interchange best practices - merchant advisory group is interchange? interchange is the rate charged...
TRANSCRIPT
Housekeeping notes
If you’re not connected by phone or can’t hear audio:
1. Dial 866.551.1530 or 212.401.6760
2. Enter PIN Code 3239438#
3. Follow the prompts to record your name and company
2
Housekeeping notes
If you cannot see the video:
1. Please refer to your original invitation and click the
“register here” button; or
2. Find the “Thank you for registering” or “Webcast Reminder”
e-mail sent from “Event Notification”; click the Event URL
and enter your e-mail address
Event URL:
http://event.onlineseminarsolutions.com/r.htm?e=233534&s=
1&k=432E345395459414D1E258F6AC57DF78
3
Housekeeping notes
Presumption of confidentiality: The MAG presumes that
you understand and accept that the information presented
during this webcast is privileged and confidential. Please do
not share any URLs, usernames, or access codes that you
received to access this event.
To watch a replay of this webcast, which will be online in the
next couple of days, please:
go to the same URL that you used to log in today;
enter the same e-mail address you used to register for this
event; and
type in access code MAG@746632
4
Moderator
Dodd Roberts MAG CEO/President
Interchange 101
Kathy Hanna The Kroger Company
Interchange and Management Analysis
Troy Carrothers Kohl’s
Laura Ermer McDonald’s
Kelly Andrus Tesoro Refining and Marketing
Chris Priebe Southwest Airlines
Best Practices Committee Chairs
Doug Linkowski Marriott International
Chris Priebe Southwest Airlines
Presenters
5
Russ Rhine Arkadin
Rhonda Sullivan SAS
Event
Facilitators
1. What is interchange?
2. What are the components?
3. How is interchange distributed?
4. What are the common pitfalls?
5. What can merchants do to affect
interchange cost?
Agenda
7
What is interchange?
Interchange is the rate charged to a merchant by a
bank for providing debit and credit card services.
The rate is determined based on factors such as
volume, average ticket price, risk and industry.
The merchant must set up this service with a
bank/acquirer, and agree to the rate prior to
accepting debit and credit cards as payment.
www.answers.com
Interchange is a multi-billion dollar industry.
8
Estimated components of interchange
Source: Diamond Management & Technology Consultants:
A New Business Model for Card Payments
9
other issuer transaction costs &
profit margin 35%
issuer rewards 44%
issuer processing 9%
network rewards 1%
network branding 3%
network servicing 4%
network processing 4%
Other fees besides interchange
Visa
• APF fee
• dues and assessment
• Base II settlement fee
• image documentation fee
• outgoing exception item
• risk fee
• zero floor limit
• account verification fee
• auth misuse fee
• raw data fee for RTC
10
MasterCard
• NABU fee
• dues and assessment
• settlement fee
• documentation image fee
• retrieval request fee
• AVS fee
• chargeback assessment fee
• chargeback support
document fee
Product
• credit
• debit
• commercial
• rewards
How is interchange charged?
11
Market Segment
• T&E
• fuel
• grocery
• other retail
Processing Technology
• card terminal
• AFD/self-service
• key entry
• e-commerce
No authorization
Late presentment
Key entered
Bad or missing data
Pitfalls that increase interchange
13
1. TALK with acquirer on regular basis-
Ask WHY? WHY? WHY?
2. Understand downgrades and
surcharges-correct actions
3. Review billing reports timely
(daily, monthly, etc.)
What can the merchant do?
14
Kohl’s – Interchange: Analysis and Management
Analysis
Understand your interchange origin and trends:
• Perform monthly analysis of network invoices
• Understand your mix between:
a) in-store and on-line
b) credit and debit
c) signature and PIN
d) card present and exceptions
Understand your true interchange costs:
• Compare the networks marketing benefits against the net expense
• Do you know:
a) The financial impact of every interchange increase?
b) Your sales breakeven point for every interchange price change?
c) Your chargeback rights?
d) When you should challenge a network response?
17
Kohl’s – Interchange: Analysis and Management
Management
Look for opportunities:
• Reduce exceptions by challenging your internal processes
• Reduce fraud and chargebacks with clearer return policies and
the implementation of fraud detection technology
• Don’t be shy … ask your acquirer for help
• Create a flexible payment hierarchy in-store and on-line to draw
attention to the lowest cost (net) network
• Take advantage of the grey
“Kick the habit” … reduce your dependency:
• Introduce a rich loyalty program for non-interchange related transactions
• Allocate interchange expense back to your stores to gain
store level involvement
• Incent your store managers to promote the loyalty program
• Don’t believe what you read … the majority of your sales can be
made on your own proprietary tender … trust me!
18
McDonald’s – interchange management
What is It • Prompting at the POS based on tender type
Primary Objective • COST SAVINGS
Implementation Scope • National across all ownership types
Timing • Upon launch in 2003
21
23
Benefits • Debit interchange cost savings
• Speed of service (D Thru)
Challenges • Card network rules (PIN & sig debit)
o Discrimination
o Min/Max
o Cardholder choice
• Communications
• Customer experience
McDonald’s – interchange management
24
Breakeven Calculation
The transaction amount at which the
1. Blended PIN debit interchange cost
IS EQUAL TO
2. Blended signature debit interchange cost
Based on the current market share at
McDonald’s of each debit network
McDonald’s – interchange management
25
• Currently based on blended interchange by auth
type vs. individual networks (PIN vs. sig debit)
• Treasury monitors rate changes and calculates
breakeven amount
• I/T implements changes in breakeven
• Field communications issued upon changes
in breakeven
McDonald’s – interchange management
26
Interchange Reporting
Data provided by interchange qualification:
Total transaction counts and amounts
Rate (includes dues/assessments)
Primary uses:
Calculate market share of each debit network used for:
○ interchange management breakeven calculation
○ management reporting for cashless program
Validate accuracy of interchange fees charged
McDonald’s – interchange management
Processing Tips
1. All card associations require partial auth capability:
• Visa charges a partial auth non-participation fee of $0.01 per
CRIND transaction that is not partial auth capable
• Pass on fees to the respective jobber if their systems are not
properly configured for this feature
2. Velocity parameters must be in place for Visa transactions to
qualify for CPS AFD rates
3. Authorization reversals:
• Visa and MasterCard require the reversal of authorizations where
the transaction was cancelled and will never be settled:
o Visa currently charges a $.045 cent fee per authorization
o MasterCard has announced that it will also start charging a fee,
but has not disclosed any details yet
• Tesoro’s processor automatically sends a reversal for any non-
settled authorization, except when a valid zip verification is present
Petroleum industry specifics
29
Processing Tips
4. Ensure CRIND limits do not exceed card association limits:
• Visa will downgrade to EIRF if transaction exceeds their limit
• Visa caps the CPS AFD rate at $0.95; however, the transaction
amount to qualify for the cap is $105, which is above their
CRIND limit for Visa consumer cards (Visa fleet limit is $150)
• Although MasterCard does not downgrade transactions that
exceed their limit, the MasterCard AFD rate cap of $0.95 only
qualifies for transactions of $112 or more, which is above the
CRIND limit for consumer cards (fleet and purchasing card limit
is $150)
5. Zip prompting at the pumps:
• Helps to minimize fraud
• None of the card associations offers any interchange savings or
chargeback protection
• Tesoro requires our jobbers to prompt for zip; otherwise, the
location is liable for any fraud chargebacks that occur
Petroleum industry specifics
30
Interchange Management Tips 1. Review all unauthorized transactions:
• Utilize a tool such as
Monarch to extract all
unauthorized
transactions by day
• Review declines for
trends
• Set thresholds by
decline reason
• In our reviews, we have found some issuers sending wrong zip
verification responses, which had a significant impact to our pay
at pump customers
• Other findings include jobbers that are attempting to accept a
card type they are not set up for
• We also use this tool to monitor our company-owned sites for
communication issues
Petroleum industry specifics
31
Response / De finition 1 2 3
83 UNMATCHED PREPAY TRANSACTION 0 0 0
84 MATHED 30 WITH 01 ON HOST 254 165 198
85 MATHED 30 WITH 05/ 13 ON HOST 2 4 4
86 MATHED 32 (Void) WITH 11/ 13/ 34 ON HOST 18 16 9
87 ACCT, AMT & TSEQ ALREADY USED 0 0 0
94 PREPAY ONLY, DUPE PREV PROCESSED TRANS 14 21 4
95 PREPAY ONLY, INTERNAL MALFUNCTION 3 12 0
96 PREPAY ONLY 0 0 0
97 PREPAY ONLY, VOID/ DRAFT NOT IN SYSTEM 1 2 0
98 REQUESTED TRANS PROHIBITED 14 16 6
Interchange Management Tips 2. Review downgrade reports from acquirer:
• We can run reports at a client or merchant level
• We can specify a date range or run by a single day
• Reports can be downloaded into excel for easy incorporation into
our analysis tool
• Address root cause with IT or jobber if downgrade is the result of
action taken at the location (e.g., not closing batches daily,
manual entry, exceeding CRIND limit, etc.)
• Not all downgrades are a result of processing errors at the
location, address root cause with processor:
o Do not assume you should be liable for all downgrades
Petroleum industry specifics
32
Interchange Management Tips 3. Review interchange reports from acquirer:
• We can run reports at a client or merchant level
• We can specify a date range or run by a single day
• Reports can be downloaded into excel for easy incorporation into
our analysis tool
• Verify that at least 90% of your transactions are qualifying for the
best rate possible
• If you are not reaching this threshold, work with your processor/
acquirer to understand why and make corrections as necessary
Petroleum industry specifics
33
36
• Identify controllable expenses
• Daily monitoring
• Hold acquirer accountable - SLA
• Hold your company accountable
• Review quarterly statistics
Keys to Success
• 10 merchant numbers or less (one for each sales channel)
• Key daily interchange data from various acquirer reports into Excel
• Key monthly acquirer reports into Excel (balance to my GL)
• Keep it simple (accomplished with 2% of 1 associate)
Current Set Up
Interchange management
37
• Pass through interchange rates vary according to card type, card
present vs. card not present, authorized vs. non authorized,
providing additional airline data, settlement date vs. authorized date,
authorized date vs. ticketed date, etc.
• The only items I can’t control are card type and CNP vs. Non CNP!
What are Controllable Expenses
• Daily monitoring of “less than optimal rates” or downgrades
• Benchmark your expectations
• When less than optimal rates as a % of total rates exceed
benchmark, research the root cause
• Reconcile our charges monthly by rate to the actual GL expense
How do we control
Interchange management
38
• Ticket Processing Group authorized purchases on Friday, but
ticketed them on Monday, causing a greater than 24-hour timeline
between the ticket date and the authorization date - saved $100K
per year
• Reservations technology accidentally coded to skip all Visa
authorizations instead of skip certain Visa test card authorizations -
lost $10K on day 1, but fixed on day 2
• Identified certain BIN ranges that had a disproportionate number of
downgraded transactions (i.e. we had 1% downgrades but BIN X
had 80% downgrades); turned out to be a Visa problem that was
costing us $200K per year
• Acquirer error, which led to a one-day downgrade of +30% ($50K);
recovered via Service Level Agreement
Examples of What We Catch…
Interchange management
To watch a replay of this webcast, which will be online
in the next couple of days, please:
1. go to the same URL that you used to log in today
2. enter the same e-mail address you used to register
for this event
3. type in access code MAG@746632
Webcast replay
42