islamic healing use among malay muslim cancer patients malaysian perspective
DESCRIPTION
SCIE (www.scie.org.au) JournalsTRANSCRIPT
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
61
Islamic Healing Use Among Malay-Muslim Cancer Patients:
Malaysian Perspective
Rosnah Mat Yatim1 Mazanah Muhamad
1 Steven Eric Krauss @ Abd. Lateef
2
1. Faculty of Educational Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia, 43400 Serdang, Selangor, Malaysia
2. Institute for Social Science Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia, 43400 Serdang, Selangor, Malaysia
* E-mail of the corresponding author: [email protected]
Abstract
The objective of this study was to identify the prevalence associated with Islamic healing (IH) use in
cancer patient. This empirical study was carried out within the four geographical zone of Peninsular
Malaysia: Northern region (Perlis, Kedah, Penang and Perak), Middle Coast (Selangor and Wilayah
Persekutuan Kuala Lumpur and Putrajaya), Southern region (Negeri Sembilan, Melaka and Johore) and
East Coast region (Pahang, Trengganu and Kelantan) between June 2013 and November 2013. The
sample consisted of 317 adult cancer patients who were receiving Islamic healing treatment at Islamic
Healing Centres and from individual Islamic healers. A well structured questionnaire that contains the
items that fulfil the research objective was used to collect the data by trained research officers. A total
of 317 patients completed the questionnaire for evaluation. The study comprised 269 women (84.9%)
and 48 males (15.1%), majorities were 51-60 years old of age (42.3%), married (82.3%), finished
tertiary education at diploma or higher certificate level (40.4%), government servant and pensioner
(49.9%) ,earning average income between Malaysian Ringgit 1000 to 5000 per month, and residence of
urban area (69.1%). The motives seeking Islamic healing were influenced mainly by the perception
about Islamic healing, religiosity and spirituality, attitude towards Islamic healing, belief about Islamic
healing, and family sanction. Then followed by recommendation from family and friend, credibility of
healer, economic factors, and understanding about Islamic healing. In this study, all the participants
have seek Islamic healing treatment for cancer treatment as complementary to conventional medicine.
Islamic healing is a reality and it deserves more investigation and appropriate legislation and control
Keywords: Islamic healing (IH), cancer
1. Introduction
Globally the incidence of cancer continues to increase. There were an estimated 14.1 million cancer
cases around the world in 2012, of these 7.4 million cases were in men and 6.7 million in women. This
number is expected to increase to 24 million by 2035. Although cancer is often considered to be more
of a develop world issue, in fact 57 per cent of all cancers (excluding non-melanoma skin cancer) occur
in less developed countries and 43 per cent in more developed countries. There were 268 cases of
cancer diagnosed per 100,000 in more developed regions, compared to 148 in less developed regions in
2012 (GLOBOCAN 2012).
Patients diagnosed with cancer normally suffer from physical, emotional, social and spiritual pain and
the journey of a cancer is a confusing and anxious experience for many cancer patients. Beyond the
fear experienced being diagnosed with initial diagnosis, the stress undergoing conventional treatment
and the worry associated with the cancer prognosis, many cancer patients are also faced with the
additional demand of making decisions about their cancer treatment including the traditional,
complementary and alternative medicine (TCAM). The use of TCAM around the world has increased
dramatically in recent times and it‘s use by patients living with cancer is particularly common (Ernst E,
2003; Tas et al, 2008; Eliot et al, 2008). TCAM commonly administered together with conventional
medical care to help to manage specific diseases (Hori et al, 2007; Algier et al, 2005; Akyol&Oz,
2011).
In Malaysia, the number of cancer cases are increasing. A total of 21,773 cancer cases were diagnosed
among Malaysians in Peninsular Malaysia in the year 2006 and registered in the National Cancer
Registry. It comprises of 9,974 males and 11,799 females, and the five most common cancer among
population of Peninsular Malaysia in 2006 were breast, colorectal, lung, cervix and nasopharynx.
Cancer seems to be predominant among Chinese as compared to Malay and Indian and it occurred at
all age. (National Cancer Registry, 2006). Besides seeing oncologist for conventional therapy, many
were known to seek complementary treatment for their cancer especially in Malaysian multi-racial,
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
62
cultural and belief. Malay-Muslim cancer patient in Malaysia is believed to frequently consult Islamic
healers who have practice Islamic healing as a choice of treatment for their illness.
Islamic healing is a modality that uses verses of the Quran or supplications of Prophet Muhammad
SAW for healing purposes. Islamic healing has been described in the Quran and sunnah (the tradition
of Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon Him) and involves both physical and spiritual factors. From the
perspective of Islamic tradition, the concept of religion is embedded in the umbrella of spirituality.
Religion provides the spiritual path for salvation and is lived as a total way of life that includes well-
being and medicine (Rasool, 2000). Within the fundamental framework of Islam, therapeutic strategies
in the Islamic medical tradition include spiritual, psychological and material aspects of healing
(Rahman et al; 2008). It would appear that Muslim patients living with cancer were found to seek
Islamic healer to treat their cancer disease and severity of the symptoms secondary to cancer, increase
quality of life and as an effort to help them to connect with and experience their whole self, including
their relationship to the Divine as they believed that for Muslims, the Quran itself is considered one of
the most powerful healing sources and is the best of all medicines available to humankind. The use of
Quranic recitation for healing has been shown to have direct healing effects on the various systems of
the human body (Razaei et al, 2008).
Malaysia is a developing country and as a result, few studies have attempted to find out the prevalence
and perspective of TCAM use among Malaysian cancer patients especially Islamic healing. At present,
there is no detailed records on the use of Islamic healing in the population for cancer treatment. As a
result, government standards relating to the quality of Islamic healing treatment in Malaysia have not
been fully addressed and not been considered in detail. Although the use of Islamic healing is becoming
widespread among Malay-Muslim, we still lack knowledge on the motives seeking Islamic healing
among Malay-Muslim cancer patient as a complementary to conventional medicine. This current
empirical study is a part of research project funded by University Putra Malaysia (UPM), aims to
determine the prevalence of Islamic healing used among Malay-Muslim cancer patient.
2. Methodology
This study was carried out within the four geographical zone of Peninsular Malaysia: Northern region
(Perlis, Kedah, Penang and Perak), Middle Coast (Selangor and Wilayah Persekutuan Kuala Lumpur
and Putrajaya), Southern region (Negeri Sembilan, Melaka and Johore) and East Coast region (Pahang,
Trengganu and Kelantan). The sample consisted of 317 adult cancer patients who were receiving
Islamic healing treatment at Islamic Healing Centres and from individual Islamic healers. A purposive
samples were selected from the Islamic Healing Centres and from individual healers. The inclusion
criteria for this study were patients with a diagnosis of cancer, 18 years of age and older, receiving
Islamic healing treatment, able and willing to participate in the study. Exclusion criteria were patients
under age 18 years, unable to understand written or verbal instructions to complete the questionnaire
and those who were not willing to participate. All 317 patients completed the questionnaires within 30
to 45 minutes. This study used a quantitative research design which is deemed sound and appropriate to
gather information from the respondents and then extensively use the statistical tools available to arrive
a particular findings and conclusion. A structured questionnaire was designed to fulfil the study
objectives. The questionnaire was divided into four sections. Section A related to socio-demographic
characteristics including age, gender, marital status, education level, occupation, income, and place of
residence. Section B was the patients‘ cancer profile. Section C was about the respondents‘
psychological and emotional status and Section D was about the motives of the respondents seeking
Islamic healing for their cancer treatment.
The questionnaire design was the outcome of many steps including comprehensive literature review,
and a brainstorming workshop. To refine the questionnaire, a pilot study was undertaken to test the
reliability of the questionnaire and was completed by 30 volunteers on two occasions. Cronbach α
coefficient of reliability ranged from 0.63 to 0.91 from the least to the most reliable questions.
Data were collected during the period from between June 2013 and November 2013 by a trained
research officer. The filled questionnaires were revised for completeness before leaving the patients
place. A quality assurance measure to check for accuracy was undertaken by field supervisors. The data
gathered in this study were analyzed and interpreted based on the descriptive and correlational analysis
using SPSS version 19 to analyze the means, standard deviations, frequency, percentage, reliability
coefficient that were computed for all the items in the surveys. The descriptive statistic measured the
variation of the items including the comprehensive descriptions of the personal detail, cancer profile,
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
63
psychological and emotional status and the motives have been identified.
3. Results
A total of 317 patients completed the questionnaire for evaluation. The study comprised 269 women
(84.9%) and 48 males (15.1%), majorities were 51-60 years old of age (42.3%), married (82.3%),
finished tertiary education at diploma or higher certificate level (40.4%), government servant and
pensioner (49.9%) ,earning average income between Malaysian Ringgit 1000 to 5000 per month, and
residence of urban area (69.1%). The results of socio-demographic and clinical characteristics of
patients are shown in Table 1.
Table 1: The results of socio-demographical characteristic of patients
Variables Frequency
(n=317)
Percentage %
Age
less than 30 5 1.6
31-40 29 9.1
41-50 67 21.1
51-60 134 42.3
61-70 68 21.5
more than 71 14 4.4
Gender
Male 48 15.1
Female 269 84.9
Marital status
Single 36 11.4
Married 261 82.3
Divorce 20 6.3
Education level
No formal education 1 .3
Primary 33 10.4
Secondary 103 32.5
Religious school 7 2.2
Diploma/ cert/ stpm 128 40.4
Degree/ Master/ Phd 45 14.2
Occupation
Government 83 26.2
Private 34 10.7
Statutory body 14 4.4
Housewife 47 14.8
Student 3 .9
Pensioner 75 23.7
Not working 50 15.8
Others 11 3.5
Income
no income 101 31.86
<RM1000 23 7.25
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
64
RM1001-RM5000 130 41.01
>RM5000 63 19.87
Place of residence
Urban 219 69.1
Rural 98 30.9
Based on Table 2, 60.9% (193) of the respondents were breast cancer, 32% (10.1%) were lung cancer,
followed by colorectal/ rectum, cervix/ uteri, lymphoma, stomach, leukemia, liver, nasopharyngeal and
other.
The most seeking Islamic healing were the patients presented with Stage 2 (29.7%) and Stage 3
(34.7%) of cancer. However, there was 11.7% (37) of the respondents were unsure with their stage of
cancer. Their cancer status was still active with 274 were considered as cancer patient including the
survivors and cancer re-occurrence. 4.1% (13) respondents claimed that they were free from cancer.
Most of them have been diagnosed with cancer more than 10 years ago and were cleared from cancer.
However, they still continue seeking Islamic healing. Surgery was still a choice for conventional
treatment for most of the cancer patient, followed by chemotherapy and radiotherapy, and most of them
are capable of doing their normal activities.
Table 2: The cancer characteristics of the respondents
Variables Frequency
(n=317)
Percentage %
Type of cancer Breast 193 60.9
Colorectal/rectum 13 4.1
Lung 32 10.1
Nasopharangeal 2 .6
Cervix/uteri 12 3.8
Lymphoma 11 3.5
Leukemia 6 1.9
Ovary 4 1.3
Stomach 8 2.5
Liver 6 1.9
Others (bone,colon, prostate, brain, kidney,
pancreas)
30 9.5
Stage of cancer 1 39 12.3
2 94 29.7
3 110 34.7
4 37 11.7
Not sure 37 11.7
Cancer status Cancer patient 186 58.7
Survivor 77 24.3
Cancer re-occurrence 11 3.5
Do not know 30 9.5
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
65
Cancer free 13 4.1
Type of conventional
therapy
Surgery YES
NO
221
96
69.2
30.3
Radiotherapy YES
NO
150
167
47.3
52.7
Chemotherapy YES
NO
177
140
55.8
44.2
Hormonal therapy YES
NO
50
267
15.8
84.2
Stem cell therapy YES
NO
4
313
1.3
98.7
Current physical
health status
I am capable of normal activities 191 60.3
I am capabale of normal activities but limited 126 39.2
The patients were asked about their psychological and emotional status before seeking Islamic healing.
Some people have a severe phobia about cancer. Before they know the real disease and unable to
accept it, they have a lot of suspicion. According to our understanding of the tumor patient, most have
suppression of the emotions after been diagnosed with cancer. Loss of hope and of future orientation,
together with the feeling of hopelessness, this is appeared to be an important sources of depression.
However, in this study, most of the patients have an average positive psychological and emotional
status before seeking Islamic healing where most of them answered ―some of the time‖ they feel more
positive about their cancer disease as shown as shown in Table 3.
Table 3: Percentage distribution of respondents’psychological and emotional status before
seeking Islamic healing
Items 1
None of
the time
2
A little
of time
3
Some of
the time
4
Most of
the time
5
All of
the
time
Means
SD
I feel irritable 8.5 19.2 43.5 27.1 1.6 2.94 0.93
I feel glad 3.2 17.4 46.7 25.6 7.3 3.16 0.91
I feel calm 3.2 21.5 38.5 28.1 8.8 3.18 0.97
I am hopeless 23.7 21.1 44.2 11.0 - 2.43 0.97
I am in a good spirits 0.6 13.9 40.4 35.6 9.5 3.39 0.86
I am satisfied with my life 2.2 15.5 40.4 28.4 13.6 3.36 0.97
My life has no meaning 25.6 22.7 39.7 11.4 0.6 2.39 1.01
I am not fit 10.1 18.0 41.6 28.7 1.6 2.94 0.97
I have confidence in myself 5.4 7.3 41.6 29.3 16.4 3.44 1.02
I have a bright future 4.7 6.0 45.1 30.6 13,6 3.42 0.96
The motives seeking Islamic healing were influenced mainly by the moderate level of perception about
Islamic healing, followed by religiosity and spirituality, positive attitude towards Islamic healing,
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
66
moderate level of belief about Islamic healing, and family sanction. Then followed by low level of
recommendation from family and friend, credibility of healer, economic factors , and understanding
about Islamic healing. The results of motives seeking Islamic healing among Muslim cancer patients
shown in Table 4.
Table 4: Level of Motives in seeking Islamic Healing
Variables Means SD
Perception about Islamic healing 2.92 0.264
Religiosity and spirituality 2.89 0.301
Attitude towards Islamic healing 2.70 0.411
Belief about Islamic healing 2.41 0.492
Family sanction 2.36 0.604
Recommendation from family and friends 2.29 0.457
Credibility of healer 2.26 0.456
Economic factors 2.20 0.487
Understanding about Islamic healing 2.17 0.384
Cultural 1.82 0.528
Dissatisfaction with conventional treatment 1.80 0.407
Delayed in hospital treatment 1.79 0.642
1-2.33=Low; 2.34-3.66=Moderate; 3.67-5=High
4. Discussion
The emergence and growth of Islamic healing therapy over the past decade as a treatment to boost
healing and quality of life for cancer patients has been remarkable. Based on Table 1, the results clearly
showed that most of the respondents who took part in this survey were aged between 51 and 60 years
old. Age is known to influence the measure of health status (Suthahar et al, 2009) and participants older
than 40 years old normally consulted traditional healer more than the young one (Al-Rowais, 2010;
Algier et al, 2005; Akyol, 2011). This result is consistent with those of the other studies done by
Montazeri et al, (2006) and Qidwai et al, (2009) where they found that aged more than 50 years were
independently associated with CAM used. In general, therefore it seems that most of the cancer
diseases was diagnosed within this age. Out of 317 respondents who filled out the questionnaire, 84.9%
were females and 15.1% were males. This result may be explained by the fact that female was reported
with higher use of CAM (Tas et al, 2008; Conboy et al, 2007; Hori et al, 2008; Can et al, 2009) for
their illness especially for breast cancer which is the most killing cancer in female. The reason for this
is not clear but it may have been something to do with different factors. The results of this study
seemed to confirm the findings of a study by Montazeri et al, (2005) in this field. However, the
findings of the current study do not support the study conducted by Tovey et al, (2005) where they
found that majority of the patients were men who seek CAM. It is probable that their studies were done
in Islamic country such as Pakistan where female decision making is restricted.
As mentioned in literature review, married patients reported higher use of CAM (Tas et al, 2008;
Conboy et al, 2007; and Hori et al, 2008). These findings agree with Tovey et al, (2005); Montazeri et
al, (2007); Al-Rowais et al, (2010) and Qidwai et al , (2009). It can therefore be assumed that the
marital status influenced the decision making in seeking Islamic healing as married patients had more
support from their spouse and family. Furthermore, highly educated get more resources and
accessibility to health services and more aware about their illness. These findings agree with Pud et al
(2005), and Maclennan et al (2002) who found that women with higher education used CAM
frequently and the visit to CAM practitioners were more frequent among highly educated individuals.
However, Montazeri et al (2007) and Al-Rowais et al (2010), stated that illiterate persons consulted
traditional healer more than university graduate did. These findings suggest that educated individuals
may have more resources and accessibility to health care information and services, and in addition they
are more aware of hazards of using non-licensed remedies. In this recent study, it can be concluded that
most of the respondents were illiterate as Malaysia is a country that every child must finish their study
at least their secondary education and there were a lot of opportunities to further their studies at tertiary
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
67
level.
Prior studies show that 54.3% of the respondents were not working including housewife and pensioner.
Meanwhile about 45.7% were still working in government and private sector. These variations can be
explained that it is possible that housewives and not working respondents find it easier to reach Islamic
healer at their convenience time. They do not need time off work and they have ample time to seek for
treatment (Al-Rowais et al, 2005). In the other hand, most of the respondents had an average of more
than RM 1000-RM 5000 for their monthly income. Mostly individual Malaysians are earning average
income and this Islamic healing are more readily available and inexpensive and affordable to average
income user. It is encouraging to compare this figure with that found by Tovey et al (2005) who found
that most of the individual who seeking CAM were earning an average income. It is observed that
Islamic healing user is higher in cities (69.1%) than in rural areas (30.9%). This result may be
explained by the fact that the Islamic healing center are more in city area and easily to access by the
patients. These findings support previous research by Molassitis et al , (2005) and Conboy et al, (2007)
who found that most of CAM Centre available in city area. However, the findings of the current studies
do not support the study conducted by Al-Rowais et al, (2010).
As shown in Table 2, breast cancer patient were more concerned about their choice of treatment. Breast
cancer patients are far more likely to be consistent users compared with other tumor sites. Morris et al
(2000) had found a significant relationship between breast cancer and complementary medicine. This
could be suggested that most of the breast cancer patient were discussing about other complementary
treatment including Islamic healing therapy options with their support group and this has helped the
patients make informed choices. Islamic healing use may play a role in the positive benefits associated
with support group attendance. This should be extended to other type of cancer especially for male
cancer patients. In this study, it was noted that the most frequently seeking Islamic healing was an
advance stage of cancer patients. This was considered as critical and life threatening condition and the
patients will seek an effort to heal (Shen et al, 2002) and Islamic healing used often increases following
cancer diagnosis and is more common among Malay-Muslim cancer patients and survivors. This result
is similar to Walshe et al, (2012). Normally, most of the cancer patient had surgery, radiotherapy and
chemotherapy as their conventional treatment. This was due to that most of the respondents in this
study were a breast cancer patients and surgery was one of the the main treatments for cancer and may
cure the cancer that is completely contained in that area and has not spread.
However, there was something lacking for the spiritual healing that can boost their inner strength.
Patients‘ tend to seek Islamic healing as this healing include the prayer, recitation of Quran and the
concept of ―tawakkal‖ that make the patients more comfortable with daily life. Prior to this study too, it
was noted that the respondents who went for Islamic healing are capable of doing normal activities
without limitation. This suggested that the respondents seemed to have the ability to perform their daily
activities as normal. In other words, health factor should not be a barrier for them to engage in their
normal daily activities and seeking for cure. Patients are encourage to engage in regular physical
activities and to works towards achieving the public health recommendation foe sufficient physical
activity during and after treatment so that they can live a more full and active lifestyle (Engquist et al,
2006). However, when it came to psychological and emotional status of the patients, it was found that
patients with positive views of misfortune because of cancer and sufficient social support were the key
elements of the healing process to alleviate spiritual suffering (Chio et al, 2008). They should keep
themselves happier, confidence, calm, desire to feel in control over the treatment of the disease,
―tawakkal‖ and submit to God.
With the increase popularity of Islamic healing among Malay-Muslim cancer patients, many seek
complementary treatment to complement the modern medicine. Patients are more optimistic about
choosing their treatment especially when it related to Islam. Most of the patients thought and
confidence that by reciting Quran, they could cure and control their metastatic disease and the believe
that every illness has a cure, and when the proper cure is applied to the disease, it heals by God‘s Will.
They became more religious since learning that they had a cancer and saw the development of cancer
as a form of punishment (Richard et al, 1984). They find hope and meaning of life and the acceptance
of uncertainty make them strong. Religion also help them to connect to the Divine as part of healing
process during the time of suffering. Moreover, to fight this life threatening disease, the patients should
come with more positive attitude towards behaviour that include perceived effectiveness of treatment,
anxiety regarding side effects and others (Hirai et al, 2007 ). The positive attitude led the desire to do
everything possible to fight the disease.
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
68
The belief that ―Ruqyah‖ (incantation) is a holistic approach, a large population of the respondent
believe that conventional medicine is a partial healing system that neglect socio-psychological and
spiritual aspect of healing. The belief in the Almighty and in the fact that through the grace of the
Almighty the spiritual element causing the illness will be removed (Ally& Laher, 2008). Besides, most
of the patients believe that the concept of healing by prayers is given by religion. This can be
definitely concluded that in Islam, the central belief of Muslim is that there is no God but Allah and
Muhammad (saw) is God‘s Prophet. Muslim has a very organized prayer life and Al-Quran is the
authority for knowing how to surrender to God‘s will in a variety of life‘s situation.
Health and faith in Islam are mutual related, where seek healer for their advice and support are the
same situation with seeking to a priest or rabbi in western context. Some Islamic healer are so well-
known and their credibility is so high that people come from near and far to see them personally.
Healer‘s credibility influences a cancer patient‘s choice for traditional healing as complementary
treatment (Mazanah et al, 2012) . Consultation and treatment from Islamic healers was common among
the participants and almost all the participants seek Islamic healing at least once after diagnosed with
cancer and the popularity of Islamic healing also increases. Earlier studies by Eisenberg (1998) showed
a similar findings as the consultation of alternative medicine in the Unites States increased between
1990-1997. Such a high prevalence must be a great concern since most of the Islamic healer are not
medically qualified and therefore their practices may not be free from risk and use of TCAM
exclusively can delay seeking medical advices in cancer patients. Moreover, not all Islamic healer hold
a valid license to practice from the Ministry of Health, which is making a lot of effort to control their
practice in the community. Patients usually reach Islamic healers on advice from immediate family and
friends. (Mazanah et al, 2012; Al-Rowais et al, 2010; Silbermann & Hassan, 2011). The findings of the
present study showed that recommendation from family and friends play a role in decision making to
seek Islamic healing. Particularly where there is a sanction from family especially for married couple.
They need to ask for their husband permission to seek Islamic healing and for not married they need to
ask permission from their parents to get a bless (Al-Rowais et al, 2010; Akyol et al, 2011). This reflects
one aspect of Muslim culture in which the wife must have a permission from the husband and children
must have a permission from the parents. The other motives that drove the patients to seek Islamic
healing were due to economic factor where the cost to seek Islamic healer is much cheaper than
conventional medicine. As for cancer treatment, the cost is high and become a burden to the patients
and family members (Schnipper, 2003). Moreover, accessibility to Islamic healer is not a barrier as
most of the patients have their own transport and support from family members that can drive them to
the healing center. Moreover, the understanding that Islamic healing normally performed by ―Raqi‖ or
―Ustaz‖, the one who recites verse of Al-Quran or ―doa‖, has sufficient knowledge and has to know the
recitation of Quran that used in ruqyah, without unethical practice of Islamic healing convinced the
patients to seek Islamic healing (Khan, 2008). Culture plays an important role in the concepts, attitude
and stigma attached to illness and cultural belief attribute to cultural norms (Razali et al, 2008).
However, in this study, even tough Malays had a very strong cultural bound towards theirs cultural
belief about traditional healing, the level of cultural that influence the patients to seek Islamic healing
was low. Dissatisfaction with conventional system and delayed in hospital treatment somehow become
one the motives for the patients to seek Islamic healing and the level for this factors is moderate.
However, Palinkas et al, (2000) reported that dissatisfaction with physician and their diagnosis were
not a cause for consulting CAM. This is not in line with Al-Rowais et al, (2010) where they found out
that the main reasons for the popularity of TCAM in Saudi were due to successful AM, preferences to
naturalness, failure of medical treatment, dissatisfaction with physician‘s diagnosis and long waiting
for doctor‘s appointment. These are important factors in the health belief model that should be of great
benefit when designing a health education and promotion campaign to explore people‘s ideas and
expectations of the health services and also to address the actual means of Islamic healing and
misguided belief about both Islamic healing and conventional medicine. Health beliefs strongly
influenced Islamic healing therapy use in this study. They had very definite ideas about Islamic healing
that were good for them and those things that would benefits their health. In a series of articles from
Canada (Verhoef et al., 2005), the author found that health beliefs were very strong influences on the
choices that breast cancer survivors made about using CAM. Not only that, in our study the patients
have specific ideas about things that were good for them, such as exercise, healthy diet, and daily
vitamins, but they also had beliefs about Islamic healing that were really benefit for them physically
and mentally.
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
69
5. Conclusion
The objective of this study to determine the prevalence for seeking Islamic healing related to Muslim
cancer patients. Their motives for seeking Islamic healing as a complementary to their conventional
treatment were almost similar to those who seek other traditional and complementary treatment for
other illness. The most important aspect before they seek Islamic healing was the perception about
what they are going to go through. The perception that they will perceive benefit from the treatment
was the main motives as by doing Islamic healing they will feel calm, relieved, confidence that they
will be cured, belief that Islamic healing will complement conventional treatment and confidence the
disease will be healed after seeing their relatives and friends with cancer cured after seeking Islamic
healing. From these good perceptions their belief in God and faith increased.
Nowadays, cancer patients are becoming more and more concerned with not only the physical aspect of
health, but the mental, emotional, and spiritual aspects as well. The use of Islamic healing therapies by
cancer patients shows the growing desire for these other aspects of health to be a part of their cancer
therapy. Many Islamic healing centers have risen up to meet the growing patient demand for Islamic
healing therapies by creating an integrative oncology initiative. With this growing popularity, Islamic
healing therapy enthusiasts are hoping that the need of patients, especially those with cancer, will be
met. Islamic healing is a reality and it deserves more investigation and appropriate legislation and
control in the healthcare management.
References
1.1.1 Ally, Y., Laher, S. (2008), ―South African Muslim faith healers perceptions of mental illness:
Understanding, aetiology and treatment‖. Journal of Religion and Health, 47, 45-56
1.1.2 Al-Rowais, N., Al-Faris, E., Gad Mohammad, A., Al-Rukban, M., Hamza, A. G. (2010),
―Traditional Healer In Riyahd Region: Reasons And Health Problems For Seeking Their Advice. A
Household Survey‖. The Journal Of Alternative And Complementary Medicine. 16(3), 199-204.
Algier, L.A., Hanoglu, Z., Ozden, G., Kara, F. (2005), ― The use of complementary and alternative
(non-conventional) medicine in cancer patients in Turkey‖. European Journal of Oncology Nursing, 9
(2), 138–146
Akyol, A. D., Oz, B. (2011), ―The Use Of Complementary And Alternative Medicine By Patients With
Cancer: In Turkey‖. Journal Of Complementary Therapies In Clinical Practice, 17, 230-234.
Can, G., Erol, O., Aydıner, A., Topuz, E. (2009), ― Quality of life and complementary and alternative
medicine use among cancer patients in Turkey‖. European Journal of Oncology Nursing, 13, 287-294.
Chio, C.C., Shih, F.J., Lin, W. R.,Hsiao, F. H., Chen, Y. T. (2008),‖The lived experiences of spiritual
suffering and the healing process among Taiwanese patients with terminal cancer‖, Journal of Clinical
Nursing, 17(6), 735–743
Conboy, L., Kaptchu, T., eisenberg, D., Gottlieb, B., Garcia, D. (2007), ―The relationship between
social factors and attitudes toward conventional and CAM practitioners‖. Complementary Therapies in
Clinical Practice, 13,146-57.
Ernst, E. (2003), ―The current position of complementary and alternative medicine in cancer‖.
European Journal of Cancer. 39, 2273-2277
Eliot, J., Kealey, C., Olver, I. (2008), ―Using complementary and alternative medicine: the perceptions
of palliative patients with cancer. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 11(1), 58-67.
2 Engquist, K. B., Taylor, C., Rosenblum, C., Smith, M., Shinn, E., Greisinger, A., Gregg, X.,
Massey, P., Valero, V., Rivera, E. (2006), ―Randomized pilot test of a lifestyle physical activity
intervention for breast cancer survivors‖. Patient Education and Counselling, 64 (1-3), 225-234
Hirai, K., Komura, K., Tokoro, A., Kuromaru, T.,Ohshima, A., Ito, T., Sumiyoshi, Y. (2007),
―Psychological and behavioral mechanisms influencing the use of complementary and alternative
medicine (CAM) in cancer patients‖. Annals of Oncology, 19 (1), 49-55.
Hori,S., Mihaylov, I., Vasconcelos, J., Mccoubre, M.(2008), ― Patterns Of Complementary And
Alternative Medicine Use Amongst Outpatients In Tokyo, Japan‖. BMC Complementary And
Alternative Medicine , 8 (14)
Eisenberg, D. M., David, R. B., Ettner, S. L. (1998), ―Trends in Alternative Medicine Use in United
States‖. JAMA. 280, 1569-1575
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
70
International Agency for Research on Cancer. GLOBOCAN 2012: estimated cancer incidence,
mortality and prevalence worldwide in 2012. Lyon, France: International Agency for Research on
Cancer/World Health Organization; 2012.
Maclennan, A. H., Wilson, D. H., Taylor, A. W. (2002), ― The Escalating Cost And Prevalence Of
Alternative Medicine‖. Preventive Medicine, 35, 166-173.
Mazanah, M., Merriam, S., Norhasmilia, S. (2012), ―Why Breast Cancer Patients Seek Traditional
Healers,‖International Journal of Breast Cancer, 2012, 9.
Montazeri, A., Sajadian, A., Ebrahimi, M., Haghighat, S., Harirchi, I. (2007), Factors Predicting The
Use Of Complementary And Alternative Therapies Among Cancer Patients In Iran. European Journal
Of Cancer Care, 16 (2), 144-149
Molassiotis, A., Margulies, A., Fernadez-Ortega, P., Pud, D., Özden, G., Scott, J. A. (2005), ―Use of
complementary and alternative medicine in cancer patients: a European survey‖. Annals of
Oncology ,16(4), 655-663.
Malaysian cancer statistics- data and figure. Peninsular malaysia (2006). National Cancer Registry
3 Morris, K.T., Johnson, N., Homer, L., Walts, D. (2000), ―A comparison of complementary
therapy use between breast cancer patients and patients with other primary tumor sites‖. The American
Journal of Surgery, 179 (5), 407-411
Palinkas, L. A., Kabongo, M. I. (2000), ―San Diego Unified Practice Research in Family Medicine
Network: The use of complementary and alternative medicine by primary care patients‖. Journal of
Family Practice. 49, 1121-1130.
Pud, D., Kaner, E., Morag, A., Ami, S., Yaffe, A. (2005), ―Use Of Complementary And Alternative
Medicine Among Cancer Patients In Israel‖. European Journal Of Oncology Nursing, 9, 124-130
3.1.1 Qidwai.W., Tabassum. R., R Hanif.R., FH Khan. F.H.(2009),” Belief in prayers and its role in healing among family practice patients visiting a teaching hospital in Karachi, Pakistan”. Pak J Med Sci, April-June
Rahman, M. T., Nazer, R., Brown, L., Shogar, I., Bouzenita, A. I. (2008), ―Therapeutic
Interventions: An Islamic Perspective‖. Journal of the Islamic Medical Association of North
America, 40 (2)
Rassool, G. H (2000), ―The crescent and Islam: healing, nursing and the spiritual dimension. Some
considerations towards an understanding of the Islamic perspectives on caring‖. Journal of Advanced
Nursing, 32 (6),1476–1484
Razali, S. M. & Yassin, A. M (2008). Complementary Treatment of Psychotic and Epileptic Patients in
Malaysia.
Transcultural psychiatry, 45(3): 455–469.
Richard, N. E., David, V. S. (1984), ―Cancer patients' insight into their treatment, prognosis, and
unconventional therapies‖. Cancer, 53 (12), 2736-2740
Rezaei, M., Hajbaghery, M. A., Seyedfatemi, N. & Hoseini, F. (2008). Prayer in Iranian cancer patients
undergoing chemotherapy. Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice, 14: 90–97.
Schnipper, H. H. (2003), ―Life After Breast cancer‖. Journal of Clinical Oncology. 21 (9), 104-107
Shen, J., Andersen, R., Albert, P., Wenger, N., Glaspy, J., Cole, M. (2002), ―Use Of Complementary
And Alternative Therapies By Women With Advanced-Stage Breast Cancer. BMC Complement And
Alternative Medicine, 2(1), 8.
Silbermann, M., Hassan, E. (2011), ―Cultural Perspectives in Cancer Care: Impact of Islamic Traditions
and Practices in Middle Eastern Countries‖Journal of Pediatric Hematology/Oncology, 33, 81-86.
Suthahar A, Gurpreet K, Ambigga D, Maniam T, Dhachayani S, Fuad I, Adlina S (2009), ―A profile of
cancer patient outcomes from a tertiary care teaching hospital in Malaysia‖. Singapore Medical
Journal , 50(7),720-723
Australian Journal of Asian Country Studies
SCIE Journals
Australian Society for Commerce Industry & Engineering
www.scie.org.au
71
Tas, F., Ustuner, Z., Can, G., Eralp, Y., Basaran, M.(2008), ―The Prevalence And Determinants Of The
Use Of Complementary And Alternative Medicine In Adult Turkish Cancer Patients‖. Acta Oncologia,
44(2), 161-167.
Tovey, P., Broom, A., Chatwin, J., Ahmad, S., Hafeez, M. (2005),‖ Use Of Traditional, Complementary
And Allopathic Medicines In Pakistan By Cancer Pateints. Rural And Remote Health, 5, 447-456
Verhoef, M., Balneaves, L., Boon, H., Vroegindewey, A. (2005), ―Reasons for and characteristics
associated with complementary and alternative medicine among adult cancer patients: a systematic
review‖. Integrative Cancer Therapies , 4, 274-286.
Walshe, R., James, E. L., Wicks, L. M., Boyes, A. W., Zucca, A., Girgis, A., Lecathelinais, C. (2012),
―Socio-demographic and medical correlates of the use of biologically based complementary and
alternative medicines amongst recent Australian cancer survivors‖. Preventive Medicine, 54 (1), 23-26