS-x1X6ev l1Cijpe ltpoaxeuroxoAA1JlltvOt elt ttXt YPlXtptXt iou XIXa 0001 l6ewpet tIX6tIXt w aoy[JlX-t1X eoO ampttVIX bepateL aelltotE xotl Oltep TooV 01tOlOlV kO[JoXlXl va ampltO-
I 402) m Iou8lXioL 8e XIXUXWVtIXt 86 XplXWUI1L IIamp XaAAtOtIX toov 80Ylla-
ill7
2 K ocL VYj a Loc 6 x 1)
middotEx t1j II Yj My[1oc xocl iJ1to t1j Kocw1j gv6oc terPOCXLlt ILev croctpamp 01t0 t1jlt t Ji A ) 1 t L t t - n VO[10U tO ouxoc laquoeyevstO ev tOCL 1)ILepocLlt exeWOCt ecY)lvev
6 Y IL oc 1t oc p ltX K oc ( cr oc p 0 lt A uY 0 0 (J t 0 U OC1toypoctpe06oct 1trlOocv tYjv 177 laquoXOCamp oihoL 1tltxvteurolt oc1teVocvtL tampv 0 Y IL oct W v K oc ( 0 oc po 1tpoccrcroucHV (3ocOLMoc Ittepov Myovte eVOCt IY)Oouvraquo 164 laquo6gtlt tltXlt 1t6AeLlt ocuo1lt tpUAOCOOeLV oc 6 I-lL oc t oc tltX xexpLILevoc U1tO tampV OC1t00t6AWvraquo 0 A6yolt 1tepl t1jlt OC1totpocOewlt tiilt ev IepoOoAOILOLO OC1tOOrOALX1j 1tept tampv e6VLxampv ellt XPLOtOV 1tpoOL6vtwv) xocl Ef3p 1123 3ev etVocL f3ef3oc[oc tOU
ypOC1ovto laquot 0 3 6 y IL oc tou f3ocmMwltraquo sepwv )ILWlt ypoctp6vtwv tOUf30t0LAtWraquo (XPLt Nestle 16 31lt 3e ev ij6txj evvo(q
1tpo tampV 10u3ocmiddotx()v eVtoAampv 1)tot EtpeO 215 laquotov v6ILoV t()v ev-tOAampV ev 3 6 Y IL oc 0 L xocl KOAOOO 214 to xoc6
Xetp6ypocltpov t 0 1 lt 3 6 Y IL oc 0 tV () 01tsvocVttov TeAO ev ti K xocl to p1j[1oc KOAOOO
220laquoEt oc1te6ocvete cruv XpLOrltgt OC1tO t()v otOLXetwv tou x60[1ou tt 4 tv x60ILltr
XV 136 AAACt xed Itlt1(PCt IDtAM ((JJ Iou8cdCjl b My(Joc XPY)at(JOltOLet(OGt ltoAMxLlt (xOG(Ct (01 ltLVOCXOC (Ou Leisegang ampltOGvtij 140 qlopamplt )O()-rw YpoundVe(OGL MYOI mpt (ampv 8oy(JtX-
(Wl (ampvaoqlLO(c)1 (Vit Mos 2 212) XOCt(amp1 XocA8OGLWl ampcrpoMywI (Abr 82) 1tept amp1-flPW1tLIWI 80y(JtX(wI bJ dVOGql0Pij ltpOC -rljv KOGI 8LOGlpeaLI (OU Xp61ou (Fuga et inv 57) ltept Etwtxamp1 (IIOGlOGL(Lou XIXI B01)flou De aet mundi 76) KOGI IIAOG(wleLwI 80y(JtX(wI (De aet mundi 17) 01 (J61ol 8t liAM XIX( mpt 80y(JtXtwI (01 Mw()Oewl amp(LIOG aUIaY0l(OGL 8t tVA1)yoptxijl iJEfl68ou (De opif mundi 25 leg alleg 3194 sacrif Abelis 19 post Caini 38) QaOGU1wl YLIe(IXL Myol mpt fleLWI XOGI xy(wv 8oY(Ja(wI ltEpL 80yJamp(wI ijlt OOqlLOGI xocL ij TCt My(JOG(OG ij alXqlamplt 81)AOUot
(ou x6a(Jou (Damp opi mundi 172 lH ltepL (amp1 t7j f)e(IXC ouOlOGlt 8L-alXOXIXA[OG amp1tO(EAetxOGtCt (01 ID(AWIOC 86y(JOG amp1OGYxOGL6tIX(ol atCt (00 omxaOOtijt qlLAO-OOqlLOGlt (Cherub 85)
1 0 iepolt Xpua60(0(Jolt (Ct xwp(OG (OGUtIX wt 36y(JIX(OG 8bJ dlt08qetOGL xltAc) -rltXlt (ou MwOccixou 16(Jou Ett(o KOAOO 2ill ltOGpiX(1)pet laquo(otlt 86y(JOGoL ql1)OIIopoundoLlt 86YiJlXaL tij 1t(crltL OXOUI apxei m(f(EuaOGLraquo (PMGr 62340) mt at t0 EIPea 215 1tIXPIXiJEveL amp(Jql[pP01to laquoT[ ea(LI tV 36y(JOGOL 1) Tl)V 1t(a(LV 0151 ql1)O 86y(JOG IXUTI)1 XOCAc)1 1J TI)I ltOGPOGYyeApoundocl XIXf)wt ItAeyev 6 XptO(6t eycb at AeyW U(JLI (J1] OPYLOfl7jlIXL (SAwtlIPMGr 6239 )- QaOGU1wc xOGi I 0e08ampgtpY)tot et (Jtv to KOAOO 2H 00lt 86y(JOGtOG ampltOaqe(OGt tamplt e6OGyyeALXamplt tV1)fleLOG tCtt amp1OGyxOGpoundoclt elt OCJltI)p[OGII laquo8w-xe at tCt e6OGyyeALXCt 86Y(JOG-i-OG tv tn (olhwl qlUAlXXn TI)1 Ow(1)piOGll tltlXyyevoc-(JevoCraquo (PMGr 82 612B) Et at (il EqleO 215 ltOGpOG(1)pei laquoa6y(JOG(OG ae tijl euOGyye-ALX1]I 8L81XOXOGA(OCl sxwcrevraquo (P MGr82 52ttB) sv OXecreL (JtVLa(oc ltpolt (amplt e6OGyye AtXCt
148 Av3peol) so3cfpou
Ex truvC6[Lou CIXt1ljlt lted)6[Le61XlhL 86y[La Ce
Cn xlXl tii K Cijv COU v6[Lou tOU cXlto(lcfaecult
ev tii evvo(q tampv euoeyyeALxampv
KEltIgtAAAION HI
TO 800rMA EN TII EEOXPUTIANIKII
Ev tj yplX[L[LIXCepoundq Co 86y[LIX ocltlXvCii llltO 8uvlaquo[Le6IX va
) 0E - I - 1IX V t n e v VOL q C t) ( It 0 (l IXI 0 e cu x p 0 cu t i t)-(l t 0 [L IX C 0 8 t) [L 0 (i t 0 u Ev t7i tvvo(q ClXotn O[LtAOUOLV 0 II A laquot (j) v
ev tiil M(VlO IXUtOU 314B Htt ouv amp1 CoU-ccuv tov v6[Lov ellIXL t a 8 6 ( [L IX C IX ClXtltlX XlXt tJt)(ltO[LIXCIX e[Lo( ye 8oxei 8061111 lOLxe COV v6[L0m 0 E e v 0 (l amp v ev Cn Kopou bull6411 laquo8 6 y [L IX bullbullbull 6IXvlaquoCltp IXUCO 1t)[LLou061XUgt 335 dx too-Ctiu e86xeL cnplXCt)yotlt elvlXL 8 6 y[L IX It 0 L 0 IX c 6 IX L Cov lt6Ae[LoV eVIXL) xIXl 6627 laquo1jv yap Campv cnPIXtLCUtampV 8 6 Y [L IX
8t)[L60LIX elvlXL Ca At)(l6tVtIXraquo) OOIXU-cCUlt O[LtAOUOLV b II 0 A U L 0 lt 2046 laquo[LIttamp KOLVOU 86y[LIXC0lt 4264 XOLVOU 86y[LIXtop) xo16132 ev6x ypoundveCIXL et3Lxamplt 7tept Campv tJt)(lLO[LlaquoCCUV C1llt HOU-3e[LtlXv 7tOLeLV ot t1X[LtiL 8UYIXVCIXL Campv 8oy[LlaquoCcuVraquo o 8ot) [L 0 0 6 e v t) 7tepl tJt)(lLO[LlaquotltOV 18154 155 laquo86y[LIXCoc A[L(lLKCu6vcuvraquo 0 A l cr X U A IdCL8elt 601 laquo81)[LoU M8oxCIXL tJt)(l(0[LIX-CIXraquo 0 Hpco8LIXlOlt 7105 (jIXOlALXIXilt 8La 86y[LIXtolt IXUCOUlt ex60[Lt)Oevraquo XlXl d tLlt
E I t n b v 0 (q t 0 U v 6 [L 0 u 8 L IX C IX y [L IX t 8 L IX-C IX Y -ij lt Ev Cn evvo(q tIXU-cll Co 86y[LIX cXTClXVtii 7tIXPa IIAIXCwvL Oikcult 6
O[LLAei ev Cn IIoALCtpoundq IXUCOU (320 p 414 H) 7tepl Campv 80Y[LcftCul
149
36ytLoc 3 ampvOPW7t(Jv qJPOVt[J(Jv t7tocv6pO(J[JIX 3e rWV EXOUOt(Jv XIX ampXOUOL(JV [JIXptY)[Jampr(Jv 7t6Ae(J Ouv(1)xtj XOW1)xIX6 1)1 rot tv
7t6AWl WX 0 IT )0 U r IX P X 0 Mor 742D dv re 36y[JML xIXl
bull I re xIXl O[JOAoytIXL xIXl )orepoc 1(IXt
-repIX r(JV 7tP(JrtVraquo
y) E v r 1i cent v v 0 ( r Y v W [J tj () 7t 0 A1)1jJ e (J IX 0-6 e v r L X 3 L oc 0 Xoc Apoundoc amp L W [J r 0 qJ LAO 0 0 p L X 0 uO e-[J e A L W 3 0 u amp p X Ev tLev r1j yevLx1j lVW[Jtj fmoA1j-
amp7tocVr(f ro 36yVA 7tOCPO ITAOCr(JVL 7tX 265C laquorij) WV 7tOAAWV MYtLOCrL Xo p1j[JXtL XPWtLEVOLraquo (B) XIX N6[Jou 7 797C) 7tepl tWV 30y-fLampr(JV 3L3ocOi(OCALWV qnAoOoqJtOC ypound Myo eoU-repo O)r(J 0 KLxeprov 7tepl rWV 30Y[Jampr(Jv OOptoc rWV xeuroXrtjtLfv(Jv xGpo aeO-[JeurLxov 3La rOO amp7t03eX0[Jevou IXOramp 7tIXpIXtY)pet laquoSapientia quae neque de se dubitare debet neque de suis decretis quae philosophi vocant 36y[JIXtoc quorum nullum sine scelere prodi poteritn (Academ priorum 2 9 27) Ev rij) U7tO ro (VO[JIX roG rOCAtjVol) qJepo[Jevltp f3L-[lAtltp De historia philosopbi 3LOCXp(VOVrIXL rEOcrlXpe xeX(JpLn[JevocL qnAoM-
xIXreu60vaeLI 6lV [JLIX ruyxampveL (ltlt[JLOCV tLev t1)V 30y[JIXrL-middot X1)Vraquo)) ExampOrtj oc(pecrt lxeL ra t3LIX My[JXrIX xocO 500v IXtpetn rt 30Y[Jampt(Jv etc rtjrOC OIvocY0[JevtJv laquoxocr lvvOLllv 3e 80y[Jampt(Jv 7tOAlWV 7tpOC I1AAtjAOC Ou[JqJwv(Jv 7tpOC pound1 reAo ampvoccpepovr(JVraquo (Diels Doxo-graphi graeci Berolini 1879 p 6045 6042) ITept 3t oi) APXeOLAOCOU AeyerOCL iSrL xocrt1 rO cpMv6[Jevov [Jampv oxe7trLx6c tv r1j 7tpocy[JocrLx6rtjrL 3 ([J(Jc laquoXocta 8e ampA1j6etocv 30y[Jocrtxo (Ritter und FreIler Rist pbilos graecae Gotha 1898) n 539oc p 440) ITepl
t b 7tAeL6tepoc 3 bApLOroreAtjC (ltPuOtXa 42 )xIXl 7tAetOrOV 7tampvrtJvmiddot 0 ITAOUtIXPX0
Mor14E laquora 7tepl My[JIXtocraquo Mor 797B laquoXIX Myot tWV Mv XIX 7tOALrtXWV ampv-3pwv XIX XPIXt1jO(JOLmiddot v6[J(Jv MVIX[JLV 7i xoc ITAOCt(JV et 7tAeUOeV ta 36 y [J IX r IX v6[Jou xad lpyoc 7tOL1jOetV centv ror 7tpampy[JIXOLVraquo iOOOD laquoxoc MYOL ptjt6p(Jv xIX13 6 y-tL oc r IX 0 0 qJ t 0 t WVraquo 1062E laquolStIXV tLampv ouv [Jtj3evol tWV [JOCXO-[Jev(Jv ampAAO 7tampVr1X o[Jo)oyetV XIX tL6evocL 6eA(JOt 7tOV OOt 301(OUOL Oocu-fltXOt(J) tv r 0 r I 6 y tL oc 0 L O[JOAoytIXv De repugn stoic 1033A t1)v rWV 3 0 y V- amp r (J) v O[JOAoytocv tv torc [ltOLC 6e(JpetaOIXLraquo 1034 B laquoltt 3 6 y [J IX Z 1j V(J) V0 totLV tepa Oewv olxooo[Jetvmiddot lepov
N T It lt - -l l yocp [Jtj-7tOIlOU OCtoV XIXL OCYLOV OUX litltLV Oli IPYOV XOCL IXVOCUO(JV
150 Av3peou
ouSev 1tOAAOU Colot 1 laquo(1tept tOU gtL xltgttamp twv ttMCiJV qnAo-06rplttlv S 6 Y L ltgt t ltgt ooSe tatW)) 0 H 9CiJ S L ltgt v 0 lt 124 laquorpLAOOOrpLotV
lJ0 R oe OU JOYOLlt ouoe oOYJltgttCiJV yVCiJOem OeLvep 0 fjVeL XotL OCiJrppOVL tJLep E1tLOtCiJ-erltgttOraquo - OLOLCiJlt XotL Mocpxolt ( amplt MYLlXtot XotL 6eLeALwSeLlt ampAY)6e((tlt rpLAoerorpLotlt laquoetlt e(tutov 23 )-
IIoAMxLe tamp rpLAoerorpLXa totUt(t MyJltgttot Leta tOU ov6-L(ttolt tOU etGY)YY)tou tCiJV O)tCiJe ( t0 ampOWL(ttOV thlV 6ehlV X(tpot-
we t0 laquoXUPLWt(ttOV thlV II U 6 (t yo P x hl V 30YLoctCiJV)) (IIpotpe1CtLx6e 21 n 21 H Pistelli Leipzig 1888)0 APLGtO-teAl]e 1tept thlV ampypocrpCiJV SOYLoctCuV tOU 11MtCiJvoe (ltPuerLx 42 p 209 14) OLOLlttle xotl tOU r(tAl)VOU rpepeL tov tEtAOV laquo11ep1 thlV I1t-1tOxpamptoue XOL 11AamptWVOe ( KLXepCiJV Lvl)L0veueL tOU Ax(t-aweLxou MYJ(ttoe amplt 6eJeuroALWaOUe IXOA1jlt xe-Xtl)t(tL xupoe u1tOxpeCiJtLxov X()L SeOLeutLXOV SLa toue o1t(t30ue laquoAn-tiochus ad istum locum pressius videbatur accedere Quoniam enim id aberentAcademici decretum (sentitis enim iam hoc me SOYL(t dicere) nibil posse percipi non debere eos in suo decreto sicut in ceteris rebus fluctuariraquo (Acadpr 2 9 29)
a) E v t fl h v 0 (q t 1t P (t X t L X e amp p x 1i e X (t-V 6 v 0 e p U 6 L E 0 Vt 0 e t amp e 1t P amp Le t 0 U amp v a p W1t 0 u Ev tn eurovvoEq totutrJ t0 SOYLot XUPLCiJlt 1totpa toLe ItCiJmiddotcxore OtltCiJe ( E1tL-Xl)tOC SLotGteMeL ta opaa amp1t0 thlV rpltgtUACiJV aOYLamptCiJV ((et opaa SOYL(ttltgt IpoundxeLe X(tAhllt et rp(tUA(t XciXhleraquo 3 9 2 Schenkl Lipsiae 1916 cr 2605) AV(tAOYCiJe thlV exampGtou aOYLcltCiJV ampPZhlV XpEVetotL TroLOtY)e x(tl tOU ampvapW1tOU (3212) To MYLltgt we X(tL tOU xextl]t(tL terxuv xotlxupoe X(taOALXOV xoc1 ampxMvl)tov laquo1t(tVt(tXou yap toXupov t0 a6WIX ampxEVl]tov t0 SOYLotraquo) (316 8)
K(tL totUt1X Lev yeVLXhle 6erov de to a6YLot euroV tn yplXLL(tteEq AeuroyoJeurov IhL ev otut7j to MYL(t GlJJltgtEVeL amp1tOrpotULV
mpl thl1l 1tp(tYLcltCuV 1ELe X(tL taeuro(te 3e tou rpLAoerorpLxou 1tdHou rpLAoerorpLXa SLMY[J(ttot e1tL elte Xota6AOU xocl xotl e1t OV6LottL thlV etGY)YYJthlV (tUthlV (tu6ev-tLXa IXOAhlv tl1tOXpeWtLXamp 3ta taLeAl) (tUthlV euro1tl tou 1tpotXtL-
te XOLVW-VLXOV thlV ampvapW1tCiJv OtL OtOLXerOV Xott yvwpLerLot tOU MYLottoe
a - f f 1l1 x(t ot1toter(te erxeovv otutou tote UfeLe eLVotL to otVCiJtepov X(tL 07) (tVtLxeLLe-VLXOV xupolt otUEleVtEot elv(tL 1tepLttOV XOI1 va
ill7
2 K ocL VYj a Loc 6 x 1)
middotEx t1j II Yj My[1oc xocl iJ1to t1j Kocw1j gv6oc terPOCXLlt ILev croctpamp 01t0 t1jlt t Ji A ) 1 t L t t - n VO[10U tO ouxoc laquoeyevstO ev tOCL 1)ILepocLlt exeWOCt ecY)lvev
6 Y IL oc 1t oc p ltX K oc ( cr oc p 0 lt A uY 0 0 (J t 0 U OC1toypoctpe06oct 1trlOocv tYjv 177 laquoXOCamp oihoL 1tltxvteurolt oc1teVocvtL tampv 0 Y IL oct W v K oc ( 0 oc po 1tpoccrcroucHV (3ocOLMoc Ittepov Myovte eVOCt IY)Oouvraquo 164 laquo6gtlt tltXlt 1t6AeLlt ocuo1lt tpUAOCOOeLV oc 6 I-lL oc t oc tltX xexpLILevoc U1tO tampV OC1t00t6AWvraquo 0 A6yolt 1tepl t1jlt OC1totpocOewlt tiilt ev IepoOoAOILOLO OC1tOOrOALX1j 1tept tampv e6VLxampv ellt XPLOtOV 1tpoOL6vtwv) xocl Ef3p 1123 3ev etVocL f3ef3oc[oc tOU
ypOC1ovto laquot 0 3 6 y IL oc tou f3ocmMwltraquo sepwv )ILWlt ypoctp6vtwv tOUf30t0LAtWraquo (XPLt Nestle 16 31lt 3e ev ij6txj evvo(q
1tpo tampV 10u3ocmiddotx()v eVtoAampv 1)tot EtpeO 215 laquotov v6ILoV t()v ev-tOAampV ev 3 6 Y IL oc 0 L xocl KOAOOO 214 to xoc6
Xetp6ypocltpov t 0 1 lt 3 6 Y IL oc 0 tV () 01tsvocVttov TeAO ev ti K xocl to p1j[1oc KOAOOO
220laquoEt oc1te6ocvete cruv XpLOrltgt OC1tO t()v otOLXetwv tou x60[1ou tt 4 tv x60ILltr
XV 136 AAACt xed Itlt1(PCt IDtAM ((JJ Iou8cdCjl b My(Joc XPY)at(JOltOLet(OGt ltoAMxLlt (xOG(Ct (01 ltLVOCXOC (Ou Leisegang ampltOGvtij 140 qlopamplt )O()-rw YpoundVe(OGL MYOI mpt (ampv 8oy(JtX-
(Wl (ampvaoqlLO(c)1 (Vit Mos 2 212) XOCt(amp1 XocA8OGLWl ampcrpoMywI (Abr 82) 1tept amp1-flPW1tLIWI 80y(JtX(wI bJ dVOGql0Pij ltpOC -rljv KOGI 8LOGlpeaLI (OU Xp61ou (Fuga et inv 57) ltept Etwtxamp1 (IIOGlOGL(Lou XIXI B01)flou De aet mundi 76) KOGI IIAOG(wleLwI 80y(JtX(wI (De aet mundi 17) 01 (J61ol 8t liAM XIX( mpt 80y(JtXtwI (01 Mw()Oewl amp(LIOG aUIaY0l(OGL 8t tVA1)yoptxijl iJEfl68ou (De opif mundi 25 leg alleg 3194 sacrif Abelis 19 post Caini 38) QaOGU1wl YLIe(IXL Myol mpt fleLWI XOGI xy(wv 8oY(Ja(wI ltEpL 80yJamp(wI ijlt OOqlLOGI xocL ij TCt My(JOG(OG ij alXqlamplt 81)AOUot
(ou x6a(Jou (Damp opi mundi 172 lH ltepL (amp1 t7j f)e(IXC ouOlOGlt 8L-alXOXIXA[OG amp1tO(EAetxOGtCt (01 ID(AWIOC 86y(JOG amp1OGYxOGL6tIX(ol atCt (00 omxaOOtijt qlLAO-OOqlLOGlt (Cherub 85)
1 0 iepolt Xpua60(0(Jolt (Ct xwp(OG (OGUtIX wt 36y(JIX(OG 8bJ dlt08qetOGL xltAc) -rltXlt (ou MwOccixou 16(Jou Ett(o KOAOO 2ill ltOGpiX(1)pet laquo(otlt 86y(JOGoL ql1)OIIopoundoLlt 86YiJlXaL tij 1t(crltL OXOUI apxei m(f(EuaOGLraquo (PMGr 62340) mt at t0 EIPea 215 1tIXPIXiJEveL amp(Jql[pP01to laquoT[ ea(LI tV 36y(JOGOL 1) Tl)V 1t(a(LV 0151 ql1)O 86y(JOG IXUTI)1 XOCAc)1 1J TI)I ltOGPOGYyeApoundocl XIXf)wt ItAeyev 6 XptO(6t eycb at AeyW U(JLI (J1] OPYLOfl7jlIXL (SAwtlIPMGr 6239 )- QaOGU1wc xOGi I 0e08ampgtpY)tot et (Jtv to KOAOO 2H 00lt 86y(JOGtOG ampltOaqe(OGt tamplt e6OGyyeALXamplt tV1)fleLOG tCtt amp1OGyxOGpoundoclt elt OCJltI)p[OGII laquo8w-xe at tCt e6OGyyeALXCt 86Y(JOG-i-OG tv tn (olhwl qlUAlXXn TI)1 Ow(1)piOGll tltlXyyevoc-(JevoCraquo (PMGr 82 612B) Et at (il EqleO 215 ltOGpOG(1)pei laquoa6y(JOG(OG ae tijl euOGyye-ALX1]I 8L81XOXOGA(OCl sxwcrevraquo (P MGr82 52ttB) sv OXecreL (JtVLa(oc ltpolt (amplt e6OGyye AtXCt
148 Av3peol) so3cfpou
Ex truvC6[Lou CIXt1ljlt lted)6[Le61XlhL 86y[La Ce
Cn xlXl tii K Cijv COU v6[Lou tOU cXlto(lcfaecult
ev tii evvo(q tampv euoeyyeALxampv
KEltIgtAAAION HI
TO 800rMA EN TII EEOXPUTIANIKII
Ev tj yplX[L[LIXCepoundq Co 86y[LIX ocltlXvCii llltO 8uvlaquo[Le6IX va
) 0E - I - 1IX V t n e v VOL q C t) ( It 0 (l IXI 0 e cu x p 0 cu t i t)-(l t 0 [L IX C 0 8 t) [L 0 (i t 0 u Ev t7i tvvo(q ClXotn O[LtAOUOLV 0 II A laquot (j) v
ev tiil M(VlO IXUtOU 314B Htt ouv amp1 CoU-ccuv tov v6[Lov ellIXL t a 8 6 ( [L IX C IX ClXtltlX XlXt tJt)(ltO[LIXCIX e[Lo( ye 8oxei 8061111 lOLxe COV v6[L0m 0 E e v 0 (l amp v ev Cn Kopou bull6411 laquo8 6 y [L IX bullbullbull 6IXvlaquoCltp IXUCO 1t)[LLou061XUgt 335 dx too-Ctiu e86xeL cnplXCt)yotlt elvlXL 8 6 y[L IX It 0 L 0 IX c 6 IX L Cov lt6Ae[LoV eVIXL) xIXl 6627 laquo1jv yap Campv cnPIXtLCUtampV 8 6 Y [L IX
8t)[L60LIX elvlXL Ca At)(l6tVtIXraquo) OOIXU-cCUlt O[LtAOUOLV b II 0 A U L 0 lt 2046 laquo[LIttamp KOLVOU 86y[LIXC0lt 4264 XOLVOU 86y[LIXtop) xo16132 ev6x ypoundveCIXL et3Lxamplt 7tept Campv tJt)(lLO[LlaquoCCUV C1llt HOU-3e[LtlXv 7tOLeLV ot t1X[LtiL 8UYIXVCIXL Campv 8oy[LlaquoCcuVraquo o 8ot) [L 0 0 6 e v t) 7tepl tJt)(lLO[LlaquotltOV 18154 155 laquo86y[LIXCoc A[L(lLKCu6vcuvraquo 0 A l cr X U A IdCL8elt 601 laquo81)[LoU M8oxCIXL tJt)(l(0[LIX-CIXraquo 0 Hpco8LIXlOlt 7105 (jIXOlALXIXilt 8La 86y[LIXtolt IXUCOUlt ex60[Lt)Oevraquo XlXl d tLlt
E I t n b v 0 (q t 0 U v 6 [L 0 u 8 L IX C IX y [L IX t 8 L IX-C IX Y -ij lt Ev Cn evvo(q tIXU-cll Co 86y[LIX cXTClXVtii 7tIXPa IIAIXCwvL Oikcult 6
O[LLAei ev Cn IIoALCtpoundq IXUCOU (320 p 414 H) 7tepl Campv 80Y[LcftCul
149
36ytLoc 3 ampvOPW7t(Jv qJPOVt[J(Jv t7tocv6pO(J[JIX 3e rWV EXOUOt(Jv XIX ampXOUOL(JV [JIXptY)[Jampr(Jv 7t6Ae(J Ouv(1)xtj XOW1)xIX6 1)1 rot tv
7t6AWl WX 0 IT )0 U r IX P X 0 Mor 742D dv re 36y[JML xIXl
bull I re xIXl O[JOAoytIXL xIXl )orepoc 1(IXt
-repIX r(JV 7tP(JrtVraquo
y) E v r 1i cent v v 0 ( r Y v W [J tj () 7t 0 A1)1jJ e (J IX 0-6 e v r L X 3 L oc 0 Xoc Apoundoc amp L W [J r 0 qJ LAO 0 0 p L X 0 uO e-[J e A L W 3 0 u amp p X Ev tLev r1j yevLx1j lVW[Jtj fmoA1j-
amp7tocVr(f ro 36yVA 7tOCPO ITAOCr(JVL 7tX 265C laquorij) WV 7tOAAWV MYtLOCrL Xo p1j[JXtL XPWtLEVOLraquo (B) XIX N6[Jou 7 797C) 7tepl tWV 30y-fLampr(JV 3L3ocOi(OCALWV qnAoOoqJtOC ypound Myo eoU-repo O)r(J 0 KLxeprov 7tepl rWV 30Y[Jampr(Jv OOptoc rWV xeuroXrtjtLfv(Jv xGpo aeO-[JeurLxov 3La rOO amp7t03eX0[Jevou IXOramp 7tIXpIXtY)pet laquoSapientia quae neque de se dubitare debet neque de suis decretis quae philosophi vocant 36y[JIXtoc quorum nullum sine scelere prodi poteritn (Academ priorum 2 9 27) Ev rij) U7tO ro (VO[JIX roG rOCAtjVol) qJepo[Jevltp f3L-[lAtltp De historia philosopbi 3LOCXp(VOVrIXL rEOcrlXpe xeX(JpLn[JevocL qnAoM-
xIXreu60vaeLI 6lV [JLIX ruyxampveL (ltlt[JLOCV tLev t1)V 30y[JIXrL-middot X1)Vraquo)) ExampOrtj oc(pecrt lxeL ra t3LIX My[JXrIX xocO 500v IXtpetn rt 30Y[Jampt(Jv etc rtjrOC OIvocY0[JevtJv laquoxocr lvvOLllv 3e 80y[Jampt(Jv 7tOAlWV 7tpOC I1AAtjAOC Ou[JqJwv(Jv 7tpOC pound1 reAo ampvoccpepovr(JVraquo (Diels Doxo-graphi graeci Berolini 1879 p 6045 6042) ITept 3t oi) APXeOLAOCOU AeyerOCL iSrL xocrt1 rO cpMv6[Jevov [Jampv oxe7trLx6c tv r1j 7tpocy[JocrLx6rtjrL 3 ([J(Jc laquoXocta 8e ampA1j6etocv 30y[Jocrtxo (Ritter und FreIler Rist pbilos graecae Gotha 1898) n 539oc p 440) ITepl
t b 7tAeL6tepoc 3 bApLOroreAtjC (ltPuOtXa 42 )xIXl 7tAetOrOV 7tampvrtJvmiddot 0 ITAOUtIXPX0
Mor14E laquora 7tepl My[JIXtocraquo Mor 797B laquoXIX Myot tWV Mv XIX 7tOALrtXWV ampv-3pwv XIX XPIXt1jO(JOLmiddot v6[J(Jv MVIX[JLV 7i xoc ITAOCt(JV et 7tAeUOeV ta 36 y [J IX r IX v6[Jou xad lpyoc 7tOL1jOetV centv ror 7tpampy[JIXOLVraquo iOOOD laquoxoc MYOL ptjt6p(Jv xIX13 6 y-tL oc r IX 0 0 qJ t 0 t WVraquo 1062E laquolStIXV tLampv ouv [Jtj3evol tWV [JOCXO-[Jev(Jv ampAAO 7tampVr1X o[Jo)oyetV XIX tL6evocL 6eA(JOt 7tOV OOt 301(OUOL Oocu-fltXOt(J) tv r 0 r I 6 y tL oc 0 L O[JOAoytIXv De repugn stoic 1033A t1)v rWV 3 0 y V- amp r (J) v O[JOAoytocv tv torc [ltOLC 6e(JpetaOIXLraquo 1034 B laquoltt 3 6 y [J IX Z 1j V(J) V0 totLV tepa Oewv olxooo[Jetvmiddot lepov
N T It lt - -l l yocp [Jtj-7tOIlOU OCtoV XIXL OCYLOV OUX litltLV Oli IPYOV XOCL IXVOCUO(JV
150 Av3peou
ouSev 1tOAAOU Colot 1 laquo(1tept tOU gtL xltgttamp twv ttMCiJV qnAo-06rplttlv S 6 Y L ltgt t ltgt ooSe tatW)) 0 H 9CiJ S L ltgt v 0 lt 124 laquorpLAOOOrpLotV
lJ0 R oe OU JOYOLlt ouoe oOYJltgttCiJV yVCiJOem OeLvep 0 fjVeL XotL OCiJrppOVL tJLep E1tLOtCiJ-erltgttOraquo - OLOLCiJlt XotL Mocpxolt ( amplt MYLlXtot XotL 6eLeALwSeLlt ampAY)6e((tlt rpLAoerorpLotlt laquoetlt e(tutov 23 )-
IIoAMxLe tamp rpLAoerorpLXa totUt(t MyJltgttot Leta tOU ov6-L(ttolt tOU etGY)YY)tou tCiJV O)tCiJe ( t0 ampOWL(ttOV thlV 6ehlV X(tpot-
we t0 laquoXUPLWt(ttOV thlV II U 6 (t yo P x hl V 30YLoctCiJV)) (IIpotpe1CtLx6e 21 n 21 H Pistelli Leipzig 1888)0 APLGtO-teAl]e 1tept thlV ampypocrpCiJV SOYLoctCuV tOU 11MtCiJvoe (ltPuerLx 42 p 209 14) OLOLlttle xotl tOU r(tAl)VOU rpepeL tov tEtAOV laquo11ep1 thlV I1t-1tOxpamptoue XOL 11AamptWVOe ( KLXepCiJV Lvl)L0veueL tOU Ax(t-aweLxou MYJ(ttoe amplt 6eJeuroALWaOUe IXOA1jlt xe-Xtl)t(tL xupoe u1tOxpeCiJtLxov X()L SeOLeutLXOV SLa toue o1t(t30ue laquoAn-tiochus ad istum locum pressius videbatur accedere Quoniam enim id aberentAcademici decretum (sentitis enim iam hoc me SOYL(t dicere) nibil posse percipi non debere eos in suo decreto sicut in ceteris rebus fluctuariraquo (Acadpr 2 9 29)
a) E v t fl h v 0 (q t 1t P (t X t L X e amp p x 1i e X (t-V 6 v 0 e p U 6 L E 0 Vt 0 e t amp e 1t P amp Le t 0 U amp v a p W1t 0 u Ev tn eurovvoEq totutrJ t0 SOYLot XUPLCiJlt 1totpa toLe ItCiJmiddotcxore OtltCiJe ( E1tL-Xl)tOC SLotGteMeL ta opaa amp1t0 thlV rpltgtUACiJV aOYLamptCiJV ((et opaa SOYL(ttltgt IpoundxeLe X(tAhllt et rp(tUA(t XciXhleraquo 3 9 2 Schenkl Lipsiae 1916 cr 2605) AV(tAOYCiJe thlV exampGtou aOYLcltCiJV ampPZhlV XpEVetotL TroLOtY)e x(tl tOU ampvapW1tOU (3212) To MYLltgt we X(tL tOU xextl]t(tL terxuv xotlxupoe X(taOALXOV xoc1 ampxMvl)tov laquo1t(tVt(tXou yap toXupov t0 a6WIX ampxEVl]tov t0 SOYLotraquo) (316 8)
K(tL totUt1X Lev yeVLXhle 6erov de to a6YLot euroV tn yplXLL(tteEq AeuroyoJeurov IhL ev otut7j to MYL(t GlJJltgtEVeL amp1tOrpotULV
mpl thl1l 1tp(tYLcltCuV 1ELe X(tL taeuro(te 3e tou rpLAoerorpLxou 1tdHou rpLAoerorpLXa SLMY[J(ttot e1tL elte Xota6AOU xocl xotl e1t OV6LottL thlV etGY)YYJthlV (tUthlV (tu6ev-tLXa IXOAhlv tl1tOXpeWtLXamp 3ta taLeAl) (tUthlV euro1tl tou 1tpotXtL-
te XOLVW-VLXOV thlV ampvapW1tCiJv OtL OtOLXerOV Xott yvwpLerLot tOU MYLottoe
a - f f 1l1 x(t ot1toter(te erxeovv otutou tote UfeLe eLVotL to otVCiJtepov X(tL 07) (tVtLxeLLe-VLXOV xupolt otUEleVtEot elv(tL 1tepLttOV XOI1 va
148 Av3peol) so3cfpou
Ex truvC6[Lou CIXt1ljlt lted)6[Le61XlhL 86y[La Ce
Cn xlXl tii K Cijv COU v6[Lou tOU cXlto(lcfaecult
ev tii evvo(q tampv euoeyyeALxampv
KEltIgtAAAION HI
TO 800rMA EN TII EEOXPUTIANIKII
Ev tj yplX[L[LIXCepoundq Co 86y[LIX ocltlXvCii llltO 8uvlaquo[Le6IX va
) 0E - I - 1IX V t n e v VOL q C t) ( It 0 (l IXI 0 e cu x p 0 cu t i t)-(l t 0 [L IX C 0 8 t) [L 0 (i t 0 u Ev t7i tvvo(q ClXotn O[LtAOUOLV 0 II A laquot (j) v
ev tiil M(VlO IXUtOU 314B Htt ouv amp1 CoU-ccuv tov v6[Lov ellIXL t a 8 6 ( [L IX C IX ClXtltlX XlXt tJt)(ltO[LIXCIX e[Lo( ye 8oxei 8061111 lOLxe COV v6[L0m 0 E e v 0 (l amp v ev Cn Kopou bull6411 laquo8 6 y [L IX bullbullbull 6IXvlaquoCltp IXUCO 1t)[LLou061XUgt 335 dx too-Ctiu e86xeL cnplXCt)yotlt elvlXL 8 6 y[L IX It 0 L 0 IX c 6 IX L Cov lt6Ae[LoV eVIXL) xIXl 6627 laquo1jv yap Campv cnPIXtLCUtampV 8 6 Y [L IX
8t)[L60LIX elvlXL Ca At)(l6tVtIXraquo) OOIXU-cCUlt O[LtAOUOLV b II 0 A U L 0 lt 2046 laquo[LIttamp KOLVOU 86y[LIXC0lt 4264 XOLVOU 86y[LIXtop) xo16132 ev6x ypoundveCIXL et3Lxamplt 7tept Campv tJt)(lLO[LlaquoCCUV C1llt HOU-3e[LtlXv 7tOLeLV ot t1X[LtiL 8UYIXVCIXL Campv 8oy[LlaquoCcuVraquo o 8ot) [L 0 0 6 e v t) 7tepl tJt)(lLO[LlaquotltOV 18154 155 laquo86y[LIXCoc A[L(lLKCu6vcuvraquo 0 A l cr X U A IdCL8elt 601 laquo81)[LoU M8oxCIXL tJt)(l(0[LIX-CIXraquo 0 Hpco8LIXlOlt 7105 (jIXOlALXIXilt 8La 86y[LIXtolt IXUCOUlt ex60[Lt)Oevraquo XlXl d tLlt
E I t n b v 0 (q t 0 U v 6 [L 0 u 8 L IX C IX y [L IX t 8 L IX-C IX Y -ij lt Ev Cn evvo(q tIXU-cll Co 86y[LIX cXTClXVtii 7tIXPa IIAIXCwvL Oikcult 6
O[LLAei ev Cn IIoALCtpoundq IXUCOU (320 p 414 H) 7tepl Campv 80Y[LcftCul
149
36ytLoc 3 ampvOPW7t(Jv qJPOVt[J(Jv t7tocv6pO(J[JIX 3e rWV EXOUOt(Jv XIX ampXOUOL(JV [JIXptY)[Jampr(Jv 7t6Ae(J Ouv(1)xtj XOW1)xIX6 1)1 rot tv
7t6AWl WX 0 IT )0 U r IX P X 0 Mor 742D dv re 36y[JML xIXl
bull I re xIXl O[JOAoytIXL xIXl )orepoc 1(IXt
-repIX r(JV 7tP(JrtVraquo
y) E v r 1i cent v v 0 ( r Y v W [J tj () 7t 0 A1)1jJ e (J IX 0-6 e v r L X 3 L oc 0 Xoc Apoundoc amp L W [J r 0 qJ LAO 0 0 p L X 0 uO e-[J e A L W 3 0 u amp p X Ev tLev r1j yevLx1j lVW[Jtj fmoA1j-
amp7tocVr(f ro 36yVA 7tOCPO ITAOCr(JVL 7tX 265C laquorij) WV 7tOAAWV MYtLOCrL Xo p1j[JXtL XPWtLEVOLraquo (B) XIX N6[Jou 7 797C) 7tepl tWV 30y-fLampr(JV 3L3ocOi(OCALWV qnAoOoqJtOC ypound Myo eoU-repo O)r(J 0 KLxeprov 7tepl rWV 30Y[Jampr(Jv OOptoc rWV xeuroXrtjtLfv(Jv xGpo aeO-[JeurLxov 3La rOO amp7t03eX0[Jevou IXOramp 7tIXpIXtY)pet laquoSapientia quae neque de se dubitare debet neque de suis decretis quae philosophi vocant 36y[JIXtoc quorum nullum sine scelere prodi poteritn (Academ priorum 2 9 27) Ev rij) U7tO ro (VO[JIX roG rOCAtjVol) qJepo[Jevltp f3L-[lAtltp De historia philosopbi 3LOCXp(VOVrIXL rEOcrlXpe xeX(JpLn[JevocL qnAoM-
xIXreu60vaeLI 6lV [JLIX ruyxampveL (ltlt[JLOCV tLev t1)V 30y[JIXrL-middot X1)Vraquo)) ExampOrtj oc(pecrt lxeL ra t3LIX My[JXrIX xocO 500v IXtpetn rt 30Y[Jampt(Jv etc rtjrOC OIvocY0[JevtJv laquoxocr lvvOLllv 3e 80y[Jampt(Jv 7tOAlWV 7tpOC I1AAtjAOC Ou[JqJwv(Jv 7tpOC pound1 reAo ampvoccpepovr(JVraquo (Diels Doxo-graphi graeci Berolini 1879 p 6045 6042) ITept 3t oi) APXeOLAOCOU AeyerOCL iSrL xocrt1 rO cpMv6[Jevov [Jampv oxe7trLx6c tv r1j 7tpocy[JocrLx6rtjrL 3 ([J(Jc laquoXocta 8e ampA1j6etocv 30y[Jocrtxo (Ritter und FreIler Rist pbilos graecae Gotha 1898) n 539oc p 440) ITepl
t b 7tAeL6tepoc 3 bApLOroreAtjC (ltPuOtXa 42 )xIXl 7tAetOrOV 7tampvrtJvmiddot 0 ITAOUtIXPX0
Mor14E laquora 7tepl My[JIXtocraquo Mor 797B laquoXIX Myot tWV Mv XIX 7tOALrtXWV ampv-3pwv XIX XPIXt1jO(JOLmiddot v6[J(Jv MVIX[JLV 7i xoc ITAOCt(JV et 7tAeUOeV ta 36 y [J IX r IX v6[Jou xad lpyoc 7tOL1jOetV centv ror 7tpampy[JIXOLVraquo iOOOD laquoxoc MYOL ptjt6p(Jv xIX13 6 y-tL oc r IX 0 0 qJ t 0 t WVraquo 1062E laquolStIXV tLampv ouv [Jtj3evol tWV [JOCXO-[Jev(Jv ampAAO 7tampVr1X o[Jo)oyetV XIX tL6evocL 6eA(JOt 7tOV OOt 301(OUOL Oocu-fltXOt(J) tv r 0 r I 6 y tL oc 0 L O[JOAoytIXv De repugn stoic 1033A t1)v rWV 3 0 y V- amp r (J) v O[JOAoytocv tv torc [ltOLC 6e(JpetaOIXLraquo 1034 B laquoltt 3 6 y [J IX Z 1j V(J) V0 totLV tepa Oewv olxooo[Jetvmiddot lepov
N T It lt - -l l yocp [Jtj-7tOIlOU OCtoV XIXL OCYLOV OUX litltLV Oli IPYOV XOCL IXVOCUO(JV
150 Av3peou
ouSev 1tOAAOU Colot 1 laquo(1tept tOU gtL xltgttamp twv ttMCiJV qnAo-06rplttlv S 6 Y L ltgt t ltgt ooSe tatW)) 0 H 9CiJ S L ltgt v 0 lt 124 laquorpLAOOOrpLotV
lJ0 R oe OU JOYOLlt ouoe oOYJltgttCiJV yVCiJOem OeLvep 0 fjVeL XotL OCiJrppOVL tJLep E1tLOtCiJ-erltgttOraquo - OLOLCiJlt XotL Mocpxolt ( amplt MYLlXtot XotL 6eLeALwSeLlt ampAY)6e((tlt rpLAoerorpLotlt laquoetlt e(tutov 23 )-
IIoAMxLe tamp rpLAoerorpLXa totUt(t MyJltgttot Leta tOU ov6-L(ttolt tOU etGY)YY)tou tCiJV O)tCiJe ( t0 ampOWL(ttOV thlV 6ehlV X(tpot-
we t0 laquoXUPLWt(ttOV thlV II U 6 (t yo P x hl V 30YLoctCiJV)) (IIpotpe1CtLx6e 21 n 21 H Pistelli Leipzig 1888)0 APLGtO-teAl]e 1tept thlV ampypocrpCiJV SOYLoctCuV tOU 11MtCiJvoe (ltPuerLx 42 p 209 14) OLOLlttle xotl tOU r(tAl)VOU rpepeL tov tEtAOV laquo11ep1 thlV I1t-1tOxpamptoue XOL 11AamptWVOe ( KLXepCiJV Lvl)L0veueL tOU Ax(t-aweLxou MYJ(ttoe amplt 6eJeuroALWaOUe IXOA1jlt xe-Xtl)t(tL xupoe u1tOxpeCiJtLxov X()L SeOLeutLXOV SLa toue o1t(t30ue laquoAn-tiochus ad istum locum pressius videbatur accedere Quoniam enim id aberentAcademici decretum (sentitis enim iam hoc me SOYL(t dicere) nibil posse percipi non debere eos in suo decreto sicut in ceteris rebus fluctuariraquo (Acadpr 2 9 29)
a) E v t fl h v 0 (q t 1t P (t X t L X e amp p x 1i e X (t-V 6 v 0 e p U 6 L E 0 Vt 0 e t amp e 1t P amp Le t 0 U amp v a p W1t 0 u Ev tn eurovvoEq totutrJ t0 SOYLot XUPLCiJlt 1totpa toLe ItCiJmiddotcxore OtltCiJe ( E1tL-Xl)tOC SLotGteMeL ta opaa amp1t0 thlV rpltgtUACiJV aOYLamptCiJV ((et opaa SOYL(ttltgt IpoundxeLe X(tAhllt et rp(tUA(t XciXhleraquo 3 9 2 Schenkl Lipsiae 1916 cr 2605) AV(tAOYCiJe thlV exampGtou aOYLcltCiJV ampPZhlV XpEVetotL TroLOtY)e x(tl tOU ampvapW1tOU (3212) To MYLltgt we X(tL tOU xextl]t(tL terxuv xotlxupoe X(taOALXOV xoc1 ampxMvl)tov laquo1t(tVt(tXou yap toXupov t0 a6WIX ampxEVl]tov t0 SOYLotraquo) (316 8)
K(tL totUt1X Lev yeVLXhle 6erov de to a6YLot euroV tn yplXLL(tteEq AeuroyoJeurov IhL ev otut7j to MYL(t GlJJltgtEVeL amp1tOrpotULV
mpl thl1l 1tp(tYLcltCuV 1ELe X(tL taeuro(te 3e tou rpLAoerorpLxou 1tdHou rpLAoerorpLXa SLMY[J(ttot e1tL elte Xota6AOU xocl xotl e1t OV6LottL thlV etGY)YYJthlV (tUthlV (tu6ev-tLXa IXOAhlv tl1tOXpeWtLXamp 3ta taLeAl) (tUthlV euro1tl tou 1tpotXtL-
te XOLVW-VLXOV thlV ampvapW1tCiJv OtL OtOLXerOV Xott yvwpLerLot tOU MYLottoe
a - f f 1l1 x(t ot1toter(te erxeovv otutou tote UfeLe eLVotL to otVCiJtepov X(tL 07) (tVtLxeLLe-VLXOV xupolt otUEleVtEot elv(tL 1tepLttOV XOI1 va
149
36ytLoc 3 ampvOPW7t(Jv qJPOVt[J(Jv t7tocv6pO(J[JIX 3e rWV EXOUOt(Jv XIX ampXOUOL(JV [JIXptY)[Jampr(Jv 7t6Ae(J Ouv(1)xtj XOW1)xIX6 1)1 rot tv
7t6AWl WX 0 IT )0 U r IX P X 0 Mor 742D dv re 36y[JML xIXl
bull I re xIXl O[JOAoytIXL xIXl )orepoc 1(IXt
-repIX r(JV 7tP(JrtVraquo
y) E v r 1i cent v v 0 ( r Y v W [J tj () 7t 0 A1)1jJ e (J IX 0-6 e v r L X 3 L oc 0 Xoc Apoundoc amp L W [J r 0 qJ LAO 0 0 p L X 0 uO e-[J e A L W 3 0 u amp p X Ev tLev r1j yevLx1j lVW[Jtj fmoA1j-
amp7tocVr(f ro 36yVA 7tOCPO ITAOCr(JVL 7tX 265C laquorij) WV 7tOAAWV MYtLOCrL Xo p1j[JXtL XPWtLEVOLraquo (B) XIX N6[Jou 7 797C) 7tepl tWV 30y-fLampr(JV 3L3ocOi(OCALWV qnAoOoqJtOC ypound Myo eoU-repo O)r(J 0 KLxeprov 7tepl rWV 30Y[Jampr(Jv OOptoc rWV xeuroXrtjtLfv(Jv xGpo aeO-[JeurLxov 3La rOO amp7t03eX0[Jevou IXOramp 7tIXpIXtY)pet laquoSapientia quae neque de se dubitare debet neque de suis decretis quae philosophi vocant 36y[JIXtoc quorum nullum sine scelere prodi poteritn (Academ priorum 2 9 27) Ev rij) U7tO ro (VO[JIX roG rOCAtjVol) qJepo[Jevltp f3L-[lAtltp De historia philosopbi 3LOCXp(VOVrIXL rEOcrlXpe xeX(JpLn[JevocL qnAoM-
xIXreu60vaeLI 6lV [JLIX ruyxampveL (ltlt[JLOCV tLev t1)V 30y[JIXrL-middot X1)Vraquo)) ExampOrtj oc(pecrt lxeL ra t3LIX My[JXrIX xocO 500v IXtpetn rt 30Y[Jampt(Jv etc rtjrOC OIvocY0[JevtJv laquoxocr lvvOLllv 3e 80y[Jampt(Jv 7tOAlWV 7tpOC I1AAtjAOC Ou[JqJwv(Jv 7tpOC pound1 reAo ampvoccpepovr(JVraquo (Diels Doxo-graphi graeci Berolini 1879 p 6045 6042) ITept 3t oi) APXeOLAOCOU AeyerOCL iSrL xocrt1 rO cpMv6[Jevov [Jampv oxe7trLx6c tv r1j 7tpocy[JocrLx6rtjrL 3 ([J(Jc laquoXocta 8e ampA1j6etocv 30y[Jocrtxo (Ritter und FreIler Rist pbilos graecae Gotha 1898) n 539oc p 440) ITepl
t b 7tAeL6tepoc 3 bApLOroreAtjC (ltPuOtXa 42 )xIXl 7tAetOrOV 7tampvrtJvmiddot 0 ITAOUtIXPX0
Mor14E laquora 7tepl My[JIXtocraquo Mor 797B laquoXIX Myot tWV Mv XIX 7tOALrtXWV ampv-3pwv XIX XPIXt1jO(JOLmiddot v6[J(Jv MVIX[JLV 7i xoc ITAOCt(JV et 7tAeUOeV ta 36 y [J IX r IX v6[Jou xad lpyoc 7tOL1jOetV centv ror 7tpampy[JIXOLVraquo iOOOD laquoxoc MYOL ptjt6p(Jv xIX13 6 y-tL oc r IX 0 0 qJ t 0 t WVraquo 1062E laquolStIXV tLampv ouv [Jtj3evol tWV [JOCXO-[Jev(Jv ampAAO 7tampVr1X o[Jo)oyetV XIX tL6evocL 6eA(JOt 7tOV OOt 301(OUOL Oocu-fltXOt(J) tv r 0 r I 6 y tL oc 0 L O[JOAoytIXv De repugn stoic 1033A t1)v rWV 3 0 y V- amp r (J) v O[JOAoytocv tv torc [ltOLC 6e(JpetaOIXLraquo 1034 B laquoltt 3 6 y [J IX Z 1j V(J) V0 totLV tepa Oewv olxooo[Jetvmiddot lepov
N T It lt - -l l yocp [Jtj-7tOIlOU OCtoV XIXL OCYLOV OUX litltLV Oli IPYOV XOCL IXVOCUO(JV
150 Av3peou
ouSev 1tOAAOU Colot 1 laquo(1tept tOU gtL xltgttamp twv ttMCiJV qnAo-06rplttlv S 6 Y L ltgt t ltgt ooSe tatW)) 0 H 9CiJ S L ltgt v 0 lt 124 laquorpLAOOOrpLotV
lJ0 R oe OU JOYOLlt ouoe oOYJltgttCiJV yVCiJOem OeLvep 0 fjVeL XotL OCiJrppOVL tJLep E1tLOtCiJ-erltgttOraquo - OLOLCiJlt XotL Mocpxolt ( amplt MYLlXtot XotL 6eLeALwSeLlt ampAY)6e((tlt rpLAoerorpLotlt laquoetlt e(tutov 23 )-
IIoAMxLe tamp rpLAoerorpLXa totUt(t MyJltgttot Leta tOU ov6-L(ttolt tOU etGY)YY)tou tCiJV O)tCiJe ( t0 ampOWL(ttOV thlV 6ehlV X(tpot-
we t0 laquoXUPLWt(ttOV thlV II U 6 (t yo P x hl V 30YLoctCiJV)) (IIpotpe1CtLx6e 21 n 21 H Pistelli Leipzig 1888)0 APLGtO-teAl]e 1tept thlV ampypocrpCiJV SOYLoctCuV tOU 11MtCiJvoe (ltPuerLx 42 p 209 14) OLOLlttle xotl tOU r(tAl)VOU rpepeL tov tEtAOV laquo11ep1 thlV I1t-1tOxpamptoue XOL 11AamptWVOe ( KLXepCiJV Lvl)L0veueL tOU Ax(t-aweLxou MYJ(ttoe amplt 6eJeuroALWaOUe IXOA1jlt xe-Xtl)t(tL xupoe u1tOxpeCiJtLxov X()L SeOLeutLXOV SLa toue o1t(t30ue laquoAn-tiochus ad istum locum pressius videbatur accedere Quoniam enim id aberentAcademici decretum (sentitis enim iam hoc me SOYL(t dicere) nibil posse percipi non debere eos in suo decreto sicut in ceteris rebus fluctuariraquo (Acadpr 2 9 29)
a) E v t fl h v 0 (q t 1t P (t X t L X e amp p x 1i e X (t-V 6 v 0 e p U 6 L E 0 Vt 0 e t amp e 1t P amp Le t 0 U amp v a p W1t 0 u Ev tn eurovvoEq totutrJ t0 SOYLot XUPLCiJlt 1totpa toLe ItCiJmiddotcxore OtltCiJe ( E1tL-Xl)tOC SLotGteMeL ta opaa amp1t0 thlV rpltgtUACiJV aOYLamptCiJV ((et opaa SOYL(ttltgt IpoundxeLe X(tAhllt et rp(tUA(t XciXhleraquo 3 9 2 Schenkl Lipsiae 1916 cr 2605) AV(tAOYCiJe thlV exampGtou aOYLcltCiJV ampPZhlV XpEVetotL TroLOtY)e x(tl tOU ampvapW1tOU (3212) To MYLltgt we X(tL tOU xextl]t(tL terxuv xotlxupoe X(taOALXOV xoc1 ampxMvl)tov laquo1t(tVt(tXou yap toXupov t0 a6WIX ampxEVl]tov t0 SOYLotraquo) (316 8)
K(tL totUt1X Lev yeVLXhle 6erov de to a6YLot euroV tn yplXLL(tteEq AeuroyoJeurov IhL ev otut7j to MYL(t GlJJltgtEVeL amp1tOrpotULV
mpl thl1l 1tp(tYLcltCuV 1ELe X(tL taeuro(te 3e tou rpLAoerorpLxou 1tdHou rpLAoerorpLXa SLMY[J(ttot e1tL elte Xota6AOU xocl xotl e1t OV6LottL thlV etGY)YYJthlV (tUthlV (tu6ev-tLXa IXOAhlv tl1tOXpeWtLXamp 3ta taLeAl) (tUthlV euro1tl tou 1tpotXtL-
te XOLVW-VLXOV thlV ampvapW1tCiJv OtL OtOLXerOV Xott yvwpLerLot tOU MYLottoe
a - f f 1l1 x(t ot1toter(te erxeovv otutou tote UfeLe eLVotL to otVCiJtepov X(tL 07) (tVtLxeLLe-VLXOV xupolt otUEleVtEot elv(tL 1tepLttOV XOI1 va
150 Av3peou
ouSev 1tOAAOU Colot 1 laquo(1tept tOU gtL xltgttamp twv ttMCiJV qnAo-06rplttlv S 6 Y L ltgt t ltgt ooSe tatW)) 0 H 9CiJ S L ltgt v 0 lt 124 laquorpLAOOOrpLotV
lJ0 R oe OU JOYOLlt ouoe oOYJltgttCiJV yVCiJOem OeLvep 0 fjVeL XotL OCiJrppOVL tJLep E1tLOtCiJ-erltgttOraquo - OLOLCiJlt XotL Mocpxolt ( amplt MYLlXtot XotL 6eLeALwSeLlt ampAY)6e((tlt rpLAoerorpLotlt laquoetlt e(tutov 23 )-
IIoAMxLe tamp rpLAoerorpLXa totUt(t MyJltgttot Leta tOU ov6-L(ttolt tOU etGY)YY)tou tCiJV O)tCiJe ( t0 ampOWL(ttOV thlV 6ehlV X(tpot-
we t0 laquoXUPLWt(ttOV thlV II U 6 (t yo P x hl V 30YLoctCiJV)) (IIpotpe1CtLx6e 21 n 21 H Pistelli Leipzig 1888)0 APLGtO-teAl]e 1tept thlV ampypocrpCiJV SOYLoctCuV tOU 11MtCiJvoe (ltPuerLx 42 p 209 14) OLOLlttle xotl tOU r(tAl)VOU rpepeL tov tEtAOV laquo11ep1 thlV I1t-1tOxpamptoue XOL 11AamptWVOe ( KLXepCiJV Lvl)L0veueL tOU Ax(t-aweLxou MYJ(ttoe amplt 6eJeuroALWaOUe IXOA1jlt xe-Xtl)t(tL xupoe u1tOxpeCiJtLxov X()L SeOLeutLXOV SLa toue o1t(t30ue laquoAn-tiochus ad istum locum pressius videbatur accedere Quoniam enim id aberentAcademici decretum (sentitis enim iam hoc me SOYL(t dicere) nibil posse percipi non debere eos in suo decreto sicut in ceteris rebus fluctuariraquo (Acadpr 2 9 29)
a) E v t fl h v 0 (q t 1t P (t X t L X e amp p x 1i e X (t-V 6 v 0 e p U 6 L E 0 Vt 0 e t amp e 1t P amp Le t 0 U amp v a p W1t 0 u Ev tn eurovvoEq totutrJ t0 SOYLot XUPLCiJlt 1totpa toLe ItCiJmiddotcxore OtltCiJe ( E1tL-Xl)tOC SLotGteMeL ta opaa amp1t0 thlV rpltgtUACiJV aOYLamptCiJV ((et opaa SOYL(ttltgt IpoundxeLe X(tAhllt et rp(tUA(t XciXhleraquo 3 9 2 Schenkl Lipsiae 1916 cr 2605) AV(tAOYCiJe thlV exampGtou aOYLcltCiJV ampPZhlV XpEVetotL TroLOtY)e x(tl tOU ampvapW1tOU (3212) To MYLltgt we X(tL tOU xextl]t(tL terxuv xotlxupoe X(taOALXOV xoc1 ampxMvl)tov laquo1t(tVt(tXou yap toXupov t0 a6WIX ampxEVl]tov t0 SOYLotraquo) (316 8)
K(tL totUt1X Lev yeVLXhle 6erov de to a6YLot euroV tn yplXLL(tteEq AeuroyoJeurov IhL ev otut7j to MYL(t GlJJltgtEVeL amp1tOrpotULV
mpl thl1l 1tp(tYLcltCuV 1ELe X(tL taeuro(te 3e tou rpLAoerorpLxou 1tdHou rpLAoerorpLXa SLMY[J(ttot e1tL elte Xota6AOU xocl xotl e1t OV6LottL thlV etGY)YYJthlV (tUthlV (tu6ev-tLXa IXOAhlv tl1tOXpeWtLXamp 3ta taLeAl) (tUthlV euro1tl tou 1tpotXtL-
te XOLVW-VLXOV thlV ampvapW1tCiJv OtL OtOLXerOV Xott yvwpLerLot tOU MYLottoe
a - f f 1l1 x(t ot1toter(te erxeovv otutou tote UfeLe eLVotL to otVCiJtepov X(tL 07) (tVtLxeLLe-VLXOV xupolt otUEleVtEot elv(tL 1tepLttOV XOI1 va