in the high court of south africa - saflii · 2020-05-21 · 22. c doubell vs raf 72291/15 23. ma...
TRANSCRIPT
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(GAUTENG DIVISION, PRETORIA)
PRETORIA THIS 6TH
DAY OF FEBRUARY 2017
MONDAY
CRIMINAL TRIALS
IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JORDAAN
IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAM
IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICUIS
IN COURT 4E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE POTTERILL
Page 2 of 18
URGENT COURT
IN COURT A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE AA LOUW IN COURT B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEWENHUIZEN
CRIMINAL APPEALS
IN COURT4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRINSLOO BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MADIMA
Name of Advocate for the state : Scheepers No. Case no. Name of appellant Jail/Bail
1. A855/15 N A Tshoka unknown
2. A238/16 L M Ndubane unknown
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHUBELA
Name of Advocate for the state : Coetzee
No. Case no. Name of appellant Jail/Bail
1. A349/13 F K Mbelu
2. A116/16 P P Dilint van Zyl
Page 3 of 18
ADMISSIONS
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHUBELE
1. J. A VAN WYK ADV 91558/16
2. A. P COMBRINK ATT 88942/16
3. C. SCHAAL ATT 88928/16
4. J. DE VILLIERS ATT 88949/16
5. F. F NYATHELA ATT 91750/16
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRINSLOO BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MADIMA
6. L. HELMGHEM ATT 88946/16
7. L. V MASALESA ATT 88927/16
8. E. J RAMMBUDE ATT 91309/16
9. G. LETSOALO ATT 90955/16
10. C. M MOTHATA ATT 43887/16
11. K. G STANLEY ATT 88947/16
Page 4 of 18
REVIEW JUDGMENT
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHUBELE
1. The State vs Peter Mkhwanazi A40/17
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 2A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTHLE IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KHUMALO IN COURT 2C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI
Page 5 of 18
OPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURTC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLOPA IN COURT6C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY IN COURT 6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DE VOS IN COURT4B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKHOBA AJ
JUDGMENTS
IN COURT 2B AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KHUMALO
GD RAMARUMO
VS
RAF
CASE NO 67408/12
Page 6 of 18
IN COURT 6B AT 9H30
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD
1. SAMUEL VS
THE RAF
CASE NO: 2951/16
LEAVE TO APPEAL
IN COURT 8A AT 09h30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE ACTING JUDGE AVVAKOUMIDES AJ
CASE NO.: 95187/2015
Dikalala Plant Hire CC Applicant v Bela-Bela Local Municipality Respondent S
CASE NO.: 39049/2013
Karabo Ramoroka Applicant v Nosabelo Ramoroka Repondent
CASE NO.: 76581/2014
Page 7 of 18
Sandile F Mtongana Applicant v
Road Accident Fund Respondent IN COURT 8B AT 9’30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE VORSTER AJ
CITY OF TSHWANE METROPOLITAN MUNICIPALITY APPLICANT CASE NO: 19347/2014
And
BAREND JOHANNES VAN DER MERWE RESPONDENT
In re:
CITY OF TSHWANE METROPOLITAN MUNICIPALITY PLAINTIFF
And
BAREND JOHANNES VAN DER MERWE DEFENDANT
SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JW LOUW IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 6 TO 20 /02/17 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI
VANESSA VAN AARDT AND NICOLAS JOHANNES VAN AARDT: 56806/14
IN COURT 8C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE THOBANE
Page 8 of 18
3RD
COURT MOTIONS
IN COURT 6E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES IN COURT 8D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOKOENA AJ
CIVIL TRIALS ALLOCATIONS ONLY
IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWA, DJP AA A M MNCGQIBISA VS MIN OF SAFETY AND SECURITY 06/2/16 25850/05
BB FERREIRA A VS MEC FOR HEALTH PP 10/3/16 20077/13
Page 9 of 18
CIVIL TRIALS DRAFT ORDERS ONLY
IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWA, DJP A C MACAMO VS RAF 66476/14
B R E SEIDERER VS RAF 39950/14
C BAILEY S VS RAF 24264/14
D K MOYO VS RAF 36751/14
E LETHUSANG P LITEDU VS RAF 20502/15
F J CHAUKE VS RAF 73273/15
G SITULO BONISWA VS RAF 952783/15
H D L DLAMINI VS RAF 18672/14
CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P 1A B SWART VS MIN OF POLICE PREFDATE 69494/14 1B ACTIVE BLUE TRADING VS DARTINGO TRADING 94 REMOVED 26248/13 NP 1C N L SELLO VS RAF PREFDATE 31004/12 1D E E PHAKOANE VS MIN OF SAFETY ND SECURITY PREFDATE 7503/12 1E J E DIEDERICKS VS RAF PREFDATE ORDERE 79227/14+29767/15
1. P TSHABALALA VS RAF 3696/16
2. 2. NL NDONGWANE VS RAF 75128/15
3. NM QAYIZA VS RAF 93163/15
4. 4. MS MASITENG VS RAF 46635/15
Page 10 of 18
5. JG VAN ZYJE VS RAF 81378/14
6. TP KWAPE VS RAF NO FILE 19128/15 NP
7. VS MAHLWELE VS RAF 2662/16
8. ET MAJWARA VS RAF 3470/16
9. MP LEDWABA VS RAF 61310/14
10. ADV. NS PETLA VS RAF 11004/15
11. MJ MARUTLA VS RAF 28829/15
12. AM MUSHI VS RAF 81569/15
13. CZG NKOSI VS RAF 77517/15
14. LS NNETE VS RAF 3419/15
15. H BOK VS RAF 89024/15
16. VF LE BRON VS RAF 72989/15
17. CJ POTGITER VS RAF 9883/15
18. MB KALEDI VS RAF 51693/15
19. R EBRAHIM VS RAF 80325/15
20. NA DINEKA VS RAF 8258/15
21. NA NTOMBELA VS RAF 98629/15
22. C DOUBELL VS RAF 72291/15
23. MA NKOMO VS RAF 60515/12
24. JACOBS L VS RAF 79896/15
25. T MASIPA VS RAF 4759/16
26. NT MTSHWENI VS RAF 7216/13
27. SS CHAIEQUE VS RAF 60206/15
28. R GRUNDLING VS RAF 5123/11
29. MM LERUMO VS RAF 46165/14
30. DC BENECKE VS RAF 56150/14
Page 11 of 18
31. VS MAHLANGU VS RAF 49080/14
32. P MACUPE VS RAF 79933/14
33. NTSESHONGA VS RAF 18831/15
34. C DLAMINI VS RAF NO FILE 59940/14 NP
35. . N SHANGE VS RAF 11775/15
36. MNYARKP-LARTEY VS RAF 47621/12
37. ER NONYANA VS RAF 71351/15
38. AE LUBISI VS RAF 68954/14
39. LM MAHLABANE VS RAF 92967/15
40. LR MATLAKA VS RAF 47562/15
41. T MTSHALI VS RAF 65680/14
42. AH JACOBS VS RAF NO FILE 29367/11 NP
43. E E KLEINHANS VS RAF 40190/13
44. PAC LEAL VS RAF 2743/15
45. CZ NGULELA VS RAF 1801/15
46. HL SAKHEPHI VS RAF 62129/14
47. NM MABUZA VS RAF 26976/15
48. GT MADIHLABA VS RAF 29097/13
49. B ZINDO VS RAF 82673/15
50. B MAPHANGA VS RAF NO FILE 52568/15 NP
51. IS MAAKO VS RAF 66275/15
52. EI NDLOVU VS RAF 11061/16
53. B NGCOBO obo T VS RAF 11064/16
54. SQ MASHEBI VS RAF 54206/15
55. TN NTOMBELA VS RAF 98627/15
56. S NDOU VS RAF READY NO FILE 81432/15 NP
Page 12 of 18
57. K C MAHOBE VS RAF READY NO FILE 24294/15 NP
58. M CEBA VS RAF 51922/15
59. RH NEL VS RAF REMOVED 19632/10 NP
60. O A ZULU VS RAF SERT NO FILE 71127/14 NP
61. ELDORETTE CC VS MAKOLE PROPERTY REMOVED 72432/13
62. RIVERSIDE SOFTWARE VS KARRAS SERVICE 85473/14
63. TS MOTAU VS MIN OF POLICE NO FILE 19418/11 NP
64. ILLIAD AFRICA VS H AND D CONSULTANTS+1 NO FILE 18511/15
NP
65. J MOLOISANE VS TLHATLHA ATT NO FILE 76715/14
NP
66. HH VAN DYL VS FJ VAN DYKE+3 OTHERS NO FILE 66760/12
NP
67. LS NDIMANDE VS THE MEM/EXEC SOCIAL DEV NO FILE
81267/14 NP
68. CG VAN DER MERWE VS WAJ VAN DER MERWE 17594/15
69. C H ROETS VS RAF READY SERTI NO FILE 40025/09 NP
70. WT PAPOLA VS PRASA 11913/16
71. KE SETUMO VS MACROBERTS INC NO FILE 80230/14 NP
72. PLUMBLINK SA VS LEUNGO CONST NO FILE 90111/15 NP
73. V E HUGO VS RAF CERT 11150/14
74. PEPPA PROD PTY LTD VS ABSA INSUARANCE NO FILE 84165/14 NP
75. HC VISSER VS WG VISSER NO FILE 99030/15 NP
76. MK MATSHIKA VS R MATSHIKA 72413/13
77. A M WESSELS VS RAF 12503/15
78. M NGWENYA VS THE MIN OF POLICE+1 66008/15
Page 13 of 18
79. JJ GELDENHUIS VS MEM OF EXECFOR HEALTH 84970/15
80. L G CHAUKE VS RAF NO FILE 67934/16 NP
81. TM MAZIBUKO VS RAF 28343/15
82. GS PHAAHLE VS RAF 34868/14
83. N MAMPA VS RAF 32808/15
84. VJ MABANYS OBO VT VS RAF 60713/13
85. B B NJOKA VS RAF 37390/16
86. MP MOLISENYANA VS RAF 29906/14
87. C AARLOCK VS RAF 24036/12
88. G BEZUIDENHOUT obo MINOR VS RAF NO FILE 23831/14 NP
89. L KOMAN VS RAF NO FILE 65100/16 NP
90. D JILI VS RAF 41246/15
91. BM TASTA VS RAF NO FILE 58357/13 NP
92. PL MASANGO VS RAF 44975/13
93. JK SEAGODIMO VS RAF NO FILE 41637/12 NP
94. JB DUPLESSIS VS RAF 68553/13
95. N RAS VS RAF 2258/13
96. VENTER N VS RAF 28066/13
97. DLAMINI DLL VS RAF 81293/14
98. BARATH BA VS RAF 28542/15
99. MOLEKO ML VS RAF 31036/15
100. P LETUKA VS RAF 513/10
101 S L KHUMALO VS RAF 26249/14
102 G ZWEERS VS DU PLESSIS PHUKUBYE SMITH ATTORNEYS NO FILE 59657/15 NP
103 J BONGIWE VS RAF 16520/16
Page 14 of 18
104 L B PHEHLUKWAYO VS RAF READY 2572/14
105 M MFHLO VS RAF READY 74824/13+
106 L BEKKER VS RAF 4930/15
107 T APHANE VS RAF 19675/16
108 Z O NKOSI VS RAF READY 21752/14
109 M LEKHULENI VS RAF READY 35104/13
110 M F MODIBA VS RAF READY 48815/10
111 J B ANDREAS VS RAF READY 64168/15
112 BS CORDIER VS RAF READY 45453/14
113 M J MOSERI VS RAF READY 21910/15
114 N E MTHEMBU VS RAF READY 84352/14
115 P M SIBIYA VS RAF REDAY 50808/15
116 DIRA T MATIBIDI VS RAF NO FILE 9338/12 NP
117 MOKHONATSI F P VS RAF NO FILE
118 SEBUKI D NKUNA VS RAF 8726/15
119 T TWALA VS RAF 26046/09
Page 15 of 18
120 T D RANKGWADI VS RAF NO FILE 85244/14 NP
121 OSCROFT M A VS RAF READINESS 16918/14 NP
122 MAMAFA N K VS RAF READINESS 5006/15
123 MATEME K M E VS RAF READINESS 48029/13
124 BOTHMA G G VS RAF READINESS 73608/13
125 M JOBELA VS RAF 10052/12
126 BOKABA W R VS RAF READINESS 59225/11
127 MATHOLO M VS RAF READINESS NO FILE 56005/15 NP
128 RAMOSHABA M M VS RAF 7379/15
129 MOTAU D G VS RAF 21268/15
130 RAMOSHABA M A VS RAF MERITS NO FILE 8727/15 NP
131 J S STRYDOM VS RAF READY 72516/12
132 MOKOMELE JD VS RAF 11080/15
133 L BEKKER` VS RAF 43768/16
134 REMOVED
135 MOLITLE N C VS RAF READINES NO FILE 66541/13 NP
136 J K MOKETSI VS MIN OF POLICE MERITS 48440/12
137 D LATEGAN VS RAF READY 1061/14
138 P MOIPEKE VS RAF READ Y 43520/13
139 P L MORABA VS RAF READ Y 48262/14
140 L MZANGWA VS RAF NO FILE 83808/14 NP
141 V R NEMONONE VS RAF READY 88062/14
142 P M MAHLATLEGO VS RAF 38427/14
143 MAHORI T M VS RAF 38574/16
144 NGOBENI D VS RAF 8552/16
Page 16 of 18
145 ROSINAH M VS RAF READINESS 48811/10
146 M N ZWANE VS RAF READY 26584/06
147 O J MANOE VS RAF READY NO FILE 42632/12 NP
148 MTHAKATHI J M VS RAF NO FILE 49890/13 NP
149 MCHIMANE AM VS RAF READINESS 51445/13
150 M P KGOLOKO VS RAF READY 46926/11
151 M P MO;LISENYANE VS RAF NO FILE 29906/14 NP
152 S N GUAYI VS RAF CERT NO FILE 67760/14 NP
153 J KONOKANE VS RAF CERT 61113/11
154 R S TSHABALALA VS RAF 33139/14
155 T P KWAPE VS RAF 19218/15
156 ADV SAYED VS RAF 82139/14
157 OJ MABOE VS RAF 42623/12
CIVIL TRIAL JUDGES
IN COURT 6A AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAULINGA
IN COURT 8B AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MATOJANE
IN COURT 6B AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD
Page 17 of 18
IN COURT 4D AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE
IN COURT 6D AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN
IN COURT 8F AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MPHAHLELE
IN COURT 8G AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALULEKE
IN COURT 4G AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE WINDWELL
IN COURT AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
IN COURT AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
COURTS AVAILABLE
Page 18 of 18