legal form (81-100)
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
1/58
1
LEGAL FORMS
( FORMS 81-100)
SUBMITTED TO:
HON. JUDGE NORFERIO NONO
Professorial Lecturer
SUBMITTED BY:
JOSEPH D. DAJAY
Student No. 2011-6-0023
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
2/58
2
FORM NO. 81 PETITION FOR CERTIORARI UNDER RULE 65
Republic of the Philippines
COURT OF APPEALSManila
ALEXANDER BERMEJO
Plaintiff - Appellee,
-versus-
CA- GR SP. No. 658725
HON. PETER DE JESUSAs Presiding Judge, RTC, Branch 55Puerto Princesa City;RACHEL F. BUAG andREGISTER OF DEEDS OF PALAWAN
Respondents
x --------------------------------------x
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI
Petitioner, by counsel and to this Honorable Court, alleges:
PREFATORY STATEMENT
This is an action to set aside the order dated July 15, 2013 ( Annex A) issued
by respondent Judge in Civil Case No. 55675, Branch 55, Puerto Princesa City,
Palawan entitled Rachel Buag vs. Alexander Bermejo, ordering the cancellation of
petitionersTCT No. 4576 of the Registry of Deeds of Puerto Princesa City, covering a
parcel of land and residential house therein built situated in Puerto Princesa City, and
directing the Register of Deeds of Puerto Princesa City to issue new TCT in favor and in
the name of Rachel Buag, as well as the order of _____ (Annex B), which denied
petitioners motion for reconsideration of said earlier order, on the ground that said
questioned order is null and void, for lack of urisdiction in issuing said order.
The instant petition also seeks the issuance of temporary restraining order and
/or temporary preliminary injunction to enjoin the implementation of said questionedorder during the pendency of the action.
THE PARTIES
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
3/58
3
1. Petioner is of legal age and with residence at Puerto Princesa City, He is
the defendant in said Civil Case No. 05527, Branch 55, Puerto Princesa
City.
2. Respondent Rachel Buag is of legal age and with residence at Bgy. San
Pedro, Puerto Princesa City, Where she may be srved with legal
processes. He is the plaintiff in said Civil Case No. 05527.
3. Respondent Peter De Jesus is of legal age and is the Presiding Judge of
Branch 55, RTC, Puerto Princesa City, who issued the questioned orders
and is sued in his official capacity as such. He may be served with legal
processes at said Branch 55, RTC, Puerto Princesa City.
4. Respondent Register of Deeds of Puerto Princesa City of legal ageand is
being sued Ihis official capacity as such, who may be served with legal
processes at his office in Puerto Princesa City, Palawan.
TIMELINESS OF PETITION
On July 15, 2013, respondent Judge issued an order, cancelling petitioners TCT
No. 4576 and directing the Register of Deeds of Puerto Princesa City to issue new title
in favor and in the name of private respondent. Petitioner received copy of said order
on July 25, 2013, and certified true copy of which is attached hereto as Annex A.
On August 14, 2013, or 5 days from receipt of said order Annex A, petitioner
filed a motion for reconsideration of said order. On August 26, 2013, the trial court
denied said motion for reconsideration, and copy thereof was served petitioner onSeptember 2, 2013. Certified true copy of said order of denial is attached hereto as
Annex B.
The instant petition is filed with the Court of Appeals within 60days from receipt
of said order Annex B.
STATEMENT OF FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS
(Narrate, in chronological order, the proceeding and facts that led to the issuance
of the questioned orders Annexes A and B and attach ordinarycopies of processes
and pleadings filed before said Annex B, marking them as Annex C, etc. )
STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES
The issues of law raised are:
1. Whether or not the respondent Judge or trial court has acted with graveabuse of discretion amounting to lack of jurisdiction or without jurisdiction,
in issuing the questioned orders Annexes A and B.
2. Whether or not petitioner is entitled to writs prayed for including a writ of
preliminary injunction to enjoin execution of said questioned orders.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
4/58
4
GROUNDS RELIED UPON FOR ALLOWANCE OF WRITS PRAYED FOR
1. The respondent Judge ortrialcourt acted with grave abuse of discretion
amounting to lack of jurisction and/or without jurisdiction in issuing the
questioned orders.
2. There is neither appeal, nor any plain and speedy remedy in the ordinary course
of law other that the instant petition.
3. Petitioner is entitled to the issuance of a temporary rstraining order to restrain the
enforcement of the questioned orders.
4. Petitioner is entitled to the award of damages and attorneys fees.
DISCUSSION
Discuss Ground No. 1
Cite and quote Sec. 75 of the Land Registration Decree and Padilla, Jr. v.
Producers Cooperative Marketing Assn., G.R. No. 141256, July 15, 2005, in which the
Supreme Court ruled that in involuntary registration of deed and in case the judgmentdebtor refuses to deliver his owners duplicate certificate of title, an entirely different and
separate action has to be filed in the RTC, acting as a cadastral or land registration
court, for the issuance of an order cancelling the judgment debtor as the purchaser of
the land in the auction sale to satisfy the judgment creditior as the purchaser of the land
in the auction sale to satisfy the judgment for a sum of money the latter order being null
and void.
Discuss Ground No. 2
Discuss Ground No. 3, and enumerate the grounds for issuance of writ ofpreliminary injunction, including petitioners willingness to post a bond I such amount as
the Court may fix.
Discuss Ground No. 4
WHEREFORE,petitioner prays for judgment:
1. Upon the filing of the petition, TRO be issued, enjoining the respondents from the
executing the questioned orders Annexes A and B, and thereafter, after
hearing, the same be converted into a writ of preliminary injunction, upon such
bond as the Honorable Court may fix;
2. The petition be given due course;
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
5/58
5
3. After proceedings, setting aside and nullifying the questioned orders Annexes A
and B;
4. Making any writ of injunction that may have been issued permanent.
5. Ordering private respondent to pay petitioner P 250,000.00 as damages and
P150,000.00 as attorneys fees.
Petitioner prays for such other reliefs as may be just and equitable in the premises.
Puerto Princesa City August 25, 2013.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION
AGA INST FORUM SHOPPING
I, ALEXANDERBERMEJO, of legal age and with residence at Lagan St. PuertoPrincesa City, after having been duly sworn, depose and say:
1. That I am the plaintiff in the above entitled complaint.
2. That I have caused the preparation by my counsel of said complaint.
3. That I have read the allegations therein contained, and that the same are
true and correct of my personal knowledge or based on authentic records.
4. That I have not theretofore commenced any action or filed any claim
involving the same issues in any court, tribunal or quasi-judicial agency
and, to the best of my knowledge, no such other action or claim is
pending therein; and if I should thereafter learn that the same or similar
action or aclim has been filed or is pending to the court wherein the
aforesaid complaint or initiatory pleading has been filed.
Witness my hand this 25th day of August 2013 at Puerto Princesa City, Palawan.
ALEXANDER BERMEJOAffiant
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
6/58
6
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for the City ofPuerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 25thday of August 2013. Affiant personally
came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land Transportation Office and
valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his photograph and signature, known to
me as the same person who personally signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed
under penalty of law to the whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. 31 ;
Page No. 46 ;
Book No. XXI;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 82 COMPLAINT FOR ANNULMENT OF JUDGMENT OF DEFAULT,IFPERIOD TO FILE PETITION FROM RELIEF THEREFROM HAS EXPIRED
Republic of the Philippines
COURT OF APPEALSManila
MAMERTO VELAYO
Plaintiff - Appellee,
-versus-
CA- GR. No. 658725
PETER DE JESUSRespondent
x --------------------------------------x
PETITION FOR ANNULMENT OF JUDGMENT
PETITIONER, by counsel and to this Honorable Court, respectfully alleges:
Petitioner is of legal age and with residence _____, while respondent is also of
legal age with residence at ____________.
1. On ___________, an adverse judgment was rendered against him in Civil case
No. _____, for a sum of money based on a promissory alleged executed by
petitioner in favor of respondent. Certified true copy of said judgment is attached
hereto as Annex A.
2. Petioner learned of said judgment against him only after two (2) years from the
date thereof, precluding him to file ordinary remedies of new trial, petition for
relief from judgment or any other appropriate remedy.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
7/58
7
3. Investigations shows that afet petitioner referred the summons to his counsel,
Atty. _____, the latter moved for the extension of time to file the answer,
whichwas grnted by the trial court. However, since then Atty. _____ did not do
anything anymore, as he migrated to the United States without informing
petitioner, without withdrawing from the case as counsel and without giving
notice of withdrawal from the case, by reason of which an adverse judgment was
rendered.
4. Petitioner has good and valid defenses to defeat respondents claims, on the
ground that he did no execute the promissory note, upon which the complaint
was based, the same being a forgery; and while he owned respondent the
amount claimed in the complaint, he already paid him such amount, thru his
authorized collector who presented to petitioner a power of attorney is attached
hereto as Annex B.
5. Petitioner was prevented, by the extrinsic frauds, from having his day in court
and in violation of his right to due process6. Petitioner attaches herewith the following, in support of this action:
Affidavit attesting to the extrinsic frauds committed and to the good and valid
defenses which petitioner has to repel and defeat respondents claims, which is
attached hereto as Annex C; and
Another affidavit of ______, attesting to the fact that Atty. ____ migrated to the
United States on or about _______,after he filed the motion for extension of time to
file answer, and since then nothing was heard from him concerning said case, asexecuted by his former secretary, Ms. _____.
WHEREFORE, petitioner prays that judgment be rendered annulling the trial
courts decision Annex A hereof, and for such other reliefs as may be just and
equitable in the premises.
Puerto Princesa City, October 24, 2013
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATIONAGA INST FORUM SHOPPING
I, ALEXANDERBERMEJO, of legal age and with residence at Lagan St. PuertoPrincesa City, after having been duly sworn, depose and say:
1. That I am the plaintiff in the above entitled complaint.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
8/58
8
2. That I have caused the preparation by my counsel of said complaint.
3. That I have read the allegations therein contained, and that the same are
true and correct of my personal knowledge or based on authentic records.
4. That I have not theretofore commenced any action or filed any claim
involving the same issues in any court, tribunal or quasi-judicial agency
and, to the best of my knowledge, no such other action or claim is
pending therein; and if I should thereafter learn that the same or similar
action or aclim has been filed or is pending to the court wherein the
aforesaid complaint or initiatory pleading has been filed.
Witness my hand this 25th
day of August 2013 at Puerto Princesa City, Palawan.
ALEXANDER BERMEJOAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for the City ofPuerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 25thday of August 2013. Affiant personally
came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land Transportation Office and
valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his photograph and signature, known to
me as the same person who personally signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed
under penalty of law to the whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. 31 ;
Page No. 46 ;
Book No. XXI;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 83 AMENDMENT AS A MATTER OF RIGHT
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIESPuerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJO
Plaintiff,
-versus- Civil case No. 5524
Collectionfor a Sum of Money
ROEL PONCE DE LEON
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
9/58
9
Defendant
x --------------------------------------x
The form should take into account the following:
A party may amend his pleading once as matter of right at any time before a
responsive pleading is served or, in the case of a reply, at any time within ten (10) days
after it is served.
The amendment is done by submitting an entirely new pleading (i.e., complaint)
adding or striking out an allegation or allegation or the name of any party, or correcting
any mistake in the name of any party or any mistake or inadequate allegation or
description in other respect, including the addition of new cause or causes of action or
the incorporation of documents, occurring before the filing of the pleading; and
indicating in the new pleading by appropriate marks, such as under lining the added orcorrected portions..
X x x x x x
Puerto Princesa City, December 12, 2013
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa CityRoll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
FORM NO.84 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND PLEADING
Republic of the Philippines
MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIESPuerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJOPlaintiff,
-versus- Civil case No. 5524Collectionfor a Sum of Money
ROEL PONCE DE LEONDefendant
x --------------------------------------x
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
10/58
10
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT
PLAINTIFF, by counsel and to this Honorable Court respectfully moves for leaveto file an amended complaint, by alleging facts more clearly and specifying the facts in a
more methodical manner, upon which certain conclusion are made. The amended
complaint showing the amendments by underlining them or indicating by appropriate
way what have been deleted therefrom, is attached hereto as Annex A.
WHEREFORE, plaintiff prays that he be given the leave of court to file an
amended complaint which is attached herewith, and that the same be admitted.
Plaintiff prays for such other reliefs as may be just and equitable in the premises.
Puerto Princesa City, December 12, 2013.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
NOTICE OF HEARING
Atty. Juan S. Magbanua
Counsel for the defendant
Bgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
Please be informed that the undersigned counsel has set the foregoing Motion
for Reconsideration for hearing on November 25, 2013 at 8:30 am, for the consideration
of the Honorable Court or soon thereafter as counsel maybe heard.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Plaintiff
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel B. Venturillo, Counsel for the defendant in
the case entitled Alexander Bermejo vs. Roel Ponce de Leon, Civil Case No. 65448,
and that such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties,
the Motion for Consideration filed in said case, as follows:
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
11/58
11
Atty. Bernardo U. Goy, counsel for the Plaintiff, by personal service by delivering
personally copy of said Motion upon said lawyer who acknowledged receipt there of as
shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 23 rdday of October 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 24th day of October2013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 24 th day of October 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land
Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing hisphotograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed the
foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth of
the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 85 - MOTION TO EFFECT FORMAL AMENDMENTS
A defect in the designation of the parties and other clearly clerical ortypographical errors may be summarily corrected by the court of the action, at its
initiative or on motion, provided no prejudice is caused thereby to the adverse party.
A clerical error is one that is visible to the naked eye or obvious to the
understanding, or one made in copying or writing. A misspelled word is clerical error.
Amending clerical errors will not prejudice the adverse party who cannot, in any event,
profit therefrom.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
12/58
12
FORM NO. 86 AMENDMENT TO CONFORM TO ISSUES TRIED.
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
Branch 47Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJOPlaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
FOR: DAMAGES
ROEL PONCE DE LEONDefendant
x --------------------------------------x
The form should conform to the following requirements:
When issues not raised by the pleadings are tried with the express or implied
consent of the parties, they shall be treated in all respects as if they had been raised in
the pleadings. Such amendments of the pleadings as may be necessary to cause them
to confer to the evidence and to raise these issues may be made up motion upon any
party at any time, even after judgment; but failure to amend does not affect the result of
the trial of these issues. If evidence is objected to the trial on the ground that it is not
within the issues made by the pleadings, the court may allow the pleadings to be
amended and shall do so with liberality if the presentation of the merits of the action and
the ends of substantial justice will be subserved thereby. The court may grant may
grant a continuance to enable the amendment to be made.
FORM NO. 87. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADINGS
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
13/58
13
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURTBranch 47
Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJOPlaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
RECISSION OF LEASE CONTRACT
ROEL PONCE DE LEONDefendant
x --------------------------------------x
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO SERVE SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADINGS
PLAINTIFF. by counsel and to this Honorable Court, alleges:
1. Plaintiff filed on ______, 2013 an action for rescission of Lease Contract,
publiciana and recovery of back rental.
2. On _________, 2012, of after the filing of said action, the house which was the
subject of the lease sought to be rescinded was burned thru the gross negligence
of defendant, causing plaintiff damages consisting of the value of said house.
3. As the destruction of the house was an event which occurred after the filing of
the action, there is need for plaintiff to file a supplemental complaint to include his
claim for the value of the house, as part of the rentals sought in said action
4. The proposed supplemental pleading complaint as attached hereto as Annex A.
WHEREFORE, plaintiff prays that the attached supplemental complaint be admitted,
upon payment of filing fees due thereon, and the Honorable Court issue a summon,
requiring him to plead thereto.
Puerto Princesa City, December 1, 2013
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa CityRoll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
NOTICE OF HEARING
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
14/58
14
Atty. Juan S. Magbanua
Counsel for the defendant
Bgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
Please be informed that the undersigned counsel has set the foregoing Motion
for Reconsideration for hearing on November 25, 2013 at 8:30 am, for the consideration
of the Honorable Court or soon thereafter as counsel maybe heard.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Plaintiff
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel B. Venturillo, Counsel for the defendant in
the case entitled Alexander Bermejo vs. Roel Ponce de Leon, Civil Case No. 65448,
and that such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties,
the Motion for Consideration filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Bernardo U. Goy, counsel for the Plaintiff, by personal service by delivering
personally copy of said Motion upon said lawyer who acknowledged receipt there of as
shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 23rd
day of October 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 24th day of October2013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 24
th day of October 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land
Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his
photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed the
foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth of
the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
15/58
15
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 88 SUPPLEMENTAL COMPLAINT
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURTBranch 47
Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJO
Plaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
RECISSION OF LEASE CONTRACT
ROEL PONCE DE LEONDefendant
x --------------------------------------x
SUPPLEMENTAL COMPLAINT
PLAINTIFF. by counsel and to this Honorable Court, alleges:
1. Plaintiff filed on ______, 2013 an action for rescission of Lease Contract,
publiciana and recovery of back rental.
2. On _________, 2012, of after the filing of said action, the house which was the
subject of the lease sought to be rescinded was burned thru the gross negligence
of defendant, causing plaintiff damages consisting of the value of said house,
said gross negligence consisting, among others,of the following:
3. Defendant installed kerosene burner inside the house for cooking purposes, side
by side his wooden stove, also inside the house.
4. Defendant poured kerosene in the burner and spilled kerosene, and since the fire
in the wooden stove was not put off, fire engulfed the place and gutted the house
completely
5. The value of the house was approximately P 500,000.00 which should be
assessed against defendant, being the result of defendants gross negligence
6. After the house was burned, defendant and his family left the leased premises,
without the knowledge of plaintiff.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
16/58
16
WHEREFORE, plaintiff respectfully prays that the defendant be held liable and be
ordered to pay plaintiff (1) back rentals from ____ to ____, or a total of P
500,000,00 representing the value of the leased house, with 12% interest on both
amounts; and (3) attorneys fees and expenses of litigation of P 250,000.00
Plaintiff further prays for such other reliefs as may be just and equitable in the
premises.
Puerto Princesa City, December 1, 2013.;
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION
AGA INST FORUM SHOPPING
I, ALEXANDERBERMEJO, of legal age and with residence at Lagan St. Puerto
Princesa City, after having been duly sworn, depose and say:
1. That I am the plaintiff in the above entitled complaint.
2. That I have caused the preparation by my counsel of said complaint.
3. That I have read the allegations therein contained, and that the same are
true and correct of my personal knowledge or based on authentic records.
4. That I have not theretofore commenced any action or filed any claim
involving the same issues in any court, tribunal or quasi-judicial agency
and, to the best of my knowledge, no such other action or claim is
pending therein; and if I should thereafter learn that the same or similar
action or aclim has been filed or is pending to the court wherein the
aforesaid complaint or initiatory pleading has been filed.
Witness my hand this 25th day of August 2013 at Puerto Princesa City, Palawan.
ALEXANDER BERMEJOAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 24
th day of October 2013.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
17/58
17
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land
Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his
photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed the
foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth of
the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 89 MOTION FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS:
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURTBranch 47
Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJOPlaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
FOR: DAMAGES
ROEL PONCE DE LEON
Defendantx --------------------------------------x
MOTION FOR BILL OF PARTICULARS
Defendant, by counseland to this Honorable Court, respectfully states:
1. The complaint alleges that defendant public official, together with herein
defendant movant, acting singly or collectively, and or in unlawful concert with
one another, in flagrantebreach of public trust and of sheer fiduciary obligations
as public officers with gross and scandalous abuse of right and power and in
brazen violation of the Constitution and laws of the Philippines, embarked upon a
systematic plan to accumulate ill-gotten wealth.
2. The foregoing allegations are conclusions of law, which plaintiff should clarify and
flesh them with facts and specific acts to enable defendant-movant to prepare
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
18/58
18
and file a responsive answer thereto which requires information as to precise
nature, character, scope and extent of plaintiffs cause of action.
WHEREFORE, defendant prays that plaintiff be ordered to file a bill of particulars ofthe facts and acts constituting the conclusions alleged in the complaint.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
NOTICE OF HEARING
Atty. Juan S. Magbanua
Counsel for the defendant
Bgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
Please be informed that the undersigned counsel has set the foregoing Motion
for Reconsideration for hearing on November 25, 2013 at 8:30 am, for the consideration
of the Honorable Court or soon thereafter as counsel maybe heard.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Plaintiff
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel B. Venturillo, Counsel for the defendant in
the case entitled Alexander Bermejo vs. Roel Ponce de Leon, Civil Case No. 65448,
and that such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties,the Motion for Consideration filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Bernardo U. Goy, counsel for the Plaintiff, by personal service by delivering
personally copy of said Motion upon said lawyer who acknowledged receipt there of as
shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 23 rdday of October 2013
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
19/58
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
20/58
20
Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJO
Plaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
FOR: DAMAGES
ROEL PONCE DE LEONDefendant
x --------------------------------------x
COMPLIANCE
Plaintiff, complying with the order directing him to file a Bill of Particulars, hereby files an
amended complaint, the requested facts or acts for, being shown by the underlined portions of
the enclosed amended complaint.
Puerto Princesa City, December 1, 2013
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADAD
Counsel for the plaintiffBrgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel B. Venturillo, Counsel for the defendant inthe case entitled Alexander Bermejo vs. Roel Ponce de Leon, Civil Case No. 65448,and that such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties,the Motion for Consideration filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Arnel Belarmino, counsel for the Defendant, by personal service bydelivering personally copy of said Motion upon said lawyer who acknowledged receiptthere of as shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 23 rdday of
October 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 24 thday of December 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
21/58
21
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 2nd day of December 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the LandTransportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his
photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed theforegoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth ofthe contents of said instrument
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 91 NOTICE OF LIS PENDENS:
The Register of Deeds
City of Puerto Princesa
RE: NOTICE OF LIS PENDENS
Sir:
Please register a notice of lis pendens of Civil Case No. 45457 on TCT No.
46468 of the Registry of Deeds for City of Puerto Princesa, covering a parcel of land
which is involved in Civil Case No. 45457 filed with the Regional Trial Court of Puerto
Princesa City and Palawan, Branch No. 47, of the following parties:
Jose Pedro and Juan dela Cruz, as plaintiff and defendants in said Civil CaseNo. 45457. In this case, plaintiff/petitioner is claiming ownership of the land which was
registered by defendant in his name, although the parcel of land belongs to plaintiff.
The land involved and covered by TCT No. 46468 is described as follows:
( Copy technical Description of land provided in the Title)
True copy of the compliant in Civil Case No. 45457 is enclosed herewith, as part
and parcel of this Notice of Lis Pendens.
The address of the person seeking registration of this lis pendens is, 335 Malvar
St. Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
Puerto Princesa City, December 1. 2013
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
22/58
22
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADCounsel for the plaintiff
Brgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
Copy furnished:
Atty. Arnel Belarmino
Counsel for the Defendant
Puerto Princesa Ciity
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel B. Venturillo, Counsel for the defendant in
the case entitled Alexander Bermejo vs. Roel Ponce de Leon, Civil Case No. 65448,
and that such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties,
the Motion for Consideration filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Arnel Belarmino, counsel for the Defendant, by personal service bydelivering personally copy of said Motion upon said lawyer who acknowledged receipt
there of as shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 23rd
day of
October 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 24thday of December 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 2nd day of December 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued
by the Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City,
bearing his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally
signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the
whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
23/58
23
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 92 CONSULTA
The Commissioner
Land Registration Authority
RE: CONSULTA
Sir:
On behalf of my client, Juan dela Cruz, who sought registration of lis pendens, of
Civil Case No. 45457, RTC, Branch 47 of Puerto Princesa City, as plaintiff in said case,
seeking recovery of one-half of the parcel of land involved in said case, and whose
request for registration of lis pendens was denied by the Register of Deed, in an order
dated October 24, 2013, copy of which was received on October 29, 2013,and at which
is attached hereto as Annex A, he undersigned counsel seeks reversal of the denial of
the register of Deeds on the following grounds:
( Enumerate the grounds)
Before discussing the forgoing grounds, a narration of the factual background is
in order.
Re-state the background
DISCUSSION(Discuss the Grounds)
WHEREFORE, it is respectfully prayed as follows:
The Register of Deeds of Puerto Princesa City be required to elevate all the
records of the case to the Honorable Commissioner of Land Registration Authority;
After hearing and proper proceedings, the order of denial of registration of lis
pendens be set aside and the Register of Deeds be required to register the lis pendens.
The undersigned further prays for such other reliefs as maybe just and equitable
in the premises.
Puerto Princesa City, November 3, 2013.
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADCounsel for the plaintiff
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
24/58
24
Brgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
Copy furnished:
1.The Register of Deeds of Puerto Princesa
2. Atty. Arnel Belarmino
Counsel for the Defendant
Puerto Princesa City
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Fely Q. Baladad, Counsel for the defendant in
the case entitled Alexander Bermejo vs. Roel Ponce de Leon, Civil Case No. 65448,
and that such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties,
the Service of consulta filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Arnel Belarmino, counsel for the Defendant, by personal service by
delivering personally copy of said Service of Consulta upon said lawyer who
acknowledged receipt there of as shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading,this 23rdday of October 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 4thday of November 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3rdday of November 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued
by the Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City,
bearing his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally
signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the
whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
25/58
25
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 93 PETITION FOR REVIEW OF LAND REGISTRATION AUTHORITYRULING
Republic of the Philippines
COURT OF APPEALSManila
ALEX M. BERMEJO
Plaintiff - Appellant,
-versus-
PETER DE JESUS CA- GR CV No. 658725Administrator ofLand Registration Authority
Defendant - Appelle
x --------------------------------------x
PETITION FOR REVIEW
PETITIONER, by counsel and to this Honorable Court, respectfully alleges:
NATURE OF PETITION
This is a petition for review pursuant to Rule 43 of the Rules of Court, to nullify
and set aside the decision rendered by the Land Registration Authority in LRA Case No.
434343 entitled Alex M. Bermejo Vs. Antonio De Jesus
As the questioned decision and resolution are executory, unless restrained,
petitioner also moves for a writ of preliminary injunction to stay their execution during
the pendency of the case.
THE PARTIES
Petitioner is of legal age and with residence at Puerto Princesa City, He is the
plaintiff in said Civil Case No. 05527, Branch 55, Puerto Princesa City.
Respondent Peter De Jesus is of legal age and is the Administrator of the Land
Registration Authority (LRA), who issued the questioned orders and is sued in his
official capacity as such. He may be served with legal processes at his office in Manila.
.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
26/58
26
TIMELINESS OF PETITION
On July 15, 2013, respondent Administrator issued an order, cancelling
petitioners TCT No. 4576 and directing the Register of Deeds of Puerto Princesa City to
issue new title in favor and in the name of private respondent. Petitioner received copy
of said order on July 25, 2013, and certified true copy of which is attached hereto as
Annex A.
On August 14, 2013, or 5 days from receipt of said order Annex A, petitioner
filed a motion for reconsideration of said order. On August 26, 2013, the trial court
denied said motion for reconsideration, and copy thereof was served petitioner on
September 2, 2013. Certified true copy of said order of denial is attached hereto as
Annex B.
The instant petition is filed with the Court of Appeals within 60days from receiptof said order Annex B.
STATEMENT OF FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS
(Narrate, in chronological order, the proceeding and facts that led to the issuance
of the questioned orders Annexes A and B and attach ordinary copiesof processes
and pleadings filed before said Annex B, marking them as Annex C, etc. )
STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES
The issues of law raised are:
3. Whether or not the respondent Adminstrator has acted with grave abuse
of discretion amounting to lack of jurisdiction or without jurisdiction, in
issuing the questioned orders Annexes A and B.
4. Whether or not petitioner is entitled to writs prayed for including a writ of
preliminary injunction to enjoin execution of said questioned orders.
GROUNDS RELIED UPON FOR ALLOWANCE OF WRITS PRAYED FOR
5. The respondent Administrator acted with grave abuse of discretion amounting to
lack of jurisdiction and/or without jurisdiction in issuing the questioned orders.
6. There is neither appeal, nor any plain and speedy remedy in the ordinary courseof law other that the instant petition.
7. Petitioner is entitled to the issuance of a temporary restraining order to restrain
the enforcement of the questioned orders.
8. Petitioner is entitled to the award of damages and attorneys fees.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
27/58
27
DISCUSSION
Discuss Ground No. 1
Cite and quote Sec. 75 of the Land Registration Decree and Padilla, Jr. v.
Producers Cooperative Marketing Assn., G.R. No. 141256, July 15, 2005, in which the
Supreme Court ruled that in involuntary registration of deed and in case the judgment
debtor refuses to deliver his owners duplicate certificate of title, an entirely different and
separate action has to be filed in the RTC, acting as a cadastral or land registration
court, for the issuance of an order cancelling the judgment debtor as the purchaser of
the land in the auction sale to satisfy the judgment creditior as the purchaser of the land
in the auction sale to satisfy the judgment for a sum of money the latter order being null
and void.
Discuss Ground No. 2
Discuss Ground No. 3, and enumerate the grounds for issuance of writ of
preliminary injunction, including petitioners willingness to post a bond I such amount as
the Court may fix.
Discuss Ground No. 4
WHEREFORE,petitioner prays for judgment:
6. Upon the filing of the petition, TRO be issued, enjoining the respondents from the
executing the questioned orders Annexes A and B, and thereafter, after
hearing, the same be converted into a writ of preliminary injunction, upon such
bond as the Honorable Court may fix;
7. The petition be given due course;
8. After proceedings, setting aside and nullifying the questioned orders Annexes Aand B;
9. Making any writ of injunction that may have been issued permanent.
10. Ordering private respondent to pay petitioner P 250,000.00 as damages and
P150,000.00 as attorneys fees.
Petitioner prays for such other reliefs as may be just and equitable in the premises.
Puerto Princesa City August 25, 2013.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
28/58
28
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION
AGA INST FORUM SHOPPING
I, ALEXANDERBERMEJO, of legal age and with residence at Lagan St. PuertoPrincesa City, after having been duly sworn, depose and say:
5. That I am the plaintiff in the above entitled complaint.
6. That I have caused the preparation by my counsel of said complaint.
7. That I have read the allegations therein contained, and that the same are
true and correct of my personal knowledge or based on authentic records.
8. That I have not theretofore commenced any action or filed any claim
involving the same issues in any court, tribunal or quasi-judicial agency
and, to the best of my knowledge, no such other action or claim is
pending therein; and if I should thereafter learn that the same or similar
action or aclim has been filed or is pending to the court wherein theaforesaid complaint or initiatory pleading has been filed.
Witness my hand this 25th
day of August 2013 at Puerto Princesa City, Palawan.
ALEXANDER BERMEJOAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for the City ofPuerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 25thday of August 2013. Affiant personally
came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land Transportation Office and
valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his photograph and signature, known to
me as the same person who personally signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed
under penalty of law to the whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. 31 ;
Page No. 46 ;
Book No. XXI;
Series of 2013;
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
29/58
29
FORM NO. 94 MOTION TO CANCEL LIS PENDENS
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURTBranch 47
Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJOPlaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-FOR: DAMAGES
ROEL PONCE DE LEONDefendant
x--------------------------------------x
MOTION TO CANCEL LIS PENDENS
Plaintiff, by counsel and to this Honorable Court, respectfully states:
1. Defendant caused the annotation or registration of a notice of lis pendens on the
subject matter of the instant suit,
2. 2. Defendant caused the recording of the lis pendens for the purpose of
molesting plaintiff, and the recordal thereof is not necessary to protect his rights
to the property, his right thereto, if any, is only indirect and contingent.
3. The recordal of the lis pendens is prejudicial to plaintiffs interest to the property
because, being the owner of said property, it is burden and it restricts itstransferability by sale, as no one will buy it during the pendency of the case and
for as long as the lis pendens is not canceled.
WHEREFORE, plaintiff respectfully prays that the notice of lis pendens be ordered
cancelled.
City of Puerto Princesa, December 2, 2013
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADCounsel for the plaintiff
Brgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
30/58
30
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
NOTICE OF HEARING
Atty. Juan S. Magbanua
Counsel for the defendant
Bgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
Please be informed that the undersigned counsel has set the foregoing Motion
for Reconsideration for hearing on November 25, 2013 at 8:30 am, for the consideration
of the Honorable Court or soon thereafter as counsel maybe heard.
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADCounsel for the Plaintiff
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Fely Q. Baladad, Counsel for the defendant in
the case entitled Alexander Bermejo vs. Roel Ponce de Leon, Civil Case No. 65448,
and that such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties,
the Motion for Consideration filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Arnel Belarmino, counsel for the Defendant, by personal service by
delivering personally copy of said Motion upon said lawyer who acknowledged receipt
there of as shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 23rd
day of
October 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 4thday of November 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for the
City of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3rd
day of November 2013.Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued
by the Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City,
bearing his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally
signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the
whole truth of the contents of said instrument
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
31/58
31
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
Form no. 95 NOTICE OF ADVERSE CLAIM
The Register of Deeds
City of Puerto Princesa
Notice of Adverse Claim
On TCT No. 45458
Registry of Deeds of Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
The undersigned hereby files this adverse claim of undersignedon the property
covered by TCT No. 45457 of the Registry o Deeds of Puerto Princesa City, and hereby
states as follows:
The TCT No. 45457 covers a parcel of land which has the following technical
description:
(Copy description from the Title)
The undersigned bought land from Baja Melissa Osia but since the undersigned
was a minor at the time of the purchase, he requested Mr. Antonio De Jesus, his uncle
to register the same in his name for the undersigneds benefit and to be held in trust for
the undersigned, and his uncle agreed and so the land was registered in his name.
The undersigned is the real and actual owner of said property, and not the
registered owner thereof, and to protect his interest thereto as actual owner, this
adverse claim is being registered on said TCT, to warn any third person from buying the
same.
Claimant address is, 335 Malvar Street, Puerto Princesa City.
City of Puerto Princesa, December 13, 2013
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
32/58
32
JULLANA REIGN NARCISOAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for the City ofPuerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3
rdday of November 2013. Affiant
personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued by the
Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing
his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed
the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth
of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
Copy furnished:
1.Antonio De Jesus
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Fely Q. Baladad, Counsel for the defendant,
and that such messenger I served upon the person of adverse party and other parties,
the Notice of Adverse Claim.
Antonio de Jesus, by personal service by delivering personally copy of said
Adverse Claim who acknowledged receipt there of as shown by his signature or initial
on the said pleading, this 5thday of November 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 4th
day of November 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
33/58
33
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for the City ofPuerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3rdday of November 2013. Affiant
personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued by the
Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing
his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed
the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth
of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 96 PETITION TO CANCEL ADVERSE CLAIM
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURTBranch 47Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJOPlaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
FOR: DAMAGES
ROEL PONCE DE LEONDefendant
x--------------------------------------x
PETITON TO CANCEL ADVERSE CLAIM
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
34/58
34
PETITIONER, by counsel and to this Honorable Court, alleges:
1. Petitioner is of legal age and with residence at Puerto Princesa City, Palawan,
Philippines, while respondent is also of legal age and with residence at Brgy.
Tagumpay, Narra, Palawan, where he may be served with summons and other
legal processes.
2. Petitioner is the absolute owner of a parcel of land situated in Narra , Palawan
with an area of 500 sq.m., with a residential house therein built and covered with
TCT No. 45457 of the Registry of Deeds for Narra Palawan, which is more
particularly described as follows:
(Copy technical description from the title)
Which has a current vale, along with the residential house, of about P
3,500.000.00.
3. On October 20, 2013, respondent registered a notice of adverse claim on said
TCT No. 45457, alleging I the affidavit of adverse claim that he bought the land
from a certain Juan Dela cruz, with residence at Puerto Princesa City for
P150,000.00, and saying that he could not secure a new title because the seller
lost his owners dupicae certificate of title, covering said TCT No. 45457.
4. The adverse claim is spurious and the alleged seller is a fake, as investigation
revealed that there was no such person named Juan dela Cruz at the given
address indicated in the adverse claim; that the plaintiffs owners duplicate
certificate is intact and is not lost, as it is in plaintiffs possession; and that theselling price of P150,000.000 was way below the actual value f the land.
5. The registration of the said adverse claim is intended to harass plaintiff and to
unreasonably burden the land in question, and done in bad faith, which caused
plaintiff damages of P500,000.000 plus attorneys feesof P 100,000.00, which
should be assed against defendant.
WHEREFORE, plaintiff prays that the notice of adverse claim in TCT 45457 be
ordered cancelled and declared null and void, and that respondent be ordered to
pay plaintiff the amount of P600,000.00 as damages.
City of Puerto Princesa, December 12, 2013.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
VERIFICATION
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
35/58
35
I, ALEXANDER BERMEJO, of legal age and with residence at Lagan St. PuertoPrincesa City, after having been duly sworn, depose and say:
1. That I am the plaintiff in the above entitled complaint.
2. That I have caused the preparation by my counsel of said complaint.
3. That I have read the allegations therein contained, and that the same are
true and correct of my personal knowledge or based on authentic records.
Witness my hand this 23rdday of October 2013 at Puerto Princesa City, Palawan.
ALEXANDER BERMEJOAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 24 th day of October 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land
Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his
photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed the
foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth of
the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. 31 ;
Page No. 46 ;
Book No. XXI;
Series of 2013;
NOTICE OF HEARING
Atty. Juan S. Magbanua
Counsel for the defendant
Bgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
Please be informed that the undersigned counsel has set the foregoing Motionfor Reconsideration for hearing on November 25, 2013 at 8:30 am, for the consideration
of the Honorable Court or soon thereafter as counsel maybe heard.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Plaintiff
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
36/58
36
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Fely Q. Baladad, Counsel for the defendant,
and that such messenger I served upon the person of adverse party and other parties,
the Notice of Adverse Claim.
Antonio de Jesus, by personal service by delivering personally copy of said
Adverse Claim who acknowledged receipt there of as shown by his signature or initial
on the said pleading, this 5thday of November 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 4th
day of November 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for the
City of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3rdday of November 2013.Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued
by the Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City,
bearing his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally
signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the
whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 97 AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF FACTS ALLEGED IN MOTION
Republic of the Philippines
City of Puerto Princesa ) s.s.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
37/58
37
AFFIDAVIT
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and with residence at Brgy. Sta Monica,
Puerto Princesa City, having been duly sworn, depose and say:
That I, Joseph D. Dajay, married and of legal age, currently working as an
analyst at the Palawan Diagnostic Laboratory, Puerto Princesa City, Palawan.
That I personally know that the person named herein in the complaint and the
person whom I personally know are one and the same person.
That he is my classmate in High school, and a friend of mine.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3rdday of November 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued
by the Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City,
bearing his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally
signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the
whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 98 NOTICE OF HEARING, WHICH REQUIRES THAT IT BE SET FORHEARING NOT LATER THAN 10 DAYS AFTER THE FILING OF THE MOTION ANDAT LEAST THREE DAYS BEFORE DATE OF HEARING, TO GIVE THE OTHERPARTY TO OBJECT, IF SO DESIRES. NOTICE IS ADDRESSED ADVERSECOUNSEL
NOTICE OF HEARING
Atty. Juan S. Magbanua
Counsel for the defendant
Bgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
38/58
38
Please be informed that the undersigned counsel has set the Motion for Bill of
particulars on December 23, 2013 at 8:30 AM for hearing or soon thereafter as the
parties may be heard and depending upon the calendar of the Court
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP Roll No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2013,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, TOTOY BIBO, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel Belarmino, Counsel for the defendant,
and that such messenger I served upon the person of adverse party and other parties,
the Notice of Hearing
Antonio de Jesus, by personal service by delivering personally copy of said
Notice who acknowledged receipt there of as shown by his signature or initial on thesaid pleading, this 5thday of November 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 4thday of November 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
TOTOY B. BIBOAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3rdday of November 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued
by the Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City,
bearing his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally
signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the
whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. FELY Q. BALADADNotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
39/58
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
40/58
40
Antonio de Jesus, by personal service by delivering personally copy of said
Notice who acknowledged receipt there of as shown by his signature or initial on the
said pleading, this 5thday of November 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 4thday of November 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
TOTOY B. BIBOAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3rdday of November 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued
by the Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City,bearing his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally
signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the
whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 100 OMNIBUS MOTION
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURTBranch 47
Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJOPlaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
FOR: DAMAGESROEL PONCE DE LEON
Defendant
x--------------------------------------x
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
41/58
41
MOTION TO DISMISS
DEFENDANT, by counsel and to this Honorable Court respectfully moves to
dismiss the complaint on the following grounds:
1. ( Enumerate all defenses known and available at the time, otherwise such
defenses may be waived, except: 1.) Lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter;
2.) pendency of another action between the same parties for the same cause
(Litis Pendencia); 3.) Bar by prior judgment (Res Judicata); 4.) Prescription or bar
by statute of limitations).
City of Puerto Princesa, December 12, 2013.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP Roll No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2013,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
NOTICE OF HEARING
Atty. Juan S. Magbanua
Counsel for the defendant
Bgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
Please be informed that the undersigned counsel has set the Motion to Dismiss
on December 23, 2013 at 8:30 AM for hearing or soon thereafter as the parties may be
heard and depending upon the calendar of the Court
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, TOTOY BIBO, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel Belarmino, Counsel for the defendant,
and that such messenger I served upon the person of adverse party and other parties,the Notice of Hearing
Antonio de Jesus, by personal service by delivering personally copy of said
Notice who acknowledged receipt there of as shown by his signature or initial on the
said pleading, this 5thday of November 2013
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
42/58
42
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 4thday of November 12013 at Puerto Princesa City.
TOTOY B. BIBOAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 3rdday of November 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No.D11-125477 issued
by the Land Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City,
bearing his photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally
signed the foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the
whole truth of the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 111 - SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY FOR PRE TRIAL PURSPOSES
SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY
KNOW ALL MEN BY THIS PRESENT
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
43/58
43
That I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age, and am the plaintiff in the case entitled
Dajay vs. Austria, et al, Civil Case No. 12345 pending before RTC-Branch No. 47,
have constituted and appointed my lawyer Atty. Arnel Venturillo as my true and lawful
attorney -in-fact, for me and my stead, in connection with the pre trial and trial of said
case, to do and perform any and all of the following acts and deeds:
a) To agree to an amicable settlement of the case or to submission to alternaive
modes of dispute resolution of said case, under such terms and condition as my
attorney-in-fact may deem proper;
b) To simply the issue of the case;
c) To amend the pleadings, which my attorney-in-fact may deem proper;
d) To stipulated or admit certain facts or documents
e) To limit the number of witnesses;
f) To agree to a preliminary reference of issues to a commissioner;
g) To agree to rendering judgment on the pleadings, or summary judgment, or
dismissal of the action on valid grounds;
h) To agree to suspending the proceedings; and
i) To agree to such other matters as may aid in the prompt disposition of the
action.
HEREBY granting and confirming all the foregoing matters which my attorney-in-fact
may do or cause to be done in the premises, with the same force and effect as if I were
the one doing them personally.
WITNESS my hand this 19thday of December 20103 at Puerto Princesa City,
Palawan, Philippines.
JOSEPH D. DAJAY
Principal
SIGNED IN THE PRESENCE OF:
___________________________ ___________________________
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
BEFORE ME, a Notary Public for Puerto Princesa personally appeared Joseph
D. Dajay with PRC ID No. 0020419, valid until May 1, 2015 bearing his photograph and
signature, and presented a document called Special Powerof Attorney, who is known to
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
44/58
44
me personally and who signed said document in my presence and acknowledged that
the same was his free and voluntary act and deed.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this acknowledgment and affixed my
notarial seal this 19th
day of December, 2013 at Puerto Princesa City.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 112 BOARD RESOLUTION OF AUTHORITY
BOARD RESOLUTION
BE IT RESOLVED, as it is hereby resolved, by majority members of the Board if
Directors of JJD LABORATORY, INC., that BAJA MELISSA O. DAJAY, Vice President,
be authorized, as she is hereby authorized, in connection with the pre-trial and trial of
Civil Case No. 12345, RTC of Palawan, Branch 47, entitled JDD Laboratory, Inc. vs.
Palawan Adventist Hospital, of which the corporation is a plaintiff, to do and perform the
following acts and deeds
a.) To agree to an amicable settlement of the case or to submission to alternaive
modes of dispute resolution of said case, under such terms and condition as my
attorney-in-fact may deem proper;
b.) To simply the issue of the case;
c.) To amend the pleadings, which my attorney-in-fact may deem proper;
d.) To stipulated or admit certain facts or documents
e.) To limit the number of witnesses;
f.) To agree to a preliminary reference of issues to a commissioner;
g.) To agree to rendering judgment on the pleadings, or summary judgment, ordismissal of the action on valid grounds;
h.) To agree to suspending the proceedings; and
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
45/58
45
i.) To agree to such other matters as may aid in the prompt disposition of the
action.
Approved and adopted this 15thday of December, 2013 at Puerto Princesa City,
Palawan.
_________________________ _________________________
Director Director
_________________________ _________________________
Director Director
_________________________ _________________________
Director Director
ATTESTED BY:
ALEXES . MENDOZA
Corporate Secretary
FORM NO. 113 CERTIFICATE OF CORPORATE SECRETARY
CORPORATE CERTIFICATE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and with address at 47 Rizal Avenue, Puerto
Princesa City, after having been duly sworn, depose and say:
That I am the Corporate Secretary of JDD LABORATORY CORPORATION , a
corporation duly organized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the
Philippines.
That at the board meeting of said corporation. At which there was a quorum, held
on December 8, 2013 at its offices at 335 Malvar Street, Puerto Princesa City, thefollowing board resolution was unanimously adopted and approved.
BE IT RESOLVED, as it is hereby resolved, by majority members of the
Board if Directors of JJD LABORATORY, INC., that BAJA MELISSA O. DAJAY, Vice
President, be authorized, as she is hereby authorized, in connection with the pre-trial
and trial of Civil Case No. 12345, RTC of Palawan, Branch 47, entitled JDD Laboratory,
Inc. vs. Palawan Adventist Hospital, of which the corporation is a plaintiff, to do and
perform the following acts and deeds
a. To agree to an amicable settlement of the case or to submission toalternative modes of dispute resolution of said case, under such terms and
condition as my attorney-in-fact may deem proper;
b. To simply the issue of the case;
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
46/58
46
c. To amend the pleadings, which my attorney-in-fact may deem proper;
d. To stipulated or admit certain facts or documents
e. To limit the number of witnesses;
f. To agree to a preliminary reference of issues to a commissioner;
g. To agree to rendering judgment on the pleadings, or summary judgment, or
dismissal of the action on valid grounds;
h. To agree to suspending the proceedings; and
i. To agree to such other matters as may aid in the prompt disposition of the
action.
That the above board resolution is still existing and in force and kept in the
records of the corporation at its offices.
WITNESS my hand and seal of the corporation this 15 thday of December, 2013
at Puerto Princesa City.
ALEXES M. MENDOZA
Corporate Secretary
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for the City ofPuerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 19 th day of December 2013. Affiant
personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land Transportation
Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his photograph and
signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed the foregoing instrument
before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth of the contents of said
instrument.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
FORM 114- PETITION FOR INTERVENTION
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURTBranch 47
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
47/58
47
Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
ALEX BERMEJO
Plaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
PARTITION OF PROPERTY
ROEL PONCE DE LEONDefendant
x --------------------------------------x
MOTION TO INTERVENE
COMES now , Pedro Bermejo by undersigned counsel and to this Honorable
Court, respectfully alleges:
1. The pending case is for partition of the land, previously owned by their
deceased parents, filed by one of the co-owners against the five co-owners, their co
ownership having arisen since the death of their parents on January 30, 2012.
2. One of the co-owners is Juan de Castro who sold his undivided interest in the
co-ownership to herein movant Pedro Bermejo, on May 23, 2013 as shown by a deed ofsale, copy of which is attached hereto as Annex 1.
3. As purchaser of the undivided share of Juan De Castro, movant Bermejo has
legal interest in the outcome of the case and in the distribution or division of the property
in question.
4. Allowing movant Bermejo to intervene will not unduly delay the adjudication of
the case and will prevent multiplicity of suits.
5. Copy of the complaint-inintervention is attached hereto and is served on theoriginal parties, as shown by the service of motion along with its enclosed complaint-
inn-intervention.
WHEREFORE, Pedro Bermejo respectfully prays that he be allowed to intervene
in the case as party plaintiff; that the attached complaint-in-intervention be admitted;
and the defendants be ordered to file their answer to the complaint-in-intervention.
Puerto PrincesaCity, Palawan, December 11, 2013
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Plaintiff
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
Roll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
48/58
48
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
NOTICE OF HEARING
Atty. Juan S. Magbanua
Counsel for the defendant
Bgy. San Pedro, Puerto Princesa City
Sir:
Please be informed that the undersigned counsel has set the foregoing Motion to
intervene for hearing on December 25, 2013 at 8:30 am, for the consideration of the
Honorable Court or soon thereafter as counsel maybe heard.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Plaintiff
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa City
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel B. Venturillo, Counsel for the defendant in
the case entitled Alexander Bermejo vs. Roel Ponce de Leon, Civil Case No. 65448,
and that such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties,
the Motion to intervene filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Bernardo U. Goy, counsel for the Plaintiff, by personal service by delivering
personally copy of said Motion upon said lawyer who acknowledged receipt there of as
shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 12th day of December 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 24 thday of December2013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 12thday of December 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the Land
Transportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his
photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed the
foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth of
the contents of said instrument
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINO
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
49/58
49
Notary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 115 ANSWER-IN-INTERVENTION
Republic of the Philippines
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT
Branch 47Puerto Princesa City, Palawan
PEDRO MANZANOPlaintiff, Civil case No. 5524
-versus-
PARTITION OF PROPERTY
JUAN DE CASTRODefendant
x --------------------------------------x
ANSWER-IN-INTERVENTION
DEFENDANT, Juan de Castro, by undersigned counsel and to this honorable
Court, respectfully alleges:
1. He is one of the co-owners of the property, subject matter of the petition for
partition, whose undivided share be sold to plaintiff intervenor.
2. He admits having sold his undivided share in the property in question to Pedro
Manzano as shown in the copy of the Deed of Sale, Annex A of the complaint-in-
intervention, but he avers in this connection that the buyer, Pedro Manzano has not fully
paid the consideration.
By way of counterclaim, defendant Juan de Castro alleges:
3. Plaintiff-intervenor has not paid the full purchase of the property to answering
defendant, as he has not paid the unpaid balance of P2,000,000.00, which he refused
to pay and still continues to refuse to pay the same, notwithstanding demands.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
50/58
50
WHEREFORE, defendant Juan de Castro respectfully prays that the complaint-
in-intervention be dismissed for lack of merit.
Alternatively, Pedro Manzano be ordered to pay the balance of the purchase
price of P2,000,000.00, before the share of defendant de Castro may be transferred to
him, a purchaser of the undivided share.
Defendant de Castro prays for such other reliefs as may be just and equitable in
the premises.
Puerto Princesa City, Palawan, December 12, 2013.
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Defendant
Bgy. Sta. Monica. Puerto Princesa CityRoll No. 75648
IBP No. 0457 - Palawan,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel s. Belarmino, Counsel for the defendant
in the case entitled Pedro Manzano vs. Juan De Castro, Civil Case No. 5524, and that
such messenger I served upon the counsel of adverse party and other parties, the
Answer -in-intervention filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Bernardo U. Goy, counsel for the Plaintiff, by personal service by delivering
personally copy of said Answer upon said lawyer who acknowledged receipt there of as
shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 12th day of December 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 24 thday of December2013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME, A Notary public in and for theCity of Puerto Princesa and the Province of Palawan this 12thday of December 2013.
Affiant personally came and appeared with Drivers License ID No. issued by the LandTransportation Office and valid until May 1, 2015, at Puerto Princesa City, bearing his
photograph and signature, known to me as the same person who personally signed the
foregoing instrument before me and avowed under penalty of law to the whole truth of
the contents of said instrument
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
51/58
51
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINONotary Public
Until December 31, 2014
Doc. No. ______;
Page No. ______;
Book No. ______;
Series of 2013;
FORM NO. 116 PETITION FOR INTERVENTION FILED WITH THE APPELLATE
COURT, EITHER BEFORE THE COURT OF APPEALS OR THE SUPREME COURT,
AS THE CASE MAY BE.
Republic of the Philippines
SUPREME COURTManila
PAL EMPLOYESS ASSOCIATION,INC.
Plaintiff - Appellee,
-versus-
GR No. 658725
COURT OF APPEALS,PHILIPPINE AIRLINES
Defendant - Appellant
x --------------------------------------x
COMES now Philippine Pacific Airlines, by undersigned counsel and to this
Honorable Court, respectfully states:
1. Pending before the Supreme Court is GR. No. 658725 entitled PAL
Employees Association, Inc. questioning the constitutionality of Executive Order No.253 which enunciates an open sky policy to giant foreign cargo airlines to the prejudice
of domestic airlines.
2. Philippine Pacific Airlines is a domestic airline cargo airline, which flies the
international airport in CLARK to foreign countries and back. The issuance of E.O. 253
has prejudiced domestic cargo airlines because of limited resources and of few cargo
airplanes they could not compete with giant foreign cargo airlines allowed to engaged in
cargo business under E.O. 253 such that the day would come when they would face
bankruptcy. One of such domestic cargo airlines affected by said E.O. 253 is herein
movant.
3. Accordingly, movant has legal interest in declaring EO 253 unconstitutional as
its declaration will preclude foreign cargo airlines from competing with domestic cargo
airlines, like herein movant.
-
8/13/2019 Legal Form (81-100)
52/58
52
4. Said EO 253 is unconstitutional apart from what has been advanced in the
pending petition to declare said executive order null and void, for the reasons discussed
in detail in the attached petition-in-intervention.
WHEREFORE, movant Philippine Pacific Airline be allowed to intervene and to
join common cause with PAL Employees Association, Inc. in the pending case, that the
attached petition-in-intervention be admitted, and that said E.O. 253 be declared
unconstitutional.
Manila, Philippines March 4, 2013
ATTY. ARNEL S. BELARMINOCounsel for the Movant
Intramuros, Manila
Roll No. 75648IBP No. 0457 - Manila,
PTR No. 11456788, issued on April 13, 2012,
MCLE Compliance Cert. No. 66587
AFFIDAVIT OF PERSONAL SERVICE
I, JOSEPH D. DAJAY, of legal age and having been duly sworn depose and say:
That I am the messenger of Atty. Arnel s. Belarmino, Counsel for the defendant
in the case entitled PAL Employees Association vs Court of Appeals, et al, and that
such messenger I served upon the Supreme, the Petition filed in said case, as follows:
Atty. Bernardo U. Goy, Clerk of Court of the Supreme Court, by personal service
by delivering personally copy of said Petiton upon said clerk of court who acknowledged
receipt there of as shown by his signature or initial on the said pleading, this 12th day of
December 2013
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have signed this affidavit this 24 thday of December2013 at Puerto Princesa City.
JOSEPH D. DAJAYAffiant