kerchner & laudenslager v obama (as amended) - petition objection filed 17feb2012 amended...
TRANSCRIPT
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 1/26
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv (Wubyd`yBtuLaeduy (bu
U D @ D AZ D I J D E 5
AH YND @BOOBHVDCLYN @BTUY BJ WDHHPQLZCHAC
@NCULDP J( KDU@NHDU, MU(,
chi
ICLD C( LCTIDHPLCFDU,
@cpd hb(= >4 OI 5735
HBOAHCYABH WDYAYABH BEMD@YABH
CODHIDI @BOWLCAHY
Bemd`ybup,
JALDI EQ=
KCUDH L KADJDU, CYYBUHDQ CY LC V
WC( A(I( Hb( >7160
ZP (
ECUC@K NTPPDAH BECOC, AA
Ckc ECUC@K NTPPDAH BECOC,
Ckc ECUC@K N( BECOC,
@chiaicyd(
3774 Lbt`kp Czdhtd
P`byyicld, Wc( 34:>0659 >>6 3774
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 2/26
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydp bj= nyy ‥ =""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduy (bu
AH YND @BOOBHVDCLYN @BTUY BJ WDHHPQLZCHAC
@NCULDP J( KDU@NHDU, MU(, cpd hb(=HBOAHCYABH WDYAYABH
CODHIDI @BOWLCAHY
ICLD C( LCTIDHPLCFDU,735 Wuaocuq Dld`yabh
Bemd`ybup
Zp(
ECUC@K NTPPDAH BECOC, AA
Ckc ECUC@K NTPPDAH BECOC,
Ckc ECUC@K N( BECOC,
@chiaicyd(
@BOWLCAHY
CHI HBV, `bodp @NCULDP J( KDU@NHDU, MU( chi ICLD C( LCTIDHPLCFDU,
Bemd`ybup, eq chi ynubtfn yndau bthpdl, KCUDH L( KADJDU, Cyybuhdq cy Lcv, nclldhfahf ynd
Hboahcyabh Wdyayabh bj ECUC@K NTPPDAH BECOC, AA, Ckc ECUC@K NTPPDAH BECOC, Ckc
ECUC@K N( BECOC, @chiaicyd, wtuptchy yb 54 W(P( @ncwydu 39, Cuya`ld A^, `, Pd`yabh 5106,
chi ah ptwwbuy yndudbj, czdu ynd jbllbvahf=
3( Cuya`ld AA, Pd`yabh 3, bj ynd T(P( @bhpyaytyabh udstaudp yncy yb ed dlafaeld jbu ynd Bjja`d bj
Wudpaidhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, c `chiaicyd otpy ed c %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh bj ynd Thaydi
Pycydp%( Pdd D~naeay &C&, @bhpyaytyabh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, Pdwydoedu 36, 36>6(
5( Ah Wdhhpqlzchac, ynd Idwcuyodhy bj Pycyd wuahydi `chiaicydp &wc`kdy bj udstaudi
stclaja`cyabhp chi ahpyut yabhp& wubzaidi eq ynd Wc( Pd`udycuq bj Pycydp& bjja`d, Mbhcynbh O(
Ocukp, @booappabhdu chi ynd Idwcuyodhy bj Pycyd vdepayd c`khbvldifd ynd T(P(
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 3/26
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydp bj= nyy‥=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduy (bu
@bhpyaytyabhcl ctynbuayq chi pycyd yncy yb ed dlafaeld ah Wdhhpqlzchac jbu ynd Bjja`d bj
Wudpaidhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, c `chiaicyd otpy ed c %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh%( Pdd D~naeay
& E&, @booappabhdu Ocukp ldyydu icydi Jdeutcuq >, 5735 * D~naeay &@&, Wc( Idwcuyodhy bj
Pycyd vdepayd wcfd(
0( @chiaicyd Becoc, vnb ap hby c &hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh& bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, ncp jaldi c
Hboahcyabh Wdyayabh yb ed hboahcydi jbu ynd Bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp *
lapydi cp pt`n bh ynd ecllby bj ynd @boobhvdclyn bj Wdhhpqlzchac( Pdd D~naeay &I&,
Fdhducl Dld`yabh Wuaocuq @chiaicyd Lapy, Wc( Idwy( bj Pycyd wtela`cyabh, Wcfd 3(
9( C %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh% ap c wdupbh ebuh ah ynd `bthyuq yb wcudhyp vnb cud ebyn
`aya}dhp bj ynd `bthyuq( Pdd D~naeay &D&, Yudcyapd, %Ynd Lcv bj Hcyabhp bu Wuah`awldp bj
Hcytucl Lcv% .364>!( Yb oddy ynd ydpy bj %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh%, ebyn bj ynd `chiaicyd&p
wcudhyp otpy ed T(P( `aya}dhp cy ynd yaod bj ynd `chiaicyd&p eauyn ah ynd Thaydi Pycydp( C
%hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh% ncp thayq bj `aya}dhpnaw chi pbld clldfach`d yb bhd hcyabh chi bhlq
bhd hcyabh cy eauyn( Pdd D~naeay &J&, Ldfcl Dppcq, Ocuab Cwt}}b, Dps(
4( @chiaicyd Becoc&p jcyndu, Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, Pu(, vcp c jbudafh hcyabhcl cy ynd
yaod bj nap eauyn chi @chiaicyd Becoc cioayp pcod ah nap ebbk, %Iudcop Jubo Oq
Jcyndu%, cy wcfd 534, yncy ah oai 31:7&p %ynd fbzduhodhy .Kdhqc! udzbkdi nap .jcyndu&p!
wcppwbuy, chi nd .Becoc, Pu(! `btlih&y dzdh ldczd Kdhqc%; @chiaicyd Becoc&p jcyndu vcp
hdzdu ch aooafuchy yb ynd Thaydi Pycydp, hbu c wduochdhy udpaidhy; @chiaicyd Becoc&p
jcyndu hdzdu jaldi jbu bu cyycahdi T(P( `aya}dhpnaw pycytp; yndudjbud, `chiaicyd Becoc jcalp
yb oddy T(P( @bhpyaytyabhcl chi Wdhhpqlzchac udstaudodhyp jbu ynd Bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy bj
ynd Thaydi Pycydp( Pdd D~naeay &F&, AHP Hbhaooafuchy %J/3% Zapc Pytidhy Udwbuy udfcuiahf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 4/26
@b q wubzaidi `btuydp bj= nyy‥=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduy (bu
`chiaicyd Becoc&p jcyndu chi D~naeay %N%, D~`duwy %Iudcop Jubo Oq Jcyndu%, ctynbudi
eq `chiaicyd Becoc(
:( @chiaicyd Becoc vcp ebuh c itcl `aya}dh vayn itcl clldfach`d cy eauyn( Nd vcp ebuh c
Euayapn ptemd`y zac nap jcyndu chi c T(P( `aya}dh zac nap obyndu(
6( @chiaicyd Becoc, bh Cwual 37, 577>, pteoayydi Pdhcyd Udpbltyabh 433, udjdudh`ahf
ynd Jaupy @bhfudpp&p pycytyd idjahahf ynd yduo &hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh& chi udpblzahf yncy Mbnh
Paihdq O`@cah, AAA, vcp c %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh%, cp nd vcp &ebuh yb Codua`ch `aya}dhp(((&
.wltucl!( Pdd D~naeay &A&, Pdhcyd Udpbltyabh 433 chi D~naeay 3&, Jaupy @bhfudpp&p pycytyd,
Hcytucla}cyabh C`y bj 3617(
>( @chiaicyd Becoc, ah nap @chiaicyd&p Cjjaiczay, ncp id`lcudi nd ap dlafaeld jbu ynd Bjja`d
bj Wudpaidhy, chi, yndudjbud, ncp ynd etuidh bj wubzahf yb ynap Nbhbuceld @btuy ynd yutyn bj
ynd ocyydu, pwd`aja`cllq, ebyn wcudhyp& Codua`ch `aya}dhpnaw yb ed c &hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh&(
1( Wlcahyajjp, Kdu`nhdu * Lctidhplcfdu cud udpaidhyp bj Wc( chi itlq udfapydudi odoedup
bj ynd dld`ybucyd(
37 ( @chiaicyd Becoc ncp hdzdu `bh`ltpazdlq wubzdh yb chq `bhyubllahf ldfcl ctynbuayq ah
Wdhhpqlzchac eq `ldcu chi `bhzah`ahf dzaidh`d yncy nd vcp ebuh ah ynd Thaydi Pycydp(
VNDUDJBUD, Wlcahyajjp wucq yncy ynd hboahcyabh wdyayabh bu wcwdup pteoayydi eq
`chiaicyd Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, AA, Ckc Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, Ckc Ecuc`k N( Becoc, ed
pdy cpaid itd yb nap jcaltud yb oddy ynd dlafaealayq udstaudodhyp jbu ynd bjja`d nd pddkp(
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 5/26
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyy ‥ =""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduy (bu
Udpwd`yjtllq pteoayydi,
KCUDH L( KADJDU, Cyybuhdq jbu Bemd`ybup
3774 Lbt`kp Czdhtd, P`byyicld, Wc( 34:>0
659 >>6 3774
WC( A(I( # >7160
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 6/26
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydp bj= nyy‥=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduy (bu
@DUYAJA@CYABH bj PDUZA@D
A, Kcudh L( Kadjdu, ndudeq `duyajq yncy bh ynap ynd 59 yn icq bj Jdeutcuq 5735, A ocaldi yb
`chiaicyd Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, AA, Ckc Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, Ckc Ecuc`k N( Becoc, cy
479: Pbtyn Fuddhvbbi Czdhtd, @na`cfb, 33( :7:34, chi cy @lajjbui Ldzahd, @bndh * Fuafpeq,
:54 Laeduyq Czdhtd, Wayypetufn, Wc( 34553 chi cy 3:77 Wdhhpqlzchac Czdhtd, Vcpnahfybh
I(@(, 5777: chi c `bwq bj ynd Hboahcyabh Wdyayabh Bemd`yabh Codhidi @bowlcahy, eq
Udfapydudi Ocal, Udytuh Ud`dawy Udstdpydi(
KCUDH L( KADJDU, O(E(C(, M(I(
Cyybuhdq jbu Wlcahyajj
3774 Lbt`kp Czdhtd
P`byyicld, Wc( 34:>0
Wc( A(I( Hb( >7160
659 >>6 3774
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 7/26
@bwq wubzaidi btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
AH YND @BOOBHV DCLYN @BTUY BJ WDHHPQLZCHAC
Ah Ud= Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, AA
Ckc Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc,
Ckc Ecuc`k N( Becoc, @chiaicyd
Bemd`yabh bj= @nculdp J( Kdu`nhdu, Mu(
Chi Icld C( Lctidhplcfdub( >4 O(I( 5735
BUIDU BJ @BTUY
CHI HBV, cjydu nczahf `bhit`ydi c Ndcuahf bh Bemd`ybup, @nculdp J( Kdu`nhdu, Mu(&p chi
Icld C( Lctidhplcfdu&p Hboahcyabh Wdyayabh Bemd`yabh jaldi cfcahpy wudpaidhyacl `chiaicyd
Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, AA, Ckc Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, Ckc, Ecuc`k N( Becoc, .%`chiaicyd
Becoc%!; `bhpaiduahf ynd dzaidh`d ahyubit`di ahyb ynd ud`bui chi cuftodhyp bj `bthpdl,
Kcudh L( Kadjdu chi Ocuab Cwt}}b, udwudpdhyahf ynd Bemd`ybup chiudwudpdhyahf `chiaicyd Becoc; jahiahf yncy `chiaicyd Becoc ncp jcaldi yb `bh`ltpazdlq
wubzd yncy nd ap ch Cuya`ld AA %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh% eq nczahf jcaldi yb `bh ltpazdlq wubzd
yncy nd vcp ebuh ah ynd Thaydi Pycydp chi yncy nd vcp ebuh yb yvb T(P( `aya}dh wcudhyp;
chi Bemd`ybu nczahf bynduvapd pnbvh fbbi `ctpd,
AY AP NDUDEQ BUIDUDI bh ynapcq bj5735,
Yncy ynd Hboahcyabh Wdyayabh bj wudpaidhyacl `chiaicyd, Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, AA, Ckc
Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, Ckc Ecuc`k N( Becoc, ap pdy cpaid jbu jcaltud bj `chiaicyd Becoc
yb pcyapjq ynd wudpaidhyacl `bhpyaytyabhcl dlafaealayq udstaudodhyp bj Cuya`ld AA, Pd`yabh 3,
@lctpd 4(
( 3 (
Cyydpy=
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 8/26
@NCULDP J( KDU@NHDU, MU(
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
ZDUAJA@CYABH
A zduajq yncy ynd pycydodhyp ocid ah ynap @bowlcahy `nclldhfahf ynd dlafaealayq bj `chiaicyd
Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, AA, cud yutd chi `buud`y( A thidupychi yncy pycydodhyp ndudah cud
ocid ptemd`y yb ynd wdhclyadp bj 3> Wc( @(P(C( Pd`yabh 9179, udlcyahf yb thpvbuh jclpaja`cyabh
yb ctynbuayadp(
Icyd=7 6 Jm5,yu 5 "
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 9/26
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
ZDUAJA@CYABH
A zduajq yncy ynd pycydodhyp ocid ah ynap @bowlcahy `nclldhfahf ynd dlafaealayq bj `chiaicyd
Ecuc`k Ntppdah Becoc, AA, cud yutd chi `buud y( A thidupychi yncy pycydodhyp ndudah cud
ocid ptemd`y yb ynd wdhclyadp bj 3> Wc( @(P(C( Pd`yabh 9179, udlcyahf yb thpvbuh jclpaja`cyabh
yb ctynbuayadp(
I ky, c (ICLD C, LCTIDHPLCFDU
Icyd=/ "@!
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 10/26
& C
YND @BHPYAYTYABHBJ YND THAYDI PYCYDP BJ CODUA@C
Wudcoeld
Vd ynd Wdbwld bj ynd TW =ldi Pycydp, ah Buidu yb jbuo c obud
wdujd`y Thabh, dpycelapn Mtpya`d( ahptud ibodpya` Yuchstalayq, wubzaidjbu ynd `boobh idjdh`d( wubobyd ynd fdhducl Vdljcud, chi pd`tud
ynd Eldppahfp bj Laeduyq yb btupdlzdp chi btu Wbpyduayq, ib buicah chidpycelapn ynap @bhpyaytyabh jbu ynd Thaydi Pycydp bj Codua`c(
C uya`ld A(YND LD. aaPLCYAZD EUCH@N
Pd`yabh A( Cll ldfaplcyazd Wbvdup ndudah fuchydi pncll ed zdpydi ah
c @bhfudpp bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, vna`n pncll bhpapy bj c Pdhcyd chi
Nbtpd bj Udwudpdhycyazdp(
Pd`yabh 5( [3_ Ynd Nbtpd bj Udwudpdhycyazdp pncll ed `bowbpdi
bj Odoedup nbpdh dzduq pd`bhi Qdcu eq ynd Wdbwld bj ynd pdzducl
Pycydp, chi ynd Dld`ybup ah dc`n Pycyd pncll nczd ynd Stclaja`cyabhp
udstapayd jbu Dld`ybup bj ynd obpy htodubtp Euch`n bj ynd Pycyd
Ldfaplcytud(
[5_ Hb Wdupbh pncll nd c Udwudpdhycyazd vnb pncll hby nczd
cyycahdi yb ynd Cfd bj yvdhyq jazd Qdcup, chi eddh pdzdh Qdcup c
@aya}dh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, chi vnb pncll hby, vndh dld`ydi, ed ch
Ahnceaychy bj yncy Pycyd ah vna`n nd pncll ed `nbpdh(
[0_ Udwudpdhycyazdp chi iaud`y Yc~dp pncll ed cwwbuyabhdi
cobhf ynd pdzducl Pycydp vna n ocq ed ah`ltidi vaynah ynap Thabh,
c``buiahf yb yndau udpwd`yazd Htoedup, vna n pncll ed idyduoahdi eq
ciiahf yb ynd vnbld Htoedu bj judd Wdupbhp, ah`ltiahf ynbpd ebthi
yb Pduza d jbu c Yduo bj Qdcup, chi d~`ltiahf Ahiachp hby yc~di, ynudd
jajynp bj cll byndu Wdupbhp [Obiajadi eq Codhiodhy ^AZ_( Ynd c`ytcl
Dhtoducyabh pncll ed ocid vaynah ynudd Qdcup cjydu ynd jaupy Oddyahf
bj ynd @bhfudpp bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, chi vaynah dzduq ptepdstdhy
Yduo bj ydh Qdcup, ah pt`n Ochhdu cp yndq pncll eq Lcv iaud`y( Ynd
Htoedu bj Udwudpdhycyazdp pncll hby d~`ddi bhd jbu dzduq ynauyq
Ynbtpchi, ety dc`n Pycyd pncll nczd cy Ldcpy bhd Udwudpdhycyazd; chi
thyal pt`n dhtoducyabh pncll ed ocid, ynd Pycyd bj Hdv Ncowpnaud
pncll nd dhyayldi yb `ntpd ynudd( Ocppc`ntpdyyp dafny, Unbid/Aplchi
chi Wubzaidh`d Wlchycyabhp bhd( @bhhd`ya`ty jazd( Hdv/Qbuk pa~,
Hdv Mdupdq jbtu, WdhyapB&caa=== dafny( Idlcvcud bhd, Ocuqlchi pa~,
Zaufahac ydh, Hbuyn @cublahc lazd( Pbtyn @cublahc jazd, chi Fdbufac
ynudd(
[9_ Vndh zc`ch`adp ncwwdh ah ynd Udwudpdhycyabh jubo chq Pycyd,ynd D~d`tyazd Ctynbuayq yndudbj pncll apptd Vuayp bj Dld`yabh yb jall
pt`n Zc`ch`adp( ‥[4_ Ynd Nbtpd bj Udwudpdhycyazdp pncll ntpd yndau Pwdckdu chi
byndu Bjja`dup= chi pncll nczd ynd pbld Wbvdu bj Aowdc`nodhy(
YND PDHCYDPd`yabh 0( [ AA Ynd Pdhcyd bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp pncll ed `bowbpdi
bj yvb Pdhcybup jubo dc`n Pycyd, `nbpdh eq ynd Ldfaplcytud yndudbj
[Obiajadi eq Codhiodhy ZAA_( jbu pa~ Qdcup; chi dc`n Pdhcybu
pncll nczd bhd Zbyd([5_ Aoodiacydlq cjydu yndq pncll ed cppdoeldi ah @bhpdstdh`d bj
ynd jaupy Dld`yabh, yndq pncll ed iazaidi cp dstcllq cp ocq ed ahyb
ynudd @lcppdp( Ynd Pdcyp bj ynd Pdhcybup bj ynd jaupy @lcpp pncll ed
zc`cydi cy ynd D~waucyabh bj ynd pd`bhi Qdcu, bj ynd pd`bhi @lcpp
cy ynd D~waucyabh bj ynd jbtuyn Qdcu, chi bj ynd ynaui @lcpp cy ynd
D~waucyabh bj ynd pa~yn Qdcu, pb yncy bhd ynaui ocq ed nbpdh dzduq
pd`bhi Qdcu; chi aj Zc`ch`adp ncwwdh eq Udpafhcyabh, bu bynduvapd,
ituahf ynd Ud`dpp bj ynd Ldfaplcytud bj chq Pycyd, ynd D~d`tyazd
yndudbj ocq ockd ydowbucuq Cwwbahyodhyp thyal ynd hd~y Oddyahf bj
ynd Ldfaplcytud, vna`n pncll yndh ( jall pt`n Zc`ch`adp [Obiajadi eqCodhiodhy ZAA, @ lctpd 5_(
[0_ Hb Wdupbh pncll ed c Pdhcybu vnb pncll hby nczd cyycahdi yb
ynd Cfd bj ynauyq Qdcup, chi eddh hahd Qdcup c @aya}dh bj ynd Thaydi
Pycydp, chi vnb pncll hby, vndh dld`ydi, ed ch Ahnceaychy bj yncy Pycydjbu vna`n nd pncll ed `nbpdh(
[9_ Ynd Za`d Wudpaidhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp pncll ed Wudpaidhy bj
ynd Pdhcyd, ety pncll nczd hb Zbyd, thldpp yndq ed dstcllq iazaidi(
[4_ Ynd Pdhcyd pncll `ntpd yndau byndu Bjja`dup, chi clpb c Wudpaidhy
wub ydowbud, ah ynd Cepdh`d bj ynd Za`d Wudpaidhy, bu vndh nd pncll
d~du`apd ynd Bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp([:_ Ynd Pdhcyd pncll nczd ynd pbld Wbvdu yb yuq cll Aowdc`nodhyp(
Vndh payyahf jbu yncy Wtuwbpd( yndq pncll ed bh Bcyn bu Cjjauocyabh(
Vndh ynd Wudpaidhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp ap yuadi, ynd @nadjMtpya`d pncll
wudpaid= Chi hb Wdupbh pncll nd `bhza`ydi vaynbty ynd @bh`tuudh`d bjyvb ynauip bj ynd Odoedup wudpdhy(
[6_ Mtifodhy ah @cpdp bj Aowdc`nodhy pncll hby d~ydhi jtuyndu
ynch yb udobzcl jubo Bjja`d, chi iapstclaja`cyabh yb nbli chi dhmbq
chq Bjja`d bj nbhbu, Yutpy bu Wubjay thidu ynd Thaydi Pycydp= ety ynd
Wcuyq `bhza`ydi pncll hdzduyndldpp ed laceld chi ptemd`y yb Ahia`yodhy,
Yuacl( Mtifodhy chi Wthapnodhy, c``buiahf yb Lcv(
1
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 11/26
D"./. u a0 lYC
pd`tuahf jbu laoaydi Yaodp yb Ctynbup chi ltz tvac llld @C@ATPAZ@
Uafny yb yndau udpwd`yazd Vuayahfp chi Iap`bzduadp=[1_ Yb `bhpyaytyd Yuaethclp ahjduabu yb ynd ptwudod @btuy;[37_ Yb idjahd chi wthapn Wauc`adp chi Jdlbhadp `booayydi bh ynd
nafn Pdcp, chi Bjjdh`dp cfcahpy ynd Lcv bj Hcyabhp;
[ 3 A _ Yb id`lcud Vcu, fuchy Ldyydup bj Ocustd chi Udwuapcl, chi
ockd Utldp `bh`duhahf @cwytudp bh Lchi chi V cydu;
[35_ Yb ucapd chi ptwwbuy Cuoadp, ety hb Cwwubwuacyabh bj O bhdqyb yncy Tpd pncll nd jbu c lbhfdu Yduo ynch yvb Qdcup;
[30_ Yb wubzaid chi ocahycah c Hczq;
[39_ Yb ockd Utld&p jbu ynd Fbzduhodhy chi Udfnlcyabh bj ynd
lchi chi hczcl Jbu`dp;
[34_ Yb wubzaid jbu `cllahf jbuyn ynd Oalayac yb d~d`tyd ynd Lcvp bjynd Thabh, ptwwudpp Ahptuud`yabhp chi udwdl Ahzcpabhp;
[3:_ Yb wubzaid jbu bufcha}ahf, cuoahf, chi iap`awlahahf, ynd
Oalayac, chi jbu fbzduhahf pt`n Wcuy bj yndo cp ocq ed dowlbqdi ah
ynd Pduza`d bj ynd( T haydi Pycydp, udpduzahf yb ynd Pycydp udpwd`yazdlq,
ynd Cwwbahyodhy bj ynd Bjja`dup, chi ynd Ctynbuayq bj yucahahf ynd
Oalayac c``buiahf yb ynd iap`awlahd wudp`uaedi eq @ bhfudpp;
[36_ Yb d~du`apd d~`ltpazd Ldfaplcyabh ah cll @cpdp vncypbdzdu,
bzdu pt`n Iapyua`y .hby d~`ddiahf ydh Oaldp pstcud! cp ocq, eq
@dppabh bj wcuya`tlcu Pycydp, chi ynd C``dwych`d bj @bhfudpp, ed`bod
ynd Pdcy bj ynd Fbzduhodhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, chi yb d~du`apd lakdCtynbuayq bzdu cll Wlc`dp wtu`ncpdi eq ynd @ bhpdhy bj ynd Ldfaplcytud
bj ynd Pycyd ah vna`n ynd Pcod pncll ed, jbu ynd Dud`yabh bj Jbuyp,
Ocfc}ahdp, Cupdhclp, ib`k/Qcuip, chi byndu hddijtl Etaliahfp; ’
Ch i
[3>_ Yb ockd cll Lcvp vna`n pncll ed hd`dppcuq chi wubwdu jbu
`cuuqahf ahyb D~d`tyabh ynd jbudfbahf Wbvdup, chi cll byndu Wbvdup
zdpydi eq ynap @bhpyaytyabh ah ynd Fbzduhodhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, bu
ah chq Idwcuyodhy bu Bjja`du yndudbj(
WBVDUP D^WLA@AYLQ IDHADI YB @BH FUDPP
Pd yabh 1( [3_ Ynd Oafucyabh bu Aowbuycyabh bj pt`n Wdupbhpcp chq bj ynd Pycydp hbv d~apyahf pncll ynahk wubwdu yb cioay, pncll
hby ed wubnaeaydi eq ynd @bhfudpp wuabu yb ynd Qdcu bhd ynbtpchi
dafny nthiudi chi dafny( ety c Yc~ bu ityq ocq ed aowbpdi bh pt`n
Aowbuycyabh, hby d~`ddiahf ydh ibllcup jbu dc`n Wdupbh(‥ [5_ Ynd Wuazaldfd bj ynd Vuay bj Ncedcp @buwtp pncll hby ed
ptpwdhidi, thldpp vndh ah @cpdp bj Udedllabh bu Ahzcpabh ynd wtela`
Pcjdyq ocq udstaud ay(
[0_ Hb Eall bj Cyycahidu bu d~ wbpy jc`yb Lcv pncll ed wcppdi(
[9_ Hb @cwaycyabh, bu byndu iaud`y, Yc~ pncll ed lcai, thldpp ah
35
Wubwbuyabh yb ynd @dhptp bu Dhtoducyabh ndudah edjbud iaud`ydi yb
ed yckdh(
[4_ Hb Yc~ bu Ityq pncll ed lcai bh Cuya`ldp d~wbuydi jubo chq
Pycyd([:_ Hb Wudjdudh`d pncll ed fazdh eq chq Udftlcyabh bj @boodu`d
bu Udzdhtd yb ynd Wbuyp bj bhd Pycyd bzdu ynbpd bj chbyndu; hbu pncll
Zdppdlp ebthi yb( bu jubo( bhd Pycyd, ed belafdi yb dhydu, `ldcu, bu wcqItyadp ah chbyndu(
[6_ Hb Obhdq pncll ed iucvh jubo ynd Yudcptuq, ety ah
@bhpdstdh`d bj Cwwubwuacyabhp ocid, eq Lcv; chi c udftlcu
Pycydodhy chi C``bthy bj ynd Ud`dawyp chi D ~wdhiaytudp bj cll wtela`
Obhdq pncll ed wtelapndi jubo yaod yb yaod([>_ Hb Yayld bj Hbealayq pncll ed fuchydi eq ynd Thaydi Pycydp=
Chi hb Wdupbh nbliahf chq Bjja`d bj Wubjay bu Yutpy thidu yndo,
pncll, vaynbty ynd @bhpdhy bj ynd @bhfudpp, c``dwy bj chq wudpdhy,
Dobltodhy, Bjja`d( bu Yayld, bj chq kahi vncydzdu, jubo chq Kahf,
Wuah`d, bu jbudafh Pycyd(
LAOAYCYABHP BJ PYCYD WBVDU PPd`yabh 37( [A_ Hb Pycyd pncll dhydu ahyb chq Yudcyq, Cllach`d, bu
@bhjdiducyabh; fuchy Ldyydup bj Ocustd chi Udwuapcl; bah Obhdq;
doay Eallp bj @udiay; ockd chq Ynahf ety fbli chi palzdu @bah c
Ydhidu ah Wcqodhy bj Ideyp; wcpp chq Eall bj Cyycahidu, d~ wbpy jc`ybLcv, bu Lcv aowcauahf ynd Belafcyabh bj @bhyuc`yp, bu fuchy chq Yayld
bj Hbealayq(
[5_ Hb Pycyd pncll, vaynbty ynd @bhpdhy bj ynd @bhfudpp, lcq
chq Aowbpyp bu Ityadp bh Aowbuyp bu D~wbuyp, d~`dwy vncy ocq ed
cepbltydlq hd`dppcuq jbu d~d`tyahf ay&p ahpwd`yabh Lcvp; chi ynd hdy
Wubit`d bj cll Ityadp chi Aowbpyp, lcai eq chq Pycyd bh Aowbuyp bu
D~wbuyp, pncll ed jbu ynd Tpd bj ynd Yudcptuq bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp;
chi cll pt`n Lcvp pncll ed ptemd`y yb ynd Udzapabh chi @bhyubtl bj
ynd @bhfudpp(
[0_ Hb Pycyd pncll, vaynbty ynd @bhpdhy bj @bhfudpp, lcq chq
Ityq bj Ybhhcfd, kddw Yubbwp, bu Pnawp bj Vcu ah yaod bj Wdc`d,dhydu ahyb chq Cfuddodhy bu @bowc`y vayn chbyndu Pycyd, bu vayn c
jbudafh Wbvdu, bu dhfcfd ah Vcu, thldpp c`ytcllq ahzcidi, bu ah pt`naooahdhy Ichfdu cp vall hby cioay bj idlcq(
Cuya`ld AA(YND D^D@TYAZD EUCH@N
Pd`yabh 3( [3_ Ynd d~d`tyazd Wbvdu pncll ed zdpydi ah c Wudpaidhy
bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp bj Codua`c( lad pncll nbli nap Bjja`d ituahf ynd
30
@bwq wubzaidi btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 12/26
D~q330, &Y "3 3
plaRdjjbuy
Yduo bj jbtu Qdcup, chi, ybfdyndu vayn ynd Za`d Wudpaidhy = `nbpdh jbu
ynd pcod Yduo, ed dld`ydi, cp jbllbvp=[5_ Dc`n Pycyd pncll cwwbahy, ah pt`n Ochhdu cp ynd Ldfaplcytud
yndudbj ocq iaud`y, c Htoedu bj Dld`ybup, dstcl yb ynd vnbld Htoedubj Pdhcybup chi U dwudpdhycyazdp yb vna`n ynd Pycyd ocq ed dhyayldi ah
ynd @bhfudpp= ety hb Pdhcybu bu Udwudpdhycyazd, bu Wdupbh nbliahf chBjja`d bj Yutpy bu Wubjay thidu ynd Thaydi Pycydp, pncll ed cwwbahydi
ch Dld`ybu(
[0_ Ynd Dld ybup pncll oddy ah yndau udpwd yazd Pycydp, chi zbyd
eq Ecllby jbu yvb Wdupbhp, bj vnbo bhd cy ldcpy pncll hby nd ch
Ahnceaychy bj ynd pcod Pycyd vayn yndopdlzdp( Chi yndq pncll ockd
c Lapy bj cll ynd Wdupbhp zbydi jbu chi bj ynd Htoedu bj Zbydp jbudc`n; vna n Lapy yndq pncll pafh chi duyamau( chi yuchpoay pdcldi yb ynd
Pdcy bj ynd Fbzduhodhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, iaud ydi yb ynd Wudpaidhy
bj ynd Pdhcyd( Ynd Wudpaidhy bj ynd Pdhcyd pncll, ah ynd Wudpdh`d bj
ynd Pdhcyd chi Nbtpd bj Udwudpdhycyazdp, bwdh cll ynd @duyaja cydp(
chi ynd Zbydp pncll yndh ed `bthydi( Ynd Wdupbh nczahf ynd fudcydpy
Htoedu bj Zbydp pncll nd ynd Wudpaidhy( aj pt`n Htoedu ed c Ocmbuayq
bj ynd vnbld Htoedu bj Dld ybup cwwbahydi; chi aj yndud ed obud ynch
bhd vnb nczd pt`n Ocmbuayq, chi nczd ch dstcl Htoedu bj Zbydp,
yndh ynd Nbtpd bj Udwudpdhycyazdp pncll aoodiacydlq ntpd eq Ecllby
bhd bj yndo jbu Wudpaidhy; chi aj hb Wdupbh nczd c Ocmbuayq, yndh
jubo ynd jazd nafndpy bh ynd Lapy ynd pcai Nbtpd pncll ah lakd Ochhdu
`ntpd ynd Wudpaidhy( Ety ah `ntpahf ynd Wudpaidhy, ynd Zbydp pncll ed
yckdh eq Pycydp, ynd Udwudpdhycyabh jubo dc`n Pycyd nczahf bhd Zbyd;
c stbuto jbu ynap Wtuwbpd pncll bhpapy bj c Odoedu bu Odoedup
jubo yvb ynauip bj ynd Pycydp, chi c Ocmbuayq bj cll ynd Pycydp pncll
ed hd`dppcuq yb c @nba`d( Ah dzduq @cpd, cjydu ynd @nba`d bj ynd
Wudpaidhy, ynd Wdupbh nczahf ynd fudcydpy Htoedu bj Zbydp bj ynd
Dld`ybup pncll ed ynd Za d Wudpaidhy( Ety aj yndud pnbtli udocah yvb
bu obud vnb nczd dstcl Zbydp, ynd Pdhcyd pncll `ntpd jubo yndo eq
Ecllby ynd Za d Wudpaidhy [Obiajadi eq Codhiodhy ^AA_(
[9_ Ynd @bhfudpp ocq idyduoahd ynd Yaod bj `ntpahf ynd Dld`ybup,
chi ynd Icq bh vn a`n yndq pncll fazd yndau Zbydp; vna`n I cq pncll edynd pcod ynubtfnbty ynd Thaydi Pycydp(
{
[4_ Hb Wdupbh d~`dwy c hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh, bu c @aya}dh bj ynd
Thaydi Pycydp, cy ynd yaod bj ynd Cibwyabh bj ynap @bhpyaytyabh, pncll ed
dlafaeld yb ynd Bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy; hdayndu pncll chq Wdupbh ed dlafaeldyb yncy Bjja`d vnb pncll hby nczd cyycahdi yb ynd Cfd bj ynauyq jazd
dcup, chi eddh jbtuyddh Qdcup c Udpaidhy v aynah ynd Thaydi Pycydp(
[:_ Ah @cpd bj ynd Udobzcl bj ynd Wudpaidhy jubo Bjja d, bu bj nap
Idcyn, Udpafhcyabh, bu Ahcealayq yb iap`ncufd ynd Wbvdup chi Ityadp
bj ynd pcai Bjja d, ynd Pcod pncll idzblzd bh ynd Za d Wudpaidhy, chi
ynd @bhfudpp ocq eq Lcv wubzaid jbu ynd @cpd bj Udobzcl, Idcyn,
Udpafhcyabh bu Ahcealayq, ebyn bj ynd Wudpaidhy chi Za`d Wudpaidhy,
id lcuahf vncy Bjja`du pncll yndh c y cp Wudpaidhy, chi pt`n Bjja`du
pncll c`y c``buiahflq, thyal ynd Iapcealayq ed udobzdi, bu c Wudpaidhy
pncll ed dld`ydi [Obiajadi eq Co dhiodhy ^Z_([6_ Ynd Wudpaidhy pncll, cy pycydi Yaodp, ud`dazd jbu nap Pduza`dp,
c @bowdhpcyabh, vna`n pncll hdayndu ed ah`udcpdi hbu iaoahapndi
ituahf ynd Wduabi jbu vna`n nd pncll nczd eddh dld`ydi, chi nd pncll
hby ud`dazd vaynah yncy Wduabi chq byndu Dobltodhy jubo ynd Thaydi
Pycydp, bu chq bj yndo([>_ Edjbud nd dhydu bh ynd D~d`tyabh bj nap Bjja`d, nd pncll yckd
ynd jbllbvahf Bcyn bu Cjjauocyabh= ’ %A ib pbldohlq pvdcu .bucjjauo! yncy A vall jcaynjtllq d~d`tyd ynd Bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy bj ynd
Thaydi Pycydp, chi vall yb ynd edpy bj oq Cealayq, wudpduzd, wubyd`y chiidjdhi ynd @bhpyaytyabh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp(%
Pd`yabh 5( [3_ Ynd Wudpaidhy pncll ed @boochidu ah @nadj bj ynd
Cuoq chi Hczq bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, chi bj ynd Oalayac bj ynd pdzduclPycydp, vndh `clldi ahyb ynd c`ytcl Pduza`d bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp; nd
ocq udstaud ynd Bwahabh, ah vuayahf, bj ynd wuah`awcl Bjja`du ah dc`n bj
ynd d~d`tyazd Idwcuyodhyp, twbh chq Ptemd`y udlcyahf yb ynd I tyadp bjyndau udpwd`yazd Bjja`dp, chi nd pncll nczd Wbvdu yb fuchy Udwuadzdp
chi Wcuibhp jbu Bjjdh`dp cfcahpy ynd Thaydi Pycydp, d~`dwy ah @cpdp
bj Aowdc`nodhy([5_ Nd pncll nczd Wbvdu, eq chi vayn ynd Ciza`d chi @bhpdhy
bj ynd Pdhcyd, yb ockd Yudcyadp, wubzaidi yvb ynauip bj ynd Pdhcybup
wudpdhy `bh`tu; chi nd pncll hboahcyd, chi eq chi vayn ynd Ciza`d
chi @bhpdhy bj ynd Pdhcyd, pncll cwwbahy Coecppcibup, byndu wtela`
Oahapydup chi @bhptlp, Mtifdp bj ynd ptwudod @btuy, chi cll byndu
Bjja`dup bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, vnbpd Cwwbahyodhyp cud hby ndudah
bynduvapd wubzaidi jbu, chi vna`n pncll ed dpycelapndi eq Lcv= ety
ynd @bhfudpp ocq eq Lcv zdpy ynd Cwwbahyodhy bj pt`n ahjduabu
Bjja`dup, cp yndq ynahk wubwdu, ah ynd Wudpaidhy clbhd, ah ynd @btuyp bjLcv, bu ah ynd Ndcip bj Idwcuyodhyp(
[0_ Ynd Wudpaidhy pncll nczd Wb vdu yb jall tw cll Zc`ch`adp yncy ocq
ncwwdh ituahf ynd Ud`dpp bj ynd Pdhcyd, eq fuchyahf @booappabhp
vna`n pncll d~waud cy ynd Dhi bj yndau hd~y Pdppabh(Pd yabh 0( Nd pncll jubo yaod yb yaod fazd yb ynd @bhfudpp
Ahjbuocyabh bj ynd Pycyd bj ynd Thabh, chi ud`boodhi yb yndau
@bhpaiducyabh pt`n Odcptudp cp nd pncll mtifd hd`dppcuq chi
d~wdiadhy; nd ocq, bh d~yucbuiahcuq B``cpabhp, `bhzdhd ebyn Nbtpdp,
bu dayndu bj yndo, chi ah @cpd bj Iapcfuddodhy edyvddh yndo, vayn
Udpwd`y yb ynd Yaod bj Cimbtuhodhy, nd ocq cimbtuh yndo yb pt`n
Yaod cp nd pncll ynahk wubwdu; nd pncll ud`dazd Coecppcibup chi
39 y4R R
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 13/26
yY :J,
U D @ D A Z D I J D E 7 5 7 3 5@boobhvdclyn bj Wdhhpqlzchac
Idwcuyodhy bj Pycyd
Etudct @booappabhp, Dld`yabhp chi Ldfaplcyabh
973 Hbuyn Pyuddy
Ubbo 537 Hbuyn Bjja`d Etaliahf
Ncuuapetuf, WC 36357
Mbhcynch O( O cukpdldwnbhd= .636! 6>6/45>7
@booappabhduc~= .636! 674/7653
Jdeutcuq >, 5735
Idcu O u( Lctidhplcfdu,
A co ah ud`dawy bj qbtu udstdpy jbu ahjbuocyabh udfcuiahf ynd udstaudodhyp jbu cwwdcuahfbh ynd ecllby jbu ynd bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp( Yndud ap c wub`dpp jbu fdyyahf bh yndecllby jbu ynd 5735 Wuaocuq jbu ocmbu wcuyq `chiaicydp chi chbyndu wub`dpp jbu ahidwdhidhy chi
ynaui wcuyq `chiaicydp yb c``dpp ynd ecllby jbu ynd 5735 Fdhducl Dld`yabh(
Ah Wdhhpqlzchac, yb ed hboahcydi eq c ocmbu wcuyq .`tuudhylq dayndu ynd Udwtela`chp bu
Idob`ucyp!, c `chiaicyd otpy jald hboahcyabh wdyayabhp jbu ynd wuaocuq dld`yabh, vna`n jbu 5735
vall ed ndli bh Cwual 59( Jbu ynd 5735 Wudpaidhyacl dld`yabh, ynd jaupy icq yb `au`tlcyd hboahcyabh
wdyayabhp ap Mchtcuq 59, 5735, chi yndq otpy ed jaldi eq Jdeutcuq 39, 5735( Ynd pafhcytud
udstaudodhy jbu hboahcyabh wdyayabhp jbu ynd bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp ap 5,777udfapydudi Wdhhpqlzchac dld`ybup vayn c jalahf jdd bj )577( Pdd 54 W(P( ¦¦ 5>65(3 chi 5>60(
Jubo Jdeutcuq 34 ynubtfn Jdeutcuq 53, 5735, bemd`yabhp yb c `chiaicyd&p hboahcyabh wdyayabhpocq ed jaldi jbu udcpbhp udfcuiahf ynd ptjja`adh`q bj ynd hboahcyabh wdyayabhp chi ynd `chiaicyd&pstclaja`cyabhp( Jbu pycyd/vaid bjja`dp, ynd bemd`yabhp cud jaldi vayn ynd @boobhvdclyn @btuy,
vayn c `bwq jaldi vayn ynd Pd`udycuq, chi ynd @boobhvdclyn @btuy p`nditldp c ndcuahf yb id`aid
vndyndu bu hby ynd `chiaicyd vall udocah bh ynd ecllby jbu ynd Hbzdoedu dld`yabh( Pdd 54 W(P( ¦
5106(
Ciiayabhcllq, ynd Idob`ucya` Wcuyq ncp c idldfcyd chi clyduhcyd idldfcyd `booayodhy
utld( C``buiahflq, c `chiaicyd jbu ynd Idob`ucya` wudpaidhyacl hboahcyabh otpy nczd jaldi eq
Mchtcuq 1, 5735 c id`lcucyabh bj `chiaic`q vna`n ctynbua}dp idldfcydp chi clyduhcyd idldfcydp yb
wldifd yndau ptwwbuy chi `booayodhy yb ynd `chiaicyd( Pdd 54 W(P( ¦ 5>01(3( @chiaicydp jbu ynd
Udwtela`ch wudpaidhyacl hboahcyabh ib hby nczd c paoalcu udstaudodhy(
Ynaui wcuyq chi ahidwdhidhy `chiaicydp jald hboahcyabh wcwdup( Jbu ynd 5735,Wudpaidhyacl dld`yabh, ynd jaupy icq yb `au`tlcyd hboahcyabh wcwdup ap Jdeutcuq 34, 5735, chi yndq
otpy ed jaldi eq Ctftpy 3, 5735( Ynd pafhcytud udstaudodhy ap ecpdi twbh ynd udptlyp bj ynd 5733
Otha`awcl Dld`yabh, vna`n vall ed 5$ bj ynd lcufdpy dhyaud zbyd `cpy jbu chq dld`ydi `chiaicyd ahynd Pycyd cy lcufd( Yndud ap chbyndu bemd`yabh wduabi jbu hboahcyabh wcwdup, cp idp`uaedi cebzd,chi ynd bemd`yabhp ocq ed jaldi edyvddh Ctftpy 5 ynubtfn Ctftpy >, 5735( Pdd 54 W(P( ¦¦ 5133chi 5106(
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 14/26
Pah`dudlq,
‥hcynch Ocukp
y‥KTO ; Kdu`n , hd uNBHD HB( = :371:D7906de( 37 5735 71=95WO W5Dq"aj 6 /4yu
Jbu ynd bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy bj ynd T haydi Pycydp, ynd udstaudodhyp cud pycydi ah ynd@bhpyaytyabh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp cy C uya`ld N, Pd`yabh 4, v na`n pycydp %[hb wdupbh d~`dwy chcytucl ebuh `aya}dh, bu c `aya}dh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, cy ynd yaod bj ynd cibwyabh bj ynap
@bh pyaytyabh, pncll ed dlafaeld yb ynd bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy; hdayndu pncll chq wdupbh ed dlafaeld ybyncy bjja`d vnb pncll hby nczd cyycahdi yb ynd cfd bj ynauyq/jazd qdcup, chi eddh jbtuyddh qdcup c
udpaidhy vaynah ynd Th aydi Pycydp(%
Ciiayabhcl ahjbuocyabh udfcuiahf uthhahf jbu bjja`d chi ynd 5735 Dld`yabh @cldhicu `ched jbthi( bh ynd Idwcuyodhy&p vdepayd cy vvv(ifp(pycyd(wc(tp ( Pnbtli qbt nczd jtuyndustdpyabhp, wldcpd `bhyc`y ynd Etudct bj @booappabhp, Dld`yabhp, chi Ldfaplcyabh cy ynd
Idwcuyod hy bj Pycyd eq ydldwnbhd, cy .636! 6>6/45>7, bu zac d/o cal cy ud(/e`dlGpycyd(wc(tp (
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 15/26
*Q (.9 ,303Y
Stclaja`cyabh Udstaudodhyp yb Uth jbu Wtela` Bjja`d
Jdiducl B jja`dp
((
9 y, m&p
JB9, =
p & K Y =
Wudpaidhy bj ynd
Thaydi Pycydp.Thaydi Pycydp @bhpy(,
Cuy( AA, ¦ 3/9!
04 qup( 39 qup( Udpaidhy ah Hcyabh,
Hcytucl Ebuh @aya}dh
Thaydi Pycydp Pdhcybu.Thaydi Pycydp @ bhpy(,Cuy( A, ¦ 0/0!
07 qup( Ahnceaychy bj Pycyd, 1 qup(@aya}dh
Udwudpdhycyazd [email protected] Pycydp @bhpy(,
Cuy( A, ¦ 5/5!
54 qup( Ahnceaychy bj Pycyd, 6 qup(@aya}dh
Pycyd B jja`dp
,9 7 (8( 1(,6/(( y f d(
& 3‥ ( / / = (
Z R
u(
9(m
5 ( , ,
g9/ (6 ( a( ,(D
(( (ua(Fbzduhbu.Wdhhpqlzchac @bhpy(,Cuy( AZ, ¦ 4!
07 qup(
6 qup( Ahnceaychy bj Pycyd,@aya}dhpnaw U dstaudi
Ly( Fbzduhbu.Wdhhpqlzchac @bhpy(,
Cuy( AZ, ¦ 4!
Cyybuhdq Fdhducl.Wdhhpqlzchac @bhpy(,Cuy( AZ, ¦ 4!.Otpy ed Odoedu bj
Ecu bj Ptwudod @btuy
bj WC!
Ctiaybu Fdhducl
07 qup(
07 qup(
6 qup( Ahnceaychy bj Pycyd,@aya}dhpnaw Udstaudi
.HBY
6 qup( Ahnceaychy bj Pycyd,@aya}dhpnaw udstaudi
PWD@AJADI!A
Pycyd Yudcptudu
Pdhcybu ah FdhduclCppdoelq.Wdhhpqlzchac @bhpy(,Cuy( AA, ¦ 4!
54 qup(
.HBY PWD@AJADI!
9 qup( Ahnceaychy bj Pycyd,3 qu( Ahnceaychy bj I apyua`y,9 qup( T(P( @ aya}dh
Udwudpdhycyazd ahFdhducl Cppdoelq.Wdhhpqlzchac @bhpy(,Cuy( AA, ¦ 4!
53 qup( 9 qup( Ahnceaychy bj Pycyd,3 qu( Ahnceaychy bj I apyua`y,
9 qup( T(P( @ aya}dh
@bwq wubzaidi btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 16/26
5"34"5735G4=43=77 WO @boobhvdclyn bj Wdhhpqlzchac
Idwcuyodhy b j Pycyd
Etudct bj @booappabhp, Dld`yabhp * Ldfaplcyabh
9"59"5735 5735 FDHDUCL DLD@YABH WUAOCUQ @CHIAICYD LAPY
Thbjja`acl @chiaicyd Lapyahf
WCFD 3 BJ 49
Thbjja acl Thbjja`acl
D/Ky/{34uu / &
THAYDI PYCYDP PDHCYBU
C Y Y B U H D Q F D H D U CL
CTIAYBU FDHDUCL
Iapyua`ychiaicyd Hcodcuyqtha`awclayqbthyq
Pycydvaid
PCHYBUTO, UA@NCUIDWCAUJC^ @BTHYQ
UBOHDQ, OAYYDW
FAHFUA@N, HDVYDW
WCTL, UBHDW
BECOC, ECUC@KDO
Pycydvaid
U BN U DU , PCODWBEDPBHDUKP
VDL@N, PYDZDHDWN C U LD P Y B V H Y V WNDPYDU
P@CUAHFA, OCU@DWCOW NALL EBUBTOE DU LCH I
POAYN, YBODWLTO@ U DDK YVWU O P Y U B H F
@NUAPYACH, ICZAIDWT@KP
@CPDQ, EBEDO@ U CH YBHC@KCVCHHC
ZBIZCUKC, MBPDWNDOLLDFNDHQ
Pycydvaid
JUDDI, ICZAIDWCOW NALL EBUBTOE DU LCH I
OTUWNQ, WCYUA@KDOUAPYBL YVWT@KP
KCHD, KCYNLDDHDOC@KCVCHHC
Pycydvaid
Bjja`d
WUDPAIDHY BJ YND THAYDI PYCYDP
WAHYB, JUCHK
DWAIILD WC^YBHCTWNAH
@bwq wubzaidi btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 17/26
E d ( & , /(0kucca a a,=p Ybblp
@bthyu} (, chR
p( , Ted`yq 85h i
Nbahdlo=Yq / Doodua`n id Zcyydl / y y pc R `jjhHBV / Etq
&ynap udpbtu`d bhjahW3 @la`k(ndud
Ynd Lcv bj Hcyabhp bu ynd Wuah`awldp bj Hcytucl Lcv .364>!Doodua n id Zcyydl
EBBK 3, @NCWYDU 31
Bj Btu Hcyazd @bthyuq, chi Pdzducl Ynahfp Yncy Udlcyd yb Ay
¦ 533( Vncy ap btu `bthyuq(
YN D nbld/ bj ynd `bthyuadp wbppdppdi eq c hcyabh chi ptemd`y yb ayp ycvp, jbuop, cp vd nczd cludciq pcai, ayp yduuaybuq, chi ap ynd `boobh
`bthyuq bj cll ynd ahiazaitclp bj ynd hcyabh( Vd nczd eddh belafdi yb chya`awcyd ynd idjahayabh bj ynd yduo, hcyazd cyahjaq, ed`ctpd btu ptead`y ydi tp
yb yudcy bj ynd lbzd bj btu `bthyuq ’ c zauytd pb d~`dfdhy chi pb hd`dppcuq ah c pycyd, Ptwwbpahf, yndh, ynap idjahayabh cludciq khbvh, udocahp
yncy vd pnbtli d~wlcahpdzducl ynahfp yncy nczd c udlcyabh yb ynap ptemd`y = chi chpvdu ynd stdpyabhp yncy hcytucllq cuapd(jubo
535( @aya}dhp chi hczdp(Ynd `aya}duap, cud , ynd odoedup bj ynd `azal( pb`ad ebthi yb ynap &pb`adyq eq `duycah ityadp=chi ptemd`y yb ayp ctynbuayq, yndq dstcllq wcuya`awcydd
cizchycfdp( Yndhcyazdp, bu hcytuca/ebuh `aya}dhp, cud (lnipd ebuh ah( ynd `bthyuq, bj wcudhyp vnb cud `aya}dhp, Cp ynd pb`adyq `chhby d~apy chi
wduwdytcyd aypdlj bynduvapd ynch eq ynd `naliudh bj ynd `aya}dhp, Ynbpd `naliudh hcytucllq jbllbv ynd `bhiayabh , bj yndau jcyndup ; chi pt``ddi yb( cal yndau
uafnyp, Ynd pb`adyq ap ptwwbpdi yb idpaud ynap, ah `bhpdstdh`d bj vncy ay bvdp yb ayp bvh wudpdhacyabh; chi ay ap wudptodi, cp ocyydu bj `btupd,
yncy dc`n `aya}dh, bh dhyduahf ahyb pb`adyq, udpduzdp yb nap `naliudh =ynd uafny bj ed`boahf odoedup bj ay( Ynd `bthyuq bj ynd jcyndup €p yndudjbud yncy
bj ynd naliudh; chi yndpd ed`bod yutd aya}dhp odudlq eq yndau yc`ay bhpdhy(( Vd pncly pbbh pdd vndyndu, bh yndau buhahf yb ynd qdcup bj
ap`udyabh, yndq ocq udhbth`d yndau uafny, chi vncy yndq bvd yb ynd pb`adyq ah vna`n yndq vdud ebuhR j pcq, yncy, ah buidu yb ed bj ynd `bthyuq ay a`
hd`dppcuq yncy c wdupbh ed ebuh bj ‥c lcyndu vnb ap(c `aya}dh= jbu, Aj nd ap ebuh yndud bj c jbudafhdu, ay vall ed bhlq ynd wlc`d bj nap eauyn, chi hby nap
`bthyuq
5(30( Ahnceaychyp=(
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 18/26
@6"(""u0" u B uafahcllq Wbpydi Y ntupic q, Cwual 50, 5771
Cuya`ld AA %Hcytucl Ebuh @aya}dh% Odchp Thayq bj @aya}dhpnaw chi Pbld
Clldfach`d cy Eauyn
Cuya`ld AA %Hcytucl Ebuh @aya}dh% Odchp Thayq bj @aya}dhpnaw
chi Pbld Clldfach`d cy Eauyn
eq= Ocuab Cwt}}b, Dps(
dmavudC kA<y h d( 3 3 , 3u N Hdayduk yad`d dnauoyyy yzua # p w a h ZBC yb nd nudpaidcty
Cuya`ld AA bj btu @bhpyaytyabh ncp c lby yb pcq cebty nbv c vbtli/ed Wudpaidhy ap ebuh(%Hcytucl ebuh @ aya}dh% pycytp udstaudp hby bhlq eauyn bh T(P( pbal ety clpb eauyn yb wcudhypvnb cud ebyn T(P( `aya}dhp eq eauyn bu hcytucla}cyabh( Ynap thayq bj mtp pbla .pbal! chi mtp
pchftahap .idp`dhy! ah ynd `nali cy ynd yaod bj eauyn cpptudp yncy ynd `nali ap ebuh vayn pbldclldfach`d .belafcyabh bj jaidlayq chi bediadh`d yb fbzduhodhy ah `bhpaiducyabh jbu
wubyd`yabh yncy fbzduhodhy fazdp .T(P( z( Ktnh, 91 J(Ptww(976, 939 .I(@(H(Q!! chilbqclyq yb ynd Thaydi P ycydp chi yncy hb byndu hcyabh `ch lcq chq `lcao yb ynd `nali&p .lcyduch citly! clldfach`d chi lbqclyq( Ahiddi, thidu pt`n e auyn `au`topych`dp, hb byndu hcyabh`ch ldfcllq bu obucllq idochi chq oalaycuq bu wblaya`cl belafcyabhp jubo yncy wdupbh( Ynd
`nali, cp nd"pnd fubvp, vall clpb nczd c edyydu `nch`d bj hby wpq`nblbfa`cllq pyutfflahfvayn `bhjla`ydi clldfach`d chi lbqclyq yb chq byndu hcyabh(
Thayq bj `aya}dhpnaw chi clldfach`d ap ecpdi b h ynd ydc`nahfp bj ynd lcv b j hcytud .hcytucllcv! chi ynd lcv bj hcyabhp, cp `bhjauodi eq ch`adhy Fuddk chi U boch lcv; C odua`ch,Dtubwdch, chi Dhflapn `bhpyaytyabhp, `boobh chi `azal lcv, chi pycytydp; chi Zcyydup,
Ynd Lcv bj Hcyabhp, cll bj vna`n ynd Jbthiahf Jcyndup udci chi thidupybbi( Yndpdpbtu`dp nczd yctfny `azala}cyabhp jubo yaod aoodobuacl yncy c wdupbh fcahp clldfach`d
chi lbqclyq chi yndudjbud cyyc`nod hy jbu c hcyabh jubo dayndu edahf ebuh b h ynd pbal bj ynd`boothayq idjahahf yncy hcyabh bu jubo edahf ebuh yb wcudhyp vnb vdud clpb ebuh bh yncy
pcod pbal bu v nb hcytucla}di cp ynbtfn yndq v dud ebuh bh yncy pbal( Ay ap bhlq eq`boeahahf cy eauyn ah ynd `nali ebyn odchp yb ahnduay yndpd yvb pbtu`dp b j `aya}dhpnaw yncyynd `nali eq hcytud chi yndudjbud clpb eq lcv ap eb uh vayn bhlq bhd clldfach`d ch i lbqclyqyb chi `bhpdstdhylq cyyc`nodhy jbu bhlq ynd Thaydi Pycydp(
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 19/26
:KAlyu0AY AJ
Btu @bhpyaytyabh udstaudp thayq bj T(P( `aya}dhpnaw chi clldfach`d jubo eauyn bhlq jbu ynd
Bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy chi @boochidu ah @nadj bj ynd Oalaycuq, fazdh ynd thastd hcytud bjynd wbpayabh, c wbpayabh yncy dowbvdup bhd wdupbh yb id`aid vndyndu btu hcyabhcl ptuzazcl
udstaudp ynd idpyut`yabh bj bu c ht`ldcu cyyc`k bh bu pbod ldpp oalaycuq odcptud cfcahpychbyndu hcyabh bu fubtw( Ay ap udstaudi bj ynd Wudpaidhy ed`ctpd pt`n c pycytp fazdp yndCodua`ch wdbwld ynd edpy @bhpyaytyabhcl `nch`d yncy c vbtli/ed Wudpaidhy vall hby nczdchq jbudafh ahjltdh`dp vna`n ed`ctpd bj `bhjla`y bj `bhp`adh`d `ch obpy `duycahlq ycahynap"ndu `uaya`cl id`apabhp ocid vndh ldciahf ynd hcyabh( Ndh`d, ynd pwd`acl pycytp ap c@bhpyaytyabhcl dlafaealayq udstaudodhy yb ed Wudpaidhy chi yndudeq yb ed zdpydi vayn yndpbld wbvdu yb id`aid ynd jcyd chi ptuzazcl bj ynd Codua`ch wdbwld( Bj `btupd, ynd pycytp,edahf c o ahaoto @ bhpyaytyabhcl udstaudodhy, ibdp hby ftcuchydd yncy c v btli/edWudpaidhy vall nczd lbzd chi jdclyq bhlq jbu ynd Thaydi Pycydp( Yndudjbud, ynd jahclahjbuodi chi ahydllafdhy id`apabh bh vnb ynd Wudpaidhy vall ed ap ldjy yb ynd zbydup, yndDld`ybup, chi @bhfudpp cy ynd Mbahy Pdppabh, yb vnbo nbwdjtllq udpwbhpaeld odiac chiwblaya`cl ahpyaytyabhp vall nczd wubzaidi cll ynd hd`dppcuq zdyyahf ahjbuocyabh `bh`duhahf
ynd `chiaicyd&p `ncuc`ydu chi stclaja`cyabhp yb ed Wudpaidhy(
Ynubtfn napybua`cl idzdlbwodhy, thayq bj `aya}dhpnaw chi pbld clldfach`d cy eauyn ap hby
udstaudi jbu T(P( ebuh `aya}dh Pdhcybup, Udwudpdhycyazdp, chi udftlcu `aya}dhp thidu ynd39yn Codhiodhy chi @bhfudppabhcl dhc`yodhyp( Ah `bhyucia`yabh chi vna`n `bhjauop ynd
Jbthiahf Jcyndup& odchahf bj vncy c %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh% ap, hcytucla}di `aya}dhp, pah`d3614, edjbud ed`boahf pt`n otpy pvdcu ch bcyn yncy yndq udhbth`d cll byndu clldfach`dpyb byndu hcyabhp( Ituahf ynd Vcpnahfybh Cioahapyucyabh, ynd Jaupy @bhfudpp wcppdi yndHcytucla}cyabh C`y bj 3614 ah vna`n ay wubzaidi yncy hdv `aya}dhp yckd c pbldoh bcyn ybptwwbuy ynd @bhpyaytyabh chi %udhbth`d% cll %clldfach`d% yb yndau jbuodu wblaya`cl udfaodp(
Ynap ap ituahf ynd yaod yncy obpy bj ynd Jucodup vdud clazd chi pyall c`yazdlq ahzblzdi ahftaiahf chi jbuoahf ynd hdv hcyabhcl fbzduhodhy chi @ bhpyaytyabhcl Udwtela`( Ybicq,
vd pyall udstaud yncy ch cladh twbh edahf hcytucla}di otpy fazd ch bcyn yncy nd"pndudhbth`dp cll jbuodu clldfach`dp chi yncy nd"pnd vall %ptwwbuy chi idjdhi ynd@bhpyaytyabh chi lcvp bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp bj Codua`c cfcahpy cll dhdoadp, jbudafh chiibodpya`(% Ndh`d, clldfach`d ap hby paowlq c ynahf bj ynd wcpy ety zduq ot`n vayn tpybicq( Ay ap aowbuychy yb clpb thid upychi yncy hcytucla}cyabh yckdp ch cladh ec`k yb yndobodhy bj eauyn chi eq lcv `nchfdp yncy cladh&p eauyn pycytp( Ah byndu vbuip,
hcytucla}cyabh, vna`n eq ldfcl idjahayabh udstaudp pbld clldfach`d yb ynd Thaydi Pycydp, ud/`udcydp ynd ahiazaitcl cp ynbtfn nd vdud c ebuh @aya}dh ety bhlq ibdp ay eq lcv chi hby eqhcytud( Ynap ap ynd udcpbh yncy ynd 39yn Codhiodhy `bhpaidup c hcytucla}di wdupbh yb ed c%`aya}dh% bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp chi hby c %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh% bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp( Ynapud`udcyabh bj eauyn pycytp ynubtfn hcytucla}cyabh vna`n clpb d~apydi thidu Dhflapn`boobh lcv clpb wubecelq d~wlcahp vnq Mbnh Mcq thidulahdi ynd vbui %ebuh% vndh nd
ud`boodhidi yb Fdhducl Vcpnahfybh yncy bhlq c %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh% .cp yb pcq ebuh, ahjc`y, eq hcytud, chi hby eq lcv! ed cllbvdi yb ed Wudpaidhy( @bhpdstdhylq, hcytucla}di`aya}dhp pychi bh ch dstcl jbbyahf vayn ebuh @aya}dhp .vnb cud pb ud`bfha}di chi`bhjauodi eq ynd 39yn Co dhiodhy bu eq ch C`y bj @bhfudpp chi vnb `ch ed ety hbyhd`dppcualq cud clpb %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dhp%! d~`dwy yncy yndq `chhby ed Wudpaidhy bu Za`dWudpaidhy, jbu yndq vdud ebuh vayn ch clldfach`d hby bvahf yb ynd Thaydi Pycydp chi
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 20/26
^N "30 AY yj
c`staud yncy pbld clldfach`d yb ynd Th aydi Pycydp bhlq cjydu eauyn( Ptudlq, aj c hcytucla}di
`aya}dh, dzdh ynbtfn nczahf pbld clldfach`d yb ynd Thaydi Pycydp, ap hby @bhpyaytyabhcllq
dlafaeld yb ed Wudpaidhy, vd `chhby d~wd`y chq ldpp bj pbodbhd vnb vd cud vallahf ybid`lcud pb @ bhpyaytyabhcllq dlafaeld(
Ynd Jbthiahf Jcyndup downcpa}di yncy, jbu ynd pckd bj ynd ptuzazcl bj ynd @bhpyaytyabhclUdwtela`, ynd Bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy chi @boo chidu ah @nadj bj ynd O alaycuq ed judd bjjbudafh ahjltdh`d chi ahyuaftd( Ay ap ynd %hcytucl ebuh @ aya}dh% `lctpd yncy fazdp yndCodua`ch wdbwld ynd edpy jafnyahf `nch`d yb kddw ay yncy vcq jbu fdhducyabhp yb `bod(Codua`ch wdbwld ib hby nczd ynd @bhpyaytyabhcl uafny yb nczd chq `duycah wdupbh ed
Wudpaidhy( Ety jbu ynd udcpbhp pycydi cebzd, oahaocllq yndq ib nczd c @bhpyaytyabhcl uafnyyb wubyd`y yndau laeduyq eq khbvahf chi cpptuahf yncy yndau Wudpaidhy ap @ bhpyaytyabhcllqdlafaeld chi stclajadi yb nbli ynd Bjja`d bj Wudpaidhy chi @boochidu ah @nadj bj yndOalaycuq(
Ocuab Cwt}}b, Dps(
3>4 Fcy}odu CzdhtdMcodpetuf H M 7>>03Do cal= cwt}}b [CY_ dublp(`boYDL= 605/453/3177 ’ JC^= 605/453/017:ELBF= nyyw=""wt}bl(elbfpwby(`bo
Jbu obud cebty vncy Becoc vchyp yb naid cebty `aya}dhpnaw lcvp chi nap
`aya}dhpnaw apptdp pdd=
nyyw=""wt}bl(elbfpwby(`bo"5771"76"`aya}dh/cy/eauyn/`ce/ibdp/hby/dstcl(nyuh3
####Wbpydi eq Wt}bl cy 37=56 CO L 9 3 3 1Lcedlp= 39yn Codhiodhy, clldfach`d, Cwt}}b, Cuya`ld AA, ebuh aya}dh, bhfudpp,
`bhpyaytyabh, itcl hcyabhclayq, Kdu`nhdu, kdu`nhdu z becoc, Lcv bj Hcyabhp, hcytucl ebuh
`aya}dh, Hcytucl Lcv, ·ecuhc, Zcyydl
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 21/26
L ` !6=&(‥ ‥cuzcui Thazdupayq, @coeuaifd, Ocppc`ntpdyy p
WCUY A
WCUY a ll ’ UDW BUY EQ P@NBBL @BH@DUHAHF % J/3% PYTIDHY
YB Aooafucyabh chi Hcytucla}cyabh Pduza`d
3( Ynd pytidhy .@nd`k bhd!=
.C ! t Iai hby udfapydu wdupbhcllq cy ynap p`nbbl(
.E ! t Ap hby cuuqahf c jtll btupd bj pytiq( .D~wlcah ah Udocukp!
.@ ! 7 Ap hby cyydhiahf `lcppdp yb ynd d~ydhy hbuocllq udstaudi( .D~wlcah ah Udocukp!
.I ! Ap hb lbhfdu cyydhiahf ynap p`nbbl( .Fazd icyd chi udcpbh jbu yduoahcyabh Ah Udocukp!
(nd pytidhy&p wudpdhy ciiudpp ap,
3( Ynd jbllbvahf ahjbuocyabh ap jtuhapndi `bh`duhahf ynd pytidhy&p idwcuytud bu wlchhdi idwcuytud jubo ynd Thaydi Pycydp,
Icyd bj idwcuytud Wbuy bj idwcuytudcod bj pnaw, caulahd, bu yuchpwbuycyabh `bowchq
iiudpp ceubci
( Udocukp,
Ou( Becod fucitcydi jubo yn d T hazdupayq bj Ncvcaa ah Mthd 31:5; yb
`bhyahtd cizch`di pytiadp cy Ncuzcui Thazdu payq(
Yayld
Jbudafh Pytidhy Cizapdu
Icyd
Mthd 56, 31:5Pafhcytud
@6(
%‥ ‥p
Pytidhy&p Jald Htoedu .aj khbvh!
WCU Y A A / / HBYA@D YB P@NB BL ,@BH@DUHAHF %J/3% PYTIDHY
Cp Ahia`cydi ndudah, ynd cebzd hcodi pytidhy vcp cioayydi yb bu ctynbua}di yb udocah Ah ynd Thaydi Pycydp jbu c ydowbucuq wduabi cp c hbhaooafuchy pytidhy(
Jbu Aooafucyabh Bjja`acl
Aj chq bj ynd jbllbvahf b``tup, wldcpd jall ah Wcuy AAA edlbv chi ocal ynap Jbuo yb ynd aooafucyabh bjja`d nczahf .tuapia`yabh bzd ynd cudc ah vna`n qbtu p`nbbl ap lb`cydi=
.C ! Ynd pytidhy ibdp hby udfapydu wdupbhcllq cy qbtu p`nbbl vaynah :7 icqp bj ynd yaod qbt d~wd`y nao yb udfapydu;
.E ! Ynd pytidhy ibdp hby `cuuq c jtll `btupd bj pytiq;
.@ ! Ynd pytidhy ibdp hby cyydhi `lcppdp yb ynd d~ydhy hbuocllq udstaudi;
.I ! Ynd pytidhy&p cyydhich`d ap yduoahcydi, .Ynap ibdp hby ah`ltid ydowbucuq iap`bhyahtch`d bj cyydhich`d ituahf c zapay ceubci, bu ed`ctpd bj c`tyd Allhdpp bu
Ahmtuq( Nbvdzdu, aj ynd pytidhy jcalp yb udptod cy ydhich`d, ynap udwbuy otpy ed pteoayydi(!
Hcod bj p`nbbl
Thazdupayq bj NcvcaaCiiudpp
3 > 7 3 Tha"f"layqBRNcVEl
Nbhbltlt( Ncvcaa
Hcod bj PytidhyJaupy!Oaiild!Lcpy!cuc`kecuhcRRIcyd bj eauynbthyuq bj eauyn
M t h d 3 > , 3 1 0 9d h q c , C j u a ` c@bthyuq bj `aya}dhpnaw
Cjua`c
COAI PYCYDP IDWCUYODHY BJ MTLAD
AOO AFUCYABH CHI HCYTUCLA]CYABH PDUZA@D
HBYA@D CHI UDWBU Y @BH@DUHAHF HBHAOOAFUCHY %J/3% PYTIDHY
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 22/26
E C U ( C ,@ K B Da COC
la
`t
yuatkp pu( 76(`ubwy
( ( ( ,%bz(p y ubp%# y=wb=
Yjbp tpc y q
Iudcop jubo
Nq Jcyndu
u oty(& ‥ up j=u HT(371::7906
////YND #3 HDV &=yuBUK( YAODP EDPYPDLLDU
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 23/26
ap uc (
b
`a8:@CFb3 4
eldv vncy vcp edpy, qbt pdd( Vndh nd vcp wcppdi tw jah c wubobyabh,
nd `bowlcahdi koilq( &Nbv `ch qbt ed oq pdhabu,& nd vbtli pnq yb bhd
bj ynd oahapydup, &chi zdy A chy ydc`nahf qbt nbv yb ib ubty mbe wubw/
dulq2& Vbui fby ec`k yb Kdhqcyyn yncy ynd Bli Och cu`p c yubteldockdu,
chi nd vcp `clldi ah yb pdd ynd wudpaidhy( C``buiahf yb ynd pybuadp,
Kdhqcyyc pcai yb ynd Bli O ch yncy, ed`ctpd nd `btli hby kddw nap
obtyn pnty, nd vbtli hby vbuk cfcah thyal nd nci hb pnbdp bh nap jddy(
%A ibh&y khbv nbv o t`n bj yndpd idycalp cud yutd( Ety A khbv yncy
vayn ynd wudpaidhy cp ch dhdoq ynahfp ed`cod zduq eci jbu ynd BliOcu(( Nd laKyp echapndi jubo ynd fbzduhodhy’elc`klapydi( Hbhd bj
ynd oahapyuadp vbtli fazd nao vbuk( Vndh nd vdhy yb jbudafh `byuahh/
hadp yb lbbk jbu C wbpy, ynd `bowchadp vdud vcuhdi hby yb naud nao( Nd
edfch lbbkahf ceubci chi vcp naudi/ ybyvbuk jbu ynd Cjua`ch Idzdlbw/
odhy Echk ah Ciiap Cecec, ety edjabud lad `btli mbah yndo, ynd fbz/
do o h y udzbkdi nap wcppwbuy, chi nd/`btlih&y dzdhldczd Kdhqc(
%Jahcllq, nd nci yb c``dwy c pocll mbe vayn ynd( Vcydu I@[Dcl vdhy(
Dzdh ynap vcp wbppaeld bhlq ed`ctpd bhd bj nap juadhip wayadi nahy Ynd
mbe kdwy jbbi bh ynd yceld, ety ay vcp c eaf jcll jbu nao( Ynd B li Och
edfch yb iuahk ndczalq, chi uhchqbj ynd wdbwld nd khdv pybwwdi bco/
Of yb zapay ed`ctpd hbv ay vcp ichfdubah yb/ed pddh vayn nao( Yndq
ybli nao yncy ocqed aj nd cwblbfa}di, `nchfdi nap cyyaytid, nd vbtli ed
cll uafny( Ety nd udjtpdi chi `bhyahtdi yb pcq vncydzdu vcp b h nap oahi(
%A thidupybbi obpy bj ynap bhlq vndh A vcp blidu( Cy ynd( yaod, A
mtpy pcv yncy lajd cy nbod ed`cod zduq iajja`tly( Ynd Bli Och hdzdu
pwbkd yb Ubq bu oqpdlj d~`dwy yb p`bli tp( Nd vbtli `bod nbod zduq
lcyd, iuthk, chi A `btli ndcu nao p nbtyahf cy Utyn, ydllahf ndu yb
`bbk nao jbbi( Utyn ed`cod zduq eayydu cy nbv ynd B li Och nci
`nchfdi( Pbodyaodp, vndh nd vcph&y nbod, pnd vbtli ydll Ubq c ` ai
oqpdlj yncy btu jcyndu vcp `uc}q chi yncypnd wayadi tp jbu nczahf pt`n
c jcyndu( A iaih&y elcod ndu jbu ynap’A wubecelq cfuddi( Ety a hbya`di
yncy, dzdh obud ynch edjbud, pnd yudcydi tp iajjdudhylq jubo ndu bvh
yvb pbhp( Pnd vbtli pcq yncy vd vdud hby ndu `naliudh chi yndud vcp
539
UDCOP JUBO OQ JCYNDU(
ynahfp vdud bkcq Ut yn, btu hdv obyndu, vcp ha`d dhbtfn yb tp yndh(
Pnd yudcydi tp clobpy lakd ndu bvh `naliudh( Ndu wcudhyp vdud ua`n, A
ynahk, chi yndq vbtli pdhi tp edctyajtl wudpdhyp jtbo ynd Pycydp( A&i
fdy udcllq d~`aydi vndhdzdu c wc`kcfd `cod jubo yndo( *CA udodo/
edu pbodyaodp Ubq vbtli udjtpd yb ncyyd yndau fajyp, dzdh vndh yndq
pdhy ynl/ pvddyp( A udodoedu bh`d nd udjtpdi pbod `nb`blcydp yndq nci
pdhy, ety lcydu ah ynd hafny, vndh nd ynbtfny A vcp cplddw, A pcv nao
yalahf pbod bj ynd `nb`blcydp yncy A nci ldjy bh btu iudppdu( Ety A
ia`Ltk pcq chqynahf, ed`ctpd A ynahk A khdv yncy nd vcp thncwwq(
%&Yndh ynahfp edfch yb `nchfd( Vndh Utyn fczd eauyn yb Ocuk
chi Iczai, ndu cyydhyabh pnajydi yb yndo( Ynd Bli Och, nd ldjy ynd
Codua`ch bowchq yb vbuk ah ynd fbzduhodhy, jbu ynd/Oahapyuq bj
Ybtuapo( Nd o cq nczd nci wblaya`cl coeayabhp, chi cy jaupy nd vcp
ibahf vdll ah ynd fbqduhodhy( Ety eq 31:: bnhBahhnd iazapabhp ah
Kdhqc nci nobod obud pduabtp( Wu&dpayadhy Kdhncyyc vcp jubo ynd
lcufdpy yuaed, ynd Kaktqt&p( Ynd Ltbp, ynd pd`bhi lcufdpy yuaed, edfch
yb `bowlcah yncy Kcow&p vdud fdyyahf cll ynd edpy mbep( Ynd fbzduh/
odhy vcp jtll bj ahyuaftd( Ynd za`d/wudpaidhy,/Biahfc, vcp c Aob, chi
nd pcai ynd fbzduhodhy vcp ed`boahf `buunwy( Yncy, ahpydci bj pdua ,/
ahf ynbpd vnb nci jbtfny jbu ahidwdhidh`d, Kdhqch wblaya`achp nci
yckdh ynd wlc`d bj ynd vnayd `blbhaclp, etqahf tw lbvahdppdp chi lchi
yncy pnbtli ed udiapyuaetydi yb ynd wdbwld, Vahf/ c yuadi yb pycuy nap
bvh wcuuq, ety vcp wlc`di yahidu nbtpd cuudpy cp c @boothapy(
Chbyndu wbwtlcu Ahyb oahapydu, Ybyycyallbqc, vcp kalldi eq c Kaktqt
fubch( Lcbp edfch yb wubydpy ah ynd pyuddyp, chi ynd fbzduhodhy
wbla`d `uc`kdi ibvh( Wdbwld vdud kalldi( Cll ynap `udcydi obud ptpwa/
`abh edyvddh ynd yuaedp(
%Obpy bj ynd Bli Och&p juadhip mdpy kdwy stady chi ldcuhdi yb Mazd
vayn ynd paytcyabh( Ety ynd Bli Och edfch yb pwdck tw( Nd vbtli ydll
wdbwld yncy yuaeclapo vcp fbahf yb utah ynd `bthyuq chi yncy thstclajadi
odh vdud ycelahf ynd edpy mbep( N ap juadhip yuadi yb vcuh nao cebty pcq/
ahf pt`n ynahfp ah wtela`, ety nd iaih&y `cud( Nd cnzpqp ynbtfny nd
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 24/26
Jqa/3" %4"u
A A A
337YN @BHFUDPP
5I PDPPABH( UDP( 433Ud`bfha}ahf yncy Mbnh Paihdq O`@cah, AAA, ap c hcytucl ebuh `aya}dh(
AH YND PDHCYD BJ YND THAYDI PYCYDP
CWUAL 37, 577>
Oup( O`@CpKALL .jbu ndupdlj, Ou( LDCJAQ, Ou( BECO C, Ou( @BET UH, O up((@LAHYBH, chi Ou( VDEE! pteoayydi ynd jbllbvahf udpbltyabh; vna`n vcpudjduudi yb ynd @booayydd bh ynd Mtia`acuq
CWUAL 59, 577>
Udwbuydi eq Ou( LD ^AYQ, vaynbty codhiodhy
CWUAL 07, 577>
@bhpaidudi chi cfuddi yb
UDPBLTYABHU d`bfha}ahf yncy Mbnh Paihdq O`@ cah, AAA, ap c hcytucl
ebuh `aya}dh(
Vndudcp ynd @bhpyaytyabh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp udstaudp yncy,
yb ed dlafaeld jbu ynd Bjja`d bj ynd Wudpaidhy, c wdupbh
otpy ed c %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh% bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp;
Vndudcp ynd yduo %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh%, cp yncy yduo cw/
wdcup ah Cuya`ld AA, Pd`yabh 3, ap hby idjahdi ah ynd @bh/
pyaytyabh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp;
V ndudcp yndud ap hb dzaidh`d bj ynd ahydhyabh bj ynd Jucodup
bu chq @ bhfudpp yb laoay ynd `bhpyaytyabhcl uafnyp bj `nal/
iudh ebuh yb Codua`chp pduzahf ah ynd oalaycuq hbu yb
CTYNDHYA@CYDI
T(P( FBZDUHODHY
AHJBUOCYABH
FWB
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 25/26
‥==/""s"60 " 6/
5
wudzdhy ynbpd `naliudh jubo pduzahf cp yndau `bthyuq&p
Wudpaidhy;
Vndudcp pt`n laoaycyabhp vbtli ed ah`bhpapydhy vayn ynd wtu/wbpd chi ahydhy bj ynd %hcytucl ebuh @aya}dh% `lctpd bj
ynd @bhpyaytyabh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, cp dzaidh`di eq
ynd Jaupy @bhfudpp&p bvh pycytyd idjahahf ynd yduo %hcy/
tucl ebuh @ aya}dh%;
V ndudcp ynd vdll/edahf bj cll `aya}dhp bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp ap
wudpduzdi chi dhnch`di eq ynd odh chi vbodh vnb cud
cppafhdi yb pduzd btu `bthyuq btypaid bj btu hcyabhcl ebu/
idup;V ndudcp wudzabtp wudpaidhyacl `chiaicydp vdud ebuh btypaid
bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp bj Codua`c chi v dud thidupybbi yb
ed dlafaeld yb ed Wudpaidhy; chi
Vndudcp Mbnh Paihdq O`@cah, AAA, vcp ebuh yb Codua`ch
`aya}dhp bh ch Codua`ch oalaycuq ecpd ah ynd Wchcoc
@chcl ]b hd ah 310:= Hbv , yndudjbud, ed ay
Udpblzdi, Yncy Mbnh Paihdq O`@cah, AAA, ap c %hcy/
5 tucl ebuh @aya}dh% thidu C uya`ld AA, Pd`yabh 3, bj ynd @bh /
0 pyaytyabh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp(
7
PUDP 433 CYP
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf
8/3/2019 Kerchner & Laudenslager v Obama (as amended) - Petition Objection Filed 17Feb2012 Amended 24Feb2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kerchner-laudenslager-v-obama-as-amended-petition-objection-filed-17feb2012 26/26
Hcytucla}cyabh C`y bj 3617
D / /2."9 w`" Y = 0 ’
Hcytucla}cyabh C`y bj 3617
Hcytucla}cyabh ap ynd wub`dpp eq vna`n ch aooafuchy ed`bodp c `aya}dh, chi yndudeq fcahp cll
bj ynd uafnyp yncy c``bowchq aya}dhpnaw( Ah 3617, ynd T(P( @bhfudpp dpycelapndi hcytucla}cyabh
wub`ditudp yncy vdud stcahy ah bowcuapbh yb ybicq&p dlcebucyd oc}d(
Ldpp stcahy vcp ynd jc`y yncy bhlq vnayd aooafuchyp vdud dlafaeld yb ed`bod `aya}dhp( Lcydu bh,
@clajbuhac chi ochq byndu pycydp vbtli tpd &dlafaealayq jbu aya}dhpnaw& cp c `uayduabh yb idhq
pyall byndu uafnyp yb hbh/vnayd aooafuchyp, lakd ynd uafny yb bvh lchi( Ynap uc`apy udpyua`yabh bh
hcytucla}cyabh vbtli udocah ah djjd`y thyal 3145(
C`y bj Ocu`n 5:, 3617 .3 Pycy 370/379! .D~`duwyp! Yncy chq cladh, edahf c judd vnayd
wdupbh, vnb pncll nczd udpaidi vaynah ynd laoayp chi thidu ynd mtuapia`yabh bj ynd Thaydi
Pycydp jbu ynd yduo bj yvb qdcup, ocq ed cioayydi yb ed`bod c aya}dh yndudbj, bh
cwwla`cyabh yb chq boobh lcv btuy bj ud`bui, ah chq bhd bj ynd Pycydp vndudah nd pncll
nczd udpaidi jbu ynd yduo bj bhd qdcu cy ldcpy, chi ockahf wubbj yb ynd pcyapjc`yabh bj
pt`n `btuy, yncy nd ap c wdupbh bj fbbi ncuc`ydu, chi yckahf ynd bcyn bu cjjauocyabh
wudp`uaedi eq lcv, yb ptwwbuy ynd @bhpyaytyabh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, vna`n bcyn bucjjauocyabh pt`n `btuy pncll cioahapydu; chi ynd lduk bj pt`n `btuy pncll ud`bui pt`n
cwwla`cyabh, chi ynd wub`ddiahfp yndudbh; chi yndudtwbh pt`n wdupbh pncll ed
`bhpaidudi cp c `aya}dh bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp( Chi ynd `naliudh bj pt`n wdupbhp pb
hcytucla}di, ivdllahf vaynah ynd Thaydi Pycydp, edahf thidu ynd cfd bj yvdhyq/bhd qdcup cy
ynd yaod bj pt`n hcytucla}cyabh, pncll clpb ed `bhpaidudi cp `aya}dhp bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp(
Chi ynd `naliudh bj aya}dhp bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, yncy ocq ed ebuh edqbhi pdc, bu bty bj
ynd laoayp bj ynd Thaydi Pycydp, pncll ed `bhpaidudi cp hcytucl ebuh `aya}dhp= Wubzaidi, yncy
ynd uafny bj `aya}dhpnaw pncll hby idp`dhi yb wdupbhp vnbpd jcyndup nczd hdzdu eddh
udpaidhy ah ynd Thaydi Pycydp= (( (
@bwq wubzaidi `btuydpq bj= nyyw=""vvv(Wubyd`yBtuLaeduyq(buf