ieee/industry applications society/technical book ... working group copy of ieee c57.110 ....
TRANSCRIPT
IEEE/Industry Applications Society/Technical Book Coordinating Committee Protection & Coordination Working Group (IAS/TBCC/3004 WG) P3004.8 “Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems” Working Group Meeting December 9, 2014 –WEB only Approved Minutes Issued January 9, 2015; Published January 22, 2015 Chair Lorraine Padden called the meeting to order at 8:00 a.m. on December 9, 2014, at WEB online meeting. Agenda: A motion was made by Jim Crook and seconded by Jeff Hensley to approve the agenda. Meeting agenda was approved. Meeting Attendees: (See Attachment) Attendees were introduced on the WEB/telecon and attendance was taken. Minutes The minutes of the previous meeting October 28, 2014 were posted online and votes were taken of the voting members in person/web and using the ePoll feature of IEEE 3004.8 mentor site. The minutes were approved and will be posted to the mentor site. IEEE Patent Slides The IEEE Patent Slides were reviewed. No patent issues were brought forward by anyone in attendance. Care will be taken for the online monitoring to avoid product specific descriptions. PAR Scope, Purpose and Schedule Working Group was asked if there were any questions regarding the Par Scope, Purpose and Schedule. There were no questions. A Task Group meeting was held on November 18 where the material for ASD sections was reviewed and comments included in the current draft. The general target is to complete the draft by First Quarter 2015, ballot the Working Group 1Q 2015 (3 week review), meeting January, invitation to ballot 1Q 2015, start formal balloting 2Q 2015, and submit to RevCom after Mid 2015. Based on formal ballot timing, a PAR extension was submitted to NesCom. The Working Group requested information on signing up in myProject so they could get the invitation to ballot. This information is on the IEEE 3004.8 mentor site and is also attached to these minutes. Still pending is the request made by the Working Group to set up a one to two hour meeting with Lisa Perry of IEEE to step through the sign-up for invitation, accepting invitation, and balloting/commenting process. NOTE: to vote on this standard, sign up in myProject, respond to the invitation to ballot, and respond to formal ballot – vote & comment. (see attachment)
IEEE/Industry Applications Society/Technical Book Coordinating Committee Protection & Coordination Working Group (IAS/TBCC/3004 WG) P3004.8 “Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems” Working Group Meeting December 9, 2014 –WEB only Old Business • Review Task List (see attached) The Task List was updated as needed. See attached. New Business • Status PAR Extension
Lisa Perry and Rasheek Rifaat submitted the PAR extension request prior to the October 20 deadline for the NecCom’s December meeting.
• Copyrights; NEMA, API, & IEEE
The copyright form needs to be sent to all persons contributing Figures and Tables. A list of Figures and Tables was added to the front of the standard. Copyright forms will be drafted and sent to the company representatives for completion of the documents.. Lisa Perry indicated that the copyrights should be in hand before the Mandatory Editorial Comments.
Jim Bryan and EASA’s contact with NEMA received positive feedback that IEEE 3004.8 could pursue copyrights with NEMA for some material proposed to include in IEEE 3004.8. Lorraine will work with Jim on the material proposed and coordinating the copyright release forms for NEMA.
Lorraine contacted Duane Brown at API regarding the vibration tables for 541. Their legal department has not finished reviewing and approving the final document. When this is available, the materials and copyright will be completed.
• Review DC Motor Protection, Clause 10 ; Bryan
There were several comments on the DC motor section prepared by Jim Bryan and Chuck Yung. Add disclaimer, this does not include train traction drives.
• Review ASD, Clause 9; Crook
The information from the November 18 Task Group meeting was reviewed. It was noted there are still several figures pending updates. These again are targeted completion prior to the next meeting.
IEEE/Industry Applications Society/Technical Book Coordinating Committee Protection & Coordination Working Group (IAS/TBCC/3004 WG) P3004.8 “Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems” Working Group Meeting December 9, 2014 –WEB only
Next Meetings The next meetings were planned as follows: Web only meeting for Tuesday January 20, 2015. (Note this is changed to Jan.22) (purpose, complete the draft for Working Group Vote) ½ Day; 8:00 am – Noon Texas Time A motion to adjourn was made by Randall Groves and seconded by Dan Ransom. Motion unanimously approved. The Meeting adjourned at 12:00 p.m. Lorraine K. Padden, Chair, IEEE P3004.8 Attachments: 3004.8 Task List, Meeting Attendees, & myProject signup instructions for invitation to ballot
IEEE/Industry Applications Society/Technical Book Coordinating Committee Protection & Coordination Working Group (IAS/TBCC/3004 WG) P3004.8 “Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems” Working Group Meeting December 9, 2014 –WEB only
3004.8 TASK LIST
Section No. Description Lead/Group
General
Yellow highlights-references to old Buff book – decide if we reference old book and/or new standards that are in development. Same for other Color Book references.
- Are they needed - If so is there new reference - If not, keep old reference
Paul Cardinal Lorraine Padden
9. Develop ASD section Jim Crook-Lead, Jeff Hensley, Dan Neeser, Tim O’Hearn, John Kay
General Check NEMA references – plan for September December 2014 meeting Jim Bryan
8.4.5
Add NEMA vibration table, copyright; plan for August OctoberDecember 2014 meeting (inquiry sent to NEMA-Lisa Perry ask about MOU;)Jim inquired to NEMA – copyright contact person.”LKP to draft”
Jim Bryan; Padden
Get with Kurt LeDoux on LV ASD application- request made by lkp- August December meeting
Lorraine Padden
Get with Michael Noonan for LV ASD applications, December meeting
Lorraine Padden
GE Example, Bharat Mistry Lorraine Padden Check, overcurrent, overvoltage, undervoltage Lorraine Padden
Send Copyright-release to WG members/post on mentor site Lorraine Padden
9.1.2
Check with Barry Wood to see if API standards discuss ASD applications; - telecon June 13, 2013 Sent emails – follow-up w/API September 2014; October Duane Brown is still waiting on API Legal to release API 541.
Lorraine Padden
11 DC ASD motor protection – plan for December 2014 Overspeed; field loss; centrifugal switch & tach feedback; armature overcurrent; thermal protection
Chris Heron, John Kay, Jim Bryan, Chuck Yung
IEEE/Industry Applications Society/Technical Book Coordinating Committee Protection & Coordination Working Group (IAS/TBCC/3004 WG) P3004.8 “Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems” Working Group Meeting December 9, 2014 –WEB only
Section No. Description Lead/Group
C37 Fig. 39 Prepare new C37 Fig. 39, ASD Zones of protection; added to D3.6; updated 3/2014; update August December 2014 use Dev. 11; keep 87M & 49
John Kay
C37 Fig. 40
Update Figure with transformer protection; update CT symbols Consult w/David Shipp on Transformer secondary configuration (ungrounded delta MV) and protection needed
Lorraine Padden
C37 Fig. 41 Update Fig. 41 to show internal protection matching Fig. 39; match symbols – December 2014
John Kay
C37 Fig. 44 Prepare V/Hz figure; added to D3.6; updated 3/2014; for V nominal – delete “nominal” John Kay
GE Bently-Nevada, vibration section; included in D3.6; need CR Provide updated text on vibration; provide references for stator monitor; provide pictures in jpeg, get CRights
Lorraine Padden
9.3.3 Request Working Group copy of IEEE C57.110 Perry/Padden
9.2.2 Multiple motors – plan for September 2014 NEC 430.130 & 131; check 3004.8 for more info
Jeff Hensley, John Kay
9.3.7 Need to add information for MV multiple motors, Jeff Hensley, John Kay>
Ask for a Web session with Lisa Perry on how to sign up in myProject so the Working Group can get invite and ballot. Full “how to” session on sign up and ballot process.
Perry/Padden
general Solicit MPR (11M) pictures for document-August 2014 (Dan Ransom); October 2014 Vendors/users
9 PSP – request to use material from other standards; copyright release Dan Ransom;
Padden
Examples Develop Synchronous motor protection example for inclusion in Annex Dan Ransom,
Padden
IEEE/Industry Applications Society/Technical Book Coordinating Committee Protection & Coordination Working Group (IAS/TBCC/3004 WG) P3004.8 “Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems” Working Group Meeting December 9, 2014 –WEB only Section No. Completed Task Description Lead/Group
General Check on VT or PT or both – VT, voltage (potential) transformer, add to abbreviations
Lorraine Padden
Fig 25 & 26 Prepare new Figures; added to D3.6; updated 3/2014 John Kay
Fig 27 Prepare bypass Figures for ASD; added to D3.6; updated 3/2014 John Kay
9.3.8.2 Partial discharge; Annex added to D3.6 from Renforth information; needs CR & review
Chris Heron, Macolm Seltzer-Grant
12.2 Class II; material from Singh added D3.6 for review
Chris Heron, Manish Singh
6.5.1 MV multifunction relay (move to end); Figures reviewed 3/25/2014 meeting; updated; added D3.7 David Bredhold
Annex B Insert Table of IEEE device numbers; added D3.6; John Kay
6.3.2 Fig. 2
Change direction of arrow, single-phasing diagram & change to 115% Jim Bryan
C37 Fig. 39 Conduct ePoll to determine if Working Group wants to use device 50/51 or device 11 – use Dev. 11; keep 87M & 49
Lorraine Padden
C37 Fig. 43 Update Fig 43 bypass Figures for ASD; show block diagram; use CT symbol; show NO/NC contacts with interlocks for bypass; show Dev 11 (Jim Crook complete May 2014)
John Kay, Jim Crook
References
Request Working Group copies from IEEE, Lisa Perry, for the reference documents and new 3000 series documents so we can clean up the references throughout the document – requested April 2014 (Perry posted to mentor site May 2014)
Lorraine Padden
8.4.1 Add stator overtemperature setting to text - plan for April 2014 meeting- Done-edited 4-22-2014
John Kay
General Check kW and hp; checking IEC & NEMA; spreadsheet reviewed June 2014 Jim Bryan
MV Add snubber information- stator winding protection, plan for July 2014 meeting
John Kay, Dave Bredhold
Copyright for thermocouple wire This section will be modified with references to the standards where copyright is not needed(8/2014)
Manish Singh
IEEE/Industry Applications Society/Technical Book Coordinating Committee Protection & Coordination Working Group (IAS/TBCC/3004 WG) P3004.8 “Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems” Working Group Meeting December 9, 2014 –WEB only
Fig w/Dev21
Update with voltage updated; jpeg; complete Sept 2014 Dan Ransom
8.6, 8.7 Review synchronous motor protection. Harmonize with B.2 and Table 6 and figures; complete Sept 2014 Dan Ransom
8.10, 8.11, 8.12
Review ; complete Sept 2014 Dan Ransom
9.1.6 PTC Figure; October 2014 Jim Crook
8.4.3.6
Online stator insulation monitoring – check to see if the draft is keeping information generic for the standard and review wording so it does not limit to one product.MSIM. Moved to Annex E. Changed wording to generic terms.
Jim Bryan
5.2.1 to 5.2.4
Soft start, wye delta – some information added in D3.7; for April 2014 meeting- check w/John, David Solicit diagrams October 2014; Jim Crook-diagrams; Updates for December 2014
John Kay, David Bredhold; Jim Crook; Louis Spence
10 DC Motor – plan for December 2014 Chris Heron, Jim Bryan, John Kay, Chuck Yung
5.2.1 add text on current and voltage and torque values; no frequency change; also graphs>
David Bredhold; Jim Crook
5.2 Contribute photos/graphs/diagrams of start methods Jim Crook
Sponsor: IEEE/IAS/TBCC/3004 WGIEEE 3004.8 Working Group
Updated: December 9, 2014 lkp
NameE-mail (this is public information unless noted otherwise) Company Designation
Attendance 12/9/2014
Working Group OfficersPadden, Lorraine [email protected] Padden Engineering, LLC Chair, Voting Member X
Working Group MembershipAbdel Khalek, Mohamed [email protected] PGESCo Aspirant Member
Alahmad, Mahmoud [email protected]
Ali, Mohammed Ashraf [email protected] SABIC E&PM Aspirant Member
Arcega, F [email protected] Universidad de Zaragoza Aspirant Member
Baird, Gregory [email protected] Jones & Carter, Inc. Aspirant Member
Bavishi, Smit [email protected] Hatch Mott MacDonald Non-Voting Member
Belayneh, Sirak [email protected] Addis Tech Voting Member Web
Bredhold, Robert David [email protected] C&I Engineering Voting Member E
Bryan, James [email protected] Voting Member WebCardinal, Paul [email protected] Non-Voting Member
Carroll, James [email protected] Kelly Services, Inc. On assignment to the Dow Chemical Company
Aspirant Member
Crook, Jim [email protected] Electric Voting Member Web
Franklin, Jerry [email protected] Engineers, Inc. Non-Voting Member
Groves, Randall
[email protected] County Public Utility District
Aspirant MemberWeb
Hensley, Jeffrey [email protected] Freese and Nichols, Inc Voting Member Web
Heron, Chris [email protected] TECO-Westinghouse Motor Company
Voting Member
Hinchliffe, David [email protected] Exelon Corporation non-Voting Member
Hohrein, Byron [email protected] Washington Metropolitan ArVoting Member Web
JAIN, MAYANK [email protected] Steel Authority of India Aspirant Member
Khan, Umar [email protected] General Electric Web
Kay, John [email protected] Rockwell Automation Voting Member E
Kim, Sangyoun [email protected] Bechtel Corporation Aspirant Member
Kloba, Theodore [email protected] CDM Smith Aspirant Member
Larsen, Ed [email protected] Schneider Electric Observer
Leschert, Duane [email protected] WorleyParsons, Ltd. Aspirant Member E
Linenbrink, Timothy
[email protected] American Engineering, PLLC
Aspirant Member
Mcalhaney Jr, John [email protected] Solutions, LLC Aspirant Member
Mohd Saad, Ahmad [email protected] PETRONAS Aspirant Member
Neeser, Daniel [email protected] Eaton Corporation Non-Voting Member
Neubauer, Arthur [email protected] Arseal Technologies Aspirant Member
O'Hearn, Timothy [email protected] Englobal Voting Member
Ostojic, Pero [email protected] Voting Member
Ransom, Daniel Leland [email protected] Voting Member Web
Scheffler, Timothy [email protected] U.S. Air ForceSeltzer-Grant, Malcolm [email protected] HVPD Aspirant MemberSingh, Manish [email protected] Suzlon Energy Ltd. Voting Member
Spence, Louis [email protected] Voting Member
Stewart, Bill [email protected] ChevronStrang Jr, Douglas [email protected] S & S ENGINEERING, P.C. Aspirant Member E
Teh, Liang Hean [email protected] Siemens Aspirant Member
Thomasson, Mike [email protected] Burns & McDonnell Voting Member
Valdes, Marcelo [email protected]
Verma, Sunil [email protected] Sinclair Knight Merz Voting Member
p y(GE)
"Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems"
University of Nebraska-Lincoln
Association
Shell Global Solutions Inc.
ee ou ty ect c oop(LCEC)
3004.8-Roster-12-09-2014.xlsx 3004.8 attend 12-9-2014 1 of 2
Sponsor: IEEE/IAS/TBCC/3004 WGIEEE 3004.8 Working Group
Updated: December 9, 2014 lkp
NameE-mail (this is public information unless noted otherwise) Company Designation
Attendance 12/9/2014
"Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems"
Working Group - InterestedBagby, Adam
[email protected] LSW Engineers Arizona, Inc.Bapat, Ashvin
[email protected] Electric Company (GE)
Basu, Partha [email protected] ExxonMobilBondeur, Michael [email protected] Elektro-ConsulingBoyce, Christina [email protected] Mentor Staff, Editor
Elgueta, Cristian [email protected] SG SCMFox, Gary
[email protected] Electric Company (GE)
Goodman, Mark [email protected] ConsultantHemmer, Michael [email protected] WorleyParsons GroupHietpas, Scott [email protected] ExxonMobilJublee, Sofyanshah [email protected]
Lagree, James [email protected] Eaton CorporationLord, Jeffrey [email protected] Siemens Industry, Inc.Marchini, Gregory [email protected] Mentor Staff, Editor
Mcconnell, Michael [email protected] Dashiell Inc.Murzaku, Edrin [email protected] ENGINEERNeitzel, Dennis [email protected]
AVO Training Institute, Inc. Perry, Lisa [email protected] Admin, Editor,
Raza, Shoukat [email protected] Saudi AramcoRempe, Kenneth [email protected] Siemens Industry, Inc.Smith, Jeremy [email protected] General Electric Smullin, Gary [email protected] Smullin Engineering, Inc.Vira, Azim [email protected] Orbis Engineering
SponsorRifaat, Rasheek [email protected] Jacobs Engineering WG 3004 Chair, Observer
Carey Cook [email protected] S&C TBCC Chair, Observer
GuestsAndrew Burgess [email protected] HVPD
Brant Wilhelm [email protected] GE Bently-Nevada
Mark Snyder [email protected] GE Bently-Nevada
* Designation; Please note in attendance column if you request a change in designation.* Voting Member - votes on minutes and other Working Group ballots, active participation required* Non-Voting Member - does not vote, active participation required* Aspirant Member - request to become a member of this Working Group and actively participate in this Standard development.* Observer - receives Working Group information, membership is not requested.* Guest - does not receive Working Group information.X - attend in person; WEB - attend via web; Tele - attend via teleconference; E - excused absence
3004.8-Roster-12-09-2014.xlsx 3004.8 attend 12-9-2014 2 of 2
PLEASE SIGN IN
Now you can access myProject, Attendance Tool, and Mentor with a single sign in. Simply enter your IEEE Account username/email and password below to begin!
USERNAME/EMAIL:
PASSWORD:
SIGN IN TO: myProject
SIGN IN
Need Help? Access the myProject User Guide (.pdf) or visit the eTools Documentation Page
Retrieve Your Account Username and/or Password Note: IEEE uses Cookies for Account Registration, Change Password and Recover Username/Password
Need an IEEE Account? Get Yours Now! It's FREE and does not require IEEE or IEEE-SA membership
What is eTools?
eTools is the Standard Association's collection of online tools and resources for standards developers.
MYPROJECTmyProject is the Standard Association's tool to allow you to better manage and keep up to date on projects and topics that you are interested in.
IMATIMAT allows Working Groups to setup meetings and record attendance.
MENTORmentor provides a secure area where Working Groups can manage documents outside of public view.
Copyright 2011 IEEE-SA
eTools
Page 1 of 1IEEE Standards Association - Sign In
10/5/2012https://development.standards.ieee.org/my-site
Quick Guide for Users of myProject and Mentor –16–
myProject Home Screen
The features shown in the screen shot and described in the table below are available to all users. (Additional features may be available based on your specific role and will appear in the lower section.)
Link Description
myTools This section will give you access to resources related to the standards process.
Help Use this link to get the latest information and help related to the screen you are on.
Messages This screen allows you to view all system notifications. You can also manage your email notifications here.
Report a Bug This page lets you report a myProject bug to the system administrator.
Announcements Breaking news about myProject may be found here.
Account This area allows you to edit your IEE-SA contact information as well as manage your affiliations.
Submit a PAR This link is for IEEE-SA Members who wish to submit a PAR for consideration by NesCom. It is used for all PAR requests/actions (modify, extend, withdraw).
Manage Activity Profile
Use this screen to join sponsor committees, working groups and projects of interest.
Sponsor P&Ps This is a comprehensive list of IEEE Sponsor P&Ps (Policies and Procedures) including their acceptance status.
Send Sponsor Message This feature can be used to send a message to a Sponsor Committee Chair or Working Group Chair.
View IEEE Society-Staff Liaisons
This link brings you to a list of all IEEE Society-staff liaisons.
View Active PARs This screen provides a view and search function on all active PARs.
Additional options may appear here.
Click on “eTools” to access other tools (Mentor and IMAT)
Additional resources can be found here
myProject™ >> Manage Activity Profile
In the list of Activity Areas below (initially a list of Societies) clicking on (+) will expand the selection into its constituent components as follows from which you may select the Technical Activity Areas in which you are interested from either a general interest standpoint or specific technical project in which you wish to be involved and presumably ballot.
Society -- What you are Enrolling in --
Sponsor Enrollment as an interested party in general work of committee or indicating an interest in being notified on Ballot Invitations for all projects in a WG or all projects in a Sponsor. Working Group
Project Enrollment as interested party in the detailed technical work of the committee and as a member in the specific Project's Ballot.
Please note that these selections will simply place you on the list of IEEE-SA recognized interested parties for that general or specific technical area. Whether or not you have become a member or voting member of the area depends on the membership criteria of that area. Please contact the respective Chair for further information or to request membership.
PROJECT KEYWORD: SEARCH
CONTINUE CANCEL
Name Designator ▲ Contact
IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society AES
IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society APS
IEEE-SA Board of Governors BOG
IEEE Broadcast Technology Society BTS
IEEE Computer Society C
IEEE Consumer Electronics Society CES
IEEE Computational Intelligence Society CIS
IEEE Communications Society COM
IEEE Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation Society DEI
IEEE Education Society EDU
IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society EMB
IEEE Electromagnetic Compatibility Society EMC
IEEE Industry Applications Society IAS
Cement Industry IAS/CI Clayton Reid
Electric Machines IAS/EM Iqbal Husain
Energy Systems IAS/ES Carey Cook
Industrial & Commercial Power Systems IAS/I&CPS Carey Cook
Petroleum & Chemical Industry IAS/PCI William McBride
Power Systems Engineering IAS/PSE Carey Cook
Power Systems Protection IAS/PSP Carey Cook
Technical Books Coordinating Committee IAS/TBCC Carey Cook
3000 Essential Std WG IAS/TBCC/3000 WG T David Mills
Power Systems Design WG IAS/TBCC/3001 WGPeter Sutherland
Power Systems Analysis WG IAS/TBCC/3002 WGFarrokh Shokooh
Power Systems Grounding WG IAS/TBCC/3003 WG Douglas Dorr
Protection & Coordination WG IAS/TBCC/3004 WG Rasheek Rifaat
Recommended Practice for the Application of Instrument Transformers in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems
IAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.1
Rasheek Rifaat
Recommended Practice for the Application of Low-Voltage Fuses in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems
IAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.3
Rasheek Rifaat
Recommended Practice for the Application of Low-Voltage Circuit Breakers in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems
IAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.5
Rasheek Rifaat
Page 1 of 2IEEE Standards Association - Manage Activity Profile
10/5/2012https://development.standards.ieee.org/[email protected]/interest-committees?s=23350...
Recommended Practice for the Protection of Power Cables and Busway Used in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems
IAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.7
Rasheek Rifaat
Recommended Practice for Motor Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power SystemsIAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.8
Lorraine Padden
Recommended Practice for the Protection of Power Transformers Used in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems
IAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.9
Rasheek Rifaat
Recommended Practice for Generator Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power SystemsIAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.10
Rasheek Rifaat
Recommended Practice for Bus and Switchgear Protection in Industrial and Commercial Power Systems
IAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.11
Rasheek Rifaat
Recommended Practice for Overcurrent Coordination in Industrial and Commercial Power SystemsIAS/TBCC/3004 WG/P3004.13
Rasheek Rifaat
Emergency & Stand By Power Systems WG IAS/TBCC/3005 WG J Weber
Power Systems Reliability WG IAS/TBCC/3006 WG Robert Arno
Maintenance, Operations & Safety WG IAS/TBCC/3007 WG Dennis Neitzel
Page 2 of 2IEEE Standards Association - Manage Activity Profile
10/5/2012https://development.standards.ieee.org/[email protected]/interest-committees?s=23350...