kpp202 ms till webb.ppt...
TRANSCRIPT
Synopsisy
• What is performance measurement (PM)?
• A historical perspective
• The Balanced Scorecard (BSC)The Balanced Scorecard (BSC)
• Keeping it real
• Hoshin Kanri
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control2
BeehiveBeehive
Group up (2-4 individuals per group).p p ( p g p)
Discuss the question below for a couple of minutes.
W it d th d i iti thWrite down the answers and prioritize among them.
Wh i f ?What is performance?
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control3
What is PM?What is PM?
P fPerformance:
The potential for future successful implementation of actions in order to reach the objectives and targets. Lebas (1995)j g ( )
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control4
Why should we measure?y
242 cm ? cm
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control5
What is PM?What is PM?
Performance measure - a metric used to quantify the efficiency and/or effectiveness of an action.
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control6
What is PM?What is PM?
P fPerformance Measurement
System
Performance measurement system (PMS) - the set of metrics used to quantify both the efficiency and effectiveness ofused to quantify both the efficiency and effectiveness of actions.
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control7
What is PM?What is PM?
P fPerformance Measurement
System
Performance measurement the process of quantifying thePerformance measurement - the process of quantifying the efficiency and/or effectiveness of action.
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control8
What is PM?What is PM?
Performance management - the process in which performance is managed in line with its corporate and functional strategies and objectives.
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control9
BeehiveBeehive
Group up (2-4 individuals per group).p p ( p g p)
Discuss the question below for a couple of minutes.
W it d th d i iti thWrite down the answers and prioritize among them.
What are the benefits for companies to ?measure?
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control10
What is PM?What is PM?
f fThe most frequent mentioned reasons for implementing measurement systems are:
M it i f f• Monitoring of performance
• Identification of areas in need of attention
E h i ti ti• Enhancing motivation
• Improving communication
• Strengthening accountability• Strengthening accountability
• Alignment between actions and strategy
• Strategy implementation• Strategy implementation
• Challenge the validity of the strategy
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control11
A historical perspectivep pPhase I
Frederick Taylor & Scientific Management The DuPont Model Detachment ownership & management Introduction of the tableau de bordIntroduction of the tableau de bord
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control12
A historical perspectivep p
Frederick Taylor and Scientific Management
- Management was responsible of devising the most efficient method of performing workI ffi i d t t i di id l k- Increase efficiency and output per individual worker
- Methods of working via analysis of existing work Methods monitored through closely monitored metrics- Methods monitored through closely monitored metrics
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control13
A historical perspectivep p
Th D P t M d l The DuPont Model
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control14
A historical perspectivep pPhase II
H man Relations Mo ement Human Relations Movement Hawthorne Studies Hierarchy of needs
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control15
A historical perspectivep p
Hawthorne Studies
“The famous experiments at Western Electric's Hawthorne plant became acknowledged as groundbreaking and provided new scientific foundations for management” (Smith 1998)management (Smith, 1998)
- Conducted between the years 1927-1932E i d d ti it l t d t k diti- Examined productivity correlated to work conditions
- Financial incentives not the only performance driver, work conditions and performance closely correlated B l t i i ff ti f l d d i- Benevolent supervision, affection for employees and group dynamics
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control16
A historical perspectivep p
Hierarchy of needs
- Needs trigger motivation- Motivation triggers performancegg p
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control17
A historical perspectivep pPhase III
Gl b li ti Globalisation Delta between book value and market value Western management practices under fire
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control18
A historical perspectivep p
Toyota
- The unquestioned position of the American management style became challenged
- Japanese goods were superior in both quality, variety and competitively priced
- Effectiveness became equally important to efficiency
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control19
A historical perspectivep p
Unconventional measures
Fi i l t i d i d f ti t f ill d il d t- Financial metrics derived from accounting systems for mills and railroads etc. - New measures focus on operational aspects that are useful for everyday decision
making
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control20
BeehiveBeehive
Group up (2-4 individuals per group).p p ( p g p)
Discuss the question below for a couple of minutes.
W it d th d i iti thWrite down the answers and prioritize among them.
Wh h ld i ?What should companies measure?
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control21
The Balanced Scorecard (BSC)
•How do we look to our shareholders? (financial perspective)
•What must we excel at? (internal•What must we excel at? (internal business perspective)
•How do our customers see us? (the customer perspective)customer perspective)
•How can we continue to improve and create value? (innovation and learning perspective)perspective)
• The BSC is the most cited and implemented performance measurement system
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control22
The Balanced Scorecard (BSC)
• Type I BSC: a specific multidimensional framework forType I BSC: a specific multidimensional framework for strategic performance measurement that combines financial and non-financial strategic measures.
• Type II BSC: Additionally describes strategy by using cause• Type II BSC: Additionally describes strategy by using cause-and-effect relationships.
• Type III BSC: Additionally implements strategy by defining objectives, action plans, results and connecting incentives withBSC.
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control23
The Balanced Scorecard (BSC)
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control24
Keeping it real
• Companies tend to develop their own PMS
• These are integrated to more extensive systems
• Breakthrough ideas are accounted forBreakthrough ideas are accounted for
• Academic gaps reflected in practice
• Utilization rather than design is the current challenge
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control25
An example: Mac TrucksKPI
Productivity
KPI
Delivery Precision
KPI
Direct Runner
Manager
KPI
Labour Efficiency
KPI
Daily throughput V Plan
KPI
Online Quality
Supervisor
KPI KPI KPIKPI
Plan
FAC Incidents
Absenteeism Rework Time
Training Participation
Section Leader KPI
SV’s
KPI
Daily throughput V Plan
KPI
Online Quality
KPI
Labour Efficiency
Section Leader
KPI
Rejected Parts
KPI
Overtime
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control27
Principle 10 – The Toyota Way
Principle 10: Develop exceptional people and teams who follow your company’s philosophyyour company s philosophy
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control28
Principle 10 part of the VPS foundation
G l i t d tGoal oriented teams
Cross functional workwork
Organizational designdesign
Visualization
Goal oriented teams are the foundation on working with operational as well as development goals
The teams goals are is ali ed and follo ed p on a reg lar basis To sec re team performance de elopment plans• The teams goals are visualized and followed up on a regular basis. To secure team performance, development plans including goals are also set and followed up on individual level
Within the teams actions and improvements are decided on how to reach the goals
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control29
Hoshin Kanri
Hoshin means directionHoshin means direction.
Kanri means management.
Together they create the compass.
Hoshin kanri is a method devised to capture and cement pstrategic goals as well as flashes of insight about the future and develop the means to bring these into reality.
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control30
Main steps in the Hoshin Kanri Process
Strategic planning• Organization’s present situation• Desired “Future State”Strategic planning Desired Future State • Select “Vision Element” for Breakthrough
Tactical planning and deployment of plan
(Catchball)
• Create plans to improve the vision element• Deploy/Cascade the plan
Implementation of plan • Execute the plan - create activities and actions• Check progress and take action on deviationsand regular review • Check progress and take action on deviations
Annual review • Improve planning• Process and create next year’s plan
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control31
CatchballCatchball
•In Hoshin Kanri, each management level’s strategy becomes the objectives of the next level down
•Catchball ensures alignment across process and functional lines. Catchball is a vigorous give-and-take that gets people involved in the strategic focus that motivates them to achieve the targets
•In Catchball, ideas generated at each level of the company are passed up or down to people at other levels for their review and input
•Those receiving an idea “catch” it, modify it (if necessary) to make it relevant h k d h i l l d i l h h l lto the work done at their level, and pass it along to the other levels
This give-and-take dialogue continues until everyone understands and agrees on the objectives, strategies, and action plans of the other levels
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control32
Focusing forcesg
B f l k f h d i
After – Shared viewHoshin Kanri
Before – lack of shared view
Shared view about common direction and alignment of goals and measurements is necessary to deliver on Business Objectives
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control33
y j
Hoshin Kanri is a system of nested PDCA ycycles
Strategic level
Strategic planning
Strategic level (Annual)
Tactic level (Weekly/Monthly)
Tactic planning and deployment of plan
PlanPlan
Operative level (Daily)
(Catchball)
Implementation of plan and regular review
DoAct DoAct
and regular review
Annual reviewCheck
Check
Annual review
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control34
Summaryy
• PM is the process of quantifying efficiency and effectiveness.
• Evolution of PM divided into three phases.
• BSC is the best known PMS.BSC is the best known PMS.
• In reality companies develop PMS after they own needs.
• Hoshin Kanri is a powerful strategic planning tool that enables the involvement of the organisation in the PM process.
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control35
Contact details
0737 65 63 88
Volvo Construction EquipmentMohammed Salloum, Finance and Business Control36