DECLASSIFIED UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE INTERAGENCY SECURITY CLASSIFICATION APPEALS PANEL,E.O. 13526, SECTION 5.3(b)(3)

ISCAP APPEAL NO. 2012-048, document no. 27 DECLASSIFICATION DATE: July 8, 2015

t . ~, ~v~ 2

' Pfl4Urvir( "(G

J ·,))Vl/YVJ,- ~ltfhh o~ I

tJw /IJ/:jvf - 5~ ;l'lfi; Rt/ fl-.111 atA~~IJ-<JU4M

~: ~ r>IA9 ~~ .vj +;~ >>s~ ('~ tmv ~~ J~ do"'~') r#/ ,___

, .7f?- Yk .. >MV __s-'~} ~~J./ Y7 uf.vt.u/ ---­~ Mw- P"~ ~ ~Zu ..v"""' ~ ~~r IW " ti<~ ~ d?c( fl.-""/- "'~?-7'C=,Lc • ?" -d.lr ~~r ~ 111M. ~w /r kt...t -'I /~-c. ~7 .lv fV""""'W /"1'!111. .~~ -,.= r'E I ~ ~· a- .. A ~!d' ~ ~ ro~

~ w ·~ ~/" ~ J.u ~ ~ /7e£d-'J

~ ~ A. /Chccfu, f [ ' hfir-~ ~ ~ftc ..H; 4 -- t-f/i t~ - Fr~

G,________ _

14~ ~--·· # ~M~~ ~ fo ~ '"~ ~ (_.-'fA .. ~PVTY~ v/o~ ~ -vj ~ l4­p;-&(cl o-f{L(_

I

2

f7l!t·5£r -flv:J ~ I~ ~6ovf- ~ .r . ~ · ~~ ~~~~ ~~~~~ v(dp-V( d- ~ ?Pj

Jj( Jwf /'1 /n<><-pP i f-A >'n ,t{,y f65~ /r-7

~ ~~- ~ ~ i~;fn b~/· ~ ~~

~~~

~/.

3

. .

.3fn-tlllf: ~b7_ . ?fc:vd_ J/~ j/~/11' /frL (O:;J­/II

t::JtJjh i-- --Pt_y ~ k~ycr, . , /0 ~9 ;( ~'7-~ 'r- ~ ~T/v--e;.. +­

(A. ), Vt/&4 f- .p{/A::J ,/./1 ~~ L<... . .,

.. ~l.> ~ /73! .r~ /-1- ov-f--­

~~ p;t// ~ ~t/ ~ ~ h~ • ~rvn7r ~/-r-- 1 hhCr-- ·dhl

.. .lJv~~-r ~ ~ ~J~~ ~ t:J Jj(;14 t;~.

~ MA/L kb (/~~- 1?(t</t ';L{0 - +t:5h -r: tau IZ / ~(j, :

J!t-r /f {4/7~ . ~. - ~ l;- ~ r-­i . ~/lfJ ~ r r ~ ~ ~/f~f~~1 ~ ~,,,7 ,·r ~r ~~~· ~ ~~su?

~ .-t> ·/lL f ,"I f) r LA-r-rft·~-ft n-.­

v 8!- -~ ~ . ~-. 1"4.. s~ '~ vA--of . ( prt/ sA)

Sl[rkrrr (olk-¢ vv{- (/f)L 1\ 54- ~ [N.­-..=::::---­

. ~ -fo g~ _;:;) ~ ~ t#o--) f~. . ,v.

~ .. ~-My~~_ 3v ·' ~7 h ~­(PlM- sy~n;~_/· ~ ~­ .

f) j (/?><-- 1::-h:wv I ·P -t<rM4it; ~ """- .-;; ~/-f--17...., ) tvo ~ .~ IV'If ~ · ~ ~Y6U- tt5 cF~ · ft.-+

~~

4

#b 7 Jj ~ /}}/--# /65 pv< ~;I s-~

At~ CvJ A/\ /~d ~

1171-~ fi-·» ~-~~ ~-~~~ ) d.-1.1 ~ ~.re{/cj ~ ~ /A/"j Y ~/~ ~ -~l_ ~ -tf~ /Uv<f~ 74

. (fit/ ~ ~li-J ~ /llsilf- ... . . ~~ -jb /uv~ tv+- I(_ #~ ~Q_

-~ ~ ' ~ -~ . ye ~~ --1 ~ /_.4.5\(2 . ~ ~ .(c)>t....;_J ~ vt/~

~ ~ to £o / . . 6j)7 ~t?tA/1.•

' . /-

f~ _ a:_fl_ ~ /~ic --f,~ i afltt~ ~ ~/l ~~ 0 ~~~(<._ }~ f.l (frf- ~ -A-I·vy ~ ·, ;

/lA) /?fc- 1 -~/·fl'/.'j 1D ~ r ';.J~.

Jl~~y .t:f (~'k ~ a. s~A c_ co/1/c:.v-/! wf~ vi- ./

( ~ ::tr~:~io)Cl~v~~~~~_As ~ a_ /'~~ ~ or ~~P(J~ s~

5 . . 17» ~J ~~IYI~

{M__ tv-ve vt. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~-r . ~ ~ f/fi>(l r4 ~ ~

·JM- . ~/-!4- ~71 ;-~/ ~ ~ ~ . "'~ .: tJr g4- . ~ <-J>~ __,~ /c--e

o~A ?v() ~ C?~ %~. ~ -~ 6t~~

J)v ~h~

•. J/<- ~ ~~ ,M,P« ~"f?L- /~r--~ ;t6v4- CA~V7 tJr atrf"'#/?:7 ~r ,~0~

~~) :!5-k--m.·c. r:;e-n;-~ f, us .7'1/,~ i . . . J

.Rm ,w .r/~-nevJ ~ r,.,_., ..._..r .s4-. ·lt'I .,J /:r 'ft,..,_ t(.ir~-f · Al !r"- ~ /h'c..1J,'4f1-l.trc I!.PrJ? SilA:k.: .....c ~ ~ ~ ~ /·4~J~

?K ~ -K lkte£.J~ ,vt)jc - J~ . ~ . ,·~ -f'b ~ ~·(a Jf/61 · /t:JJ~4.J ~=r ~ a_ ~ )?,~5+(( <Po ~ --1-v ~~-- ~ ~~-Z>~

6

~ pitor I~ fD Mf a. f(rl-· p ~ ~~ ~71' -p Jvp.Jv-7- rf.

F/fJhl- Sv~ - ?~ftv?/(.h'-UJ:

k-f r ~ (r!.-vA ~ a /'~//ht-7 c ~ ()/JY)_J - c:/t}y_) ;'

~ -tt- c;; /i -fTr-L , ~ ~~ dVz C( c 1tv f ;­

~ft?r> _<>! ~t..A>fi' f,"f . /'~l::f ~ /lr-VJV'~j'

;[:?y ~f ---jv t5:J W<- t~Av(d/1 i Lve- r r!Vi­

-ft.. ~ - --ft;-rhA- s~ ~ ~] -{lr ~

j f'hdn ­") /11~~ 4vf- /Z-t/tJ pt(:.q tVrC- f?3; ~.5

(/ vYILif ~l.u!- ,tt"'rft· j:·rzc·~-t . ~J) ;;~ 'fv/V~.

?I ~,r '" ;W,nlf fiwv;• r '"r--~ y.v~ -1 ": ~. /(J{ . 1/f 11- 6'0?4-<~.-<-M ~

c;itce ~ d-t)~-r-- rr?

~ ~-""v~

\kc /r ;t d{ ('{. 8 @ {z)Lqp -< ""5

~ - IlV

U 5~trf _~v-y GJ6;:Vcn·~ -f&(_vfr

~,(-') ~ .)1Jf~oJ fv prf- ~~S r~ '-f- .

TL-z_ ~J ~~ ?VII- f4- ~cl to ~?

J~ I'V1 ·: ~ if<v~ .fl£_ ~ ~~ -;1) ~ ~ ;/;i)

1

tL ~ / --r

7

~-

<:c ~ cJ..;"S ~~ J~ ~5~

JlJikf"ch r M~:bo-.~-

:;:R;(;)IV/~ =r; Ykr inr.;n 5 t¥!UM FE! ~R:V~;;>

'1

8 Withheld from public release by National Archives and Records Administration under 36 C.F.R. § 1256.50

~ mq ~ fu ~~ N~ hi- I ~ vJM ~J-

) ~~ ce'dn /f dale- ~ ~

-i .~J ~~

Y~-~-. ~ ;'f/l)r A -n, -led ~ ~~7 t-t-­

0//.PV· fl:?/ SJI-tJ~ cJ.-1--- CA/~r ~ ~ /bf/"7'7

ttu~l-~ F. Co ;rv~fV~ ~ fi/~, · ~;P ftr.

. . -cbt d-->-t r J ,......e. ~ lJ <:)...A re._ .s;.· ~

{; /dJ~'J /1 g, /.'v'/4_ J./n -rf.N\ ri'H>f.y.

~61 . ~~~ ~ +r, ~ yvv-~ ~ f,_,d_ • ~ t.<­

7 .4ur- - ~ 5~ ~.._,.,,. ~ l.a.J IV!M~~~ c;A/~~. -fie ~~ w§.vf- .{/I);V/vv/11)/o/ ~~ ·k H;4/~

~r1 r::J3 - fA/"0 ~k k vV~ ~ M H-z,3M (. -fr 14( ~ ~ / 11 f-e._, e-vr

~I V"';)~ /...il"'~ --fvr-~

I /,/.·/1 I' .. / C! 6~~JZ,~. ~VV*J vta.A J o-v => b~~ '-'t"'· cTrt r 1~==-==-------___,2-J,......-----rlv....,.......~r v- .> rt c/ft:?t..--e 5 lvrr/tl ~ ~ ,f

~~I r~_A~ tv y~ /~ 7D PA

rt

!

< -7

-<-

-

1-

i

I

­

­

9

/jffv ~t~v :)>/ - J~ 0 P f b~ - s~ -fL_ 7/y ~ pr vftJ ­

-f7Jy; w ~tl 1/- ~ J-F~ -;J7t;__ ~ MtJ- ~tJ ~ j0fv<-£::?~ f£u- 'r+r~ jd.j -jL ~ ?<NtJI ~ ~ ~~-~ ,- . /'"~ LOv'(cY ~ ~~ ~v--"--1.. -(Dt-;f ""-'" Up .

.. J~ 5&iAte?{ ~ d.'& M+ ­

~ ~[A_ S~ ~ · ~~ So

.. ~ . c. tvJ~' ;;.-L"' ~ Clo_;--UP . ctev-n ~·~'-C..· .

74:J . ~ "A~br It cJf ~ o~-t- · (p .. (J~>~L- ~ ·- ,

¥ r r;r ~~ i ~ /Lt'"'-h{--' ~ . ~ . ~ ->s :~, ~ ft?../7' · 'blv\~ 6 -v./r --j;;_ ~ ;..r-­

~ 't/'(\ '

fvM fo, "' f-ur .II ,...v'/0j 1~ /1 .. ~ A-v--~1-.

· P,.e y:v rre,~ yc_,._ ~ ~ , tt /3,~ tAd..·"" "'~~ ~~ +. fy((

~ , Ill~ vvt<f rvvri:dr"t..NtLcl<-<4 ~f- ~·7' ~ k' ~'K ·,n ¥' ~IS£ (e-5 - ·~ /v4L I<M(/J~ ~r- I 'I-.

10

~ . ~ ~) '" ~ -n_;, ~/h ·, ~) fW 1tr ~ ~tkf /~"c-4<--7 ... JD~d--j b~ A-A? ~.-<_ s-~~ ~~;

..

~ v-~ ~

~~

11

f;n;,Jyt '~'} fr'i'?n '1 ( ~d-<_f t; J7 tr fk ;IA~'l~ s~ . ?; c~ 1R /1'/ , ~ ~

fi~&LL- Aj~ ~ P /:.v+v ~ ~

s_~ ·. -:;c:-...,e ·-rL .$Y2<4-.s-v~J .s./';rli<H,_

{/'/vJ U/h~'·c;_,.~ -n, !iPt>.TT /f- ~ J~!~-/?u - /

tnJ~f fZU1A) h~ 5 (t :b-~Ptflr ~~ pi(A/~ ~(A,~ Y~ -::f~c~ Jz,h, ---(1 ?I~ ~~5 ~ .

J~ Jt0Z~ ·

il{ (,~ q 5-?~4:!_~ ,, ·;;;: fo-~~.(Jvvv

11~<--1 flu~,;- !'--;/} /'7 - w~ vv...,"' r ~1.£ -lv .. #11 FIJ-It :rAI'M , . I

lMJ~ 11..:,_ hy·U;-- ~ ~ "'-v··~ .d1

~ ~ ;vw-v-e. . :~r~ ,vr:;lo ~ j[~ CA~/YI; ~ ~ ~ ~. I

.. 0;'tviJtF~A- 11t lr~~+ f ~s. ~

12

/J dtd ";/ f¥v'JJ<r"" 6(v-£rJ NN Cod 7> w0 ~ -fJj ,__

Jl~'iie- ;!l-(64-a-i;'t;/IJ ~ -h• Hlf- ;.#-k-l - /t- /1-jd r ~~~~ / o/}_P llc&t?ftr<:- tfj -fi!Jt 1 ---(r;v1( ~y -- . t-/~ ,e-vf-­

t1J ;tA. #! tY '1 /{/It .ruf ~~ h •)1-1 to F;44 .

Jlv{+--~~~~ 0'tV~"f-~-fc;r ·c. -cfVl4--£.flJ /~ <>-f J"-'~ - I'~ /h; &.n> / j>lt-rJ­,j . 1/7 ~ ~ hJ j,.?fvr-<_ ~Y -:ib C/•~""~ .JorJ?.

/fL j5 ~r~ ~ ~ ·;ez..,vr{- ==~ .-<-4

~ r{,uyJ ~~ ~ ~ r( t~r ~-

~L. 1".5 .. /VV )1'--L ~ d~~J rf ~

S#-- tf(:z t/7-r . ~ • • ·

~f-:s&Mvl~,¢11! /t- W a daw-- r~/~ 7 ~I

· ~ . ~ ·~ Wv~14 r -/Ut /iVf .

1L. f/JtJwr11 f/'/M ~ Jaltr tAJ tJI/ I ,.-,r .tt71 Jc ~...~ u t- d4r- ?-J ~ .i;.,ptvtf- . ~ ~---

13 Withheld from public release by National Archives and Records Administration under 36 C.F.R. § 1256.50

"£11, (h . ~; w Urn Ml1f~ .

I : I

.fi1ft ,ft4t/ hel MJ-- ~ ~ ~ ?~~ . +r ,·/ ~- -/0 ~ ?vg ~~ {/:/~~~ . ~· ~ ~

Fe;

./

- S1V3 ..,

I "1/.:Fr NJv1 /vUI'hl~ ~ (kll/0·J-- ~ --14__ ~.

J~: {p6 °<0 <r" .. . Hi-q. ~. MFL d.S--(Y,b~ ..

4w h 1/;, th:J/ J :' h?; J~ ~~ ~ ~. f~; ~I _5~ ~ I ~ ~- :

'' I

15

J· ·~- ~JZ( . rty~t>

( p~~ ~~j"

J~ ~ --rL. ~ +> ( ~ I '-[ft__

.. !l--...- SA- Gv+ ~ ~~ ---T-u 1-h C-( .it:;>~

k/ f~ L<.. lv_;~ J~ ~ ~ -~ . dtJ6iA-r~ ~ 6~; ~~ ~~+- c (\.-e_ --r{- ~ l ~ ~ Ovt_ -rL..._

~ ~vJ0+j .0-. . S 1a..1< . c-r :: A-~ - ve-JU

.. (/1Mr~ ~ 4u.M 1-- ~ L-vv1 ~yc..rv~,u_ j ~

.. ({\/'; j . ~--s;:i'-~J ~ +fv_. PG{ l CVS-hM..J ( jr./J

. ~~·~ . 'rvter.x<.evv~) . ---(4 ·-PLJ'kA- .. ·

. _: · ~~-

~~ -\v ~ s~ fl:>t tJ.-<c,Y._ ,.._ · · ~ ~ .

~ JJ( ~- p~~ ~r i .

k- . . ()v {)J:, I 'v\.

~ -tu +L ~+- \'-f-­

16

..

~. <h-' - o-f ----rk cf./ ~W'b ---w- J ~· ~ j

J\c_ ~ ~s~ w~ Y/c­+ {/V"'V\ ~ -h.> dcz) - ­

~ fPBI (A;~ ( . .n- YF . p ..-< £ev (A/'J t.,A

s L .~~ ~ (pVOU2Ar?. !