introduction to ethanol production – no, not the drinking kind! bia h. thomas, ph.d. che 473a...
Post on 19-Dec-2015
214 views
TRANSCRIPT
Introduction to Ethanol Production – No, Not the Drinking Kind!
Bia H. Thomas, Ph.D.
ChE 473A Lecture
October 19th, 2011
St. Louis, MO
Outline
• Why is Ethanol Important?• How is Ethanol Made?• The Monod Model• The Wonderful World of Kinetics• The Bioreactor Setup• Some Analytical Techniques• Sample Results• Modeling• Some Final Thoughts
The Renewable Energy Question
• Current world oil consumption is 88 million barrels/day which will continue to grow rapidly
• By 2050 the world population will reach 9-10 billion and current reserves of both oil and natural gas will be exhausted
• How to supply the vast quantities of energy, fuels and chemicals when oil, gas and coal are no longer readily available is one of the most challenging and important problems now facing humanity
• Renewable sources of energy and chemicals will replace the fossil-based fuels and products
• Ethanol is one of the renewable sources of energy which is considered a cleaner source of bioenergy
Ethanol Production From Corn
• 2010: 13 billion gallons of ethanol
Source: www.ethanolrfa.org/industry/locations
The Case for Ethanol
• Demand for ethanol is increasing with ever mounting pace: In 2003, the US production of bioethanol was 2.8 billion gallons from 175 million gallons in 1980 and 1.77 billion gallons in 2001
• Bio-ethanol is derived from cellulosic and lignocellulosic biomass via the following processes:
CellulosicMillingLiquefactionSaccharificationFermentation
LignocellulosicPretreatmentSaccharificationFermentation (C6 and C5)
• Ethanol can be produced from corn, a starch-based cellulosic biomass, according to the reaction:
yeast (X), 36°CC6H12O6 → 2C2H5OH + 2CO2
Glucose (S) → 2 Ethanol (P) + 2 Carbon Dioxide
The Dry Grind Process
• Dry grind:– Corn processed whole– Less complex– Lower initial capital cost– Fewer unit operations – 3 products: ethanol, CO2,
and DDGS• Wet milling:
– Only 30% of facilities are wet milling
– Fractionation of corn kernel into starch, gluten, fiber, germ
• Separation: chemically or enzymatically
– Products: ethanol, gluten meal, gluten feed, oil
• Starch component can be processed into many products
Hammer Mill
Slurry Tank
Liquefaction Fermentor
Beer Well
Distillation Column
Molecular Sieves
Ethanol Storage Tank
1st EffectEvaporator Whole
StillageTank
Centrifuge
Ring Dryer
ThinStillageTank
3rd EffectEvaporator2nd Effect
Evaporator
CO2Scrubber
Syrup Tank
DDGs
Ethanol
Whole Stillage
CornMash
Thin Stillage
Syrup
WDGs
Corn Carbon Dioxide
To CO2 Scrubber
Hammer Mill
Slurry Tank
Liquefaction Fermentor
Beer Well
Distillation Column
Molecular Sieves
Ethanol Storage Tank
1st EffectEvaporator Whole
StillageTank
Centrifuge
Ring Dryer
ThinStillageTank
3rd EffectEvaporator2nd Effect
Evaporator
CO2Scrubber
Syrup Tank
DDGs
Ethanol
Whole Stillage
CornMash
Thin Stillage
Syrup
WDGs
Corn Carbon Dioxide
To CO2 Scrubber
Fermentation Processes
• Ideal fermentation processesIdeal fermentation processes• Growing cells are consuming the substrate (sugars) and producing Growing cells are consuming the substrate (sugars) and producing
more cellsmore cells
rsx = rate of substrate consumptionrsx = rate of substrate consumptionrx = rate of cell growthrx = rate of cell growths = substrate concentrations = substrate concentrationx = cell concentrationx = cell concentrationP = ethanol concentration (in anaerobic case)P = ethanol concentration (in anaerobic case)
rx
Cells (x)P
Cells (x)
rsx
The Monod Model
• Monod's model describes the relationship between the specific growth rate and the growth limiting substrate concentration as:
where µm is the maximum specific growth rate and Ks is a saturation constant
• Despite its empirical nature Monod's model is widely used to describe the growth of many organisms. Basically because it does adequately describe fermentation kinetics
• Model has been modified to describe complex fermentation systems
Assumptions and Constraints
• Monod model represents a very simple model of cell growth and product formation
– Fermentation processes are often much more complex
• Modifications may need to be introduced to handle more complicated systems
• Additional equations would be required to handle multiple products and multiple organisms
• The model has also assumed that product formation is linked to biomass growth
• In reality, many commercially important products are produced in a non-growth associated manner
• The model assumes that biomass and product formation can be represented by averaged yield coefficients
• These assumptions may sometimes be an oversimplification and such a model would give unrealistic results
Why Is It Important?
• When the model is solved numerically, a number of curves are obtained
• With the model it is possible to:
– Determine the number of fermentations that can be performed per year
– Amount of profit that can be made.
Kinetics, Kinetics, More Kinetics
• The rates of microorganisms’ growth, the consumption of glucose, and the formation of products are:
Xrdt
dXX
Xqrdt
dPPP
(1)
(3)
(2)
(4)
Rate of reaction relative to cell mass concentration
Rate of reaction relative to ethanol concentration
Rate of reaction relative to glucose concentration
Specific growth rate without inhibition effect Monod’s model
(5)
(6)
Yield coefficient (X w.r.t. S)
Yield coefficient (P w.r.t. S)SS
PP
dS
dPY
SS
XX
dS
dXY
SK
S
dt
dX
x
XY
qr
dt
dS
o
oSP
o
oSX
S
m
SP
PS
1
/
1
The Bioreactor Setup
Thermostatically controlled
heating/cooling water bath
Variable Speed Drive
Gas Meter
Analyzer
Fraction Collector
Bidirectional Pump
37L Reactor
Inoculum Port
Thermocouple
Drive Belt
Draft Tubefor heating/
cooling
The Bioreactor Setup
Online biochemistry analyzer for ethanol concentration detection
Automatic temperature control via draft tube
pH meter for optimum pH control
Fraction collector for automatic sampling system
Turbine impeller for uniform yeast distribution
Temperature Read Out
Bench-scale 37L Stirred Fermentor (active volume: 16 L)
Analytical and Measurement Techniques
• YSI analyzer– Takes online samples every hour to measure ethanol and glucose
concentrations– Automatically samples test tubes for substrate concentration
• Spectrophotometer– Absorbance measurement for each test tube – Absorbance used for calculating yeast concentration in each test tube
using calibration curve• Gas Meter:
– Measures the volume of CO2 evolved during fermentation– Volume used to calculate number of moles of ethanol produced
• Other methods such as Brix Glucose Test and Ethanol Reagent Kits can be used to determine sample composition
Sample Results
TA Results
0
5
10
15
20
0 500 1000 1500T ime (min)
Su
bst
rate
Co
nce
ntr
atio
n (
g/L
)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Eth
ano
l C
on
cen
trat
ion
(g
/L)
Subst rate Concent rat ion Ethanol Concent rat ion
• Results of the base line study (20 g/L of glucose and 4 g/L yeast) at 36°C• pH kept between 5.5 and 4.0• Samples taken every 45 minutes
Sample Results
Yeast concentration inside the fermentor throughout the experimentation time
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
0 10 20 30 40 50Time (hr)
Ye
ast
co
nce
ntr
atio
n in
sid
e t
he
re
act
or
(g/L
)Glucose 50 g/L
Glucose 100 g/L
Glucose 150 g/L
Glucose 200 g/L
Glucose 250 g/L
• The plot shows that at high initial glucose concentrations the growth of the yeast gets affected and thus, the yeast takes longer time to inhibit the growth
Sample Results
• Yeast was not incubated prior to experiment which explains the delay in the production of ethanol for all groups
• From the figure initial glucose concentrations of 50, 100, and 150 g/L allowed fermentor to reach its maximum capacity
• For the 2 highest glucose concentrations students believe that the time for the experiment was not long enough
Ethanol production throughout the experimentation time
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
0 10 20 30 40 50Time (hr)
Eth
an
ol C
on
cen
tra
tion
insi
de
th
e r
ea
cto
r (g
/L)
Glucose 50 g/L
Glucose 100 g/L
Glucose 150 g/L
Glucose 200 g/L
Glucose 250 g/L
Slight Problems
• What can go wrong?
• Errors given by the analytical equipment
• Error in reading gas meter
• Water bath can stop working
• Error given by misuse of analyzer
• Faulty impeller motor shaft
• Faulty pumps
Kinetic Modeling
Glucose and Ethanol Concentration vs Time
0
5
10
15
20
0 500 1000 1500T ime (min)
Subs
trat
e C
once
ntra
tion
(g/L
)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Eth
anol
Con
cent
ratio
n (g
/L)
Subst rate Concent rat ion Model-SEthanol Concent rat ion Model-P
Xrdt
dXX
Xqrdt
dSSS
Xqrdt
dPPP
2.5
44.12
1.0
386.0
P
S
I
m
I
m
q
q
K
SK
S
μm = maximum specific growth rate
KI = saturation coefficient for cell growth
qP = specific ethanol production rate
qS = specific glucose production rate
• Experimental data consistent with basic Monod model• Kinetic parameters are obtained from Baltes (1994, Biotechnol. Prog.)
Final Thoughts
• Ethanol is NOT the answer – As fuel or to drown your sorrows!
• Multi-prong approach is necessary to solve world’s energy problems– Solar, Wind, Biogas, Bio-oil, Biodiesel, Biochemicals, …
• Multidisciplinary efforts are necessary to make it work
• Applied engineering and scale-up research will make solutions feasible and cost effective
• Alternative energy technologies must have legs of its own to survive– No tax credits– No government incentives
• What you learn in this class will help solve the problems of today and of the future
Questions