introduction to randomized controlled clinical trials (2nd edn). john n. s. matthews, chapman &...

1
1328 BOOK REVIEWS 3. INTRODUCTION TO RANDOMIZED CONTROL- LED CLINICAL TRIALS (2nd edn). John N. S. Matthews, Chapman & Hall/CRC, Boca Raton, FL, 2006. No. of pages: 283. Price: $59.95. ISBN 978-1-58488-624-2 This revised version of the popular text by John Matthews includes several welcome additions and some thoughtful reworking. The aim of the book remains, as for the first edition, to provide an in- troductory text on clinical trial methodology for final-year undergraduate or postgraduate students of statistics. The author does not define its remit to include issues of trial management and practical implementation, which are amply covered by other authors, such as Altman [1], Friedman et al. [2] and Pocock [3]. Instead, the focus is on describing the fundamental statistical and mathematical prin- ciples which underpin the randomized concurrently controlled clinical trial that is used in many areas of medical research. The 12 chapters of the book now cover all of the essential topics in this area. The first six deal with the topics of basic background, bias, sample size calculations, methods of allocating patients, blinding and placebos and analysis issues. In the first edition of the book, most of the mathematical concepts were presented for the case of normally distributed data. This is still largely (although not exclusively) true for the chapters that are in com- mon between the two editions, but in the second edition there is a new chapter (Chapter 7) on the analysis of clinical trials involving binary and sur- vival time endpoints. This is a definite strength, and at over 50 pages, the addition represents a substantial inclusion of new material. Topics cov- ered include analysis of data from trials of binary and survival time outcomes, adjusting binary out- comes for baseline observations and analyses using randomization models. Treatment of material is concise, but the key concepts are covered clearly and at a suitable level. The remaining five chapters of the book cover the topics of monitoring data, subgroups and multiple outcomes, protocols, spe- cial designs (crossovers, equivalence and cluster randomized trials) and meta-analysis. A minor point is that there is very limited discussion of Bayesian approaches and repeated measures anal- ysis. Coverage of all the topics is logically struc- tured, clearly written and well motivated. Each chapter ends with exercises, the solutions to which are included at the end of the book. Throughout the book, worked examples are given which have been taken from the medical literature. The methods described in the text are implemented, often in the context of the exam- ples, using two software packages, Minitab and R. The use of R, which is universally available, will allow the book to be of use to a wider audience. Preceding the ‘Solutions to Exercises’ is a section on ‘Further Reading’. The author acknowledges that this is ‘a highly selected and personal view of an extensive literature’. However, this sec- tion, together with the References, could be more comprehensive. In summary, this second edition is a very welcome revision. The author has drawn upon his experiences to provide a valuable account of the important statistical underpinnings of the random- ized clinical trial. Having a text written primarily for students of statistics is highly desirable and this book is ideal for its intended audience. REFERENCES 1. Altman DG. Practical Statistics for Medical Research. Chapman & Hall/CRC: London, 1991. 2. Friedman LM, Furberg CD, DeMets DL. Funda- mentals of Clinical Trials (3rd edn). Springer: New York, 1998. 3. Pocock SJ. Clinical Trials: A Practical Approach. Wiley: New York, 1983. SUSAN TODD Medical & Pharmaceutical Statistics Research Unit The University of Reading Reading, U.K. (DOI: 10.1002/sim.3075) Copyright 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Statist. Med. 2008; 27:1325–1328

Upload: susan-todd

Post on 06-Jul-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Introduction to randomized controlled clinical trials (2nd edn). John N. S. Matthews, Chapman & Hall/CRC, Boca Raton, FL, 2006. No. of pages: 283. Price: $59.95. ISBN 978-1-58488-624-2

1328 BOOK REVIEWS

3. INTRODUCTION TO RANDOMIZED CONTROL-LED CLINICAL TRIALS (2nd edn). John N. S.Matthews, Chapman & Hall/CRC, Boca Raton,FL, 2006. No. of pages: 283. Price: $59.95. ISBN978-1-58488-624-2

This revised version of the popular text by JohnMatthews includes several welcome additions andsome thoughtful reworking. The aim of the bookremains, as for the first edition, to provide an in-troductory text on clinical trial methodology forfinal-year undergraduate or postgraduate studentsof statistics. The author does not define its remitto include issues of trial management and practicalimplementation, which are amply covered by otherauthors, such as Altman [1], Friedman et al. [2]and Pocock [3]. Instead, the focus is on describingthe fundamental statistical and mathematical prin-ciples which underpin the randomized concurrentlycontrolled clinical trial that is used in many areasof medical research.

The 12 chapters of the book now cover all ofthe essential topics in this area. The first six dealwith the topics of basic background, bias, samplesize calculations, methods of allocating patients,blinding and placebos and analysis issues. In thefirst edition of the book, most of the mathematicalconcepts were presented for the case of normallydistributed data. This is still largely (although notexclusively) true for the chapters that are in com-mon between the two editions, but in the secondedition there is a new chapter (Chapter 7) on theanalysis of clinical trials involving binary and sur-vival time endpoints. This is a definite strength,and at over 50 pages, the addition represents asubstantial inclusion of new material. Topics cov-ered include analysis of data from trials of binaryand survival time outcomes, adjusting binary out-comes for baseline observations and analyses usingrandomization models. Treatment of material isconcise, but the key concepts are covered clearlyand at a suitable level. The remaining five chaptersof the book cover the topics of monitoring data,subgroups and multiple outcomes, protocols, spe-cial designs (crossovers, equivalence and cluster

randomized trials) and meta-analysis. A minorpoint is that there is very limited discussion ofBayesian approaches and repeated measures anal-ysis. Coverage of all the topics is logically struc-tured, clearly written and well motivated. Eachchapter ends with exercises, the solutions to whichare included at the end of the book.

Throughout the book, worked examples aregiven which have been taken from the medicalliterature. The methods described in the text areimplemented, often in the context of the exam-ples, using two software packages, Minitab and R.The use of R, which is universally available, willallow the book to be of use to a wider audience.Preceding the ‘Solutions to Exercises’ is a sectionon ‘Further Reading’. The author acknowledgesthat this is ‘a highly selected and personal viewof an extensive literature’. However, this sec-tion, together with the References, could be morecomprehensive.

In summary, this second edition is a verywelcome revision. The author has drawn upon hisexperiences to provide a valuable account of theimportant statistical underpinnings of the random-ized clinical trial. Having a text written primarilyfor students of statistics is highly desirable andthis book is ideal for its intended audience.

REFERENCES

1. Altman DG. Practical Statistics for MedicalResearch. Chapman & Hall/CRC: London, 1991.

2. Friedman LM, Furberg CD, DeMets DL. Funda-mentals of Clinical Trials (3rd edn). Springer: NewYork, 1998.

3. Pocock SJ. Clinical Trials: A Practical Approach.Wiley: New York, 1983.

SUSAN TODDMedical & Pharmaceutical Statistics

Research UnitThe University of Reading

Reading, U.K.

(DOI: 10.1002/sim.3075)

Copyright q 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Statist. Med. 2008; 27:1325–1328