journal club slides for grizzly bears exhibit augmented insulin sensitivity while obese prior to a...

25

Upload: dave-bridges

Post on 22-May-2015

477 views

Category:

Science


2 download

DESCRIPTION

Journal Club Slides for the article ""Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation"." available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2014.07.008

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation
Page 2: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Body Weight and Insulin Sensitivity

• Negative Correlation • Insulin resistance

may have evolved to prevent excessive weight gain

BMI by County Type II Diabetes by County

Abbasi et al, J. Am. Col. Card. 2002 CDC, 2012

Chang et alDiabetes Care, 1994

Page 3: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

How Does Insulin Resistance Lead to Type II Diabetes

Food

CirculatingNutrients (Glucose)

InsulinSecretion

Glucose Production

Glucose Disposal

Nutrient Storage

Insulin Resistance

Page 4: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Not All Obese People Get Insulin Resistance or Type II Diabetes

• About a third of obese people are not insulin resistant or hyperlipidemic. They are known as Metabolically Healthy Obese people

• What mechanism underlies this is unclear

Page 5: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Weight Fluctuations in Bears

Page 6: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

The Question at Hand

• Bears seem to be able to cycle between fat accumulation and release on regular intervals

• What are the effects on insulin sensitivity that are associated with these massive fluctuations in weights?

Page 7: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

“Patient” Characteristics

May

OctoberJanuary

Page 8: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Insulin and Glucose Levels are Unchanged in “Obese” Bears

Normally with elevated fat mass you would expect a big increase in insulin resistance

These are therefore a model of massive weight gain without increased diabetes

May

OctoberJanuary

Page 9: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Changes in Insulin Sensitivity

More obese in October, but far more insulin sensitive.

May

OctoberJanuary

Page 10: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Key Questions

1. Why are lean(-ish) mid-hibernating bears insulin resistant

2. Why are obese pre-hibernating bears insulin sensitive

Page 11: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Are These Changes Due to Inflammation?

May

OctoberJanuary

Page 12: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Relationship Between Lipolysis and Insulin Sensitivity

AdiposeTriglycerides

Serum FFA

Lipolysis InsulinResistance

MitochondrialStress

Insulin

Basic Monoamines

Rate Limiting Steps in Lipolysis are HSL and CGI-58 Phosphorylation

Page 13: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Increased Lipolysis in Hibernating Bears

May

OctoberJanuary

Page 14: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

WHY ARE OBESE, PRE-HIBERNATING BEARS INSULIN SENSITIVE?

Page 15: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Functionally

• Need to store a lot of weight without side effects of hyperglycemia

• Some signal must occur to mediate this transition

• But what is the mechanism underlying this?• What tissue is the originator of this effect?

Page 16: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

PI3K Dependent Insulin Signaling

Page 17: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

PTEN Phosphorylation

PTEN

PhosphorylationOn Serine 308

InsulinSensitizationDue to ElevatedPIP3/Akt Signaling

Page 18: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Measuring Protein Phosphorylation

Measured both total protein and phosphorylated protein, the ratio is presented here

Page 19: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

PI3K Signaling Enhanced Adipose Gastroc

Liver

May

OctoberJanuary

Page 20: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Insulin Responsiveness in WAT

May

OctoberJanuary

HibernatingBear WAT ModestEffects of Insulin

Non-hibernatingBear WAT DramaticEffects of Insulin

Page 21: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Cause or Effect?

Page 22: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Insulin Promotes Weight Gain

• You need insulin to promote lipid accumulation into fat tissue.

• Possibly PTEN mediated insulin sensitization of fat tissue is causing the weight gain but does not cause sensitization of other tissues.

• Where is the knockout grizzly????

Page 23: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Adipose PTEN as a Regulator of Insulin Sensitivity

Page 24: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Confounders and Questions?

• Big changes in energy usage rate in hibernating bears?

• Is it PTEN or PTEN phosphorylation that’s changing. What is the signal?

• What stimulates the lipid breakdown in the hibernating bears?

Page 25: Journal club slides for Grizzly Bears Exhibit Augmented Insulin Sensitivity while Obese Prior to a Reversible Insulin Resistance during Hibernation

Conclusion