karen’skorner enforceabilty inserting lists into contracts: clarity
TRANSCRIPT
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKorner
Enforceabilty
Inserting lists into contracts:
Clarity
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerInserting lists into contracts:
Clarity
Enforceability
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerInserting lists into contracts:
Use clear words.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerONE VERY IMPORTANT CONCEPT:
Agen
t Liab
ility
Ambiguity
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerFor example…
Seller
The water pressure regulator is not functioning properly.
Buyer Inspection Notice
The garbage disposal is not functioning properly.
The roof leaks in a few places, per the inspection report.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerAfter seller bites your head off…
Seller Will
Replace the water pressure regulator;
Repair the garbage disposal;
Repair the roof where it is now leaking into the hallway bathroom.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerIf a court needs to enforce either of the two lists…
Anything that is not specifically in the list is intentionally excluded.
Rule of Negative Implication
Intent of the parties
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerIf a court needs to enforce either of the two lists… Therefore… a
court will likely rule thatSeller is obligated to replace the water pressure regulator and repair garbage disposal.
Because the inspection report is not incorporated into the list of items disapproved, it must have been intentionally excluded by the buyer’s agent.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerIf a court needs to enforce either of the two lists…
Because the seller obligated himself to ONE specifically-identified roof repair, he must have intentionally excluded any verbiage that obligates him to repair any other specific places on the roof.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerNinja Rules to live by
when making lists
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerNinja Rules to live by
when making listsDon’t mention documents in a list without incorporating the document into the list:Incorrect: The roof leaks in a few places, per the inspection report.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerNinja Rules to live by
when making listsDon’t mention documents in a list without incorporating the document into the list:Correct: The roof leaks in a few places, as depicted on page 4 of the inspection report. Page 4 of the inspection report is attached to this document and incorporated herein by reference.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerNinja Rules to live by
when making listsKeep in mind that anything left off of the list will likely be considered intentionally excluded.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerNinja Rules to live by
when making listsDon’t use the words “including, but not limited to…” These words are completely unenforceable – because these words are ambiguous.
Karen’sKorner
Karen’sKornerNinja Rules to live by
when making listsDon’t use the term “and/or”. Use either and or or.