james goulka - scottsdale economic developmentscottsdale/documents/... · day 1: bank make you a...

54
James Goulka Managing Director Arizona Tech Investors 1

Upload: others

Post on 04-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • James Goulka

    Managing Director Arizona Tech Investors

    1

  • You Profits OPM

    2

  • Savings Sweat Equity

    3

  • Reward for doing what you do Use it to: Reinvest in the business to grow it Buy a Lamborghini

    4

  • You get cash You incur obligations

    5

  • Grants Debt Equity

    6

  • + Keep 100% control of business + Keep 100% ownership of business + No repayments; no recurring costs - Specific qualifications - Paperwork to apply - Paperwork to report after grant

    7

  • Local: Flinn Foundation ($25,000) State: Innovation Challenge ($250,000) Federal: SBIR ($2,000,000)

    8

  • Credit Cards Personal Loans Bank Loans Leasing Alternative Debt Structures

    9

  • Personal Obligation Affects Your Personal Credit Score Crazy Interest Rates Bad for Your Family 10

  • Better Rates than Credit Card Debt You are on the Hook, Not Your Business Your Family is at Risk Schedule of Repayment of Principal + Interest

    11

  • Character: Personal; credit history Capacity: Probability that the bank will be repaid from company cash flow Capital: How much have you contributed to equity in the company to cushion any losses Collateral: Assets that can be sold to satisfy the bank debt Conditions: Purpose of the loan. Are you an attractive customer (other business, high interest rate, big shot) 12

  • You want to borrow $100,000 @5% interest Day 1: Bank make you a loan + 19 others of $100,000 each Day 365: 1 loan goes bad = $100,000 loss 19 borrowers pay $5000 interest = $95,000 = Portfolio Lost Money

    13

  • Banks are Not in the Business of Taking Risk IF you qualify for a loan: Required repayments; No Permanence Covenants Priority Use of Your Cash, Not Business Low Cost of Capital

    14

  • Alternative Funding Source Focused on Capital Equipment Sources: Leasing Companies + Bank Leasing Departments + Equipment Providers’ Leasing

    15

  • Benefits: 100% financing of equipment Various tax advantages No disposal problem Obligations: Still a loan of capital Covenants You Don’t Own the Assets Higher cost of funding (pre-tax)

    16

  • Privately arranged transactions Uniquely customized to the needs of the borrower and lender

    17

  • Legitimate Banks Commercial Finance Companies Private Individuals Sourced Through Intermediaries Not So Legit

    18

  • Same as Any Other Debt: Required repayments; No Permanence Priority Use of Your Cash, Not Business Covenants Plus: Lien on Assets More Expensive than Simple Debt Equity Give Up (Smaller) Personal Guaranties?

    19

  • The Profound Shift: You No Longer Make All of the Decisions Get Cash Give Up a portion of the ownership of the company 20

  • Give Up a portion of the ownership of the company Investors Have Powers: Expect to Be Partners

    21

  • Context: SEC Rules Securities issued to the public Securities issued to private investors

    22

  • Angels: $ Their own money

    VCs: $$ Other people’s money

    23

  • 24

    Sheet1

    Friends & Family1100

    Angels502000

    Venture Capital10010000

    Debt etc500020000

    Friends & Family1100Angels502000Venture Capital10010000Debt etc500020000

    Sheet2

    Friends & Family100

    Angels2000

    Venture Capital100,000

    Debt & Otherunlimited

  • Net worth of $1 million or more

    Or

    Income for each of last 3 years › $200,000 pa if single › $300,000 pa if married

    25

  • No liquidity Unproven management Unproven technology Unproven markets Unknown competitors lurking in the

    bushes No predictability

    26

  • Able to assess and absorb the risk Invests own money Invests brainpower

    › Due diligence on investment › Board or Advisor › Know-how

    Invests time Opens contact database

    27

  • All over Some in press (individuals and groups) Some are known only to domain

    experts (eg franchising) Established Angel Groups ™ Harder for Some Domains Than Others

    28

  • Can make smaller investments ($25,000)

    Leverage from multiple brains Leverage from single center Shared due diligence Aggregated capital = better terms Multiple ways to invest Multiple ways to participate Fun

    29

  • Pension Funds

    Endowments

    Wealthy Individuals

    Family Offices

    30

  • Entrepreneurs are not the VC’s

    customers: the investors are

    Entrepreneurs are means to an end

    Compete for limited partners based on performance

    31

  • Limited: 7 years (longer for pharma)

    Exits are means to evaluation

    Since the capital belongs to the Limited Partners, returns are distributed to them and not reinvested

    32

  • Angels $250,000 to $2 million

    VCs $2 million to $100 million

    33

  • Medium Size $500 million

    Investment partners: 5 people

    Partner Portfolio: 10 companies

    Avg deal size $10 million

    34

  • Angels Own money IRR Driven Modest amounts Easy reinvestment Minimal costs VCs Limiteds’ money Multiple Large investments Driven No reinvestment High costs to limiteds

    35

  • Valuation

    36

  • 2 equal sized investments Target Return for portfolio: 25% p.a. At the end of year 1:

    › 1 fails: complete loss › Need 50% p.a. on the other one

    Critical Problem: Don’t know which is which

    Therefore expect 50% p.a. on all

    37

  • Assumptions:

    -10 investments -$10 million each -All on same day -All are exited on same day in 5 years

    38

  • 1 returns 10x = $100 million 8 return 1.1x = $ 88 million 1 complete loss = $(10) million Total Cash Return = $178 million IRR = 16%

    39

  • Deal Terms

    Due diligence

    Taking care of the team: Option Pool

    Governance 40

  • Terms matter God or the devil is in the details Investors expect management to

    negotiate as hard as they do—Almost You’re not the only fish in the sea Experienced lawyer is essential

    41

  • Rule #1: Do not run out of money

    Rule #2: People don’t throw around millions: it takes time to do a deal. Assume: 3 months for angels 9 months for VC

    42

  • 98 Arizona individual investors Entrepreneurs, Technology Executives,

    Accountants, Lawyers, Investment Bankers, Consultants

    54 companies $15 million invested Direct and through ATIF Sidecar Funds

    Partner with Desert Angels & Others

    43

  • Software & SaaS Semiconductors & Sensors New Materials Medical devices Diagnostics Capital efficient green tech

    44

  • Where › Arizona (44 of 54) › Southwest (CA, CO, UT, TX)

    Size: $250,000 - $1,500,000

    Stage

    › Prototype or Alpha customer › Revenue not required (but nice) 45

  • 300 Inquiries

    150 Applications

    30 Semifinalists

    15 Presenters

    4-10 Investments 46

  • JOBS Act: Enable more people to invest in early stage companies.

    Intention: Great Execution: Devil in the Details

    47

  • Indiegogo Kickstarter Rewards & gift based fund raising platforms Not purchase of securities Not regulated by SEC

    48

  • For issuance of securities Regulated by SEC Issuers & Platform report to SEC Investors report to Platforms

    49

  • Rules for Issuer:

  • Rules for Investor: If income or greater of NW $100K 10% of either max of $100K

    51

  • Rules for Platform: A new form of securities dealer Registered with SEC Defined anti-fraud provisions

    52

  • Must provide investors with Education Information about issuers Ongoing communications channel Must not provide investors with Investment advice Solicitations for purchases or sales Holding cash and securities

    53

  • 54

    Funding Your Business3 Sources of FundingFunding by YouFunding by ProfitsFunding by OPM3 Kinds of OPMGrants: Lightest ObligationsGrants: ExamplesDebt: Fixed ObligationsDebt: Credit CardsDebt: Personal DebtDebt: Bank Loan – Can You Get One? – 5 Cs of CreditDebt: Bank EconomicsBank Debt: Your ObligationsDebt: LeasingLeasing: Your ObligationsDebt: Alternative DebtAlternative Debt SourcesAlternative Debt: �Your ObligationsOPM: Equity: Investors Owning a Share of Your Company�Equity: Your Obligations�Equity: Selling Stock�Early Stage InvestorsWhere Angels PlayAngel Investor: SEC DefinitionWhy This Definition?Angel Investor:�Operative DefinitionAngel Investors: �Where Do You Find Them�Why Angel GroupsVC Fund Investors: The LPsVenture Capital BusinessLife of Venture FundsDeal ScaleFund Scale�Return ParametersWhat Matters Most �to Angels & VCsInvestor ArithmeticPartner Portfolio EconomicsPortfolio ResultsWhat Matters 2nd Most: Derisking the DealDerisk by Deal TermsDerisk by Lead TimeATI Who We AreATI Domains We LikeATI FocusATI Deal Funnel ~ OthersCrowdsourcing: �New Sources of CapitalCrowdsourcing: Source #1: Non-Securities PlatformsCrowdsourcing: Source #2: Securities PlatformsCrowdsourcing: Source #2: Securities PlatformsCrowdsourcing: Source #2: Securities PlatformsCrowdsourcing: Source #2: Securities PlatformsCrowdsourcing: Source #2: Securities Platforms���Arizona Tech Investors (ATI)���James Goulka�Managing Director�[email protected]�602-463-0844