impacting product development and support through additive ......our global footprint product line...
TRANSCRIPT
Caterpillar Non-Confidential
Please note: Caterpillar policy does not allow for content to be recorded with smart phones or other devices unless specific approvals have been
sought and granted prior to the beginning of the presentation.
Impacting Product Development and Support through
Additive Manufacturing
Thierry Marchione, Caterpillar Inc.
AGENDA:
•Different matrix, different road map
•Gap assessment and mitigation
•Present applications
•Moving forward
Manufacturing Technology & Solutions
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
OUR GLOBAL FOOTPRINT PRODUCT LINE
END MARKET
Construction Mining
Equipment
Diesel & Natural
Gas EnginesIndustrial Gas
Turbines
Diesel-Electric
Locomotive
3 Million+Products at Work
Around the World
98,400Full-time
Employment*
We Provide Solutions
that Help Our Customers
Build a Better World
171 DealersServing 192 countries*
500,000+Connected Assets*
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
A different matrix for AM
AM
success
Light weighting
Product
Performance
Supply chain
High volume/ High cost
Low volume/ Low cost High volume/ Low costAM
success
Light weighting
Product
Performance
Supply chain
Robustness
Durability
Emission regulation
Tooling
Lead time
Sourcing issue
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
A different matrix for AM
Material
MFG
processes
Product
MFG
practices
Aerospace
Composite Injection molded polyurethane
Safety
fabrication
Caterpillar
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
2014 - 2016
2016 - 2020
Optimized products
Gages, jigs and fixtures, tooling
Metal prototypes, legacy and non-critical service parts
Performance parts, first-fit applications
Advanced applications (e.g., structural)
Desktop
deployment
A different Road Map for AM
MicroFoundry
Caterpillar Non-Confidential
Please note: Caterpillar policy does not allow for content to be recorded with smart phones or other devices unless specific approvals have been
sought and granted prior to the beginning of the presentation.
Impacting Product Development and Support through
Additive Manufacturing
Thierry Marchione, Caterpillar Inc.
AGENDA:
•Different matrix, different road map
•Gap assessment and mitigation
•Present applications
•Moving forward
Manufacturing Technology & Solutions
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Gaps analysis
Material properties “The Cornerstone”
Digital technologies
“The Enabler”
Process capabilities & control “The Maker”
Post processing & QC “The Healer”
“As Designed” “As Manufactured”
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Topology Optimization
Surface Optimization
Thermal Simulation
FEA comparison
Down selectionfor 32 solutions
Digital technologies
FEA validation
Test Bench
Manufacturing Challenges
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Material development
1. Single layer, single bead test
2. Single layer, surface
3. Volume build
4. Scanning strategy
5. Cracking mitigation
6. Component check
“IP safe haven” H10, M2, 8620, Haynes 230, Hastelloy X, Waspalloy, MarM247 and 17-4 refined
Compliance to specification to establish
Simulation software and fundamental simulation in WIP
Developed semi-empirical model based on operator tangible parameters
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
100x – As Printed 100x - Anneal 100x – HIP 100x - Wrought Alloy
Yield Strength (MPa) Ultimate tensile (MPa) Elongation (%)
Horizontal As-Printed 686.5 ± 25 808.1 ± 15 5.7 ± .3
Horizontal HIP 526.2 ± 10 941.3 ± 10 31.6 ± 3.8
Vertical As-Printed 640.6 ± 10 835 ± 40 11.8 ± 1.2
Vertical HIP 521.5 ± 10 902.3 ± 40 28.4 ± 10
Wrought Alloy 390 ± 10 860± 10 47.7± 10
As-Printed (HRC) 32.7
HIP (HRC) 27.2
Wrought Alloy (HRC) 16.0
HIP Microstructure
Material development Haynes 230
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Post processing & QC
PLAN for dimensional stock
QC difficult on internal feature
(Eddy current , CT Scan and/or ultrasonic)
REDESIGN for post-operation finishing
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Increase deposition rate (technology or/and parts classification)
Reduce volume material (lattice, TO and Hybrid)
Heat treat trade off
Plan for finishing
Low cost material ???
Market trend
Survey other technologies
Saving cost with PBF
Slow
Slower
Moderate
Fast
Caterpillar Non-Confidential
Please note: Caterpillar policy does not allow for content to be recorded with smart phones or other devices unless specific approvals have been
sought and granted prior to the beginning of the presentation.
Impacting Product Development and Support through
Additive Manufacturing
Thierry Marchione, Caterpillar Inc.
AGENDA:
•Different matrix, different road map
•Gap assessment and mitigation
•Present applications
•Moving forward
Manufacturing Technology & Solutions
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Supply chain mitigation: Gas Turbine Fuel Swirler
ORIGINAL
CASTING
Benefits: Reduce leadtime: 9 monthS to 6 weeks
Cost reduction 35% (32-step process to 14 steps)
Better quality
Enable redesign for better durability and performance
Inspiration for development additional production
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Supply Chain Mitigation: AT Legacy Suspension Valve
Background: Part 7U6910 made obsolete by the supplier without notification. Based on sales, part still required
Manufacturing options : Machine from solid: Expensive, special cutting tools needed, Long lead time
Additive Manufacturing: Allows more complex forms, minimizes post processing
Validation: Test underway on customer machine that had long back order
Material: 17-4PH, Stainless Steel or 8620
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Developing “Next Generation” Reciprocating Engine Components
The Bold Goal: Increase life of reciprocating engine part by 2.5X
from 8,000 hours to 20,000 hours
Previous efforts w/ traditional manufacturing & materials Minor improvements
No line of sight to life goal
A new approach required Rethink operating mode and temperature behavior
Results: Nickel alloys fully developed (Haynes 230, Waspalloy, Inconel 718 and tested for high temperature
operating condition)
Top 3 concepts are being tested on engine
Parts will be fully validated as part of NPI process including typical engine NPI validation process of 20K hours / first overhaul interval
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
Large Engine Sea Water Pump Bracket
Objective: Develop a design process that utilizes Optimization Software, Materials and Additive Manufacturing processes
Why Print : Avoid high tooling cost for low volume components
Enables Improved Performance: Optimized Natural Frequency
Increased Fatigue Life
Radical weight reduction for cost mitigation
Next Steps: Back-to-back part testing
Material: 17-4PH, Stainless Steel, Inconel 625
Processes challenge: Sand printing, PBF, and DMLS
Consider hybrid manufacturing
Caterpillar Non-Confidential
Please note: Caterpillar policy does not allow for content to be recorded with smart phones or other devices unless specific approvals have been
sought and granted prior to the beginning of the presentation.
Impacting Product Development and Support through
Additive Manufacturing
Thierry Marchione, Caterpillar Inc.
AGENDA:
•Different matrix, different road map
•Gap assessment and mitigation
•Present applications
•Moving forward
Manufacturing Technology & Solutions
Caterpillar Non-ConfidentialManufacturing Technology & Solutions
CRAM Cost Reduction efforts for Additive Manufacturing
SCAM duplication of Supply Chain application for Additive Manufacturing
MAM pursuing Material development specific material for Additive Manufacturing
DDAM Digitally Differentiated product merging by using digital thread for
Additive Manufacturing
Moving forward