Dear AIP Com.Nagesh,

~ Common Member’s Humble Opinion ~

I read with concern the messages that were shared among members, the first one

from you, the second one by Com.JP in reply to your first one and your subsequent

counter to his reply, all happening within 24 hrs of an incident that was the subject of

the messages.

Those messages are reproduced at the end.

I am also in possession of other materials that were circulated amongst members

regarding the Agra Federal Council Report, Kolkatta NEC report and a copy of a report

titled CRIME 11/2013 in the Court of CJMC, Tvpm, which I am sure, are available

with you.

It is matter of concern for all of us and that cannot be denied.

But, I am perplexed to understand that you have decided to settle the issue through

short messages.

What I understand is that neither you nor the SG Com.Vivek Singh were present at

the place, during the occurrence. Probably, both of you would have had telephonic

conversation with others who were present in the scene and decided your next course

of action.

I feel, it would have been prudent to have discussed and analyzed about the

happenings in the presence of our CS members.

An individual deciding on a sensitive issue, after telephonic conversation results only

in churning out emotions. This is a matter which appears to be in the hands of an

external body (police, cybercrime etc).

I feel, you should have exercised caution, and taken advice from the elite CS members

before circulating sensitive news to all common members.

Frankly admitting, we – the common members are not well informed about any of

these happenings.

I am also sure, most of the NEC & CS members also may not be aware of everything

related to this issue.

There are two individuals who are involved and both of them must be aware of the

background of the episode.

It is disappointing that you circulated messages which only compound the confusion

as you have not mentioned the contents of the complaint and preferred only to name

the complainant.

It is only fair on the part of common members, to have a convincing message from

you.

What clearly appears is the degeneration of high moral grounds in people who are

supposed to set standards for members.

In our Organization, there is a system of how to decide on an issue and finalyze and

how to communicate to the common members, which you are aware of.

Unfortunately, the leaders have clearly understood that it is easier to whip up the

emotions and make something convincing rather than proper reasoning after a joint

consultation.

The charges you place against Com.JP in your second message, unfortunately apply

to your current style of functioning with regard to the current episode of not taking

into the detailed views of the CS.

I know, you are learned, experienced and have come across similar situations in your

successful trade union career.

If your observation of not being provided with copies and other official documents is

genuine, then sadly you or the SG failed in ensuring the possession of what is NF’s

property.

If the incidents of such malicious mails attributed to individuals to promote Com.JP

and tarnish the images of you, Com.Vivek Singh & Com.Mihir are true, then that also

should not be spared lightly.

In trade union, unlike politics, two wrongs do not make up for one right and both

wrongs are wrongs and should suffer the same consequences.

It’s only clear from your message that the house (NF) needs cleansing.

It appears that there is something more to the posts (positions of power) than what

we, as common members see.

There appears to be lack of mutual trust amongst the brains that governed / govern

NF.

Perhaps our seasoned leaders have their own game plan and we, the innocent

members continue to repose our good faith in ‘taking for granted’ what they say.

I am sure, you would have anticipated the members reacting to your messages asking

for why there was no information about the day-to-day follow up of SR2009 at

Yogakshema.

You would also felt sympathetic to the genuine concerns of the members when

circulars on meal coupon, Unit Meetings are issued - humiliating and demeaning the

dignity of the cadre.

You would have also been kind enough to see the victims of Special Rules shown the

door and loitering with pending appeals waiting to be heard by the Management or the

Judiciary.

You would definitely accept that we, the common members, are not at all a party to

the current episode but are being fed with the circulation of this hasty message

without any of those details which we have been quite patiently expecting (SR, MC,

UM etc).

The purpose of election to these top posts is only to serve our interest and being

transparent in actions.

I leave it to your wisdom to decide in what way your message in haste in the current

episode is going to strengthen the Federation’s Unity.

You could have waited for a fair trial as the complaint is about moral turpitude (which

can never be compromised at any level, particularly higher levels) and the parties to

this complaint on either side are individuals for whom the common members have

utmost good faith and regards.

The end result of all these communications from both sides is that the members

cannot come to any conclusion; we are confused about the agenda behind; we are

worried whether the cadre’s interest is going to take a back seat.

Please ensure a fair trial; discuss the issue with both parties; take the view of the elite

CS /NEC; ensure that the Federation doesn’t lose its steam in fighting the

Management united and at the same time, we expect fitting action against the guilty.

We Pray,

Leaders Unity Zindabad!

National Federation Zindabad!

Best Wishes & Regards,

~ts.rajan~

Member, NFIFWI

21.01.2015

Appended below are the messages that I received in the last 24 hours.

To all members of NFIFWI through CS/NEC members.

"Black Day for National Federation"

Dear Comrade

Based on a false complaint of R.Jayprakash,, Five Policemen from (Kerala) Trivandram

raided the house of our SG Com.Vivek Singh at Varanasi yesterday (FEDERATION

FOUNDATION DAY). Com Vivek Singh was on the way to Guawati to attend EZ council

meeting. Only Mrs. Vivek Singh was present in the house.

After knowing the information, all comrades of Varanasi Division along with the Division

leaders & ZS(NCZ) rushed to the place.

Police informing that a complaint has been filed by R. Jayprakash at Trivandram & FIR

has been registered, searched the house & confiscated laptop, hard disc & other

gadgets belonging to the Organisation. They have informed that a charge sheet will be

framed & summons to appear in the court at Trivandram will be issued soon.

This type of shameless & dastardly act has never happened in the history of NF. It is an

act of personnel vendetta.

Police personnel entering the house of SG & conducting search operations before the

family members during his absence & in front of the neighbors on a false & politically

motivated complaint.

The entire All Ind leadership condemns the act of R.Jayprakash for conspiring against

our SG Com Vivek Singh & for his deliberate & concerted attempt to derail the ongoing

process of negotiations. His false & politically motivated conspiracy will be exposed

soon. Entire NATIONAL FEDERATION will stand with SECRETARY GENERAL Com.

Vivek Singh.

Detailed letter will be sent to all members shortly

G NAGESH AIP

Com.R.Jayprakash reply message to A.I.P message:-

Dear Com.G.Nagesh,

You have sent a message as the All India President defaming and condemning

R.Jayprakash falsely implying and attributing false allegations against me. You had

understood the truth about the complaint, inspite of which this defaming message

against me is publicised. The fact is that as informed to whole organisation earlier

"Cyber crime Complaint was filed against false and defamatory anti federation (in

2010-2013),anti JP mails through fake and unidentified email id's and not any

individuals". In fact it is a matter of shame that now it is coming to light that the fake

email id belongs to Com.Vivek Singh as per cyber crime investigation. To my shock and

surprise it is a black day for NF to know the truth that a senior leader of NF -Com.Vivek

Singh was operating the fake email id(in 2010-2013) and engaged in anti NF emails

defaming NF and defaming the then SG. I call upon you to take cognisance of the cyber

crime investigation reports and if it is proved, to take severe action against the person

involved (Com Vivek singh as understood ).I also request and call upon you to send the

truthful message to all members immediately withdrawing the false message defaming

me.

Regards.R Jayprakash

(Former SG,NFIFWI)

CC To All CS & NEC members(Through AIP,NFIFWI) and All Members of NFIFWI

Dear J.P,

You had sent a message addressed to me in the social media, copy sent to many. If you

had filed complaint as S.G, why copies were not given to the AIP, C.S and NEC and also

not handed over the important papers to the new team after the FCM, Indore. You failed

to hand over the documents of NFIFWI to the new team even after the request made to

you as per the decision of CS/NEC. This has been your practice of defaming every one

who is not toeing your line. During your period several mails circulated defaming many

CS Members. Highly derogatory mails were sent against me when I was AIP, against

Sri.Vivek Singh when he was AIP, and the mails sent against Sri.Mihir Lokhandwala

when he contested against you in Trivandrum FCM. At that time Sri. E.J.M.Reddy had

admitted in writing that his email i.d was misused for sending all the derogatory mails

against Mihir Lokhandwala by Sri. Rajiv Gulati. In the CS meeting we requested you to

file a complaint under cyber crime. But, you refused to do so saying that organisational

matters must be discussed, settled within the organisation and not to go to court of law

or any outside agency and was accepted by the CS. Now we understand that you had

done this to protect him for his help done to you to win the elections against Sri. Mihir

Lokhandwala. We are not so ignorant and are also aware of your hidden agenda of

defaming the N.F leadership. Henceforth organisation will not restrain and explore all

options including legal action against the forces trying to destabilise the organisation.

G.Nagesh,AIP

Black chapter in the history of NFIFWI

CC: to GS & ZS