inquiry into homelessness in victoria · support to help them navigate access to housing options...
TRANSCRIPT
Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Ms Lauren Henley
Organisation Name:Council of the Ageing, Victoria Your position or role: Senior Policy Officer
SURVEY QUESTIONSDrag the statements below to reorder them. In order of priority, please rank the themes you believe are most important for this inquiry into homelessness to consider:: Housing affordability,Public housing,Services,Employment,Family violence,Indigenous people,Mental health,Rough sleeping
What best describes your interest in our Inquiry? (select all that apply) : A peak body
Are there any additional themes we should consider?
YOUR SUBMISSIONSubmission:
Do you have any additional comments or suggestions?:
FILE ATTACHMENTSFile1: 5e322b6f11db5-2020 01 30 COTA Vic Homelessness Submission FNL.pdfFile2: 5e322b6f15864-2020 01 30 COTA Vic Homelessness Submission FNL.docxFile3:
Signature:Lauren Henley
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
1 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION:
VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS
Prepared by
COTA Victoria
January 2019
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
2 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 2
To:
Parliament of Victoria
Legislative Assembly, Legal and Social Issues Committee
Parliament House, Spring Street
EAST MELBOURNE VIC 3002
Via email to: [email protected]
COTA Victoria
Prepared by:
Lauren Henley
Policy Officer
Council on the Ageing Victoria
Authorised by
Tina Hogarth-Clarke
Chief Executive Officer
Council on the Ageing Victoria
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
3 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. About COTA Victoria ............................................................................................................................ 4
2. Introductory comments ....................................................................................................................... 4
3. Summary of recommendations ........................................................................................................... 5
4. Homelessness amongst older people: A demographic snapshot ....................................................... 9
4.1. General statistics .......................................................................................................................... 9
4.2. Older women ................................................................................................................................ 9
4.3. Our nation’s first people .............................................................................................................. 9
4.4. Older people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds ...................................... 10
5. Effectiveness of responses to older people experiencing or at risk of homelessness ..................... 11
5.1. Generic homelessness services .................................................................................................. 11
5.2. Responses to homelessness within the aged care system ....................................................... 11
5.3. Availability of gender-appropriate services .............................................................................. 13
5.4. Addressing the needs of people experiencing or at risk of homelessness through bushfire
response and relief ................................................................................................................................. 13
6. Hidden drivers of financial stress amongst older Victorians ............................................................ 14
6.1. Employment discrimination ....................................................................................................... 14
6.2. The gender gap in retirement income ....................................................................................... 16
6.3. Relationship breakdown or loss of a partner ............................................................................ 18
6.4. Elder abuse ................................................................................................................................. 18
6.5. Poor mental health..................................................................................................................... 19
7. How the current housing landscape is driving housing insecurity across the ageing population ... 19
7.1. The need for better systems navigation .................................................................................... 19
7.2. Rental affordability .................................................................................................................... 21
7.3. Tennant rights ............................................................................................................................ 21
7.4. Availability of public housing ..................................................................................................... 23
7.5. Mortgage Stress.......................................................................................................................... 23
8. The role of accessibility in meeting the housing needs of Victoria’s ageing population ................. 24
8.1. Ensuring new properties are universally accessible ................................................................. 24
8.2. Modifying existing rental properties ......................................................................................... 25
8.3. Improving the effectiveness of existing home modifications schemes ................................... 25
8.4. Increasing the accessibility of common areas in apartment buildings .................................... 26
9. Concluding statement ........................................................................................................................ 26
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
4 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 4
1. ABOUT COTA VICTORIA
Council on the Ageing (COTA) Victoria is the leading not-for-profit organisation representing the
interests and rights of people aged over 50 in Victoria. For 70 years in Victoria, we have led
government, corporate and community thinking about the positive aspects of ageing. Today
our focus is on promoting opportunities for and protecting the rights of people 50+.
We see an ageing population as a time of opportunities for personal growth, contribution and
self- expression. We believe there are obvious National, State, community, family and individual
benefits from this approach. We are also focused on the protection of the rights of people aged
50+.
COTA Victoria is a not-for-profit member based organisation run by, for and with Victorians
aged 50+. We fund our activities and services through the support of government, members,
philanthropic trusts, businesses and the public.
We have an experienced Board, highly qualified, permanent staff located in a central
Melbourne office location and a broad State membership. We also have over 130 community
volunteers throughout Victoria with skills in training, group facilitation, policy development and
advocacy, including volunteers bi-lingual in a number of languages. We work with local
government, senior citizen centres, community houses and a broad range of community and
service organisations.
COTA Victoria is supported by financial assistance from the Commonwealth and Victorian
Governments.
2. INTRODUCTORY COMMENTS
We thank the Legal and Social Issues Committee for providing COTA Victoria with an
opportunity to submit evidence to inform the Parliamentary Inquiry into Homelessness in
Victoria. In order to fulfil the requirements of this inquiry, we note that the Committee has
been directed to:
1. Provide an independent analysis of the changing scale and nature of homelessness across Victoria.
2. Investigate the many social, economic and policy factors that impact on homelessness; and
3. Identify policies and practices from all levels of government that have a bearing on delivering services to the homeless.1
The issues raised throughout this submission are of relevance to all three of the
aforementioned terms of reference for this inquiry.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
5 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 5
As people age, they often experience changes in their physical and economic circumstances
which have a profound impact on their housing requirements2 As such, this submission will
highlight the rising rate of homelessness amongst Victoria’s ageing population and shine a light
on some of the social and economic factors underpinning this shift.
The effective prevention, early intervention and response to housing stress across Victoria’s
ageing population is a matter of increasing public concern. The number of people aged over 65
is projected to have increased to 1.1 million by 2021, growing at more than twice the rate of
the general Victorian population.3 By 2031, Victorians aged over 60 living in Greater Melbourne
will comprise 22% of the population. In rural and regional areas, almost 31% of Victorians will
be aged over 60. To this end, our submission has a strong focus on the need for government
policy that will enhance access to secure, accessible and affordable housing to prevent older
Victorians from falling into a cycle of homelessness in the future.
Our submission is based on the broad definition of homelessness as adopted by the Australian
Bureau of Statistics. Under the ABS definition, a person is considered to be homeless if they do
not have suitable accommodation alternatives and their current living arrangement:
Is in a dwelling that is inadequate.
Has no tenure, or if their initial tenure is short and not extendable; or
Does not allow them to have control of, and access to space for social relations.4
3. SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS
Recommendation 1:
The Victorian Government submit evidence to the Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality
and Safety and liaise directly with the Commonwealth Department of Health to reinforce the
need for:
The inclusion of questions addressing housing and the risk of, or experience of
homelessness in all aged care assessment processes.
Greater investment in the Assistance with Care and Housing Sub-Programme of the
Commonwealth Home Support Programme.
Improvement of interfacing arrangements between aged care, homelessness, health, social
service and disability systems to provide a “no wrong door” approach for people
experiencing or at risk of homelessness.
The provision of funding to enable specialist aged care providers to build residential aged
care facilities for older people who have experienced homelessness; in recognition of the
unique needs this cohort may present with.
The revision and indexation of the Homeless Supplement for residential aged care providers
to meet the costs incurred by facilities in providing specialised services for older people who
have experienced homelessness.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
6 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 6
Recommendation 2:
The Victorian Government consult with relevant stakeholders to determine how the needs of
older Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People and People from culturally and linguistically
diverse backgrounds can be most effectively met into the future. This might involve expanding
funding to community controlled organisations that can deliver services that are culturally
appropriate and provide clients with an adequate sense of cultural safety.
Recommendation 3:
The Victorian Government provide funding to increase the supply of gender appropriate
emergency housing.
Recommendation 4:
The Victorian Government, as part of its Inquiry into the Bushfire Crisis, carefully examine:
The effectiveness of response efforts aimed at providing appropriate shelter to Victorians
without safe and secure accommodation.
The effectiveness of recovery efforts and best practice approaches to prevent people
affected by bushfires from falling into a cycle of homelessness.
Recommendation 5:
The Victorian Government invest in initiatives that will enhance opportunities for older people
to earn income in later life. Such initiatives should:
Challenge ageist attitudes by educating employers about the benefits of hiring and retaining
older workers.
Re-skill older workers and provide them with tailored support to enable them to change
careers or re-enter the workforce.
Recommendation 6:
The Victorian Government revise the eligibility requirements for free TAFE courses to ensure
that mature aged job seekers and workers who are experiencing employment vulnerability are
provided with an opportunity to retrain and access new career pathways.
Recommendation 7:
The Victorian Government include older women of working age when framing targets and
outcomes under The Victorian Government’s Gender Equality Strategy: ‘Safe and Strong’.
Recommendation 8:
The Victorian Government submit evidence to inform the Review of Retirement Incomes to
demonstrate the need for the Commonwealth to structure a range of income streams that are
tailored to the needs of older women.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
7 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 7
Recommendation 9:
The Victorian Government invest in capacity-building initiatives that aim to increase financial
literacy amongst older women who are on lower incomes, and who may have fewer financial
resources available in retirement.
Recommendation 10:
The Victorian Government:
Increase investment in awareness-raising initiatives that aim to inform older Victorians
about free financial counselling services that are already available.
Expand funding of Financial Counsellors to enhance their capacity to provide outreach
support and financial counselling to people who are not digitally connected.
Recommendation 11:
The Victorian Government, in implementing the recommendations of the Royal Commission
into Victoria’s Mental Health System, give careful consideration to the relationship between
mental illness and homelessness.
Recommendation 12:
The Victorian Government invest in initiatives that provide older Victorians with tailored
support to help them navigate access to housing options and prevent them from falling into a
cycle of homelessness.
Recommendation 13:
The Victorian Government liaise with the Commonwealth to reinforce the need for tailored
services that can assist people to navigate the aged care system either in person, or over the
phone.
Recommendation 14:
The Victorian Government provide evidence to inform the Australian Government’s review of
retirement income to demonstrate the relationship between financial insecurity and
homelessness across Victoria’s ageing population, suggesting that there be an increase in
Commonwealth Rent Assistance for Older Renters.
Recommendation 15:
The Victorian Government invest in awareness-raising initiatives to:
Educate tenants about their rights and responsibilities under the new Residential Tenancies
Regulations.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
8 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 8
Educate housing providers about the capital investment benefits of modifications that
enhance accessibility, and the rights of older tenants to make the required adjustments to
age in place.
Recommendation 16:
The Victorian Government establish targets to increase the availability of affordable housing for
older people experiencing housing stress as part of the ‘Homes for Victorians’ package of
initiatives.
Recommendation 17:
The Victorian Government, in consultation with relevant stakeholders, develop a long-term
strategy for planned future investment in social and affordable rental housing to meet the
demands of Victoria’s ageing population.
Recommendation 18:
The Victorian Government work with the Commonwealth to ensure the inclusion of universal
design principles in all new properties to ensure their cost-effective adaption to the needs of
Victoria’s ageing population.
Recommendation 19:
The following improvements be made to the proposed Residential Tenancies Regulations:
Where modifications are part of transitioning out of hospital care or a requirement to
qualify for hospital-in-the-home reprograms, consent to make modifications should be
automatically granted.
Renters that install home modifications to support accessibility, safety, health and ageing in
place, should not be required to remove and pay for the costs of restoring properties to
their previous condition.
Recommendation 20:
The Victorian Government work with the Commonwealth to develop a nationally consistent
approach to funding structural and personal modifications to existing properties to enable
residents to age in place. Home modifications schemes must be appropriately funded to enable
assessments to be undertaken and modifications to be completed in the shortest time frame
possible.
Recommendation 21:
The Victorian Government invest in awareness-raising initiatives to educate owners
corporations about the benefits of universal design features and the precedent that has been
set by VCAT’s decision in the case of ‘Owners Corporation v Black’.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
9 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 9
4. HOMELESSNESS AMONGST OLDER PEOPLE: A DEMOGRAPHIC SNAPSHOT
4.1 GENERAL STATISTICS
One in seven people experiencing homelessness are over the age of 55.5 This figure has steadily
increased over the past few years. In the absence of appropriate policy intervention, it is likely
to continue to increase as Victoria’s population ages.
On census night in 2016:
Around 3311 people over the age of 55 in Victoria were homeless.
2421 Victorians over the age of 55 were ‘marginally housed’. According to the Australian
Bureau of Statistics, the term ‘marginal housing’ applies to substandard housing’, caravans,
housing with no security of tenure and overcrowded housing environments.6
The following sub-sections of this submission provide an overview of the current situation for
older women, older Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and older people from
culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds respectively. We urge the Committee to
consider the overrepresentation of these population groups within Australia’s homeless
population and to implement policy solutions that consider their unique needs.
4.2 OLDER WOMEN
Single Older women are the fastest growing group of people experiencing homelessness in
Australia.7 Between 2011 and 2016, there was:
A 70.8 per cent increase in the number of women between 65 and 74 who reported being
homeless.
A 61 per cent increase in women aged 75 years and over who reported being homeless.
A 30% increase in the number of women aged between 65 and 74 years who had accessed
homeless services.
A 75% increase in older women sleeping in their cars.8
While these figures are alarming in themselves, there is also likely to be a high level of statistic
invisibility amongst this cohort. This is because many older women experiencing housing stress
are reported to be staying with friends or family or remaining in at risk situations to avoid
sleeping rough.9
4.3 OUR NATION’S FIRST PEOPLE
The rate of homelessness is higher amongst Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. One in
28 Indigenous people were homeless on Census night in 2016, representing around 20% of
Australia’s homeless population.10 A recent study undertaken by the Australian Housing and
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
10 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 10
Urban research Institute found that indigenous people over the age of 65 were 12.3 times more
likely to access homelessness services than their non-indigenous counterparts.11
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities are also disproportionately affected by
overcrowding. 32% of people who live in severely overcrowded environments are Aboriginal or
Torres Strait Islander people. The Australian Bureau of Statistics defines severe overcrowding as
a home in which at least four extra bedrooms would be needed to adequately accommodate
the residents.12
Kinship obligations to care for extended family, entrenched disadvantage and chronic housing
shortages in remote parts of Australia continue to contribute to a cycle of housing insecurity,
overcrowding and homelessness across the indigenous population. This suggests a need for
culturally appropriate policy responses, co-designed by the communities they aim to assist.
4.4 OLDER PEOPLE FROM CULTURALLY AND LINGUISTICALLY DIVERSE
BACKGROUNDS
People from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds are disproportionately impacted
by homelessness. While three in ten Australians aged 65 and over were born overseas13 (28.2%
of Australians), this population group comprises 46% of Australia’s homeless population.14
Research suggests that older people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds in
particular are at higher risk of becoming homeless. Factors contributing to this situation
include:
Language barriers.
Difficulty accessing Australia’s complex services and systems.
The fact that on average, older people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds
are of poorer socioeconomic status than older Anglo-Australians.
The fact that many older migrants have come to Australia to live with family and have not
been able to purchase their own home. These people have nowhere to go in the event of a
family breakdown.15
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
11 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 11
5. EFFECTIVENESS OF RESPONSES TO OLDER PEOPLE EXPERIENCING OR AT
RISK OF HOMELESSNESS
5.1 GENERIC HOMELESSNESS SERVICES
A recent survey of professionals working across the homelessness sector revealed low levels of
success in accommodating the needs of older people experiencing or at risk of homelessness.
Factors contributing to this shortfall include:
Resource limitations.
A lack of long-term housing options for people experiencing homelessness.
The high cost of rent in the private market; particularly in areas that are well connected to
public transport and other vital services and facilities.
Growth in the overall level of demand for secure, affordable housing.16
These issues will be explored elsewhere in this submission.
5.2 RESPONSES TO HOMELESSNESS WITHIN THE AGED CARE SYSTEM
Aged care services are in a strong position to assist older people who are at risk of
homelessness. The primary service providing support to older people at risk of homelessness
under the aged care system is the ‘Assistance with Care and Housing (ACH) program’, which is a
subprogram of the Commonwealth Home Support Programme (CHSP). Key issues with the
program can be summarized as follows:
The program is still poorly resourced and has a relatively low profile.
• ACH providers do not operate in all parts of Australia.
ACH providers and aged care assessment services are generally not well connected to other
existing housing services.17
To determine eligibility for the ACH, an individual must first be assessed by an assessor from
a Regional Assessment Service (RAS). There are extensive waiting lists for these
assessments, which means support is often unable to be provided in a timely manner.18
While the ACH program has a strong focus on supporting people in the community, there are
separate measures in place to support people who have experienced homelessness in
residential care. The ‘homeless supplement’ is provided to aged care homes that specialize in
caring for people with a history of homelessness, in recognition of the fact that the costs
associated with providing care to this cohort may be significantly higher.19 Unfortunately, this
approach does not appear to be driving effective outcomes for consumers. The current funding
landscape does not make it financially viable to support people at this level due to increased
costs and the need to provide this client group with consumables.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
12 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 12
As identified in sections 4.3 and 4.4 of this submission respectively, older Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander people and older people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds
are disproportionately impacted by homelessness. In implementing improvements to the
current service system, Governments must therefore consult with relevant stakeholders to
determine how the diverse needs of these cohorts can be most effectively met into the future.
This might involve expanding funding to community-controlled organisations that can deliver
services that are culturally appropriate and provide clients with an adequate sense of cultural
safety.
Earlier this year, the Commonwealth Department of Health commenced work on the
development of a homelessness action plan under the Aged Care Diversity Framework. This
action plan is intended to assist the aged care sector to respond to the support needs of older
people experiencing or at risk of homelessness. At the time of writing this submission, the final
action plan had still not been released. It is hoped that once available, the action plan will
improve responses to homelessness across the aged care system.20
Recommendation 1:
The Victorian Government provide evidence to the Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality
and Safety and directly liaise with the Commonwealth Department of Health to reinforce the
need for:
The inclusion of questions addressing housing and the risk of, or experience of
homelessness in all aged care assessment processes.
Greater investment in the Assistance with Care and Housing Sub-Programme of the
Commonwealth Home Support Programme.
Improvement of interfacing arrangements between aged care, homelessness, health, social
service and disability systems to provide a “no wrong door” approach for people
experiencing or at risk of homelessness.
The provision of funding to enable specialist aged care providers to build residential aged
care facilities for older people who have experienced homelessness; in recognition of the
unique needs this cohort may present with.
The revision and indexation of the Homeless Supplement for residential aged care providers
to meet the costs incurred by facilities in providing specialised services for older people who
have experienced homelessness.
Recommendation 2:
The Victorian Government consult with relevant stakeholders to determine how the needs of
older Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People and People from culturally and linguistically
diverse backgrounds can be most effectively met into the future. This might involve expanding
funding to community-controlled organisations that can deliver services that are culturally
appropriate and provide clients with an adequate sense of cultural safety.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
13 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 13
5.3 AVAILABILITY OF GENDER-APPROPRIATE SERVICES
As outlined in section 4.2 of this submission, older women experience higher rates of
homelessness than other population groups. There is a need for research and evidence-based
policy that is responsive to the unique needs of older women experiencing homelessness.
There is currently an overwhelming lack of gender-appropriate emergency housing for older
women. The small number of female only rooming houses that do exist rarely have vacancies,
resulting in many women being placed in mixed gender rooming houses, which are not always a
safe option.
Recommendation 3:
The Victorian Government provide funding to increase the supply of gender appropriate emergency
housing.
5.4 ADDRESSING THE NEEDS OF PEOPLE EXPERIENCING OR AT RISK OF
HOMELESSNESS THROUGH BUSHFIRE RESPONSE AND RELIEF
As bushfires continue to rage throughout Victoria, the matter of disaster response and relief is
now more critical than ever before. Smoke from the Victorian bushfires has repeatedly resulted
in extremely hazardous air quality. During these times, residents have been advised to stay
inside with their windows and doors shut. For the homeless population, however, this may not
be an option. Those without safe and secure housing are therefore most at risk of experiencing
respiratory problems, dehydration and other health complications associated with prolonged
exposure to smoke.
COTA Victoria commends Victorian authorities for taking the needs of the homeless population
into account during the 2019/20 bushfire crisis. The threat caused by fires and resulting air
conditions led to relief measures being put in place for people who are homeless, including:
Free access to swimming pools.
Free cinema tickets.
People being directed to libraries, shopping centres or community hubs.21
These positive efforts now require assessment and evaluation as to their effectiveness as an
intervention. An evaluation process could result in improving those relief measures used and
identifying new measures.
While bushfires pose a significant health threat to people without safe and secure housing, fires
also increase the rate of risk and experience of homelessness. A member of COTA Australia who
has experienced homelessness first-hand told us:
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
14 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 14
“The main reason I was left without rental accommodation was because of the 2009
bushfires. Rental accommodation became scarce and prices went up as a result of the
demand created in the area by those who had lost their homes. Also, we moved in a
hurry before the following fire season because I no longer felt safe where we were living.
This may be happening for some people again now.”
Issues relating to the rental market are explored further in sections 7.3 and 7.4 of this
submission. It is imperative, however, that the Victorian Government carefully considers how to
best prevent those affected by the 2019/20 bushfire crisis from falling into a cycle of
homelessness in the future.
COTA Victoria welcomes the Victorian Government’s announcement of a two-year inquiry into
the bushfire crisis. We note that the second report from this inquiry, due to be handed down in
2021, will focus on response and recovery. COTA Victoria strongly recommends the above
issues be carefully examined through the Inquiry process.22
Recommendation 4:
The Victorian Government, as part of it’s Inquiry into the Bushfire Crisis, carefully examine:
The effectiveness of response efforts aimed at providing appropriate shelter to Victorians
without safe and secure accommodation.
The effectiveness of recovery efforts and best practice approaches to prevent people
affected by bushfires from falling into a cycle of homelessness.
6. HIDDEN DRIVERS OF FINANCIAL STRESS AMONGST OLDER VICTORIANS
COTA Victoria hopes this inquiry will enable the Victorian Government to implement proactive
measures to prevent older people from falling into a cycle of homelessness. Issues relating
specifically to the current housing market will be outlined in detail in section 7 of this
submission. These issues cannot, however, be viewed in isolation. There are a number of other
drivers which may impact upon an individual’s retirement income and housing security as they
age. We have outlined some of these factors in the following sub-sections of this submission to
provide the Committee with a holistic insight into the needs of Victoria’s ageing population.
6.1 EMPLOYMENT DISCRIMINATION
The number of people aged 55-64 on Newstart has increased by more than 55,000 people in
under five years.23 This is reflective of an increase in the number of people below retirement
age who are locked out of the workforce due to systemic ageism.24
While people are now expected to remain in the workforce for longer than ever before:
Two thirds of employers say they are reluctant to hire workers who are over the age of 50.25
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
15 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 15
People over the age of 50, on average, spend twice as long looking for work than their
younger counterparts.26
Through our work at COTA Victoria, we frequently hear about the distress, poor health and
poverty experienced by older people who are unfairly excluded from paid employment. Many
of our stakeholders feel as though there is a significant disconnect between public policy and
attainable and realistic employment outcomes.
While systemic ageism is one of the most dominant factors contributing to the rate of
unemployment amongst people over the age of 55, older people may also face other unique
barriers to obtaining and retaining employment in later life. For example:
Some people can experience a decline in their physical health as they age. This means that
older people who are employed in more physically demanding roles may need to be
supported to retrain and find alternative employment options.
Many older women have large gaps in their employment history as a result of taking time
out of the workforce to tend to caring responsibilities. This can diminish their ability to re-
enter the workforce in later life.27
In light of the above, it is disappointing that government policy currently only supports
Victorians to access free or subsidized accredited training that is at a higher qualification level.28
Barriers still exist for older workers who may already possess a higher-level qualification but are
looking to upskill or retrain in a different area.
It is clear that Victoria needs a new public policy framework to enable meaningful opportunities
for workers as they age. To this end, COTA Victoria believes that there are a number of
measures that can be implemented by Government and industry to improve the productivity of
Victoria’s ageing population. These measures are outlined in detail in the evidence we
submitted to inform the Inquiry into Sustainable Employment for Disadvantaged jobseekers in
July this year. The reporting date for this inquiry is 30 June 2020.
In the meantime, COTA Victoria is leading a new innovative project to support jobseekers who
are over the age of 50 to obtain paid work. The ‘Reach, Train, employ’ project focuses on
building the capacity of older people to enter employment in the aged care and disability
sectors to meet a growing demand of more than 17000 new jobs in Victoria by 2023.
Participants will receive support to complete a Certificate III in Individual Support (Ageing and
Disability) (CHC33015). The certificate will be delivered by RMIT University with a brand-new
curriculum co-designed by industry experts and people with lived experience. Good Shepherd
Australia and New Zealand (GSANZ) are providing financial counselling and a life coach to the
participants and the Future Social Services Institute (FSSI) will be evaluating the project. The
Department of Social Services (Commonwealth) have funded the project through its Try Test
and Learn Fund.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
16 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 16
In summary, participants receive a range of enabling supports including:
Career guidance.
Employment assistance through resume writing, interview techniques and coaching to understand the employment market.
Enhancing IT and digital literacy.
Financial counselling.
Mental health and wellbeing support.
Assistance with student and employment placements.
Personal support.29
Recommendation 5:
The Victorian Government invest in initiatives that will enhance opportunities for older people
to earn income in later life. Such initiatives should:
• Challenge ageist attitudes by educating employers about the benefits of hiring and
retaining older workers.
• Re-skill older workers and provide them with tailored support to enable them to change
careers or re-enter the workforce.
Recommendation 6:
The Victorian Government revise the eligibility requirements for free TAFE courses to ensure
that mature aged job seekers and workers who are experiencing employment vulnerability are
provided with an opportunity to retrain and access new career pathways.
6.2 THE GENDER GAP IN RETIREMENT INCOME
As outlined in section 4.2 of this submission, older women are the fastest growing group of
people experiencing homelessness in Australia. One of the most dominant drivers of housing
stress among older women is the gender gap that exists in retirement income. In order to
properly understand this gap, it is first necessary to scrutinize the gender pay gap that still
exists for women of working age. We know, for example, that:
• Women who work in full-time roles earn 18% less than men. • 43% of women work part-time. • Women take an average of five years out of the workforce to care for children or other
family members.30
As a result of these factors:
• Women only receive a third of the government tax concessions on super, with men
receiving the other two thirds.
• Women retire with on average 47% less superannuation than men.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
17 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 17
• 35% of women aged 60-64 years do not have any superannuation.
• Two thirds of single older women have less than $50000 in savings.
• 40% of older single retired women live in poverty.31
The following factors may contribute to older women’s experiences of housing stress:
• Women live an average of 5 years longer than men, which means they are required to stretch their retirement income further.32
• Women exhibit much lower levels of financial literacy than men. This may further
increase their vulnerability to financial hardship in retirement.33
Other factors affecting the financial security of older women are explored in section 6.4 of this
submission, which relates to elder abuse.
In September 2019, the Australian Government announced a comprehensive review of the
retirement income system. This review process is still underway. The final report from the
review will be provided to government by June 2020.34 As demonstrated elsewhere in this
submission, retirement income is a key driver of homelessness amongst older Victorians. To this
end, COTA Victoria hopes the federal review will result in outcomes that will help to alleviate
housing stress across Victoria’s ageing population.
At a state level, COTA Victoria commends the Victorian Government on the development and
progressive implementation of ‘Safe and Strong’: the Victorian Government’s Gender Equality
Strategy. This strategy places Victoria at the forefront of efforts to address the gender pay gap
between men and women. While the Strategy already recognizes the cumulative impact of the
gender pay gap on economic security,35 it would be useful for the strategy to include targets
and outcomes that are specific to older women of working age.
Recommendation 7:
The Victorian Government include older women of working age when framing targets and
outcomes under The Victorian Government’s Gender Equality Strategy, ‘Safe and Strong’.
Recommendation 8:
The Victorian Government submit evidence to inform the Review of Retirement Incomes to
demonstrate the need for the Commonwealth to structure a range of income streams that are
tailored to the needs of older women.
Recommendation 9:
The Victorian Government invest in capacity-building initiatives that aim to increase financial
literacy amongst older women who are on lower incomes, and who may have fewer financial
resources available in retirement.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
18 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 18
6.3 RELATIONSHIP BREAKDOWN OR LOSS OF A PARTNER
According to the Australian Institute of Family Studies, divorced people who are over the age of
55 have less disposable income and fewer assets than their married counterparts.36 This is
concerning when considering the rapid rise in the number of older people seeking divorce.37
Losing a partner through death can also increase an individual’s financial vulnerability,
particularly in instances where the deceased spouse has had sole responsibility for managing
the household finances.38
While many people will experience a change in income as a result of losing a partner, they may
be entitled to receive income from sources such as:
• Government payments. • Bank accounts that are in the deceased partner’s name.
• Partner’s insurance or superannuation.
• Unclaimed money that may be available through shares or other investments.39
This financial maze can be difficult for people to navigate at the best of times, let alone at a
time when they are experiencing significant grief and loss. This situation can be even more
daunting for older people with low levels of financial literacy who may be learning how to
navigate the retirement income system for the very first time.40
Recommendation 10:
The Victorian Government:
Increase investment in awareness-raising initiatives that aim to inform older Victorians
about free financial counselling services that are already available.
Expand funding of Financial Counsellors to enhance their capacity to provide outreach
support and financial counselling to people who are not digitally connected.
6.4 ELDER ABUSE
Elder abuse is one of the key drivers of homelessness amongst older people. Most victims of
elder abuse are women. A staggering 46.9% of women over the age of 55 who access specialist
homelessness services reported family violence as their primary reason for seeking support.41
Elder abuse can directly contribute to financial stress for older people when it involves the loss
of the family home, property or other assets. It can also result in debts and unpaid loans,
ongoing and unsustainable support of other family members and increased costs associated
with health and wellbeing needs. Elder abuse is sometimes perpetrated by family members of
the older person who have moved back into the family home as a result of their own
homelessness. Abuse and family violence can result in older parents who are living with adult
children having to move out with nowhere to go.42
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
19 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 19
Seniors Rights Victoria (SRV), a significant program of COTA Victoria, holds an independent role
as the key statewide community legal service dedicated to preventing and responding to elder
abuse. We refer to the separate submission that SRV has made to this inquiry and urge the
Victorian Government to implement all recommendations set out within.
6.5 POOR MENTAL HEALTH
The issues of housing stress, homelessness and mental illness are all interrelated. While the
Royal Commission into Victoria’s Mental Health system was still underway at the time of writing
this submission,43 we wish to draw the Committee’s attention to the following findings from a
2018 report that was published by the Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute:
There is a lack of affordable, safe and appropriate housing for people with mental illness.
People who are discharged from mental health facilities face an increased risk of
experiencing homelessness.
Integrated programs that aim to address housing and mental health are effective, but do
not meet current demands.
Secure housing would enable people to place a greater focus on mental health treatment
and rehabilitation.44
Recommendation 11:
The Victorian Government, in implementing the recommendations of the Royal Commission
into Victoria’s Mental Health System, considers the relationship between mental illness and
homelessness.
7. HOW THE CURRENT HOUSING LANDSCAPE IS DRIVING HOUSING
INSECURITY ACROSS THE AGEING POPULATION
7.1 THE NEED FOR BETTER SYSTEMS NAVIGATION
Australia’s housing market is complex and difficult for many older people to navigate. Those
who find service navigation most difficult are people with low levels of digital and English
literacy, which is concerning when considering that.
People who are over the age of 65 have the lowest levels of digital inclusion of any
population group in Australia, with around half of older adults still not using the internet.45
Around 14% of Victorian adults have a low level of English literacy which may make it
difficult for them to read and interpret complex written information.46
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
20 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 20
In light of the above barriers, there needs to be more in person support available to assist
people to navigate what is currently a scarce and complex housing market. COTA Victoria would
therefore support additional investment in initiatives that seek to fill this gap. One approach
might be to build on existing services such as Housing for the Aged Action Group’s ‘Home at
Last’ and ‘Retirement Housing Assistance and Advocacy Program’’. This program provides a
triage response to a range of complex housing needs presented by older people including
retirement housing, Independent Living Units and other housing options.47
A tailored response is all the more critical for older people who have been homeless, as these
people may have no recent rental history to support their application for accommodation. A
member of COTA Victoria with lived experience of homelessness told us:
“Once someone becomes homeless it instantly becomes extremely difficult to be
successful in a rent application because you have no current references. The longer this
goes on for the worse it gets – a significant contributor to the trap of homelessness.”
Consideration must also be given to how people interact with the aged care system, as this may
be the first point of contact for many older people experiencing housing stress. In a 2019
report, the Australian Housing and Urban research Institute noted:
“The My Aged Care website can present a significant challenge to many older people,
who may choose to forego services rather than engage in a steep learning process
around the technology.”48
The aged care navigator services currently being trialed throughout Australia are helping to
address existing barriers by providing consumers with tailored support to help them navigate
the aged care system in person or over the phone. The trial has been funded until June 2020 to
road-test a number of different approaches to service navigation. The outcomes of this trial will
provide greater insights into what is needed to effectively support older people to navigate
complex service systems into the future.49
Recommendation 12:
The Victorian Government invest in initiatives that provide older Victorians with tailored
support to help them navigate access to housing options and prevent them from falling into a
cycle of homelessness.
Recommendation 13:
The Victorian Government liaise with the Commonwealth to reinforce the need for tailored
services that can assist people to navigate the aged care system either in person, or over the
phone.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
21 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 21
7.2 RENTAL AFFORDABILITY
While more Victorians are renting than ever before, the 2019 Rental Affordability Index (RAI)
has revealed a situation that is untenable for older renters, 42 per cent of whom now live in
relative poverty.50
Of the 69,000 rental properties analyzed as part of the 2019, annual Rental Affordability
Snapshot:
There were no properties that were affordable to rent for a single person on Newstart. This
is concerning when considering that the number of people aged 55-64 on Newstart has
risen by more than 55,000 in less than five years.51
0.8% of properties were affordable and appropriate for a single person on the Aged
Pension. Rental affordability for people on the aged pension has declined dramatically over
the past six years as welfare payments have not kept up with rent increases.52
The level of financial strain on older renters is further exacerbated by higher healthcare costs
and the need to be located in areas well connected to transport, health and community
services.
Recommendation 14:
The Victorian Government provide evidence to inform the Australian Government’s review of
retirement income to demonstrate the relationship between financial insecurity and
homelessness across Victoria’s ageing population, suggesting that there be an increase in
Commonwealth Rent Assistance for Older Renters.
7.3 TENNANT RIGHTS
Security of tenure is still a major factor affecting housing security amongst older renters, with
Research conducted by the Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute revealing that
Australia still lags behind other countries when it comes to rental rights and tenant protections.
A survey undertaken by CHOICE, National Shelter and the National Association of Tenant
Organisations in 2017 found that:
• 83% of renters had no long-term security • 62% were scared to ask for a longer lease • 50% had been discriminated against • 50% feared being unfairly blacklisted • 21% had waited more than a week for urgent repairs • 14% had avoided making a complaint or requesting repairs for fear of adverse
consequences such as rent increases, eviction, bad references, blacklisting and bullying.53
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
22 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 22
The recent amendments to the Residential Tenancies Act And proposed Residential Tenancies
Regulations will go a long way towards addressing some of these barriers. While the regulations
were still in development at the time of writing this submission, we understand that the new
changes will:
• Introduce longer leases.
• Remove the 120 day ‘no specified reason’ notice to vacate a premises.
• Limit the use of ‘end of fixed-term’ notices to vacate premises.
• Create a property owner blacklist to protect consumers from property owners who have
previously breached their obligations.
• Speed up bond repayment.
• Allow early release of bond.
• Introduce a new bond cap & up-front rent cap for most properties.
• Speed up reimbursement for urgent repairs.
• Reduce the frequency of rent increases.
• Require fixed rent amounts in advertisements.54
Positively, these reforms will also grant tenants the right to keep pets, provided they have
obtained the landlord’s written consent which can only be refused by order of the Victorian
Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The onus will be on the landlord to seek approval from VCAT if
they wish to refuse consent to a pet.55 It is our hope that this may go some way towards
addressing the current lack of pet friendly accommodation, which is a major driver of
homelessness in Australia.56
While the aforementioned changes are welcomed, COTA Victoria is concerned over the limited
scope of minimum standards, the lack of energy efficiency standards and the conditions set for
modifications (as explored under 8.2 of this submission). These are detailed in our response to
the proposed Residential Tenancies regulations.
It is our hope that the issues highlighted in our response will be adequately addressed through
the consultation process, resulting in a final set of regulations that strengthen, promote and
uphold the rights of tenants across Victoria. Once the regulations have been finalized, the
Victorian Government will then need to turn its attention to increasing awareness and
understanding of the regulations amongst consumers. In doing so, the Government must be
cognizant of the digital divide that still exists for many older Victorians and the need to provide
information in formats that are easy to understand.
Recommendation 15:
The Victorian Government invest in awareness-raising initiatives to:
Educate tenants about their rights and responsibilities under the new Residential Tenancies
Regulations.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
23 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 23
Educate housing providers about the capital investment benefits of modifications that
enhance accessibility and the rights of older tenants to make the required adjustments to
age in place.
7.4 AVAILABILITY OF PUBLIC HOUSING
Public housing has historically provided a necessary safety net for many older people who are
unable to keep up with the increasing costs of private rentals. Regrettably, however, there has
been a gradual decrease in investment in public housing across all levels of government.57
According to a 2019 report published by the Productivity Commission, Victoria is currently
spending half the national average per person on public housing.58 Meanwhile, there are
84,000 adults and children on the public housing waiting list and 500 more being added each
month.59
COTA Victoria commends the Andrews Government on its election commitment to invest $200
million over three years to increase Victoria’s social housing supply.60 We are concerned,
however, that the conservative target of 1000 new properties that has been set under this
initiative will be insufficient in meeting the needs of Victoria’s ageing population. Furthermore,
we would like to see the Government establish targets to increase the availability of affordable
housing for older people experiencing housing stress as part of this package of initiatives.
Recommendation 16:
The Victorian Government establish targets to increase the availability of affordable housing for
older people experiencing housing stress as part of the ‘Homes for Victorians’ package of
initiatives.
Recommendation 17:
The Victorian Government, in consultation with relevant stakeholders, develop a long-term
strategy for planned future investment in social and affordable rental housing to meet the
demands of Victoria’s ageing population.
7.5 MORTGAGE STRESS
Average mortgage debt for older Australians has increased by 600% over the past 30 years,
with people also carrying more debt relative to their income. Almost half of all homeowners
between the ages of 55 and 64 are still paying off a mortgage. This is alarming when
considering that 32 per cent of older people live on less than $400 per week,61 and more than
one in four older mortgagors are making repayments that exceed 30% of their total disposable
income.62
Low-income homeowners are at significant risk of not being able to cover their mortgage
repayments when there is a change in their disposable income or when interest rates rise. This
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
24 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 24
may force them to draw down on their superannuation in order to cover mortgage repayments,
leaving them to struggle with other everyday expenses. As identified in section 6.2 of this
submission, older women may be hardest hit as they retire with an average of 47% less
superannuation than men.
If people are depleting their super accounts to pay-off mortgage debt, this may have
implications for the welfare system, as demand for the Aged Pension will increase. This
situation may also lead to other downstream costs to health and social services, with research
revealing that older people who experience mortgage stress show a significant decline in their
mental health.63
The aforementioned factors demonstrate a need to ensure the experience of housing stress
amongst older homeowners is carefully examined as part of the Federal Government’s Review
of Retirement Incomes.
8. THE ROLE OF ACCESSIBILITY IN MEETING THE HOUSING NEEDS OF
VICTORIA’S AGEING POPULATION
Many people experience a decline in their physical health as they age. As such, people over the
age of 65 currently account for 40% of the 4.4 million people with disability across Australia.64
This points to an increasing need for universally designed and adaptable housing that is
responsive to the changing needs of Victoria’s ageing population.
8.1 ENSURING NEW PROPERTIES ARE UNIVERSALLY ACCESSIBLE
There are not enough accessible, age friendly properties available to meet demand.
Additionally, new properties are not being built with accessibility in mind, as universal design
principles for housing are yet to be incorporated into the National Construction Code.65
Developing new properties that do not incorporate universal design principles will limit the
number of properties available to meet the changing needs of Victoria’s ageing population. This
will lead to downstream costs for government, as residents will need to retrofit properties for
accessibility through publicly funded home modifications schemes.
Recommendation 18:
The Victorian Government work with the Commonwealth to ensure the inclusion of universal
design principles in all new properties to ensure their cost-effective adaption to the needs of
Victoria’s ageing population.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
25 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 25
8.2 MODIFYING EXISTING RENTAL PROPERTIES
For many older people, restrictions on the modifications that can be made to rental properties
has exacerbated an already limited supply of appropriate housing. Modifications to homes
supports longer-term tenure, ageing in place and importantly addresses the dearth of private
rental housing that is appropriate for older people and people with disability where
modifications for accessibility, health and safety are required.
The recent reforms and proposed Regulations to the Residential Tenancies Act (2020) stipulate
that rental providers can no longer unreasonably refuse consent to tenants installing property
modifications recommended by health professionals.66 Despite these changes, however, there
is a concern that older tenants still may not act on their needs for fear of eviction or an increase
in rent. Under the proposed Regulations, there is also a requirement for the tenant to remove
structural modifications and pay for costs of restoration prior to leaving a property unless
otherwise agreed to by both parties. This does not acknowledge the benefits that modifications
made to improve accessibility may present for future tenants.
Recommendation 19:
The following improvements be made to the proposed Residential Tenancies Regulations:
Where modifications are part of transitioning out of hospital care or a requirement to
qualify for hospital-in-the-home reprograms, consent to make modifications should be
automatically granted.
Renters that install home modifications to support accessibility, safety, health and ageing in
place, should not be required to remove and pay for the costs of restoring properties to
their previous condition.
8.3 IMPROVING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF EXISTING HOME MODIFICATIONS
SCHEMES
Existing home modifications schemes are complex and confusing for consumers to navigate and
are not always able to provide modifications in a timely manner. A more streamlined response
would not only enhance the ability of older Victorians to age in place but may also result in
savings for health services by reducing falls, GP visits and hospital admissions.67
Recommendation 20:
The Victorian Government work with the Commonwealth to develop a nationally consistent
approach to funding structural and personal modifications to existing properties to enable
residents to age in place. Home modifications schemes must be appropriately funded to enable
assessments to be undertaken and modifications to be completed in the shortest time frame
possible.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
26 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 26
8.4 INCREASING THE ACCESSIBILITY OF COMMON AREAS IN APARTMENT
BUILDINGS
The building Code of Australia was updated in 2011 to require common areas in all new
apartment buildings to meet minimum accessibility standards.68 These standards did not apply
to older buildings that had been constructed prior to 2011. However, an outcome from a case
heard by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal in 2018, has set a new precedent that
may have implications for apartment complexes constructed before 2011.
Ms Black is the owner/occupier of a fourth floor apartment in one of Melbourne’s inner
suburbs. While she was still able to access her apartment itself after her physical health had
declined, the common areas in her apartment building were not fully accessible and presented
her with a number of challenges. She had asked the owners’ corporations responsible for
maintaining the building to make modifications so that she could access the buildings’ common
areas independently, including the main entrance, courtyard and carpark. When the owners’
corporations had failed to make the necessary changes, Ms Black pursued the matter under the
Victorian Equal Opportunity Act. The Act requires public entities to make reasonable
modifications to enable a person with disability to access a service and includes specific
reference to owners’ corporations.
The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal ordered the two owners’ corporations
responsible for maintaining the building to make the necessary modifications to enable Ms
Black to access the common areas of the building independently. This involved widening
doorways and installing automated doors, ramps and handrails. The Tribunal’s ruling clearly
states that owners corporations are required to make modifications to apartment buildings to
accommodate the access needs of owners and Occupiers with disability.69
Recommendation 21:
The Victorian Government invest in awareness-raising initiatives to educate owners
corporations about the benefits of universal design features and the precedent that has been
set by VCAT’s decision in the case of ‘Owners Corporation v Black’.
9. CONCLUDING STATEMENT
Thank you once again for providing COTA Victoria with an opportunity to submit evidence to
inform this inquiry. We hope that the information and recommendations outlined throughout
this submission will assist the Victorian Government to plan for the changing needs of Victoria’s
ageing population.
Should you require any further information in relation to any of the issues raised throughout
this submission, please do not hesitate to contact COTA Victoria’s Policy Officer, Lauren Henley.
Lauren can be contacted on (03) 9655 2140, or at [email protected].
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
27 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 27
End Notes
1 Parliament of Victoria (2019) 'INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS IN VICTORIA', accessed 10 December 2019 <https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/lsic-lc/inquiries/article/4282>. 2 Australian Bureau of Statistics (2018) 'HOUSING TRANSITIONS FOR OLDER AUSTRALIANS', accessed 8 December 2019 <https://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/2081.0~ACLD~Main%20Features~Housing%20transitions%20for%20older%20Australians~55>. 3 Victorian Department of Health & Human Services (2015) 'Mental health and wellbeing of older people: 10-year mental health plan technical paper. 4 Australian Bureau of Statistics (2016) 'Census of Population and Housing: Estimating homelessness', accessed 10 December 2019 <https://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/mf/2049.0>. 5 Australian Bureau of Statistics (2018) ‘Older Australia at a glance: 'People at risk of homelessness', accessed 8 December 2019 <https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/older-people/older-australia-at-a-glance/contents/diversity/people-at-risk-of-homelessness>. 6 Australian Bureau of Statistics (2016) 'Census of Population and Housing: Understanding the Census and Census Data', accessed 12 December 2019 <https://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/2900.0~2016~Main%20Features~OPGP%20Homelessness%20Operational%20Groups%20~10155>. 7 McDonald, P. (2017) 'Homelessness: Older women couch surfing, sleeping in cars due to unaffordable housing', accessed 27 June 2019 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-08- 07/older-women-become-hidden-face-of-homelessness/8782816 8 Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2019) 'Older clients of specialist homelessness services', accessed 9 December 2019 <https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/homelessness-services/older-clients-of-specialist-homelessness-services/contents/clients-services-and-outcomes>. 9 Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (2019) 'An effective homelessness services system for older Australians', accessed 19 December 2019 <https://www.ahuri.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0022/47371/AHURI-Final-Report-322-An-effective-homelessness-services-system-for-older-Australians.pdf>. 10 Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2019) 'Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people: a focus report on housing and homelessness', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/housing-assistance/indigenous-people-focus-housing-homelessness/contents/summary>. 11 Burke, K., written for Domain (2019) ‘Tsunami’ of older Australians at risk of homelessness', accessed 20 December 2019 <https://www.domain.com.au/news/life-shocks-contribute-to-rapid-rise-in-number-of-homeless-older-australians-ahuri-report-912829/>. 12 Council to Homeless Persons (2018) 'No room to breathe; why severe overcrowding is a form of homelessness', accessed 21 December 2019 <https://chp.org.au/no-room-to-breathe-why-severe-overcrowding-is-a-form-of-homelessness/>.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
28 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 28
13 Special Broadcasting Corporation and St Vincent de Paul Society NSW (2018) 'Culturally Diverse Australians and Homelessness', accessed 22 January 2020 <https://www.sbs.com.au/sites/sbs.com.au.home/files/cald_fact_sheet_final.pdf>. 14 Australian Bureau of Statistics (2018) 'Older Australia at a glance', accessed 22 January 2020 <Older <https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/older-people/older-australia-at-a-glance/contents/demographics-of-older-australians>. 15 VMCH (2019) (Housing struggle for culturally diverse older people', accessed 22 January 2020 <https://vmch.com.au/news/housing-struggle-for-culturally-diverse-older-people/>. 16 Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (2019) 'An effective homelessness services system for older Australians', accessed 19 December 2019 <https://www.ahuri.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0022/47371/AHURI-Final-Report-322-An-effective-homelessness-services-system-for-older-Australians.pdf>. 17 National Older Women’s Housing and Homelessness Working Group (2018) 'A NATIONAL PLAN FOR CHANGE: INCREASING HOUSING SECURITY FOR OLDER WOMEN RETIRING INTO POVERTY', accessed 10 December 2019 <https://www.mercyfoundation.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Retiring-into-Poverty-National-Plan-for-Change-Increasing-Housing-Security-for-Older-Women-23-August-2018.pdf>. 18 Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (2019) 'An effective homelessness services system for older Australians', accessed 19 December 2019 <https://www.ahuri.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0022/47371/AHURI-Final-Report-322-An-effective-homelessness-services-system-for-older-Australians.pdf>. 19 Commonwealth Department of Health (2019) 'Homeless supplement for aged care', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.health.gov.au/health-topics/aged-care/providing-aged-care-services/funding-for-aged-care-service-providers/homeless-supplement-for-aged-care>. 20 Australian Association of Gerontology (2019) '2019-02 Aged Care Diversity Framework Homelessness Action Plan Survey for Professionals', accessed 10 December 2019 <https://www.aag.asn.au/news-publications/aag-submissions/2019-02-aged-care-diversity-framework-homelssness-actiona-plan-survey-for-professionals>. 21 Carroll, V., written for The Big Issue (2020) 'How are homeless people in Australia affected by the bushfires Down Under?', accessed 22 January 2020 <https://www.bigissue.com/latest/how-are-homeless-people-in-australia-affected-by-the-bushfires-down-under/>. 22 Carp, P., written for the Guardian (2020) 'Victoria announces inquiry into bushfire crisis as Morrison flags royal commission', accessed 22 January 2020 <https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/jan/14/victoria-announces-inquiry-into-bushfire-crisis-as-morrison-flags-royal-commission>. 23 Donnellan, A., written for ABC News (2018) 'Number of older Australians on Newstart growing by 10,000 a year', accessed 8 December 2019 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-09-25/mature-workers-on-newstart/10195296>. 24 Council on the Ageing Australia (2019) 'MEDIA RELEASE: Rental market leaves pensioners out in the cold in new affordability report, as COTA demands urgent action on housing', accessed 8 December 2018 <https://www.cota.org.au/news-items/media-release-rental-market-leaves-pensioners-out-in-the-cold-in-new-affordability-report-as-cota-demands-urgent-action-on-housing/>.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
29 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 29
25 Australian Human Rights Commission (2018) 'Employing Older Workers', accessed 29 July 2019 <https://www.humanrights.gov.au/our-work/age-discrimination/publications/employing-older-workers-2018>. 26 Williamson, B. on behalf of ABC Radio Adelaide (2017) 'Age discrimination: Over 50s search twice as long for work ‘, accessed 29 July 2019 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-05-19/age-discrimination-over-50s-worst-bracket-to-beunemployed/8540548>. 27 Taylor, P, Roland, L. and Zhou, J., written for Federation University Australia (2017) 'Retaining Australian Workers - A Guide to Best Practice', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.monash.edu/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/2052093/WP2017-02.pdf>. 28 Victorian Department of Education and Training (2020) 'Check your eligibility for subsidized training', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.skills.vic.gov.au/victorianskillsgateway/Students/Pages/vtg-eligibility-indicator.aspx>. 29 Council on the Ageing Victoria (2019) 'Reach, Train, Employ', accessed 12 December 2019 <https://www.cotavic.org.au/our-programs/reach-train-employ/>. 30 Women in Super (2019) 'THE FACTS ABOUT WOMEN AND SUPER', accessed 10 December 2019 <https://www.womeninsuper.com.au/content/the-facts-about-women-and-super/gjumzs>. 31 Women in Super (2019) ‘THE FACTS ABOUT WOMEN AND SUPER’, accessed 14 December
2019 < https://www.womeninsuper.com.au/content/the-facts-about-women-and-
super/gjumzs>.
32 Health Agenda Magazine (2019) ‘LIFE EXPECTANCY: HOW LONG CAN YOU LIVE?’, accessed 14
December 2019 <https://www.hcf.com.au/health-agenda/health-care/research-and-
insights/life-expectancy-in-australia>.
33 Wilkins, R., written for University of Melbourne (2018) 'HILDA Survey reveals striking gender and age divide in financial literacy’, accessed 13 December 2019 <https://theconversation.com/hilda-survey-reveals-striking-gender-and-age-divide-in-financial-literacy-test-yourself-with-this-quiz-100451>. 34 Commonwealth Department of Treasury (2019) ‘Retirement Income Review’, accessed 29
September 2019 <http://treasury.gov.au/review/retirement-income-review>.
35 Victorian Government (2019) 'Safe and strong: A Victorian Gender Equality Strategy', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.vic.gov.au/safe-and-strong-victorian-gender-equality>. 36 ABC News (2018) ‘The financial impact of divorce lingers for decades’, accessed 13 December
2019 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-07-26/divorce-financial-impact-affecting-older-
women/10037520>.
37 The Sydney Morning Herald (2015) ‘Grey divorce has huge impact in the retirement years’,
accessed 13 December 2019 <https://www.smh.com.au/money/planning-and-budgeting/grey-
divorce-has-huge-impact-in-the-retirement-years-20150527-ghah6i.html>.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
30 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 30
38 AISC’s (Australian Security and Investments Commission) Money Smart (2019) 'Financial Implications of Death of a Partner', accessed 13 December 2019 <https://www.york.ac.uk/inst/spru/research/pdf/Bereavement.pdf>. 39 AISC’s (Australian Security and Investments Commission) Money Smart (2019) ‘Losing your
partner’, accessed 13 December 2019 <https://www.moneysmart.gov.au/life-events-and-
you/life-events/losing-your-partner>.
40 AISC’s (Australian Security and Investments Commission) Money Smart (2019) 'Financial Implications of Death of a Partner', accessed 13 December 2019 <https://www.york.ac.uk/inst/spru/research/pdf/Bereavement.pdf>. 41 Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2019) 'Older clients of specialist homelessness services', accessed 8 December 2019 <https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/homelessness-services/older-clients-of-specialist-homelessness-services/contents/clients-services-and-outcomes/reasons-and-needs-for-shs-services>. 42 Seniors Rights Victoria (2019) 'Elder Abuse as Family Violence', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://seniorsrights.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Elder-Abuse-as-Family-Violence-FINAL.pdf>. 43 Royal Commission into Victoria's Mental Health System (2019) 'About us', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://rcvmhs.vic.gov.au/about-us>. 44 Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (2018) 'Housing, homelessness and mental health: towards systems change', accessed 10 December 2019 <https://www.ahuri.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0023/29381/Housing-homelessness-and-mental-health-towards-systems-change.pdf>. 45 Hocking, B. (2018) 'Older Australians suffering from digital inclusion gap', accessed 27 June 2019 <https://www.yourlifechoices.com.au/technology/computers/addressing-thedigital-inclusion-gap 46 VICTORIAN PUBLIC LIBRARIES IN ACTION (2016) 'Reading and literacy for all', accessed 21 December 2019 <https://www.slv.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/Reading-and-literacy-for-all-adult-literacy-libraries_0.pdf>. 47 Housing for the Aged Action Group (2013) 'Home At Last Here to Help', accessed 23 January 2019 <https://www.oldertenants.org.au/home_at_last>. 48 Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (2019) 'An effective homelessness services system for older Australians', accessed 19 December 2019 <https://www.ahuri.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0022/47371/AHURI-Final-Report-322-An-effective-homelessness-services-system-for-older-Australians.pdf>. 49 Council on the Ageing Australia (2019) 'Aged Care Navigators', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.cota.org.au/information/aged-care-navigators/>. 50 The New Daily (2019) ‘Older Australians have the highest rate of rental poverty in the OECD’,
accessed 14 December 2019
<https://thenewdaily.com.au/finance/retirement/2019/11/27/rental-poverty-older-
australians/>.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
31 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 31
51 Donnellan, A., written for ABC News (2018) 'Number of older Australians on Newstart growing by 10,000 a year', accessed 8 December 2019 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-09-25/mature-workers-on-newstart/10195296>. 52 Bleby, M., written for The Australian Financial Review (2019) 'Rental affordability for age pension recipients worst in six years', accessed 14 December 2019 <https://www.afr.com/property/residential/rental-affordability-for-age-pension-recipients-worst-in-six-years-20190426-p51hg1>. 53 National Shelter (2017) 'National Renters Survey with CHOICE and NATO' accessed 23 January 2020 <https://shelter.org.au/national-renters-survey-with-choice-and-nato/>. 54 Victorian Government (2019) 'Rent Fair - rental reforms for Victorians', accessed 16 December 2019 <https://www.vic.gov.au/rentfair-rental-reforms-victorians>. 55 Victorian Government (2019) 'Rent Fair - rental reforms for Victorians', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.vic.gov.au/rentfair-rental-reforms-victorians>. 56 Pets of the Homeless Australia (2020) 'Who we help and why', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://petsofthehomeless.org.au/who-we-help-and-why/>. 57 Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (2019) ‘Social housing as infrastructure: rationale, prioritisation and investment pathway’, accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.ahuri.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0014/43214/AHURI-Final-Report-315-Social-housing-as-infrastructure-rationale-prioritisation-and-investment-pathway.pdf>. 58 Productivity Commission (2019) 'annual Report on Government Services', accessed 14 December 2019 <https://www.pc.gov.au/research/ongoing/report-on-government-services>. 59 The socialist (2019) ‘Labor pushing ahead with public housing sell-offs’, accessed 14
December 2019 <https://thesocialist.org.au/labor-public-housing-sell-offs/>. 60 Victorian Department of Premier and Cabinet (2018) Media release" 'Building New Homes to Fight Homelessness', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/building-new-homes-to-fight-homelessness/>. 61 Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (2019) 'Financial and life ‘shocks’ contribute to a surge in the number of homeless older Australians', accessed 18 December 2019 <https://www.ahuri.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0020/53093/AHURI-MEDIA-RELEASE-Financial-and-life-shocks-contribute-to-a-surge-in-the-number-of-homeless-older-Australians-27-November-2019.pdf>. 62 Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (2019) 'Mortgage stress and precarious home ownership: implications for older Australians', accessed 13 December 2019 <https://www.ahuri.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0024/45069/PES-319-Examining-the-impacts-of-growing-mortgage-debt-amongst-older-Australians.pdf>. 63 Collett, J., written for The Sydney Morning Herald (2019) 'Mortgage stress harming mental health of older Australians', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.smh.com.au/money/borrowing/mortgage-stress-harming-mental-health-of-older-australians-20190828-p52ln1.html>. 64 Australian Network on Disability (2019) 'Disability Statistics', accessed 8 December 2019 <https://www.and.org.au/pages/disability-statistics.html>. 65 Australian Network for Universal Housing Design (2020) 'ABCB Project', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://anuhd.org/accessible-housing-national-consultation-forums-2018/>.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
32 of 33
COUNCIL ON THE AGEING VICTORIA SUBMISSION: VICTORIAN INQUIRY INTO HOMELESSNESS | 32
66 Consumer Affairs Victoria (2019) 'Tenants installing fixtures and altering the rental property', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.consumer.vic.gov.au/housing/renting/during-a-lease-or-residency/repairs-maintenance-and-changes-to-the-property/tenants-installing-fixtures-and-altering-the-rental-property>. 67 National Aged Care Alliance (2018) 'Assistive Technology for Older Australians Position Paper', accessed 16 September 2019, retrieved from <https://naca.asn.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/NACA_Assistive_Technology_for_Older_Australians_Position_Paper-1-June2018.pdf>. 68 Australian Government Federal Register of Legislation (2011) 'Disability (Access to Premises - Buildings) Standards 2010', accessed 23 January 2020 <https://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/F2010L00668/Explanatory%20Statement/Text>. 69 Human Rights Law Centre (2018) 'Victorian Supreme Court finds owners corporations must modify apartments for owners with a disability', accessed 14 December 2018 <https://www.hrlc.org.au/human-rights-case-summaries/2018/10/22/owners-corporations-must-modify-apartments-for-owners-with-a-disability>.
LC LSIC Inquiry into Homelessness in Victoria
Submission 235
33 of 33