imagine auto inc. – 913 310-9927 996tt / gt2 exhaust comparison an imagineauto inc. presentation...
TRANSCRIPT
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
996TT / GT2 Exhaust Comparison
An ImagineAuto Inc. Presentation
August 7, 2003
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
A baseline set of testing methodologies was determined and communicated to all manufactures prior to the tests.
Consistent testing methodologies ensure accurate, comparable results were achieved. Although different test scenarios would have produced higher or lower numbers, these methodologies and scenarios ensure the results are comparable from muffler to muffler.
• A 2001 Porsche 996TT with 20,000miles, stage 4 ECU upgrade, and K24 turbos was used.
• A minimum of 50 miles was put on the car with each muffler to account for ECU calibration
• Dynojet 248 Dynamometer
• DB tests were taken 12 ft from rear of the car by a Radio Shack Digital db Reader part number 33-2055
• Backpressure tested 3” post turbo and 3” pre cat
• 3k constant load pulls were done on the dyno, under part throttle load.
• SAE HP correction was done based on weather station information. The correction factor for all runs was 1.06-1.07DIN.
• Intake temperatures were held to within 10 degrees F
• Resonance is judged on whether or not a conversation can be carried on with someone in the back seat.
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Factory 996TT Exhaust - FREE
DB Interior DB Exterior
Idle – 84db 81db
3k – 96db 93db
WOT – 101db 97db
Statistics
Weight – 54lbs
Backpressure 6.3lbs
AFR – 12.2
Weather Station information
Absolute pressure - 29.01in.Hg
Air intake temp – 101.2 degrees F
Vapor Pressure - .51in.Hg
Correction Factor – 1.07DIN
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Europipe 996TT Exhaust - $4,410
DB Interior DB Exterior
Idle – 69db 91db
3k – 86db 103db
WOT – 91db 109db
Statistics
Weight – 54lbs
Backpressure 2.5lbs
AFR – 12.5
Weather Station information
Absolute pressure - 29.08in.Hg
Air intake temp – 95.8 degrees F
Vapor Pressure - .52in.Hg
Correction Factor – 1.06DIN
If the factory were to ever make a high performance muffler this would be it. The workmanship and quality is certainly what you would expect from a European product. The muffler is well packaged and the unit is sold with several goodies such as an angled wrench and handle to ease installation. Exhaust tips are also included in the package and for a small fee can be upgraded to the X50 look.
Sound is sometimes hard to put into words. Imagine a throaty sound and a slight rasp under full acceleration. The muffler sets the standard for pleasant sound and zero resonance. There is a sound presence through the midrange, however it just reminds you that the muffler is there.
The Europipe muffler’s claim to fame is the large 70mm pipes compared to the factory's 60mm. The system is rather bulky and compares to the factory muffler in regards to weight and difficulty of installation. A 2 Year warranty is included
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Fabspeed Sport 996TT Exhaust – $3,495
DB Interior DB Exterior
Idle – 88db 89db
3k – 101db 96db
WOT – 104db 100db
Statistics
Weight – 35lbs
Backpressure 2.25lbs
AFR – 12.2
Weather Station information
Absolute pressure – 29.03in.Hg
Air intake temp – 108.4 degrees F
Vapor Pressure - .59in.Hg
Correction Factor – 1.07DIN
Designed around the single canister version, the new Sport Quiet is just that – quiet - compared to its predecessor. The exhaust utilizes the separate cat system and attachment based on V-band clamps. If you are upgrading from the Super Sport, the system can be interchanged in about 15 minutes leaving the cats in the car. The quality is consistent to other Fabspeed products with that same impressive mirror polish.
The overall sound of the Fabspeed Sport Quiet is pleasant. If the Fabspeed Super Sport is too much for everyday driving, this one may be just right. Resonance is slightly detectable around the 2500 mark. This muffler doesn't prohibit any conversation or create an annoyance for daily driving. The system sounds throaty with a hint of burble on deceleration. Full acceleration produces an exotic howl that will make those standing on the curb look up.
System includes V-bands, aircraft clamps, muffler straps and hardware.
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Fabspeed GTII Super Sport 996TT Exhaust - $3,495
DB Interior DB Exterior
Idle – 88db 94db
3k – 102db 101db
WOT – 104db 110db
Statistics
Weight – 30lbs
Backpressure 2.25lbs
AFR – 12.3
Weather Station information
Absolute pressure - 28.9in.Hg
Air intake temp – 103.0 degrees F
Vapor Pressure - .64in.Hg
Correction Factor – 1.07DIN
As one of the first aftermarket vendors to offer a replacement muffler for the 996TT, Fabspeed has shown to have scaled the learning curve and is confident in the performance of their product. The original GTII Super Sport is a three-piece design that utilizes separate 100 Cell German cats. The system uses the V-band clamp system for faster on and off access and install time. The system has been updated since its original debut through a restructuring of the mounting brackets and a small design change to lower resonance levels. Overall quality is nothing less than FabSpeed has shown us through the years.
This system is not for the faint of heart. The Super Sport GTII does resonant and lets you and your surroundings know you mean business. If you enjoy the raw sound of the turbos spooling up and the backpressure flutter, then this system would be ideal.
The muffler is constructed from 63.5 T304SS and the kit is equipped with V-bands, mounting brackets, tailpipe pieces and aircraft quality clamps.
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Fabspeed Sport Track 996TT Exhaust - $495 (requires Fabspeed cats)
DB Interior DB Exterior
Idle – 85db 88db
3k – 108db 104db
WOT – 105db 114db
Statistics
Weight – 11lbs
Backpressure 1.75lbs
AFR – 12.5
Weather Station information
Absolute pressure - 28.9in.Hg
Air intake temp – 105.0 degrees F
Vapor Pressure - .67in.Hg
Correction Factor – 1.07DIN
If you have the Fabspeed Sport or Super Sport these pipes are a must. They are designed to attach directly to the cats and allow a dual muffler bypass. The system is interchangeable in about 15 minutes even under the hottest conditions. We changed this system out with a set of gloves on the dyno.
Anyone headed to the track or drag strip will appreciate this option.
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
GHL 996TT Exhaust - $2,900
DB Interior DB Exterior
Idle – 90db 96db
3k – 102db 98db
WOT – 107db 106db
Statistics
Weight – 30lbs
Backpressure 3lbs
AFR – 12.2
Weather Station information
Absolute pressure – 29.07in.Hg
Air intake temp – 104.9 degrees F
Vapor Pressure - .61in.Hg
Correction Factor – 1.06DIN
New to the scene, this muffler is actually two systems. The cats are separate from the mufflers and instead of one common canister, two separate mufflers are used. 100 Cell metal media cats are piped into a 3-inch pipe then to the muffler. The tailpipe is necked back to factory size to allow for factory fitment of the tips. Installation of this muffler is as easy as it gets. Because of the separate mufflers and removable cats the system can be installed in less than an hour. The quality and welds of these mufflers are definitely from the upper echelon of the aftermarket world. Almost unheard of is the lifetime warranty this muffler carries.
The GHL sound is rather unique. It carries a hollow throat and a high-end rasp that is much different than factory. It is noticeable but not overpowering. GHL mufflers are known for no resonance and that was very clear to the ear. The muffler is equipped with support straps and is constructed from T304SS.
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
RUF 996TT Exhaust - $5,900
DB Interior DB Exterior
Idle – 80db 92db
3k – 88db 95db
WOT – 92db 100db
Statistics
Weight – 53lbs
Backpressure 3lbs
AFR – 12.4
Weather Station information
Absolute pressure – 29.01in.Hg
Air intake temp – 100.0 degrees F
Vapor Pressure - .37in.Hg
Correction Factor – 1.06DIN
As you would expect from RUF the presentation is first rate. RUF starts with a factory muffler and retools it to their specifications. The muffler quality is good given the majority of it is factory. Cats and the original outlets are removed to accommodate RUF's signature two-pipe outlets. The rest of the design is kept secret by the German designers.
Sound is excellent. It is as quiet as a factory muffler with a little more emphasis on the flutter and throat that you can just barely detect on the factory system. The muffler maintains the factory lack of resonance and is barely audible driving down the road. The system is supplied with all new nuts and gaskets. Due to its size, installation is awkward just as on the factory muffler.We would like to point out that this muffler can be purchased separate of the RUF system, however it is very clear that the muffler has been designed to work particularly with the RUF setup. This is important to note when studying the performance test results.
NOTE: A factory muffler baseline was rerun after the RUF test since the RUF produced unexpected low results through the midrange. The baseline was identical to the first baseline. The results are unexplained and may represent a problem with just this particular muffler.
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Turbo-Exhaust.com 996TT Exhaust - $2,000
DB Interior DB Exterior
Idle – 85db 92db
3k – 110db 105db
WOT – 104db 110db
Statistics
Weight – 12lbs
Backpressure 2lbs
AFR – 12.3
Weather Station information
Absolute pressure – 28.91in.Hg
Air intake temp – 101.2 degrees F
Vapor Pressure - .51in.Hg
Correction Factor – 1.07DIN
These mufflers are based on modified stock systems. Seven versions exist and are based on minimal backpressure, minimum weight and maximum HP. Wrapped in thermal blankets the systems get the energy out of the muffler as fast as possible. Installation is as simple as it gets because of the size and lack of weight. It actually took more time to hook the 02 sensors up than it did to install this system.
Sound is not what this muffler had in mind when designed. Built around track use these mufflers are quiet enough to pass track db limits. They do carry resonance in most RPM ranges inside the interior. All of which is not an issue on the track or under a helmet. For the cost, no one can complain.
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
All Exhaust Summary - HP
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
All Exhaust Summary - Torque
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
HP & Torque Summary
Exhaust 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000 AverageTurbo-Exhaust.com 128 195 277 391 458 470 484 474 457 454 365.0Factory 125 182 247 338 429 448 452 440 437 419 346.0Europipe 145 213 305 409 429 455 452 464 440 439 351.0Fabspeed Sport 120 173 248 363 453 469 476 483 467 454 371.5Fabspeed GTII Super Sport 128 190 271 384 447 461 463 469 452 442 376.9Fabspeed Sport Track 127 189 274 385 466 493 487 490 462 402 400.0GHL 121 177 250 365 438 458 470 460 440 427 357.4RUF 136 200 274 363 404 415 425 427 438 419 361.0
Exhaust 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000 AverageTurbo-Exhaust.com 270 341 416 514 535 494 462 415 369 341 417.5Factory 263 319 371 444 501 471 431 385 354 313 388.5Europipe 305 372 458 437 500 478 432 407 356 328 413.0Fabspeed Sport 252 303 372 477 529 493 454 423 378 338 410.3Fabspeed GTII Super Sport 268 332 407 504 521 484 442 411 365 334 418.3Fabspeed Sport Track 271 330 411 505 544 518 465 429 373 302 433.8GHL 255 310 375 479 511 481 448 402 440 427 396.7RUF 284 350 411 476 472 436 406 374 354 317 400.9
HP
Torque
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Turbo-Exhaust.Com vs Stock
Turbo-Exhaust.Com Exhaust Comparison
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000
RPMs
HP
/To
rqu
e Turbo-Exhaust.com HP
Factory HP
Turbo-Exhaust.com Torque
Factory Torque
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Europipe vs Stock
Europipe Exhaust Comparison
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000
RPMs
HP
/To
rqu
e Factory HP
Europipe HP
Factory Torque
Europipe Torque
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Fabspeed Sport vs Stock
Fabspeed Sport Exhaust Comparison
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000
RPMs
HP
/To
rqu
e Factory HP
Fabspeed Sport HP
Factory Torque
Fabspeed Sport Torque
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Fabspeed GTII Super Sport vs Stock
Fabspeed GTII Super Sport Exhaust Comparison
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000
RPMs
HP
/To
rqu
e Factory HP
Fabspeed GTII Super Sport HP
Factory Torque
Fabspeed GTII Super Sport Torque
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
Fabspeed Track vs Stock
Fabspeed Sport Track Exhaust Comparison
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000
RPMs
HP
/To
rqu
e Factory HP
Fabspeed Sport Track HP
Factory Torque
Fabspeed Sport Track Torque
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
GHL vs Stock
GHL Exhaust Comparison
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000
RPMs
HP
/To
rqu
e Factory HP
GHL HP
Factory Torque
GHL Torque
Imagine Auto Inc. – 913 310-9927
RUF vs Stock
RUF Exhaust Comparison
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 6500 7000
RPMs
HP
/To
rqu
e Factory HP
RUF HP
Factory Torque
RUF Torque