kya zaeef hadees par amal kar sakte most importent
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
1/51
kya zaeef hadees par amal kar sakte hai??Is bat me shak nahi ki Is poori Ummat ke Hidayat aur Falah ka Zariya Quraan Kareem hai aur
Ahadees Nabwi a.s uski behtareen Taseer aur Tashreeh hai!aur yahi dono Islam ke "uniyadi
#akha$
hain!%ahan tak Quraan ki bat hai to iske &ahi hone me koi &hak ki 'un(aish hi nahi!.)ekin
(ahan tak
bat Ahadees ki hai to isme iski kai Qisme hain!.
!
%aise &ahi Hadees * Hasan Hadees * Zaee Hadees aur #o$u Hadees!.#o$u Hadees ko +hor
diya (aye
,kyonki ye bilkul bhi -abil e -ubool nahi to ba-i teeno tarah ki Ahadees na sir Qabil e Aihtram
hain balki Qabil e amal bhi hain!.
!
)ekin "ad-ismati se aa( ba$ lo' bari shiddat se ye bat phelane ki koshish karte hain ki Zaee
Hadees
bilkul bhi Qabil e aitmaad aur Qabil e amal nahi!."alki Amal ke laya- &ir &ahi Ahadees
hain!.Hamiska inkar nahi karte ki pehle &ahi Ahadees hi li (ayen'i!lekin (in umoor me &ahi Hadeesen
mo(ood na hon wahan Zahir si bat hai ki Zaee Hadees se hi istadlal karna pare'a!.Isliye
Zaee Hadees ki ahmiyat ko bhi na$ar anda$ nahi kara (a sakta!Kyonki /een ke kitne hi masail
in Zaee Hadeeson se hi &abit hain!..(inpar 0oori Ummat Amal kar rahi hai!
!
Aur ek khas 1r-e Naam Nihad Ahle Hadees , 2hair #u-allideen ka Ahnaa par ye il$am bilkul
'halat
hai ki wo &ahi Hadees ke mu-able me Zaee Hadees ko tar(eeh dete hain aur Ahnaa ke masail
ki
"uniyad Zaee Ahadees hain!..kyonki bohot si Hadeesen &anadan Zaee hoti hain )ekin
/oosre Qarain
se inka #a$moon &abit hota hai!aur wo Qarain itne #a$boot hote hain ke inko kisi bhi tarah
na$aranda$ nahi kiya (a sakta hai
!
&abse pehle Zaee Hadees ki Taree %an lete hain!Ulama ne Zaee Hadees ki Taree ku+h yoon
ki hai 3
!
) $# "! %&' ) )16 ,
!
4ani Hadees Zaee wo hai (isme na &ahi Hadees ke &harait (ama hon aur na hi Hasan Hadees
ke
&harait (ama hon!
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
2/51
Ulama ne aamtor par isi taree ko ikhtiyar kara hai!.)ekin ek bat yahan 'haur karne ke laya-
hai aur
wo ye Ki #uhaddiseen (ab kisi Hadees par Zaee ka hukm la'ate hain to wo Uski &anad ke
aitbar se
la'ate hain * uske #atan , #a$moon aur #ahoom ke aitbar se nahi!..%abki Fu-ha Hadees ko
Uski &anad se $yada uske #atan ke aitbar se $yada parakhte hain!..aur wese bhi #u(tahideen
aur Fu-ha ki Hadeeson ke #ayne * #urad aur #ahoom ko behtar (anne wale hain! Isliye
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
3/51
$aroori nahi ki (ab #uhaddis kisi Hadees ko Zaee kahe to wo 5a-ai me Zaee ho* &anad uski
Zaee ho sakti lekin #atan ,#a$moon bhi uska Zaee ho ye Zaroori nahi!.
!
Isliye Tadreeb Ul 6awi me Zaee Hadees ki bahas me aapko ye ibarat mile'i
!
7 ," +** ) - !, ./ 0 1 / ! 2 3, 0 4 5 6 7 89 # $ ) 6 8 # :, ; )
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
4/51
Isi Tarah Ha$rat Ibn Hammam r.a bhi apni Kitab Fathul Qadeer me armate hain ki 3 7Hadees ko
Hasan
ya &ahi ya Zaee kehna sir &anad ke liha$ se Zanni tor par hai * wa-ae
,asal me (aya$ hai ki &ahi 'halat ho aur Zaee &ahi ho8!., Fathul Qadeer 9:;
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
5/51
Iske Alawa Ha$rat Ibn &alah r.a apni mayanaa$ Kitab #u-addamah Ibn &alah me armate hain 3
7#uhaddiseen (ab kisi Hadees ko 2hair &ahi batate hain to ye is Hadees ke Fil 5a-ae ,asal
Ki$b par
ya-een nahi hota * isliye ki Hadees 2hair &ahi bhi kabhi 5a-ai me
&a+h+hi hoti hai!isse to itni murad hoti hai ki iski &anad is sharat par nahi %o #uhaddiseen ne
&ahat
keliye mu-arrar ki hai8!.
, #u-addamah Ibn &alah :
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
6/51
/ekhiye &+an
Isi liye Ha1$ Ibn Abdul "ar r.a ne apni Kitab 7Al Tamheed8 me likha hai ..
!
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
7/51
8 ***08 **************# **** ****************** ****************** **************1 "
4ani "ohot si Ahadees &anad ke aitbar se Zaee hoti hain lekin #ayne ke aitbar se &ahi hoti
hain!..
Aur is bat ka i-rar khud 2hair #u-allideen ke Aalimon ko bhi hai!isliye Fatawa Ulama e
Hadees me
hai 3 Neend Na-is e wu$u hai aur inki dalil Zaee Hadeeseen hain!.so wo Asnad ki haisiyat se
mardood hain aur mayne ke liha$ se ma-bool hain!., Fatawa Ulame e Hadees >;
/ekhiye &+an
In sab baton se pata +hala ki #uhaddiseen (ab kisi Hadees par Zaee hone ka hukm la'ayen to
wo
hukm uski &anad ke liha$ se hota hai * matan , #a$moon ke liha$ se nahi!.aur Alhamdulillah
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
8/51
(aisa ki
pata +hala ki &anad ke Zaee hone se uske #atan ka Zaee hona la$im nahi aata!.
!
Zaee Hadeeson par amal ko lekar &abse bari &hahadat to Imam Tirmi$i r.a apni Kitab &unan
Tirmi$i
me dete hain!.Kitni hi Hadeeson ko na-al karne ke bad Imam Tirmi$i r.a armate hain
!
8 Iski &anad Qawi nahi!,)ekin phir bhi Ulama &ahaba r.a ka isi Hadees par amal hai 8
!
4ahan ek aham bat yad rakhni +hahiye ki %ab Imam Tirmi$i r.a kisi Hadees ke bad ye armayen
ki ye
Hadees 2hareeb ,Zaee hai lekin &ahaba r.a aur Ahle Ilm ka ispar amal hai!.Iska matlab 'oya
wo
Hadees Imam Tirmi$i r.a ke na$deek &ahi hai!.. A'ar+he #uhaddiseen ki shart ke mutabi-
,&anadan
Zaee hai * lekin uska #atan Na &ir Qawi hai balki Qabil?e?amal bhi hai!.isliye unhone Zaee
hone ka
hukm &anad par la'aya hai aur +hunki uska #atan aur #a$moon sahi tha isliye uspar &ahaba
r.a ke
amal ki bat kahi hai!.(ab hi to armate hain ki &ahaba r.a aur Ahle Ilm ,Fu-ha ka ispar amal
hai!..kyonki wese bhi Fu-ha ke na$deek &anad se $yada uska #atan aham hota hai!..aur
Fu-ha hi
Hadees ke #ayne aur #urad ko behtar (ante hain!.
!
Aur wese bhi Ulama ye Qaida (ante hain ki 3 %ab #u(tahid kisi Hadees se istadlal kare to ye uske
&ahi
hone ki /alil hai!, Qawaid Uloom ul Hadees @>
!
Isliye Ha$rat Ibn Hummam r.a Imam Tirmi$i r.a ke in a-wal ke bare me armate hain3 74e (umlata-a$a karta hai is Hadees ki asal Qawi hai * a'ar+he Khas ye &anad $aee hai!.,Fathul
Qadeer =>
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
9/51
Ha$rat &haukani r.a bhi apni kitab Neel ul Auwtar me na-al karte hain ki 8 0hir Ha$rat Ibn Abdul
"ar
r.a ne ,bawa(ood sanad Zau ke iski &ahat &ahi hone ka hukm la'aya hai* Ulama ke isko
-ubool kar
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
10/51
lene ki wa(ah se!. "as radd kara hai isko &anad ke aitbar se aur -ubool kara hai iske #ayne
, #a$moon ke aitbar se!.aur hukm la'aya hai aisi ba$ Ahadees par %o is dar(e par nahi
pohon+hi balki iske -areeb bhi nahi pohon+hi!. , Nail ul Auwtar
!
In sab baton se pata +hala ki Zaee Hadeesen Aamtor par Zaee &anad ke aitbar se hoti hain *
#ayne ke aitbar se nahi!.Tab hi ko Aksar 5o Ulama %o Hadees ko Zaee keh rahe hote hain *
5ahi uspar amal kar rahe hote hain!.Kyonki 5o Hadees #ayne ke hisab se &ahi hoti hain!
Zaee Ahadees par Amal ki ku+h &oorten 3?
Zaee Hadees "aab e Ahkaam me3
%ahan tak Ahkaam e &hariyyah me Zaee Hadees ke istemal ka tallu- hai to %amhoor
#uhaddiseen o
Fu-aha ke tar$ e amal se saa $aahir hai ki Zaee se Hukm e &harii par istadlal kiya (asakta hai
* bashart yeh keh Zau shadeed na ho yani sanad me koi #uttaham ya Ka$$ab rawi na ho*
Zaee se istadlal ki +hand soorten hain!
!
0ehli soorat3 #asale me is ke ilawah koi #a$boot daleel na ho* mukhtali makaatib e 1kr ke
tallu- se iski Taseel hasbe $ail hai3?
=Hana1yyah3?
!
i Imam Abu Haneea 6ahmatullahi alaih ka Irshad hai
8
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
11/51
us ke $au par #uhaddiseen mutta1- hain aur Hana1yah ne -iyaas na kar ke is ko mamool bih
banaya!
> 1/31,325 ,
ii #uha--i- Ibnul Hummam r.a armate hain
8 *, ** *: * ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** * ****D ******************************K EI**** ******************************1 !&9E
L
Zaee (o mau$oo ki had tak na pohon+hi hui ho us se istehbaab sabit hota hai .,Fathul Qadeer
"aab
Nawa1l
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
12/51
&haai 3?
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
13/51
i Ha1$ Ibn Qayyam r.a ne na-al kara hai ki Imam &haai r.a ke na$deek Zaee Hadees Qayas
par
mu-addam hai * Ghunan+he unhone Haram #akki ke andar Au-at #akrooha me Nama$ parne
ke (awa$
wali hadees ko Zau ke bawa(ood Qayas par mu-addam kiya hai !
*** **************0 4***5 ************** "** ************** ****4& **"5************** **************Y * **< * ** ** ** ** ** ** *
ko apne ek -ol ke mutabi- bawa(ood $aee ke Qayas par tar(ih di !
> 41/15 ,
/ekhiye &+an
Hanabala 3?
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
14/51
Ibn Na(aar Hambali ne &harah Al Kokab ul #uneer , @>;
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
15/51
Ha1$ Harwi r.a ne Zamm il Kalam me Abdullah bin Ahmad se na-al kiya ki #aine apne walid se
poo+ha ki ek shakhs ko masla darpesh hai aur shahar me ek #uhaddis hai * %o
$aee hai , ek riwayat me hai 3 wo &ahi aur sa-eem me tami$ nahi kar pata aur ek Fa-ih hai (o
Ahle
6ai aur Qayas me se hai * wo kisse masla poo+he Farmaya 3 Ahle 6ai se to poo+he nahi *
kyonki Zaee
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
16/51
ul Hadees Qawi ul 6ai se behtar hai!
, Zamm il Kalam =>*=B
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
17/51
Fi-ah Hambali ki #astand tareen kitab 7Al #u'hni8 me Ibn Qaddamah r.a ne likha hai
8 **** *********** ************ *********2 ,&3*** *********! ********* ) ZD*** *********" ********* ) 8
4ani Nawa1l aur Fa$ail me sahi Hadees ka hona shart nhi
Nee$ Imam ke khutbe ke doran Ha$reen ke Ihtaba , Is tarah bethna ki sureen $ameen par ho
aur dono 'hutne khare hon * aur dono ba$uon ya kisi kapre wa'herah se inhe bandh liya (aye ki babat likha ki koi hara( nahi * ki Ghand ek &ahaba r.a se marwi hai * lekin na karna behtar hai
* kyonki Hu$oor a.s se marwi hai ki Aap a.s ne Imam ke khutbe ke doran habwah se mana
armayahai!.Isliye a'ar+he Hadees $aee hai * a$al habwah ka tark karna hai !.
08M88,206/2 ,
@ Fu-aha aur #uhaddiseen 3?
i Ha$rat Ibn Qayyam r.a armate hain ki 8 4ani aamtor par bhi &abhi Aima is bare me Imam
Ahmad
bin Hambal r.a ke muwa1- hain * Aima me se koi bhi aisa nahi %o Zaee Hadees ko Qayas par
#u-addam na rakhta ho !.
> 25/15 ,
0hir "a-ayda #isalon se sam(haya bhi hai ki kis Tarah Imam Abu Hania r.a aur dee'ar Aima
r.a ke
na$deek Zaee Hadees bhi Qayas par #u-addam hai!.
ii Imam Abu /aood r.a ke mutalli- Ha$rat Ibn Ha(ar r.a ne na-al kara 3? 8 Imam Abu /aood r.a
ka
ma$hab hai ki (ab kisi "ab me $aee Hadees ke alawa nahi milti * to ise ikhtiyar kar lete hain *
kyonki $aee Hadees inke na$deek Qayas se Qawitar hai !. [ 045 KT8436 ,
iii Ha1$ Ibn Ha(ar r.a isi Kitab me armate hain ki Imam Abu /aood r.a ne (in Ahadees ko $ikr
karke inpar sukoot ikhtiyar kiya hai * wo 9 -ism ki hain..
a "a$ wo hain %o "ukhari aur #uslim me mo(ood hain ya wo &ahi ki shart par hain!
b "a$ wo hain %o Hasan )i$atihi ke -abeel hain
+ "a$ wo hain %o Hasan )i'hairihi hain
d "a$ wo hain %o Zaee hain!.
0hir armate hain 3
8 *** **********\ &' *** **********# 4$** **********6 8 **5 * ** ** ** ** * **!> ********** 6 * **; ******* ** *) "
4ani Tamam Qismen Imam Abu /aood r.a ke na$deek Ahta(a( ke -abil hain !..
[ 045 KT8435 ,
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
18/51
Zahiriyah 3?
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
19/51
Abu #uhammad Ibn Ha$am Zahiri (inka Tashaddud mashhoor hai * apni Kitab 7Al #uhalla8 me
ruku se pehle Qunoot parne se mutalli- Hadees bariwayat Hasan bin Ali r.a laye * aur iske
mutalli- likhte hain 3
4e Hadees a'ar+he is laya- nahi ke isse istadlal kiya (aye * lekin Ghunke 6asoollAllah a.s se is
silsile me
aur koi Hadees hame nahi mili * isliye ham ise ikhtiyar karte hain!..
61/304 ,
/JJ&6I &JJ6AT 3?
A'ar $aee Hadees par amal karne me ahtiyat ho * to isko tamam Ha$raat ikhtiyar karte hain *
Ghunke
Imam Nauwi r.a ne Kitab 7Al A$kar8 me amal bil Zau ki soorton ko $ikr karte hue armaya 3
8 &8
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
20/51
Imam Ahmad r.a armate hain 3
8 %ab Halal aur Haram ki bat aaye'i to Asaneed , &anad ki (an+h parakh me sakhti se kam
len'e aur
%ab Fa$ail Aamal , Tar'heeb aur Tarheeb ki bat aaye'i to ham Asaneed me Tasahul , Narmi
"arten'e 8 L yani isme Zaee Hadees bhi na-al karen'e M!, Al Kiaya =;9
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
21/51
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
22/51
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
23/51
Imam Ahmad r.a ki yahi bat Ha$rat Ibn Taimiya r.a ne apne Fatawa , &aah :@< %ild =B me bhi
na-al
Kari hai!
Imam Nauwi r.a ki Kitab 7Arbain8 ki &harah Fathul #ubeen me Ibn Ha(ar #akki r.a ke Ala$ hain
8 4ani Fa$ail Aamal me Zaee Hadees par amal ke bare me Ulama ka ittea- hai * kyonki a'arwo 5a-iatan &ahi thi * to isko iska Ha- mil 'aya * warna ispar amal karne se na to Haram ko
Halal karna la$im aaya aur na iske baraks ,ulta * aur na hi kisi 'hair ka Ha- pamal ,barbad
karna !!8
[ ^ N4 N_!`a ,
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
24/51
Ha$rat Nauwi r.a Apni Kitab A$kar me armate hain 3
7#uhaddiseen aur Fu-aha aur unke alawa Ulama ne armaya hai ki Zaee Hadees par amal
karna Fa$ail
aur Tar'heeb aur tarheeb me %aya$ aur #ustahab hai!(abki wo Hadees #an'harat na ho8!..
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
25/51
, A$kar
;=
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
26/51
%aisa ki Ar$ kiya 'aya ki Zaee 'hair mo$u A-aid wa Ahkam ke alawa me %amhoor ke na$deek
Qabil e Amal hai!.A-aid aur Ahkam me "ab me Tashaddud aur Fa$ail * Tar'heeb wa Tarheeb ke
mamle me Narmi ki bat Imam Ahmad r.a aur Imam Hakim r.a se na-al Kari 'ayi!..
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
27/51
)ekin ku+h ke na$deek Ahkam me bhi Zaee Hadeeseen Qabil e istadlal hain!.%aisa ki Imam
Ahmad r.a aur Imam Abu /aood r.a ke -ol se pata +hala!.ki a'ar "ab me koi aur Hadees na ho
to usko +horte nahi hain!Ahkam me bhi Zaee Hadees Ke Qabil e -ubool hone ki Tasreeh
Ha$rat Ibn Ha(ar Asa-alani r.a ne apni Kitab 7Al Nukt Ibn &alah8 aur Ha$rat &uyuti r.a ne
7Tadreeb ul 6awi8 me ki hai ki Zaee Hadees Ahkam me bhi Qabil e amal hai!.aur (aisa ki
Ha$rat Nauwi r.a ne armaya ki a'ar usme Ahtiyat ka pehloo hai to ispar amal (aya$ hai!
Teesri &oorat 3?
Kisi Hadees ko Tala--i "il Qubool Hasil ho (ana 3
A'ar kisi Hadees ko Tala--i bil Qubool hasil ho (aye aur iske mutabi- Fu-aha* Ahle Ilm ya aam
Ummat ka amal ho (aye!.Tab to Zaee Zaee hi nahi rehti balki iske $ariye 5u(oob aur
&unniyat tak ka suboot hota hai!.
%aisa ki Ha$rat Allama %a$airi r.a armate hain 8 Aur %ab koi #ursal Hadees ho ya koi aisi Hadeesho
(iske kisi rawi me $au ho aur ham ye dekhen ki sab lo'on ka ispar I(maa hai aur sab iske -ayal
hain!
To ya-eenan ham ye %an len'e ki wo Hadees &ahi hai aur isme koi &hak nahi hai!., To(ihun
Na$ar &aah @
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
28/51
%aisa ki Ha$rat %alal Uddeen &uyuti r.a 7Tabreeb ul 6awi8 Kitab me armate hain ki 7"a$
#uhaddiseen
armate hain ki Hadees par &ahat , &ahi hone ka hukm la'a diya (aye'a * %ab Ummat ne ise
Qubool
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
29/51
kar liya ho!.a'ar+he iski &anad &ahi na bhi ho!..
aa'e na-al kara ki Ha$rat Ibn Abdul "ar r.a Kitab 7Al Asta$kar8 me ye bat Imam Tirmi$i r.a se
na-al karte hue armate hain ki Imam "ukhari r.a is Hadees Al "ahar 7Huwat Tahuru #aauhu8
ko &ahi kehte hain!Halanki #uhaddiseen is (aisi &anad wali Hadees ko sahi nahi kehte lekin
Hadees mere na$deek , Ibn Abdul "ar r.a &ahi hai kyonki Ulama me isko Tala--i bil Qubool
hasil hai!.. , Tadreeb ul 6awi
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
30/51
Isi kitab me aa'e armate hain ki
8 Ibn &amaani r.a aur ek %amaat ye kehti hai ki Hadees ke muwa1- I(maa ka hona* ye Hadees
ki
&ahat ,&ahi hone par /alalat karta hai!Is Hadees ke is bat ko muta$ammin hone ki wa(ah se
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
31/51
ki isko tala--i bil -ubool Hasil hai!..
, Tadreeb ul 6awi =>
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
32/51
Ha$rat &akhawi r.a ne Fathul #u'hees me kaha hai ki 8 %ab Ummat Hadees Zaee ko -ubool
karle to &ahi yahi hai ki ispar amal kiya (aye!yahan tak ki wo 4a-eeni aur Qatii Hadees ko
#ansookh karne me #utawatar Hadees me dar(e me sam(hi (aye'i!aur isi wa(ah se Imam
&haai r.a ne Hadees 7)a 5asiyyat )i 5aris8 ke bare me ye armaya hai ki isko Hadees ke Ilm
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
33/51
wale , Ulama e Hadees sabit nahi kehte hain lekin Aama Ulama ne ise -ubool kar liya hai aur
ispar amal karte hain* yahan tak ki isko Aayat 5asiyat ka Nasikh -arar dete hain!., Fathul
#u'hees =@;
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
34/51
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
35/51
Ha$rat Zahid Kausari r.a bhi apni Kitab me armate hain 3
8 Aima ka bator dalil kisi Hadees ko le )ena ye unki tara se us Hadees ko &ahi Qarar dena
ho'a *
"alki Tamam %amaaton ke %amhoor Ahle Ilm is Usool par hain ki Khabar e 5ahid ko Ummat (ab
uski
Tasdee- karte hue Qubool karle to ye Ilm e 4a-eeni ka Fayda deta hai!
, #a-alat Kausari B
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
36/51
2hair #u-allideen ke 'har ka hal 3?
In sab Hawalon ke bad aayen dekhen khud 2hair #u-allideen ke Akabireen ka Zaee Hadees
aur uspar amal ke bare me kya khayalat hain!.
=3? 2hair #u-allideen ke &haikh ul Islam &anaUllah Amratsari &ahab Fatawa &anaiya me &awal
ke %awab me armate hain 3
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
37/51
8 Zaee Hadees ke sath bhi %o Fel ,amal sabit ho wo "idat nahi hota * aisa Tashaddud karna
a+h+ha
nahi!. , Fatawa &anaiya @=
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
38/51
amal hai* Khusoosan Imam "eh-ee
,r.aaur Imam Ibnul #an$ar ,r.a ka 6iwayat kar ke Is se Istadlaal karna aur 0hir &adiyon se
#uhaddiseen ka Is par Taamul Qabil?e?Amal hai.8
, Fatawa &anaiya @@
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
39/51
Isi Fatawa ek &awal ke %awab me Farmate hain3 8 Is Hadees me a'ar+he $au hai * ma'ar
Taamul Ahle Ilm ka is Hadees ke $au ko 6aa , door karta hai!(aisa ki Usool Hadees me hai
ki Taamul Ahle Ilm se Hadees ka Zau 6aa ,door hota hai!., Fatawa Na$eeriya 9==;
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
40/51
8
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
41/51
Aur apni doosri Kitab &unan Tirmi$i ki &harah Tohatul Aho$i me armate hain
**!= +*****) **N ****** **O;** ***T** *** *** ***U*** ***U****" ****** ***U*** **!"0** ****E1*** ;******* ****** 601/1(*** 5***4 0** ,
4ani is "ab ki Hadees par amal karna hi behtar hai aur Aula hai isliye ki ye Hadees a'ar+he
Zaee hai
ma'ar iska &hahid mo(ood hai!.
, Is ibarat se pata +hala ki #aulana #ubarakpuri &ahab ke na$deek A'ar Hadees Zaee bhi ho
lekin
uske doosre &hahid mo(ood hon * to wo Hadees Qabil e Hu((at L yani Qabil e amal M ho (ati hai
:3? Fatawa Ulama e Hadees me hai 3 8 Zaee Hadees (abke Khair ul Qurun me mamool baha ho
to wo Ummat ke han #a-bool hai!, >
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
42/51
Nawab &iddi- Hasan &ahab Farmate hain 3 8 A'ar Koi Hadees &anad ke aitbar se Zaee bhi ho
lekin
iske #a$moon par poori Ummat ka amal ho * to is Hadees par amal karna $aroori ho (ata hai.
Hatta ki
isko Zaee kehne wale Ulama bhi ispar amal karte hain !
N8 N",,
B 3? #aulana Ismail &al1 &ahab ek Hadees ke bare me armate hain 3
8 Ibn #a(ah ki is Hadees ko Zaee
hone ke bawa(ood %amhoor Ummat ne Qubool kiya hai !8
+,T bR/ N,441 ,
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
43/51
3? #akalat Noor 0uri me ek Hadees ki Zau ko tasleem karne ke bad armaya 'aya hai 8
/oosre
&hawahid aur iske ham mayne doosre tara- ki bina par isme Quwwat peda ho +huki hai aur
iska Zau (ata raha hai 7!., #akalat Noor 0uri @B
= 2hair #u-allideen ke #uha--i- ul Asar Nasir Uddeen Albani (inki teh-ee- par 'hairmu-allideen
ko na sir naa$ hai aur poora ya-een hai aur andha aitmaad bhi wo bhi Zaee Hadeeson par
amal ko
lekar kya armate hain mulay$ha ho!
Nis &haaban ki Hadees $ikr karne ke bad %o armate hain * uska khulasa pesh hai!
8 "a$ 6iwayaten "a$ ko Quwwat pohon+hati hain!hasil kalam ye ki ,Nis &haaban wali
Hadeesen #a(mui liha$ se bila shuba &ahi hain * iski &ahat me koi &huba nahi!&ahat to isse
kam Taadad se sabit
ho (ati hai * Zau a'ar 2hair &hadeed ho * (aisa ki ye Hadees $er?e?bahas hai !.8
N$ 7 N44138/3 ,
== Halanki Ha$rat Ibn Taimiya r.a mu-allid ,Hambali hain * lekin +hunki 'hair mu-allideen
inke kai
hawale na-al karte hain aur inki baton aur teh-ee- par aitmaad karte hain * isliye hawala
na-al kara (a raha hai!
Ha$rat Ibn Taimiya r.a armate hain 3
4eh Ahadees Inme &e Aksar Aisi hain ki a'ar unme se Kisi ek Hadees ki &anad Alaahida Kardi
%aaye Toh
5o &anad Kisi Halke 4a &akht
Kalaam &e Khaali Nahi Ho'i!)ekin &anad Ka Taadud Aur Kasrat??Tar- &e Nasul Amr #e
,4aani Ha-i-at 5a-iya Ke Aitebaar &e Un Ahadees Ke &aabit Hone Ke 2humaan?e?2haalibKa Faida Haasil Hota Hai!.
, Fatawa Ibn Taimiya 9;
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
44/51
2hair #u-allideen ke Akabireen ki in ibaraton se bhi yahi pata +halta hai ki inke bare bhi kahin
na kahin Zaee Hadees ke Qabil e Hu((at aur Qabil e amal hone ke -ayal rahe hain!.lekin
mo(ooda dor ke ku+h lo' Zaee Hadees ko lekar to taree-a ikhtiyar kiye hue hain wo kisi bhi
tarah sahi nahi!.
Ab masla ye bhi peda hota hai ki Zaee Hadees par amal ki kya soorten hain aur kab wo Qabil e
amal ban (ati hai!.aur kin &harait aur umoor ko dhyan me rakhte hue uspar amal karna (aya$
hai!.
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
45/51
Zaee Hadees kab Qabil?e?amal ban (ati hai!.
A'ar Zaee me ku+h Qarain paye (ayen to us Hadees ka Zau Khatm ho (ata hai aur wo Qabil e
Istadlal
aur Amal ke -abil ho (ati hai!.
= A'ar koi Hadees Kai #ukhtali Tar- yani kai &anadon se #arwi hai to usse us Hadees ka Zau
khatm
ho (ata hai!Iski wa(ah se wo Hadees #autbar * Qawi aur Qabil e amal ban (ati hai!4ahi bat
Nu$hatun
Na$ar me Ha$rat Ibn Ha(ar r.a ne* Tadreeb ul 6awi me Ha$rat &uyuti r.a * aur #ee$an ul Kubra
me Ha$rat &hairani r.a na-al karte hain!..aur (iski Tasreeh Khud 2hair #u-allideen ke Aalim
#aulana
Abdur 6ahman #ubarakpuri 7Abkar ul #anan8 me aur Abdullah 6opri 8 Fatawa Ahle Hadees8
me karte
hain!..
Ha$rat Ibn Ha(ar r.a armate hain ki 7#astoor ,(iske halat maloom na ho ki Hadees %o Zaee
hoti hai (ab Taddud Tara- ,kai &anadon se moid ho (aye to Hasan )i'hairihi ho (ati hai !.8
,c8 N;>/78 ,
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
46/51
/oosra Qarina ye hai ki wo Hadees Zaee kisi Asal &harii dalil ke muwa1- ho!Khuwah koi Nas
Quraani ho* Qol?e?&ahaba r.a ho ya &hariat ka koi Qayda aur Zabta ho * Us #a$moon wa
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
47/51
#ayne ka doosri Hadees me paya (ana !
89d5 045 KT8,
; Ibn Ha(ar r.a ne $ikr armaya hai a'ar koi aisa Qarina mil (aye %o Hadees Zaee ko Qubool
karne
,aur ispar amal karne ko 6a(eh bataye to isko Hasan )i'hairihi kehte hain !. ,c8 N;>/68 ,
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
48/51
Zaee Hadees par amal ke &harait3?
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
49/51
Han ye $aroor hai ki $aee Hadees ka saboot mohtamil hota hai * isliye isse istadlal ke wa-t
ku+h umoor ka liha$ rakhna $aroori hai * Ha1$ &akhawi r.a ne Al Qol ul "adii me Ha1$ Ibn Ha(ar
r.a se na-al kara hai ki 3
Zaee Hadees par amal ki ; &harten hain 3?
=3? 4e $au 'hair shadeed ho * Ghunan+he wo Hadees (iski riwayat tanha aise shakhs se ho %o
Ka$$ab
ya mutham bil ki$b * ya Fahish ul 'halat ho * Khari( ho'i!.
3? Iska #a$moon Qawaid &haria se kisi -ayde ke tahat aata ho!. +hunan+he wo ma$moon
khari( u$
amal ho'a %o maha$ ikhtraii ho.. Usool?e?&haria me se kisi asal se mel na khata ho!
;3? Ispar amal karte wa-t iske saboot par a-eeda na rakha (aye * balki sir iske sawab ke husool
kiummeed ke sath kiya (aye!#ubada aan Ha$rat #uhammad a.s ki (anib ek bat %o wa-ae ne
aapne na
armayi ho* iska Aapki tara mansoob karna la$im aa (aye !
[ ^ N4 N_!`e ,
/ekhiye &+an
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
50/51
In &ab baton ke bad Alhamdulillah maloom hua ke Hadees par Amal karne 4a Na karne ka
#aiyaar
sir Quwwat?e?&anad aur Zau?e?&anad nahi balke Iske liye Ku+h aur Usool bhi hain* (isme khara
utarne
ke bad Zaee Hadees bhi Qabil e amal ban (ati hai!.&anad to isliye hai taki &anad ke $ariye
-
7/24/2019 Kya Zaeef Hadees Par Amal Kar Sakte Most Importent
51/51
maloom
ho %aaye ke 4e Hadees #o$u hai 4a 2hair?#o$u
hai!Kahin Hadees banai hui to nahi!
Isliye %ab &anad se pata +hal %aaye ki Hadees %HJJTI nahi hai to Ab iske bad Hadees par amal
Karne 4aNa Karne ke liye &anad ko Nahi dekha %aye'a balki Hadees ko Amal
"il?Hadees ke Usoolon par 0arkha
%aaye'a!.aur unpar Khara utarne ke bad Zaee Ahadees bil Ittea- Qabil e Qubool ho'i!.
"aharhal Hamari 2u$arish ka hasil ye hai Zaee Ahadees ka inkar karna * unhe -abil e amal na
manna *
aur in ko Ahadees ki eherist se khari( kar dena!.. 4e Aslaa ke Tar$ wa Amal ke khila hai!. ye
wa-t
ha$ir ka 1tna hai aur ye &hariat Islamia ke sath dosti nahi balki dushmani hai!./een ke naam
par
"edeeni hai!aur Hadees ka i-rar nahi balki inkar ka rasta kholne wala aur #unkir e Hadees ki&a me
khud ko khara karne wala amal hai!.
Hasil 2u$arish ye ki Zaee Hadees ka Aima #uta-adimeen ne masail &haria me aitbar kiya
hai!.aur
ispar apne amal ki "uniyad bhi rakhi hai!.Inka inkar karna /in ke U(ale me Ghand ka inkar
karna hai *
a'ar+he wo &oora( ki roshni me aankhon se o(hal $aroor hota hai * lekin uska 5a(ood khatm
nahi
hota!..Isi tarah a'ar+he Zaee Hadees &anad ke aitbar se $aee ho lekin aksar #atan se aitbar
se &ahihoti hai * Isliye Ulama uska inkar karne ke ba(aye usko amal me late hain!..
A))AH Taala se /ua hai wo hame /een ki &ahi &am(h ata kare!aur Ahadees e 6asoollAllah a.s
ki i$$at
aur ahtraam aur Unpar Amal ki tauee- ata kare!.Aameen