labor and employment spotlight address · 2020. 2. 7. · sources: “millennial careers: 2020...
TRANSCRIPT
Labor and Employment Spotlight Address
2019 Food & Beverage ExchangeOctober 3, 2019
— Recruiting and retaining talent—best practices
— Managing a contingent workforce
— Employee background checks
— Social Security “No Match” Letters
Agenda
Recruiting and Retaining Top Talent
U.S. economy is relatively strong, labor market is tight
— Quality talent is in high demand and short supply across the spectrum of skill and compensation in most functional areas—manufacturing, R&D, sales, marketing, finance, technology, customer service, etc.
— Employees have more choices of where to work. Younger workers, including Millennials and Generation Zs, want more than a competitive wage/salary and health benefits
The Talent Problem
4
The Talent Pool—Millennials
“Millennials” (born 1981–1996)—close to 50% of U.S. workforce today; estimated to reach 75% by 2030 (Bureau of Labor Statistics).
— Change jobs more often than prior generations
— Value diversity and inclusion in peer groups and management ranks
— Believe companies should behave ethically and address social and environmental interests—not just profits
— Digital natives—comfortable with social media, sharing applications, and technology solutions at work
— Seek high level of engagement with their managers
— Value flexible work arrangements, work-life balance, and “high-trust” culture
Sources: “Millennial Careers: 2020 Vision (ManpowerGroup); The Deloitte Global Millennial Survey 20195
Talent Recruiting and Retention—Solutions
—Social media campaign—meet candidates where they are
— Internships—develop new talent from the inside
—Employee recruiting incentives—use your talent to grow it
—Career days—showcase your company
— Industry conferences and trade shows—brand your company as a great place to work
—Re-think the interview/application process—panel interviews, skills assessments, creativity/problem solving exercises
—Diversity and inclusion—identify a strategy, develop a culture
6
Talent Recruiting and Retention—Solutions
The competition is on for innovative employee benefits . . .
— Competitive wage and salary schedules—know your market
— Incentive compensation: bonus plans (MBO/financial performance), equity plans, award programs
— In-house training programs
— Flexible scheduling/telecommuting
— Career ladders
— Education reimbursement
— Community service—paid days, team outings
— Wellness programs
— Product discounts
— “Family friendly” benefits: maternity/paternity leaves, child care benefits, sabbaticals7
Managing A Contingent Workforce
Categories:
— Independent contractors
— Temporary employees
— Interns
Benefits:
— Fill need for limited scope or temporary work
— Respond to exigent circumstances (e.g., surge in product demand)
— Lower labor costs (no benefits, payroll taxes)
— Flexibility—adjust workforce to fluctuating business needs
Contingent Workforce
9
Independent Contractors
Risks/consequences of misclassifying workers as contractors v. employees . . .
For Workers:
— Payroll taxes
— Employee benefit eligibility
— Minimum wage/overtime laws
— Antidiscrimination/leave coverage
— Workplace safety/worker’s comp
— Unemployment benefit eligibility
— Union organizing
For Companies:
— Back taxes, interest, and penalties
— Back benefits (Microsoft)
— Back wages if below minimum wage
— Missed overtime wages (1.5X)
— Unpaid workers comp premiums + penalties
10
The Classification Challenge
— No single or simple test to determine employee/contractor status
— Different tests used by different agencies and under different laws
— Lack of past scrutiny may lead to false sense of security and lack of diligence
IC Classification Tests
11
IC v. Employee Differences
Employees
— Paid on a W-2
— Provided with tools by employer
— Work in an environment controlled by their employer
— Output controlled by employer
— Provided training, instruction, and supervision by their employer
— Work on-site
— Access to benefits, workers’ comp, and unemployment insurance protection
— Perform core functions within company
— Participate in company sponsored programs and events
— Work for single employer for multiple years
Independent Contractors
— Paid on a 1099
— Provide own tools
— Operate in business-to-business contractual relationships
— Work from negotiated statements of work on per-project basis
— Not supervised by company
— Usually do not work solely on-site
— File own taxes
— Invoice company per deliverables
— Have multiple clients
— Invest in their businesses
— Maintain business licenses and insurance
12
IRS Test: Right to Control
Three categories considered:
Behavioral control over what the worker does and how s/he does it
Financial control over the business
Relationship between the parties
Behavioral control factors:
— Instructions
— Training
— Integration
— Assistance
— Continuity
— Delegation
IRS Test: Right to Control
— Hours of work
— Percentage of time
— Place of performance
— Sequence of work
— Oral/written reports
14
Financial control factors
— Compensation (per hour/per job)
— Expenses
— Tools and Materials
— Facilities
— Entrepreneurial risk
IRS Test: Right to Control
15
Relationship factors
— Exclusivity
— Availability
— Employer’s right to discharge
— Employee’s right to end relationship
Other considerations
— W-2 or 1099?
— Intent of parties—agreement?
— Benefits
IRS Test: Right to Control
16
With your contractors, you should
— Know your vendors
— Define the relationship clearly, in writing
— Engage ICs only for non-core, project work
— Focus on end result, not means
— Establish discrete, shorter-term assignments
— Encourage an “open relationship”
Minimize IC Misclassification Risk
17
With your contractors, you should avoid
— Dictating hours of work, dress codes, etc.
— Getting involved in hiring/training/discharge
— Including ICs in company benefit plans
— Including ICs in employee performance review process or employee trainings
— Bringing back ex-employees as ICs for same job
Minimize IC Misclassification Risk
18
Within your company, you should
— Document basis for classification
— Be consistent in your classifications
— Review benefit plans to expressly exclude workers the company treats as ICs
— Regularly review and audit company’s compliance with attorney guidance
Minimize IC Misclassification Risk
19
Joint employer risk—same challenges . . .
— No single or simple test to determine joint employer liability
— Different tests used by different agencies and under different laws
— Tests change under different administrations
Temporary Employees
20
U.S. Department of Labor: “not completely disassociated”standard under FLSA (29 CFR § 791.2).
Proposed DOL rule would apply four-factor test focusing on whether alleged joint employer entity actually exercises control to:
— Hire or fire the worker
— Supervise and control the worker’s schedule or employment conditions
— Determine the worker's rate and method of pay
— Maintain the worker's employment records
Temporary Employees
21
— NLRB: Browning–Ferris Industries of California, Inc., 362 N.L.R.B. No. 186 (August 27, 2015). Two-part test. Two entities are joint employers if they:
1) have “right to control” work done and how that work is done;
2) co-determine matters governing essential terms and conditions of employment (e.g., hiring, firing, discipline, supervision, direction of work, wages, hours of work, scheduling the number of workers, seniority, overtime, and work assignments).
— Proposed NLRB Rule would reverse Browning-Ferris test and focus on whether entity possesses and exercises “substantial direct and immediate control over the essential terms and conditions of employment of another employer’s employees in a manner that is not limited and routine.”
Temporary Employees
22
— Laws to Consider
— Procedure to Obtain Information
— How to Lawfully Use Information
— Procedure for Rejecting an Applicant because of a Criminal History
Overview—Background Checks
Ban the Box
The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)
State law mini-FCRAs
Non Discrimination Laws
Laws to Consider
24
Ban The Box
Illinois, Chicago, and Cook County—No criminal history inquiries prior to job interview, or until after conditional job offer if no interview occurs
Other jurisdictions with Ban the Box—California, Connecticut, Washington D.C., Hawaii, Baltimore, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Kansas City, New Jersey, New Mexico, NYC, Oregon, Philadelphia, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington
• Not all inclusive
25
When is FCRA Applicable?
— Employers may require applicants for employment to submit to background checks as a condition of hiring
— Similarly, employers may require their current employees to submit to background checks as a condition of continued employment and to terminate employees who refuse
— Applies when employer uses an outside “consumer reporting agency” to obtain information about an individual’s background, motor vehicle, record, credit history, or other background
The Fair Credit Reporting Act
26
Pre-check Disclosure and Authorization Requirements
Before requesting a background check, an employer must:
— Provide written disclosure
— Obtain written authorization
— Provide certification to the agency
Procedure to Obtain Information
27
Obtain Written Authorization
— Employers must obtain prior written authorization from the applicant before obtaining a report
— FCRA disclosure and authorization cannot be part of the employment application—must be a separate document
— Applicant signature may be electronic
Procedure to Obtain Information
28
If you decide to reject a candidate, you must be able to show that the candidate’s conviction bears a “rational relationship” to the duties and responsibilities of the position sought.
This policy must be applied uniformly to all candidates with criminal backgrounds (i.e., candidates of all racial backgrounds, both genders, etc.) in order to prevent a disparate treatment discrimination claim.
Examples:
— Embezzlement
— Theft
— DUI
How to Lawfully Use Information
29
Pre-Adverse Action Disclosure
— Before you can take any adverse action based in whole or in part on information in the consumer report, you are required to give the individual a pre-adverse action disclosure that includes a copy of the individual’s consumer report and a written description of the individual’s rights under the FCRA
— “Adverse action” = decision not to hire, not to promote, to deny a raise, to demote, to terminate, or to take any other action that negatively affects the applicant or employee
— Should give applicant a reasonable amount of time (five days) to notify you of an error
Procedure for Rejecting an Applicant
30
Arrest Records
In Illinois, cannot rely on arrest records to take adverse action.
But, can rely on the underlying “acts” to justify adverse action.
If absent, then possibly terminate?
No retaliation
Maintaining records
Confidentiality
— Keep information about applicants’ and employees’ criminal records confidential
— Only use it for the purpose for which it was intended
Final Notes On Background Checks
32
SS No Match—What is it?
— SSA Letter—Notice that employee’s name/SS#, as reported by employer regarding wages, do not match SSA records
Reasons
— Invalid SS#, identity theft, administrative errors, name discrepancy such as unreported name change or hyphenated or multiple last names
Background—On again, off-again, and litigation
On the rise again due to new administration
— Policy move to address illegal immigration
Social Security No Match Letters
33
Received a No-Match Letter; Now What?
Best Practices
— Do Not Ignore. Why? In event of raid or I-9 audit by ICE, evidence that employer “knowingly” hired persons without proper U.S. work authorization
— But, do not immediately terminate. Why? Prohibited from terminating based on no-match letter alone, per law
Best Practices—No Match Letter
34
— Check your records to determine if name/SS# on file match those listed by SSA on no-match letter
— If no longer employed, document efforts to confirm the accuracy of the information. No further action. Retain documents for four years
— If employed, provide employee with copy of letter and confirm that information on the SSA letter is accurate. If the information in the employer’s files is not accurate, revise the employer information and wage reporting accordingly (e.g., administrative errors), submit a tax form W2-C and retain the no-match letter and documentation of change
Best Practices—No Match Letter (cont’d)
35
If employee confirms that the information listed in the no-match letter is accurate, ask him or her to contact the local SSA office and allow a “reasonable” period of time (i.e., 120 days) for resolution. Document efforts to resolve discrepancy and retain no-match letter
If no “resolution” contact counsel and proceed with caution
Best Practices—No Match Letter (cont’d)
36
This presentation contains images used under license. Retransmission, republication, redistribution, and downloading of this presentation, including any of the images as stand-alone files, is prohibited. This presentation may be considered advertising under certain rules of professional conduct. The content should not be construed as legal advice, and readers should not act upon information in this publication without professional counsel. ©2019. Nixon Peabody LLP. All rights reserved.
Brian Alcala, PartnerChicago, [email protected]+1 (312) 977-4366
Seth Neulight, PartnerSan Francisco, [email protected]+1 (415) 984-8377