initial environmental examination (draft) – part 3 · 2019. 11. 6. · initial environmental...

57
Initial Environmental Examination (DRAFT) – Part 3 Project Number: 51423–002 November 2019 Mongolia: Vegetable Production and Irrigated Agriculture Project Prepared by the Ministry of Food, Agriculture, and Light Industry for the Asian Development Bank

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jan-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Initial Environmental Examination (DRAFT) – Part 3

    Project Number: 51423–002 November 2019

    Mongolia: Vegetable Production and Irrigated Agriculture Project

    Prepared by the Ministry of Food, Agriculture, and Light Industry for the Asian Development Bank

  • CURRENCY EQUIVALENTS (as of 22 October 2019)

    Currency Unit - Tugrik (MNT) MNT 1.00 = US$ 0.0004 US$ 1.00 = MNT 2,687.61

    ABBREVIATIONS

    ADB - Asian Development Bank IPASS - Institute of Plant and Agriculture Science CS-EMP - Construction Site EMP IPP - Institute for Plant Protection CSC - Construction supervision company LAR - Land Acquisition and Resettlement EA - Executing Agency LIC - Loan implementation consultant EBA - Environmental Baseline Assessment MET - Ministry of Environment and Tourism EHS - Environmental, health and safety MOFA - Ministry of Food, Agriculture, and Light Industry EIA - Environment Impact Assessment OPF - Operators of project facility EMA - Environmental monitoring agency PIC - Project Implementation Consultant EMP - Environmental management plan PIU - Project Implementation Unit FSR - Feasibility Study Report PMO - Project Management Office GAP - Gender action plan RT - Refrigerating ton GDP - Gross Domestic Product SPS - Safeguard Policy Statement GHG - Greenhouse Gas TOR - Terms of Reference GRM - Grievance redress mechanism TRTA - Transaction Technical Assistance IA - Implementing Agency WHO - World Health Organization IEE - Initial environmental examination

    WEIGHTS AND MEASURES

    °C degree centigrade m2 square meter dB(A) A-weighted sound pressure level in decibels m3/a cubic meter per annum cm centimeter m3 cubic meter g gram m3/d cubic meter per day ha hectare kg kilogram m3/s cubic meter per second km kilometer mg/l milligram per liter km2 square kilometer mg/m3 milligram per cubic meter kW kilowatt mm millimeter L liter t metric ton LAeq Equivalent continuous A-weighted sound t/d metric ton per day MW megawatt t/a ton per annum m meter m3 cubic meter

    NOTE In this report, "$" refers to US dollars.

    This initial environmental examination is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. Your attention is directed to the “terms of use” section of this website. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.

  • TABLE OF CONTENTS

    I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................ I A. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................ I

    B. BACKGROUND ................................................................................................. I

    C. PROJECT COMPONENTS.................................................................................. II

    D. ENVIRONMENT BASELINE ............................................................................. XIV

    E. POTENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES ................ XV

    F. PUBLIC CONSULTATION AND GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM ................... XVIII

    G. CLIMATE CHANGE ....................................................................................... XVIII

    H. ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN .......................................................... XIX

    I. RISKS AND KEY ASSURANCES ...................................................................... XIX

    J. CONCLUSIONS ............................................................................................. XIX

    II. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... 1 A. PROJECT RATIONALE ...................................................................................... 1

    B. PROPOSED PROJECT ...................................................................................... 2

    C. ENVIRONMENTAL SAFEGUARDS ....................................................................... 2

    III. POLICY, LEGAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK ....................................... 3 A. OVERVIEW ..................................................................................................... 3

    B. MONGOLIA’S ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK ....................... 3 C. ENVIRONMENTAL STANDARDS ......................................................................... 7

    D. OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS .......................................... 11

    E. ADB SAFEGUARD POLICY STATEMENT .......................................................... 12

    IV. PROJECT DESCRIPTION ...................................................................................... 14 A. IMPACT, OUTCOME AND OUTPUTS ................................................................. 14

    B. DESIGN SCHEME AND CONSTRUCTION METHODS ........................................... 15

    1. OUTPUT 1 .................................................................................................... 16

    2. OUTPUT 2 .................................................................................................... 48

    C. ASSOCIATED AND EXISTING FACILITIES .......................................................... 50

    V. DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT (BASELINE) .......................................... 56 A. NATURAL ZONES OF MONGOLIA ..................................................................... 56

    B. ECOLOGY ..................................................................................................... 56

    C. GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY .................................................................... 57

    D. GEOLOGY AND SOILS .................................................................................... 57

    E. CLIMATE ...................................................................................................... 58

    F. RIVER BASINS .............................................................................................. 60

    G. AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND NOISE LEVELS ....................................................... 61

    H. PHYSICAL CULTURAL RESOURCES .................................................................. 62

    I. LAND USE AND SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS........................................................ 62

    J. SUBPROJECT 1 – TSAKHIR IRRIGATION SCHEME ............................................. 63 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................... 63

    2. SOILS .......................................................................................................... 63

    3. CLIMATE ...................................................................................................... 65

    4. HYDROLOGY – WATER RESOURCES .............................................................. 66 5. WATER QUALITY ........................................................................................... 67

  • 6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS .................................................................. 68

    K. SUBPROJECT 2 – YOLTON IRRIGATION SCHEME .............................................. 70 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................... 70

    2. SOILS .......................................................................................................... 70

    3. CLIMATE ...................................................................................................... 71

    4. HYDROLOGY - WATER RESOURCES ............................................................... 73

    5. WATER QUALITY ........................................................................................... 74

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS .................................................................. 75

    D. SUBPROJECT 3 – ERDENEBUREN IRRIGATION SCHEME ................................... 76 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................... 76

    2. SOILS .......................................................................................................... 76

    3. CLIMATE ...................................................................................................... 78

    4. HYDROLOGY – WATER RESOURCES .............................................................. 79 5. WATER QUALITY ........................................................................................... 80

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS .................................................................. 81

    E. SUBPROJECT 4 – BOOMIIN AM IRRIGATION SCHEME ....................................... 83 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................... 83

    2. SOILS .......................................................................................................... 83

    3. CLIMATE ...................................................................................................... 85

    4. HYDROLOGY - WATER RESOURCES ............................................................... 86

    5. WATER QUALITY ........................................................................................... 87

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS .................................................................. 88

    F. SUBPROJECT 5 – TSUL-ULAAN IRRIGATION SCHEME ....................................... 89 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................... 89

    2. SOILS .......................................................................................................... 90

    3. CLIMATE ...................................................................................................... 91

    4. HYDROLOGY – WATER RESOURCES .............................................................. 92 5. WATER QUALITY ........................................................................................... 93

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS .................................................................. 95

    G. SUBPROJECT 6 – ULAANDEL IRRIGATION SCHEME .......................................... 96 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................... 96

    2. SOILS .......................................................................................................... 97

    3. CLIMATE ...................................................................................................... 98

    4. HYDROLOGY – WATER RESOURCES .............................................................. 99 5. WATER QUALITY ......................................................................................... 100

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS ................................................................ 101

    H. SUBPROJECT 7 – KHUREN TAL IRRIGATION SCHEME ..................................... 103 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................. 103

    2. SOILS ........................................................................................................ 103

    3. CLIMATE .................................................................................................... 105

    4. HYDROLOGY - WATER RESOURCES ............................................................. 106

    5. WATER QUALITY ......................................................................................... 107

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS ................................................................ 108

    I. SUBPROJECT 8 – NOGOON KHASHAA IRRIGATION SCHEME ........................... 109

  • 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................. 109

    2. SOILS ........................................................................................................ 109

    3. CLIMATE .................................................................................................... 111

    4. HYDROLOGY – WATER RESOURCES ............................................................ 112 5. WATER QUALITY ......................................................................................... 113

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS ................................................................ 114

    J. SUBPROJECT 9 – IVEN GOL IRRIGATION SCHEME.......................................... 116 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................. 116

    2. SOILS ........................................................................................................ 116

    3. CLIMATE .................................................................................................... 117

    4. HYDROLOGY - WATER RESOURCES ............................................................. 118

    5. WATER QUALITY ......................................................................................... 120

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS ................................................................ 120

    K. SUBPROJECT 10 – OKHINDIIN TAL IRRIGATION SCHEME ................................ 121 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................. 121

    2. SOILS ........................................................................................................ 121

    3. CLIMATE .................................................................................................... 123

    4. HYDROLOGY - WATER RESOURCES ............................................................. 124

    5. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS ................................................................. 126

    L. SUBPROJECT 11 – SUGNUGUR IRRIGATION SCHEME ..................................... 129 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................. 129

    2. SOILS ........................................................................................................ 129

    3. CLIMATE .................................................................................................... 131

    4. HYDROLOGY – WATER RESOURCES ............................................................ 132 5. WATER QUALITY ......................................................................................... 133

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS ................................................................ 134

    M. SUBPROJECT 12 – DULAANII TAL IRRIGATION SCHEME .................................. 135 1. LOCATION, GEOGRAPHY AND TOPOGRAPHY ................................................. 135

    2. SOILS ........................................................................................................ 135

    3. CLIMATE .................................................................................................... 136

    4. HYDROLOGY – WATER RESOURCES ............................................................ 137 5. WATER QUALITY ......................................................................................... 138

    6. SITE VEGETATION AND HABITATS ................................................................ 139

    VI. ANTICIPATED IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES .................................. 141 A. APPROACH ................................................................................................. 141

    B. PROJECT AREAS OF INFLUENCE AND SENSITIVE RECEPTORS ........................ 141

    C. ANTICIPATED PROJECT BENEFITS AND POSITIVE IMPACTS ............................. 142

    D. PRE-CONSTRUCTION PHASE ....................................................................... 142

    E. CONSTRUCTION PHASE ............................................................................... 143

    F. OPERATION PHASE ..................................................................................... 156

    G. CLIMATE CHANGE AND GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS ................................. 164

    H. INDIRECT, INDUCED, AND CUMULATIVE IMPACTS ........................................... 171

    VII. ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES .......................................................................... 174 A. NO PROJECT ALTERNATIVE ......................................................................... 174

  • B. CHOICE OF CROPS TO PROMOTE .................................................................. 174

    C. AGRICULTURAL AND IRRIGATION TECHNOLOGIES ADOPTED ............................ 174

    D. OWNERSHIP OPTIONS ................................................................................. 175

    E. ALTERNATIVE SUBPROJECTS ....................................................................... 175

    VIII. PUBLIC CONSULTATION, PARTICIPATION AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE 176

    A. PUBLIC CONSULTATION ............................................................................... 176

    B. FEEDBACK FROM PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS ................................................... 176

    C. FUTURE CONSULTATIONS AND DISCLOSURE ................................................. 181

    IX. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM ................................................................ 183 X. ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN ............................................................... 184 XI. PROJECT ASSURANCES .................................................................................... 185 XII. CONCLUSIONS .................................................................................................... 187 APPENDIX 1: ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN ................................................ 189 APPENDIX 2: DRAFT TERMS OF REFERENCE ............................................................. 219 APPENDIX 3: MINUTES OF MEETINGS FOR IRRIGATION SUBPROJECTS ................. 229 APPENDIX 4: QUESTIONNAIRES FOR THE IRRIGATION SUBPROJECTS .................. 263 APPENDIX 5: WATER ALLOCATION VOLUMES FOR AGRICULTURE AND ENVIRONMENTAL FLOWS FOR EACH SUBPROJECT .................................................. 275

  • 82

    Table V-12 Native fish species of the Khar Lake-Khovd Basin

    Species Upstream of Khovd

    River

    Downstream of Khovd and Chonokharaikh Rivers, Khar-Us

    and Khar Lakes

    Mongolian grayling (Thymallus brevirostris) + +

  • 83

    Siberian grayling (Thymallus arcticus arcticus) + -

    Stone loach (Barbatula toni) (See note below) + +

    Source: Baasanjav, G. and Tsendayush, Y. 2001. Fishes of Mongolia. ADMON, Ulaanbaatar

    • Mongolian grayling (Thymallus brevirostris) is vulnerable regionally (in Mongolia) and on a global level. The main threats are (in order) from habitat degradation (mainly sedimentation from mining), fishing and pollution.

    • Siberian grayling (Thymallus arcticus arcticus) is near threatened regionally (in Mongolia) and not assessed on a global level. The main threats are illegal fishing (commercial), habitat degradation due to pollution from gold mining, and habitat loss caused by gold mining and falling river levels.

    • Stone loach (Barbatula toni) is not threatened (least concern) regionally (in Mongolia) and not assessed on a global level. However, desk top research shows that this species is more likely to occur in the Pacific (Amur) watershed in the western region and the Selenge River Basin in the central region, and if often misidentified in the western region.

    E. Subproject 4 – Boomiin Am Irrigation Scheme

    1. Location, Geography and Topography

    2. Soils

  • 84

    Figure V-8: Boomiin Am Irrigation Subproject Soil Map

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

    Table V-13. Soil Profile of Boomiin Am Command Area

  • 85

    Soil horizon

    Depth, m Characteristic

    1 A 0.0-0.3 Sandy loam, yellow brown soil. Gravel more than 2 mm = 10 %, High carbonate content

    Source: Integrated agricultural laboratory

    3. Climate

    Table V-14: Mean Monthly Climate Data in the Boomiin Am Irrigation Subproject Area

    Source: Hydro-Us Co. Ltd

    Month Mean Temperature

    (oC) Maximum

    Temperature (oC) Minimum

    Temperature (oC) Humidity

    (%) Wind speed

    (m/s) Precipitation

    (mm)

    January -25.41 -3.78 -30.44 60.5 0.73 1.09

    February -19.03 -0.17 -34.58 53.8 1.16 0.64

    March -4.85 15.1 -24.98 44.7 2.03 2.28

    April 5.5 22.33 -12.3 36.44 2.65 1.51

    May 10.87 25.69 -5.86 34.5 2.88 7.59

    June 17.03 29.68 2.99 36.89 2.29 25.77

    July 19.44 31.9 6.97 37.63 1.94 13.98

    August 17.13 30.9 3.63 39.8 2.34 17.99

    September 10.49 26.1 -5.51 38.7 2.37 5.61

    October 2.06 18.73 -14.45 41.7 1.89 4.80

    November -9.66 8.91 -25.47 49.2 1.49 0.36

    December -20.4 -1.99 -33.95 58.4 0.86 0.93

  • 86

    4. Hydrology - Water Resources

    Figure V-9: Bodonch River Basin, Hydrological Gauging Station

    Source: Information and Research Institute of Meteorology, Hydrology and Environment

    Table V-15: Water Resources in the Bodonch River at Boomiin Am Irrigation Scheme

    Month Mean Maximum

    Discharge (m3/s)

    Mean Minimum Discharge

    (m3/s)

    Mean Discharge (m3/s)

    % of Annual Discharge

    April 4.77 0.14 1.23 7.92

    May 7.77 0.44 2.28 14.7

    June 12.1 0.29 2.79 18.0

  • 87

    Month Mean Maximum

    Discharge (m3/s)

    Mean Minimum Discharge

    (m3/s)

    Mean Discharge (m3/s)

    % of Annual Discharge

    July 14.3 0.49 2.91 18.8

    August 10.4 0.20 2.34 15.1

    September 13.2 0.21 1.87 12.1

    October 13.0 0.16 1.33 8.62

    November 4.80 0.05 0.51 3.33

    December 1.58 0.00 0.09 0.60

    January 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00

    February 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.01

    March 0.50 0.00 0.12 0.77

    Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring.

    5. Water Quality

    Figure V-10: Water Chemistry of Bodonch River

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

  • 88

    Figure V-11: Suspended Solids in Bodonch River at Boomiin Am Irrigation Scheme

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

    6. Site Vegetation and Habitats

  • 89

    F. Subproject 5 – Tsul-Ulaan Irrigation Scheme

    1. Location, Geography and Topography

    18 Kottelat, M. 2006. Fishes of Mongolia. Washington: The World Bank.

  • 90

    Figure V-12: Location of Tsul-Ulaan Irrigation Scheme

    Source: TA Consultants based on Google Map

    2. Soils

    Figure V-13: Soil Map for Tsul-Ulaan Irrigation Scheme

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

  • 91

    Table V-16: Soil Profile and Analysis

    Soil horizon

    Depth, m Characteristic

    1 O 0 to 0.1 Grass Root zone with slightly decomposed organic matter. Silty clay soil and surface littered with stones. Surface highly susceptible to wind erosion

    2 A 0.1 to 0.35 Grey brown soil, with less stone and gravel. High calcic soil. Silty clay

    3 E 0.35 to 0.5 Ferrous red soils have accumulated have in this layer, where 5 to 10 cm diameter gravel is found, and because of water erosion, clay particle sediment lies in this layer between sand and gravel.

    4 B 0.5 to 0.7 Sand and gravel.

    5 C > 0.7 Fully saturated sandy clay soil with gravel

    Source: Integrated agricultural laboratory

    3. Climate

    Table V-17: Mean Monthly Climate Data in the Tsul-Ulaan Subproject Area

    Average Temperature

    (oC)

    Absolute Maximum

    Temperature (oC)

    Absolute Minimum

    Temperature (oC)

    Humidity (%)

    Wind speed (m/s)

    Precipitation (mm)

    January -23.7 3.2 -45.1 73.9 0.5 1

    February -17.6 12.9 -44.5 67.6 0.8 0.8

  • 92

    March -5.4 19.4 -37.0 54.2 1.8 1.8

    April 5.9 29.6 -19 42.5 2.7 5

    May 13.2 32.0 -9.5 41.9 2.9 7.6

    June 18.8 34.8 -0.5 46.2 2.4 21

    July 20.5 36.9 3.2 50.7 2.1 27.4

    August 18.0 34.3 -2.4 52.3 1.7 20.6

    September 11.3 32.0 -8.2 50.1 1.7 3.9

    October 2.2 24.0 -27.8 51.5 1.4 2.8

    November -9.1 15.6 -35.5 63.7 1.1 1.7

    December -18.9 9.2 -44.6 72.7 0.7 1.5

    Average 1.3 36.9 -45.1 55.4 1.7 95.0 Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

    4. Hydrology – Water Resources

  • 93

    Figure V-14: Khovd River Basin – Location of Hydrological Gauging Stations and Tsul-Ulaan

    Irrigation Scheme Source: TA Consultant based on National Atlas

    Table V-18: Water Resources of the Khovd River at Tsul-Ulaan Subproject Area

    Month

    Mean Maximum Discharge

    m3/s

    Mean Minimum Discharge

    m3/s

    Mean Discharge

    m3/s

    % of Annual

    Discharge

    April 50.1 14.7 28.6 3.78

    May 109.3 30.4 65.5 8.65

    June 272.2 53.9 146.2 19.3

    July 358.3 63.4 183.1 24.2

    August 237.5 51.1 131.5 17.37

    September 117.0 31.2 71.2 9.41

    October 66.3 26.4 45.0 5.94

    November 38.7 17.5 27.9 3.68

    December 26.9 7.0 18.7 2.47

    January 22.8 4.2 14.1 1.86

    February 30.1 3.7 12.1 1.60

    March 32.1 3.3 13.1 1.72 Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

    5. Water Quality

  • 94

    Figure V-15: Water Chemistry of the Khovd River

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

    Figure V-16: Suspended solids in the Khovd river water

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

    19 Ministry of Nature and Environment, 1998. Water quality monitoring guidelines.

  • 95

    6. Site Vegetation and Habitats

    Table V-19 Native fish species of the Khar Lake-Khovd Basin

    Species Upstream of Khovd

    River

    Downstream of Khovd and Chonokharaikh rivers, Khar-Us and

    Khar Lakes

    Mongolian grayling (Thymallus brevirostris) + +

    Siberian grayling (Thymallus arcticus arcticus) + -

    Stone loach (Barbatula toni) (See note below) + + Source: Baasanjav, G. and Tsendayush, Y. 2001. Fishes of Mongolia. ADMON, Ulaanbaatar

  • 96

    • Mongolian grayling (Thymallus brevirostris) is vulnerable regionally (in Mongolia) and on a global level. The main threats are (in order) from habitat degradation (mainly sedimentation from mining), fishing and pollution.

    • Siberian grayling (Thymallus arcticus arcticus) is near threatened regionally (in Mongolia) and not assessed on a global level. The main threats are illegal fishing (commercial), habitat degradation due to pollution from gold mining, and habitat loss caused by gold mining and falling river levels.

    • Stone loach (Barbatula toni) is not threatened (least concern) regionally (in Mongolia) and not assessed on a global level. However, desk top research shows that this species is more likely to occur in the Pacific (Amur) watershed in the western region and the Selenge River Basin in the central region, and if often misidentified in the western region.

    G. Subproject 6 – Ulaandel Irrigation Scheme

    1. Location, Geography and Topography

  • 97

    Figure V-17: Location of Ulaandel Irrigation Scheme Source: TA Consultants based on Google Map

    2. Soils

    Figure V-18: Soil Map of Ulaandel Irrigation Scheme

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

    Table V-20: Soil Profile of Ulaandel Irrigation Scheme

  • 98

    Soil horizon

    Depth, m

    Characteristic

    1 A 0.0-0.25 Grey brown soil. > 2mm Stone and gravel around 30 % of soil. High calcic soil. Sandy loam

    2 E 0.25-0.5 5-10 cm diameter gravel occurs and by the water erosion affected to clay particle sediment to down layer between sand and gravel.

    3 B 0.5-0.7 Sand and gravel.

    Source: Integrated agricultural laboratory

    3. Climate

    Table V-21: Mean Monthly Climate Data in the Ulaandel Irrigation Subproject Area

    Month Average Temperature

    (oC)

    Maximum Temperature

    (oC)

    Minimum Temperature

    (oC)

    Humidity (%)

    Wind speed (m/s)

    Precipitation (mm)

    January -21.9 3.2 -46.1 55.0 2.5 0.6

    February -16.5 5.1 -42.7 49.2 2.7 0.5

    March -7.7 17.1 -34.3 40.4 3.7 1.4

    April 1.9 24.1 -21.0 36.5 4.2 4.1

    May 9.1 28.9 -10.9 36.5 4.2 9.9

    June 14.8 31.3 -2.3 41.1 3.4 20.4

    July 16.7 34.6 0.0 43.8 3.2 26.1

    August 14.5 30.6 -2.4 45.2 2.9 21.2

    September 8.0 32.8 -11.1 43.4 2.9 5.7

    October -0.4 20.1 -22.8 45.3 3.3 2.6

    November -10.9 12.5 -33.0 49.7 3.3 1.3

    December -18.2 7.0 -39.7 53.6 2.8 1.0 Average -0.9 34.6 -46.1 45.0 3.3 94.7

    Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

  • 99

    4. Hydrology – Water Resources

    Figure V-19: Khar-Us Lake-Khovd River Basin Showing Ulaandel Irrigation Scheme,

    Hydrological Gauging Stations and Meteorological Observation Stations Source: TA Consultants based on National Atlas

  • 100

    Table V-22: Water Resources of the Sagsai River at Ulaandel Subproject Area

    Month Maximum Discharge

    (m3/s) Minimum Discharge

    (m3/s) Mean Discharge

    (m3/s) % of Annual Discharge

    April 20.0 0.06 6.87 3.79

    May 59.8 8.11 24.5 13.5

    June 112.0 11.40 39.7 21.9

    July 94.6 16.54 41.5 22.9

    August 71.1 9.74 27.9 15.4

    September 33.7 3.59 16.0 8.81

    October 24.7 0.02 9.44 5.21

    November 13.5 0.02 5.30 2.92

    December 9.3 0.04 3.23 1.78

    January 7.2 0.01 2.33 1.28

    February 6.5 0.01 1.84 1.02

    March 7.5 0.08 2.61 1.44 Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

    5. Water Quality

    Figure V-20: Water Chemistry of the Sagsai River

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

    20 MNS-ISO-16075-1:2018 Guidelines for treated wastewater use for irrigation projects: The basis of a project for irrigation

  • 101

    Figure V-21: Suspended solids in the Sagsai river water

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

    6. Site Vegetation and Habitats

  • 102

    Table V-23 Native fish species of the Khar Lake-Khovd Basin

    Species Upstream of Khovd River

    Downstream of Khovd and Chonokharaikh Rivers, Khar-Us and

    Khar Lakes

    Mongolian grayling (Thymallus brevirostris) + +

    Siberian grayling (Thymallus arcticus arcticus) + -

    Stone loach (Barbatula toni) (See note below) + + Source: Baasanjav, G. and Tsendayush, Y. 2001. Fishes of Mongolia. ADMON, Ulaanbaatar

    • Mongolian grayling (Thymallus brevirostris) is vulnerable regionally (in Mongolia) and on a global level. The main threats are (in order) from habitat degradation (mainly sedimentation from mining), fishing and pollution.

    • Siberian grayling (Thymallus arcticus arcticus) is near threatened regionally (in Mongolia) and not assessed on a global level. The main threats are illegal fishing (commercial), habitat degradation due to pollution from gold mining, and habitat loss caused by gold mining and falling river levels.

    • Stone loach (Barbatula toni) is not threatened (least concern) regionally (in Mongolia) and not assessed on a global level. However, desk top research shows that this species is more likely to occur in the Pacific (Amur) watershed in the western region and the Selenge River Basin in the central region, and if often misidentified in the western region.

  • 103

    H. Subproject 7 – Khuren Tal Irrigation Scheme

    1. Location, Geography and Topography

    Figure V-22. The location of Khuren Tal Irrigation Scheme

    Source: TA Consultant based on Google Map

    2. Soils

  • 104

    Figure V-23. Soil Map – Khuren tal Irrigation Scheme

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

    Table V-24. Soil profile

    Soil horizon

    Depth, m

    Characteristic

    1 A 0-0.3 Grass Root zone with slightly decomposed organic matter. Sandy loam soil and surface filled with small gravel.

    2 E 0.3-0.4 Grey brown soil. Less stone and gravel. Low calcic soil. Sandy loam

    3 B 0.4-0.6 Sandy loam, low calcic layer.

    https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/percolating

  • 105

    4 C >0.6 Fully saturated sandy clay soil with gravel

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

    3. Climate

    Table V-25. Mean monthly climate data in the Khurental irrigation subproject area

    Average Temperature

    oC

    Maximum Temperature

    oC

    Minimum Temperature

    oC

    Humidity %

    Wind speed, m/s

    Precipitation mm

    January -22.4 -0.2 -42.1 70.4 0.9 3.0

    February -18.6 8.0 -42.3 66.7 1.0 2.6

    March -10.1 15.3 -37.2 58.7 1.5 4.3

    April 1.5 23.9 -24.4 47.1 2.1 7.9

    May 9.0 29.2 -12.4 43.3 2.4 17.3

    June 14.4 32.7 -3.8 47.6 2.2 34.8

    July 16.5 35.8 0.1 52.0 2.0 58.9

    August 14.0 32.0 -3.2 55.3 1.8 49.0

    September 7.8 27.2 -13.5 52.4 1.8 24.0

    October -0.7 21 -29.5 55.2 1.5 8.9

    November -12.4 10.5 -36.7 65.2 1.2 5.3

    December -19.7 4 -39.8 69.8 1.0 3.9

    Average -1.7 35.8 -42.3 57.0 1.6 219.8 Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

  • 106

    4. Hydrology - Water Resources

    Figure V-24. Ider River Basin – Location of Khurental irrigation scheme, Hydrological Gauging

    Stations and Meteorological observation stations Source: TA Consultant based on National Map

    Table V-26. Water resources of the Ider river at Khuren tal subproject area

    Month Maximum Discharge

    m3/s Minimum Discharge

    m3/s Mean Discharge

    m3/s % of Annual Discharge

    April 8.8 0.00 2.24 3.70

    May 24.3 1.01 9.57 15.8

  • 107

    June 32.1 0.60 9.79 16.1

    July 36.2 0.15 11.24 18.5

    August 48.9 1.22 13.63 22.5

    September 21.0 1.25 9.00 14.8

    October 18.4 0.64 3.95 6.52

    November 2.2 0.00 0.59 0.98

    December 1.7 0.00 0.19 0.31

    January 1.2 0.00 0.11 0.19

    February 1.3 0.00 0.11 0.19

    March 1.9 0.00 0.18 0.30 Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

    5. Water Quality

    Figure V-25: Water chemistry of the Ider River

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

    Figure V-26: Suspended solids in the Ider River water

  • 108

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

    6. Site Vegetation and Habitats

    Figure V-27: Current Situation for Khuren Tal Irrigation Scheme (Upper: head work/intake;

    lower: main canal and cropland)

  • 109

    I. Subproject 8 – Nogoon Khashaa Irrigation Scheme

    1. Location, Geography and Topography

    Figure V-28: The location of Nogoon Khashaa Irrigation Scheme

    Source: Based on Google Maps.

    2. Soils

  • 110

    Figure V-29. Soil Map of Nogoon Khashaa Subproject Area

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

    Table V-27: Soil Profile of Nogoon Khashaa Subproject Area

  • 111

    Soil horizon

    Depth, m

    Characteristic

    1 A 0.0-0.3 Silty clay loam, High organic matter, dark brown color. High carbonate content

    2 E 0.3-0.6 Light color soil. loamy clay. High carbonate content, less organic matter than upper layer.

    3 B >0.6 Silty clay. High carbonate content

    4 C >0.9 Gravel and sandy loam.

    Source: Integrated agricultural laboratory

    3. Climate

    Table V-28: Mean Monthly Climate Data in the Nogoon Khashaa Irrigation Subproject Area

    Month Average Temperature

    (oC)

    Absolute Maximum

    Temperature (oC)

    Absolute Minimum

    Temperature (oC)

    Humidity (%)

    Wind speed, (m/s)

    Precipitation, (mm)

    January -22.4 -0.2 -42.1 70.4 0.9 3.0

    February -18.6 8.0 -42.3 66.7 1.0 2.6

    March -10.1 15.3 -37.2 58.7 1.5 4.3

    April 1.5 23.9 -24.4 47.1 2.1 7.9

    May 9.0 29.2 -12.4 43.3 2.4 17.3

    June 14.4 32.7 -3.8 47.6 2.2 34.8

    July 16.5 35.8 0.1 52.0 2.0 58.9

    August 14.0 32.0 -3.2 55.3 1.8 49.0

    September 7.8 27.2 -13.5 52.4 1.8 24.0

    October -0.7 21 -29.5 55.2 1.5 8.9

    November -12.4 10.5 -36.7 65.2 1.2 5.3

    December -19.7 4 -39.8 69.8 1.0 3.9 Average -1.7 35.8 -42.3 57.0 1.6 219.8

    Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

  • 112

    4. Hydrology – Water Resources

    Figure V-30: Khyargas Lake-Zavkhan River Basin

    Source: TA consultant based on National atlas

    Table V-29: Water Resources of the Sagsai River at Nogoon Khashaa Subproject Area

  • 113

    Month Maximum Discharge

    (m3/s) Minimum Discharge

    (m3/s) Mean Discharge

    (m3/s) % of Annual Discharge

    April 23.1 0.17 4.87 10.44

    May 26.7 0.95 9.17 19.7

    June 20.8 0.60 6.41 13.7

    July 24.0 0.64 7.08 15.2

    August 45.4 0.28 7.53 16.2

    September 19.2 0.25 5.35 11.5

    October 12.7 0.39 2.90 6.21

    November 4.56 0.26 1.23 2.64

    December 1.66 0.04 0.57 1.23

    January 1.64 0.00 0.42 0.90

    February 1.77 0.00 0.42 0.89

    March 2.05 0.01 0.68 1.46 Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

    5. Water Quality

    Figure V-31: Water Chemistry of the Chigestei River

    Source: Central Laboratory of Environment and Metrology

  • 114

    Figure V-32: Suspended Solids in Chigestei River Water

    Source: Central Laboratory of Environment and Metrology

    6. Site Vegetation and Habitats

  • 115

    Figure V-33: Current Situation for Nogoon Khashaa Irrigation Scheme (Upper: head

    work/intake; lower: main canal and cropland)

    Species Rivers Lakes

    Mongolian grayling (Thymallus brevirostris) + +

    Stone loach (Barbatula toni) (see note below) + +

    Potanini`s osman (Oreoleuciscus potanini Kessler) + +

    Source: Baasanjav, G. and Tsendayush, Y. 2001. Fishes of Mongolia. ADMON, Ulaanbaatar

  • 116

    J. Subproject 9 – Iven Gol Irrigation Scheme

    1. Location, Geography and Topography

    Figure V-34: Location of Iven Gol Irrigation Scheme on the North Side of Iven River Valley

    Source: TA Consultant based on Google Map

    2. Soils

    Figure V-35: Soil Map of Iven Gol Irrigation Scheme

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

  • 117

    Table V-30: Soil profile

    Soil horizon

    Depth, m Characteristic

    1 A 0.0-0.3 Silty clay loam, High organic matter, dark brown color. High carbonate content

    2 E 0.3-0.6 Light color soil. loamy clay. High carbonate content, less organic matter than upper layer.

    3 B >0.6 Silty clay. High carbonate content

    4 C >0.9 Gravel and sandy loam.

    Source: Integrated agricultural laboratory

    3. Climate

    Table V-31: Mean Monthly Climate Data at Iven Gol Irrigation Subproject

    Month Average Temperature

    (oC)

    Absolute Maximum

    Temperature (oC)

    Absolute Minimum

    Temperature (oC)

    Humidity (%)

    Wind speed (m/s)

    Precipitation (m)

    January -25.0 1.5 -48.5 76.0 0.6 2.7

    February -19.7 8.1 -42.5 75.6 0.8 2.4

  • 118

    March -7.7 22.9 -36.0 66.9 1.9 2.8

    April 3.8 30.0 -23.3 48.9 2.9 6.4

    May 11.6 35.6 -12.2 48.2 2.8 20.4

    June 17.3 39.8 -5.0 54.7 2.4 55.4

    July 19.7 43.0 -1.1 62.8 1.9 72.0

    August 17.1 39.1 -0.3 67.2 1.7 72.7

    September 10.1 33.0 -9.4 63.3 1.9 32.3

    October 1.3 28.3 -25.1 64.9 1.6 8.7

    November -11.0 19.1 -36.5 73.8 1.0 5.2

    December -20.7 10.4 -44.0 77.1 0.6 4.0

    Average -0.3 43.0 -48.5 64.9 1.7 284.9 Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

    4. Hydrology - Water Resources

  • 119

    Figure V-36: Iven Gol River Basin with Location of Irrigation Scheme, Gauging Station and

    Meteorological Station Source: TA consultants based on National Atlas

    Figure V-37: Iven Gol River Flow Control Measurement

    Source: TA consultants’ field survey

    Table V-32: Control Discharge Measurement, Iven Gol River (2019.06.11) River

    Location Coordinates Hm F

    m2 B m

    V m/sec

    h m

    Q m3/sec

    Remarks

    Iven Gol Sant Soum

    49o 16’ 15.7” 105o 16’ 49.3” 789 1.48 5.20 0.15 0.28 0.23

    Water is clear, no smell, no odor, pH=8.8 EC-124 μS/m

    Source: TA consultants

  • 120

    Table V-33: Water Resources in Iven Gol River for Iven Gol Subproject Area

    Month Mean Discharge

    (m3/s) % of Annual Discharge

    April 0.60 8.27

    May 0.90 8.88

    June 0.92 11.60

    July 1.11 17.80

    August 1.18 19.71

    September 0.98 17.23

    October 0.55 11.52

    November 0.17 2.65

    December 0.02 0.37

    January 0.02 0.33

    February 0.02 0.25

    March 0.09 1.46 a Derived with reference to the available data for flow estimation in the overall inclusive Orkhon River Basin Source: TA consultants

    5. Water Quality

    6. Site Vegetation and Habitats

    21 MET, 2015, Surface water regime and water resource of Mongolia, [Editor G.Davaa]. Ulaanbaatar. P.

  • 121

    Table V-34: Threatened fish species believed to be present in the Orkhon River

    Mongolian

    name

    English name Latin name

    International

    status

    Regional

    status

    Fish

    1 Shiver khilem Siberian

    Sturgeon

    Acipenser baerii Endangered Critically

    Endangered

    2 Tul Siberian

    Taimen

    Hucho taimen Vulnerable Endangered

    3 Zevge Sharp-snouted

    Lenok

    Brachymystax Lenox Not Rated Vulnerable

    4 Shiwer khadran Artic Grayling Thymallus arcticus Least Concern Near

    threatened Source: Baasanjav, G. and Tsendayush, Y. 2001. Fishes of Mongolia. ADMON, Ulaanbaatar

    K. Subproject 10 – Okhindiin Tal Irrigation Scheme

    1. Location, Geography and Topography

    Figure V.x: Location of Okhindiin Tal Irrigation Scheme

    2. Soils

  • 122

    Figure V.x. Okhindiin tal Irrigation Subproject Soil Map

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

    Table V.x: Soil Profile

    Soil horizon

    Depth, m

    Characteristic

    1 O 0.0-0.3 Sandy and silt loam, High organic matter, dark brown color. High carbonate content

    2 A 0.3-0.6 Dark color soil. loamy clay. High carbonate content, less organic matter than upper layer.

    3 E >0.6 Silty loam. High carbonate content

    Source: Integrated agricultural laboratory

  • 123

    3. Climate

    Table V.x: Mean Monthly Climate Data in the Okhindiin Tal Irrigation Subproject Area Average

    Temperature, oC

    Absolute Maximum

    Temperature, oC

    Absolute Minimum

    Temperature, oC

    Humidity % Wind speed,

    m/s

    Precipitation, mm

    January -22.9 -18.3 -27.8 74.2 1.4 3.1

    February -18.2 -11.4 -24 71.6 1.5 2.4

    March -6.6 1.2 -12.8 61.9 2.2 3.1

    April 3.9 12.8 -2.2 48 2.9 9.7

    May 11.5 20.2 4.4 48.4 3.1 22

    June 17.7 26.8 11.6 56.3 2.6 49.6

    July 19.9 28.2 14.7 64.1 2.1 71.3

    August 17.4 25.3 12 68.6 2.1 73.3

    September 10.3 10.3 4.8 65.3 2.1 36

    October 1.5 1.5 -3.7 65.1 1.9 11

    November -9.9 -9.9 -14.8 71.7 1.7 5.8

    December -19.3 -19.3 -24.1 74.6 1.5 3.9

    Average 0.4 7.7 -5.2 64.1 2.1 291.2

  • 124

    4. Hydrology - Water Resources

    Figure V.x: Confluence of the Selenge and Orkhon Rivers

    Source: Gidrocom Co.Ltd

    Table V.x: Selenge River Water Resources for Okhindiin Tal Subproject Area

    Month Mean

    Maximum Discharge (m3/s)

    Mean Minimum Discharge

    (m3/s)

    Mean Discharge (m3/s)

    April 379.0 50.7 191.8

    May 728.0 176.0 346.1

    June 737.9 125.0 331.8

  • 125

    July 1252.0 160.7 442.7

    August 2465.0 135.0 544.9

    September 1465.0 114.0 458.3

    October 751.0 110.0 288.4

    November 309.0 43.9 137.2

    December 118.0 22.5 55.1

    January 95.5 11.3 37.7

    February 113.0 11.3 31.7

    March 152.0 17.5 42.8

    Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

    Figure V.x: Water Chemistry of the Selenge River

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

  • 126

    Figure V.x: Suspended Solids in Selenge River Water

    Source: Central Laboratory for Environment and Metrology

    5. Site vegetation and Habitats

    Figure V.X: Land Cover of Pasture Grasses on the Subproject Site.

  • 127

    Figure V.x: important bird area MN054 (left) and the subproject site’s location within the IBBA (right). Source: IBAT query, October 2019.

    22 BirdLife International. 2019. Important Bird Areas factsheet: Delta of Orkhon and Selenge Rivers. Downloaded from http://www.birdlife.org on 21/10/2019.

    http://www.birdlife.org/

  • 128

    Table V.x: Threatened fish species are believed to be present in the Selenge River

    Common name Scientific name Global Regional status

    Siberian Sturgeon Acipenser baerii Endangered Not Rated

    Siberian Taimen Hucho taimen Vulnerable Not Rated

    Sharp-snouted Lenok Brachymystax lenox Not Rated Vulnerable

    23 https://www.ramsar.org/document/the-ramsar-sites-criteria

  • 129

    L. Subproject 11 – Sugnugur Irrigation Scheme

    1. Location, Geography and Topography

    Figure V-38: Sugnugur Irrigation Scheme Plan and Overview

    Source: TA consultants based on Google Map

    2. Soils

  • 130

    Figure V-39: Soil Map of the Sugnugur Subproject Area

    Source: Institute of Geography and Geo-ecology

    Table V-35: Soil Profile

    Soil horizon

    Depth (m)

    Characteristic

    1 A 0.0-0.6 Silt loam, High organic matter, dark brown color. less carbonate content

    2 E 0.6-0.8 Loamy soils.

    3 B >0.8 Loamy. Medium react with carbonate content

  • 131

    4 C >1.2 Gravel and sandy loam

    Source: Integrated agricultural laboratory

    3. Climate

    Table V-36: Mean Monthly Climate Data for Sugnugur Irrigation Subproject

    Month Average Temperature

    (oC)

    Maximum Temperature

    (oC)

    Minimum Temperature

    (oC)

    Humidity (%)

    Wind speed (m/s)

    Precipitation (mm)

    January -26.0 -2.2 -46.5 70.2 2.1 2.4

    February -21.3 5.9 -46.0 66.3 2.5 2.4

    March -10.1 19.4 -36.9 61.0 3.3 2.8

    April 1.5 27.9 -24.7 48.1 4.2 6.4

    May 9.1 29.5 -18.9 47.4 4.3 21.6

    June 15.2 27.9 -3.5 54.1 3.7 36.3

    July 17.8 31.0 0.5 62.4 3.1 56.6

    August 15.4 29.3 -1.5 64.3 3.1 70.8

    September 8.1 21.0 -14.0 59.0 3.4 25.3

    October -0.6 23.2 -21.6 58.5 3.2 7.5

    November -13.2 14.2 -35.0 65.9 2.7 4.0

    December -22.0 3.0 -41.7 70.1 2.3 4.1

    Average -2.2 23.1 -24.2 60.6 3.2 240.2 Source: National Agency for Meteorology and Environment Monitoring

  • 132

    4. Hydrology – Water Resources

    Figure V-40: Sugnugur River Basin with Sugnugur Irrigation Scheme and Gauging Station

    Source: Consultant based on National atlas