it central station ca api management comparison

1
Featured Review Most Helpful Review Valuable Features Room For Improvement Deployment Issues Stability Issues Scalability Issues Technical Support Alternate Solutions Quotes from Member Reviews Valuable Features Valuable Features Valuable Features Sr. Manager - Technology Governance and Architecture at a tech services company Sr. Manager - Technology Governance and Architecture at a tech services company Sr. Manager - Delivery, Enter- prise & Platform Architect at a tech services company Valuabe Features Most Valuable Feature Is Security Along With Performance And Scalability. The most valuable feature is security, which is the most important to our company. Then comes performance, scalability, and I see tremendous per- formance value without compromising the security. It gives us peace of mind, for example there are so many penetration attacks happening, DDoS kind of attacks happen in our API infrastructure if you don’t have the security. With the out of the box security features from CA API Management, I can focus on the business logic to deliver the real value to the consumers, without worrying about the security.... What I felt was when we reviewed it along with the multiple other vendors in the market was that the operational side of API Management is pretty simple, so that we can ramp it up very fast in our organization. The way the product is built was really good. What I felt was when we reviewed it along with the multiple other vendors in the mar- ket was that the operational side of API... Ability to create and test API “microser- vices” using RAML Develop policies that can be applied and re-used across API’s and... The seamless conversion between rest and soap and service catalog. V3 is way better then v2, and v4 has further improvements. We have the ability to secure, control, transform,... It lacks the ability for billing and metering the API usage to invoicing in v3, however, v4 does have this.... No issues encountered. From our perspective, the most important aspect is the ability to scale without com- promising performance as well as security... Mulesoft doesn’t provide a complete stack. For example, it doesn’t have BPM/Workflow, BAM, or Identity Management... We’ve had no issues with the deployment. Only issue is with connecting it to Exchange Server. No issues with scalability. I did not require technical support. There have been no stability issues. Good scalability in AWS/EC2. 9/10 - They’re very quick to help with tickets and deploy fixes. For API we looked at Apigee, Axway, Mashery, and CA Layer 7. For ESB/SOA we looked at SAG webMethods, and IBM. Ability to create and test API “microser- vices” using RAML Develop policies that can be applied and re-used across... The additional features are to keep up with the security aspects. That’s one aspect, the market is changing. As we started several... Initial setup is good. It’s straightforward. It’s not that tough and it’s an appliance, so that kind of took away wireless... So far the stability has been really good, we haven’t had any problem. I believe we have been using it for sometime.... We are able to scale both horizontal and vertically, so we have an internal user base as well as external user base and we are... The technical support has been good. They have dedicated technical support for us, we have dedicated account managers from... If I’m looking for an API management vendor then I would look at the API management vendor’s capability, their products capability... Read more Read more Read more Read more Read more Read more Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review Read full review The Operational Side Of API Management Is Pretty Simple. It’s provided a complete and architecturally sound solution for building... Exchange integration would be a good im- provement however it has made it very... Mahesh R. Mahesh R. SrManager2193 We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said. Metrics 5,764 1,078 15 320 8.6 2,812 2,335 1 334 9.0 2,705 1,480 3 307 8.7 Views Comparisons Reviews Followers Avg. Rating Views Comparisons Reviews Followers Avg. Rating Views Comparisons Reviews Followers Avg. Rating IT Central Station Ltd. does not endorse or recommend any products or services. All review excerpts quoted in this document were taken from full user reviews of the solutions. The vendor sponsor of this report (CA Technologies) chose the review snippets about their product. These reviews are marked as ‘Sponsored’. Review snippets of other vendors included in this report are a snapshot of the content which appear on IT Central Station comparison pages. The views and opinions of reviewers quoted in this document, IT Central Station websites, and IT Central Station materials (i.e. Content) do not reflect the opinions of IT Central Station. We make no guarantees about the accuracy, currency, suitability, or quality of the content, and we assume no responsibility for unintended, objectionable, inaccurate, misleading, or unlawful content made available by Content authors or other third parties. ©2016 IT Central Station, All Rights Reserved. IT Central Station Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Top Comparisons Top Industries Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager vs. CA API Management Apigee vs. Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager Apigee vs. IBM API Connect IBM API Connect vs. CA API Management CA API Management vs. Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager Microsoft Azure API Management vs. IBM API Connect Microsoft Azure API Management vs. CA API Management Intel Mashery API Management vs. Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager Akana API Management vs. IBM API Connect See more CA API Management competitors See more Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager competitors See more IBM API Connect competitors Compared 20% of the time. Compared 34% of the time. Compared 16% of the time. Compared 17% of the time. Compared 12% of the time. Compared 16% of the time. Compared 12% of the time. Compared 12% of the time. Compared 15% of the time. REVIEWERS VISITORS READING REVIEWS VISITORS READING REVIEWS Financial Services Firm Engineering Company Insurance Company Hospitality Company Financial Services Firm Media Company Recruiting/HR Firm Transportation Company Financial Services Firm Comms Service Provider Retailer Marketing Services Firm 36% 18% 9% 9% 28% 23% 10% 6% 28% 13% 12% 10% Read more Video Review from a Real User Principal Architect at a tech services company Vijay A. Product Comparison API Management CA API Management Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager IBM API Connect VP Product Development at a financial services firm VP Product Development at a financial services firm Director of Architecture at a healthcare company VP35799 VP35799 Hari K. Principal Architect at a tech services company Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert SOA and Security Consultant at a software R&D company SOA and Security Consultant at a software R&D company SOA and Security Consultant at a software R&D company SOA and Security Consultant at a software R&D company Architect at Ness Technologies Architect at Ness Technologies Architect at Ness Technologies Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert Vijay A. Jordan B. Alon A. Alon A. Alon A. Alon A. Perminder S. Perminder S. Perminder S. Jordan B. Jordan B. Jordan B. Jordan B. Jordan B. Jordan B. Jordan B. Sr. Manager - Technology Governance and Architecture at a tech services company Mahesh R. We also looked at WS02 which was way too complex and needed almost 14-15 VMs to run. As we had Datapower, it was a... Read more Architect at Ness Technologies Perminder S. Sr. Manager - Delivery, Enter- prise & Platform Architect at a tech services company SrManager2193 CA API Management Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager IBM API Connect

Upload: vuongnguyet

Post on 14-Feb-2017

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IT Central Station CA API Management Comparison

Featured Review

Most Helpful Review

Valuable Features

Room For Improvement

Deployment Issues

Stability Issues

Scalability Issues

Technical Support

Alternate Solutions

Quotes from Member Reviews

Valuable Features Valuable Features Valuable Features

Sr. Manager - TechnologyGovernance and Architecture at a tech services company

Sr. Manager - TechnologyGovernance and Architecture at a tech services company

Sr. Manager - Delivery, Enter-prise & Platform Architect at a tech services company

Valuabe Features

Most Valuable Feature Is Security Along With Performance And Scalability.

The most valuable feature is security, which is the most important to our company. Then comes performance, scalability, and I see tremendous per-formance value without compromising the security. It gives us peace of mind, for example there are so many penetration attacks happening, DDoS kind of attacks happen in our API infrastructure if you don’t have the security. With the out of the box security features from CA API Management, I can focus on the business logic to deliver the real value to the consumers, without worrying about the security....

What I felt was when we reviewed it along with the multiple other vendors in the market was that the operational side of API Management is pretty simple, so that we can ramp it up very fast in our organization. The way the product is built was really good.

What I felt was when we reviewed it along with the multiple other vendors in the mar-ket was that the operational side of API...

Ability to create and test API “microser-vices” using RAML Develop policies that can be applied and re-used across API’s and...

The seamless conversion between rest and soap and service catalog.

V3 is way better then v2, and v4 has further improvements. We have the ability to secure, control, transform,...

It lacks the ability for billing and metering the API usage to invoicing in v3, however, v4 does have this....

No issues encountered.

From our perspective, the most important aspect is the ability to scale without com-promising performance as well as security...

Mulesoft doesn’t provide a complete stack. For example, it doesn’t have BPM/Workflow, BAM, or Identity Management...

We’ve had no issues with the deployment. Only issue is with connecting it to Exchange Server.

No issues with scalability.

I did not require technical support.

There have been no stability issues.

Good scalability in AWS/EC2.

9/10 - They’re very quick to help with tickets and deploy fixes.

For API we looked at Apigee, Axway, Mashery, and CA Layer 7. For ESB/SOA we looked at SAG webMethods, and IBM.

Ability to create and test API “microser-vices” using RAML Develop policies that can be applied and re-used across...

The additional features are to keep up with the security aspects. That’s one aspect, the market is changing. As we started several...

Initial setup is good. It’s straightforward. It’s not that tough and it’s an appliance, so that kind of took away wireless...

So far the stability has been really good, we haven’t had any problem. I believe we have been using it for sometime....

We are able to scale both horizontal and vertically, so we have an internal user base as well as external user base and we are...

The technical support has been good. They have dedicated technical support for us, we have dedicated account managers from...

If I’m looking for an API management vendor then I would look at the API management vendor’s capability, their products capability...

Read more Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

Read full review

The Operational Side Of API Management Is Pretty Simple.

It’s provided a complete and architecturally sound solution for building...

Exchange integration would be a good im-provement however it has made it very...

Mahesh R.

Mahesh R.

SrManager2193

We asked business professionals to review the solutions they use. Here are some excerpts of what they said.

Metrics

5,764

1,078

15

320

8.6

2,812

2,335

1

334

9.0

2,705

1,480

3

307

8.7

Views

Comparisons

Reviews

Followers

Avg. Rating

Views

Comparisons

Reviews

Followers

Avg. Rating

Views

Comparisons

Reviews

Followers

Avg. Rating

IT Central Station Ltd. does not endorse or recommend any products or services. All review excerpts quoted in this document were taken from full userreviews of the solutions. The vendor sponsor of this report (CA Technologies) chose the review snippets about their product. These reviews are marked as ‘Sponsored’. Review snippets of other vendors included in this report are a snapshot of the content which appear on IT Central Station comparison pages.

The views and opinions of reviewers quoted in this document, IT Central Station websites, and IT Central Station materials (i.e. Content) do not reflect the opinions of IT Central Station. We make no guarantees about the accuracy, currency, suitability, or quality of the content, and we assume no responsibility

for unintended, objectionable, inaccurate, misleading, or unlawful content made available by Content authors or other third parties.

©2016 IT Central Station, All Rights Reserved. IT Central Station Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Top Comparisons

Top Industries

Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager vs. CA API Management

Apigee vs. Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager

Apigee vs. IBM API Connect

IBM API Connect vs.CA API Management

CA API Management vs.Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager

Microsoft Azure API Management vs. IBM API Connect

Microsoft Azure API Management vs. CA API Management

Intel Mashery API Management vs. Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager

Akana API Management vs.IBM API Connect

See more CA API Management competitors See more Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager competitors See more IBM API Connect competitors

Compared 20% of the time. Compared 34% of the time.Compared 16% of the time.

Compared 17% of the time. Compared 12% of the time. Compared 16% of the time.

Compared 12% of the time. Compared 12% of the time. Compared 15% of the time.

REVIEWERS

VISITORS READING REVIEWS VISITORS READING REVIEWS

Financial Services FirmEngineering CompanyInsurance CompanyHospitality Company

Financial Services FirmMedia CompanyRecruiting/HR FirmTransportation Company

Financial Services FirmComms Service ProviderRetailerMarketing Services Firm

36%18%9%9%

28%23%10%6%

28%13%12%10%

Read more

Video Review from a Real User

Principal Architect at atech services company

Vijay A.

Product ComparisonAPI Management

CA API Management Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager IBM API Connect

VP Product Development at a financial services firm

VP Product Development at a financial services firm

Director of Architecture at a healthcare company

VP35799

VP35799

Hari K.

Principal Architect at atech services company

Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert

SOA and Security Consultant at a software R&D company

SOA and Security Consultant at a software R&D company

SOA and Security Consultant at a software R&D company

SOA and Security Consultant at a software R&D company

Architect at Ness Technologies

Architect at Ness Technologies

Architect at Ness Technologies

Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert

Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert

Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert

Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert

Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert

Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert

Consultant Principal on: MuleSoft Expert, Oracle Fusion Expert, webMethods Expert

Vijay A.Jordan B.

Alon A.

Alon A.

Alon A.

Alon A.

Perminder S.

Perminder S.

Perminder S.

Jordan B.

Jordan B.

Jordan B.

Jordan B.

Jordan B.

Jordan B.

Jordan B.

Sr. Manager - TechnologyGovernance and Architecture at a tech services company

Mahesh R.

We also looked at WS02 which was way too complex and needed almost 14-15 VMs to run. As we had Datapower, it was a...

Read more

Architect at Ness Technologies

Perminder S.

Sr. Manager - Delivery, Enter-prise & Platform Architect at a tech services company

SrManager2193

CA API Management Mulesoft Anypoint API Manager IBM API Connect