inflation and unemployment inflation 1. historical experience of inflation 2. causes of inflation 3....
TRANSCRIPT
INFLATION AND UNEMPLOYMENT
INFLATION
1. Historical experience of inflation
2. Causes of inflation
3. Costs of inflation: why is inflation a problem?
4. How can inflation be controlled?
UNEMPLOYMENT
1. Historical experience
2. Causes of unemployment
3. Policies to reduce unemployment
CAUSES OF INFLATION: THEORY
1. The quantity theory of money: inflation in the long-run
2. The excess demand model of inflation
3. Supply-side explanations of inflation: cost-push
4. A dynamic model of inflation: the wage price spiral
The quantity theory of money
Expenditure = Sales
quantity x velocity = price level x outputof money of circulation (P) (y) (M) (V)
MV = Py
Suppose V and y are constant
then P = (V/y)M
or rate of change in P = rate of change in M
Excess demand model of inflation
If AD > AS……….prices riseif AD < AS……….prices fall
AS
AD1
AD2
P2
P1
y1 y2
AD3
y3
Price
Output
But can output continue to rise?
AD can increase for several reasons:
• consumption suddenly increases
• investment increases (expectations improve)
• money supply increases (fall in r)
• exports increase (world trade expands)
Supply-side explanations of inflation
AD
AS1
AS4AS3
AS2
Price
Output
P4
P3
P2
P1
y1 y2 y3 y4
Supply-side:• increase in wages• increase in import prices• price-fixing by suppliers
Interaction between demand and supply
P1
P2
P3
y*
AD1
AD2
AD3
AS1
AS2
AS3
Govt policy is to keep y at y*:- increase in costs offset by govt expansionary policy
But what about continued increase in prices?
Inflation is self-perpetuating:
• the wage-price spiral- wages ‘cause’ prices- prices ‘cause’ wages
• expectations of inflation- wage negotiators look at future price levels
A dynamic model of inflation: the wage price spiral
The wage-price spiral: a dynamic model of inflation
Demand shockDemand for
goods increases
Demand for labour increases
Wages increase
Prices increase
Supply shock:wage push
Supply shock:e.g. OPEC
Real wagebargaining
Cost-pluspricing
A dynamic model of inflation: the augmented Phillips curve
Price inflation
Wage inflation
Inflationary expectations: low
Inflationary expectations: high
p1
0u1
Inflation
Unemployment0
The Phillips Curve ‘Trade-off’
I
II
III
Inflation = Expected inflation - U
COSTS OF INFLATION
• menu costs
• shoe-leather costs: searching for best buy
• adverse effects on fixed income groups
• adverse effects on savings
•adverse effects on growth of GDP / capita - lower investment due to uncertainty - shortens investors time horizon (quick returns)
• costly to reduce inflation: dis-inflation => unemployment
• hyper-inflation is economically and politically disastrous - complete collapse of market economy - political instability
An example of hyper-inflation: Germany 1923
Price index1921 July 1
1922 July 7
1923 Jan 195
July 5,230August 66,017Sept 1,674,755Oct 496,209,790Nov 15 54,448,000,000
COSTS OF DEFLATION
• borrowers find their real debts increasing - discourages borrowing - fall in asset prices reduces consumption
• lenders lose if debtors go bankrupt
• prices decline but wages are sticky - decline in demand for labour - fall in profits and investment
• real interest rates increase - discourages investment
• leads to persistent recession: consumers delay spending
CONTROL OF INFLATION
• requires a powerful commitment to stable prices - implies strict control over G (G = T)
• control over inflation in hands of CB - inflation is lower in countries with independent CB
• govt needs to set clear inflation targets - avoids govt pressure to relax monetary policy
• govt not permitted to finance deficits through creation of high-powered money - must borrow from private sector
•supply-side policies needed - labour market flexibility - anti-monopoly policy to increase competition
• high level of scrutiny of CB needed - openness of how decisions are reached - subject to scrutiny / questioning by elected body • increasing emphasis placed on controlling interest rates - less emphasis on controlling money supply - use open market operations to control interest rates
•accurate forecasts of macro-economy needed - lagged effect of monetary policy on economy - need forecasts of turning points - need to forecast ‘leading indicators’ (change in stock, long-term bond yields, commodity prices, overtime working)
• stopping hyper-inflation - nominal exchange rate ‘anchor’(e.g. dollarisation) (to restrain cost-push inflation, including imported inflation)
- restrictive fiscal policies (balanced budget) - tight monetary policies (e.g. via independent CB) - structural reforms (liberalise financial markets, flexible labour markets, free trade, privatisation of public enterprise, anti-monopoly policies)
Argentina 1989-94
Fiscal balance Inflation Growth (% GDP)
1988 -5.6 340 -1.91989 -0.6 3000 -6.21990 +1.4 2300 0.11991 +1.7 170 8.01992 +2.2 24 8.71993 +2.2 10 6.01994 +1.1 3 4.5
Short-term pain = long-term gain?
Has inflation been beaten?• strong public support for price stability - ageing population prefers low inflation
• financial markets strongly averse to inflation - govt keeps close eye on financial markets - pre-emptive action taken v. inflation
• greater price competition - supply-side changes (labour markets, privatisation, internet trading, creation of new markets) - erosion of trade union power
• less vulnerable to oil price hikes - more alternative sources of energy - diversification in use of energy
UNEMPLOYMENT
• varies between countries
• varies within countries over time
• varies within countries at any point in time
CAUSES OF UNEMPLOYMENT
• collapse in aggregate demand
Policy action: - need for fiscal / monetary policy action
• mismatch between labour demand and labour supply - geographical immobility of labour - skill / occupational mismatch
Policy action: - need for spatial policies - re-training programmes
• welfare benefits ‘too high’ Policy action: - creation of work incentives (New Deal) • hiring / firing costs too high - employment legislation ‘too tough on employers’
Policy action: - reduce fixed costs of employing labour
• wages too high (trade union power) - wages are sticky downwards - efficiency wage v. nominal wage
Policy action: - more flexible wages needed (especially with fixed exchange rate e.g. euro)
NATURAL RATE OF UNEMPLOYMENT
Definition: unemployment existing when the economy is in equilibrium (AD =AS)
Determinants:
• job search
• structural factors (mismatch)
• voluntary unemployment
• unemployment benefit
• hysteresis and long-term unemployment
CHARACTERISTICS OF HIGH UNEMPLOYMENT COUNTRIES
1. Unemployment benefit• available for long periods• no pressure on unemployed to get a job 2. Unions• high degree of unionisation• unions very active in wage negotiations• no co-ordination in collective bargaining
3. Taxation• high payroll taxes• high minimum wages• high income taxes