introduction botulism score results · • the proposed botulism-score may be helpful in the...

1
A retrospective case study through review of patient charts. Symptoms, medical treatment including botulism antitoxin treatment and patient outcomes were registered. For monitoring of disease progression a scoring system was developed. Blood and stool from all patients were sent (Fig. 2/3 Day 1) to the Danish State Serum Institute (SSI) to verify the clinical diagnosis and from one patient also to the German Robert Koch Institute (RKI). A 76-years-old woman presented at her local hospital with a four hours history of diplopia, sore throat, vertigo and general discomfort. The patient had eaten dinner at a private party with retired colleagues the previous day. Within hours of admittance, the patient developed dysarthria, bilateral abducens nerve palsy, dysphagia and difficulty breathing. During this time and the next day, several of her friends from the dinner party were admitted with similar symptoms. A tentative diagnose of foodborne botulism was suspected. We present the symptoms, treatment and outcomes of the patients in the largest foodborne botulism outbreak registered in Denmark. All nine female persons exposed developed symptoms of botulism with varying severity. Average age of the patients was 74 years (68-81). Four patients had severe symptoms with need for intubation and were hospitalized 35-83 days. Five patients had mild symptoms with no need for intubation and were hospitalized 6-9 days Time from diagnosis to the first antitoxin treatment was minimum seven hours because of logistical challenges (see Fig. 1). Eight patients were treated with antiserum. Four patients were treated with Trivalent- Antitoxin, two with Heptavalent-Antitoxin and two patients were treated with Heptavalent- and Trivalent-Antitoxin. One allergic reaction to the Trivalent-Antitoxin was registered. All patients survived. After three months all had recovered, five patients with no deficits and four with mild motor deficits. Blood samples from seven patients were tested positive for Botulinum Toxin A in mouse bioassay. Clostridium botulinum was cultured from three patient´s stool samples. These three isolates were further tested positive for Botulinum Toxin A with PCR and subtype A5 with whole genome sequencing. Homemade jelly rand with red caviar was tested positive for C. botulinum neurotoxin which indicated it as the source of the botulism outbreak. *CORRESPONDING AUTHOR ( current address ): Katrin S. Meffert, MD Department of Geriatric Medicine Malteser Hospital Waldstr. 16 24939 Flensburg Germany Tel. +4915257399273 E-mail: [email protected] Figure 2: Overview over the Botulism-Score by Patient The four patients with a long lasting severe illness developed symptoms within the first 24 hours. Organising antitoxin treatment for a large outbreak requires cooperation both internationally and within the country. A non-measurable side effect of the toxin was that all patients were calm and described a feeling like they were intoxicated, which resulted in underestimation of the severity of the disease. The proposed Botulism-Score may be helpful in the management of new outbreaks. Botulism is a muscle-paralyzing disease caused by bacteria Clostridium botulinum. Symptoms of food-borne botulism most commonly appear 12-24 hours after eating contaminated food . Therefore, a scoring system allows clinicians to make a fast triage when dealing with an outbreak. It helps with the detection of patients with severe illness and need of ventilator therapy. A helpful tool for prioritizing the patients who should be treated first with antitoxin and finding the patients in need of a second antitoxin treatment. We adapted the well known Myasthenia Score. The aim was to develop a score to fit symptoms of botulism and is easy to use. Introduction Botulism Score Method Benefits of Scoring: Figure 1: Logistical Challenges Blue arrows: transport of antitoxin, with time between diagnosis and treatment with antitoxin Red lines: transport of patients to hospitals in Odense & Flensburg 22 h ≈8 H ≈8H ≈7 H Results Conclusion Figure 3: Overview over the symptoms and their occurence by patient. Symptoms of Botulism ( No symptoms = 0 points) Double vision [0-1 point] Eye muscle disorder [0-2 points, number of affected eyes] Facial muscle paresis [0-2 points, number of affected sides] Ptosis [0-1 point] Dysphagia [0-4 points] subjecHve swallowing disorder (1) minimal coughing or throat clearing while drinking water (2) severe coughing (3) cannot swallow (4) Hoarseness [0-1 point] Dysarthria [0-1 point] Cannot liO head [0-1 point] Bradycardia (<60/min) [0-1 point] Σ = Total Score 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Day 0 / 3rd quarter Day 0 / 4th quarter Day 1 / 1st quarter Day 1 / 2nd quarter Day 1 / 3rd quarter Day 1 / 4th quarter Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 Day 8 Day 9 Day 10 Day 15 Day 16 Day 17 Day 19 Day 21 Day 22 Day 23 Day 31 Day 40 Day 52 Day 73 Day 89 Day 96 Double vision Eye muscel disorder Facial muscel parese Ptosis Hoarseness Swallowing disorder Dysarthria Cannot liO head Bradycardia Number of affected paHents with test items ≈10 H

Upload: others

Post on 18-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Introduction Botulism Score Results · • The proposed Botulism-Score may be helpful in the management of new outbreaks. • Botulism is a muscle-paralyzing disease caused by bacteria

A retrospective case study through review of patient charts. Symptoms, medical treatment including botulism antitoxin treatment and patient outcomes were registered. For monitoring of disease progression a scoring system was developed. Blood and stool from all patients were sent (Fig. 2/3 Day 1) to the Danish State Serum Institute (SSI) to verify the clinical diagnosis and from one patient also to the German Robert Koch Institute (RKI).

A 76-years-old woman presented at her local hospital with a four hours history of diplopia, sore throat, vertigo and general discomfort. The patient had eaten dinner at a private party with retired colleagues the previous day. Within hours of admittance, the patient developed dysarthria, bilateral abducens nerve palsy, dysphagia and difficulty breathing. During this time and the next day, several of her friends from the dinner party were admitted with similar symptoms. A tentative diagnose of foodborne botulism was suspected. We present the symptoms, treatment and outcomes of the patients in the largest foodborne botulism outbreak registered in Denmark.

•  All nine female persons exposed developed symptoms of botulism with varying severity.

•  Average age of the patients was 74 years

(68-81). •  Four patients had severe symptoms with

need for intubation and were hospitalized 35-83 days.

•  Five patients had mild symptoms with no

need for intubation and were hospitalized 6-9 days

•  Time from diagnosis to the first antitoxin

treatment was minimum seven hours because of logistical challenges (see Fig. 1).

•  Eight patients were treated with antiserum.

Four patients were treated with Trivalent-Antitoxin, two with Heptavalent-Antitoxin and two patients were treated with Heptavalent- and Trivalent-Antitoxin. One allergic reaction to the Trivalent-Antitoxin was registered.

•  All patients survived. After three months all

had recovered, five patients with no deficits and four with mild motor deficits.

•  Blood samples from seven patients were

tested positive for Botulinum Toxin A in mouse bioassay.

•  Clostridium botulinum was cultured from

three patient´s stool samples. These three isolates were further tested positive for Botulinum Toxin A with PCR and subtype A5 with whole genome sequencing.

•  Homemade jelly rand with red caviar was

tested positive for C. botulinum neurotoxin which indicated it as the source of the botulism outbreak.

*CORRESPONDING AUTHOR (current address):

Katrin S. Meffert, MD Department of Geriatric Medicine

Malteser Hospital Waldstr. 16

24939 Flensburg Germany

Tel. +4915257399273 E-mail: [email protected]

Figure 2: Overview over the Botulism-Score by Patient

•  The four patients with a long lasting severe illness developed symptoms within the first 24 hours.

•  Organising antitoxin treatment for a large

outbreak requires cooperation both internationally and within the country.

•  A non-measurable side effect of the toxin was

that all patients were calm and described a feeling like they were intoxicated, which resulted in underestimation of the severity of the disease.

•  The proposed Botulism-Score may be helpful

in the management of new outbreaks.

•  Botulism is a muscle-paralyzing disease caused by bacteria Clostridium botulinum. Symptoms of food-borne botulism most commonly appear 12-24 hours after eating contaminated food .

•  Therefore, a scoring system allows clinicians to make a fast triage when dealing with an outbreak.

•  It helps with the detection of patients with severe illness and need of ventilator therapy.

•  A helpful tool for prioritizing the patients who should be treated first with antitoxin and finding the patients in need of a second antitoxin treatment.

We adapted the well known Myasthenia Score. The aim was to develop a score to fit symptoms of botulism and is easy to use.

Introduction Botulism Score

Method

Benefits of Scoring:

Figure 1: Logistical Challenges Blue arrows: transport of antitoxin, with time between diagnosis and treatment with antitoxin Red lines: transport of patients to hospitals in Odense & Flensburg

22h

≈8H≈8H

≈7H

Results

Conclusion

Figure 3: Overview over the symptoms and their occurence by patient.

SymptomsofBotulism(Nosymptoms=0points)Doublevision [0-1point] Eyemuscledisorder [0-2points,numberofaffectedeyes]

Facialmuscleparesis[0-2points,numberofaffectedsides]

Ptosis [0-1point] Dysphagia [0-4points]

•  subjecHveswallowingdisorder(1)•  minimalcoughingorthroatclearingwhiledrinkingwater(2)•  severecoughing(3)•  cannotswallow(4)

Hoarseness [0-1point] Dysarthria [0-1point] CannotliOhead [0-1point] Bradycardia(<60/min) [0-1point]

Σ = TotalScore

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

Day0/3rdquarter

Day0/4thquarter

Day1/1stquarter

Day1/2ndquarter

Day1/3rdquarter

Day1/4thquarter

Day2

Day3

Day4

Day5

Day6

Day7

Day8

Day9

Day10

Day15

Day16

Day17

Day19

Day21

Day22

Day23

Day31

Day40

Day52

Day73

Day89

Day96

Doublevision Eyemusceldisorder Facialmuscelparese Ptosis HoarsenessSwallowingdisorder Dysarthria CannotliOhead Bradycardia

Num

bero

faffe

cted

paH

entswith

testitem

s

≈10H