ivan g. smith elementary school€¦ · cover letter from owner’s project manager section 1 opm...

466
MSBA 60% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SUBMISSION IVAN G. SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DANVERS, MASSACHUSETTS JULY 26, 2019

Upload: others

Post on 01-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • MSBA 60% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SUBMISSION

    IVAN G. SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLD

    AN

    VERS, MA

    SSAC

    HU

    SETTS

    JULY 26, 2019

  • JULY 26, 2019

    MSBA 60% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SUBMISSION IVAN G. SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOL

    DANVERS, MASSACHUSETTS

    ARCHITECT

    OWNER’S PROJECT MANAGER

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    35 Braintree Hill Office Park, Suite 300 Braintree, MA 02184

    Tel: 781.794.1404 Fax: 781.794.1405

    www.pmaconsultants.com

    July 26, 2019 Michael McGurl - Project Coordinator Massachusetts School Building Authority 40 Broad Street, Suite 500 Boston, MA 02109

    RE: Smith Elementary School Project 60% Construction Documents Submittal

    Dear Mr. McGurl:

    On behalf of the Town of Danvers, attached please find our 60% Construction Documents (CD) Submittal for the Ivan G. Smith Elementary School Project. This submittal has been compiled by Tappe Architects in collaboration with PMA Consultants, W.T. Rich, Town, School, and DPW administration with input from the Smith School Building Committee. Please note that the Smith School Building Committee unanimously voted to approve submittal of the 60% CD package to the MSBA on 7/26/2019. PMA has coordinated and reviewed the materials within and finds this submittal to be complete and in accordance with all MSBA requirements.

    As previously stated, the project team has benefitted from the Town of Danvers’ experience with public school construction projects. PMA (OPM), W.T. Rich (CMR), and the Danvers DPW/Engineering/School Departments have provided a continual review of the drawings as they progressed. Throughout the design process, recommendations to the architect by the OPM and CMR have included those pertaining to constructability, operability, bid-ability, clarity, site logistics, technical accuracy, efficiency, coordination, and cost effectiveness. Tappe has continued to do a great job of immediately incorporating input into the drawings. Regarding the 60% CD Pricing Set, PMA’s in-house licensed Professional Mechanical Engineer provided an updated review, multiple PMA Project Managers reviewed the documents, Colliers (Cx Agent) has provided review comments, and W.T. Rich has provided preliminary review comments. The Proposed Project as documented within the 60% CD submittal is within the District's Budget as outlined in the MSBA Project Scope & Budget Agreement and MSBA Project Funding Agreement. The project schedule remains mostly unchanged from the Design Development (DD) submission with the addition of actualized task completion dates. Per MSBA requirements, the MSBA’s DD Review and the project team’s response is included in this package. We look forward to the MSBA's review of this submission. As always, please feel free to contact me with any questions or concerns.

    Best Regards,

    Joseph DeSantis Senior Associate PMA Consultants – OPM

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    CONTENTSCOVER LETTER FROM OWNER’S PROJECT MANAGER

    SECTION 1 OPM DELIVERABLES 1.1 REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF DESIGNER SUBMISSION 1.2 COORDINATION REVIEW 1.3 COMMISSIONING CONSULTANTS REVIEW 1.4 MSBA SD REVIEW COMMENTS AND DISTRICT RESPONSE 1.5 UPDATED PROJECT SCHEDULE 1.6 LETTER CONFIRMING PROJECT REVIEW FROM STATE AGENCIES

    SECTION 2 SCOPE AND BUDGET 2.1 SCOPE AND BUDGET NARRATIVE 2.2 RECONCILED CONSTRUCTION MANAGER @ RISK COST ESTIMATE 2.3 UPDATED TOTAL PROJECT BUDGET

    SECTION 3 DESIGNER DELIVERABLES 3.1 UPDATED WORK PLAN 3.2 BASIS OF DESIGN NARRATIVES 3.3 UPDATED BUILDING CODE ANALYSIS 3.4 PROPRIETARY ITEMS 3.5 INTERIOR COLOR THEORY STATEMENT 3.6 STRUCTURAL DESIGN NARRATIVE 3.7 STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS AND FLOOR LOADS 3.8 CONFIRMATION OF STRUCTURAL DESIGN REVIEW PROCESS 3.9 ENERGY CALCULATIONS 3.10 LIFE CYCLE COST ANALYSIS FOR ENERGY AND WATER 3.11 HEAT GAIN AND LOSS CALCULATIONS FOR HVAC 3.12 ELECTRICAL LOAD CALCULATIONS 3.13 SECURITY AND VISUAL ACCESS REQUIREMENTS 3.14 QUALITY CONTROL STATEMENT 3.15 APPROVAL STATUS 3.16 RECONCILED DESIGNER ESTIMATE

    SECTION 4 SPACE TEMPLATE 4.1 SPACE TEMPLATE 4.2 SPACE TEMPLATE CERTIFICATION 4.3 DESE SUBMISSION

    APPENDIX APPENDIX 60% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS (UNDER SEPARATE COVER) 60% PROJECT MANUAL (UNDER SEPARATE COVER)

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    OPM DELIVERABLES

    1

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    1.1REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF DESIGNER SUBMISSION

    OPM DELIVERABLES

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    As outlined in the OPM cover letter, PMA has reviewed and fully recommends/approves this 60% CD submission to the MSBA. PMA has verified that this submittal is in accordance with the MSBA Module 6 60% CD Guidelines. This submission was approved unanimously by the Smith School Building Committee on 7/26/2019.

    1.1 OPM RECOMMENDATION TO APPROVE SUBMISSION

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    1.2COORDINATION REVIEW

    OPM DELIVERABLES

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Date:

    Project: 

    Subject: 

    Prep

    ared

     by: 

    Distribution: 

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    1.0 Archite

    ctural

    1.0.1

    FS‐101

    A9/25

    /201

    8Co

    ordina

    te lo

    catio

    n of con

    densing un

    its fo

    r cold room

    s, as req

    uired 

    (exterior o

    r roo

    f mou

    nted

    ?).

    Tapp

    e10

    /22/18

    : Typ

    ically ro

    of  m

    ounted

    Closed

    1.0.2

    A201

     – A20

    2; 

    A302

    9/25

    /201

    8Co

    ordina

    te heigh

    t of roo

    f scree

    n with

     Mecha

    nical equ

    ipmen

    t heigh

    ts.

    Tapp

    e10

    /22/18

    : Once fin

    al equ

    ipmen

    t sizing is complete this will be po

    ssible.

    Ope

    n

    1.0.3

    AD10

    0; E‐001

    2/22

    /201

    9Ve

    rify prop

    osed

     pha

    sing plan

    s match W

    T Rich pha

    sing plan

    s (than

    ks fo

    r ad

    ding

     note ab

    out tem

    porary byp

    ass). V

    erify

     Electric

    al Early Site

     Plan E‐

    001 matches as w

    ell.

    Tapp

    e3/12

    /19: Pha

    sing plan

    s  & Early Site

     Elect plan ha

    ve bee

    n coordina

    ted with

     WT Rich per th

    eir review com

    men

    ts fo

    r ER1

    Closed

    1.0.4

    A401

    , A40

    22/22

    /201

    9FYI, verified that bathroo

    ms h

    ave at least 5

    ’ of tile per Owne

    r’s re

    quest a

    t 2/14

    /19 fin

    ishes re

    view

     mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    e(non

    e requ

    ired)

    Closed

    1.0.5

    A419

    2/22

    /201

    9Gym

     cou

    rt lo

    go sh

    ould be confirm

    ed by To

    wn. 

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : tow

    n comfirmed

     bulldog

     logo

     at 0

    1/23

    /19 prog

    amming mee

    ting

    Closed

    1.0.6

    A411

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail D1

     – Forum

     stair. To

     be mod

    ified

     per 2/14/19

     mee

    ting with

     owne

    r. Re

    mov

    e carpet and

     cha

    nge riser m

    aterial from woo

    d.Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : lineo

    lum trea

    ds with

     woo

    d risers is w

    hat is c

    urrently in

     the 

    MSB

    A DD

     subm

    ission. 

    Closed

    1.0.7

    A200

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail C1

     – M

    ain en

    tran

    ce: C

    onsid

    er add

    ing windo

    w to

     wall abo

    ve 

    cafeteria

     per con

    versation at 2/14/19

     mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : add

    tiona

    l high windo

    ws will be ad

    ded to th

    e cafeteria

     for the

     60

    % CD subm

    ission

    Closed

    1.0.8

    A200

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail C1

     – M

    ain en

    tran

    ce: C

    onsid

    er re

    visin

    g material o

    f exterior w

    all 

    abov

    e cafeteria

     per con

    versation at 2/14/19

     mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : materail cha

    nging to m

    ason

    ry ven

    eer

    Closed

    1.0.9

    A, Gen

    eral

    2/22

    /201

    9Plea

    se con

    firm ro

    om num

    bers m

    atch plan discussed with

     Assistan

    t Su

    perin

    tend

    ent.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    :Roo

    m num

    bers m

    atch wha

    t was app

    roved by

     the  Assistan

    t Su

    perin

    tend

    ent.

    Closed

    1.0.10

    A202

    2/22

    /201

    9Discussed ha

    ving

     6’ b

    ullet resistan

    t glass in

     fron

    t of cafeteria with

     Keith at 

    9/5/18

     mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    eCW

    12 currently sc

    hedu

    led to have insulated security glazing

    Closed

    1.0.11

    A101

    B2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail C1

     – Tha

    nk you

     for rem

    oving carpet from

     project areas per David 

    Lane

     & Tracey Mara. 

    Tapp

    e(non

    e requ

    ired)

    Closed

    1.0.12

    A101

    A2/22

    /201

    9Kitche

    n / K

    itche

    n toilet layou

    ts: T

    hank

     you

     cha

    nging access to

     Toilet R

    #157

    , as d

    iscussed at 8/28/18

     mee

    ting with

     Dan

    vers Foo

    d Service Director. Tapp

    e(non

    e requ

    ired)

    Closed

    1.0.13

    A101

    B2/22

    /201

    9Discussed ad

    ding

     com

    mun

    icative do

    or betwee

    n Kind

    ergarten

     classroom

    s at 1/23/19

     staff w

    orksho

    ps. P

    lease revise fo

    r next sub

    miss

    ion, or a

    dvise

     if 

    not p

    ossib

    le.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : doo

    rs were ad

    ded for the

     MSB

    A DD

     Sub

    miss

    ion

    Closed

    1.0.14

    A417

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail A1

     – W

    hy th

    e curved

     corne

    r?Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : corne

    r is c

    urved to in

    crea

    se use writea

    ble wall surface in

     corne

    r an

    d increa

    se collabo

    ratio

    nClosed

    Tapp

    e – Ch

    arlie Hay & M

    att B

    arnh

    art

    DAN

    VER

    S IV

    AN G

    . SM

    ITH

    ELE

    MEN

    TAR

    Y –

    DD

    REV

    IEW

    CO

    MM

    ENTS

    July 19, 201

    9

    Danv

    ers Ivan G. Smith

     Elemen

    tary Schoo

    l

    60% CD Pricing Set ‐ PMA Re

    view

     Com

    men

    ts (6

    /27/19

     set)

    PMA Co

    nsultants 

    Page 1 of 8

    Date:

    Project: 

    Subject: 

    Prep

    ared

     by: 

    Distribution: 

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    1.0 Archite

    ctural

    1.0.1

    FS‐101

    A9/25

    /201

    8Co

    ordina

    te lo

    catio

    n of con

    densing un

    its fo

    r cold room

    s, as req

    uired 

    (exterior o

    r roo

    f mou

    nted

    ?).

    Tapp

    e10

    /22/18

    : Typ

    ically ro

    of  m

    ounted

    Closed

    1.0.2

    A201

     – A20

    2; 

    A302

    9/25

    /201

    8Co

    ordina

    te heigh

    t of roo

    f scree

    n with

     Mecha

    nical equ

    ipmen

    t heigh

    ts.

    Tapp

    e10

    /22/18

    : Once fin

    al equ

    ipmen

    t sizing is complete this will be po

    ssible.

    Ope

    n

    1.0.3

    AD10

    0; E‐001

    2/22

    /201

    9Ve

    rify prop

    osed

     pha

    sing plan

    s match W

    T Rich pha

    sing plan

    s (than

    ks fo

    r ad

    ding

     note ab

    out tem

    porary byp

    ass). V

    erify

     Electric

    al Early Site

     Plan E‐

    001 matches as w

    ell.

    Tapp

    e3/12

    /19: Pha

    sing plan

    s  & Early Site

     Elect plan ha

    ve bee

    n coordina

    ted with

     WT Rich per th

    eir review com

    men

    ts fo

    r ER1

    Closed

    1.0.4

    A401

    , A40

    22/22

    /201

    9FYI, verified that bathroo

    ms h

    ave at least 5

    ’ of tile per Owne

    r’s re

    quest a

    t 2/14

    /19 fin

    ishes re

    view

     mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    e(non

    e requ

    ired)

    Closed

    1.0.5

    A419

    2/22

    /201

    9Gym

     cou

    rt lo

    go sh

    ould be confirm

    ed by To

    wn. 

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : tow

    n comfirmed

     bulldog

     logo

     at 0

    1/23

    /19 prog

    amming mee

    ting

    Closed

    1.0.6

    A411

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail D1

     – Forum

     stair. To

     be mod

    ified

     per 2/14/19

     mee

    ting with

     owne

    r. Re

    mov

    e carpet and

     cha

    nge riser m

    aterial from woo

    d.Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : lineo

    lum trea

    ds with

     woo

    d risers is w

    hat is c

    urrently in

     the 

    MSB

    A DD

     subm

    ission. 

    Closed

    1.0.7

    A200

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail C1

     – M

    ain en

    tran

    ce: C

    onsid

    er add

    ing windo

    w to

     wall abo

    ve 

    cafeteria

     per con

    versation at 2/14/19

     mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : add

    tiona

    l high windo

    ws will be ad

    ded to th

    e cafeteria

     for the

     60

    % CD subm

    ission

    Closed

    1.0.8

    A200

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail C1

     – M

    ain en

    tran

    ce: C

    onsid

    er re

    visin

    g material o

    f exterior w

    all 

    abov

    e cafeteria

     per con

    versation at 2/14/19

     mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : materail cha

    nging to m

    ason

    ry ven

    eer

    Closed

    1.0.9

    A, Gen

    eral

    2/22

    /201

    9Plea

    se con

    firm ro

    om num

    bers m

    atch plan discussed with

     Assistan

    t Su

    perin

    tend

    ent.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    :Roo

    m num

    bers m

    atch wha

    t was app

    roved by

     the  Assistan

    t Su

    perin

    tend

    ent.

    Closed

    1.0.10

    A202

    2/22

    /201

    9Discussed ha

    ving

     6’ b

    ullet resistan

    t glass in

     fron

    t of cafeteria with

     Keith at 

    9/5/18

     mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    eCW

    12 currently sc

    hedu

    led to have insulated security glazing

    Closed

    1.0.11

    A101

    B2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail C1

     – Tha

    nk you

     for rem

    oving carpet from

     project areas per David 

    Lane

     & Tracey Mara. 

    Tapp

    e(non

    e requ

    ired)

    Closed

    1.0.12

    A101

    A2/22

    /201

    9Kitche

    n / K

    itche

    n toilet layou

    ts: T

    hank

     you

     cha

    nging access to

     Toilet R

    #157

    , as d

    iscussed at 8/28/18

     mee

    ting with

     Dan

    vers Foo

    d Service Director. Tapp

    e(non

    e requ

    ired)

    Closed

    1.0.13

    A101

    B2/22

    /201

    9Discussed ad

    ding

     com

    mun

    icative do

    or betwee

    n Kind

    ergarten

     classroom

    s at 1/23/19

     staff w

    orksho

    ps. P

    lease revise fo

    r next sub

    miss

    ion, or a

    dvise

     if 

    not p

    ossib

    le.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : doo

    rs were ad

    ded for the

     MSB

    A DD

     Sub

    miss

    ion

    Closed

    1.0.14

    A417

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail A1

     – W

    hy th

    e curved

     corne

    r?Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : corne

    r is c

    urved to in

    crea

    se use writea

    ble wall surface in

     corne

    r an

    d increa

    se collabo

    ratio

    nClosed

    Tapp

    e – Ch

    arlie Hay & M

    att B

    arnh

    art

    DAN

    VER

    S IV

    AN G

    . SM

    ITH

    ELE

    MEN

    TAR

    Y –

    DD

    REV

    IEW

    CO

    MM

    ENTS

    July 19, 201

    9

    Danv

    ers Ivan G. Smith

     Elemen

    tary Schoo

    l

    60% CD Pricing Set ‐ PMA Re

    view

     Com

    men

    ts (6

    /27/19

     set)

    PMA Co

    nsultants 

    Page 1 of 8

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    1.0.15

    A102

    B2/22

    /201

    9No do

    or to

     5th grade

     classroom

     area en

    tran

    ce?

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : no do

    or in

     this locatio

    n to kee

    p the op

    en con

    nection to th

    e core 

    elem

    ents (toilet roo

    ms, sm

    all group

    , STE

    AM).  It also

     wou

    ld nee

    d to be a 

    dual egress d

    oor, sw

    inging

     in both directions.

    Closed

    1.0.16

    A102

    2/22

    /201

    9(M

    inor) d

    oor swings to

     enter acade

    mic area ap

    pear in

    consisten

    t. See 

    second

     floo

    r doo

    r betwee

    n Co

    lumn lin

    es H and

     H.2. 

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : doo

    r 201

     has be revised to ope

    n ou

    tward into th

    e STEA

    M / Elev 

    Lobb

    yClosed

    1.0.17

    A601

    ‐A60

    32/22

    /201

    9Miss

    ing windo

    w sc

    hedu

    le? 

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : Refer to

     A52

    1‐A5

    23 fo

    r windo

    w ty

    pes

    Closed

    1.0.18

    A414

    2/22

    /201

    9Ve

    stibule @ M

    ain en

    tran

    ce: 

    1.)      Is th

    is whe

    re th

    e salvaged

     mosaic will go an

    d no

    t on the exterio

    r of 

    the bu

    ilding? 

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : currently th

    e salvaged

     mosaic is located in th

    e main en

    try 

    vestibule. W

    ill coo

    rd. location with

     FAA

    P, buidling plan

    s and

     other item

    s thea

    t nee

    d space on

     this wall.

    Closed

    1.0.19

    A414

    2/22

    /201

    92.)      Sho

    uld confirm

     size of teller w

    indo

    w @

     3/5/19 Security mee

    ting.

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : pass thru windo

    w was re

    view

    ed at the

     security mee

    ting an

    d was 

    acceptab

    le 

    Closed

    1.0.20

    A414

    2/22

    /201

    93.)      W

    ill 4’ p

    orcelain wall loo

    k od

    d if rest of schoo

    l/area ha

    s 3’ tile? 

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : Tile heigh

    ts to

     be ap

    prox. 3

    '‐0" in th

    e first floo

    r clasroo

    m wing, 

    and 5'‐0" in lo

    bby, caféteria, and

     second

     floo

    r classroom

     wing.  

    Closed

    1.0.21

    A414

    2/22

    /201

    94.)      W

    hy doe

    s this v

    estib

    ule ha

    ve a sk

    ylight?

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : skylight is in

     the en

    try cano

    py to

     allo

    w add

    ition

    al daylight

    Closed

    1.0.22

    A001

    2/22

    /201

    9Re

    view

     Rated

     Wall A

    ssem

    bly legend

     with

     floo

    rplans. C

    onfirm 2‐hou

    r rated

     assembly prov

    ided

     for E

    mergency Electrical Roo

    ms. 

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : 2hr ra

    ting ad

    ded to Emerg. Elect 135

    A.  Emerg. Elect. 2

    03A 

    alread

    y show

    s 2hr ra

    ting

    Closed

    1.0.23

    A111

     – A11

    2B2/22

    /201

    9Co

    ordina

    te RCP

    s with

     MEP

     locatio

    ns (g

    rilles, ligh

    ting, te

    lecomm devices, 

    etc.)

    Tapp

    e03

    /05/19

    : coo

    rdination on

    going for 6

    0% CD subm

    ission

    Ope

    n

    1.02

    4A1

    01A, 

    A101

    B, A10

    2B7/11

    /201

    9Au

    tomated

     Externa

    l Defibrillators (A

    EDs) lo

    catio

    ns do no

    t app

    ear to be

     show

    n on

     the flo

    or plans

    Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    1.02

    5A1

    01A

    7/11

    /201

    9Th

    e exterio

    r doo

    r of A

    rt Roo

    m 167

     is m

    issing its doo

    r designa

    tion.

    Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    1.02

    6A1

    01A, 

    C3/A42

    2, 

    E101

    Al7/18

    /201

    9Plea

    se con

    firm Vestib

    ule 14

    9 ha

    s a designa

    ted light fixture. A ligh

    t fixture 

    in th

    is locatio

    n is conflictin

    g be

    twee

    n RC

    P, eng

    larged

     RCP

    , and

     ligh

    ting 

    plan

    Tapp

    e/AE

    IOpe

    n

    1.02

    7A1

    1B7/18

    /201

    9Sh

    ould a m

    ounting he

    ight be prov

    ided

     for light fixture ST2 in Stair 1 & 3? 

    Also, this fixture is not sh

    own on

     A11

    BTapp

    e/AE

    IOpe

    n

    1.0.28

    !603

    7/19

    /201

    9Plea

    se provide

     finish m

    aterial selectio

    ns (e

    .g. flooring & paint)

    Tapp

    e

    1.0.29

    Multip

    le7/19

    /201

    9Plea

    se have acou

    stical con

    sulta

    nt re

    view

     staff b

    athroo

    m adjacen

    cies and

     verify ad

    equa

    te "acou

    stical priv

    acy" is provide

    d. (S

    taff ba

    throom

    s nea

    r staff d

    ining, etc.)

    Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    2.0 Plum

    bing

    / Fire Protection

    2.0.1

    PFP‐20

    1A & 

    C400

    9/25

    /201

    8Plum

    bing

     or C

    ivil coordina

    ting be

    low groun

    d? Provide

     und

    ergrou

    nd 

    utilitie

    s plan.

    AEI/ Nitsch

    10/22/18

    : Site

     Utilities (1

    0 ft outsid

    e the bu

    ilding) are sh

    own on

     civil site 

    utility plan (She

    et C‐400

    ). Ong

    oing

     coo

    rdination with

     MEP

    .Closed

    2.0.2

    P200

    A2/22

    /201

    9Ad

    ditio

    nal floor drains req

    uired in Cafeteria/ K

    itche

    n area

    s?AE

    IAll d

    rains req

    uired for IW con

    nections have be

    en in

    clud

    ed. Final 

    coordian

    tion of all flo

    or drains/flo

    or sink

    s in the kitche

    n will occur during 

    the CD

     design ph

    ase.

    Ope

    n

    2.0.3

    P203

    A – 

    P203

    B2/22

    /201

    9Ad

    ditio

    nal roo

    f drains req

    uired at M

    echa

    nical equ

    ipmen

    t locations? 

    AEI

    Fina

    l roo

    f drain lo

    catio

    ns will be coordian

    ted with

     the archite

    ct and

     mecha

    ncial eng

    inee

    r during the CD

     design ph

    ase.

    Ope

    n

    2.0.4

    P‐ plans

    2/22

    /201

    97/12

    /201

    9Miss

    ing de

    tails and

     flow

     diagram

    s for Plumbing

    . Flow diagram

    s are st

    ill 

    missing

     from

     the 60

    % CD set.

    AEI

    Plum

    bing

     details are show

    n on

     drawing P‐60

    0 of th

    e DD

     set. Flow

    /rise

    r diagrams w

    ill be includ

    ed as p

    art o

    f the

     CD subm

    ission.

    Ope

    n

    Page 2 of 8

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    2.0.5

    FP20

    1A – 

    FP20

    2B2/22

    /201

    9Plan

    s are difficult to read

    . Whe

    re is sp

    rinkler piping routing? Rise

    rs 

    located?

    AEI

    DD drawings sh

    ow th

    e sprin

    kler m

    ains leaving the mecha

    nical roo

    m and

     be

    ing distrib

    uted

     across e

    ach flo

    or. Sprinkler hea

    d locatio

    ns are sh

    own. 

    Bran

    ch sp

    rinkler piping will be completed

     during the CD

     design ph

    ase.

    Closed

    3.0 Mecha

    nical

    3.0.1

    M10

    39/25

    /201

    8Co

    nfirm

     rooftop eq

    uipm

    ent locations and

     proximities to

     other equ

    ipmen

    t mee

    t cod

    e (e.g. intakes and

     exhau

    st distan

    ces).

    Bala

    10/22/18

    : The

     design intent is fo

    r equ

    ipmen

    t locations to

     mee

    t or e

    xcee

    d code

     clearan

    ces for air intakes a

    nd exhau

    st as w

    ell as s

    afety clea

    rances.

    Ope

    n

    3.0.2

    M10

    39/25

    /201

    8Co

    ordina

    te heigh

    t of, an

    d if louv

    ers req

    uired in, roo

    ftop

     equ

    ipmen

    t screen

    s, as req

    uired, with

     Architect.

    Bala

    10/22/18

    : The

     intent is th

    at th

    e roof sc

    reen

    s will be of su

    fficien

    t heigh

    t to 

    screen

     units. Lou

    ver o

    pening

    s an

    d clea

    rances will be coordina

    ted.

    Ope

    n

    3.0.3

    M10

    1 – M10

    29/25

    /201

    8

    Indicate m

    ain du

    ct and

     pipe distrib

    ution, zon

    ing, and

     risers. Flow diagram

    s wou

    ld also

     be he

    lpful for cost e

    stim

    ating. 

    2/22

    /19: Flow diagram

    s and

     add

    ition

    al details are no

    t include

    d in DD 

    subm

    ission.

    Bala

    10/22/18

    : Main du

    ct and

     pipe distrib

    utions are in

    dicated. Schem

    atic flow

     diagrams w

    ill be includ

    ed in

     the DD

     subm

    ission. 3/8/19 Hot w

    ater/chille

    d water dua

    l tem

    perature flow

     diagram

     has bee

    n ad

    ded to th

    e DD plans.

    Closed

    3.0.4

    M10

    19/25

    /201

    8Su

    pplemen

    tal coo

    ling for E

    lectric

    al, TeleD

    ata spaces or E

    levator M

    achine

     Ro

    om, etc?

    2/22

    /19: In

    dicate sizin

    g/ qua

    ntities. 7

    /12/19

    : Add

     detail for unit/piping

    .Ba

    la10

    /22/18

    : Ductle

    ss sp

    lit sy

    stem

     AC un

    its are noted

     in th

    e specificatio

    ns. 

    Actual qua

    ntity

     and

     locatio

    ns will be de

    term

    ined

    .Ope

    n

    3.0.5

    M10

    19/25

    /201

    8Eq

    uipm

    ent install/access/ m

    ainten

    ance/ rem

    oval plan for M

    echa

    nical 

    Room

     on first floo

    r?Ba

    la10

    /22/18

    : All eq

    uipm

    ent w

    ill be de

    signe

    d for p

    rope

    r mainten

    ance access 

    and remov

    al.

    Closed

    3.0.6

    M10

    1 – M10

    39/25

    /201

    8Miss

    ing Sche

    dules, Details, etc. for cost e

    stim

    ating. 

    2/22

    /19: M

    ultip

    le details miss

    ing from

     DD pa

    ckage. Sched

    ules are not 

    complete – miss

    ing all equ

    ipmen

    t information. 

    Bala

    10/22/18

    : Major equ

    ipmen

    t cap

    acities are in

    dicated on

     drawing M10

    3. 

    Details will be includ

    ed in

     DD subm

    ission. 3/8/19 Details have be

    en add

    ed 

    and ad

    ditio

    nal sched

    ule da

    ta is in

    clud

    ed on the DD plans.

    Ope

    n

    3.0.7

    M10

    1 – M10

    32/22

    /201

    9Ad

    d exha

    ust to specialty

     room

    s: Cop

    y Ro

    om, A

    rt Roo

    ms, etc. tha

    t sho

    uld 

    not b

    e recirculated

    , as n

    eede

    d.Ba

    la3/8/19

     Kiln

     exh

    aust is in

    dicated.  A

    rt ro

    om is exh

    austed

    / ve

    ntilated 

    throug

    h the ER

    V system

     and

     is not re

    circulated

    .Closed

    3.0.8

    M10

    32/22

    /201

    9Co

    ordina

    te ro

    oftop eq

    uipm

    ent w

    ith Electric

    al.

    Bala

    3/8/19

     Roo

    ftop

     unit e

    lectric

    al data ha

    s be

    en coo

    rdinated

    .Closed

    3.0.9

    M10

    1B2/22

    /201

    9Ve

    ntilatio

    n an

    d/or coo

    ling prov

    ided

     in Electric

    al Roo

    m/ E

    merg. Electric

    al 

    spaces? Te

    lecomm sp

    aces? 7/12

    /19: Any

     doo

    r lou

    ver o

    r und

    ercut 

    prov

    ided

     for E

    merg Elect c

    losets?

    Bala

    3/8/19

     Will be includ

    ed in

     the CD

     docum

    ents.

    Ope

    n

    3.0.10

    M10

    1 – 

    M10

    2B2/22

    /201

    9Co

    ordina

    te con

    densate piping

     from

     Mech eq

    uipm

    ent to ne

    arest a

    pproved 

    FD. 

    Bala

    3/8/19

     Will be includ

    ed in

     the CD

     docum

    ents.

    Ope

    n

    3.0.11

    M10

    1B2/22

    /201

    9Co

    mbu

    stion air for boilers in

     Mecha

    nical R

    oom re

    quire

    d?Ba

    la3/8/19

     Com

    bustion air for boilers and

     water hea

    ters is in

    diacted on

     the 

    DD plans.

    Closed

    3.0.12

    M10

    1A2/22

    /201

    9Kitche

    n ventilatio

    n an

    d cooling eq

    uipm

    ent to be

     provide

    d. Is kitc

    hen 

    exha

    ust g

    ood a Type

     1 (g

    rease) hoo

    d? If so

    , coo

    rdinate all n

    ecessary fire 

    protectio

    n, duct a

    ccess p

    anels, fire alarm

     devices, e

    tc. as req

    uired).

    Bala

    3/8/19

     Final details w

    ill be includ

    ed in

     the CD

     docum

    ents.  Kitche

    n is 

    curren

    tly not provide

    d with

     coo

    ling.  P

    lease confirm

     desire

    d intent.

    Closed

    3.0.13

    Specs

    2/22

    /201

    9Have sequ

    ence of o

    peratio

    ns bee

    n de

    velope

    d yet for any

     of the

     system

    s? 

    7/12

    /19: Con

    firm all SO

    Os are includ

    ed and

     provide

     con

    trols diagrams, 

    as nee

    ded, on plan

    s.Ba

    la3/8/19

     Will be includ

    ed in

     the CD

     docum

    ents.

    Ope

    n

    3.0.14

    M10

    1A, 

    M10

    1B, 

    M10

    2B7/16

    /201

    9Do

     the learning

     cen

    ters/small group

     classroom

    s/resource ro

    oms s

    uch as 

    Small G

    roup

     Rea

    ding

     201

     or E

    SL Classroom

     217

     nee

    d to have their o

    wn 

    thermostat a

    s req

    uired by

     CHPS

    ?Ba

    la/Tap

    peOpe

    n

    Page 3 of 8

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    3.0.15

    M10

    1A, H

    VAC 

    Sche

    d, 

    E101

    Ap7/18

    /201

    9

    M10

    1A sh

    ows a

     (2) ceilin

    g fans "CF

    /1" in Lob

    by 138

    , how

    ever th

    e fans are 

    not listed

     on the HV

    AC sc

    hedu

    le, and

     E10

    1Ap do

    es not sh

    ow pow

    er fo

    r the

     fans. Sho

    uld these fans be on

     a switc

    h, if so

     E10

    1Al d

    oes n

    ot sh

    ow a 

    desig

    nated sw

    itch locatio

    n.

    Bala/AEI

    Ope

    n

    3.0.16

    M10

    1A, 

    M10

    1B, 

    M10

    2B7/18

    /201

    9Are the CU

    H's an

    d FTR's e

    lectric

     or h

    ydronic? The

     units are not sp

    ecified

     in 

    the HVA

    C sche

    dule so

     it is ukn

    own (see

     3.0.19). B

    oth piping

     and

     pow

    er 

    requ

    iremen

    ts have no

    t bee

    n coordina

    ted with

     eith

    er of the

    se units.

    Bala/AEI

    Ope

    n

    3.0.17

    M10

    1A7/18

    /201

    9Re

    ceiving/Gen

    eral Storage 153

     show

    s a CUH on

     the North wall, ho

    wever 

    there is no

     sche

    duled reference #.

    Bala

    Ope

    n

    3.0.18

    M10

    1A7/18

    /201

    9Cu

    stod

    ial Storage 152

     show

    s a FTR

     unit o

    n the West w

    all, ho

    wever no 

    leng

    th has bee

    n specified

    .Ba

    laOpe

    n

    3.0.19

    HVAC

     Sched

    7/18

    /201

    9Plea

    se com

    plete HVA

    C sche

    dule fo

    r units listed

     but sp

    ecs n

    ot provide

    d. 

    Plea

    se also

     includ

    e specificatio

    ns fo

    r CUH, FTr, FPB

    , AC, BC, PR, and

     EXV

     that are sh

    own on

     the flo

    or plans but not in

     the HVA

    C sche

    dule

    Bala

    Ope

    n

    4.0 Electrical

    4.0.1

    E301

    B9/25

    /201

    8Co

    nfirm

     if fire ra

    ting requ

    ired arou

    nd Electric

    al/ E

    merg. Electric

    al Roo

    ms. 

    Coordina

    te with

     Architect, as n

    eede

    d.AE

    I10

    /22/18

    : Emergency electric closets re

    quire

     2hr ra

    ting.

    Closed

    4.0.2

    E‐01

    9/25

    /201

    8Indicate whe

    re pow

    er is entering bu

    ilding. Coo

    rdinate with

     Civil, as 

    need

    ed.

    AEI

    10/22/18

    : Drawing E3

    01A indicates w

    here pow

    er enters the

     building

    Closed

    4.0.3

    E‐01

    9/25

    /201

    8

    Wha

    t is c

    onne

    cted

     to EP?

    2/22

    /19: W

    ill pan

    el sc

    hedu

    les b

    e prov

    ided

    ? A sche

    dule sh

    owing all 

    equipm

    ent a

    nd correspon

    ding

     electric

    al re

    quire

    men

    ts wou

    ld be he

    lpful. 

    7/12

    /19: Finalize PB

     sche

    dules ‐ in

    fo m

    issing

    .

    AEI

    10/22/18

    : The

     SD do

    cumen

    ts do no

    t sho

    w circ

    uitin

    g so it will not be 

    possible to

     determine wha

    t is p

    lann

    ed to

     be on

     EP by

     review

    ing the 

    draw

    ings. The

     SD na

    rrative indicates w

    hat w

    ill be on

     emergency po

    wer. 

    3/8/19

    : PB Sche

    dules w

    ill be prov

    ided

     in th

    e CD

     Sub

    miss

    ion an

    d will 

    includ

    ed all electrical re

    quire

    men

    ts.

    Ope

    n

    4.0.4

    E301

    A – 

    E303

    B9/25

    /201

    8Sh

    ow pow

    er fo

    r all major equ

    ipmen

    t on po

    wer plans. 2

    /22/19

    : Include

     and

     coordina

    te fo

    r CDs

    . AE

    I

    10/22/18

    : The

     SD do

    cumen

    ts will not sh

    ow circ

    uitin

    g sin

    ce th

    e exact size

    s of HVA

    C eq

    uipm

    ent a

    re not fina

    lized

    , but large HVA

    C eq

    uipm

    ent is s

    hown 

    on plans and

     one

     line

     diagram

     whe

    re app

    ropriate. 3

    /8/19: Pow

    er to

     all 

    major equ

    ipmen

    t will be fin

    alize

    d for the

     CD subm

    ission.

    Ope

    n

    4.0.5

    E‐80

    09/25

    /201

    8Fire Alarm

    : Hea

    t detectors in

     spaces ven

    ting stea

    m. 

    AEI

    10/22/18

    : Hea

    t detectors have be

    en sh

    own in th

    e mecha

    nical roo

    m.

    Closed

    4.0.6

    E301

    A2/22

    /201

    9Kitche

    n area

     show

    n on

     drawing is bo

    xed ou

    t with

     reference to detail 1 on 

    shee

    t E50

    1. She

    et E50

    1 is no

    t include

    d in th

    e draw

    ing set. (W

    ould like to

     review

     that pen

    dant ligh

    ts are in

    clud

    ed whe

    re Kitc

    hen mee

    ts Cafeteria).

    AEI

    3/8/19

     Drawing E5

    01 is com

    plete an

    d inlcud

    ed in

     the DD

     set.

    Closed

    4.0.7

    E‐00

    02/22

    /201

    9Co

    mplete lighting fixture sc

    hedu

    les.

    AEI

    3/8/19

     Lighting fixture sc

    hedu

    le has bee

    n completed

    .WLI to

     coo

    rdinate an

    d assis

    t on site light lo

    catio

    ns and

     fixture selection.  

    Electrical will own 

    Closed

    4.0.8

    E201

    A – 

    E202

    B2/22

    /201

    9Elevators o

    n em

    ergency po

    wer? Co

    nnect e

    mergency electric m

    echa

    nical 

    equipm

    ent to EP

    , if so & coo

    rdinate with

     Bala.

    AEI

    3/8/19

     Will add

    ress in

     CD subm

    ission.

    Ope

    n

    4.0.9

    E301

    A2/22

    /201

    9Sh

    eet E

    ‐501

     miss

    ing, sh

    owing electrical hoo

    k‐up

    s for kitc

    hen eq

    uipm

    ent.

    AEI

    3/8/19

     Drawing E5

    01 is com

    plete an

    d inlcud

    ed in

     the DD

     set.

    Closed

    4.0.10

    E501

     & E70

    07/12

    /201

    9Co

    mplete Sche

    dule of K

    itche

    n Eq

    uipm

    ent a

    nd Sched

    ule of M

    echa

    nical 

    Equipm

    ent. Sh

    ow all fire alarm devices, p

    ower, e

    tc. for Kitc

    he.

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    Page 4 of 8

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    4.0.11

    E101

    Ap, 

    E101

    Bp, 

    E102

    Bp, 

    E121

    Ap, 

    E121

    Bp

    7/11

    /201

    9Gen

    eral note: M

    issing inform

    ation on

     receptacle pan

    el designa

    tions, 

    homerun

    s back to pan

    els.

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    4.0.12

    E101

    Al7/11

    /201

    9

    Display cases in Lobb

    y 13

    8 show

    n on

     A10

    1A and

     C1/A7

    03 in

    dicates "

    3" 

    Dia. Puck Ligh

    ting Hardw

    ired by

     Elec." Pu

    ck ligh

    ting is no

    t sho

    wn or 

    specified

     in th

    e lighting sche

    dule. A

    re th

    ese fixtures integral to the case 

    itself? If not and

     are to

     be prov

    ided

     by EC

     con

    tractor p

    lease specify

     fixture 

    type

    . Sho

    uld these recessed

     ligh

    ts be on

     a sw

    itch an

    d/or dim

    mer to

     allo

    control if e

    ver n

    eede

    d?

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    4.0.13

    E101

    Al, 

    E101

    Bl, 

    E102

    Bl7/11

    /201

    9Gen

    eral note: ligh

    ting plan

    s miss

    ing sw

    itch locatio

    ns, switc

    h de

    signa

    tions/circ

    uit d

    esigna

    tions

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    4.0.14

    E101

    Al, 

    E101

    Bl, 

    E102

    Bl7/11

    /201

    9Ligh

    ting fixtures P

    14 and

     P18

     are sh

    own throug

    hout th

    e lighting plan

    s. 

    Both fixture de

    signa

    tions are not sp

    ecified

     in th

    e lighting fixture sc

    hedu

    le. 

    Is th

    is a typo

    ? If no

    t, plea

    se provide

     fixture specificatio

    ns fo

    r P14

     and

     P18

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    4.0.15

    ES10

    07/17

    /201

    9Th

    e electrical site plan do

    es not sh

    ow pow

    er to

     the water bottle

     filler 

    adjacent to

     the ba

    sketba

    ll court.

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    4.0.16

    E102

    Bl7/18

    /201

    9Th

    e wall m

    ounted

     ligh

    t fixtures a

    t the

     2nd

     floo

    r of S

    tair 3 do

     not have a 

    fixture designa

    tion. Are we are to assum

    e these are ST2 to m

    atch th

    e rest?AE

    I/Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    4.0.17

    E000

    7/19

    /201

    9Plea

    se com

    plete lighting fixture sc

    hedu

    le on E0

    00, m

    ore specifically fo

    r site lights S

    1, S2, S3, and

     S4.

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    4.0.18

    ES10

    07/19

    /201

    9

    The mon

    umen

    tal schoo

    l sign with

     electronic display at th

    e So

    uth East side

     of th

    e site requ

    ires p

    ower, h

    owever it is not sh

    own on

     ES100

    . The

    re is a 

    hand

    hole adjacen

    t to the sig

    ns lo

    catio

    n for the

     site ligh

    ting, sh

    ould pow

    er 

    for the

     sign

     also

     be pu

    lled into th

    e ha

    ndho

    le and

     then

     to th

    e sign

    ? Plea

    se 

    coordina

    te.

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    4.0.19

    Gen

    eral

    7/19

    /201

    9

    DPS (Keith) h

    as expressed

     interest in

     includ

    ing cell ph

    one sig

    nal b

    oosters, 

    either in

     the project o

    r outsid

    e of th

    e project. Ca

    n Tapp

    e plea

    se have a 

    subcon

    sulta

    nt provide

     ROM pric

    ing or se

    e wha

    t can

     be do

    ne to

     be 

    "boo

    ster re

    ady" so

     DPS

     can

     easily do this ou

    tside of our project?

    AEI/Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    5.0 Te

    leDa

    ta

    5.0.1

    T101

    A – T2

    .059/25

    /201

    8Pa

    per size is diffe

    rent th

    an th

    e rest of the

     set. 

    Edvance

    Corrected for the

     SD subm

    ission.

    Closed

    5.0.2

    Gen

    eral

    7/19

    /201

    9

    Per d

    iscussio

    ns at the

     7/1/19 techno

    logy design mee

    ting with

     DPS

    , Tap

    pe 

    to coo

    rdinate Distric

    t Fiber con

    nectivity

    . Dan

    vers con

    necting all schoo

    ls this summer. Tap

    pe to

     coo

    rdinate op

    timal lo

    catio

    n for D

    anvers to

     leave a 

    coil.

    Tapp

    e/Da

    nvers

    Ope

    n

    Page 5 of 8

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    6.0 Civil

    6.0.1

    C400

    9/25

    /201

    8Settlemen

    t vau

    lts and

    /or flex conn

    ectio

    ns re

    quire

    d for F

    W, D

    omestic

     Water, San

    itary, e

    tc?

    Nitsch

    10/22/18

    : This w

    ill be coordina

    ted in fu

    ture su

    bmiss

    ions, flex conn

    ectio

    ns 

    will be show

    n as nee

    ded. Not clear on “Settle

    men

    t vau

    lts” commen

    t.Closed

    6.0.2

    C400

    2/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : Please ad

    d no

    te to

     drawings in

    dicatin

    g tree

    s on ea

    st side

     of a

    ccess 

    road

     are to

     be prun

    ed. 

    Warne

    r Larson

    WLI will add

     an ad

    ditio

    nal clarification no

    te on L100

     Site

     Prep for p

    runing

    .  Tress a

    re currently called ou

    t as to be

     protected

    .Closed

    6.0.3

    C400

    2/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : Please ad

    d no

    te stating that DPW

     will te

    mpo

    rarily relocate Pop

    e Mem

    orial stone

    , and

     brin

    g ba

    ck once WT Rich re

    quests. 

    Nitsch

    This no

    te is currently on the DD

     subm

    ission

    Closed

    6.0.4

    C400

    2/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : Mow

     strip

     to be ad

    ded at fa

    r north and

     far sou

    th parts of b

    uilding 

    (whe

    re th

    ere is no

     walkw

    ay con

    flict).

    Warne

    r Larson

    Adde

    d to th

    e draw

    ings and

     detailed

    Closed

    6.0.5

    C400

    2/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : Add

     sedimen

    t trap to drainage sw

    ale.

    Nitsch / Warne

    r Larson

    WLI and

     Nitsch to

     coo

    rd on de

    tail. W

    ill be coordina

    te prio

    r to Co

    n Co

    review

    , will provide

     a se

    dimen

    t foreb

    ay or structure with

     sump to collect 

    sedimen

    t. Closed

    6.0.6

    C400

    , L20

    12/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    :  DP

    W Dire

    ctor not fu

    lly bou

    ght in to unit p

    avers. David W

    arne

    r to 

    prov

    ide ph

    otos from

     other su

    ccessful projects. 

    Warne

    r Larson 

    / DPW

    WLI to

     provide

     images from

     other projects.

    Closed

    6.0.7

    C400

    2/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : Bollards in fron

    t of schoo

    l to be

     pow

    der c

    oated (w

    ith protective 

    elem

    ent for plows).

    Warne

    r Larson

    Correct.  Detalied an

    d specs c

    oord/call this finish

     trea

    tmen

    tClosed

    6.0.8

    C400

    2/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : DPW

     Dire

    ctor to

     follo

    w up regarding preferred material for ra

    iling

    s in east “

    courtyard”.

    DPW / Warne

    r Larson

    WLI noted

     that pow

    dercoa

    ted fin

    ish was prefered by

     DPW

    .  Cu

    rren

    tly 

    calling

     for this o

    n the de

    tails and

     specs.

    Closed

    6.0.9

    L201

    , L50

    22/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : Switc

    h be

    nche

    s to gran

    ite.

    Warne

    r Larson

    Correct.  Currently sh

    owing this on

     drawings, d

    etails an

    d in sp

    ecs.

    Closed

    6.0.10

    C400

    2/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : Delete irrigation at U8 fie

    ld, lea

    ve dom

    estic

     con

    nection/sle

    eve.

    Warne

    r Larson

    Deleted no

    te callin

    g for irrigation on

     the U8 fie

    ld.  Plum

    bing

     to coo

    rd on 

    prov

    iding water so

    urce fo

    r future irrigation.  W

    LI to

     add

     slee

    ves u

    nder 

    pavemen

    tClosed

    6.0.11

    C400

    2/22

    /201

    9As disc

    ussed at 2/14/19

     Lan

    dscape

     design mee

    ting with

     Owne

    r & W

    arne

    r Larson

    : DPW

     Dire

    ctor to

     follo

    w up (Verify

     no concerns) regarding

     species 

    of tree

    s/plan

    tings. Tow

    n mov

    ing aw

    ay from

     Pin Oak.

    Warne

    r Larson

    WLI noted

     that DPW

     did not have an

     issue with

     Pin Oaks a

    s the

    y are mainly 

    alon

    g the pe

    rimeter of the

     site and

     acorn drop shou

    ld be a prob

    lem.  We 

    can wait o

    n feed

    back from

     Tow

    n.  

    Closed

    6.0.12

    L300

    2/22

    /201

    9Plea

    se kee

    p bo

    ttom

     wall / to

    p of wall lab

    els c

    onsis

    tent (see

     main 

    entran

    ce).

    Warne

    r Larson

    spot grade

    s have be

    en re

    vised for D

    D subm

    ission

    Closed

    6.0.13

    L300

    2/22

    /201

    9Plea

    se provide

     detail for ra

    ised walkw

    ay @

     main en

    tran

    ce.

    Warne

    r Larson

    adde

    d de

    tail to #16

    /L50

    0Closed

    6.0.14

    L502

    2/22

    /201

    9Plea

    se provide

     detail for playgroun

    d eq

    uipm

    ent.

    Warne

    r Larson

    need

     feed

     back from

     Tow

    n's p

    laygroun

    d focous group

    .  Fo

    oting de

    tail is 

    prov

    ided

    .Closed

    6.0.15

    C200

    2/22

    /201

    9Erosion an

    d sedimen

    t con

    trol plan do

     not sh

    ow U8 fie

    ld or b

    asketball 

    court.

    Nitsch

    Erosion control p

    lans have be

    en re

    vised to in

    clud

    e scop

    e of work. 

    Closed

    6.0.16

    L201

    2/22

    /201

    9De

    tail 3 – Is water fo

    untain with

     bottle

     filler a

     typo

    ?Warne

    r Larson

    Curren

    tly sh

    owing a water fo

    untaing with

     a bottle

     filling

     attachm

    ent.  

    Owne

    r to confirm

     produ

    ct is wan

    ted.  C

    oord with

     plumbing

     if fo

    untain is in

    .Closed

    Page 6 of 8

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    6.0.17

    L200

    2/22

    /201

    9Th

    ree charging

     stations sh

    own in SW side

     of v

    isitor p

    arking

     area. Has David 

    Lane

     review

    ed th

    is? Doe

    s this g

    et us a

    ny CHPs points?

    Tapp

    eYe

    s.  The

    se are add

    ed sp

    ecifically fo

    r CHP

    S requ

    iremen

    ts EE.10

    .0 (2

    % of a

    ll pa

    rking shall h

    ave charging

    , 123

     spaced

     @2%

    =2.46 stalls)

    Closed

    6.0.18

    L200

    2/22

    /201

    9Travis from

     Dan

    vers Eng

    inee

    ring De

    partmen

    t req

    uested

     20’ wide access 

    road

     aroun

    d bu

    ilding. Plans in

    dicate entrance to access roa

    d is 16

    ’ at 

    entran

    ce from

     staff p

    arking

     lot. Ca

    n this be

     increa

    sed?

    Tapp

    e

    Yes, The

     road

     can

     be mad

    e 20

    '.  Fire

     Dep

    t Chief app

    roved this section be

    ing 

    16' as the

    re is a hill along

     this section an

    d they wou

    ld not se

    tup there.  

    Locked

     collapsab

    le bollard are in

    stalled at to

    p of access roa

    d, staff w

    ill not 

    be able to driv

    e.

    Closed

    6.0.19

    L200

    2/22

    /201

    9Is th

    e revised access ro

    ad to

     service area

     show

    n? (A

    s a re

    sult of tu

    rning 

    radius stud

    ies d

    one in Ja

    nuary 20

    19?)

    Tapp

    eCo

    rrect

    Closed

    6.0.20

    5/L501

    7/12

    /201

    9De

    tail 5/L501

     show

    s a 4' embe

    dmen

    t for th

    e stee

    l bollards a

    roun

    d  th

    e gene

    rator a

    nd tran

    sformer. Is the

     4' embe

    dmen

    t req

    uired?

     The

    re m

    ay be 

    some cost sa

    ving

    s to redu

    ce th

    is to 1'.

    Warne

    r Larson

    Ope

    n

    6.0.21

    L201

    7/19

    /201

    9Project tea

    m to

     con

    firm DPW

     Dire

    ctor re

    ceived

    /reviewed

     David W

    arne

    r's 

    email regarding

     durab

    le paint produ

    ct fo

    r play area

    s.Warne

    r Larson

    Ope

    n

    6.0.22

    L201

    7/19

    /201

    9Similarly

     to 6.0.22 ab

    ove, please ha

    ve project te

    am con

    firm design of 

    wall/s

    tairs by play area (horizon

    tal "clim

    bing

    " tran

    sverse wall? M

    ural? Etc)

    Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    6.0.23

    L201

    7/19

    /201

    9Pe

    r disc

    ussio

    ns at 6

    /7/19 Playgrou

    nd Design mee

    ting, W

    arne

    r Larson to 

    investigate/verify that 8' slid

    es can

     be prov

    ided

     ILO 6' slid

    es fo

    r main play 

    area

    .Warne

    r Larson

    Ope

    n

    7.0 Structural

    7.0.1

    S101

    A, S10

    1B2/22

    /201

    9

    Footing siz

    es do no

    t app

    ear to match Structural R

    eport include

    d in SD 

    subm

    ittal to

     MSB

    A. For example, in

    terio

    r foo

    tings (F

    8) are 8’ x 8’ x 2’; 

    structural re

    port in

    clud

    ed in

     SD indicates the

    y shou

    ld be 9’x9’x2’. A

    ppea

    rs 

    F8 and

     F9 may be flipp

    ed.

    EDG

    The plan

    s sho

    w th

    e revised footing siz

    es. Since th

    e SD

     subm

    ission, th

    e footing siz

    es have be

    en re

    vised ba

    sed on

     the curren

    t colum

    n layo

    ut.

    Closed

    7.0.2

    S008

    , S20

    1‐S303

    , S40

    3, 

    S501

    , 2/22

    /201

    9Plea

    se labe

    l all de

    tails.

    EDG

    Only the typical d

    etails that have no

    t bee

    n cut o

    n plan

    s are title

    d. The

     section de

    tails are not title

    d as th

    ey are re

    ferenced

     on the plan

    s.Closed

    7.0.3

    S102

    B, S10

    3A, 

    and S103

    B7/12

    /201

    9

    Slab

     on de

    ck th

    ickn

    esses a

    re not clearly id

    entified on

     structural floo

    r plans. 

    The tw

    o‐way arrow

     show

    n on

     the sla

    b on

     deck flo

    or plans sh

    ould be 

    includ

    s in the no

    tes/key iden

    tifying

     the wha

    t makes up thickn

    esses 

    indicates (i.e

    . 5‐1/4", 3", etc)

    EDG

    Ope

    n

    7.0.4

    Gen

    eral

    7/19

    /201

    9At th

    e DD

     cost e

    stim

    ate reconciliation, cost e

    stim

    ators ide

    ntified

     spray FP 

    requ

    iremen

    ts as v

    ague

    . Tap

    pe to

     clarify/verify that in

    tumescent only 

    requ

    ired on

     prim

    ary structure pe

    rimeter & trusses.

    Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    8.0 Eq

    uipm

    ent

    8.0.1

    Q10

    1B, typ

    ical

    2/22

    /201

    9Draw

    ings sh

    ow th

    at 2 cha

    rging stations will be ad

    ded to each classroo

    m. IT 

    Director Colby

     Cou

    sens in

    dicated that th

    e distric

    t owns cha

    rging stations 

    that can

     be brou

    ght to ne

    w sc

    hool. W

    e shou

    ld con

    firm th

    is with

     Keith.

    Tapp

    elocatio

    ns on plan

    s are sh

    own so th

    at pow

    er can

     be prov

    ided

     for the

     charging

     stations. Exten

    t of o

    wne

    r provide

     vs n

    ew to

     TBD

    Ope

    Page 7 of 8

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Item No.

    Ref.

    Date Ope

    ned

    Review

     Com

    men

    tAc

    tion by

    Commen

    t Respo

    nse

    Status

    8.0.2

    Q10

    1B, typ

    ical

    7/19

    /201

    9Pe

    r disc

    ussio

    ns at the

     7/1/19 techno

    logy design mee

    ting with

     DPS

    , Tap

    pe 

    to in

    vestigate locatio

    n for "

    chill out boo

    th" (sensory).

    Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    8.0.3

    Gen

    eral

    7/19

    /201

    9(M

    inor) F

    riend

    ly re

    minde

    r, pe

    r disc

    ussio

    ns at 6

    /7/19 Land

    scap

    e de

    sign 

    mee

    ting, DPW

     requ

    ested ne

    w so

    ccer nets include

    d in project sc

    ope.

    Tapp

    eOpe

    n

    9.0 Plum

    bing

    9.0.1

    P101

    A7/17

    /201

    9Sh

    ould add

    ition

    al floo

    r drains b

    e ad

    ded in th

    e Janitor/Cu

    stod

    ial R

    ooms 

    (Jan 15

    9, Custodial Storage 152

    , Custodial W

    orksho

    p 15

    1)?

    AEI

    Ope

    n

    Page 8 of 8

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Smith

    Ele

    men

    tary

    Sch

    ool

    W.T

    . Rich

    Des

    ign

    Revi

    ew o

    f 60%

    Con

    stru

    ctio

    n Do

    cum

    ents

    dat

    ed 6

    /27/

    19

    No.

    Spec

    Sec

    tion

    Num

    ber

    Draw

    ing

    Page

    No

    .

    Loca

    tion

    / Det

    ail #

    / Ro

    om #

    / Co

    l Lin

    e /

    Para

    grap

    h #

    Impo

    rtan

    ceCo

    mm

    ent /

    Issu

    e / Q

    uest

    ion

    Sour

    ceDr

    awin

    g.

    Set

    Cons

    ulta

    ntDe

    sign

    Team

    Res

    pons

    e or

    Com

    men

    tsSt

    atus

    1TO

    CSe

    ctio

    ns 0

    7710

    0, 0

    7720

    0, a

    nd 0

    8630

    0 sh

    ould

    be

    part

    of T

    B 07

    0002

    HME

    DD S

    et&

    60

    % C

    DW

    TRNo

    FSB

    . Will

    be

    assig

    ned

    to G

    C; E

    xpec

    t to

    cost

    mor

    e if

    not b

    id

    by ro

    ofer

    .Op

    en

    2TO

    CSe

    ctio

    ns 0

    8411

    0, 0

    8441

    0, a

    nd 0

    8451

    3 sh

    ould

    be

    part

    of T

    B 08

    0001

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRAg

    reed

    . Cur

    rent

    ly in

    clude

    d in

    FSB

    080

    001.

    close

    d

    3TO

    CSe

    ctio

    n 09

    6510

    shou

    ld b

    e pa

    rt o

    f TB

    0900

    05HM

    EDD

    1/3

    0/19

    WTR

    Agre

    ed. C

    urre

    ntly

    inclu

    ded

    at h

    eadi

    ng in

    sect

    ion

    0965

    10. W

    ill

    add

    to T

    OC.

    close

    d

    400

    3132

    Rem

    embe

    r to

    inclu

    de G

    eote

    chni

    cal r

    ecco

    men

    datio

    ns a

    s par

    t of

    this

    spec

    ifica

    tion.

    Thi

    s is i

    mpo

    rtan

    t as i

    t out

    lines

    wha

    t typ

    e of

    so

    il ca

    n be

    use

    d w

    here

    . Thi

    s will

    ass

    ist in

    the

    Site

    Sub

    . bid

    ding

    pr

    oces

    s. Th

    is w

    ill b

    e re

    quire

    d fo

    r ERP

    -1

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TR

    Subs

    urfa

    ce a

    nd la

    b te

    st d

    ata

    are

    inclu

    ded

    in th

    e sp

    ec.

    Inte

    rpre

    tatio

    ns sh

    ould

    be

    mad

    e ba

    sed

    on th

    is da

    ta.

    All r

    epor

    ts a

    re li

    sted

    in th

    e Su

    bsur

    face

    Dat

    a se

    ctio

    n an

    d co

    pies

    ca

    n be

    obt

    aine

    d by

    the

    bidd

    ers f

    rom

    Wes

    ton

    & S

    amps

    on u

    pon

    requ

    est.

    close

    d

    501

    1000

    Gene

    ral

    Chan

    ge LE

    ED to

    CHP

    SHM

    EDD

    Set

    &

    60%

    CD

    WTR

    upda

    ted

    for E

    R-1.

    No

    chan

    ged

    for 6

    0% C

    DOp

    en

    601

    1000

    Sect

    . 1.1

    Add

    Stru

    ctur

    al S

    teel

    and

    Con

    cret

    e. W

    e ha

    ve fo

    und

    in th

    e pa

    st

    that

    hav

    ing

    the

    EOR

    and

    Arch

    itect

    at t

    hese

    mee

    tings

    is m

    ost

    bene

    ficia

    l. HM

    EDD

    1/3

    0/19

    WTR

    We

    will

    hav

    e ou

    r con

    sulta

    nts a

    vaila

    ble

    for t

    he m

    eetin

    gsCl

    osed

    701

    1000

    Sect

    . 1.1

    5

    This

    sect

    ion

    is no

    t who

    lly cl

    ear.

    I bel

    ieve

    that

    all

    prop

    rieta

    ry

    item

    s mus

    t be

    clear

    ly id

    entif

    ied

    in th

    e Co

    ntra

    ct D

    ocum

    ents

    . If

    they

    are

    not

    and

    one

    man

    ufac

    ture

    r is s

    pecif

    ied,

    this

    is ta

    ken

    as

    the

    basis

    of d

    esig

    n an

    d th

    e su

    bcon

    trac

    tor h

    as th

    e rig

    ht to

    subm

    it an

    as e

    qual

    with

    out r

    eque

    stin

    g a

    subs

    titut

    ion.

    Onl

    y w

    hen

    thre

    e m

    anuf

    actu

    rers

    are

    spec

    ified

    and

    the

    subc

    ontr

    acto

    r wish

    es to

    us

    e an

    alte

    rnat

    e m

    anuf

    actu

    rer i

    s a su

    bstit

    utio

    n re

    ques

    t re

    quire

    d.

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRTh

    is se

    ctio

    n w

    as re

    vise

    d fo

    r ER-

    1. A

    ny p

    ropr

    ieta

    ry it

    ems w

    ill b

    e id

    entif

    ied

    if re

    quire

    d as

    we

    prog

    ress

    thro

    ugh

    CD's

    Clos

    ed

    801

    1000

    Sect

    . 1.2

    .CFi

    lling

    this

    in w

    ill n

    eed

    to b

    e a

    team

    effo

    rt R

    e: it

    ems b

    y Ow

    ner.

    HME

    DD S

    et&

    60

    % C

    DW

    TRDE

    LETE

    D IN

    ER-

    1 SP

    EC. R

    evisi

    ted

    in 6

    0%. C

    omm

    ent s

    till a

    pplie

    s.Op

    en

    901

    1000

    Sect

    . 1.2

    .DPl

    ease

    conf

    irm S

    ectio

    n 1.

    2.D.

    1HM

    EDD

    Set

    &

    60%

    CD

    WTR

    Revi

    sed

    in E

    R-1

    spec

    . Rev

    ision

    not

    carr

    ied

    to 6

    0%.

    Open

    1001

    1000

    Sect

    . 1.8

    .AOn

    ce th

    e SO

    V is

    set/

    appr

    oved

    , it s

    houl

    d no

    t be

    upda

    ted.

    Onl

    y co

    ntra

    ct m

    odifi

    catio

    n sh

    ould

    be

    adde

    d vi

    a CO

    . Ple

    ase

    conf

    irm

    this

    is th

    e in

    tent

    .HM

    EDD

    Set

    &

    60%

    CD

    WTR

    NEED

    S TO

    BE

    UPDA

    TED

    AS O

    THER

    PAC

    KAGE

    S AR

    E AD

    DED

    / BID

    Op

    en

    1101

    1000

    Sect

    . 1.9

    .ATh

    is Se

    ctio

    n re

    ques

    ts a

    Lien

    Wai

    ver.

    Cann

    ot li

    en a

    pub

    lic p

    roje

    ct.

    HME

    DD S

    et&

    60

    % C

    DW

    TRre

    mov

    ed in

    ER-

    1 Re

    visio

    n no

    t car

    ried

    in 6

    0%Op

    en

    1201

    1000

    Sect

    . 1.9

    .D.1

    0Ch

    ange

    LEED

    to C

    HPS

    HME

    DD S

    et&

    60

    % C

    DW

    TRRe

    vise

    d in

    ER-

    1 sp

    ec R

    evisi

    on n

    ot ca

    rrie

    d in

    60%

    Open

    1301

    2200

    S001

    Unit

    Price

    sSh

    ould

    this

    be p

    art o

    f thi

    s con

    trac

    t? T

    o be

    disc

    usse

    d w

    ith th

    e te

    am. S

    eem

    s tha

    t Ite

    ms 2

    -4 sh

    ould

    be

    inclu

    ded.

    HME

    DD S

    et&

    60

    % C

    DW

    TRun

    it pr

    ices a

    re b

    eing

    rem

    oved

    . CM

    shou

    ld in

    clude

    in th

    e GM

    P th

    e pr

    oper

    allo

    wan

    ce fo

    r the

    se ty

    pes o

    f ite

    ms.

    Add

    unit

    price

    s fo

    r aba

    tem

    ent (

    eg a

    sbes

    tos l

    ined

    pip

    e)?

    Ope

    n

    1401

    4320

    Gene

    ral

    Just

    thro

    win

    g th

    is on

    e ou

    t the

    re…

    can

    we

    inco

    rpor

    ate

    a m

    atrix

    of

    who

    ow

    ns w

    hat i

    nspe

    ctio

    ns in

    to th

    is se

    ctio

    n. T

    his a

    lway

    s see

    ms

    to b

    e an

    exe

    rcise

    bet

    wee

    n th

    e OP

    M a

    nd th

    e CM

    onc

    e th

    e pr

    ojec

    t has

    star

    ted.

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRPe

    r 1.4

    B th

    e CM

    is re

    spon

    sible

    to su

    bmit

    a sc

    heud

    lue.

    Ple

    ase

    star

    t the

    mat

    rix a

    nd th

    en p

    ass a

    long

    to th

    e OM

    P an

    d de

    sing

    team

    .C

    lose

    d

    Gene

    ral N

    otes

    on

    Desig

    n Re

    view

    :

    Smith

    - 60

    % D

    esig

    n R

    evie

    w -M

    aste

    r MSB

    A .x

    lsx

    1 of

    24

    7/24

    /201

    9

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Smith

    Ele

    men

    tary

    Sch

    ool

    W.T

    . Rich

    Des

    ign

    Revi

    ew o

    f 60%

    Con

    stru

    ctio

    n Do

    cum

    ents

    dat

    ed 6

    /27/

    19

    No.

    Spec

    Sec

    tion

    Num

    ber

    Draw

    ing

    Page

    No

    .

    Loca

    tion

    / Det

    ail #

    / Ro

    om #

    / Co

    l Lin

    e /

    Para

    grap

    h #

    Impo

    rtan

    ceCo

    mm

    ent /

    Issu

    e / Q

    uest

    ion

    Sour

    ceDr

    awin

    g.

    Set

    Cons

    ulta

    ntDe

    sign

    Team

    Res

    pons

    e or

    Com

    men

    tsSt

    atus

    Gene

    ral N

    otes

    on

    Desig

    n Re

    view

    :

    1501

    8120

    Sect

    . 1.3

    .ACh

    ange

    to n

    o sm

    okin

    g on

    scho

    ol p

    rope

    rty

    HME

    DD S

    et&

    60

    % C

    DW

    TRAg

    reed

    . Will

    revi

    se.R

    evisi

    on n

    ot ca

    rrie

    d in

    60%

    Open

    1602

    4100

    Gene

    ral

    Rem

    inde

    r- Al

    l Sub

    -Bid

    trad

    es w

    ill b

    e re

    quire

    d to

    cut/

    cap/

    mak

    e sa

    fe a

    ll ex

    istin

    g ut

    ilitie

    s in

    and

    arou

    nd th

    e to

    be

    dem

    olish

    ed

    scho

    ol. T

    his n

    eeds

    to b

    e in

    corp

    orea

    ted

    into

    thei

    r spe

    cifica

    tions

    . HM

    EDD

    1/3

    0/19

    WTR

    will

    coor

    d. w

    ith a

    ll co

    nsul

    tant

    s to

    inclu

    de in

    thei

    r spe

    csclo

    sed

    1702

    4100

    Sect

    . 3.4

    .A.2

    Plea

    se co

    nfirm

    fire

    wat

    ch d

    urat

    ion

    HME

    DD S

    et&

    60

    % C

    DW

    TRth

    is is

    adeq

    uate

    for u

    s. W

    ill co

    nfirm

    if a

    ccep

    tabl

    e to

    the

    tow

    n.Op

    en

    1802

    4100

    Sect

    . 3.5

    .CPl

    ease

    conf

    irm. P

    er o

    ur G

    eote

    ch m

    eetin

    g on

    2/1

    2- fo

    unda

    tions

    w

    ere

    to b

    e re

    mov

    ed a

    tleas

    t 24"

    from

    bel

    ow su

    rface

    exc

    ept a

    t de

    tent

    ion

    area

    s whe

    re it

    wou

    ld n

    eed

    to b

    e fu

    ll re

    mov

    alHM

    EDD

    1/3

    0/19

    WTR

    spec

    to b

    e up

    date

    dCl

    osed

    1902

    4100

    Sect

    . 3.5

    .D&

    ESe

    ctio

    ns D

    &E

    are

    redu

    ndan

    t.HM

    EDD

    1/3

    0/19

    WTR

    will

    upd

    ate

    for 6

    0% C

    D Es

    t Sub

    miss

    ion

    Clos

    ed

    2003

    3000

    Sect

    2.3

    Sect

    ion

    does

    not

    corr

    espo

    nd to

    requ

    irem

    ents

    show

    n on

    Dw

    g S0

    01HM

    EDD

    Set

    &

    60%

    CD

    WTR

    Inclu

    ded.

    See

    1.2

    -11.

    Dra

    win

    gs a

    nd th

    e sp

    ecifi

    ctio

    ns w

    ill b

    e ed

    ited

    for c

    omfo

    rmat

    ion

    of th

    e tw

    o do

    cum

    ents

    Revi

    sions

    not

    carr

    ied

    in 6

    0%.

    Open

    2103

    3000

    Sect

    . 1.2

    Plea

    se a

    dd u

    nder

    slab

    insu

    latio

    n as

    scop

    e w

    ork

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRIn

    clude

    d in

    MSB

    A DD

    subm

    isssio

    n. S

    ee 1

    .2-1

    1Cl

    osed

    2203

    3000

    Sect

    . 2.2

    Add

    Barr

    ier O

    ne?

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRYe

    s. In

    clude

    d In

    clude

    d in

    MSB

    A DD

    subm

    isssio

    n. S

    ee 2

    .2F.

    5.Cl

    osed

    2303

    3000

    Sect

    . 3.1

    2Pl

    ease

    pro

    vide

    fnish

    es fo

    r equ

    ipm

    ent s

    labs

    and

    oth

    er h

    orizo

    ntal

    ex

    pose

    d fin

    ishes

    that

    are

    not

    cont

    aine

    d w

    ithin

    g th

    e ex

    terio

    r co

    ncre

    te sp

    ecifi

    catio

    n.

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRse

    vera

    l fin

    ishes

    show

    n in

    3.1

    2. A

    dvise

    if re

    ques

    ted

    is no

    t list

    ed.

    Clos

    ed

    2403

    3515

    Gene

    ral

    Is th

    is Se

    ctio

    n re

    leva

    nt. N

    ot sh

    own

    in fi

    nish

    sche

    dule

    .HM

    EDD

    Set

    &

    60%

    CD

    WTR

    Yes.

    See

    floor

    fini

    sh a

    t STE

    AM 2

    02 o

    n A6

    03. E

    xpen

    sive

    and

    not

    man

    y su

    bs o

    ut th

    ere

    who

    per

    form

    . Rec

    onsid

    er?

    Open

    2505

    1200

    Gene

    ral

    Inclu

    de fu

    rnish

    and

    inst

    alla

    tion

    of th

    erm

    al b

    reak

    s tha

    t are

    in

    regr

    al to

    the

    stru

    ctur

    al st

    eel i

    nsta

    llatio

    n.

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRPa

    ds fo

    r the

    rmal

    bre

    ak a

    re n

    ot u

    sed

    in a

    ny d

    etai

    ls fo

    r the

    pr

    ojec

    t.Cl

    osed

    .

    2605

    5100

    A574

    Genr

    eral

    Plea

    se p

    rovi

    de sp

    ecifi

    catio

    n fo

    r 2" w

    elde

    d w

    ire m

    esh

    for s

    tair

    guar

    drai

    l sys

    tem

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRW

    ill a

    dd to

    spec

    for 6

    0% C

    D Es

    t Sub

    miss

    ion

    Clos

    ed

    2705

    5100

    L502

    Deta

    ils 3

    & 7

    Need

    mat

    eria

    l size

    s for

    raili

    ngs

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRw

    ill u

    pdat

    e fo

    r 60%

    CD

    Est S

    ubm

    issio

    nCl

    osed

    2807

    7200

    A121

    BSk

    ylig

    htTh

    ere

    is no

    det

    ail o

    r spe

    cifica

    tion

    for t

    he A

    lum

    inum

    Sky

    light

    Sy

    stem

    nor

    the

    skyl

    ight

    at C

    L N.1

    -4.2

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRse

    e se

    ctio

    ns 0

    8620

    0 an

    d 08

    6300

    Clos

    ed

    2931

    2000

    Sect

    . 1.3

    ..A.4

    All s

    ubm

    ittal

    s nee

    d to

    be

    stam

    ped

    by a

    PE?

    Is th

    is al

    l inc

    lusiv

    e?HM

    EDD

    1/3

    0/19

    WTR

    Subm

    ittal

    s for

    des

    ign

    of e

    xcav

    atio

    n su

    ppor

    t and

    dew

    ater

    ing

    (whe

    re

    desig

    ned

    by a

    PE)

    requ

    ire a

    PE

    stam

    p. O

    ther

    s do

    not.

    Clos

    ed

    3031

    2500

    Gene

    ral

    Chan

    ge LE

    ED R

    ef. t

    o CH

    PSHM

    EDD

    1/3

    0/19

    WTR

    upda

    ted

    in E

    R-1

    Clos

    ed

    3132

    1313

    Sect

    . 1.3

    The

    stip

    ulat

    ions

    of t

    his s

    ectio

    n m

    ay sc

    are

    off s

    ome

    pote

    ntia

    l bi

    dder

    s. Th

    is pa

    ckag

    e is

    norm

    ally

    bou

    ght o

    ut w

    ith th

    e st

    ruct

    ural

    co

    ncrt

    ete

    pack

    age.

    Any

    way

    to re

    duce

    the

    requ

    irem

    ents

    or m

    ake

    them

    a b

    it m

    ore

    cond

    ition

    al?

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRW

    e ha

    ve sp

    ecia

    lty p

    avin

    g on

    this

    proj

    ect.

    Our

    list

    of q

    uals

    will

    re

    mai

    nCl

    osed

    3232

    1313

    Sect

    . 1.3

    .BCo

    rdin

    ate

    w/ S

    dra

    win

    gsHM

    EDD

    1/3

    0/19

    WTR

    No n

    eed

    for c

    oord

    inat

    ion

    betw

    een

    pavi

    ng a

    nd st

    ruct

    ural

    .Cl

    osed

    Smith

    - 60

    % D

    esig

    n R

    evie

    w -M

    aste

    r MSB

    A .x

    lsx

    2 of

    24

    7/24

    /201

    9

  • MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS

    Smith

    Ele

    men

    tary

    Sch

    ool

    W.T

    . Rich

    Des

    ign

    Revi

    ew o

    f 60%

    Con

    stru

    ctio

    n Do

    cum

    ents

    dat

    ed 6

    /27/

    19

    No.

    Spec

    Sec

    tion

    Num

    ber

    Draw

    ing

    Page

    No

    .

    Loca

    tion

    / Det

    ail #

    / Ro

    om #

    / Co

    l Lin

    e /

    Para

    grap

    h #

    Impo

    rtan

    ceCo

    mm

    ent /

    Issu

    e / Q

    uest

    ion

    Sour

    ceDr

    awin

    g.

    Set

    Cons

    ulta

    ntDe

    sign

    Team

    Res

    pons

    e or

    Com

    men

    tsSt

    atus

    Gene

    ral N

    otes

    on

    Desig

    n Re

    view

    :

    3332

    1313

    Gene

    ral

    Colo

    red

    conc

    rete

    wal

    kway

    s may

    resu

    lt in

    cost

    incr

    ease

    s. Sh

    ould

    be

    iden

    tifie

    d by

    ERP

    -02

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRsp

    ecia

    lty p

    avin

    g ha

    s bee

    n id

    entif

    ied

    on th

    e M

    SBA

    DD d

    raw

    ings

    20

    19-0

    2-28

    Clos

    ed

    3432

    1313

    Sect

    . 2.5

    This

    sect

    ion

    shou

    ld b

    elon

    g to

    the

    WDC

    File

    d su

    b-bi

    d. M

    ost

    conc

    rete

    subs

    will

    exc

    lude

    this

    wor

    k.

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRW

    e di

    ssag

    gree

    . Jo

    int s

    ealin

    g is

    part

    of t

    he sc

    ope

    of w

    ork

    that

    a

    conc

    rete

    pav

    ing

    cont

    ract

    or w

    ill o

    wn.

    Clos

    ed

    3532

    1400

    Sect

    . 2.3

    Sect

    . 2.3

    refe

    renc

    es w

    eeps

    . Dra

    win

    g L5

    00 d

    oesn

    ot d

    epict

    thes

    e.

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TRW

    eeps

    are

    not

    par

    t of t

    he d

    esig

    n. W

    eeps

    will

    be

    rem

    oved

    from

    th

    e sp

    ec se

    ctio

    nCl

    osed

    3632

    1816

    L201

    Stag

    e En

    larg

    emen

    tW

    ill th

    ere

    be m

    ultip

    le th

    ickne

    sses

    with

    in th

    e po

    ured

    in p

    lace

    ru

    bber

    safe

    ty su

    rfacin

    g? A

    fall

    zone

    is in

    dica

    ted,

    but

    di

    ffere

    ntia

    ted

    dept

    hs a

    re n

    ot in

    dica

    ted.

    HME

    DD 1

    /30/

    19W

    TR

    Yes,

    The

    re w

    ill b

    e va

    rious

    PIP

    thick

    ness

    es.

    Play