9/1/2014 Into the Woods With TERFs All Enraged : Transgender Forum

http://www.tgforum.com/wordpress/index.php/into-the-woods-with-terfs-all-enraged/ 1/6

Into the Woods With TERFs All Enraged

Babs | Sep 1, 2014 | Comments (0)

Protesters at MichFest

Some time in the early nineties when I was living a stealth female life and exploring my true gender with my late

wife, and with other middle age middle class couples in which the husband was transgender, I became aware of

a controversy that was occurring in the summer wilds and woods of Michigan. The Michigan Womyn’s Music

Festival, often referred to as MWMF or Michfest, has occurred every August since 1976 near Hart Michigan, in a

small wooded area in northern Oceana County known as Whiskey Creek. The event is completely built, staffed,

run and attended by women. But not all women are welcome, only those women who were arbitrarily assigned

female at birth can attend and are deemed to be real women! Transwomen are not welcome!

After Nancy Burkholder, a trans festival goer was asked to leave the festival in 1991, a protest movement against

the “womyn-born-womyn” (WBW) intention developed. The festival’s term for its intended attendees is (WBW):

women who were assigned female at birth, raised as girls, and currently identify as women. Opponents contend

that the intention constitutes discrimination against transgender people, many of whom they say identify as

women, are legally female, and have to cope with the same effects of sexism and misogyny in their daily lives in

addition to the discrimination of being transgender in our society.

To be honest, my first reaction was… what kind of a real woman would want to run around in the insect ridden

wilds of Michigan? Are you kidding? This is something you really want to do? Honestly, camping in the woods,

bonding with nature and among our “own,” it sounded like a “guy” thing is what these “womyn” really want to

do. Okay, I take it back, they advertise ”3 vegetarian meals a day.”

But this summer a lot of LGBT people, people truly interested in equality and aware of the damage of sexism and

discrimination in our society have taken notice and spoken up, and I too, have given the whole thing a second

look and a litt le thought, and it is worth exposing these exclusionary “womyn” for what they are.

This year a number of LGBTQ organizations (including Equality Michigan, National Center for Lesbian Rights and

Home

My TGForum

Messages

Profiles

TGF Members List

TGF Discussion Board

Transgender Pics

Resources

The CDS Bookstand

TGF Event List

TGF Mailing List

9/1/2014 Into the Woods With TERFs All Enraged : Transgender Forum

http://www.tgforum.com/wordpress/index.php/into-the-woods-with-terfs-all-enraged/ 2/6

the Human Rights Campaign among others) have asserted that the MichFest believes transgender womyn are

“less than” other womyn, and that the Festival’s intention is the equivalent of the U.S. military’s “Don’t Ask,

Don’t Tell” policy.

The Michfest founder Lisa Vogel responded to the call for the boycott by issuing a statement on their Facebook

page.

Their sisterly spirit is a bit contrived and painful to read so I will repost just a bit of their conclusionary bullet points

with a brief remark in italics:

We believe all humans suffer under patriarchy; ( OK that seems reasonable)

We believe that transgendered womyn are womyn; (Yes, we are womyn, but we are transgender

womyn, not “transgendered” as the erudite Fox News mavens call us on a good day)

We believe that females experience a unique, historical, and debilitating oppression as a class under

patriarchy; (OK that sounds reasonable)

We believe that the subjugation of females is an international phenomenon, experienced across time,

culture, nation, class, ethnicity, ability and race;(OK, perhaps I might add organized religion to that list)

MWMF has, since its inception in 1976, formed itself as a space for womyn-born-female as a means to

resist and survive the debilitation of female subjugation; ( Here is where we have a problem in that it

strongly implies that some womyn, i.e. trans womyn contribute to the debilitation of female subjugation …

where did this come from?)

We believe that support for womyn-born-female space is not at odds with standing with and for the

transgender community;( oops … see the previous statement and explain why this is not pure manure!)

We believe that the statements calling for the boycott of the MWMF neither speak for all transgender

womyn nor include all of their voices, many of whom are silenced or ignored with regard to their support

of the Festival’s intention of womyn-born-female space, for example, the New Narratives Conference held

in Portland, Oregon this Spring. (Certainly not ALL transgender women agree on everything and I’m overly

unimpressed that they found a handful-plus of confused or self-hating or down trodden people from a

class of people who experience the highest percentage of societal discrimination and lack of self esteem.

Was that the best they could do?)

Emily Dievendorf, executive director of Equality Michigan said it best:

“Discrimination is at its ugliest when we know it exists and we choose to create a sacred space

within in it – to wrap ourselves with it – because everything else, the?privilege and validation that

it may be woven into, can feel so damn good. This year we are declaring that we have had

enough of Michfest’s double talk and can see through it. If Michfest is to be trans inclusive then it

must change the “intention” to illustrate a wide open door and a safe space for transwomen. In

the meantime, while Michfest leaders continue to dig their heels into the excuses and allegiances

of yesteryear, Equality Michigan will continue to ask citizens of our state to be clear in their position

of inclusion and to invest in the women’s festivals that leave no?woman behind.”

So, who are these so called “feminists” who appear to double talk and seem so intent on actively “excluding”

transgender women and feminists?

My personal experience with “feminists” who have really made a positive difference for women/womyn has been

nothing but positive, especially as a trans activist. Certainly my late wife, my best friend, whose support and love

was so strong that I was able to be honest about myself and helped me not only to survive, but thrive and

develop as a strong, responsible woman. As a feminist and a teacher she successfully took a lead on the late

sixties so that the female teachers in New Jersey’s second largest school system were no longer forced to wear

skirts or dresses.

As a transgender activist, it was clear that the early support of NJ NOW and individuals who had been leaders in

that organization played a key part in some of our legislative successes in New Jersey.

Today I’m in a long term relationship with a “feminist.” A leader, former President of NY-NOW who marched, got

on the pulpits and TV, and later as an executive, was a role model and raised the glass ceiling for a whole

industry of women.

9/1/2014 Into the Woods With TERFs All Enraged : Transgender Forum

http://www.tgforum.com/wordpress/index.php/into-the-woods-with-terfs-all-enraged/ 3/6

Doer’s are those “feminists” who embrace and include transgender women.

Then there are the TERFs: Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminism, or TERF, has been described as a loosely-

organized collective with a message of hate and exclusion against transgender women in particular, and

transgender people as a whole. They have attached themselves to radical feminism as a means to attempt to

deny trans women basic access to health care, women’s groups, restroom facilit ies, and anywhere that may be

considered women’s space.

I suppose that in every group of people who have been downtrodden and experienced discrimination, there is a

tendency to seek out those others who they can put down and discriminate against to make themselves appear

higher on a social totem pole or ladder. Rather than do things to empower themselves, apparently they find it

easier to trash someone perceived to be on a lower rung who may be more vulnerable and less able to fight

back. One may call it pathetic and perverted behavior , but unfortunately it ’s not uncommon.

Janice Raymond

Janice Raymond, author of The Transsexual Empire: The Making of the She-Male authored a paper in the early

1980s that the Health and Human Services branch of the U.S. Government used to deny trans men and women

trans-related medical care, for example. Since then, they have continued to use anti-transgender rhetoric, as

blogger Cristan Williams suggests “using the banner of feminism much in the same way that Westboro Baptist

Church uses Christianity.” They use rhetoric suggesting that trans women are would-be rapists, that we are “men

invading women’s spaces” — (Cathy Brennan, head of Gender Identity Watch and are “forcing penises on

lesbians” — Justin Norwood, Gender Identity Watch). They and radical right wing homophobic religious

organizations such as the AFA use the same ugly language to frame their transphobia. For transpeople they are

two peas in a pod…. Amazing!

Their words can cause actual harm. The group Gender Identity Watch (GIW) worked with the right-wing anti-

gay group, Pacific Justice Institute, to help prevent a Colorado teen from being able to use the women’s

restroom. It was reported that Cathy Brennan, the GIW leader used social media and outed the teen, who was

already being bullied, and she was subsequently put on suicide watch. Their actions often incite others to

denigrate or discriminate a minority — which is the definition of a hate group.

Brennan, an attorney by profession, is also alleged last year to make a four figure donation to a Maryland State

Senator to derail that State’s transgender non-discrimination legislation.

Of course we cannot overlook Lisa Vogel.

What drives these TERFs? Perhaps it is something very basic, insecurity, jealousy, maybe even penis envy? I do

not know, I do not get it, I don’t understand why some people expend so much energy to destroy the lives of

others. But beware … they are few, but they are there and they hurt us.

Tags: featured, Identity, Janice Raymond, MichFest, MWMF, TERFs, Transgender, Transsexual

Category: Opinion, Polit ics

Cross-dressing Shopping ↓Worldwide shipping

Transgender Forum / Blogs The most informative blogs for the TG Community

Cross-dressing Galleries ↓Crossdresser & TG Photo Gallery

9/1/2014 Into the Woods With TERFs All Enraged : Transgender Forum

http://www.tgforum.com/wordpress/index.php/into-the-woods-with-terfs-all-enraged/ 4/6

About Babs: “Babs” is a member of the Executive Committee of the Democratic National Committee, Deputy

Vice Chair of the NJ Democratic State Committee and Polit ical Director of the Gender Rights Advocacy Association

of NJ. For the current campaign she serves on the Executive Committee of Trans United 4 Obama. She has

served as Vice Chair of the DNC Eastern Caucus, President of NJ Stonewall Democrats, Co-Chair of National

Stonewall Democrats Federal PAC Board, Vice-Chair of Garden State Equality, Executive Board member of National

Stonewall Democrats as Chair of the DNC Relations Committee and a member of the NJ Civil Unions Review

Commission.

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to receive more just like it.

Subscribe via RSS Feed

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Search TGForum

Login Status

You are not logged in.

Username

Password

LOG IN Forgot? Register

9/1/2014 Into the Woods With TERFs All Enraged : Transgender Forum

http://www.tgforum.com/wordpress/index.php/into-the-woods-with-terfs-all-enraged/ 5/6

9/1/2014 Into the Woods With TERFs All Enraged : Transgender Forum

http://www.tgforum.com/wordpress/index.php/into-the-woods-with-terfs-all-enraged/ 6/6

Archives

Select Month

© Transgender Forum 2014. All rights reserved.

Directory powered by Business Directory P lugin