internal audit review at human resources division
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
1/38
1
INTERNAL AUDIT REPORT
HRD
(FOR THE PERIOD OF JUNE 2011 AUGUST 2011)
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
2/38
2
01) OBSERVATION
We observed that executive positions have been only interviewed by Head of thedepartment without participation of HRM
1. Managerial Level
Currently managerial level positioned are interviewed by HRM & then interview by
BOD. There fore this is in satisfactory level.
2. Executive Level- Some instances without HRM Participation
3. Clerical staff & minors- HR representative with the segment heads
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
This could lead to select an influenced candidate by interviewer even without
required qualification.
Possibility of recruiting non suitable candidates (Physically as well as mentally)
Possibility of recruiting terminated employees.
RECOMMENDATION
Executive level - must be interviewed by both, head of the department & HRM for
benefit of the establishment and avoiding mismatches.
Clerical staff & minors - In this stage all interviews should be done by department
heads & HR representative who is having required knowledge as an interviewer.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
3/38
3
If at any time, HRM has been unable to participate at the interview due to urgently
cropped up priorities, he makes sure that the recommended candidate is
interviewed again by HRM, references checked and the recommendation referred
to DO for approval prior to assumption of duties. PMEs are interviewed by GMPand finally selected by MD.
HR Executives are trained to conduct the preliminary interview all manual workers
and the clerical hands. After the segment heads interview and recommendation,
HRM or AMHR does the final selection.
02) OBSERVATION
It was noted that there were no formal standards of qualification requirement for
recruiting of executive level & above for various departmental positions. Such as
Accounts Executive - Part qualification of ICASL/CIMA
PMD Executive - Relevant Degree such as B.Com/ Marketing/CIM/SLIM
HR Executive - Diploma in HRM/Part qualifications of IPM/Degree
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
Selection of unqualified candidate could tarnish the image of the position as well as
image of the company.
Turnover Ratio of employees will be higher as they are not able to handle the works
assigned.
Will be a disturbance to other employees and the segment heads.
RECOMMENDATION
A written standard for required qualification should be introduced each and everyposition.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
4/38
4
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
Different positions entail different qualifications. Business needs practical hands
too to contribute to the corporate goals. If gone by the qualifications alone TT willnot have the right people to match the culture and this fast paced business
environment. Expertise in a trade is much important than a paper to our business.
The Qualified with the required previous exposure have been duly compensated at
recruitment. But at TT its the expertise of the practical people who have always
proved their mettle. Theoreticians will die and go with their theories.
03)OBSERVATION
It was noted that a formal induction program has not been conducted for the newly
recruited employees by the HRD.
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
This would lead to a delay in understanding the company procedures, culture etc,
No proper awareness about the code of conduct and disciplinary procedures.
RECOMMENDATION
An orientation program should be conducted for all the new employees at least
once a month selected batch wise. This could lead a moral affection of the
employee.
We suggest the induction program should be included the followings.
The corporate video Issue the orientation kit to the new recruits The new recruits will be given a brief history of the company, its structure, name
of the director board, and the senior management, nature of the business and
current standing in the industry. Company growth, current strength of workforce. Hours of work and late attendance.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
5/38
5
Prohibited acts, fire evacuation procedure & first aid facilities Training opportunities, performance appraisals. Use of telephones New employee registration Collect relevant documents from the new employees New employees will be getting their employee no. and the
temporary/permanent card.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
All managerial and Executive staff are being properly informed of the HRD and
Admin procedures, guidelines and the systems in place. No one in that category can
deny it. Further the Code of conduct issued and explained, Email and internet policy
issued and explained. Leave procedures, bar code swiping, punctuality, company ID
card and expected discipline explained. HR executives have been trained to carry
out the job of all clerical and below category employees.
04) OBSERVATION
As per the sample checked, we observed following weaknesses in personal files
documentation process.
4.1. Original certificates have been attached in personal files.
EPF No Name
5260 H.Mohomad Rizwan
4.2. Non-related referees have not been referred.4.3. Non availability of NIC copy.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
6/38
6
EPF No Name
3781 N.G.Indika Priyadharma
2195 S.Chamara Rasanga Pieris
4.4. Non availability of appointment letters
EPF No Name
5447 W.G.N J. Kumara Abeyrathne
5764 Dumindu Tharanga
4.5. CV without applicant signatures
EPF No Name
3781 N.G.Indika Priyadharma
2803 K.S.S.K.Madarasinghe
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
Incomplete personal files would mislead the users (company) in very important
instances to ascertain the qualification of employee. Anyone could fool the HRD by
giving fraudulent records.
RECOMMENDATION
Original certificates should be in safe custody under HRM if the original certificateis a must for the concerned job and certified copies should be filed in the personal
file.
For all other employees certified copies should be filed in the personal files.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
7/38
7
When recruiting executive and above executive level employees should checkwith non related referees for ensure the employee past situation, professional
background etc. A proper format or a specimen should be prepared by HRD for this.
Should be kept ID copies and appointment letters in personal files for everyemployee.
Should be obtained signatures on CVs.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
Original certificates will continue to be in their personal files as it is the right
location and easily accessible place. Maintaining additional envelopes and files for
each employees certificates is costly and tracking time is consuming.
All referees have been referred to and checked for comments on the applicant
(3781 / 2195) Details of NICs of both the employees mentioned was not legible and
they were asked to get new IDs. 2195 already collected. 3781 advised again to obtain
a new ID.
(5447 / 5764) LOAs are in the respective files.
(3781/2803) Both CVs had been down loaded from E-mail
05) OBSERVATION
We have Identified, that there are some documentation processing delays in new
recruitments by HRD.
Delay in sending Appointment letters Delay in providing Job descriptions
Details are as follows.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
8/38
8
EPF No Date of Join Date -
Appointment
Letter given
Date - Job
Description
given
5734 (M.R.M.Misbah) 11.07.11 15.07.11 22.07.11
Delay in processing B-cards
Details are as follows.
EPF No Name Date of Join Date of B-card
Issue
5805 M.M.L.Geethanjali
Marasinghe
08.08.11 08.09.11
5797 K.T.T.Jayamini 02.08.11 08.09.11
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
This would lead unsatisfaction of the employee from beginning of the employment.
Employees are not aware that what they have been assigned.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended to be prearranged appointment letters, job descriptions for
every employee at the time of appointment.
B-cards should also be processed within a set time frame to avoid problems in the
process.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
9/38
9
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
5734 Was absorbed issuing an LO. LOA was issued in 4 days as the JD was pending withthe segment head for amendments.
5805 / 5797 B cards will not be issued to any new recruit immediately. Each B card costs
TT Rs.10/- and labour dept issues only limited number to the companies. Employer can
take even six months or more to arrange the forms to the employees. TT remits the
contributions on time and the employer is reserved with the discretion to arrange the
docs as and when possible. With the transformation of B cards to NIC Electronic card,
the B card formalities would be done away with.
05) OBSERVATION
We observed following weaknesses in Increments/Promotions.
BOD approval form was not made available in personal files for increments.
Details are as follows.
EPF No Name Increment given Date
2195 S.Chamara Rasanga Pieris 01.09.2007
2466 M.F.M. Riyasath 01.08.2010
3114 B.W.Prabath Perera 01.09.2010
Non compliance of increments schedule and deviation to Delegation of Authority
It has been observed that increment schedule in HR management folder for the
month of August 2011 is not tally with the finance increment schedule.
Details are as follows.
EPF No Employee name Department Increment
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
10/38
10
5384Suranga
ThilakasiriDNW 2500
5390 Nisran SAD Tyre 1000
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
It is crucial. This is violation of delegation of authority. Anybody could getincrement if delegation of authority is ignored.
Two figures in two places could mislead the BOD and user of the information.
RECOMMENDATION
It must be obtained approvals from BOD for increments and promotions for eachemployee.
All the reports which are pertaining to one subject must match each other. Youhave to make sure publishing before it has been published.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
2195 / 2466 / 3114 - Increments effected for all employees annually go on one
continuous paper for BOD approval. That paper cannot be filed in each employees
personal file as it contains approx. 10 legal size papers. This exercise will cost TT
additional 2 toners and around 600 pages and extra time for filing too. HRD is notfacilitated with a copier for such jobs.
Pls note that not a single cent has been given to any employee as an increment
without BOD approval.
5384 / 5390 - HRD folder may not have contained these two due to an oversight.
The increments of this SR and the Clerk were duly approved by DO and MD and the
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
11/38
11
papers were sent for payroll. Your staff may pls check the approved docs at
finance.
06) OBSERVATION
06.01) In our audit perusal, we noted there was an incomplete format for ID cards
process.
ID card Issues
Current Format
Date Name Division Date of
Join
Date of
Temporary
card Issue
Signature
We cannot identify whether they issued or not permanent ID card quickly by
checking the Register.
07.02) Further, we noted that there was ID processing delay by the HRD.
EPF No Date of Temporary Card Date of Permanent Card Issue
5746
5747
5757
5764
5768
5765
06.07.11
01.07.11
28.06.11
11.07.11
19.07.11
23.06.11
08.08.11
06.08.11
12.08.11
06.08.11
08.08.11
08.08.11
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
12/38
12
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
Could create unnecessary complication between HRD & employees.
Employeesattendance is registered under the temporary card for more than one
month.
RECOMMENDATION
It should be maintain a proper format for identify date of join, issuing date oftemporary card and permanent card promptly.
Following format is recommended for avoiding above mentioned weakness and for
easy identification whether permanent card issued or not.
Date Name Division Temporary
card No
Signature Date of
Permanent
card Issue
EPF
No
Date
of
Issue
Signature
We strongly recommend that ID cards process should be speed up for avoidingunnecessary problems among employees and the HRD.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FORACTIVATION
All Executives and above categories are issued with their ID cards on the date of
appointment provided he/she fulfils the personal file formalities
Permanent ID card cost the company approx. Rs.100/- Therefore all other staff from
clerical grade down below are issued with temporary numbers in line with the
policy decision taken by TT as the turnover is comparatively high in these
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
13/38
13
categories. The permanent EPF number is issued immediately before the
preparation of the next payroll. The above format for temporary cards are
maintained for HRD records. No permanent card can therefore be issued quickly to
the said categories. It is presumed that Auditing staff had not understood theprevailing procedure.
07) OBSERVATION
It was noted in our audit, there are some system weaknesses in following areas.
7.1; Attendance could be modified in the system.
7.2; Cumulative leaves not in the system and HRD staff has to check one by one if an
employee ask about the leaves available.
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
This is very serious issue. Since, if this could be modified, an absent person could be
modified as attended to office.
It is not possible to calculate the balance leave/leave taken in a instant even after
having sophisticated facilities.
Possible frauds and malpractices
RECOMMENDATION
We recommend that except all field staff such as sales reps, if any modification is
required to the attendance records, it has to be notified to SMIT by copying to
relevant segment head.
Any modifications, a daily audit trial should be obtained and should be certified by
HRM and filed in a serial sequence for future reference.
System should be modified as to get details of employees leave in a instant rather
than manual calculation. Necessary modification should be made by HRD throughIT.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
14/38
14
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
The procedure in place is The downloaded attendance data is e-mailed to the
segments in the morning and the segment head OKs the info with his remarks forabsent employees / Those who have not swiped the cards. HRD takes the segment
heads remarks as reliable info to update the attendance manually where necessary.
Even if SMIT to do this, he will have to rely on the info of the segment head. Other
than the Field Sales force there are few other segments who send out their staff for
field visits/jobs and keep HRM/AMHR informed by mail. The segment head then
certify their attendance on the attendance sheet and requests HRM/AMHR to
update the records. We prefer if that can be handled by SMIT, but he too will have
to do what HRM/AMHR does.
Leave info of any employee can be viewed on the screen with the software
available. Auditors seem to have not understood the system.
08) OBSERVATIONS
Statutory Payments
08.1; Workmen compensation scheduled has not been maintained.
08.2; Accident register has not been maintained.
08.3; Employee Provident Fund, Employee Trust Fund.
EPF and ETF have been remitted to the Inland Revenue & Central Bank on
time. Cross checked with the schedule.
08.4; Gratuity
We checked the accuracy of the gratuity provision. It has been noted that
in order.
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
15/38
15
It creates a complication between employee and TTSL due to non attending staffmatters.
HRD will not be in a position to answer the accidents details when BOD needs thedetails for a decision making.
Non compliance with the ISO standards
RECOMMENDATIONS
There should be a schedule and details of workmen compensation payable to
employees.
Accident Register is maintained only in the factory premises. But this should be
maintained under HRD which is OHSAS requirement.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
Workmen compensation policy and schedules are maintained. No auditor asked for
it.
Though ISO states to the contrary the Accident register is to be maintained at the
Medical center run by the company as per the factory ordinance. Since we are yet
to establish same, it is now maintained at the factory as advised by the FE.
HRM has handled the ISO auditors on the matter.
09. OBSERVATION
HRD do not aware that security deposits control is prevailing at TTSL. (As per the
explanation given by the AHRM)
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
If HRD does not know the company procedures, it is regretful thing to be
happened.Non reliance with the HRD information given to employees and outsiders.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
16/38
16
RECOMMENDATIONS
All the HRD members must be trained and known the company procedures related
to the employees issue.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
There are no security deposits taken from any staff at present. What AHRM had said
was that. The records and the controls over the deposits that were collected up to
year 2010 are available at finance. HRM is more regretful to see that the auditing
staff had not understood what was said.
10. OBSERVATIONS
It has been observed that performance evaluation has not been carried out as per
company requirement.
Executives- Quarterly
Below Executives- Bi Annauly
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
This could demoralize/de-motivate the staff who is willing to expose their
performance to the BOD.
This will lead to high staff turnover.
Non evaluation of executives will lead undue promotions and increments.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Performance evaluation should be done in stipulated time frame by HRD alongwith divisional heads.
This has to be done with immediate effect and this is very much important forachieving the company goals and objectives.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
17/38
17
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
HRM /AMHR KPI says that Executive staff evaluations are to be done bi-annually
which was carried out for this year. As discussed with SMA too at several KPIreviews, Evaluating low category staff is not possible.
11. OBSERVATION
We observed that company cadre requirement is not filled by the HRD in some
divisions. And also, there are more staff has been recruited by some divisions above
the approved carder.
Details are as follows.
August 2011
Cadre Evaluation Report
Division
Division
approved
Present
Status Variation
cadre
Corporate (DO's & MD office) 12 12 0
MD office 12 14 -2
Imports 9 8 1
PMD(BHW/GHW/Tyre/Electrical/Steel) 31 29 2
Quality control 24 30 -6
Brand management division 10 10 0
CRMD 31 33 -2
Modern trade 7 6 1
GFEC 9 8 1
Finance 26 25 1
CCD/RU 17 16 1
ITD 8 8 0
MMD 2 2 0COO office 1 1 0
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
18/38
18
HRD 10 10 0
Procurement 9 8 1
Administration 7 4 3
General maintenance 17 13 4Premises maintenances 13 12 1
Security - H/O 1 1 0
Stores 100 98 2
GCIS factory 50 41 9
Color factory - Ganga 26 27 -1
DNW - (HW)- SAD/sales rep/ASE 146 125 21
North operations 21 17 4
Supplies(hardware/tyre/electrical) 67 62 5
Tyre- SAD/Sales rep/ASE/ME 29 24 5
Corp institution staffs/ Field staff 15 17 -2
Electrical - SAD/ sales rep/ASE 80 77 3
CVMD 33 34 -1
LVMD 11 10 1
Transport 241 233 8
Bazaar - SAD/supplies/Sales 34 33 1
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
This is the prime target of the HRD. If this target is not achieved, the entire
company will lose the corporate target.
RECOMMENDATIONS
HRD must fill cadre requirement on time. Enabling the other department meet
company requirement.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FORACTIVATION
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
19/38
19
Cadre is being provided to manage the work in hand. Even alternative
arrangements have been made with DO approval to meet the urgencies. There is a
dire shortage of manual workers in the market. But HRD has managed to provide
workers going thru many difficulties.
QC technicians were recruited with BOD approval. Likewise CREs, MEs for
Institution and MD office staff Colour GM and Sales Trainer were recruited with
BOD direction.
12. OBSERVATION
We observed that a laborer was terminated of misconduct (smoking ganja cigars)
has been reinstated.
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
It is the companys general rule that ex workers should not be reinstated in their job
without prior approval of BOD.
RECOMMENDATION
We strongly recommend that not to entertain this kind of recruitment which is a
total deviation.
We suggest taking disciplinary actions or termination of service against employees
for misconduct of following areas.
Violation of company policies
EPF No Name Reasons for
terminate
5768 S.P.Pushpakumara Using Ganja
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
20/38
20
Insubordination Poor attendance & continued late attendance Unauthorized absence Unauthorized possessions Use a sale of alcohol or control substances on work premises or during working
hours even outside work premises.
Unauthorized possessions, use or sale of weapons, firearms, explosives Poor performance of duties and negligence of duties Theft & dishonesty Physical violence, sexual harassment or disrespect towards fellow worker, visitors
members of public
Misuse of facilities such as emails, faxes, telephones etc.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
Not only the said 11 areas that qualify for disciplinary action, there are many more
activities that contributes to misconduct.
True that the said employee was terminated sometime back for smoking ganja. He
learnt a lesson in his life and went through lot of hardships in his life for the grave
mistake he made because of associating with bad companions. No other
complaints.
The man got changed and started a new lease of life. He is one of the hard workers
at BHW stores today who had been working continuous nights. Once realizedsome change. He could be one of them. So far so good after taking back.
13. OBSERVATIONS
We observed that long outstanding staff loans have not been written off.
EPF EMP NAME DIVISION A/L AMOUNTBALANCE AS
GRA-1 L/A
GRA-2 L/A
526 ASLAM PROCUREMENT LEFT 3,000.00 300.00
746PRADEEP KLIYANAGE D.N.W. H/W LEFT 6,000.00 330.00
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
21/38
21
2031 D.SAMPATH TRANSPORT LEFT 3500.00 350.00 938 LEFT 1382 LEFT
1326W.S.PUSHPAKUMARA TRANSPORT LEFT 3600.00 360.00 344 LEFT 293 LEFT
1776KUSHANWIJEGUNASEKARA D.N.W. H/W LEFT 5000.00 485.00 1663 LEFT 1438 LEFT
755 P.L.R.INDIKA D.N.W. H/W LEFT 5,000.00 500.00
760 NAJEEM D.N.W. H/W LEFT 3,000.00 500.00
179 M.RISHAN BAZAAR LEFT 5,500.00 550.00 692 LEFT 959 LEFT
705 S.M.NIHMAN D.N.W. H/W LEFT 6,500.00 650.00
1735 M.M. LAL INDIKA TRANSPORT LEFT 3400.00 680.00 1686 LEFT 1171 LEFT
534 DUMINDA PRASAD STORES H/W LEFT 2,900.00 691.00 312 LEFT 343 LEFT
1447 SURASH PERERA C.C.D LEFT 3,500.00 700.00
801 R.C.J.PERERADISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4,500.00 900.00 1037 LEFT 842 LEFT
933 FERNANDODISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 3,000.00 900.00
837 YASANTHA TRANSPORT LEFT 2,500.00 1,000.00
982 R.SILVA D.N.W. H/W LEFT 5,000.00 1,000.001969 M.S.M.SHAMIL .D.N.W. ELE LEFT 10000.00 1,000.00 1667 LEFT 2080 LEFT
679 WIJEKULASOORIYA SECURITY LEFT 3,500.00 1,050.00
827 MOHAMED ALI ADMIN LEFT 2,700.00 1,068.00
229 M.ZIYAN LEFT 2,190.00 1,095.00
419 S. PRIYANTHA STORES H/W LEFT 3,300.00 1,158.00
824 FAWSAN FINANCE LEFT 2,900.00 1,160.00
452 M.ROSHAN LEFT 1,800.00 1,200.00
1024 M.B.M.ANWER TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 1,200.00
1035 M.A.M.HANIF BAZAAR LEFT 4,000.00 1,200.00
1235 K.M.R.KUMARA TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 1,200.00 1491 LEFT
1564 K.D.THUSHARA TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 1,200.00 1382 LEFT 752 LEFT1727 K.A.LESLY KUMARA C.FACTORY LEFT 3,000.00 1,200.00 1233 LEFT 1529 LEFT
3417 K.M.RASVI .D.N.W. ELE LEFT 7,500.00 1,323.00 3225 LEFT 3274 LEFT
1909 M.M.S.GUNASEKARA TRANSPORT LEFT 3500.00 1,400.00 715 LEFT 1600 LEFT
376 RUSHDY LEFT 4,000.00 1,500.00
580 PIYADASA LEFT 2,400.00 1,500.00
589 MISWERDISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 3,000.00 1,500.00
714 RISHAN TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 1,500.00
943W.NISHANTHALAKMAL SILVA TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 1,500.00
1052 M.H.M.ROSHAN TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 1,500.001442 W.D.KUMARA D.N.W. H/W LEFT 5,000.00 1,500.00 881 LEFT 1421 LEFT
3271 PRIYADARSHANA TRANSPORT LEFT 4,500.00 1,500.00
544M.N.DILRUKFERNANDO FACTORY LEFT 3,300.00 1,592.00
1124M.B.R.PUSHPAKUMARA TRANSPORT LEFT 3,200.00 1,600.00 940 LEFT 938 LEFT
1589 K.T.SAMAN C.FACTORY LEFT 2,800.00 1,680.00 1560 LEFT 1443 LEFT
1514 T.G.PRASSANA STORES H/W LEFT 2,900.00 1,740.00 1550 LEFT 1118 LEFT
1369 R.R.B.D. Indrajith STORES H/W LEFT 3500.00 1,750.00 1618 LEFT 802 LEFT
491 MADAPATH LEFT 3,000.00 1,800.00
540 D.I.J.GUNAWARDANE V.M.D LEFT 3,000.00 1,800.00859 H.J.P.SILVA FACTORY LEFT 2,000.00 1,800.00 1150 LEFT 1152 LEFT
2739CHINTHAKABANDARA .D.N.W. ELE LEFT 6,000.00 1,800.00 2151 LEFT 2494 LEFT
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
22/38
22
804 A.K.KELIM STORES H/W LEFT 2,650.00 1,855.00
861 FERNANDO FACTORY LEFT 3,100.00 1,860.00
1171 W.M. ASHOKA TRANSPORT LEFT 3800.00 1,900.00 730 LEFT 818 LEFT
883 P.MUKANDY TRANSPORT LEFT 3,200.00 1,920.00 669 LEFT 1386 LEFT
1021
K.H.A.PRADEEP
MANOJ ANANDA TRANSPORT LEFT 3,200.00 1,920.00 1651 LEFT 1158 LEFT1025 M.B.M.AJMEER TRANSPORT LEFT 3,200.00 1,920.00 913 LEFT 663 LEFT
1053 DUMINDA KUMARA FACTORY LEFT 3,200.00 1,920.00 871 LEFT 1058 LEFT
1151 W.K. DARSANE FACTORY LEFT 3,200.00 1,920.00
515 NISHANTHA LEFT 2,800.00 1,960.00
1146 G.A.M.D. BANDARADISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4,000.00 2,000.00 622 LEFT 1037 LEFT
845 A.W.M. SALMAN D.N.W. H/W LEFT 4,500.00 2,050.00
424 K.WITHANAGE STORES H/W LEFT 3,000.00 2,100.00 559 LEFT 802 LEFT
798S.N.SUNILPATHMASIRI SECURITY LEFT 3,500.00 600.00 370 LEFT
1334 W.M.D.CHAMARA C.FACTORY LEFT 3,000.00 2,100.00 1529 LEFT 1424 LEFT
1386 H.S.JAYANTHA TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 2,100.00 767 LEFT 883 LEFT
2214J.A. ISHANARAVINDA
DISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 5,500.00 2,200.00 1717 LEFT 2206 LEFT
885 S.M.IMTHIYAS D.N.W. H/W LEFT 4,500.00 2,250.00 644 LEFT 1146 LEFT
975 YASEERDISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4,500.00 2,250.00 1037 LEFT 1146 LEFT
1686 P.K.C. MANOJ TRANSPORT LEFT 4,500.00 2,250.00 208 LEFT 1651 LEFT
1996 W.D. NUWAN FACTORY LEFT 4,500.00 2,250.00 1429 LEFT 1237 LEFT
294 U.PUSHPA KUMARA TRANSPORT LEFT 3,300.00 2,310.00 343 LEFT 534 LEFT
567 L.D.M.JAYASINGHE TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 2,400.00 290 LEFT 1122 LEFT
727 W.H.THILAKERATNE TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 2,400.00
825 FAJOOL DISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4,000.00 2,400.00 919 LEFT 1094 LEFT
1113B.S. KRISHANTHAKUMARA STORES H/W LEFT 3,000.00 2,400.00 431 LEFT 1088 LEFT
1452 P.B.BALASORIYADISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4,000.00 2,400.00 1413 LEFT 1451 LEFT
1718M.D. DINUSHGUNATHILAKA
.DISTRIBUTIONELE LEFT 4000.00 2,400.00 1579 LEFT 1669 LEFT
1817 K.V.A.N. VITHANA.DISTRIBUTIONELE LEFT 4000.00 2,400.00 1806 LEFT 1413 LEFT
2871 KUMARA FACTORY LEFT 6,000.00 2,400.00
3255 P.L.NIROSHANA STORES G.H.W LEFT 6,000.00 2,400.00
1330 L.A. PRIYANTHA TRANSPORT LEFT 5000.00 2,500.002561 D.M.CHAMINDA STORES H/W LEFT 4,500.00 2,500.00 2478 LEFT 1801 LEFT
573M.PRADEEPNISHANTHA STORES H/W LEFT 2,800.00 2,520.00
1005W.M.SAMPATHPIYADARSHANA D.N.W. H/W LEFT 6,500.00 2,600.00 703 LEFT
110U.SANJEEWAPERERA FACTORY LEFT 4,500.00 2,700.00 115 LEFT 138 LEFT
990 M.R.T.K.SILVA FACTORY LEFT 3,000.00 2,700.00
1209 W.SURESH SILVA C.FACTORY LEFT 3,000.00 2,700.00 1334 LEFT 1424 LEFT
2446S.S.RUWANCHAMARA TRANSPORT LEFT 4,500.00 2,700.00 2106 LEFT 1919 LEFT
962 B PRADEEP MAHESHDISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4,000.00 2,800.00
984 W.S.K.FONSEKA SECURITY LEFT 3,300.00 2,870.00
1219 B.A.KAMAL JAYASIRI SECURITY LEFT 3,200.00 2,880.00
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
23/38
23
771 S.JAYAWARDANA TRANSPORT LEFT 5,000.00 3,000.00 610 LEFT
1026 M.I.M.ASHROF TRANSPORT LEFT 3,000.00 3,000.00 974 LEFT
1103 M.SATKUNESWARACOLOURGENARAL LEFT 8,000.00 3,000.00 966 LEFT
1211C.N. SUMINDAPERERA TRANSPORT LEFT 3000.00 3,000.00 812 LEFT 1495 LEFT
1606 M.F.A. HUDAIFA FACTORY LEFT 3,000.00 3,000.00 1522 LEFT 1607 LEFT
3396 GUNARATHNA FACTORY LEFT 6,000.00 3,000.00
1424R.T. ERWINNAWARATNA C.FACTORY LEFT 4400.00 3,080.00 1443 LEFT 1233 LEFT
1130SAMPATHFERNANDO FACTORY LEFT 3,500.00 3,150.00
122 PRIYADARSANA LEFT 4,000.00 3,200.00
1118 SAMAN KUMARA STORES H/W LEFT 4,000.00 3,200.00 343 LEFT 1119 LEFT
1408 D.G.D.GOMES SECURITY LEFT 3,200.00 3,200.00 798 LEFT
1413 M.G.G. FERNANDODISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4000.00 3,200.00 1717 LEFT 1817 LEFT
1451T. D.PADMAKUMARA
DISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4000.00 3,200.00 1601 LEFT 1510 LEFT
1668W. DILIP MANOJFERNANDO
DISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4000.00 3,200.00 1671 LEFT 1600 LEFT
1669 G. GLEN ANTHONYDISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4000.00 3,200.00 1713 LEFT 1717 LEFT
1672A.D.M.SAMARASINGHE
DISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4000.00 3,200.00 1671 LEFT 1668 LEFT
1522 T.A.T. NISHAM FACTORY LEFT 3700.00 3,330.00 1559 LEFT 1614 LEFT
2166S.A. SUMITHKARUNATHILAKA SECURITY LEFT 4,800.00 3,360.00
1245 M.N.M.SARJUN FACTORY LEFT 3,500.00 3,500.00 1194 LEFT
959P.C.NEOMALFERNANDO D.N.W. H/W LEFT 9,000.00 3,600.00 692 LEFT 1241 LEFT
1612 FARHANDISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4,000.00 3,600.00 825 LEFT 1509 LEFT
1627 R.K. RATHNAYAKADISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4000.00 3,600.00 776 LEFT 1094 LEFT
2140K.B.SAMARATHUNGA TRANSPORT LEFT 4,500.00 3,600.00 1378 LEFT 2106 LEFT
1094P.D.H.S.GUNAWARDANE D.N.W. H/W LEFT 5000.00 4,000.00 1072 LEFT 1577 LEFT
1166 D.M.C. ROHANA FINANCE LEFT 4,000.00 4,000.00 1434 LEFT 664 LEFT
1651 H. RUWAN SAMPATH TRANSPORT LEFT 5,000.00 4,000.00 208 LEFT 1686 LEFT
1044 S. NISHANTHA TRANSPORT LEFT 4,500.00 4,050.00
2390 M.G.SAMANTHA STORES ELE LEFT 4,500.00 4,050.00 2388 LEFT 2503 LEFT
2206B.D. RUWANPUSHPAKUMARA
.DISTRIBUTIONELE LEFT 5,000.00 4,500.00 2021 LEFT 2214 LEFT
2307R.M. NIHALRATHNAYAKE SECURITY LEFT 5,000.00 4,500.00
2245 W.K.I. PIYASOMA STORES H/W LEFT 4,700.00 4,700.00
3064 SUSANTHA STORES H/W LEFT 6,000.00 4,800.00
2925 H.A.R.PERERA .D.N.W. ELE LEFT 7,500.00 4,927.00 2941 LEFT 2494 LEFT
1347 W.W. SAJEEWA
COLOUR
GENARAL LEFT 10000.00 5,000.00 720 LEFT 1231 LEFT
1919NIROSHANRAVINDRA TRANSPORT LEFT 5,000.00 5,000.00 1491 LEFT 1493 LEFT
2447 H.M. CHANDANA FACTORY LEFT 6,000.00 5,400.00 2111 LEFT 2697 LEFT
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
24/38
24
ROSHAN HERATH
2891A. SUMEDHAMENDIS
DISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 5,500.00 5,500.00 2525 LEFT 1717 LEFT
987 M.G.M.SABITH HRD LEFT 5,900.00 5,900.00 152 LEFT 377 LEFT
2840R.P. RUWANSAMPATH TRANSPORT LEFT 6,000.00 6,000.00 2656 LEFT 2657 LEFT
3328 L.A. SAMAN FACTORY LEFT 6,000.00 6,000.00
1739 N.W. SAHABANDU D.N.W. H/W LEFT 10000.00 7,000.00 706 LEFT 1312 LEFT
770 WASANTHA C.C.D LEFT 23,500.00 11,500.00
964K.M.C.S.SAMARAKOON D.N.W. H/W LEFT 7,500.00 6,750.00 881 LEFT 2083 LEFT
2657 JAGATH EKANAYAKE TRANSPORT LEFT 6,300.00 -600.00 3092 LEFT
2632 T.D.GUNASEKARA STORES TYRE LEFT 6,600.00 0.33 2478 LEFT 2366 LEFT
3631 SANJAYA TRANSPORT LEFT 6,600.00 -0.11 3636 LEFT
2720PADMANADANSUDHARAN D.N.W.H/W LEFT -3,000.00
3636 J.KUMARA TRANSPORT LEFT 6,000.00 3,000.00 2894 LEFT
2497 BONYFACE SAD ELE LEFT 7000.00 4,900.00 3683 LEFT 2212 LEFT3590 SANJEEWA STORES BHW LEFT 6,600.00 3,300.00 3586 LEFT
1642H.T.SURESH-OVERPAYMENT D.N.W. H/W LEFT 0.00 -1,000.00
3118T.L. PREMALAL-OVERPAYMENT SECURITY LEFT 0.00 -600.00
3303 ARUNA DE SILVADISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 6,000.00 960.00
3303 MICHEL SILVADISTRIBUTIONH/W LEFT 4,500.00 1,800.00
2195S. CHAMARARASANGA ADMIN LEFT 5,000.00 -2,250.00
3066 JAYANTHA STORES G.H.W LEFT 6,000.00 1,800.00 3255 LEFT3296 U.A.C.S. JAYADEWA .D.N.W. ELE LEFT 6,500.00 650.00 3461 LEFT 3303 LEFT
3461L.P. SURANGALAKMAL
.DISTRIBUTIONELE LEFT 6,500.00 1,300.00 2425 LEFT 3296 LEFT
3534 FERNANDO STORES CLR. LEFT 6,600.00 1,320.00 3587 LEFT 3066 LEFT
2771 FERNANDO STORES GHW LEFT 7000.00 2,800.00 3066 LEFT
865 Mr. M.S.M. ISMATH COLOUR FAC. LEFT 7500.00 750.00 3276 LEFT 2048 LEFT
3727A. MOHAMED
SANOOS .D.N.W. ELE LEFT 7500.00 5,250.00 2497 LEFT
2928 D.B. KALANSOORIYA D.N.W. TYRE LEFT 10,000.00 1,000.00 1544 LEFT 3072 LEFT
3276
H.A.D. AMIL
SENEVIRATHNE COLOUR PEB LEFT 10,000.00 2,000.00 2577 LEFT 3522 LEFT3736 IMTIYAS QC - ELE LEFT 10,000.00 1,000.00 3682 LEFT
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
This will show irrecoverable figures as receivable.
Understating the expenditures
Question is how they can be cleared without recovering those outstanding
balances.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
25/38
25
RECOMMENDATIONSNecessary actions should be taken to recover these outstanding balances.
If those balances are unable to recover this should be written off ASAP without
dragging.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
Reports are not complete and updated. Some in these lists have already settled the
dues. Those who have done the clearances have cleared the outstanding. Those
who have directly paid and settled with the cashier need to be updated. Those
who rejoined the services did the clearance of the previous number and had settled
the outstanding. Those need to be updated.
14. OBSERVATION
Weaknesses in payroll system
14.1. Even though employee left from the company as per the personal file &
monthly folder, the particular name is continuously mentioned in payroll.
EPF No Name Vacated
Month
Payroll
5524 R.D.S.C
Wijerathne
June July/August
14.2. Final dues setoff through IOUs without any acknowledgement.
EPF No Name
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
26/38
26
5618 Shantha Kularathna
5616 H.Rathna Banda
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
It is critical point and leads to be a fraud due to continuously payment for leftemployees.
It is a high risk transaction, where a left employee turn back and say that they didnot receive final dues.
Deviation to the set policies and procedures of the company.
RECOMMENDATION
It must be ensured whether the employees are in the company or not before startout payments.
HRD should not entertain final payments through IOU which is not a generalpractice in this establishment.
It is recommended to get an acknowledgment from the relevant segment head toconfirm their divisional staff by a mail in every month by HRD.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
5524 - Employee was removed from the payroll for prolonged absence and was
reinstated the following month after excusing him on valid grounds.
Not a single rupee has been paid extra to any left employee.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
27/38
27
5616 / 5618 - these two were among the four new Truck operators who grouped
for creating unnecessary issues and they were immediately sent off after taking
resignations. There was a delay in getting their dues cleared as the FR was at
finance and GFEC from 4/6 to 10/6 and HRM therefore spoke to DO and settledthem quickly by taking money on IOU and the corresponding cheque was then
raised in favour of TT to settle the IOU.
Therefore the systems need flexibility to handle critical issues.
Auditors seem to have not read properly the content of the documents in file.
15. OBSERVATION
We observed that in some instances, exit interviews have not been conducted by
the HRD and proper records are not available in the HRD.
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
Some time we might lose loyal/good employees without any reason.
Tarnishing the company image as they are not having a chance to expose their
genuine ideas to HRD.
RECOMMENDATION
EPF No Name
5680 W. Sunanda Fernando
5691 R.A Sujith Lakmal
5604 W.M.A.Ranjith Weerasinghe
5388 M.S.M Rashadh
5167 T.Priyanath Sagara Fernando
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
28/38
28
We recommend that exit interview should be done prior to the finalization of exit of
employee. Where you could find reasons to retain wanted/important staff &
employees.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
Exit interviews are being conducted in all cases other than the VOPs. The clearance
form itself has a provision for same whether conducted or not. The special
statements they make are recorded and with HRM for situational rectifications.
19. OBSERVATION
We observed that High employee turnover in the company. This will lead to high
cost recruitment advertisements as well as disturbance to the smooth operations of
the company.
As per the financial records advertisement for recruitments have been specified as
follows.
Monthly average is Rs. 500000/= and this will be equal to 40 workers salary.
POSITION DEPARTMENT JULY AUGUST SEPTEMBER TOTAL SPENT
PUREMATAL WORKERS PUREMETAL 19,320.00 19,320.00
PRODUCTION HELPER PUREMETAL 31,752.00 31,752.00
HEAVY VEHICLE & BIKE MECANICS VMD 21,168.00 21,168.00
A. PROCUMENT MANAGER CPD 113,823.04 113,823.04
SALES MANAGER SALES DNW 113,823.04 113,823.04
BAZZAR SALES EXECUTIVE SALES BARRAR 17,202.64 17,202.64
MARKETING EXECUTIVE SALES INST 12,566.40 12,566.40
STORE KEEPER STORES 10,890.88 10,890.88
SALES REP DNW 14,137.20 14,137.20
MACHINIST VMD 15,400.00 15,400.00
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
29/38
29
LATHE MEN GCIS FAC. 15,400.00 15,400.00
PRODUCT MANAGEMENT EXECUTIVE PMD 26,389.44 26,389.44
SALES REP NORTH OPERATION NORTH SALAES 23,750.50 23,750.50
DOMESTIC ELECTRIC APPLIANCE VMD 89,964.00 89,964.00
TRUCK OPERATOR & DISTRIBUTION HELPER TRANSPORT 86,268.00 108,494.40 34,398.00 229,160.40
DISTRIBUTION REP DISTRIBUTION 51,072.00 68,796.00 119,868.00
GRAFIC DESIGNER BMD 9,215.36 9,215.36
SALES REP (DNW) DNW 121,054.08 121,054.08
MANAGER TRADE COMMUNICATIONS COR 25,132.80 25,132.80
STORES & FACTORY WORKERS STO. & FAC. 37,422.00 29,106.00 66,528.00
PETTY CASHIER & ACCOUNT ASST. FINNACE 13,823.04 13,823.04
FIELD AUDITOR SAD 31,752.00 31,752.00
PLUMBER MAINTENANCE 18,522.00 18,522.00
TOTAL 522,823.20 524,041.62 113,778.00 1,160,642.82
Employee Turnover as a whole
In Division wise turnover
Left Amount Present Carder Turnover ratio
July August July August July August
IMPORTS 0 1 7 8 0% 12.5%
PMD 1 3 32 29 3.12% 10.3%
QUALITY CONTROL 2 2 32 30 6.25% 6.7%
CRMD 0 1 32 33 0% 3%GFEC 1 1 7 8 14.28% 12.5%
FINANCE 0 7 27 25 0% 28%
CCD 0 1 16 16 0% 6.25%
ADMINISTRATION 0 1 5 4 0% 25%
GENERALMAINTENANCE 2 3 14 13 14.28% 23.1%
PREMISESMAINTENANCE
0 3 12 12 0% 25%
STORES 9 8 101 98 9% 8.2%GCIS FACTORY 2 6 46 41 4.34% 14.6%
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
30/38
30
DNW 13 11 132 125 9.9% 8.9%
NORTH OPERATION 3 3 14 17 21.4% 17.6%
SUPPLIERS 3 5 56 62 5.4% 8.1%
TYRE 4 4 26 14 15.4% 16.7%
VMDC 2 2 32 34 6.2% 5.9%LVMD 0 1 11 10 0% 10%
TRANSPORT 9 14 232 233 3.9% 6%
BAZAAR 2 2 32 33 6.25% 6%
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
This is high risk to the company & it leads to increased of cost. As well as this is
mainly affect to the company image.
RECOMMENDATION
It must be analyzed what are the reasons for left and gain proper solutions as soon
as possible.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
Turnover has been high in worker and staff categories due to low income. Those
who reside in distant places are boarded and their income is not enough to meet
the ends.Job market has become competitive with many projects taking shape across the
country and the said categories have opted the opportunities with them without
considering to stay at one place for a career.
20. OBSERVATION
Non availability of succession plan
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
31/38
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
32/38
32
01 HARDWARE
Mr.Keerthi
Mr.Nuwan
Is that Mr.Nuwancapable of doingMr.Keerthis
responsibilities?
02SAD - HARDWARE
03DISTRIBUTION -HARDWARE
Mr. Munasinghe
Mr pradeep
Is that Mr.Pradeepicapable and qualifiedto handle in theabsence of MSD?
04 ELECTRICAL
Mr. Nalaka
Mr.Ruberu
Can Mr.Ruberu handlethe Mr.Nalakas
responsibilities at atime?
05 SAD - ELECTRICAL
06 DISTRIBUTION -ELECTRICAL (EVSO)
07BAZAAR Mr. Illiyas
-NO replacement atall?
08
SAD - BAZAAR Mr.Nasith
Mr.Manula
What is the Mr.Manulas role
compared tomr.Naseeth?
09DISTRIBUTION -BAZAAR
Mr.papilyMr.Pradeep
How couldMr.Pradeep do twojobs at time?
10
TYREMr.faris
Mr.Sahalan
What is theMr.Shalans
qualification andexperience comparedto Mr.fariss?
11 SAD - TYRE
12INSTITUTION Mr.palitha
Mr.Chathuranga
Can Mr. Chathurangahandle the cases sameas Mr.palitha
13NORTH OPERATIONS Mr.kumar
-No replacement
14 MODERN TRADE Mr.Miflah _ No replacement
15
ADMINISTRATION Mr.Jayarathne
Mr.Sanjeewa
How could
Mr.Sanjeewa fulfill theBOD requirement asSAM?
16MAINTENANCEDIVISION
Mr.Weerarathne_
No replacement
17 SECURITY Mr. Kulathunga Mr.Sudarshana
18 BMD Mr.Anzaff Mr.Ryan Jusitified
19
TELE- MARKETING(CRMD)
Mr.Sajith
Mr.Harshad
Is Mr.Harshads
experience couldfulfill the BODrequirement.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
33/38
33
20
FINANCE Mr.Aliyboy
Mr.Azard
Can FM represent theFC whenqualifications iscompared?
21CREDIT CONTROLDIVISION (CCD)
Mr.Chamara Mr.S.Madarasinghe
Is that Mr.Marasinghecompetent & capableas Mr.Chamara?
22
HUMAN RESOURCESDIVISION
Mr.Sudarshana
Mr.Imitiyaz
Is that Mr.Imitiyasiqualified andcompetent as HRM tofulfill the BODrequirement?
23
PRODUCT
MARKETING DIVISION(PMD)
Mr.Ponkowan
Mr.Shiraz
How could it possible?What is the
experience andqualification havingMr.Shiraz comparedto GM.
24IMPORTS Mr.Pathegama
Mr.AjithCan be considered tosome extent.
25 IT DIVISION Mr. Cardir Mr.Isitha
26
MATERIAL
MANAGEMENT UNIT
Mr. Ashon
Mr.Fahim
Can Mr.Fahimrepresent the BOD onbehalf AMMC
compared to hisportfolio?
27 PROCUREMENT Mr.Ajith _ No replacement-Risk?
28 QC - ELECTRICAL
Mr.Marzook
Mr.Muzni Can be considered.
29 STORES (TYRE)
Mr.Samath
No replacement at all.Store is very criticalarea where you needmanysubordinates.ButMr.Marzook is
continuing his task inhis old age withoutany immediatereplacement to him.
30 STORES (GHW)
31 STORES (BHW)
32 STORES (CLR)
33 STORES (GCIS)
34 STORES (ELE)
35
STORES (CVMD)
36 STORES (G2)
37 TRANSPORT Mr. Hasantha Mr.Palitha Mr.Palitha could beassigned as successorof Mr.Nevil.But howhe qualifies replaceMTL?
38 VEHICAL MAINT. DIV.(CVMD)
Mr.Nevil
Mr.Palitha39 LIGHT VEHICALMAINT. DIV. (LVMD)
Mr.Kaiz
40PUREMETALS Mr.Chandana
Mr.Yasri
Mr.Chandana is anengineer and Mr.Yasryis B.com degree
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
34/38
34
RISK & IMPLICATIONS
Lack of this plan means we are in the dark. Without this succession plan an
establishment could not plan its unforeseen future.
A sudden retirement of an employee could results in severe back logs in the
division.
RECOMMENDATION
The employee selected as second officer should capable for the position with
educational and professional experience. HRD should prepare a succession plan and
be kept to inform the BOD which will help for future planning.
SEGMENT HEAD COMMENTS AND THE DEADLINES BY THE SEGMENT HEAD FOR
ACTIVATION
True that there are positions which do not have a successor and to be filled from
outside in case the need arises. But it is not the case with all positions. One may
think that the suggested names are not capable. Then who are running the depts.
At present when the heads are away or on leave. The second layer is practically
Holder?
41 CORPORATE OFFICE
42 MD'S OFFICE
43 GCIS FACTORY Mr. Sama Mr.Hilmy Is that Mr.Hilmycapable as Mr.Sama44 COLOR FACTORY
45
GFECMr.J.C.
KothalawalaMr.Reeza
Is that Mr.Reezaqualified as SMA tofulfill the BODrequirement?
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
35/38
35
competent to run the show, only thing is they need to be equipped with the
managing and reporting skills.
GFEC CHECK LIST ONHRMHUMAN RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
Month of August 2011- Reviewed on 11.08.2011
NO Things to Do. DoneNotDone
If not whyremarks
1 Did you retain employees for operations & sales support above 95%at any given time?
2 Did you fill cadre vacancies for operations & sales supportwithin 30 days?
3Did you conduct the carder evaluations at least once in 6 monthswith GFEC
Bi annualevaluation papersare completed, tobe finalized withGFEC
4Are you updating promptly the details of the new employees andtheir contact numbers?
To be done forExecutives also asper theinstruction given
be MD.
5Did you appraise the Executive and non executive level performanceat least once in 6 months?
6Did you conduct the Exit Interviews when the staff is leaving?
7
Did you manage attendance & punctuality for operations & salessupport categories above 90% level and executive level & above at95% level?
8
Are you having one to one meeting with each and every segment
head by communicating with them in advance?
9Did you remove all the notices within 7 days from the notice boards?
10Are you conducting canteen committee meeting each and everymonth without missing a single?
11
Are you checking the staff transports bus whether any unauthorizedpeople are being transported? If so what actions have you taken?
12Did you get the BOD approval for any new recruitment especially forExecutive levels and above. Their expected salary always should bewithin the company standard and if any variations BOD approval
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
36/38
36
needed for any divisions.
13Are all the employees given the job descriptions and their task
documents?
14 Whether All the salary increments and promotions should be basedon this performance evaluation.
15Are you checking Employee Dress Code especially female staff andmonthly awareness session is conducted?
16Did you Review and repeat standard notices, circulars once a quarter.
17
Did you maintain highest level of confidentiality without anycomplains about the employee related matters ?
18Did you achieve any Extra Ordinary Contribution for the month andsubmit the paper to MD office?
Not submittedthe grip that HRMmaintain inoperations &defending thecompany in alllegal cases incourts of law areindeed the extraordinarycontribution of
HRM to thecompany.
19Did you send the KPI on or before 10th of the following month toGFEC
20
Did you send your monthly HRD folder before 10thof the followingmonth to BOD and GFEC?
21Did you notify to segment heads and security on prohibited areas tooutsiders.
22
Did you implement the pre interview formats as per BOD
requirement? Before end ofOctomber.23 Have you started Time Study Exercise for each department wise? 24
Did you take approval for leave from both MD and DO as an EMCmember?
25How many court cases pending and how many attended during themonth? How many cases completed in favour of the company.
5 court cases & 2labourdepartmentcases.All arerunning cases.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
37/38
37
New proposals of HRD
Recruitment the best & retained. It must be improved & lectured personal management skills for all division heads
& succession persons in next in each division. This is a major reason for turn over
the employers.
It shouldnt be terminated quickly employers when a person done wrong thingwithout find reasons.
Should be done surveys in each divisions. Should be done annual events. Through this each & every employer can recognize
not only below executive level but all minor levels.
Should be done annual rewards ceremony for high performance for everydivisions.
Should be kept standard acceptable uniform policy in salary increments. In thispersons should be ranked & give rates like A, A-, B, B+ e.t.c. As well as it should be
given automatically increments & promotions without further requesting as late
when a person is being promoted
Should be transparency procedure for general things as well as should give handbooks for above executives & minor levels.
Meetings should be limited to specific time period & everyone should comeprepare questions suggestions & talk & find solutions & go.
HRD Folder
Suggestions
HRD folder includes main things which relevant to department. But furthermore
if it can be including following things it may be very needful.
All left employees in detail wise as resigned, vacated as well as fireseparately.
Details about all court cases & labour department cases.
Late comers to be address and to be acknowledged division heads. Canteen committee not held regularly with all the members.
-
8/13/2019 Internal Audit Review at Human Resources Division
38/38