john m. boone, ph.d. faapm, fsbi, facr professor and vice
TRANSCRIPT
John M. Boone, Ph.D. FAAPM, FSBI, FACRProfessor and Vice Chair (Research) of RadiologyProfessor of Biomedical EngineeringUniversity of California, DavisSacramento, California
Former Relevant Roles :Deputy Deputy Editor, (6 years)Associate Editor, (16 years)Associate Editor, RadiologyChair, Journal Business Management CommieeMember, Editor Search Commiee (1998 and 2012)Member, Publisher Assessment Team (1995)Reviewed over 150 Manuscripts in last decade
8/1/2013
2
Nitty‐Gritty of Review (4)Nitty‐Gritty of Review (4)
Efficiency (1): getting the job done
• Recommend voice recognition software (DNS)
• Print out or tablet read
• First red – pen document (specific comments)
• Second Read (if necessary) – brush up on the big picture for your overall assessment
How to be a journal referee (JMB) How to be a journal referee (JMB) Aug 5, 2013 IndianapolisAug 5, 2013 Indianapolis
© John M. Boone © John M. Boone
Nitty‐Gritty of Review (5)Nitty‐Gritty of Review (5)
Efficiency (2): Keeping track of your reviews
REVIEWS
GRANTS
MANUSCRIPTS
AJRMedical_Physics
PMBRadiology
2011_08_11_CT‐Dose.docx2011_12_08_MTF‐eval.docx2012_04_15_TaxDay.docx2013_08_06_Referee.docx
How to be a journal referee (JMB) How to be a journal referee (JMB) Aug 5, 2013 IndianapolisAug 5, 2013 Indianapolis
© John M. Boone © John M. Boone
Final CommentsFinal Comments• The reviewer is not a collaborator on the team
• Do not redesign the experiments and suggest that they all be redone. This is the authors’ science, not yours, and your job is to evaluate their science, and not make it your own.
• Recognize the work that addressing your comments would require. If you are suggesting changes of some sort, put yourself in the shoes of the authors. The criteria for experimental methods is acceptability, not perfection
• Rather than requiring more months of experiments, reject the manuscript with good explanation
How to be a journal referee (JMB) How to be a journal referee (JMB) Aug 5, 2013 IndianapolisAug 5, 2013 Indianapolis
© John M. Boone © John M. Boone
Final CommentsFinal Comments• The reviewer is not a collaborator on the team
• Do not redesign the experiments and suggest that they all be redone. This is the authors’ science, not yours, and your job is to evaluate their science, and not make it your own.
• Recognize the work that addressing your comments would require. If you are suggesting changes of some sort, put yourself in the shoes of the authors. The criteria for experimental methods is acceptability, not perfection
• Rather than requiring more months of experiments, reject the manuscript with good explanation
How to be a journal referee (JMB) How to be a journal referee (JMB) Aug 5, 2013 IndianapolisAug 5, 2013 Indianapolis
© John M. Boone © John M. Boone
Final CommentsFinal Comments• The reviewer is not a collaborator on the team
• Do not redesign the experiments and suggest that they all be redone. This is the authors’ science, not yours, and your job is to evaluate their science, and not make it your own.
• Recognize the work that addressing your comments would require. If you are suggesting changes of some sort, put yourself in the shoes of the authors. The criteria for experimental methods is acceptability, not perfection
• Rather than requiring more months of experiments, reject the manuscript with good explanation
How to be a journal referee (JMB) How to be a journal referee (JMB) Aug 5, 2013 IndianapolisAug 5, 2013 Indianapolis
© John M. Boone © John M. Boone
Final CommentsFinal Comments• The reviewer is not a collaborator on the team
• Do not redesign the experiments and suggest that they all be redone. This is the authors’ science, not yours, and your job is to evaluate their science, and not make it your own.
• Recognize the work that addressing your comments would require. If you are suggesting changes of some sort, put yourself in the shoes of the authors. The criteria for experimental methods is acceptability, not perfection
• Rather than requiring more months of experiments, reject the manuscript with good explanation
How to be a journal referee (JMB) How to be a journal referee (JMB) Aug 5, 2013 IndianapolisAug 5, 2013 Indianapolis
© John M. Boone © John M. Boone
8/1/2013
3
How to be a journal referee (JMB) How to be a journal referee (JMB) Aug 5, 2013 IndianapolisAug 5, 2013 Indianapolis
El FinEl Fin