leading from behind - rnc's "ten for ten" ebook series

7/31/2019 Leading From Behind - RNC's "Ten For Ten" eBook Series

1/47

1


2/47

8

@*AV VD@[ KX@V@KAG V@BM' LHABA[ [VXAVMEP LN GMAF@JE NXLBHMD@JF DA[ UMAIMJMF ABMX@KAJ @JNG]MJKM AXL]JF VDM ULXGF

Vdm _xm{`fmjv Da{ Hmmj Xl}jfg Kx`v`k`smf Nlx Gaki`je Aj L~mxagg [vxavme @j Vdm Xme`lj A{_xlvm{v{ Da~m [pxmaf' El~mxjbmjv{ Da~m Hmmj Vlppgmf Ajf ^`lgmjkm Da{ M{kagavmf* $[ab Pl}jebaj'Lhaba Klj{`fmx`je Vaxemvmf [ajkv`lj{' Aea`j{v [xà'Vdm D`gg'6,8=,11)

Lhaba{ _lg`k`m{ Axl}jf Vdm Ulxgf Da~m Hmmj _a{{`~m Ajf Af Dlk*_xm{`fmjv Lhabafm{mx~m{ kxmf`v nlx i`gg`je L{aba h`j Gafmj' h}v vdm Xmp}hg`kaj kdaggmjemx `{ xèdv vl {a vdavflm{j%v abl}jv vl a {}kkm{{n}g nlxmèj plg`k* @j vdm B`ffgm Ma{v' a{ umgg a{ `j M}xlpm ajf A{à'k}xxmjv plg`k da{ hmmj pa{{`~m ajf af dlk* $Mf`vlxàg' Xlbjm%{ Ulxgf'Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' 1?,4,18)

Lhaba Da{ Na`gmf Vl [vajf ]p Nlx D}baj Xèdv{ Ajf Fmblkxak Av Im Blbmjv{*Ajljmudl{ hmmj xmaf`je vd`{ paem l~mx jmaxg vdm pa{v nl}x max{ ijlu{ um vd`ji vdmxm{ abpgm xllb nlx na`xkx`v`k`{b ln _xm{`fmjv Lhaba{ nlxmèj"plg`k xmklxf* Nxlb X}{{à vl Hadxa`j vl Mepv' dm da{ na`gmf vl{vajf }p nlx d}baj xèdv{ ajf fmblkxak av im blbmjv{* D`{ pa{{`~`v `j [xà da{ agglumf a haf{`v}av`lj vl emv ulx{m* Vdm Axah [px`je pxm{mjvmf fajemx{ h}v ag{l lpplxv}j`v`m{ nlx Abmx`kaj plg`kvdav Bx* Lhaba ua{ {glu vl {m`sm ajf da{ hmmj vll dm{`vajv vl nlgglu }p lj* Um vd`ji vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{u`gg pa a px`km nlx d`{ na`g}xm vl nlxem a {vxljemx pl{v"uax xmgav`lj{d`p u`vd @xaq' ajf d`{ {mvv`je ln

fmafg`jm{ `j Anedaj`{vaj `jkxma{mf vdm x`{i{ vdmxm nlx ]*[* `jvmxm{v{* $Mf`vlxàg' Udmxm{ Pl}x Nlxmèj _lg`k _xlexab' Bx*Xlbjm


3/47

;

Ulxgf Jl Gljemx [ullj{ Nlx Lhaba

Lhaba Da{ Jlv Bajaemf Vl Xaf`kagg Vxaj{nlxb Abmx`ka{ [vajf`je @j Vdm Ulxgf Vdxl}ed Vdm@gg}b`jav`je Nlxkm Ln D`{ H`lexapd Lx _mx{ljag`v* Udmj pxm{`fmjvàg kajf`favm Haxaki Lhaba{umpv `jvl M}xlpm `j 8??4' vmgm~`{`lj {kxmmj{ {dlumf ba{{`~m' aflx`je kxluf{* H}v vdm gavm{v V^ `baem{nxlb ahxlaf axm nax blxm lb`jl}{3 blh{ `j vdm B}{g`b ulxgf hm{`me`je ]*[* mbha{{`m{' vlxkd`jeAbmx`kaj ngae{ ajf m~mj h}xj`je Lhaba d`b{mgn `j mnnè* Vdm vul {mv{ ln `baem{ {dlu a eap hmvummja{p`xav`lj{ ajf xmag`v3 A pxm{`fmjv udl `{ plp}gax l~mx{ma{ da{ jlv bajaemf vl xaf`kagg vxaj{nlxb

Abmx`ka{ {vajf`je `j vdm ulxgf vdxl}ed vdm `gg}b`jav`je nlxkm ln d`{ h`lexapd lx pmx{ljag`v* $Cl{d Emx{vm`jUlxgf{ Lhaba Nm~mx Kllg{'_lg`v`kl' 0,81,18)

Lhaba Xmpmavmfg _xlb`{mf Vl Xm{vlxm Abmx`ka{ [vajf`je @j Vdm Ulxgf* LHABA3 Ajf um u`ggxm{vlxm l}x blxag {vajf`je `j vdm ulxgf* Um u`gg ljkm aea`j gmaf vdm ulxgf jlv c}{v b`g`vax`g' h}vf`pglbav`kagg' mkljlb`kagg* $[mjavlx Haxaki Lhaba' Xmbaxi{ Av A Kabpaèj M~mjv' Kdaxgm{vlj' [K' 1,1?,?4)

@j 8??4' Lhaba _xlb`{mf Vdav Ljm Ln Vdm Vd`je{ Vdav @ @jvmjf Vl Fl A{ _xm{`fmjv @{ VlXm{vlxm Abmx`ka%{ [vajf`je @j Vdm Ulxgf* LHABA3 Ajf ljm ga{v pl`jv @ uajv vl baim* @v `{`bplxvajv nlx }{ vl }jfmx{vajf vdav vdm ua um axm pmxkm`~mf `j vdm ulxgf `{ el`je vl baim af`nnmxmjkm' `j vmxb{ ln l}x kapak`v vl emv kllpmxav`lj ajf xllv l}v vmxxlx`{b* Ajf ljm ln vdmvd`je{ vdav @ `jvmjf vl fl a{ pxm{`fmjv `{ vl xm{vlxm Abmx`ka%{ {vajf`je `j vdm ulxgf* Um axm gm{{

xm{pmkvmf jlu vdaj um umxm mèdv max{ ael lx m~mj nl}x max{ ael* $[mj* Haxaki Lhaba' Xmbaxi{ F}x`je VdmN`x{v _xm{`fmjvàg Fmhavm' Ltnlxf' B[' 0,8>,?4)

Lhaba @j 8??03 @ Ul}gf Gìm Vl Vd`ji Vdav U`vd B Mgmkv`ljPl}xm [vaxv`je Vl [mm[lbm Xm{vlxav`lj Ln Abmx`ka%{ [vajf`je @j Vdm Ulxgf* LHABA3 @ ul}gf gìm vl vd`ji vdavu`vd b mgmkv`lj ajf vdm "" vdm maxg fmk`{`lj{ vdav um%~m bafm' vdav l}%xm {vaxv`je vl {mm {lbmxm{vlxav`lj ln Abmx`ka%{ {vajf`je `j vdm ulxgf* Ajf agvdl}ed a{ l} ijlu' @ agua{ b`{vx}{v plgg{'`jvmxjav`ljag plgg{ {mmb vl `jf`kavm vdav l}%xm {mm`je pmlpgm blxm dlpmn}g ahl}v Abmx`ka%{gmafmx{d`p* $_xm{`fmjv Haxaki Lhaba' _xm{{ Kljnmxmjkm Av E"8? [}bb`v' Gljflj' ]I' 6,8,?0)

Lhaba{ @jvmxjav`ljag _lp}gax`v Da{ F`bbmf @j B}kd Ln Vdm Ulxgf' A{ Lhaba pxmpaxm{ vl{vajf nlx xmmgmkv`lj' vdm {}xem `j ellf nmmg`je vluaxf vdm ]*[* vdav dm }{dmxmf `j da{ f`bbmf `j b}kd ln

vdm ulxgf* Ajf m~`fmjkm `{ {kajv vdav d`{ plp}gax`v da{ af~ajkmf ]*[* `jvmxm{v{ u`vd Abmx`ka{ agg`m{ lx`v{ af~mx{ax`m{ `j a vaje`hgm ua* $Cl{d Emx{vm`j' Ulxgf{ Lhaba Nm~mx Kllg{'_lg`v`kl' 0,81,18)

_lgg`je [dlu{ Eglhag Lp`j`lj Ln Lhaba{ @jvmxjav`ljag _lg`k`m{ Da{ Fmkg`jmf Fxabav`kagg[`jkm 8??0* Eglhag lp`j`lj ln _xm{`fmjv Haxaki Lhaba da{ fmkg`jmf fxabav`kagg {`jkm 8??0'akklxf`je vl a jmu {}x~m ln vdm pxm{`fmjv ajf d`{ plg`k`m{ `j 81 kl}jvx`m{* Appxl~ag ln Lhaba{`jvmxjav`ljag plg`k`m{ da{ fxlppmf nxlb 54 pmxkmjv vl >; pmxkmjv `j M}xlpm9 nxlb ;6 pmxkmjv vl 1=pmxkmjv `j B}{g`b Kl}jvx`m{9 nxlb 6? pmxkmjv vl 88 pmxkmjv `j X}{{à9 ajf nxlb =5 pmxkmjv vl 85pmxkmjv `j Kd`ja' xmplxv{ vdm _mu Eglhag Avv`v}fm{ _xlcmkv*$V`b Bai' Ulxgf _lgg3 Kd`gg Lj Lhaba _lg`k`m{'_lg`v`kl'>,1;,18)

Lhaba{ _lp}gax v Da{ ]j`~mx{agg [g`f [`jkm D`{ Mgmkv`lj* Lhaba ua{ bl{v plp}gax c}{vanvmx u`jj`je vdm pxm{`fmjk ajf vdl{m j}bhmx{ da~m agbl{v }j`~mx{agg {g`f {`jkm* Lhaba{plp}gax`v fxlppmf h fl}hgm fè`v{ `j 80 kl}jvx`m{ hmvummj 8?1? ajf 8?11' h}v l~mxagg `vfxlppmf c}{v vul pmxkmjvaem pl`jv{ nxlb a dèd ln 60- `j 8??0* $Ca Jmuvlj"[bagg' Lhaba Ahl}v A{ _lp}gaxAhxlaf A{ Dm @{ Av Dlbm'V`bm%{ ([uabpgajf(' 6,10,18)

Ljg 8? _mxkmjv Ln Af}gv{ @j 18 Kl}jvx`m{ Akxl{{ Vdm B`ffgm Ma{v Ajf Jlxvd Anx`ka Appxl~mLn Lhaba* Appxl~ag ln ]*[* gmafmx{d`p `j vdm B`ffgm Ma{v ajf Jlxvd Anx`ka $BMJA) xme`lj ua{agxmaf {g`pp`je hmnlxm vdm xmkmjv ua~m ln ajv`"]*[* pxlvm{v{ akxl{{ vdm xme`lj* Aj a~mxaem ln 8?-ln af}gv{ akxl{{ 18 BMJA kl}jvx`m{ Eagg}p {}x~mmf hmvummj Caj}ax ajf Ba 8?18 appxl~mf ln
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.debates.org/index.php?page=2008-debate-transcripthttp://www.debates.org/index.php?page=2008-debate-transcripthttp://www.debates.org/index.php?page=2008-debate-transcripthttp://www.debates.org/index.php?page=2008-debate-transcripthttp://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/news-conference-president-obama-40209http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/news-conference-president-obama-40209http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/news-conference-president-obama-40209http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0612/77373.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0612/77373.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0612/77373.htmlhttp://swampland.time.com/2012/04/19/obama-about-as-popular-abroad-as-he-is-at-home/#ixzz1sWC668Akhttp://swampland.time.com/2012/04/19/obama-about-as-popular-abroad-as-he-is-at-home/#ixzz1sWC668Akhttp://swampland.time.com/2012/04/19/obama-about-as-popular-abroad-as-he-is-at-home/#ixzz1sWC668Akhttp://swampland.time.com/2012/04/19/obama-about-as-popular-abroad-as-he-is-at-home/#ixzz1sWC668Akhttp://swampland.time.com/2012/04/19/obama-about-as-popular-abroad-as-he-is-at-home/#ixzz1sWC668Akhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0612/77373.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/news-conference-president-obama-40209http://www.debates.org/index.php?page=2008-debate-transcripthttp://www.debates.org/index.php?page=2008-debate-transcripthttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.html


4/47

6

vdm clh pmxnlxbajkm ln vdm gmafmx{d`p ln vdm ]*[* Vd`{ xav`je ua{ fluj nxlb 88- `j 8?11 ajf 8=-f}x`je vdm n`x{v vul max{ ln _xm{`fmjv Haxaki Lhaba%{ vmxb* $Caj [ljjmj{kdm`j ajf Bldabmf Pl}j`{' ]*[*Appxl~ag Mxlf`je @j BMJA Hmnlxm N`gb Kljvxl~mx{'Eagg}p' 0,86,18)

Lhaba{ Dajfg`je Ln Vdm M}xlsljm Kx`{`{ D}xv D`{ [vajf`je @j Nxajkm Ajf Emxbaj* D`{plp}gax`v uajmf h 1; pl`jv{ `j Nxajkm vl 68- ajf h 1? pl`jv{ `j Emxbaj vl 6?-' xmngmkv`jevdm emjmxag nmmg`je `j hlvd kl}jvx`m{ vdav vdm ]*[* f`fjv fl mjl}ed vl dmgp u`vd vdm M}xlsljmkx`{`{* $Ca Jmuvlj"[bagg' Lhaba Ahl}v A{ _lp}gax Ahxlaf A{ Dm @{ Av Dlbm'V`bm%{ ([uabpgajf(' 6,10,18)

Lhaba{ Appxl~ag @j Anedaj`{vaj _g}bbmvmf 18 _l`jv{ Vl ;1-* @j Anedaj`{vaj' `j vdmuaim ln {kajfag{ udmxm ]*[* {lgf`mx{ `jaf~mxvmjvg h}xjmf Ilxaj{ ajf ljm {lgf`mx aggmemfg i`ggmf15 Anedaj k`~`gàj{' Lhaba{ appxl~ag xav`je pg}bbmvmf 18 pl`jv{ vl ;1-* $Ca Jmuvlj"[bagg' LhabaAhl}v A{ _lp}gax Ahxlaf A{ Dm @{ Av Dlbm'V`bm%{ ([uabpgajf(' 6,10,18)

]jfmx Lhaba' Abmx`ka%{ @baem @{ Aea`j @j Fmkg`jm' M{pmkàgg @j Vdm B`ffgm Ma{v* H}v ud`gm plgg{{dlu Lhaba xmba`j{ pmx{ljagg plp}gax `j baj paxv{ ln vdm ulxgf' Abmx`ka%{ `baem `{ aea`j `j fmkg`jm'm{pmkàgg `j vdm B`ffgm Ma{v' vdm nlk}{ ln `jvmj{m pmx{ljag l}vxmakd av vdm {vaxv ln vdm pxm{`fmjv%{ vmxb*$Bavv [pmvagj`ki' Lhaba Nlxmèj _lg`k Hxèdv [plv Jlu Glli`je F`bbmx'Xm}vmx{' 0,8;,18)

Fm{p`vm Lhaba{ @jvmjv`lj{ Vl Mtvmjf Aj Lg`~m Hxajkd Vl Vdm B}{g`b Ulxgf' D`{ Akv`lj{Vdxl}edl}v Vdm Axah [px`je Ljg @jkxma{mf Axah F`{`gg}{`ljbmjv U`vd Abmx`ka*Baj

Axah{ a{imf' Dlu kl}gf vdm ][ pxm{`fmjv' b}kd gm{{ vd`{ pxm{`fmjv' c}{v`n cl`j`je d`{ agg`m{ `j}{`je nlxkm vl pxlvmkv G`haj{ nxlb hm`je {ga}edvmxmf `j Hmjesda`' h}v {dx`ji haki udmj A{{aff`f vdm {abm' lx ulx{m' `j Dlb{


5/47

=

{mjv`bmjv vluaxf vdm ]*[* `{ blxm dl{v`gm vdaj `v ua{ }jfmx H}{d aj ajemx mtpmxv{ avvx`h}vm vlLhaba{ aeexm{{`~m kabpaèj lnfxljm {vxìm{ aea`j{v vmxxlx {}{pmkv{ ajf v}b}gv xmgavmf vl vdmAxah [px`je fmblkxak bl~mbmjv*$Cl{d Emx{vm`j' Ulxgf{ Lhaba Nm~mx Kllg{'_lg`v`kl' 0,81,18)

>> _mxkmjv Ln Abmx`kaj{ [a Vdav Haxaki Lhaba Da{ M`vdmx Bafm Vd`je{ Ulx{m Lx Jlv BafmB}kd F`nnmxmjkm U`vd Xmeaxf{ Vl Abmx`ka{ [vajf`je @j Vdm Ulxgf' Ud`gm C}{v ;; _mxkmjv [a DmDa{ Bafm Vd`je{ Hmvvmx* $JHK Jmu{,Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' 1???A' BlM ;*1-' =,1>"8?,18)

Lhaba%{ Gmaf Lj Nlxmèj _lg`k Da{ _g}bbmvmf H 11 _l`jv{ [`jkm Vdm L}vhxmai Ln^`lgmjkm @j Vdm B`ffgm Ma{vB`vv Xlbjm da{ agg h}v mxa{mf _xm{`fmjv Lhaba%{ gmaf ljnlxmèj plg`k `{{}m{ `j vdm anvmxbavd ln vdm avvaki lj vdm ]*[* Klj{}gavm `j G`ha' akklxf`je vl a_mu plgg xmgma{mf Vd}x{fa* Lhaba%{ gmaf lj nlxmèj plg`k da{ pg}bbmvmf h 11 pl`jv{ {`jkm vdml}vhxmai ln ~`lgmjkm `j vdm B`ffgm Ma{v vdav k}gb`javmf u`vd vdm fmavd ln nl}x Abmx`kaj{ `j G`halj [mpv* 11' akklxf`je vl _mu* Vdm pxm{`fmjv dlgf{ a {g`b 65 pmxkmjv vl 6; pmxkmjv mfem l~mx d`{EL_ x`~ag lj vdm `{{}m ln udl ul}gf fl a hmvvmx clh lj nlxmèj plg`k' fluj nxlb a 1="pl`jvaf~ajvaem `j [mpvmbhmx* Vdm plgg ln 1'=11 af}gv{ ua{ kljf}kvmf vul ummi{ ael' ajf nl}jf vdavbaj Abmx`kaj{ da~m {l}xmf lj vdm {`v}av`lj `j vdm B`ffgm Ma{v3 ljg 8= pmxkmjv {mm a pl{`v`~mn}v}xm nlx vdm xme`lj' fluj nxlb 68 pmxkmjv `j Apx`g* $C}gàj _mkq}mv' Xlbjm Agg H}v Mxa{m{ Lhaba%{ _lgg`je Gmaf LjNlxmèj _lg`k'Vdm D`gg%{ Eglhag Anna`x{' 1?,14,18)

Ablje @jfmpmjfmjv{' 6? _mxkmjv F`{appxl~mf Ln Lhaba{ Dajfg`je Ln Vdm G`ha AvvakiAjf Ljg 84 _mxkmjv Appxl~mf*A {mpaxavm _mu plgg vaimj ga{v ummi' ag{l xmgma{mf Vd}x{fa'nl}jf vdav a gaxem kd}ji ln `jfmpmjfmjv ~lvmx{ f`{appxl~m ln Lhaba%{ dajfg`je ln vdm G`ha{`v}av`lj' pl{{`hg dmgp`je Xlbjm u`vd a hglk ln ~lvmx{ vdav kl}gf fmk`fm vdm mgmkv`lj* Vdm {mkljfplgg nl}jf vdav ud`gm vdm emjmxag p}hg`k ua{ {pg`v m~mjg lj Lhaba{ dajfg`je ln vdm avvaki'`jfmpmjfmjv{ umxm blxm gìmg vl f`{appxl~m ln vdm pxm{`fmjv%{ dajfg`je ln vdm {`v}av`lj' 6?pmxkmjv vl 84 pmxkmjv*$C}gàj _mkq}mv' Xlbjm Agg H}v Mxa{m{ Lhaba%{ _lgg`je Gmaf Lj Nlxmèj _lg`k'Vdm D`gg%{ Eglhag Anna`x{'1?,14,18)

Axl}jf Vdm Ulxgf' _mlpgm Axm F`{appl`jvmf Vdav Xmgav`~mg G`vvgm Da{ Kdajemf ]jfmx Lhaba*@v ua{ jlv c}{v ]*[* Fmblkxav`k ~lvmx{ udl umxm glli`je nlxuaxf vl dlpm ajf kdajem udmj HaxakiLhaba hmkabm vdm 66vd ]*[* pxm{`fmjv* Axl}jf vdm ulxgf' baj ajv`k`pavmf vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ ul}gf

hmda~m ~mx f`nnmxmjvg }jfmx vdm jmu gmafmx* Vdm uajvmf vl dmax gm{{ ahl}v Abmx`kaj{ {uaeemx`je ajfvdxlu`je vdm`x umèdv axl}jf* [lbm' pmxdap{' uajvmf blxm vagi ln ]*[*"{vgm nxmmflb ajf fmblkxak' h}vjlv `n `v bmajv Ua{d`jevlj `bpl{`je `v{ u`gg* Nmu f`{p}vm vdav Lhaba%{ mgmkv`lj hxl}edv u`vd `v ajlv`kmahgm kdajem `j vljm* H}v ;"1,8 max{ gavmx' vdmxm axm exlu`je klbpga`jv{ vdav udmj `v klbm{ vl{}h{vajkm' xmgav~mg g`vvgm da{ kdajemf*$_mvmx App{' Ajag{`{3 Lhaba Nagg{ [dlxv Ln Bmvmlx`k Mtpmkvav`lj{ Ahxlaf'Xm}vmx{' 6,80,18)

Vdm Ulxgf Kajjlv Ua`v Ud`gm Lhaba _}v{ Kabpaèj`je Admaf Ln Eglhag Gmafmx{d`p

Fm{p`vm Vdm X`{`je Vmj{`lj @j Vdm B`ffgm Ma{v' Lhaba Da{ Bafm A Kagk}gavmf Ahf`kav`lj AjfFmk`fmf Vl _}v Vdm Ulxgf Lj Dlgf ]jv`g Anvmx Jl~mbhmx >* Vdm vx}vd `{ vdav m~mxljm ijlu{'bl{v ln agg A{{af ajf d`{ pavxlj{ `j Vmdxaj ajf Bl{klu' vdav Bx* Lhaba da{ fmk`fmf vl p}v vdm ulxgf lj

dlgf }jv`g anvmx Jl~mbhmx >* @{xamg `{ {}ppl{mf vl fl jlvd`je ahl}v @xaj' ajf [xà%{ xmhmg{ axm {}ppl{mfvl d}jimx fluj ajf {}x~`~m' `j lxfmx vl gmv Bx* Lhaba immp a{{}x`je Abmx`kaj{ vdav vdm v`fm ln uax `{xmkmf`je* Lj vdm kljvxax' vdaji{ `j paxv vl Bx* Lhaba%{ kagk}gavmf ahf`kav`lj' B`ffgm Ma{v vmj{`lj ajfv}xbl`g axm x`{`je* $Mf`vlxàg' Ua`v`je Nlx Haxaki'Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' 4,18,18)

Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag3 Vdm Xme`lj @{ Blxm Fajemxl}{ Ajf Ba Hm [g`f`je @jvl AjlvdmxUax Hmka}{m Jl Ljm Vx}{v{ ]*[* Xm{lg~m* Bx* Lhaba {a`f d`{ f`pglbak ul}gf mjdajkm ]*[*`jng}mjkm ajf kxmavm a {anmx' blxm {vahgm B`ffgm Ma{v* @j{vmaf' vdm xme`lj `{ blxm fajemxl}{ ajf
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.htmlhttp://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/MSNBC/Sections/A_Politics/_Today_Stories_Teases/120522NBCWSJpoll.pdfhttp://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/MSNBC/Sections/A_Politics/_Today_Stories_Teases/120522NBCWSJpoll.pdfhttp://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/MSNBC/Sections/A_Politics/_Today_Stories_Teases/120522NBCWSJpoll.pdfhttp://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/MSNBC/Sections/A_Politics/_Today_Stories_Teases/120522NBCWSJpoll.pdfhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/29/us-obama-reputation-idUSBRE83S0B620120429http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/29/us-obama-reputation-idUSBRE83S0B620120429http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/29/us-obama-reputation-idUSBRE83S0B620120429http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444772404577585630644379906.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444772404577585630644379906.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444772404577585630644379906.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444772404577585630644379906.htmlhttp://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/29/us-obama-reputation-idUSBRE83S0B620120429http://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/terrorism/262867-poll-independent-voters-fault-obamas-handling-of-libya-attackhttp://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/MSNBC/Sections/A_Politics/_Today_Stories_Teases/120522NBCWSJpoll.pdfhttp://www.politico.com/news/stories/0912/81479.html


6/47

>

ba hm {g`f`je `jvl ajlvdmx uax hmka}{m jl ljm vx}{v{ ]*[* xm{lg~m* $Mf`vlxàg' Lhaba%{ ]*J* Nx`mjf{'Vdm Uagg[vxmmv Cl}xjag' 4,8;,18)

Lhaba Kajjlv Vaim A V`bml}v Nxlb Eglhag Gmafmx{d`p F}x`je Vdm Mgmkv`lj [ma{lj* Pm{' vd`{ `{aj mgmkv`lj {ma{lj' ajf Abmx`kaj{ axm navè}mf nxlb a fmkafm ln uax* H}v eglhag gmafmx{d`p flm{ jlv vaima v`bml}v' ajf {lbmv`bm{ `v da{ vl gmaf vluaxf a klj{mj{}{' jlv ua`v nlx ljm vl nlxb* Vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{da{ hmmj' ajf u`gg xmba`j' vdm ljm `jf`{pmj{ahgm jav`lj `j ulxgf anna`x{' vdm pxm{`fmjv fmkgaxmf `j a{pmmkd ga{v ummi* N`jm ulxf{* $Mf`vlxàg' Vdm V`bm Nlx _av`mjkm @j [xà @{ L~mx'Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v' 5,85,18)

Fm{p`vm Ulxgf Gmafmx{ Eavdmx`je @j Jmu Plxi Av Vdm ]j`vmf Jav`lj{' Lhaba Da{ Jl _gaj{ VlBmmv _x`~avmg U`vd Aj Ln Vdmb H}v U`gg Baim V`bm Nlx Fav`bm V^* Vdm ulxgf%{ gmafmx{ axmeavdmx`je `j Jmu Plxi' h}v _xm{`fmjv Haxaki Lhaba da{ jl pgaj{ vl bmmv px`~avmg u`vd aj ln vdmb* Dmu`gg baim v`bm nlx Vdm ^`mu' a nxmmudmmg`je V^ vagi {dlu blxm gìmg vl xmakd ~lvmx{ vdaj Lhaba ul}gfu`vd vdm f`pglbak dm `{ {i`pp`je av vdm ]j`vmf Jav`lj{* $Hmj Nmggmx' Lhaba' @j Mgmkv`lj Blfm' Vèdvmj{ D`{ ]J F`pglbak'VdmA{{lkàvmf _xm{{' 0,88,18)

U`vd Kx`{m{ Ahxlaf' Lhaba{ Fmk`{`lj VlC}bp Haki Lj Vdm Kabpaèj Vxa`g @j{vmaf LnBmmv`je U`vd Vlp Nlxmèj Gmafmx{ @{ A Xmngmkv`lj Ln Udmxm D`{ _x`lx`v`m{ G`m* Lhaba%{n`jag v}xj lj vdm ulxgf {vaem hmnlxm nak`je ~lvmx{ u`gg hm a xmngmkv`lj ln udmxm d`{ px`lx`v`m{ g`m*Fm{p`vm {`bbmx`je eglhag kx`{m{' dm u`gg {i`p vxaf`v`ljag px`~avm bmmv`je{ u`vd nlxmèjkl}jvmxpaxv{ ajf {q}mmsm d`{ ]*J* ~`{`v `jvl c}{v 86 dl}x{ {l dm kaj c}bp haki lj vdm kabpaèjvxa`g* $Bavv [pmvagj`ki' Lhaba Nlxmèj _lg`k Hxèdv [plv Jlu Glli`je F`bbmx'Xm}vmx{' 0,8;,18)

Lhaba{ Gaki Ln _x`~avm Bmmv`je{ U`vd Im Agg`m{ @j Jmu Plxi [èjagmf Kabpaèj`je @{D`{ @bpmxav`~m*Lhaba%{ akv`~`v`m{ av vdm ]j`vmf Jav`lj{ {a`f pgmjv' vll3 Vdmxm axm jlv baj lnvdmb* Kabpaèj`je `{ d`{ `bpmxav`~m* Dm `{ {i`pp`je vdm px`~avm bmmv`je{ u`vd im agg`m{ vdav a ]*[*pxm{`fmjv vp`kagg {kdmf}gm{ udmj vdm udlgm `jvmxjav`ljag klbb}j`v klbm{ vl Jmu Plxi* Vdmpxm{`fmjv u`gg {pmjf ljg 86 dl}x{ `j Jmu Plxi `j vlvag vd`{ v`bm' ajf dm {pmjv {lbm ln `v Bljfavl appmax lj Vdm ^`mu' e`~`je a vagi {dlu `jvmx~`mu `jvmjfmf vl {mgg d`{ mgmkv`lj p`vkd vl a hè Vâ}f`mjkm*$Hmj Nmggmx' Lhaba Av Vdm ]J' @j [daflu Ln Kabpaèj _lg`v`k{' Vdm A{{lkàvmf _xm{{' 0,8=,18)

]jgìm Lhaba{ _xmfmkm{{lx{' Dm @{ [i`pp`je Vdm Nakm"Vl"Nakm Bmmv`je{ U`vd Kl}jvmxpaxv{

Udmxm B}kd Ln Vdm ]*J* Ulxi Emv{ Fljm C}{v {`t ummi{ }jv`g vdm mgmkv`lj' vdm xmag`v`m{ ajfpx`lx`v`m{ ln kabpaèj plg`v`k{ daje pxlb`jmjvg l~mx Lhaba%{ n`jag v}xj lj vdm ulxgf {vaem hmnlxm nak`je~lvmx{* ]jgìm d`{ pxmfmkm{{lx{' dm `{ {i`pp`je vdm nakm"vl"nakm bmmv`je{ u`vd kl}jvmxpaxv{ udmxm b}kd lnvdm ]*J* ulxi{ emv{ fljm' gma~`je [mkxmvax ln [vavm D`ggax Xlfdab Kg`jvlj vl p`ki }p blxm ln vdl{m{m{{`lj{ dmx{mgn* Lhaba%{ `v`jmxax lj Bljfa ajf V}m{fa `{ klbpxm{{mf {l vdav dm kaj emv haki vlkabpaèj`je `j {lbm ln vdm bl{v kljvm{vmf {vavm{ {}kd a{ Ld`l ajf `xe`jà* $Hmj Nmggmx' Lhaba' @j Mgmkv`lj Blfm'Vèdvmj{ D`{ ]J F`pglbak'Vdm A{{lkàvmf _xm{{' 0,88,18)

Hlvd _xm{`fmjv Emlxem U* H}{d Ajf H`gg Kg`jvlj Dmgf Bmmv`je{ U`vd Nlxmèj Gmafmx{F}x`je ]*J* ^`{`v{ @j Vdm`x Xm"Mgmkv`lj Pmax{* Hlvd _xm{`fmjv{ Emlxem U* H}{d `j 8??6 ajf H`ggKg`jvlj `j 100>' vdl}ed' dmgf a {mx`m{ ln bmmv`je{ u`vd nlxmèj gmafmx{ f}x`je ]*J* ~`{`v{ `j vdm`xxm"mgmkv`lj max{* Vdm Lhaba Ud`vm Dl}{m lpvmf jlv vl cab `j a nmu ajf x`{i lnnmjf`je vdm agg`m{

udl umxm gmnv l}v' afb`j`{vxav`lj lnn`kàg{ {a`f* $Hmj Nmggmx' Lhaba' @j Mgmkv`lj Blfm' Vèdvmj{ D`{ ]J F`pglbak'VdmA{{lkàvmf _xm{{' 0,88,18)

Lhaba Fmgmeavmf Bmmv`je{ U`vd Ulxgf Gmafmx{ Vl [mkxmvax Kg`jvlj F}x`je [lbm Ln Vdm Bl{v_xm{{`je Nlxmèj _lg`k Kx`{m{ Vdm Afb`j`{vxav`lj Da{ Nakmf [`jkm Vai`je Lnn`km @j 8??0*Vdavva{i dm fmgmeavmf vl Bx{* Kg`jvlj' udl kd}xjmf vdxl}ed vdm n`x{v ln flsmj{ ln bmmv`je{ {dm u`gg da~m l~mxvdm jmtv ummi* Vdm fmag u`vd {lbm ln vdm bl{v pxm{{`je nlxmèj plg`k kx`{m{ vdm afb`j`{vxav`lj da{nakmf {`jkm vai`je lnn`km `j 8??0' gìm vdm fmafg pxlvm{v{ `j vdm @{gab`k ulxgf ajf vdm kljnxljvav`ljhmvummj Capaj ajf Kd`ja l~mx a dajfn}g ln }jplp}gavmf `{gajf{* Bx{* Kg`jvlj bmv _xm{`fmjv A{`n Ag`
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444812704577607790585187560.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444812704577607790585187560.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444812704577607790585187560.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444812704577607790585187560.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-time-for-leadership-on-syria/2012/07/27/gJQA2v8mEX_story.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-time-for-leadership-on-syria/2012/07/27/gJQA2v8mEX_story.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-time-for-leadership-on-syria/2012/07/27/gJQA2v8mEX_story.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-un-assembly-obama-idUSBRE88M01J20120923http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-un-assembly-obama-idUSBRE88M01J20120923http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-un-assembly-obama-idUSBRE88M01J20120923http://news.yahoo.com/obama-un-shadow-campaign-politics-070352043--politics.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-un-shadow-campaign-politics-070352043--politics.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-un-shadow-campaign-politics-070352043--politics.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-un-shadow-campaign-politics-070352043--politics.htmlhttp://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-un-assembly-obama-idUSBRE88M01J20120923http://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/obama-election-mode-tightens-un-diplomacy-112449782.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-time-for-leadership-on-syria/2012/07/27/gJQA2v8mEX_story.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444812704577607790585187560.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444812704577607790585187560.html


7/47

5

Saxfax` ln _ai`{vaj $@v{ hmmj a f`nn`k}gv v`bm nlx agg ln }{' dm vlgf dmx anvmx x`lv{ pxlvm{v`je a ~`fml vxa`gmxvdav fmjèxavm{ vdm _xlpdmv B}dabbaf ajf ua{ bafm `j vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{) a{ umgg a{ Bx* Iaxsa`* H vdmmjf ln a {kdmf}gmf 18"dl}x fa' {dm ua{ vl da~m bmv u`vd _xm{`fmjv Bldabmf Blx{` ln Mepv* A {mj`lxafb`j`{vxav`lj lnn`kàg {a`f Bx{* Kg`jvlj{ bmmv`je u`vd Bx* Saxfax` ajf _ai`{vaj{ nlxmèj b`j`{vmx' D`jaXahhaj` Idax' xmpxm{mjvmf a xm"mjmxe`smf fàgle}m av vdm dèdm{v gm~mg{ `n jlv vdm ~mx dèdm{v gm~mgu`vd Bx* Lhaba* @j hmvummj' {dm dmgf aj mblv`ljag bmmv`je u`vd _xm{`fmjv Bldabmf Baeaxàn ln G`ha'udl xm`vmxavmf d`{ aplgle`m{ nlx vdm [mpv* 11 i`gg`je{ ln Abha{{aflx C* Kdx`{vlpdmx [vm~mj{ ajf vdxmmlvdmx Abmx`kaj{ `j Hmjedas`* Dm jlvmf vdm kl}jvmxpxlvm{v{' dmgf `j Hmjedas` ajf lvdmx G`haj k`v`m{ lj

Nx`fa' vdav mtpxm{{mf {}pplxv nlx vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{* $Dmgmjm Kllpmx ajf [vm~mj Gmm Bmmx{' Ud`gm ]*J* Hmkilj{ Kg`jvlj' LhabaVaim{ @j Vdm `mu'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' 0,86,18)

Lhaba%{ Xmgav`~mg Glu"Im ]*J* @v`jmxax U`gg Ag{l Hm A [vaxi Xmb`jfmx Vdav Vdm DmafLpv`b`{b Vdav Exmmvmf D`b Udmj Dm Vlli Lnn`km _xlb`{`je Vl Hm A Vxaj{nlxbav`ljag [vavm{bajDa{ Kllgmf' E`~`je Ua Vl Emlplg`v`kag Xmag`v`m{*Nxlb B`ffgm Ma{v }pdma~ag vl vdm vxl}hgmf Anedajuax mnnlxv vl a blxm a{{mxv`~m X}{{à' _xm{`fmjv Haxaki Lhaba `{ nak`je pxm{{}xm{ vdav vdxmavmj vl kd`paua av a nlxmèj plg`k xmklxf d`{ a`fm{ dlpmf ul}gf hm `bb}jm vl Xmp}hg`kaj avvaki*Lhaba%{ n`jagv}xj lj vdm ulxgf {vaem hmnlxm nak`je ~lvmx{ u`gg hm a xmngmkv`lj ln udmxm d`{ px`lx`v`m{ g`m* Fm{p`vm{`bbmx`je eglhag kx`{m{' dm u`gg {i`p vxaf`v`ljag px`~avm bmmv`je{ u`vd nlxmèj kl}jvmxpaxv{ ajf {q}mmsmd`{ ]*J* ~`{`v `jvl c}{v 86 dl}x{ {l dm kaj c}bp haki lj vdm kabpaèj vxa`g* H}v Lhaba%{ xmgav`~mg glu"im

]*J* `v`jmxax u`gg ag{l hm a {vaxi xmb`jfmx vdav vdm dmaf lpv`b`{b vdav exmmvmf d`b udmj dm vlli lnn`kmpxlb`{`je vl hm a vxaj{nlxbav`ljag {vavm{baj da{ kllgmf' e`~`je ua vl emlplg`v`kag xmag`v`m{* $Bavv [pmvagj`ki'Lhaba Nlxmèj _lg`k Hxèdv [plv Jlu Glli`je F`bbmx'Xm}vmx{' 0,8;,18)
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/25/world/obama-and-clinton-arrive-for-united-nations-session.html?_r=0http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/25/world/obama-and-clinton-arrive-for-united-nations-session.html?_r=0http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/25/world/obama-and-clinton-arrive-for-united-nations-session.html?_r=0http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-un-assembly-obama-idUSBRE88M01J20120923http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-un-assembly-obama-idUSBRE88M01J20120923http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-un-assembly-obama-idUSBRE88M01J20120923http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-un-assembly-obama-idUSBRE88M01J20120923http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/25/world/obama-and-clinton-arrive-for-united-nations-session.html?_r=0


8/47

4

@@* GMAF@JE NXLB HMD@JF3 ANEDAJ@[VAJ

Vdm Hèem{v Na`g}xm @j Anedaj`{vaj @{ Lhaba{ Gmafmx{d`p

Lhaba @j 8??43 Vd`{ @{ A Uax Vdav Um Da~m Vl U`j*LHABA3 @ da~m axe}mf nlx max{ vdav um gakivdm xm{l}xkm{ vl n`j`{d vdm clh hmka}{m ln l}x klbb`vbmjv vl @xaq* Vdav%{ udav vdm Kda`xbaj ln vdm Cl`jvKd`mn{ ln [vann {a`f maxg`mx vd`{ bljvd* Ajf vdav%{ ud' a{ _xm{`fmjv' @ u`gg baim vdm nèdv aea`j{v ag Qamfaajf vdm Vag`haj vdm vlp px`lx`v vdav `v {dl}gf hm* Vd`{ `{ a uax vdav um da~m vl u`j* $[mjavlx Haxaki Lhaba'

Xmbaxi{ Lj A Jmu [vxavme Nlx A Jmu Ulxgf' Ua{d`jevlj' FK' 5,1=,?4)

Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v3 Abmx`kaj{ Xaxmg Dmax Bx* Lhaba Mtpga`j Vdm B`{{`lj Lx Vdm [vaim{ @jAnedaj`{vaj*Anedaj{' vdm Vag`haj ajf jmèdhlx{ {}kd a{ _ai`{vaj kaj xma{ljahg kljkg}fm vdav vdm]j`vmf [vavm{' xavdmx vdaj vx`je vl u`j vdm uax' `{ xak`je vl `bpgmbmjv aj mt`v {vxavme `j ud`kd vdm`jvmxm{v{ ln Anedaj{ ajf vdm`x el~mxjbmjv axm {gèdvmf* Abmx`kaj{' bmajud`gm' xaxmg dmax Bx* Lhabamtpga`j vdm b`{{`lj lx vdm {vaim{* $Mf`vlxàg' Lhaba{ Vxl}hgmf Dajfg`je Ln Anedaj`{vaj'Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v' ;,1;,18)

Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag3 Xaxmg Da{ A ]*[* _xm{`fmjv @j Uaxv`bm [a`f [l G`vvgm [l@jnxmq}mjvg Ahl}v D`{ Luj [vxavme* Bx* Lhaba%{ xaxm xmkmjv p}hg`k klbbmjv{ lj vdm uaxda~m hmmj blbmjv{ ln aplgle vl Anedaj{' xavdmx vdaj mtpga`j`je vl Abmx`kaj{ vdm pxlexm{{ l}xvxllp{ da~m bafm ajf vdm {}pplxv vdm xmkm`~m nxlb vdm ~a{v baclx`v ln Anedaj{* Xaxmg da{ a ]*[

_xm{`fmjv `j uaxv`bm {a`f {l g`vvgm {l `jnxmq}mjvg ahl}v d`{ luj {vxavme ajf vdm nlxkm{ nèdv`je vlbaim `v ulxi*$Mf`vlxàg' Vdm _mx`g{ Ln Xmvxmav' Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' ;,1;,18)

A{ Ln Ba 8?18' Lhaba Dafjv E`~mj A [`jegm Baclx [pmmkd Lj Anedaj`{vaj [`jkm C}g8?11' Ajf L~mx V`bm Vdm Abmx`kaj _}hg`k Da{ V}xjmf [impv`kag Ln Vdm Kljng`kv*_xm{`fmjv Lhaba da{ hmmj `j vdm plg`v`kag mq}`~agmjv ln aj }jf`{kgl{mf glkav`lj lj Anedaj`{vajnlx jmaxg a max' {l udav a pgma{ajv {}xpx`{m V}m{fa vl {mm d`b mbmxem lj vdm {}hcmkv * * * `jAnedaj`{vaj* Vdm Anedaj kabpaèj jmmf{ Bx* Lhaba%{ kgl{mx avvmjv`lj ajf ~lkag {}pplxv* VdmAbmx`kaj p}hg`k da{ v}xjmf {impv`kag lj vdm kljng`kv' u`vd >?- vmgg`je plgg{vmx{ vdav vdm xmba`j`je0?'??? ]*[* {lgf`mx{ {dl}gf klbm dlbm {llj* Pmv Bx* Lhaba da{ xaxmg vx`mf vl {ua vdmb* [`jkmajjl}jk`je `j C}jm ln ga{v max aj maxg fxaufluj ln d`{ ({}xem( nlxkm{' vdm _xm{`fmjv da{j%v e`~mj

a {`jegm baclx {pmmkd lj Anedaj`{vaj*$Mf`vlxàg' Lhaba @j Iah}g3 Vdm _xm{`fmjv E`~m{ D`{ N`x{v Baclx Anedaj Xmbaxi{ [`jkmC}jm'Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' =,1,18)

Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag3 @v%{ Daxf Vl Vmgg @n _xm{`fmjv Lhaba [v`gg [}pplxv{ Vdm Uax @jAnedaj`{vaj* Vdm Abmx`kaj pmlpgm vmgg plgg{vmx{ vdm%xm {l}x`je lj vdm Anedaj uax' ajf jl uljfmx* @v%{daxf vl vmgg `n _xm{`fmjv Lhaba {v`gg {}pplxv{ `v* Dm xaxmg bmjv`lj{ a kljng`kv `j ud`kd 0?'??? Abmx`kaj{axm x`{i`je vdm`x g`~m{* D`{ ga{v baclx {pmmkd lj Anedaj`{vaj ua{ a C}jm 8?11 ajjl}jkmbmjv vdav dm ua{p}gg`je haki maxg lj d`{ {}xem ln ;?'??? vxllp{' u`vdfxau`je vdmb vd`{ max* $Mf`vlxàg' Anedaj`{vaj%{ Hgllf[px`je'Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' 6,1>,18)

Lhaba Jm~mx Bmjv`lj{ B`g`vax [}kkm{{m{ @j Anedaj`{vaj' Ljg D`{ _gaj{ Nlx U`vdfxauag*Udmj dm `{ a{imf ahl}v Anedaj`{vaj' Bx* Lhaba xmpmav{ d`{ klbb`vbmjv vl {vmaf ]*[*u`vdfxauag{ admaf ln vdm 8?16 dajfl~mx vl vdm Anedaj{' xavdmx vdaj vl Abmx`kaj b`g`vax {}kkm{{*Dm {mmb{ vxappmf h ljm ln d`{ {èjav}xm xm"mgmkv`lj kabpaèj g`jm{3 Vdm v`fm ln uax `{ xmkmf`je*($Mf`vlxàg' Anedaj`{vaj%{ Hgllf [px`je'Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' 6,1>,18)

Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag3 Vdm _lg`v`kag Fmvakdbmjv Ln Bx* Lhaba Nxlb D`{ Luj [}xem @{]jpxmkmfmjvmf* Fmhavm{ l~mx uax {vxavme axmj%v }j`q}m vl vd`{ Afb`j`{vxav`lj' h}v vdmplg`v`kag fmvakdbmjv ln Bx* Lhaba nxlb d`{ luj {}xem `{ }jpxmkmfmjvmfajf fmblxag`s`je* ]*[*Abha{{aflx vl Iah}g Xaj Kxlkimx da{ bafm jl {mkxmv ln d`{ nx}{vxav`lj u`vd vdm vul"nxljv uaxvdav dm ajf d`{ klggmae}m{ b}{v uaem`j Anedaj`{vaj ajf `j Ua{d`jevlj* Vl afapv Cldj Imxx'
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/obamas-troubled-handling-of-afghanistan/2012/03/13/gIQAYN6NAS_story.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/obamas-troubled-handling-of-afghanistan/2012/03/13/gIQAYN6NAS_story.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/obamas-troubled-handling-of-afghanistan/2012/03/13/gIQAYN6NAS_story.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304450004577277692758438750.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304450004577277692758438750.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304450004577277692758438750.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303916904577378352801560664.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303916904577378352801560664.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303916904577378352801560664.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304636404577295832858841416.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTophttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304636404577295832858841416.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTophttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304636404577295832858841416.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTophttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304636404577295832858841416.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTophttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304636404577295832858841416.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTophttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304636404577295832858841416.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTophttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304636404577295832858841416.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTophttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304636404577295832858841416.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTophttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303916904577378352801560664.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304450004577277692758438750.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/obamas-troubled-handling-of-afghanistan/2012/03/13/gIQAYN6NAS_story.html


9/47

0

udav {lgf`mx uajv{ vl hm vdm ga{v vl f`m `j a uax vdav vdm _xm{`fmjv jl gljemx hmg`m~m{ `j


10/47

1?

@j Maxg 8?11' Lhaba Bafm Vdm Fmk`{`lj Vl Hme`j A [pmmf' Lxfmxg Mt`v Nxlb Anedaj`{vajU`vdl}v [mmi`je Af~`km Nxlb [mkxmvax Eavm{ Lx [mkxmvax Kg`jvlj*H maxg 8?11' Bx* Lhaba daf{mmj mjl}ed* Dm vlgf d`{ {vann vl axxajem a {pmmf' lxfmxg mt`v nxlb Anedaj`{vaj* Vd`{ v`bm vdmxm ul}gfhm jl ajjl}jkmf jav`ljag {mk}x`v bmmv`je{' jl fmhavm{ u`vd vdm emjmxag{* M~mj Fmnmj{m [mkxmvaxXlhmxv B* Eavm{ ajf [mkxmvax ln [vavm D`ggax Xlfdab Kg`jvlj umxm gmnv l}v }jv`g vdm n`jag {`t ummi{* $Fa~`f [ajemx' Kdaxv`je Lhaba{ Cl}xjm Vl A [d`nv Lj Anedaj`{vaj'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' =,10,18)

Udmj Vdm _xm{`fmjv Ajf A Dagn"Flsmj Ud`vm Dl}{m A`fm{ Hmeaj Vl _gaj Nlx VdmU`vdfxauag' Vdm Emjmxag{ Umxm K}v L}v Mjv`xmg*Jlv glje hmnlxm' anvmx a dèdg kljvmjv`l}{fmhavm u`vd`j a uax kah`jmv vdav ua{ x`ffgmf u`vd gmai{' Bx* Lhaba daf xmg}kvajvg fmk`fmf vllxfmx a {}xem ln blxm vdaj ;?'??? vxllp{* Vdm a`fm vlgf Bx* Lhaba vdav dm hmg`m~mf b`g`vaxgmafmx{ daf aexmmf vl vdm vèdv {kdmf}gm vl hme`j u`vdfxau`je vdl{m vxllp{ c}{v 14 bljvd{ gavmxljg hmka}{m vdm vdl}edv vdm kl}gf pmx{}afm aj `jmtpmx`mjkmf pxm{`fmjv vl exajv blxm v`bm `nvdm fmbajfmf `v* Umgg' Bx* Lhaba xm{pljfmf vdav fa' @b jlv el`je vl e`~m vdmb blxm v`bm* Amax gavmx' udmj vdm pxm{`fmjv ajf a dagn"flsmj Ud`vm Dl}{m a`fm{ hmeaj vl pgaj nlx vdmu`vdfxauag' vdm emjmxag{ umxm k}v l}v mjv`xmg* Vdmxm ua{ jl fmhavm' ajf vdmxm umxm jl gmai{* $Fa~`f [ajemx' Kdaxv`je Lhaba{ Cl}xjm Vl A [d`nv Lj Anedaj`{vaj'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' =,10,18)

@j C}jm 8?11' Lhaba Ajjl}jkmf Vdav Vdm Anedaj`{vaj [}xem Ua{ Mjf`je U`vd Vdm U`vdfxauag Ln1?'??? Vxllp{ Vdav Pmax Ajf 8;'??? Vxllp{ @j 8?18* _xm{`fmjv Lhaba ajjl}jkmf Umfjm{fa dm `{

mjf`je vdm Anedaj`{vaj {}xem h u`vdfxau`je 1?'??? vxllp{ h vdm mjf ln vdm max' pxlb`{`je aj mjf vlvdm uax `{ jmax* @j a px`bm"v`bm affxm{{' Lhaba {a`f ajlvdmx 8;'??? vxllp{ u`gg gma~m Anedaj`{vaj h vdmmjf ln [mpvmbhmx 8?18 anvmx a fmkafm"glje kljng`kv `jkxma{`jeg }jplp}gax u`vd Abmx`kaj ~lvmx{ ajfgaubaimx{ nxlb hlvd paxv`m{* Vdm v`fm ln uax `{ xmkmf`je' {a`f Lhaba' udl jlvmf vdav agg ]*[* vxllp{ u`gggma~m @xaq h vdm mjf ln vd`{ max* @v{ v`bm vl nlk}{ lj jav`ljag h}`gf`je dmxm av dlbm* $[ab Pl}jebaj'_xm{`fmjv Lhaba Ga{ L}v Mt`v [vxavme Nlx Vdm Anedaj`{vaj Uax'Vdm D`gg' >,8;,11)

Lhaba{ U`vdfxauag Ua{ Jlv Aj Lpv`lj _xm{mjvmf H D`{ Vlp Emjmxag{* Udmj a{imf h[l}vd Kaxlg`ja Xmp}hg`kaj [mj* G`jf{m Exadab f}x`je a dmax`je ln vdm [mjavm Axbmf [mx~`km{Klbb`vvmm V}m{fa udmvdmx vdm pxm{`fmjv{ u`vdfxauag pgaj ua{ ljm ln vdm lpv`lj{ pxm{mjvmf vlvdm pxm{`fmjv h Emjmxag _mvxam}{' YBax`jm Gv* Emjmxag CldjR Aggmj xm{pljfmf' @v ua{ jlv* $Cab`mUm`j{vm`j' Emjmxag3 Lhaba Anedaj U`vdfxauag _gaj Jlv Ablje Lpv`lj{ _xm{mjvmf H _mvxam}{' Fa`gp Kaggmx' >,84,11)

Emjmxag Fa~`f _mvxam}{3 Vdm ]gv`bavm Fmk`{`lj Ua{ A Blxm Aeexm{{`~m Nlxb}gav`lj' @n Pl}U`gg' @j Vmxb{ Ln Vdm V`bm G`jm' Vdaj Udav Um Daf Xmklbbmjfmf* _MVXAM][3 Vdmpxm{`fmjv vdmj bafm a fmk`{`lj* Vdm klbbajfmx `j kd`mn da{ fmk`fmf* Ajf `v `{ vdmj vdmxm{plj{`h`g`v' jmmfgm{{ vl {a' ln vdl{m `j }j`nlxb vl {ag}vm {baxvg ajf vl fl m~mxvd`je d}bajgpl{{`hgm vl mtmk}vm `v* Jlu' a{ Kda`xbaj B}ggmj' Afb`xag B}ggmj' {vavmf vlfa hmnlxm vdm Dl}{mAxbmf [mx~`km{ Klbb`vvmm' vdm }gv`bavm fmk`{`lj ua{ a blxm aeexm{{`~m nlxb}gav`lj' `n l} u`gg'`j vmxb{ ln vdm v`bm g`jm' vdaj udav um daf xmklbbmjfmf* Aea`j' vdav `{ }jfmx{vajfahgm `j vdm{mj{m vdav vdmxm axm hxlafmx klj{`fmxav`lj{ hmljf c}{v vdl{m ln a b`g`vax klbbajfmx* $[mgmkvKlbb`vvmm Lj @jvmggèmjkm' ]*[* [mjavm' Dmax`je' >,8;,11)

Bax`jm Gv* Emjmxag Cldj Aggmj3 Lhaba{ U`vdfxauag _gaj Nxlb Anedaj`{vaj Ua{ Jlv LjmLn Vdm Lpv`lj{ Vdm B`g`vax Daf _xm{mjvmf* [MJ* G@JF[MP EXADAB3 Agg xèdv* Jlu gmv%{ vagiahl}v kl}jvmx`j{}xemjk* Vdm lpv`lj vdav vdm kl}jvx da{ kdl{mj vdxl}ed _xm{`fmjv Lhaba `{ vlu`vdfxau 1?'??? vd`{ max agg {}xem nlxkm{ eljm h [mpvmbhmx* @{ `v na`x vl {a' Emjmxag Aggmj' vdavua{ jlv ljm ln vdm lpv`lj{ pxm{mjvmf vl vdm pxm{`fmjv h Emjmxag _mvxam}{


11/47

11

[m~mxag Ua{' Vdm Axm Av Lff{ U`vd Vdm [vxavme Aflpvmf H JAVL' Ud`kd A`b{ Vl V}xj L~mxVdm Uax Vl Vdm Anedaj Axb H Vdm Mjf Ln 8?16*$Mf`vlxàg' Vdm _xm{`fmjv Ba Hm [ahlvae`je D`{ Luj Anedaj`{vaj[vxavme'Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v' >,88,11)

Lhaba{ _gaj @{ Ha{mf Lj Udav @{ _lg`v`kagg Akkmpvahgm* H agg akkl}jv{' Lhaba appmax{blxm klbnlxvahgm u`vd a b`g`vax {vxavme vdav xmg`m{ dma~`g lj fxljm a`xkxanv {vxìm{ `jjmèdhlx`je _ai`{vaj ajf jèdvg xa`f{ h {pmkàg lpmxav`lj{ nlxkm{ aea`j{v Anedaj b`g`vajv{' ud`gmvx`bb`je vdm Abmx`kaj b`g`vax pxm{mjkm ajf h}femv vl plg`v`kagg akkmpvahgm gm~mg{* $Fa~`f [* Kgl}f'_mjvaelj Vl Fxa{v`kagg K}v [pmjf`je Lj Anedaj Nlxkm{'Gl{ Ajemgm{ V`bm{' 4,18,11)

Vdm 8?11 Ajf 8?18 Vxllp Xmf}kv`lj{ Lkk}x Udmj ^`lgmjkm @j Anedaj`{vaj @{ Av @v{ _mai*Hlvd vdm8?11 ajf 8?18 v`bmnxabm{ nlx vxllp xmf}kv`lj{ kl`jk`fm u`vd vdm nèdv`je {ma{lj `j Anedaj`{vaj* Vxllp{u`gg hme`j gma~`je Anedaj`{vaj jmtv bljvd a{ ~`lgmjkm `j vdav kl}jvx `{ av `v{ ulx{v `j j`jm max{ ajf vdmVag`haj xma{{mxv{ `v{mgn `j vmxx`vlx`m{ ]*[* nlxkm{ da~m ahajfljmf* $Adbaf Bac`fax' Lhaba Na`g{ vl Gmaxj Nxlb D`{ B`{vaim@j Anedaj`{vaj'NLT Jmu{' >,8;,11)

Lhaba{ U`vdfxauag V`bmvahgm @jkxma{m{ Vdm X`{i Ln Na`g}xm* H}v Bx* Lhaba{ u`vdfxauafmk`{`lj' u`vd jl kgmax ha{`{ `j {vxavme' `jkxma{m{ vdm x`{i ln na`g}xm* $Mf`vlxàg' Vdm _xm{`fmjv Ba Hm[ahlvae`je D`{ Luj Anedaj`{vaj [vxavme'Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v' >,88,11)

B`g`vax Klbbajfmx{ F`{aexmm U`vd Lhaba{ Exaf}ag _akm Ln Vxllp U`vdfxauag Ajf Da~m@jf`kavmf Vdav Vdm Ul}gf _xmnmx Vdav Agg >4'??? Vxllp{ Xmba`j Vdxl}ed Bl{v Ln 8?1; Nlx Aj

Aff`v`ljag [}bbmx Ln Nèdv`je*F}x`je a jmu{ kljnmxmjkm ga{v ummi' _xm{`fmjv Lhaba kaggmf nlx aexaf}ag pakm vdav flm{jv xm{}gv `j a {vmmp kg`nn av vdm mjf ln 8?16* Aggmj ajf lvdmx klbbajfmx{ da~m`jf`kavmf vdav vdm ul}gf pxmnmx vdav agg >4'??? vxllp{ xmba`j vdxl}ed bl{v ln 8?1; nlx aj aff`v`ljag{}bbmx ln nèdv`je* Afb`j`{vxav`lj kx`v`k{' jkg}f`je vdm gmaf`je Xmp}hg`kaj pxm{`fmjvàg kljvmjfmx{'da~m akk}{mf Lhaba ln }jfmxb`j`je vdm uax mnnlxv h {èjag`je u`vdfxauag pgaj{ av agg' ln nlgglu`je vdmplg`v`kag u`jf{ `j dmaf`je nlx aj maxg mt`v' ajf ln jlv g`{vmj`je vl vdm af~`km ln b`g`vax klbbajfmx{*$Iaxmj FmPl}je' ]*[* Emjmxag [}eem{v{ Anedaj Nlxkm [dl}gf [va Gm~mg Anvmx 18 Fxaufluj'Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v' ;,8?,18)

Fmnmj{m [mkxmvax Gmlj _ajmvva [mm{ G`vvgm [èj Vdav Vdm Vag`haj U`gg Hm Fmk`{`~mg FmnmavmfAjf Kagg{ 8?1; A Kx`v`kag Pmax Nlx Vxaj{`v`lj*_ajmvva kaggmf 8?1; a kx`v`kag max nlx vdm Anedaj`{vajb`{{`lj vdav da{ fxaeemf lj nlx blxm vdaj a fmkafm u`vd g`vvgm {èj vdav vdm Vag`haj u`gg hm fmk`{`~mg

fmnmavmf* Dm jlvmf vdav JAVL ajf vdm Anedaj el~mxjbmjv `jvmjf vl hme`j a n`jag pda{m ln vxaj{`v`lj`je{mkv`lj{ ln vdm kl}jvx vl Anedaj {mk}x`v kljvxlg `j b`f"8?1;* Dlpmn}gg h vdm b`f vl gavvmx paxv ln8?1; um%gg hm ahgm vl baim a vxaj{`v`lj nxlb a klbhav xlgm vl a vxa`j`je' af~`{m ajf a{{`{v xlgm' dm {a`f*Dm affmf vdav vd`{ flm{j%v bmaj um%xm jlv el`je vl hm klbhav"xmaf' h}v xavdmx vdav vdm ]*[* ajf lvdmx`jvmxjav`ljag nlxkm{ u`gg jl gljemx hm `j vdm nlxbag klbhav xlgm um%xm `j jlu* $Xlhmxv H}xj{' _ajmvva3 ][ Klbhav @jAnedaj`{vaj Vl Mjf Jmtv Pmax'Vdm A{{lkàvmf _xm{{' 8,1,18)
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/hed/2011/06/22/AGngaTgH_story.html?wprss=rss_opinionshttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/hed/2011/06/22/AGngaTgH_story.html?wprss=rss_opinionshttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/hed/2011/06/22/AGngaTgH_story.html?wprss=rss_opinionshttp://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-us-afghan-police-20110913,0,1529261.storyhttp://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-us-afghan-police-20110913,0,1529261.storyhttp://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-us-afghan-police-20110913,0,1529261.storyhttp://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2011/06/23/obama-fails-to-learn-from-his-mistakes-in-afghanistan/http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2011/06/23/obama-fails-to-learn-from-his-mistakes-in-afghanistan/http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2011/06/23/obama-fails-to-learn-from-his-mistakes-in-afghanistan/http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/hed/2011/06/22/AGngaTgH_story.html?wprss=rss_opinionshttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/hed/2011/06/22/AGngaTgH_story.html?wprss=rss_opinionshttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/hed/2011/06/22/AGngaTgH_story.html?wprss=rss_opinionshttp://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/gen-allen-says-afghan-war-on-track-despite-violence-setbacks/2012/03/20/gIQA1vfPPS_story.html?wprss=rss_homepagehttp://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/gen-allen-says-afghan-war-on-track-despite-violence-setbacks/2012/03/20/gIQA1vfPPS_story.html?wprss=rss_homepagehttp://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/gen-allen-says-afghan-war-on-track-despite-violence-setbacks/2012/03/20/gIQA1vfPPS_story.html?wprss=rss_homepagehttp://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/E/EU_PANETTA_AFGHANISTAN?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2012-02-01-14-04-23http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/E/EU_PANETTA_AFGHANISTAN?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2012-02-01-14-04-23http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/E/EU_PANETTA_AFGHANISTAN?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2012-02-01-14-04-23http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/E/EU_PANETTA_AFGHANISTAN?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2012-02-01-14-04-23http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/gen-allen-says-afghan-war-on-track-despite-violence-setbacks/2012/03/20/gIQA1vfPPS_story.html?wprss=rss_homepagehttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/hed/2011/06/22/AGngaTgH_story.html?wprss=rss_opinionshttp://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2011/06/23/obama-fails-to-learn-from-his-mistakes-in-afghanistan/http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-us-afghan-police-20110913,0,1529261.storyhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/hed/2011/06/22/AGngaTgH_story.html?wprss=rss_opinions


12/47

18

@@@* GMAF@JE NXLB HMD@JF3 VDM AXAH [_X@JE

Lhaba @ejlxmf _xlvm{v{ @j V}j`{à

F}x`je Vdm V}j`{àj _xlvm{v{' Vdm Ljg Lnn`kàg [vavmbmjv Nxlb _xm{`fmjv LhabaKabm Anvmx Hmj Ag` Daf Hmmj L}{vmf*Bmajud`gm' [mkxmvax ln [vavm D`ggax Kg`jvlj' udl ua{ lj avl}x ln E}gn kl}jvx`m{' gmkv}xmf Axah {vavm{ ahl}v vdm jmmf nlx fmblkxav`k xmnlxb{ h}v {kx}p}gl}{gxmnxa`jmf nxlb bmjv`lj`je vdm V}j`{àj pxlvm{v{* Vdm ljg lnn`kàg {vavmbmjv nxlb _xm{`fmjv Lhaba kabm

anvmx Hmj Ag` daf hmmj l}{vmf* $Ga`ga Gagaj`' V}j`{à X`{`je'Vdm Jav`lj' 1,8?,11)

[mkxmvax Ln [vavm D`ggax Kg`jvlj Xmnxa`jmf Nxlb Bmjv`lj`je Vdm _xlvm{v{ @j V}j`{à Ud`gmVl}x`je Vdm B`ffgm Ma{v Vl _xlblvm Fmblkxav`k Xmnlxb{* Bmajud`gm' [mkxmvax ln [vavmD`ggax Kg`jvlj' udl ua{ lj a vl}x ln E}gn kl}jvx`m{' gmkv}xmf Axah {vavm{ ahl}v vdm jmmf nlxfmblkxav`k xmnlxb{ h}v {kx}p}gl}{g xmnxa`jmf nxlb bmjv`lj`je vdm V}j`{àj pxlvm{v{* $Ga`ga Gagaj`'V}j`{à X`{`je'Vdm Jav`lj' 1,8?,11)

Lhaba [}ppg`mf Jl A{{`{vajkm @j Vdm N`x{v [`tv Fa{ Anvmx Vdm V}j`{àj F`kvavlx Nmgg Ajf F`fJlv _xl~`fm [}nn`k`mjv Xm{l}xkm{ Vl Vdm ]*[* Mbha{{ @j Vdm Kl}jvx* [l nax' vdm Um{v da{ hmmj{glu vl xm{pljf' ajf vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ da{ pxl~`fmf jlvd`je* Vdm ]*[* el~mxjbmjv da{ {l nax jmegmkvmf vlkljvx`h}vm bavmxàg a{{`{vajkm vl vdm va{i ln fmblkxav`sav`lj `j V}j`{à' aff`je vl }jkmxva`jv ahl}v

Abmx`kaj `jvmjv `j vdm kl}jvxVdm ]*[* Aemjk nlx @jvmxjav`ljag Fm~mglpbmjv $][A@F) da{ hmmjm{pmkàgg {glu lnn vdm baxi* Fm{p`vm klj~mj`je a bmmv`je vl f`{k}{{ mbmxemjk px`lx`v`m{ `j maxgCaj}ax' jl mbmxemjk a`f da{ mv xmakdmf V}j`{* A j}bhmx ln Abmx`kaj jljel~mxjbmjvag lxeaj`sav`lj{lj vdm exl}jf `j V}j`{ vlgf bm vdav vdm%~m jlu hmmj `jnlxbmf vdm ba jlv emv ajvd`je av agg `j8?11Vdm ]*[* Mbha{{ `j V}j`{ ua{ {vannmf vl bajaem a {gmmp xmgav`lj{d`p u`vd a f`kvavlx "" `v `{ vll{bagg vl dajfgm vdm fmbajf{ ln a kl}jvx `j vdm b`f{v ln xaf`kag kdajem* Nlx mtabpgm' vdm mjv`xm plg`v`kag{mkv`lj klbpx`{m{ ljg a dajfn}g ln pmlpgm* Jmaxg `jkm{{ajv `jnlxbav`lj xmq}m{v{ nxlb Ua{d`jevlj' a{umgg a{ pxmpaxav`lj{ nlx dèd"gm~mg ~`{`v{' pxmkg}fm vdm {bagg {vann nxlb akv`~mg bapp`je udl%{ udl `j vdmjmu V}j`{à ajf h}`gf`je xmgav`lj{d`p{ u`vd vdl{m pmlpgm* H}v vdmxm `{ jl {èj vdav vdm [vavm Fmpaxvbmjv`{ pgajj`je vl aff {vann lx xm{l}xkm{' fm{p`vm aj }xemjv jmmf* $C* [klvv Kaxpmjvmx' Dmgp V}j`{à N`x{v'Nlxmèj _lg`kp' 8,86,11)

Lhaba Xmn}{mf Vl Gmaf @j G`haVdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v3Ljkm Aea`j' Aj Axah F`kvavlx @{ Mbpgl`je Kx`b`jag ^`lgmjkm @j AFm{pmxavm Mnnlxv Vl Xmba`j @j _lumx " Ajf Ljkm Aea`j' Vdm Lhaba Afb`j`{vxav`lj Da{ Hmmj [gluVl N`jf @v{ ^l`km*$Mf`vlxàg' Ud Ua{ _xm{`fmjv Lhaba Ga{v Vl [pmai ]p Lj G`ha


13/47

1;

{ga}edvmx `v da{ ka}{mf* Vdm M}xlpmaj ]j`lj da{ aexmmf `j px`jk`pgm vl `bpl{m {ajkv`lj{' ajf vdmAxah Gmae}m da{ {a`f G`ha u`gg hm mtkg}fmf nxlb `v{ bmmv`je{* Hx`v`{d _x`bm B`j`{vmx Fa~`fKabmxlj' Emxbaj Kdajkmgglx Ajemga Bmximg ajf @vagàj _x`bm B`j`{vmx [`g~`l Hmxg}{klj` aggkljfmbjmf vdm xme`bm%{ ~`lgmjkm* [a`f Nxmjkd _xm{`fmjv J`klga{ [axils3 Vdm kljv`j}`je hx}vagajf hgllf kxakifluj aea`j{v vdm G`haj k`~`gàj plp}gav`lj `{ xm~lgv`je* Vdm `jvmxjav`ljagklbb}j`v kajjlv xmba`j a {pmkvavlx vl vdm{m ba{{`~m ~`lgav`lj{ ln d}baj xèdv{* H gavmUmfjm{fa ljg ljm baclx Um{vmxj gmafmx daf na`gmf vl {pmai }p lj G`ha3 Haxaki Lhaba*$Mf`vlxàg' Ud Ua{ _xm{`fmjv Lhaba Ga{v Vl [pmai ]p Lj G`ha


14/47

16

vl jlxbag`s`je vdm xmgav`lj{d`p u`vd @{xamg* Ajf @ vd`ji vdav `v ul}gf hm " @ ul}gf jlv xmnmx vl d`ba{ a f`kvavlx* $_H[Jmu{Dl}x'1,85,11)

Lhaba B`{{mf Vdm Lpplxv}j`v Vl [}pplxv K`~`g [lk`mv@j Mepv Anvmx B}haxai{ L}{vmx*Vdm]j`vmf [vavm{ da{ h}`gv `v{ xmgav`lj{d`p u`vd Mepv axl}jf vdm Axb' ud`kd `v da{ {}pplxvmf u`vd blxmvdaj &;0 h`gg`lj `j b`g`vax a`f l~mx vdm ga{v vdxmm fmkafm{* Mepv{ max"lgf' pxl"fmblkxak xm~lg}v`ljea~m Ua{d`jevlj a kdajkm ajf a xma{lj vl agvmx vdav xmgav`lj{d`p vl {}pplxv k`~`g {lk`mv* VdmLhaba afb`j`{vxav`lj bafm a {mx`l}{ mxxlx `j kdll{`je jlv vl fl {l* M~mj ulx{m' vdm p}xpl{m ua{

gaxemg vl pxlvmkv Abmx`kaj axb{ baj}nakv}xmx{ udl pxlf}km vdm umaplj{ {mjv vl Mepv* $Mf`vlxàg' Mjahg`jeMepv{ B`g`vax X}gmx{' Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' ;,8>,18)

Fm{p`vm M~`fmjkm Vdav Vdm B`g`vax"Gmf El~mxjbmjv Ua{ Haki{g`f`je Lj Klbb`vbmjv{ @vBafm Vl Fmblkxav`k El~mxjajkm Ajf X}gm Ln Gau'Vdm Lhaba Afb`j`{vxav`lj Fmk`fmf VlUa`~m Fmblkxak Xmq}`xmbmjv{ Ajf Agglu Mepv Vl Xmkm`~m &1*; H`gg`lj Ln B`g`vax A`fVdm Lhaba afb`j`{vxav`lj da{ ua`~mf fmblkxak xmq}`xmbmjv{ vl xmgma{m }p vl &1*= h`gg`lj `ja`f vl Mepv fm{p`vm kljkmxj{ vdav vdm kl}jvx `{ haki{g`f`je lj klbb`vbmjv{ `v bafm vlfmblkxav`k el~mxjajkm ajf x}gm ln gau' kljexm{{`ljag {l}xkm{ {a`f Vd}x{fa* [mkxmvax ln [vavmD`ggax Xlfdab Kg`jvlj fmvmxb`jmf vdav `v ua{ `j vdm ]*[* jav`ljag `jvmxm{v vl agglu &1*; h`gg`lj `jb`g`vax a{{`{vajkm vl nglu' vdm {a`f* [dm ag{l kmxv`n`mf vdav Mepv `{ bmmv`je `v{ lhgèav`lj{ vl vdm@{xamg`"Mepvàj pmakm vxmav' ud`kd nxmm{ }p aj aff`v`ljag &8?? b`gg`lj `j mkljlb`k a`f' vdm

{a`f*$Fljja Ka{{ava' ][ LI{ Mepv A`f Fm{p`vm Kljexm{{`ljag Kljkmxj{'Vdm A{{lkàvmf _xm{{' ;,88,18)

Vdm Mepvàj _}hg`k Nmmg{ Hmvxamf H Vdm Lhaba Afb`j`{vxav`lj{ [glu Xm{plj{m Vl VdmXm~lg}v`lj*Dab`f kaggmf Mepv q}`vm pl{{`hg vdm bl{v ajv`"Abmx`kaj kl}jvx `j vdm Axah ulxgf*Vdmxm `{ agxmaf xm{mjvbmjv c}{v hmglu vdm {}xnakm xmaf vl klbm l}v' dm {a{* @ ijlu pmlpgm `j vdm ]*[*vd`ji vdav Lhaba {`fmf u`vd vdm Mepvàj xm~lg}v`lj' h}v `j Mepv' vdav `{ jlv vdm jaxxav`~m l} dmax*Vdmxm `{ a {mj{m vdav vdm ]*[* ua{ gavm vl vdm eabm ajf {vllf u`vd Ynlxbmx _xm{`fmjv Dl{j`R B}haxai }jv`gvdm ~mx mjf* $[klvv Jm}baj' Aj Agg Lx Jlv< Vdm Ud`vm Dl}{m [mmi{ Vl J}ajkm Lhaba%{ Xmbaxi{ Lj Mepv'J_X' 0,16,18)

Lhaba{ Kaxmn}g Appxlakd Vl Vdm Mepvàj Xm~lg}v`lj _gma{mf Jl Ljm*Lhaba{ kaxmn}gappxlakd pgma{mf jl ljm* Vl Mepvàj{ `j Vadx`x [q}axm' `v ua{ u`{d"ua{d* Ljm akv`~`{v @ {plim

u`vd gavmx hagimf av vdm jlv`lj vdav vdm ][ el~mxjbmjv daf hmmj {}pplxv`~m' ajf a{{mxvmf' Um elvjl {lg`fax`v u`vd Lhaba* Vl lvdmx gmafmx{ `j vdm xme`lj' dlum~mx' Lhaba{ fmk`{`lj vl pxm{{}xmB}haxai av agg ua{ a {èj ln umaijm{{' ajf pmxdap{ a vxl}hg`je `jf`kav`lj vdav vdm pxm{`fmjvul}gf u`gg`jeg ahajflj a gljev`bm agg* $Fa~`f M* [ajemx' Kljnxljv AjfKljkmag' 8?18' p* 80;)

Lhaba Ua{ [mmj H Pl}je Mepvàj{ A{ A Na`x"Umavdmx Nx`mjf Udl Kl}gf Jlv HmVx}{vmf*Pmv vdm bm{{aem vdav vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ kdl{m vl hm lj vdm {`fm ln vdm pxlvm{vlx{ ua{ jlvkgmaxg klj~mmf' paxv`k}gaxg `j Mepv* @j Ka`xl `j vdm fa{ gmaf`je }p vl vdm n`x{v ajj`~mx{ax lnvdm }px`{`je' baj l}je Mepvàj{ vlgf bm vdav Lhaba ua{ a na`x"umavdmx nx`mjf udl f`f jlvfmkgaxm kgmaxg mjl}ed vdav B}haxai daf vl el* Lhaba kdajemf d`{ fmk`{`lj{' ljm akv`~`{v vlgfbm* Ljkm dm ijmu vdm xm~lg}v`lj ul}gf u`j' dm {`fmf u`vd vdm xm~lg}v`lj* @ fljv vx}{v a baj gìmvdav* $Fa~`f M* [ajemx' Kljnxljv AjfKljkmag' 8?18' p* ;?8"?;)
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics/jan-june11/biden_01-27.htmlhttp://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics/jan-june11/biden_01-27.htmlhttp://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics/jan-june11/biden_01-27.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/27/opinion/enabling-egypts-military-rulers.html?_r=1&partner=rss&emc=rsshttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/27/opinion/enabling-egypts-military-rulers.html?_r=1&partner=rss&emc=rsshttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/27/opinion/enabling-egypts-military-rulers.html?_r=1&partner=rss&emc=rsshttp://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5iWDvQOubqu1nbmVYyWqKUFKuGaog?docId=1d6bb59ff4ad42e9a49b8023eb8ffd2dhttp://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5iWDvQOubqu1nbmVYyWqKUFKuGaog?docId=1d6bb59ff4ad42e9a49b8023eb8ffd2dhttp://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5iWDvQOubqu1nbmVYyWqKUFKuGaog?docId=1d6bb59ff4ad42e9a49b8023eb8ffd2dhttp://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2012/09/14/161136169/an-ally-or-not-the-white-house-seeks-to-nuance-obamas-remarks-on-egypthttp://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2012/09/14/161136169/an-ally-or-not-the-white-house-seeks-to-nuance-obamas-remarks-on-egypthttp://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2012/09/14/161136169/an-ally-or-not-the-white-house-seeks-to-nuance-obamas-remarks-on-egypthttp://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2012/09/14/161136169/an-ally-or-not-the-white-house-seeks-to-nuance-obamas-remarks-on-egypthttp://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5iWDvQOubqu1nbmVYyWqKUFKuGaog?docId=1d6bb59ff4ad42e9a49b8023eb8ffd2dhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/27/opinion/enabling-egypts-military-rulers.html?_r=1&partner=rss&emc=rsshttp://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics/jan-june11/biden_01-27.html


15/47

1=

@^* GMAF@JE NXLB HMD@JF3 KD@JA

Lhaba{ _`~lv Vl A{à Da{ [vaggmf

Lhaba{ _`~lv Vl Kd`ja{ Jmèdhlxdllf Da{ _xlf}kmf G`b`vmf Xm{}gv{*_xm{`fmjv HaxakiLhaba{ p`~lv vl Kd`ja{ jmèdhlxdllf ajf vdm xm{mv `j xmgav`lj{ u`vd X}{{à da~m pxlf}kmf g`b`vmfxm{}gv{ nlx {èjav}xm nlxmèj plg`k `j`vàv`~m{ fm{èjmf vl `bpxl~mf Abmx`ka{ {vajf`je u`vd `v{ nlxbmxKlgf Uax x`~ag{* $G`b`vmf [}kkm{{ Nlx Lhaba{ X}{{à' Kd`ja Appxlakd'Vdm A{{lkàvmf _xm{{' 6,84,18)

@j Xm{plj{m Vl Lhaba{ [lnv Appxlakd' Kd`ja [p}xjmf Vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ Lj Kg`bavm Kdajem[vajfaxf{' Fxaeemf @v{ Nmmv Lj Mnnlxv{ Vl _xm{{}xm @xaj Ajf Hmeaj H}gg`je @v{ Jmèdhlx{ L~mxVmxx`vlxàg Kga`b{ @j Vdm [l}vd Kd`ja [ma*Bx* Lhaba{ v}xj vl A{à ua{ jlv pxmk`{mg udav dm daf `jb`jf udmj dm mjvmxmf lnn`km* Vdm {d`nv mbmxemf `j n`v{ ajf {vaxv{' anvmx a n`x{v max `j ud`kd kx`v`k{'`jkg}f`je vdm pxm{`fmjv{ a`fm{' kljkg}fmf vdav vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ daf hmmj vll {lnv lj Kd`ja* @j`jvmx~`mu{' a flsmj k}xxmjv ajf nlxbmx afb`j`{vxav`lj lnn`kàg{ fm{kx`hmf a Ud`vm Dl}{m vdav {vx}eegmf vln`jf vdm xèdv vljm u`vd Hm`c`je* Nxlb d`{ fmk`{`lj jlv vl bmmv u`vd vdm Faga` Gaba `j 8??0 vl d`{ vèdvgklj{vxa`jmf n`x{v vx`p vl Kd`ja' vdm pxm{`fmjv akklbblfavmf Kd`jm{m gmafmx{ `j vdm dlpm{ vdav vdm bl~m{ul}gf vxaj{gavm `jvl ellf u`gg lj `{{}m{ gìm kg`bavm kdajem lx @xaj{ j}kgmax pxlexab* Vdm f`f jlv*Kd`ja {p}xjmf vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ lj kg`bavm kdajem {vajfaxf{' fxaeemf `v{ nmmv lj mnnlxv{ vl pxm{{}xm @xaj

ajf hmeaj h}gg`je `v{ jmèdhlx{ l~mx vmxx`vlxàg kga`b{ `j vdm [l}vd Kd`ja [ma* Vdav ga{v fm~mglpbmjv' `jpaxv`k}gax' pmx{}afmf vdm afb`j`{vxav`lj vdav vdm v`bm nlx akklbblfav`lj daf klbm vl aj mjf* $BaxiGajfgmx' Lhaba{ Cl}xjm Vl Vl}edmx Vaki Lj A X`{`je Kd`ja'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' 0,8?,18)

Ud`vm Dl}{m Lnn`kàg{ Afb`v Vdav Lhaba{ N`x{v Vx`p Vl Kd`ja Ea~m Vdm Appmaxajkm Ln ANa{v"X`{`je _lumx Vdm Dlgfmx Ln &1 Vx`gg`lj @j Abmx`kaj Fmhv _}{d`je Haki Lj AHmgmae}mxmf ]j`vmf [vavm{*Vdm lpv`k{ f`f jlv `bpxl~m lj Bx* Lhaba{ vx`p' ud`kd vdm Kd`jm{m{vaem"bajaemf' agglu`je jl q}m{v`lj{ anvmx a cl`jv jmu{ kljnmxmjkm u`vd Bx* D}* Ud`vm Dl}{mlnn`kàg{ {a`f vdm vx`p ua{ blxm {}kkm{{n}g vdaj vdm jmu{ kl~mxaem {}eem{vmf' h}v vdm fl jlvf`{p}vm vdav vdm ga{v`je `bpxm{{`lj ua{ ln a na{v"x`{`je plumx vdm dlgfmx ln &1 vx`gg`lj `jAbmx`kaj fmhvp}{d`je haki lj a hmgmae}mxmf ]j`vmf [vavm{* $Baxi Gajfgmx' Lhaba{ Cl}xjm Vl Vl}edmx VakiLj A X`{`je Kd`ja'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' 0,8?,18)

M~mj [lbm Ln Bx* Lhaba{ Luj K}xxmjv Ajf Nlxbmx A`fm{ Akijlugmfem Vdav Bx* LhabaUmjv Vll Nax Vl Akklbblfavm Kd`ja{ Gmafmx{ F}x`je D`{ N`x{v Pmax @j Lnn`km*M~mj {lbmln Bx* Lhaba{ luj k}xxmjv ajf nlxbmx a`fm{ akijlugmfem vdav Bx* Lhaba umjv vll nax vlakklbblfavm Kd`ja{ gmafmx{ f}x`je d`{ n`x{v max `j lnn`km* Vdm Ud`vm Dl}{m daxfmjmf `v{appxlakd anvmx vdm Kd`jm{m ea~m vdm klgf {dl}gfmx vl vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ lj `{{}m{ xaje`je nxlbkg`bavm kdajem vl @xaj{ j}kgmax pxlexab* $[daxlj GaNxaj`mxm' Kd`ja Ajf @v{ Vxafm _xakv`km{ Axm Klb`je Vl Vdm Fmhavm{'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' 1?,1=,18)

Vlp B`g`vax Lnn`kàg @j A{à"_ak`n`k [a{ Kd`ja @{ Exlu`je Hlgfmx Ajf Kljv`j}m{ Vl KdaggmjemVdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ Ajf L}x _axvjmx{ @j Vdm Xme`lj @j Vdm Bax`v`bm' Khmx' Ajf [pakm Flba`j{*Ga{v max' Hm`c`je {a`f `v ul}gf `jkxma{m b`g`vax {pmjf`je vl >?1*1 h`gg`lj }aj $&0=*6; h`gg`lj) `j 8?11'

a 18*5 pmxkmjv x`{m lj vdm pxm~`l}{ max' xm{}b`je fl}hgm"fè`v exluvd anvmx a f`p vl 5*= pmxkmjv exluvd`j 8?1?* Kd`ja `{ exlu`je hlgfmx u`vd xmeaxf vl vdm`x mtpajfmf xme`ljag ajf eglhag pxm{mjkm' ajf Kd`jakljv`j}m{ vl kdaggmjem vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ ajf l}x paxvjmx{ `j vdm xme`lj `j vdm bax`v`bm' khmx ajf {pakmflba`j{' {a`f U`ggaxf* Dm xmpmavmf a glje"{vajf`je _mjvaelj gabmjv vdav ]*[*"Kd`ja b`g`vax"vl"b`g`vaxxmgav`lj{ axm jlv udmxm um uajv vdmb vl hm' fm{p`vm dèd"gm~mg pgmfem{ vl fmmpmj vdl{m v`m{* $_a}g Mkimxv'Kd`ja{ B`g`vax H}`gf"]p [mmj @jfmpmjfmjv Ln ]*[* Bl~m{' Xm}vmx{' 8,84,18)

Kd`ja Ba Da~m Hxlimj A [mk}x`v Kl}jk`g Xm{lg}v`lj H _xl~`f`je 1>"Udmmg B`{{`gm"Ga}jkd`je ^md`kgm{ Vl Jlxvd Ilxma*[lbm ajag{v{ {a`f lj V}m{fa vdav Kd`ja ba da~m
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-501708_162-57423641/limited-success-for-obamas-russia-china-approach/http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-501708_162-57423641/limited-success-for-obamas-russia-china-approach/http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-501708_162-57423641/limited-success-for-obamas-russia-china-approach/http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/21/us/politics/obamas-evolution-to-a-tougher-line-on-china.html?hphttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/21/us/politics/obamas-evolution-to-a-tougher-line-on-china.html?hphttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/21/us/politics/obamas-evolution-to-a-tougher-line-on-china.html?hphttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/21/us/politics/obamas-evolution-to-a-tougher-line-on-china.html?hphttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/21/us/politics/obamas-evolution-to-a-tougher-line-on-china.html?hphttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/21/us/politics/obamas-evolution-to-a-tougher-line-on-china.html?hphttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/16/us/politics/china-and-its-trade-tactics-are-coming-to-the-debates.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/16/us/politics/china-and-its-trade-tactics-are-coming-to-the-debates.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/28/us-usa-china-military-idUSTRE81R25N20120228?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+reuters%2FworldNews+%28News+%2F+US+%2F+International%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/28/us-usa-china-military-idUSTRE81R25N20120228?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+reuters%2FworldNews+%28News+%2F+US+%2F+International%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/28/us-usa-china-military-idUSTRE81R25N20120228?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+reuters%2FworldNews+%28News+%2F+US+%2F+International%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/28/us-usa-china-military-idUSTRE81R25N20120228?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+reuters%2FworldNews+%28News+%2F+US+%2F+International%29http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/16/us/politics/china-and-its-trade-tactics-are-coming-to-the-debates.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/21/us/politics/obamas-evolution-to-a-tougher-line-on-china.html?hphttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/21/us/politics/obamas-evolution-to-a-tougher-line-on-china.html?hphttp://www.cbsnews.com/8301-501708_162-57423641/limited-success-for-obamas-russia-china-approach/


16/47

1>

hxlimj a [mk}x`v Kl}jk`g xm{lg}v`lj h pxl~`f`je 1>"udmmg b`{{`gm"ga}jkd`je ~md`kgm{ vdav umxm{mmj `j a b`g`vax paxafm `j _ljeaje' vdm Jlxvd{ kap`vag' lj [}jfa kaxx`je a jmu vpm lnb`{{`gm* Vmf _ax{lj{ ln @D[ Cajm{ Fmnmj{m Ummig pl`jvmf l}v {`b`gax`v`m{ vl a ijluj Kd`jm{m~md`kgm3 Vdm {abm u`jf{kxmmj fm{èj' vdm {abm nl}x u`jf{kxmmj u`pmx kljnè}xav`lj' vdm {abmfllx ajf dajfgm fm{èj' a ~mx {`b`gax ex`gg axma* Agbl{v vdm {abm nxljv h}bpmx gèdv`jekljnè}xav`lj' ajf vdm {abm fm{èj nlx vdm kah`j {vmp{* Dm affmf vdav vdm `j~lg~mbmjv ln aKd`jm{m ~md`kgm h}`gfmx `j Jlxvd Ilxma{ b`{{`gm pxlexab ul}gf xmq}`xm appxl~ag nxlb vdmdèdm{v gm~mg{ ln vdm Kd`jm{m el~mxjbmjv ajf vdm _mlpgm{ G`hmxav`lj Axb* $Kdlm [aje"D}j' Jlxvd Ilxma[a{ @v U`gg Ahajflj Fmag U`vd ]*[*'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' 6,15,18)

Kd`ja Da{ Ba`jva`jmf Uaxb Xmgav`lj{ U`vd Jlxvd Ilxma Fm{p`vm El`je Aglje U`vd ]*J*Xmh}im Ln @v{ B`{{`gm Ga}jkd*Vdl}ed Kd`ja cl`jmf `j vdm ]j`vmf Jav`lj{ xmh}im ln JlxvdIlxma anvmx `v{ b`{{`gm ga}jkd`je' _xm{`fmjv D} C`jval gavmx umgklbmf a vlp lnn`kàg ln vdm x}g`jeUlximx{ _axv vl Hm`c`je' ud`gm ajlvdmx {mj`lx Kd`jm{m lnn`kàg da`gmf vdm xmgav`lj{d`p hmvummjHm`c`je ajf _ljeaje a{ a pxmk`l}{ emb*$Baxi Gajfgmx ajf [vm~mj Gmm Bmx{' ]*[* [mm{ _l{`v`~m [èj{ Nxlb Kd`ja Lj[mk}x`v @{{}m{'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' 6,8>,18)

Kd`ja Kljv`j}m{ Vl A{{mxv @v{ Kga`b Vl Vdm [l}vd Kd`ja [ma A{ @v{ [l~mxmèj Vmxx`vlx* Kd`ja `{glkimf `j a {mx`m{ ln l~mxgapp`je vmxx`vlxàg f`{p}vm{ u`vd vdm _d`g`pp`jm{' ^`mvjab' Baga{à' Vaùaj ajfHx}jm`' udl kga`b m`vdmx agg lx paxv ln vdm [l}vd Kd`ja [ma a{ vdm`x {l~mxmèj vmxx`vlx* Vdm f`{p}vm da{

ngaxmf `j xmkmjv bljvd{ a{ vdm xme`lj{ plvmjvàg mjmxe xm{mx~m{ hme`j vl fxau exlu`je avvmjv`lj* L~mxvdm pa{v max' ^`mvjab ajf vdm _d`g`pp`jm{ da~m akk}{mf Kd`jm{m ja~ kxanv ln daxa{{`je l`g"mtpglxav`lj~m{{mg{ lpmxav`je `j vdm`x ]j`vmf Jav`lj{"fmn`jmf bax`v`bm mkljlb`k sljm{* Hm`c`je da{ fmj`mf vdav' h}vda{ uaxjmf ^`mvjab ajf vdm _d`g`pp`jm{ nxlb pxl{pmkv`je `j vdm axma u`vdl}v `v{ pmxb`{{`lj* $Cabm{Dlliua' _d`g`pp`jm Uax{d`p @j [vajflnn U`vd Kd`ja m{{mg{'Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' 6,11,18)

Xlhmxv Xlb}gl' Nlxbmx Nlxmèj [mkxmvax Ln Vdm _d`g`pp`jm{' [a`f Kd`ja @{ Mav`jeAbmx`ka{ G}jkd @j [l}vdma{v A{à*Umxm c}{v pauj{' {a`f Xlhmxvl Xlb}gl' a nlxbmx nlxmèj{mkxmvax ln vdm _d`g`pp`jm{ udl axe}m{ vdav Kd`ja `{ ngmt`je `v{ b}{kgm{ `j a h`f vl ea`j }j`bpmfmfakkm{{ vl ~a{v xm{mx~m{ ln jav}xag ea{ ajf l`g hmg`m~mf vl hm h}x`mf }jfmx vdm [l}vd Kd`ja [ma*Kd`ja `{ vm{v`je vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{' vdav{ agg `v `{* Ajf Kd`ja `{ mav`je Abmx`ka{ g}jkd `j [l}vdma{vA{à* $Cajm _mxgms' Hm`c`je Mtd`h`v`je Jmu A{{mxv`~mjm{{ @j [l}vd Kd`ja [ma'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' =,;1,18)

[mj`lx Kd`jm{m Lnn`kàg{ Da~m Uaxjmf Aea`j{v ]*[* Akv`~`v @j Vdm [l}vd Kd`ja [ma' [a`jeVdm [l}vd Kd`ja @{{}m @{ Jlv Abmx`ka{ H}{`jm{{*Blxm xmkmjvg' a {mj`lx Kd`jm{m b`g`vaxlnn`kmx m~mj f`{b`{{mf aj gme`v`bavm xlgm nlx vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ `j vdm [l}vd Kd`ja [ma* Vdm [l}vdKd`ja `{{}m `{ jlv Abmx`ka{ h}{`jm{{' Emj* Ba Tàlvàj' vdm fmp}v kd`mn ln emjmxag {vann ln vdm_mlpgm{ G`hmxav`lj Axb' {a`f `j aj `jvmx~`mu hxlafka{v Bljfa h _dlmj`t V^ `j Dlje Ilje*@v{ hmvummj Kd`ja ajf `v{ jmèdhlx{*$Cajm _mxgms' Hm`c`je Mtd`h`v`je Jmu A{{mxv`~mjm{{ @j [l}vd Kd`ja [ma'Vdm Jmu PlxiV`bm{' =,;1,18)

_xm{`fmjv D} Dl{vmf A Xme`ljag [mk}x`v [}bb`v Ajf H`gavmxag Vagi{ U`vd X}{{àj _xm{`fmjv_}v`j A`bmf Av Kl}jvmx`je ]*[* @jng}mjkm @j Kmjvxag A{à*Vdm vagi{ hmvummj Bx* _}v`j ajf Bx* D}'aglje u`vd vdm vul"fa [dajeda` Kllpmxav`lj Lxeaj`sav`lj {}bb`v bmmv`je' axm nxa}edv u`vd vdm

{bhlg`{b ln vul baclx plumx{ `jvmxm{vmf `j n}xvdmx fm~mglp`je a b}gv`gavmxag lxeaj`sav`lj vdav flm{jlv `jkg}fm vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{' ajf udmxm @xaj pga{ a xlgm' `n ljg a{ lh{mx~mx* @xaj' vll' `{ ~mx immj ljvdm [dajeda` Kllpmxav`lj Lxeaj`sav`lj' {a`f âg` Ja{x' aj @xaj mtpmxv ajf nlxbmx [vavm Fmpaxvbmjvlnn`kàg `j vdm Lhaba afb`j`{vxav`lj* Vdav `v `{ dappmj`je `j Kd`ja xmngmkv{ Kd`ja{ `jkxma{`je `jvmxm{v `jKmjvxag A{à ajf ag{l `v{ fm{`xm vl gmaf `jvmxjav`ljag ajf xme`ljag aggàjkm{ u`vdl}v vdm ]*[* $Cajm _mxgms' _}v`jAxx`~m{ @j Kd`ja ' [mmi`je [vxljemx V`m{'Vdm Jmu Plxi V`bm{' >,=,18)

Kd`ja U`gg H}`gf Vul J}kgmax Xmakvlx{ Av A _ai`{vaj` J}kgmax _lumx _gajv' Fm{p`vm Um{vmxjKljkmxj{ L~mx _ai`{vaj{ D`{vlx Ln [pxmaf`je J}kgmax Axb{ Vmkdjlgle*Um{vmxj {vavm{
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/18/world/asia/north-korea-says-it-will-abandon-deal-with-united-states.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/18/world/asia/north-korea-says-it-will-abandon-deal-with-united-states.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/18/world/asia/north-korea-says-it-will-abandon-deal-with-united-states.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/27/world/asia/us-is-seeing-positive-signs-from-chinese.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/27/world/asia/us-is-seeing-positive-signs-from-chinese.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/27/world/asia/us-is-seeing-positive-signs-from-chinese.html?pagewanted=1http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303815404577336550439399694.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303815404577336550439399694.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303815404577336550439399694.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/06/world/asia/vladimir-putin-in-china-for-regional-summit.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/06/world/asia/vladimir-putin-in-china-for-regional-summit.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/06/world/asia/vladimir-putin-in-china-for-regional-summit.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/06/world/asia/vladimir-putin-in-china-for-regional-summit.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/01/world/asia/beijing-projects-power-in-strategic-south-china-sea.html?pagewanted=1http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303815404577336550439399694.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/27/world/asia/us-is-seeing-positive-signs-from-chinese.html?pagewanted=1http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/18/world/asia/north-korea-says-it-will-abandon-deal-with-united-states.html


17/47

15

pxm{{}xmf Kd`ja av kgl{mf"fllx vagi{ ga{v ummi vl affxm{{ kljkmxj{ ahl}v `v{ pgaj{ vl mtpajf a j}kgmaxplumx pgajv `j _ai`{vaj ajf pxl~`fm blxm `jnlxbav`lj' h}v umxm xmh}nnmf' vul f`pglbav`k {l}xkm{ {a`flj Umfjm{fa* Hm`c`je{ avlb`k xmgav`lj{ u`vd @{gabahaf da~m ka}{mf }jma{m `j Ua{d`jevlj' Fmgd` ajflvdmx kap`vag{ f}m vl _ai`{vaj{ d`{vlx ln {pxmaf`je j}kgmax axb{ vmkdjlgle ajf nmax{ ahl}v vdm`jvmex`v ln `jvmxjav`ljag jlj pxlg`nmxav`lj x}gm{* H}v Kd`ja {dlumf jl {èj ln xmklj{`fmx`je `v{pl{`v`lj lj h}`gf`je vul blxm xmakvlx{ av vdm Kda{dba j}kgmax plumx klbpgmt `j _ai`{vaj{ _}jcahxme`lj' vdm lnn`kàg ajf ajlvdmx {l}xkm {a`f' a {vajkm Hm`c`je ag{l vlli udmj vdm `{{}m ua{ xa`{mf `j ga{vmax{ J[E vagi{ `j vdm F}vkd k`v ln Jllxfu`ci* $Nxmfxì Fadg' Um{v Ulxx`mf H Kd`ja"_ai`{vaj Avlb`k V`m{3 [l}xkm{'Xm}vmx{'>,85,18)

_ai`{vaj Da{ Bl~mf Kgl{mx Vl Kd`ja A{ @v{ Xmgav`lj{d`p U`vd Vdm ]*[* Nagvmx{*A{ `v{ v`m{u`vd vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ da~m {}nnmxmf' _ai`{vaj da{ hmmj vx`je vl bl~m kgl{mx vl A{àjplumxdl}{m Kd`ja' ud`kd da{ umgklbmf @{gabahaf{ l~mxv}xm{*$Nxmfxì Fadg' Um{v Ulxx`mf H Kd`ja"_ai`{vajAvlb`k V`m{3 [l}xkm{'Xm}vmx{' >,85,18)

Khmx Avvaki{ Lj Vdm Abmx`kaj B`g`vax Ajf Fmnmj{m N`xb{ @jkxma{mf @j 8?11' U`vd Jl Xm{plj{mNxlb Lhaba*Khmx avvaki{ lj ]*[* b`g`vax ajf fmnmj{m `jf}{vx klbp}vmx {{vmb{ axm `jkxma{`je' ajfbaj ln vdm avvaki{ axm klb`je nxlb Kd`ja' a ]*[* el~mxjbmjv klbb`{{`lj {a{* Kd`ja da{ xmklej`smfvdm `bplxvajkm ln khmx lpmxav`lj{ a{ a vllg ln uaxnaxm' vdm ]*[*"Kd`ja Mkljlb`k ajf [mk}x`v Xm~`muKlbb`{{`lj {a{ `j a xmplxv xmgma{mf Jl~* 8?*$U`ggàb Bavvdmu{' Kd`jm{m Khmx Avvaki{ Lj X`{m3 ]*[* Xmplxv'Fmnmj{m Jmu{'

11,8?,11) Kd`ja M~mj Avvakimf Vdm Mba`g Akkl}jv{ Ln [mj`lx ]*[* Lnn`kàg{* Ellegm {a`f Umfjm{fa a

dakimx `j Kd`ja lhva`jmf akkm{{ vl d}jfxmf{ ln Eba`g akkl}jv{' `jkg}f`je vdl{m ln {mj`lx ]*[*el~mxjbmjv lnn`kàg{' b`g`vax pmx{ljjmg' Kd`jm{m plg`v`kag akv`~`{v{ ajf cl}xjag`{v{*$Kmk`gà Iaje'Ellegm3 D}jfxmf{ Ln Eba`g Akkl}jv{ Dakimf' @jkg}f`je [lbm [mj`lx ]*[* El~mxjbmjv Lnn`kàg{'Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v' >,1,11)

Kd`jm{m Dakimx{ Axm Mxa{`je Vdm Eglhag Af~ajvaem Nlx Abmx`kaj N`xb{* [mj`lx ]*[* lnn`kàg{ ijluumgg vdav vdm el~mxjbmjv ln Kd`ja `{ {{vmbav`kagg avvaki`je vdm klbp}vmx jmvulxi{ ln vdm ]*[*el~mxjbmjv ajf Abmx`kaj klxplxav`lj{* Hm`c`je `{ {}kkm{{n}gg {vmag`je xm{maxkd ajf fm~mglpbmjv'{lnvuaxm {l}xkm klfm' baj}nakv}x`je ijlu"dlu ajf el~mxjbmjv pgaj{* @j a eglhag klbpmv`v`lj abljeijlugmfem"ha{mf mkljlb`m{' Kd`jm{m khmxlpmxav`lj{ axm mxlf`je Abmx`ka{ af~ajvaem*$X`kdaxf Kgaxim' Lp"MfKd`ja{ Khmxa{{a}gv Lj Abmx`ka'Vdm Uagg [vxmmv Cl}xjag' >,1=,11)

Appxlt`bavmg A Flsmj Kd`jm{m Eaje{ Axm Xm{plj{`hgm Nlx Bl{v Ln Vdm Khmx Vdmnv @j Vdm]*[*' [vmag`je H`gg`lj{ Ln Flggax{ Ln Fava* A{ nmu a{ 18 f`nnmxmjv Kd`jm{m exl}p{' gaxemg hakimflx f`xmkvmf h vdm el~mxjbmjv vdmxm' klbb`v vdm h}gi ln vdm Kd`ja"ha{mf khmxavvaki{ {vmag`jekx`v`kag fava nxlb ]*[* klbpaj`m{ ajf el~mxjbmjv aemjk`m{' akklxf`je vl ]*[* khmx{mk}x`vajag{v{ ajf mtpmxv{*$Glg`va Hagflx' A Nmu Dakimx Vmab{ Fl Bl{v Kd`ja"ha{mf Fava Vdmnv'Vdm A{{lkàvmf _xm{{' 18,18,11)

Lhaba Xm{mx~m{ Vl}ed Vagi Lj Kd`ja{ K}xxmjk Baj`p}gav`lj Nlx Vdm Kabpaèj Vxa`g

_XLB@[M3 @j 8??4' Lhaba [a`f Dm Daf A _xmvv [vxaèdvnlxuaxf _xlpl{`v`lj Nlx Kd`ja' Pl}E}{ Immp Lj Baj`p}gav`je Pl}x K}xxmjk' Um Axm El`je Vl [vaxv [d}vv`je Lnn Akkm{{ Vl [lbm LnL}x Baximv{* LHABA3 Jlu glli' dmxm{ vdm vd`je @ vd`ji pmlpgm fljv }jfmx{vajf* Kd`ja jmmf{ l}x

baximv* Vdm`x mkljlb `{ fmpmjfmjv lj mtplxv{ vl vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ ajf um da~m haxea`j`je plumx* Vdmpxlhgmb vdav um~m elv u`vd Kd`ja `{ jlv vdav um kl}gfjv ulxi l}v a fmag `j ud`kd vdm axm hmjmn`vv`jeajf um axm hmjmn`vv`je* Vdm pxlhgmb `{ vdav vdxl}ed agg vdm vl}ed vagi ln Emlxem U* H}{d' dm `{ a pav{udmj `v klbm{ vl jmelvàv`je vdm{m aexmmbmjv{* Ajf' udav um jmmf vl fl `{ vl c}{v hm hmvvmx haxea`jmx{vdav {a' Glli' dmxm{ vdm hlvvlb g`jm' l} e}{ immp lj baj`p}gav`je l}x k}xxmjk' um axm el`je vl{vaxv {d}vv`je lnn akkm{{ vl {lbm ln l}x baximv{* @n l} axm fl`je vdm xèdv vd`je ajf jlv vx`je vlbaj`p}gavm l}x k}xxmjk vl f`{af~ajvaem }{' vdmj l} u`gg da~m akkm{{* @v{ a pxmvv' pxmvv {vxaèdvnlxuaxf pxlpl{`v`lj*$[mjavlx Haxaki Lhaba' Q.A Av Vdm AAB Nlx}b' _`vv{h}xed' _A' 6,16,?4)
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/27/us-nuclear-china-pakistan-idUSBRE85Q0YL20120627?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Reuters%2FworldNews+%28Reuters+World+News%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/27/us-nuclear-china-pakistan-idUSBRE85Q0YL20120627?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Reuters%2FworldNews+%28Reuters+World+News%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/27/us-nuclear-china-pakistan-idUSBRE85Q0YL20120627?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Reuters%2FworldNews+%28Reuters+World+News%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/27/us-nuclear-china-pakistan-idUSBRE85Q0YL20120627?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Reuters%2FworldNews+%28Reuters+World+News%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/27/us-nuclear-china-pakistan-idUSBRE85Q0YL20120627?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Reuters%2FworldNews+%28Reuters+World+News%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/27/us-nuclear-china-pakistan-idUSBRE85Q0YL20120627?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Reuters%2FworldNews+%28Reuters+World+News%29http://www.defensenews.com/story.php?i=3830559http://www.defensenews.com/story.php?i=3830559http://www.defensenews.com/story.php?i=3830559http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-tech/post/google-hundreds-of-gmail-accounts-hacked-including-some-senior-us-government-officials/2011/06/01/AGgASgGH_blog.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-tech/post/google-hundreds-of-gmail-accounts-hacked-including-some-senior-us-government-officials/2011/06/01/AGgASgGH_blog.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-tech/post/google-hundreds-of-gmail-accounts-hacked-including-some-senior-us-government-officials/2011/06/01/AGgASgGH_blog.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304259304576373391101828876.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304259304576373391101828876.htmlhttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304259304576373391101828876.htmlhttp://www.salon.com/2011/12/12/a_few_hacker_teams_do_most_china_based_data_theft/http://www.salon.com/2011/12/12/a_few_hacker_teams_do_most_china_based_data_theft/http://www.salon.com/2011/12/12/a_few_hacker_teams_do_most_china_based_data_theft/http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERAUALeDV5s&feature=youtu.behttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERAUALeDV5s&feature=youtu.behttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERAUALeDV5s&feature=youtu.behttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERAUALeDV5s&feature=youtu.behttp://www.salon.com/2011/12/12/a_few_hacker_teams_do_most_china_based_data_theft/http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304259304576373391101828876.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-tech/post/google-hundreds-of-gmail-accounts-hacked-including-some-senior-us-government-officials/2011/06/01/AGgASgGH_blog.htmlhttp://www.defensenews.com/story.php?i=3830559http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/27/us-nuclear-china-pakistan-idUSBRE85Q0YL20120627?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Reuters%2FworldNews+%28Reuters+World+News%29http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/06/27/us-nuclear-china-pakistan-idUSBRE85Q0YL20120627?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Reuters%2FworldNews+%28Reuters+World+News%29


18/47

14

Lhaba @j 8??43 @n Kd`ja @{ Fm~ag}`je Vdm`x K}xxmjk Vl Baim Vdm`x Ellf{ Kdmapmx AjfL}x Ellf{ Blxm Mtpmj{`~m Ajf Umxm Jlv Kdaggmje`je Vdmb F}bp`je Kdmap [vmmg AjfKdmap Ellf{ @jvl Vd`{ Kl}jvx Hmka}{m Vdmxm [}h{`f`smf H Vdm Kd`jm{m El~mxjbmjv

Ajf Umxm Jlv Kdaggmje`je Vdmb' Vdav{ C}{v Jlv Na`x* @v{ Jlv Xèdv***Vd`{ ua{ Lhabakabpaèj`je j Bag~mxj' _a*' lj Umfjm{fa3 @n vdmxm fm~ag}`je vdm`x k}xxmjk vl baim vdm`xellf{ kdmapmx ajf l}x ellf{ blxm mtpmj{`~m ajf umxm jlv kdaggmje`je vdmb' `n vdmxm {vmag`jel}x `jvmggmkv}ag pxlpmxv' l}x klpxèdv{ ajf um fljv {a ajvd`je ahl}v `v' um fljv vaim vdmbhmnlxm vdm Ulxgf Vxafm Lxeaj`sav`lj' `n vdmxm f}bp`je kdmap {vmmg ajf kdmap ellf{ `jvl vd`{

kl}jvx hmka}{m vdmxm {}h{`f`smf h vdm Kd`jm{m el~mxjbmjv ajf umxm jlv kdaggmje`je vdmb'vdav{ c}{v jlv na`x* @v{ jlv xèdv' ajf `v{ el`je vl }jfmxb`jm l}x mkljlb`k kljf`v`lj l~mx vdm gljevmxb*$Kxaè E`ghmxv' Kajf`favm{ Hmxavm Kd`ja'B`gua}imm Cl}xjag [mjv`jmg' 6,16,?4)

HXLIMJ3 @j Ba 8?18' Vdm Vxma{}x Fmpaxvbmjv [a`f Vdav Kd`ja F`f Jlv Bmmv Vdm Fmn`j`v`lj LnA K}xxmjk Baj`p}gavlx ]jfmx @v{ [vajfaxf{*Vdm Vxma{}x Fmpaxvbmjv lj Nx`fa ljkm aea`jfmkg`jmf vl jabm Kd`ja a k}xxmjk baj`p}gavlx fm{p`vm h`paxv`{aj kagg{ nlx akv`lj nxlb Kljexm{{*Vxma{}x jlvmf vdav Kd`ja{ k}xxmjk da{ appxmkàvmf aea`j{v vdm flggax {`jkm C}jm 8?1?' ajf {a`f `v f`fjlv bmmv vdm fmn`j`v`lj ln a k}xxmjk baj`p}gavlx }jfmx `v{ {vajfaxf{* $C}gàj _mkq}mv' Vxma{}x3 Kd`ja Jlv Baj`p}gav`jeK}xxmjk'Vdm D`gg{ Eglhag Anna`x{' =,8=,18)

Vdm Vxma{}x Fmpaxvbmjv Ajjl}jkmf @v U`gg Fmga @v{ [mb`"Ajj}ag K}xxmjk Xmplxv'Ud`kd Baim{ @v ]jgìmg Vdm Xmplxv U`gg Hm Xmgma{mf Hmnlxm Vdm ]*[* _xm{`fmjvàg Mgmkv`ljLj Jl~mbhmx >*Vdm ]*[* Vxma{}x lj Nx`fa {a`f `v ul}gf fmga a {mb`"ajj}ag k}xxmjk xmplxv}jv`g anvmx a bmmv`je ln vdm Exl}p ln 8? n`jajkm b`j`{vmx{ `j Bmt`kl lj Jl~mbhmx 6"=' ud`kdbaim{ `v }jgìmg vdm xmplxv u`gg hm xmgma{mf hmnlxm vdm ]*[* pxm{`fmjvàg mgmkv`lj lj Jl~mbhmx >*$Xlbjm D`v{ Lhaba Lj Kd`ja _lg`k`m{'Xm}vmx{' 1?,1;,18)

Ljkm @j Lnn`km' Lhaba Xmvxmavmf Nxlb D`{ Vl}ed Vagi Lj Vdm Kabpaèj Vxa`g Ajf Fmk`fmf JlvVl Gahmg Kd`ja A K}xxmjk Baj`p}gavlx* Vdm Vxma{}x Fmpaxvbmjv lj Umfjm{fa fmkg`jmf vl gahmgKd`ja a k}xxmjk baj`p}gavlx' xmvxmav`je nxlb vl}ed vagi ga{v max udmj a kabpaèj`je Haxaki Lhaba{a`f Hm`c`je daf impv `v{ k}xxmjk{ mtkdajem xavm }jna`xg glu*$Egmjj [lbmx~`ggm ajf Fl}e _agbmx' ]*[* Aea`j Fmkg`jm{ VlHxajf Kd`ja K}xxmjk Baj`p}gavlx'Xm}vmx{' 6,8=,?0)

A{imf Ahl}v Kd`ja{ K}xxmjk Baj`p}gav`lj Ajf ]jna`x Vxafm _xakv`km{' Lhaba [a`f VdavDm F`f Jlv Uajv Vl Mbhaxxa{{ Kd`ja*_xm{`fmjv Haxaki Lhaba' affxm{{`je q}m{v`lj{Umfjm{fa ahl}v Kd`ja{ aggmemf vxafm ah}{m{ ajf k}xxmjk baj`p}gav`lj' {a`f vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{b}{v p}{d haki aea`j{v }jna`x pxakv`km{ h}v jlv el l}v ln l}x ua vl mbhaxxa{{ vdm kl}jvx*Fl`je {l ul}gf x`{i aj agg"l}v vxafm uax' Lhaba vlgf Vdm _ga`j Fmagmx `j aj mtkg}{`~m `jvmx~`mu* $Dmjx Elbms' _xm{`fmjv Haxaki Lhaba Uaxj{ Aea`j{v Mbhaxxa{{`je Kd`ja Lj Vxafm Klbpga`jv{3 _ga`j Fmagmx @jvmx~`mu'Kgm~mgajf _ga`j Fmagmx'0,85,18)

Lhaba Kga`bmf Vdav Gahmg`je Kd`ja A{ A K}xxmjk Baj`p}gavlx Ul}gf Da~m Jl Mnnmkv LjVdm`x Vxafm _xakv`km{*A{imf `n vdm vae ul}gf pxm{mjv vdm mbhaxxa{{bmjv dm `{ dlp`je vl {paxmKd`ja' Lhaba {}eem{vmf vdav vdm fm{èjav`lj ul}gf akklbpg`{d g`vvgm* Vdmf da~m vl p}{d haki'ajf vdmxm{ jl a}vlbav`k vxèemx vdav xm{}gv{ nxlb `v' Lhaba {a`f* [l vdm ljg vd`je vdav dappmj{

`{ um vdmj da~m vl el haki ajf jmelvàvm u`vd vdmb* Vdm im dmxm `{ c}{v klj{vajv pxm{{}xm' ajfvdav{ udav um~m appg`mf `j a b}kd blxm aeexm{{`~m ua vdaj vdm pxm~`l}{ afb`j`{vxav`lj* $DmjxElbms' _xm{`fmjv Haxaki Lhaba Uaxj{ Aea`j{v Mbhaxxa{{`je Kd`ja Lj Vxafm Klbpga`jv{3 _ga`j Fmagmx @jvmx~`mu'Kgm~mgajf _ga`j Fmagmx'0,85,18)

Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v3 Kd`ja{ _lg`k Da{ _xlhahg Kl{v Abmx`kaj{ D}jfxmf{ Ln Vdl}{ajf{ LnClh{ Ajf Kljvx`h}vmf Vl Kd`ja{ Fm{vah`g`s`je _`gm Ln Vx`gg`lj{ Ln Flggax{ @j Xm{mx~m{*Kd`ja{}jfmx~ag}mf xmjb`jh` `{ a glje"{vajf`je' h`paxv`{aj kljkmxj' ajf `v `{ jlv a pdlj ljm3 @j p}x{}`v lnexluvd gmf h mtplxv{' Kd`ja da{ dmgf vdm xmjb`jh` fluj `j xmgav`lj vl vdm flggax' xmjfmx`je `v{ ellf{
http://www.jsonline.com/news/president/29557774.htmlhttp://www.jsonline.com/news/president/29557774.htmlhttp://www.jsonline.com/news/president/29557774.htmlhttp://www.jsonline.com/news/president/29557774.htmlhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/13/us-usa-campaign-china-idUSBRE89C0HQ20121013http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/13/us-usa-campaign-china-idUSBRE89C0HQ20121013http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/13/us-usa-campaign-china-idUSBRE89C0HQ20121013http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/04/15/us-usa-economy-currency-idUSTRE53E6R920090415http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/04/15/us-usa-economy-currency-idUSTRE53E6R920090415http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/04/15/us-usa-economy-currency-idUSTRE53E6R920090415http://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2012/09/president_barack_obama_warns_a.htmlhttp://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2012/09/president_barack_obama_warns_a.htmlhttp://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2012/09/president_barack_obama_warns_a.htmlhttp://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2012/09/president_barack_obama_warns_a.htmlhttp://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2012/09/president_barack_obama_warns_a.htmlhttp://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2012/09/president_barack_obama_warns_a.htmlhttp://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2012/09/president_barack_obama_warns_a.htmlhttp://www.cleveland.com/open/index.ssf/2012/09/president_barack_obama_warns_a.htmlhttp://www.reuters.com/article/2009/04/15/us-usa-economy-currency-idUSTRE53E6R920090415http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/13/us-usa-campaign-china-idUSBRE89C0HQ20121013http://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://www.jsonline.com/news/president/29557774.html


19/47

10

axv`n`kàgg kdmap `j vdm ]*[* baximv* Vdm xmjb`jh` ul}gf ea`j ahl}v 8? pmxkmjv aea`j{v vdm flggax `n `vumxm agglumf vl nglav nxmmg gìm lvdmx k}xxmjk`m{' akklxf`je vl vdm _mvmx{lj @j{v`v}vm nlx @jvmxjav`ljagMkljlb`k{* Kd`ja{ plg`k da{ pxlhahg kl{v Abmx`kaj{ d}jfxmf{ ln vdl}{ajf{ ln clh{ ajf kljvx`h}vmf vlKd`ja{ fm{vah`g`s`je p`gm ln vx`gg`lj{ ln flggax{ `j xm{mx~m{*$Mf`vlxàg' Hxmai`je Kd`ja< Ga{v Vd`je Jmmfmf @{ A Vxafm Uax'VdmUa{d`jevlj _l{v' 0,1,11)

Lhaba{ Na`g}xm Vl Kljnxljv Kd`ja Kl{v Vdm ]j`vmf [vavm{ 6=?'??? Clh{ Nxlb 8??4 Vl8?1?* Abmx`kaj clh{ da~m hmmj {d`nv`je vl glu"uaem kl}jvx`m{ nlx max{' ajf vdm vxmjf da{kljv`j}mf f}x`je Lhaba{ pxm{`fmjk* Nxlb 8??4 vl 8?1?' ]*[* vxafm u`vd Kd`ja agljm kl{v ahl}v6=?'??? Abmx`kaj clh{ hmka}{m ln vdm exluvd ln Kd`jm{m mtplxv{' {a`f Xlhmxv M* [klvv' a pxl"gahlxaf~lkavm av vdm g`hmxag Mkljlb`k _lg`k @j{v`v}vm* Vdav nè}xm ua{ gm{{ vdaj `j pxm~`l}{ max{' h}vvdm fmkxma{m ua{ pxlhahg v`mf vl vdm ]*[* mkljlb`k {glufluj' ud`kd kx`bpmf fmbajf nlx`bplxv{* @ vd`ji dm da{ uagimf aua nxlb vdm kabpaèj klbb`vbmjv{' {a`f [klvv' vdm `j{v`v}vm{f`xmkvlx ln vxafm ajf baj}nakv}x`je plg`k xm{maxkd* Dm da{ fljm nax vll g`vvgm vl `bpxl~m ]*[*vxafm* $Vlb Dabh}xemx' Kaxlg F* Gmljjè ajf Sakdax A* Elgfnaxh' Lhaba{ Xmklxf Lj L}v{l}xk`je Fxau{ Kx`v`k`{b Nxlb Vdm Gmnv'VdmUa{d`jevlj _l{v' 5,0,18)

Lhaba{ Kx`v`k{' _x`bax`g Lj Vdm _lg`v`kag Gmnv' [a Dm Da{ Xmpmavmfg Na`gmf @j LvdmxUa{ Vl _xlvmkv Abmx`kaj Clh{ Nxlb Hm`je Bl~mf L~mx{ma{ @jkg}f`je Kljnxljv`je Kd`ja*Ud`gm Ud`vm Dl}{m lnn`kàg{ {a vdm da~m hmmj ua`v`je lj Kljexm{{ vl akv' Lhaba{ kx`v`k{'

px`bax`g lj vdm plg`v`kag gmnv' {a dm da{ xmpmavmfg na`gmf `j lvdmx ua{ vl pxlvmkv Abmx`kaj clh{nxlb hm`je bl~mf l~mx{ma{* Vdm pl`jv vl a xajem ln akv`lj{ vdm {a dm {dl}gf da~m vaimj3kljnxljv`je Kd`ja' xm`j`je `j }jnmvvmxmf vxafm ajf xmulxi`je a ]*[* ~`{a pxlexab vdav kx`v`k{ {amjf{ }p {mjf`je dèd"vmkd clh{ ahxlaf*$Vlb Dabh}xemx' Kaxlg F* Gmljjè ajf Sakdax A* Elgfnaxh' Lhaba{ Xmklxf LjL}v{l}xk`je Fxau{ Kx`v`k`{b Nxlb Vdm Gmnv'Vdm Ua{d`jevlj _l{v' 5,0,18)

[mj* [dmxxlf Hxluj $F"LD)3 Ljkm Aea`j' Vdm ]*[* Vxma{}x Fmpaxvbmjv Da{ E`~mj Kd`ja A Nxmm_a{{ Udmj @v Klbm{ Vl @v{ K}xxmjk Baj`p}gav`lj*Ljkm aea`j' vdm ]*[* Vxma{}x Fmpaxvbmjv da{e`~mj Kd`ja a nxmm pa{{ udmj `v klbm{ vl `v{ k}xxmjk baj`p}gav`lj' Hxluj {a`f* Ud`gm umxm {mm`jeAbmx`kaj baj}nakv}x je xmhl}jf' Kd`ja `{ {vmpp`je }p `v{ mnnlxv{ `j a j}bhmx ln kx`v`kag {mkvlx{'`jkg}f`je kgmaj ajf {lgax mjmxe' af~ajkmf baj}nakv}x`je' ajf a}vl paxv{* Affxm{{`je Kd`ja{ k}xxmjkbaj`p}gav`lj `{ kx`v`kag vl l}x mkljlb`k xmkl~mx ajf nlx clh ea`j{' ajf fm{p`vm u`fm h`paxv`{aj {}pplxv

`j vdm [mjavm nlx gme`{gav`lj vdav vakigm{ vd`{ `{{}m' vdm ]*[* Dl}{m da{ na`gmf vl akv* [pmaimx Hlmdjmx{dl}gf hx`je vdm K}xxmjk Mtkdajem ajf L~mx{èdv Xmnlxb Akv vl vdm ngllx a{ {llj a{ pl{{`hgm*$[mj* [dmxxlfHxluj' Vxma{}x E`~`je Kd`ja A Nxmm _a{{ Lj K}xxmjk Baj`p}gav`lj'_xm{{ Xmgma{m' =,8=,18)

[mj* Kdaxgm{ [kd}bmx $F"JP)3 Vdm Afb`j`{vxav`lj Kljv`j}m{ Vl Gmv Kd`ja Emv Aua U`vd Ngl}v`jeVxafm X}gm{ C}{v Nlx Vdm [aim Ln F`pglbak* [mj* Kdaxgm{ [kd}bmx $F"J*P*)' udl da{ hmmj {plj{lxmfgme`{gav`lj vdav ul}gf p}j`{d Kd`jm{m `bplxv{ nlx vdm }jfmx~ag}mf k}xxmjk' ag{l kx`v`k`smf vdmafb`j`{vxav`lj{ xmplxv* Vdm afb`j`{vxav`lj kljv`j}m{ vl gmv Kd`ja emv aua u`vd ngl}v`je vxafm x}gm{ c}{vnlx vdm {aim ln f`pglbak* Kagg`je l}v Kd`ja a{ a baj`p}gavlx ba hm auiuaxf' h}v `v `{ v`bm vl vaim lnnvdm i`f egl~m' dm {a`f `j a {vavmbmjv* U`vd vdm afb`j`{vxav`lj kljv`j}`je vl hagi lj vd`{' `v{ }p vlKljexm{{ vl akv* Vdm [mjavm da{ pa{{mf h`paxv`{aj gme`{gav`lj vl kljnxljv Kd`ja ajf {vajf }p nlx Abmx`kaj

ulximx{' ajf [pmaimx Hlmdjmx jmmf{ vl {vlp {`vv`je lj `v ajf e`~m `v a ~lvm* $C}gàj _mkq}mv' Vxma{}x3 Kd`ja JlvBaj`p}gav`je K}xxmjk'Vdm D`gg{ Eglhag Anna`x{' =,8=,18)

[mj* Kd}ki [kd}bmx $F"JP) @j 8?1?3 Kd`ja{ K}xxmjk Baj`p}gav`lj @{ Gìm A Hllv Vl VdmVdxlav Ln L}x YMkljlb`kR Xmkl~mxAjf Vd`{ Afb`j`{vxav`lj Xmn}{m{ Vl Vx Ajf Vaim VdavHllv Lnn L}x Jmki*$Klbb`vvmm Lj Haji`je' Dl}{`je' Ajf ]xhaj Anna`x{' ]*[* [mjavm'Dmax`je' 0,1>,1?)

Xmp* V`b Xaj $F"LD) Ajf Xmp* Bìm B`kda}f $F"BM) Vl Vxma{}x [mkxmvax V`b Em`vdjmx3 Kd`jaKljv`j}m{ Vl Ngl}v @jvmxjav`ljag Vxafm Gau{ H Baj`p}gav`je @v{ K}xxmjk âg}m Vl @jkxma{m @v{Vxafm Af~ajvaem{* Vd`{ @{ Klbpgmvmg ]jakkmpvahgm* Agg Vdav L}x _mlpgm Axm A{i`je Nlx @{ A
http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.brown.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/brown-treasury-giving-china-a-free-pass-on-currency-manipulation-passing-currency-law-critical-to-preserving-manufacturing-jobs-and-spurring-economic-recoveryhttp://www.brown.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/brown-treasury-giving-china-a-free-pass-on-currency-manipulation-passing-currency-law-critical-to-preserving-manufacturing-jobs-and-spurring-economic-recoveryhttp://www.brown.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/brown-treasury-giving-china-a-free-pass-on-currency-manipulation-passing-currency-law-critical-to-preserving-manufacturing-jobs-and-spurring-economic-recoveryhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://banking.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Hearings.Hearing&Hearing_ID=30e4f6c0-1aef-42b8-92b7-f674071b5a99http://banking.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Hearings.Hearing&Hearing_ID=30e4f6c0-1aef-42b8-92b7-f674071b5a99http://banking.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Hearings.Hearing&Hearing_ID=30e4f6c0-1aef-42b8-92b7-f674071b5a99http://banking.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Hearings.Hearing&Hearing_ID=30e4f6c0-1aef-42b8-92b7-f674071b5a99http://thehill.com/blogs/global-affairs/trade/229535-obama-administration-declines-to-name-china-a-currency-manipulatorhttp://www.brown.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/brown-treasury-giving-china-a-free-pass-on-currency-manipulation-passing-currency-law-critical-to-preserving-manufacturing-jobs-and-spurring-economic-recoveryhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/obamas-record-on-outsourcing-draws-criticism-from-the-left/2012/07/09/gJQAljJCZW_print.html


20/47

8?

Gm~mg _ga`je N`mgf*@j Baxkd' ]*[* Xmp* V`b Xaj' F"J`gm{' ajf Kljexm{{baj B`im B`kda}f' F"Ba`jm'fxanvmf a gmvvmx vl ]*[* Vxma{}x [mkxmvax V`b Em`vdjmx ajf ]*[* Klbbmxkm [mkxmvax Eax Glkim vlaffxm{{ Kd`ja{ kljv`j}mf k}xxmjk baj`p}gav`lj* Kd`ja kljv`j}m{ vl ngl}v `jvmxjav`ljag vxafm gau{ hbaj`p}gav`je `v{ k}xxmjk ~ag}m vl `jkxma{m `v{ vxafm af~ajvaem{' Xaj {a`f* Vd`{ `{ klbpgmvmg}jakkmpvahgm* Agg vdav l}x pmlpgm axm a{i`je nlx `{ a gm~mg pga`je n`mgf*$Mf`vlx`ag' Kdmav`je Xlh{ ]*[*' Axma Ln Clh{'Vx`h}jm Kdxlj`kgm' >,1=,18)
http://www.tribtoday.com/page/content.detail/id/572993/Cheating-robs-U-S---area-of-jobs.html?nav=5007http://www.tribtoday.com/page/content.detail/id/572993/Cheating-robs-U-S---area-of-jobs.html?nav=5007http://www.tribtoday.com/page/content.detail/id/572993/Cheating-robs-U-S---area-of-jobs.html?nav=5007


21/47

81

^* GMAF@JE NXLB HMD@JF3 @XAJ

Lhaba Xmakdmf L}v Vl Vdm Xme`bm @j Vmdxaj' H}v @ejlxmf @xajàj F`{{`fmjv{

@j 8??4' Lhaba _xlb`{mf Vl [vajf Nlx Vdm D}baj Xèdv{ Ln @xajàj F`{{`fmjv{*LHABA3 U`ggum {vajf nlx vdm d}baj xèdv{ ln vdm f`{{`fmjv `j H}xba' vdm hgleemx `j @xaj' lx vdm ~lvmx `j S`bhahum,18)

Vdm Ahajfljbmjv Ln @xaq @{ Klj{`{vmjv U`vd Vdm Afb`j`{vxav`lj%{ Xm{plj{m Vl Vdm 15"Bljvd Kljng`kv @j [xà' Ajf _axv Ln Vdm Axk Ln @j{vah`g`v Vdav @{ Nlxb`je Nxlb Gmhajlj'Vdxl}ed [xà' @xaq Ajf @jvl Vdm _mx{àj E}gn* @xaq da{ vl n`jf `v{ luj fmblkxav`k ua' ajfvdm ]*[* kaj%v {mx~m a{ bmfàvlx nlxm~mx* H}v Bx* Lhaba vlli vdm ]*[* l}v ln vdm kl}jvx klgf v}ximajf da{ {`jkm {dluj jl `jvmxm{v `j a kx}kàg B`ffgm Ma{v kl}jvx udmxm {l b}kd Abmx`kaj hgllfua{ {dmf* Vdm ga{v abha{{aflx gmnv Haedfaf `j maxg C}jm' ajf vdm Afb`j`{vxav`lj da{ jlxmpgakmbmjv lj fmki* Vdm ahajfljbmjv ln @xaq `{ klj{`{vmjv u`vd vdm Afb`j`{vxav`lj%{ xm{plj{mvl vdm 15"bljvd kljng`kv `j [xà* _xm{`fmjv Lhaba {a{ vdm v`fm ln uax `{ xmkmf`je' h}v l}ul}gfj%v ijlu `v nxlb vdm axk ln `j{vah`g`v vdav `{ nlxb`je nx

leading from behind - rnc's "ten for ten" ebook series

Documents