intel equity research (1) - wordpress.com
TRANSCRIPT
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Intel
Equity Research CityU Research & Investment Club
Authors
Gerald Akhmelvan Kenneth Hans Periatna Waleed Meraj Qureshi
Andreas Kusnadi Muhammad Saif Ullah
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
The content and opinions in this report are written by university students from the CityU Student Research & Investment Club, and thus are for reference only. Investors are fully responsible for their investment decisions. CityU Student Research & Investment Club is not responsible for any direct or indirect loss resulting from investments referenced to this report. The opinions in this report constitute the opinion of the CityU Student Research & Investment Club and do not constitute the opinion of the City University of Hong Kong nor any governing or student body or department under the University.
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Intel Corporation (INTC) 11th Gen roadmap, commitment to change, and development in IOTG sets Intel for long-term growth We view that the market is overreacting and shifting most of its attention to Intel’s delay on their 7nm chips. Intel is currently undergoing a strategic transformation into a data-centric company. Client Computing Group (CCG) does comprise a majority of Intel’s revenue (2019: 51.8%, 2Q20: 48.2%), and the recent news of Intel’s delay on their 7nm chips may have investors losing confidence as AMD and NVIDIA have technological and manufacturing edge over Intel. However, we believe that investors are turning their heads away from long-term growth potential in their Data Center Group (DCG) and Internet of Things Group (IOTG), also combined with a solid upcoming 11th gen product pipeline. Intel’s architecture day highlights their commitment to continue delivering timely, high-quality products to clients, indicated by Intel’s statement that some of their GPUs will be made in external foundries (very likely TSMC). Their Tiger Lake processors represents a major improvement to their previous processors, offering superior single-core performance to AMD’s Ryzen 7 4800U series and [their IrisXe GPU] comparable performance with NVIDIA’s MX-350 GPU. Intel has also secured multiple partnerships with OEMs for their notebook CPUs, including major existing customers such as HP, Dell, and Lenovo, along with Acer and Asus, to name a few. We expect that the strong demand for their CPUs and GPUs can allow minimization of market share losses to AMD and NVIDIA. Intel has robust financials and fundamentals, shown by their consistent free cash flow generation ability, a healthy balance sheet, and quality capital allocation. This provides investors a cushion for downside risks and volatility nearing the election and amidst global uncertainty, in our view. It also allows Intel to continuously invest in the long-term development of segments such as IOTG, where we believe will experience double-digit growth post COVID-19 (base case: 1Q22), driven by increased demand of electric and autonomous vehicles, mainly in China. The rise in enterprise digital transformation, AI usage, users of digital banking and online wallets, and wearables also contributes to the increased demand for data storage, which serves as a positive future catalyst for Intel’s data center processors as more companies deem data center and cloud spending to be a necessity. We remain overweight on INTC, with a price target of $63.44.
13 October 2020 United States
Equity Research Rating: Overweight Current Share Price: $53.88 Price Target: $63.44 52-Week Range: $43.63–69.29 Market Cap: $229.17B Enterprise Value: $241.39B
Technology, Media & Telecommunications Gerald Akhmelvan – Lead Analyst [email protected] Kenneth Hans Periatna [email protected] Waleed Meraj [email protected] Andreas Kusnadi [email protected] Muhammad Saif Ullah [email protected]
40,00
50,00
60,00
70,00
Jan-20 Apr-20 Jul-20 Oct-20
INTC
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Table of Contents Revenue Breakdown (2019) ............................................................................................. 3
Largest Customers ................................................................................................................................................................................ 4 Competitors Revenue Breakdown and 5 Year Share Price Performance ........................................................................... 4
Industry Trends ................................................................................................................... 5 Sales of Global Semiconductor Market .......................................................................................................................................... 5 Personal Computing Device Shipments ........................................................................................................................................ 6 IoT Spending ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 6 Semiconductor Sales Segments ....................................................................................................................................................... 6
Investment Catalysts and Risks ....................................................................................... 6
Catalysts .................................................................................................................................................... 6 Intel’s Tiger Lake (10nm) demonstrates enhancement in laptop CPUs and comparable performance to AMD’s 7nm processors. ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Massive growth potential for IOTG segment driven by increased EV sales trend in 3 major regions. .................... 8 Intel’s actions show commitment and willingness to adapt. ................................................................................................. 9
Risks ........................................................................................................................................................... 9 Intel faces intense competition on the CCG segment and market share is continuously being eaten by AMD. .. 9 Other risk factors ................................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Valuation ........................................................................................................................... 10
Summary ................................................................................................................................................ 10
Discounted Cash Flow (85%) ............................................................................................................. 10
Comparables (10%) ............................................................................................................................. 12
Precedent Transactions Analysis (5%) ............................................................................................. 12
Summary of Financials .................................................................................................... 13
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Revenue Breakdown1
Client Computing Group (CCG): This segment includes platforms designed for end-user form factors and generates 51.8% of Intel’s revenue. Data Center Group (DCG): The DCG segment provides cloud services and makes up 32.8% of Intel’s revenue. Internet of Things Group (IOTG): The IOTG segment develops autonomous vehicles and produces high-technology products such as Intel’s VR Sports. This segment accounts 6.6% of Intel’s revenue and has shown constant high growth in the past five years. Non-Volatile Memory Solutions Group (NSG): The NSG segment manufactures products such as NAND technologies and covers 6.1% of Intel’s revenue. Programmable Solutions Group (PSG): Intel’s PSG segment constructs configuration devices, design software and power solution products. It books 2.8% of Intel revenue following a constant growth since 2015.
1 Pie chart may not equal to 100% due to rounding.
9000
13000
17000
21000
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Figure 1. Revenue by Regions (Millions USD)
China (Including Hong Kong)SingaporeUnited States
Source: Company Reports
13%
17%
11%
8%
10%
12%
14%
16%
18%
20%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Figure 3. Intel's Three Largest Customers (% of Revenue)
Lenovo Group Limited Dell Inc. HP Inc.Source: Company Reports
32.8%
6.6%
6.1%2.8%
51.8%
Figure 4. Revenue by Product Segments (2019)
DCG IOTG NSG PSG CCGSource: Company Reports
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 1Q20 2Q20
Figure 2. Revenue by Product Segments (Millions USD)
DCG IOTG NSG PSG CCGSource: Company Reports
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Largest Customers
For the past 5 years, Intel’s three largest customers, Dell Inc, Lenovo Group Limited, and HP Inc., accounted for an average of 41% of Intel’s net revenue. Revenue from these customers was from sale of platforms and various components mostly provided by the CCG and DCG operating segments. We expect CCG to experience low single-digit growth supported by upcoming 11th gen products, partially offset by a declining market and heavy competition from peers AMD and NVIDIA. We presume DCG will have mid-single-digit growth from increased demand of infrastructure expansion from hyperscalers, cloud computing and data centers, and cloud builders in the telecommunication and service provider companies. With the acquisition of Mobileye and partnership with Geely, we predict IOTG’s high growth will continue and will be set off by growing automotive sales post COVID-19. Due to the decreasing trend in NAND prices, slowing demand across communication and embedded segments, coupled with uncertainty arising from COVID-19, we believe that the growth in NSG and PSG may be limited or flat. Competitors Revenue Breakdown and 5 Year Share Price Performance
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
65
70
75
Oct-15 Oct-16 Oct-17 Oct-18 Oct-19 Oct-20
Figure 5. INTC 5 Year Price and Major Events
March 2020: Coronavirus Market Crash, INTC share price dropped by 34.8%
April 2019: INTClowered revenue guidance by $2.5 billion due to weak demand
July 2020: INTCannounced delays in their 7nm chips
July 2019: INTC sold their smartphonemodem business to AAPL
October 2017: Strong Q317 results, +6% in total revenue yoy, IOTG +23% yoyrevenue growth
June 2018: CEOBrian Krzanich resigned
July 2018: Beginning of US-China Trade War
Table 1. Competitors' Revenue Breakdown
Company Major Revenue Segments Regional (FY19) Product Mix (FY19) Major
Customers
AMD Ryzen Chips and Gaming Console custom chips in PS4 and Xbox
US (26.2%), APAC (57.8%), Europe (11.3%), Others
(4.7%)
Computing and Graphics (70%), EESC (30%)
Google, Amazon, Oracle
NVIDIA Data Center platforms and GeForce GPUs for gaming
US (8.1%), APAC (77.3%), Europe(9.1%), Others (5.5%)
Graphics (54%), Computer and Networking (46%)
Microsoft, Alphabet, Apple
IBM Power9 processor, Cloud-based
services, Cognitive Computing and Consulting
Americas (47%), APAC (21.3%), EMEA (31.7%),
Cloud and Cognitive Software (32%), Global Business and Technology Services (57%),
Systems (11%)
BNP Paribas, JP Morgan Chase,
Daimler AG
TSMC Manufacturing Apple’s new Arm-based processors and Nvidia GeForce GPUs
US (59.3%), APAC (32.7%), EMEA (6.3%), Others (1.7%) Wafer (86.7%), Others (13.3%)
Apple, AMD, NVIDIA
Source: Company Reports
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Industry Trends
Sales of Global Semiconductor Market
• Cylicality in memory market and pricing of memory products were the main driver in 12% global semiconductor sales decrease from 2018 to 2019.
• 2020 forecast of $426 billion is a revision of WSTS’ fall 2019 forecast of $436 Billion. This downgrade was attributed by disruptions in supply chain from the COVID-19 pandemic.
$412,2
$468,8
$412,3$426,0
$452,0
$350,0
$375,0
$400,0
$425,0
$450,0
$475,0
$500,0
2017 2018 2019 2020F 2021F
Figure 10. Total Sales of Global Semiconductor Market (Billions USD)
Source: The World Semiconductor Trade Statistics
$88,4
$166,0
$22,1
$114,7
$79,5
$171,0
$26,5
$95,6
$0,0
$30,0
$60,0
$90,0
$120,0
$150,0
$180,0
Desktop PC +Desktop
Workstation
Notebook +Mobile
Workstation
DetachableTablet
Slate Tablet
Figure 11. Personal Computing Device Shipment by Category (In Million USD)
2019
2023
Source: International Data Croporation
0
20
40
60
80
100
Oct-15 Oct-16 Oct-17 Oct-18 Oct-19 Oct-20
Figure 6. AMD
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
Oct-15 Oct-16 Oct-17 Oct-18 Oct-19 Oct-20
Figure 7. NVDA
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
Oct-15 Oct-16 Oct-17 Oct-18 Oct-19 Oct-20
Figure 8. IBM
0
20
40
60
80
100
Oct-15 Oct-16 Oct-17 Oct-18 Oct-19 Oct-20
Figure 9. TSM
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
• We assume and expect the pandemic to be over by 1Q22, and will help support global sales. We think that the growth will be mainly driven by, including but not limited to, IOT in health and data center segments.
Personal Computing Device Shipments
• Personal Computing Devices’ demand is expected to decline by 1.2% CAGR over the next 4 years due to decline of Slate Tablet and Desktop PC demand, partially offset by increased demand for Notebooks and Detachable Tablets.
• Rising demand for notebooks sector due to its portability and increasing performance. • The entrance of chrome-based detachable tablets that mainly focuses on educational purposes
potentially see an increase in demand for the same reason as the above.
IoT Spending
• $742 billion forecast for spending on IoT in 2020 is a downward revision compared to the previous forecast of 14.9% in 2019 as COVID-19 dampens economic activities.
• Wearable technology has garnered popularity during the pandemic as consumers start to become more health conscious, and we expect this trend to continue in the future. This could potentially bring more revenue for semiconductor companies as infrastructure of wearable technologies are heavily supported by semiconductor components.
• Increase in wearables will provide more data for wearable technology companies, which in turn will increase demand for data center products as firms collect data on consumer behavior.
Semiconductor Sales Segments
• The share of global semiconductor sales by categories mostly remain constant from 2018. • Communication still holds the largest share of the sales. We deem smartphones as a necessity
currently and this sector will most likely keep growing in the future from the development of 5G. • Computer section still holds a lot of potential as the demand for cloud computing is on the rise, as
we believe that firms will need to incorporate cloud computing inside their businesses.
Investment Catalysts and Risks Catalysts
$646,0 $681,2$742,0
$825,8$919,2
$1.023,0
$1.138,6
$0,0
$250,0
$500,0
$750,0
$1.000,0
$1.250,0
2018 2019 2020F 2021F 2022F 2023F 2024F
Figure 12. Spending on IoT (In Billions USD)
Source: International Data Corporation
33,0%
28,5%
13,3%
12,2%
11,9%1,3%
Figure 13. Global Semiconductor Sales by Categories (2019)
Communication
Computer
Consumer
Automotive
Industrial
Government
Source: Semiconductor Industry Association
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Intel’s Tiger Lake (10nm) demonstrates enhancement in laptop CPUs and comparable performance to AMD’s 7nm processors. The major discriminant between the new Intel processors and its competitors’ is their ability to tackle a prevalent problem in laptops, which is the inconsistency in performance when laptops are plugged in to an AC2 adapter compared to when they are unplugged or run on the device’s battery (DC). In Figure 143 we can see that the performance spread between AC and DC’s performance is smaller (2% on single core and 0.6% on multi core) in Tiger Lake compared to AMD’s Ryzen 4800 U (68% difference on single core and 33.7% on multi core), and to Tiger Lake’s predecessor, Intel Ice Lake (9.26% difference on single core and 44.35% on multi core performance).
Intel’s new integrated GPU, IrisXe, looks promising as it outperformed NVIDIA’s discrete GPU MX350 and AMD’s Ryzen 4800U, while its medium-end i5 outperformed AMD’s Ryzen 7 4800U. This surprised us because integrated GPUs would face more constraints on performance compared to discrete GPUs like NVIDIA’s MX 3504. Despite releasing a 10nm processor, Intel achieved comparable or even better performance than competitors who have implemented 7nm chips inside their processors. This portrays a bold statement from Intel, signaling that they cannot be counted out yet from the race.
2 AC = Alternating Current, DC = Direct Current 3 Geekbench is a platforms to test both angles of CPU performance, from the perspectives of single core and multi core performance. Geekbench Open CL tests GPU performance. 4 Integrated GPUs have to share their RAM with their CPUs while discrete GPUs have their own RAM.
1549
675
1145
6034
4834
2726
1588
1140
1251
6075
6461
3935
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000
Intel Core i7-1185G7
AMD Ryzen 7 4800U
Intel Core i7-1065G7
Figure 14. Performance Using AC Current vs DC Current Tested Using Geekbench 5.2*
Multi Core (AC) Single Core (AC) Multi Core (DC) Single Core (DC)
*The higher the better
(Ice Lake)
(Tiger Lake)
Source: Tom's Hardware
59845
51741
46620
59828
0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000
Intel Core i7-1165G7
Intel Core i5-1135G7
AMD Ryzen 7 4800U
Nvidia MX-350
Figure 15. GPU Performance Tested Using Geekbench 4 Open CL*
Source: wccftech
*The higher the better
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Massive growth potential for IOTG segment driven by increased EV sales trend in 3 major regions. According to Deloitte, the Advanced Driver-Assistance Systems (ADAS) is expected to be an 11 billion USD business in 2022. By the same year, they also expect that the cost of semiconductor content to reach USD600 per car, up from around USD400 in 2019. With Mobileye, Intel is tapping into a relatively uncharted market which Deloitte believes to have a 5-year CAGR growth of 23.6%. Furthermore, Intel is collaborating with Geely in their Zero Concept model (produced by Lynk & Co., a joint venture between Geely and Volvo), which features Mobileye’s SuperVision™ ADAS technology. Intel also announced that they have secured a long-term and high-volume agreement with Geely Auto for ADAS, which means that more Geely vehicles will be using Mobileye’s technology. China is one of the fastest growing electric vehicle (EV) market, with McKinsey predicting the units sold to reach a range of 2.4 million to 3.5 million units by 2022. We believe that the demand for EV5 will pick up once the pandemic recedes and subside (base case scenario: 1Q22).
5 BEV = Battery Electric Vehicle, PHEV = Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicle
220
339
574
1062
2015 2016 2017 2018
Figure 18. Light EV Sales (Thousand Units)
China
BEV PHEVSource: McKinsey
115 158200
361
2015 2016 2017 2018
Figure 20. Light EV Sales (Thousand Units)
United States
BEV PHEVSource: McKinsey
154 169232
320
2015 2016 2017 2018
Figure 19. Light EV Sales (Thousand Units)
European Union
BEV PHEVSource: McKinsey
151
254
146
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
1Q18 2Q18 3Q18 4Q18 1Q19 2Q19 3Q19 4Q19 1Q20 2Q20
Figure 16. Mobileye Revenue (Millions USD)
Source: Company Reports
+68.2% growth
150
300
475
60018%
27%
40%
45%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
2000 2010 2020 2030
Figure 17. Price of Semiconductor Components in a Car and Proportion of Electronics Cost to Total Car Cost (USD)
Semiconductor Price (per car)Proportion of Total Car Cost
Source: Deloitte, IHS
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Intel’s actions show commitment and willingness to adapt. After the drop in their share price, Intel carried out a $10 million share buyback which rewarded their shareholders. Apart from that, Intel also got into an agreement with TSMC, which gives TSMC the right to begin mass production of Intel’s CPUs and GPUs next year, reducing Intel’s 7nm delay by around 6 months. By outsourcing to TSMC in their production, Intel can focus on their future 5nm chips by intensifying their research and development activities in the near future. Intel has also appointed Safroadu Yeboah-Amankwah as their chief strategy officer, who previously served McKinsey as a senior partner and global head of the transformation practice of TMT. We believe that this management change points Intel to the right direction.
Risks
Intel faces intense competition on the CCG and DCG segment and market share is continuously being eaten by AMD and NVIDIA. Intel lost significant CPU market share of around 9% in the period 2Q19 to 3Q19 when they first delayed their 7nm chips to 2021. AMD has pressured Intel’s market position by consistently offering products that were better in terms of price-to-performance; AMD’s Ryzen series are cheaper than Intel’s processors but still provided comparable performance. Intel’s delay announced in 2Q20 allows AMD to potentially be able to supply customers with 3nm chips by 2022. Should AMD maintain its technological advantage over Intel, we may see Intel’s market share dropping to 50-55%, a further 10-15% decrease. Moreover, the recent acquisition of Arm by NVIDIA provides the Intel competitor considerable synergies and potential enhancement for their data center products. However, the impact of this acquisition may be limited in the next few years as it is hindered by regulatory and bureaucratic processes, in our view. AMD has also been rumoured to be in talks to buy Xilinx in a $30 billion deal. We view that, should the deal go through, AMD may have to finance it using debt and may reduce future margins. Therefore, we need to continue to keep an eye out on these acquisition deals. Other risk factors that could negatively impact the share price include: (1) material, negative events affecting HP, Dell, or Lenovo (2) COVID-19’s negative effects on the global economy, lockdown measures, and consumption are longer than expected (3) mis-execution of their 11th gen roadmap (4) weaker-than-expected demand in CCG, IOTG, and DCG segments (5) worsening of the trade tension
0,00%
10,00%
20,00%
30,00%
40,00%
50,00%
60,00%
70,00%
80,00%
90,00%
Q12015
Q22015
Q32015
Q42015
Q12016
Q22016
Q32016
Q42016
Q12017
Q22017
Q32017
Q42017
Q12018
Q22018
Q32018
Q42018
Q12019
Q22019
Q32019
Q42019
Q12020
Q22020
Figure 21. x86 CPU Market Share of AMD and Intel Over The Last 5 Years
Intel AMDSource: Statista
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
situation between the US and China that may substantially affect Intel (6) significant loss of market share in CCG and DCG through increased competition from AMD and NVIDIA.
Valuation Summary Our target price of $63.44 or a 17.7% upside from the current share price of $53.88 (12/10/20) is derived from a weighted average of 3 valuation models, namely a Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) model, a Comparables, and Precedent Transaction Analysis. We get a fair value share price of $58.28 from our DCF model, $87.08 from Comparables, and $103.97 from our Precedent Transaction Analysis. DCF valuation was given the highest weighting with 85%, while Comparables, and Precedent Transaction Analysis were given 10%, and 5% respectively. Our valuation is supported by our belief of growth potential in their data-centric businesses, strong fundamentals amidst global uncertainty, and strategic transformation of the company.
Discounted Cash Flow (85%) Our fair value share price of $58.28 reflects our base-case scenario of low single-digit revenue growth in the next 2 years, a $4.43 EPS in FY20, and a $4.91 EPS in FY21. We expect a flat 2% revenue growth in 2021 (vs estimates of -2%) and modest mid to high-single-digit growth in 2022 forward, mainly driven by top-line growth in IOTG, CCG, and DCG segments, reflecting economic recovery post COVID-19 (base case: 1Q22), narrowing gaps in technology and manufacturing advantage, and increased digitalization of global industries. Assumptions are made while also considering severe pressure from competitors, including NVIDIA’s enhanced data center chips through its acquisition with Arm, AMD’s future Ryzen releases and their potential acquisition of Xilinx. We view that NVIDIA’s acquisition with ARM may have an effect 2022/2023 onwards, taking into account the lengthy bureaucratic process and regulatory compliances.
20 70 120 170 220 270
52 Week Trading Range
Current Analyst Forecasts
Comparables Valuation
Precedents Valuation
DCF Valuation
Share Price ($)
Figure 22. Football Field Valuation Summary
Sources: Internal Valuation Model and Yahoo Finance
Current share price (12/10/20): $53.88
$66.14$51.97
$87.03 $227.9
$87.08 $170.9
$42
$43.63
$82
$69.29
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Table 2. Valuation Summary US10Y Treasury (12/10/20) 0,78%
Cost of Equity 8,26% Tax Rate 14,5% After Tax Cost of Debt 2,71% WACC 7,15% Terminal Growth Rate 1,90% Equity Value (Millions USD) 248275
Shares Outstanding (Millions USD) 4260
Current Share Price 58,28
Table 3.
Intel FCFF Projections
In millions of USD 2019 2020E 2021E 2022E 2023E 2024E
Revenue: 71965 74124 75606 79387 86532 95185 (-) Cost of Revenues, MG&A, R&D and Others -49930 -52665 -52671 -54297 -58917 -64762
Operating Income (EBIT): 22035 21459 22935 25090 27614 30422
Operating Margin: 30,6% 28,9% 30,3% 31,6% 31,9% 32,0%
(-) Income Taxes (EBIT*Tax Rate) -2754 -3111 -3326 -3638 -4004 -4411
(+) Depreciation and Amortization 10826 10121 10496 10941 11782 12800
Net Change in Working Capital 3058 -2677 1385 -640 870 161
(-) Capital Expenditures -16213 -15195 -16633 -18259 -20768 -22844
Free Cash Flows to the Firm (FCFF) 16952 10596 14857 13493 15494 16128
Discount Period: 0,5 1,5 2,5 3,5 4,5
Discount Rate (WACC): 7,15% 7,15% 7,15% 7,15% 7,15%
Cumulative Discount Factor: 0,97 0,90 0,84 0,79 0,73
PV of FCFF 10237 13396 11355 12169 11822
Table 4. Sensitivity Analysis of WACC and Terminal Growth Rate changes on share price
Terminal Growth Rate
58,28 1,60% 1,7% 1,80% 1,90% 2,00% 2,10% 2,20%
WA
CC
6,85% 58,76 59,88 61,03 62,23 63,48 64,78 66,14
6,95% 57,52 58,59 59,70 60,85 62,04 63,29 64,59
7,05% 56,33 57,35 58,42 59,52 60,67 61,86 63,10 7,15% 55,22 56,20 57,22 58,28 59,38 60,53 61,72
7,25% 54,07 55,02 56,00 57,01 58,07 59,16 60,30
7,35% 53,00 53,91 54,86 55,83 56,84 57,90 58,99
7,45% 51,97 52,85 53,75 54,69 55,67 56,68 57,72
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Comparables (10%) Our price of $87.08 assumes a normalized group forward P/E multiple of 17.7x attached to forecasted FY21 EPS of $4.92 for INTC.
Precedent Transactions Analysis (5%)
We obtain a share price of $103.97 for Intel from our Precedent Transactions Analysis model. We assign a weightage of 5% as we view this methodology to be less relevant for valuing Intel. Nevertheless, the selected set is shown below:
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Summary of Financials Intel Corporation In Millions USD except per share data and percentages Income Statement FY18A FY19A FY20E FY21E FY22E FY23E
Revenue 70848 71965 74124 75606 79387 86532
Cost of Sales -27111 -29825 -30761 -30243 -30770 -33315
Gross Profit 43737 42140 43363 45364 48616 53217
R&D -13543 -13362 -15195 -15499 -16274 -17739
MG&A -6750 -6150 -6338 -6464 -6788 -7398
Adj. EBIT 23444 22628 21830 23400 25555 28079
Net Interest -30 -6 -129 -122 -103 -67
Tax -2264 -3010 -3199 -3415 -3730 -4101
Adj. Net Income 21150 19612 18501 19864 21722 23911
Reported EPS 4,48 4,71 4,43 4,92 5,37 5,91
Adj. EPS 4,50 4,39 4,34 4,85 5,31 5,84
Payout Ratio 26% 26% 29% 29% 29% 29%
Balance Sheet & Cash Flow Statement FY18A FY19A FY20E FY21E FY22E FY23E
Cash and Cash Equivalents 11650 13123 25701 34265 41194 50912
Accounts Receivable 6722 7659 7783 7534 8336 9086
Inventories 7253 8744 7709 7863 8256 8999
Other Current Assets 3162 1713 1705 1739 1826 1990
Current Assets 28787 31239 42898 51400 59612 70988
PP&E 48976 55386 62586 70722 79916 90305
Long-Term Investments 9430 7243 6785 6785 6785 6163
Other Non-Current Assets 40770 42656 44573 45779 45135 44334
Total Assets 127963 136524 156843 174686 191448 211790
Short-Term Debt 1261 3693 2254 2254 2254 2254
Accounts Payables 3824 4128 4153 4083 4154 4497
Other Current Liabilities 11541 14489 12766 15172 15385 16657
Current Liabilities 16626 22310 19173 21509 21793 23409
Long-Term Debt 25098 25308 36093 36093 36093 36093
Other Non-Current Liabilities 11676 11402 10946 11006 11869 13426
Total Liabilities 53400 59020 66211 68608 69755 72928
Shareholders' Equity 74563 77504 90631 106078 121693 138862
Total Liabilities and Equity 127963 136524 156843 174686 191448 211790
Net Debt
Cash Flow from Operating Activities 29432 33145 28930 31958 33621 37521
Incl. D&A 9085 10826 10121 10496 10941 11782
Incl. Change in Working Capital -1910 1148 -1529 -144 -784 86
Published by CityU Research & Investment Club
Cash Flow from Investing Activities -11239 -14405 -16990 -15568 -17194 -19703
Incl. Capital Expenditures -15181 -16213 -15195 -16633 -18259 -20768
Cash Flow from Financing Activities -18607 -17565 -7511 -7827 -9498 -8101
Incl. Dividend Payments -5541 -5576 -5700 -5839 -6378 -7013
Net Change in Cash -414 1175 4428 8563 6930 9718
Adj. FCFF 13144 15373 11898 13583 13620 15011
Ratio Analysis FY18A FY19A FY20E FY21E FY22E FY23E
Gross Margin (%) 61,7% 58,6% 58,5% 60,0% 61,2% 61,5%
Adj. EBIT Margin (%) 33,1% 31,4% 29,5% 31,0% 32,2% 32,5%
Adj. EBITDA Margin (%) 45,9% 46,5% 43,1% 44,8% 46,0% 46,1%
Adj. Net Income Margin (%) 29,9% 27,3% 25,0% 26,3% 27,4% 27,6%
Dividend Yield (%) 2,32% 2,28% 2,47% 2,76% 3,02% 3,32%
ROCE(%) 21,2% 19,1% 14,6% 14,0% 13,8% 13,7%
ROE (%) 28,4% 25,3% 20,4% 18,7% 17,8% 17,2%
ROA (%) 16,5% 14,4% 11,8% 11,4% 11,3% 11,3%
Asset Turnover Ratio (%) 55,4% 52,7% 47,3% 43,3% 41,5% 40,9%
Adj. EBIT / Interest (x) 50,1 46,3 43,7 46,8 51,1 56,2
Debt / EBITDA (x) 1,64 1,76 2,07 2,02 1,91 1,83
Debt / Equity (x) 0,72 0,76 0,73 0,65 0,57 0,53
Net Debt / Equity (x) 0,56 0,59 0,45 0,32 0,23 0,16
Net Debt / EBITDA (x) 1,28 1,37 1,27 1,01 0,78 0,55
Current Ratio 1,73 1,40 2,24 2,39 2,74 3,03
Quick Ratio 1,30 1,01 1,84 2,02 2,36 2,65
Cash Ratio 0,70 0,59 1,34 1,59 1,89 2,17
P/E (x) 10,44 12,66 11,52 10,37 9,49 8,63
P/BV (x) 1,63 2,05 2,31 1,97 1,72 1,51
EV/EBITDA (x) 5,15 7,01 6,94 6,54 6,07 5,56
Source: Company Reports and CURIC estimates
Notes:
Cash and Cash equivalents includes cash, short-term investments, and liquid trading assets.
Long-Term Investment includes equity investments and other long-term investments
Other Non-Current Assets include goodwill, intangible assets, and other long-term assets
Other Non-Current Liabilities include contract liabilities, income taxes payable, deferred income taxes, and other long-term liabilities
Incl. = including or of which, e.g. 7.52 billion of depreciation is included in FY18 Cash Flow from Operating Activities of 29.4 billion.