iaop ows 17 leveraging outsourcing to modernize while maintaining applications
TRANSCRIPT
JW Marriott Hill CountrySan Antonio, Texas
February 19-22, 2017
Leveraging Outsourcing to Modernize While Maintaining Applications
Anthem’s New AMS Approach Proves You Don’t Need to Pick One or the Other
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Speaker Introduction
Chief Marketing OfficerWGroup
Managing PrincipalWGroup
President and CEOWGroup
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Session Objectives
Learn how a new approach to AMS sourcing can enable the modernization of core IT systems and maintenance of applications in parallel. See Anthem’s playbook and methodology for this innovative sourcing delivery model.
1
Learn how to stratify which suppliers can truly help you transform core systems, and which ones that may only be able to handle tasks. See the evaluation criteria that Anthem leveraged in assessing its suppliers for transformational work.
2
Understand the potential for running modernization and maintenance in an integrated effort, as opposed to separate initiatives. 3
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
IT TransformationAdvisory IT Strategy Service Delivery Transformation “Digital” Transformation
Goal(s): Align IT to the business. Shift from run to grow.
Improve service to the business and users and reduce cost. Speed and competitive differentiation.
SpecificService:
Technology Enabled Business Strategy
Mergers, Acquisitions, & Divestitures
Cost Optimization
IT Assessments / Remediating Complex IT Issues
IT Governance & Demand Mgmt.
Interim IT Executive / Interim CIO
Sourcing Advisory Strategy RFP to Contract Renewals Transition Governance
Vendor Management
ITSM / Process Optimization
Organizational Design
Cloud Strategy & Roadmap
Application Portfolio Transformation & Rationalization
Exploratory Investment / Innovation Lab Competency
Automation
Cognitive / Autonomics
Staff Augmentation (via upGrow Service Business) Interim | Contract and Contract to Hire | Permanent Placement
About WGroup
Helping IT and Sourcing Leaders Drive Transformation Since 2004.
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Do these challenges have a familiar ring?
Business agility, innovation and value creation are key to Anthem’s success, but are hindered by organizational challenges
Rapid growth and acquisitions have resulted in multiple operating models, inefficiencies and higher costs
Level of complexity across the organization makes managing the business of IT difficult and expensive
Opportunities for improving operating effectiveness via standardization, rationalization, modernization, and process improvement
App. Development teams, are overwhelmed with demand for services and forced to operate in a reactive mode
Need to establish sustaining IT capabilities: Business engagement and creation of a strategic IT roadmap & governance model Clearly articulated target application architecture Application portfolio rationalization to simplify the application landscape Demand management and execution must align with target application architecture Continued focus on rapid innovation to exploit technology capabilities and opportunities
Anthem is working to transform health care with trusted and caring solutions. Our health plan companies deliver quality products and services that give their members access to the care they need. With over 73 million people served by its affiliated companies, including nearly 40 million enrolled in its family of health plans, Anthem is one of the nation’s leading health benefits companies. Additional detail http://www.anthem.com
About Anthem, Inc.
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved. - 6 -
Health plans are continually evolving to find the right mix of capabilities that will help them win and retain customers in aincreasingly competitive marketplace
Change in Market Dynamics
Health plans need to increasingly make compelling features available to consumers, and faster time to market is becoming a critical factor to acquiring and retaining customers.
Changes in Market Dynamics
Faster Time To Market
New entrants such as Oscar are changing the way that technology is viewed by health plans. With the emergence of the $5 PMPM model, larger health plans need to manage costs while delivering cutting edge features to their member base.
Technology Enabled Lower PMPM Alternatives
Simple and Convenient
Customer Loyalty Through Advocacy
The target consumer base places a greater emphasis on usability, convenience and
productivity. Improved consumer experience when leveraged for support staff will enable the
solving of customer problems the “first” time.
To deliver the “retail” mindset, health plans need to adopt a consumer-centric approach
and analytics to enable the right outcomes across the consumer journey.
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Initial State & Implications
Six business units contract for ADM services independently: Commercial, Government, Infrastructure, Information Security, Corporate Applications, and the Office of the CIO
A significant number of applications contracts in the portfolio to expire at the end of 2015: Poor alignment of supplier / contract with Anthem needs Current applications sourcing approach is fragmented and contributes to increased cost and complexity while limiting agility, quality and overall business value: No
application strategy defined with the business leadership
Initial State and Problem:
Overall Strategy Supplier & Contract Strategy Why Now?
Modernize Enterprise Application architecture while absorbing legacy functionality
Optimize support model for effectiveness and efficiency across the ecosystem
Commercial IT systems are highly complex, require strong quality control, significant modernization, and partners with a product mindset
Explore cognitive compute platforms
Modernization approach, experience, capabilities, commitment, costs, etc. – key evaluation parameters
Major consideration by Supplier tier:
Task Takers: How big of a hurdle is it to invest and change their model?
Engineers: Do they have the domain expertize to define, govern and deliver on modernization?
Transformers: Do they have the execution capability to drive operating efficiency?
Restructuring operating model and partnerships today enables future savings
Drive substantial transformation in the next 2-3 years with the right partners (uplift in skills, capabilities, tools, and repeatable processes)
Leverage supplier investments for enterprise services
Accelerate transition to end state architecture; jumpstart application rationalization and significant savings
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved. - 8 -
As the core of Anthem’s operations, the WGS platform exhibits a number of challenges prevalent in most health plan systems
Why Modernize WGS?
Area Current Challenge(s) Future Opportunity
Data ModelGroup-CentricCore administrative assets are currently focused on employer businesses
Consumer-CentricBuild out new capabilities to address marketplace shifts towards consumerism
UsabilityTransactionalFocused on integrating native datasets to process claims
ExperientialShift to contextual, user-focused transactions for areas such as member self-service
PlatformsLarge Mainframe FootprintRely on mainframes resulting in high fixed infrastructure and talentacquisition/management costs
Hybrid-TechnologiesShift to newer platforms, reducing costs, increasing quality and improving speed-to-market
Release Times
Long Release CyclesCurrent release cycles range between 8 and 20 weeks
Continuous IntegrationEmploy automation and CI/CD capabilities to reduce time-to-market (typically 20%)
DevelopmentPhilosophy
Custom DevelopmentLarge custom-built with opportunistic integrations with packaged software
Cloud/XaaS-FirstConsider Cloud/XaaS before custom build, wherever appropriate
TalentLegacy Talent ModelFocused on issue resolution, production incidents and “lights on” activities
DevOps Talent ModelRetrained to deliver value added services and solutions using cuttingedge technology
CostFocused on “Lights On”Largely driven by capital expenditures such as data center maintenance etc.
Focused on Value DeliveredShift to operating expenditures and focus budget on value added capabilities
Why Modernize?
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Governance & Vendor Management
“The Most Important Part of Value Realization”
New skills, processes, behaviors, and objectives.
Root Cause Analysis Business SLA & OLA mgmt. Change Management
Business Outcomes
What You Want, in Business Terms
Realization of Your Expected Outcomes
Delivery of Business Value
Transformation Program
Business Strategy Alignment Define key Business Metrics and
Translated to IT Outcomes Integrate Infra. and Apps Strategy Cloud Modernization Program ITSM-Enabled Service Delivery
Model Re-Solution Service Delivery
Reference Architecture Embed Automation and
Autonomics Relentless focus on Security
Non-Prescriptive Solutioning
With or without a formal RFP
Flexible for Providers to solution against core competencies.
Iterative Solution Enhancement
Encourage Innovation
Contracting
New Contract Terms
New SLA & OLA Models
Gain Sharing Clauses
Flexibility (limit MRCs)
Modernize while Maintaining
Realization Management
Agile Approach to Sourcing
Win-win, risk-mitigated agreement(s) with the best-fit service provider(s) to meet short and long term business
objectives, at the right price.
Transition Management
Sourcing Toward Outcomes with Speed
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Evaluation CriteriaProcess Overview
1. Rank most important to least important (as a % of total = 100%)
2. Detailed criteria within each category3. Score 0-5
4. Normalize to account for “outliers”
Blank Not Scored0 Unacceptable / does not meet requirements or non-responsive
1 Weak / could meet requirements with major improvement(s)
2 Marginal / could meet requirements with minor improvement(s)
3 Acceptable / meets requirements
4 Very Good / meets / exceeds requirements
5 Excellent / meets / exceeds requirements with significant value
Category DescriptionAbility to Meet Anthem ObjectivesAgreement TermsBusiness Continuity Planning (BCP) Disaster Recovery and AvoidanceClient ReferenceContract FlexibilityCorporate ProfileCultural FitDelivery LocationsFinancialInvestmentsHuman Capital and Staff Development and RetentionManagement CommitmentModernizationOral PresentationRisk Management and GovernanceSecurity and ComplianceService DeliveryTechnical and technology Management CompetenceTechnical Demonstration WorkshopTerminationTransition
Evaluation Categories
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Process & Scope
RFP Towers
Claims EB&C Provider Product TP&E
Incumbent(s) Vendor 1, Vendor 2 Vendor 3, Vendor 4, Vendor 5 Vendor 6, Vendor 7, Vendor 8 Vendor 9, Vendor 10 Vendor 11, Vendor 12
Scope: 149+ SOWs @ $118M+ in Annual Spend
StrategyDevelopment RFP Preparation Supplier Q&A/
Proposal DevDue Diligence /
Hackathons / Best & FinalContract
NegotiationsProposal
Evaluation
August 2015 September November January 2016 February March April / May
Initiated RFP Engaged WGroup
Released RFI to 13 Suppliers
Released RFP Invited 9 Suppliers Proposals Received Down Selected to
Tower Finalists BAFOs Received Award Notice
Process
True partnership between WGroup and Anthem IT, Procurement, and Legal Experienced consultants who each had extensive technology, architecture and sourcing experience Clearly articulated outcome approach, allowing providers to innovate the solution
Keys to Success
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Technology Patterns – e.g., Data Fabric - API Integration - Micro services – Containers – Automation – Machine Learning - AI
Modernization & Strategic Project List
Modernization Patterns – e.g., Re-platform -Remediate -
Replace
Workforce Competencies
Rewards & Recognition
New Business Model & Requirements
Application Development & Maintenance Delivery
Governance and Modernization Council
New Operating Model
Business outcome focus Cohesive & integrated IT capability Modernization integrated with
delivery Continuous feedback
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Key Lessons Learned
Involvement of IT Executives and Application Leaders “Modernization, business as usual” rather than “a Modernization Project” Business Model driven modernization Point-of-View provided as a baseline Evaluation criteria and criteria weights carefully developed to measure capabilities and fit Hackathons – Demonstrating what was being sold Pre-RFP Site visits to narrow supplier list Pre-Final Selection Supplier Site Visits – during Hackathon period Contract Highlights Risk-based pool – to fund modernization based on achievement of business outcomes/ROI Significant Application Development Productivity Improvements Subcontracting incumbent to reduce transition risk for specific applications SLAs supporting outcomes and clearly defined roles, responsibilities and SLA hand-offs
© 2017 IAOP. All Rights Reserved.
Panel Discussion
Chief Marketing OfficerWGroup
Managing PrincipalWGroup
President and CEOWGroup