l i open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/v89/pdf/v89-n28.pdfroad song-wes montgomery...

8
I __ Weather: Is it a nice day? Isn't this a nice Reamer? Polar ice cap nears Cambridge. X i I T A Q n I f " . . ... - -- L vJ % Lj-4JL- I I , ULUMl¥- oY NU. 4S % MIT', UAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS FRIDAY, MAY 16. 1969 FIVE CFNTqr By Alex Makowski Merits of the present tenure system and the values and limita- tions of our present grading and exam processes highlighted the lsecond open hearing for the New Lewis Commission Friday. Professor Gian-Carlo Rota. chairman of the Freshman Advi- sory Council, developed a lengthy analysis of our grading system. Charging that our ABCDF marks do not properly evaluate as well as popularly believed, he suggested that the new panel consider a restructuring of MIT's grading procedure. Discussion of tenure compared the current American system to a proposed five or ten year contract structure. This, emphasized the professor offering the idea, would take some of the pressure off the backs of junior faculty members. But Professor Sheldon Penman reminded the audience of the ef- fect this system has had in the Soviet Union. Rather than easing fear of Department Chairmen, ap- -,:~~-;3prehension among young profes- ;%,~ .;-;sors has increased. .'.V3x,~:3;s -Improved curriculum -. ,;~W Professor Joseph Licklider, as well as several others present, ask- ed investigation of our curriculum structure. He urged that the esta- blishment of such "discovery" riy Schey oriented courses as special project labs not be over-ruled solely be- cause of their high cost. Emphasis shoutd be placed on subjects which develop a sometimes atrophied investigative skill. Another curriculum-oriented -. debate concerned freshman courses. Many first-year students, . - . :, one professor charged, are turned, ' : .. N ,,: , ,i, , off when confronted with the::,; sit-down, fact-dispension course s they take. Some way must be found to encourage the motiva- x ; tion ofnew students. touched on the issue of graduate 777", education. Why should there be a special distinction, one professorcer- queriednbetween graduate and un- dergraduate students? Ano theer participant challenged the -privi- e schtea o the i sued to Master Whcat, tohen should becther e Insat i-- specaditnctsn An professor called .... an' qeraiedbtween graduthe anew Lewis degradupafthe cotriutionts Anthese p00coartiipn challenged the MITivi. l~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~PegienHoad Jhsonatus Faccoredty Chaitrma Wal adDctoampuni dts.-' , ,, ~' >, I ;'~i: rl ' ' SW l MYe listen to faculty comment during the recent Lewis Commission ;tFriedman-Samuelson debate oto by Joe Kashi ter Rosenblith r Cure-all? Yet with all tf;is discussion Harold Federow warned, we must avoid expecting the commissior to be a panacea for MIT. The old Lewis report, he pointed out, con tains too many suggestions for .reform that were never irample mented - as if the community conscience were eased by seeing the problems set down in print. -President Johnson agreed that a solution never results from just the presentation of the diffi- culties. He promised action based on the findings of the panel. (Please turn to page 3) .L ~By Joe Kashi The Samuelson-Friedman de- bate produced some smoke and heat, but little light as fiscal pro- ponent Paul Samuelson of MIT and monetary promoter Milton Friedman managed to agree only that both monetary and fiscal policy were are important. Fiscal policy deals with govern- mental attempts to control econ- omic growth through the use of taxes and other forms of econ- omic stimuli or brakes. One form of stimulus would be deficit spendirig by the government, which is often an economic spur. Likewise, a budgetary surplus often tends to slow down an overheated economy. ' Nixon advisor Friedman, an Economics pro- fessor from the University of Chi- cago and a frequent economic adivsor to Richard Nixon and Barry Goldwater, believes that' the government can best help the ec- onomy by controlling the amount of money in circulation. This is the so-called monetary policy. The Federal Reserve Bank is primarily responsible for this form of regulation. In addition, the Federal Reserve Bank is usually free of the political restrictions imposed by a Congress reluctant to increase taxes. In this way, it is able to speed up or slow down the economy as it feels necessary by increasing or decreasing the sup- ply of money. While neither Samuelson nor Friedman totally disavowed the usefulness of the other's form of economic policy, both claimed that events had born out their own respective schools of policy. Friedman offered the continuing inflation as an example. Jolmson finally was able to increase effect- ive taxes with the surcharge, but this raise had a negligible effect upon the economy. Keynesian ec- onomics predicted otherwise. Samuelson countered by stating that the monetary supply was increasing at the same time, thus negating the'effect of the tax raise. Moral position Samuelson did admit he was arguing from a moral position at times, notably for regulatory com- missions such as the SEC whose primary function is to protect people. The nation must decide the goal towards which its econ- omic policy is to be directed, taking humanitarian objectives in- to account. Some topics were not substan- tially disputed by either speaker. Both Friedman and Samuelson actively advanced free interna- tional trade. However, Friedman went further and advocated the abolition of all tariffs, arguing that competition and efficiency would enable the US to more than hold its own. Samuelson stated that the dollar has become an over-valued currency. To this, Friedman answered: "So what... [the US is so economically power- ful that] ... they don't have to like t, they have to take it...there's still a minimum of coercion in the vorld." Photo , y H Photo by Har, rds given Those receiving the award were Ivan R. Burns '69, Alan M. Gold- berg '69, William B. Grossman '69, Stephen H. Kaiser G, An- thony K. Lima '69, Jonathan M. Morey '69, David E. Newman '69, Michael R. Terry G, and James R. Truitt Jr. '69. Professor Ross H. Smith, Di- rector of Athletics, presented the Class of 1948 Award for the outstanding athlete of the year to Jeffrey M. Weissman '69. The Eastern College Athletic Confer- ence Merit Medal went to Geof- frey G. Hallock '69. The Cochrane Award for a (Please tun to page 3) By Harold b'ederow Karl Taylor Compton Prizes, and Baker Awards were presented to students and faculty members at last Thursday's Awards Convo- cation. Compton prizes The Karl -Taylor Compton Prizes went to Daniel J. Finger- man '69, Anthony George '69, Peter Q. Harris '69, Maria L. f Kivisild '69, Mark J. Mathis '69, Robert McGregor '69, and the Black Student Union. Shirley A. Jackson G, and Fred D. Johnson Jr. '72 accepted the award for the BSU. Baker awards for excellence in teaching went to Lawrence L. Bucciarelli, Assistant Professor of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Ir- won M. Rubin, Assistant Professor of Management, and Harry M. Schey, Instructor in Physics. Undaunted by the poor publi- city and a beautiful day, MIT gathered Thursday in the Great Court to honor outstanding stu- dents, staff, and faculty members of the past year. There were many parents in the small crowd of about 150. Those who came early pulled Ichairs from one of the stacks and set them up for parents and friends. Thsoe who came after the ceremonies started stood around the perimeters. Many appeared to be unin- formed about the event. The Re- gistrar had neglected to post a sign '' on the bulletin board in Building 7 to say that classes had been cancelled. Instead, a letter was circulated to all professors re- questing them to announce the cancellation of classes. Prather presides Ceremonies began at about 11 am and were presided over by UAVP Richard Prather '72, substi- tuting for UAP Mike Albert '69. After an introduction, Prather presented Professor Patrick Hur- ley, Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, who awarded the William A. Stewart Award for outstanding contributions to ex- tracurricular life at MIT. Photo by Dick Kooli.h. courtesv Techni,;.. Goque \ ·x ...... a,--n lIy.jUrRN Peter Q. Harris receives a Compton Award from Chairman of the Corporation James R. Killian, Jr. CONTINUOUS NEWS SERVICE SINCE 1881 Open hearing considers grading tenure pits circulation against taxes EXAMS JUN'E 2. 1969 student awal

Upload: others

Post on 11-Feb-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: L I Open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N28.pdfRoad Song-Wes Montgomery Shape of Things to Come-George Benson SwnummertimePaul Desmond Betwixt & Between-Kai

I __Weather:

Is it a nice day?Isn't this a nice Reamer?

Polar ice cap nears Cambridge.

X i I T A Q n I f " . . ... - --

L vJ % Lj-4JL-

I

I

, ULUMl¥- oY NU. 4S%

MIT', UAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS FRIDAY, MAY 16. 1969 FIVE CFNTqr

By Alex MakowskiMerits of the present tenure

system and the values and limita-tions of our present grading andexam processes highlighted the

lsecond open hearing for the NewLewis Commission Friday.

Professor Gian-Carlo Rota.chairman of the Freshman Advi-sory Council, developed a lengthyanalysis of our grading system.Charging that our ABCDF marksdo not properly evaluate as well aspopularly believed, he suggestedthat the new panel consider arestructuring of MIT's gradingprocedure.

Discussion of tenure comparedthe current American system to aproposed five or ten year contractstructure. This, emphasized theprofessor offering the idea, wouldtake some of the pressure off thebacks of junior faculty members.

But Professor Sheldon Penmanreminded the audience of the ef-fect this system has had in theSoviet Union. Rather than easingfear of Department Chairmen, ap-

-,:~~-;3prehension among young profes-;%,~ .;-;sors has increased.

.'.V3x,~:3;s -Improved curriculum-.,;~W Professor Joseph Licklider, as

well as several others present, ask-ed investigation of our curriculumstructure. He urged that the esta-blishment of such "discovery"

riy Schey oriented courses as special projectlabs not be over-ruled solely be-cause of their high cost. Emphasisshoutd be placed on subjectswhich develop a sometimesatrophied investigative skill.

Another curriculum-oriented -.debate concerned freshmancourses. Many first-year students, .- . :, one professor charged, are turned, ' : .. N ,,: , ,i, ,off when confronted with the::,;sit-down, fact-dispension course s they take. Some way must befound to encourage the motiva- x ;tion ofnew students.

touched on the issue of graduate 777",education. Why should there be aspecial distinction, one professorcer-queriednbetween graduate and un-dergraduate students? Ano theerparticipant challenged the -privi-

e schtea o the i sued to Master

Whcat, tohen should becther e Insat i--specaditnctsn An professor called .... an'qeraiedbtween graduthe anew Lewisdegradupafthe cotriutionts Anthesep00coartiipn challenged the MITivi.l~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~PegienHoad Jhsonatus Faccoredty Chaitrma WaladDctoampuni dts.-'

, ,, ~' >, I ;'~i:

rl ' '

SW lMYe

listen to faculty comment during the recent Lewis Commission

;tFriedman-Samuelson debate

oto by Joe Kashi

ter Rosenblith

r

Cure-all?Yet with all tf;is discussion

Harold Federow warned, we mustavoid expecting the commissiorto be a panacea for MIT. The oldLewis report, he pointed out, contains too many suggestions for

.reform that were never iramplemented - as if the communityconscience were eased by seeingthe problems set down in print.

-President Johnson agreed thata solution never results from justthe presentation of the diffi-culties. He promised action basedon the findings of the panel.

(Please turn to page 3)

.L ~By Joe KashiThe Samuelson-Friedman de-

bate produced some smoke andheat, but little light as fiscal pro-ponent Paul Samuelson of MITand monetary promoter MiltonFriedman managed to agree onlythat both monetary and fiscalpolicy were are important.

Fiscal policy deals with govern-mental attempts to control econ-omic growth through the use oftaxes and other forms of econ-omic stimuli or brakes. One formof stimulus would be deficitspendirig by the government,which is often an economic spur.Likewise, a budgetary surplusoften tends to slow down anoverheated economy.

' Nixon advisorFriedman, an Economics pro-

fessor from the University of Chi-cago and a frequent economicadivsor to Richard Nixon andBarry Goldwater, believes that' thegovernment can best help the ec-onomy by controlling the amountof money in circulation. This isthe so-called monetary policy.

The Federal Reserve Bank isprimarily responsible for this formof regulation. In addition, the

Federal Reserve Bank is usuallyfree of the political restrictionsimposed by a Congress reluctantto increase taxes. In this way, it isable to speed up or slow down theeconomy as it feels necessary byincreasing or decreasing the sup-ply of money.

While neither Samuelson norFriedman totally disavowed theusefulness of the other's form ofeconomic policy, both claimedthat events had born out theirown respective schools of policy.Friedman offered the continuinginflation as an example. Jolmsonfinally was able to increase effect-ive taxes with the surcharge, butthis raise had a negligible effectupon the economy. Keynesian ec-onomics predicted otherwise.Samuelson countered by statingthat the monetary supply wasincreasing at the same time, thusnegating the'effect of the taxraise.

Moral position

Samuelson did admit he wasarguing from a moral position attimes, notably for regulatory com-missions such as the SEC whoseprimary function is to protectpeople. The nation must decidethe goal towards which its econ-omic policy is to be directed,taking humanitarian objectives in-to account.

Some topics were not substan-tially disputed by either speaker.Both Friedman and Samuelsonactively advanced free interna-tional trade. However, Friedmanwent further and advocated theabolition of all tariffs, arguingthat competition and efficiencywould enable the US to more thanhold its own. Samuelson statedthat the dollar has become anover-valued currency. To this,Friedman answered: "So what...[the US is so economically power-ful that] ... they don't have to liket, they have to take it...there'sstill a minimum of coercion in thevorld."

Photo , y HPhoto by Har,

rds givenThose receiving the award were

Ivan R. Burns '69, Alan M. Gold-berg '69, William B. Grossman'69, Stephen H. Kaiser G, An-thony K. Lima '69, Jonathan M.Morey '69, David E. Newman '69,Michael R. Terry G, and James R.Truitt Jr. '69.

Professor Ross H. Smith, Di-rector of Athletics, presented theClass of 1948 Award for theoutstanding athlete of the year toJeffrey M. Weissman '69. TheEastern College Athletic Confer-ence Merit Medal went to Geof-frey G. Hallock '69.

The Cochrane Award for a(Please tun to page 3)

By Harold b'ederowKarl Taylor Compton Prizes,

and Baker Awards were presentedto students and faculty membersat last Thursday's Awards Convo-cation.

Compton prizesThe Karl -Taylor Compton

Prizes went to Daniel J. Finger-man '69, Anthony George '69,Peter Q. Harris '69, Maria L.f Kivisild '69, Mark J. Mathis '69,Robert McGregor '69, and theBlack Student Union. Shirley A.Jackson G, and Fred D. JohnsonJr. '72 accepted the award for theBSU.

Baker awards for excellence inteaching went to Lawrence L.Bucciarelli, Assistant Professor ofAeronautics and Astronautics, Ir-won M. Rubin, Assistant Professorof Management, and Harry M.Schey, Instructor in Physics.

Undaunted by the poor publi-city and a beautiful day, MITgathered Thursday in the GreatCourt to honor outstanding stu-dents, staff, and faculty membersof the past year.

There were many parents inthe small crowd of about 150.Those who came early pulledIchairs from one of the stacks andset them up for parents andfriends. Thsoe who came after theceremonies started stood aroundthe perimeters.

Many appeared to be unin-formed about the event. The Re-gistrar had neglected to post a sign

''

on the bulletin board in Building7 to say that classes had beencancelled. Instead, a letter wascirculated to all professors re-questing them to announce thecancellation of classes.

Prather presidesCeremonies began at about 11

am and were presided over byUAVP Richard Prather '72, substi-tuting for UAP Mike Albert '69.After an introduction, Pratherpresented Professor Patrick Hur-ley, Department of Earth andPlanetary Sciences, who awardedthe William A. Stewart Award foroutstanding contributions to ex-tracurricular life at MIT.

Photo by Dick Kooli.h. courtesv Techni,;.. Goque\·x...... a,--n lIy.jUrRN

Peter Q. Harris receives a Compton Award from Chairman of the Corporation James R. Killian, Jr.

CONTINUOUS NEWS

SERVICE SINCE 1881

Open hearing considers grading tenure

pits circulation against taxes

EXAMS

JUN'E 2.

1969 student awal

Page 2: L I Open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N28.pdfRoad Song-Wes Montgomery Shape of Things to Come-George Benson SwnummertimePaul Desmond Betwixt & Between-Kai

- a

rECORDSRECORDS'

I I-

cm_ of Course

MOTOR SALESRte. 1, DedhamDalzell (Dedham Plaza)

329-1100

--- --

I

declined to recommend otherchanges that have been urged thissession in Congress.

Nixon's reforms have a hollowring because of the way he wentabout recommending them. The.President has executive powersthat allow himn to change theorder of call, end occupationaldeferments, make standards moreuniform, and modernize the sys-tem without Congressional ap-proval.

And he neglected to commenton the future of what manyyoung people feel is the symbol ofthe antiquated draft: DirectorLewis B. Hershey, with his sightgetting worse and his age advanc-ing.

The President's call for Con-gressional action was full of therecent rhetoric of draft recorm,aiming for equity and reasonable-ness: "We can do no less for theyouth of our country," he said.Young men turning 18 and otherswho care had hoped for more.

r

ICE

r

iBIL

fc

pr

P

iaEm

l

I

PAGE 2 WEDNESDAY,MAY28, 1969 THE TECH

WASHINGTON (CPS)-President Nixon last-week pro-posed a major overhaul of theSelective Service System thatwould include selection of 19year-olds first by lottery. But thePresident's proposals fell far shortof completely eliminating the in-equities and uncertainties inherentin the draft.

He asked Congress to admendthe Selective Service Act. so hecould make these changes:

*Change from an oldest-first toa youngest-first call-up system,

*Reduce the period of primevulnerability from seven years toone year,

*Utilize a random, or lottery,selection system,

*Continue undergraduate de-ferments but place students in theprime vulnerability pool for oneyear after studies end,

*Permit graduate students tocomplete the full year instead of-one term if they are ordered forinduction, and

*Review guidelines, pro-cedures, and standards related toexemptions and deferments.

The trouble with Nixon's pro-posals, as even the New YorkTimes noted, is not what is in itbut what is not. The Presidentvirtually ignored the suggestionsmade by a 1967 White Housecommission that would havecleaned up uniform standards onall local boards. Moreover, Nixon

b

- 301230143015301630173018300130023003

C - 3004

3006

30083009

. 30103011

.- 3013

Road Song-Wes MontgomeryShape of Things to Come-George BensonSwnummertimePaul DesmondBetwixt & Between-Kai Winding & J. J. JohnsonCalling Out Loud-Nat AdderleyWhen It Was Done-Walter Wanderle .A Day in the Life-Wes MontgomeryWave-Antonio Carlos JobiimThe Glory of Love-Helrbie MannWe and the Sea-Tamba 4You, Baby-Nat AdderleyDown Here on the Ground-Wes Montgomery 'Have You Met Miss Jones?-Artie ButlerIsrael-Kai Winding & J. J. JohnsonTrust In Me-Soul Flutes

Soul Machine-Richard BarbaryI'll Be Anytfing for You-Tamiko JonesSamba Blim-Tamba 4

President's draft overhaulfalls short of total reform

I .jSt

420each

stereo album

HARVARD SQUAREOpen Thurs.,'til 9 PM

M.I.T. STUDENT CENTERMEDICAL CENTER396 Brookline Ave., Boston

TheCo Ilegrate

DepartmentStore

mmmm

Page 3: L I Open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N28.pdfRoad Song-Wes Montgomery Shape of Things to Come-George Benson SwnummertimePaul Desmond Betwixt & Between-Kai

· ·- . --- · I -·---- ' `- ·· I 'e- ~ ~ -r-

- L-

-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

.- q i a 1

I

I

f

(continued from page 1)

Following up on their GeneralAsseminbly appearance, ProfessorJohn Graves and Jim Smith offi.cially presented their proposal fora Bachelor of Arts degree. Theirun-structured program would per-mit students more freedom indesigning their MIT education.

As for staffing the new Lewisgroup, one professor asked thatemphasis be placed on selectingyounger men. "We older profes-sors" he remarked, "look to the.past, while younger men look tothe future."

Faculty housingReturning to faculty-related is-

sues, a need for on-campus facultyhousing was expressed. The es- ·

sence of a true college communityis the faculty-student interchangepossible only when professors canreadily mingle with under-graduates.

Johnson welcomed the senti-ment. Many times, while strollingthrough the campus after dinner,he had sensed the absence ofMIT's faculty. Some way to over-come the pre-dinner exodus mustbe found.I

. I

L

a

THE TECH WEDNESDAY. MAY 28. 1969 PAGE 3I

Wiesner described the powerfulspatial limitations. He related hismeetings with Johnson, discus-sions of the possibility of branchcampuses. Reflecting the MITscientific emphasis, they could

nevertheless offer more diversity."What we should do," replied

Professor Dwight Baumann, "issell MIT franchises." "Fifty mil-lion dollars," returned Wiesner,"would be about right."

The Varsity Club Trophy for theliving group having the highestratio of intercollegiate letter win-ners to eligible members went toBeta Theta Pi. Maria Kivisild re-ceived the MITAA Pewter Bowlfor outstanding contributions towomen's athletics. The Qua-drangle Club award went to Al-bert Lau '72 and Peter ArnoldSanders Jr. '72. They were theoutstanding freshmen athletes.

Music awardsBaton Society awards for out-

standing contribution to music atMIT went to Wendell C. Brase '69,and William B. Grossman '69. TheFrederick Gardiner Fasset Jr.award went to William SamuelStroud '70, for the unselfish de-monstration of the qualities ofspirit, dedication, and service infurthering the ideals of the MITfraternity brotherhood.

Horatio G. Daub '70 receivedthe Scott Paper Foundation Lead-ership award. The James N. Mur-phy award for outstanding Insti-tute employees went to RichardP. Reavis, a porter at BurtonHouse.

The Convocation concludedwith remarks by President John-son. Then the crowd left - theprize-winners and families tolunch in the Student Center, thestudents and secretaries back towork.

iconanuea yrom page ·1,senior who has shown qualities ofhumility, leadership, and scholar-ship in the intercollegiate athleticprograms went to George A. Hus-tak '69, and James R. Yankaskas'69. gold Awards in Athletic Ad-ministration went to Lee A. Dilley

*'69, Jeffrey M. Weissman'69, BenT. Wilson '70, and James R. Yan-kaskas.

Silver Awards for Athletic Ad-ministration went to Carl B. Ever-ett '69, Joel M. Hemmelstein '70,Richard C. Hood '70, Kathleen F.Jones '71, John W. Oehrli '69,Walter C. Price Jr. '70, Robert N.Schulte '7i, and Stephen L.Wiener '69. Certificate awards inAthletic Administration went toRichard D. Boettger '70, HenryDuBose Montgomery Jr. '71,Cleveland Smith Jr. '69, and PaulW. Sullivan'71.

The Burton R. Anderson Jr.Award to the Manager of the Yearwent to Robert N. Schulte '71.

the city of Boston in a restaurant

so regal the Charles is known

AIE ~ as our moatDIVE

HAT EA X RESTAURANT· ·. .'.

Cambridge Charter House Motor Hotel5 Cambridge Parkway 491-3600On the Charles between Longfellow Bridge and Science Museum. Parirng Expansion .

More. housing, though, meansexpansion, and Provost Jerome

Full/part time openings forSYSTEMS PROGRAMMERS

with experience in:Compiler design, monitor systemsprocess control, MIS, I/O control

or data collection systemscall 4924870

CODON CORPORATION

You Oan/alRmmmmme.ml.-- .. Nock.....~m~

!1 Q

OUR UNIVERSITY SHOPSummer suits and sportwear

made-on our exclusive modelsSUITS of Dacron polyester-and-cotton poplin

in olive, blue mix, British tan or natural, $ 6 0in Dacron-and-worsted tropicals, from $ 80

ODD JACKETS of cotton seersucker, $42.50;of Dacron and flax blend

in our more-fitted model, $ 55

'g-. ....- ODD TROUSERS of Colorful' ' ..;. polyester-and-cotton; from $14;

Dacron-and-worsted, $ 25,Dacron-and-cotton poplin, $12 2 :

i{ 3And Bermuda shorts, sport shirts, etc.

ESTABLISHED 1818: M~~~w~rf>/sys/ 2 ~~

d Ucn's z'Boys ljkrnisbings. [ats : ,~hors]34 MADISON AVE., COR 44.TH ST., NEW YORK, N.Y. i0017

X ~~~46 NEWBURY, COR. BERKELEY, BOSTON, MASS. 02116 i.VLahTA - *CHICAGO -LOS ANGELES - PnTrSBURGH * SAN FRANCISCO * WAHINGTNG

~ [ '~ " .. ' . . . x2:~:: ·~":':''d ~

Engineering careers with the City of New York offer excellent op-portunities for advancement and better salaries than ever before.But real job satisfaction can come from helping to improve life forover eight million people in the greatest city in the world.For the Engineer this means helping to plan and construct newschools, hospitals, subways, bridges and miles of new highways; todevise lower cost housing; to eliminate air & water pollution; andto plan & implement sanitary engineering programs. This meansyou will be participating in programs of essential public service aswell as great professional challenge.These are just some of the many exciting projects open to you asa City Engineer. Nowhere else, will you find greater opportunitiesfor such valuable experience to broaden your specialty.Immediate openings are now available in many of our City agenciesfor trainee, junior and assistant level Engineers.June graduates will be hired as Junior Engineers. Students receiv-ing degrees in June, 1970 can be hired this summer as Engineertrainees- and then take leave of absence to return to school fordegree.

New York City is, of course, an Equal Opportunity Employer.Please write or call and we will send you full details.

Ideas offered for Lewis study

MIT honors achievementsatAwards Day convocation

i-oer- -_W IMA

_twe

CIVIL,ELECTRICAL,MECHANICALANDAIR-POLLUTIONCONTROLENGINEERS

New York City - a city of constant challenge - offers a variety ofopportunities for Engineers who would enjoy a demanding career,that is personally rewarding.

RECRUITMENT DIVISION, DEPT. C-10

NEW YORK CITYDEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL

220 Church St., NYC 10023(212) 566-8700

I

Page 4: L I Open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N28.pdfRoad Song-Wes Montgomery Shape of Things to Come-George Benson SwnummertimePaul Desmond Betwixt & Between-Kai

PAGE 4 WEDNESDAY, MAY 28, 1969 THE TECH

VOL. L£XXXIX, NO. 2 7 MA Y 23, 1969BOARDOoF DIRCToRs

Second-class postage paid at Boston, Massachusetts. The Tech is published everyTuesday and Friday during the college yewr, except during college vacations, byThe Tech Room W20-483, MIT Student Center, 84 Massachusetts Ave.,Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139. Telephone: Area Code 617, 876-5855 orUN4-6900, extension 2731. United States maid subscription rates: $4.25 for oneyear, $8.00 for two years.

zr

2tL

mcm

a05r.

9;;wm

m

P.

F-

wF.

a

J.-

mF

ihi

00I--m

confine ourselves to words, for thehour is getting late and the time foraction is ufeon us.

Yours - with some sorrow, somepity, and a little hope,

Michael AlbertAn Open Letter to the FacultyMiddlemen.

My salutation may seem strong or,sad; mean or mild: it is only the way Ifeel[, nothing more and certainly no-thing less. Your role, whether it be awelcome one or not,' is in no wayfitting for any group; you must notacquiesce.

:This ;University, like all others, issuffering from many and varied mala-dies. Some would have us believe thatthe germs are students - thus you needonly eliminate the most unruly onesand health -shall abound. Do not befooled, gentlemen - you should haveto eliminate us all, and then lo andbehold someone would suggest that"Oh well, we were wrong all along, thegerms are faculty." A personal purge isno answer, we must come together, notapart.

That however seems patently ab-surd - How can we come together?The common assumption is that theonly way is to cover over disagree-ments, avoid dissension, and ride outthe storms with smiles and good willfor all. Under those conditions, yoursmiles are plastic, your good-will false;let us dispense with pretense please,and remember that we are equals. Wecannot be afraid of our emotions, if itis anger we feel we must show it, to dootherwise is to invite disaster. Disagree-ment by any other name is still dis-agreemenM. To come to terms we mustallow reality to surface. One can beemotional and at the same time ra-tional - indeed there is in my mind agrave questio n about whether or'notone can be rational without beingemotional, at least in times such .asthese.

We are all concerned that there bechange; we are all concerned thatnon-violence prevail; but are we asconcerned about violence to tothers asviolence to ourselves? And how do wedefine violence, do we include psycho-logical and economic deprivation whenwe talk of intimidation? The normal·,rrder.~of-..u---':ives-is--pernmIated by alevel of Coercion and force that isinhuman and indeed intolerable -speak not to me of sit-ins, while thewar wages; I don't want to hear aboutfree speech from any save those whospeak freely. The material deprivationof the ghetto; the spiritual deprivationof all our lives - reason enough Ibelieve to rebel.

It is difficult to address you as awhole, you have~ little in commonamong yourselves; less in common witlime. At the same time we are all peopleand if I am right the problems andthoughts that occupy my mind should,must, and will occupy yours. In thefuture I intend to treat you as equalsand people - you ask what can thatmean? It means simply that I willrespect your integrity and intelligence,I shall speak to you as I would to myfriends, no words deleted, no ideasspared ~ my style will reflect myfeelings. .

The decorum of your meetings re-flects MIT, as it was, not as it is. Youare treated like children - and youaccept it. It eludes me to think why.Don't you share my angers and frustra-tions? Don't you desire to work hardand long not at 'business as usual' butat rebuilding this sick society? Hasn'tthe sterility of our personal relation-ships provoked you to thought; to adesire for change? Does the war eat atyour mind? Indeed, are your kidsrebelling? Do you really feel you couldstand trial? I couldn't.

Let me not drag on. There is abattle being waged near and far, ittakes many forms; it has many effects.The time is not far distant when therewill be no middle ground. The events

-at Berkeley should teach you thatwhen the time is right for guns and gasyour countenanced visages aren'tworth a damn - They will not pause intheir attack because of your demeanor- let your objective neutrality be

-damned, my brothers are being killed- they are your students, I believe.

Patience is not' always a virtue,neutralism is partisan - choose yourviews, do not let the m choose you.

Peace and Power,Michael Albert

Tlhe current dilscussion of the role of defense research at MIT (Ed. note: Instead of our usual letterscomes at a time when there is an enourmous amount of ambiguity in clmw r rnigtrerte

the strategic arms race. ~~~~~~unique letters:- open letters to thethe strategic arms race. ~~~~~~~students, faculty, and administration

Deployment of MIRV and ABM is being justified in terms of the fo A ieAbr.W eltathis is an appropriate way to close the

poss~litythat the Russians are attempting to gain a first strike term, and we hope that the community

capability vis a vis this nation. This would mean that they would bewilrathmntespitnwicthey are written.)

able to launch a nuclear attack against this country which would be so Brothers and Sisters,devastating as to eliminate the possibility of effective retaliation by This past week guns and helicoptersthe US. At present, both nations have a second strike capability, i.e.,marcltdiou nwyerggno initial attack could destroy enough of the enemy's retaliatoryutpaedciolsyemSmonIforces to prevent the attacked nation from devastating the attacking ko okhri;aohrpro

know went away to straighten out aIpower. It is this uneasy balance which some analysts fear is being normal sensitive and b~autiful head,,upset. for those attributes seem of late to

The prime evidence offered in the case supporting the hypothesis ivt nypihrsi n iatrthat the Soviets are seeking a first strike capability is the continuingJmsltepdotianrht

and frustration, for a brief rest before adeployment of their SS-9 missiles and Po laris-type submarines. Theneasulonmmstrctbn-SSO9 is seen as a first strike weapon because of its higher accuracy and factors. Why?greater payload than previous models, both prerequisites for Why indeed? Because there's shiteffectiveness against hardened missile sites. In contrast, second-strice adgraei h oe ftegetweapons, such as the Soviet SS-1 1, need not be as accurate or wiew rv nnwrasi upowerful in order to be effective' against cities, which are the 'prime burbia and fight wars of attritionagainst everyone - including ourselves.targets in a second strike. Because we're all afraid of hitchhikers,

However, data on the SS-9 is incomplete, and it is possible that it-- the price of cars is going up, andrepresents an evolutionary upgrading of the Soviet missile force ratherevro'satanrtovryeel.·than a major attempt at gaining a first strike capability. ThisBeaswea ko thtalte

world is dying and the other half -interpretation is bolstered by the continuing deployment of the lessweitsnaldad-ndoeofuexpensive SS-1 l's; one would expect that if the Soviets were truly seems to be able to do much, exceptseeking a first strike, they would use their entire missile budget for the the people in the west. They can visit

SS-9. If SS-9 deployment levels off within a year or so, it will be tenregssoaetnsadpaevident that the Soviet objective was not a first strike. If, on the other frlgtnn.Sc?-Iral aethand, deployment continues, our second strike capability may be in wne hti ikSo alright you say I'm a pessimistjeopardy. 'but then there is U Thant who suggests

In that case, we will have to take some sort of action to preserve that the whole World has about tenour deterrent. The least expensive action to take under those -er ett o-adte osbccircumstances would be to deploy Poseidon missiles (equipped withto'uiesauul.I-Lab's MIRV) on our Polaris subs. While we do not favor deployment NoI'ntapesmt.nfcIbelieve that I am a pragmatist. I don'tof MIRV at this time, it is imp~ortant that the system be ready to go if accept that the human race exists so asSoviet intentions prove unfavorable. to self-destruct; I don't accept that

We reiterate our oppostion to the Safeguard ABM system as a, man needs to compete, kill, or starve. Imeans for preserving our deterrent, since it is unlikely that it will wligtsanoIbeevthte

anbuild a society in wyhich men relatesafeguard anything. If a means of preserving our second strikecalyas equals, cooperating; striving only toIcapability is needed, Poseidon will-be cheaper and easier to deplo fulfill their own needs and desires -than Safeguard. In addition, deploying Safeguard is likely to convince human and natural desires, rather than

the Russians that we are seeking a first strike capab0iliyhi hwiit t ek.ind'imposed.'tby .anunre~a-, propa-gained by extending the proposed system to protect our cities against gads an'aiuaie oilodr

a Soviet second strike. ~~~~~We on the left have a vision, an,intuition, if you will, of a society in

The only real solution to the theat of nuclear devastation, however, which we are all responsible for ourwill be some sort of US-Soviet agreement on strategic arms limitation. own behavior and there's no "law and

The possibility of achieving such an agreement may be seriouslyore"-isadjutcanlv.jeopardized by completing the final two months of MIRV testing, Tieyusy ogtsoe rte which are about to begin. If these tests are completed, the Soviets willwhcerwayopef.How does all this happen? Regret-have no choice but to assume that we have deployed MIRV, and they tably I must report that it will notwill upgrade their efforts accordingly. Therefore, we call on the Nixon occur without a very great disturbance.

administration to at least postpone the last testing phases and seekBuofcrswemtrmmbrhaproductive talks with the Russians; if this is not done, a goldenthsausqoiadsurnc-aopportunity to lift some of the burden of producing nuclear arms dsubneo vr au vrwrshipped in any church or human head.from the people of this nation will be lost. For myself the Way, while cluttered

While we find it difficult to defend some of the projects now and cloudy, is well outlined, eveo ifunderway at Lincoln Labs, it -should be noted (hat that laboratory isridnwtaltlegltndmcfa.actively engaged in research in seismic array detectors and satelliteMyondsrsemdthtIpsuacommunications techniques which will nake it ossible for us to pt htalw et eaefel-PO ~~~~with others, love whom I choose, livemonitor Soviet compliance with any arms-control treaty without as I like; thus I must avoid cornpro-on-site inspection. We look forward to the day when the Special raising myself and what I believe in,Laboratories will be able to work in entirely civilian fileds. However,avi(tusthvenclrbigin light of the current situation, it should be pointed out that some ofhyeantpd.Itiscuryhtthe projects currently be'mg done there are likely to bring that day masta utwiki h oement. No coincidence, I believe. Thecloser. fact that the Movement is where one

r rvn I ~~~~~pursues theN kind of society I've out-¢lined and also the only place left that is

- ------- ~ ~ spiritually' alive -is certainly no sur-W A- _Z_ I ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~prise.

be possible, as everyone else suggests,Ithat you are too old to live? I thinknot.

Yours in Freedom and Expectation,fMichael AlbertI

An Open Letter to the AdministrationGentlemen:

-When I ran for office I was askedwhether I would be able to get 'alongwith you - I answered that I didn't seewhy not, though I didn't believe it wasa prerequisite. Now I wonder. I havefound as I thought to be the case thatyou are well motivated and personable.I have found that 'despite your- ages Icould like you, but still I wonder.

At first I thought that our goalswere really quite parallel. But for thefact that you were victims of yourposition and place I thought we. mighteven be partners of a sort, but nowalas I wonder. How deep do the effectsof your positions go? Are your titlesand actions in any wyay distinguishable?

Your interests, so manifold andvaried, seem to dwarf my naive con-cerns. While I worry about workerscontrol and the quality of daffy livingyou must consider the maintenance ofGetrural Motors and Lockheed, forthey are certainly a very real pd-t ofyour lives. While I oppose militarymuscle because it has long since growncancerous you must be a b~it morecautious - for there are corporate andpolitical interests to consider; what ofthe next trip to Washington, and whatof M.I.T.R.E. Corp. with its own kindsof South East Asian Treaties (or is itmore precise to say contracts)? While Iam able to speak long and hard againstmanipulation, you must be a littlemore coy. For there is project CAM toconsider and then some. To stressmanipulation might be risky for thefather figures of the faculty. (Even ,ifthat role came by evolution rather thandesign.) How could you convince thetechnicians that your first duty is tocountry and labor; the faculty andalumni that you are their servant in acontihi-Y'aI'Ciff-f6i~'sfa-silit~; iffd'litly,-..of course, the students, that you arechampions of change devoted entirelyto our present and future interests?How in fact can you support large scalechange while decrying non-violent De-mocratic dissent as irresponsible? Ahbut I must not forget, every leadermust have a consensus, and of coursedissension must be held to a minimumat all costs.

Your',idea of change and commit-ment, at least on this campus, .seems tobe talk and discussion. I am not -sofond of the spoken word, maybe it isbecause I am irresponsible - maybe it'sbecause I hear very little being said bythose in power; very little being saidthat hasn't been said before.

You have set up a commission toinvestigate defense department ties,well and good by some standards, Isuppose, however the MIRV is aboutto be deployed and the crimes drag on.But then you have other concerns,don't you?

You have condoned and supportedthe establishment of a conlmittee toinvestigate ROTC. A little late, don'tyou think? Russell's tribunal did amore than adequate job'to say nothingof the Nuremberg trials. But then youhave other concerns also?

A commission to investigate educa-

naive doubts linger, for I remember thediscussions of grades and requirements.Then there is the commission's namewhich harks back to a time. befor.emany of us were born; meaningless, ormaybe perhaps it tells us something.But I have only to worry about know-ledge; how it can be taught and learn-ed: You must of course consider fund-ing, prestige, and , is it possible, thefutures of your corporations.

"Can we work tog,,,ether," they ask.The only grounds upon which we canmeet together as equals and partnersare the grounds for change. I am nolonger interested in long-winded de-bates on the merits of the status quo -the status quo is obscene and immoral.If we are to talk attlength -it must be ofchange and how to get it that wespeak, and we must no speak, and we'must not speak falsely, nor can we

Recently someone asked me aboutnon-violence. I said that I wished Icould afford to be. There are someother things about which I must .- ysimilar words; what of yourselves, bro-thers and sisters, can you afford what Icannot, or are we of the same world?The walls of your memory will echo

your sorrowThe pictures of sadness are not-what

they seem

So hold out your smile, take my hand.and be happy

These pictures of sadness are not allthey seem

Jorrna Kaukonen--Jefferson AirplaneErich Fromm has said that capita-

lism and brotherhood are incompa-tible. I agree, and so I will devote mylife to brotherhood - capitalism bedamned. What about yourself,' nexttime we meet should I call you boss, orbrother?

If you are too young to die, can it

Chairman ....

Editor .....Business Manager ..

Production Manager...

Night Editors ...

News Editors ...Sports Editor ...

Photography Editor...

Adveftising Editor ..The Tech is pleased to anm

. . .. .. ....... . ..Greg Arenson'70

. . .. .. .. .. ... ~Steve Carhart '70

. .. .. .. .. .. . .. Julian James '70

. .. .. .. .. . .. Bruce Weinberg '71Randy Hawthorne '7 1, Carliss Baldwin '72

. . .. .Greg Bernhardt '7 1, Jay Kunin '71

. . .. .. .. .. ... Ray Kwasnick '71

. . .. .. .... .. .. . .Craig Davis '71

. . .. .. .. .. ... Steve Bailey '72

Editor, Steve Bailey '72. We regret to a~nnounce the resignation ofCarliss Baldwin '72, Night Editor.

nounce the ele~ction ot our new Advertising

-A , reportsFirst strikeIn 1- -- . · ---. · , rq .I - -- ' - -X' ·-.C I JrTrt-

Page 5: L I Open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N28.pdfRoad Song-Wes Montgomery Shape of Things to Come-George Benson SwnummertimePaul Desmond Betwixt & Between-Kai

THE TECH WEDNESDAY, MAY 28,1969 PAGE 5

------- --I----�a���---�uu I ii - o II I c- L

- _I _--�espll-IIC--� I.

_ _-

- ---- _L

UNDERWRITERS AND INVESTMENT BANKERS1 dlL~~~~~~~a ~~~~-~~~bl - ~ ~~II -

-L_ l _ .I I . I I -"

_i ,l Ir , S BCI II I I I II I

I

IIiiI�r

j.

sirr

E

a

i

a

iB

.r:pI,

i5

d

"2L:

S

·I::

I,

,,

I

i

I

11

I

I

rII

I

tIII -t

r

I

I

I

II

1

1

11

II

project. He spent some time inreading the textbook and sometime doing homework problems.There was some time spent listen-ing to what I (Dr. King) call freeassociations about the materialand some time in interviews inwhich I would suggest things toread that might be of interest. Thematerial was approached in manydifferent ways from one day tothe next, so that in a funny way itreally wasn't concentrated. Thestudents just didn't sit down anddo problem seven and do problemeight and nine. It was rathervaried.Q. How did you go about guid-ing the students' projects?A. First, all the projects wereworked on in partnerships. Ofcourse they had some problems-since you had to have compatiblepeople but the relationships wereof the kind that the Institute doesnot ordinarily foster. Anyway Iwould be in the laboratory fromnine'to ten thirty every day tosort of wander around and ad-mire, or question, or worry, orwhatever seemed appropriate. inother words I worked the sameway that graduate thesis super-visors work with their students.

wonder secretly if there are somekind of records. There really wereno records. I did keep a book ofthe interviews with somethingabout what questions they askedthat also served as a sort ofscratch record of what we talkedabout so that things that werementioned several times could bebrought up in lecture.Q. What sort of encouragementwas there to do the homework?A. Well, we had a transient oc-currence. My graduate assistantdecided that it would be pedago-gically sound if the homeworkwere collected and corrected, andI felt there was some sense to this.So I said, well go ahead andcollect the homework, and every-body sort of looked down. Soonafter they started complaining inprivate., Maybe they j ust don't likehaving the homework collected.So we rescinded the order. You(the interviewer) have seen thereport and know that most of thehomework was done.Q. How important do you thinkproblem sets are in a course likethis when there are so many otherthings going on?A. I feel that doing homeworkproblems is useful if one learns

problems or less problems.. Myguess is that the sort of dailyinterview we had put on a littlepressure. The importance of anydifferent ingredients of this exper-iment is plainly different for dif-fereni people.Q. The question was not justabout problem sets but aboutdifferent ways of learning.A. Well the students in generalwere exposed to a cycle of seeingsomething in the morning in laband talking about that. If any oneof them was particularly interest-ed in that topic then I would sendhim off to find out about it. Thenlater in the afternoon there was ahomework problem on the samesubject as the lab and discussion.The role of the problems was toforce the student to sit down afterseeing the material or before see-ing it and work it out for himself.Q. What about the students? Dothey get tired of just seeing phy-sics?A. Naturally it varied. The pro-gram is not the end-all since itsuits some students and notothers, in fact it suits some teach-ers and not others.Q. Then what about the integra-tion of lab work into the curricu-lum?A. I don't think it will succeedvery well. The corridor labs andproject labs are the best of a badthing. In the last analysis the bestthink is for a student to come to aresearch lab and find someonewhom he enjoys working with andsomeone who will take him ser-iously and get him going.Q. What sort of topics do youthink are amenable to study inthis way?A. Far more subjects are amen-able to it than seems obvious atfirst glance. That is one of thereasons for my wanting to havemore publicity. In fact any seriouswork is done in concentratedform. It is possible to turn aroundand ask how people have beenputting up with the five coursesituation.O. What about evaluation?A. I think the only way you canis not to evaluate it but to press tohave a number of people try it outand the degree of enthusiasm willmeasure it. It will become part ofthe system, and no one really-valuates the system. It will be,valuated by the fact of someone

else trying it or not.

By Charles Mann tration would be a method ofIt started in 1963 when I was teaching that I would like, and

teaching classes on a regular basis that students might like it too. Inlike everyone else and also trying point of fact, the notion of break-to do some research. I became ing up time has its origin inaware of how fragmented mytime childhood. There is a theory thatwas so I though it would be nice if children have a short attentionI could do my teaching and then span and therefore one shouldmy research and not have my change what they are doing andweek broken up withan hour here interrupt it. This is true if whatand an hour there. It was purely they are doing is boring. Some-selfish. how the idea of everything being

Tfien along came the CCCP in fifty minute chunks hasgrownwhich was an extensive study of and stayed with us.our curriculum. It set a stop to So the time seemed ripe andany other development, but it did we started putting it together, Ione very important thing asfaras first started the project in con-I was concerned: it authorized junction with other departments,project labs. I then worked on our but every time I found someoneproject lab which hits students who was really interested he wasvery well sometimes, and some- too busy or his department headtimes they get very frustrated. wouldn't let him do it.OneoftheMaybe they are learning that they problems is that innovators tenddo or don't want to become ex- to be the same fraction of theperimental physicists, the kind faculty, and they are all busy. Butthat work with apparatus rather I did get hints and encourage-than computers. I could see that ments.the lab suffered from meeting at Q. How about going into moreintervals and between times the detail on the structure of thestudents' apparatus would sort of course.come apart; people would borrow A. Well, any particular studentthings from it. spent a certain amount of time

Finally, I started to formalize working in a laboratory learningthis and put it together. It looked about certain instruments and la-nore and more to me thatconcen- ter applying the instrument to a That is more or less how the how to do them correctly, since

project part of it worked. I might one does such problems regularlysay that some students were who (as a physicist). I think that thewanted to have their hands held homework problems (and onethe whole time and some who could say that an MIT educationwanted to do ittheirwaywithno is coming and doing the threehelp whatsoever. Somewhere in thousand homework problems)the middle is a reasonable corm- are important but not equally sopromise. for everyone. It isn't right to

The reading and so on came make everyone come and do theout in the interviews. I would ask three thousand problems. Thesequestions about the homework students were generally very re-'How far along are you?' That has sponsible and thoughful peoplean evaluatory tone that bothers and they could tell themselvesthe students a little and they whether they should do more

. auto Omeurope..n n d~~~~~~~~~~~ept.

STUDENTIFACUITY GRANT ProgramS1pecial rates in European overseas travel1 for purchase, lease, & rental of cars. For

gadetails and brochu re write: University - Grant Dept., Auto Europe, 1270 Second E

Avenue, New York, New York 10021. Zedetails and brochure write: University _ssBSI ~~s ~~Bs~s

Ia

, N

', :I

en :

n-

:{s *'A

John King- Concencentrated Studies

You Can Bu ylhisIf You Want To

!:=2;~

The Association's Original SoundTrack Album Of "Goodbye Columbus"

on - WlarnerBos.- 7Arts Recora& & 7bpes

IMMAEDIATEVE1NTURE CAPITAL

AVAILABLEfor new businesses

We are looking for graduate students who have soundideas for new products or services as well as the capa-bilities to head up as principals new organizations tosee the projects culminated.

Reply only in writing, submitting detail plans. Do notinclude confidential infornmtion.

~~~~~~~o~~~~~·-Olobu~aEdw ,s, inc.

25 Broadway, New York, N.Y. 10004

Page 6: L I Open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N28.pdfRoad Song-Wes Montgomery Shape of Things to Come-George Benson SwnummertimePaul Desmond Betwixt & Between-Kai

. - ------ -- -- - -

Sm-IN isC

FOlyON AND

PerftctNEIoaiil

-~~~~~~~~~~~TAX

- -- I I I-

r~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~_ _l~l

_ 1

.----

---- �, -- -· ---,....,,,,,.... __,,, r -- rrrr-r··-· , .

ti

lafi-

I

I

tI

I

I

PAGE 6 WEDNESDAY, MAY 28, 1969 THE TECH

MI1T.

l^CARDN

ILEKOumtfD I VaughanBy Robert Mccall

The first recording of RalphVaughan William's 7th Sym-phony, based on themes from hissoundtrack of the film Scott ofthe Antarctic, uses some unusualtechiniques, making the albumworth noting. First: the insertionof spoken superscriptions at thebeginning of each movement bySir Ralph Richardson adds tre-mendously to the overall theme ofthe Antarctica journey of Scott,and also recalls other heros whofought nature and lost. Anothernovel device is a "wind machine"in the first and fifth movementsof the Symphony.

The movements suggest the dif-ferent moods of the explorers:arrival, setting off on the journey,,during it, and the end, as they dieof frostbite three miles from theirdestination. ";To suffer woeswhich hope think infinite..." be-gins the first movement (AndanteMaestoso), depicting the awesomemajesty of the southern wasteswhich the expedition is about tocross. Vaughan Williams introdu-ces a theme that is presentthroughout the Symphony (withthe. exception of the fourth move-ment) played by the bass instru-ments that express the drudgeryand monotony in all phases of thecrossing.

The second movement (Moder-ato) is a quick scherzo, which

slows~.down little by little into thebass theme. ";There go the shipsand there is that Leviathan..."Now they are alone and eager inthe task before them, the journeystarts quickly and easily, but thesnow, the cold, the wind, and thewolves are against them as theyreach the mood that is to prevailthroughout the crossing.

The third (Lento) is a musicaldescription of the landscape aboutthem, starting with the intricatebeauty at their fimgertips and thensuddenly rising in a majestic swellas if approaching a large barrier,elegant in its imposing nature.This movement. is, ironically, theweakest of the Symphony, calling-upon themes and moods fromother movements without suffi.cient development of any.

The fourth movement (An-dante Sostenuto) has no feeling ofAnarctica: it is warm and humnan,depicting the men inside the tentand away from the cold, the menwho can forget, for one briefmoment, that their lives are indanger. Yet, towards the end, thiswarmth dies off into nothingness,ike the fading flicker of an extin-

gwisned flame.Cinema orgnp

The lines for the last mnove-ment are taken from CaptainScott's Journal:"I do not regretthis journey; we took risks, weknew we took them, things havecome out against us, therefore, wehave no cause for complaint." TheEpilogue (Alla Marcia Moderato,ma non troppo)_has the forces ofnature finally -overpowering the'

theme that is re'lated to the men,but more in a way expressing anybrave man overwhelmed by cir-cumstances.

Vaughan Williams' SymiphonyNo. 7 is well done and is not, assome critics. have inferred, down-graded by the fact that it hascome out of the cinema. Othergreat composers of our time haverewritten concert music frowntheir movie scores, among -themShostikovich and Procoftoff, andlittle is said of them in this re-spect. Andre Previn has, perhaps,put too much embellishment intothe music; however this served tointensify the spectacular nature ofthe score. This Symphony is listedas the first of a series of VaughanIWilliams' Symphonies.

or

FULL ; PLYYtLON TUIELUS

650x13735nd0 x 14775/750 x 14825f80M x 14185/850 x 14775/670 x 15815/710 x 1585/70x 15

..Lr

220

s36

$257

i1l

"4e

NATION-WIDE GUARANTEE 0NO LIMIt ON MILES oNO LIMAT' ON MONTHS

~ft." _.." -TO" w 0 . Gw a_rrubakm' l ~.Ag -9- A ,,;.)

-1le a -W4 40 a dc" STATE

FRIEE IRE M0VNTEW&E MlrutPEOTO N

New England warehouse for P9l201

-DIELAARLA1I lot

THE 50,00Q0 Nu TM

CAMBRIDGE TIRlE COMPANYV1c- "Nationwido Wholwcle Warehouse DistributorsN290 ALBANY STREET * CAMBRIDGE. MASS. 02139 FREE

Off Mass. Ave. Near M. 1. T. WIN

GED * TELEPHONE 864-7575 * * * TIRES

ICE #6UURS.7:30 A.M. to S:30 P.M. CIHANGEDSWturdaV: 7:30 A.M. to 2.00 P.M. to

VTIES _ummOVER A HALF CENVTURY OF SERVICE

MEMIM: HaGAte 1STON AWD CAMMIDGE C1AMPRS OF ConUMCE

Pack your entire campus collection in a trunk.

Then call United. We'll pick up your trunk and sendit home, safe-and-sound, via air freight. Paynothing till it gets there. WI's the quickest, surestway to get your prized possessions home.Costs a lot less than you think.

United's a great way to get yourself home, dtoo. If you're a member of our 12-2 1.Club, make the trip for half-fare.Have a nice summer.

Call United Air Freight inBoston at 567450 0.

fiiendly, Onese0~~~~~~~~~

I | c '-ink i forpo',to patc:.: mys toothzbrushl'.Gi

SUMMER JOBS AVAILABLELearn while you earn

George Lerman Day CampNeeds male counselors

male waterfront specialistsmale crafts specialistsroale nature specialists

Lerman Day Camp is sponsored by

Associated Jewish Community Center,

a social work agency. A camp job withus will be particularly useful to stu-dents in social work, education,psychology.

Call: Robert MillerDirector of Camping542-1870 weekdays

e * * > h > | e· 2·3.:.:

:r ... ' .. . ·. ·... ., ~. > .: .e+ be

:.,, .>. .: . :i. A; r. .a. . e .. | ^: .> ..@~f-··:·2·it. :: @ i*4- .. . > >..,, >~is:~.: -;-^ :*^.; R | {-;. *; .A.>.- :A.*: :s -:: .:, .:. . Ne

A:: ; >--;X '··i ·2h" :^·. i ::!;4:

·. ":' , · ·-r- · , ...

I lORMiC.00

Unusual effects accentWTVilliams' 7th

Masicwsetts Institute of TechnologyFaculty. Staff, and Students

MAY PURCHASE

At Wholesale Prices

."Firtstone.r

$794

-149"$9$6

s$12g

$1496

BAKrERIES

INSTAUAMON

6 VO~ ,6 626 voII1 EXCH.

Fit ost CS" 7312 VOLT 7 EXCH

PULL Gewants* providers fw btedFoplacomnt FRas wainl90 dwo

go/800/v8x u l5se8"No Trade-In Required

|ATI SAME

P RtlCEsWE SELL

IOURW

NEVENLAR4

SERVIFACILI

7:lck up all yourcares and woes. And sweaters. And shoes.And those'Roge-r Williams LP's your grandmother sent you.

And the psychedelic poster that art major you were dating in Januarypainted so you'd have something to remember him by.

Page 7: L I Open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N28.pdfRoad Song-Wes Montgomery Shape of Things to Come-George Benson SwnummertimePaul Desmond Betwixt & Between-Kai

movie...'Teorema'- who wants to decipher it?

By Robert Fourer : more. ISymbolism in the arts, movies break d

in particular, can (and usually able andoes) fail for a wide -variety of able w;reasons. Mostly, though, the prob- deeds, alem is some combination of the ence ottwo simplest ones: the symbolism entirely;is too obvious, or too obscure. In nothing-the case of Teorema, the latest able disfilm by Pier Pasolini (of The is thickGospel According to St. Mat- obvious]thew), it is both, and the result is muchmore than doubly unfortunate. seemed 1

To begin with, Teorema is a Theparable; so its strength must lie in that theits symbolism, and little else. The plex syifilm opens, after a diffuse intro- viewer vduction that becomes clear only or at lealater, as a young man (Terrance ful paratStamp) comes to visit a middle- trying toclass Italian family. All of them- the urgemother, father, son, daughter, and and wamaid-are mysteriously, and usu- The scelally sexually, attracted to him; from boand he benevolently satisfies their especialldesires. After treating them all in ing his clturn, he is suddenly required to Of coleave (though the audience is was intenever told why); and again, one Pasoliniby one, his hosts come to him, deity tobegging him t6 stay. Their themes pherableare similar: he has changed their take sevself-knowledge, their whole out-look on life, and they cannot bear -

it without him.In short, Pasolini has created

the most obvious Christ-type fig- .'ure one could ever hope to see. If othe movie ended right there, there, Ewouldn't be much to puzzle,about-everything would be rea- ,sonably, if not entirely, clear cut. bThe director, however, has broad- "er ideas. After 'the young man *leaves-and he -is-not -seen.again- .lhe examines the five others once* cP .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

HuriWednesda, Thurs-Sa-Week of J* Shows* Sat armusymne

j

Now, one by one, theyown, but in an unpredict-Ld seemingly uninterpret-ay. Some perform goodand some bad; some influ-hers, and some withdraw; the daughter can do-she contracts an incur-ease. The symbolism herec and complicated, andly Pasolini -is working withmore than he at firstto be.trouble now, though, isappearance of this com-

mbolism is intrusive; thewishes it would go away,st resolve itself. A success-ble should tempt one intoo figure it out; in Teorema, is more just to sit backtch uncomprehendingly.rnes, in any case, are far)ring, and Pasolini has any haunting way of shoot-haracters.murse, it's possible the filmended this way-perhapswanted the effects of hisbe random and undeci-

.Unfortunately, it woulderal more viewings, and a

*. * UN 4-4580ounu

cC

Starts today Boston premiere of

John Huston's ·'SINFUL DAVEY"

r

TR 6-4226uouuC

mphrey Bogart time! 'iy only: "BEAT THE DEVIL;;at: "The African Queen' "June 1-7: "CASABLANCA" s daily 5:30, 7:30, 9:30and Sun matinees 3:30

IUUu flVllfl~flrlJ EIUU IB(BU

fair amount of curiosity, to checkeven this out. If anyone's reallyinterested, at least he could doworse.

One scene,the love-making epi-sode between the young visitorand the daughter; comes to anabrupt and uncharacteristic endwith what is by far the sloppiestjump cut in the entire film; it's asif the scene is supposed to reach aclimax as soon as the camerareaches the girl's breasts. It wouldbe hard to convince' anyone thatsomething hasn't been cut out;with all the fuss over censorship,-maybe someone should take alook at the changes that don'treach court.

* II. I LI,,.. I VVIL.A ILO..'T. I , IVIA /.IO, I u;I r Iu.- I

Relax and Divert

CAMPUS CUE590 Commonwealt Ave. .(Opposite B. U. Towers)

Pocket Billiards"6reur for a

* Date"'

MALE HELP WANTED

10 hours-$40

20 hours-$80

30 hours-$120

40 hours-$ 160

Requirements:

Neat appearance, car, bondable

No experience necessary, we will train

part-time and - full-time positions available.

..- For personal interview

Call 267-8870

"I know thewax homewith my eyes closed:

Then you know the way too well.Because driving an old familiar route can make you

drowsy, even when you're rested.When that happens, pull over, take a break '

and take two NoDoze Action Aids.* They'll help youdrive home with your eyes open. .

NoDoz Action Aids. No car should be without them. _wT.M. 01968 Bristol-Myers Co.

1 - -- --

Counselors wanted for inner city daycamp, male and female, artistic andathletic. Cambridge CampingAssociation sponsoring innovativeproject for disadvantaged July to midAug. Phone 547-8223 or UN4-0690

Il111

w

|

Tech students, turntextbooks for quickthe MIT Coop in theCenter.

in

cas

Stu

your;h atident

I

PARTHENON RESTAURANTA UTHENTIC GREEK CUISINE

EXCELLENT EUROPEAN AND AMERICAN WINESALL KINDS OF LIQUOR

UNIQUE HELLENIC ATMOSPHERE FEATURINGTHE ANCIENT GREEK PARTHENON

OPEN EVERY DAY1I a.m. to p.m.

Extremely Moderate PricesFor Reservations Call 491-9592

924 Mass. Ave.(BETWEEN HARVARD AND

CENTRAl SQUARES)

S.,

I-- -- - -~~~~~~~~~~~~1-----

I

I

--,.- . .

II

II[

LI

I

I

i

i

I

II

II

II

THPF TFrH w\ArCrjilqr)AV UAV 9A lIro Dri= -/

i

I

I

.:· -����-:. .... ·:·: .:-·:_·�·;-;-- . .r''-.::: ··:. ' ·:: -"`

·-·: � i ·.:i .i·i i :·:·.·: · :C ·:;:·.·:··'·:·:··:·..:''''''·:::�: +· ·.:.·:.:I .'C"�':·:: :�...:I.- ·.·.·;X-:·�.�:··:·' · .. ...., I,;::�i.·::·.·. ·.·::·...:·::.::.:

·-: ·̀: "": ..-·.. :·:· ·- ··:'

·:-...i·..�: i�::: ::·:: :.: :..r·:·:·:.

·: : ii·zii

:·' i 3

:· ,, ·::.:.�:�:�::::�::�::�j;�.·:1�-·- ·

Page 8: L I Open hearing considers grading tenuretech.mit.edu/V89/PDF/V89-N28.pdfRoad Song-Wes Montgomery Shape of Things to Come-George Benson SwnummertimePaul Desmond Betwixt & Between-Kai

PAGE 8 WEDNESDAY, MAY 28, 1969 THE TECH

- fWilson cracks New EnglandAE dumps: SAM for IA titlesteeplechase mark in 8:51.8

to the article in Science do notmean driving too fast, since thesimulator machines "drive" at afixed speed which the driver can-not change. Speedometer errors,the researchers say, "are related totime spent watching the speedo-meter."

It is impossible to tell, fromthe fact that a driver mad "speed-ometer errors," the article goeson, whether drugs would alter thespeed at which a person wouldnormally drive. But the research-ers say they have reason to believethat drivers "high" on marijuanawould drive more slowly thannormally, rather than faster'.

The testers recruited experi-enced marijuana users for most ofthe experiments, but also ran thetests on persons who had neverused the drug.

Iirecan

MEI~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Ml

I

By Pete PeckarskyBen Wilson '70 led the New

England IC4A's 3000 meter steeplechise from start to finish as-heset a conference record in thegrueling event. The Golden Jetwas favored to win the event andwas granted the pole position onthe starting line. After two laps,he had opened up twenty yards ofdaylight on the pack. Charlie Langof UMass closed the gap to fiveyards on Wilson midway throughthe race but was unable to ap-proach any closer. With two lapsto go, the Golden Jet cut in theafterburners and left Lang farbehind. Wilson streaked to thetape in the record time of 8:51 .8.His effort smashed the year-oldmark posted by 1968 BAA Mara-thon Champion Amby Burfoot of

-Wesleyan.In the three mile, Art Dulong

-Holy Cross distance phenom,and Wilson waged a battle royalefor the -first half of the race.Wilson shot out to the lead for the

first half mile in a typically quickstart. On the third lap, RichardSpurling of UConn and Dulongcame storming past. Wilson stayed-right, with them for a lap untilSpurting tired and faded. Wilsonshadowed D)ulong for the nexttwo laps until Dulong suddenlypulled away at the mile and one-half mark as the effects ofWilson's -record-setting steeple-chase race began to take their toll.The race ended with the runnersin that order.

Back in the pack, newly-elected 1970 outdoor track cap-tain Larry Petro '70 was fightingfor fifth place. Petro closed thegap to 20 yards on Ron Wayne ofUJMass with a lap to go. However,Paul Ho ss, of UMass slipped aheadof Petro in the final kick over thelast lap as Petro finished seventh.

On the strength of WilsonI's tenpoint -effort, MIT placed 15th inthe meet. Coast Guard and HolyCross tied at 35 points apiece forthe championship.

The intramural softball crownwas bitterly contested betweentwo even adversaries, SAE andSAM, until the SAElors clinchedthe game and the title on the last.pitch of the season. Winning pit-cher Don Paul's ground single upthe middle drove in the tying andwinning runs in the 7-6 triumph.

At the beginning of the game itappeared that the Sarnmies wouldrepeat their 12-4 clubbing of theSAElors. Al Czernicki led off witha lined single to left field. Withthe infield drawn in for the bunt,Stu Nernser poked a ground ballin the hole which the shortstopmake a fine stop on ,but couldn'tdo anything with. Ira Sacks load-ed the bases with a shot to leftfield. Rich Haberman's and KenGilbert's sinlgles drove in a runapiece to leave the bases stillplugged with no outs. -However,Paul induced the next two battersto pop up before walking rivalhurler Paul Sitkus and forcing inyet another score. SAE got out ofthe inning without any furtherdamage.

In the bottom of the secondSAE drews within one.

That's how twhe game stayeduntil the seventh as the Sarnmiescontinually got under Paul's softpitching. SAE didn't have muchsuccess against the hard throwingSitkus either. However, Sitkus, ledoff the top of the seventh with awalk. Rick Dorman forced him atsecond, but Czerniickci drove himall the way home with a misplaced

If you drinks

Photo by Gary DeBarW'nick '71 stretches vainly for over-SAE runner slides in safely.

it into foul territory, two runscame home to make the score 6-5.Sitkus bore down and poured twostrikes past Paul before the SAEhurler connected for the gamewinning hit.

SAM second baseman Ray Kwaslthrown peg from the catcher as an 'single to right. Infield was againdrawn for.Nemser, who. has areputation as a dangerous bunter,but Nemser crossed up the de-fense with a tremendous triple toright field. On the next pitchSacks made it 6-3 with a single tocenter. It appeared to be icing onthe cake with Sitkus pitching, butit was not to be.

Sitkus, w1ho was pitching hisfourth game in six days, lost hisstuff. Jim Seeger started it with ahard ground ball to left field. JeffHallock after creaming two longfouls lined a single to center.Colber Reisz dropped a perfectbunt down the third base line toload the bases. Chris Thurner thenchopped a high hopper towardsthird. When Haberman deflected

don't drive;

By Jag Zager Bentley pulled ahead to stay inThe long season came to its the sixth, asMontgomeryran into

quiet end last Friday as the varsity a streak of wildness. A single, a hitbaseball was defeated by Bentley batsman, and a walk, combinedCollege by a 5-4 margin. The loss with two wild pitches gave thegave the engineers a 6-15 mark, visitors a 5-3 lead.considerably below last year's re- In the bottom of the ninth, thecord of 11-12. In order to reach varsity came to life as Moosethis year's mark, the team had to' Freyberg led off with a walk. He

as MIT baseball coach came to anend. Individual statistics showBob Dresser as the team's leadinghitter with a .270 mark in 20games; John Compton was secondat .251, while Tech AllStar JeffWeissman hit .231 and led thesquad in Runs Batted In with 17.Leading the moundsmen wasDavid deWitte, who compiled a48 mark, while setting a new MITrecord for games won .in a career,as he was 44 in hisjunior year.

Next year's squad will be co-captained by Bob Gerber andBruce Wheeler, who is returningfrom a year at Princeton.

went to second on an error, andscored on a lined single off the batof senior Mike Neschleba, alsoplaying his last game. Neschlebaproceeded to steal second base,but died there'as Lee Bristol skiedto left to end the game, as well asthe season.

Thus, Fran O'Brien's first year

play .500 ball for the last eightgames.

Friday's game was another in aseries of close contests that mighthave gone either way. After twoscoreless innings, MIT came to lifein the bottom of the third, asTom Pipal reached second base ona throwing error, advanced tothird Oil a long fly ball, and scoredgon a passed ball. Starting pitcherPat Montgomery was able to holdthis lead for four innings as hepitched no-hit ball, but in the topof the fifth, the Bentley hitterswent to work. A walk and threesingles turned a 1-0 ballgame intoa 3-1 deficit, as well as ending thethreat of another shutout.

The Batsmen tied the score inthe bottom of the fifth, whenPipal led off with. a hit to leftfield. Dave deWitte, concluding afine career at Tech, followed witha long double to left field, puttingjrunners on second and third withnone out. Captain Lee Bristolsingled, home Pipal, and Bob Dres-ser knocked in deWitte with aninfield out.

(CPS) - A recent experimentdesigned to test the comparativeeffects of alcohol and marijuanaon driving performance has showngrass the winner in nearly everycategory. The research was repor-ted in the current issue of Science

The test, run in Seattle, Wash.,by the state's Department of Mo-tor Vehicles and medical profes-sors from the· University of Wash-ington; measured the responses ofindividuals intoxicated with alco-hol, high on marijuana, and innormal condition. The subjects,who were tested repeatedly over aperiod of weeks to prevent error,were placed inside a driving simu-lator which shows movies of dri-ving situations and measures thespeed and strengtlh of their re-sponses to te6 films.

The simulators, the Motor Ve-hicles department says, will soonreplace standard driving tests forWashington applicants for drivers'licenses. The machines, an officialsays, "test the quality of a per-son's driving--not just whetheror not he avoids violations."

The test subjects were mea-sured for steering errors, use ofturn signals at the wrong time,speedometer errors, and total er-rors.

In every case, and after re-peated tests, drivers who wereunder the influence of alcoholmade significantly more errors inall the categories except steering.Drivers who experienced a "nor-mal social marijuana high" mademore speedometer errors than theothers, but in all other areas theirdriving was exactly like that undernormal conditions. They alsomade the same number of totalsrrors as "normal" test subjects.

Sveedometer errors, according

Photo by Gary DeBardiDave Dewitte '69 beats out an infield hit in Wednesday's game againstNortheastern. The varsity ended the season with a 6-15 record bylosing a 5-4 decision to Bentley.

;h >. ^1 4-' cu

W .0 W 0

%O Ca ,,.0> Cobo

X Q l_ .C o

=>,C qb a In= _ °b 'Vty E' too~c.0V)jE Z co0'

Softball1. SAE2. SAM3. PDT4. Bexley 'A'S. LCA6. DU7. Burton 'A'8. Connor 59. Baker Z

ATOTheta ChiBurton 2

13. Sigma ChiSPESenior HouseBurton 3AStudent HousePhi Riamn Knnoa

Volleyball

1. Persians2. Graduate Economics3. Club Latino4. PSK 'A'5. Burton 2 'A'6. TEP 'A'7. Ashdown 'A'8. Burton 5 'A'9. PBE10. Burton 3 'A'11. Connor 5 'A'12. LCA13. Baker 'A'14. Connor I 'A'15. DTD

TDC

Soccer

i.PLP2. Bexley3. East Campus4. TD5. NRSA-ATO6. Baker A

ZBTDTD

9.SPE

6 Y

-P= t-,tl

IR)

i;

A.

E

Tech nine loses last game 54

and if you smoke.is

SAEj Persiani PL, win