%~i@. - hfslawyers.org · 3. i1' fl~)' ~ 1t . ii5d9l~, a ~ ffi #-to . 9=' 3c, ~ m,...
TRANSCRIPT
%~i@. (2017J 61 %
-&ij~m~r*fiU*-rfli1! ~ij~ff~ffi~~l_~ffiI ft8~ij~
%-i!- (rfJ) tK ~ A;; foJ, rfJ 1f yifi tdJ-i?:
~~-~~~~~#~~~~ff,OO~~~~ff«*f~fiA;;
1fffiYf IPJ ~~ 11 ~1,.~ JlR 1f yifi 1,.~ ~ 1f yifi ~~ 11 ffJ ~%» (~~K (2 0 1 6 J 30
%)~~~~~ff, ~~~~~ff«*f~fiA;;1f~M~11~~JlR
1f yifi ~ ~ 1f yifi ~~ ~ ffJ ~~ ;t %» ( Sj£ ~K (201 7 J 1 7 %) ~bt «~
A;;$*f~_*~~~~#~~~~ffOO~~~~ff(*f~fiA;;
1f}eYf fPJ ~~ 11 ~ /E- JlR 1f yifi ~ ~ 1f yifi ~~ 11 ffJ ~% >ffJ i@. ~P » ( ~ K ( 2 0 1 6 J
10 %) ,« ~~~' ~ A;; ff * f~*~JlR1f yifi/E- ~1f yifi 111: ffJ i@.~)X Sj£
~ ~ (2017 J 82 % ) m~$, ~$t~*1,.~JlR1f Yifi, ~ ~ 1f yifi I 11:i@.~p
~P~ 0
- \ $i~W!£0 ~H~Uijj0 §]~UijjiiE~ 8{J A~ ffilE
(-) o/it7j9L~~/~~$yrpiJ1..~ a1JA..9i ~ rnJ
-i!-~~~%~~~~*, A~ro~,~~~~, ~~~m~~
I~, jJ'*~1q:%*1t-ffJ AP1 0
- 1
C.::..) ~ -it7J1L~./~ ~ ~-*= ~rp -i.iE.:p; a~A. W~ ~
I~~ ~~, ~~~ft~~OO~~*~.~~~~(~~~#
00 :fr j}~) 1f-€t~1tf ~A Vi 0
=, $i~~~idlfH~Vm0~~ViP~~(fJA9i~# (-) 0-l!R1f:Yrp
1. tffl:if tf $ A R: #~ 00 1tit;
2. ~ ·ff 5i: 1* J{R ~ *" if}EX. ft YfP 1ft- ,f};
3. **If!-1lft~.f£~/~Jm)\.P;;
4. ·n:*.1l~n}A..*{f.~.I1f~f§11~~ijf Ii;];
5. £ ·ff ~ff o
(-=-) 0-~ 1t~ifi
1. tmtf~$A~#~OO3tH;;
2. ~*itffJlR~ *{}~{f-yip )Jf~i;
3. ~**!§ 00 11 ~~~iT f3 W~~,g.fliJ W'J 9! I;
4. ,L£ 00 1r~~ =m 11 it1* JPYi r~ ; 5. Jbff ~%o
**~~M~~~~~, ~~1*~~f3~,#**~~ili~~
J*.1*~~ o
-, $~~~0~~~~~.~~~e~m~(fJ~M
(-) tf itn9tt.0-11R~.t ~ifi i.iE .:p; il ili.fJt ~ JtA r #;f1-:
1. !f1 i. ~Yi ~0-]ffi f*: YfP iiE fJ %i~* ( -~Wi f7t) ;
2. Jt ffi" iiE ~ fp 1t;
- 2
3. lR 1~if Vifi ~-tt~ 5!ifJmit ~'*~ il s}] #*4;
4. tf1 itAJlfi {f-¢1ft ill A ~ tf1 itA~ *--¢1ft{f Jm{f~/E-JmA 91 '
{f *- -¢1ft -t fl fA *5! if *9}-~ 1.8 11 5! if ffijf 1'61 FfJ il s}] # tI-& f5J ;t tf1
itA tf1 it /E-Jmif Vifi ~;t~;
5. tf1 itA1liJtJJ =- -t YtlTi ~~ lE W~}~ p.~ Jt =-*0
C=-) 0/ -it?J~ %./~ ~ -1f: vip iJ1. ~S ~.fit 5ZYA r ~t7ft:
1. tf1 it~Yt~ J}} ~ if Vifi il-:f$ ~i~* (-~ wg 171) ;
2. j{ 171il ~ fp 14:;
3. lR 1~if Vifi ~ '*~ 5! if Jm it ~ -tt FfJ il S}] # tI-;
4. tf1 itAJlfi{f ~ it:h tf1 itA~~ :t±%1* ~FfJ il s}] # *4;
5. tf1 itAJlfi {f 00 1=r ~ it ill A FfJ tf1 it A~ *--¢1ft 91 I (fSlt tf1 itA
*~~~it~hFfJ~~~f5J~~#)#~**ifMMFfJ~~#tI-&
f5J ;t tf1 itA tf1 it /L."- ~ if Vifi FfJ ;t ~ ;
6. tf1 itAJlfi {f~it ~ 00 1=rM; ~~N~~iY. FfJ il sA #*4;
7. tf1 it A1liJtJJ =- -t YtJa][~ lE llif *}~ p.~ Jt =-*0
1m \ 01{JH~Uijj0 ~~UffJ liE ~ 8{J '$' :Ht~¥J¥
1. -tR =t% §j 5! -N\31=r *X14:'~ ~, ~ jc~ 00 *- tfL *' A ~ [Zf] 1*' ~
jc~ iY., 11 ti riD ~ 5! -N\3 tf1 it i~ iL /E- Jm if Vifi ' /E- ~ if Vifi, :h *- -¢1ft N~
~14: FfJ A 91 tf1 it ~Yt ~ /E- Jm if Vifi, /E- §j if Vifi il-:f$ 0
2. ii' ~Jt iEjz;fjL *' A ~ [Zf] 1*&ii' ~ 00 1=r 1t iY. riD ii' ~ * rr tf1 itR
iLJ}}Jmif~, J}}§jif~,:h*--¢~N~~#~A91tf1~~~J}}Jmif
Vifi, /E- §j if Vifi il 4$ 0
- 3
3. i1' fl~)' ~1t iI5d9L~, A ~ ffi #-to 9=' 3c, ~M, 00 1=1 J£-~ tU ~~ ~
jt1~ 00 1q1t~, fpJ rP ~ 5t: f&J ~ ili i~ iL0Imff VijJ , J/} ~ if YiP *w, ~* .ft*~*#~A~~~~£0~~~ ~~~~~~n$~.4
(W)~~~~*, A~ffi~,~~~~, ~M~~~~I*, W
*~,~($)~.OO1=1~~~~~~5t:~~ili.~~,S~~*
* (rtJ) rK§j5t}6J~~o
4. rr iiJ 5t %J ~~ rfJ i~~ 1± ~Jt at ~&. fJ 1£ ~Jt tf1 it# *4 ~ lf1 *: tt M '1.A ~~ if-J '* it-~~ fp it- if. ~ fp it-L ~!J "*it- ~ ~ itt~ ~~~n;~._A~~~~*Jt*#. ~~~#~~~_~*~
tB ~ $ *~~, #¥f-$ ~~%~ tf1 i.#*3\-tll*/~' §j 54:ff 0
5. ~ §] #: If)t , -iN- # ~*1T W{~ 1£ ~ j( at ~~ ~ 1t ill ~~ 71Yf it
~ Jm ~ l)ijJ, ~ \3] ~ VfP iiE ~ ~ )jcJt 0
6. /~ lffi ft VijL 0 a] ft YTfJ ~ I it1ffiJ ij; J!'*, Itf1m, :i! 1J; i!~E$
j~~ )1:;r: rq: ~0llR*Vf\1, ~ \3] ft VfI1 11 Jm ~it- ~, riJ '* 11 ~~1l#- fl Jf
*~*fi~m~~~~~~~ffi0~.~ , 0§j~~~~o
li \ 01IJH~Vijj0 ~~Vi'HI1Jt~~~fl
t9= yJR- 1m 1t VtfJ, J~ §] 1* VTfJ if-J If!-1i, Etr ~ f§' ;t =6f5 1'1 ~ A 91 ffi }!J/}
~~~,0§]~~~8~*~I~~#~.~!~tf1~~~*ft~
m* E t~i}o
\3] ~ 1TiE,k;ffL *JtL ~ -);p 51 ~ -0-lffi1* Vtfi J/} ~ ~ VfIl Ff-J ~~~1fI it,
~~~~0~ff~.0§]~~~$tt~~0~~~ 0§]~~8~
:!*~l! :1tiL~~:r!~~11, ~*~1)11, ;;if{~~1~~~jLt, {t~7t
- 4
1Jt.:Itt /f} JlR 1* vrr, /f} BJ 1* vrr I 1tll- 'f-1t, *~;e: 1t, it 0"-*-1* I£:- JlR if vrr '
I£:- BJ 1* vrr JlR Fi~ 1tJfJ 0
$1* vrr t~~EI ~ 1~%/f} JlR 1* vrr, /f} BJ 1* Vip ~ Jt 9}-3t )fiE i~ ~, 1*
~~~~¥~fi~~~~I~ o l£:-~1*~,I£:-BJ*~EI~~~1*~
t~1?-7fJl ~ ~ 41-*i}ll, Jl~ ~ ~1/~1o tA~ ~c1*~~ ~mi;)J, f-1=r 1f vrr
t~~~Pi ;fJ)fIJ, Jft iT if vrr t~~%-Pi)( 9}-o
1£:-~~~,I£:-~1f~~~&~~I~~~m~~ft1o ~ ~fi~
~*~~ o 0~1*~,I£:-BJ1*~&~~~m~~M~~ft**~~
~~~~BJ~fi~~*,~~~~~~~BJ~fi~~**~~~ff
~ .~ /f} ~1* vrr, /f} BJ 1* Vrr :i! A~ J~J~ tA ~ ~, ~ BJ 5i iT iEj( tIL * 10 Wn
1* vrr t}} %- %- ~ ~ fA ~ if!-1ft -tR 1% if vrr 5i ffiA~ ~ *~It 1%J ~ )zL I! 0
I31t 14: : 1. I£:- Jl~ 1* vrr tA ~%iG * 2. /f} BJ if ViV tA\ll ~4: iG *
~'. \ " /~. .
. , . I
~AEW~ '5i]a] .
2017 ~ 10!J 24 EJ
- 5 .
~i4; 111~IJ tI:l 1El ~
£1& ,,,'
Jt
j(1t~Jt ~~ ft ij&
1fYrJ1** iiE~5i1f
~~** iiE %
Jr17tiiE % ? i rJf1f±1l!.
J'Jf 1£ 1f-1iL ,2?(jt: fJ-i~ tJL¥94;{t
±~hl. ~* t -it
j}/~ It it -t-At it
w~~
~:h1111t at f!3J
foJat ~IJ* 1f-1i-t n fA:f 5t-1f :f~I1t
t~~1f;ff~
foJ ~ ~1f~~
f6J )Jj
~ 11::. at f!3J 1£ foJ ±~ foJ ~n (~;:] ) 11t ~~ iiE aJ] A
~J±foJ# ~ mJJ
~:i±foJ# ~ 7t
- 7
¥
JJj
'tfi
~
:ti±1Pr~ ~~ttff
Mrrt* f~M #~~~fIL
¥~~~x
~1ft1iE 4'J .t~~%
lIX. f!tM # iiE -~
lRf~M# ~ ift iiE f$
Jtf.li: at 1"91
~~~.t1: !t.j- raj
iiE 4tJ ~ -ry
7k.!fL
7f<.*
~~ #;~~ JJj A. 91. fcJ at -tar JiI!. :l: :i::t Fr # if. f4t ~ ~lH* i)11
~i§A~
00 ~~r¥t JJj
~ ~
~ ~?.._L
IJJ lJ. {
.ill: JIR 4i
~.(fM*M.* -tar # 4t ~ I it
Ilx f~ fPJ # {- .ill: 4t#JiR§
-t~tt#lW-% iiE 1~.t ft
1t i1f fur *P 9~ 00 itt ~
,*:WM# Jy~ R;~if; r§
-8
.JltR f,]
ri: ~ ,tJ:.
~ I
$ jjt
fiJ
I
5t:
faJ fff.",'
~
1. ~~*rE tfJ 1~A ~ flf 9U Jffi § ~P ~ \ iA. ~1f-13 (-*=- f7t ), ~ It ~ Jb jltJtJ~ =-t $t }(f if [ill1\[ Jtt " 2. 'm}.jJt>l-f 7JYf $t ~ ~~~ -EE ~ ~ 1 ~Lft 11= Jb ~~ llR ~ !ffli #L ~ ,fM ~, tftf~1I*x ~~ tiJ f}f ,tE if!1iL;fP 3:-1f iiJ *iT~~ !'If*It 0
- 10 ·
~1-t 'liJilj ill 1:s M
~
Jt
xitftlt ~~ X. j!fr.
f4t ~ifi -I1f ti i.iE~. *-ft lIR:lt *"~ iiE ~
-r;j
*f f7t i.iE '% P$ifJf1£~
r)ftf~1ft ,&;ft fJ 19:. ;fJU~;g ft
11k±!!: ~~ It 1;5
11, /L.' ~1! -1 A~f6
~~
*7JIJ.I ft fJ.r rli]
1PJ at #1 if *-tf-lft5i
I 1f:iji IP]
,Hi ~ 1'f.w. 1PT jIt Jj[ if .QR :fi
t8i/JJ
.~Jl:atr~ ft MltMiif ~f3)'l (~~ ) .I{1: 1lP.1J iiEllJ] A
~.Ii iPT ftl ~ .WJ
~1±fET# ~ IJt
-12
~ +
JJj
'It
~
~:i±{oJ#
-t'±~ff ~r..± ~ txf\ + '
1'5]" Elf 1IX.1Ef {oJ #-t'±~1i
~1i ilE-f7
~ **JAiij %
~f ji: ~ ~ JJj A PJ. 1'5]" Elf {oJ ±{IJ, ~ :i±{oJ # ji:1f-t .±±~ i)11
JBZ1Ef1PJ# ilE -f7
~1fJJ->M 00 5'~ ~ JJj
1IX.1Ef{oJ # ~1i ilE-f7
-t .± ~ JJj
JJ. -t .± I!R ~
~ {£ {oJ ftttf..* {oJ # -t .± .I1t ~Jl at 1'0]
1IX.1Ef{oJ # -t .± ~*I!R~
~1IW~Jl at 1'0]
-t.±tt*I!R~ ilE -f7 ~ **
ilE -f7 JAiij %
it W{oJ # 5'~ 00"* ~ 7l<-f
~W{oJ#Y~J~~* ~ 7l<-f
- 13
I (~7!: rf1 iH Ar\\l~ IE rp il1rr ;f(itf: -Q[l~m~'{j ~M~4. 1t-~ M1Hr-J !kftl: fA lJi. ~ ~ mIJ:j4f,*m:f1-if\'Z(fJ~~ rn l;J!)
l~~ $~A~~_:__________~~~_~~ ___ -IU
·14·
J'JT
tE Jf!1ft ~ %
...
-il• ~ ~ 5:£: faJ ~ %
"$ ~ ~ 5:£: faJ ~ %
•
1. J~*til lfJ i~A WJ'JT ~IJ ~ §I ~p ;9;, iA Ji-;l:Ji ~ (-~ ~ 171 ), ~ Jt 3§t 7J JLIJ~ -=- -t :t J11 iE Wj[ fit 0
2. lfJ i~A 1K*-t ~yt~t Jb\. E] 1fVip -11 ~ Erg, Jt~*1t7J Jt JR- E] 1f Vip tk ~ ;f~ ~, #- WIf J!;fX ~~ tt J'JT {f if1ft{tJ I If E] 5i iT iE.k $ n1*If 0
-15