hsqe management annual report 2014 - ukdn waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were...

35
UKDN Waterflow HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 Summer 2015 Let’s keep Britain flowing. Water. Wastewater. Drainage. Infrastructure.

Upload: others

Post on 30-Sep-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

   

UKDN Waterflow HSQE Management Annual Report 2014

Summer 2015

 

Let’s keep Britain flowing.

Water. Wastewater. Drainage. Infrastructure.

Page 2: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  2  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table of contents  

Foreword 3

Executive Summary 5

1.0 Close Call Incidents 7

2.0 HSQE Performance Management 8

3.0 Health and Safety Trends Analysis 10

4.0 Analysis of Accidents 14

5.0 Logistics 19

6.0 Breaches 20

7.0 Safety Communications 22

8.0 Monitoring and Measuring 24

9.0 Risk Register 25

10.0 Operational HSQE Manager Competency Review 29

11.0 Plan, Do, Check, Act 30

12.0 HSQE for 2015 31

Chief Executive’s review 34

Page 3: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  3  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Foreword from our Chief Operating Officer

Health and Safety is not just the responsibility of the company. We must

all play our part.

As a company, we have a legal obligation

towards health and safety. However, if this is our

only reason for implementing our health and safety management systems, then, as a

company, we have no real safety culture. First

and foremost, keeping people safe must be an ethical and moral decision, not because of legal

reasons.

It is because of our approach to Health and Safety that UKDN Waterflow has a ‘No

Compromise’ attitude. We make no apologies for

the fact that people have been removed from the company for not sharing this same philosophy.

There is no place within our company for people

who put themselves and other at risk of injury.

Over the past two years our company has had to change and adapt to the needs of the

market. Our work covers many sectors, ranging from domestic property, to high-risk sectors,

such as rail and underground networks. We work in confined spaces and have lone workers, but this does not mean we cannot manage the risk out of what we do to ensure that we are

safe and injury free.

We introduced internal health and safety audits, which covered an office and site based

audit for each of our locations and we have also increased the number of site inspections. In

addition, we have also undertaken independent third party audits with Achilles Link-up, which we passed with no improvement recommendations.

We are a responsible company and care about our environment. To ensure that we treat

environmental issues in the same way as health and safety, we have achieved ISO 14001 accreditation. As part of this certification, we have spent time finding ways to reduce our

carbon footprint, in turn, reducing our impact on the environment.

Whilst I congratulate our HSQE department for the clear improvements we have made, I

must remind everyone that health and safety is not just the responsibility of the company.

We must all play our part and we all have a duty to ensure company employees, customers, partners and stakeholders are kept safe and free from injury. We have made very good

progress, but there is still a way to go before we report our first injury free year. If everyone

plays his or her part, I am sure it will not be long before we achieve our aim.

Kevin Mouatt CDir FloD

Chief Operating Officer

Page 4: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  4  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Who is UKDN Waterflow?

We are an innovator. An end-to-end provider of infrastructure services, from households, through to major contractors.

Page 5: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  5  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Executive Summary

The purpose of our 2014 annual report is to demonstrate the commitment and culture of continual improvement of HSQE performance at UKDN Waterflow.

This will be used to demonstrate to our people, clients, stakeholders and competitors, that

UKDN Waterflow considers the safety of all of our people and those that may be affected by

our work, to be paramount. We put safety first and plan for First Time Right.

With on-going formal monthly reviews of our systems of work by our Chief Operating Officer

- our dedicated director for health and safety – UKDN Waterflow analyses incidents, through

category break down, root cause and human behaviour. We have made great strides during 2014, in targeting 100% compliance, which will benefit our employees and the communities

in which we operate.

HSQE highlights for 2014

§ Appointment of Kevin Mouatt, Chief Operating Officer and dedicated Director for Health and Safety

§ Introduction of First Response Safe Systems of Work, with Take 5 check lists for risk

controls

§ Take 5 themed site engagement and inspection from operational management, which in November and December 2014 reached 100% of target

§ Increase in reporting of events where incidents may have been under reported, by

event categorisation and promoting and investigating close call reporting § Dedicated day for monthly HSQE performance review.

Health and Safety Summary for 2014

AFR - The accident frequency rate (AFR) for the group at the end of 2014 was at 0.15. This

is compared to an AFR of 0.13 for 2013.DDOR1 Incidents - The reported incidents for the Group for 2014 included 28 Close Calls, 26 No

Lost Time Accidents, 15 Lost Time Incidents and 2 RIDDOR Reportable Incidents.

Breaches of health and safety – There were 10 breaches recorded and entered on the

ICAR Register in December 2014. There were Five Category 2 breaches and Five Category 3 Observations made. All actions were programmed with close out dates. 8 Actions were

closed with two still outstanding.

Safety Communications – In total 138 Safety Alerts were issued in 2014. 34 Internal Alerts and 104 External Alerts. In addition quarterly HSQE Engagement were carried out nationally

to all Operations Managers and Site Teams, with presentations on various HSQE

campaigns to promote and improve safety.

                                                                                                               1 Whilst it appears that there was decrease in performance with the rising AFR, after analysis of RIDDORs for

2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than 2013; the number of days lost from RIDDORs in 2014 was 45 compared to 108 for 2013; the RIDDOR incidents from 2014 were less severe than those of 2013 without prediction or trend. For comparison 2012 AFR = 0.43.

Page 6: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  6  

 

 

 

 

 

 

We delivered over 40 sites for Thames Water’s Sewer Crossing Rail project, with no incidents

or injuries, significantly improving the hydraulic efficiencies of London’s sewers.

WATER AND

SEWERAGE

Page 7: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  7  

 

 

 

 

 

 

1.0 Close Call Incidents January to December 2014  

The information below shows the number of ‘close calls’ that were raised in 2014 and their causes.

28 ‘Close Calls’ have been raised year to date.

 

Fig.1. Close Call Causes for 2014

Service Strikes were the dominant Close Call event during 2014. Work groups have focused on case studies for service strikes, whilst they have also been used to instruct operatives of

the assessment and actions to take prior to working on site. The second and third most

common cause for close call events were thorough checks not being conducted and third party involvement. With the issue of Take 5 – Operator check lists and Safe System of Work

(SSOW) and the increased site inspection engagement, the business should be in a better

position to monitor the pre-check use and third party protection on site.

An ‘Event-Close Call’ report card has been created following consulation with

representatives from IC&I and IS Nationally. The Event-Close Call Card is designed to

capture ‘Close Call’ (near miss / near hit) events, whilst taking immediate actions to improve conditions and activities. This is set for trial in IS-Rail Region for January 2015 with

presentations and Site Person in Charge workshops by the HSQE Rail and Systems

Manager. Following the trial and review, it is intended for national roll out to improve the reporting culture further, in 2015.

4   1   1   2   2   1   1   2  

10  

1   3  

Checks  not  

conducted  

Contact  with  

electrical  

discharge  

Deliberate  Act  

Exposed  to  

harm

ful  

substance  

Hit  by  a  flying  

object  

Hit  by  m

oving  

vehicle  

Infrastructure  

defect  

Planning  

Service  Strike  

Slipped  /  

Tripped  on  

same  level.  

Third  Party  

Close  Call  Causes  

Page 8: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  8  

 

 

 

 

 

 

2.0 HSQE Performance Management – Leading and Lagging data Leading and lagging data is important, because it provides input and output activity, demonstrating HSQE performance across the business.

Proactive (KPIs) input is gathered from training compliance, site inspection and engagement, customer satisfaction reporting, programmed internal and external audit,

campaigns and communication. Reactive (KPIs) output is gathered from incidents and

accident information inclusive of RIDDOR, Lost Time and No Lost Time Incidents, Environmental Incidents and Quality Incidents defined as incident with no injury but damage

or service failure from critical process non-conformance.

Fig 2. Leading and Lagging Graph

§ December had an increase in performance compared to November, from a reduction

in incident, with 3 No-Lost Time Accidents reported in December 2014 and a

sustained KPI of 100% for site engagement and inspections by operations teams. 98

inspections were set and carried out in December

§ November demonstrated an increase in leading (proactive) measures. This is from the increase in site inspection and meeting the site engagement KPI for November.

91 Inspections set & 91 carried out

Page 9: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  9  

 

 

 

 

 

 

§ October showed a decrease in performance compared to that of September, with 1 LTI and 2 No LTI and a slump in Site Inspections – Engagement from 83% down to

66% of inspection target met

§ September shows an increase in both leading and lagging performance. 83% of the target for supervisory inspections were reached, increasing the leading measure

With a decrease of ‘Minor No Lost Time’ incidents and no incidents resulting in ‘Lost

Time’ incidents for the period

§ August demonstrated a drop in input compared to July 14, as a result of the decrease in site inspection activity.

Page 10: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  10  

 

 

 

 

 

 

3.0 Health and Safety Trends Analysis We use industry guidance from the Health and Safety Executive to measure health and safety performance across our business. Section 3.1. AFR

The Accident Frequency Rate (AFR) for the group for 2014 Year End is at 0.15. This is measured from January 2014 – December 2014. This is an improvement from 0.16 for

November 14 at Period 11’s YTD figure.

It could be considered that the AFR is not improving for 2014. After analysis of RIDDORs for

2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: there were

less man-hours worked in 2014 than 2013; 45 days were lost due to RIDDORs in 2014 for

both incidents, compared to 108 days lost for RIDDORs for 2013. The RIDDOR incidents from 2014 were less severe than those of 2013 without prediction of occurrence and without

trend. For comparison 2012 AFR = 0.43.

Fig 3. UKDN Waterflow AFR.

 AFR  =  0.15  for  2014.  

 

Section 3.2. Total No of RIDDOR Incidents

The total number of man hours worked and the total number of RIDDOR Incidents for 2012

& 2013 was reviewed in November 2014 by the COO and Head of HSQE and amended to reflect, both the changes to RIDDOR Regulations 2012 and to ensure consistency for the

reporting for 2014 onwards. (Fig 4).

 

 

 

 

 

 

Fig 4. UKDN Waterflow AFR. Total No of RIDDOR Incidents

0.43  

0.13  0.15  

2012   2013   2014  

UKDN  WATERFLOW  AFR    

Page 11: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  11  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Accident Frequency Rate has been split for the Group, for Insurance, Commercial and

Industrial (IC&I) the AFR is measured at 0.00, whilst for Infrastructure Solutions (IS) the AFR is recorded at 0.43.

Both RIDDORs recorded for the last 12 Months have occurred at Infrastructure Solutions in the months of January 2014 and March 2014. The AFR for the business with the inclusion of

the hours worked by subcontractors is 0.09.

Section 3.3 Accident Frequency Rates for RIDDOR, Lost Time Incidents and No Lost Time Incidents

The graph below demonstrates (using a cumulative figure) incident rates for 3 types of injury

related events. No – Lost Time Incidents, Lost Time incidents and RIDDOR Incidents. These are recorded over a 12 Month Rolling Period to demonstrate trend over a continuum.

Fig 5. 12 Month Rolling Accident Frequency Rates for RIDDOR, LTI and No - LTI

Figure 5 shows that there has been an increase in the number of minor no lost time and

minor lost time incidents in the between January and May 2014. It is suggested that there

may have been ‘under reporting’ of incidents in previous years and that this has increased

as the safety culture has improved with campaigns and HSQE awareness sessions in early

6  

2   2  

2012-­‐535  Staff   2013-­‐573  Staff   2014-­‐509  Staff  

0.00  

1.00  

2.00  

3.00  

4.00  

5.00  

6.00  

7.00  

8.00  

9.00  

Rolling  RIDDOR  Rate   Rolling  LTI  Rate   Rolling  Non  LTI  Rate  

12  Month  Rolling  Incident  Rates    for  Periods  1  -­‐  12  January  -­‐  December  2014    (Incidents  Per  100,000  worked)  

Page 12: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  12  

 

 

 

 

 

 

2014 and continual HSQE engagement since. The numbers have stabilised during the last quarter, giving the business a good benchmark for setting performance targets for 2015.

Page 13: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  13  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Our no-dig solutions saved Cross Rail over £10m, but more importantly by diverting

exposure of a skilled engineering workforce, we reduced the health and safety impacts to

staff and local stakeholders.

RAIL AND INFRASTRUCTURE

Page 14: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  14  

 

 

 

 

 

 

4.0 Analysis of Accidents (events resulting in injury) The following section shows a summary of all accidents and their causes. Events resulting in injury are analysed for the whole of 2014. Section 4.1. Event Categories Fig 6.a. Event Types (Incident Triangle)

Fig 6. Event Category

   

In December 2014, and after final review, it has been reported that for 2014, there have been 28 Close Calls, 36 No Lost Time Accidents, 15 Lost Time Accidents and 2 RIDDOR

(Over 7 Day Lost Time) Events. Following the trial and the successful implementation of the

new ‘Event Close Call’ Cards, results in 2015 will be reflective of a true incident triangle,

where there is a relationship between the number of serious incident and close calls reported (Heinrich Law – Incident Triangle). It is still evident that Close Call Events are under

reported.

Section 4.2 Injury Causes

Fig 7. Injury Causes

8%  

2%  4%  

4%   4%  

4%  

19%  41%  

14%  

Injury  Causes  January  -­‐  December  2014  

Exposed  to  harmful  substance  

Fell  from  height  <2m  

Hit  by  a  flying  object  

Hit  by  falling  object  

Hit  by  hand  tool  

Hit  by  Hand  Tool  /  Electrical  Tool  

Hit  by  something  fixed  or  sta]onary  

35%  

19%  

44%  

2%  

Event  Categories  2014  

Close  Call  

Lost  Time  Accident  

No  Lost  Time  Accident  

Page 15: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  15  

 

 

 

 

 

 

The largest injury cause of injury in the business is from manual handling activity from either incorrect lifting, pushing or pulling. This followed by being hit by something fixed or

stationary whereby the injured person has made contact with a fixed object. A 3rd significant

injury cause were the injured person has been hit by a flying object, either from pressure and loss of grip of a tool, or a projectile / debris from the activity

Fig 7.a. Body Parts Injured From Accidents During 2014

 From the Chart in Fig 7.a. Body Parts Injured, it can be seen that the significant and most

common injuries are injuries to the Back = 15 and the Hand = 12.

Back Injuries = 16

8 of the back injuries resulted in lost time injury with 7 of the back injuries not resulting in any

lost time. 14 of the injuries were as a result of manual handling. 1 of the Injuries was sustained from

slipping and tripping.

Actions taken to reduce back injury and accidents resulting from manual handling have

included, Onsite refresher training, ‘Pristine Condition’ Manual Handling Film presentation,

safety alerts and tool box talks. This has also been monitored through increased site inspection, where one objective is to record handling activity and interact with operatives to

promote awareness. A specific lifting Safety Alert was communicated during December 2014

detailing manual handling techniques.

Hand Injuries = 12

1 of the 12 hand injuries resulted in lost time. The hand injuries differed significantly in both

injury cause and root cause.

Actions taken to reduce hand injury included the issue of first response safe systems of

work, Take 5 – Site Assessment, Safety Alerts and briefings during the 3rd quarter of 2014. Periodic promotion of PPE awareness was also carried out. This has also been monitored

through increased site inspection, where one objective is to record handling activity and PPE

use, with interaction between managers and operatives to promote awareness for protecting

the hands.

5  

16  

1   5   4  

12  

1   5   1   2  

Arm   Back   Eye   Face   Foot   Hand   Head   Leg   Respiratory   Torso  

Body  Parts  Injured  

Page 16: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  16  

 

 

 

 

 

 

For all injuries actions have been taken to reduce accident, injury and absenteeism during the year in the form of awareness campaigns and training for manual handling; hand and

electrical tool use and the correct use of personal protective equipment (PPE). Proactive

measures are taken in the form of routine Tool Box Talks and monthly issue of Safety Alert, both internally created and client / industry issue.

Section 4.3. Root Cause Analysis Fig 8. & Fig 8.a. Accident Root Causes for January - December 2014 demonstrates that the root causes of accidents were predominantly contributed by individual behaviour (28 incidents = 54% of the accidents) as opposed to unsafe conditions or failure in safe systems of work. It was noted at the October 2014 HSQE Management meeting that review of employee selection during recruitment must be considered. For 2014 the IP Behaviour was 46% of the Root Causes of all ‘Events’ (both accidents and incidents combined). An improvement from 50% for the first half of the year. Period 06 – June 2014 HSQE Management Report.

Fig 8. Root Cause of Accidents 2014

 

2%  

54%  

11%  

4%  

15%  

6%  8%  

Accident  Root  Cause  2014  

 Insufficient  Training  /  Competence  

IP  Behaviour  

PPE  Not  Used/Defec]ve/Inadequate/Not  Available  

Safe  System  of  Work  not  followed  

Third  Party  Behaviour  

Unforeseen  Risk  

Uniden]fied  Hazard  

Page 17: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  17  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Fig 8.a Accident Root Cause Total 2014  

 

Whilst HSQE Engagement Sessions will continue to strive for improvement with

themes for ‘Take 5 Behavioural change’, more must be done to reduce incidents,

with increased attention for a change in attitudes and behaviours. Disciplinary is now

considered for all Behavioural Incident Accident as a way of modifying behaviours

and reviewed at the HSQE Monthly Management meeting with the Head of HSQE

and Chief Operating Officer.

A Close Call reporting trial / campaign is underway for review in January 2015. This

is being trialled in the IS-Rail Region. Following the trial and review, it is intended for

national roll out to improve the reporting culture further, in 2015. It is designed for

improvement of hazard reporting and close call activity, with an aim to improve

operative behaviour and eliminate accident.

Section 4.4. Actions Taken to Prevent Recurrence

All accidents are investigated with a review of the Safe System of Work inclusive of

risk, activity / task, equipment / tool use and work environment. Findings and

suggested actions to prevent recurrence are discussed with minutes taken at the

Monthly HSQE Management Meeting by Head of HSQE and Chief Operating Officer.

These actions are recorded with ownership agreed and recorded on the ICAR

1  

28  

6   2   8   3   4  

Accident  Root  Cause  2014  

 

Page 18: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  18  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Register. Actions / Improvements are managed by HSQE Coordinator. (Breaches of

HSQE in Section 7.)

Fig 9. Action Following Accident and Incident Investigation %

 The Graph shows action taken following the Accident and Incident. 2 Events resulted in

formal disciplinary action. 1 Accident in January 2014 resulted in Disciplinary Action for 4

members of staff one of which resulted in terminating their employment. 1 Close Call in

December resulted in First Stage - Verbal Warning. 43% of Accidents have required further

coaching or training for employees. 31% of Accidents required early stages of disciplinary

action in the form of a ‘Record of Conversation’. A Record of Conversation is kept on file for

an employee, this is recorded between Line or Senior Management discussing the incident,

preventative and immediate action and the instruction to follow a policy / procedure. Failure

to do so will result in formal disciplinary action.

Fig 9.a. Action Taken with the IP YTD

The chart shows No. of actions taken with the IP (Injured / Involved Person).

For the Individual / Injured or Involved Person (IP), where training / mentoring and

engagement with IP is not sufficient disciplinary action is taken.

43%  

2%  2%  

22%  

31%  

AcXon  Taken  with  the  Injured  Person  /  Involved  Person  

(IP)  2014  

Coaching  /  Refresher  Training  

Diciplinary  Ac]on  

Lecer  to  Third  Party  

No  Ac]on  Required  

Record  of  Conversa]on  

35  

2   2  

18  

25  

Coaching  /  Refresher  Training  

Diciplinary  Ac]on   Lecer  to  Third  Party  No  Ac]on  Required   Record  of  Conversa]on  

AcXon  Taken  with  the  Injured  Person  /  Involved  Person  

(IP)  2014  

Page 19: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  19  

 

 

 

 

 

 

5.0 Logistics  

It is important that we operate a plant and fleet portfolio, which is right for the job and sufficiently maintained to ensure it is safe for use on site. In addition we must ensure that our staff are suitably trained with the correct certificates and industry standards.

Section 5.1. Vehicle Incident / Behaviour – Driver Assessment is under review. Risks and controls in the interim have been added to the Risk Register.

The Logistics Team, will produce reports for vehicle incident and driving behaviour for the inclusion of the HSQE Report.

Speeding Offenders (Drivers) will receive a letter from Head of HSQE detailing

consequences that could occur following an incident and the action that will be taken if found speeding again.

The report will detail the activity of driving behaviour nationally. This will include reactive and proactive measures for improving driver behaviour and safe vehicle use.

Section 5.1.1. Road Traffic Accidents - RTA 1. IP stopped vehicle at end of shift to allow secondary operative to collect his belongings from another vehicle. IP was sitting in vehicle

on highway with vehicle stationary. A third party reversed into IP's parked vehicle. IP

reported that he had suffered whiplash. The IP was not parked in a parking bay and was parked in the highway. IP was given a record of conversation with A Douglas (Line

Manager.) This was an incident on the highway, thus not reportable by which HSE

determines. (Verified by NJM Associates on 08.01.15.)

Section 5.2. Plant and Equipment Management – Plant and Equipment Compliance is

being measured as part of ongoing internal audit and review. Competent persons have been

selected by regional / area managers to ensure all equipment is deployed to site fit for purpose and safe for use. A schedule has been developed for ensuring competent persons

trained around the business conduct the necessary inspection within the appropriate time

scales. Adherence to the new procedure will be measured as part of the weighted scoring

system. This is monitored weekly and will be managed by the Logistics team to ensure compliance.

Page 20: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  20  

 

 

 

 

 

 

6.0 Breaches

For 2014, there were 8 Category 1 breaches, 112 Category 2 breaches

and 26 Category 3 Observations made. All actions were programmed

with, owners, close out dates and corrective action and entered on to the

Improvement Corrective Action Register (ICAR) for logging, tracking and

analysis.

Breaches are categorised into 3 categories.

1 = Major, a non-conformance or event which has the potential for major / significant

personal injury, major property / asset damage or major / significant impact on the environment.

2 = Minor, a non-conformance / event which has the potential for minor personal injury,

minor property / asset damage or minor impact on the environment.

3 = Observation, an observation made with room for improvement or suggested alternative method of work.

Fig 10. (Improvement Corrective Actions) in Health and Safety

There were 146 breaches recorded and entered on the ICAR Register in 2014.

In summary, the 146 breaches were recorded and entered on the ICAR Register. For all

breaches the responsible person is identified and corrective/ preventive action assigned with

timely close out dates.

Actions

Cat 1. – All Cat one breaches are reported to the COO. Formal interview with Head of HSQE

and Director.

Cat 2. – Review of action at dedicated Monthly HSQE meeting with Head of HSQE and

COO.

Cat 3. – Recommendation and corrective action completed at time of assessment where

practical.

8  

112  

26  

Category  1   Category  2   Category  3  

HSQE  Breaches  for  2014.    

Page 21: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  21  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Commercial owners are liable for health and safety of its visitors and building users, we

understand getting the drainage working again is important, but so is working safely. Our approach to safety has been rewarded

with our 0.08% AFR

COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL

Page 22: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  22  

 

 

 

 

 

 

7.0 Safety Communications

Safety communications are important for both our industry and our

business, as an example of sharing best practice.

Section 7.1. Internal Communications

For 2014, in total 138 Safety Alerts were issued group wide. Of these, 34 were made internally and 104 were issued following escalation from clients, fellow contractors and

governing bodies.

The alerts are accessible from the dedicated HSQE Page on the company intranet ‘UView’,

these are also issued on site from operational managers and supervisors on site, in the form

of a tool box talk.

In addition to monthly tool box talks and safety alerts. The HSQE team travel nationally to

visit all site teams and managers quarterly. This is to carry out HSQE promotional

presentations, workshops and training sessions. These visits are also used to hold open forums for any HSQE innovation, concerns or issues with the allowance of open discussion

and sharing of HSQE information and promotion incident free working.

Fig 11. Number of Communications Issued for 2014

3   3  

0  

4  3  

5  

3  

1  2  

4  3   3  

7  

3  

10  

2  

4   4  5  

19  

14  

7  

22  

0  

Jan-­‐14   Feb-­‐14   Mar-­‐14   Apr-­‐14   May-­‐14   Jun-­‐14   Jul-­‐14   Aug-­‐14   Sep-­‐14   Oct-­‐14   Nov-­‐14   Dec-­‐14  

Number of Communications Issues for

2014

Internal     External    

Page 23: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  23  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Fig 12. Examples of Staff Alerts

 

8.0

Page 24: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  24  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Monitoring and Measuring To fulfil the business commitment to improving health and safety, HSQE activity and performance is monitored and measured through, Site Inspection for Operation Activity and premises and procedural audit for facility safety management.

For site inspection and engagement. Each operational manager and supervisor are set a number of visits to achieve per month. The target benchmark is set at 85%. The following

chart represents Operational Manager and Supervisor Engagement in each of the business

groups and regions.

Fig 12. Site Inspection – Regional / Area Performance

There was a consistent result of onsite engagement in November and again in December

2014 through safety inspection with 100% of target achieved compared to that of 66% for

October. IC&I completed 100% (up from 96%) of target inspections and IS completed 98% (down from 105%) of target.

The operational managers and supervisors set with KPI’s for Site Inspection are monitored for performance and reviewed by HSQE and the COO for trend analysis and to ensure

consistent reporting.

Section 8.1 Premises / Procedure Audits

All areas are audited 6 monthly by HSQE to ensure improvement and compliance. Based on

a scoring system to aid and promote improvement. In addition the business is routinely audited by external bodies, such as: NQA for OHSAS 18001, ISO 14001 & ISO 9001;

Achilles UVDB & Achilles RISQ; as well as other client and industry accreditations.

117%  

94%  

110%  

92%  83%  

100%   100%   100%  

CENTRAL  IC&I   NORTHERN    IC&I  

SOUTH  EAST    IC&I  

SOUTH  WEST    IC&I  

CCTV  IS   HGV  IS   RAIL  IS   REHAB  IS  

Percentage  of  Site  InspecXon  Target  Reached  

December  2014  

Page 25: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  25  

 

 

 

 

 

 

9.0 Risk Register The Risk Register section includes subjects and risks identified during Monthly HSQE Management Review at the HSQE Management Meeting with the Head of HSQE and The Chief Operating Officer. They are listed with interim controls and actions and proposed long term control measures. These will be monitored at all HSQE Management meetings to report on progress.

No Risk Identified Impact Interim Control

Measure

Proposed Long

Term Control Measure

1 External ‘New Driver’

Assessment stopped in September 2014.

Evaluation proved poor

offering no value. New assessment to be

sought.

Drivers not assessed

or deemed competent pose risk

to other drivers, the

public and themselves. Impact

on insurance

premiums.

Drivers

mandate is managed by

Fleet Hire.

New starters

are deemed

competent by Line

Management or

professionally

trained operatives.

Drivers handbook

issued,

understood and signed for by all

drivers.

Tracker reports

are monitored

by logistics

team.

Actions taken

for speeding offenders,

incidents and 3rd

party complaints.

Driver handbook

to be reviewed, amended and

reissued to all

drivers.

Comprehensive

Driver assessment to

be evaluated

and

implemented.

This would be

carried out for all new drivers

and driving

offenders. This would be carried

out periodically

thereof.

All the above

are under

review by Logistics

Manager.

Page 26: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  26  

 

 

 

 

 

 

2 Employees Driving at Speed.

Drivers pose risk to other drivers, the

public and

themselves. Impact on insurance

premiums.

Drivers handbook

issued,

understood and signed for by all

drivers.

Tracker reports

are monitored by logistics

team.

Actions taken

for speeding

offenders,

incidents and 3rd party

complaints.

Driver handbook to be reviewed,

amended and

reissued to all drivers.

Comprehensive

Driver assessment to

be evaluated

and implemented.

This would be carried out for

all new drivers

and driving

offenders. This would be carried

out periodically

thereof.

All the above

are under review by

Logistics

Manager.

3 Incident, accident and

event as a result in

change in the following: - SSOW, Legislation,

client agreement or

review of practice.

Incident, Accident,

damage, misconduct

of employee.

Safety Alerts,

Tool Box Talks,

Presentations, memo’s and

HSQE

Engagement

Sessions.

Web based

regular reading

with assessment and

scoring.

This is on the IT

programme for

development.

4 Incident as a result of

equipment not being

maintained and checked correctly.

Injury, damage,

failure in safety

critical equipment and non-

conformance.

Plant and

equipment

procedure. Uview Plant and

equipment

register.

Nominated competent

persons tested

in testing of equipment.

Electronic

(PDA) check list

to be created for operative

ownership.

KPI to be set, managed and

acted upon for

Plant & Equipment.

Page 27: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  27  

 

 

 

 

 

 

All the above are under

review by

Logistics Manager.

5 Portable plant requiring

refuelling on site.

Serious Incident

resulting in explosion, burns, fire.

Environmental

Incident involving pollution and

damage.

Risk

assessment reviewed for

petrol and

diesel plant with instruction on

how to refuel

safely without

risk to persons or environment.

Prohibition of

purchase or rehire of petrol

plant. Risk

assessments and instructions

issued

nationally.

To find solution

to prevent spillage and

prevent the

need to refuel on site with

open

containers.

Page 28: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  28  

 

 

 

 

 

 

We are a market leader in the drainage industry and we currently manage over

300,000 customer contacts from our Birmingham Customer Service Centre that

results in over 100,000 visits to customer locations annually.

INSURANCE AND HOUSEHOLD

Page 29: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  29  

 

 

 

 

 

 

10.0 Operational HSQE Manager Competency Review At the monthly HSQE Review by Head of HSQE and the Chief Operating Officer, operational management and supervisory HSQE competence is reviewed and scored.

The scoring is based on the fundamentals of each person’s competence in HSQE Leadership, HSQE Control and HSQE Engagement.

The scores are tabled and reviewed quarterly. For those scoring less than 80% further training and coaching will be given to enable the person to improve and engage effectively.

Areas for improvement are visible and can be used for performance review. This HSQE Monthly Manager Competency Review is in its infancy and will be used as a tool for driving and measuring improvement.

Page 30: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  30  

 

 

 

 

 

 

11.0 Plan, Do, Check, Act (Leadership – Engagment – Control) We have adopted the HSE’s Industry Guide INDG417 (rev1) developed by the Institute of Directors (IOD) and HSE for Leading Health and Safety at Work ‘Plan, Do, Check, Act’.

This summarises the business’s monthly and YTD performance and its desire to demonstrate Leadership, Control and Engagement, using ‘Plan, Do, Check, Act’.

Section  11.1.  PLAN    

‘How do you demonstrate the board’s commitment to health and safety?’

• Director for Health and Safety Appointed with active role in H&S Management and improvement strategy.

• Procedures for HS available with defined responsibilities for HSQE. (Under redevelopment to revise business HSQE Objectives. Once complete CEO&COO to sign and reissue to all.)

• Director of H&S (COO) reviews HSQE performance monthly and presents to the board.

• Senior Management Site Inspection / Engagement to be conducted (not conducted at present)

• Senior Management Engagement at HSQE Engagement Sessions to be planned (Not conducted at present).

• Slot on main Board Meeting designated to HSQE Management

• Slot on Monthly Operational Management Meeting for HSQE Review, feedback and update.

• Provision of HSQE Team.

• Accident Root Cause Analysis

 

 

Page 31: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  31  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Section  11.2.  DO    

What  have  you  done  to  ensure  the  

organisation,  at  all  levels  including  the  

board,  receives  competent  health  and  

safety  advice?  

• Monthly  Board  Report  

• Intranet  for  visible  HSQE  Procedures  

• Safety  Communications  

• Quarterly  HSQE  Engagement  

Presentations.  

• Competent  HSQE  Team  

• Availability  of  H&S  Consultant  

• Reactive  and  Proactive  feedback.  

How  are  you  ensuring  all  staff  –  including  

the  board  –  are  sufficiently  trained  and  

competent  in  their  health  and  safety  

responsibilities?  

• Training  Matrix  with  minimum  

requirements  which  is  managed.  It  

indicates  skill  gaps  and  training  

requirements.  

• Directors  Training  Matrix  not  in  place.  

How  confident  are  you  that  your  

workforce,  particularly  safety  

representatives,  are  consulted  properly  on  

health  and  safety  matters  and  that  their  

concerns  are  reaching  the  appropriate  level  

including,  as  necessary  the  board?  

• HSQE  Engagement  sessions  give  

opportunity  for  feedback,  suggestions  

and  improvements.  Reported  

monthly  on  ICAR  Register  when  

identified.  

• Site  Engagement  Sessions  

(Inspections  from  all  levels)  include  

the  opportunity  for  feedback,  

suggestions  and  improvements.  

Reported  monthly  on  ICAR  Register  

when  identified.  

• Senior  Management  Inspections  not  

currently  carried  out.    

• HSQE  has  an  open  door  policy  and  

reminds,  requests  and  facilitates  

improvement  and  issues  

What  systems  are  in  place  to  ensure  your  

organisations  risks  are  assessed  and  that  

sensible  control  measures  are  established  

and  maintained?  

• HSQE  Conduct  and  Review  Risk  

Assessment.  

• Reviewed  Annually  (or  following  

incident  or  change  in  legislation)  

• The  system  is  audited  by  both  

internal  and  external  verification  to  

measure  its  effectiveness  and  

maintenance.    

• Risk  Register  produced  for  HSQE  

Monthly  Management  Review.  

Page 32: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  32  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Section  11.3.  CHECK  

How  well  do  you  know  what  is  happening  

on  the  ground,  and  what  audits  or  

assessments  are  undertaken  to  inform  you  

about  what  your  organisation  and  

contractors  actually  do?  

• Site  inspection  from  HSQE    

• Site  inspections  from  Operational  

Management  

• Client  Site  inspection  

• Subcontractor  Evaluation  

• Audit  by  external  verifiers    

• Independent  annual  audit  and  review  

of  years  H&S  performance  external  

H&S  Professional  

• Sample  site  audit  by  external  auditors  

• Planned  and  Unplanned  inspection    

What  information  does  the  board  receive  

regularly  about  health  and  safety,  e.g.  

performance  data  and  reports  on  injuries  

and  work  related  ill  health?  

• Minutes  from  HSQE  Management  

Meeting  

• HSQE  Management  /  Board  Report  

for  Period  and  YTD.  

• Comprehensive  report  detailing  

performance  and  previous  

performance  data  analysis.  

• Monthly  pack  to  review  period  and  

year  to  date  progress  on:-­‐  

1. Events  -­‐  Accidents  and  Incidents  HSQE  

Performance  Measurement  

2. Accident  Frequency  Rate  –  Trends  

Report  

3. Analysis  of  Accidents  (Events  resulting  

in  injury)  

4. Logistics    

5. Breaches  in  HSQE    

6. Safety  Communications  

7. Monitoring  and  Measuring  

8. Risk  Register    

9. HSQE  Competency  Assessment    

10. Plan  –  Do  –  Check  –  Act

  (Leadership,  Control  and  

Engagement  

Do  you  compare  your  performance  with  

others  in  your  sector  and  beyond?  

• Proactive  HSQE  Performance  is  

compared  with  fellow  contractors  and  

competitors  by  NWR,  TFL  and  LUL.  

• Annual  Accident  Frequency  Rate  is  

Page 33: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  33  

 

 

 

 

 

 

compared  with  same  sector  and  

industry.  

Where  changes  in  working  arrangements  

have  significant  implications  for  health  and  

safety,  how  are  these  brought  to  the  

attention  of  the  board?  

• This  would  be  brought  to  the  

attention  of  the  COO  by  Head  of  

HSQE  at  the  time.  (Reactive)  

• Planned  works  would  be  considered  

and  shared  with  HSQE  for  discussion  

and  recording  at  HSQE  Management  

Meeting.    

• Monthly  Report  

• Minutes  from  HSQE  Management  

Meeting  

• Inspection  Report  

 

Section  11.4.  ACT  

What  do  you  do  to  ensure  appropriate  

board  level  review  of  health  and  safety?  

§ To  ensure  appropriate  board  level  

review  of  health  and  safety  the  Chief  

Operating  Officer  meets  Head  of  

HSQE  on  a  monthly  basis  to  discuss  

HSQE  Proactive  and  Reactive  

Performance.  Improvements  and  

Actions  are  agreed  and  a  report  

created  and  submitted  to  the  board  

for  review  (and  action  were  

necessary).  

§ Formal  Management  Review  by  Head  

of  HSQE  and  COO  

§ COO  delivers  and  presents  full  report  

to  Main  Board  

§ Monthly  Management  Review  of  H&S  

§ Annual  Review  of  H&S  Policy  

 

 

Page 34: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  34  

 

 

 

 

 

 

12.0 HSQE for 2015 With an established practice now in place for site HSQE performance monitoring, Take 5 Themed Safe Systems of Work already introduced and a continual improving safety culture, UKDN Waterflow needs to keep the momentum for 2015. Area Manager HSQE Sessions, will start the year with key HSQE Ownership performance management targets for monthly capture to monitor and measure improving performance.

Page 35: HSQE Management Annual Report 2014 - UKDN Waterflow · 2013 and 2014, it is noted that there were two RIDDOR Incidents for each year: There were less man-hours worked in 2014 than

HSQE  Management  Annual  Report        

 

 

 

 

Water.  Wastewater.  Drainage.  Infrastructure     Page  |  35  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Chief Executive’s review Like other companies in our industry, we place a huge importance on improving safety. We’ve come a long way in the last year but there is still much we can do to improve.

I would like to thank all of our people personally for their

hard work over the past year. We have seen many changes across the group and we have still maintained

our focus on safety, which has been reflected in the

achievement of a zero AFR.

Delivering an exceptional health and safety performance

is how we do business. Our clients can be assured that

when they work with UKDN Waterflow, our approach to health and safety will have an impact on their overall

health and safety performance.

Building on our talents as an innovative and specialist provider of drainage and infrastructure

services, we must continue to focus our efforts on keeping our people, partners, stakeholder

and members of the public, safe. Nothing is too important that it cannot be done safely and we want everyone to go home safely at the end of the day.

I look forward to continuing this good work in 2015. Please don’t hesitate to speak to me

personally if you have any questions.

Nick Harris

Chief Executive Officer