legal mall - supreme court of florida · rar^uwany ernt€•vew mhttnet chart+3 ike petiffener in...
TRANSCRIPT
rus n a a>n sopne c r ,
ru rc éte ct ctrørtics Desc<t AT CALHØUN C
,wne, OCTpre,w cower
INMATE INITIALS C - o .2 -3%.2
a 330 ce
j<'£fv NCetf S, î~ctCkck , Ssu€rayR
/:c er2£ût9 Dcf4fliest€wi· G F' c'* Økk€CNeAr,
n><ó e n iHeaw comacrea×n L J>rsrt rurre,yCOJ4ADErv
e(EJP G NDEWTCQ
Q~unt.sDcc reemdL ßRtEr 8< Pat rzoM ER
dlA t c liME L Ctit9nlks Ûe Seg€
c,y ye uw CepRtc Tc «J«>Sri747cerv[96(y 2 Sout trt estu? EMhid'*F)
Dnt'V €
/gls4ptfHoW N, V
LEGAL MAll
e«n nftenr£ of zurenesr esaus
fÂcrics2/9k>le' ÑAMC C4 (IO di
(9M'o/2tv€C/ C>€Ndt4Apgpç1rtrer1€ttr7 o f
Affmens
3 ; Th e M
(16 Í® 'Ý È# r C'r e nt def Zo2 399- do n'¯o
/·faty<rgj¶Ôle dér?fìrt R MAEEÝ
Ô€øtERAL €eCet.v3L2 Otf4AfMiri
of cortpeyrtms
TGt Soûtig Ô?//?cter) ÅÊN€/
}htláhøsee, ft an¼+ 32 39?- 25-oo
1FGAL MAll
Tasis or <~oureur.3 E o 2)
C€Þ7tFre^t97è of Eh7Entg7 PèASciv3
rnece «r cmrenrs -m
779/dl€ of' CtTr97tetVS
P12cb m rett19R cf Sist 76tWrd
Størci«err or fac73
st»wicumpy 44m¢unravr
/7A6uméwr4
s
yggygyg ; DiscRCTraN¢1Ry ÖR/3DrCrtoA, /?EVi€co
<SMouro &£ tycœf7£h krNe'p6® YN€ ftRSr
Des7/Lecf' c*obRT ôF f)ff£ral ifr13 P€st/ r o
Ê€7tfrch€A PAoM €xWACtseyG ifts Reta r9ecess r<r roc cauRr ø9xn eyms o eTN€ D€ÿMA7+1ACNT crP coRø€cieac1rJ rg ce,
btT C tPit /Yt9£y b'Rec€DuR€'S usoDcx SEcr yJW. 279 fr encD4 3røtrures 7<s caea9 öfrirrif€S7 eV Lwjusfec€
®ovvcLt/3/oA/
c artrcenre er scence
LEGAL MAll
Trøstå or cerørean< p
Norco, 2cr/ Arc WJáovrr # t-? Ce·n. 9 ,z 2e p
/ Cas74 Sn th, 93: Lt~5 &t7c V'9/ 97 5.op. éY91 5 tV. 3
37 y /.233, 193¥ ·' 3 3r
+4, ca e $hi t e, 'M G S e>. Po' 930 Cfen 00)
S al em u-. /fe i m, V 4 3 Cr« 5' d ?? , 2 WV C 1973)
/{n 1-cra v . d it9tg ]? ' 2®'Ÿ 4
à<.wries v. sinte, s¼ Sa u W7, s'i¥ Cft, ist ocs earò 7
De3ae y, Sketc, G3? So ·24 VYo (f7n (St ocm 299y)
S fde v.. t99ti (tAry 977 Ja. 2d £233, t933^ Çf7,,,. E'thoCr4 2037)
€<r19te tr. ÈSmqc, 45'b tôt c o7, ¡3_57-,, t o2 S,Cf. 12'3'Er', 72 4£4
24 7(f3 ( tF Era)
rynorrisan v . ¿·.e ferre, s'92 f. Supµ jos~x r 1o71 - ?3 (s2>vy. 19&v) 9
/W ot /f v .. 01/tc Datan ,e il , Yt ? l.e. 3, S'39 (197y)
vv f¼ye K r. Dt99er 5tra Sm 2d / 07 / a7 (fen. mocn 1991)
rtopet>n cursrerarcari
p¶efitte È S*C# Ü't3gætsce £ see. 2
¿ppycie Z 3ec '7
M12 fvt le E
¡Qg NC i c ll\ S ec . 4 0
1774 f e c t< £ .sec, a v W-
17ANste [ 8ec.
rî.,s. cnøsrzn>rran5
¿sr y
fyth
S
arufn 19arriernerte-.c
.5ec. fvY. 279 F'4namîn . 2 2to (n)Cs)
Rar^uwAny Erntۥvew
Mhttnet Chart<S DeSue ur>+3 ike Petiffener in th C 7
Cntineurg Ccurr Orc ut / Courf a n C prse n o. ; y
f,ye4 n C<jref aF Nnbe43 CarPuS , nn d wiqy ¡t
c t eri Joe C,yed n %f&e Mppent fu the Årst ocafr
1ppen /
Zu (k:5 [o«rtsdecJrønøi Bri-ef he ulti Ô£ c'cArred t
tc;s proper nn,+>< , og its the Pef'h'uner¿ he re ne
is Supporfest by Ak< 'tecards Á, the cer ,r uvnenE,$
p cathourt ¢oun †h P 2 C"' t n
er.sf 73esfr>'tf Owr/ • APPewt Near ude
rq a. to 33s ¢ reurf C t
Pe er hh mer ti re feet al Dc'l er /2 2·t r,vien
spi h|ow , PPC i k ÍÌ ikÊrt?
«s Ít c c h I's A
/ .
47&<car °E' Pner3
ourf eevt(h (J ce f Cers ter f Cwrf art Úc feber 2 o
</s ort er (24 69 kIrrt ej# Éf ings orp:c3 c){ cçàfr
dgetEast 9 u *rrec/cenn/ [ustri¼zdfari A+rder § 77 o S
óv f rovemÓ er o2 3 2 a (t / p
pe/cfr'cn C e Cf r (btr is
f¾ Grdef E9 ete respe
la the fin enz Carpvs ri fe3r
ÍÌ$Sts o n eH erryt Ceon9 e.t / trS f&ar tonrot Oe/e guy 73 A feg n Qe
&nd feÍÌÍrbc1Pr f ePIy .
1%e pebbianer lentned by deÂ+cto <Tudyc filtew Reyr's fer
n order had been enfered arj hes C<tr,y af /k f>en·s Cerfus ®n
,9ry Mr, 20tt , ståecia h IV€d ¼ høbm cupo des n j
(y) vueniks 117fer kÛtich h<S pppen
ced
a cle.rty 23) 2oil ffÊt/ceraer rl-e4 M fef|ftor er e 9fvei
rppest t Yhe First &st½c F Owt et MePent , e.wi d e 4 . r ettse
33o C/1 esfryátt S c<Í Centf òf /hacyr)
. n Ftryf DCf) M5'sr ned (D/b G2
qqsf i3 2ata Genern t Covnse r n1 s De teht'eus Sen f
c yudye rHie,r Rey, s / er #1 9ap re e ord f esrwis
concede'g Sh
c usefzfc'oner's knbeøs' ° f
/9 AffM / ,
Gyj / yusé 3t, 2012 hr O3kra 2 9 'r
ce c>r p·efr'ft é ter h bhs Y ° (d aaaf
be Peer /k cr s n n c fe 2>n e d in tt e3 cvz3p he had be Pren ous pro se
3 Art c flo cre Ótq
fef/frarrec (t) d M l'eSfor15e Mr9t<t here is 176 C'NÊà')
/ f it e Soedherr auri; Aef or f S of f 4 is D as f rek / Coury ert fece
4 * decis e ac,* '9s rey Ct tY • of cander the fr c le \f . See. Y (6) fteriërs
c«nst.ht««n e>¢ n †^'' 'O P""*' *# #3Corrt pro s·e Snnet'onin9 P 4'hord·
9.
c,c .ç.ti,e c t a, z o r 2 4)r z+cec t cour t Gu dj e'S %'a i€, C'enr té , ne d rVinr str'iter
-ere 4 sq decr71cø énnC f' o ffW / 6 C
Depnernaent of Correctrbñs i's corender de's'u'ptinnety 9pnst Peh'frener-
under Sechen 99¼7?9 Viin af., atte3eb9 pefrÜner' had been ® pæuc
pro Ce sancfioned by t<~e Desfrtci- Court sTödge3 en 63my cooMy c,ceo,
Court cAse c1o W-02Gr* tuiccin †>2me ep‡nz'on does net ci+e tLa !? pu6is e
c,9se r%zikerN<q i¼ fue Douthern Coact heP°''fers of flnere been >9 prev?e
pre se SAnctaort Nect'elen'' been entered te ceñ.shtvte a Ley t sø,1cty
pw iWs f=1net h ) -Porther snncti¼n preoced-n3s ar3
n belated nppent , when a ndice of ñppe,,t had nd beein C'red,
hoc k A 4 f¼ be Ed PP ''' #cnn+e d to c'epresent M S y ria hk e
pqqpen t . l eSe bE$ircef Q'udoery v9aea &ût of 1%e Hnders Carpay
int ts not nkjec) w+tfer i the beided a9ppent , nød ca43 cwthout
uris 4r ete on h ass'er f ·the denîài order comcér+n S /Say Coept1y Cercu<t
Courf ense n•_ C¿y_62çÇ.
3
St< nemMy Acceerst€vr
7%e &<g rem e Coca / û Yue im feres f J ust ce e, 7
escretfo.nney JurezdtcMon btrie&>, where étme ces
pAn e l of cTudc,e 3 t^3e ll C4 k , nmet 1-tancsér iter'S h 3
c (<èn fue pefitomer' by bwë3 interest n the se
Ce»tacen) v7 &l#9Vitfegf of 167 usfe'Ct tu)4rch fine ce
pefcite'mer fra:« expostŠ3 htš l'rQury of bei tzn e n,ne
t'q H+f-e pr~is ,rp , usûeck ür dye mi f ,
19ppent i¥a 1999 who Knecos as cuett vts µ< pnne e e
på Per Cures Mffrirm opine'en lethout presde fr'+-·> ns
p,fe-teeveer hns .served 21 trency of t<mtwuAt deten fehn.
p.·~isan thnt the e<rrit est hqbens corpus expose.c p,7e em e j
Couvtty Otecurt Coecrf , So frug pnrief børbarte ly Sincken
betrated 11ppen/ av, usemndte prederr9bù ike P%boner
kn4 been Prevteus ty pro se 5;meNon by n p,,net eG
oi +¾x O'sfraef Cour[ , wi+ew />o Suct--> Grinhben quthors'f<¡ exis
t'n fue ¼14een Co«ei Ref.>rFs .
Ntas fra bezem f c.urt pnnæt hss risiced the Depeurs 4
recfàæis fc> ørb:leneÿ¡uy conduxf drycìptrøøcy proce¾res
Gyntt1sf pete fr oxt er jg ft^< trere br esq f l.» cr A 't3 nnbarem Crve t n g
u^usunt punishmenf , wk.wp (A z jonnel 14•->c«u ¼ betød espp
peett,'em wth nff:<inve'f3 Gem Deparfvueñ/ cf e.creefenq,
Akt o f Cniko¼n C. E, my re
ÔRauniD ars€
skK'7/ownog JWesnacirow /2èvi€r..;
SN~<a räc riecepr£o <:--mené ruc fjæg7
' c r <°c oé7 cf nøres i as ræc.>,yr ,7ePertrience fron, éxén.e,,, ¿¿,3A/Gr+rs 7Ts nécér3 y, 7u e pp ,,a
cW rrwüvr cF ¶>Prd Ec recev3!)UC7' D/Scepinyngry PRe.cgí>ygg
umaEr< áccréoty 99y ,779 feon,-o,9 37,7To ceivcEnl r.) vvtsniprSy cf àMTG .
Sini-c And federn/ ânstefubbn 9ur>r.7mtee's n Person access 1½ th
roarf to Redress ihjuryes under htzficte I ô¢¢· .21 Fim ansfr7utrirn and
under' +1rte i S4 nud ty¼ Armendment Lyhts fu the ws_
.5<yvn v. Divfforî e ; alsti toL 4Y¼2Y8' +V-9 (c.n. 9 r9eit zou
Øounds v-Smi%, 43% Q.3. T27 , Tdi 97 3.Ct. IV74 Fa Ced, pp
Cim), hu! ** ' bad im, mvm Crm·ar*oon now)
A&cte E see. at F7« e,cst, 5 Ín fe,
Access j, co<..<rts.' The. Ccx.trf3 shnli
be opert fa every Per:son for redreSSof i-my thfurvy > rmd.aus/Re ähøl!he adwit'ines feced v><tk«ut sote, deni^b
crr de løy -
i¼is Supre-c Coorg .gocepte d ô&'t%dn'tìm >^n t°eMajne v· S¼fe,
^/?& do.24 930 [m ye,oo) ja review Senefr~ons t'aposed &q t+1x
Dc S treck Cour t c f (?ppen i . fik /cs le f Sec. lY ftñ, Const,
Uvader flu (oMSict rt9ht of 4 Egynt Proteeft'on òf the (nc.o 23 Sntìl
an 19rt«¡+ [ 3ec. 2 aç F7s.const. , and i'a the /V¼ 19mndenenf f, f@
(1-3.Vonstefution thab courf óbou id I ©^!ÈS¢· 4ccerf <Ívrissfùken /-o
(7view Hee first Duftref Qourt·'> October i 2, 2at2 of)inebr> pro s e
SP1mC li'anM9 t he pe in f r'on er a n d the OÒ¤ Õer' I Ti 2 a i x Di're c t¼q r utber)
I*C Depnefmen·f of CorrecfEons to kke acÈi'an r9pæt febkoney,
uncler Sectrom 9VV.279 f.3,, is *6erbnric cruel n9md Urjusuhl Purlisip,1
tv1ent. See b6 19mend. ct·3. C'enst., Grficie E 3C<. Il F''f·¢¤"3t.] J i
Heem, yç3 w L 977 e ny C19es); see 19ppendr× Æ in>Cr4 Coctober tz
.2ar1 opinior? >9ad óctaber isì zotR Dr'reekive_ ·lo entkos.zer C E wrteden
Kne petitioner >9sserfs Me O!EÈrdt Court deüs‡on W.utrrr9nt
rvview lay ¼<3 cauí? errhere he open/un rends A P4net az' <fudycs
Inød previously edered pra .spnc fians 199Ainst pet,t e
hi'wt fket if he cenètnue to /le piends unth the Desfrtti e
P°se Snne ficas ref'erryny Ik Departnnent up e¼rree
7C fions ander see f reh 999.279 F?« Sig see 19ppendex !L mA^rt aher t2, 2csez rapinan)
urt 64 net cite to n de O Published a fine Southerrurt 12eps eter's a p
P o Ee~ ínne!ùrn à9Ams ffcb pe o
Court case no.9a 2
hartonríe esSerfion. See ffe P kn v e, 32 pzco p 3
Ü¢A SePfember ti, 2cra )( Published decisebn by Disèreet cwt pr seSancfron A<3ning
Wel(<t n6 pujottshed opInt'er7 hein referr'ence d k by (+e D stref
Court of Petitebner hee y prey sty 3nney
nd nàf a3 A vunèfer oF cw. Se /1gfùte V ·îeCtion yf=tn. FL <Tüd. t9dmin - 2. 2t o c g C i
ern rj i Government
Exeretse of pcsurer andfc<rtsdéc†,vn
udJe3 Shr1/1 ¢c»? s ft fu|-€. ,;7 pryne /
and Shnti consder ench cr+se and
C oncorrrynce s f 19 nujari4 ep
Pnnet shrH! be necessney ¼ y d
FurHnervmore, /ke petitioner hnd not been pro se zonefibned by
he D:sfree f c.<wrl Ar ft~e three Panel of shd9e's utF, cmrk, end
(Vinrsidler k enter 69 Show c19use order sn 199ust- 31, Zol@ Sor
Pehícèrter k s im urhy he skau l d not be senc fr'ane d by hw
A'Ithy 4 betnfed appent of n order,rthech dertied q peh¥ràn ('or
ført t o f kr9herls C orpus c'+ Êerring I¼ DefArt or ee1 y o G Corre C fior?S
for dùcépliañey Procedur'es ta foe conduefe.d acjnins†· peit4,y
Onder § 9yy. g?cy F~tra. Std,
The Derw/went & Wrecbons Generst Counsel on thyast 13
2on j¾es &,rßnen DeÚlîtes conceede Fehléoner is eritrNzd to
è appert t .
TM ¿hsérteé cari t1 dp's ßar%rièty use¿ be/,steg nppe,t pr c
4o enfer 19 iéteyrt/ Snncfi'an Whert Zhd piri7ej =f Utîdjeg o d
enc½ høve durésdetfër> h ¢Œ5:ä'er Ike oro'er Which here oye
Décepé dewed n Pe,44re'j far wrd of knbens c erptes c
vafy cir«urt ¢ourt e nse nwvike °n n% , ß
1s pro s e Ê<7<nj (s n vée rnf r an af /k cow f 3 y
er , Y k e peli j i ë r> ¿eg[n9
u py theriz e d . See 19ppend- )< /L i n ifèn foba i
(turty ti-1ere l's nef previcus sancfr ecis:'on by thib D s e
ouré pra s e snmfabniny Pefifi¼v) , ushere ßeAnfed
?pperti lu4 no/ 6eea grnnfea fu Serve 9s a nohce f nPren/ c nder
pgfiere if sectr'on Y (b) Ce) 54 † Court ¼reepenet e F u~0dge's And A* <J s s3 V H dee s 6,
o f a ujeit a f knben3 CupuS ber ay d e nse </
October Sì zot he Oted n CurNn e fe ir i favl er 19 sser t.s o a
t Gre.,y caod of u u-ty /of thbens CorpuJ a
ncé cbntien9ea '349 a2
g y hør brtet c ("·( 1 / H < Dnk'd C
puc c lett n ñ on Afover r ber 2 3, z o t
7 33ocìq fonol fke rAire f o f /1 hen3 c e nunder cease n
ftthf) d oc tre 4 re e
ce erec /t'on s Yo A1 3P 3 yDeprArfrvien†
qù43< Swy tnal i o
cerwr/ Cwrt CCwn fy
,5fnfe, 5% Se. 3 7
.ff fke cowspinm s tes
Pr r æn fø<r 3roun d 3 fo r retieß
fir e fergy court ^^vSt f53t!<
¼¢ arr,f , reg annj g responsefrom f¼ de·ferülmy Ru f¼r' fy .TG Jo 3V ys-7.
-/pe de Facte *°hyk e pe la frovt er dc d viet reeer've
dernarssnt orderyq 77 Re y es t er's f~e bru Y ¡ eut
y coun set cancedes , n
7
c4 not recetve ff,e Courf de:^'resseri order en /709usi !3, 2ci
sc·57 Êke Op|19tÃn p
Cop men .) ,
^'#'' '# Meut f Cnri dA not pre e peh 1 th
e s t/4t s yn é order UW /r ? QFfy h ofn y c 19,w/ Prpr
M inefree of nppenj ,
On t y 2 39 e 12 he Ot·ed 9 43et&d j•
pur . 10 - 3 30 cn L oc«er TFe ht<ø i ¼ r$c firs t D: s /crcurt Y a c6
e appmi frem G/Geun Gwëy &c-</ cows r
knbens cupus d,smissni arder Ash cm3e na.r 3
2 syt yme d f k m / -.n9s S frrë k'en a3 uvnGu ikset±e d
trau d ßwánric asser Nun fknt Pekkhner had been prevütes t y
3rnnchén by n ~PHnet af duaf9e3 of the Orsfri 4 Court, cm/r
¿)bsolufety na Southern Courj- rzeporters Crh9/son extat. of th
DL s fre c f ü 4 e Cs tsset F- CinrA-, n n d FMnedi Her's ¾3erh¼n ' h C enc arrenee
tiend t's n breakdoto>-) e H our c) dicài SYStew, ik this c4.se
bi s /t t cf pe dy e isSc if È? eq 3 I4't a II'vry f ian k b.e bk3 p
thficarice rios panet C°inric nnd rMørst-fier.s de he ¼s
petikaner le M*E P SMc /h+t he prief<e,pn
im bac/c en 197v . tTud9 *»93 on Pehtioner-3 or
Dppery/ panel 9 3 04'fi 4i nnd '71/en ceu n
92-3otc, on 4~T. #3* C'to. †2-o2çó fut it ey Per Gr FNy
on IUwy 27, (%'t n'"Ha&fed +-r tTwe ty, 29py, Des
G Jy ,ça , 24 †VO (Crvt . L 5'r Oct1 4999)
rtrus p><inct naut (Cnsws in 1992 €nse rio. 92-02% 43
malle Proze uì by /ke Smte AWumey cF¢,4 op q
ft art'¿n o n ty¼ ty 3r /992 , whrch CTA.pe ¢<h/F Mn d GnrGe i
jµ ,¿ rptres, dîd n a / hnv e <)ìscr sd<c j¼n h enf er ihm Per Curt
/4ffèrrn opuŸcèn an C4se e'te. Ty ozac S¼¾eperti fa ike
tit o tte proSeg ea r G H ***f ?j l ŸŸY - 3ee $fn f e + ^?9uI/ne,
9g> ba4 1333, 2233 (frr m M19 2ao
These éd9e's tennes fue Nebexs Gr'ptrs NPoses pefri
C we en / u ø fnt..) A 1 de km f r n ire boC Prow> Fidmi s ser C1 e ß
19 s t t y, t 972 , at hæb hr 3t cf enrS peh ffon er ß, 3
delnsÀed '·''r/de' la*Ete Presegw c4se no. 92- oz
LEGAL gqy
urr'ertify L<vrinecÊutty 4'efrithed fly th+se ba/rècø <yud9e's i j·)pp,ef,
ncçnt by ŒfIsV" J tíféqrg y Snnctib 3 Qg7pg,,µ [k y
G e èt f a ün et 9 n 4 by SÊrüÑent e Êe i Led appen f äng
/ Noveof n's n vnnndest- <n sMe, r'eguir<ny Yha
3 uprern e GJÉ S 7) AÍ't f by &cceptivj3 da.s -
cretianøry r'erri'en) of S case, See £M9te v. d'snne yye, u.3.
(c7 , 1377 /c2 3 Cr. ÉS 7t / ,tV .2 Jg3 Jerrî5c;9
V, E-efettre, 5'92 P/ 505'a, lo71 -'73 CS.T2 y ¿9T(Y V.
/Vic L)annell, YET . E'39 (i9&_
Conc4testetv
/ßused c·.n fke tyr9cwjeñ fs 9
f r espandert f s <fWISCons r eZertot 'u s f,èe An d Žu fre ? ? 3h C
fke traferest <)fef enfer 89 Gr'der Oc epfih3
I,e Suprew e
tartSfee r w °
C€RTEfrC4Ter?sdrëfr ort
p ikrS 3°MJF HUt'!BY O piwce4 w, Ike kmtd
Cut¼ 19ppeet 7 he i t 2 e
)cf M dì, PG oc 7 P
||ffariaCAf Par G 4 GeMerA2 ov''S
bzrASSee e þmssec 7ft 32
pt yout f The Fcerte 9
/ o Ø(eR 11 ø h432e€rt D vrt / Stree f ,Ce«f , S , 2m ,
o g /A t 3
'f AItaictfø5t. C N 6AO S 0)eÃu€
11-7.2 931gCn/hens; Correc/s o »o / 3 e r|9 5'G) Sau fhegf- Zwst et t>†rOses'<reßtacut#s Es e Fe«r• 32
LEGAL MAIL