legacy - august 2014
DESCRIPTION
Complimentary, on-line magazine by Wild Game Fish Conservation International. Featuring issues that impact wild game fish, wildlife artists, conservation-based businesses, fishing photos and more - something valuable for all.TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
…………………..
LLeeggaaccyy
eeMMaaggaazziinnee ooff WWiilldd GGaammee FFiisshh CCoonnsseerrvvaattiioonn IInntteerrnnaattiioonnaall
IIIssssssuuueee 333444 | AAAuuuggguuusssttt 222000111444
Published by:
Wild Game Fish Conservation
International
OOOnnn ttthhheee cccooovvveeerrr::: DDDooouuuggglllaaasss CCChhhaaannnnnneeelll ,,, BBBrrriii ttt iiissshhh CCCooollluuummmbbbiiiaaa,,, CCCaaannnaaadddaaa
AAAttt tttrrreeemmmeeennndddooouuusss rrr iiissskkk ddduuueee tttooo CCCaaannnaaadddaaa ’’’sss rrreeeccceeennnttt aaauuuttthhhooorrr iiizzzaaattt iiiooonnn fffooorrr
NNNooorrrttthhheeerrrnnn GGGaaattteeewwwaaayyy PPPiiipppeeelll iiinnneeesss ppprrrooojjjeeecccttt
IIInnn TTThhhiiisss IIIssssssuuueee
BBBrrreeeaaakkkiiinnnggg NNNeeewwwsss ––– AAAccctttiiiooonnn AAAllleeerrrttt
CCCooonnnssseeerrrvvvaaatttiiiooonnniiisssttt EEExxxtttrrraaaooorrrdddiiinnnaaaiiirrreee
JJJiiimmm aaannnddd DDDooonnnnnnaaa TTTeeeeeennnyyy
HHHooosssttteeeddd tttrrriiipppsss,,, GGGaaalllllleeerrryyy
“““FFFiiissshhhyyy””” BBBuuusssiiinnneeesssssseeesss
FFFiiissshhhiiinnnggg TTTiiipppsss aaannnddd TTTrrriiiccckkksss
WWWiiillldddllliiifffeee AAArrrtttiiissstttsss
CCCooommmmmmuuunnniiitttyyy AAAccctttiiivvviiisssmmm
SSSeeeaaafffooooooddd CCCooonnnsssuuummmppptttiiiooonnn
SSSaaalllmmmooonnn FFFeeeeeedddllloootttsss
EEEnnneeerrrgggyyy GGGeeennneeerrraaatttiiiooonnn
MMMooorrreee
![Page 2: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Wild Game Fish Conservation International (WGFCI): Established to
advocate for wild game fish, their fragile ecosystems and the cultures and economies that rely on their robust populations.
LEGACY – Journal of Wild Game Fish Conservation: Complimentary, no-
nonsense, monthly publication by conservationists for conservationists
LEGACY, the WGFCI Facebook page and the WGFCI website are utilized
to better equip fellow conservationists, elected officials, business owners and others regarding wild game fish, their contributions to society and the varied and complex issues impacting them and those who rely on their sustainability.
LEGACY exposes impacts to wild game fish while featuring wild game fish
conservation projects, fishing adventures, wildlife art, accommodations, equipment and more. Your photos and articles featuring wild game fish from around planet earth are
welcome for possible inclusion in an upcoming issue of LEGACY. E-mail them with
captions and credits to Jim ([email protected]).
Successful wild game fish conservation efforts around planet earth will ensure existence of these precious natural resources and their ecosystems for future
generations to enjoy and appreciate. This is our LEGACY.
LLeeggaaccyy
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
Founders
Bruce Treichler Jim Wilcox
![Page 3: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Contents
WGFCI Outreach via Legacy and Facebook _________________________________________________________ 7
BREAKING NEWS: PROTECT WILD SALMON _______________________________________________________ 8
Peace Arch Rally Schedule _____________________________________________________ Error! Bookmark not defined.
Busted __________________________________________________________________________________________ 10
5 Wisconsin Anglers Busted for Poaching on Devils Lake _______________________________________________ 10
Wild Game Fish Economics _______________________________________________________________________ 12
Monster sockeye run starting to enter Fraser River _____________________________________________________ 12
Special Report ___________________________________________________________________________________ 15
Special Report: Southern Resident Killer Whales _______________________________________________________ 15
Conservationists Extraordinaire – Walking the Talk _________________________________________________ 16
Jim and Donna Teeny ________________________________________________________________________________ 16
Featured Fishing Adventures, Photos, “Funnies” and Not so Funny: _________________________________ 17
Fish for Peacock Bass on Brazil’s Aqua Boa River with host Camille Egdorf ______________________________ 17
Fly Gal Ventures Hosted Travel: New Zealand – December 2014 _________________________________________ 18
Brown bears fishing for returning salmon at Brooks Falls, Katmai National Park, Alaska __________________ 19
Hidden Paths - Slovenia: Sava River- fishing club Radovljica ____________________________________________ 20
The Big Halibut That Didn't Get Away! _________________________________________________________________ 21
Ling cod on light tackle _______________________________________________________________________________ 22
Blue Marlin: Released to Fight Again __________________________________________________________________ 23
Jim Wilcox with a chinook salmon _____________________________________________________________________ 26
Conservation-minded businesses – please support these fine businesses ___________________________ 28
Kingfish West Coast Adventure Tours _________________________________________________________________ 28
Dave and Kim Egdorf's Western Alaska Sport Fishing __________________________________________________ 29
UWET "STAY-DRY" UNDERWATER TOURS ____________________________________________________________ 30
EcoDepot: “Solar Saves Salmon”! _____________________________________________________________________ 31
Spirit Bear Coffee Company ___________________________________________________________________________ 32
Winsmes Fly Fishing Lodge, Norway __________________________________________________________________ 33
Congratulations to Bravo Restaurant and Lounge Management and Staff ________________________________ 34
Rhett Weber’s Charterboat “Slammer” _________________________________________________________________ 35
Riverman Guide Service – since 1969 __________________________________________________________________ 36
Learn to fish: experienced, conservation-minded professional instructors ________________________________ 37
Westcoast Fishing Adventures ________________________________________________________________________ 38
Waters West Guided Sportfishing _____________________________________________________________________ 39
Fishing Tips and Tricks ___________________________________________________________________________ 41
You May Be Killing Steelhead And Not Even Know It ____________________________________________________ 41
Wildlife Artists: __________________________________________________________________________________ 43
Artist Beau Dick with one of his creations ______________________________________________________________ 44
Diane Michelin: “Still Time” ___________________________________________________________________________ 45
Dan Wallace (Haida): Eagle Pendant (featured) _________________________________________________________ 46
New from Anissa Reed Designs and Art ________________________________________________________________ 47
The Wilds ____________________________________________________________________________________________ 48
![Page 4: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Editorial Opinion _________________________________________________________________________________ 49
Work together for fish, or pull the recovery plug ________________________________________________________ 49
Seafood consumption: Public health risks and benefits _____________________________________________ 50
Enjoy seasonal wild salmon dinners at these fine restaurants:___________________________________________ 50
Norwegian Scientists Warn Against Eating Farmed Salmon: Everything You Need to Know About
Farmed Fish _________________________________________________________________________________________ 51
Salmon farmer signs 'fish waste to protein supplement' deal ____________________________________________ 55
WGFCI: protecting what needs protected __________________________________________________________ 57
Sam Mace: Crackdown on Deadbeat Dams _____________________________________________________________ 57
Maria Cantwell, Patty Murray, Denny Heck: Protect Wild Salmon Rally ___________________________________ 57
Preliminary examination of contaminant loadings in farmed salmon, wild salmon and commercial
salmon feed _________________________________________________________________________________________ 57
Community Activism, Education, Litigation and Outreach ___________________________________________ 58
Honoring the 47 – One year later ______________________________________________________________________ 59
2nd thoughts on 3 oil terminals _______________________________________________________________________ 62
Oil Trains in Washington: Bad for Business, Unacceptable Risk _________________________________________ 63
Millions of Americans live in the blast zone. Do you? ___________________________________________________ 64
State firefighters want Inslee to halt Bakken crude by rail till safety concerns addressed __________________ 65
Confronting Canada Day - Dan Wallace, Audrey Siegl ___________________________________________________ 69
The Answer is Still NO to Northern Gateway Pipelines __________________________________________________ 71
Enbridge and Kinder Morgan: We take offense to you ruining our land air and water ______________________ 72
Winning the farmed salmon war one battle at a time ____________________________________________________ 73
Farmed-Salmon-Boycott launches a NEW WEBSITE!! ___________________________________________________ 74
Olympia “Salmon Confidential” Premiere – October 5 ___________________________________________________ 75
Call for Action: No Salmon Farming Expansion without Wild Salmon Protection __________________________ 77
Getting Nervous? – Marine Harvest Canada presents science refuting Alexandra Morton’s lawsuit _________ 78
Wild Salmon Warrior Radio with Jay Peachy – Tuesday Mornings ________________________________________ 81
Wild Salmon Warrior Radio – Recent Archives _________________________________________________________ 82
Salmon feedlots __________________________________________________________________________________ 83
Salmon farm Production Manager to jail _______________________________________________________________ 84
Level playing field needed for aquaculture _____________________________________________________________ 85
As fish farms proliferate, diseases do too ______________________________________________________________ 87
Report slams fish farm secrecy on B.C. coast __________________________________________________________ 89
Skwah First Nation open statement in support of the “Protect Wild Salmon Rally” ________________________ 93
DFO aims to streamline fish-farm regulations __________________________________________________________ 96
Energy Generation: Oil, Coal, Geothermal, Hydropower, Natural Gas, Solar, Tidal, Wind _______________ 98
Petroleum – Drilled, Refined, Tar Sands, Fracked _________________________________________________________ 99
Petropolis - Rape and pillage of Canada and Canadians for toxic bitumen ________________________________ 99
Pacific Northwest's Salish Sea Eyed as Fossil Fuel Gateway ___________________________________________ 102
Pipeline proponents consider explosives in ocean to scare whales from potential oil slicks ______________ 108
City of Vancouver says Kinder Morgan skirting questions about Trans Mountain pipeline ________________ 111
![Page 5: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The oil boom in one slick infographic _________________________________________________________________ 114
Chinese oil pipeline burns, thousands evacuated ______________________________________________________ 115
Officials: Oil Train Dangers Extend Past Bakken _______________________________________________________ 116
ISIS Sabotaged Oil Pipeline in Baghdad... Tigris River on fire ___________________________________________ 119
Northern Gateway is not alone - 5 more pipelines to watch _____________________________________________ 120
PIPELINE ON WHEELS ______________________________________________________________________________ 124
Oregon subsidizing Rainier rail safety project allowing 14 more oil trains a month _______________________ 130
Winnipeg derailment renews safety concerns about crude oil shipments ________________________________ 133
Oil by rail data shows 10-15 trains of Bakken crude move weekly through Thurston County, 11-16 go in
Pierce ______________________________________________________________________________________________ 135
Coal __________________________________________________________________________________________________ 138
Federal Court Halts Plans for Colorado Coal Mine Citing Climate Change Concerns ______________________ 139
Geothermal ___________________________________________________________________________________________ 142
Canada’s high temperature geothermal reserves are in British Columbia ________________________________ 142
Hydropower ___________________________________________________________________________________________ 143
“DamNation” _______________________________________________________________________________________ 143
Don't rush Site C dam, mayor urges __________________________________________________________________ 144
About 14,000 young salmon die in Elwha River release of 2.6 million fish ________________________________ 146
County Won't Intervene in Weyco Land Fees __________________________________________________________ 148
Liquefied Natural Gas __________________________________________________________________________________ 150
LNG terminals could collapse B.C. wild salmon run: SFU scientists _____________________________________ 150
Solar _________________________________________________________________________________________________ 151
30MW of solar to be built on former Notthinghamshire colliery sites ____________________________________ 153
Government action ______________________________________________________________________________ 156
B.C. First Nation evicts CN Rail, logging companies, fishermen from their lands _________________________ 157
Greenwashing __________________________________________________________________________________ 159
Rail Officials Explain Improvement Grant to Chehalis Officials __________________________________________ 159
Third-party evidence confirms Marine Harvest's healthy salmon ________________________________________ 161
Wild Game Fish Management ____________________________________________________________________ 163
Feds Quintuple Allowed Catch on Endangered Salmon Species ________________________________________ 163
Rich countries pay zombie fishing boats $5 billion a year to plunder the seas ___________________________ 166
![Page 6: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
LLeeggaaccyy
Forward The August 2014 issue of Legacy marks thirty four consecutive months of our
complimentary eMagazine; the no-holds-barred, watchdog journal published by Wild Game Fish Conservation International.
Legacy is published each month to expose risks to the future of wild game fish and
their fragile ecosystems around planet earth to our growing audience. This unique magazine also introduces leading edge alternatives to today’s unsustainable practices.
Each month Legacy selects wildlife artists to feature, several conservation-
minded businesses to promote and several fishing photos from around planet Earth.
Our hope is that those who read Legacy will come to understand that what is good for
wild game fish is also good for humans. Similarly, what is bad for our planet’s wild game fish is really bad for humans!
A growing number of recreational anglers and others around planet earth are
passionate about conserving wild game fish and their continued availability for this and future generations to enjoy and appreciate. Additionally, growing numbers of
consumers and retailers are paying close attention to the impacts each of us have on
global resources through our daily activities and purchases.
We continue to urge our readers to speak out passionately and to demonstrate
peacefully for wild game fish and their ecosystems; ecosystems that we are but one small component of.
As recreational fishermen, conservation of wild game fish is our passion. Publishing
“Legacy” each month is our self imposed responsibility to help ensure the future of these precious gifts that have been entrusted for safekeeping to our generation.
Bruce Treichler
James E. Wilcox Wild Game Fish Conservation International
![Page 7: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters WGFCI Outreach via Legacy and Facebook
July issue of Legacy read in these countries
![Page 8: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
BREAKING NEWS: PROTECT WILD SALMON
Press Release
Canada Fails to Protect Wild Salmon From Industrial Salmon Farms
We call on the North American Free Trade Agreement Body (NAFTA) to investigate
this failure before it is too late!
“Protect Wild Salmon”
Peaceful Rally at Peace Arch Border Crossing
Saturday, July 19, 2014 (11:00 am – 3:00 pm )
Keynote Speakers include:
Joanne Charles, Semiahmoo First Nation Councillor Zeke Grader, Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen’s Association Ernie Crey, Cheam First Nation Fisheries Portfolio Craig Orr, Watershed Watch Salmon Society Alexandra Morton, Pacific Coast Wild Salmon Society Dr. Claudette Bethune, Clinical Scientist Chief Judy Wilson, Neskonlith First Nation and UBCIC Secretary-Treasurer BC Salmon farms are 98% owned by Norwegian companies raising Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) and remain
plagued with diseases from mutating viruses and parasites that proliferate and can be passed onto wild salmon.
Ernie Crey is of the opinion that the Government of Canada dangerously increased the threats to wild salmon
survival by approving a 41% expansion plan of fish farms along the migration routes of sockeye salmon. “Instead
the Canadian Government has virtually ignored the $26 million Cohen Commission report. Justice Cohen
warned - salmon farms have the potential to do serious or irreversible harm to wild salmon, exclaimed a
disappointed Craig Orr. “The Canadian Government has no plans to view fish farm locations in relation to
inward/outward migration of wild salmon for their protection, and this irresponsible,” stated Bob Chamberlin of
UBCIC. Industrial feedlots never shovel their manure and use chemicals and antibiotics to protect farmed fish,
which pollute the environment and threaten human health. “The Canadian Government has, to date, refused to
remove the Department of Fisheries and Ocean’s conflict of interest as it continues with a mandate to promote,
support and enable salmon farm expansion, and, at the same time, regulates this industry. This is
unacceptable,” stated Chief Judy Wilson. Recently the Canadian Government removed a major part of the
Fisheries Act to allow the release of delousing drugs directly into the water that can kill wild salmon (section 56).
Dr. Alexandra Morton leveled the following sharp criticism at the Government of Canada, “The sheer
recklessness of allowing Atlantic salmon on the Fraser salmon migration route is unforgiveable and has to stop if
we expect wild salmon to deal with everything else we are throwing at them!” Alex added “We will only stop this
when everyone stands up … I think this is happening!” Astonishingly, the Canadian government is considering
an Aquaculture Act to give the industry unprecedented rights in Canada’s marine waters and fish.
The First Nations Wild Salmon Alliance, a coalition of 80 First Nations, witnessed the unacceptable, devastating
impact fish farms have on wild salmon and will look at government’s “duty to consult” before any fish farms are
sited on migration routes of wild salmon. Health experts around the world point to the health dangers of farmed
salmon consumption due to relatively high levels of contaminants such as PCBs, dioxins, pesticides, and flame-
retardants, which are proven to impair cognitive function and are known carcinogens. “Salmon are carnivores
and farms have been criticized globally for using unsustainable fishery resources,” observed Dr. Claudette
Bethune. Although there is room for some forms of aquaculture, scientists and experts conclude that a feasible
and sustainable solution lies in moving ocean fish farms onto land in containment, farming herbivore fish, and
growing the entire food chain. “Stakeholders on both sides of the border urge NAFTA to follow through with the
investigation. Wild salmon don’t recognize borders, and therefore both countries need to work together to protect
wild salmon, its habitat and the health of their citizens,” asserted Zeke Grader.
Eddie Gardner
Event Coordinator
![Page 9: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 10: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Busted
5 Wisconsin Anglers Busted for Poaching on Devils Lake
July 6, 2014
![Page 11: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Five Wisconsin anglers have been charged in Ramsey Court with exceeding their possession limit of
walleyes in excess of 100 fish on Grand Lake in North Dakota according to a report on
GrandForksHerald.com. The daily creel limit is 5 per person and 10 in possession.
Here are the charged men’s names and their hometowns. They were turned in by another concerned
angler who called the Report all Poachers hotline and tipped off North Dakota Game and Fish
authorities
Michael Wirkus, Racine Wis.
Donald Klatkiewicz, Mukwonago, Wis.
Daniel Klatkiewicz, Hales Corners,
Wis.
Robert Richer Jr., Hales Corners, Wis.
Allen Lafave, Racine, Wis.
Unnamed juvenile
Authorities caught the group on June 20, 2014 and a quick search of the vehicle resulted in 25 whole
walleyes. A search of the house they were staying in, however, resulted in another 135 walleyes
cleaned and frozen in 45 freezer bags. That put the men exactly 100 over their possession limit.
The group will appear in court August 18 and face up to $1,725 a piece
in fines.
Being over the possession limit is a Class B Misdemeanor in North Dakota.
![Page 12: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Wild Game Fish Economics
Monster sockeye run starting to enter Fraser River
July 4, 2014
Sockeye by the thousands could start
swimming up the Fraser River shortly.
The prized red sockeye entering the river now
are the offspring of the 2010 run — the largest
sockeye return on the Fraser in the last 100
years.
This year is shaping up to be similar in scope,
with a mid-range forecast by Fisheries and
Oceans Canada officials set at 23 million
sockeye. The bulk of it will be in the late run
which includes the prodigious Adams River
stock.
Editorial Comment:
Canada must no longer ignore the cultural, environmental and economic benefits directly associated with robust wild salmon populations.
Canada’s expansion of ocean-based salmon feedlots, open pit mines, dilbit export, hydropower generation, floodplain development and irresponsible logging will lead to the shameful demise of British Columbia’s iconic, wild Pacific salmon and all that rely on them
![Page 13: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
“The early Stuart run is just starting to enter the Fraser River,” said Jennifer Nener, DFO area director
for the Lower Fraser. There were just a handful counted since test fishing started.
“We need considerably more data before considering any openings,” she said.
They’ll know more in a few short weeks.
Fishermen are checking their gear. Guiding outfits are hiring and
booking like mad. Tackle stores are adding inventory. Many are
watching the test fishery numbers with considerable interest. The
computer modelling puts the estimated Fraser return total anywhere
between about 7 million and 70 million sockeye.
Sto:lo fisher and Grand Chief Ken Malloway said he figures the 23 million estimate is on the
conservative side.
“I say it may be closer to 30 million,” he said. “I’m getting pretty anxious.”
The FSC fishery won’t open until the numbers in the river are higher, but they might also open the dry
rack fishery at that time.
Regardless of the exact numbers, this season is going to have broad local impacts.
Aboriginal, commercial, and sport fishery opportunities for Fraser sockeye are all expected to open at
various times this season.
One concern raised by conservation groups is the that the exploitation
rate on Interior Fraser Coho will be going up to 16 per cent, from three
per cent. The “exploitation” rate is the limiting of unintentional by-
catch by commercial fishers to protect the endangered species. Coho
and sockeye tend to co-migrate through the system, and get caught in
the nets together.
It’s only for one year, said Nener, and the rationale for a higher rate is to better manage the sockeye
and the coho. Coho numbers have improved.
“I’ve never seen it that high,” said Malloway about the increased rate of allowable by-catch.
But good sockeye returns this summer also mean economic benefits for different users.
Up to 23 Sto:lo communities are in negotiations to sign an agreement under the Aboriginal Fisheries
Strategy.
“It’s going to mean that Sto:lo families should have enough fish, and also opportunities to make a
living off fishing the way we used to,” said Malloway.
Ernie Crey, fisheries adviser to the Sto:lo Tribal Council, said the Early Stuart run, one component of
the big Fraser run, could sustain aboriginal fisheries on a scale that no one has seen in a while.
Sto:lo fishing families are not only planning an earlier than usual dry-rack fishery in the Fraser
Canyon, but also a food, social, and ceremonial (FSC) fishery.
“We have not had a general opening on the Early Stuart for a long time. The run has been generally
weak,” he noted.
![Page 14: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Economic opportunities for Sto:lo under AFS, meaning the chance to sell their catch, are likely
coming for the Early Summer run, the first of four main runs on the Fraser.
Dean Werk, president of the Fraser Valley Salmon Society predicts there will be “lots of happy
fishers” in all the user groups.
“We may never see a year like this again.”
It’s going to mean ample opportunities to get out on the river.
“People are excited to hear we are going to have some good returns,” he said. “Chilliwack and area
has the most to gain from what we’re about to see.”
Fishing is a major economic driver for Chilliwack and area.
“Even at half the number they’re predicted, it’s still going to be good.”
Guides and other tourism-related businesses are poised to do well this
season.
“This is the hub of it all,” said Werk, who also owns Great River Fishing Adventures.
He’s looking to hire more river guides.
“We’re booked solid and virtually sold out right now.”
From the Vedder Canal to Hope is where “the magic” is, he said. “People need to be in the gravel
reach.”
![Page 15: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Special Report
Special Report: Southern Resident Killer Whales
10 Years of Research and Conservation
June 25, 2014
Today, NOAA Fisheries released a report
highlighting the accomplishments of 10 years
of dedicated research and conservation of the
endangered Southern Resident killer whale
population. With a decade of federal funding
and productive partnerships with the killer
whale community, we have taken targeted
actions, collected substantial new data, and
refined scientific techniques to protect this
listed species and ensure a strong foundation
for its recovery.
Some Findings and Milestones
Southern Residents favor Chinook
salmon as prey.
They are among the most contaminated
marine mammals in the world.
When vessels are present, they hunt
less and travel more.
NOAA established new vessel approach
regulations and oil spill contingencies to
protect the whales.
In the winter, they forage along the West Coast as far south as central California.
Looking Ahead
The population continues to struggle to recover, due in part to the influence of risk factors we have
yet to fully understand. While we have come a long way in understanding of some key aspects of
these risk factors, and have improved our ability to protect these animals, many questions still
remain.
Editorial Comment:
Amazing – Nothing new after spending
millions of taxpayer dollars the past ten
years
As with other taxpayer-funded, “cash
cows”, more time and money will be
required to resolve many questions.
In the meantime:
Chinook salmon populations continue
to plummet
Increased risks of catastrophic oil spills
Increased noise pollution (sonar,
engine noises) with increased oil and
coal tankers
Southern Resident killer whales and other
marine wildlife are doomed if society fails
to effectively protect them and their
ecosystems.
![Page 16: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Conservationists Extraordinaire – Walking the Talk
Jim and Donna Teeny
![Page 17: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Featured Fishing Adventures, Photos, “Funnies” and Not so Funny:
Fish for Peacock Bass on Brazil’s Aqua Boa River with host Camille Egdorf
Base camp: Aqua Boa Amazon Lodge Dates: December 18-27. 2014 Est. cost: $4,000
Book your Peacock Bass fishing adventure with Fishing with Larry
III'''mmm hhhooossstttiiinnnggg aaannnooottthhheeerrr gggrrrooouuuppp tttooo ttthhheee
AAAmmmaaazzzooonnn iiinnn DDDeeeccceeemmmbbbeeerrr 222000111444!!!
WWWhhhooo wwwaaannntttsss tttooo jjjoooiiinnn mmmeee???
CCCaaammmiiilllllleee
You can land 30 to 100+ peacock bass per day. Some will be huge. The lodge has exclusive rights to over 100-miles of the Agua Boa River so you literally have an entire river to yourself.
There is a giant reserve area – birds, wildlife, no people, no mosquitoes. There is one guide per two anglers per boat.
Includes: airport reception, all transfers in Brazil, 240-mile deluxe roundtrip flight Manaus, Brazil to lodge, lodging, daily laundry service, meals, soft drinks, beer, wine, and local liquor, fishing license, free copy of Larry’s 40-page book Fly fishing for Peacock Bass. We also supply all flies, and fly patterns. Plus, courtesy of Agua Boa Amazon Lodge - Free 8-day Global Rescue Insurance, a $119.00 value.
Does not include: international airfare, Brazilian visa, satellite telephone calls, liquor, airport taxes, overnight hotel and meals in Manaus, and tackle. (Our hosted groups usually stay together at a nicer hotel in Manaus.)
![Page 18: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Fly Gal Ventures Hosted Travel: New Zealand – December 2014
![Page 19: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Brown bears fishing for returning salmon at Brooks Falls, Katmai National
Park, Alaska
Watch realtime bear cam HERE
![Page 20: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Hidden Paths - Slovenia: Sava River- fishing club Radovljica
![Page 21: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The Big Halibut That Didn't Get Away!
It was 99 inches long between 550-560 pounds! I would have released it, but it had swallowed my
Davis Spanker jig and was bleeding.
The angler who hooked into it thought he was snagged on the bottom and couldn't get it to budge so
handed me the rod and I got it coming in, then handed him his rod back and he fought it for 45
minutes and gave out from exhaustion and handed me the rod back and I finished fighting the battle
landing the GIANT!
It would be the all tackle World record, but you are instantly disqualified if anyone else touches your
rod!!! The guy standing in the photo is 6'7"
George Davis – Alaska Wild Adventures
![Page 22: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Ling cod on light tackle
Rhett Webber: Owner / Operator “Slammer” – Westport, Washington
![Page 23: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Blue Marlin: Released to Fight Again
Photo credit: Frank Rodriguez – Owner: The Fa La Me
![Page 24: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 25: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 26: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Jim Wilcox with a chinook salmon
Fishing out of Westport, Washington with longtime friend Terry Turner on “Slammer”
![Page 27: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 28: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Conservation-minded businesses – please support these fine businesses
Kingfish West Coast Adventure Tours
Trophy Salmon and Steelhead fishing on the Kitimat River with driftboat, riverraft or pontoonboat, we
offer as well remote streamside wading. We are specialized in fly-fishing and conventional fishing
techniques for silver chrome aggressive steelhead and salmon. We give our clients the opportunity to
fish our headwaters, tributaries and mainstream Kitimat River. The lower section of the Kitimat River
we target with the jet boat and is considered tidal and can offer phenomenal fishing for salmon as
they migrate upriver.
![Page 29: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Dave and Kim Egdorf's Western Alaska Sport Fishing
Booking Now for 2014
Montana: (406) 665-3489 Alaska: (907) 842-5480
![Page 30: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
UWET "STAY-DRY" UNDERWATER TOURS
UWET "STAY-DRY" UNDERWATER TOURS
TTHHEE WWOORRLLDD''SS UULLTTIIMMAATTEE EECCOO--TTOOUURR UNDERWATER EXPLORATIONS
of
SEATTLE'S PUGET SOUND
You, Your Family, Couples, Friends, Parents/Grandparents with Children, and Groups...
Anyone can become a UWET Explorer!
Individuals (ages 6/up) seeking interactive small group experiences...
UWET Tours are very small group (4 Explorers maximum per tour)!
Travelers and Cruisers seeking pleasant low-stress tour experiences...
UWET Tours are 100% "Stay-Dry" underwater investigations (explorers do not even get their feet wet)!
Everyday People who fantasize about being a "real" explorer sharing the excitement
and glory of discovery with others... UWET Discovery Tours transform ordinary people into Genuine Underwater Eco-Explorers who have a DVD of their discoveries to share with others!
![Page 31: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
EcoDepot: “Solar Saves Salmon”!
EcoDepot powers up a music fest and spreads the word
![Page 32: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Spirit Bear Coffee Company
Welcome to Spirit Bear
Welcome to Spirit Bear Coffee, the home of the world's finest Organic Coffee.
Why organic coffee instead of conventional coffee? Conventional coffees are grown with herbicides, pesticides and fungicides which are extremely dangerous for the farmers, their families, and the surrounding ecosystem.
Organic coffee is grown without these chemicals and, as such, has a much gentler impact on the local environment.
Coffee trees normally do not grow in direct sunlight. Trees have now been genetically engineered to be sun-resistant. Widespread clear-cutting has been carried out to make way for these new strains of trees.
These are just two examples of why Organic Coffee is a reason, logical, and ethical alternative to mainstream sources.
![Page 33: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Winsmes Fly Fishing Lodge, Norway
![Page 34: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Congratulations to Bravo Restaurant and Lounge Management and Staff
![Page 35: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Rhett Weber’s Charterboat “Slammer”
Reserve your 2014 Pacific Ocean fishing adventures on Slammer through Deep Sea
Charters – Westport, Washington
222000111444
Westport Salmon Seasons Set:
Now through September 30: one wild
or one hatchery Chinook (King) and one
hatchery Coho (Silver) OR two hatchery
Coho (Silvers).
This is the first year since 1983 that
the season has been set to go 7 days
a week for the whole year!
Large quotas of both species.
![Page 36: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Riverman Guide Service – since 1969
Kim Malcom – Owner, Operator
Licensed and Insured Guide
Quality Float Trips – Western Washington Rivers – Steelhead, Salmon, Trout
KKKiiimmm MMMaaalllcccooommm’’’sss
RRRiiivvveeerrrmmmaaannn GGGuuuiiidddeee SSSeeerrrvvviiiccceee (((333666000))) 444555666---888444222444
![Page 37: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Learn to fish: experienced, conservation-minded professional instructors
View our six-panel, information brochure HERE
![Page 38: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Westcoast Fishing Adventures
We are a world class fishing destination with 17 years of guiding experience on the Skeena and
nearly all the remote systems of the North extending our boundaries as far as the head waters of the
Nass river.
Guests of Westcoast Fishing can expect a professional experience from the time you book your trip
we are licensed to guide on over 30 rivers including area lakes and Ocean fishing for halibut &
salmon. There are no extra rod days fees when fishing with our company we include them in the
package. Guests will stay at our B&B Style Lodge nested in between the mountains and the Skeena
River.
If you’re looking for a unique steelhead fly-fishing adventure — an expedition off the beaten path —
this is your trip. By truck, by boat, by helicopter (if you’re feeling rich ), or walk and wade — whatever
it takes — we’ll explore hidden valleys and fish where very few people have step foot before. Make
your reservations today or visit our guided adventures page for more information.
![Page 39: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Waters West Guided Sportfishing
We are full time USCG/WDFW licensed Washington and
Oregon fishing guides and charters.
We fish year round for trophy Salmon, Sturgeon, Steelhead
and Trout in Washington and Oregon's rivers, lakes, and
bays.
If you are looking for a top fishing guide who is familiar with
Washington and Oregon's popular fisheries such as, Buoy 10
near Astoria, Oregon, the beautiful Olympic Peninsula, scenic
Drano Lake, or the famous Columbia, Cowlitz,
Wynoochee and Chehalis Rivers, then look no further.
I offer both full (8-9hr.) and half day (4-5hr.) fishing trips and
charters at affordable rates for any skill level.
LLeettss FFiisshh!!
![Page 40: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 41: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Fishing Tips and Tricks
You May Be Killing Steelhead And Not Even Know It
STEELHEADERS ARE GENERALLY PRETTY SERIOUS ABOUT CATCH-AND-RELEASE,
BUT IT’S LIKELY THAT MANY ARE MORTALLY WOUNDING FISH WITHOUT EVER
KNOWING IT.
There are few species of fish as vulnerable as wild steelhead.
These fish are beset on all sides by threats both natural and man-made. With their numbers
dwindling, it’s safe to say, every steelhead counts. It’s vital that those of us who fish for them practice
the best catch-and-release practices.
However, common landing practices can kill fish without the angler ever knowing. A team of
biologists studying steelhead in British Columbia discovered this problem, quite by accident. These
scientists were tagging steelhead with GPS trackers. They determined that the least intrusive way to
capture the fish was, well, the same way we do it. With a fly rod. They landed the fish, tagged them
with the GPS device and released them. When they went to their computer to track the fish’s
progress they discovered something alarming.
Within two hours many of the fish they had tagged, and released in good health, were dead. They
collected the fish and performed autopsies to determine what had gone wrong.
![Page 42: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
In every case the cause of death was head trauma. It turns out that
‘steelhead’ is a misnomer. The fish’s head is, in fact, its most
vulnerable spot.
When landing the fish the researchers had played them into shallow water where they would be easy
to tail. As the fish came into the shallows they were no longer, fully submerged. Without the
resistance of the water surrounding them, their powerful thrashing was able to generate momentum
that is not possible underwater. The flopping fish simply hit their heads on a rock.
The fish appeared fine when released, but their injured brains began to swell and soon they were
dead.
It makes perfect sense if you think about it. Fish have evolved in an environment where hitting their
head on anything with enough force to cause damage is almost impossible. Their brains lack the
natural protection enjoyed by terrestrial species.
Luckily, this unfortunate outcome is easily avoided.
The angler has a couple of good options.
Landing fish by hand in knee deep water is a little tougher but much safer for the fish. You can
grab the leader to control the fish long enough to tail it. After a fish or two it will feel very
natural.
When possible, it’s best to use a good catch-and-release net. This is safest for the fish and
easiest for the angler. A net helps you seal the deal while the fish is still fresh and requires
little reviving.
Always control your fish once he’s landed.
Keep his gills wet and support his head in case he makes a sudden attempt to escape.
Keeping him, dorsal fin up, will keep his range of motion side-to-side, making it harder for him
to injure himself.
When possible keep him in deeper water.
Never beach a fish when landing him
Never lay him on the bank for a photo. It’s just not worth it.
Wild steelhead are precious resources.
Those of us who come to the river looking for them must lead by
example and do our best to be good stewards of these remarkable
fish.
Their future is, literally in our hands.
![Page 43: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Wildlife Artists:
![Page 44: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Artist Beau Dick with one of his creations
![Page 45: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Diane Michelin: “Still Time”
Original watercolor
10" x 8"
#2 of a series of 10
See more of Ms. Michelin’s amazing work at Fly Fishing Fine Art
Welcome to Fly Fishing Fine Art, including original paintings, limited edition prints and commissions in fly fishing and angling themes, by Canadian watercolor artist Diane Michelin. Diane is anxious to capture the essence of fly fishing and record those memories that bring us back to the river. Her art is currently on display in museums, fly shops, lodges and private collections. Browse through the gallery, and contact Diane Michelin directly to discuss your purchase of fly fishing fine art.
![Page 46: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Dan Wallace (Haida): Eagle Pendant (featured)
Oxidized Silver – 1 ½”
![Page 47: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
New from Anissa Reed Designs and Art
Get your WILD hippy on
From size 2T to adult XL
I dyed them myself and hand screened a new "Born TO Be W-I-L-D" version of my TM logo.
Kid sizes are $20 and adult sizes are $25. Shipping is $5 in Canada
Tell me what size and I'll let you know what I have in stock..
All tie dye have been colour set and washed in hot water and dried.
I also have ladies cuts.
![Page 48: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The Wilds
The Wilds: Owen Owen Owen, Holly Arntzen, Wil D Silversalmon, Kevin Wright, Christine Domeij
Sinclair and Shawn Soucy.
![Page 49: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Editorial Opinion
Work together for fish, or pull the recovery plug
by Jim Wilcox (Wild Game Fish Conservation International)
July 4, 2014
It’s time for our citizens to demand conservation (wise use)
of our tax dollars used to fund local, state and federal
projects. Of particular concern to me is the ongoing
expenditures of billions of dollars to recover Washington-
origin, wild Pacific salmon.
As a lifelong outdoorsman, this is truly a noble undertaking.
Unfortunately, the actions of our elected officials who react
to corporate thugs permit unwise utilization of the land and
water resources required to recover wild salmon.
From the proposed dam on the upper Chehalis River, to
steep slope clear cut logging, to ocean-based salmon
feedlots, to floodplain development, to source point and non-
source point pollution, to increased oil and coal exports - the
list of risks to Washington’s wild Pacific salmon is long and
complex.
The point being is that we all need to either work together to recover these magnificent fish and their
ecosystems or we should pull the financial plug on their recovery.
We simply cannot have robust populations of wild salmon while we
continue raping the very resources they require to thrive.
Jim Wilcox
![Page 50: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Seafood consumption: Public health risks and benefits
Enjoy seasonal wild salmon dinners at these fine restaurants:
![Page 51: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Norwegian Scientists Warn Against Eating Farmed Salmon: Everything You
Need to Know About Farmed Fish
February 15, 2014
![Page 52: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Women, children and adolescents should avoid eating farmed salmon,
according to Norwegian doctors and international experts. The reason
is that salmon feed contains harmful pollutants.
Talking to VG, specialist Anne-Lise Birch Monsen and Physician and professor of medicine, Bjørn
Bolann say that it is uncertain in both the amount of toxins and how they affect children, adolescents
and pregnant. They point out that the type of contaminants that have been detected in farmed
salmon have a negative effect on brain development and is associated with autism, AD / HD and
reduced IQ.
A large European study involving about 8,000 newborns, shows that pregnant women with high
levels of toxins in the body have children with lower birth weight, which may have an adverse effect
on child health.
Conservative party (Høyre) economic policy spokesman Svein Flåtten asks fisheries minister to
respond in the Parliament on whether Norwegian farmed salmon is dangerous to eat for children and
pregnant women.
I want to know what she can do to make Norwegian consumers and society sure that Norwegian
farmed salmon is a healthy and clean product. That’s what we’ve been hearing from researchers for
years, says Flåtten to NTB.
He believes there is reason to take seriously the warning raised by doctors.
- There is no doubt that such claims may have a negative effect on salmon industry. Therefore, it is
important to clarify this quickly. I expect the health authorities to look closely at the findings
discussed, he said.
If you eat seafood, unless you catch it yourself or ask the right questions, the odds are pretty good it
comes from a fish farm. The aquaculture industry is like a whale on steroids, growing faster than any
other animal agriculture segment and now accounting for half the fish eaten in the U.S.
As commercial fishing operations continue to strip the world’s oceans of life, with one-third of fishing
stocks collapsed and the rest headed there by mid-century, fish farming is seen as a way to meet the
world’s growing demand. But is it really the silver bullet to solve the Earth’s food needs? Can marine
farms reliably satisfy the seafood cravings of three billion people around the globe?
This article looks at aquaculture and its long-term effects on fish, people, and other animals. With this
industry regularly touted as a paragon of food production, whether you eat seafood or not, you should
know these nine key facts about farmed fish.
1. Farmed fish have dubious nutritional value. The Omega-3 Levels are Not What You Think
Here’s a frustrating paradox for those who eat fish for their health: the nutritional benefits of fish are
greatly decreased when it’s farmed. Take omega-3 fatty acids. Wild fish get their omega-3’s from
aquatic plants. Farmed fish, however, are often fed corn, soy, or other feedstuffs that contain little or
no omega-3’s. This unnatural, high-corn diet also means some farmed fish accumulate unhealthy
levels of the wrong fatty acids. Further, farmed fish are routinely dosed with antibiotics, which can
cause antibiotic-resistant disease in humans.
![Page 53: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
2. The farmed fishing industry robs Peter to pay Paul. Small Prey Fish May be Driven to
Extinction
While some farmed fish can live on diets of corn or soy, others need to eat fish – and lots of it. Tuna
and salmon, for example, need to eat up to five pounds of fish for each pound of body weight. The
result is that prey (fish like anchovies and herring) are being fished to the brink of extinction to feed
the world’s fish farms.
“We have caught all the big fish and now we are going after their food,” says the non-profit Oceana,
which blames aquaculture’s voracious hunger for declines of whales, dolphins, seals, sea lions, tuna,
bass, salmon, albatross, penguins, and other species.
3. Fish experience pain and stress.
Contrary to the wishful thinking of many a catch-and-release angler, the latest research shows
conclusively that fish experience pain and stress. In one study, fish injected with bee venom engaged
in rocking behavior linked to pain and, compared to control groups, reduced their swimming activity,
waited three times longer to eat, and had higher breathing rates. Farmed fish are subject to
the routine stresses of hyperconfinement throughout their lives, and are typically killed in slow, painful
ways like evisceration, starvation, or asphyxiation.
4. Farmed fish are loaded with disease, and this spreads to wild fish populations.
Farmed fish are packed as tightly as coins in a purse, with twenty-seven adult trout, for example,
typically scrunched into a bathtub-sized space. These unnatural conditions give rise to diseases and
parasites, which often migrate off the farm and infect wild fish populations. On Canada’s Pacific
coast, for example, sea lice infestations are responsible for mass kill-offs of pink salmon that have
destroyed 80% of the fish in some local populations. But the damage doesn’t end there, because
eagles, bears, orcas, and other predators depend on salmon for their existence. Drops in wild salmon
numbers cause these species to decline as well.
![Page 54: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
5. Fish farms are rife with toxins, which also damage local ecosystems.
You can’t have diseases and parasites infecting your economic units, so operators fight back by
dumping concentrated antibiotics and other chemicals into the water. Such toxins damage local
ecosystems in ways we’re just beginning to understand. One study found that a drug used to combat
sea lice kills a variety of nontarget marine invertebrates, travels up to half a mile, and persists in the
water for hours.
6. Farmed fish are living in their own feces.
That’s right, fish poop too. Farmed fish waste falls as sediment to the seabed in sufficient quantities
to overwhelm and kill marine life in the immediate vicinity and for some distance beyond. It also
promotes algal growth, which reduces water’s oxygen content and makes it hard to support life.
When the Israeli government learned that algal growth driven by two fish farms in the Red Sea was
hurting nearby coral reefs, it shut them down.
7. Farmed fish are always trying to escape their unpleasant conditions, and who can blame
them?
In the North Atlantic region alone, up to two million runaway salmon escape into the wild each year.
The result is that at least 20% of supposedly wild salmon caught in the North Atlantic are of farmed
origin. Escaped fish breed with wild fish and compromise the gene pool, harming the wild population.
Embryonic hybrid salmon, for example, are far less viable than their wild counterparts, and adult
hybrid salmon routinely die earlier than their purebred relatives. This pressure on wild populations
further hurts predators who rely on fish like bears and orcas.
8. See: the Jevons Paradox.
This counterintuitive economic theory says that as production methods grow more efficient, demand
for resources actually increases – rather than decreasing, as you might expect. Accordingly, as
aquaculture makes fish production increasingly efficient, and fish become more widely available and
less expensive, demand increases across the board. This drives more fishing, which hurts wild
populations. Thus, as the construction of new salmon hatcheries from 1987 to 1999 drove lower
prices and wider availability of salmon, world demand for salmon increased more than fourfold during
the period. The net result: fish farming cranks up the pressure on already-depleted populations of
wild fish around the world.
9. When the heavy environmental damage they cause is taken into account, fish farming
operations often are found to generate more costs than revenues.
One study found that aquaculture in Sweden’s coastal waters “is not only ecologically but also
economically unsustainable.” Another report concluded that fish farming in a Chinese lake is an
“economically irrational choice from the perspective of the whole society, with an unequal tradeoff
between environmental costs and economic benefits.” Simply put, aquaculture drives heavy
ecological harms and these cost society money. In the U.S., fish farming drives hidden costs of
roughly $700 million each year – or half the annual production value of fish farming operations.
![Page 55: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The new agreement has important implications for Scotland's salmon farming industry in terms of sustainability
Salmon farmer signs 'fish waste to protein supplement' deal
July 11, 2014
![Page 56: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Salmon waste is set to be turned into a dietary product, providing an
alternative source of protein that will help combat malnutrition.
An agreement has been signed between independent Scottish salmon farmer Loch Duart and
nutrition technology firm CellsUnited to significantly increase the value extracted from farmed
salmon.
Under the deal, Loch Duart will supply
CellsUnited with up to 450 tonnes of salmon
viscera and heads. The salmon by-product will
be used to produce Cellper, a nutritional
compound that can be given to people who
cannot otherwise digest protein.
The by-product will undergo a complex refinement process to produce the product, which can be
used in two forms - either as a dietary supplement in basic granular form that can be transported to
remote parts of the world, or as a liquid nutritional supplement for hospital patients.
The arrangement has important implications for Scotland's salmon farming industry in terms of
sustainability. Currently when salmon are prepared for customers, the guts are disposed of through
insilation and once filleted, the heads and frames are used in low-grade applications such as fertiliser
and pet food.
Important breakthrough
Loch Duart director Andy Bing says that the Cellper process is derived from technology developed for
long-distance space travel.
"The full nutritional benefit, including that of the viscera, frames and
heads, can be used to combat malnutrition in developing countries and
to speed the recovery of many categories of hospital patients in the
developed world. We are delighted to be part of this important
breakthrough," he commented.
According to CellsUnited managing director Andy Smith, the aquaculture industry represents a clear
commercial opportunity for the company's technology.
"We plan to spend the next 18 months working closely with Loch Duart before establishing volume
production, which will need a minimum of 4,500 tonnes of salmon waste a year. Our relationship with
Loch Duart will continue as part of our permanent R&D base in Dingwall," he said.
Loch Duart's farm is based in North West Scotland, where it produces around 5,000 tonnes of
salmon each year. It claims to be the first fish farm in the world to achieve RSPCA Freedom Food
approval, employing farming methods that include low density stocking farming, a rotational fallowing
system, swim-throughs and feed from sustainable sources.
Editorial Comment:
Culled, dead and dying, diseased salmon
will likely be included as waste to be
utilized in this effort to “improve nutrition”.
To what level is humanity sinking?
![Page 57: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
WGFCI: protecting what needs protected
.
Sam Mace: Crackdown on Deadbeat Dams Inland Northwest Director
Save Our Wild Salmon
Thanks to you and project partners for bringing DamNation to Olympia, Washington this evening -
further evidence of why new dams such as the one proposed for the Chehalis River should be
opposed,
Hopefully those who care about wild Snake River and Columbia River salmon and steelhead will sign
the "Crackdown on Deadbeat Dams" petition to President Obama at:
http://www.change.org/petitions/president-barack-obama-crack-down-on-deadbeat-dams.
Maria Cantwell, Patty Murray, Denny Heck: Protect Wild Salmon Rally
US Congress (Washington state)
This message was also sent to regional TV media:
KCPQ 13 (FOX), KING 5 (NBC), KIRO 7 (CBS), KOMO 4 (ABC),
We at Wild Game Fish Conservation International invite you to join a broad coalition of concerned
individuals and organizations for the the July 19, Protect Wild Salmon Rally at the International Peace
Arch border crossing between Canada and the USA.
Details of this important rally are available at:
http://issuu.com/steelhead-salmon-society/docs/protect_wild_salmon_rally
![Page 58: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Community Activism, Education, Litigation and Outreach
![Page 59: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Honoring the 47 – One year later
No Grays Harbor Crude Oil Export – Ever!
![Page 60: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The horrific events of July 6, 2013 when forty seven regular folks in the community of Lac Méganatic,
Quebec, Canada lost their lives were emotionally remembered today, one year later across North
America and around planet Earth.
These law-abiding citizens and their town center were “vaporized” immediately following the
derailment of several antiquated tank cars loaded with highly volatile Bakken deposit crude oil. This
Bakken crude exploded into an intense fireball that burned for more than three days – first responders
were simply overwhelmed.
The Quinault Indian Nation, Citizens for a Clean Harbor and others held a moving rally in Aberdeen,
Washington near the Port of Grays Harbor shipping terminals on this day to honor “The 47” and to
vow that the Port of Grays Harbor shipping terminals and their associated rail lines will never be used
to transport, store or export crude oil.
Editorial Comment:
The diverse history and optimistic future of Grays Harbor, its
communities and citizens are unique – they must continue to be
protected from the madness associated with the proposed storage
and export of crude oil – one single crude oil spill into the Chehalis
River, its estuary, Grays Harbor or the nearshore habitat of the
Pacific Ocean would irreversibly and irresponsibly impact this
diverse yet tight knit community and many more.
Logging Fishing
Tourism
![Page 61: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 62: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
2nd thoughts on 3 oil terminals
Grays Harbor County projects that were easily embraced last year are now challenged
July 13, 2014
The town of Westport, dotting a windswept peninsula that juts into Grays Harbor, shows off
panoramic views and offers tourists an affable collection of restaurants and stores festooned with
American flags.
Make no mistake, though, it's a flinty workplace where many jobs remain tied to natural resources in
the harbor itself. The town's expansive marina furnishes a sizable commercial fishing fleet, an
industry that rewards those who can roll with nature's ebb and flow.
"You don't always see the treasure," said Larry Thevik, who at age 66 has plied these waters for 44
years in pursuit of albacore, salmon, halibut and, nowadays, Dungeness crab. "Sometimes you see
the hardship."
It's difficult enough for Thevik and other fishermen to deal with commercial fishing's good and bad
seasons, and the uncertainties that haunt their marketplace. But another industry that sees Grays
Harbor as a gateway to the world wants to muscle into the area in a big way. Three companies are
proposing to build or expand terminal operations that would bring in crude oil by rail from the Midwest
and transfer it to ships for transport to refineries and, ultimately, consumers.
The nation's extraction of oil, the sudden growth of the commodity's movement by rail and a
corporate play to enlarge the West Coast's role in moving and refining crude has plunged Gray's
Harbor, Vancouver, and other Northwest communities into an indelible struggle over how they'll
define themselves economically, environmentally, politically.
In Washington and Oregon, at least 10 refineries and port terminals are planning, building or already
operating infrastructure to support oil-by-rail cargoes. It's highly likely that most oil trains headed from
North Dakota's Bakken oil fields to Grays Harbor County would travel through the Columbia Gorge
and Clark County.
Backers of more oil infrastructure say the industry can co-exist with others. Thevik disagrees. He
sees risks piling up. He fears the specter of unprecedented amounts of toxic crude ruining a fishing
industry, worth tens of millions of dollars annually, that depends on a sustainable ecology.
In opposing the oil industry's expansion in his community, Thevik joins with a growing number of
people along rail lines stretching from the North Dakota oil fields to the Pacific Ocean in challenging a
critical cog in the industry's wheel: getting its product to market.
READ ENTIRE COLUMBIAN ARTICLE HERE
![Page 63: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Oil Trains in Washington: Bad for Business, Unacceptable Risk
July 8, 2014
There is a rapidly growing threat to Washington’s powerful mix of local economies, natural beauty,
and internationally significant tech and manufacturing sector: a massive explosion in crude oil
transport through the state. And when I write “through” the state, that’s just it: it’s not for us.
Our brand as a state (Evergreen State) is largely defined by beautiful places, wonderful creatures,
and great experiences: Orcas, salmon, crab, Puget Sound, Mount Rainier, ferries and Pike Place.
Dave Matthews at the Gorge. Columbia River wineries, apples and wheat. Hiking and kayaking, or
espresso in a million different places. Craft brewing.
All those wonderful qualities are put at risk by turning Washington into a funnel for crude oil to Pacific
markets. Also at risk – by virtue of proximity to the oil train tracks through Seattle – are a few
companies with a touch of name recognition: Starbucks. Vulcan. Seattle Seahawks.
READ ENTIRE WACATALYST ARTICLE HERE
![Page 64: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Millions of Americans live in the blast zone. Do you?
When oil trains derail we all pay the price. How close are you and your family to a disaster waiting to happen? Use the blast zone map HERE to find out and take action.
![Page 65: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
State firefighters want Inslee to halt Bakken crude by rail till safety concerns addressed
Gov. Jay Inslee should to do everything in his power to halt the
movement of Bakken crude by rail through the state until a state
agency study is completed next year and measures are put into place
to make sure the oil can be transported safely.
So says a resolution passed by the Washington State Council of Fire Fighters at its annual
convention in Spokane in late June. It also asks Inslee to make sure local communities have enough
resources to combat any oil explosions, spills and derailments and says association members “will
work closely with communities it now serves to inform them of our concerns about crude by rail
transportation and engage them in discussions about maintaining a healthy and safe community
based on prevention and preparation.”
The lengthy resolution lays out concerns about the safety of the rail lines, the tanker cars, the
flammability of the crude and the ability of local communities and firefighters to handle big crude
accidents or explosions should they occur.
The resolution specifically mentions Grays Harbor as one of the areas of major concern, where oil
trains could travel “possibly through Rochester along the Chehalis River west on the Genessee
&Wyoming (railroad) lines to three proposed marine transfer terminals at the Port of Grays Harbor.”
“Our railroads do not transport any crude oil in Washington. Before we would do so, the necessary
infrastructure upgrades and operating protocols would be put in place to ensure that it was
transported safely,” said Michael E. Williams, director of corporate communications for Genessee
&Wyoming Railroad.
Plans to bring crude oil in rail tanker cars to ship by barges and tankers from Port of Grays Harbor
facilities are proposed by Imperium Renewables, Westway Terminals and U.S. Development. The
storage facilities would all be in Hoquiam, but the oil trains of up to 150 cars would travel through
Aberdeen. There were three derailments of grain cars in Grays Harbor this spring within a short time.
Genessee &Wyoming would be the carrier to handle rail shipments to Grays Harbor if those projects
are approved.
![Page 66: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The council members endorsed Inslee and are strong supporters of him, said Geoff Simpson, their
legislative lobbyist. They hope to meet with him soon about concerns expressed in the resolution.
Founded in 1939, the state council is the largest group of professional unionized firefighters in the
state, with 8,000 members and 133 locals, including crews in Aberdeen and Hoquiam.
The resolution notes concerns about plans to expand rail capacity to receive the oil at four refineries
and that “newly proposed marine transfer stations at the ports of Vancouver and Grays Harbor will
greatly increase the number of oil trains traveling in our state.”
It also notes the city council of Vancouver voted to oppose the proposed oil terminal and movement
of Bakken crude through its city. The final decision on that project will rest with Inslee.
The resolution quotes concerns stated by the National Transportation Safety Board.
There is no mandate for railroads to develop comprehensive plans or to secure the availability
of necessary response resources.
The carriers have effectively placed the burden of fixing or remediating the environmental
consequences of an accident on local communities along the route.
The resolution then warns “this burden to protect is being placed on local jurisdictions — many who
are struggling to maintain their firefighters and first responders, let alone provide them with adequate
resources to respond to oil fires, explosions and derailments.”
The resolution also asks that after March 1, if Inslee and the appropriate state agencies determine
that the crude by rail is safe to move through cities and rural areas, the council “be informed as to the
existence of adequate public resources to prepare for and deal with oil fires, spills and derailments.”
The resolution also points out that the vast majority of the rail cars
that could be loaded with the crude are DOT-111s “which have been
known to puncture upon impact since 1991.” The DOT-111 cars make
up some 78,000 of 92,000 cars in service, the resolution estimates.
Locals support resolution
The council is part of the International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) and the presidents of both
locals, Dave Swinhart of Local No. 2639 in Aberdeen and Doug Stankavich of Hoquiam Local No.
315, said they support the resolution. Neither was present for the vote. Both Hoquiam delegates
voted in favor, Aberdeen’s had to leave to return to work.
“We’re fighting already to keep positions in place,” said Stankavich referring to the layoff of four
firefighters that almost came to pass in Hoquiam due to budget constraints. He is worried whether
there will be enough firefighters on duty to handle a major oil emergency with five to seven
firefighters working on a daily basis, even given mutual aid provided by other cities.
Swinhart liked the fact the resolution asks that the topic be investigated and that safety be vetted for
communities regarding potential hazards. He also worries about the aging of the rail infrastructure..
![Page 67: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Both union leaders made a point to mention they did not want to speak against the possibility of more
family wage jobs coming to the Harbor but worried more jobs may be lost in the event of a spill or
explosion, particularly in the seafood industry.
The resolution was given a “do pass” recommendation by two committees, one on safety and health
and the other legislative matters and was passed by two-thirds of a standing vote.
The IAFF is holding its national convention in Cincinnati, Ohio from July 14-18. “I have scanned the
resolutions for the international convention and do not see any dealing with Bakken crude,” Simpson
said.
The council will meet with the governor to discuss the resolution after the IAFF national convention.
![Page 68: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 69: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Confronting Canada Day - Dan Wallace, Audrey Siegl
Watch, Listen, Learn HERE
![Page 70: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
From the organizers:
“This year on Anti-Canada day, we come to the streets to express solidarity with people everywhere
fighting for a life worth living, specifically those who resist the reality of the Canadian state and its
ecocidal and genocidal projects in the false names of economics and progress.
This demonstration is the second in a series to build Vancouver’s energy for a frontline fight against
the industrial mega-projects which would directly affect the health and quality of our lives, and further
displace indigenous communities throughout western Canada.
Once again we come together to honour and celebrate the ongoing resistance at Unist’ot’en, an
indigenous camp set up by elders, warriors, and other community members.
Unist’ot’en camp is set up at a crucial landmark on the pathway of multiple oil and gas pipelines.
Including the recently approved Enbridge Northern Gateway Project and the Pacific Trail Pipelines
(facebook.com/Unistoten).
These industrial infrastructure projects are inextricably connected to furtherance of the highly
ecologically destructive practices, including fracking and tar sands, and the volatile tankers that bring
these toxic fluids all over the world.
For life, land and liberation. Against the pipelines and the world that needs them.”
![Page 71: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The Answer is Still NO to Northern Gateway Pipelines
![Page 72: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Enbridge and Kinder Morgan: We take offense to you ruining our land air and
water
“We’ll stop you. We’ll fight you. We’ll sue you.”
Watch, Listen, Learn HERE
In solidarity with protests taking place over the federal government’s decision on the Northern
Gateway pipeline, a group of Northern BC residents took action to show their opposition to all oil and
gas pipelines.
“Our community refuses to sit idle. We will take a stand for our future, the salmon, clean water, fresh
air and healthy communities!” (Chris Timms)
This evening, a large group of residents, elders and Gitxsan took over a TransCanada Open house in
Hazelton. The group walked into the open house and took part in a flashmob and banner drop. The
banner read No Pipelines, showcasing the communities angst over the litany of LNG pipelines that
threaten the Skeena river and wild salmon runs. The flash mob had community members “die in” on
the floor of the open house after someone yelled,“ gas leak!” This part of the action was in solidarity
with those suffering at the extraction sites of fracked natural gas. The actions highlight what looks to
be a growing opposition to not only oil pipelines but gas pipelines as well. Last week a direct action
workshop in the Kispiox Valley(South of Hazelton) was packed with community members promoting
these tactics.
“All angles of OIL and LNG including, pipelines, frack sites, tar sands, terminals, tankers and point of
consumption keeps us solid in our united stand against all projects contributing to pollution and
climate change.” (Mel Bazil of both Gitxsan and Wet’suwet’en people)
![Page 73: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Winning the farmed salmon war one battle at a time
Farmed Salmon Boycott Rally at Walmart (photo credits: Chris Gadsden)
See you at the Protect Wild Salmon Rally July 19 at the International Peace Arch
PPrrooffiittiinngg ffrroomm ssaalleess ooff uunnssuussttaaiinnaabbllee,,
uunnhheeaalltthhyy,, eeccoossyysstteemm--ddeessttrrooyyiinngg,, ffeeeeddlloott
ssaallmmoonn ttoo uunnssuussppeeccttiinngg ccuussttoommeerrss..
![Page 74: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Farmed-Salmon-Boycott launches a NEW WEBSITE!!
This is an interactive website designed to help people organize boycott rallies in their respective
locations independently, using tools that are powerful, peaceful and respectful!
Check all the tools:
Map and Gallery of boycott rallies already held and ongoing;
Calendar of rallies, and an Entry form for new ones;
Rally How-To: basics, guidelines, downloads;
Wild Salmon champions;
More.
![Page 75: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Olympia “Salmon Confidential” Premiere – October 5
Limited Seating
Admission by Donation
![Page 76: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
I am trying to protect the wild salmon of British Columbia from the impact of salmon farms.
Government refuses to acknowledge the problems. I need your help to communicate the true costs of
this industry through science, films, advertising, websites and brochures. You can read more about
my work here: alexandramorton.ca
See the documentary: Salmon Confidential
Watch 60 Minutes episode from May 11, 2014
Your greatly-appreciated donations will go to the non-profit (not a charity)
Department of Wild Salmon
DBA Pacific Coast Wild Salmon Society
Box 399
Sointula, BC V0N 3E0
You can mail a check if you prefer.
Thank you for your generous support
Alexandra Morton
![Page 77: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Call for Action: No Salmon Farming Expansion without Wild Salmon
Protection
![Page 78: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Getting Nervous? – Marine Harvest Canada presents science refuting
Alexandra Morton’s lawsuit
Following the recent hearing in Federal Court of my lawsuit over the transfer of fish carrying disease
agents into to the Ocean, Marine Harvest was quoted in two European news articles, Undercurrent
News and FIS. Their statements suggest that the science is settled with respect to PRV and the risk it
poses to wild fish in the Pacific Ocean. These statements are misleading and warrant a response.
June 9 2014, I took Canada and Marine Harvest to federal asking the court to decide if it is legal for
Canada to give salmon farming companies the power to transfer diseased salmon into net pens in the
ocean.
![Page 79: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Canada appears to have given the companies this power through the transfer conditions in their
federal aquaculture licences. Although the case was about one licence given to one company, it
appears that all federal licenses contain these transfer conditions. The farm in question is on BC's
wild salmon migration route – as are many other fish farms operating on the Pacific Coast.
Lawyers Margot Venton and Lara Tessaro with Ecojustice argued that: no, this is not consistent with
the laws of Canada. In particular the transfer conditions are contrary to s. 56 of the Fisheries Act
General Regulations which requires DFO to make the decisions about each transfer of fish and that
they may only be transferred if they are not carrying disease or disease agents that may be harmful to
the conservation and protection of fish. This case is based on one particular March 2013 transfer of
farmed Atlantic salmon infected with the piscine reovirus from a hatchery near Sayward, BC to a
salmon farm on the migration route of the Fraser sockeye – but it could set a precedent for all salmon
farms in BC.
We await Court’s the decision. This is a very important decision and could make all the difference to
how much disease BC wild salmon are exposed to and ultimately their fate as feedlot environment
viruses are known to be dangerously virulent.
Another viral Load?
Alexandra Morton:
I found the statements by Marine Harvest about me offensive, but they also deserve clarification.
Specifically Marine Harvest states they have provided “independent third party evidence that
confirms”:
1. Piscine reovirus is natural to BC and has always been here
2. It is not associated with the salmon heart disease, HSMI
3. That the disease HSMI has never been found in BC
Whoa cowboys slow that runaway pony down, aren't you are getting a little ahead of yourselves!
If Marine Harvest wants us to believe these claims are true, show us the publish peer-reviewed
scientific.
![Page 80: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
OLYMPIA CHAPTER OF TROUT UNLIMITED
JULY 23, 2014 7:00PM
NORTH OLYMPIA FIRE STATION
5046 BOSTON HARBOR ROAD NE
STEELHEAD FISHING ON
THE COWLITZ RIVER
Program:
The public is invited to the July 23, 2014 meeting of Trout Unlimited for an active and descriptive
presentation by Casey Weigel on fishing for the prized Steelhead on the Cowlitz River. He will be
covering available data regarding plants and forecasts for the upcoming seasons as well as
describing the hot spots to fish from bank or boat and cover the special disabled fisherman access.
His fishing techniques will be shared on how to catch this sought after trophy fish. He has
manufactured special lures and 'mystery' hooks (to be shown for the first time at this meeting) that
contribute to hooking and landing a prized Steelhead from the river. Be ready to have a well delivered
presentation and a “hands on” tackle discussion during the program.
Refreshments and a fishing equipment raffle will follow his presentation.
Bio: Casey Weigel
Casey Weigel grew up fishing the farm ponds of the Midwest in Iowa, Nebraska and Kansas. When
he came out to Washington as a teenager he fell in love with steelhead fishing on his first guided
fishing trip on the Cowlitz River. He started guiding in Washington State on the Kalama, Wynoochee,
Humptulips and Satsop Rivers in 2003. With his wife Jessica, they operate the “Waters West Guide
Service” offering services on the Wynoochee, Columbia, Cowlitz, Satsop, Nisqually and Chehalis
rivers. They have been “doing this as a team for 10+ years and realize we wouldn't have made it this
far without each other”. Casey fishes exclusively under the Waters West Guide Service name.
Catching fish is always important but so is customer service before and after the trip.
![Page 81: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Wild Salmon Warrior Radio with Jay Peachy – Tuesday Mornings
“Streaming like wild Pacific salmon”
CCJJSSFF 9900..11 FFMM iiss SSiimmoonn FFrraasseerr
UUnniivveerrssiittyy''ss aarrttss,, ppuubblliicc aaffffaaiirrss aanndd
iinnddiiee mmuussiicc rraaddiioo ssttaattiioonn!!
CCJJSSFF ssttrriivveess ttoo pprroovviiddee ppooiinnttss ooff vviieeww
tthhaatt aarree rraarreellyy eexxpprreesssseedd iinn mmaaiinnssttrreeaamm
mmeeddiiaa..
![Page 82: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Wild Salmon Warrior Radio – Recent Archives
June 24, 2014: The War is On! – Heavy Crude Oil (toxic diluted bitumen)
July 1, 2014: Aboriginal title, Ocean-based salmon feedlots, Killer whale hazing, Kinder
Morgan / Trans Mountain pipeline expansion, Northern Gateway Pipeline
Approval – War is On!
July 8, 2014: Trans Canada pipeline discussion, Expected Fraser River sockeye return
July 15, 2014: First Nations litigation status update: Title and Rights, Environmental
Assessment, Consultation, Timeline of NEB hearings, Burnaby oil storage
![Page 83: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Salmon feedlots
![Page 84: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Salmon farm Production Manager to jail
The employee confessed misreporting of salmon aquaculture cages
![Page 85: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Level playing field needed for aquaculture
When considering the costs of growing fish, specifically Atlantic salmon in land based
operations, it is imperative that there be a level playing field. It can easily be shown that if
ocean based open pen operations were required to be environmentally sustainable,
without government assistance and no compensation for mass mortality, these farms
would in fact be an economic disaster.
July 11, 2014
Let’s consider a three point minimum requirement for the open pen industry to continue operation.
These points could have been made several years ago, and if enforced it is likely that most ocean
pens would be shut down by now because of excessive costs or lack of technological capability.
The ocean environment and coastal communities would be far better for this eventuality.
Here are the suggested regulatory requirements.
Ocean based open pen operators MUST research, develop and install means of waste
reclamation within a specified time frame and meet a recovery efficiency of 90 per cent of waste,
or cease operations.
Use of pesticides for sea lice control that are harmful to other species must be discontinued.
There will be no compensation for mass mortality of fish, and no approval for the marketing of fish
that are infected with ISA virus or other diseases.
Why waste reclamation? Exactly 100 per cent of fecal and food waste goes directly into the ocean
rendering the area uninhabitable by any other species. No other living organism, including humans
can get away with such pollution. Waste in the outer periphery of the area is consumed by other
species, including lobster, exposing them to poisons being used in the industry.
Why a total ban of the pesticides? Cooke Aquaculture has used illegal pesticides, proven to be
lethal to lobsters. They have been caught twice, fined once, pocket change compared to their
profits. Studies in Norway have shown that accumulated toxins in fish from these farms may put
unborn babies at risk. In general, the toxins are foreign to the ocean environment and are no doubt
harmful to all living organisms in the area. Without the pesticides, sea lice would attack the caged
fish by the millions, again rendering the operation totally unviable.
Compensation for mass mortality? Roughly $120 million has been spent to compensate open pen
operators for the mortality of millions of fish over the past few years. This is beyond comprehension.
In lieu of compensation, Cooke aquaculture was approved by CFIA to market 240,000 ISA infected
fish as close to maturity as they could get before they died of the disease, as an alternative to the
compensation.
![Page 86: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Capital assistance? Cooke aquaculture was given a grant/loan combo of $25 million to expand
operations in Nova Scotia by the previous government. The whereabouts of these Nova Scotia tax
dollars has never been revealed.
Now let’s look at the economic viability of land based operations vs. ocean based in this new light.
The land based operators ensure environmental protection in the design. Ocean based are not
required to do anything about environmental protection, do not have the technology, but if developed
would be so costly as to likely result in an operating deficit. Strike one.
Land base operators do not have to use pesticides. Ocean based operators require these dangerous
chemicals to kill sea lice. Without the protection the fish would not likely survive. Strike two.
To my knowledge land based operators have not received government assistance in large numbers
and have not been compensated for mortality. Strike three.
Will the Doelle/Lahey regulatory review framework require that the open pen fish farming industry
meet the aforementioned requirements for environmental protection? If they do the industry will shut
down because of excessive costs.
More likely, compromise will allow the industry to continue to operate at a profit and pollute and
poison the ocean
.
Whatever the outcome, if the ocean based operations were to be
totally committed to protection of the environment, land based
operations would win the economic viability comparison by a
landslide.
A strong appeal to support land based operations and boycott ocean open pen products.
This will send a message that health and the environment are
important to us all. Greed of corporate giants, coupled with
government arrogance, incompetence and apathy has created this
ocean monster. As individuals we can help to bring it down.
Fred Giffin
Geographic location: Nova Scotia, Norway
![Page 87: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
As fish farms proliferate, diseases do too
June 26, 2014
Aquaculture has become a booming industry in Chile, with salmon and other fish farmed in floating
enclosures along the South Pacific coast. But as farmers densely pack these pens to meet demand,
diseases can easily pass between fish — for example, an outbreak of infectious salmon anemia that
emerged in 2007 caused the deaths of more than a million fish and threatened to cripple the industry.
And unsustainable aquaculture methods can have a wider impact,
spreading disease to the world’s already vulnerable ocean fisheries
and contaminating the environment.
![Page 88: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Earlier this year, Tamara Awerbuch Friedlander, an instructor in the Department of Global Health and
Population at Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH), traveled to Chile to work with faculty
members at the University of Antofagasta to develop research and an academic curriculum focused
on preventing the spread of diseases and parasites among farmed fish, and from aquacultures to the
wild fish population, without the use of potentially harmful chemicals.
Awerbuch Friedlander uses mathematical modeling to study the complex social and biological
systems behind the spread of diseases, and has previously focused on AIDS and Lyme disease,
among others.
In Antofagasta, she taught a three-week course on mathematical modeling to students, based on the
long-running course she developed and teaches at HSPH. She described her approach as holistic. “I
teach students to look at a range of factors relevant to the spread of a disease — such as ecological
impact and human behavior — to develop a mathematical model. This can then be used to explore
the effect of each factor in the presence of the others as well as new interventions.”
She and her Chilean colleagues hope to develop a strategy for promoting sustainable aquaculture
that they can share with policy makers. Factors they are taking into account include the economic
motivations of fish farmers and consumers’ aversion to the use of insecticides and antibiotics.
Potential approaches for disease control could include keeping fewer
fish in each pen and removing them before they have had time to
become infested by potentially disease-causing insects, Awerbuch
Friedlander said.
Her work in Chile this year was funded by the Fulbright Specialist Program. Scholars accepted into
the program are added to a roster for five years and can be approached by researchers in other
countries who are interested in their work. The program is an excellent opportunity that many
researchers may not be aware of, but should be, Awerbuch Friedlander said. “For the next five years,
I can look forward to collaborations around the world.”
![Page 89: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
A sockeye salmon is reeled in by a fisherman along the shores of the Fraser River near Chilliwack. A report by the Environmental Law Centre at the University of Victoria is concerned that a lack of information about fish-farm disease outbreaks could endanger wild B.C. salmon
Report slams fish farm secrecy on B.C. coast
July 1, 2014
![Page 90: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The federal government puts wild salmon stocks and research at risk
by not releasing important data about fish farms along the B.C. coast,
says a report by the Environmental Law Centre at the University of
Victoria.
The report takes issue with the lack of information available to researchers and the public about when and where disease outbreaks occur on salmon farms. Currently, when there is a disease outbreak at an aquatic animal facility — such as a fish farm — it must be reported to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency.
However, the federal agency only makes some of that information available to the public. For example, on March 26 a fatal virus called hemorrhagic septicemia was reported in Atlantic salmon somewhere in B.C. with no further details.
“The basic issue is that government fails to disclose exactly where diseases have broken out, and only releases such extremely generalized information when it’s too late to be useful. This needs to change,” states the report.
There are hundreds of fish farms in B.C. Dozens pepper the coastal areas of Vancouver Island. According to Fisheries and Oceans Canada, farmed Atlantic salmon is the country’s top seafood export. Production has increased fourfold in the past 20 years and B.C. accounts for half of it.
“Detailed information about outbreaks should be public, especially for
scientists trying to find solutions,” said Calvin Sandborn, supervising
legal director.
The report was prepared by law student Sam Harrison on behalf of the Wuikinuxv Nation on the northwest coast. They wanted to look at the effects of salmon farms in traditional fishing territories.
Sandborn said the most shocking thing about the report is how Canada’s laws compare to other countries. He noted Norwegian fish farm owners in B.C. face fewer reporting regulations here than in their own country.
“Canada used to be seen as a leader in environmental protection law,
now we’re the laggards,” he said.
David Lane, executive director of the T. Buck Suzuki environmental foundation, said the report should be a wake-up call to the federal government.
“We have wild salmon to protect in this province and we have to know what’s going on to inform policy and respond to potential dangers,” he said, noting the costly near-collapse of the Chilean salmon farm industry in 2007 after disease spread.
He also cited the 2012, $26-million report by Justice Bruce Cohen on
the disappearance of the Fraser River sockeye. Cohen called for a
relocation of fish farms along wild salmon migration routes, such as in
and around the Discovery Islands, and warned that “devastating
disease could sweep through the wild populations, killing large
numbers of wild fish without scientists being aware of it.”
Both Lane and Sandborn said that public pressure led to better regulations and reporting on sea lice at fish farms and they hope to see the same for disease outbreaks.
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency said Canada follows international guidelines set by the World Organization for Animal Health on reporting of animal diseases.
![Page 91: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
“The Government of Canada is committed to protecting human and animal health, and providing the public, stakeholders and trading partners with up-to-date information on reportable disease detections in Canadian livestock and aquatic animals,” said spokeswoman Lisa Murphy.
The agency said providing more details would result in the release of
information considered confidential and covered under the Privacy
Act.
![Page 92: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Canada Fails to Protect Wild Salmon from Industrial Fish Farms -
North American Free Trade Agreement Body (NAFTA) Calls for an Investigation!
Protect Wild Salmon Rally Peace Arch Border Crossing
Saturday, July 19, 2014 (11:00 am – 3:00 pm)
Keynote Speakers Zeke Grader, Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen’s Association
Ocean Aquaculture – An Unsustainable Venture
Dr. Claudette Bethune, Clinical Scientist
Fish Farm Inability to control diseases/unsustainable feed sources
Ernie Crey, Cheam First Nation Fisheries Portfolio
Industrial Fish Farms - A Threat to First Nation Fisheries
Craig Orr, Watershed Watch Salmon Society
Lack of implementation of Cohen Commission Recommendations
Alexandra Morton, Pacific Coast Wild Salmon Society
Court Battle to Stop the Spread of Diseases
More speakers to be confirmed!
The Issues:
NAFTA: Conduct the investigation of Canada’s failure to protect wild salmon from open-net feedlots,
before it’s too late!
For More Information:
Eddie Gardner
Director of Net-Pen Farmed Salmon Boycott
[email protected]; 604-792-0867
Justice Cohen warns “…fish Farms have the potential to cause serious or irreversible harm
to wild salmon.”
Canada opens door to aggressive fish farm expansion, further endangering wild salmon!
Canadian government guts Fisheries Act, removing wild salmon protection measures from
harmful pollutants, parasites and mutating viruses from fish farm sites
![Page 93: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Skwah First Nation open statement in support of the “Protect Wild Salmon
Rally”
Attn: Government of Canada
July 2, 2014
It has come to our awareness that the Secretariat for the Commission for Environmental
Cooperation, an environmental dispute body established under the North American Free Trade
Agreement (NAFTA), recommended a formal investigation be undertaken into Canada’s failure to
protect wild salmon from disease and parasites from industrial fish farms in British Columbia in
response to a petition by Pacific Coast Wild Salmon Society, Kwikwasu’tinuxw Haxwa’mis First
Nation in Canada, and the U.S.-based Center for Biological Diversity and the Pacific Coast
Federation of Fishermen’s Associations.
The Skwah First Nation supports the petitioners as it is our duty and stewardship responsibility to
help protect wild salmon, which are critical to our cultural, spiritual and physical well-being. Although
we acknowledge wild salmon are besieged with many pressures and stresses, fish farms pose a very
dangerous, yet preventable threat, a threat that could bring irreversible harm to wild salmon.
Scientists are raising concerns that fish farms are fighting a losing battle to fight off imported viruses,
and their open-net feedlots are breeding grounds for parasites that are dangerous to wild salmon and
that aid in transfer of diseases from fish farms to wild salmon.
Fisheries and Oceans, Canada continues to regulate the aquaculture industry, while at the same
time, supporting, enabling and promoting this industry. We believe it is imperative that the Canadian
Government put wild salmon first, and remove the Fisheries and Oceans Canada’s conflict of interest
as recommended by the Cohen Commission. We find it appalling that the Canadian government
recklessly and irresponsibly opened the doors to the current aggressive expansion of fish farms, all
the while virtually ignoring the $26 million dollar Cohen Commission report which makes it clear,
salmon farms do not belong on wild salmon migration routes. We call on the Canadian Government
to immediately and transparently respond to and fully implement the Cohen Commission’s
recommendations, beginning with recommendation # 15 to explicitly consider the wild salmon
migration routes when siting salmon farms.
Instead of protecting wild salmon, the Canadian Government recently removed a crucial part of the
Fisheries Act (Section 56) that would allow fish farm release of chemicals dangerous to fish, such
as, delousing drugs, into wild salmon habitat that could do great harm wild fish.
We believe that the actions of the Canadian Government pose a threat to Aboriginal Rights to a
fishery, raising a “duty” to consult with river First Nations, and that would include the Skwah First
Nation. Salmon farms sited on the migration routes of the Fraser sockeye directly impact us and yet
new sites are being proposed in complete absence of consultation with the salmon nations of the
Fraser River. We endorse the net-pen farmed salmon boycott led by Skwah First Nation elder, Eddie
Gardner, as part of our response.
We are in solidarity with all the stakeholders on both sides of the border that a full investigation into
Canada’s failure to protect wild salmon from industrial fish farms is well warranted.
Chief Bob Combes
Skwah First Nation
![Page 94: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 95: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Seemingly the Salmon Farm in Kilkieran has got permission
to lay a pipe for 2-3 MILES across land and road and take
water from lake Loughanmore (Loch an Oir) to treat diseased
fish at Ardmore Point.
Thousands ( if not millions) of gallons water could be used Is
this true?
Is it not totally reckless to remove water needed for local
communities which has previously had issues with supply?
![Page 96: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
DFO aims to streamline fish-farm regulations
Critics say the new rules are a step backwards
June 26, 2014
Amendments to federal Fisheries Act regulations will specifically allow salmon farmers to treat their fish with pesticides and drugs as part of its effort to streamline aquaculture regulation, Fisheries Minister Gail Shea announced Thursday.
Editorial Comment:
Canada’s Fisheries Act is an ineffective shadow of what it once was. It’s been repeatedly gutted by elected thugs to benefit government-enabled corporate expansion
These amendments were recommended and endorsed by the largely foreign-owned
salmon feedlot industry
![Page 97: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters The Fisheries Act’s anti-pollution measures prohibit anyone from dumping anything that would harm fish or fish habitat, unless authorized by the Department of Fisheries and Oceans.
Shea said the rules proposed Thursday will streamline the regulation of aquaculture — which is now governed by 10 different federal acts — within DFO and help give an industry that is worth $2 billion a year to the Canadian economy a chance to grow.
The BC Salmon Farmers Association welcomed Shea’s announcement, which it hopes will “formalize our current farming methods (and) encourage positive environmental practices,” according to a statement from the organization’s executive director Jeremy Dunn.
However, industry critics look at the proposed changes, which have not yet been spelled out in detail, as stripping away regulations without enough scientific understanding of the impact.
DFO officials said the changes will clarify how salmon farms can operate under the provisions of the Fisheries Act.
“What the new regulations do is set the conditions under which
operations can use pesticides or drugs, and be in compliance both
with the Fisheries Act and all other federal (law),” said Trevor
Swerdfager, assistant deputy minister for Fisheries and Oceans
Canada.
And the regulation will include requirements to self-report the types
and amounts of materials used, which DFO will publish annually on its
website.
The changes are also part of the federal government’s process of taking on regulatory responsibility for fish-farm licensing and control that it assumed from the B.C. provincial government in 2010 as the result of a B.C. Supreme Court decision.
To Karen Wristen, executive director of the Living Oceans Society, the changes represent steps backward.
Wristen said the former provincial regime required more frequent reporting of pesticide and drug use than Shea is proposing. She added that the Cohen Commission inquiry into the decline of sockeye salmon populations recommended that the federal government separate the responsibilities for regulating aquaculture and promoting the industry that now reside with DFO.
“This seems to be going in the wrong direction in a number of respects,” Wristen said.
Craig Orr, executive director of the Watershed Watch Salmon Society, argues that DFO doesn’t know enough about the effects of sea-lice pesticides now and should do more studies on them rather than relax regulations.
“We have a dearth of science, but we have a real zeal for reducing the few regulations we have to make it easier to pursue open net-pen aquaculture,” Orr said.
Swerdfager said the text of the new regulations will be published in the Canada Gazette in the coming weeks and the department will be open to public comment. The hope is to have them in force by the end of the year.
![Page 98: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters Energy Generation: Oil, Coal, Geothermal, Hydropower, Natural Gas, Solar, Tidal, Wind
![Page 99: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters Petroleum – Drilled, Refined, Tar Sands, Fracked
Petropolis - Rape and pillage of Canada and Canadians for toxic bitumen
Watch video HERE
![Page 100: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 101: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 102: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Pacific Northwest's Salish Sea Eyed as Fossil Fuel Gateway
Proposed projects would move oil, gas, and coal through the ecologically sensitive marine area.
May 8, 2014
![Page 103: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Trains loaded with crude oil from North Dakota's Bakken shale formation rumble past the outfield bleachers of the Seattle Mariners' baseball stadium several times a week. From there, the trains head north, their cargo destined for multiple refineries in Washington State.
The traffic is new: Just three years ago, no oil trains were coming to Washington. Bakken crude is filling a void created by dwindling shipments from aging oil fields on Alaska's North Slope, and the petroleum industry wants to bring in more. But the push to build more rail and shipping capacity in the Pacific Northwest is spurring debate over how that oil flow will affect the region—and where it should ultimately go.
The issue is particularly important for residents of the coastal towns that ring the Salish Sea, a group of waterways shared by Washington State and British Columbia that includes the Puget Sound. A region that historically has been "at the vanguard of environmental progress globally is right at the cusp of becoming one of the world's biggest fossil fuel export hubs," said Eric de Place, policy director for the Sightline Institute, a Seattle-based environmental think tank.
Gateway for Fossil Fuel Export
Speckled with emerald isles and hemmed by snow-capped peaks, the Salish Sea is an ecologically rich marine environment. The area is home to more than 100 at-risk species, a list that includes sea turtles, whales, owls, and sharks. The communities lining its shores are largely powered by clean energy. Washington State, for example, gets four-fifths of its electricity from renewable sources, primarily hydroelectric dams on the Columbia and Snake rivers.
But the recent oil and gas boom could transform a region with nary a coal mine or oil well in its backyard into a robust fossil-fuel gateway. After all, the straightest path between these fossil fuel deposits in the interior of North America and markets overseas "goes through the Pacific Northwest," said de Place.
A number of proposed port projects along the coasts of Washington, Oregon, and British Columbia seek to move not only oil from the Bakken and Canada's oil sands, but also coal from the Powder River Basin in Montana and Wyoming, and natural gas from northeastern British Columbia and the U.S. Southwest. (See related story: "North American Natural Gas Seeks Markets Overseas.")
Debate over the projects is not just about the environment—it's also about exports. None of the Bakken crude coming into the Salish Sea area is headed out unrefined to international markets, because a decades-old policy bans most U.S. exports of domestic oil (except for a small amount that goes almost entirely to Canada).
The oil industry and others argue that the ban, which dates to the oil embargo crisis in the 1970s, should be lifted so U.S. producers can benefit from prices on the international market. New capacity to move oil within the Pacific Northwest and Canada could lay the groundwork for eventual exports.
"The Pacific Northwest is going to have acute pressure to become an energy hub," said Charles Ebinger, an energy security expert at the Brookings Institution in Washington, D.C., who has advocated lifting the export ban for economic and security reasons. "It is just a matter of how many of those projects both in the U.S. and Canada the environmental community lets get built."
Will More Trains Mean More Ships?
Editorial Comment:
This statement regarding unrefined oil export
to foreign markets is accurate
Bakken and other unrefined US-origin oil may
be exported to other US ports (ie California)
![Page 104: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The first oil trains began rolling through the Pacific Northwest less than two years ago, and traffic has increased steadily since then. Refineries can currently accept about 300,000 barrels of oil per day by rail, according to a Sightline report by de Place, and they are working to boost capacity so they can take more.
If all of the planned facilities are built, Sightline estimates that the region's oil-by-rail capacity will more than triple to 962,7000 barrels per day. That's more than the controversial Keystone XL pipeline, which would carry crude from Canada's oil sands to U.S. Gulf Coast refineries.
At least for now, concerns that oil trains will necessarily lead to increased vessel traffic in the Salish Sea and elsewhere along the West Coast are unfounded, according to Frank Holmes, the Olympia, Washington-based Northwest region director for the Western States Petroleum Agency, an industry trade group that represents oil producers and refiners.
The de facto ban on domestic crude oil exports means only refined products such as diesel and jet fuel can be shipped abroad. As for the traffic of vessels carrying refined products, Holmes says it remains "fairly constant" even with the new oil, because it is replacing lost supply from Alaska. And tanker shipments of crude from Alaska's North Slope, Holmes said, have dropped from about 250 vessels a year in the 1990s to 123 in 2013.
"You're seeing Alaskan production declining and a brand new, good-quality oil being developed domestically," he said. "So, it is a nice fit."
The Tar Sands Twist
But oil trains filled with Bakken crude are not the only means by which shipping traffic in the Salish Sea could rise. After all, there is no restriction on the export of Canadian oil, and the industry is moving to open paths overseas for it.
Kinder Morgan is proposing to nearly triple the capacity of its Trans Mountain pipeline, which runs from Edmonton, Alberta, southwest to Burnaby, British Columbia, to 890,000 barrels per day. If approved, about 80,000 more barrels would flow daily to Washington's refineries, up from the current 142,000, noted Holmes. The bulk of the rest would be shipped to Asia, ramping up vessel traffic for crude oil through the Salish Sea.
To handle the additional export load, Kinder Morgan wants to expand its marine terminal for the pipeline. Under its proposal, tanker traffic would be poised to jump nearly sevenfold, from about five tankers per month to 34.
With the pressure of new oil traffic adding on to existing calls to export coal, "I think we can anticipate a massive increase in crude transport through the straits," said Matt Krogh, a campaigner for the environmental group ForestEthics who is based in Bellingham, Washington. His group is calling for a moratorium on permitting new projects in Washington until the state can decide whether all the developments are a net benefit to the region.
Editorial Comment:
Of course new storage and export
facilities will increase the number of oil
freighters and barges on Washington’s
coast!
Editorial Comment:
100% Pure Bovine Excrement!
There will be an additional 1,000+
freighters transporting condensate,
liquefied natural gas, Bakken oil, diluted
bitumen and coal via the Salish Sea to
coastal waters and beyond
![Page 105: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Rail cars outside the Antelope Coal Mine in Douglas, Wyoming, the fourth largest coal mine in the U.S., are sprayed with an agent that helps suppress dust.
Caught Up by Coal
The crude-by-rail boom in the Pacific Northwest snuck up on residents who were focused on the pros and cons of several proposed coal terminals. As cheap natural gas has eroded the domestic market for coal, producers have turned to markets in Asia and Europe. But the lack of port capacity in the Pacific Northwest has constrained coal exports to Asia. (See related story: "As U.S. Cleans Energy Mix, It Ships Coal Problem Abroad.")
Boosting exports could bring thousands of jobs and millions of dollars
in tax revenue to the region, but the prospect of increased rail traffic
and ships threading tricky passages through the Salish Sea's San Juan
Islands alarms conservation groups. (See related story: "Seeking a
Pacific Northwest Gateway for Coal.")
![Page 106: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/106.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The proposed Gateway Pacific Terminal north of Bellingham, for example, would have the capacity to ship 54 million metric tons of bulk commodities a year, most of that coal. At full capacity, according to the project backers, the export facility would create 1,250 jobs and pump nearly $140 million into the area economy.
Currently undergoing an environmental impact review, the terminal would also bring nine coal trains, each a mile long, through Seattle and north along the Puget Sound coast daily. It would draw 487 ships a year through the Strait of Juan de Fuca and the San Juan Islands, raising concerns about traffic congestion at railroad crossings, air pollution, and the risk of fuel oil spills in the waterways.
Jack Weiss, a city council member in the coastal town of Bellingham, said the terminal played a large role in local elections last fall. "A lot of money came into the election from interests opposed to the coal terminal," he said. Now four of the seven officials elected to the county council that will evaluate the permit for the Gateway Pacific Terminal would be inclined to reject it.
Bellingham was accustomed to weighing safety concerns about increased coal train traffic, Weiss said, but oil by rail is even more worrisome. "Much of the tracks are right against the Puget Sound, the Salish Sea area," he said. "If you had an accident there, then we would have our own little personal Exxon Valdez situation."
How many of these projects eventually get approved and built remains to be seen, said Brookings Institution's Ebinger. Indeed, of six proposed coal terminals in the Northwest, three have fallen through in the past two years, stymied by siting and funding problems. And Kinder Morgan's Trans Mountain expansion project is still under review.
"I don't think it is going to be a cakewalk for the energy industry, by any means," Ebinger said.
Nevertheless, factors such as the "almost insatiable" appetite for coal in Asia and growing pressure to move North American crude, Ebinger said, are strong market forces in the industry's favor.
That reality has driven the anti-fossil fuel campaigns by ForestEthics' Krogh and others. Krogh said, "My nightmare scenario is all of these terminals becoming a faucet to the world that you can't turn off."
Editorial Comment:
China’s appetite for North America’s
thermal coal is rapidly winding down
North America does not have the
capacity nor the will of the people to
transport vast stockpiles of crude oil
![Page 107: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/107.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Hey, whale friends, not to worry: if oil giant Kinder Morgan spills a little oil in your habitat, they'll drop a few bombs to warn you.
We couldn't make this stuff up if we tried.
Read all about it at Grist.org - http://bit.ly/1rYZcIs
Angela Koch:
Even though a BC judge ordered Orca habitat protection back in 2011, it seems the
opposite has been done.
This article fails to mention that fish farms are taking the food out of the mouths of the orca
as well...when our fisheries ministers order the overfishing of recovering herring stocks of
which a large portion goes on to make fish farm food, then one can easily surmise those
herring feed the bigger fish that the Orca feed on... if this isn't done intentionally then
someone in Ottawa doesn't have the first clue on how things work in our oceans....sad and
dangerous decisions being made by people sitting thousands of miles away, that only care
about their filthy fish farms and their oily pipelines....it's become easy to see that Orca and
wild salmon are in their way!
![Page 108: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/108.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Pipeline proponents consider explosives in ocean to scare whales from
potential oil slicks
June 30, 2014
The proponents of two controversial pipelines to British Columbia’s
coast say they would consider deploying underwater firecrackers,
helicopters and clanging pipes, among other methods, to ensure
whales don’t swim toward any disastrous oil spill that might result
from increased tanker traffic carrying bitumen to Asia.
It’s called hazing and documents obtained by The Globe and Mail show the methods have been
studied carefully by U.S. scientists before and since the disastrous Exxon Valdez oil spill killed 22
orcas in 1989.
![Page 109: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/109.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Last month, the Washington State Department of Ecology asked Trans Mountain to describe any
plans it might have to help whales in a spill. In the preamble to its request filed with the National
Energy Board, the department notes the proposed expanded pipeline would contribute to “potential
cumulative effects on sensory disturbance,” something that “was determined to be significant for
southern resident killer whales.”
“NOAA [National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration] identified oil
spills as an acute extinction threat to the southern resident killer
whales,” the U.S. department says in its request for information from
the pipeline project.
“Please describe any Trans Mountain plans to minimize the direct acute threat to marine mammals in
general and southern resident killer whales in particular by applying techniques such as the use of
‘hazing’ to drive the animals out of areas heavily affected by surface oil slicks,” says the request for
information.
On June 18, Trans Mountain replied that some
hazing methods “have historically worked well
with killer whales,” and it might consider
endorsing them in consultation with Canada’s
Department of Fisheries and Oceans, the lead
Canadian response agency.
“The need for and use of marine mammal
deterrence activities would be considered prior
to or during emergency response operations,”
Trans Mountain writes.
It then lists the techniques that might be
available, including fire hoses directing streams
of water at whales, boat traffic to generate
noise, helicopters to make noise and stir up
water and other acoustic deterrents.
The response notes that NOAA has approved
use of metal pipes called Oikomi pipes for
noise and a kind of low-frequency bomb in the
event of an oil spill, but Trans Mountain
cautions: “No single deterrence technique will
work in all situations.”
Northern Gateway’s submission to the National Energy Board last year discussed hazing for three
pages, adding “oil response plans (including a marine mammal hazing plan) will be developed with
DFO and certified responders before operations.”
Fisheries and Oceans did not reply to The Globe’s questions about hazing.
Editorial Comment:
Officials in Canada and in the USA are insane
if they believe these inhumane acts in the
name of corporate greed will be tolerated.
As a society that promotes animal welfare,
protection and recovery of endangered species
and desires to transition away from fossil fuels:
• Increased oil tanker traffic from North
America’s west coast to Asian markets must
be halted.
• Spilled oil impacts ecosystems for decades
(ie. Exxon Valdez, Deepwater Horizon…)
• Hazing will be ineffective in saving Killer
whales
• Hazing will further spread spilled oil
• What methods will be proposed to save other
marine life from oil spills – NONE!
![Page 110: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/110.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
If both pipelines are approved, tanker traffic
plying the B.C. coast would increase by more
than 600 ships a year, raising concerns from
aboriginals, environmentalists and U.S. officials
about the increased potential for a spill on the
Pacific coast.
U.S. authorities have closely examined hazing
for years. One 1994 study found Oikomi pipes
– 2.4-metre-long reverberant metal pipes hung
from a vessel and hit to produce a ringing
sound – could be deployed from boats spaced
180 metres apart to create an acoustic fence to
move whales away.
Underwater firecrackers, also called seal
bombs, have also been studied. They are small
explosives inside a cardboard tube. When
weighted, set with an eight-second fuse, and
tossed into the sea, they sink and explode with
an acoustic signal.
A report of 1986 said they have been used successfully in hazing non-whale marine species.
But despite all the studies, Don Noviello, an oil spill response specialist at Washington State’s
Department of Fish and Wildlife and author of reports on hazing, said it’s not clear whether the
techniques will work.
“I am unaware that any whale hazing techniques have been, or will be, scientifically tested on actual
whales,” Mr. Noviello said.
Added Vancouver Aquarium whale specialist Lance Barrett-Lennard: “I do think that hazing might be
appropriate in some circumstances.”
Did you deploy the firecrackers to frighten the whales?
Editorial Comment:
The reality is that tanker traffic along the west
coast of British Columbia and Washington
state will increase by more than 1,000. Of
course, this number is doubled because these
are round trips that also include escort
vessels.
British Columbia’s planned expansion of
Liquefied Natural Gas, shipments of
condensate from Asia to Kitimat, Bakken field
oil shipments through Washington ports to
California and shipments of thermal coal from
Wyoming and Montana to Asian markets all
contribute to a recipe for catastrophic
disaster..
![Page 111: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/111.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Oil tanker passing through Burrard Inlet from Chevron refinery in Burnaby BC, end point for Kinder Morgan’s TransMountain pipeline, which the corporation is seeking to expand..
City of Vancouver says Kinder Morgan skirting questions about Trans
Mountain pipeline
July 4, 2014
![Page 112: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/112.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
VANCOUVER - Kinder Morgan has failed to answer many of the questions put to the company about its proposed Trans Mountain pipeline, the city of Vancouver charged Friday.
The city submitted 394 written questions as part of the National Energy Board's regulatory review process but said the Texas-based company did not respond to 40 per cent of them, covering everything from emergency management plans to compensation in the event of an oil spill.
"We submitted almost 400 questions and only about 248 of them were answered," said Sadhu Johnston, deputy city manager. The rest "were quite inadequate in the way they were answered, with either no answer or only partial answers."
"As interveners we are trying to assess the proposed project and are finding it quite difficult to get information on the project.
"That does make it hard for us to fully evaluate the proposal and to prepare our experts and our expert testimony to ask the right questions and formulate an opinion."
The city submitted a request to the energy board Friday asking the regulator to compel Kinder Morgan to respond to the outstanding requests.
As part of the board review of the pipeline that would link the Alberta oil sands to Port Metro Vancouver, the company had to respond to more than 10,000 questions submitted by hundreds of groups and individuals granted intervener status by the board.
Under new rules for the regulatory review, there is a strict timeline and the board decided not to allow direct oral questioning of company officials. All questions must be submitted in writing ahead of hearings set to begin in early 2015.
It's a very restrictive process, Johnston said.
"It's really become quite undemocratic, the way the NEB is running the process," he said.
The city said the responses it did receive made it clear that the
company will not cover the first responder costs incurred by
Vancouver in the event of disaster and it said the responses from
Kinder Morgan raise questions on the economic feasibility of the
project.
B.C. Green MLA Andrew Weaver has also complained about the responses provided by the company to his 500 questions.
Editorial Comment:
This corporate bullying by government-
enabled thugs comes at a time when those
along the mighty Fraser River are looking
forward to the many benefits of record runs
of returning wild sockeye salmon.
One major spill of diluted bitumen into the
Fraser River – with inadequate spill
response - will shamefully and irreversibly
impact these and other wild salmon and all
that rely on them.
The madness must be stopped!
![Page 113: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/113.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
He filed a motion with the energy board Thursday asking them to demand full and adequate responses from Kinder Morgan and to revise the review timetable to incorporate "new and reasonable" deadlines for information requests and evidence.
"Many of the answers I received are simply unacceptable," Weaver, a Nobel Prize-winning climate scientist, said earlier in a statement.
"They are refusing to consider any oil spill larger than a small fraction of a tanker's cargo, and basing their oil spill analysis on a response capacity that simply doesn't exist. The lack of substantive response shows a disregard for the essential role that interveners play in the hearing process."
He laid out his concerns in an 89-page response submitted to the board, pointing out each instance where Kinder Morgan's responses fell short.
Kinder Morgan declined a request for an interview.
Scott Stoness, vice-president of regulatory and finance for the company, said in an emailed statement that Trans Mountain believes it provided robust responses to questions "that were within the scope of the regulatory review."
Some of the information is market sensitive or would be a security risk
to release, he wrote.
"It is normal in regulatory processes that there are debates about whether questions are appropriate and/or in scope," Stoness wrote.
"We understand some interveners may not be satisfied with the answers we provided. That is why the NEB process allows for interveners to make motions on the responses we submitted," he wrote.
They will have another opportunity to question the company and to submit their own evidence later this year, he said.
![Page 114: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/114.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The oil boom in one
slick infographic
Oil, oil everywhere! It’s coming … by sea, by rail, and by pipeline.
Over the past five years, domestic oil production has jumped by 50 percent.
The boom adds up to a mess of oil – and oil data.
Click HERE to see how much of the black stuff has been flowing domestically, and why the Northwest may be in for a crude awakening
![Page 115: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/115.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Chinese oil pipeline burns, thousands evacuated
July 1, 2014
BEIJING (AP) — A leaking oil pipeline caught fire in the northeastern Chinese port city of Dalian,
forcing the evacuation of nearly 20,000 residents, a government oil company said Tuesday.
The pipeline was damaged by construction work at about 6:30 p.m. on Monday, allowing oil to flow
into a sewage pipe, where it caught fire, China National Petroleum Corp. said in a statement. It said
the oil burned for 25 minutes before being extinguished.
No deaths or injuries were reported. CNPC said 20,000 nearby residents were evacuated.
Five people from the construction company blamed for damaging the pipeline were detained by
police while an investigation was underway, the official Xinhua News Agency said.
China has suffered a series of accidents involving leaking oil pipelines. In June 2013, a leaking oil
tank in Dalian caught fire, killing four people, and an explosion caused by a leaking oil pipeline last
November in the eastern port city of Qingdao killed 62 people.
Such incidents have fueled opposition to allowing oil-handling facilities in densely populated cities.
Members of the public have grown more alarmed about the proximity of oil lines to municipal utility
lines, residential neighborhoods and commercial districts.
![Page 116: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/116.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Officials: Oil Train Dangers Extend Past Bakken
June 27, 2014
BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) — The dangers posed by a spike in oil shipments by rail extend beyond
crude from the booming Bakken region of the Northern Plains and include oil produced elsewhere in
the U.S. and Canada, U.S. safety officials and lawmakers said.
Acting National Transportation Safety Board Chairman Christopher
Hart said all crude shipments are flammable and can damage the
environment — not just the Bakken shipments involved in a series of
fiery accidents.
Hart cited recent derailments in Mississippi, Minnesota, New Brunswick and Pennsylvania of oil
shipments from Canada. He said those cases exemplify "the risks to communities and for the
environment for accidents involving non-Bakken crude oil."
Hart's comments were contained in a letter to U.S. Sens. Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley obtained by
The Associated Press. They add to growing pressure on federal regulators to improve oil train safety
in the wake of repeated derailments, including in Lac-Magentic, Quebec, where 47 people were killed
in a massive conflagration last July.
Citing the highly volatile nature of Bakken oil, Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx last month
ordered railroads to notify states of shipments from the region so firefighters and first responders can
better prepare for accidents.
But Wyden and Merkley told Foxx on Thursday that the order leaves emergency personnel in the
dark on oil shipped from outside the Bakken region.
The Oregon Democrats urged Foxx to expand his order to cover crude from all parts of the U.S. and
Canada. They also pressed for the 1 million-gallon minimum threshold in Foxx's order to be lowered
to include smaller shipments.
"With the exception of the Lac-Megantic accident, every accident
involving crude oil, ethanol and other flammable materials since 2006
has resulted in a hazardous materials release of less than 1,000,000
gallons," Wyden and Merkley wrote to Foxx in a letter.
They said the derailments cited by the transportation safety board show that trains carrying non-
Bakken crude or less than 1 million gallons pose the same "imminent hazard" that Foxx has asserted
for Bakken oil.
![Page 117: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/117.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Bakken oil on average travels more than 1,600 miles to reach its destination, transportation officials
said. That's much further than oil from some other parts of the country.
U.S. transportation officials said the lengthier journey increases the overall risk exposure for Bakken
oil — and is one reason it's being treated differently than other hazardous cargos.
Representatives of the oil industry and officials in North Dakota also have complained about Bakken
oil being singled out by regulators — although for opposite reasons. The American Petroleum
Institute and American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers have argued Bakken oil is no more
volatile than other light, sweet crudes.
The concerns aired Thursday by the NTSB and Oregon senators
essentially flip that argument on its head, to say different types of
crude and other hazardous liquids such as ethanol also pose a
significant safety risk.
"Accidents involving crude oil or flammable liquids of any kind, especially when these liquids are
transported in large volumes, such as in unit trains or blocks of tank cars, can have disastrous
consequences," Hart said.
Association of American Railroads spokeswoman Holly Arthur said the rail industry is complying with
Foxx's original order. She said the group would have to see the specifics of any proposed changes
before commenting further.
About 700,000 barrels of oil a day — enough to fill 10 "unit trains" of 100 tank cars each — is coming
out of the Bakken by rail, according to the North Dakota Pipeline Authority. That's about 70 percent of
crude-by-rail shipments nationwide, according to federal officials.
Yet the same hydraulic fracturing — or "fracking" — technology that has helped drive the boom in the
Bakken region during the past decade is being employed on shale oil fields elsewhere. Crude from
the tar sands of western Canada is also fueling the surge in North American production.
Charles Drevna, president of American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers, said he supports
getting more information on oil trains to first responders so they're ready for potential accidents.
According to an analysis done for the U.S. State Department, more than half the loading capacity of
oil train facilities built in recent years is in parts of the U.S. and Canada outside the Bakken region.
That includes loading terminals in Colorado, Ohio, Oklahoma, Texas, Wyoming, New Mexico, Utah
and parts of western Canada.
![Page 118: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/118.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 119: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/119.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
ISIS terrorists sabotaged oil pipelines led to significant spill and fire in river Tigris, Tikrit, north of Baghdad in Iraq. Iraq ministry of interior claim this is "under control". See for yourself how much it is.
ISIS Sabotaged Oil Pipeline in Baghdad... Tigris River on fire
April 17, 2014
ISIS: Islamic State in Iraq and Syria
Editorial Comment:
Terrorism continues to be a global concern.
Increasing oil pipelines, oil trains, oil ships and
storage tanks is increasing all of the risks
associated with petroleum products, including the
increasing risks of terrorism as reported in this
article.
Exporting North American fossil fuels to Asian
markets is not worth these increased risks
![Page 120: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/120.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
While all eyes are on Northern Gateway today, it is not the only big pipeline project that is promising to change the North American energy landscape. The stalled Keystone XL is just one of 5 other major projects in various stages of approval
Northern Gateway is not alone - 5 more pipelines to watch
From Keystone XL to Trans Mountain - 5 pipeline systems that could help move oil out of Alberta
June 17, 2014
![Page 121: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/121.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
It's decision day for the Northern Gateway pipeline. In Ottawa, camera positions are being marked
out, pencils sharpened and microphones tested. All eyes are fixed on the clock, waiting for markets
to close, so today's announcement doesn't ruffle any financial feathers.
Northern Gateway pipeline approved with 209 conditions
But Northern Gateway isn't the only pipeline that could remake the face of North America's energy
supply and roil the continent's political waters. Here is a list of five more — some well-known, others
not so much:
1. Keystone XL
Why it matters
If the oilsands are going to expand by two-million barrels per day in the next eight years, the industry
needs as many ways of getting it out of Alberta as possible. TransCanada's Keystone XL will be a big
part of that export plan. If it ever gets up and running, the plan is for it to carry 830,000 barrels per
day from just outside Edmonton, through the middle American states and down to the Texas
refineries on the Gulf of Mexico coast.
What's the problem?
U.S. President Barack Obama's unwillingness to make a decision on whether or not to allow the
pipeline to cross the border. The Americans tell us they want to make sure it's safe, technically and
environmentally. The truth of the matter is, it's all about politics. Obama, like politicians on both sides
of the American political divide, sees the dollar signs next to TransCanada's pipeline. But he gets a
lot of money from environmentalists and they have turned Keystone XL into the bad boy of climate
change.
Where it stands
The southern portion of the pipeline is built and working, although there were some problems with the
welds. After two U.S. State Department environmental assessments and a redrawing of the route
around an environmentally sensitive area in Nebraska, everyone is still waiting on a decision from the
White House.
2. Energy East
Why it matters
If Northern Gateway doesn't get built, this is another way to get 1.1-million barrels per day of
Canadian oil to tidewater – the long way around, mind you. The terminus for this pipeline is Saint
John, N.B. For now though, it is about breaking eastern Canada's Middle Eastern and West African
oil habits.
![Page 122: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/122.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
What's the problem?
The plan is to change an existing natural gas pipe into an oil pipe. That means a lot of retrofitting and
it also worries Ontario gas customers, who get 40 per cent of their home heating fuel in the winter
through that pipe. Also, the existing pipeline ends just west of Montreal. To make it to Saint John,
about 900 kilometres of new pipes need to be built.
Where it stands
TransCanada submitted a project description to the National Energy Board in March. NEB
information sessions have only just begun.
3. Line 9 reversal
Why it matters
Canadian energy independence. And another way to eventually get bitumen to tidewater. When
Enbridge built the pipeline between Sarnia, Ont., and Montreal in the 1970s, it was originally meant to
bring western oil to eastern Canada. As the global economics of oil changed, the flow was reversed
to bring Middle Eastern and African oil to Ontario. Now Enbridge wants to switch it back around.
What's the problem?
While Enbridge will initially use Line 9 to ship conventional oil, the company has left open the
possibility of switching to heavier grades (i.e., oilsands bitumen) in the future. That has many people
in the Toronto area worried since the pipe runs through important municipal water sources. There is
also a fear in the U.S. state of Maine, where the belief is that Line 9 will be hooked up to the
Montreal-Portland Pipeline sending Alberta bitumen through areas where there are many important
municipal water sources.
Where it stands
The pipeline is divided into two sections. Line 9a runs from Sarnia, Ont., to just west of Hamilton. The
regulatory process is complete and the flow has been reversed for that portion. Line 9b runs the rest
of the way to Montreal. The NEB hearings are over and in March of this year approval was granted to
reverse the flow.
4. Trans Mountain expansion
Why it matters
It's the only pipeline that brings Alberta oil to the Pacific coast. Owner Kinder Morgan wants to
expand the carrying capacity of the line by twinning the pipes. Right now, it carries about 300,000
barrels per day. If the expansion is approved, that number will bump up to 890,000 barrels a day. The
pipeline has been in operation since 1953, largely incident free.
![Page 123: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/123.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
What's the problem?
Northern Gateway. It would be fair to say that Trans Mountain's expansion application is suffering
collateral damage from the controversy farther north.
Where it stands
Kinder Morgan filed its application with the NEB in December of last year. If it makes it through the
application process, construction begins in late 2015 or early 2016, and by 2017 the company should
be pumping that extra 600,000 barrels of oil each day.
5. Flanagan South/Seaway Twin
Why it matters
This is actually two pipelines but they will work in tandem. They are both in the U.S., but they are
linked and integral to the Canadian system. Flanagan South — an Enbridge project — will move an
additional 600,000 barrels per day from Illinois to the big storage hub in Cushing, Okla. Seaway Twin,
owned by the Seaway Crude Pipeline Company, will move an additional 450,000 barrels a day out
of Cushing to the refineries on the Texas coast.
What's the problem?
None – if you're an Alberta oil guy. More bitumen flowing means more money. Plenty – if you're an
environmentalist. More bitumen flowing means more greenhouse gases.
Where it stands
Seaway will be up and running later this month. Flanagan South is built and is scheduled to start
pumping sometime later this year.
![Page 124: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/124.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
PIPELINE ON WHEELS
Railroad shipments of volatile crude oil into America's cities have dramatically increased,
with explosive results.
CRUDE-BY-RAIL ROLLS INTO AMERICA'S CITIES
In March of 2014, Andrés Soto confirmed his nagging fears: Mile-long trains loaded with highly
explosive crude oil had been rolling through his hometown of Richmond, California, unannounced,
since the previous September.
Soto, a longtime activist and organizer for Communities for a Better Environment, had previously
heard about the oil industry's push to bring crude-by-rail to the west coast. In late January, his
organization came across an industry report highlighting the local rail yard's intentions to allow the
practice.
![Page 125: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/125.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The following month, crude-by-rail popped back up on Soto's radar after a woman from La-Mégantic,
Quebec, spoke to Richmond residents about how her town was destroyed after 63 tankers filled with
explosive crude oil derailed and exploded, creating a fireball that killed 47 people.
Though the woman's eyewitness account terrified him, Soto figured he would deal with the issue if
and when it came to Richmond. He assumed, as most people would, that local residents would get
plenty of time and opportunity to weigh in on any decision to allow crude-by-rail next to their homes,
schools and businesses.
He was wrong.
A GLUT OF OIL, BROUGHT ON BY FRACKING AND TAR SANDS
Since late 2012, as hydraulic fracturing and tar sands drilling created a glut of oil, the industry has
scrambled to transport as much of it as possible from remote drill sites in North Dakota and Canada
to the east and west coasts, where it can potentially be shipped overseas to more lucrative markets.
Along the way, these trains run through many small towns and main streets, underneath large cities
and over bridges, and even along steep mountainsides and wetlands in pristine wilderness areas like
Glacier National Park. But while communities along the tracks take on the risk of these volatile
visitors, which occasionally derail and explode, they often aren't told what's in them, or even when
they'll be charging through.
"This latest betrayal is just part of a lifelong experience," says Soto, who, as a Richmond native, has
seen firsthand the many environmental injustices forced upon residents of this industrial town. The
city has around 400 pollution sites and the surrounding area has a high number of industrial
accidents, making Richmond's county, one of the most dangerous places to live." Many Richmond
residents suffer high rates of asthma, cancer and heart disease. Some of Soto's own family
members, who all grew up in Richmond, have been diagnosed with cancer and rare auto-immune
diseases.
But the threat of crude-by-rail is not unique to industrial towns like Richmond. Because trains have
played such a major role in shaping America over the past two centuries, today you can find them in
every kind of community, carrying benign goods like grain, hogs and, of course, us. But with the
growth in crude-by-rail, coupled with lax regulations, these icons of American culture are viewed
more warily as their foreboding tank cars chug by, filled with crude oil and marked with barely
perceptible warning signs.
Oil rail shipments have increased 6,000 percent from 2008 to 2014, which adds up to about 800,000
barrels of oil transported across America per day, according to the National Transportation Safety
Board. The increase in rail traffic, however, has not been met with increased regulatory scrutiny. For
example, oil trains are not subject to the same strict routing requirements placed on other hazardous
materials, so while trains carrying chlorine are barred from travel through the middle of cities, trains
carrying explosive crude oil can pass through with no problem.
In addition, over the past two decades, the National Transportation Safety Board haswarned, to no
avail, that older tank cars known as DOT-111's, which make up 69 percent of the U.S. tank car fleet,
are prone to puncturing during an accident. These so-called "soda cans on wheels" were first
designed in the 1960s to carry harmless materials like corn syrup, yet about 92,000 of them are
now used to transport hazardous chemicals (with only 14,000 of those tank cars built to the latest
safety industry standards).
![Page 126: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/126.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Also, fire departments, police and first responders often don't know basic safety information, like
whether a train passing through their town will be carrying extremely flammable Bakken shale oil
from North Dakota, or tar sands oil from Alberta, Canada, which is notoriously difficult to clean up. As
a result, many communities learn of crude by rail projects by accident—or because of one.
More crude oil was spilled in U.S. rail incidents in 2013 than was spilled in the nearly four decades
since the federal government began collecting data on such spills.
LACK OF ENVIRONMENTAL, PUBLIC REVIEW, DESPITE ACCIDENTS
Given the lack of regulations and increased rail traffic, it's not surprising that crude-by-rail accidents
have skyrocketed, spilling oil, starting fires, causing explosions and tragically costing lives. The
largest accident happened in July of 2013 in Quebec, but since then a number of derailments have
occurred, including an accident in Lynchburg, Virginia, where a train carrying crude oil derailed in the
downtown area, creating a 200-foot high fireball, prompting the evacuation of some 300 people, and
spilling crude into the nearby river.
Yet, shipping crude-by-rail has, so far, escaped significant environmental and public review. This is
partly because it is so new and partly because many of the permitting decisions—decisions that will
impact thousands of citizens—are being made at the most local of planning levels. Only recently, in
response to community outcry and litigation, have these decisions been brought to the public's
attention. And where full and complete environmental and public health reviews have begun, citizens,
officials and scientists have largely been opposed to these projects and their risks.
![Page 127: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/127.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Richmond residents found out from news reports that crude-by-rail was going through their city only
after local media spotted the trains in Richmond's rail yard, about a half-mile from an elementary
school. State officials with the California Energy Commission didn't know about the project, and the
only agency that did was the local air quality district, which issued an operating permit to Kinder
Morgan in February of 2014 without any notice or public process. Though the California
Environmental Quality Act requires regulatory agencies to conduct full environmental impact
assessments of such projects, the air district avoided its responsibilities by putting the project in the
same category as vehicle registration and dog licenses.
"I was flabbergasted," Earthjustice attorney Suma Peesapati told local television station KPIX after it
broke the story. "This just happened under the cover of night."
Earthjustice quickly sued Kinder Morgan and the air district on behalf of environmental justice and
conservation groups for ignoring the well-known and potentially catastrophic risks to public health
and safety, and for turning a blind eye to permitting the project in an already polluted and
overburdened low-income community.
Similar stories of "discovering" these pipelines on wheels can be found all across the country.
In Hoquiam, Washington, a small town in Grays Harbor, people were largely unaware of plans to turn
the major estuary, which is home to commercial and tribal fishing, into an industrial crude oil zone.
Members of the Quinault Indian Nation, outraged at plans to build three crude oil shipping terminals,
which threaten the tribe's treaty-protected fishing and gathering rights, turned to Earthjustice after
local agencies permitted the projects based on the conclusion that they would have no significant
environmental impact.
An aerial view of Grays Harbor, WA, where planned crude oil terminals threaten treaty-protected
fishing and gathering rights.
![Page 128: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/128.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
"It makes no sense whatsoever to allow Big Oil to invade our region,"
says Fawn Sharp, president of the Quinault Indian Nation. "We all have
too much at stake to place ourselves square in the path of this
onrushing deluge of pollution, to allow mile-long trains to divide our
communities and jeopardize our air, land and waters."
The Quinault and a group of conservation organizations appealed the permits. And in October of
2013, the Washington Shorelines Hearings Board agreed with the tribe, rejecting the permits for the
proposed terminals for failure to address significant public safety and environmental issues. Two of
the terminal projects have begun full environmental review processes, and the tribe and local
community are fully engaged in opposing them.
On the other side of the country, many residents of a housing project in Albany, New York,
discovered that crude-by-rail was coming only after they started seeing—and hearing—long lines of oil-
filled rail cars chugging close to their homes and the community playground. They soon found out that
in 2012 Global Companies LLC received state permits allowing it to double crude oil storage and
loading capabilities at its Port of Albany terminal.
To access the port—which adjoins low-income communities and a playground and is within blocks of
an elementary school, a senior facility and a center for the disabled—trains carrying the explosive
crude travel a rail line that passes directly through the heart of the city. Yet, the State Department of
Conservation approved the project without requiring a full environmental impact review and without
complying with its own environmental justice policy, which requires community participation and input
on such proposals.
"Some of our clients can literally stick their hand out of their kitchen window and almost touch the
trains going by," says Earthjustice attorney Christopher Amato, who, on behalf of a number of groups
sent a letter to the New York Department of Conservation, asking the agency to require a full
environmental assessment that takes into account not just the rail project but all of the impacts that
will come with turning the Port of Albany into a major oil shipping hub.
In March of 2014, Albany residents successfully convinced the county to halt the expansion plans. The
news followed pressure by a broad coalition—including community and environmental groups like
Earthjustice.
CRUDE-BY-RAIL PROPOSALS CONTINUE, AS COMMUNITIES TAKE ACTION
Despite significant pushback from communities, the oil and gas industry continues to ramp up its
crude-by-rail operations to take advantage of the current fracking boom around the country. In
Washington, Oregon, and California, there are more than a dozen known proposals for new or
expanded crude-by-rail capacity.
![Page 129: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/129.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
In addition, certain members of Congress are calling for the lifting or loosening of the ban on crude oil
export to other countries.
"Both coasts are in the crosshairs of the oil industry," says Kristen Boyles, an Earthjustice attorney
who represents tribes and conservation groups in Washington and Oregon who are fighting crude-by-
rail.
In February of 2014, the Department of Transportation took the first initial steps to making crude-by-
rail safer now, issuing an order that requires railroads to inform state emergency management officials
about the movement of large shipments of crude oil through their states and urging shippers to avoid
using older model tanks cars that are easily ruptured in accidents.
In addition, communities, no longer content to just lie down on the tracks and hope for additional
regulations, are taking matters into their own hands. In December of 2013, two Chicago
aldermen proposed that its City Council declare the DOT-111 tank cars a "public nuisance" and ban
them from the city. And in February and March of 2014, city councils in Spokane, Seattle and
Bellingham, Washington, passed resolutions requiring greater disclosures by railroads on traffic and
routes, while Minnesota and the Washington state legislatures debated rail safety bills. Most recently,
the city of Richmond and the neighboring city of Berkeley passed resolutions demanding tighter
regulations or outright bans of the shipping of crude-by-rail through their communities.
"We didn't go looking for this fight," says Soto, who has spent much of
his life fighting social injustice and shows no signs of slowing down.
"But we're going to fight it all the same."
![Page 130: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/130.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Oregon subsidizing Rainier rail safety project allowing 14 more oil trains a month
June 19, 2014
![Page 131: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/131.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
In downtown Rainier, a small Columbia River town where oil trains carried more than 300 million
gallons of volatile crude last year, trains and traffic today share the road, creating a hazard the state
soon plans to fix.
An $8.9 million project would install curbs,
reconfigure parking and add designated
pedestrian and vehicle crossings on A Street,
allowing trains to speed up from 10 mph to 25
mph and blow their horns fewer times.
It has another key impact. Improvements would
allow the number of mile-long oil trains passing
through Rainier to increase from 24 monthly to
38, helping expansion plans and profits for an
oil export terminal operated near Clatskanie by
Massachusetts-based Global Partners.
Though regulators and Gov. John Kitzhaber acknowledge significant
gaps in Oregon’s readiness for oil train accidents, the state’s first
major financial commitment to safety improvements subsidizes a
project allowing more oil trains.
An ongoing boom in North Dakota is pushing unprecedented amounts of oil into the country’s rail
system, leading to a string of accidents that has raised safety concerns nationwide.
The North Dakota crude is far more flammable than traditional crude
and moves in tank cars that aren’t as safe as they could be.
Project advocates, including the governor, say improvements to crumbling A Street are overdue and
will help both safety and economic development in Columbia County, where unemployment is higher
than average and wages are below average.
“This is a longstanding project designed to increase safety by separating trains from vehicle and
pedestrian traffic,” said Rachel Wray, a spokeswoman for Kitzhaber. “No matter what companies
haul, people living along rail lines in Oregon deserve safe infrastructure in their communities.”
While the A Street project has been under consideration for years, increased oil train traffic has finally
given it momentum.
Rainier Mayor Jerry Cole said he’s pushed for the upgrade — “a huge safety concern” — since he
was elected more than a decade ago, only to see the state’s interest wax and wane. He understands
the recent urgency. “If oil trains weren’t coming through, you wouldn’t see this project on the table,”
he said.
It has attracted scrutiny from crude-by-rail opponents. If the state is
going to spend millions on oil train safety, said Brett VandenHeuvel,
executive director of Columbia Riverkeeper, it should hire more rail
inspectors, prepare firefighters or plan for increased spill risks.
Editorial Comment:
A recipe for disaster
Highly explosive product
Inadequate rail cars
Under-resourced first responders
Faster moving trains
More trains
More traffic and train interactions
![Page 132: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/132.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
“There are a lot of other important gaps right now that need to be filled before helping an oil train
company expand its profits,” VandenHeuvel said.
Taxpayer watchdogs say safety improvements on Rainier’s main street could be achieved for far
less. Jody Wiser of Tax Fairness Oregon said if Rainier was concerned about safety, it long ago
could’ve changed its diagonal, head-first downtown parking into parallel parking with better views of
oncoming trains.
“There are way less elaborate methods that could increase safety dramatically,” Wiser said. “And the
community hasn’t taken those steps.”
Though no accidents between trains and cars have been reported in Rainier in the last five years,
Larry McKinley, an Oregon Department of Transportation manager, said the project would
undoubtedly increase safety. “They’re looking at it as a precaution into the future,” he said.
Construction wouldn’t start until at least late 2016, he said.
Most of the project’s funding will come from the state. Portland and Western Railroad, which operates
the line between Portland and the Clatskanie export terminal, will chip in $750,000 for rail
improvements. The city of Rainier expects to match that.
The Oregon Legislature approved $2 million earlier this year. The Oregon Department of
Transportation’s rail division will add $1.5 million for crossing improvements. And Connect Oregon, a
state lottery-funded program, is expected to contribute $2.9 million. Final cost estimates are still
being drawn up.
The Rainier project is just one part of a concerted state effort to increase economic development in
Columbia County.
Connect Oregon is also slated to spend $4 million at nearby Port
Westward to allow larger ships to access Global Partners’ oil train
terminal and a proposed coal export terminal.
Global is working on a $50 million to $70 million expansion of its facility, which ships oil to West
Coast refineries. The company wants to increase the amount of oil it moves from trains onto barges
to 1.8 billion gallons.
It’s currently limited to 50 million gallons, a cap it far exceeded last
year.
The Connect Oregon awards will be finalized in August by the state transportation commission.
![Page 133: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/133.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Winnipeg derailment renews safety concerns about crude oil shipments
June 20, 2014
![Page 134: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/134.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
WINNIPEG – An overnight train derailment at the Symington rail yard took all day Friday to clean up.
There were no injuries or leaks after three cars carrying crude oil jumped the tracks and remained
upright, but CN crews and heavy machinery were busy at the site near Fermor Avenue and Plessis
Road on Winnipeg’s eastern edge.
“We’re a city of railroads, we have major rail tracks running through the centre of our city, right next to
where people live,” said St. Boniface councillor Dan Vandal, who’s been outspoken on the topic of
rail safety.
The train was moving at a slow speed. Crews quickly responded to check the tanks and tracks.
The cause of the derailment is still being investigated and the Transport Safety Board was notified.
CN Rail says two of the cars were DOT-111 tankers, the same type of
crude oil carrying cars involved in the Lac-Megantic train derailment
and explosion nearly a year ago that killed 47 people.
Since then, “Transport Canada is requiring that all DOT-111 tank cars built before the January 2014
proposed standard that are used to transport crude oil and ethanol be phased out or refitted within
three years,” said Transport Canada in a statement.
“City hall has moved a motion, this is what we want, we’ve punted it up to the federal government.
The federal government is working with the railroad companies and transportation authority and they
have the authority to make the improvements,” said Vandal.
CN insists the hundreds of tanker cars that move through Winnipeg every day are safe, even if
accidents sometimes happen.
“CN has a very comprehensive emergency response plan in place for any type of incident so we
work closely with emergency responders if necessary,” said CN rep Warren Chandler over the
phone.
Transport Canada also says these tankers are being replaced with about 55,000 new tank cars,
representing nearly half of the current DOT-111 tank car fleet transporting crude oil.
![Page 135: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/135.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Oil by rail data shows 10-15 trains of Bakken crude move weekly through Thurston County, 11-16 go in Pierce
June 24, 2014
The state Military Department has publicly released oil-trains data from four operators of rail lines that
carry the volatile Bakken crude oil from North Dakota and Montana inside Washington state.
The data released on Tuesday included an oil-traffic report from BNSF Railway that shows 10 to 15
unit trains of volatile Bakken crude oil are shipped through Thurston County every week and 11 to 16
such trains pass through Pierce County. A unit train has about 100 tanker cars each carrying about
680 barrels, which makes each train worth about 68,000 barrels of crude, according to the state
Department of Ecology.
On Monday, it was disclosed that Tacoma Rail moves three trains of 90 to 120 tanker cars per week -
all within Pierce County. The oil may go to U.S. Oil, which operates a refinery near the waterfront.
The oil-by-rail data had been considered secret until the U.S. Department of Transportation issued an
order in May for companies to release such information to emergency response personnel in each
state by June 6 - if shipments exceed 1 million gallons. Concerns over the oil’s movement have
![Page 136: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/136.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
grown steadily after at least four incidents including the disastrous July 2013 explosions in Lac
Megantic, Canada, that killed 47 and left that community scarred.
The Military Department, which oversees the Emergency Management Division, refused to cloak the
reports in secrecy and gave railroads an opportunity to seek a court order blocking their release. It is
the agency’s typical procedure to notify third parties about an information release when potentially
proprietary information is involved, spokesman Chris Barnes said Tuesday.
But no court action was taken, and the military released details to The Olympian, News Tribune and
other news organizations that had requested the data. It also posted links to the BNSF report with
three others on its web site Tuesday afternoon.
Courtney Wallace of BNSF Railways told McClatchy Newspapers that the company changed its tune
about releasing the data once it learned from federal transportation officials that the data wasn’t
protected from disclosure.
“Once it became clear from the federal government that crude oil was not considered sensitive,
secure information, we continued on our path of simply complying” with the department’s emergency
order, spokeswoman Courtney Wallace said in an email to McClatchy for a story by reporter Curtis
Tate.
Oil by rail shipments have skyrocketed in Washington state and 17
million barrels were shipped inside the state last year, according to
state officials. U.S. Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., has said that figure
could triple in the next few years.
The oil-by-rail data had been the subject of hearings in the state Legislature this year, and a bill
requiring such disclosure passed the House but was blocked in the Senate by the Republican-
dominated Majority Coalition Caucus, which sought a study instead of disclosure. BNSF officials
claimed in testimony that too much detailed disclosure would put them at odds with the Homeland
Security Department, based on terrorism concerns. The Western States Petroleum Association
testified there were proprietary concerns related to oil volumes.
BNSF is considered the nation’s largest shipper of crude by rail.
Officials with county-level emergency management organizations have been reviewing the data for a
few weeks since shortly after it was turned over to the Military Department on June 6. It remains to be
seen how well the data will satisfy the needs of emergency responders.
Kathy Estes, director of Thurston County Emergency Management, said last week that she would like
to see even more detailed information showing oil volumes. The data she received did not specify
how much oil is on a train.
“My perspective is we are getting snapshots in time. We don’t have a lot of information about historic
quantities. We are just getting familiar with the receipt of the data and how we will use it,’’ Estes said.
“This is new for us and we’re happy to know more about what is occurring here.’‘
Estes said that it is possible the county’s emergency management plans will have to change once
they get a better sense of the hazards. She said additional drills or changes in drills are quite
possible.
![Page 137: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/137.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
“It’s a logical result. Because it is a bigger hazard in our communities
we will spend more time preparing” for, Estes said.
Spokesmen for Pierce County Emergency Management have not yet responded to a reporter’s
queries last week about how it may respond to the new information.
Editorial Comment:
This article only addresses the tip of the iceberg.
The rail cars carrying the Bakken deposit oil and those carrying toxic diluted bitumen from
Alberta's tar sands are inadequate for transporting these hazardous materials. The
updated rail cars are also inadequate. The issue is that they rupture easily during
derailments resulting in catastrophic losses and risks to wild ecosystems.
Bakken oil extracted by extremely dangerous fracking practices is now understood to be
far more volatile than traditional crude oil.
At the same time toxic diluted bitumen is impossible to clean up following spills - in
addition, it sinks to the bottom of waterways, thus irreversibly risking fragile wild
ecosystems.
There is so very much to risk with so little to gain from the extraction, transportation and
burning of these petroleum products - They should be left in the ground!
![Page 138: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/138.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Coal
![Page 139: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/139.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Federal Court Halts Plans for Colorado Coal Mine Citing Climate Change
Concerns
July 3, 2014
The federal coal leasing program has many flaws, such as cheating
taxpayers out of billions of dollars, increasing mining that damages
nearby land and water resources, and subsidizing the coal mining
industry’s efforts to boost exports. But the biggest problem is that the
Bureau of Land Management (BLM) pays almost no attention
whatsoever to the very obvious fact that when burned, coal will
release carbon pollution and contribute to climate change.
![Page 140: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/140.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
However, thanks to an important recent court ruling, the BLM may now have a tougher time denying
its role in unlocking huge amounts of carbon pollution. A federal court last week blocked Arch Coal’s
plans to expand a coal mine in Colorado, on the grounds that the BLM failed to consider the impacts
of climate change when it approved the mine expansion.
“This decision means that these agencies can’t bury their heads in the sand when confronting the
very real impacts of climate change,” said Ted Zukoski, an attorney with Earthjustice, which brought
the case along with WildEarth Guardians, High Country Conservation Advocates and the Sierra Club.
Jeremy Nichols, WildEarth Guardians’ Climate and Energy Program director added, “This mine
expansion was a lose-lose-lose proposition. We stood to lose our backcountry at the expense of our
climate. Thankfully, the feds will have to take into account the costs of carbon pollution before
approving more coal mining.”
One key component of the court ruling points to the BLM’s failure to
incorporate the federal government’s “social cost of carbon” in its
review. InsideClimate reports:
The decision was a significant judicial endorsement of a policy tool known as the “social cost of
carbon,” which economists and climate scientist use to put a price in today’s dollars on the damages
from drought, flood, storm, fire, disease and so forth caused by future global warming due to our
emissions from burning fossil fuels.
The BLM has tried to defend its head-in-the-sand approach to coal leasing and climate change with a
variety of excuses, and it’s worth reading through the court ruling for the judge’s rebuttals (key
sections are pages 16-32). One that deserves particular attention is the judge’s rejection of BLM’s
argument “that the same amount of coal will be burned whether or not” this particular coal lease is
approved.
This is a familiar argument from fossil fuel companies and the federal agencies that too often favor
their interests, and it has been debated at length in regard to fossil fuel projects such as the Keystone
XL pipeline and coal export proposals—check out KC Golden’s post for a good explanation of some
of the reasons why this is a weak argument, such as that it:
a.) defies basic economics
b.) ignores the x-factor: economic “lock-in” to dangerous climate disruption
c.) is morally dubious
This court ruling highlights yet another simple reason why this argument is so absurd when it comes
to federal coal leasing – coal competes with other, less polluting forms of generating electricity. The
judge writes (page 30):
The production of coal in the North Fork exemption will increase the supply of cheap,
low-sulfur coal. At some point this additional supply will impact the demand for coal
relative to other fuel sources, and coal that otherwise would have been left in the ground
will be burned.
![Page 141: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/141.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
That gets to the core of why the federal coal leasing program is in such need of reform, and why
community, health and environmental groups have called on Interior Secretary Sally Jewell to
establish a moratorium on coal leasing. Even as the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency moves
forward with rules to limit carbon pollution from power plants, the BLM is simultaneously leasing coal
at cheap rates, ignoring the enormous damage it will do to our climate and undermining progress
toward cleaner forms of energy.
President Obama knows that when it comes to fossil fuel reserves, “We’re not going to be able to
burn it all,” and it has been over a year since he reminded us that “someday, our children and our
children’s children, will look at us in the eye and they’ll ask us, did we do all that we could when we
had the chance to deal with this problem and leave them a cleaner, safer, more stable world?
Instead of heeding those words, the BLM continues to do all it can to subsidize the coal industry at
the expense of everyone else. Right after the court ruling came down, it announced plans to hold yet
another coal lease sale in Colorado, which would likely give more than 8 million tons of publicly
owned coal, at subsidized rates, to the reserves of Bowie Resource Partners—a company that
is aiming to boost coal exports from the West Coast.
![Page 142: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/142.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Geothermal
Canada’s high temperature geothermal reserves are in British Columbia
![Page 143: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/143.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Hydropower
“DamNation”
Watch Movie Trailer HERE
2014 DamNation Screening Schedule HERE
Sign Petition to President Obama HERE: Crackdown on Deadbeat Dams
Sam Mace
Inland Northwest Director Save Our Wild Salmon
“Congratulations. I am so excited for this film!”
Editorial Comment:
Thanks to Patagonia and project partners for DamNation – with the history of failed dams in the USA, no new dams should be built.
![Page 144: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/144.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Don't rush Site C dam, mayor urges
July 9, 2014
![Page 145: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/145.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
The community most affected by the proposed third dam on the Peace River is urging the B.C.
government to get more answers before going ahead.
Hudson's Hope Mayor Gwen Johansson made the rounds of Vancouver media this week, backed up
by a consultant's report that questions the need for the $8 billion project assessed by a federal-
provincial joint review panel this spring.
Energy Minister Bill Bennett has said the cabinet will consider the federal panel's report and decide
this fall whether to issue permits to allow construction to begin in 2015.
The report by planning and engineering consultants Urban Systems reinforces many of the doubts
expressed by the joint review panel, including the cost of the dam and the alternatives available to
meet anticipated power demand.
Those options include upgrading the gas-fired Burrard Thermal generating station in the Lower
Mainland. The federal review estimated that upgrade could be done for the $1 billion that BC Hydro
would pay in interest on the debt generated by the Site C dam.
Urban Systems looked at other options, including geothermal, solar, new natural gas generation and
"microgrids" with distributed power from solar or other small sources.
Johansson said the dam would flood more productive farmland in the Peace River valley, and commit
the region to another big power source for 100 years at a time when small, distributed sources are
becoming competitive.
"Hudson's Hope has done its bit," Johansson told CBC radio Wednesday. "We have suffered the
consequences of the Bennett Dam and Peace Canyon dam. If there are alternatives I think we
should have a really close look at them."
The Urban Systems report compares Site C's estimated power cost of $110 per megawatt hour with
a new gas cogeneration plant in Calgary that is expected to cost $30 per megawatt hour.
Johansson echoed the joint review panel and NDP leader John Horgan's call for Site C to be
reviewed by the B.C. Utilities Commission, to assess its cost estimates and BC Hydro's projections
for future electricity demand.
![Page 146: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/146.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Water from the Elwha River flushes through rearing pens at the state Department of Fish and Wildlife's Elwha Channel fish hatchery west of Port Angeles on Wednesday.
About 14,000 young salmon die in Elwha River release of 2.6 million fish
June 19, 2014
PORT ANGELES — About 14,000 dead 6-month-old salmon were counted in the rearing ponds of
the state Department of Fish and Wildlife's Elwha River rearing facility after 2.6 million were released
Tuesday afternoon.
“That's higher than normal mortality would be at this time,” said Randy Aho, hatchery operations
manager for the Fish and Wildlife region that stretches from the Long Beach Peninsula to the Strait of
Juan de Fuca.
“I would say normal mortality [would be] a few thousand, especially with this large number.”
About 14,000 dead fish out of 2.6 million total represents a 0.5 percent mortality rate.
![Page 147: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/147.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
State-run facility
Aho said the young chinook, eager to access the salt water of the Strait of Juan de Fuca, likely
injured and killed themselves banging against the sides and bottoms of the rearing ponds at the
state-run facility about 3½ miles from the mouth of the river.
The deaths had nothing to do with the amount of sediment in the river or the rearing ponds, Aho said,
nor did they involve fish disease.
“It's just an unfortunate event,” Aho said.
He estimated the 14,000 fish had eaten about $200 worth of food over their six months of life.
Last April, some hundreds of year-old chinook were found along the lower banks and mouth of the
Elwha following their release from the rearing facility into silt-choked river water.
April release
Facility staff had released 196,575 young fish April 5.
Department of Fish and Wildlife officials said then the amount of sediment in the river likely
contributed to their deaths by damaging their gills and making it harder for them to breath.
The sediment coursing down the Elwha has been freed by the removal process for the once-towering
Elwha dams, part of a $325 million river restoration project still underway.
Smolting stage
Rearing facility staff released the 2.6 million fish Tuesday afternoon once they saw that the young
salmon were throwing themselves against the sides of the rearing ponds, Aho said.
The 6-month-old chinook had reached their smolting stage, he said, meaning they were ready to
leave the river.
“When they reach that stage, they want to get the hell out of there,” he said.
“They want to get out to the salt water.
“By releasing them when they did, that eliminated higher mortality rates.”
Aho said staff members use fish activity level as a sign the fish are ready to be released.
Staff members had planned to release them later that evening to take advantage of a low tide, Aho
said, which helps the water in the rearing ponds, and the fish therein, reach the Strait more quickly.
Cover of night
The evening was also sought so the young fish could have the cover of failing light to protect them
from predators, Aho added.
The roughly pinky-finger-sized young chinook were born in Fish and Wildlife's Sol Duc hatchery in
Beaver and were trucked to the Elwha facility between March 10 and April 23, Aho said.
The 32,500 pounds of fish were transported over numerous trips, he added.
On April 5, Aho said, the Elwha River facility released 201,074 year-old chinook that experienced no
mortality. ?????
![Page 148: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/148.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
County Won't Intervene in Weyco Land Fees
No: Lewis County Commissioners Won’t Join Grays Harbor Counterparts
Weyerhaeuser's decision to charge between $150 and $250 for a limited number of access permits
has many sportsmen and government officials up in arms, but their hands are tied.
Nonetheless, some counties are trying to find a solution.
Lewis County isn’t one of them.
Officials from Grays Harbor County want to eliminate tax breaks for landowners charging for public
access. Some Cowlitz County officials like that idea as well, but others want Weyerhaeuser to reduce
or waive access fees for current and past company employees. Lewis County commissioners aren’t
going to do anything because they say it wouldn’t make much of a difference.
“One reason, it’s private property. We don’t have any control over how they use it or what their tax
rate is,” Commissioner Bill Schulte, who represents West Lewis County and lives in the Doty-Dryad
area, said. “Personally, I’m disappointed, but it’s their property and it’s legal.”
Another reason Lewis County isn’t going to get involved, Schulte said,
is because it wants to build a dam on the Chehalis River right through
Weyco property and it doesn’t want to make waves.
“They are our partners in that project and how we negotiate a
settlement will be around those lands will determine the success of
that project,” he said. “We’re going to have to negotiate and it doesn’t
work well if we start out slamming them over something that isn’t in
our jurisdiction.”
Commissioner Edna Fund agrees and said the majority of
Weyerhaeuser landholdings aren’t in Lewis County to begin with.
“(Most of it) is out of our jurisdiction, and if we pass something, it doesn’t change anything,” she said.
“At this point, it’s not on our agenda.”
“I don’t have much of a comment,” Commissioner Lee Grose said. “It’s private property.”
![Page 149: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/149.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
In an email to The Chronicle, Weyerhaeuser
spokesman Anthony Chavez said the company
is, “Currently evaluating the proposed
ordinance in Grays Harbor County and
question the county's authority to tax our
timberlands in this way. Our preliminary
research suggests the ordinance is
inconsistent with state law and invalid.”
Chavez said the company enacted the permit
fees to combat the expenses of road
maintenance and illegal dumping that occurs
on their property.
Under the new permits, only the hunter, his or
her spouse and their immediate children under
18 years old will be allowed to be on the
property. Everyone else will be required to buy
a separate permit. If someone shoots an
animal, they won’t be allowed to bring
unpermitted friends onto the property to help
them drag it out.
Skeptics of the new plan say vandals will still
have from February to the end of July to
damage the property and the company should
have reached out to hunting groups who would
have helped repair the damage for free
Despite the frustrations echoed by hunters and
county officials, the permits are in high
demand.
The 800 permits available for the Vail tree farm sold out in three
minutes; Pe Ell South’s 550 available sold out in 12; as of Thursday Pe
Ell North had sold 330 of 500.
The company says it implemented the permit system to recoup some of the expenses it sees from
road wear, vandalism and illegal dumping, but many people from the public see it as a money grab.
In an earlier interview with The Chronicle, Chavez said the company wants to keep its land open to
the public but it also wants to recoup some of the damages it sees from its usage.
Editorial Comment:
Unbelievable!
Weyerhaeuser Company, the one
responsible for irresponsible logging
practices that contributed to the
catastrophic flood damage throughout the
Chehalis River basin December 3, 2007
now charges Washington taxpayers and
others to access rivers, streams and lakes
and the wildlife these public waters sustain
Outdoor recreation in Washington state is
becoming more and more a wealthy
person’s pastime.
More Washington citizens and visitors are
turning away from outdoor recreation in
Washington state – simply too costly with
greatly reduced opportunities.
Closing Big Timber lands to the public will
lead to increased poaching and damage.
Truly shameful that Lewis County
Commissioners are in bed with
Weyerhaeuser Company so as to not make
waves regarding the proposed Chehalis
River dam that will never be constructed.
![Page 150: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/150.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Liquefied Natural Gas
Young salmon smolts use the underwater eelgrasses of Flora Banks and the surrounding shallow channels to adjust to the Pacific’s salt waters, following their outbound migration from the Skeena River watershed.
LNG terminals could collapse B.C. wild salmon run: SFU scientists
New science shows that Pacific Northwest LNG and Prince Rupert LNG are smack dab in
the most sensitive spot for millions of Skeena salmon, treasured by fisheries, anglers,
First Nations and sushi lovers.
July 9, 2014
READ ENTIRE VANCOUVER OBSERVER ARTICLE HERE
![Page 151: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/151.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Solar
![Page 152: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/152.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 153: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/153.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Anesco is to build solar parks on three former colliery sites in Nottinghamshire
30MW of solar to be built on former Notthinghamshire colliery sites
July 1, 2014
![Page 154: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/154.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Three former collieries are set to witness what is being billed as
"major regeneration" as a 30 megawatt solar array is installed across
brownfield sites in the East Midlands.
The old coal-mining land in Nottinghamshire – split over Welbeck Colliery in Mansfield, Gedling in
Lambley and a third site in Bilsthorpe – will see enough ground-mounted solar panels constructed to
provide power to around 10,000 homes.
From coal to solar
Of the three sites, the Welbeck Colliery, which was owned by UK Coal and closed in 2011, will be the
first to come online. The 32 acre, 11.2 megawatt (MW) solar farm will encompass 44,160 solar
panels mounted on approximately 15 kilometres of frames. The energy generated is predicted to
power more than 3,450 homes in the local area and lead to carbon savings of around 5.11 tonnes
each year.
Construction is being managed by renewable energy consultancy Anesco in conjunction with
landowners, Harworth Estates, who own 30,000 acres across 200 sites.
Eddie Peat, director of Natural Resources at Harworth Estates, said: "Low carbon energy projects
are an important part of Harworth Estates' commitment to the community and the environment, and
our solar projects with Anesco will deliver both energy for thousands of new homes and new jobs for
the region."
The Welbeck site will be followed by 5.74 MW installations at both Gedling and Bilsthorpe. There is
also a fourth installation currently in the planning stage for Askern, in South Yorkshire.
Anesco, which previously constructed a 30 acre, 5 MW solar farm in the New Forest and a 40 acre,
10 MW solar farm at Owls Lodge, near Andover, is aiming to commence construction on all three
sites by the end of the year.
"These sites are based in the Midlands and north of England, which is important as we believe it is
essential that solar developments are made across the UK and not just in the south west," said
Adrian Pike, CEO of Anesco.
Record-breaking
The solar industry broke records in the UK, meeting an estimated 3.9 per cent of the UK’s electricity
demand over 24 hours on Saturday June 21, according to a Guardian report.
In 2013, Anesco was named the UK's fastest growing private company in the prestigious Sunday
Times Fast Track 100.
![Page 155: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/155.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
![Page 156: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/156.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Government action
![Page 157: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/157.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
B.C. First Nation evicts CN Rail, logging companies, fishermen from their
lands
July 10, 2014
![Page 158: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/158.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
VANCOUVER - Buoyed by a landmark Supreme Court of Canada
decision, hereditary chiefs of the Gitxsan (GIT-san) First Nations have
served eviction notice to CN Rail, logging companies and sport
fishermen to leave their lands.
Chief negotiator Gwaans (gwons) Bev Clifton Percival says these companies have until Aug. 4 to
cease operations and leave 33,000 square kilometres of Gitxsan territory along the Skeena River in
northwestern British Columbia.
Clifton Percival says the band has been trying to negotiate a treaty with the Crown since 2001 but
hasn't made any progress and hasn't had any negotiations for several years.
She says in 2012, some of the lands awarded to the Gitxsan in an earlier high court ruling were given
to the neighbouring Kitsumkalum (kits-um-kalem) and Kitselas (lit-sey-liss) nations in an agreement in
principle signed with the provincial and federal governments.
The Gitxsan say because of the Crown's failure to consult them, the companies are trespassing.
Clifton Percival says timber sales, fishing licenses and rail shipments can continue after the Crown
has obtained the consent of their chiefs.
![Page 159: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/159.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Greenwashing
Rail Officials Explain Improvement Grant to Chehalis Officials
Pitch: Funds Will Improve Capacity for Current Loads, Not Oil Trains, Business Claims
June 27, 2014
Don Seil, Pacific region general manager for Genesee & Wyoming, presented the Chehalis City
Council with a plan to improve the Puget Sound and Pacific Railroad earlier this week.
The Puget Sound and Pacific is a railroad subsidiary company of Genesee & Wyoming that
interchanges to the BNSF and Union Pacific railroads. Most of its infrastructure is nearly a century old
and in need of repair. Four trains derailed from it between April and May.
The Transportation Investment Generating Economic Recovery, or TIGER, Grant, is a $9 million
federal grant, which was applied on behalf of Genesee & Wyoming by the Port of Centralia. It would
improve rail infrastructure between Blakeslee Junction and Grays Harbor. If awarded, Genesee &
Wyoming will contribute $3.9 million in matching funds. No local money is required.
Last year, the company moved 36,000 car loads and employed about 40 people locally, Seil said.
According to him, the improvements are needed to keep up with growing demands on the rail line.
The grant will bolster the track’s capacity for longer and more
frequent trains hauling brewers’ grain, soybean meal and automotive
parts from the Midwest.
ed: of course this track’s renovation is being done to “grease the skids” for the proposed
Grays Harbor oil storage and export facilities.
The money would improve rails, ties and bridges, upgrade two crossings, allow trains to travel up to
20 miles per hour from the current 10 mph, make two 8,000-foot sidings for trains to pull off the main
line for others to pass and possibly create a quiet zone within Centralia.
The plan is endorsed by Gov. Jay Inslee, Sixth District Congressman Derek Kilmer, the Department
of Defense, numerous companies and several Washington cities, including the city of Centralia.
The port will benefit from the grant improvements because the trains often block truck access to some
of its property, according to Port Executive Director Kyle Heaton. The port will also receive $50,000
for handling the application.
![Page 160: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/160.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
At the end of his presentation, Seil asked the council to write a letter of support for the project, but
because Chehalis won’t be impacted by the improvements, city officials won’t write it.
“It was just information for us,” Chehalis City Manager Merlin MacReynold said. “We’re not directly
affected, so I don't see our council getting involved with stuff going on in another jurisdiction.”
Centralia would be most directly impacted since the rail line runs through town. Seil gave the same
presentation to Centralia City Council in mid-April.
The quiet zone would be created by shutting down six crossings along Sixth Street, but trains would
move through the area quicker and wouldn’t have to blow their horns at every crossing. The grant
would pay for those improvements, but only if Centralia approved.
The city drafted a letter of support for the grant and Mayor Bonnie Canaday signed it.
Although oil is mentioned nowhere in the 32-page application, nor at any point during Seil’s
presentation, the Puget Sound and Pacific could become key in moving oil to three facilities planned
for the Port of Hoquiam, if those are approved.
Oil isn’t mentioned, Seil said, because the company’s focus is on materials it is already shipping, not
potential ones.
“The reason we’re putting forth the application through the Port of Centralia is that it gives us the
opportunity to handle our current customers,” he said. “If crude comes, we’ll handle it, but there may
be needs to expand even further.”
Seil also said that Genesee & Wyoming owns only the rail line and as a common carrier it is legally
required to accept whatever materials its customers’ cars are holding, so long as they meet federal
regulations.
110000%% PPuurree
BBoovviinnee
EExxccrreemmeenntt
![Page 161: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/161.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Third-party evidence confirms Marine Harvest's healthy salmon
June 19, 2014
![Page 162: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/162.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Marine Harvest Canada (MHC) has provided the Federal Court of Canada with information resulting
from significant new research confirming the company's salmon are not a risk to wild salmon or
consumers.
Responding to a legal challenge initiated by Alexandra Morton against the Minister of Fisheries and
MHC, last week the company provided the Court with evidence including fish health data, which
refuted the allegations made by the marine biologist showing them as clearly erroneous and
scientifically baseless.
The legal challenge - which questions the authority of the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans to allow
the company to transfer fish from its facilities - includes allegations that the piscine reovirus (PRV) is
linked to heart and skeletal muscle inflammation (HSMI), and suggests that the latter is present in
MHC's farm-raised Atlantic salmon.
MHC provided the Court with independent third party evidence that confirms PRV occurs naturally in
wild fish in the Pacific Northwest, predates the start of BC salmon farming operations, does not
compromise fish health in the farms of MHC or in farmed or wild salmon in BC in general, and is not
associated with HSMI. Furthermore, HSMI has not been found in any fish (farmed or wild) in the
Pacific Northwest despite extensive testing.
"While the court would have been within its right to dismiss this case due to lack of evidence brought
forth by the applicant, Marine Harvest wanted the case to proceed to set the record straight," says
Vincent Erenst, Managing Director at MHC. "Since these allegations were made, we've
commissioned a significant amount of independent research confirming our fish are healthy."
Proceedings were completed on 13 June. Justice Rennie will rule on the authority of the Minister of
Fisheries and Oceans to authorize BC's salmon aquaculture facilities to transfer fish from one site to
another in the coming months.
Marine Harvest Canada is British Columbia's leading aquaculture company and supplier of Sterling
brand salmon, producing 40,000 tonnes of fresh farm-raised salmon at sites on and around
Vancouver Island.
Don Staniford:
“Complete & Utter Cr*p Quote of the Week from Marine Harvest Canada's Managing
Director: "While the court would have been within its right to dismiss this case due to lack of
evidence brought forth by the applicant, Marine Harvest wanted the case to proceed to set
the record straight"”
“I guess Marine Harvest paid for the studies or even wrote a report which one of the many
prostitute rent-a-scientists signed - or even their best friends at the CFIA?”
Addie Hollingsworth:
“Who did the studies?”
“Where is the proof?”
![Page 163: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/163.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Wild Game Fish Management
Feds Quintuple Allowed Catch on Endangered Salmon Species
Expecting a huge sockeye run, DFO widens the net for coho.
June 27, 2014
Fisheries and Oceans Canada is allowing commercial fishermen to
catch five times as many endangered coho salmon in anticipation of
this year's massive sockeye run on the Fraser River.
Conservationists are outraged with the federal decision, which they say will further threaten the coho
species in the rush to allow fishermen a greater catch during the annual sockeye return. This year's
return is expected to be tremendous, as high as 70 million fish.
![Page 164: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/164.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Sockeye and coho swim together in the areas open to commercial fishing, which means coho are at
risk of getting caught in the net along with the sockeye.
The government has tried to protect coho by limiting the unintentional bycatch to three per cent since
1998. Canada's new plan quintuples that and will allow for 16 per cent bycatch.
A spokesperson for Fisheries and Oceans Canada, known as DFO, said in an email that coho stocks
were returning and could sustain the increased catch, but that claim was met with skepticism from
conservationists.
"It's confusing," said Gord Sterritt, executive director of the Upper Fraser Fisheries Conservation
Alliance. "What's basically happening is that DFO is allowing open season on an endangered salmon
that has not yet been declared recovered."
More data needed
Interior Fraser coho was put on the federal list of endangered species in 2002 after stocks decreased
at an alarming rate because of overfishing in the 1990s.
Only in the past three years have coho stocks begun showing signs of recovery. According to DFO's
2014 forecast, about 50,000 of the endangered salmon will return, which exceed the department's
long-term recovery goal of 40,000.
Sterritt, who is also the fisheries resource manager for the Northern
Shuswap Tribal Council, said three years was too little recovery time
to go on. "We need more data," he said. "We could be in a position
where we're driving these stocks down again."
Aaron Hill, a biologist with Watershed Watch Salmon Society, said that the federal decision was "very
short sighted" and delaying the species' recovery.
Hill said coho catches could be significantly decreased by moving the fisheries off the coast and in-
river where the two species separate. In-river fisheries are historically run by First Nations.
Coho is 'extremely vulnerable': scientist
Dr. Patricia Gallaugher, director of the Centre for Coastal Science and Management at Simon Fraser
University, is renowned for her work and research with salmon conservation in B.C.
She said coho was an "extremely vulnerable" species that DFO was
mandated to protect and recover under the federal Wild Salmon Policy.
The increase of the bycatch rate seems to be in direct conflict with that mandate, said Gallaugher.
According to DFO, the most recent generation of coho averaged 36,000 fish.
Even if this year's returns were to reach 50,000, the scientist finds a fivefold bycatch rate "highly
surprising" as it would also imply a fivefold increase in returns, she said.
Bycatch can be prevented
Both Gallaugher and Hill said this year's massive salmon run is only due to a few strong sockeye
populations. Many other populations are still doing poorly or are classified as endangered.
![Page 165: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/165.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Like the coho, such populations would also be hurt by this year's intensive fishing.
Gallaugher said fishermen could avoid or
manage bycatch of endangered salmon by
using special gear or placing them in recovery
boxes from which they could be released into
the ocean.
"But all of that takes time, and if you're rushing
to get as many fish as you can then it's not
going to happen," she said.
It would also require a strong DFO presence to
ensure enforcement, and Gallaugher doubts
the department has the capacity.
Editorial Comment:
These bycatch experiments have failed
miserably in Oregon and Washington for
the very reasons identified:
Time
Money
Human greed
Effective enforcement
![Page 166: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/166.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Rich countries pay zombie fishing boats $5 billion a year to plunder the seas
June 25, 2014
The industrial fleet that now drags the high seas for fish has a combined engine power 10 times
stronger than it did in 1950. Its nets are so huge that they’re sometimes big enough to hold 12 jumbo
jets. And it is largely thanks to this all-out assault on high-seas fishing stocks that two-thirds of those
stocks (paywall) are at the brink of collapse—or well past the edge.
![Page 167: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/167.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
But instead of discouraging this trend, rich countries are paying those vessels to overfish like there’s
no tomorrow. Japan, China, the US, the EU and other countries pay $27 billion to subsidize these
vessels, according to a report (pdf) by the Global Ocean Commission, an independent body of
international leaders focused on ocean conservation policy. Of that, $5 billion alone goes on fuel
subsidies from rich countries to industrial fishing fleets.
Global Ocean Commission
![Page 168: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/168.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Without the subsidies, most of these businesses would fail. So thoroughly have industrial fleets
overfished the seas that they couldn’t afford the fuel to travel the ever-increasing distance needed to
catch the same amount of fish if their governments didn’t lavish public funds upon them.
In economics, you’d call these zombies — unprofitable companies that
would fail if governments didn’t prop them up.
There are two big problems with zombies. First, they take resources that could go to support new,
productive companies. And by subsidizing zombies, governments allow them to keep prices low,
driving productive companies out of business.
If industrial fleets weren’t subsidized, they’d go out of business. Small-scale fisheries that don’t need
enormous amounts of fuel to catch huge hauls of fish—i.e. the ones using sustainable fishing
practices—would then in theory thrive. Many of these fishermen are in poor countries whose
governments can’t afford to compete in the industrial looting.
Worse, there’s a double-whammy zombie effect going on in the fishing context. Government
subsidies to highly destructive industrial fleets don’t just deprive small-scale fishermen of finite
taxpayer dollars and edge them out of the market with cheap prices; they also rob them of current
and long-term fishing stocks.
Global Ocean Commission
![Page 169: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/169.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Not all subsidies are bad. In fact, subsidies to promote fishery resource conservation and
management—things like stock assessments and stock monitoring—are exactly the kinds of things
we should be pressing our governments to foot the bill for (those are represented in blue in the chart
below). But some $16 billion in subsidies goes exclusively toward making it cheaper to catch more
fish.
That’s a problem, given that the global deepwater fleet is already 2.5
times bigger than what the GOC says is sustainable to maintain global
fish stocks.
Global Ocean Commission
![Page 170: Legacy - August 2014](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042610/568c54751a28ab4916bee073/html5/thumbnails/170.jpg)
Legacy – August 2014
Wild Game Fish Conservation International
2014 – Honoring Sacred Waters
Take, for example, the global high-seas bottom-trawl fleet. The top 12 highest-catching nations pony
up a total of $152 million a year, worth a quarter of what the fleet catches. Yet this fleet’s margins are
typically 10%. That means these highly destructive vessels couldn’t stay in business if not for
government gimmes.
Global Ocean Commission
Governments tend to be leery of slashing subsidies because of the
potential impact on jobs and, hence, politics.
For instance, in 2006 Spain upped its fuel subsidy 60% after fishermen blockaded Mediterranean
ports to protest oil prices. But the industrial fisheries are actually not huge employers, even within
their sector: GOC reports that the biggest vessels catch 65% of all marine fish, while employing only
4% of fishermen.