k digital simulation of seismic rays · the eastern section of the seismological society of america...

95
äFöSR CO CO K O 00 7Ö-2391TR 1. Thl3 document hap hnonnpproved for public rc.U:r;t; .md sale ; Itü d'..trlbutlon ls unllffllted. 5j DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS Supplement to Final Report 1 June 1966 Through 30 May 1970 Prepared for Geophysics Division Air Force Office of Scientific Research Arlington, Virginia 22209 By P. L. JACKSON August 1970 SEP 20'm GEOPHYSICS LABORATORY INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Sponsored by Advanced Research Projects Agency Nuclear Monitoring Research Office Project VELA UNIFORM ARPA Order No. 292, Amendments 32 and 37 Contract AF 49(638)-1759 Bistritmtion of this documgntls milimitech ^

Upload: others

Post on 20-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

äFöSR

CO CO

K O 00

7Ö-2391TR 1. Thl3 document hap hnonnpproved for public rc.U:r;t; .md sale ; Itü d'..trlbutlon ls unllffllted.

5j

DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS Supplement to Final Report

1 June 1966 Through 30 May 1970

Prepared for Geophysics Division Air Force Office of Scientific Research Arlington, Virginia 22209

By P. L. JACKSON

August 1970

SEP 20'm

GEOPHYSICS LABORATORY

INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

Sponsored by Advanced Research Projects Agency Nuclear Monitoring Research Office Project VELA UNIFORM ARPA Order No. 292, Amendments 32 and 37 Contract AF 49(638)-1759

Bistritmtion of this documgntls milimitech

^

Page 2: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

DISCLAIMER NOTICE

THIS DOCUMENT IS THE BEST

QUALITY AVAILABLE.

COPY FURNISHED CONTAINED

A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF

PAGES WHICH DO NOT

REPRODUCE LEGIBLY .

. ~ :. __ ...,

Page 3: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

8071-33-Fi

DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS Supplement to Final Report

1 June 1966 Through 30 May 1970

Prepared for Geophysics Division

Air Force Office of Scientific Research Arlington, Virginia 22209

By P. L. JACKSON

Sponsored By Advanced Research Projects Agency Nuclear Monitoring Research Office

Project VELA UNIFORM iRPA Order No. 292, Amendments 32 and 37

August 1970

Gcophytici Loberotory

THI INSTITUtj Of SCItNCj AND ttCHNOt.TQT

T H I UNIVIISItT Of wiCHiC*N

Ann Arbef, Michigan

Page 4: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

'

FOREWORD

The research described in this report was conducted by the Geophysics Labora- tory of Willow Run Laboratories, a unit of The University of Michigan's Institute of Science and Technology. The work was performed as part of Project VKLA UNIFORM, sponsored by the Advanced Research Projects Agency and monitored by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research under Contract No. AF 49(638)-1759. The research period extended from 1 June 1966 through 30 May 1970; the Project Scientist is Mr. William .1. Best.

The principal investigators for this project were P. Jackson, R. Turpening, and D. Willis. This report was submitted for publication in July 1970. The Wtllow Run Laboratories' report number is 8071-33-F|.

ili

Page 5: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

PREFACE

The investigation reported in this dissertation was conducted at the

Geophysics Laboratory of the Institute of Science and Technology, The

University of Michigan, over a three-year period. During this period the

preliminary results of this work have been described in presentations,

reports, and a journal article.

On April 5, 1968, a slide presentation of computer-drawn plots was

made to the Geophysical Advisory Committee of the U. S. Air Force Office

of Scientific Research, Alexandria, Virginia.

On April 13, 1968, a paper concerning this work was presented to

the Annual Meeting of the Seismological Society of America, in Tucson,

Arizona (Jackson, 1968).

A major report, including listings and flow diagrams of computer

programs was submitted In September, 1968 to the Air Force Office of

Scientific Research (Willis and Jackson, 1968).

On October 5, 1969, a paper was presented to the Annual Meeting of

the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks-

burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969).

A Journal article describing the application to a spherical earth

appeared in the Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America in

June, 1970 (Jackson, 1970).

During this three-year period numerous progress reports on this

investigation have been submitted to the Air Force Office of Scientific

Research and the American Petroleum Institute.

Page 6: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Ttii' latlior would like to thank David E. Willis, James T. Wilson,

Charles C. Ruf.", Henry N. Pollack, Paul W. Pomeroy, Timothy C. Swanson,

and Rom.>r M. Turpening for helpful suggestions and encouragement. He

also would like to thank Mrs. Clara M. Randazzo for Invaluable help in

preparing the manuscript.

Vl

Page 7: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

ABSTRACT

Simulation of seismic rays for a spherical earth and a flat earth has been

achieved in highly complex models. Travel times and approximate amplitudes of

seismic waves can be found for both two- and three-dimensional models of portions

of the earth. In seismology and other disciplines ray construction customarily has

been applied to simplified geometries. It has been necessary to assume that the

seismic wave velocity distribution of the earth was relatively uniform and symmetric.

Recently, however, the earth has been found to be more complex and non-

uniform than formerly assumed. A need has thus arisen in seismology to test highly

heterogeneous models of seismic velocity distribution. At the same time the devel-

opment of the modern digital computer has provided a means of performing the

necehsary ray constructions and numerical calculations.

The problem at complicated seismic velocity distributions was therefore investi-

gated in terms of the most appropriate use of the digital computer. For this investi-

gation a velocity field was set up, and the propagation mmputatlnns made for short

segments of rays within this field. Total travel timt's are found by adding the travel

times of connected ray segments. Essentially, the nature of propagation was dupli-

cated on the computer, In that, at the location of fach Kigiiifnt along the path of propa-

gation, the initial condition and effect of the surrounding* dclrrmini- the »ucrording

direction of the following segment.

Both visual aiid numerical results have shown that this simulation method can

be usefully applied to Investigation of seismic velocity distributions of portions of

the earth of any size or complexity.

vll

Page 8: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

CONTENTS

Prefaco li

List of Fi^utvs v

Introduction 1

Two-Dimensional Simulation 9 Flat Earth 9 Spherical Earth 12

Three-Dimensional Simulation 14

Auxiliary Computations 18 Travel Time 18 Approximation of Amplitude 19 Reflection 20 Multiple Reflections and Refractions 20 Interface Location 22

Computer Programs 22

Resul tH 24 Accuracy 24 Plane Waves 26 Spherical Earth 27 Three-Dimensional 27 Potential Application to Seafloor Spreading Problem 29

Conclusions • 33

Appendix: Listings of Computer Programs ••• 57

ix

Page 9: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

FIGURES

1. Reference Frame for Incrementing Rays. 37

2. Computer Output Using Direct Ray Simulation for 38 Five P-Rays,

3. Propagation of P Through Hypothetical Crust ind Upper 39 Mantle Structure.

4. Propagation of PcP Through Hypothetical Crust and Upper 40 Mantle Structure Shown in Figure 3.

5. Plots of P. PcP, PKP, PKIKP, PKKP, and PKIKKIKP Rays 41 Generated with a Spherical Earth Program.

6. Multiple Reflection. PcP and PKP Rays up to PKKKKKP. 42

7. Uniformity of Plotting and Travel Times Symmetrically 43 Plotted from 700 km Depth.

8. Three-Dimensional Ray Tracing in a Region Defined by 44 30 x 30 x 30 Velocity Samples.

9. Line Source at Depth for Three-Dimensional Representation 45 as Shown in Figure 8,

10. Three-Dimensional Ray Tracing with Velocity Distribution 46 Defined by Continuous Mathematical Function.

11. Three-Dimensional Ray Tracing with Velocity Functions 47 Specified for Different Regions.

12. Ray Paths From Earthquake Above Underthrusting Lithosphere 48 at Continental Plate Boundary. Depth of Focus: 50 km.

13. Ray Paths From Earthquake Above Underthrusting Lithosphere 49 at Continental Plate Boundary. Depth of Focus: 100 km.

14. Ray Paths Frcm Earthquake Within Underthrusting Lithosphere 50 at Continental Plate Boundary. Depth of Focus: 60 km.

15. Ray Paths From Earthquake Within Underthrustlng Lithosphere 51 at Continental Plate Boundary. Depth of Focus: 110 km.

16. Earthquake Above Underthrustlng Lithosphere at Continental 52 Plate Boundary. Depth of Focus: 50 km.

Xi

Page 10: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

17. Earthquake Above Underthrusting Lithosphere at Continental 53 Plate Boundary. Depth of Focus: 100 km.

18. Earthquake Within Underthrusting Lithosphere at Continental 54 Plate Boundary. Depth of Focus: 60 km.

19. Earthquake Within Underthrusting Lithosphere at Continental 55 Plate Boundary. Depth of Focus: 110 km.

xii

t

Page 11: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Introduction

Possibly no artificial construction has been more useful to science

than the ancient concept of the ray. Not only in seismology, but in all

scientific fields concerned with the transfer of energy, reasoning with

and construction of rays have resulted in fundamental advances.

The firm basis of rays in science is most dramatically shown in

optics. From ancient times to the present, light rays have been used

for intuitive visualization and have resulted in advances in optics and

related fields. Archimedes, Aristotle, Roger Bacon, Kepler, Newton,

Young, Fresnel, Rutherford, and Conpton all used the ray concept. Newton's

Optiks (1730; 1952) is probably the most lucid example of rays as both

a rationale and a means of intuitive understanding and imaginative dis-

covery; almost every figure in Newton's book is a ray tracing.

In seismology, with which this thesis is concerned, the use of rays

aided Mohovoricic (1910) in discovering the discontinuity between the

mantle and the crust; Gutenberg (1914) inferred the existence and esti-

mated the size of the earth's core with the aid of rays; and, in theor-

etical analysis, Zoeppritz (1919) employed the ray concept to derlvt the

relationships of reflected and refracted dilatational and distortion«!

waves at an interface.

Current selsmologlcal contributions to the knowledge of the earth

continue to rely on the concept of rays. Current issues of scientific

journals in seismology usually contain several articles which are il-

lustrated by and rely on seismic rays.

Page 12: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

In scismics r^st ray tracing has been based on Herglotz-Wiechert

formulation as extended by Bullen (1963), Helbig (1965) used this geo-

metrical construction for a graphical method for spherical shells,

Sph ically symmetric ray tracing has also been described by Julian and

Anderson (1968) and shown by Lewis and Meyer (1968). Engdahl, et al,

(1968) employed the formulation for the 1968 P-Phase Tables (Taggart,

et al., 1968).

Iyer and Punton (1963) broke away from rigid geometrical limita-

tions in constructing successive wavefronts by applying Huygens' princi-

ple involving complicated logic. Yacoub, et al, (1968) also departed

from rigid geometry by considering regions of constant velocity in which

the interfaces can be oriented In any direction. He also computed the

amplitudes by Zoeppritz's equations for rays crossing an Interface.

The ray simulation described In this dissertation Is based upon a

new concept leading to the treatment of heterogeneous structures and the

travel-time solutions for any discretely specified and/or analytically

represented velocity distributions.

An advance in the art of tracing rays Is thus a significant contri-

bution to the science of seismology; and, by extension, to other sciences.

Currently two aspects of recent scientific and technological development

provide, first, a new requirement and, second, a practical means of

satisfying this requirement.

The requirement to Investigate non-slmpllfled, heterogeneous velo-

city distributions, has arisen from the discovery that the earth Is less

symmetric and more heterogeneous than previously supposed. More accurate

Page 13: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

and extensive seismic measurements are currently being made. The need

for greater understanding has made simplifying assumptions of the velo-

city distribution of the earth less useful. Tracing rays through

heterogeneous velocity structures and determining their travel times

would be useful in gaining detailed understanding of the earth.

The practical means to achieve the tracing of rays and determina-

tion of travel times through complex velocity distributions is the em-

ployment of the modern digital computer. Complicated velocity distribu-

tions imply unpredictable velocity gradients. In large regions a ray

must be constructed with many different computations because of changes

within relatively small regions. With a digital computer one can carry

out successive computations, which enables one to treat the complicated

velocity distributions indicated by modern seismology.

With these two aspects in mind—the requirement and the apparent

means of fulfilling the requirement—a preliminary trial was made to

develop a new method of ray tracing. The point of departure was to

somehow propagate rays through some type of mathematical or representa-

tional cross-section of a velocity distribution. The approach was to use

a sampled structure into which a short segment of a ray could be intro-

duced at a given location and with which the directions and positions of

successively added segments could be found as functions of the velocity

distribution represented by the structure.

A rectangular two-dimensional grid of equally-spaced points was

considered. The grid points represented positions on a vertical cross-

section of the earth, each point corresponding to a given horizontal and

Page 14: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

viTtical (list.im.- from a reference point. A "sampled" velocity and slope

would tnrr.spond to each point of the Rrid. A means was then required

of usin^ the velocities and slopes, and the relationships between neigh-

boring samples of their values, to "propaßate" short successive segments

of the rays through the sampled velocity distribution. This means was

found. An introductory description follows.

Hie aforementioned grid was considered as a matrix in which the

rows represented discrete horizontal distances along the cross-section,

while the columns represented discrete vertical distances, as shown in

Figure 1. Such a matrix can be represented as a vector with two Indices.

Call the vector V , in which i represents the row, and j Che column of

the matrix. For each set of indices (i,j) a position on Che cross-secCion

can bo identified. For example, let Che inCerval bcCween Che samples be

10 km. Then the indices (i ■ 1, j ■ 1) could represent Che reference

point (0,0) at the surface of the earth and on Che cross-secdon; Che in-

dices (i - 10, j - 1) represent a distance 90 km from Che reference polnc

on the surface; the indices (I - 5, j ■ 3) a horizontal distance 40 Ion

from the reference point at a depth of 20 km. The indices must be inte-

gers greater than zero to represent Che macrix in Che computer. For Chls

reason the smallest pair of indices (1,1) are taken Co represenC an ori-

gin (0,0). This bias is easily handled, as Che source can be anywhere

within the bounds of the matrix, provision for measuring from the source

location must be made.

At each location defined by two indices there corresponds a velocity

V . and a slope S... These values at discrete points can be referenced i j ij

Page 15: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

fron locations closest to then. A ray, however, is a succession of

short segments of possibly differing directions. These sepients may be

Joined together nt non-discrete locations, say the coordinates (h,d),

where h is horizontal distance and d is depth in a cross-section of the

earth. At each matrix location (h,d) a computation must be made to de-

temine the direction and hence end position of a succeeding segment.

The ray segnent midpoints could Chen be referred to the nearest discrete •

(itJ) location co determine Che velocity V and slope S. For example,

consider the scale, or stapling Incerval as shown In Figure 1 was 10 km,

ard Che ray segnent midpoint was located wich respect to Che matrix at

h • 4.75, d • 3.25 corresponding Co H - 37*5 ka and D - 22.5 ka on Che

referenced cross-secdon of Che earch. The velocity V and slop« S would

be found ac Che locadon IndlcaCed by Che Indices (1 • 5, J ■ 3), and

could be easily referenced; If desired, one could Incerpolace Che values

beewcen Chose found aC (1 - 5, j ■ 3) and (i - 4, J • 4).

AC Che nidpoint of every ray segnent a value for velocity and slope

Is found. For geonecrlcal ray tracing, Snell's law requires the knowl-

edge of an Incident direcdon wich respect to an Interface and Che velo-

clcy of Che nedlun on elcher side of Che interface. The representational

structure described above supplies this Infomation. The direction of the

IncldenC ray segnenc and Che slope of Che Incerface a.c known, therefore

Che IncldenC angle for Snell's law can be found. The velocity V. of Che

nediun on Che IncldenC side of Che Incerface Is found as described In Che

lasc paragraph. The veloclcy V. on Che energlng side can be found by ex-

Cending Che ray segnenc in Che saie direction as the -ncldent ray for

Page 16: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

the Httinmeni , .i^ain using the technique described in the last paragraph.

Fur .1 fixed rectangular Cartetiian coordinate eystea, a horizontal

distance can he represented at» L sin 6 and a vertical distance as L cos 0,

where I. U a length of a ray segment and 6 Is the angle fro« the up-

ward vertical. 0 is positive in the counterclockwise direction. Now

consider that the head of an incident ray sagaent of angle 0. located at

(h. td. )t and, hy invoking Snell's law the anerging angle is found to he

** , a» shown In Figure 1. The location of the tail end of the eaerging n

ray segment is found to be h ■ h. + 0.3 L sin 6, d ■ d. ♦ 0.5 L cos 8.

As the direction and location of the eacrging ray sagaent as wall aa

the velocities and slopes of the isaediate surrounding regions arc known

whenever they may he within the defined aatrix, the eaerging ray sapient

can he redefined as the new incident ray aapwnt, and succaading seg-

ments generated and Joined end-to-end until a coopletc ray is forasd.

Travel times of the radiation of seisalc waves froa the disturbance

to the HeiNioometer are of fundauntal importance in seiaaology. The in-

formation to determine travel times is available with this ray tracing

method. Each segment of the ray is located in a region In which the

velocity is known. The travel time for each segaent can be found by di-

viding the length of rhe seprntt by the average velocity along its

length. The travel cime for the ray is then the sum of Che travel tiaes

of the sepnents. The distance of travel la found by suaalng Che lengths

of the segments. This distance is useful for computing spherical spread-

ing and logarithmic attenuation.

6

Page 17: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

The approach described above was teated with a conputer prograa.

The initial reaulta were proaising, and Che ideas seemed Co be valid.

A aeiamic ray could he simulated through a matrix representing a sampled

velocity distribution in a vertical cross-section of the earth. The in-

veatigation to produce a useful, accuratec and versatile seismic ray

simulation was then commenced. The ensuing Investigation waa mainly de-

voted to attacking the following problems:

1. Accommodating ray angles through the entire rangt of 360* ( and

of using any defined slope In aasociation with any given ray angle,

2. Reflection from an interface,

3. Both critical and non-critical multiple reflections,

4. Precisely locating an Interface between matrix-designated dis-

crete locationa and extending the ray to thia interface,

5. Developing and testing a method to obtain high accuracy, of

determining travel times and approximate amplitude in a multiply-reflec-

ting model,

6. Adding the capability of apecifying regions of velocity charac-

teristics defined by an analytical mathematical function,

7. Treating both curved and flat earth,

8. Applying the concept f a throe-dimensional model, and

9. Making the method general so that one program can be used for

many different regions of the earth.

A versatile tool has been developed for the scientific investiga-

tion of velocity distribution in the earth. Any conceivable velocity

distribution can be almulated and cohered to actual travel times in

Page 18: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

investiiMtiuna where Reoaetrlcal ray approxlaatlons are valid. In addi-

tion, the tifthod 1M expandable, and can be uaed aa a baae for «ode con-

version, the .iddition of Zoepprics'a equation! for anplltude, extenalon

to the jtmoNphere where winds provide a Moving aediu«, and, possibly,

for Reoaetrlc diffraction.

The simulation of seisaic rays can be performed with sicher two» or

three-dimensional models. Flat ssrth modsls naturally accowodate them-

selves to a rectangular Cartesian coordinate system. Curved earth

models, which at first glance would appear to be better treated in polar

coordinates, are also trested in a rectangular Carteaim system becauss

the velocities and slopss for a spherical earth are easily referer.ccd.

Also the compatibility of coordinate systems between flat and spherical

earth enables one to inssrt ssmpled values for anomaloua regions within

a spherical earth model.

Aa first conceived, it wss thought thst the two-dimensional techni-

que of ray tracing could be incorporated into the three-dimensional

technique, and two-dimensional tracing performed when holding the values

along one of the axes of the three dimensions constant. However, the

use of three-dimensional models required s sufficisntly different tech-

nique that the two types sre better explained ssparatsly. The descrip-

tion of the use of the three-dimensional modal is not self-contained.

To avoid repetition of identical material, pertinent matter presented in

the two-dimensional section will be referred to when describing its use

In three dimensions.

8

Page 19: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Two-Dlacnstonal Sliulatlon

FUt Earth

Both discrete values assigned to a matrix and continuous mathemati-

cal fisictions may be employed to reference velocity. To aid in visuali-

zation, the following exposition is based on the discrete case.

Construct a two-dimensional scalar field representing the seismic

velocity characteristics and slopes along a plane in a medium, such that

V - f(xft) fl)

S - g(x(t) - h(V) (2)

where V is the velocity (actually the speed with which seismic P-waves

propagate, but to be referred to henceforth as velocity, in keeping with

common practice In seismology), f, g, and h are functions, and x,s represent

distances parallel to the axes of a rectangular Cartesian coordinate sys-

tem. The functions f and g may be defined differently for specified regions

of the field, and can Include both continuous mathematical functions and

references to tables of arbitrary and discretely changing values. The

function g may be derived directly from f as the normal to the gradient,

or specified separately. One might term S a vector, as it corresponds

to a direction and Is based on the gradient. However, It is defined as

an angle and Is used as a scalar quantity in the computation.

Consider a matrix of discrete values, the rows of which represent

equally spaced horizontal positions within the scalar field. For each

element of the matrix a velocity and slope Is assigned which corresponds

to the location represented In the scalar field. Values for velocities

and slopes can be found In the scalar field at any point not corresponding

9

Page 20: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

to thf lii.. i.tf loc.itlons represented by liie n..itrix elements. These

values art* foiiiid bv either USIMR those of the matrix elements to which

the location is closest or Interpolating betwi-en the nearest horizontal

and vertir.il elements of the matrix. Thus for any position in the sca-

lar field, the value for the velocity and slope can be found by refereme

to the nearest element of the matrix.

As arbitrary values can be stored in the matrix, any type of velo-

city distribution can be referenced to the scalar field. Through such

a reference system a completely heterogeneous velocity distribution can

he used for ray tracing; the limits of heterogeneity are limited only by

the detail with which the matrix elements represent the scalar field.

That Is, by the distance represented by two adjacent elements of the ma-

trix. The matrix with the velocities and slopes represented as its ele-

ments is necessary to arbitrarily represent velocity distributions, but

not to perform ray tracing through the scalar field.

Select a position x. , z. for the head end of an incident ray seg-

ment of length L and an angle 0. (O^eOöO*). The midpoint of this seg-

ment is the location which is used to determine the incident velocity

V. in the manner described above. Reference 6. to the negative z-axls,

counterclockwise positive. The z-axis, which represents depth in the

earth cross-section, is positive downward. Extend the ray segment a

distance I. in the direction 9,. k

The Initial emerging location P. is found by extending the ray seg-

ment at the incident angle 6. , shown in Figure 1, using the two following

equat inns:

10

Page 21: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

x = x, + L sin 0. (3a) p k k

z » z. + L cos 9. (3b) p k k

The midpoint of this extended ray segment is the location which is used

to determine the initial emerging velocity V . m

Sufficient information (position and angle of the ray, and the

velocities and slopes surrounding the region of the ray) is available

to construct the ray continuation by Snell's law. The equation used for

this purpose Is

em - ARCSIN[(Vm/Vk) sin (6^)] + Sk (A)

where 0 is the angle of emergence, V is the emerging velocity, V. is

the incident velocity, and Sk(-90<,<S$90o) is the slope of the Interface

referenced counterclockwise positive from the x-axis. In case of con-

tinuous velocity functions S. is the normal to the direction of the

velocity gradient. The extension of this segment is termed "probing"

in the sense that one must repetitively probe for the proper emerging

angle 6 . For the first repetition 6 replaces 6 in Equation (3)

and P , P are recomputed. A new 6 is determined using the newly-found

V in Equation (A). Equations (3) and (4) are repeated in succession, m

each time using the previously determined value of 6 for 6. in Equation

(3). The repetition is terminated when successive values of 6 are suf- m

ficlently close in value (Id - 6 ,|<c, where c is a predefined small m m—i

value).

This repetition is necessary because the location of the extension

computed with the incident angle is in general different from the loca-

tion computed with the emerging angle. If the ray is penetrating into

11

Page 22: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

a region of increasing velocity the emerging angle between the ray segment

and the normal to the interface will be too large. If penetrating into

a region of decreasing velocity this angle will be too small. These

improperly evaluated angles are found because the tentative ratio V /V. m K

may be a different value from the ratio as found when extending the ray

with the correct emerging angle. One can asymptotically converge to the

correct emerging angle bv repeating these computations. These repeti-

tions are performed to improve accuracy for computations using any given

ray segment length L. Linearity of the velocity function is assumed with-

in the distance L. Also, to improve accuracy one might reduce the seg-

ment length L, as the accuracy is an inverse function of L, and L is not

required to be equal length for all ray segments. However, it still

must hold that the difference between two successively-determined emer-

ging angles 0 would have to be a small value.

When the sufficiently accurate 6 is found by repeatedly applying m

Equations (3) and (4), the emerging ray segment and angle is determined.

This emerging segment and angle is then treated as the incident segment

with a new location and angle. Segments are repeatedly computed, the

tail of the "emerging" segment joined to the head of the "incident" seg-

ment repeatedly until the ray, which is the sunmation of all the seg-

ments, penetrates to the surface or the boundary of the defined cross-

section of the earth.

Spherical Earth

Consider a velocity distribution with depth for a symmetric earth.

12

Page 23: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

One can compute the velocity and slope for any position (x,y) within a

circle representing the cross-section of the entire earth. The velocity

is found as follows:

Vk - f(R) = f[(xk2 + yk

2)?'2] (5)

where f is a function of the radius R; V. is found for any location de-

fined by (x, ,y.) from either a table and interpolating, or by computing

some mathematical function of the radius R ■ (x2 + y2) 2.

For each location defined by (x, ,y, ) a slope S. can be found,

Sk - ARCTAN (yk/xk) ± TT/2 (6)

where y and x are the coordinates of a given location, y-0, x*0 are the

coordinates of the center of the earth, and the sign of 71/2 depenas upon

the quadrant In which y and x are found.

The angular distance at which a ray emerges Is found by

A - ARCTAN (yk/xk) (7)

where the proper quadrant is determined from the relationships of the

signs of x and y, and where x and y are located within a small predefined

distance from the surface of the earth.

The depth of penetration, or, correspondingly, the minimum radius

of the ray upon reflection is found by computing the minimum radius along

a given ray, and retaining that radius to correspond with the other pre-

viously described data of the emerging ray.

Any region which is defined by minimum and maximum values

or functions of x, y, or R can be postulated so that a different function

can be invoked. For example, one might wish to investigate the travel

times of rays which penetrate an anomalous region in an otherwise symmetric

13

Page 24: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

region of the earth. Within the limits defined, any sampled value can

be inserted for the positions defined by x and y, as in the flat earth

case.

Three-Dimensional Simulation

Construct a three-dimensional scalar field representing the seismic

velocity characteristics of a medium, such that

V - f(x,y,z) (8)

Sj^ - g(x,y,z) (9)

S2 - h(x,y,z) (10)

where, as in the two-dimensional fields V Is the velocity, S. represents

the slope with respect to the z-axls, S« the slope along planes parallel

to the x,y plane, and f, g, and h are functions. Positions within the

field are referenced in a three-dimensional orthogonal Cartesian coordi-

nate system. Directions within the field are referenced In a spherical

coordinate system, in which the angle from the positive z-axls is

4)(0<(|»<-rT) and the direction from the a-axls in a'plane parallel to the

x,y plane is the angle 9(0<9<2Tr), the same as that described for two di-

mensions. A segment L oriented in a direction defined by (j) and 6 pro-

jects a distance P on the z-axis z

and on the x-axis as

and on the v-axis as

P - L cos (() (11) z

P - L sin (j) sin 6, (12) x

P - L sin (J) cos 9. (13) y

14

Page 25: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

To visualize the role of the two slopes ^j (-TT/2<S1<7T/2) and S.,(0. S2<2TT)

more clearly, consider an interface or a plane normal to the gradient

which lies obliquely to all of the axes. Then the slope S Is the di-

hedral angle between the z-axis and the plane of the interface

(when interface is mentioned it also refers to the normal plane to the

gradient). The slope S. is found by the angle of the line which defines

the intersection between the x,y plane and the plane of the Interface,

and is referenced as in the two-dimensional case.

The coordinate system is a right-handed system in which the z-axis

is downward. Thus when a region of the earth is represented positive z

values correspond to depth from the surface of the earth, or from an

arbitrary horizontal boundary. Although an orthogonal Cartesian coordi-

nate system is employed for position, a new position can hs determined

by employing a length L, and the angles $ and 6. The two coordinate

systems are complementary.

We see from the foregoing definitions that, as in the case of the

two-dimensional system, we have sufficient information to compute Snell'«;

law In fhe three-dimensional system: L, ^, 0, x, y, z, V, S., and S..

However, in the three-dimensional system the algebraic and trigonometric

processes become much more Involved.

Consider a velocity distribution in which the gradient is everywhere

parallel to the z-axis as defined above. Such a distribution would cor-

respond to a region of the earth in which all interfaces were parallel

to the surface of the earth. Therefore, no velocity change would occur

along a horizontal direction. With such a velocity distribution, the

15

Page 26: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

i<ri,(in.tl .iiv.l>' ". of » ray would never change» althoufth It* «ign night.

This Is Sft-jiwe V • V, and, therefor« P • 6. , a« aeen by reference

to Equation (4). The «traightnefta of the ray ia illustrated in the

orthoRraphii- projection in the x.y plane of Figure 8. The total change

In direct ion will be in the angle 4, which can be computed aa

♦B • ARCSIH|(Vi|/Vlt) aln^-S^J ♦ Slk (14)

where the Ruhacripta ■ and k refer to emergence and Incidence aa in the

two-dimensional caae.

Uc now consider a scalar field in which the interface* «ay be any

orientation in three-dimensional apace; Che condition described in Che

last paragraph would not hold for this caae. If Che coordinaces were

oriented in such a manner that Che t-axi* waa perpendicular Co Che inter-

face, then the condition holds where 6 does not need Co be recompuced

and a simple expression for ♦, Equation (14), can be employed. AC any

Riven location within Che field Che anglea 9. and ♦. are known, aa well

as the »lopes S . and S. . If a coordinate system can be found in which

the r-.ixls Is perpendicular to the interface defined by S.. and S,. , Chen

the calculation of Snell's law for 4 in Equation (14) needs only Co

he used.

Such a coordinate system can be found by rotating the axes as a

function of S.. and S... After rocation Che positions x,y,s are referenced

by x'.y^z' and the angles $ and 6 by 4* and 6* to Che new oriencations

of the coordinate system axes. Snell's law can then be invoked with para-

meters referenced to the new coordinate system. The new position is

found as fellows.

16

Page 27: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Let S* b« Che »igle by which the x- and y-asee are rotated around

the s-aKis, and S! the angle by which the x'-axia ia rotated about the

y'-axia (or, viewed differently, the angle with which the s-axia ia

tilted to becoae normal to the interface.) For a continuoua ■atheaatl-

cal function angle S* ia 2

SJ • (ii/2) - arctan(AX/AY) (15)

where AX and AY are directional derlvativea along the x-asia and v-axia

respectively. S* is found aiailarly aa

8J - (»/2) - arccos(AZ/AX> ♦ AY2 ♦ AZ1)1* (16)

where AZ is the directions! derivstive along the s-axia. For ssapled

functions S! and S^ are

S'j- (ii/2) - SjU.j.k) (17)

and

S'j- S2(l.J.k) (18)

respectively.

The coordinste sxss can then be rotated, and correaponding location«

in the new coordinate syataa found by rotscing first sround Che s-axia

and next sround the y'-sxls:

X- • X cos (S*2) ♦ Y sin (Sj) (19)

Y' - Y cos (SJ) - X ain (Sj) (20)

X» - XM cos (S|) - Z sin (SJ) (21)

Z* - Z cos (SJ) ♦ X- sin (SJ) (22)

The angles 6* and +* are found in a aiailar Manner by coaputing a

position with trigonoBstric functions, rotating the coordinate axea, and

caking Inverse trlgonoastrlc functions of the sngles of a directed vector

froa the origin to the posicion In Che new coordinste systea.

17

Page 28: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Wh*n f.K-h Hfitpient of the ray is computed, the new position can be

round bv rotating th« coordinates back into Che originally specified

i-oordinatf system. From this position in the given coordinate system

the incident velocity V Is known, and by repeated computation in the

manner deticribed in the section on two-dimensional tracing Che proper

emerginK .wu;!«— •> and ; can be asymptotically approached Co within a fli wk

predetermined small value.

In returning the rotated coordinate system, the values V* and V* k m

required tc compute Snell's law to determine the emsrging angle A*, are

VJ - Vk (23)

'i " Vk * (Vm " Vk) co• ^ (24)

where, again, the prims refers to values In the new coordinate system,

.md .*' refers to the repetitively probed value to correctly determine V . m m In the rotated coordinate system we are concerned with only one

direction of reflection, so this can be handled in the sams manner aa in

F.quation (30) of the next section. The only angle affected is A', aa 6*

will he unaffected. However, in the originally given coordinate system,

the direction of the ray may reverse itself in its projection on the

x,y pl.m«-.

Auxiliary Computatlona

Trawl Times

AH each segment of the ray is found and added on to the preceding

Hegmentfl, the travel time can be determined. The time of travel for

each *ean<>nt is simply the length of the individual segment L divided

18

Page 29: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

by the average velocity V at which It la propagating( ao that the total

travel time TT of a ray la n

TT - [ L /V (25) aM

where n la the total nunber of aegaents fro« the lay's origin to ita

eaergence on the surface.

ApproKlaatlon of ^»plltude

The total diatance D a ray haa travelled la n

D - J L (26) a-1 a

Knowing chia diatance, one can coapute the aaplitude dinenalon due to

apherical apreading and the exponential attenuation to energy dlaaipa-

tlon aa

^ - Aa(l/D) axp(-cD) (27)

what« A la the aaplitude at the receiver, A la the aaplitude at the

aourca, and c la the attenuation coefficient.

In caae of non-critically reflected raya and the enaulng refracted

raya, the partition of energy la rigoroualy coaputed by Zoepprits's

aquatlona. The approxlaat.ve approach uaed here la that of Praanal'a

reflection coefficient at notaal Incidence. At a reflective interface

where non-critleal reflection occura the approxlaate reflected aaplitude

Arl.

Ar • \(Vk * Vl>/(Vk 4 Vl> (28)

and the aubaequantly refracted «plltude la

Vl • \ - Ar (29)

19

Page 30: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

iU-f loction

Reflrction is required whenever an interface of auffir lent velocity

difference Is encountered by the ray, or whenever the critical angle it

exceeded. At such a boundary the reflected angle 8 la

9t - w - ei ♦ 28J 1 2nir (30)

where n is -1, 0, or 1, ao that the condition 0*d<2ir la fulfilled.

Multiple Reflections and Mfractlona

When the ray is both reflected and refracted at an interface, it

splits into two separate raya. To accosaodate thla fact, and to trace

out both ray branches, the inforaation of the angle, poaition, total

travel time and distance to the interface, and approxiaate aaplltudes

cosiputed by Fresnel'-. reflection coefficient at nons«! incidence auat

he stored for one ray branch while the inforaation for the other is

employed for further ray tracing. Ihia is accoaplished by continuing

with the reflected ray until it eaerges or strikes another interface.

In emerRing at the surface all the required data, auch aa distance,

total travel tiae, approxiaate aaplitude, and the depth of penetration

of the ray is available. The depth of penetration is found by coaparing

the depth at all segaents of the ray, and retaining the poaition aost

distant from the surface. One then returns to the previous interface

from which non-critical reflection occurred, and, uaing Che inforaation

listed in the laat paragraph which haa been retained, continues with the

refracted ray. As an enseable of inforaation can be retained froa pre-

20

Page 31: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

vlouM reflections, on« Is sble to accoModst* «s many aultiple reflec-

tions as desired.

The Multiple reflections nay be accomodated in the following Ban-

ner. Consider arrays of any arbitrary number of element« for each para-

•eter needed to construct a ray, say

H(l),V(l)te(i).TT(i),Tl(l), and A(i), (31)

where H Is horizontal position, V is vertical position, 6 Is angle of

the first refracted segment, TT is trsvel time to the interface under

consideration, TL is total path length to the interface, and A is aapli-

tude; the index i in each value in (31) represents the reflection nuaber.

On« starts at the inception of a ray with ial. At the first non-critical

reflection, the refracted values are stored under the index 1"1, and the

reflected under the index i>2; aiailarly, if another interface with

non-critical reflection is encountered, the ref acted ray is given the

index l"2, while the ref» *y is given the ndex i"3, and so on.

For each non-critical reflected ray the index is increaented by 1, while

the corresponding refracted ray is referred to by the previous index.

It is seen that any arbitrary nuaber of reflected rays can be acconao-

dated and traced by increasnting indlcea in this aanner. After any

given reflected ray haa reached ita destination the index i is reduced

by 1, and the previously refracted ray la then continued by using the

initial conditions of the paraasters Hated in (31) with the next lower

index nuaber. It can be seen that all refracted rays will be traced out

until the index reverts ro 1*1, which is the index nuaber of the inci-

dent ray. Also, because previoualy refracted rays nay subsequently

21

Page 32: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

encounter .1 new set of multiple reflections, all multiple reflections

of the originally reflected or refracted rays will be accommodated.

Interface l.ocatlons

Because interface locations are so critical In affecting the loca-

tion of the emergence of a ray, a means was developed of precisely lo-

cating the interface and extending or retracting the ray to terminate

precisely on the interface. This is accomplished in the tollowlng man-

ner. The location of a point Is found in the square defined by four

matrix elements and located on the Interface. The horizontal and verti-

cal distance from the ray segment head end to this point is determined.

Knowing the slope of the interface, the angle of the ray, and the

horizontal and vertical distances to the defined point, a series of

computations In which the law of sines is invoked is then made. Many

different angular conditions are involved as a result of combinations of

ray angle, slope, and positive or negative horizontal distances. For

details, one can consult the subroutine GINMAD in the Appendix, where

the computations are given in Fortran.

Computer Programa

Three main programs have been developed. The first is for two-

dimensional flat earth, the second for two-dimensional spherical earth,

and the third for three dimensions. All have been written in the most

general computer language, Fortran. The version is Fortran IV-G, each

program of which has been compiled and run on the IBM 360/67 computer

22

Page 33: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

of The University of Michigan. The programs Include plotting instructions

which have been used for the Illustrations.

Subroutines have been developed to precisely reflect at an interface,

to extend the ray precisely to the surface, to compute Snell's law for

any incident angle across an interface of any slope, to increment initial

horizontal and vertical positions and angles, and to compute reference

travel times for each ray making up an onset ting plane wave.

The indexing for the spherically symmetric case has been made com-

patible with that for velocity distributions with a rectangular reference

system, in such a manner that the data for horizontal layering structures

can be read in by a Fortran Namellst. In this way anomalous regions

which are very heterogeneous can be included.

The programs have been made general, so that a different number of

samples and size of sampling interval, number of multiple reflections,

incremented or changed output, number of initializations, etc., can be

entered without recompiling the programs. Thirty to forty values are

read from Fortran Namelists; the values can be changed individually.

Fach ray increment involves calling trigonometric functions approxi-

mately 7 to 25 times (usually about 15 times). For an indication of the

time required, see Figure 7. The computation for Figure 7, including

loading, 20 travel-time printouts, and plotting instructions, required

10 seconds of IBM 360/67 computer time. It is felt that this is reason-

able and economical time for such ray tracing.

The three main programs and their subroutines are listed in the

Appendix.

23

Page 34: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Results

Accuracy

The method of ray simulation was developed primarily with synthetic

data. First very simple data were used for testing and developmental

purposes. As the work progressed, it was felt that a test was necessary

to determine its accuracy.

For this reason ehe method for tracing rays in spherically symmetric

earth was attempted. For at least 60 years the earth has been investigated

as a spherically symmetric structure in which the velocity gradient every-

where points directly at the center of the earth. Much of seismology

has been concerned with this model. Because of the continued investiga-

tion of this model over most of the world for such a long period of time,

many travel times from individual disturbances at many distances have

been recorded.

From these travel times a velocity-depth distribution of the earth

has been inferred. This distribution is one of the fundamental problems

of seismology, and most seismologists have been concerned with it.

Recently Herrin, et al. (1968) published the 1968 Seismological

Tables for P Phases in a special issue of the Bulletin of the Seismologlcal

Society of America (BSSA). These tables represented the latest refine-

ments of the contributions of the science of seismology. In this

special issue a velocity vs. depth distribution of the mantle was given.

As both the velocity distribution and travel times were given in this

special issue of BSSA, a model was available to test this method of

ray tracing.

24

Page 35: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

As one might expect, the ray tracing method was initially shown to

be inaccurate in the first tests. Two improvements were made in the

technique as it then existed. The first was to take the incident velo-

city at the midponnt of the inciden1: ray segment and the emergent velo-

city at the midpoint of the emergent ray segment. The second change

was to repeat the computation of Snell's law, as explained in the two-

dimensional modelling section, until the proper emerging velocity was

found. It was found with a testing program that the proper value of

emerging velocity was approached in a damped, oscillating fashion. It

was then a simple expedient to compare successive values until the dif-

ference between them was less than an arbitrary value.

This latter change, for which the need was not formerly apprehended,

was the key to achieving as much accuracy as desired, without reducing

the length of the ray segments to require an uneconomlcally large amount

of computation. As Snell's law is the basis of both this method and

that used for the 1968 P-Phase Tables (Engdahl, et al. 1968) the two

methods should result in identical relationships between velocity distri-

bution and travel times. Differences should be due only to the size of

the sampling intervals, length of the incremented segments, and method

of interpolation.

The equivalence between the two methods has been found. As the

sampling Interval and segment length were reduced, the travel times

shown in the 1968 P-Phase Tables have been approached more and more

closely when using the same velocity distribution.

25

Page 36: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

The avuracy is Illustrated in Figure 2, where the velocity distri-

bution used for the 1968 P-Phase Tables was approximated with samples

taken at 15 km intervals with 9 km segments. Figure 2 is a reproduction

of a computer output using this ray tracing method and also shows cor-

responding distances and travel times from the 1968 P-Phase Tables, The

average difference between the two methods in travel times for the five

P-rays shown in Figure 1 is .252 seconds, or an average difference in

travel times between methods of 1/100 of 1%. As the standard deviation

of the P-Phase Tables is 1 second, .252 seconds is considered satisfac-

tory. Every indication is that the travel time vs. velocity distribution

values could be made closer by further reduction of the sampling interval

and segment length.

Plane Waves

Figures 3 and 4 were drawn to investigate the simulation of a plane

wave. The velocity structure is based upon a hypothetical velocity dis-

tribution within a cross section from the Pacific Ocean across the Coast

Ranges, Central Valley of California, the Sierras, and part of Nevada.

Figure 3 represents a PcP wave from A • 30° and Figure 4 a P wave from

the same distance. The simple subroutine Planit was used as a reference

for travel time across the wavefront. These figures were obtained in

May 1969 as an aid in Charles G. Bufe's investigation of PcP waves (1969).

Bufe was able to estimate PcP-P travel-time differences, and anticipate

arrival anomalies.

26

Page 37: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Spherical Earth

Figures 5 through 8 illustrate two-dimensional seismic ray tracings

of an entire cross-section through the earth. In Figure 5 only a single

reflection was allowed, enabling one to obtain PcP, PKKP, PKIKKIKP, and

P rays. Had no reflection been allowed below the critical angle of in-

cidence, only the PKP, PKIKP, and P would have been drawn in Figure 5.

With four reflections allowed one can generate PKP type waves up to

PKKKKP, as shown in Figure 6.

In Figure 7 a source at 700 km depth was simulated. Rays were

traced from this source at 18° intervals, and each ray traced inde-

pendently of the others. Note that the second K leg of the initial

18° ray is overtraced by the second K leg of its symmetric counter-

part the 360° - 18°, or 342°, ray. This overtrace indicates high

positional accuracy, in that A and travel times differ by less than

.01% between symmetric rays.

Three Dimensional

Illustrations of computer plots In three dimensions are shown in

Figures 8 through 11. To clearly show the paths of the rays in three

dimensions a computer program was devised to show a perspective and

three orthogonal projections. Figures 8 through 11 show a single-point

perspective in the upper left portion of the figures, and three or-

thogonal projections along the principle planes in the remaining portions

of the figures. Consider that the (x,y) plane represents the surface of

the earth, and the positive z-axis corresponds to depth In the earth.

27

Page 38: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

In Figure 8 and Figure 9 a velocity distribution increasing with

depth .mJ (laviiu; zero slope everywhere with respect to the surface is

shown. In Figure 8 cones of rays from a point source at the «surface

are shown; ravs of a sufficiently large initial angle undergo critical

reflection and return to the surface (xty plane). In Figure 9 a line

source at depth is shown. Points are chosen along the line, and fans

of rays are propagated toward the surface. It should be pointed out

here that any type of initializing rays may be chosen. For example, in

Figure 9 the points of origin along the line could have been made much

closer together, and the angular extent of the fan decreased, with any

choice of angles between individual rays chosen. As described in the

section on the computer programs, the values for the increments of these

points and angles can be entered in the Nanellst.

Figures 10 and 11 illustrate an oblique gradient with respect to

the z-axis. The mathematical distribution of the velocities in Figure

10 is

V - 6.0 + X + 2Y + 3Z (32)

These illustrative figures make use of velocity values which exceed nor-

mal earth velocities. These velocities were used for the purposes of

demonstrating the capability of tracing such a distribution. In Figure

11 a sampled layer extending from a level corresponding to 40 km depth to

190 km depth is placed within the field described for Figure 9. The

gradient is parallel to the z-axis within this slab, and from 140 km to

190 km depth the velocities are constant. As shown in Figure 10, one can

define regions in three-dimensional space which can be either analytical

mathematical functions or sampled data. The number, sizes, or shapes of

the regions are not restricted.

28

Page 39: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Potential Application to the Seafloor Spreading Problem

In the theory of seafluor spreading, the earthquake zones are

associated with upward veiling zones, such as the Mld-Atlantlc Ridge,

where surface material Is being produced, and the boundary between

large lithospherlc pistes as In the Clrcum-Paclf1c zone.

The problem of these boundaries, one of which Is Impinging on the

other, is treated by laacks, Oliver, and Sykes (1968). They postulate

that one plate underthrusts the other, particularly in island arc re-

gions. At this boundary the lithosphere (the upper 100 kB of the earth's

surface) of the oceanic plate is bent downward into the underlying

asthenosphere of the continental plate. The precise geometry in which

the two plates Join is not known, and differs between regions. Isacks,

Oliver and Sykes (1968) postulated several configurations as a function

of local conditions and rate of underthrusting. Mitronovas, Isacks, and

Secber (1969) have investigated this problem in the Tonga Islands arc.

Murdock (1969) has discussed velocity distribution under the Aleutian

Region. Carder, et al. (1967) have documented travel-time anomalies

from the L0NGSH0T explosion.

Figures 12 through 15 were drawn with an arbitrarily-chosen geometry

baaed on the models postulated. In the geometry chosen the 6.75 km/sec

layer is taken as the topmost layer which bends downward and the surflcial

6.00 km/sec layer is unaffected by bending. These figures show different

earthquake locations and the directions of seismic waves propagating from

them. TVo of the earthquakes are directly above and two directly beneath

the upper boundary of the underthruating lithosphere. The two earthquakes

29

Page 40: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

.»bow t h« ! .'unJarv .ire located In reKion» where volcanic activity and

mlnui s«is^i. .utivltv Is Indicated (Mitronova«, l*-.iiks, and Seeber,

I'»'«'»*. Tin iwv> i II t liquakes beneath the boundary are located where most

seismi, at n-ss and the lilgheHt probability of earthquakes are thought

to occur. T1K- rays (or thehe plots were generated at W radial incre-

ments from a point source.

AltiiiHi.-.!-. the frequency of earthquakes with sources above is less

than the frequency of those within the underthrusting llthosphcre, both

source regions have been shown for contrast. This contrast arise« fro«

trapped waves within the low velocity layer when the source is within

the layer. Ray» from within the layer critically reflect at the interface

at angles greater than 55* from the normal, to the Interface. Rays from

sources outside the low velocity layer can be critically reflected only

when the inclination of the interface through which the rays have entered

Is oriented differently from the interface through which they would have

otherwise emerged. Parallel interfaces bounding a low velocity layer

cannot trap rays whicn enter from outside the layer. In the model used

for Figures 12 through 13 critical reflection from externally generated

rays can only occur where the Interface of the low-velocity layer is

curved, as shown by the one critically reflected ray In Figure 12.

The effects of the low-velocity layer are clearly neen in Figures

12 through IS. Shadow zones are found at the surface when the source is

above the layer. These occur because the ray« penetrating the layer are

bent toward the normal of the interface. These rays are displaced from

the paths they wouldhnve taken in the absence of th« low-velocity layer.

30

Page 41: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

and they emerge at a greater distance from the source than would other-

wise be the case. Fron sources within the low-velocity zone, the influ-

ence of critical reflections is shown in Figures 14 and 15. Three

separate groups of rays can be seen propagating up the low-velocity layer:

Chose initially reflecting from the upper interface, those which do not

Couch either Che upper or lower interface, and those Initially reflecting

fro« chc lower interface.

Travel times from each of chc four sources are shown in Figures 16

through 19. In Figures 16 and 17, the focal depchs are SO km and 100 km

respecdvely, with sources above Chc layer. The shadow tones caused by

Che ray dlsplacemencs are evidenc. Travel-dme anomalies above 2 seconds

occur near Che limit of Che shadow tones nearesC Che source.

Travel cimes for sources wichit Che downward bending layer are shown

in Figures 18 «id 19, where Che focal depchs are 60 and 110 km respecdve-

ly. Cricical reflecdons occur with a large angular excenc from Che

source. The Chrec separace arrival sequences are produced by Che three

groups of rays described above. The three separate legs of the travel-

time curves occur at distances approximacely Che same as Chose where Che

shadow tones are produced for Che sources above Che layer as shown in

Figures 17 and 18.

These resulcs indicate chac large effeccs upon travel times are

found within SO km of the poinc where Che underchruscing lichosphere

starts Co bend downward from Che unpercurbed oceanic place. A percinenc

invescigacion of seismic propagation in the Tonga Islands arc

(Hictonovaa, at al. 1969) was conducted with five seismometer locations

31

Page 42: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

sp.ii t-j .it .:; '.nu is ,>i US km t.. 200 Un from this jiolnt toward the under-

thrust nu*. 1 i' no .ptiftf. rh< lu'art'st s«'i sraoneter location toward the oceanic

plat«- w.i> ipp'-cxim.itcl v JJ(» km distant 011 R.ir.it ..a,-.! in the Giok Islands.

I'nfortunat il v, tin- location of the si-isnuioeters were dictated by the

positions ot tht- .iv.iil.ihU' islands, and wer»- not within Che region in

which r iv ttiiiu»; HIKIWH shadow zones and multiplo arrivals.

To invest tgalc tht travol times '.. v.<iid the region shown in Figures

1J through I'}, tin- sphericjl earth p: .»•.i ■n was attached as a subroutine

to Che fl.it earth program. Many rays exceeded Che boundaries shown in

Figures '.: through 1'i wlchout reaching the surface. These rays wer«

used as sources for the spherical earth program. This was accomplished

by saving the location, angle, travel time, and distance cravelled as an

input to tlu- spherical earth subroucint*. Travel times out co approxi-

Riatetv HO0 were found. These closely paralleled the 1968 P-Phase Tables

for corresponding depths of focus. The anomalies found were a maximtai

of .,» seconds, in.I were .it the maximum in the region near 25*. No

conclusions wer«» drawn ft^m these results.

Finur«"» 1J throunh 1" illustrate the diagnostic capabillCy of Che

method prt-sonted in this study. The travel times are particularly ra-

vcalink; at distance* within 50 km of the point at which Che iichosphere

starts to herd downward. They depend upon the location of Che source,

varv with direction, and produce distinctive features in Che ray dia-

grams and travel-time curves. Civen a set of seismograas at suicablc

distances from the earthquake in a continental place boundary area, an

invest IKat ion .'f the velocity distribution and source depth can be aided

32

Page 43: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

with this method. A more detailed investigation would also Include azi-

muthal effects, which could he found by projecting the given model on

cross-sections at various angles with the cross-section shown.

It Is not the purpose of this study to investigate a portion of the

earth in detail, but rather to present a method to aid in such investi-

gations. For example the travel tines and anomalies found with curved

earth out to 60* war« not pursued as Co chair meaning, but rather a method

to obtain chem using a spherical «arch subroutine was demonstrated. Also,

Che model chosen for Che «mderthrusting lichosphere did noc Include Che

6.00 km/sec layer. Many variations of the model would be made during a

decalled Invesdgaclon—variadons such as chlcknesses of Che layers,

effaces of depch, and, cherefore, heat, on Che velocity of Che layers,

angle of downward banding, extent of Che downward thruating layer,

effects upon the overlying layers, departures from horizontal layering,

and many ocher variadons. It is apparent that such changes can be

accommodaced by chis ray simulation method. The results of these changes

are given hoch visually and numerically.

Conclualona

This study has resulted In an economical and versatile method to

aid In seismic analysis. Geometric ray tracing can be performed with

models representing any conceivable veloclcy distribution wlchln Che

earch. Refreceive aa well aa reflecclve compucstions can be performed.

Including multiple reflections. Travel clmes and approximace ampllcudea

can be decemlned for theae veloclcy distributions.

33

Page 44: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

>Hu' »M i <• primary goals of seismology Is to model the velocity

ilist rlhut i.nis within the earth. Hypotheses of velocity distributions

•iff . i<i. t iiMious ! v being produced by seismologists. An important test

tor the valiJity of these models has been developed.

Cumputi-r drawn plots .md numerical output of travel times have

been us«, d to illustrate the capabilities of this simulation method.

The travel times can he made arbitrarily close to those published by

the Seismological Society of America. This method of geometrical ray

tracing performs as accurately and with more versatility Chan previous-

ly published ray tracing techniques.

It is hoped and expected that this technique will be used by the

»eismological profession and chat it will be extended and inproved, as

any uneful, new contribution should.

34

Page 45: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

References

Bufe, C. C. (l^ft'J), "An estimate of the configuration of the surface of the earth's core from the consideration of surface focus PcP travel times. PhD. Dissertation, The University of Michigan.

Carder, D. S., D. Tocher, C. G. Bufe, S. W. Steward, J. Eisler, and E. Berg (1967), "Seismic wave arrivals from LONGSHOT, 0° to 21* " Bulletin of the SeismoloRical Society of America. Vol. 57, No. 4, pp. 573-590.

Bullen, K. E. (1963), An introduction to the theory of seismology. Third Edition, Cambridge University Press.

Engdahl, E. R., J. N. Taggart, J. L. Lobdell, E. P. Arnold, and G. E. Clawson (1968), "Computational methods." Bulletin of the Selsmolo- gical Society of America. Vol. 58, pp. 1339-1344.

Gutenberg, B. (1914), "Über Erdbebenwellen, VIIA. Beobachtungen an Registierungen von Fernbeben in Gottingen und Folgerungen über die Konstitution des Erdkorper," Got tinger Nachrichten, pp. 1-52.

Heibig, K. (1965), "A graphical method for the construction of rays and travel times In spherically layered media," Part I: Isotropie Case, Bulletin of the Selsmologlcal Society of America. Vol. 55, 641-651

Herrin, E.( E. P. Arnold, B. A. Bolt, G. E. Clawson, E. R. Engdahl, H. W. Freedman, D. W. Gordon, A. C. Hales, J. L. Lobdell, 0. Nuttli, C. F Ronney, J. N. Taggart, and W. C. Tucker (1968), "1968 Selsmologlcal tables for P-phases," Bulletin of the Selsmologlcal Society of America. Vol. 58, pp. 1193-1241.

Isacks, B.( J. Oliver, and L. R. Sykes (1968), "Seismology and the new global tectonics," Journal of Geophysical Research. Vol. 73, No. 18, pp. 5855-5899.

Iyer, H. M. and V. W. Punton (1963), "A Computer program for plotting wavefronts and rays from a point source in dispersive mediums," Journal of Geophysical Research. Vol. 68, No. 11.

Jackson, P. L. (1968), "Two- and Three-dimensional ray tricing through inhomogeneous media," Paper presented to the Annual Meeting of the Selsmologlcal Society uf America, Tucson, Arizona, April.

Jackson, P. L. (1969), "Seismic ray simulation," Paper presented to the Eastern Section, Selsmologlcal Society of America, Blacksburg, Va., October.

Jackson, P. L. (1970), "Seismic ray simulation in a spherical earth," Bulletin of the Selsmologlcal Society of America. Vol. 60, No. 3, pp. 1021-1025.

Jacob, K. H. (1970), "P-residuals and global tectonic structures investi- gated by three-dimensional seismic ray tracing with emphasis on L0NGSHOT data," Paper presented to the Annual Meeting of the Ameri- can Geophysical Union, Washington, D. C.» April.

35

Page 46: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

.Iftfn-vs, il. uul K. K. Bullen (1^48), Seismological tables. British A sis i 11ion for the Advancement of Science, London.

Julian, B. R. and D. L. Anderson (1968), "Travel times, apparent velo- ritiis and amplitudes of body waves," Bulleti.i of the Seismologlcal SiHi.'t y of America. Vol. S8, pp. 339-366.

Lewis, B. T. K. .md R. P. Meyer (1968), "A Seismic Investigation of the upper mantle to the west of Lake Superior," Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America. Vol. 58, pp. 565-569.

Mitronovas, W., B. Isacks, and L. Seeber (1969), "Earthquake locations and seismic wave propagation In the upper 250 km of the Tonga Island arc," Bulletin of the Seismologlcal Society of America. Vol. SO, pp. 1115-1135.

Mohoroviciif, A. (1910), "Jahrbuch des meteorologischen," Observatoriums in Zagreb (Agram) fur das Jahr 1909. Vol. 9, pt. 4, pp. 1-63.

Murdock, J. M. (1969), "Crust-mantle system in the Central Aleutian res Ion—A hypothesis," Bulletin of the Seismologlcal Society of America. 59, 1543-1558,

Newton, I. (1730; 1952). Qptlks. or a treatise of the reflections. refractions, inflections, and colours of light. Reprint, based on the Fourth Edition, London, Dover Publication, Inc., New York

Willis, 0. E. and P. L. Jackson (1968), Collection and Analysis of Seismic wave propagation data. University of Michigan, Willow Run Laboratories, Geophysics Laboratory, Annual Report Number 8071-15-P.

Yacouh, N. K,, J. H. Scott, and F, A. McKeown (1968), Computer technique for tracing seismic rays In two-dimensional geological models. Geological Survey, Open-File Report, U. S. Department of the Interior.

Zoeppritz, K. (1919), "Über Erdbebenwellen Vllb." Goettinger Nachrichten. pp. fih-R4,

36

Page 47: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

(Matrix Elements Indicating Positions On Earth Cross-Section

FIGURE 1. REFERENCE FRAME FOR INCREMENTING RAYS. Seismic velocity and slope are associated with each matrix element. Referencing for the slope is shown at element (2, 1). An Interface between two velocity layers can be positioned between matrix elements as shown by the dotted line through B. The scale, or sampling inter- val, is the distance between matrix elements as represented in kilometers. An incident ray segment of length L and initial angle \ extends from A to B. Coordinates of B are found by extension from A: Bx = Ax ♦ L sin \, Bz * Az + L cos ^ The segment BPj is the first "probing" segment to obtain initial values of seismic velocity at midpoint 1. The angle »m is computed with Snell's law, using emerging velocity at midpoint 1. in- cident velocity at midpoint k, and Incident angle \. "Probing" segments are recom- puted using successive values of ')m until the absolute value of ('<m - ''m.i) is less than a predetermined small value. The velocity and slope associated with the segment BPm and the last computed value of "m are then used as the Incident ray parameters, and a subsequent emerging angle computed for the ray segment proceeding from point Pm.

37

Page 48: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Ji u; ■-^ ^ ^-^ H ^ J w W J > < < u «5

eg

K H '/5 ^ ^ to oi d H 0, ^ J CM CM in CM rp

O 00

S to

Q ^-< Z o C/5

i Z CM *•* a> 00 to K S r-* —'

w b K OS O Ü mmm^

| e 5 e a«

• o w

8 «A S 3 X • • • • • H e « 1 ► m 1 9 s 2 8 O m «« ■M «•

m 9 »• M O s « - «1 p • • • • • m 0 « e A O Ck •* * • I I 2 5 •

* H

04 ä s s 8 s s H «i • • • • •

O MO r 5 • o I 11

u H » « « s s H 58 » « n ^3 • • • • • 0. 2

•• « s X o *

o e i» « m 9808 • • • • u i5 • r> one » (

a • • • • • tE «e > •■ <

& "* **

en !*• n • t» • • e e • • • e 4»

8 *i*i** 1 » o «ft A

^ o tm Oh> O MO -< O « OO H^ • oc S !* •* • • * 1 • • • • •

i -88 4

^^ fig' «•on n tf M M ^ ( ■ •» < ■ ^ W VI

A % A-A A< * A ' A'A-A 'A

> q n,

B'u *- £ .5 a 0 *-

.s 11 ^ S o rt

> u

(A

in*

C Pi

bß c

T3 C

>* & s* •

o ü o a»

^00 S^

& (0

in x 1 ■

(A

9 00 C

00

Z »H

SSE

h O 0)

11 CO

u a> o o»

ÜH W C £ c.2 5.2 t;

? n, bß

p rt .3 O

»^ a £ x

o

(0

? a» 0 (A

u *<

(0

05 'S W bo

O a) U ^ w y

BJ "^ Tt ^

38

Page 49: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

sdaiawoiiM Ni Hidao

39

Page 50: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

9

sdaiawcnw NI Hid3a 8 8 2?

u

ft h

40

Page 51: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

FIGURE 5. PLOTS OF P, PcP, PKP, PKIKP, PKKP, AND PHKKIKP RAYS GENERATED WITH A SPHERICAL EARTH PROGRAM. Jeffreys-Bullen core and 1968 P-phase mantle velocity distributions. Radial velocity distribution sampled at 70 km Intervals. Rays seg-

ment lengths 70 km.

41

Page 52: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

FIGURE 6. MULTIPLE REFLECTIONS. PcP and PKP rays up to PKKKKKP. Four multiple reflect ions preset Into computer program. Any number of multiple reflec-

tions can be preset into program.

42

Page 53: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

a »

•8,

r«" H U S s >«

s p u >

£ ►■ Si cut

n u E , u >> r • « £ E B gi, c.

« o »

i £ 4. H « '^ E SSII

M > — 3 e A ft) X - > a

J S ir. £

ft w • •- 0Q E

H §; Lj K — <«

.": f <«

isii

E S 0 5

43

Page 54: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

v» ,/

« » \

}

»

v V i i ^ 1

k x\\l/ J^l/ '

• J imß^T* _- -

'^/^flPW Bfei. ■ ~~~~-—~

Z' |\ v^- N^1 > ^

s A

/. •»-

K\\ 11 /

1 / // 1 11 \\ \vl |y

I »X

KU.l HK H. THREE DIMENSIONAL RAY TRACING IN A REGION DEFINED BY 30 MO 30 VELOCITY SAMPLES Constant velocity in planes parallel to the x. y plan«', inrreasini: velocity in z-direction for IS sample points from the x. y plane. Four i uns nf rays originating from point in the x, y plane. Rays emerging at tin \. v plane shown by slash marks with orientation ot angle of emergence. I ppt i left one-point perspective; remaining views: labelled orthographic pro-

jections.

44

Page 55: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

M

JIM JW JW J I It

HGURE 9. LINE SOURCE AT DEPTH FOR THREE-DIMENSIONAL REPRESENTA- TION AS SHOWN IN FIGURE 8. Plotting defects In upper right (x, z) projection: all

lines should extend to x-axls.

45

Page 56: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

%1;' \

.J KUilUF 10. TURKF-DIMENSIONAL RAY TRACING WITH VELOCITY DISTRIBU- IION DFUNKD BY CONTINUOUS MATHEMATICAL FUNCTION. Velocity 4.0

0 l )\ ■ 0.3y • 0.6/.. whero v(»lumr is defined as in Flpure 8.

46

Page 57: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

--n

—A

FIGURE 11. THREE-DIMENSIONAL RAY TRACING WITH VELOCITY FUNCTIONS SPECIFIED FOR DIFFERENT REGIONS. Sampled values for intermediate layer be- tween A and D. Velocity = 4.0 * 0.15x ♦ 0.3y ♦ 0.6z for layers above A and below P

Volume is defined as in Figure 8.

47

Page 58: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

g

3S|

K » | X ^ -

> 3 S • B~ - ~ < r * t -. £ i 3

lÄ 1c- <a |

ft* = 2 8 ^ J w >■< |

P4 £ "7 - H »j

K§ » y o 5

C< u.

48

Page 59: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

«I « a

s 2 o. -

3 E

I1- fci Up

g§ S--

I;*

«I gs u.w

KB.

>■<

5S W

i§ K O SO

.(UIH) 7

49

Page 60: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

,ä,...,..,,.-.">:--.-..■ ' '■' '■ ••;"■-*'-

? 9 SS 2c

li i8. lit

,s

11 Ul s 11 Ui (!]

u u

SS 11

50

....■■■,■,■....■■-

Page 61: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

!?■'■■. ■

"I Es

11 I 1* K J<

I:. z 32 lll

111 pi x ■

Is !/]H x< <E

ü H

a I wz «o Sg SH

.(um)

51

Page 62: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

P

>

20 Critically

Reflected Rays

Shadow Zone Due to Critical

Reflections

ll I I.

{Toward Underthrustlng Llthosphere

Away From UndcrthrusUnn Llthosphere

Portion of Travel Time Curve Unaffected by Llthosphere Bending

I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 20 40 60 100 120 140 160 180 200

DISTANCE FROM DISTURBANCE (km)

Z 2.5

2 2.0 u I 1.8 BE U E S 1.0

0.5

0

H 0.5

p

Critical Reflection Region

Shadow Zone

.L_J I I I L 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

DISTANCE FROM DISTURBANCE (km)

FIGURE 16. EARTHQUAKE ABOVE UNDERTHRUSTING LITHOSPHERE AT CON- TINENTAL PLATE BOUNDARY. Depth of focus: 50 km. Above: Travel times to- ward and away from underthrustlng llthosphere. Below: Differences between travel times toward and away from underthrustlng llthosphere. See Figure 12 for ray paths

and velocity distribution.

52

Page 63: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

,

1 i ru

st

bas

e

1 1 leS et«00

5^«

\« uß 0 \ < j u-

§ eg

s o CM

O

M

u

4 9F 4B

c

«fj r • E

= c ^,

0. c -

s U 5 ««Si ^N z Ho"

g < ffi

G L

I 1

tim

s

and

^< 3 a ftM

5 o 5H >, ^N tf « s = • u o eg E )E

RT

00

kn

3

for

H e-- o u 5 .. * p « a o z «-^ < w R &

H o CO 00 s < 0 0)

§

QU

AK

E

Dep

th

riso

n.

o JC .J «

o ea

u >: o-

(oat) awn laAVHi

S9 ^ pa

ü

53

Page 64: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

I a»

§

~ 8

UM

SI j Ml

Srt .-a .2

■ill s ö i S SjJfl sill

Hm b «rf '«OS

9o I" Z § >. a» P i B & i «jp

0 5.2:^ fci >.

2 *

If oo o

W ttJ

0) 0) CO >

. ^ 0) o

V

a

(oas) awu laAVHX

w H 05 I

E ft a

54

Page 65: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

• ■ - —^- —- —

'

u u z <

5

5

I w u

s

u i

^^ B

7. 2 u w £ o

p «. " b k 1 .

R i i I. H Ä O ~ p < u 3 - - • 'S re T-

■ I a S 2 Cm *> JZ -. *

BP*!!

Pg I fe£ ilji i 5 S tti c "s .- W -^ „ « i c 2 9 ^'« 5 -S I o S 8 I F g H .5 '^

L

en U. KT "" «^ ^ a.

ä

S K-I o *" >" o s c o - >• 5«- es w Q 0

4» Tt 2 Ä a>

o> o So •"Si

SJ2 (aas) awinaAVHi 0* H

c o (A

'C M a

55

Page 66: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

r

APPENDIX

Listings of Computer Programs

56

»

Page 67: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

■ - . ■

t'iiiuur," Hiu ^ hi Ai h^MTH r.PM^^-sf r r IHM Mdnt-i Mmui m vn MI VrViH iiöTHiTfTi'fM I s "'>T riiJ~7\"NT'rVÄ'y S "Ah F^P^'IP >ii A 11 il IHQIIIII;H FMI MI mi i , lUAVKl II»"1, I'lMAN^i«, M'PU|i»!MA1h A'-I'l I IllllHS ftt<t- f.HMMUTH),

MAMiiim HAU AMi-TI-««; Al l'WAH(-T UM I V I I S 11-n

MM K it

nr.r

AUUAV [if ^.AMMI jn M | MJW(7M AMf,| h ftT AUP(\v rnMTA|M|MR IMtT t Al AMf.l P ftp

"KinriTv V/AIIIF«, "WHift-i' nüTr'iTT"Tiiii(-H(-Ar> |.iK.AI ITifcT <;AM(>| Ui\ m iii'l- WA| nm «AV

irrwh-Mt-MTATIfM (H»r.| f nf- iMfiot-MT WAV^

hVMIIMPMTt A| i»j»r>M,ltN1 MV AT Tt-MllAT I IIM

KIIU I/HMI Al (MrpFMf-MTAT IHM IIP |Mf)h>.MT UAVS

I <. MSfn

nt ^UAT r, }> yr\ ^ i PKAr i iMriw I F

\/»UT)IAI jMryt-Mt-MTATipri nt- INf.lll^NI HAVS

IM^TAMTh IW KM MHUPFM SAMP|P pfllMT«; U * V ■..(.f.Mt-'MT I (-MCTH KAWIMIIM MliMHFW MF RAV | MCPFMPMT » T I (INS «KWITTW TU iNrinoF owFri^h iMTt-uFAr> i.nrATiiiN^ LMITrw TM Mil) TIP) V r. kv VPIflCfff TO r.M'F Akh-FAMANfF

""WTWXWtTTW! nUiMWifcTlnKiAi IWAMU ^wiTrM T(l fwrinnF I PI AMF -.».uTrH in i>ir.i.iii>f r AI fm. At liiw«; FIH* iMf.lnfMi PI AK^ «AVF

iPini <;i.iiTrH Tn tNf.LHf» r.A( rnwp HLOTTfUB IPHB^M lIMfT flF HIIMMFU (IF M(IU|;(IMTAt SAMP) F PdlMTS .IPIIUSH I IM|T (IF VFPTICAI MIIMHFB (|F VFMT(rAI SAMPIF PflfMT^ TüPTTP gi-itTfti Tn TMnimF imHÜWTTT VWlTfmTH

IIF PAW Til N/FlliriTV WWFM WAKlivl A CIIMPIITFH l*'\\l

MAMFIIST IMPIIT MF VFIMCMv AMI SLdPF (lATA

A

t\

A r A A A

"A

'. A

_A A A r. I A A

1 l ■'

]f I* IK

T

A I A

r MA fM si.i|TrH in tNr.L'inF r.dMTiMiinii«; MATMFMATir.Ai r K'Mlil T MHMUFP OF Mlli.TTPIFBPFI.Fr.TTnM«: Al.l fUlPh r K'PB NIIMMPH OF |MITIA( ANr,|. F IMf.PFMFMT5; f MHM MIIMPF (IF t^ITIAl HfiPI/dMTAI IMT.PFMFMT^ f MHTM TdTAI MHMUFP IIF IMITIAI BAY«;

FHMf. TIMNi

9 '

11 T Niriy/ MIIMHFH nF IMITIäI V'FBTir AL r'yrwFMFMT«;

r. Mill IMF MIIMMFfi (IF rALCriMP l.tMFS MFCFSSABV Til nilTLlNC STMIir.TIIPF r PBir.w IMJTIAI H(i«l7nMTAi pnsttldM IIF PAY

r OBICV IMITIAI VFBTTfAl Pn^ITfdM MF BAY r PMM IMITIAI AMP|. ITIIPF \/AlllF r oFF\(F| PFFFPFNTF WFinCITV Td MAKF N'(n/IF

-m PI (IT <rh iKKi nrrrta IFST SMALL «AIMF Td TFST BFPFATFO FMFBr,rN AMr,|.F l)| PPPH EMr. F S WFMMF v/FHiriTv niFFCBFwrF MFr,F<;<;aBy tn r.aii<F RFFLKTfnfMT" Y ABBAY rilMTAIMIMP, HdPIiMlMTAI. PdSfTIdMS FIIP PLOTTIMr, Y ABBAY rnKlTAIMIMf; WFBTlTfil. Pd^TTlOMS Phft PLljTTINh

A A A A A A T" t A A A

17 '•*■>

'i I,

\f >"' *> .. IM '. n '•I

r SYMWOI TAMI.F r AMPI AMP| ITIIdF r AMf-l Fl IMP IHFMt' AMr.i F (IF BAY f. AMCI F? FMFBCTMr. AMr.l F (IF RAY r AMT ABBAY FOB AMPI ITMOFS AFTFR r AT ^RBAY FOB TRAVFI TI MF ■;

HFKLFCTtnNS

1.1.

<.'7

ABBAY FdB VAI IIF«; (IF AMf-IFS Td HF BFTIIRMFn Tli AFTFP BFFi.FCTI' A r (.i roMBFr, rnMHdP rriMv/FB MTCTA dKM

SIIMPnilTIMF TO ^iiupnilTrM^Tfr SlintdlMT IMF Td dl^TAMTF FRdM

IMCRFMFMT IMITIAI AMCI.F dF IMC I HP MCE IMCRFMI« MT ( NTTTAI. HhH \ /WH k'C PHSltldM IMfBFMFMT IMITIAI. VFBTK.SL PUSlTldM <niiR"rF 'Td PMISBCPMCF dH «AV

HfSTAMr.F FROI* FOr.F (IF F(FLn Td FMFPnFMCF HF BAY r FFF CIMF dF FMFBGIMT. AM(;t F ( ARd\/F 1.00 IF CRITICAL AMCLF) r r.jMMAd siippdintMF Td uBiMr, BAY FMH PBFCISFLY Tfi IMTgRPACP r r.r. UFRTKAI iMtRPMC^t PPOR penRIMr. AMCI.F" " r r,r,r, WFRTKAI IMCRFMFMT

r MM MOBWdMTAI IMCRFMFMT FdB FMFRr-IMr, ANr,LF "S9

57

Page 68: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

r r r r r

TTiTn «wTTrTTTrri^nirATF fpjTir.fti. .«^FlFf.'t irtf4 I I I (NTFRI M \/ M i IP HF PIP i i M r IJW i T ' " ni i Mn i r A T P » P TnoN FBrfM"H?FIR TTimV" (M HIlHl/ilMTAI POnHPO IMPIFV P(KITI(1M iMAMi SUIITCM TI\ iMnifATF (I«;F IIF ^FcrnMÖ" MAMF'I I ST IM i AwwAv pnn v/Hnri T v vAiii F <; AFTFB «FFLFCTION

IM li Af

I C

I ^»-r I ^MMF I v/w

vuMTrw fii IMMjrATF IMTFMFAr.F IMIMMFU MF TJM»;«; THwnnr.M INNFO LOOP

^0

hi»

hi

VIHTtr.M PUCIHUi IMI>Fy PdSIT'lO'N IWAVH MMP |M IMTFT.FB MIIMHFB (IF M|NMTFS >;nfirn Til IMHtfATF FMFBr.FNCF' TO SURFftrF" ■sHTrH TO IMrilfATF BCFIFTTIflM

hi

IMflPy FIIB MIMWPB OF B4V »FFIFfTlflN IMTFOM VA) HP HF t>\ ,| HHMUWW OF pinTTlMf. t^r.BFMFNTS"" AUUAV t-n« ^I^TA^^F^ BAV«; MAVF TMAVPILFO «MMAV POU V/AIIIP«; nF MOB I^HMTAr "pn<lf ION ' _" Hrm!;rwTAi pusmuM nF BAV sFr.FMMT Tn ntTgKwiwj vFinr.iTv

A ^Q A 70 A 7f A 7?

r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r

t / ,i 11 KiPI OT nM i't

■■I .■

TMPMITW'

PI i •M t

T u >; i i'1 T I

p I

A 7-* A ru

_A 7^ A TT A 7«

HD*i|rwTAl "pwrmpn" pns'Tlnw »FHTKAI Pn«;iTinM MF BAV SFr.MFNT TO DFTFBMINF VFtnClTV

pwnHpn MIIPI7(IMTAI pn<;iT|nN FOB roMPHTiMr. vFinf.ITv rnmiAMT: I,S7'>B

AUMAv POP \/AI um MF VFBTIfAl POSITIOM

A 74 A no

TTWmrWSTTfH OHAUFIS Pn^lTIAKi pnmi pwoHpn vcuTirAi pnsiTinM FOB roMPiiTINr. VFLUCITV P| AMI! «iimunilTIMP FHB IMfinFM't TBAVfl tTMFTfW PLAN? "WAVF roi v nmir FMMrTiriM TU enMPMTF VFinr.tTV u ir.u nu ir.iMAi on iC;M

CFr TUAV'PI TIMF IM SPniMnS AWQVF tMTFT.FB MINUTES

"IT

«'7' M

~BQ" 90

«lIMfiPT >;iiMUniiT IMC TO rOMOiiTF FMFBr.INf. ANr.LF FOB ANV GIVFN ANRLF Ä WV AMU K| npc A q?

(;( np IMTFM^POI ATF" { <ÄVFnT"\/ALIIF HF SLOPF " I 9T SPFFH PHUKPfi \(AI MF OF v/FinciTV A 9* IMIM T«A\'FI TiMP IN' MiKiiifFS Ä TBF^rM miMWMHTiMP Tfi rriMPMTF VFLflCITIFS FOB IINOEBTHBIISTIMP LITHflSP A

95

l SPFFtl "Ft

TFNTATIVF VAMiF HP VFlOCfTV VFi nr r TV

97 OB

niMFHSHlM oi(io), P.KIQl. r.t.mo), nwilOlt AT(IO), AMTIIOK INTHO A 99 n "A IOO

n 11.1-MC IHM A(ni,7s\, B(l?l,7S), SLPBATI l?lt7^> A 101 «««PI MTTIMT. iMTfinrTinN«**

ntMFNSIflN X(1f>f>0l« v(innn) 102 10^

n» TA P i T, i r « I T , P ( T T_, IMIIM, i«;tiBF/^.14169?7,0tl.S70B,()»0/ MAMCI i <;T /MAUI / MniN!,nF|.M,HFr.IM,NMIILT,nBir,VftlBir,HtrM lPrmSH,JPORSHt

irwmAr t\/Pi niF, emi TP .npr . lNAML,NnBtNnv.NnMtnEl VtnELMtTFSTtMATHt ICY ?r i p , WTTVFI , l^nwiF, t Px&rT,PMM,AniF,X,Y,NULlNF,Sr,A,IPtANE.IPLnT/NAM2

LCAM (<.,MAMT) o T f.M = n« i r.H ip . i PI OT.PO.o) ~r,n TO i " ~ TAN Pl.TDFS (0. tSCA«0« «Sr.A,»« tHt I

A 104 A IDS A 10* A 107 A 10«

109 A 110 A 111

112 m

i F i iMAMi , FH.l i r-n TO 7 BFAH I *,■*<*) ((Alt . .11 . 1=1 t IPOB SM) ,J»lt JPOBSH) oPAii (h,-\U) M «( I ,,l 1 ,1 = 1 .IP'nBSH) ,,l«l,JPnBSH» OPAIl ('..MAMP)

'joi TP n,n)

115 A 11(S A 117 A 11«

58

Page 69: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

'•■with ('.•■»M RTTürffT TTTTTWT 1 M ^T « nr T 11 iKTSTSV

II- (i ci in, •■I,"i r,n TM '•» r Ai i P| I'-'i- (»( M ,v( n ,Mni IMI; , I , riif'i | will

« »«i ii ■

im •(■> | - i .WHIM

«sn.n

UP I T(- (7,^S) w^M M,iiW ! f.M.im Jf.v

nn >> i = i, in A K 11»n.

TT'TTi'rÄ'^i ^~t'5rT'TTrr~prÄVfT'

I wi.i-rn

»7-1 ^MT(1/1=1. ^1(1/ IrdK 1(;M

(KKr, tM.iiuicw.AK fl .fii«ll I ,u ir.M.mt-^Ar,

14

?1

n i( 17 | =(iui(,w T»PI(I;>»tHoni .l»P.I( 17 l*,SO"1 \/P| r Al i, n IMTMr»n

IT (T7.i P.m r.n'Tn X] MP| T = MP| T*1 iMMMr tMllM+l ip i iMiiM.r.f;, jcvri p) r,Al.i Awn Pi =AMr,i p?

^v«:TPk

u ■

i.i.

ü '• ,, i,

4 / /* M

4w

SI s>

■ /. I I

tTh S7

S4 fi(1

IP ( AMr;t pi ,r,T,7, i r,n in w. tp (iMnwtP.Ko, 11 r, = «( i ,,ri/BPPVPI

•••P| MTTjMf; |M^TRIir.TinN**« IP M PI lu.pn.i) r,n in A.

IP (MPI T.MP.I) RM TO 7 V(MI>| 7|=1>.H t M V(MP| Tl=P!(i;i Aip| T = MP| T*1

»:t • »ü

HHn=r,<.<;iM( AMr-i PI i /?, r 7

RRRaRkmSIANRI P 1 I / ' . PIP=0I(17l*w"^__ PT.ISP.M 1/ Unnn t>t ( 17 I=P1P*HP1M P.K 17 isPT.ur.r,f; ATI 17 l = ftT( f/UniPPArftG/N/FI h7 nM( 17 )=nM( 17 l*niPBArttr.

««apurr r IMI; iM^TPIirT IIIN**«■ ( IPI jit.pn.o» t P (IPI MT.PO.OI r.n rn a

IF ( IVFI .FO,1,AMn.MP(.T.r,P./.l y(MPl. Tl = P.i( 17 1 V(MP| T1=PI{I71

MP|.T=NP| T-1 w 71 7? 7^

« rnMTlMnp A r »«« A*« A

IF fP.M IZJ.ßP.tiH 60 TO H "A" q t<;ilBP = l _ A

TF ( IFKAri.Pn.l ) f.AI I RlNM»n (ÄNf;LFl",Sl.nP,PlTl7.i,PJ( 17 1 ,1M,IS,AT( I A

74 7S 7A. 77 7«

59

Page 70: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

111

r

I M .nM( ! ' I ,nt^WA( ,v/H , I miwf:, Anif-,SI.P»«T( I ,,!») r?Mwt -'- nt <; t A- ( i' M l M -iiu I r.M i "MI ••« M' IIKM-11'' i i ■ i -1. i in'iFa'Är AMPI «(PMM»AMT( ]7 1/HMI ! / I («hvi'lUFr. «nM( 1 M I _ tMINaATI 17)/AO, I s^-r --• TM |N

A 17W

IRO

1«?

1 WS

URJTF L7»^' 'M ^TA.UKM.TMlM.SPf , AT( i; I, AMPl IP flWBftF.FO.n WHtTP'(7,1<t P.M I?) ,P1(T; » .ANCLFl

«'••■■ !■ i iir r |Ni(; i M<,Toiir T I IIN«** IP i I PI nr. t-M .in r.n TM i n » ( NIP) TV»P.H t7 I

"vTHpf T I - P 1 ( 17 1 " ' ~ MPi r-i »M r-i r Ai i PI IMP m -M ,y ( 7) .MPI T, i ,o,o, V» MP| rm

• a B u <i *

A IWh Al «7 A IHH A 1B<» A 190 A mi A 19? A |P^ \ )'><. A 1QS A 19* A )<?7

r,n rn u A m« n IP ( PI ( 1/ >.';T..s.AMn.P.M 17 l.r,Tt.5.ANn.PJ( 17) .LT.JPPRSH-.S.ANn.PH 1 A 190

1 n .i T, i pnw<;H-.M r.d TO is | |B0 r ^v . PinTTiMf, iM«;TPiir.TinM *«♦ A ?01

ip ( i PI "i .pn.iM r,n TH ]■? r'UST MPI r = ^'•,l r-i A ?0^ rm PI IMP I K( ->! ,y( 7) ,MP| T,\ ,0,0,1» MP| T-n

1 7 r OM T I MI i. r •** •«* IT rriMTtMiip

i."3 I TF (7.^Bl I'l ( T / ) ,P.I{ I 7 ) .AMr,|.Fl,nN( 17 1 . ATI 17 )

A ?04 A ?0S Ä ?0^ A ?07 A ?0H A 20«»

r PI (IZ »»PI IIZ1*1t-nHIRH r r.Al i I-'MPI H(PI .P I.HM, AMT, AT, AMr.i F?.17tXtYtL> 14 IP ( I 7 .FP.1 1 r.n TO ^i

i \/ u ■ n AMTI I7-1 \-{ l-AMT( I/ ) 1*AMT( I>^-'n I 7^1 7-1

A 210 A 211 A 212 A 818 A 214 A 21^ TTTT

A 21B A 219

1 s

I = P I P ♦ , >; , I - P I I *. s A M r, i p 7 - r I i ( i 7 \

f.n rn s I ■ P I ( I M*.S ,l«P.t( 17 ) + , S

A 220 A 221

PI PP lIMr P I P*HMM P ipwim-p i i + r.r.r, I M - P I P u n M ♦ . s I C - P,| PUHH* . ^ IP ( ti-'p ! T^.pn.n i r,n rn i ^ WRTTF M.^l P M 17 1 .P! ( 17 ).V/FL.cLOP,ANr,LFl

1^ IP MMTPAT .PH. i i r.n Til 1H IF IMATH.pn.n r.n tn TT Ic I 1 St L T, 1 1 rn rn q ^ IP ( l^.r.T, iPnpc,M,nR. i^,r.T.,jp'nRSW.nR, IM.LT.l t Gh TU 13 I I IrPIP-f.S

,U,I«P1 l+.S ypj =A( I n,.i.i i i*i;r.«(PM-.i.i.i)<i| A( 111»J.IJ-1 >-A( lll..ijjn r.n rn l«

17 r.ALI TUPNTK ( PIP,PI,I,VF| ,<;inPF,QIFRAr.) IP n IM T.PM. n üB|_ ■ INT MTI

A 222 A 223 A 22* A 22* A 22^ A 227 A >2P A 22«, A 230 A 231 A 232 A 233 A 23* A 23* A 23fr A 237 A 23«

60

Page 71: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

'

in 1 M\~\ =(> A ?^9 i(= (iMTM/\r.mi.i i <;i (IP(: = <;I I^P A ?4()

A ?4)

-

lIMIrU

if; ( iww.MF, 1 ) f»n Tn ig

r-n tn s

A ?4? A ?41 A V*i. A P^S

lo 1 <;o(;ph=vt:| ir.ui T=(>

A ^n

A ?A7

HM«R*<IM(ANM P?) A 2AR A ?/.1

PT 7f;<;7 = Pi ( 17 I+HM/7. A ^SO a ?isi

P,ITPRT«P,I( T7 )+r,r,/7, it ( P.lTpST.LT.l.) r,n rn 9

A ?S? A ?c.^

IF (MATH.FO.Il ßh TU jr« I T T-PT TI;<:T + .S

A P^A A ?BS

.l.l.lsP.lfH^+.S

<:PFFn=M t n..i.i.n+r,c;ft(p.iTF<;T-j.ij)*(4( III ,.IJ,I-1)-A( III.JJJ)) A Z'iv «;i np = u( i ,,M

TF (<;pFHn,Fn.v/Fi .ANn.UKL.Po.i i r,n Tn 2? A ;Kfi A ?«>£)

Tf (ANr,( iil.r,T.PlTT+,S«ift^.AKfrs.AMr,LPULT.5.*f>lTT+,lii>A5» SCffP-lCIHtlS 1 ) A ?M

?n r.n Tn ?i r.AM TBKNf.H (PITPST.P.lTF^T.SPFFn.SLP.Olf-RAC)

A '?h7 ■■" A 7M

?\ TF (^PPFn.po.v/Fi.AMn.i.iKL.Fn.u r,n TH 77 TVWsn

1 ?f.i A ?f.5

^i np=?i P r,n Tn ?^ A ?67

rr " TN/PtTsl ' r.n Tn s

A 2ft» A ?fr9

?? rnMTTMMF IF ( ANr,LF1.f;T.PITT + .«i5HS.ANn.ANr,LFl.LT.^.#PITT + .5t>H5.ANn.ABS(VeL-S

A 270 A 271

iPFprn.ftT..?» ^inp=^tnpp ...... TF (An<;(<;pFFn-TSPFFn).i.T.TF<;T) r-n TD ?I5

' A 272 A 27^

T<;p^Fri=<;PFFn TAIL MNnFT («NRI F1 ,ANr.|.F?,VFL«SPFFn,Sl.nP,!r,RIT,FFF)

A 274 A 27^

rPNTTMIF r.niMTiNiiF

"A 27f. A 277

TF (TWIMTF.FCV.n WRTTF (T.^^V \/FL, SPFFR, ANRLF?, ANßLFl. SLnP,PJTF§T TF (AHMSPFFn-WH|. ).r,F.VFLniF.AMn.U.LF.NM(ILT.ANn,IVW.LT.l.nR.ICRIT

A 27fi A 27g

I.FO.I » r-n Th ?*. VFI=SPFHn

A 2SÖ n 2R1

■ TNTfÄr.iil IVWsO

A 2fl? A 2«?

■>(■,

r,n Tn 5 TF ( TWRITF.FP.l I WR1TF d,^^» P 1 ( I 7 ), P.I ( I 7 ) , IM, 1 S

A 2«4 A 2«^

TF ( !FXAr,T.LT.?T r,n TO 97 r.AI 1 OINMAH (ANr,l.Fl,«;LnPfPI(T7),PJ( 17), IM,1S,AT( IZ ) ,OM( IZJtDIFRAC,

A 2Rfi A 2ft7

71 iwpi ,i';iiHP,AMp,*i.PRiTn,.m r.nNTTNiiF

A JflA A 2ft9

r. TF «twHtTF.iirt.v» wRtTF n.^i PKtn.p.iiin.tw.is

•**PLnTT!N0 TNSTPiir.TinM**« A 290 A 291

TF ( TPI nT.Fo.r«) rn rn ?R X(MP|.T)=Pll(I7)

A 292 A 29?

V(NP| T»=PI(T7) NP| TsMPI T-T

A 294 A 29«>

CAM PI.1MF (X(?T ,Y(?),NP|.T,1 ,n,n,i) MPI T=o

A 29^ A 297

7fl CnNTTNIIF A 29P

61

Page 72: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

r « <: >S ft ft « A ?g4 IP (irwiT + ivui.r.p.7) en TO S A ino IF ( K.RiT.pü, i i nn rn in A 101 t VW = 1 A 1(1? T7=I7+1 A 101

^nwt I? »=(iM( i7-n A 1(U ATI 17 l«ftT( |7-1 1 A i n '■ P I 1 I 7 ) = M I I I 7 -1 ) A HU, P.M I7) = P,I( 17-1 ) A 10 7 AM Til 7 ) = AMT( i7-n*l ^BPFn-WPl. l/ISPFFO+VPL) A 10" VFlrSPFHn A 10M n.ii T7-1 i = ftwr,i P? ," '■'111

(NTI I7-n = SPPRl A -HI IF 1 I7-MMIII T) l'>,?q ,?g All?

?<» 17=17-1 A - -^ ITMT«1 A n 'i r,n in s AUK

10 ANAI F ? = P I T-aMRI F i ♦?. «<;i. OP a ii^ IF I A^r,| P?.r,F.7.*PIT) ÄMRLF7aAN0LF7-?.-»PIT A 117 IF ( fiMH FP.LT.P. ) AMr,LF7sANr,LF7 + ?.#PIT A 11M IVW=1 A 11« r,n rn s A 1?()

il r.nMTlMHE A i?1 TAIL rnMBFr, IBPCIM.HFLMtMnH.lB) A 1?? CALI rnMVF« inR!r,wfnFLw,Mnv,iw) A 1?1 (■All (TlMMDH (riRtftM.flPLM.NftM.lHf A 1?^

i? mMTINHF A •»PS " r «««pinTTiNR iMSTmir.TinN**« Ä 1?h

CALI PLTFNn A 1?7

r A 1?M r. A 1?W ii FORMAT ('O«,?Fft.?,7I4) A 11(1 1A FORMAT MOFA.?) A 111 IS FORMAT M>hF10,7) A 11? iA FORMAT ( 'ni^TÄMr,FKTLOMFTFRSTT(MIN)TT(SFC) • t • TOTAL ( SFC ) AMPL T TtinE • » A 111 17 FORMAT I «OlNITIALAMr,! F , 1 Ml T I ALOI ST ANCF , INI T I ALOEPTH • ) A lit IB FORMAT 1 •ONOM-^IIRFACF! «.SFT.II A IIS

r PND A WM

SIIBROIlTlNF "ftTNMAO ( ANftL Fl ,R , ()l . Pj , IM, 1H, AT ,fiKi,r), A, 1 Snhp, AhlF .SLPft A R 1 - 1 T) n 7 OAU PfF?,PlP,P|F57/K^7l>7q,^.H5«»,A.71?W/ - - n s

4ND1P1«A«S(ANRIF1-H-PIF7) n *» AMhl^7 = A»<;tAtM(,,|.n-B-PIFS?| » s IF 1 AMIltFI.LT.AOTF.OR.AMDIF?,! T, AOIF» RFTIIRN p *

■ IF miiRF.Po.r.) RTI TO 1 ""h ' 7" nv=i .-P.I n n ANCsAHMrOSI PIF-ANCI Fl ) 1 H 4 IF (4NR,LT,,n>i Awr, = .09 H 10 r, iNi=-nw/AMr. R 11 r,o TO 7 h i?

i \lm%\ PRAT/lOf», » 19 IHsSI.PHAT B I* H=M PRAT-IH >» 18 IF (W.I. T..ni ) Vs.S » i*. IF (H.IT..HI) H=.5 R 17 nv«is-pj-i.*v R 1« nH=iM-Pt-l.»M R IQ IF »AMr,LFi.r,T.PiF7.AMn,ANr,LFi.LT.PTEl?) nv«nv*i. H ?0 IF ( AN^LFI .r,T.P!F1 r»H«nH*i, R ?1

62 4

Page 73: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

■ "

■'■■■■ --.■•. ,^,m9m

TF («NRLHl.lT.PtF?» RO TO f,

IF (aNr,|F|.fiF.PIF.AMO.>NGLP|<LT.PtF,)?> RD TO » IF (nv,LT,-nH«TAN(RRn r.|N—n|N JFJBR.RT.ANRI.Ft-PIFV) MN—RIN

TF (ARMnm.i T..nnn nH..nni R 77 nvH=nv/nH H

R 73 7i*

r,AMMASATAN(hvMt IF (f)H*nv,r,T.n.) on tn ?

R R

DFI T=ARS(OAMWft)_H H R

?7

? mMTINMF HFI T»ftR«;(r,ftMMA)*B

R R

?4

1 rnNTiNMF r,)M=AR<;»H««;iM(nFLT»/STN(ANr>|Fi»)

R 4

3) 3?

TF »B.RT.|,5T hM«1,5 >< ^3

3A

37 3H 3»*

r,n TO 7 r.nNTTNIIE !F |nv.(;T.-OH*TAN(HRn RTVS*XPi TF (..R,LT.O..«Nn.A»»S«RR).r,T.PIF3?-ANr,lFl) r,|N>-r,|N r.n tn 7 CnNTTWlF IP tnV.r.T.-nM^TAMfBHH RTW—RTM IF (ftft.r.T.ANfUFt-PIF?) R|Na-r,|N IP in i r.nNTINi.'E

4? 4.3

4»-

"Tr (r)v.LT.-nM*TAKi(AMM r.fi«—r.fki TF (RR.LT.O..ANn.«RS(M).(;T.P|F7-ANr,LEn CIX — r.IN fnwTiwnp P1«(;|N*MN|*Nr,LF1 »♦PI

"P.t.ft|M«f «J AMRl en ♦P.I ATa«un*r,iN/A nNinSiinATniJ RFTIIRN

TUP

H

R R

4A 44 50 SI 5?

54

R K7 H 5'--

T—tn:.-

<Ti«niiTfMF TBfwr.M Tvr»,pj.t,wi!L.SLnPF.öirB*ci

^inPF>n,

1 ? 3

r.n in y? IF >p|p.LTt6o.?» f.n rn 4 IF jPi.V.f.F.?.?» afTfrTT

yft »A.75 51 hPF««,"

7 a 4

r.n in i? f 10 1

VFI«PHI VIOFPTHI r. u r i?

5inPF«n. r.n Tn i> r. 14

4 IP IP|J«lf«l«l ftrt Trt ^ VF| »A,

t H r. tft

5inPF-n. r.n Tn t,

f. 11 r. IN

5 WFI «#.,75 5LnPF«n.

r. i«» c ?o

A r.MnFi>.M4M*m.i-^.fti4.57«*iPi»-5n.9i C 71

63

Page 74: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

IF (r.«Aitt-i .(-T.o. i (;n TM H 77 IF (vM.i.r.T.M .» r.n m 7 r,n Tn } ■>

7 nFPTH^<.r>,*{ P[.i-g. )«n|FMAr »/F| =Pn| V ( nfPTM ( ?*< <;i OPhrO, r,n TO y ■>

71

A )F (i.7774«(PtP-fcS.7».r,f ,Pi.i-f..A» r.n Tn in IF (r.BAiiFi .er,*,» r,n Tr» Q 30

^lHPFS.SSHS ll •\7

Q r.n tn »7

liFPIM«<.«.M.U4Ha(Pt.|.ft.7|'».^7q*|P|p(.Sn.S| »•niFRAC

w -

3fc UFI spni v ( n#PVU]

10 r.n in 1 7 r>FMnMi»,M, 7_P|p

37 3«

11: (MFMnM.i T,(nMt | nFMnMs.hAi «1 noe,1.S7n«_AT*N» (^J.S-PI.IWOFNnMI

■3« ' 40

IF i«Ai>.r.T.?«.ii r.n TO «7 11 «7

is (»Aft.r.T.»•*,*» m m 11 OF p TM.*n.♦1JH,»-B *n t »niCRAC 4A «Ft .pni viftPPTt?! r.n rn 17

11

11 «F| .^.>H C| npf.o.

i7

}•> BFTHOW MM

n

«0« T~

MMf TfnM pni v («i I

BF TllHFl n 1 3

r FMO n " 4»

k.MBft(.ti^F ^»M^T (rTii,Yr.i,A|.i,4m;,ni.k,icilT» irut tmn

t 7

i^TA Pi/^.1<.»<077/ OAIA K'l /I ,S -sT^». «I /

3

«A*AM« /All r.M.o,

•I

Mr.,«. 7 a

IF ir m,r.p,n,,»Nn,rin,i »,»| 1 r,n Tn 1 " 9 10 IT— 17

«F irr.i T,».»PP[ i r.n TO » r.M,7,«Pt

1 r.n Tn ^ JF irr.r.T.PiM i r.n Tn 7

n 1*

9 en In ^ r.MaPf

n ^

wr.i.i.

FFFtAAXtfcirr 1 11 1*

IF 1 A««(FFI-I.r.c.t.i ftn Tn i •ar ...... i\ii« |«ii FFF I M M ■«Xbi'.Hf I.AM IF irf i,r.T,»,»Pii ri.)«rt.iO.«P| IF irii.iT,^,» rf.i.rT.u>,»rr r.n Tn *>

71 27

7» ft irBiT«i >%

I

Page 75: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

r,n Tn * t ?h -^ rr wrrii W TT-

~~ PKin ~ —— p ^t)<!

r <iiHnniil TMI: rrcMPr, (n,i<H,M,ini t- I IF MM.r.T.N) UFTIIUM ^ v nsrnm F ,:«_

UrH*llM h fc

T-

^iiDRmiTlMf rnt*\icu (v,r>v,N,lvi f- I 1! itw.t'-T.Mi nPTimk T —y"

IValV»! r.

BCTIIBM r, •> PW ""K- A«

—wwwwTwnüwwi >M.nu>.T"> 1—r* IF IIK.«"-!.»!» BFTIIBN " ? |M.|H*T •- » MBM^DM M <■ BFItlUM "M '< FMD H *6

^liaBINIT|NI- PI ANIT |H,nU|r.,«T.nKitB.I1|F.bF»-l I | nNBr*-n*TTn«cT*>nn«nTT T ? «LON/OFF I ^

ip«nipw ■ i *. FMH I M

65

Page 76: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

WWW»»» ftW » i,i<>.tu If«! KVUTM rmK^-^FT T IHM SfS\V\ lit- VKM.iITV nt^THIMilTtll^ IS SF T HP 4N0 PAVS ARF MBIIPAr.ATH»

1UAV/H tIM^v, i>n;TAMfH IM r>|iLTA OI-r.HHI-S ANO K1 LOHfcTFRSt »NO " APPUIIV | M« T» «M.JI i Turn *. Awt- rnMPiiTFn,

HAMH|<;T P/^AMETFUS A| PHABFTir A| tV IISTFl) r rtpri ^i;^ nF f|BriF TM HF PIIITTFO FdH FAUTMIS tIRCii>"Ff:'»PMr.F r rior? M/I- fif TIPTIF TO HF PI OTTFP FMH COHF-MANTLF HniiNntav r r mr < «vi/t- OF ( !uri F rn MF PI OTTFII FHQ IMNFB CO»t r rw«» "/««iwiiH u»r>tM AKf.i F Tn WMir.M r.lffn.PS >BF MUlTTPQ r rm». MIWIMHW UAMIM *»r.( F TO WMITM CITAFS AUF PLOTTFO

r l'Fn IM'. t-»PO>.TFMTI Al r;F|PFMFHT HV AT TFNII AT | OM "T HFT.KM K H ifFTFuv. pt-u nFr.aFE OF FABTMIS ABC r fcnr.j. «,«M i i>l«.TA»rF TO UMITM IMTFBFAtF SMOHI n Hfc APPBpAC.Mfn r k»ri>(>l FM Top TO MMITIPIV OATA TO r.MANr.F VF| Of | TV | NPllT r uii* ' . MA«|wii'< ..-. i .'»TM DoSITiniu r tmUMIM MlkifMiiM MOUT 7r<»iT Al FdSITiniM f MAP CHlTrn TM IMri.oHF APPABFluT VFIOflTV f friur (MlTfM To |MO|rATF BloTTtMr. (IF r|«f.LFS r irvflF J«H|»IIM MKXHFB OF BAY | Aif OFK-FMTAT I (INS f lOAT «iufTCK TO rHAMT.F POBTIIIM OF l)ATA WV FACTlIB HCntf f IOIFIK sov wFFlFrTlom OF AMPI ITiinF (OlFFilSIOM mPH-IC I ^WT t f TPIOT SWITTM TO inrinnF rAiroup PinTTünr. f tpp ^M|TrM TO TO«ft •»HlTTDlF p.BAY«. |pptppptFTC. i

>l

n JJL

is I* 17 I" I«»

71 ??

^0 r -?— r r f

r

I CAMP «iiMiitu np «AMPI F POTM^ TO CFATFH OF FAHTM |«i»|Tl- ^u|TfM TO IMri.MOF "I ACAinSTir VBITFOIlTS ^___ M.»«*T MAitMiiM MII»»«FB \* OATA i tST t(> HF f.M»mr.ifi> UV FiiCWÄT" •MVfFr. MAVIMIIM IIF|TA »T wMfrw nnTPiiT IS i^lSMFrt MAVOIIM MÄliI»(l« KKTAMrF TO WUfrH OUTPUT IS MlSMfO «»l>.liAT Mtti|M|iM MiiMaFa IM nATA I |ST TO gf r.HAMr.FO WV FACPAT MIAiOFnT M|M|MMW Ot|.TA AT HHlfM HllTPllT IS BTtBPH M|«iii(M Mt»j|MiiW mcTAMrS TO UMlfw nnTPoT IS wISMFn A.11M111 T MtMHFB C(F UII|T|PIF B F Ft. Ff T | PMS ALIUMFÖ

MM th|TIAl AWMl|T<inF uAI HF PBFTI lOfATin*- HF |A>TFBFArc ••FTMFFN" SAMPt'F" P(T| NTS I tWMOii MIMM OF MiMt/OAiTAI SAMPIF 0O|A.TS MSFfT

TT

94

f 7 r r r

MIIMMFB OF WFBTtrAI. SAMPIF Pn|k<TS llSFO MiiMMFB HF KIIOMFTFBS «C~TWFFN"S**PI.F POINTS BAY SFr.MFA,T I FAir.Tw w|ki|WMW unBITäMTAI POS|l|llS_*iCf>Ö?h FI('ATf»«r. pnfMT WFPBFSFMTFn OlSTANfF TO f.FNTF» OF F*BTH

vFinriTv o|FFF8Fk>rF MFfFSSABV TO fAllSF PFFieCTION, MAitM.i« vFBTjrAi pr.s^Tin»! w|M|WllW VFBtlfAl POSlftO»»

TT

4? VF| 1.1»

UFDWA« \IFBH|M

A«»PI ^vMu.-, TAHI F

A«»P| ITnnF

"ST 44 47 411

r r r r r r

•« ■ FT Avr.i F > AVT AT «PPVFI ABf.

|nr|l'FNT AA>r.| F OF BAV FWFBr.tAir. AAif.l F f»F BAY ABUAV FHB AMPI ITonFS »FffB •fFLFCTInNV ABBAY Fnw TOftVFl TI ««F S APPABFHT «FinriTY iniSTANf.F |N KH hlVfOFH HY TMAVd T|P«F| pFBTirAi pr-n|T|nA> n|w|nFn *Y MnBi;nATAi POSITin»»

f mnmn CHHBOHTIME ir PBFriSFiv Wfjfi BAY AT SIIBFACF

r TT 1 ABBAY FfB VAM'FS OF ANA^FS TO HF BfTllBNF» Til AFTf IgFLfrTt f n BAiifAl vFinriTY <t <.TB|HiiT|llN OF A SPMFPIC»L FA^TM r KFPTM HftV|HIIW IFPTM BFACMFn HY BAY (4^7| HM-BADIISI f n«« > tv ■ i IM Y*

49

«- »>

%4

*7

§«»

■ »

66

Page 77: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

T"

nj<;T«

wnp jMf MDB7 KM trim 11»'!»-«

nunprri BUR iPPnacRiiii HTWFRr mMK dt- f-McorMMr, Awri wjARnvF JL.ort IF r.BITICAL^ ANf.l.F) wnOI^IlMTAi TMrfiMMlPKitATII»! OF BAY SF^MFNT" MOPI/flMTAI pfKfTIOM IM K || flHFTt-BS ^wiTfw Tn tMOlfATt: r«ITir.»l. «FFL Ff.T IHM ^l-'ITrH F'lP MA«IMr. HFACMFn IMTFUFAfF

f-d

iMFar,F ^uiirw FOU MAviwr. FMFor.Fn AT ^imFAfF WITH KAV

iMtiM NiiMnFe nc T|MF^ TMBfmr.w |n»iFB_tri(>p \\¥r TPAVFITIMF (M IMTFr.FB MIMMFH nFHlKinTFS ' IWFI nr swirrH jr\_i»i»irATF BFFi.Fr.TtnM AT i^TFBFAr.F IVW «TuitrM FTP BFAfH|Mr, BFFCFrf int« IWWU rntlMT FfU» MUMHFB fiF ^F"HFNT1AI

(CBITKAL I»« MlM-fP ITIC4H r.BITirAI BFrtFf TKIN^

»>7 » •

71) 71 7?

17 XBJT lüppir KWfl

I

\M\r-t FOB MMMqFB OF BAY HFF|.Fr.T |I)N «wirrM FOB HAWIMR HFAr.HFn CRITICAL Awr.i F TCTrr:FF"vrALiie «F ftP»TM 7TF pftrtkPo «AtiTT VFBTIfAl BO^ITIMN |M INTFCFR MIMftFft OF SAMPLE PHINTV

TBTTTTR MPI flT

-ftH" 0! PM PIT

VFBftrAI PO^ITJOM IM kiFARF^T (NTFr.Fa NUMMFM l»F ^AI»P| FS «wTTrw Tn BFAO HAT* nn FI»<;T r»Lt WMFM HSFO |g simnnitT|MF

71 7t 7-. 7». 77 TU

TUTU wwKw iw mm^ni NiiMRFB OF PinTTINf. INrRFüfNTS

AB8AV FOB UAI IIF«. OF MOBt^ONTAI MOB ( IMIII. wi^rri?fli iv UNPir r.nmTAWTt «.i4|«a

POSITION

BO

«1 B? Ml

TTTT—HIWPW mi UP nr —WWWI WlfTIWI PW IfPWWCI Pit» Mn«|7nMTA| pn<(|TinM |» %AMPI F POINTS FariM HtFFBfBNr.F PIPBOB P»»WFIT"V*M««" n» MiwurnNTAL wsinnu— PIBFF MomynwTAi pnsiTin* FOB nMgi»|gif|qg OF vti:nr,|Tv_ P.I ABBAV ^PB «Ai lift f»F WOlfK'.Al PftTTTIllN P.M WFBTirAI POSITIIW IM MMgif POIMTS FBflM f.PMFB OF FABTw

»- BC

0(l

pmin WAIHP if ulTTfS ^n^iTinN nvi plffl rti ntra vFHTirAi. pn^innN IM SAHFLP POINT« FBHM CFNTF« OF FABTM PBftÄ*irv«rnrTfr"vi6*TtCAi NlllTTnl VFBTirAl POSITIfW FOB t>F TFBK|N*T ION OF WFLOCITV

P.M1 P.I.I7 PIPBOB P.IBFF BAD I nisfANff F«n""f**^B" of FABT^'TN'^üMPLF^TMTS

hlSTAMfF FBON fFMTFB OF FABTM

«1 a? Ql •14 oV o».

wmiw wtifü nwi ffiw nr um w WPCT nwwfi BAOllS M|N|MI|M BAIMlH BFACMFO BV «AY |N (CfLOMFTFRS ■mm WWPWIIW In mi Ipcvniinici nrwn iNtisrAff SFf TRAVFI T|MP |N «FrONni AMOVF |NTFr.FB MfNllUS tiNnFT <ii«7VnTTB» "Ti» C/WBiiTr rsfwnnrrw.ir rWi ANVT.TVI:«- AV...L»r

AND SIOPP

-ST t)A CM

inn

in? Q OPF «I HPFB <PFFn 1««|N

WFI VFIOI

■TW! SAWFO WAIHF OF <|.nPF IP*

tos in«.

"tOT" to«

pnm VFin? wTi'M vFin* wiinfv VFBINf

TOJSTS-Rr-SATOfifmnrÄTTilN TMAVF) TtMF tw MlNllTFS VFitlf ÄT*n|<"TANfF FBriM CFMFR OF FARTM |N SAMPLF POINTS VflOrtTV vriiVtTv HW* mm 6">rcTiniii VFlOTITV -TNTrirnATinw nr neBTM-Tr"Ut«»ir »rtitnir vifliVlTv

TÖ5- lin

ABBAV TO MOm PRFWIÖII« VPtor.jTV VALliM AFftH «FFL^CT t HNS" VfTtfAl INfBFMFNTATinill OF BAY 5Fr.MFNT VFBTBM OFPTM |N KlLOMfTFtS

nr It? m it*

cimannTINF urwi n |P| ,i».ltON( ANT,ftf,~ANf.LF?»t 7 t««Y.t I n I MF N K t ON PH|ft |j Rjnwt, f,|.M10|, ONIIQI. ANT 11 n» , „AlQOl, JMJ 00 0

H. wfi nrPYUm

67

Page 78: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

HfMt-NMf'* » ( """M , vjionni A l?n

r.AM .1 i..'i T >, irui i ,i»i.-,n,,|v.iw/-<.i4,i«)<j,i.s7nM,(j,ntn,ntn/ ' & )?i »»- (1 .'T.I 1 ..\ TU fc 4 1??

MMMMIM mATAIfi/ ^^r.M(.».,f^AMP,| IMUFB.l IMMOO.^IMPKM.WFLniF.nFCllir,, A l?3 »MMMiil B.Kvn ...Fur ^,^MM»-.T<iA«P,PNM,t IMIMCf IWBITFtPHhCftSCA^.IHCl.C? A 1?* »prj.r lur^.MiuMM.nnuMftw.v^MMiti.wFUMAii.l^r.KM.inAT.lPLnT.IPP.HINnÄT, A 1?H ■»MAi(f>AT,»-«ri>AT, iMimt. i AAP.Tri-r ,MiMnFr,tMAxnfr.,r.M|N.r.MA«fMiMnKM,HAii A I^«.

*""«• A 1?/ BPAO Jfc.l'AIAI'") A I?»* H-AI1 »»..-»M (n( 1 t,|.1 ,1 IMWFB1 A 1?«>

nn 1 fr»lni<*T,MA«nAT A Ml IM 1 l»(i» f lul-ArriAT A 191

1 rriMfiMii». A 1*1 7 rnNftMli A 1 »<.

r ••»••••««•■•«•PI HTTItur. |M«TR|ir.T|IIM*««««**««*««****««* A n*> «* i |PI nT.m.iM r.n TO 4 A 117 r*ii PI Tnn c. ,^«"(i,n, .^rA,*^ ,«.,» A n* IF ( ir |pr,».n,i»i r.n Til ^ A 11Q

rAii ..riuri 1 T^AM^.I..rM|Ki,rMA»tr.iRr.i,riRr.ifo«i 1 A 1*0 r^M priHn iT<<\Mp.i..r*f*.r.MAvtf|Af.*.ciBC3*ntli i 1*1 r»M .ri-ri -'^"•'.i. .r"|k..rMA«,f iBC?,f.|Rr,?tOtll 4 I*?

t r. » ii-..,. A ,fc1

4 fnwIIWIt- A 1*4 VtliT«M«|P.)M;)-l.lo«AMPKM A 14* MnB;i,M.|P|(in-l,l««;A»"P«»» A 14». *i»l T.o Ä 147 MlM M- ••' A 14« vw(.| ■».l| tn A |4q IF IKVH .r.T.I |MVF»-H KVF| ■?.*^AMPKM.|-KVFl A 1^0 •run fap || IM»,* A |f| vt| • I^AfP-PM171 A \%7

. ■ II7»VM IW A l^ J • i. •-|. ....... 11 1 / 1 A 1S«> ..gtt-.t «.1 ».-^ t» ( ». .1 i ? 1 A ISf«

•rut f,n A 19» II»-TI.W.H A I*«» IMSBr.»..»« A 140 tww.n A 14| l«wB«»» A 14? ntr.F<i»r«, A 141

* rm-TiMi». A 144 f ••••••••«•••••»( OTT l^r. |»'^T8llf ttnh*«««*«*a*««*B*««»« A 149

1»- I ffl <'T,FO,n| r.n rn T A 144 MPI T.^-PI T.I A 147 IF IMM t,«"1.!! AH TP 4 A 14* «i»P| TlcP.lf III A IM» YI^PI TI»P|1171 A 170 . .. T.^PI?♦! A 171

4 , . rf , A 17? T riWTtMNi A 179 r ••••••«••.. ••.•••••••••••••(«••••••••■••••• A 174

IMlM.fklllM*! A I" IF llMMM.r.i-.irvri Fl BFTMRIK A [74 ^»«r.t PfaMNM *■•> k 17> praFF*P|i f/i».v*MnB|«ir A 17B . . .i .. •• i ' i ..'•.■ tu «*r A |7«

9

Page 79: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

»I(f7 >■•»!( 17 1 ♦MOB INC A IBO

!*= «Pt( r/».i T.HnBMiM.n«.p| (i; ».r,T,HnRMAx.nR.p.i( 17 KLT.WFPMIN.OR.PJ

A 1«) a 1R?

r. u i7).r,T.«F»MAxt r,n rn >s A 1H3

A IBiV tF ( IPI OT.FO.O» r.n TO H X(WPI T)-P,I(T7I

A 1«S A IHl"!

ft VIMPI TI-PT(T7I rOMTINIIF

A 1HV A IRR

r. IF t IWRITF.r.F.l) WRITF «7,?«) P H ! 7 » , P.t( 1 7 1 . »< FLdl , ANGLFl

A IRQ A 140

?F «PCI 17».1 T.OIBF» »FTMRW PII.PIBFF-1,

A 141 A IP?

P.M»T^AMP-P.IBFF RAni>^nBT(PII»PII«P.I.|«P.|.n

A I'n A 1 "A

IF (BAnnK.r.T.Pini» nanTii^>B>ni WFI ■T^AMP-B»ni

A ms A 196

KVFI «WF| «VFI 1»VF| ».S A IQH

P.I.I?-T^aMP.P.M|7l A 1QQ A ?()0

♦ f «Mt>.LT..ftAAH PM>.,Artftl IF IPIf.LT.O.» PTI?"-PII?

A ?ni A ?n?

ABR*P.M7/P||7 IF («Rc.r.F.n.) on rn 9

A ;>cn A 704

knwfsnwtAiRuviT^ GO Tn in

A ?0^ A ?0h

0 f nUTINIIF «LOPF-ATANIABRI-PIT?

A ?07 A ?0R

nr IF (ivFinr.Fo.ni r,n rn n

A ?0U A ?10

IF (IVW.FO.n WFIOl.VFiniH A 311 A ?1?

n rww.A IF iwFini,LT,,ftSi r,n rn i?

A ?1* A ?1A

vriiU«vFirt^ Alt tn-ATf |7U^Fr,MFN*S*MPKM/VFLn«

A ?IS A ?16

1? IF IRADI.r.T.TCAMP.t. ) OP TO ?^

. A ?I7 A ! R

TV BAn^.BAOl irB|T>n A ??0 IF nwFinf.Ffl.rt» vpiniaVFin? ivFinr-n

A"7?T 1 ???

nn 1* n-l.A piPRnn.pnin*HnRtNr/?,

A ffj A ??<.

P.tpRnft.P.U]7t>\>TRIHf/>, PlllaPIPBOft-l. A ??A

" p.ui»Tiu«w-p.iBBft*r— - - B«n>»«;oHTiPin«Pin*p.i.n*p.Mi)

A ?T7 A ??R

IF (ftAn?.RT.T*AMP.1.| RH TH ?1 IF i«n«(B«m-R«n?i.i.F..no^i r,n rn |f

A ??<* A ?10

OAM.BAh? ^PFFnaT^AMP-RAO?

ATTl " A ?1?

««"FFn.^BFfh vFin?-M«KSPFFnt*iSPFFo-KSPFFO»"»<niKSPFFn*n-n(KSPtfnn

A ?M A ?^4

r.tll MNHFT »ANRl FUANftl F?,WFLni,VFLn?,^LC»PF,ICR!T,FFF) A ?1S A ?^8

.irBiT-irBiT^.ir.BtT IF i.ir.BiT.RF.^i r,n TO ?S

A ?^7 A ?■**

IF iirBiT.Fo.M r.n in 1*, A 2^9

69

Page 80: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

>. „ ... .,■■..; ■.■.,;■ ■■ .: ■ . ■ ■ —.

IS

Mnp i Mr i^K^i-Mft^ i M ( ft Mr, i (-7 >

VPB TMT ä TTlRffrTJwTTfTTÄTTTTTT^T ^n^| TlMi it- r OM ri MI if

IF ( («WH.r.T.i ) |VWRsTVWR-1

v P 1 1 n = \/ n n ?

A ?4()

TTTST A ?»? A lut A 244 A PA«? A ?4(S

1 T

I (■ 1 P

IP

■>} ( 1 IMTPH.PO, 1) r,n Td

t |wmTp,r.p.A) WBITF (7.^0) vptm .vFLn?,st.nPF, i? (|«WB,NP',n) Rfi TO 17

( ^PFHri.r,T.\/i 1 . AMII. flns(n(KVFi.ii-n(KVPLl*l) ).r,T.veLi)lF) GO in 19 (VH .'.T .^Pt-m.AMn.ftRsi iV(KVFL 1 )-n(KVFLl-in .GT.VtLDlF) 0,0 TO 19'

A ?47 A 24H

rnMT IMlF

A ?49 A 250_ A ?Sl A 25?

IP ( If.HIT.FO.fM <;i ilPPu ■ ^1 OPF r.ii Tu ->? rnM TiMuh c.n rn '1 niM TI^lll^-

r,n Tn 1 n A 253 •A 25« A ?'6h A 25^ A 2,57 A 25«

vFl in-vVi ni TftM wi'i'IMT ( ftMf.l F| .91 (1PF.PH 17 ) ,P.|( 17 ) «TSAMP.FOntrtVeLtnNI 1Z).AT( 1

171 .«^n.KM.vH (i'.PH ,PI T ?, 4R r,, ^PF F n ,TTM 1 NC . R An AH, PK tC 1. EORF Sf KVFLI) • «««««««»DiitiitimPI nTTIMT, IM<;THHrTI(1N*<"l'**»'l'**«*«*«*«'t'W* 1 (- MPMU.pn.ru r,n Tn 5n "" IP I fPI I1T .Pn.ri) x |Mp| T)«P,I( 17 )

70

r

vi MPi 1) =PI ( 171 "' ' "•" ■ rftM P| IMP (<( 1 ) ,Y(1 ) .MPLT.1»D.Otl )

r nw T JMMP

• « :s« * i:t u A « « >» 4 a >» 4 A « « i * * 4 # *.» a « * « « * «'i * «in*!»* A « « 4141 ^c iji i|i >|i«1» ^

IP ( I'-iMTP.r.t-.M WRTTf (7.^01 PI( 17),ANr,Lei.SLnPF ^i nppu = >;i npp ip 1 ir.wiT,Fo, 1) Rn 1 INTFB«I »/PI tl^aVfl m VH m w =UM ni nn TU 1 <

Tn ??

"PT 1 IMTPP=^ —

1 V/M nr.«i IP ( I / .pn.MiiMin T 1 nn TU s 1 7 = 1 ;*i it- M 7 .r.T .MiiMni r 1 «pTiiRTT-

nw( 171 nfiNi i7-M A T( PI ( P.M ir.B AMT

I F

I / 1 = A

17 ) ^P

t; »«p 1 T»n (17 1 = ( pllP

TM 7-M 1(17-1) M I ;-M

AMI ( (7-1 )«( iniKVFl.l )-n(KVFI.2n/(n<KVFLl )+L1(KVFL2) ) ) |l«;,Ffi,1 ) ftMTI 17 )=.S#AMT( 17-1 )

«Fl r I J IP

r riM IMP

nr v ( 1

( 17-1 ( W All 1

P = 1 TI Ml II- H(;p = f

7-1 ) rVFI '17 1 = AMM P? ns.r.t ,P AHART R AfMH^^RAIlA»

M|l|

\/C|

AMC,

IP

I «F

Tl P = M ni k = \/ I P7 = P ( n-- p 1

1 nr r 1

III TIP*! PI ni IT-AMf.l p 1+"?.'*^TiPFR TF,r,F,4) WRITF (7,30) ANr,LFUSLnPFR,AMRLF2

A 2,>9 A 2^0 ~A 2AI " A 262 A 2iS3 A 2(S4 A 265 A 2^ A HI A 26« A 269 A 270 A 271 A 272 A 273 A 274 A 275 A 27C« A ?77. A 278 A 279 A 2*0 A 111 A 2R2 A fRI A 2ft4 A 2R5 A 2B«S A 2B7 A ?Rn A JAO A 290 A ?<»1 A 292 A 293 A 294 A m A 29(S A 297 A 29« A m

70

'

Page 81: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

.

:,:•.:-,,■,.:■:•. ..

i IF (flNr,|.F?.r.T.7.«PIT) 4Mr,LF? = ANr,LF?-?,«PIT TF (AMftl FJ.l.T.n.» ÄNr,LF9 = 4Nr,LP?+?.*Pn HnRiNr,= (<;F';MFN.t.Fnr,F»;)*siN( ANRI.F?) -vTRTMrsKPr-MTN+FnftF^Ur.nsiANfiLF?) aT(ln=AT( I7) + SAMPKM«FnrFS/VFLn4

A 300 ä tm A 302

A 304 nM( in=nM(i7 )+Fnr,FS«SAMPKM vFLn3=vFi.n4

305 3nc

Fnr,FS=n. I\/W=l

>07 30B

IVWR=H r,n in 5

3oq 310

?3 rOMTINIIF TF (IWRITE.r,F.3) WRITF (7,?P) AT( IZ ) ,nN{ I Z » , VFLOl, SAMPM, ANGLE 1,PIT

'311 312

1 I7),Ptl(IZ) CALL RDRD (PT(TZ),P.MlZI,ANRLFl,ISAMP,FOr,E,nN{ IZ)fAT(IZI ,SAMPKM,D(

3li 314

IKVFLUni'JTA» " IF {PKm.LT.l. ) niST4«0ISTA + lR0.

^15 31(S

nKM=nFr,KM«ni<TA APPVFI =nKM/AT(17»

517" 31«

AMPi s| UNM*äKIT( m/nwnz n*FXP(nPCLnr,*nN( m i TMIN=AT(IZ)/ftO.

A ^1«J 320

ISFC=TMIN «;Fr = ftO.*(TMIN-ISFC)

'321 322

TF (IWRlTfi.RF.?) WtttTP <?.**) ATlintONIlII RAnilSsSAMPKM<OiRAniUS

423 324

nFPTH=«;»MPKM*(TS4MP-l J-RAnilü IF (OKM.LF.MTNnKM.nR.nKM.RF.MAXOKM) GO TO 24

A 3?5 326

WRITE (7,?B» niSTÄ,nKHfTMTN,Si:r,,AT(IZJ,RADUSfnPPTHtAWPL. IF (IA4P.F0.1» WRJTF (7,31) APPV6L

WJLTIP 1 A 327 32«

?4 rnMTiNiiF TVFi.nr.si "i 32<?""

330 TMFRRFsl <;LnPFR«si.npF

A 331 332

r. ?6

«**ft«**««***»**«p(.nTTTNr: INSTRUCTinN*«*****««»***i"i>* IF (IPLOT.FO.O) RO TO 26

333 334

X(NPI.TTrP.MIZ) Y(MP|.T)«PI(IZ)

33!) 33(S

MPI.TsO 'A 337

33« ?6 r.

rnMTiNiiF «««««««««««nil**«*****«»***««******«****»«»*«***«**»*«

33<5 340

IF (fMpRftp.Pö.u en rn ?? IF (IPP.FO.l.ANn.lMFRGE.FO.l) Rfl TO 22

3*1 342

Mill TIP-MIILTIP-1 IF (IZ.EO.l) RETURN

A 3Z.3 344

I7-IZ-1 .ir.RiT»n

3^5 34(S

ANr,i.E?»r.ij(i7» VFLn3«VELnr.Y(lZ) ;

347 34«

HnRINC»SERMFN«SIN(ANRLE2) A 344

350 wPl>lNr»SFRMPN*CnSUNr,LE9» ivFi nr,«i

351 352

r. r,n Tn s 354

354 ?7 FORMAT (inF4.?)

FORMAT (•',F(S.7,FlO,?,F7.?,Ffc,?,Ffl.2,2F9.2,F8.2,I6) "A i*5

35* ?p FORMAT MOINITIALAMfiLF,DEPTH,f.niSTANC6'/'ntLTAtfiKMMlNS6CTOTSECftAO

11HSnEPTHAMPL» , iMIILTIPLFS' ) 35« 30 FORMAT |»TfIPi,f,ffl) 3M

71

Page 82: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

11 FRfiMAT { ' APPAWPNT\/PLnr,ITY=',PS.?) A ^^0 pNfi A ^h\«

SimnnilTINE Rnsn (PIR,P,IR,ANir,LFl,ISAMPtFnr,F,nN,AT,l)llFRAC,A,niSTA) R 1 RAMP = i<;aMP-), _JL-_2

^AMt-r T SAMP b S nn j»i.3o R 4 Ms,^ R S PTWr.!»pnfie*STN(AN(»LPl) P t Piwr.,i = Fn'-.F*r.n';( AMCI.FI) ' n 7 POPsSAMP-PJR __5 ?_ PMaPfR-l. — " H" Q RAni=SQRT(PRR*PRR*PII»PII ) R 10 IF (RAni.LT.RAMPi r,n rn i H ll PTNri=-PiNri R \? PTKff;) = -PTwr.l R1 I» M«-l . R 1» PIRVpfR + PlNr, 1 " ~ R IT P,IR = p,|R + PINr..l R 1A ATrAT+ntFRAfcH^PrtftFM R—rr nNanN*niFRAr«Fnr,F*H H 18 IF ( R AD rrr^/RAMP^PTiRFVAKtri.RAnf.LT.ftAMP+EftfiEl ftn Tu 5 PT'TT rnMTIMUF R ?n ! F ( A R < (FfR - 1. ) . L T7 I'M ) PIRsl.01 R ?!' ÄRr,s(SAMP-P.IRl/(PIR-l . ) R 22 TMFTÄ = ÄTAKi(ÄRftl R—7T nr<;TA=(1.57nR-AR<;(THFTAn*S7.?P'>R R 2*

"fT" (TMPTä.LTTöT» OHTA=n.570ft*ARS<THETA»»*,?7.245<!. U W RFTIIRN R 2ft

r. FND R 27*

SIIRRnilTINF RPHIMT ( ANGLF],SLP,PIR,PJR.TSAMP,FORE.VEL.ON,AT.SAMPKM, IVFI ni,piT,piT?,«RrMSPFFn,LiMiNC,RAni,PRECi,pnr,ES,Ki)

c c

1 2

NF = 0. P!?=PIR-1.

t e 4

PRHaTSAMP-p.lB RÄni=SORT(PRH*PRR*PlI«PI 1)

c c

5

r «♦•«•»•♦»«C.HFrK TO SFF IF RAY IS INWARO OR niJTWARn***««****«*»* KVFI=K1

t c

7.

IF (SPFFD.IT.VFL) KVFL=K1-1 C 9 RAnTFS=TSAMP-KVFI.-PRFr,I C 10 IF (SPFFn.i.F.vFi.) r,n TrTT C TF IF (RADTFS.I T.RAm i r,n Tn ? c. 12 r.n TO i C TT" -.flMTINUF c 14 IF (RÄni.l.T.HADTFSl GO TO 2 C 15 flfl Tfl ^ C 1ft r.nfotiNiiF r TT H=I. C IB _____ J J_

H=-l. C 20 r.nNTlNllF C 21 ««**«*«*<;PT HDRIZDNTAL f, VERTICAL INCREMFNTS OF RAY««*«***«»* C 22 PlSCl«FnRF*<«IN(ÄN6LFl) C 23 PIMr.i=Fnr.E«rn';(ANRLFl I C 2* nn s I=I,IIMINC C W PRRgTSAMP-P.IB f. 2ft PII=PIR-1. C 27 R A nIs SOR T(PRR«PRR»PII»PI1 | C 2B ««■**«*«««*«TF<;T FhR CLnSFNFSS TO RADIUS OF RFFLECT10N C 29

72

Page 83: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

IF (AB«;(HAnTFS-RAnn.LT..ft*Fnr,F) r,n rn A 30

r. NF.NF+l, «««»«««INCRFMFNT f, FIND TRftVELTlMF t 01STANCF*************

31 32

PIR»PIR+H*PINCI P.IRsPJR-i-HiXPINr.J

31 34

AT»AT+H*SAMPKM*FnC,E/VFLni nN.nN+H*<;AMPKM*FnGF

3«; 36

rnNTIMII»S rnMTINtIF

37 3fl

PIII«AHStPin IF (Piii.LT..nnon Piii«.nnoi

30 40

IF (PII.LT.n.) PHI—PHI ARRsPRR/PIII

41 42

IF (ARR.RE.O.) r,n TD 7 ^LP«ATAN(ARR)+PIT?

43 44

7 RP TO B r.nNTINUE

45 46

A «;LP»ATAN(ARR»-PIT? CnNTINDE

47 4B

PhriP«;-Nt:*PbftP*H RFTIIRN 50 FNn SI*

«

T

73

Page 84: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

Ponr.BftM Hn« TH*FP.nt««^M{(|nM*t Mnnpt OF EARTH SECTKtN I 1 Mnnn nt- vt-mriTv nrsTHfmiTinN is SFT UP »Mr» p»vs »Rt PROPAftAfFD w t

1 9 TQAVFI IIMF<;. PI TAMfF IN KILOMFTFRS. »NO i APPBOXIMATF A»»PI rTnnFs ARF COMPIITFO I

1 «

A ^VMMIII TABIF ' t

ABHAv np <;aMPi po «Fi.nr.iTv «äLIIF^ 1 »■ 1 7

AAFF AOIF

PBflBFn «Finri TV VAUIF MINIMUM ANr,| F AT WHir.M PRFCISF INTFRFACF LKCATION IS tlSfO

1 » 1 9

«FFI Al PMA AMP| AMf.l f>

iMr in^NT «FI nr.lTv / ANr,| F FBDM BdTATFn 7-AXI«;

» 10 1 11

AMP| I TlinF FMFfiCINf. AMr,| F IN »-V PLANF (

I 17

AMT AT

ABHAV KlH AMPiltimtS AftfR »PPLPCTlftMS " ( APBAV FOB TRAVFI TIMF^ j I 19

«A«;? ABWAV rnMTAiNiNr, «;A(«iPLFn SLnPF «AIHFS " / nisTANr.F AI riNr simFAr.ciN KM

» I'- 1 17

nriABr. ABBAV FfT1 niP^ t rrKiMF nF MATMFMATKAI.Iv nFTEB»iNFn INCLINATION I

I in I 19

nnBFF Bfr.iN nFr.|Mn BMA

IMITI Al AMr,| F HF RAV / k 70 k 71

INITIAI WATIIIN FnR INri INCATinN i nip / k 71

ri.i INTFBMFniATF WAIHF FOB BMTATinN ( ABBAv FOB VAMIF«; nF ANr,LfS Tn HF RFTMRNFO TU AFTER REFLECTI i

» 7* 1 7%

rij n jNFi TLIMF» r\ |NFM rnMRFf; rOMIlFP

ABPAV FHB <1A«IN^ BFtBArTPh |Nf| |IXAT|ftl«( iPT(:H »PPtPCTIft»» 1 INri INATinM i i 27 FMFBr.iNr. ANr,i F FROM 7-A»IS ~ "t* i INrilNATIOK' IN HFr.RFFS i » 79

r ^imRIMiTINF Td iMrBFUFNT INITIAL ANGLE Of INCIDENCE •! CMHRIIMTINF FUB I "1 T I Al IZINR 7-VALI)F S '

k 90 k SI

rOMMOB rDMVFB

M.HBnnriNF rn iNrBFM^Nt »NltUL HAkl^AhTil »nHITKUi t «imBOMTINF TU INrBFKFNT INITIAL VERTICAL POSITION t

i M t 39

rriM^T rPl

rnN^TANT FriB MATM FlINrTlflN J BF-BUTATFli »-pnmTinM |

\ 9« i 9*

rn«;iNF OF iNn INATION i PBn.iFrTinN ON BnTATFn «AXIS i

k 9* k 97

rv r? non OFI n

pRn.iFrTinN nu V-AAVIS IN ROTATFO coRRniNATES 1 PBniFrTiow nw ;-A«f«i IN BOTATFO cnoRniNATES <

k 9R k 99

IMrBFMFNTATinN IN 7-n|RFrTinN i INITIAI i;ATIMN INr.RFKFNT FOR 1 VALUE i

k 40 k 41

DFI M r»Fi v

If.rMFHF».TATinN »Nf.l F nF INffh^NT RAV< i INITIAI IMTinN INrRFMFNT IN V t

k 4? k 49

CIFBAf1

msTA • M^VANrF «N KM »FtwF^N UMPL* PniNTS ' i ni^TANrF IN KM FRnM OBK.IN i

k 44 k 44

nv Farn FATM

fiHTAMrF INKlinMFTFR^ *~l H^TAMCF TO INTFRFACF OR SURFACE i

k 44 k 47

F Ar TUB MITH 7 IN MATM EIINCTION t » FArTnp FnR MATH FlINCTinN I

k 4H k 49

FATV FFF

FArTn« FOB V-VALUE IN MATM FUNCTinN I (.IMF OF FMFRr.INr. ANr.LFlAROVF 1,00 IF CRITICAL ANT.LEl i

k U k »I

r.r.r. BAV ^Fr.MPNT | FNr.fM J IMrBFvf-^iTATinN |N RnTATFO Y-OIRECTinN t k 9»

r.fM r.san

IMfBFMFNT Tn INTERFACE nR SURFACE < r.BAniFNT i

t »4 k 99

HHM MDFB^ 1«

trpt T

IT |MrBF>«FNT ^1 PinTTINC UAB|AK|F FHB PFRSPFCTIVF I

1 44 k 97

rnuMTtp FOB <impniiT|NF rALLS 1 rmiNT FOB «• » T | A| IXATIIIN INCREMENTS IN I J

I 9* k 99

r i;wITrM tn iNnirATF rPiTKAi RffLlCTtftN 1 i Mt

Page 85: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

r ifBvr <w|TrM j:ni» fBiTirti, BPUFfTinN« A • ' r TrvriF r in

UAVIMIIU MiiMare nr BAV iwfBPMPixTATinw?

<vrTru iiKtn IN PIOTTI»«-. cwfTrM rn iMrinnr ppFri^F i*<TFaF«rF inr.ATiui»^

A »■*

r ir,|N r IM

SwiTrn FHU BnTAfliiw i nnp rrMMTFB Fr» MliB|/nMT«| I»«!! l«| WATIIIM t^Cbtrmh^r*.

A «•• A < .

f. IM r I"»TM

\MUfh vkitit hf »bnuti\ P| vAint- «BBAV FOB |NH|r«T|»r. MATH FUMfTinM AkTF» i*r»-i» r 1 11.- <n|TrM Fnw BF-anf«tih»i iiuio «M|TrM FOB P| ««IF W«VF | M T 1 A(. I 7 Mfnfct

A t ■ A » ■

e »MI r i PI m$

A »t

r itffi <w|TrM fn INTIII^F ?*ifnMP Pihftfiur. «wfTrM Fn« HFFlFrTldM«

r. i <Fr PbiiHFn v UAIIIP TBAWFI T|MF IM INTFr.FB MIM4FB OF M|NIITFS

r T^IWF ^uiTfM rn TNniriTF F«FBr.FNrF rn ^iiBF«rF r l«l*TM «•■«V FOB IIFT«|*<|Nr. M«TM |i||Nr.T|IIM «••T»» HFt-LKnnM A tl

r. IMIW f IW

MIMHFO HP T|WF< TURmtr.M Ikkf* mOP rntmiTFB FOB |M|T|*I |/«Tiri»i« nF 7

'"I 7-

f IVM <W|Tr.M FOB BFFIFrTtnN A -1 C IViNi r iw« «wirr.M FOB BFFi FrnnN

A -? A f»

T. " IVMk r. iwM ««ITfM FOB IIF«r.M|Mr. BFF|Fri|nN ir.B|Ttr«l (W M.»-fl»IT|r»l 1

" "A' •«•. A »•.

r TUiTTF r it IMHF« FfM MlHMIFB OF ««V •FFLFCTinM A «T

r .iFfWSM Kuirru rnt HITH riiwrTfrmi HHIT nF VFRTim MIMWF« HF VFBT|r«L <«MK»- PMI»<T<S

A «>A A Hi

r ' »KIT»« r, «PO»*M

(uirr^ fna iiKihft MATM ntMr.TTnKi HM|T OF V-V«lllF<

A NO A m

r IHATU r ««TM «WtTr.N Fn* M«TM FMNTTinM

A .-> A ->

r. "n? r. «11«

MAVIWIH IfMIT WO HATU rilhfTfnN f*11 7 MftllMM» »-WAIMF Fn« MATM FlIMCTIOM

1 w A «•>

r. »uv MAVflKlH V.VIIIIf rr» M«Tu FilNCTfim M|M|M|IN | |W|T FOB MATM ri|«if Tlom |V II

—r" a* A «7

W|N|M||M / W»| HF FOB M4TM FtlMCT|nN A ^K

A u<* ■■ r Mli«TH

r. IMHII T «wiTru rivi ««TM riwrriMi — - MUMRFB OF »MllfBlF RFF|FCT|nN* «LinNFO

A inr< A im

r Nnn MiMMFB OF IWfTfAITirn «Mr.lPK I.I... MliMMFB nF | |l»|T««l|I«T|nM INtBFMFMT^

A ir»? A in»

r MOIM TnTAl NMMHFB nF |M|1t«L RAV^ A {A«. A > —

r M»t T ».nm« YW v-viiiir |isnTru!?4T!(* iwfu-Mrms — rniiNTFB Fn« Pinttinr.

A > •

A |<' f

Tf"" MM IMP r MlrtVMI

MMMMFB n» r«irnwp UNF^ «iPff«Alv'Tn Antil^ ^tB^n.«!. «VMROI Fn« PinTTtmr,

A • - A lit«

f n"^ PBn.iFrrinM n* f MIS A 111 r HN r n»ifin

AMIV Ft» nT^TiNrrc nvf MIVP TRiwriim |NfT|AI nFPTM nF BAV «HMBCF

A 11? A m

r rwiAv fhlTlAl Mfl»f>rt»i»AL frfl<lIf|A*i m Biv |M|T|At V-W»||iF

A rr*

f. MMJi nfp IM AMRLF FRIW /-A»H

A It* A 111

f. •! PinrTikiA mitfll rn* prB^preTwr •MAV Fnt f-WAIilFS

A It" A ii«

t FIT rnNstAMtt «.l*l*<» A l>0

75

Page 86: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

r -r t r r r r

Ml II

T-TTT nur Mr *au*v i-ni» ?.v«i MF«

•»^- IKITMI »«•*•• IT.".f nrnp

wti« Pv.iurin» M »Bi««»i-n » im^|i|..«. IM H(1|«TI-I> ( rinyi>|i»«TF S

• 171 TTTT

• If"

T BTTO itb^.ll»^ mitf.H r wi* MiiMVn LWAI M» !»■ aniMtn r<MiBiM*«*TP^ f Jl< w».4MT*Ti:i« V.PK^ITIII*' r itit|M I».II a««.n|«Ti- v»i tit »mi iii..aiiTAt tMr. rnn«n|M*iFs r ttm- iiMii», iic i-|v f «r« win? «rt||»i. ••»riiiii

» MI

■T ?T7 fgTTvi., tt^ f PWW wwyp rCTfRW TWTglt r «i IK »,», n» r «i i»- i.|.uTi».'. o.m T in f <l H MMMIMI*. WIIIVI VAlllf i»* 1$ r tilii «f»> fntt.!. r lucu MiMJ !»• v-v ai «fC i» Bii|»im r<>nan|«t«T»-s

T— —TTT ifSWiriTWI PWIIHI 7-mtllP ti« MMMPH * PIK i r II«IU

lit MftflMln v.vAinr 1*t»> tUAui:| i|". |H MIMiiTFt

t «»«ov ruMtniMiMf. Miat7)>*<TAi HoMTTrWTTWFC «rtiiMt •.-•. K« iiii*TTi»r.

rww«y"nvr~tn nrrjvr.

Tr*-

m

iti

k

A

A A

1 r r

t

*UM«v $fm PI i»i 'f uilTATKO VA| II« W 01 MM

»niAren f w»i ne • i»»ii lertim \*. i.iiT»T»n r.O«An|MATF Sr^Tie»»

.. •.. ,. .■ » AHHJ «nTATim« ppnm.n y-vAii.i. i». bntATfft TTWI»ffris*tFX i> t^ux^KtuTt w*i ■•» IM anTATfMr. r.imiiniMATFS ; • ». ^ •» . i • Tt » «i i.r üf» iinTATtriM |».TH*"i."t «T». v«i ■•» »nil BCtOTATUIN

A I4T T-«-i«ir

-A"1§0 A 191 I If? A iw

A 19» "» 19*>

A 197

«wit*« rnur

«aa*« n'B PI nttl'T. • auAv n-b Jl OTT|MT RflfATffl »-"»I i'f

/»|^|».r. «satKAi pp^iTinns fn« PiniTinr. PMitTi»«r

A 19«* r rwr A Ifil

/ wanit-rrt önT»TPf» » 9A«9I1 M*M »t »ar.iiwr. . rnMpiii» i>

«TTTVTTV ii iv- » Tv

tfl iUTI»>f.

wi w m '<- BAY WIMtWI 1W »f-KOTATHl C»0*"|N<iTfS Pi« | T f IB .!• P"^|T|n». FOB T»«T|xr.

n<|T|MH «Ofc TKTrWß .,i n» MATM »ii^rtini»

i wr * IM

■ * m A lf.9 A IR* A IfcT A IM A 1A«

rrnf »I Mt ^aiAatt »«a PIA«pr?.T|vr

i ITfl A 171 A ITI A 179

n,,,«*«,.,». PIMA,. i..i,,n,. riTiMoi.-A-iToiT ANTHöT. A»ü6I. tKJÜ6 A iU li, UBIT'M, l»AfHHm A 179

■ii^minr *I%,OO.IM. mft.iw.vM, wmvcvtTWfi KWfWWWCTW '* IT* • ■•ei nTT|»r. |»i(Tai<r T|oi»*a« A 177

tiiMi-Ncim- %i»f>fii. VI>«M, »OUTMI (>rt«i, vniTRTTT'iirrr'mimyTTSvn f .1 IT* in»TM>i »!•"» , «naTuii 9>v«i , viiBTH«i7nni 'A 179

• MB ••• A 1 NCI '

76

»

Page 87: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

r>»i« pii,PiTT,tro|TairbvT.|MiM>.is.iiBF,li<, iw,IM,|»«n/*,141 •>«*?'. 1 ,«'Ti»"i A IM 1fl*t...,ti,ii,ii,n.n,«i,K/

VMMH IM /.••!, ••n|i> .iii-i •'>,Mtr.|><l»»«ii| T ,<iu K.VI'IK ir.M,i., |i>riu^»<,,|i<iiii^M(

ii ■i-tiAr,uri it|i',|wo tTi-(Ki->.|tan.'ii:i ntnvr.« l'-*wi .MIM.MIIV .MiM,»<Mii,t ' i wt>ii- 7i H.iwD.M.tfPoiKH.irvri t-.tfi-i-vt-i ,in#ri ,!>»•«, «mi- .«,/,<nuiM|(v< «IMI.IM tulM;,vii|.T«7,ItllVTM)tviibTMl,Mil !• F.vr«,ll>| 4».|-, I«*,l«,|M,K»-mil-,VPI-l'«., «ritu^T.t-^rM,!-«rw^i-lirii^NWATM.Iui •■T,»!^«,»»!! «(M|^V,*>I| vtMWl'W^«MiSVIiS«

A

IM IM

A TUP

1 • u if MCIIW ir.M It. i iij*hi .m.» t r.n m i »Mil I*>.HMI I I r«f l , I,K |.|i1.lt>riu«Mt,.l>l,.lPli»<;>'l,«« 1 ,«H(-" • i Dl-^li |fc,«.M Mlwll.l.tfl.l.l (||M«<M|(.laf t.IWn*«M| »«■ItRMWSMI

A

T

1 IM tut

1 mil- •t.s'»!

TMI PI in».<« i»>,,«:r»,«»,,<.r »,*,,*,!

1 U l«.S

1 '7 r •><» <p| ilTt |MI. f» c Tbiir TIUM»'»

If | IPI HT#H>,-«| f.ll til * 1 I--

r*ii Brpr |f|l|9fl1l#Hi.TW;T;il«P;'T1 r*M PI I'l- 1 roUTHl M | tVMillul n |«S«1( r>,o. n

1 flHI - >II|

f»li MI I« t iviiPTior i i .vnniMX i i,t,,i .r.fi.n r «i i PI IM. 1 VKPTH^I « i .VMDTMII 1 l,«!,! ,n,i<, n

70? 71.«

r y ffViftMNi 7f.H

nn tu i.i.HfiH If 1 t^UITI .•.l . 1 1 WPltl. IT.SM IwUfe IP rV*Kt*i#1ltaVa*PTn t.Fr.lN,(ii:r.»»._>,,iofT • • • «1 P«Aa

«•Ml T»i» KBIT!- i»,s».| pi;r.i».tmir.l»n,Mbtr.Mt.iu|r.w

'. 9n* ?il7 ?,^

>lo 71 1

■Ml F9.MPr.fll ' ri i-'KJ.ptr.imn

. "713

if iri i.i.j.n.f,« n ?»*F>»-f.i !I*B> II- ir.M««9«nT«P|T| rt.t«*M«9«*»1T«<>.t.|MM nn 4 i»i,i'. »ii n.".

71* 71- 71*

\ 1 UV-'»

IWa^

A 7|w

771

w.i ?7>

>.! » t... ' ( ..

I*» IMI |7I..<ATM IMA tM(»ATM

i

77H >?* 777

V^ATMI-'ATM

I VATMsMATM 77«

|wiiiiar /

?»l ir.|i-*»i

•»•n t'i<*. * 7*?

Ml 1 1/HMHfC.M M.l| 17 1 -• w |i... A 7*«. 1

« Pirii/i.nuir.n rrwliwiif

A A

?1^ 7^7

lui. i ■'< ImPfl •/»♦.SlVM

A

A 7>«* .I.M.M l/l*,S'in| A 7*«

77

Page 88: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

■ tt • I |/|*.^r>nt A 74| A ?A7 A 74^

• rt«Br..F*rii/v<iiT||:*rn«i;i;rruFAfV*F*CV«FirM*r*ri4l A 74* A 74^

4 r.n Tu ». tfWfllMf

A >4». A ft!

•<M.PIT/>..IMI..I.KI • nCFI-<MIM t ,.I.Kt

1 m A 74M

h rrwKTlNiif ruH.riKiMMfti

A 7 SO A ?%J

<I|W,<|N(IIM«| A ?%> A ?M

l«P|«PI| t;|«rMM*P H t/ la^K« A 7^4 " A ys-i

«M«P.II i;t*r«M-Pt {I7I«<HII " w»i«iiP|«rnFf-p«i|7i*^aFP

1 7** A 7S7

IP««P«I | M»rat»>*i«Plata*« r;.riK»ri |MF>I

A 7SH A 7%«»

r««n«;«siNiaMniii>l A Üi

A 74| rv«na7*rn«(AMr.i r>T A 74?

A 74) vaF»'>rVarMM.rK*<IIM A 74*

A 7*.4

if iaM<iv*FM.i c..nn4i vaffa.oos A 7A* A 747

lMFT«««T«N(ttaFK/v>rP) IF IVafF.lT.n.l TMF1«ap|T*TuFt«

A 74H A 74Q

IF |iBFF.iT.n.,*i>in,vlFF-.«t.F.rt. 1 TM?T*«?.«1»lT»T»iFTÄ •ipH«i.*arn«ifaFFi

A 770 A 771

7 Riin;r.icnBT(PAru«rirH«rir.n>fir.n*FieviPievT IF M;,I F.ni r.n TO *a

A 777 A 77^

HP\ T«i«»iT*1 IMWalNlMtol A 774 IF (iMiw.r.F.irvriFt r.AU <v<<Ti?it Al PMA-FI PMIkl

A 774 A 777

luRin-INRlPy n iMFi.ri i«iF9

A 77* A 77*»

T" •••»inTTfMr. iN^TBiirTin»!«** IF iiPint.Fo,«» r.n tn a

A 7an ■ A 7«!

IF •inn.Fo.A.na.HPiT.r.T.n r.n rn « *lMPt TI-P.M I;I-IP«I l7i-1.i«ivPFas*P.iM7) 1/FFBM.F

A 7«?^ A 74^

«flBTHII 1 laP 11 t7l*^n. A 7»* A 7"5

vnanoi i i«>f ,.p«i I;I A 7M;

A 7*7 VOBTM?! t l«P| I |T|»W, in« TM1| 1 lap.ll Ifl^Ma

I 7B* A 744

VA*TM««I <.»l.-(B«n7»» MP| TaKPI Tal

1 790 A 7QI

r •

••••■••••a ••••4«***B rnNTfMlIF

A 29> A 7Q1

« n«i to«r.aaiit|«|ia(t|.PH*|l MMMaOBI triat |IM| TuCTA 1

A 794, A 7Q»

..r.(.,nai foarn<«TMna» nnnar.arnsiai PMAI

A 71*' A 207

!»• •IBFU.FO.T.OB.fWINI.fö.T» ftlT Trt 1* IF i ivii.FQ.ii r.n Tn ?*

A 79* " A 7W

IPI««P|aHMM A Iftö"

78

#

Page 89: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

VP (ill' ■« ' .

ypr.ypv*nnn in r «Mi i NMI.

*vpf-»r T ^crr.«^. .«err

ill'/ |«)iirp|ar AM.yP |»^fkM P.I I I/ (•inrp|aCM*««)rP JarHH

101 TTTT"

II

»F ifi'^rn. 11 rn in «i IF (K^IM.MF.H r.n Tn |i UM«THI -rnn<T»F»fM.JPI•T7 1-1. r.n mi? r n»'T|iiiiF V»« IM»»A( t,.'.« I

t4Cn*»PÄfT7T-T.1

• 101 I 10* « »n*> 1 Irtfr « 107 * mw A 100

« 111 « 11? * 111

rnnTiMiF «II i;»»«t ( t ; i*n|»-BAr*r./VMATHJ nw(t7).n»jrT7i»nTT»ir»i: 1$ i tPi MT.PII.II r,n in u

»«»PI itTTi^r. ini^TÄurrrfw*** I»I^«» TF nvn.Fn,i.nw,wptT.r,F.n IIPIT«WHT-I »INPi TI.P.il t7l.|PK(|{t.1.|a|VPPIS«»J(|7ll/Pf*He viwpi Ti.PT(T7wrwiTT7T=Trrrnmnr!r-i tfi. tm (np| T |.P.I| II |*^0, vneTHii»Pl T)>Pr(Tn*«n.~ «rie 1W7I»JP| TI«1I,-PK(I7I

1 Mi A IIS

A 117 T'llP A II«

TTTTT A 171

A 171

A 1?»

«nsTH^INPLT taP.II 17 I ♦SO, vn»TMirBaiTi«Ti,-.PKrm—

r.OftiTIMif IF llH«|TF.r.F.7| MPITF |7tM»

A 1?7

A 174 ■ m A 131

•••

u rwTTTTTWdTI 1 Tn w 14 miBF«l IT" fnniTiMDF

f iB.HUM*rHiiF*nnn*«PFF ;pK..HHN»<iiFF*rmn«r*FF ;pt •»»p»ri»M-r.r.r.i.««ii

AIPMA,THFTA.!C*VT,II,MATH

yp.t.vvp*<ftM»r.r.r.>rmi IF «»•«<J7P M,|.F,,OftSI /P.la.OOS AM>.| FWATAW7PI/7P.M IF I/PI.IT.H.I AMT.I F|aPtT«AMr.LFl IF «;PI,I T.A. .AMO,7P.T.nFT". 1 TNf.LTl•7.*PTT*Iwr,lFl ri iNF7*A0rn«i7Pi( i

IF IF It IF

nvn.pn.n r.n tn ?7 ( IVIIII.FO.II r.n TO 44 • i»M.Fn,n Tin TIT IIPFH .Fo.n r.n JHAIM,»II;,I i f,n

14

17

>^ rn 4

TO 14 vM«lHi«rnM^T*f:ArH«(P| i in<

-r.n wm rnNllMiir VMINlallltltll rnNTtwiF ov.|. IF

A 14| i m A 14%

A 147

i.i«FArv4|p.Min.|.i

PK M 71 I |F»»rT,FO,11

rur- A S4« 1 WB A 151 r-wir-

A 1»1 k 1W

r.Aii OINMAO IP|(I7I.P.II m.p«(in.ov.ATiwi.nMiii A 195

ICIlBFan * A «F. «;CIP T i P ! 1171 »prn 7i i»TTTTTi nrmnwTWsr nnTA.<npTMPmyi-'n>iftHi*iPHiti

lir.wi »«nfFBAf •npiAMiHP.ii mHmir.vi*iP.M m-o«

A J57 TMir

A 94« I M

79

Page 90: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

m0mmi%*m%, r^MntMtr f IM

MlMal tit/» /».M,

A Uft A *fct

i•^lH^ IN4»».» '»KT«,(.««..TM|M,\|.f,»TH;i.A«»M|. !► i !»»• i't,!..■,.»> r.o tii m A ^*./

r IIIPfllfffM »HTBiirTTWi»«« «|l»t>l t l.w M t l|.|»KM7l-<. I»IV»>FIIS»P.M l/l l/PKH^L^ A >#.M *I»IPI Ti.Mii tM*it>iiiiM-i.wiMpri)<.rrn7ii7vmiF f fu tM« i • •■! t ttP II 17 l*^n.

A ^'0 A »71

VOPTMI|MP| Tl.Pt(If»»^n, IH« |M»I • t'l t 1 «1 .-P« 1 | / t

A »7? A *1\

VfMlTM^IMPI TtaPtlt;!*^. «<>u tw^i».» i tt«p,ii i;i»sn.

*

| 1T4 • '»7'.

vnu iM«ik.i>i Ti«*l.-PKtin A -liy

fAM PI l»•^ mtttVM I.M>lT,1.n,n,)l r«i| P^VMM I»I».PI ti ,VI»-PI Tt,.t,Mi^v»«?,r.l1»>m,-1,n

A ■47« A »7«

f»ll P^v-l« llin>TMl|MPtTI,Vn«TMHM<>lTl..t,miSVW?.CLlNFW,-\.1l A ^Alt A ^«1

run PI I^P ««n»TM»7»r,vn»Tu>iir,ii»LT,i,o,n,n r»ii PI t »it. iinptM«!« t.vnuTM^n i.MPtT.l.n.n.n

A "*•? A »"1

r •PI TaO

•■• ••• • A ta« A »P*

1» r.n TO >> - t

A '«flf> A »«7

N if iPiii7».r.T,.n.*»in,P.ij!7».r.T.,*.ANn.PjiiM.iT..iPij«H-.s,*»in,Pi IM.I T,ipr»^M..%.»Nn,Pmii».i.T,iu»n»*M-,»t pn TO >^

(T A j**"' A »AQ

>n »i- MPinT.fo.M ftA Th >| TAM PI IMP i «MI.VII i,MPiT,t .n.n.it A Wl

rmi PI |MF KOPTH«!« i,vn«iM>M i*MPLT.i«n.fl.n 1 ^9? A »0»

»iP| t.rt • A V»».

>1 77

rnMTttaii^ IF 117,FH.» i f.n TO 4« A »Q7

AMTM;.1I«| I-ANTIHI |«ftNT|17.n AlOH A »Q«

i»-t;-i »«•r.i F>«f t ii i;i A 401 ri l»iF>.fif,if T7» " MktM.tMATHI|7I •

A 407 A 40»

IF |WATM,FO,t| |VVa« , • ft ATU A 40*.

tf IM»TM.»:H,A| (WKV.I r.n TO «.

A ifl*. A 407

~f% I»p|JI7I»,S itP.il 1 * l».S

A 4h» A 404

7*

I4M| I7»».S TWwTtMUF

• A 411 « 1 |w*«k> t •»<►•« t' i <; - »;• i*r.r.r. •

A 41? A 4M

r iTt:i««PK*nnn A 414

A 41* ifTfKftyMnpfirmMV " ■ t ir««.« tti**«uFF*«T|0«r«FF

• 1 M' A 41 1

' i •«T i • f t «• •' H«-> T1 <«fKM t|«»««Tt«*«W*ttt<MIM

•• C 41« A 41««

|».TfM»,^ «

A" i>0

Page 91: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

n=TT<;*.«i

nw«^ij>o«T( i ,.t,t<i /»on. TP" TFv,i.t,.fM i iws.s

? F (41 PHA , (;F.P! ft) <L t hi | 0*1 , . C| IMx (M

«I \<.*1<

T»T?VsTl<*r.HM-«;nM«"<;RM RIMsRH )M«r.RFF-^l |n«SRFF RfHs^l (n*rRFF*PRI»«»SHFF nv>ain-xPK tp nmi.Pft.it r.tt Tn ?6 TF^T TO SFF IF BAY FNO tS IN SAMPl.Fn HHr-Idh. ^HT SWlTf.MFS

^pnwn rn TUP RFrinw.—n^RFrr^wY.-PTrnwpTiTP ROTaTinN OF rnn»n|N4TFs ANH BF^tii.TiMr, niHFr.TinMs... TP (iM.r.p.Hi<)f7XwnnM.iT.MK.y.Awn. is.r,p.Mj«;vTAiMTT7T^Ti.p.M)i-y.

I .r,F.MlS7,ANn.Tn.l F.M1I.7 ) Ml TO ?6 —nnrrnnm

IW)fX"0

A Mil, ID

TP jHiTH.po.i.Awn.jM.ftP.^i r,n Tn ?q WATHsl

"TWATMMZt-l. IF «IVX.FO.?» KMATHBI

LMATH-I IF «fwx.Fo.i» r,n in ?«» TW1-1 r,n tn is

TTffrrpmP IMisn

A i4n A 441

A 44? "Ä'444"

A 44S

A 447 "A -44fl"

A 44<J

"STTo" A 4SI

TT

rviipi rMMarn^mMAi

~<RM«HTvri»wn— rAFFBrn<;(Rnp<:F)

A 4?? A 4'i?(

^r 4^4" A 4^^

A 4S7 r,n rn ?B 7^ nwrmnF

IVXX>|WXX4l rr nvxy.po.jM I.M4TH.O KM«TH>n

TvnriTv ■ IF «MATH.FO.O) r,n TD >Q H4TH-A ■■■ ■" ' " " iMftTHii;)«n

A 4 A4 4 4(KS

■" IWIt.l r.n in is

A 466 A 467

>? rnNTiNiiF om,iK,p|T-m I.J.K)

A 468 A 46W

f.BM.rnmPRi.i«» ^RMa^INIPAI.IK)

4 4 70 A 471

rppp«rn<iArwT,..t.tm SRFF«^|N»«l>« |«,t«RM

A 47? A 47^

7« f.ONTfMiP XXPI.PK iz)«r,«M4.p.Mm«s»»M

A 474 A 47'?

x».i.».in7)*rhM.pinM*^AM XPlBXXP|«r.HFF-PK(IZ)*SRFF

A 4V6 A 477

XPK«PK(|7)«rBFF*XXPI«SRFF rrmrnsin INF»)

A 47H A 471

n»«7«A«»^isiN(r.i.iMF?) i A 4»0

81

Page 92: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

.

v K = r v*r nM + r Y):I;IIM

v u f-' F = r v ^ r n M- r y ^'^ H M ^

FT^Fär 7 » r H F H + x y «<; «TF

A 4R1 A ar*? A *R^ A ARA A 4R5 A 4R(S A 4«7

THPTAaATANfXRFP/VRPF) IF IVBPP.l.T.f .1 THFT/S = PTT*TMPTft IF { XUFF.I T.O. .ÄMn.VRF^.nP.O. » THFTA«?.«PIT*THETA A| PHA1 «ÄHr.n^l 7BFF ) Al PHA = AI PHA1 ~ ' "~ i F ( I VII.FO. 1 I fill Tfl P

T

A ARfl A 4flq A 490 A 4P1 A 4<3? A &P3

TO rOMTTMII I \/M = n IF (MAIM.WF.iT"rrrrT?r~TA WMATHP= r.n tu ^

■^n r DM Tiwii

A 4^4 A 4q>S

rnNST-t-FArM<'TiM->-Fflr.\/«'Tis-t-PAr.n*Tin r ' F

A 497 A 49« A 499 A «ifto A 501

A 503

^1 : A (i M , i <;, i n) IF

r

V'MA TH5 = rOMTIMII

~Tr nn.iT.n r,n rn u IP (TM.

TTlB^N) fi IF (IWB w6 f TP

i;T.iPnR^M.nK.i«itr.T..ipnRSH.nR. iM.LT.i.nn.is.LT.l.DR.lD.CT.KP TV TTT ?r> ITF.FO.O) r,n TO 3? 7,Mt iM(mtp?(m.pt<(m.vMATMi

IP ( ftH<;tvwftTH?-WMäTH1 J,flT,,fiW| J TO TR !1 M/FI =i

Al PMA7 = A| PHA I nTTP T nn ^H

TP ARFFrVMATHl*

mmr

TH.FO.

BMIMF' in

PMPRftlNft WPLOCITV ANH ANftLF****

TT^nTTTTRTrHrFTTTWTnTTri^TTTnre (VMATH7-WMATH1 )*ABS(f.nS( ALPHAl) )

Rfl TH ^A ^S mMTtMIIF

AnpFrWMÄTH) +r,RAn>!<cn<; ( AI.PHAI ) ■^A rnMTlMiiF

rAl I ^.jNhFT (AL(*MA IF (Al PHA1 .M.PIT,

"A 504 A 505 A 50^ A 507

"X"50Tr" A 509

I \/W = (l r.n TU 7

A 51rt A 511

>^ IVFI =" IF ( I\»W,MF. i i r.n Til '4

A 512 A 513

I v/u=n r,n Tn 7

A 51A A 515

14 rnMTiMMF AFF I=\/MATH1

A MA A 517

(•,RAn=r,*<(,»tjTiFArMx<FÄrw+PÄcn>!<FÄP,n+rir.v*FiCVj A 51« A 519 A 52Ö A 521 A 522 A 523 A S2A A 525 A 52^ A 527

,ALPHAT,AFFI,aRFF,RFPALFfir,RYT,PPF) AMn. Al. PHA1 .LT.2.*PIT) THETAmTHET A + P I T

T7PTTI ALPM&1=?.*P!T-AI.|JHA1 F.i) WRITF (7,S4) AFFI.ARFE.ALPHAl.THtTA

A fP A 529 A hW A 531

■M

IF (Al IF ( I W

I^F ( I I

IF ("AB r OM TI M

PMAi.r, RITF.R PTfTTTT I.F0.1 S ( 7TP^ IIP

4.R*r,ns I r.n T

r-7Tn

(ALPHAIT n 17

rmv^'i i nn rn-^'

A 5^2 A 533 A 51A A 535 A ffi A 537 A S3R A 539

T-^ATT

lo r »9

m = 7T r nw TIM FN1rT_ nF rnMTlN .IM A TH =

rrr UP

up MATH

sm vPi.nr,ITV nPTFRMiNATinKi'Lonp****

82

Page 93: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

TTT

Al PHA = AI PHA1 TF (Aft^n/MATMI-ftR^Pt.rP.VFinTF. AMn.T7.I.F.MMIIl.T.ftlvlir.TVM.I T.T'l no TH

TP' riTRVT.To,IT r,n tn 4's 1 VMsO

r,n in 7 TAMTlMlF TF ( 1WR|TP,0F,A) WRTTF (7,S7) XP I , XP.I, XPK , MATH , KM ATH . I.MATH

"IP »!pyAr:T,Pö,n mi L■T:INWAR■ IXPI,yP,I,VPK,nw,ATI ITTTf^rrnmnryr; 1 AFFl,A|.PHft7,THFTA,AniF )

TP (1 PLOT,iiv, fly Trmrmr

Al rn Tn ift rnMiiMiiF ______ IGIMsO

««»PI nTTTNr, iN<;THiir.TinN**>K X^IPI T) = f.i(I7)-(PKnn-1. rfWPTT^5TriTT7TT7PT»Tr?r^ Y(NPLT)=Pn T7) + (PK( T7. )-1. )«(HPFRS-PT ( 17) )/PP»«iLF

S4 /

C, H ^

SSV

^'t, A

SS4

xn6TMWMPm=p.inn+,w. VnPTHl(MPLT)=PI(17)+SO.

A ^A(i A Sftl

A SiS^

A SAS

XnBTH?(MPLTl=^1.-PK(in vnHTH9(NPLT)=P!(17)+SO.

TnRTHi(TiPLT)«P,i(l7)+sn, YnRTH^(MPLT)«3<.-PK(IZ)

ran PI TMP (xm.vn),"Mni.itK».n,ii rAM PI IMP (XnRTHId , .YORTHWl )tMPLT,ltO»0. 1 )

rail PI. IMP (ynflTH^( i) «vnRTH^d i, NPLTtito,n.i)

r TTT mMTIMIIf

IF (IWRITF.RF.M WR1TF (7fS^) RIN.THFTA, ALPHA?, XP I , XP.), XPK "AT TF (ir.BVT+IVW.RF,?) p,n TH 7

IF (ir.RYT.Fo.i) r,n Tn AS

rwiT

T I'M A HAY

-A"^AR" A 5M

A ^71 A ^17 A =17^

"TS'^T«— A S7S

T7aT7+1 A ^77 rwTfTunwnü-i i AT( 17)=AT(H-1 )

• A - ^ R A «!7^

PT(iz)»pi(iz-n P.K 1Z)=P.I(IZ-1 )

" A' sflO A «i«!

Pf(TZ) = Pt< (17-11 ANT(I7)»AMT( 17-1 ) «( WMATHP-VMATH1 ) / (\/MATH?+WM ATHl )

A SR? A 'ifl3

TVIHIrl r,n in Q rnMTiNiiF i\niii=n

A 'iHA A 'i«5

"S5~ A SB7

r.T.u 17- PK.H 17-

1 ) 1 )

= ÄNr,| F1 =r.LlNF'

TMATN(!7-n=MATH A1! IF ( t7,LF,NMIILT) GO TD Uh

"A ^«R A "SSM

A «»«n A SQl A «iP? A SQB

r,n in ?? rnMTTNUF A(S

no "TT

TTf,Rvt.Prt.t.ilR.aRS(ABFP-ÄPFit ).r,P.vPi.blF) A7 1=1,? (Al PMA1.LT.M

A| PHA1 = P!T-AI.PHA? A TSR! A SPS

AI.PHA1 s-ALPWA] IF (ALPHAl.RT.PIT) ALPHA! «?,*P 1T-AI.PHA1 ALPHABALPHAI

A7 rnMTIMHF rwATRTTJmrM'nr

A 5QA A HO? X^ o S

A «SQQ T "KM"

83

Page 94: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

It- ( MMM.Ml. 1 . Af'M.K'.IATH.Rl.n \ MATHr'l TV" t p-' A TM [T? i'. cn.n. AMH#| MATM. Pft. H MATMsV" |MATH(t7)«MATH Tf ( AK'v ( A^M - 'int >■ ) .c.F. vn hTPT T^Wsf" IF (MATH,Pü,^! r,n Til 7 I BTPI -1 r.n Tn li

A ^.01 A An? A (SOI

TTKM" A ftOS

TTvrnrrnr r A| | rdwuFc

r Ai i niMnpP r AM r nMVPH r A 11 rnMwnw r IUI T i MI IF

A AftA A AOQ

A All A M?-

A AM

/.u

^<4

( ni-r,iM,iim M.Mfm, T« ) ( uFniMii.npi n,>l(Tii,"TwriT ( DB i r,\/, nF| \/ ,Mfn/, iw ) ((TS ?r,M,iiH HiMHH, TMI

r M i «*-.!P| iiTTlMr; IMSTRIir.TinN*** PI TFMfi

r

^1

TTTTpr A hXS

TTATS' A M7

FOUi'lA T ( 1 OH'. . 7 I FPU MA 1 ( • •,HP«,?)

-TTTOTTäT"! 'rit<TAMi'PKl| nMFTFRSTTJMTKHTTISFO'.'TnTALISFnAHPLITIinFM PHBoiA 1 ( "> I M I T I A| A MCI PjJ^1 JT 1 ALII I ST ANCF . 1N1 T I ALOEPTH • ) HnuWAT I'','.FM,PI ■ "- "' ' —~ . pnawAT ( 'ndMiiiTrnMAi mMTpniiTSASPriLLnws! i /' Ti«iaiTF=i!PT,p.i,PK«vi>iATH

11 • /" I w w I T f- s ? : A n 11: A L P H Ä rf H FTTrn^W.TTTMÄTHTy' 1W R I T b » 3: A no: AP^ItARF 7P.AI PMAl.rHHTAi/tIUP|TP=4!AnnTWni. IMPS:'/'l.XPt.XPJ.XPK»,»MATH,KMAT

AMP A *zn A (S2)

TTHtT A *?■!*

A h?S TM-I MATMI rtAMr>?.r,TM.TMPTA,A|.PMA?tXPT.XPJ'/'IWPTTF«'.I?) ^h FfiüMA T M » ,ftF1l1,9) ^7 t-'npMAT ( ' ' ,'<F1".',^T5T ^H FOHMAT ('',71-^.7,^17)

FMII " ' «SimnnilTIMF RI MM An ( PI ,P.l,PK ,nv,4T,nMtr),A,CLIMP?.AlMGLPltAniF)

A A?A A h?.l

A (S?Q A A^« B 1

tP ( A«<(7TT^^i>-!.,?7\,| T.AniF» RFTIIBN ri ir.ns»r.ns(r.i INF7) rr"nnrrrn INFJ-PTü?),LT.,nr» TtiP.iWTff!— r.tM=nv/ri KIT;

Tiöi Tn"= f;IKl«stNir.LINP?) ' PI ^PI+OHI IO*?IN( AMr,i PI \

1—r ■* B-

B S

p,i = p,i + nm fTOtTHTI ANn pi ) PK = PK+r.iMornsir.i. IMP? ) TT TJ; i T~"i VT "Ä~="Si A T=: AT+O'.r.IM/A

TTOiTTKR H'öT? IN WP Tl IBM

R 7 -R—fT

H

H "IT

B

u

TTTrT ft4A L1NPS PRINTEII

84

Page 95: K DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS · the Eastern Section of the Seismological Society of America in Blacks- burg, Virginia (Jackson, 1969). A Journal article describing the application

I UNCLASSIFIED Sm-uritv CtttNHilu'atiun

DOCUMENT CONTROL DAI A -RAD i.Sfiurilv i litstifit atiun uf lillr hinli uf al>\ttmt iim/ intlrkiiu; unnuliilinn must hv t-nli-fi-J uhin tht uirttill trptttt i» • IM\\*I%< *h

I ORIGINATING AC1IVITY l( nr/mru/i' aulluit I

Willow Run Laboratories of Hit« Institute of Science and Technoloior, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. Michigan

2U HLI'OHI SICUKlT. Cl »'.Sil II »TlON

UNCLASSIFIKI) 2A. CROUP

3 REPORT TITLE

DIGITAL SIMULATION OF SEISMIC RAYS

4 DESCRIPTIVE NOTES llypr nf rrpotl anj inr/uoVr Jultst

Scientific Final. Part 2 S AUTHORISI llitsl numr. miilJIr inilial, luil name t

P. L. Jackson

6 REPORT DATE

August 1970 7a. TOTAL NO OF PAGES

Xii ♦ 85 7* NO or Rcrs

23

BO.CONTRACT OR GRANT NO.

AF i9(638)-n59 6. PROJECT NO

8652 c.

62701D

9a.ORIGINATOR S REPORT NUMtUHlSI

8071-33-F

• t OTHER REPORT NOISI (Any ..»*re numlttt Ihul mmthramtrnJ Ihn trpotl I

AFOSR-70-2391TR 10 DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT

1. This document has been approved for public release and sale; Its distribution Is unlimited.

1. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

TECH, OTHER

12 SPONSORING MILITARY ACTIVITY

AF Office of Scientific Research (SRPG) 1400 Wilson Boulevard Arlington. VA 22209

13 ABSTRACT

Simulation of seismic rays for a spherical earth and a flat earth has been achieved in hiuhly complex models. Travel times and approximate amplitudes of seismic waves can be found for both two- and three- dimensional models of portions of the earth. In seismology and other disciplines ray construction customarilv has been applied to simplified geometries. It has been necessary to assume that the seismic wave velocity distribution of the earth was relatively uniform and symmetric.

Recently, however, the earth has been found to be more complex and non-uniform than formerly assumed. A need has thus arisen in seismology to test highly heterogeneous models of seismic velocity distribution. At the same time the development of the modern digital computer has provided a means of performing the necessary ray constructions and numerical calculations.

The problem of complicated seismic velocity distributions was therefore investigated in terms of the most appropriate use of the digital computer. For this investigation a velocity field was set up, and the pmpauation computations made for short segments of rays within this field. Total travel times are found by adding the travel times ui connecieu ray begmeuib. Eba^niiany, lite nature of propagation was duplicated an the com- puter. In that, at the location of each segment along the path of propagation, the initial condition and effect of the surroundings determine the succeeding direction of the following segment.

Doth visual and numerical results have shown that this simulation method can be usefully applied to in- vestigation of seismic velocity distributions of portions of the earth of any size or complexity.

14 KEY WORDS

Seismology Digital Simulation

Seismic Rays Seismic Travel Times

Seismic Velocity DistributIons

DD A1473 UNCLASSIFIKI) Security Classification