introduction to designing online community nov09
TRANSCRIPT
Designing for online communities:thinking about social and technical design
Nancy White/Full Circle AssociatesMatt Moore/Innotecture
Human spectrogram
Tech + Social:Tech + Social:Technology has
fundamentally changed how we can be together
http://technologyforcommunities.com/
what is online community anyway?
• Our baseline definition(s)
Learning Communities
Knowledge Networks
Communities of Practice
Online Communities
Knowledge Networks
Labels!!!
Communities of Practice
• A group of people...• Who share challenges, passions or interest• Interact regularly• Who learn with and from each other• Improve their ability to do what they care
about ---- Etienne Wenger
individual group community network
Many: Networks
We: Communities
Me: the IndividualPersonal identity,
interest & trajectory
Bounded membership;
group identity, shared interest
Boundaryless; fuzzy,
intersecting interests
http://www.flickr.com/photos/dnorman/436670816/
Many: Networks
We: Communities
Me: the IndividualIndividual
learning, personal learning
environments …
Classes, informal learning cohorts,
conferences, clubs…
Facebook, Twitter,
YouTube, Wikipedia, etc…
Many: Networks
We: Communities
Me: the IndividualPersonal identity,
interest & trajectory
Bounded membership;
group identity, shared interest
Boundaryless; fuzzy,
intersecting interests
social design purpose, people and processes
technical design tools and infrastructure
social design: purpose
• gain > pain• who’s purpose?• orientations
purpose exercise
• What is the purpose of your community/group?
• Community Checklist
our purpose strengths
• (we’ll fill this in as the pairs report out…)
our purpose challenges
• (we’ll fill this in as the pairs report out…)
revise?
• After hearing other people’s ideas, do you want to alter yours at all?
• Share any changes at your table - briefly
social design: people
attitude
learning style
motivation
Experience - technology
learning
network maps
• sticky notes• big paper• pens• see Eva Schiffer’s NetMap process
http://netmap.wordpress.com
social design: process
online facilitationcommunity management
rolesnorms, rules, agreements
role modelingBut we'll come back to this...
technical design tools and infrastructure
technical stewardship
access
tool selectionImplementation/configurationpractices
addressing inherentcommunity tensions Tools
Groupasynchronous
IndividualInteracting
Publishing
synchronousGroup
asynchronous
discussion boards
teleconference
chat
instant messaging
member directory
wikiblog
telephony/VoIP
individualprofile page
e-mail lists
scratch pad
RSS
“new” indicators
subscription
podcast
contentrepository
presenceindicator
buddy list
security
Q&A systems
RSS aggregator
newsletter
calendar
videoconference
application sharing
whiteboard
site index
participation statistics
search
subgroups
personalization
communitypublic page
versioncontrol
documentmanagement
UseNet
contentrating
scheduling
polling
commenting
networking tools
tagging
bookmarking
sharedfiltering
geomapping
www.TechnologyForCommunities.com
Etienne WengerNancy WhiteJohn Smith
which tools?
• minimum, elegant configuration• where you do/don’t have choice• straddling tools – the reality today
process design
driven by purposeshaped by technologyeffected by people
scaffolds/pathstechnical experimentationfacilitation
roles exercise
• Design a job description for a community leader/facilitator/manager (decide) for either an internal or external community
• For each line of the description, begin to think about a story or scenario that embodies that job requirement.
sharing it out
• Have a dramatic title for each story• Make it real• Listen for key ideas as others tell their
story
15% solution
Noticing and using the influence, discretion and power individuals have right now.
– Keith McCandless
don’t worry – there will be bumps in the road…TALK about them
and…
• Other issues: monitoring and evaluation, more on technology…
• Where to learn more? With whom?• Where to practice?
Resources
Online Community Checklisthttp://onlinefacilitation.wikispaces.com/Online+Community+Planning+Checklisthttp://onlinefacilitation.wikispaces.com/OZ+Online+Community+Workshops
Nancy’s Bloghttp://www.fullcirc.com
Matt’s Bloghttp://innotecture.wordpress.com/
Nancy’s Wikihttp://onlinefacilitation.wikispaces.com/
Nancyw at fullcirc dot comMatt’s at innotecture at gmail dot com
… meetings
… relationships
… community cultivation
… access to expertise
… projects
… context
… individual participation
… content publishing
… open-ended conversation
Community activities
oriented to …
Base material from: Digital Habitats: Stewarding technology for
communities© 2009 Wenger, White, and Smith
activities oriented to …
… meetings
… context… community cultivation
… access to expertise
… projects
… open-ended conversation
… content publishing
… individual participation
… relationships
© 2007 Wenger, White, and Smith
Purpose:
Community activities
oriented to …
… meetings
… context… community cultivation
… access to expertise
… projects… open-ended conversation
… content publishing
… individual participation
… relationships
© 2007 Wenger, White, and Smith
No image skills
Existing relationships
Basis for evaluation - motivated
Diverse skills/motivation
New to web meetings
… meetings
… access to expertise
… context… community cultivation
… projects… open-ended conversation
… content publishing
… individual participation
… relationships
© 2006 Wenger, White, and Smith
Community activities
oriented to …
course
… meetings
… access to expertise
… context… community cultivation
… projects… open-ended conversation
… content publishing
… individual participation
… relationships
© 2006 Wenger, White, and Smith
Community activities
oriented to …
support community
Togetherness Separateness
Interacting Publishing
Individual Group
http://www.flickr.com/photos/dsevilla/189528500/in/set-1368427/
Emerging ro
les
and
practic
es…