igor budak

LESS FORMAL TOOLSLESS FORMAL TOOLSFOR ENVIRONMENTAL FOR ENVIRONMENTAL

MANAGEMENTMANAGEMENT

TEMPUS DEREL seminar in TEMPUS DEREL seminar in Novi SadNovi Sad, May 30-31, May 30-31, 201, 20133

Igor BudakIgor Budak

22

Introduction

Environmental labeling of products

Life Cycle Assessment

Eco-design

ContentContent

The Environmental Management System (EMS) is one of the most used management tools for different types of organizations because it enables the integration of environmental protection in all activities of an organization.

Experiences of small and medium-sized enterprises have shown that the introduction of EMS is a complex process, and also demanding administratively in terms of human resources, as well as from the standpoint of consulting services, which discourages its use in small organizations.

For this reason, a range of other voluntary tools for the environmental improvement used in various countries and organizations in the world has been developed.

These less formal tools are applied in specific circumstances, on the basis of decision within the organization or in some case in the industrial sector, or jointly with local, regional or state government.

IntroductionIntroduction

Less formal tools (LFT) of environmental management are adapted to local conditions, and perhaps that is the reason for their efficiency.

LFT can be the first step of the formal introduction of EMS.

Also, LFT can be used as an effective extension of the existing EMS, for permanent environmental improvement.

Some of the best known and most widely used less formal tools are:LCA - Life Cycle Assessment,Environmental Labelling of Products,Eco-design,Green Public Procurement,Environmental Performance Evaluation,Social responsibility of an organization,Energy efficiency,Cleaner production,Environmental benchmarking,Environmental accounting,etc.

IntroductionIntroduction

55

E M S t o o l s

Formalmanagement

sistems

Less formal management

tools

Standardized environmental evaluation &EMS audit

Certified projects of local authorities and organizations

for environmental

protection

- EMS according to standardISO 1400x

- EMS according to EMAS directive

- EMS in the framework of IMS

- Life Cycle Assessment,

- Environmental Labeling of Products,

- Eco-design,

- Green Public Procurement,

- Environmental Performance Evaluation,

- Social responsibility of an organization,

- Energy efficiency,

- Cleaner production,

- Environmental benchmarking,

- Environmental accounting,

- etc.

- ISO 14001, 04 (EMS)

- ISO 14030, 31, 32 (EPE)

- ISO 19001 (audit of EMS & QMS)

- ISO 14020, 21, 24, 25 (eco-labeling)

- ISO 14040, 41, 42, 43, 44, 48, 49 (LCA)

- ISO 14050 (EM vocabulary)

- ISO 14062 (Integration in product design)

- STN 839060 (EA implem. in product standards)

- STN 839066 (EM sistem sertification & registration)

- Eco lighthouse (Norway)

- Eco mapping (Belgium)

- Scheme for podršku aktivnosti za zaštitu žs MAF (Švedska)

- Schema Convoy (Germany)

- Eco camping (Germany)

- Eco profit (Austria)- Creation of green profession (Danmark)

LFT selectionLFT selection

66

7777

The main reasons for the introduction of eco-labels, include the following:

promoting the development, production, advertising and use of products that endanger the environment as little as possible;

stimulating production which saves natural resources to the maximum extent and uses recyclable materials;

providing customers with complete and reliable information on the environmental impact of specific product/service, which makes buying easier for buyers interested in the environment protection.

ENVIRONMENTAL LABELLINGENVIRONMENTAL LABELLING

88

PRODUCERS CUSTOMERS

ECOLABEL

PURCHASING

999999

Emergence of a large number of eco-labels, as well as the problems with their implementation, have led to a series of activities run by the International Organization for Standardization – ISO, to determine and define the firm concepts, parameters, guidelines and terminology related to the environmental labeling at the international level.

The result is a series of standards ISO 14020 (in Republic of Serbia SRPS ISO 14020), which currently includes standards ISO 14020, ISO 14021, ISO 14024 and ISO 14025.

This series of standards is the first published document that refers to the environmental labeling, and it was published in 1998.

ECO LABELS AND ISO STANDARDSECO LABELS AND ISO STANDARDS

1010101010101010

Documents belonging to ISO 14020 series require, among other things, that environmental labels must:

result in better environmental management,

be applicable in all countries,

represent the interests of consumers,

be scientifically based,

take into account the product life cycle,

be accurate, verifiable and relevant to the product in question,

must not create difficulties when exporting and

be practical and usable.

ECO LABELS AND ISO STANDARDSECO LABELS AND ISO STANDARDS

11111111111111111111

ISO 14020 promotes 9 principles that should apply to all eco labels and declarations:1.– Environmental labels and declarations must be accurate, verifiable and relevant, and should not be confusing.2.- The procedures and requirements for environmental labels and declarations must not be prepared, adopted or applied without previous adjustment to the international market.3.- Environmental labels and declarations must be based on scientific methodology, which is complete and comprehensive to the extent to which it supports the claims and gives results that are accurate and repeatable.4.- Information on the procedures, methodology and any criteria for support of environmental labels and declarations must be available and accessible to all interested parties.5.- When creating environmental labels and declarations all relevant aspects of the product life cycle must be considered.

BASIC PRINCIPLES OF ECO LABELINGBASIC PRINCIPLES OF ECO LABELING

121212121212121212121212

6. - Environmental labels and declarations should not hinder innovation that could maintain or enhance environmental effect.

7. - Any administrative requirements or requirements for information on environmental labels and declarations must be limited to those necessary to establish compliance with applied criteria and standards for labels and declarations.

8. - The process of developing environmental labels and declarations should be open to consultation with interested parties. One must invest certain effort to reach the consensus in this process.

9. - Information on the environmental aspects of products or services relevant to the labels or declarations must be available to buyers and potential buyers by the subject who formed the label or declaration.

BASIC PRINCIPLES OF ECO LABELINGBASIC PRINCIPLES OF ECO LABELING

1313131313131313131313131313

There are a number of different approaches to environmental labelling. Within the ISO 14020 series of standards, so far, apart from the standard ISO 14020, standards ISO 14021, ISO 14024 and ISO 14025 were prepared, within which three types of environmental labelling were defined:

• Type I - Voluntary, based on a multiple criteria third-party program, under which a license is granted which authorizes the use of the environmental labels for products, which confirms the overall fitness for the environment within certain product category, and which is based on the life cycle assessment.

• Type II - Self-declaration by environmental claims - refers to the environmental labelling performed without an independent third party certification, by manufacturers, importers, distributors, retailers or anyone else who benefits from such claim.

• Type III - Voluntary labelling programs based on quantifiable data about the product life cycle from the environmental aspect, provided by the manufacturer, independently verified (e.g., by a third party) and presented as a series of categorized parameters within the sectored groups.

Environmental labels classification Environmental labels classification

1414

Type I environmental labellingType I environmental labellingProgram name Country Year

Blue Angel Germany 1977TCO Development Sweden 1980

Environmental Choice program

Canada 1988

BRA MILJOVAL Sweden 1988

White Swan Scandinavian countries 1989

Eco Mark Japan 1989Green Seal USA 1989

Good Environmental Choice Australia 1989Environmental Choice New Zealand 1989

NF Environnement France 1991Milieukeur Netherland 1991Eco Mark India 1991Eco-label EU 1992Eco Mark South Korea 1992

Green Mark Program Taiwan 1992Green Label Singapore 1992

Medio Ambiente Spain 1993El Distintiu Spain-Catalonia 1993

Umweltzeichen Austria 1993Prijatelj Okoliša Croatia 1993

Environmental Friendly Product

Czech Republic 1994

Kornyezetbarat Termek Hungary 1994Green Label Program Israel 1994Green Label Thailand Thailand 1994

Water Lily Lithuania 1996Ekološki Podesan Proizvod Slovakia 1998

Ekologiczny Poland 2000Green LabelEco Label

Hong Kong 2000

Environment 2000 Zimbabwe 2000Vitality Leaf Russia 2001

The Program for Development of Ecological

Marking in UkraineUkraine 2002

Green Choice Philippines Philippines 2002Qualidade Ambiental Brazil 2003Ecolabel Indonezia Indonesia 2006

Prijatelj životne sredine Serbia 2009

Prijatelj OkolišaBosnia and Herzegovina

– Federation 2009

1717

www.ec.europa.eu/ecolabel

1818

Type II environmental labellingType II environmental labelling

An important phase of editing this area of environmental labelling is the development of International Standard ISO 14021 - Environmental labels and declarations - Self-declared environmental claims (Type II environmental labelling), first published in 1999.

According to this standard, self-declared environmental claims include the statements, labels or symbols relating a particular activity, product or service of manufacturers, which may impact the environment.

This is a special type of advertising.

They are placed on the product or product packaging, the accompanying product documentation, technical audit, or are referred to in advertisements in printed or electronic media such as TV and Internet.

They are issued by the manufacturer, importer, distributor, dealer, or anyone who might benefit from such an announcement, but without certification by an independent third party, which is one of the main differences compared to type I.

1919

Overview of frequently applied type II Overview of frequently applied type II environmental claims and labels environmental claims and labels

Compostable Degradable Designed for disassembling Extended product lifetimeRenewed energyRecyclableRecycled contentPre-consumer material Post-consumer material Recycled materialRenewed (recovered) materialsReduced energy consumptionReduced consumption of resourcesReduced water consumptionRe-usableRechargeableWaste minimisation

List of most frequently used terms in self-

declared environmental claims from ISO 14021 International Standard

2020

Mobius loopMobius loop

The Mobius loop is a self -declared environmental label, whose use is not charged, but it is technically regulated. The symbol should not be used in a modified form and as such appropriated by the companies, as their logo or other symbol. This symbol is not protected and it is used in various ways and in different variations, and in most general sense it indicates:that the product (or the part of it) is recyclable

that the recycled materials were used in the production process.

2121

Bearing in mind the importance of the environmental declaration in the global market, it is not surprising that an increasing number of companies their commitment towards caring for the environment are manifesting through different logos.

Self-created self-declared labels Self-created self-declared labels

22222222

Type III environmental labellingType III environmental labelling

An important ISO standards development stage related to environmental labelling is determining ISO 14025 in 2000, which defined type III environmental declaration as quantified environmental data for a product, with pre-determined parameters, based on the ISO 14040 series of standards, not excluding the additional environmental data that are in accordance with type III environmental declaration.

Therefore, type III environmental labelling should provide quantified environmental information based on life cycle assessment (LCA) and pre-set categories of parameters set by a qualified third party and verified by the same or another qualified third party.

The goal is to ensure communication of quantified and verifiable environmental information about the product, including the entire life cycle.

232323232323

The basic principles of type III environmental The basic principles of type III environmental labellinglabelling

Objectivity - Quantitative data on environ-mental protection with pre-set categories of indicators pre-set based on scientifically accepted and valid methods of LCA. This quantitative analysis is more objective than the qualitative certification method which is used for Type I environmental labelling.

Non-selectivity and neutrality – There are no prespecified levels of environmental performance the report must possess. Assessment of information regarding product is left to the consumer.

Comparability - Information from the environmental declarations are collected and calculated by the general regulations. Due to the existence of different product categories, data collection methods and life cycle assessment which are unique to a particular category are accepted as a rule for a given category.

Credibility – Environmental declarations , in most cases, are reviewed and verified by a third party, thereby LCA results have greater credibility than self-declared environmental claims that are typical for type II labels and claims.

242424242424

The procedures for type III environmental labellingThe procedures for type III environmental labelling

1. Establishing product evaluating methods;

2. Organizing committees – which should ensure transparent monitoring and participation in consultations with stakeholders;

3. Establishing product category rules (PCR) with committees;

4. Establishing and maintaining a database of LCA parameters;

5. Managing the process of verification - LCA results followed by product evaluation applicants have been reviewed by auditors who are bound by contract or directly employed by the administrator;

6. Control of the product registration status - the administrator has also the responsibility of determining the period after which the product registration expires;

7. Managing the program website - the Internet is a very important tool for advertising environmental product declarations;

8. Program improvement and education of consumers and applicants - income is the main motive for companies to participate, and the administrator should try to reinforce that motivation emphasizing the growing environmental awareness of consumers and educating consumers on how to find and use information about the declarations;

9. Cooperation with other type III programs - GEDnet.

2525

Examples of type III environmental labels

2828

LCA, as the name suggests, is a method for evaluating products and manufacturing processes, in terms of environmental impact in all phases of the product life cycle - from extraction of raw materials, through design, production and distribution, to application and treatment at the end of life.

LIFE CYCLE ASSESMENTLIFE CYCLE ASSESMENT

29292929

Analysis of possibilities to improve environmental effects of products in various stages of their life cycle;

The decision making process in industry, government institutions and NGOs, either at the strategic level, or the current (daily) level related to planning, setting of priorities, designing and manufacturing;

In the process of identification of significant indicators of the environmental protection efficiency;

LCA is an essential tool in the evaluation of the product in environmental labelling programs and the creating environmental statements and declarations of products;

Application of LCA in the development of new and/or redesign of existing products (or product systems) allows the integration of environmental aspects into the design process in accordance with ISO/TR 14062.

Fields of LCA application Fields of LCA application

3131

LCA beginnings date back to the 60s of the 20th century.

Before 1990, this method was developed and applied mostly in unorganized manner - different actors (institutional and industrial) have applied various methods for data search, which were then expressed in different, often incompatible units.

The year 1990 can be considered, due to the SETAC conference (Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry), when a differently performed and until then, incomparable analysis were methodologically unified.

At the next SETAC conference in 1992, the process of further harmonization of LCA methodology was carried out and, in 1997 the roof LCA standard ISO 14040 was published, and served as a base on which other standards in this group were further developed and published.

In the period between 1997 and 2002, there has been intensive development of LCIA methods, and consequently, after 2002 intensified development of databases to support the LCIA methods.

Historical development of LCAHistorical development of LCA

32323232

Development of the ISO series of International Standards listed here significantly contributed to more harmonized and organized application of LCA method.

LCA and ISO International StandardsLCA and ISO International StandardsInternational label Label in R. of Serbia Name StatusISO 14040:1997 SRPS ISO 14040:2000 Environmental management -

Life cycle assessment - Principles and framework

Withdrawn

ISO 14041:1998 SRPS ISO 14041:2002 Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Goal and scope definition and inventory analysis

Withdrawn

ISO 14042:2000 SRPS ISO 14042:2005 Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Life cycle impact assessment

Withdrawn

ISO 14042:2000 SRPS ISO 14043:2005 Environmental management - Life cycle assessment – Life cycle interpretation

Withdrawn

ISO/TR 14047:2003

/ Environmental management - Life cycle impact assessment - Examples of application of ISO 14042

Active

ISO/TS 14048:2002

SRPS ISO/TS 14048:2006

Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Data documentation format

Active

ISO/TR 14049:2000

SRPS ISO/TR 14049:2005

Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Examples of application of ISO 14041 to goal and scope definition and inventory analysis

Active

ISO 14040:2006 SRPS ISO 14040:2008 Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Principles and framework

Active

ISO 14044:2006 SRPS ISO 14044:2009 Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Requirements and guidelines

Active

33333333

Life cycle perspective

Focus on the environment

LCA is a relative approach structured around the functional unit

Iterative approach

Transparency

Clarity

The advantage of the scientific approach

Basic principles of LCABasic principles of LCA

353535353535

LCA systematically evaluates aspects and environmental impacts of the product system.

LCA is characterized by the relative approach due to funding of the methodology at a functional unit.

The depth and timescale of the LCA may vary significantly, depending on the defined objective and subject.

LCA methodology is open to the inclusion of new scientific knowledge and improvements.

There is no single method for conducting the LCA; the application of LCA is characterized by flexibility in accordance with the intended application and the requirements of the organization.

Key features of LCAKey features of LCA

Example of a product system for LCA(from ISO 14040:2006)

An example of a set of unit processes within the product system (from ISO 14040:2006)

3636

Examples of flows within the product system in LCA

Type of flow Example

Basic flows which enter the unit process

Oil from the soil and radiation from the sun

Basic flows which leave the unit process

Emissions into the air, discharges into water or soil, radiation

Flows of intermediate products

Basic materials and subassemblies

Flows of products entering or leaving the system

Recycled materials and components for reuse

373737373737

LCA method consists of four phases (interconnected as shown in figure):1) defining the objective and subject;2) inventory analysis;3) impact assessment and4) interpretation.

Phases of LCAPhases of LCA

3838383838383838

Life Cycle Inventory analysis (LCI)Life Cycle Inventory analysis (LCI)

Course of the LCI in accordance with ISO 14044

3939

Life Cycle Impact Assessment (LCI)Life Cycle Impact Assessment (LCI)

Basic elements of the LCIA phase

4141Relations between elements within the interpretation phase with other phases of LCA

Interpretation of the life cycleInterpretation of the life cycle

42420%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Resources Climate change Ecosystem quality Human health

Manufacturing Installation Use phase End-of-life

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Human health Ecosystem quality Climate change Resources

Water Detergent Electricity

43434343

Ecodesign represents the integration of environmental aspects into planning, designing and development of products and processes.

Ecodesign:

enables the reduction of undesirable and harmful impact on the environment throughout the entire product life cycle,

improves the product quality from the environmental aspect,

aims to reduce the negative environmental impacts on the without undesired effects on the product quality.

Ecodesign (term used in Europe) or Design for Environment – DfE (term used in the US) defines a new way of product development, whereby the environmental aspects are given the same status as functionality, durability, price, selling time, aesthetics, ergonomics and quality.

ECODESIGNECODESIGN

4444Implementation of ecodesign for obtaining

environmentally compatible products

4545

Ecodesign and conventional design relationship

Ecodesign strategy wheel

4646

No.Descriptio

nQty

.

"A" cast iron "B" steel "C" aluminium

MaterialMass(kg)

Processes MaterialMass(kg)

Processes MaterialMass(kg)

Process

1donji deo kućišta

1Cast ironGGG60 I

55.292Casting, Drilling, Milling

G-AlSi12 (230) I


G-AlSi12 (230) I


2gornji deo

kućišta1

Cast ironGGG60 I


G-AlSi12 (230) I


G-AlSi12 (230) I


3prvi deo

rotor1

Cast ironGGG60 I

7.261Casting, Drilling,

Steel25CrMo4

7.250Casting, Drilling

G-AlSi8Cu3


4drugi deo

rotora1

Cast ironGGG60

7.261Casting, Drilling,

Steel25CrMo4

7.250Casting , Drilling

G-AlSi8Cu3


5kolenasto

vratilo1

Cast ironGGG70


Steel25CrMo4


Carbon steel c55


6 klip 4Aluminium

alloyG-AlSi8Cu3

0.302Casting, Drilling

Aluminium alloy

G-AlSi8Cu30.302

Casting, Drilling,

aluminium

Aluminium alloyG-

AlSi8Cu3


7gornji deo klipnjače

4Cast iron

GG350.611

Casting, Drilling, Milling

Carburized Cr-Mo steel42CrMo4


Carburized Cr-Mo steel

42CrMo4


8donji deo klipnjače

4Cast iron

GG350.205

Casting, Drilling, Milling

Carburized Cr-Mo steel42CrMo4


Carburized Cr-Mo steel

42CrMo4


9klipna

osovinica4

Cast ironGGG70


Steel high grade15Cr3

0.155 Casting

Stainless steel

X35CrMo17 I

0.155 Casting

igor budak

Documents

environmental labels

environmental benchmarking

environmental accounting

iso standards

series of standards

standardization iso

formal introduction

used management tools