indonesia aid effectiveness

8/14/2019 Indonesia Aid Effectiveness

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/indonesia-aid-effectiveness 1/17

Egfkgaxed Pkdf Od|jkp Def Ajjahvezagaxx

Nqievd F' Vqsk

Fa|qvu Oegexvap+Hmdepodg jkp Fazank|oagv JqgfegcOegexvpu kj Gdvekgdn Fazank|oagv \ndggegc+@d||agdx

Odgend. 06/01 Dqcqxv 0<<5



0

… kgnu jkp Madnvm xahvkp



Okgvapau -0<<0%.Egvapgdvekgdn Hkgjapagha kg Jegdghegc jkp Fazank|oagv.

dcpaaf vk |pkzefa okpa jegdghegc jkp fazank|oagv.dgf def ajjahvezagaxx

Vma Bdidpvd Hkooevoagv2 Def Jkp Fazank|oagv Ajjahvezagaxx. Egfkgaxed―x Pkdf Od| Vk 0<46

Fkmd -Gkz 0<<=%. Jknnks/q| Egvapgdvekgdn Hkgjapagha

kg Jegdghegc jkp Fazank|oagv

agfkpxaf Fkmd Fahndpdvekg kg Jegdghegc jkp Fazank|oagv.

padjjepoegc vma Okgvappau Hkgxagxqx

Pkoa -0<<8%

Mecm/Nazan Jkpqo kg Mdpokgerdvekg.

hkooevvaf vk vdia dhvekg vk eo|pkza vma odgdcaoagv

dgf ajjahvezagaxx kj def. dgf

vk vdia xvkhi kj hkghpava |pkcpaxx

Eg ndva 455<x. egvapgdvekgdn okzaoagvx kj DEF padneraf vmdv vpdgxdhvekg hkxv kj def sdx xecgejehdgv.`acdg skpiegc vk mdpokgera

Oenaxvkgax eg Def Ajjahvezagaxx

\dpex -0<<1%. Mecm/Nazan Jkpqo

agfkpxaf vma \dpex Fahndpdvekg kg

Def Ajjahvezagaxx vk |pkokva vma ajjahveza qxa

kj def jqgfx'

Dhhpd -Xa|v 0<<=%. Mecm/Nazan Jkpqoagfkpxaf Dhhpd Dcagfd kj Dhvekg+DDD

vk dhhanapdva |pkcpaxx eg Def Ajjahvezagaxx

8



Egfkgaxed―x Fazank|oagv Hmdnnagca Egfkgaxed ex d oeffna eghkoa hkqgvpeax. sevm d 08< oennekg

kj |k|qndvekg' Uav. Egfkgaxed hkgvegqax vk jdha xecgejehdgvfazank|oagv hmdnnagcax. ax|ahednnu eg vma dpadx kj |kzapvupafqhvekg. xapzeha fanezapu dgf fahagvpdnerdvekg'

\kzapvu pdvax mdza jdnnag vk 46'4! eg 0<<5. uav ndpcagqo`apx kj Egfkgaxedgx paodeg |kkp dgf zqngapd`na'

Pacekgdn fex|dpeveax dpa d iau jadvqpa kj |kzapvu eg vmahkqgvpu. cezag vma zdxv xera dgf zdpuegc hkgfevekgx egfejjapagv |dpvx kj vma hkqgvpu'

Jqpvmap ajjkpvx ex xvenn gaafaf jkp Egfkgaxed vk oaav dnn vmaOFC vdpcavx'

Vma eo|naoagvdvekg kj fahagvpdnerdvekg paodegx hko|na}dgf hkgvegqax vk |kxa hmdnnagcax'

Agkpokqx ajjkpvx ex xvenn gaafaf vk dffpaxx hneodva hmdgcaexxqax -oevecdvekg dgf dfd|vekg%

6



1

KFD Hkgvpe`qvekg vk Fazank|oagv

Ajjahvezagaxx

Vma odeg hkgxvpdegv 2 gkv vma ndhi kj jegdghedn paxkqphax `qvvma gaaf vk vpdgxndva vma a}exvegc paxkqphax egvk àvvapfazank|oagv kqvhkoax vk od}eoera vma ajjahvezagaxx kj dnn evx paxkqphax hkooevvaf vk fazank|oagv. eghnqfegca}vapgdn dxxexvdgha'

Vkvdn dnn cpdgvx dgf nkdgx naxx vmdg 1! kj ckzapgoagvx|agfegc9

Mks hdg KFD hkgvpe`qva vk fazank|oagv ajjahvezagaxx;† Vk agxqpa okpa ajjahveza dgf ajjeheagv qvenerdvekg kj

fkoaxveh paxkqphax vk dhhaxx egvapgdvekgdn igksnafcadgf àxv |pdhveha. dgf vk agmdgha egxvevqvekgdn hd|dhevu.

† Vk axvd`nexm xuxvaox vmdv dpa q| vk xvdgfdpfx kj egvapgdvekgdn àxv |pdhveha' Ev ex d`kqv |qvvegc vma pecmvxuxvaox eg |ndha'

Egfkgaxed skqnf neia vk 2† \dpvehe|dva eg dgf egjnqagha egvapgdvekgdn def dphmevahvqpa

jpko d OEH |apx|ahveza† Od}eoera eo|dhv kj fahnegegc Kjjehedn Fazank|oagv

Dxxexvdgha jkp fazank|oagv ajjahvezagaxx

† A}|dgf |dpvgapxme|x sevm dnvapgdveza jkpox kj jegdgha



KFD Hkgvpe`qvekg vk Fazank|oagv

Ajjahvezagaxx

:

Fazank|oagvAjjahvezagaxx

Xkqgf \pkcpdo

Egxvpqoagvx-@qfcav.

\pkhqpaoagv. avh%

Paxkqphax-Jqgf. MqodgHd|evdn. avh%

DEF AJJAHVEZAGAXX



3

Egfkgaxedg Pkdf Od| vk

Fazank|oagv Ajjahvezagaxx

\dpex Fahndpdvekg -0<<1% dgf DhhpdDcagfd jkp Dhvekg -0<<=% ‘ vdiegc evjqpvmap

Bdidpvd Hkooevoagvx2† Bkegv dx|epdvekgx -gkv nacdnnu `egfegc%

pacqndpnu pazeasaf† Vmpaa dpadx kj hkooevoagvx

Dhvekg |ndg dgf Vdpcavx vk 0<4< dgfzexekg vk 0<46



\dpex Fahndpdvekg -0<<1%

Jpko fkgkpxme| vk ksgapxme|

Fazank|oagv

Ajjahvezagaxx

6 'P a

x qn v x . *

1 'O q v q dn d

h h k qg v d ` e n e v u

Ksgapxme|-\dpvgap hkqgvpeax%

\dpvgapxxav vmadcagfd

4

Dnecgegc sevm|dpvgapx―

dcagfd

Qxegc|dpvgapx― xuxvaox

Dnecgoagv-Fkgkpx / \dpvgap%

0

Mdpokgexdvekg-Fkgkpx / Fkgkpx%

Axvd`nexmegchkookg

dppdgcaoagvx

Xeo|nejuegc|pkhafqpax

Xmdpegcegjkpodvekg

8

=



5

Dhhpd Dcagfd jkp Dhvekg+ DDD-Xa|vao`ap 0/6. 0<<=%

\FD Odiegc |pkcpaxx. `qv gkv agkqcm. dgf senn vdia dhvekg vk dhhanapdva |pkcpaxx

Xvpagcvmagegc Hkqgvpu Ksgapxme| kzap Fazank|oagv

@qenfegc Okpa Ajjahveza dgf Eghnqxeza \dpvgapxme|x jkp

Fazank|oagv Fanezapegc dgf Dhhkqgvegc jkp Fazank|oagv Paxqnvx

Nkkiegc Jkpsdpf

† aghkqpdca fazank|egc hkqgvpeax vk faxecg‖sevm dhveza

xq||kpv jpko fkgkpx‖hkqgvpu/`dxaf dhvekg |ndgx

vmdv xav kqv veoa/`kqgf dgf okgevkpd`na |pk|kxdnx vkeo|naoagv vma \dpex Fahndpdvekg dgf vma Dhhpd Dcagfdjkp Dhvekg



4<

Dpadx kj Hkooevoagvx Hkooevoagv 42 Xvpagcvmagegc Hkqgvpu Ksgapxme| kzap

Fazank|oagv

† Eo|pkzegc vma egvapgdvekgdn ckzapgdgha kj def dgf xvpagcvmagegc xkqvm/xkqvm hkk|apdvekg

† Xvpagcvmagegc hd|dheveax dgf qxegc xvpkgcap ckzapgoagv xuxvaox Fazank|oagv |dpvgapx senn dnecg vmaep |pkcpdooegc huhnax

sevm vmkxa kj ckzapgoagv. qxa vma ckzapgoagv jkpodv jkp pa|kpvegc vmaep

dxxexvdgha. dgf eghpadxegcnu qxa ckzapgoagv#x jegdghedn odgdcaoagv dgf|pkhqpaoagv xuxvaox' Eg vma x|epev kj |dpvgapxme|. sa senn dnxk aghkqpdcafazank|oagv |dpvgapx vk jqnnu. xeghapanu dgf vpdgx|dpagvnu qgvea vmaep def'

Hkooevoagv 02 Fanezapegc dgf Dhhkqgvegc Fazank|oagvPaxqnvx† Xvpagcvmagegc d jkhqx kg. dgf hd|dhevu vk odgdca `u. fazank|oagv paxqnvx

† Skpiegc vkcavmap vk pazeas |pkcpaxx dhpkxx fazank|oagv |dpvgapxme|x

Hkooevoagv 82 @qenfegc Okpa Ajjahveza dgf Eghnqxeza\dpvgapxme|x jkp Fazank|oagv† Fazank|egc d gas |dpvgapxme| |dpdfeco

† Xvpagcvmagegc a}exvegc def egxvpqoagvx dgf xmd|egc gas kgax

† A}|dgfegc fednkcqa vk eghnqfa gas dhvkpx



44

Egfkgaxedg Pkdfod| jkp Def Ajjahvezagaxx-Bdidpvd Hkooevoagvx% ‘ \pkcpaxx

Kj vma vkvdn 8< |dpvgap kj fazank|oagv. 0:|dpvgapx mdza xecgaf vma fkhqoagv'

Sa mdza axvd`nexmaf Xahpavdpedv jkp D6FA.eghnqfegc fkgkp vpqxv jqgf vk xq||kpv ev―x

dhvezeveax'

Vmapa dpa xvenn paxapzdvekgx kg exxqax kg qgvuegcdef. `qfcav dnecgoagv dgf qxegc |pkhqpaoagvxuxvaox' Kgnu xkoa fkgkp mdx d pkdfod| vk

eghpadxa qgvuegc def Okxv F\ egvapzagvekgx+pax|kgxax kg vma dhvekg

odvpe}. adcap vk xaa vma jepxv xva|x vk `a vdiag `uCKE



Oegexvapedn |knehu cqefdgha

D6FA

Vpqxv Jqgf

Odgdcaoagv

Kjjeha

Pa|kpvegc vk

Hmdep kj Odgdcaoagv

Hkooevvaa

Xq||kpvegc dnn nazanx

Pa|kpvegc \knehu Cqefdgha

Jnks kj jqgfx

Jqgfegc Oahmdgexo

Xvaapegc Hkooevvaa

Odgdcaoagv Hkooevvaa

Fazank|oagv

|dpvgapVmaodveh Skpiegc Cpkq|x

Def jkp Fazank|oagv Ajjahvezagaxx Xahpavdpedv

D6FAX Hkkpfegdvekg Oahmdgexo

40



48

Skpiegc Cpkq|x

Qgev+Skpiegc Cpkq| \dpvehe|dvegc F\ "%

SC \pkhqpaoagv S@. DF@. BEHD. Gavmapndgf. Dqxdef

SC \q neh Jegdghedn

Odgdcaoagv

S@. BEHD. Gavmapndgf. Dqxdef.

Xsevrapndgf. FJEF

SC kg Fednkcqa Oahmdgexo S@. BEHD. Gavmapndgf. Dqxdef.Xsevrapndgf. FJEF. HEFD. Capodgu.

Qxdef

SC Fazank|oagv kj Jegdghegc

Oahmdgexo

BEHD. Gavmapndgf. Dqxdef. Xsevrapndgf.

FJEF

SC \ndggegc. Okgevkpegc *Azdnqdvekg

S@. BEHD. Gavmapndgf. Dqxdef.

Xsevrapndgf. Capodgu. FJEF. Qxdef

SC Hd|' @qenfegc * Igksnafca

Odgdcaoagv

S@. BEHD. Dqxdef. Xsevrapndgf. FJEF.

HEFD. QGF\. QXdef

"% Kvmap Fazank|oagv \dpvgapx dpa egzevaf vk bkeg vma Skpiegc

Cpkq|x



\DPEX FAHNDPDVEKG 2 CKZAPGOAGV

\PKHQPAOAGV XVPDVACU

Fedcgkxveh Skpix-0<<5/0<4<%

@dxanega Egfehdvkp *Hko|nedgha \apjkpodgha Egfehdvkp

Cd| Dgdnuxex dgf Pahkooagfdvekg-hkqgvpu xuxvao / faz' |dpvgapx― xuxvao%

Xvpdvacu

Xvpdvaceh \ndg 2C\ Pajkpo -\mdxa 0%

Eo|pkzaoagv kj vma C\―x XuxvaoEo|pkzaoagv kg

Hkqgvpu Xuxvao

Ckzapgoagv ‘ Faz' \dpvgapx

Fednkcqax

Dnecgoagv

Ckzapgoagv ‘ Faz' \dpvgapx

Dhvekg \ndg

Qxegc Hkqgvpu―x

\pkhqpaoagv Xuxvao



GDVEKGDN PAJKPO kg

CKZAPGOAGV \PKHQPAOAGV

8 Dx|ahvx eg C\ Pajkpo 2

Ckzapgoagv \pkhqpaoagv Pajkpo xvdpvaf eg uadp 0<<< jknnksegc vma„gdvekgdn pajkpo 455=‟' C\ pajkpo ex d |dpv kj `qpadqhpdveh dgf jegdghedn

pajkpo'

4' Nacexndvekg dgf Pacqndvkpu Jpdoaskpi'Vma hqppagv gdvekgdn pacqndvekg ex \paxefagvedn Fahpaa Gqoàp =< Uadp 0<<8' \F=<+0<<8 ex d gdvekgdn pacqndvekg dgf cqefanegax vk hdppu kqv |q`neh |pkhqpaoagv ù

hagvpdn+nkhdn ckzapgoagv egxvevqvekgx dgf xvdva/ksgaf agvap|pexax'

0' Xvpagcvmagegc vma \pdhvevekgapx'Xegha 0<<1. |pkhqpaoagv |pdhvevekgapx mdza vk mknf gdvekgdn |pkhqpaoagv

hapvejehdvekg'8' Pajkpo kg Egxvevqvekgdn Jpdoaskpi'

\paxefagvedn Fahpaa Gqoàp 4<: Uadp 0<<3 hkghapgegc Axvd`nexmoagv kj Gdvekgdn\q`neh \pkhqpaoagv Dcaghu -G\\D%' Vma G\\D ex deoaf |dpvehqndpnu vk 2 fazank|xvpdvaceh. |knehu dgf pacqndvekg9 Hkgfqhv okgevkpegc/azdnqdvekg dgf fazank|egc a/|pkhqpaoagv9 fazank| dgf eo|pkza hd|dhevu kj |pkhqpaoagv |pdhvevekgapx9 dgf|pkzefa dfzeha dgf pahkooagfdvekg'



Fdpa vk Fk…

"Zexekg sevmkqv dhvekg ex oapanu d fpado'

Dhvekg sevmkqv zexekg bqxv |dxxax vma veoa'

Zexekg sevm dhvekg hdg hmdgca vma skpnf'"

Bkan @dpiap

4:



Vmdgi ukq

indonesia aid effectiveness

Documents