ivan g. smith elementary school€¦ · cover letter from owner’s project manager section 1 opm...
TRANSCRIPT
-
MSBA 60% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SUBMISSION
IVAN G. SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLD
AN
VERS, MA
SSAC
HU
SETTS
JULY 26, 2019
-
JULY 26, 2019
MSBA 60% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS SUBMISSION IVAN G. SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
DANVERS, MASSACHUSETTS
ARCHITECT
OWNER’S PROJECT MANAGER
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
35 Braintree Hill Office Park, Suite 300 Braintree, MA 02184
Tel: 781.794.1404 Fax: 781.794.1405
www.pmaconsultants.com
July 26, 2019 Michael McGurl - Project Coordinator Massachusetts School Building Authority 40 Broad Street, Suite 500 Boston, MA 02109
RE: Smith Elementary School Project 60% Construction Documents Submittal
Dear Mr. McGurl:
On behalf of the Town of Danvers, attached please find our 60% Construction Documents (CD) Submittal for the Ivan G. Smith Elementary School Project. This submittal has been compiled by Tappe Architects in collaboration with PMA Consultants, W.T. Rich, Town, School, and DPW administration with input from the Smith School Building Committee. Please note that the Smith School Building Committee unanimously voted to approve submittal of the 60% CD package to the MSBA on 7/26/2019. PMA has coordinated and reviewed the materials within and finds this submittal to be complete and in accordance with all MSBA requirements.
As previously stated, the project team has benefitted from the Town of Danvers’ experience with public school construction projects. PMA (OPM), W.T. Rich (CMR), and the Danvers DPW/Engineering/School Departments have provided a continual review of the drawings as they progressed. Throughout the design process, recommendations to the architect by the OPM and CMR have included those pertaining to constructability, operability, bid-ability, clarity, site logistics, technical accuracy, efficiency, coordination, and cost effectiveness. Tappe has continued to do a great job of immediately incorporating input into the drawings. Regarding the 60% CD Pricing Set, PMA’s in-house licensed Professional Mechanical Engineer provided an updated review, multiple PMA Project Managers reviewed the documents, Colliers (Cx Agent) has provided review comments, and W.T. Rich has provided preliminary review comments. The Proposed Project as documented within the 60% CD submittal is within the District's Budget as outlined in the MSBA Project Scope & Budget Agreement and MSBA Project Funding Agreement. The project schedule remains mostly unchanged from the Design Development (DD) submission with the addition of actualized task completion dates. Per MSBA requirements, the MSBA’s DD Review and the project team’s response is included in this package. We look forward to the MSBA's review of this submission. As always, please feel free to contact me with any questions or concerns.
Best Regards,
Joseph DeSantis Senior Associate PMA Consultants – OPM
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
CONTENTSCOVER LETTER FROM OWNER’S PROJECT MANAGER
SECTION 1 OPM DELIVERABLES 1.1 REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF DESIGNER SUBMISSION 1.2 COORDINATION REVIEW 1.3 COMMISSIONING CONSULTANTS REVIEW 1.4 MSBA SD REVIEW COMMENTS AND DISTRICT RESPONSE 1.5 UPDATED PROJECT SCHEDULE 1.6 LETTER CONFIRMING PROJECT REVIEW FROM STATE AGENCIES
SECTION 2 SCOPE AND BUDGET 2.1 SCOPE AND BUDGET NARRATIVE 2.2 RECONCILED CONSTRUCTION MANAGER @ RISK COST ESTIMATE 2.3 UPDATED TOTAL PROJECT BUDGET
SECTION 3 DESIGNER DELIVERABLES 3.1 UPDATED WORK PLAN 3.2 BASIS OF DESIGN NARRATIVES 3.3 UPDATED BUILDING CODE ANALYSIS 3.4 PROPRIETARY ITEMS 3.5 INTERIOR COLOR THEORY STATEMENT 3.6 STRUCTURAL DESIGN NARRATIVE 3.7 STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS AND FLOOR LOADS 3.8 CONFIRMATION OF STRUCTURAL DESIGN REVIEW PROCESS 3.9 ENERGY CALCULATIONS 3.10 LIFE CYCLE COST ANALYSIS FOR ENERGY AND WATER 3.11 HEAT GAIN AND LOSS CALCULATIONS FOR HVAC 3.12 ELECTRICAL LOAD CALCULATIONS 3.13 SECURITY AND VISUAL ACCESS REQUIREMENTS 3.14 QUALITY CONTROL STATEMENT 3.15 APPROVAL STATUS 3.16 RECONCILED DESIGNER ESTIMATE
SECTION 4 SPACE TEMPLATE 4.1 SPACE TEMPLATE 4.2 SPACE TEMPLATE CERTIFICATION 4.3 DESE SUBMISSION
APPENDIX APPENDIX 60% CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS (UNDER SEPARATE COVER) 60% PROJECT MANUAL (UNDER SEPARATE COVER)
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
OPM DELIVERABLES
1
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
1.1REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF DESIGNER SUBMISSION
OPM DELIVERABLES
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
As outlined in the OPM cover letter, PMA has reviewed and fully recommends/approves this 60% CD submission to the MSBA. PMA has verified that this submittal is in accordance with the MSBA Module 6 60% CD Guidelines. This submission was approved unanimously by the Smith School Building Committee on 7/26/2019.
1.1 OPM RECOMMENDATION TO APPROVE SUBMISSION
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
1.2COORDINATION REVIEW
OPM DELIVERABLES
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Date:
Project:
Subject:
Prep
ared
by:
Distribution:
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
1.0 Archite
ctural
1.0.1
FS‐101
A9/25
/201
8Co
ordina
te lo
catio
n of con
densing un
its fo
r cold room
s, as req
uired
(exterior o
r roo
f mou
nted
?).
Tapp
e10
/22/18
: Typ
ically ro
of m
ounted
Closed
1.0.2
A201
– A20
2;
A302
9/25
/201
8Co
ordina
te heigh
t of roo
f scree
n with
Mecha
nical equ
ipmen
t heigh
ts.
Tapp
e10
/22/18
: Once fin
al equ
ipmen
t sizing is complete this will be po
ssible.
Ope
n
1.0.3
AD10
0; E‐001
2/22
/201
9Ve
rify prop
osed
pha
sing plan
s match W
T Rich pha
sing plan
s (than
ks fo
r ad
ding
note ab
out tem
porary byp
ass). V
erify
Electric
al Early Site
Plan E‐
001 matches as w
ell.
Tapp
e3/12
/19: Pha
sing plan
s & Early Site
Elect plan ha
ve bee
n coordina
ted with
WT Rich per th
eir review com
men
ts fo
r ER1
Closed
1.0.4
A401
, A40
22/22
/201
9FYI, verified that bathroo
ms h
ave at least 5
’ of tile per Owne
r’s re
quest a
t 2/14
/19 fin
ishes re
view
mee
ting.
Tapp
e(non
e requ
ired)
Closed
1.0.5
A419
2/22
/201
9Gym
cou
rt lo
go sh
ould be confirm
ed by To
wn.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: tow
n comfirmed
bulldog
logo
at 0
1/23
/19 prog
amming mee
ting
Closed
1.0.6
A411
2/22
/201
9De
tail D1
– Forum
stair. To
be mod
ified
per 2/14/19
mee
ting with
owne
r. Re
mov
e carpet and
cha
nge riser m
aterial from woo
d.Tapp
e03
/05/19
: lineo
lum trea
ds with
woo
d risers is w
hat is c
urrently in
the
MSB
A DD
subm
ission.
Closed
1.0.7
A200
2/22
/201
9De
tail C1
– M
ain en
tran
ce: C
onsid
er add
ing windo
w to
wall abo
ve
cafeteria
per con
versation at 2/14/19
mee
ting.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: add
tiona
l high windo
ws will be ad
ded to th
e cafeteria
for the
60
% CD subm
ission
Closed
1.0.8
A200
2/22
/201
9De
tail C1
– M
ain en
tran
ce: C
onsid
er re
visin
g material o
f exterior w
all
abov
e cafeteria
per con
versation at 2/14/19
mee
ting.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: materail cha
nging to m
ason
ry ven
eer
Closed
1.0.9
A, Gen
eral
2/22
/201
9Plea
se con
firm ro
om num
bers m
atch plan discussed with
Assistan
t Su
perin
tend
ent.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
:Roo
m num
bers m
atch wha
t was app
roved by
the Assistan
t Su
perin
tend
ent.
Closed
1.0.10
A202
2/22
/201
9Discussed ha
ving
6’ b
ullet resistan
t glass in
fron
t of cafeteria with
Keith at
9/5/18
mee
ting.
Tapp
eCW
12 currently sc
hedu
led to have insulated security glazing
Closed
1.0.11
A101
B2/22
/201
9De
tail C1
– Tha
nk you
for rem
oving carpet from
project areas per David
Lane
& Tracey Mara.
Tapp
e(non
e requ
ired)
Closed
1.0.12
A101
A2/22
/201
9Kitche
n / K
itche
n toilet layou
ts: T
hank
you
cha
nging access to
Toilet R
m
#157
, as d
iscussed at 8/28/18
mee
ting with
Dan
vers Foo
d Service Director. Tapp
e(non
e requ
ired)
Closed
1.0.13
A101
B2/22
/201
9Discussed ad
ding
com
mun
icative do
or betwee
n Kind
ergarten
classroom
s at 1/23/19
staff w
orksho
ps. P
lease revise fo
r next sub
miss
ion, or a
dvise
if
not p
ossib
le.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: doo
rs were ad
ded for the
MSB
A DD
Sub
miss
ion
Closed
1.0.14
A417
2/22
/201
9De
tail A1
– W
hy th
e curved
corne
r?Tapp
e03
/05/19
: corne
r is c
urved to in
crea
se use writea
ble wall surface in
corne
r an
d increa
se collabo
ratio
nClosed
Tapp
e – Ch
arlie Hay & M
att B
arnh
art
DAN
VER
S IV
AN G
. SM
ITH
ELE
MEN
TAR
Y –
DD
REV
IEW
CO
MM
ENTS
July 19, 201
9
Danv
ers Ivan G. Smith
Elemen
tary Schoo
l
60% CD Pricing Set ‐ PMA Re
view
Com
men
ts (6
/27/19
set)
PMA Co
nsultants
Page 1 of 8
Date:
Project:
Subject:
Prep
ared
by:
Distribution:
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
1.0 Archite
ctural
1.0.1
FS‐101
A9/25
/201
8Co
ordina
te lo
catio
n of con
densing un
its fo
r cold room
s, as req
uired
(exterior o
r roo
f mou
nted
?).
Tapp
e10
/22/18
: Typ
ically ro
of m
ounted
Closed
1.0.2
A201
– A20
2;
A302
9/25
/201
8Co
ordina
te heigh
t of roo
f scree
n with
Mecha
nical equ
ipmen
t heigh
ts.
Tapp
e10
/22/18
: Once fin
al equ
ipmen
t sizing is complete this will be po
ssible.
Ope
n
1.0.3
AD10
0; E‐001
2/22
/201
9Ve
rify prop
osed
pha
sing plan
s match W
T Rich pha
sing plan
s (than
ks fo
r ad
ding
note ab
out tem
porary byp
ass). V
erify
Electric
al Early Site
Plan E‐
001 matches as w
ell.
Tapp
e3/12
/19: Pha
sing plan
s & Early Site
Elect plan ha
ve bee
n coordina
ted with
WT Rich per th
eir review com
men
ts fo
r ER1
Closed
1.0.4
A401
, A40
22/22
/201
9FYI, verified that bathroo
ms h
ave at least 5
’ of tile per Owne
r’s re
quest a
t 2/14
/19 fin
ishes re
view
mee
ting.
Tapp
e(non
e requ
ired)
Closed
1.0.5
A419
2/22
/201
9Gym
cou
rt lo
go sh
ould be confirm
ed by To
wn.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: tow
n comfirmed
bulldog
logo
at 0
1/23
/19 prog
amming mee
ting
Closed
1.0.6
A411
2/22
/201
9De
tail D1
– Forum
stair. To
be mod
ified
per 2/14/19
mee
ting with
owne
r. Re
mov
e carpet and
cha
nge riser m
aterial from woo
d.Tapp
e03
/05/19
: lineo
lum trea
ds with
woo
d risers is w
hat is c
urrently in
the
MSB
A DD
subm
ission.
Closed
1.0.7
A200
2/22
/201
9De
tail C1
– M
ain en
tran
ce: C
onsid
er add
ing windo
w to
wall abo
ve
cafeteria
per con
versation at 2/14/19
mee
ting.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: add
tiona
l high windo
ws will be ad
ded to th
e cafeteria
for the
60
% CD subm
ission
Closed
1.0.8
A200
2/22
/201
9De
tail C1
– M
ain en
tran
ce: C
onsid
er re
visin
g material o
f exterior w
all
abov
e cafeteria
per con
versation at 2/14/19
mee
ting.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: materail cha
nging to m
ason
ry ven
eer
Closed
1.0.9
A, Gen
eral
2/22
/201
9Plea
se con
firm ro
om num
bers m
atch plan discussed with
Assistan
t Su
perin
tend
ent.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
:Roo
m num
bers m
atch wha
t was app
roved by
the Assistan
t Su
perin
tend
ent.
Closed
1.0.10
A202
2/22
/201
9Discussed ha
ving
6’ b
ullet resistan
t glass in
fron
t of cafeteria with
Keith at
9/5/18
mee
ting.
Tapp
eCW
12 currently sc
hedu
led to have insulated security glazing
Closed
1.0.11
A101
B2/22
/201
9De
tail C1
– Tha
nk you
for rem
oving carpet from
project areas per David
Lane
& Tracey Mara.
Tapp
e(non
e requ
ired)
Closed
1.0.12
A101
A2/22
/201
9Kitche
n / K
itche
n toilet layou
ts: T
hank
you
cha
nging access to
Toilet R
m
#157
, as d
iscussed at 8/28/18
mee
ting with
Dan
vers Foo
d Service Director. Tapp
e(non
e requ
ired)
Closed
1.0.13
A101
B2/22
/201
9Discussed ad
ding
com
mun
icative do
or betwee
n Kind
ergarten
classroom
s at 1/23/19
staff w
orksho
ps. P
lease revise fo
r next sub
miss
ion, or a
dvise
if
not p
ossib
le.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: doo
rs were ad
ded for the
MSB
A DD
Sub
miss
ion
Closed
1.0.14
A417
2/22
/201
9De
tail A1
– W
hy th
e curved
corne
r?Tapp
e03
/05/19
: corne
r is c
urved to in
crea
se use writea
ble wall surface in
corne
r an
d increa
se collabo
ratio
nClosed
Tapp
e – Ch
arlie Hay & M
att B
arnh
art
DAN
VER
S IV
AN G
. SM
ITH
ELE
MEN
TAR
Y –
DD
REV
IEW
CO
MM
ENTS
July 19, 201
9
Danv
ers Ivan G. Smith
Elemen
tary Schoo
l
60% CD Pricing Set ‐ PMA Re
view
Com
men
ts (6
/27/19
set)
PMA Co
nsultants
Page 1 of 8
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
1.0.15
A102
B2/22
/201
9No do
or to
5th grade
classroom
area en
tran
ce?
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: no do
or in
this locatio
n to kee
p the op
en con
nection to th
e core
elem
ents (toilet roo
ms, sm
all group
, STE
AM). It also
wou
ld nee
d to be a
dual egress d
oor, sw
inging
in both directions.
Closed
1.0.16
A102
2/22
/201
9(M
inor) d
oor swings to
enter acade
mic area ap
pear in
consisten
t. See
second
floo
r doo
r betwee
n Co
lumn lin
es H and
H.2.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: doo
r 201
has be revised to ope
n ou
tward into th
e STEA
M / Elev
Lobb
yClosed
1.0.17
A601
‐A60
32/22
/201
9Miss
ing windo
w sc
hedu
le?
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: Refer to
A52
1‐A5
23 fo
r windo
w ty
pes
Closed
1.0.18
A414
2/22
/201
9Ve
stibule @ M
ain en
tran
ce:
1.) Is th
is whe
re th
e salvaged
mosaic will go an
d no
t on the exterio
r of
the bu
ilding?
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: currently th
e salvaged
mosaic is located in th
e main en
try
vestibule. W
ill coo
rd. location with
FAA
P, buidling plan
s and
other item
s thea
t nee
d space on
this wall.
Closed
1.0.19
A414
2/22
/201
92.) Sho
uld confirm
size of teller w
indo
w @
3/5/19 Security mee
ting.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: pass thru windo
w was re
view
ed at the
security mee
ting an
d was
acceptab
le
Closed
1.0.20
A414
2/22
/201
93.) W
ill 4’ p
orcelain wall loo
k od
d if rest of schoo
l/area ha
s 3’ tile?
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: Tile heigh
ts to
be ap
prox. 3
'‐0" in th
e first floo
r clasroo
m wing,
and 5'‐0" in lo
bby, caféteria, and
second
floo
r classroom
wing.
Closed
1.0.21
A414
2/22
/201
94.) W
hy doe
s this v
estib
ule ha
ve a sk
ylight?
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: skylight is in
the en
try cano
py to
allo
w add
ition
al daylight
Closed
1.0.22
A001
2/22
/201
9Re
view
Rated
Wall A
ssem
bly legend
with
floo
rplans. C
onfirm 2‐hou
r rated
assembly prov
ided
for E
mergency Electrical Roo
ms.
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: 2hr ra
ting ad
ded to Emerg. Elect 135
A. Emerg. Elect. 2
03A
alread
y show
s 2hr ra
ting
Closed
1.0.23
A111
– A11
2B2/22
/201
9Co
ordina
te RCP
s with
MEP
locatio
ns (g
rilles, ligh
ting, te
lecomm devices,
etc.)
Tapp
e03
/05/19
: coo
rdination on
going for 6
0% CD subm
ission
Ope
n
1.02
4A1
01A,
A101
B, A10
2B7/11
/201
9Au
tomated
Externa
l Defibrillators (A
EDs) lo
catio
ns do no
t app
ear to be
show
n on
the flo
or plans
Tapp
eOpe
n
1.02
5A1
01A
7/11
/201
9Th
e exterio
r doo
r of A
rt Roo
m 167
is m
issing its doo
r designa
tion.
Tapp
eOpe
n
1.02
6A1
01A,
C3/A42
2,
E101
Al7/18
/201
9Plea
se con
firm Vestib
ule 14
9 ha
s a designa
ted light fixture. A ligh
t fixture
in th
is locatio
n is conflictin
g be
twee
n RC
P, eng
larged
RCP
, and
ligh
ting
plan
Tapp
e/AE
IOpe
n
1.02
7A1
1B7/18
/201
9Sh
ould a m
ounting he
ight be prov
ided
for light fixture ST2 in Stair 1 & 3?
Also, this fixture is not sh
own on
A11
BTapp
e/AE
IOpe
n
1.0.28
!603
7/19
/201
9Plea
se provide
finish m
aterial selectio
ns (e
.g. flooring & paint)
Tapp
e
1.0.29
Multip
le7/19
/201
9Plea
se have acou
stical con
sulta
nt re
view
staff b
athroo
m adjacen
cies and
verify ad
equa
te "acou
stical priv
acy" is provide
d. (S
taff ba
throom
s nea
r staff d
ining, etc.)
Tapp
eOpe
n
2.0 Plum
bing
/ Fire Protection
2.0.1
PFP‐20
1A &
C400
9/25
/201
8Plum
bing
or C
ivil coordina
ting be
low groun
d? Provide
und
ergrou
nd
utilitie
s plan.
AEI/ Nitsch
10/22/18
: Site
Utilities (1
0 ft outsid
e the bu
ilding) are sh
own on
civil site
utility plan (She
et C‐400
). Ong
oing
coo
rdination with
MEP
.Closed
2.0.2
P200
A2/22
/201
9Ad
ditio
nal floor drains req
uired in Cafeteria/ K
itche
n area
s?AE
IAll d
rains req
uired for IW con
nections have be
en in
clud
ed. Final
coordian
tion of all flo
or drains/flo
or sink
s in the kitche
n will occur during
the CD
design ph
ase.
Ope
n
2.0.3
P203
A –
P203
B2/22
/201
9Ad
ditio
nal roo
f drains req
uired at M
echa
nical equ
ipmen
t locations?
AEI
Fina
l roo
f drain lo
catio
ns will be coordian
ted with
the archite
ct and
mecha
ncial eng
inee
r during the CD
design ph
ase.
Ope
n
2.0.4
P‐ plans
2/22
/201
97/12
/201
9Miss
ing de
tails and
flow
diagram
s for Plumbing
. Flow diagram
s are st
ill
missing
from
the 60
% CD set.
AEI
Plum
bing
details are show
n on
drawing P‐60
0 of th
e DD
set. Flow
/rise
r diagrams w
ill be includ
ed as p
art o
f the
CD subm
ission.
Ope
n
Page 2 of 8
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
2.0.5
FP20
1A –
FP20
2B2/22
/201
9Plan
s are difficult to read
. Whe
re is sp
rinkler piping routing? Rise
rs
located?
AEI
DD drawings sh
ow th
e sprin
kler m
ains leaving the mecha
nical roo
m and
be
ing distrib
uted
across e
ach flo
or. Sprinkler hea
d locatio
ns are sh
own.
Bran
ch sp
rinkler piping will be completed
during the CD
design ph
ase.
Closed
3.0 Mecha
nical
3.0.1
M10
39/25
/201
8Co
nfirm
rooftop eq
uipm
ent locations and
proximities to
other equ
ipmen
t mee
t cod
e (e.g. intakes and
exhau
st distan
ces).
Bala
10/22/18
: The
design intent is fo
r equ
ipmen
t locations to
mee
t or e
xcee
d code
clearan
ces for air intakes a
nd exhau
st as w
ell as s
afety clea
rances.
Ope
n
3.0.2
M10
39/25
/201
8Co
ordina
te heigh
t of, an
d if louv
ers req
uired in, roo
ftop
equ
ipmen
t screen
s, as req
uired, with
Architect.
Bala
10/22/18
: The
intent is th
at th
e roof sc
reen
s will be of su
fficien
t heigh
t to
screen
units. Lou
ver o
pening
s an
d clea
rances will be coordina
ted.
Ope
n
3.0.3
M10
1 – M10
29/25
/201
8
Indicate m
ain du
ct and
pipe distrib
ution, zon
ing, and
risers. Flow diagram
s wou
ld also
be he
lpful for cost e
stim
ating.
2/22
/19: Flow diagram
s and
add
ition
al details are no
t include
d in DD
subm
ission.
Bala
10/22/18
: Main du
ct and
pipe distrib
utions are in
dicated. Schem
atic flow
diagrams w
ill be includ
ed in
the DD
subm
ission. 3/8/19 Hot w
ater/chille
d water dua
l tem
perature flow
diagram
has bee
n ad
ded to th
e DD plans.
Closed
3.0.4
M10
19/25
/201
8Su
pplemen
tal coo
ling for E
lectric
al, TeleD
ata spaces or E
levator M
achine
Ro
om, etc?
2/22
/19: In
dicate sizin
g/ qua
ntities. 7
/12/19
: Add
detail for unit/piping
.Ba
la10
/22/18
: Ductle
ss sp
lit sy
stem
AC un
its are noted
in th
e specificatio
ns.
Actual qua
ntity
and
locatio
ns will be de
term
ined
.Ope
n
3.0.5
M10
19/25
/201
8Eq
uipm
ent install/access/ m
ainten
ance/ rem
oval plan for M
echa
nical
Room
on first floo
r?Ba
la10
/22/18
: All eq
uipm
ent w
ill be de
signe
d for p
rope
r mainten
ance access
and remov
al.
Closed
3.0.6
M10
1 – M10
39/25
/201
8Miss
ing Sche
dules, Details, etc. for cost e
stim
ating.
2/22
/19: M
ultip
le details miss
ing from
DD pa
ckage. Sched
ules are not
complete – miss
ing all equ
ipmen
t information.
Bala
10/22/18
: Major equ
ipmen
t cap
acities are in
dicated on
drawing M10
3.
Details will be includ
ed in
DD subm
ission. 3/8/19 Details have be
en add
ed
and ad
ditio
nal sched
ule da
ta is in
clud
ed on the DD plans.
Ope
n
3.0.7
M10
1 – M10
32/22
/201
9Ad
d exha
ust to specialty
room
s: Cop
y Ro
om, A
rt Roo
ms, etc. tha
t sho
uld
not b
e recirculated
, as n
eede
d.Ba
la3/8/19
Kiln
exh
aust is in
dicated. A
rt ro
om is exh
austed
/ ve
ntilated
throug
h the ER
V system
and
is not re
circulated
.Closed
3.0.8
M10
32/22
/201
9Co
ordina
te ro
oftop eq
uipm
ent w
ith Electric
al.
Bala
3/8/19
Roo
ftop
unit e
lectric
al data ha
s be
en coo
rdinated
.Closed
3.0.9
M10
1B2/22
/201
9Ve
ntilatio
n an
d/or coo
ling prov
ided
in Electric
al Roo
m/ E
merg. Electric
al
spaces? Te
lecomm sp
aces? 7/12
/19: Any
doo
r lou
ver o
r und
ercut
prov
ided
for E
merg Elect c
losets?
Bala
3/8/19
Will be includ
ed in
the CD
docum
ents.
Ope
n
3.0.10
M10
1 –
M10
2B2/22
/201
9Co
ordina
te con
densate piping
from
Mech eq
uipm
ent to ne
arest a
pproved
FD.
Bala
3/8/19
Will be includ
ed in
the CD
docum
ents.
Ope
n
3.0.11
M10
1B2/22
/201
9Co
mbu
stion air for boilers in
Mecha
nical R
oom re
quire
d?Ba
la3/8/19
Com
bustion air for boilers and
water hea
ters is in
diacted on
the
DD plans.
Closed
3.0.12
M10
1A2/22
/201
9Kitche
n ventilatio
n an
d cooling eq
uipm
ent to be
provide
d. Is kitc
hen
exha
ust g
ood a Type
1 (g
rease) hoo
d? If so
, coo
rdinate all n
ecessary fire
protectio
n, duct a
ccess p
anels, fire alarm
devices, e
tc. as req
uired).
Bala
3/8/19
Final details w
ill be includ
ed in
the CD
docum
ents. Kitche
n is
curren
tly not provide
d with
coo
ling. P
lease confirm
desire
d intent.
Closed
3.0.13
Specs
2/22
/201
9Have sequ
ence of o
peratio
ns bee
n de
velope
d yet for any
of the
system
s?
7/12
/19: Con
firm all SO
Os are includ
ed and
provide
con
trols diagrams,
as nee
ded, on plan
s.Ba
la3/8/19
Will be includ
ed in
the CD
docum
ents.
Ope
n
3.0.14
M10
1A,
M10
1B,
M10
2B7/16
/201
9Do
the learning
cen
ters/small group
classroom
s/resource ro
oms s
uch as
Small G
roup
Rea
ding
201
or E
SL Classroom
217
nee
d to have their o
wn
thermostat a
s req
uired by
CHPS
?Ba
la/Tap
peOpe
n
Page 3 of 8
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
3.0.15
M10
1A, H
VAC
Sche
d,
E101
Ap7/18
/201
9
M10
1A sh
ows a
(2) ceilin
g fans "CF
/1" in Lob
by 138
, how
ever th
e fans are
not listed
on the HV
AC sc
hedu
le, and
E10
1Ap do
es not sh
ow pow
er fo
r the
fans. Sho
uld these fans be on
a switc
h, if so
E10
1Al d
oes n
ot sh
ow a
desig
nated sw
itch locatio
n.
Bala/AEI
Ope
n
3.0.16
M10
1A,
M10
1B,
M10
2B7/18
/201
9Are the CU
H's an
d FTR's e
lectric
or h
ydronic? The
units are not sp
ecified
in
the HVA
C sche
dule so
it is ukn
own (see
3.0.19). B
oth piping
and
pow
er
requ
iremen
ts have no
t bee
n coordina
ted with
eith
er of the
se units.
Bala/AEI
Ope
n
3.0.17
M10
1A7/18
/201
9Re
ceiving/Gen
eral Storage 153
show
s a CUH on
the North wall, ho
wever
there is no
sche
duled reference #.
Bala
Ope
n
3.0.18
M10
1A7/18
/201
9Cu
stod
ial Storage 152
show
s a FTR
unit o
n the West w
all, ho
wever no
leng
th has bee
n specified
.Ba
laOpe
n
3.0.19
HVAC
Sched
7/18
/201
9Plea
se com
plete HVA
C sche
dule fo
r units listed
but sp
ecs n
ot provide
d.
Plea
se also
includ
e specificatio
ns fo
r CUH, FTr, FPB
, AC, BC, PR, and
EXV
that are sh
own on
the flo
or plans but not in
the HVA
C sche
dule
Bala
Ope
n
4.0 Electrical
4.0.1
E301
B9/25
/201
8Co
nfirm
if fire ra
ting requ
ired arou
nd Electric
al/ E
merg. Electric
al Roo
ms.
Coordina
te with
Architect, as n
eede
d.AE
I10
/22/18
: Emergency electric closets re
quire
2hr ra
ting.
Closed
4.0.2
E‐01
9/25
/201
8Indicate whe
re pow
er is entering bu
ilding. Coo
rdinate with
Civil, as
need
ed.
AEI
10/22/18
: Drawing E3
01A indicates w
here pow
er enters the
building
Closed
4.0.3
E‐01
9/25
/201
8
Wha
t is c
onne
cted
to EP?
2/22
/19: W
ill pan
el sc
hedu
les b
e prov
ided
? A sche
dule sh
owing all
equipm
ent a
nd correspon
ding
electric
al re
quire
men
ts wou
ld be he
lpful.
7/12
/19: Finalize PB
sche
dules ‐ in
fo m
issing
.
AEI
10/22/18
: The
SD do
cumen
ts do no
t sho
w circ
uitin
g so it will not be
possible to
determine wha
t is p
lann
ed to
be on
EP by
review
ing the
draw
ings. The
SD na
rrative indicates w
hat w
ill be on
emergency po
wer.
3/8/19
: PB Sche
dules w
ill be prov
ided
in th
e CD
Sub
miss
ion an
d will
includ
ed all electrical re
quire
men
ts.
Ope
n
4.0.4
E301
A –
E303
B9/25
/201
8Sh
ow pow
er fo
r all major equ
ipmen
t on po
wer plans. 2
/22/19
: Include
and
coordina
te fo
r CDs
. AE
I
10/22/18
: The
SD do
cumen
ts will not sh
ow circ
uitin
g sin
ce th
e exact size
s of HVA
C eq
uipm
ent a
re not fina
lized
, but large HVA
C eq
uipm
ent is s
hown
on plans and
one
line
diagram
whe
re app
ropriate. 3
/8/19: Pow
er to
all
major equ
ipmen
t will be fin
alize
d for the
CD subm
ission.
Ope
n
4.0.5
E‐80
09/25
/201
8Fire Alarm
: Hea
t detectors in
spaces ven
ting stea
m.
AEI
10/22/18
: Hea
t detectors have be
en sh
own in th
e mecha
nical roo
m.
Closed
4.0.6
E301
A2/22
/201
9Kitche
n area
show
n on
drawing is bo
xed ou
t with
reference to detail 1 on
shee
t E50
1. She
et E50
1 is no
t include
d in th
e draw
ing set. (W
ould like to
review
that pen
dant ligh
ts are in
clud
ed whe
re Kitc
hen mee
ts Cafeteria).
AEI
3/8/19
Drawing E5
01 is com
plete an
d inlcud
ed in
the DD
set.
Closed
4.0.7
E‐00
02/22
/201
9Co
mplete lighting fixture sc
hedu
les.
AEI
3/8/19
Lighting fixture sc
hedu
le has bee
n completed
.WLI to
coo
rdinate an
d assis
t on site light lo
catio
ns and
fixture selection.
Electrical will own
Closed
4.0.8
E201
A –
E202
B2/22
/201
9Elevators o
n em
ergency po
wer? Co
nnect e
mergency electric m
echa
nical
equipm
ent to EP
, if so & coo
rdinate with
Bala.
AEI
3/8/19
Will add
ress in
CD subm
ission.
Ope
n
4.0.9
E301
A2/22
/201
9Sh
eet E
‐501
miss
ing, sh
owing electrical hoo
k‐up
s for kitc
hen eq
uipm
ent.
AEI
3/8/19
Drawing E5
01 is com
plete an
d inlcud
ed in
the DD
set.
Closed
4.0.10
E501
& E70
07/12
/201
9Co
mplete Sche
dule of K
itche
n Eq
uipm
ent a
nd Sched
ule of M
echa
nical
Equipm
ent. Sh
ow all fire alarm devices, p
ower, e
tc. for Kitc
he.
AEI
Ope
n
Page 4 of 8
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
4.0.11
E101
Ap,
E101
Bp,
E102
Bp,
E121
Ap,
E121
Bp
7/11
/201
9Gen
eral note: M
issing inform
ation on
receptacle pan
el designa
tions,
homerun
s back to pan
els.
AEI
Ope
n
4.0.12
E101
Al7/11
/201
9
Display cases in Lobb
y 13
8 show
n on
A10
1A and
C1/A7
03 in
dicates "
3"
Dia. Puck Ligh
ting Hardw
ired by
Elec." Pu
ck ligh
ting is no
t sho
wn or
specified
in th
e lighting sche
dule. A
re th
ese fixtures integral to the case
itself? If not and
are to
be prov
ided
by EC
con
tractor p
lease specify
fixture
type
. Sho
uld these recessed
ligh
ts be on
a sw
itch an
d/or dim
mer to
allo
w
control if e
ver n
eede
d?
AEI
Ope
n
4.0.13
E101
Al,
E101
Bl,
E102
Bl7/11
/201
9Gen
eral note: ligh
ting plan
s miss
ing sw
itch locatio
ns, switc
h de
signa
tions/circ
uit d
esigna
tions
AEI
Ope
n
4.0.14
E101
Al,
E101
Bl,
E102
Bl7/11
/201
9Ligh
ting fixtures P
14 and
P18
are sh
own throug
hout th
e lighting plan
s.
Both fixture de
signa
tions are not sp
ecified
in th
e lighting fixture sc
hedu
le.
Is th
is a typo
? If no
t, plea
se provide
fixture specificatio
ns fo
r P14
and
P18
AEI
Ope
n
4.0.15
ES10
07/17
/201
9Th
e electrical site plan do
es not sh
ow pow
er to
the water bottle
filler
adjacent to
the ba
sketba
ll court.
AEI
Ope
n
4.0.16
E102
Bl7/18
/201
9Th
e wall m
ounted
ligh
t fixtures a
t the
2nd
floo
r of S
tair 3 do
not have a
fixture designa
tion. Are we are to assum
e these are ST2 to m
atch th
e rest?AE
I/Tapp
eOpe
n
4.0.17
E000
7/19
/201
9Plea
se com
plete lighting fixture sc
hedu
le on E0
00, m
ore specifically fo
r site lights S
1, S2, S3, and
S4.
AEI
Ope
n
4.0.18
ES10
07/19
/201
9
The mon
umen
tal schoo
l sign with
electronic display at th
e So
uth East side
of th
e site requ
ires p
ower, h
owever it is not sh
own on
ES100
. The
re is a
hand
hole adjacen
t to the sig
ns lo
catio
n for the
site ligh
ting, sh
ould pow
er
for the
sign
also
be pu
lled into th
e ha
ndho
le and
then
to th
e sign
? Plea
se
coordina
te.
AEI
Ope
n
4.0.19
Gen
eral
7/19
/201
9
DPS (Keith) h
as expressed
interest in
includ
ing cell ph
one sig
nal b
oosters,
either in
the project o
r outsid
e of th
e project. Ca
n Tapp
e plea
se have a
subcon
sulta
nt provide
ROM pric
ing or se
e wha
t can
be do
ne to
be
"boo
ster re
ady" so
DPS
can
easily do this ou
tside of our project?
AEI/Tapp
eOpe
n
5.0 Te
leDa
ta
5.0.1
T101
A – T2
.059/25
/201
8Pa
per size is diffe
rent th
an th
e rest of the
set.
Edvance
Corrected for the
SD subm
ission.
Closed
5.0.2
Gen
eral
7/19
/201
9
Per d
iscussio
ns at the
7/1/19 techno
logy design mee
ting with
DPS
, Tap
pe
to coo
rdinate Distric
t Fiber con
nectivity
. Dan
vers con
necting all schoo
ls this summer. Tap
pe to
coo
rdinate op
timal lo
catio
n for D
anvers to
leave a
coil.
Tapp
e/Da
nvers
Ope
n
Page 5 of 8
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
6.0 Civil
6.0.1
C400
9/25
/201
8Settlemen
t vau
lts and
/or flex conn
ectio
ns re
quire
d for F
W, D
omestic
Water, San
itary, e
tc?
Nitsch
10/22/18
: This w
ill be coordina
ted in fu
ture su
bmiss
ions, flex conn
ectio
ns
will be show
n as nee
ded. Not clear on “Settle
men
t vau
lts” commen
t.Closed
6.0.2
C400
2/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: Please ad
d no
te to
drawings in
dicatin
g tree
s on ea
st side
of a
ccess
road
are to
be prun
ed.
Warne
r Larson
WLI will add
an ad
ditio
nal clarification no
te on L100
Site
Prep for p
runing
. Tress a
re currently called ou
t as to be
protected
.Closed
6.0.3
C400
2/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: Please ad
d no
te stating that DPW
will te
mpo
rarily relocate Pop
e Mem
orial stone
, and
brin
g ba
ck once WT Rich re
quests.
Nitsch
This no
te is currently on the DD
subm
ission
Closed
6.0.4
C400
2/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: Mow
strip
to be ad
ded at fa
r north and
far sou
th parts of b
uilding
(whe
re th
ere is no
walkw
ay con
flict).
Warne
r Larson
Adde
d to th
e draw
ings and
detailed
Closed
6.0.5
C400
2/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: Add
sedimen
t trap to drainage sw
ale.
Nitsch / Warne
r Larson
WLI and
Nitsch to
coo
rd on de
tail. W
ill be coordina
te prio
r to Co
n Co
m
review
, will provide
a se
dimen
t foreb
ay or structure with
sump to collect
sedimen
t. Closed
6.0.6
C400
, L20
12/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: DP
W Dire
ctor not fu
lly bou
ght in to unit p
avers. David W
arne
r to
prov
ide ph
otos from
other su
ccessful projects.
Warne
r Larson
/ DPW
WLI to
provide
images from
other projects.
Closed
6.0.7
C400
2/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: Bollards in fron
t of schoo
l to be
pow
der c
oated (w
ith protective
elem
ent for plows).
Warne
r Larson
Correct. Detalied an
d specs c
oord/call this finish
trea
tmen
tClosed
6.0.8
C400
2/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: DPW
Dire
ctor to
follo
w up regarding preferred material for ra
iling
s in east “
courtyard”.
DPW / Warne
r Larson
WLI noted
that pow
dercoa
ted fin
ish was prefered by
DPW
. Cu
rren
tly
calling
for this o
n the de
tails and
specs.
Closed
6.0.9
L201
, L50
22/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: Switc
h be
nche
s to gran
ite.
Warne
r Larson
Correct. Currently sh
owing this on
drawings, d
etails an
d in sp
ecs.
Closed
6.0.10
C400
2/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: Delete irrigation at U8 fie
ld, lea
ve dom
estic
con
nection/sle
eve.
Warne
r Larson
Deleted no
te callin
g for irrigation on
the U8 fie
ld. Plum
bing
to coo
rd on
prov
iding water so
urce fo
r future irrigation. W
LI to
add
slee
ves u
nder
pavemen
tClosed
6.0.11
C400
2/22
/201
9As disc
ussed at 2/14/19
Lan
dscape
design mee
ting with
Owne
r & W
arne
r Larson
: DPW
Dire
ctor to
follo
w up (Verify
no concerns) regarding
species
of tree
s/plan
tings. Tow
n mov
ing aw
ay from
Pin Oak.
Warne
r Larson
WLI noted
that DPW
did not have an
issue with
Pin Oaks a
s the
y are mainly
alon
g the pe
rimeter of the
site and
acorn drop shou
ld be a prob
lem. We
can wait o
n feed
back from
Tow
n.
Closed
6.0.12
L300
2/22
/201
9Plea
se kee
p bo
ttom
wall / to
p of wall lab
els c
onsis
tent (see
main
entran
ce).
Warne
r Larson
spot grade
s have be
en re
vised for D
D subm
ission
Closed
6.0.13
L300
2/22
/201
9Plea
se provide
detail for ra
ised walkw
ay @
main en
tran
ce.
Warne
r Larson
adde
d de
tail to #16
/L50
0Closed
6.0.14
L502
2/22
/201
9Plea
se provide
detail for playgroun
d eq
uipm
ent.
Warne
r Larson
need
feed
back from
Tow
n's p
laygroun
d focous group
. Fo
oting de
tail is
prov
ided
.Closed
6.0.15
C200
2/22
/201
9Erosion an
d sedimen
t con
trol plan do
not sh
ow U8 fie
ld or b
asketball
court.
Nitsch
Erosion control p
lans have be
en re
vised to in
clud
e scop
e of work.
Closed
6.0.16
L201
2/22
/201
9De
tail 3 – Is water fo
untain with
bottle
filler a
typo
?Warne
r Larson
Curren
tly sh
owing a water fo
untaing with
a bottle
filling
attachm
ent.
Owne
r to confirm
produ
ct is wan
ted. C
oord with
plumbing
if fo
untain is in
.Closed
Page 6 of 8
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
6.0.17
L200
2/22
/201
9Th
ree charging
stations sh
own in SW side
of v
isitor p
arking
area. Has David
Lane
review
ed th
is? Doe
s this g
et us a
ny CHPs points?
Tapp
eYe
s. The
se are add
ed sp
ecifically fo
r CHP
S requ
iremen
ts EE.10
.0 (2
% of a
ll pa
rking shall h
ave charging
, 123
spaced
@2%
=2.46 stalls)
Closed
6.0.18
L200
2/22
/201
9Travis from
Dan
vers Eng
inee
ring De
partmen
t req
uested
20’ wide access
road
aroun
d bu
ilding. Plans in
dicate entrance to access roa
d is 16
’ at
entran
ce from
staff p
arking
lot. Ca
n this be
increa
sed?
Tapp
e
Yes, The
road
can
be mad
e 20
'. Fire
Dep
t Chief app
roved this section be
ing
16' as the
re is a hill along
this section an
d they wou
ld not se
tup there.
Locked
collapsab
le bollard are in
stalled at to
p of access roa
d, staff w
ill not
be able to driv
e.
Closed
6.0.19
L200
2/22
/201
9Is th
e revised access ro
ad to
service area
show
n? (A
s a re
sult of tu
rning
radius stud
ies d
one in Ja
nuary 20
19?)
Tapp
eCo
rrect
Closed
6.0.20
5/L501
7/12
/201
9De
tail 5/L501
show
s a 4' embe
dmen
t for th
e stee
l bollards a
roun
d th
e gene
rator a
nd tran
sformer. Is the
4' embe
dmen
t req
uired?
The
re m
ay be
some cost sa
ving
s to redu
ce th
is to 1'.
Warne
r Larson
Ope
n
6.0.21
L201
7/19
/201
9Project tea
m to
con
firm DPW
Dire
ctor re
ceived
/reviewed
David W
arne
r's
email regarding
durab
le paint produ
ct fo
r play area
s.Warne
r Larson
Ope
n
6.0.22
L201
7/19
/201
9Similarly
to 6.0.22 ab
ove, please ha
ve project te
am con
firm design of
wall/s
tairs by play area (horizon
tal "clim
bing
" tran
sverse wall? M
ural? Etc)
Tapp
eOpe
n
6.0.23
L201
7/19
/201
9Pe
r disc
ussio
ns at 6
/7/19 Playgrou
nd Design mee
ting, W
arne
r Larson to
investigate/verify that 8' slid
es can
be prov
ided
ILO 6' slid
es fo
r main play
area
.Warne
r Larson
Ope
n
7.0 Structural
7.0.1
S101
A, S10
1B2/22
/201
9
Footing siz
es do no
t app
ear to match Structural R
eport include
d in SD
subm
ittal to
MSB
A. For example, in
terio
r foo
tings (F
8) are 8’ x 8’ x 2’;
structural re
port in
clud
ed in
SD indicates the
y shou
ld be 9’x9’x2’. A
ppea
rs
F8 and
F9 may be flipp
ed.
EDG
The plan
s sho
w th
e revised footing siz
es. Since th
e SD
subm
ission, th
e footing siz
es have be
en re
vised ba
sed on
the curren
t colum
n layo
ut.
Closed
7.0.2
S008
, S20
1‐S303
, S40
3,
S501
, 2/22
/201
9Plea
se labe
l all de
tails.
EDG
Only the typical d
etails that have no
t bee
n cut o
n plan
s are title
d. The
section de
tails are not title
d as th
ey are re
ferenced
on the plan
s.Closed
7.0.3
S102
B, S10
3A,
and S103
B7/12
/201
9
Slab
on de
ck th
ickn
esses a
re not clearly id
entified on
structural floo
r plans.
The tw
o‐way arrow
show
n on
the sla
b on
deck flo
or plans sh
ould be
includ
s in the no
tes/key iden
tifying
the wha
t makes up thickn
esses
indicates (i.e
. 5‐1/4", 3", etc)
EDG
Ope
n
7.0.4
Gen
eral
7/19
/201
9At th
e DD
cost e
stim
ate reconciliation, cost e
stim
ators ide
ntified
spray FP
requ
iremen
ts as v
ague
. Tap
pe to
clarify/verify that in
tumescent only
requ
ired on
prim
ary structure pe
rimeter & trusses.
Tapp
eOpe
n
8.0 Eq
uipm
ent
8.0.1
Q10
1B, typ
ical
2/22
/201
9Draw
ings sh
ow th
at 2 cha
rging stations will be ad
ded to each classroo
m. IT
Director Colby
Cou
sens in
dicated that th
e distric
t owns cha
rging stations
that can
be brou
ght to ne
w sc
hool. W
e shou
ld con
firm th
is with
Keith.
Tapp
elocatio
ns on plan
s are sh
own so th
at pow
er can
be prov
ided
for the
charging
stations. Exten
t of o
wne
r provide
vs n
ew to
TBD
Ope
n
Page 7 of 8
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Item No.
Ref.
Date Ope
ned
Review
Com
men
tAc
tion by
Commen
t Respo
nse
Status
8.0.2
Q10
1B, typ
ical
7/19
/201
9Pe
r disc
ussio
ns at the
7/1/19 techno
logy design mee
ting with
DPS
, Tap
pe
to in
vestigate locatio
n for "
chill out boo
th" (sensory).
Tapp
eOpe
n
8.0.3
Gen
eral
7/19
/201
9(M
inor) F
riend
ly re
minde
r, pe
r disc
ussio
ns at 6
/7/19 Land
scap
e de
sign
mee
ting, DPW
requ
ested ne
w so
ccer nets include
d in project sc
ope.
Tapp
eOpe
n
9.0 Plum
bing
9.0.1
P101
A7/17
/201
9Sh
ould add
ition
al floo
r drains b
e ad
ded in th
e Janitor/Cu
stod
ial R
ooms
(Jan 15
9, Custodial Storage 152
, Custodial W
orksho
p 15
1)?
AEI
Ope
n
Page 8 of 8
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Smith
Ele
men
tary
Sch
ool
W.T
. Rich
Des
ign
Revi
ew o
f 60%
Con
stru
ctio
n Do
cum
ents
dat
ed 6
/27/
19
No.
Spec
Sec
tion
Num
ber
Draw
ing
Page
No
.
Loca
tion
/ Det
ail #
/ Ro
om #
/ Co
l Lin
e /
Para
grap
h #
Impo
rtan
ceCo
mm
ent /
Issu
e / Q
uest
ion
Sour
ceDr
awin
g.
Set
Cons
ulta
ntDe
sign
Team
Res
pons
e or
Com
men
tsSt
atus
1TO
CSe
ctio
ns 0
7710
0, 0
7720
0, a
nd 0
8630
0 sh
ould
be
part
of T
B 07
0002
HME
DD S
et&
60
% C
DW
TRNo
FSB
. Will
be
assig
ned
to G
C; E
xpec
t to
cost
mor
e if
not b
id
by ro
ofer
.Op
en
2TO
CSe
ctio
ns 0
8411
0, 0
8441
0, a
nd 0
8451
3 sh
ould
be
part
of T
B 08
0001
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRAg
reed
. Cur
rent
ly in
clude
d in
FSB
080
001.
close
d
3TO
CSe
ctio
n 09
6510
shou
ld b
e pa
rt o
f TB
0900
05HM
EDD
1/3
0/19
WTR
Agre
ed. C
urre
ntly
inclu
ded
at h
eadi
ng in
sect
ion
0965
10. W
ill
add
to T
OC.
close
d
400
3132
Rem
embe
r to
inclu
de G
eote
chni
cal r
ecco
men
datio
ns a
s par
t of
this
spec
ifica
tion.
Thi
s is i
mpo
rtan
t as i
t out
lines
wha
t typ
e of
so
il ca
n be
use
d w
here
. Thi
s will
ass
ist in
the
Site
Sub
. bid
ding
pr
oces
s. Th
is w
ill b
e re
quire
d fo
r ERP
-1
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TR
Subs
urfa
ce a
nd la
b te
st d
ata
are
inclu
ded
in th
e sp
ec.
Inte
rpre
tatio
ns sh
ould
be
mad
e ba
sed
on th
is da
ta.
All r
epor
ts a
re li
sted
in th
e Su
bsur
face
Dat
a se
ctio
n an
d co
pies
ca
n be
obt
aine
d by
the
bidd
ers f
rom
Wes
ton
& S
amps
on u
pon
requ
est.
close
d
501
1000
Gene
ral
Chan
ge LE
ED to
CHP
SHM
EDD
Set
&
60%
CD
WTR
upda
ted
for E
R-1.
No
chan
ged
for 6
0% C
DOp
en
601
1000
Sect
. 1.1
Add
Stru
ctur
al S
teel
and
Con
cret
e. W
e ha
ve fo
und
in th
e pa
st
that
hav
ing
the
EOR
and
Arch
itect
at t
hese
mee
tings
is m
ost
bene
ficia
l. HM
EDD
1/3
0/19
WTR
We
will
hav
e ou
r con
sulta
nts a
vaila
ble
for t
he m
eetin
gsCl
osed
701
1000
Sect
. 1.1
5
This
sect
ion
is no
t who
lly cl
ear.
I bel
ieve
that
all
prop
rieta
ry
item
s mus
t be
clear
ly id
entif
ied
in th
e Co
ntra
ct D
ocum
ents
. If
they
are
not
and
one
man
ufac
ture
r is s
pecif
ied,
this
is ta
ken
as
the
basis
of d
esig
n an
d th
e su
bcon
trac
tor h
as th
e rig
ht to
subm
it an
as e
qual
with
out r
eque
stin
g a
subs
titut
ion.
Onl
y w
hen
thre
e m
anuf
actu
rers
are
spec
ified
and
the
subc
ontr
acto
r wish
es to
us
e an
alte
rnat
e m
anuf
actu
rer i
s a su
bstit
utio
n re
ques
t re
quire
d.
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRTh
is se
ctio
n w
as re
vise
d fo
r ER-
1. A
ny p
ropr
ieta
ry it
ems w
ill b
e id
entif
ied
if re
quire
d as
we
prog
ress
thro
ugh
CD's
Clos
ed
801
1000
Sect
. 1.2
.CFi
lling
this
in w
ill n
eed
to b
e a
team
effo
rt R
e: it
ems b
y Ow
ner.
HME
DD S
et&
60
% C
DW
TRDE
LETE
D IN
ER-
1 SP
EC. R
evisi
ted
in 6
0%. C
omm
ent s
till a
pplie
s.Op
en
901
1000
Sect
. 1.2
.DPl
ease
conf
irm S
ectio
n 1.
2.D.
1HM
EDD
Set
&
60%
CD
WTR
Revi
sed
in E
R-1
spec
. Rev
ision
not
carr
ied
to 6
0%.
Open
1001
1000
Sect
. 1.8
.AOn
ce th
e SO
V is
set/
appr
oved
, it s
houl
d no
t be
upda
ted.
Onl
y co
ntra
ct m
odifi
catio
n sh
ould
be
adde
d vi
a CO
. Ple
ase
conf
irm
this
is th
e in
tent
.HM
EDD
Set
&
60%
CD
WTR
NEED
S TO
BE
UPDA
TED
AS O
THER
PAC
KAGE
S AR
E AD
DED
/ BID
Op
en
1101
1000
Sect
. 1.9
.ATh
is Se
ctio
n re
ques
ts a
Lien
Wai
ver.
Cann
ot li
en a
pub
lic p
roje
ct.
HME
DD S
et&
60
% C
DW
TRre
mov
ed in
ER-
1 Re
visio
n no
t car
ried
in 6
0%Op
en
1201
1000
Sect
. 1.9
.D.1
0Ch
ange
LEED
to C
HPS
HME
DD S
et&
60
% C
DW
TRRe
vise
d in
ER-
1 sp
ec R
evisi
on n
ot ca
rrie
d in
60%
Open
1301
2200
S001
Unit
Price
sSh
ould
this
be p
art o
f thi
s con
trac
t? T
o be
disc
usse
d w
ith th
e te
am. S
eem
s tha
t Ite
ms 2
-4 sh
ould
be
inclu
ded.
HME
DD S
et&
60
% C
DW
TRun
it pr
ices a
re b
eing
rem
oved
. CM
shou
ld in
clude
in th
e GM
P th
e pr
oper
allo
wan
ce fo
r the
se ty
pes o
f ite
ms.
Add
unit
price
s fo
r aba
tem
ent (
eg a
sbes
tos l
ined
pip
e)?
Ope
n
1401
4320
Gene
ral
Just
thro
win
g th
is on
e ou
t the
re…
can
we
inco
rpor
ate
a m
atrix
of
who
ow
ns w
hat i
nspe
ctio
ns in
to th
is se
ctio
n. T
his a
lway
s see
ms
to b
e an
exe
rcise
bet
wee
n th
e OP
M a
nd th
e CM
onc
e th
e pr
ojec
t has
star
ted.
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRPe
r 1.4
B th
e CM
is re
spon
sible
to su
bmit
a sc
heud
lue.
Ple
ase
star
t the
mat
rix a
nd th
en p
ass a
long
to th
e OM
P an
d de
sing
team
.C
lose
d
Gene
ral N
otes
on
Desig
n Re
view
:
Smith
- 60
% D
esig
n R
evie
w -M
aste
r MSB
A .x
lsx
1 of
24
7/24
/201
9
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Smith
Ele
men
tary
Sch
ool
W.T
. Rich
Des
ign
Revi
ew o
f 60%
Con
stru
ctio
n Do
cum
ents
dat
ed 6
/27/
19
No.
Spec
Sec
tion
Num
ber
Draw
ing
Page
No
.
Loca
tion
/ Det
ail #
/ Ro
om #
/ Co
l Lin
e /
Para
grap
h #
Impo
rtan
ceCo
mm
ent /
Issu
e / Q
uest
ion
Sour
ceDr
awin
g.
Set
Cons
ulta
ntDe
sign
Team
Res
pons
e or
Com
men
tsSt
atus
Gene
ral N
otes
on
Desig
n Re
view
:
1501
8120
Sect
. 1.3
.ACh
ange
to n
o sm
okin
g on
scho
ol p
rope
rty
HME
DD S
et&
60
% C
DW
TRAg
reed
. Will
revi
se.R
evisi
on n
ot ca
rrie
d in
60%
Open
1602
4100
Gene
ral
Rem
inde
r- Al
l Sub
-Bid
trad
es w
ill b
e re
quire
d to
cut/
cap/
mak
e sa
fe a
ll ex
istin
g ut
ilitie
s in
and
arou
nd th
e to
be
dem
olish
ed
scho
ol. T
his n
eeds
to b
e in
corp
orea
ted
into
thei
r spe
cifica
tions
. HM
EDD
1/3
0/19
WTR
will
coor
d. w
ith a
ll co
nsul
tant
s to
inclu
de in
thei
r spe
csclo
sed
1702
4100
Sect
. 3.4
.A.2
Plea
se co
nfirm
fire
wat
ch d
urat
ion
HME
DD S
et&
60
% C
DW
TRth
is is
adeq
uate
for u
s. W
ill co
nfirm
if a
ccep
tabl
e to
the
tow
n.Op
en
1802
4100
Sect
. 3.5
.CPl
ease
conf
irm. P
er o
ur G
eote
ch m
eetin
g on
2/1
2- fo
unda
tions
w
ere
to b
e re
mov
ed a
tleas
t 24"
from
bel
ow su
rface
exc
ept a
t de
tent
ion
area
s whe
re it
wou
ld n
eed
to b
e fu
ll re
mov
alHM
EDD
1/3
0/19
WTR
spec
to b
e up
date
dCl
osed
1902
4100
Sect
. 3.5
.D&
ESe
ctio
ns D
&E
are
redu
ndan
t.HM
EDD
1/3
0/19
WTR
will
upd
ate
for 6
0% C
D Es
t Sub
miss
ion
Clos
ed
2003
3000
Sect
2.3
Sect
ion
does
not
corr
espo
nd to
requ
irem
ents
show
n on
Dw
g S0
01HM
EDD
Set
&
60%
CD
WTR
Inclu
ded.
See
1.2
-11.
Dra
win
gs a
nd th
e sp
ecifi
ctio
ns w
ill b
e ed
ited
for c
omfo
rmat
ion
of th
e tw
o do
cum
ents
Revi
sions
not
carr
ied
in 6
0%.
Open
2103
3000
Sect
. 1.2
Plea
se a
dd u
nder
slab
insu
latio
n as
scop
e w
ork
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRIn
clude
d in
MSB
A DD
subm
isssio
n. S
ee 1
.2-1
1Cl
osed
2203
3000
Sect
. 2.2
Add
Barr
ier O
ne?
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRYe
s. In
clude
d In
clude
d in
MSB
A DD
subm
isssio
n. S
ee 2
.2F.
5.Cl
osed
2303
3000
Sect
. 3.1
2Pl
ease
pro
vide
fnish
es fo
r equ
ipm
ent s
labs
and
oth
er h
orizo
ntal
ex
pose
d fin
ishes
that
are
not
cont
aine
d w
ithin
g th
e ex
terio
r co
ncre
te sp
ecifi
catio
n.
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRse
vera
l fin
ishes
show
n in
3.1
2. A
dvise
if re
ques
ted
is no
t list
ed.
Clos
ed
2403
3515
Gene
ral
Is th
is Se
ctio
n re
leva
nt. N
ot sh
own
in fi
nish
sche
dule
.HM
EDD
Set
&
60%
CD
WTR
Yes.
See
floor
fini
sh a
t STE
AM 2
02 o
n A6
03. E
xpen
sive
and
not
man
y su
bs o
ut th
ere
who
per
form
. Rec
onsid
er?
Open
2505
1200
Gene
ral
Inclu
de fu
rnish
and
inst
alla
tion
of th
erm
al b
reak
s tha
t are
in
regr
al to
the
stru
ctur
al st
eel i
nsta
llatio
n.
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRPa
ds fo
r the
rmal
bre
ak a
re n
ot u
sed
in a
ny d
etai
ls fo
r the
pr
ojec
t.Cl
osed
.
2605
5100
A574
Genr
eral
Plea
se p
rovi
de sp
ecifi
catio
n fo
r 2" w
elde
d w
ire m
esh
for s
tair
guar
drai
l sys
tem
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRW
ill a
dd to
spec
for 6
0% C
D Es
t Sub
miss
ion
Clos
ed
2705
5100
L502
Deta
ils 3
& 7
Need
mat
eria
l size
s for
raili
ngs
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRw
ill u
pdat
e fo
r 60%
CD
Est S
ubm
issio
nCl
osed
2807
7200
A121
BSk
ylig
htTh
ere
is no
det
ail o
r spe
cifica
tion
for t
he A
lum
inum
Sky
light
Sy
stem
nor
the
skyl
ight
at C
L N.1
-4.2
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRse
e se
ctio
ns 0
8620
0 an
d 08
6300
Clos
ed
2931
2000
Sect
. 1.3
..A.4
All s
ubm
ittal
s nee
d to
be
stam
ped
by a
PE?
Is th
is al
l inc
lusiv
e?HM
EDD
1/3
0/19
WTR
Subm
ittal
s for
des
ign
of e
xcav
atio
n su
ppor
t and
dew
ater
ing
(whe
re
desig
ned
by a
PE)
requ
ire a
PE
stam
p. O
ther
s do
not.
Clos
ed
3031
2500
Gene
ral
Chan
ge LE
ED R
ef. t
o CH
PSHM
EDD
1/3
0/19
WTR
upda
ted
in E
R-1
Clos
ed
3132
1313
Sect
. 1.3
The
stip
ulat
ions
of t
his s
ectio
n m
ay sc
are
off s
ome
pote
ntia
l bi
dder
s. Th
is pa
ckag
e is
norm
ally
bou
ght o
ut w
ith th
e st
ruct
ural
co
ncrt
ete
pack
age.
Any
way
to re
duce
the
requ
irem
ents
or m
ake
them
a b
it m
ore
cond
ition
al?
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRW
e ha
ve sp
ecia
lty p
avin
g on
this
proj
ect.
Our
list
of q
uals
will
re
mai
nCl
osed
3232
1313
Sect
. 1.3
.BCo
rdin
ate
w/ S
dra
win
gsHM
EDD
1/3
0/19
WTR
No n
eed
for c
oord
inat
ion
betw
een
pavi
ng a
nd st
ruct
ural
.Cl
osed
Smith
- 60
% D
esig
n R
evie
w -M
aste
r MSB
A .x
lsx
2 of
24
7/24
/201
9
-
MSBA 60% CD SUBMISSION IVAN G SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOLTAPPÉ ARCHITECTS
Smith
Ele
men
tary
Sch
ool
W.T
. Rich
Des
ign
Revi
ew o
f 60%
Con
stru
ctio
n Do
cum
ents
dat
ed 6
/27/
19
No.
Spec
Sec
tion
Num
ber
Draw
ing
Page
No
.
Loca
tion
/ Det
ail #
/ Ro
om #
/ Co
l Lin
e /
Para
grap
h #
Impo
rtan
ceCo
mm
ent /
Issu
e / Q
uest
ion
Sour
ceDr
awin
g.
Set
Cons
ulta
ntDe
sign
Team
Res
pons
e or
Com
men
tsSt
atus
Gene
ral N
otes
on
Desig
n Re
view
:
3332
1313
Gene
ral
Colo
red
conc
rete
wal
kway
s may
resu
lt in
cost
incr
ease
s. Sh
ould
be
iden
tifie
d by
ERP
-02
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRsp
ecia
lty p
avin
g ha
s bee
n id
entif
ied
on th
e M
SBA
DD d
raw
ings
20
19-0
2-28
Clos
ed
3432
1313
Sect
. 2.5
This
sect
ion
shou
ld b
elon
g to
the
WDC
File
d su
b-bi
d. M
ost
conc
rete
subs
will
exc
lude
this
wor
k.
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRW
e di
ssag
gree
. Jo
int s
ealin
g is
part
of t
he sc
ope
of w
ork
that
a
conc
rete
pav
ing
cont
ract
or w
ill o
wn.
Clos
ed
3532
1400
Sect
. 2.3
Sect
. 2.3
refe
renc
es w
eeps
. Dra
win
g L5
00 d
oesn
ot d
epict
thes
e.
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TRW
eeps
are
not
par
t of t
he d
esig
n. W
eeps
will
be
rem
oved
from
th
e sp
ec se
ctio
nCl
osed
3632
1816
L201
Stag
e En
larg
emen
tW
ill th
ere
be m
ultip
le th
ickne
sses
with
in th
e po
ured
in p
lace
ru
bber
safe
ty su
rfacin
g? A
fall
zone
is in
dica
ted,
but
di
ffere
ntia
ted
dept
hs a
re n
ot in
dica
ted.
HME
DD 1
/30/
19W
TR
Yes,
The
re w
ill b
e va
rious
PIP
thick
ness
es.
Play