islamic teachings on reproductive health and fertility transition
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
1/38
ISLAMIC TEACHINGS ONREPRODUCTIVE HEALTH AND
FERTILITY TRANSITIONIN MUSLIM-MAJORITY COUNTRIES
Mehtab S. Karim, Ph.D.
Head, Reproductive Health Program
Professor of DemographyDepartment of Community Health Sciences
Aga Khan University
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
2/38
As societies transform from apredominantly traditional to apredominantly modem system they tendto experience considerable demographicchanges. Ansley Coale (1984) notes thatthis "transformation is the substitutionof slow growth achieved with low
fertility and mortality for slow growthmaintained with relatively high fertilityand mortality rates."
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
3/38
During the 1960s and 70s while trying toexplain persistently high fertility in the
developing during, most WesternDemographers had taken the view thathigh fertility was generally embedded in
cultural and religious factors, whichencouraged high fertility in most countriesof Latin America, Africa and Asia.
In this respect, much more has been writtenabout high fertility among Muslims than
about the followers of any other religion.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
4/38
For example even when no considerablefertility decline was noted in anydeveloping country, Dudley Kirk (1966)in his review of Muslim fertility,
observed that:
Muslim populations tended to have highfertility, that there was no evidence ofdecline, and that in a given country,Muslims tended to have higher fertilitythan adherents of other religions.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
5/38
Caldwell took a similar view about sub-Saharan Africa, arguing that high fertility
rates in the region , "have much to do witha religious belief system, that operatesdirectly to sustain high fertility.
He further contended that in his study ofseveral developing countries, thecommonest factor in explaining highinfant mortality was the predominance of
Muslim countries. He argued that highinfant mortality in these countries was dueto lower status assigned to women intheses predominantly Muslim countries,
which also leads to higher fertility .
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
6/38
However, taking a broader view,Bongaarts, in his theory of proximate
determinants of fertility postulates, thatdue to socio-biological factors, fertility islikely to be lower than its maximumvalue as a result of:
delayed female age at marriage, higher use of contraception, high prevalence of induced abortion and, prolonged practice of breastfeeding
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
7/38
In Islamic scriptures, as recorded in the
revealed book the Quran andHadith(sayings of the Prophet),views on eachof the four proximate determinants of
fertility are available.
These issues have also been widely
debated in the writings of the earlyMuslim jurists and scholars.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
8/38
ISLAMIC TEAHINGS ONFAMILY PLANNING
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
9/38
In Islamic scriptures, as recorded inthe revealed book the Quran andHadith(sayings of the Prophet,
PBUH), views on each of the fourproximate determinants of fertilityare available in the writings of the
early Muslim jurists and scholars.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
10/38
On MarriageAmong His signs is this, that He created foryou mates from among yourselves, that youmay dwell in tranquillity with them
The Quran, Surah 30:21
The Prophet (PBUH) discouraged celibacyand encouraged all Muslim males andfemales to get married.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
11/38
One finds general references in the QuranandHadith regarding marriageable ageand the age of sound judgment, withoutspecifying a fixed age.
However, some scholars have argued that,if a girl is married at too young age, anelement mentioned in the Quranofdwelling in tranquillity could be missing.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
12/38
Thus, Imam Abu Hanifa suggested an ageof marriage of 18 years for boys and 17 for
girls.
Subsequently, these were adopted in theOttoman Family Law before the First
World War.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
13/38
On Lactation
Mothers shall suckle their children for twowhole years
The Quran, Surah 2:233
Imam Al-Ghazali was of the opinion thatsince mother must breastfeed the children fortwo years, therefore, while the mother islactating, to avoid another pregnancy,couples should practice birth control.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
14/38
On Contraception
In Hadith, azl (coitus interruptus) ismentioned either as a saying of the Prophetor as his tacit approval. The Prophets(PBUH) companion Jabir relates:
We used to have recourse to azl during
the days of the Prophet while the Quranwas being revealed. He came to know of itbut he did not prevent us from doing so.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
15/38
Throughout the Middle Ages, Muslim
physicians instructed people oncontraceptive methods.
Thus the most well known Muslimphysician al-Razi gave illustrations of thedifferent methods of contraception in hisbook Al-Hawi. He suggested three waysfor preventing conception:
withdrawalprevention of ejaculation orapply to the uterus a tampon or a certain
spermicide.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
16/38
In sum, there was a general consensus amongearly Muslim scholars that contraception ispermitted in Islam.
However, most scholars accept thatcontraception is not acceptable in twosituations:
if it is used to avoid having female childrenor
if it is used to avoid parentalresponsibilities
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
17/38
On Abortion
Those who support abortion quote the followingverse:
We created man from a product of wet earth.Then placed him as a drop (of seed) in a safelodging. Then fashioned We the drop a clot,then fashioned We the clot a little lump, then
fashioned We the little lump with bones, thenclothed the bones with flesh, and then producedit as another creation....
The Quran, Surah 23:14
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
18/38
Imam Bokhari quotes aHadithof the Prophet:
All of us have been kept as a drop of seedwhich remains in the shape of a drop in
the mothers womb for 40 days. Then foranother 40 days, it remains in the form of aclot of blood. Then another 40 days itremains in the form of a lump of flesh.Then an angel is sent to the fetus whoblows spirit (life) in to it.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
19/38
The most recent formulation on abortion,given by the grand Mufti of Egypt andRector of Al-Azhar reads as follows:
During the first four months, fetal life isnot believed to be human. Thus, juristicconsensus exists only to the point that
abortion after four months amounts totaking a life, but this limit may be setaside, if the mothers life is at risk.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
20/38
Opposing ViewsMaulana Maududi, a highly respected
scholar from the Indian sub-continentmakes the following arguments in his bookBirth control, first published in 1943:
The birth control movement is a plotagainst Islam.
To import birth control methods into
developing countries would be tantamountto ushering in moral malaise and,Women would feel free to join the labor
force and abandon their traditional roles.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
21/38
Maulana Maududi, however,allowed the practice of birth
control if a couple so desires forpersonal reason but not as aconcern for population growth
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
22/38
Do Muslim countries have a typicaldemographic pattern?
In The Demography of Islamic Nations,Weeks (1988) found noticeable regional
and temporal diversity in fertility amongMuslim countries. He argued that,
The single most remarkable demographicaspect of Islamic societies is the nearlyuniversal high level of fertility.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
23/38
Samuel P. Huntington in his well publicizedbook, The Clash of Civilizations states:
The Resurgence of Islam has been fueled byequally spectacular rates of populationgrowth Population growth in Muslimcountries, provides recruits forfundamentalism, terrorism, insurgency, andmigration. [thus] demographic growththreatens Muslim governments and non-
Muslim societies alike [and] Each of thesechallenges is having and will continue to haveinto the 21st century a highly destabilizing
impact on global politics
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
24/38
In a monograph on Reproductive Behaviour inMuslim Countries (1997), which I prepared for
UNFPA in 1997, based on the analyses of DHSdata from 12 Muslim countries, I had hadtaken the view that:
while poor socioeconomic conditions mighthave played an important role in maintaininghigh fertility in Muslim countries, more
recently effective family planning programscoupled with high female literacy seem tohave become major factors in achievingfertility transition in these countries.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
25/38
Post 9/11 there has been considerableinterest in Muslim population livingaround the World.
For example, the Economist ofLondon came out with a special issueon 13th September, 2003, with an
estimated population of 1.5 billionand the following regionaldistribution:
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
26/38
Distribution of Muslim Population by RegionSouth Asia
Middle East and
North AfricaSubsaharan
Africa
South East Asia
Central Asia
Europe and
North America
East Asia
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
27/38
I am of the view that:Demographic transition begun in most ofthe Muslim-majority countries at some timeover the past two decades, and in some, it
has moved very rapidly. Elsewhere, there isonly little evidence of the onset of fertilitydecline.
I support my view with the following dataand illustrations:
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
28/38
# of countries with CDR
of 1970 200025+ 10 0
20-24 6 4
15-19 12 7
10-15 10 6
5-9 5 18
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
29/38
Trends in Fertility Decline: 1960-2000
Till the early 1960s, fertility rates in almostall Muslim countries were fairly high.During the past 40 years many countries
have experienced substantial declines. Themost dramatic regional declines occurred inNorth Africa, where Egypt began with thegreatest early decline, quickly joined by
Tunisia, Morocco, and Algeria. All threeSouth-East Asian countries experiencedsimilar declines.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
30/38
Thus, in a majority of countries in theMuslim world, there is considerableevidence of demographic transition,
particularly in fertility, during the past 25years.
Muslim countries in East and West Africasaw only modest declines in fertility, whilein Asia, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Yemen andOman were the exceptions. The mostremarkable recent declines on the otherhand, were experienced by Bangladesh andIran.
Regional trends in fertility declines are
F tilit D li i N th d N th
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
31/38
Fertility Decline in North and North-East African Countries
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Algeria
Egypt
Libya
Moroc
co
Sudan
Tunisia
C
omoros
Djibo
uti
Somalia
TFR
Year 1960-65 Year 1970-75 Year 2000-05
F ili D li i W Af i
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
32/38
Fertility Decline in West AfricanCountries
TFR
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
89
B
urkin
aFaso
Chad
Gambia
Guine
aMa
li
Maurita
niaNi
ger
Sene
gal
SierraLe
one
Year 1960-65 Year 1975-80 Year 2000-05
Fertility Decline in West Asian
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
33/38
Fertility Decline inWest Asian
Countries
Fertility Decline in South-Central Asian
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
34/38
Fertility Decline in South-Central AsianCountries
0
2
4
6
8
Afgha
nistan
Banglad
esh
Iran
KirgyzIstan
Maldi
ves
Pakis
tan
Tajiki
stan
Turkme
nista
n
Uzbakis
tan
TFR
Year 1960-65 Year 1975-80 Year 2000-05
Fertility Decline in South East Asian Countries
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
35/38
Fertility Decline in South-East Asian Countries6.7 6.7
5.44.4 4.2
2.5 2.9 2.4
4.7
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Brunie
Da
ressalam
Malaysia
Indonesia
T
FR
1960-651975-802000-05
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
36/38
83
7472
6460
41
57 5449 48
28
64
56 56
14 1410 9 8
5
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Percen
t
Chima
Iran
UK
Turkey
Italy
Bulgaria
Indonesia
Bangladesh
Phillipines
India
Pakistan
Algeria
Egyp
t
SouthAfrica
Coted'lvoire
Niger
Sudan
Senega
l
Ethiopia
Mozambique
Country
Similarly, currently married women using
contraception show no significant
differences between Muslim and non-Muslim Countries- 2003
IN CONCLUSION
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
37/38
IN CONCLUSIONThere appears to be no typical pattern ofreproductive behavior which could be
described as Islamic. Islam as such seems tobe neither a hindrance nor a stimulating factorin fertility decline.
It seems that governments in most Muslimcountries, due to a pragmatic thinking haveadopted a positive approach to birth control.
However, with a few exceptions, contraceptiveuse rate is low and consequently fertility ishigh in some Muslim countries, similar to
other countries in the same region.
-
8/2/2019 Islamic Teachings on Reproductive Health and Fertility Transition
38/38
Recently Prof. Mehtab Karim co-edited a book with Prof. Gavin Jones
on Islam, the State and Population.Hearst & Co. London. 2005