impact of restrictive state policies on utilization and expenditures in the medicaid program roberto...
TRANSCRIPT
Impact of Restrictive State Policies Impact of Restrictive State Policies on Utilization and Expenditures in on Utilization and Expenditures in
the Medicaid Programthe Medicaid Program
Roberto Vargas, MD, MPHRoberto Vargas, MD, MPH1,21,2
Carole Gresenz,Carole Gresenz, PhDPhD22
Jessie Riposo, MSJessie Riposo, MS22
Jeannette Rogowski, PhDJeannette Rogowski, PhD33
JosJosé é Escarce, MD, PhDEscarce, MD, PhD1,21,2
1.Division of General Internal Medicine and Health Services Research, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA
2.RAND Health3.University of Medicine and Dentistry New Jersey, School of Public
Health
BackgroundBackground
For state Medicaid programs, the For state Medicaid programs, the Deficit Reduction Act eliminatedDeficit Reduction Act eliminated Need to offer all benefits to all Need to offer all benefits to all
enrolleesenrollees Requirement of states to get federal Requirement of states to get federal
waivers before limiting benefits or waivers before limiting benefits or imposing co-pays and cost sharingimposing co-pays and cost sharing
Mandatory periods of public Mandatory periods of public comment prior to implementing comment prior to implementing such changessuch changes
Restrictive Policies and Restrictive Policies and MedicaidMedicaid
Restrictive drug policies have been Restrictive drug policies have been associated with lower rates of associated with lower rates of prescription filling and more prescription filling and more intensive use of acute care, nursing intensive use of acute care, nursing homes and higher overall costshomes and higher overall costs
Cost sharing and limits on physician Cost sharing and limits on physician visits in Medicaid have varying visits in Medicaid have varying effects on physician visits rates but effects on physician visits rates but no significant impact on overall costs.no significant impact on overall costs.
Aims Aims
To examine the effects of To examine the effects of restrictive policies on use of care restrictive policies on use of care by a nationally representative by a nationally representative sample of Medicaid enrollees sample of Medicaid enrollees over a six-year periodover a six-year period
Data SourcesData Sources
State Medicaid Summaries from State Medicaid Summaries from
1997-20021997-2002 Summaries of state plan benefits Summaries of state plan benefits
including scope of medical care (Limits including scope of medical care (Limits
on visits and services and co-pays)on visits and services and co-pays)
The Medical Expenditure Panel The Medical Expenditure Panel
Survey (MEPS), 1997-2002Survey (MEPS), 1997-2002
Study SampleStudy Sample
Adults 18-64 Adults 18-64 with at least one full with at least one full
calendar year of data in MEPScalendar year of data in MEPS We excluded: We excluded:
Patients who were pregnantPatients who were pregnant
Had additional forms of insuranceHad additional forms of insurance
Were enrolled inn Managed care or Were enrolled inn Managed care or
HMO’sHMO’s
Study DesignStudy Design
Cross sectional, yearly analytic files of Cross sectional, yearly analytic files of
respondents respondents
Multivariate regression models and Multivariate regression models and
simulationssimulations
Estimate the impact of state policy variationEstimate the impact of state policy variation
Controlling for individual characteristics, Controlling for individual characteristics,
health care market factors, and community health care market factors, and community
contextual factors contextual factors
OutcomesOutcomes
Utilization:Utilization: Outpatient office-based physician visitsOutpatient office-based physician visits Outpatient office visits (non-physician and Outpatient office visits (non-physician and
physician)physician) Emergency room visitsEmergency room visits Inpatient acute care hospital admissionsInpatient acute care hospital admissions
Expenditures:Expenditures: Prescription drug expendituresPrescription drug expenditures Total healthcare expenditures excluding Total healthcare expenditures excluding
vision and dental servicesvision and dental services
Key Independent Variables: Key Independent Variables: Medicaid Restrictive Medicaid Restrictive
PoliciesPolicies Any physician visit co-payAny physician visit co-pay Any emergency room visit co-payAny emergency room visit co-pay Any prescription drug co-payAny prescription drug co-pay Inpatient admission co-pay for stay of Inpatient admission co-pay for stay of
greater than $21greater than $21 Any inpatient co-pay charged dailyAny inpatient co-pay charged daily Office-based physician visit limit Office-based physician visit limit Less than or equal to three Less than or equal to three
prescription limit per monthprescription limit per month
AnalysisAnalysis Regression Models:Regression Models:
Office-based visits: Negative binomial Office-based visits: Negative binomial modelmodel
Any emergency room: Logit modelAny emergency room: Logit model Any inpatient night: Logit modelAny inpatient night: Logit model Expenditures: selected Two-part modelsExpenditures: selected Two-part models
Simulations:Simulations: We simulated values for the utilization We simulated values for the utilization
and expenditures weighted for the MEPS and expenditures weighted for the MEPS sampling designsampling design
Descriptive Data:Descriptive Data:Individual Individual
CharacteristicsCharacteristicsIndividual-Level VariablesIndividual-Level Variables
FemaleFemale 64%64%
Non- Hispanic Black Non- Hispanic Black 28%28%
HispanicHispanic 21%21%
Other Non-WhiteOther Non-White 5%5%
Non-Hispanic WhiteNon-Hispanic White 46%46%
SSI RecipientSSI Recipient 41%41%
Income<povertyIncome<poverty 59%59%
Less than high schoolLess than high school 48%48%
Descriptive Data:Descriptive Data:OutcomesOutcomes
Utilization and ExpendituresUtilization and Expenditures Mean (Std Err)/Mean (Std Err)/
%%
# Office-based physician visits# Office-based physician visits 5.70 (0.33)5.70 (0.33)
# Total office-based visits# Total office-based visits 8.03 (0.69)8.03 (0.69)
Any emergency room visit %Any emergency room visit % 24%24%
Any inpatient admission %Any inpatient admission % 14%14%
Prescription expendituresPrescription expenditures $1098.28 (56.92)$1098.28 (56.92)
Total medical expendituresTotal medical expenditures $4575.92 (320.53)$4575.92 (320.53)
Descriptive Data:Descriptive Data:Restrictive Medicaid Restrictive Medicaid
PoliciesPoliciesPolicyPolicy 19971997
Any Physician Visit Co payAny Physician Visit Co pay 1818
Limit on number of Physician VisitsLimit on number of Physician Visits 1717
Any Emergency Room Co payAny Emergency Room Co pay 44
Prescription Co payPrescription Co pay 2929
Limit on number of prescriptions per monthLimit on number of prescriptions per month 1111
Inpatient Admissions Co payInpatient Admissions Co pay 1414
Inpatient Daily Co payInpatient Daily Co pay 55
Regression ResultsRegression Results
Visit limit policies Visit limit policies had no significant had no significant impact on visits that included non-impact on visits that included non-physician care, emergency room visits, physician care, emergency room visits, or inpatient hospital staysor inpatient hospital stays
Limiting prescriptionsLimiting prescriptions to three per to three per month had no significant effect on any of month had no significant effect on any of our utilization or expenditure measuresour utilization or expenditure measures
Per day inpatient co-payPer day inpatient co-pay was not was not associated with hospitalization rates or associated with hospitalization rates or expendituresexpenditures
Regression ResultsRegression Results
Co-pays for physician visitsCo-pays for physician visits Lower Any ER visit rate (20% Lower Any ER visit rate (20%
compared to 25%; p<0.10)compared to 25%; p<0.10) Higher rates of inpatient Higher rates of inpatient
hospitalization (18% compared to hospitalization (18% compared to 13%; p<0.05)13%; p<0.05)
Higher average total expenditures Higher average total expenditures ($5,431 compared to $4,271; ($5,431 compared to $4,271; p<0.05)p<0.05)
Regression ResultsRegression Results
Inpatient admission co-pays of Inpatient admission co-pays of greater than $21greater than $21 Fewer Admissions (9% compared to Fewer Admissions (9% compared to
15%; p<0.10)15%; p<0.10) ER visit co-paysER visit co-pays
Lower total expenditures ($3,719 Lower total expenditures ($3,719 compared to $4,665; p<0.01)compared to $4,665; p<0.01)
Regression ResultsRegression Results
Prescription drug co-pays:Prescription drug co-pays: Lower expenditures ($4,145 Lower expenditures ($4,145
compared to $5,088; p<0.05)compared to $5,088; p<0.05) Prescription drug co-pays:Prescription drug co-pays:
Significantly lower average number Significantly lower average number of physician office-based visits (5.58 of physician office-based visits (5.58 compared to 6.70; p<0.05)compared to 6.70; p<0.05)
ConclusionsConclusions Some Some co-paysco-pays were associated with were associated with
lower expenditures and utilizationlower expenditures and utilization Visit limit policies,Visit limit policies, no significant no significant
impact on either outcomes of interestimpact on either outcomes of interest Certain restrictive policies are Certain restrictive policies are
associated with associated with unintended unintended consequencesconsequences such as the association such as the association of physician visit co-pays with higher of physician visit co-pays with higher hospitalization rates and costshospitalization rates and costs
ImplicationsImplications
Efforts to reduce costs through Efforts to reduce costs through restrictive policies have varying restrictive policies have varying effects on utilization and expenditureseffects on utilization and expenditures
As states consider greater use of As states consider greater use of restrictive policies there is a need to restrictive policies there is a need to monitor the impact of restrictive monitor the impact of restrictive policies for unintended consequencespolicies for unintended consequences
Supplemental Supplemental SlidesSlides
ResultsResults
Simulation VariableSimulation
ValueMean Std Err Mean Std Err Mean Std Err Mean Std Err Mean SE Mean SE
Any Office-Based Doctors Visit Limit 0 6.29 (0.37) 8.59 (0.62) 0.23 (0.02) 0.15 (0.01) 1109.85 (53.88) 4367.27 (314.30)1 6.00 (0.48) 8.35 (0.84) 0.24 (0.02) 0.13 (0.01) 1158.08 (59.87) 4953.56 (472.73)
Any Physician Visit Co pay 0 6.08 (0.36) 8.68 (0.68) 0.25* (0.02) 0.13** (0.01) 1115.04 (49.85) 4270.69** (267.43)1 6.38 (0.59) 8.07 (0.84) 0.20* (0.02) 0.18** (0.02) 1152.68 (87.88) 5430.74** (546.01)
Any ER visit Co pay 0 6.24 (0.34) 8.52 (0.62) 0.23 (0.01) 0.14 (0.01) 1120.45 (39.32) 4664.96* (255.82)1 4.88 (0.71) 7.94 (1.39) 0.24 (0.05) 0.14 (0.01) 1254.47 (146.76) 3718.50* (686.33)
Any Prescription Co pay 0 6.70** (0.47) 8.75 (0.75) 0.22 (0.02) 0.15 (0.01) 1108.34 (57.79) 5087.92** (397.68)1 5.58** (0.37) 8.18 (0.69) 0.25 (0.02) 0.14 (0.01) 1151.77 (62.87) 4144.60** (303.82)
Limit of Three Rx per Month 0 6.15 (0.33) 8.51 (0.61) 0.23 (0.01) 0.14 (0.01) 1126.5 (37.46) 4589.28 (256.60)1 7.15 (1.47) 7.56 (1.53) 0.29 (0.09) 0.15 (0.05) 1364.48 (432.14) 5565.32 (2042.71)
Any Inpatient Admission Co pay 0 - - - 0.15* (0.01) - 4671.56 (261.84)greater than $21 Per Stay 1 - - - 0.09 (0.02) - 3778.01 (726.14)
*p<0.10; **p<0.05
Any Prescription Drug Expenditure
(Spec 1)Any Expenditure
(Spec 1)Physician Office-
Based VisitsPhysician and Non-Physician Visits Any ER Visit
Any Inpatient Hospital Night
States Level Restrictive States Level Restrictive PoliciesPolicies
Policy Level VariablesPolicy Level Variables 19971997 19981998 19991999 20002000**
20012001 20022002
Any Physician Visit Co payAny Physician Visit Co pay 1818 1818 1818 1717 1717 1919
Limit on number of Physician Limit on number of Physician VisitsVisits
1717 1717 1717 1717 1717 1717
Physician Visit and Co pay Physician Visit and Co pay RestrictionRestriction
77 77 77 88 77 77
*Data missing for one state*Data missing for one state
State Level ER Restrictive State Level ER Restrictive Policies Policies
Policy Level VariablesPolicy Level Variables 19971997 19981998 19991999 20002000**
20012001 20022002
Any Emergency Room Co payAny Emergency Room Co pay 44 44 44 44 44 44
Limit on number of Emergency Limit on number of Emergency Room VisitsRoom Visits
44 44 44 44 44 44
Emergency Room Co pay and Visit Emergency Room Co pay and Visit RestrictionRestriction
11 11 11 11 11 11
*Data missing for one state*Data missing for one state
State Level Inpatient State Level Inpatient Admission PoliciesAdmission Policies
Policy Level VariablesPolicy Level Variables 19971997 19981998 19991999 20002000**
20012001 20022002
Inpatient Admissions Co payInpatient Admissions Co pay 1414 1616 1616 1515 1515 1515
Inpatient Daily Co payInpatient Daily Co pay 55 55 55 55 55 55
Inpatient Stay LimitInpatient Stay Limit 1212 1212 1212 1212 1010 1010
*Data missing for one state*Data missing for one state
State Level Prescription Drug State Level Prescription Drug PoliciesPolicies
Policy Level VariablesPolicy Level Variables 19971997 19981998 19991999 2000*2000* 20012001 20022002
Prescription Co payPrescription Co pay 2929 2929 3030 3131 3030 3131
Limit on number of Limit on number of prescriptions per monthprescriptions per month
1111 1212 1212 1212 1010 1010
Both Rx Co pay and limitBoth Rx Co pay and limit 55 66 66 77 55 55
*Data missing for one state*Data missing for one state