how to test a lens « canon rumors.pdf

7/27/2019 How To Test a Lens Canon Rumors.pdf

1/12

search...

HOME FORUM CONTACT ADVERTISE REVIEWS PROFILES ARTICLES PRICE WATCH: CAMERAS LENSES ACCESSORIES

TweetTweet

69

How To Test a LensIntroduction

This is the second article we have posted written by Roger Cicala. Its an insanely

indepth look at testing lenses.

Enjoy!cr

By: Roger Cicala

LensRentals.com

If you read my articles very often, you may have realized Im not one to let a lack of knowledge prevent me

from writing on a topic. First-hand knowledge I mean. I write a lot of articles that I may spend 6 weeks

researching before I feel knowledgeable enough to start writing. But this is one topic that I know well: itswhat I do for a living. About 8,000 new lenses have come through Lensrentals over the years, each one has

to be tested, inspected, and accepted before it goes on the shelf. And every day 150 to 400 lenses returnfrom rental and go through the same process before they ship out again.

I dont mean to suggest were lens reviewers, dissecting and measuring every possible aspect and index ofa lens. That takes days, tons of equipment, and a mindset that I dont have: full-blown obsessive-

compulsive nitpicking disorder. Im glad there are people who do that. Ill never be one of them.

(Dont get me started on the whole are-lens-reviews-worthwhile thing. I find it very similar to measuring the

height of one third-grader and then saying all third graders are 4 feet, 7 inches tall and weigh 52 pounds.

Someday someone will start evaluating 20 copies of a given lens, include the copy-to-copy variation in theirreviews, and in a short time will own the lens review business. But thats another topic.)

Why Bother?

When we get that shiny new box home, we expect it to be perfect. And it probably will be. But afteropening some 8,000 shiny new lens boxes I can assure not all of them are. Whether its quality control at

the factory or getting knocked around in shipping our experience is about 2% of new lenses need to beexchanged. It varies by brand and it varies by lens complexity (an autofocus zoom with image stabilization

is more likely to have problems than a manual focus prime). But every lens needs at least a basic

checkout when you first get it home. Used lenses, of course, require it even more.

There are several levels of testing and examination one can do. The simplest is go take some pictures andsee if they look okay. This works well, and has the advantage of getting to take pictures, but has some

shortcomings, too. First, you may not notice a problem until it is too late to return or exchange the lens.

Second, if something is wrong, simple photographs dont usually determine what kind of problem the lenshas. This lens is soft is a good article title, but not a good description of a problem.

(BTW if you send a lens in to factory repair with This lens is soft as the only description of the problem,

chances are extremely high that it wont be fixed. Trust me on this. We have 20 lenses a week go in to

factory service. Weve learned.)

Class 1 to Class 12 Less ons, Animations, Videos & more Math, EVS, Science, English, SST www.MeritNation.com/CBSE

OpenSooq .com/ _

Jobs in Oman - 2013 All New Jobs in Oman. Apply Free! www.bayt.com/oman

62
http://twitter.com/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.canonrumors.com%2Ftech-articles%2Fhow-to-test-a-lens%2Fhttp://www.canonrumors.com/tech-articles/how-to-test-a-lens/http://www.google.com/url?ct=abg&q=https://www.google.com/adsense/support/bin/request.py%3Fcontact%3Dabg_afc%26url%3Dhttp://www.canonrumors.com/tech-articles/how-to-test-a-lens/%26gl%3DOM%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dca-pub-4883675891742296%26ai0%3DC1FmphfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBuzch-UD_PDUxDLAjbcBEAEgn4GIDigDUN3h4ewCYIEEoAHS66vuA8gBAakCFkMdXrkdUj7gAgCoAwHIA58EqgS5AU_QD1Pf6AG0gpnNQcZKT0qkVJgS7LSNunhpqTe4nm1Btkda6tAAJVWCLUdB4qG30KKrbyDW5QZx3IF14E1ODq_SNRCt_Gv-tluD7vnnx9Hc9feNN5TAJPvKN4e1a9N-pZ1ZEmHJhfTQYLzm8g9tPK4f1Wd1XmkbOZJaaScGiVp5Iy9o2hjDi2d5pwrhjFh_8Aa5tKhCZBHgYQl4bJVc3dWwVeMqX6ivHLc4fiXwrJEOzTsoeMLoiP3H4AQBiAYBgAeWlNQR%26ai1%3DCLVq3hfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBs-c3t8D__SWiVboh4WeCxACIJ-BiA4oA1Dv4Z3F_f____8BYIEEoAHxj7jZA8gBAeACAKgDAcgDnwSqBLgBT9BPDBz0G426K35TokpPE-lWlxPtqIqienSoavWSb5YNT2Tv2kBkXO0TVeg5nOPMoq8lNda9BnGFzHfvTE8SqMo3DayhJvK0Gdj__-yCnc_z6oc4ndZ4vM0v3exwkSe0i15LLYXE_dt94EkID6y-qNYfqkx8mfjRgXxsJU7IUwUKK23bD9OGaWqx_nJPn-Br5VpfQ6aJ8wvRuI-alF7dFYWj4KrdukrqtDh-IQFakw_NO8ieU_2PcOAEAYgGAYAH9-_HJg%26ai2%3DC3cz2hfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBozQx9ED3Jus3lTo3YXCQhADIJ-BiA4oA1DGk5nJAWCBBKABpIaU-QPIAQHgAgCoAwHIA58EqgS4AU_QTxIW9BqNuit-U6JKTxPpVpcT7aiKonp0qGr1km-WDU9k79pAZFztE1XoOZzjzKKvJTXWvQZxhcx370xPEqjKNw2soSbytBnY___sgp3P8-qHOJ3WeLzNL93scJEntIteSy2FxP3bfeBJCA-svqrWH6E4epv40YF8bCVOyFMFCitt2w_Thmlqsf5yT5_ga-VaX0OmifML0biPmpRe3RWFo-Cq3bpK6rQ4fiEBWpMPzTvInnz1z1_gBAGIBgGAB8T56wY&usg=AFQjCNExTFP6qzLCBu4I5T4ppSpXvIiqLwhttp://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=CLVq3hfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBs-c3t8D__SWiVboh4WeCxACIJ-BiA4oA1Dv4Z3F_f____8BYIEEoAHxj7jZA8gBAeACAKgDAcgDnwSqBLgBT9BPDBz0G426K35TokpPE-lWlxPtqIqienSoavWSb5YNT2Tv2kBkXO0TVeg5nOPMoq8lNda9BnGFzHfvTE8SqMo3DayhJvK0Gdj__-yCnc_z6oc4ndZ4vM0v3exwkSe0i15LLYXE_dt94EkID6y-qNYfqkx8mfjRgXxsJU7IUwUKK23bD9OGaWqx_nJPn-Br5VpfQ6aJ8wvRuI-alF7dFYWj4KrdukrqtDh-IQFakw_NO8ieU_2PcOAEAYgGAYAH9-_HJg&num=2&cid=5GhOncfO58ToDT-TkiDV_XlF&sig=AOD64_2Mx6cjziHzVg4tgEHHzELDYfu9Qg&client=ca-pub-4883675891742296&adurl=http://om.opensooq.com/registration&nm=1http://twitter.com/canonrumorsguyhttp://www.facebook.com/pages/Canon-Rumors/161708613875756https://plus.google.com/u/2/b/100168399520065139880/http://www.canonrumors.com/feed/http://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=C1FmphfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBuzch-UD_PDUxDLAjbcBEAEgn4GIDigDUN3h4ewCYIEEoAHS66vuA8gBAakCFkMdXrkdUj7gAgCoAwHIA58EqgS5AU_QD1Pf6AG0gpnNQcZKT0qkVJgS7LSNunhpqTe4nm1Btkda6tAAJVWCLUdB4qG30KKrbyDW5QZx3IF14E1ODq_SNRCt_Gv-tluD7vnnx9Hc9feNN5TAJPvKN4e1a9N-pZ1ZEmHJhfTQYLzm8g9tPK4f1Wd1XmkbOZJaaScGiVp5Iy9o2hjDi2d5pwrhjFh_8Aa5tKhCZBHgYQl4bJVc3dWwVeMqX6ivHLc4fiXwrJEOzTsoeMLoiP3H4AQBiAYBgAeWlNQR&num=1&cid=5GhOncfO58ToDT-TkiDV_XlF&sig=AOD64_318mkF5fr9_02VLlCELuTk8Ubikg&client=ca-pub-4883675891742296&adurl=http://cbse.meritnation.com/cbse-signup2%3Fmncid%3DAdwords_Display_Gulf_CBSE&nm=1http://www.canonrumors.com/http://www.canonrumors.com/http://www.google.com/url?ct=abg&q=https://www.google.com/adsense/support/bin/request.py%3Fcontact%3Dabg_afc%26url%3Dhttp://www.canonrumors.com/tech-articles/how-to-test-a-lens/%26gl%3DOM%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dca-pub-4883675891742296%26ai0%3DC1FmphfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBuzch-UD_PDUxDLAjbcBEAEgn4GIDigDUN3h4ewCYIEEoAHS66vuA8gBAakCFkMdXrkdUj7gAgCoAwHIA58EqgS5AU_QD1Pf6AG0gpnNQcZKT0qkVJgS7LSNunhpqTe4nm1Btkda6tAAJVWCLUdB4qG30KKrbyDW5QZx3IF14E1ODq_SNRCt_Gv-tluD7vnnx9Hc9feNN5TAJPvKN4e1a9N-pZ1ZEmHJhfTQYLzm8g9tPK4f1Wd1XmkbOZJaaScGiVp5Iy9o2hjDi2d5pwrhjFh_8Aa5tKhCZBHgYQl4bJVc3dWwVeMqX6ivHLc4fiXwrJEOzTsoeMLoiP3H4AQBiAYBgAeWlNQR%26ai1%3DCLVq3hfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBs-c3t8D__SWiVboh4WeCxACIJ-BiA4oA1Dv4Z3F_f____8BYIEEoAHxj7jZA8gBAeACAKgDAcgDnwSqBLgBT9BPDBz0G426K35TokpPE-lWlxPtqIqienSoavWSb5YNT2Tv2kBkXO0TVeg5nOPMoq8lNda9BnGFzHfvTE8SqMo3DayhJvK0Gdj__-yCnc_z6oc4ndZ4vM0v3exwkSe0i15LLYXE_dt94EkID6y-qNYfqkx8mfjRgXxsJU7IUwUKK23bD9OGaWqx_nJPn-Br5VpfQ6aJ8wvRuI-alF7dFYWj4KrdukrqtDh-IQFakw_NO8ieU_2PcOAEAYgGAYAH9-_HJg%26ai2%3DC3cz2hfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBozQx9ED3Jus3lTo3YXCQhADIJ-BiA4oA1DGk5nJAWCBBKABpIaU-QPIAQHgAgCoAwHIA58EqgS4AU_QTxIW9BqNuit-U6JKTxPpVpcT7aiKonp0qGr1km-WDU9k79pAZFztE1XoOZzjzKKvJTXWvQZxhcx370xPEqjKNw2soSbytBnY___sgp3P8-qHOJ3WeLzNL93scJEntIteSy2FxP3bfeBJCA-svqrWH6E4epv40YF8bCVOyFMFCitt2w_Thmlqsf5yT5_ga-VaX0OmifML0biPmpRe3RWFo-Cq3bpK6rQ4fiEBWpMPzTvInnz1z1_gBAGIBgGAB8T56wY&usg=AFQjCNExTFP6qzLCBu4I5T4ppSpXvIiqLwhttp://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=C3cz2hfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBozQx9ED3Jus3lTo3YXCQhADIJ-BiA4oA1DGk5nJAWCBBKABpIaU-QPIAQHgAgCoAwHIA58EqgS4AU_QTxIW9BqNuit-U6JKTxPpVpcT7aiKonp0qGr1km-WDU9k79pAZFztE1XoOZzjzKKvJTXWvQZxhcx370xPEqjKNw2soSbytBnY___sgp3P8-qHOJ3WeLzNL93scJEntIteSy2FxP3bfeBJCA-svqrWH6E4epv40YF8bCVOyFMFCitt2w_Thmlqsf5yT5_ga-VaX0OmifML0biPmpRe3RWFo-Cq3bpK6rQ4fiEBWpMPzTvInnz1z1_gBAGIBgGAB8T56wY&num=3&cid=5GhOncfO58ToDT-TkiDV_XlF&sig=AOD64_3tvyayyfkIW5XSbsD3eGn4kacKDg&client=ca-pub-4883675891742296&adurl=http://www.bayt.com/en/job-seekers/create-account/%3Fq%3Djobs%2Bin%2Boman&nm=1http://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=CLVq3hfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBs-c3t8D__SWiVboh4WeCxACIJ-BiA4oA1Dv4Z3F_f____8BYIEEoAHxj7jZA8gBAeACAKgDAcgDnwSqBLgBT9BPDBz0G426K35TokpPE-lWlxPtqIqienSoavWSb5YNT2Tv2kBkXO0TVeg5nOPMoq8lNda9BnGFzHfvTE8SqMo3DayhJvK0Gdj__-yCnc_z6oc4ndZ4vM0v3exwkSe0i15LLYXE_dt94EkID6y-qNYfqkx8mfjRgXxsJU7IUwUKK23bD9OGaWqx_nJPn-Br5VpfQ6aJ8wvRuI-alF7dFYWj4KrdukrqtDh-IQFakw_NO8ieU_2PcOAEAYgGAYAH9-_HJg&num=2&cid=5GhOncfO58ToDT-TkiDV_XlF&sig=AOD64_2Mx6cjziHzVg4tgEHHzELDYfu9Qg&client=ca-pub-4883675891742296&adurl=http://om.opensooq.com/registration&nm=1http://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=C1FmphfDGUbrRFci6igewkoDgBuzch-UD_PDUxDLAjbcBEAEgn4GIDigDUN3h4ewCYIEEoAHS66vuA8gBAakCFkMdXrkdUj7gAgCoAwHIA58EqgS5AU_QD1Pf6AG0gpnNQcZKT0qkVJgS7LSNunhpqTe4nm1Btkda6tAAJVWCLUdB4qG30KKrbyDW5QZx3IF14E1ODq_SNRCt_Gv-tluD7vnnx9Hc9feNN5TAJPvKN4e1a9N-pZ1ZEmHJhfTQYLzm8g9tPK4f1Wd1XmkbOZJaaScGiVp5Iy9o2hjDi2d5pwrhjFh_8Aa5tKhCZBHgYQl4bJVc3dWwVeMqX6ivHLc4fiXwrJEOzTsoeMLoiP3H4AQBiAYBgAeWlNQR&num=1&cid=5GhOncfO58ToDT-TkiDV_XlF&sig=AOD64_318mkF5fr9_02VLlCELuTk8Ubikg&client=ca-pub-4883675891742296&adurl=http://cbse.meritnation.com/cbse-signup2%3Fmncid%3DAdwords_Display_Gulf_CBSE&nm=1http://www.lensrentals.com/http://www.canonrumors.com/tech-articles/how-to-test-a-lens/http://twitter.com/search?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.canonrumors.com%2Ftech-articles%2Fhow-to-test-a-lens%2Fhttps://twitter.com/intent/tweet?original_referer=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.canonrumors.com%2Ftech-articles%2Fhow-to-test-a-lens%2F&text=How%20To%20Test%20a%20Lens%20%C2%AB%20Canon%20Rumors&tw_p=tweetbutton&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.canonrumors.com%2Ftech-articles%2Fhow-to-test-a-lens%2Fhttp://www.canonrumors.com/feed/https://plus.google.com/u/2/b/100168399520065139880/http://www.facebook.com/pages/Canon-Rumors/161708613875756http://twitter.com/canonrumorsguyhttp://www.canonrumors.com/accessories/http://www.canonrumors.com/lenses/http://www.canonrumors.com/cameras/http://www.canonrumors.com/tech-articles/http://www.canonrumors.com/photographer-profiles/http://www.canonrumors.com/reviews/http://www.canonrumors.com/advertise/http://www.canonrumors.com/contact-form/http://www.canonrumors.com/forumhttp://www.canonrumors.com/http://www.canonrumors.com/


2/12

Buy Apple iPad 4 Online

www.MarkaVIP.com/iPad

Save 85% on an iPad 4 & iPad Mini. Join

MarkaVIP Online Today!

At the other end of the spectrum is Extreme Tester Guy (and you are a guy, there are no Extreme Tester

females) who will spend 16 hours testing a lens in every way possible including the laser collimator he

keeps in the garage. Hell send back 6 copies to get the perfect lens which he wont take pictures withbecause a new lens has just been released and hes too busy getting a perfect copy of that one. This

article will just bore Extreme Tester Guy, he really wants to be a lens reviewer.

But without taking it to extremes, a little basic testing does several things. It will let us know the lens we

bought is what we expect it to be, that its assembled properly, functions as it should, and provides areasonable match for our camera (if you dont understand what I mean by that last statement, you might

want to read the two This Lens is Soft articles).

Testing will also show us some important characteristics of the lens that werent listed on the B&H blurb orthe manufacturers website. The marketers are quick to tell you it has +Supermicrosecretformula coating_,4 aspherical, and 2 ultra-beyond-low reverse distortion elements. BUT do they ever tell you if it focuses

using internal, rear or front element groups? If it is parfocal (if you zoom in on the subject is the lens still in

focus, or does it need to be refocused)? Is the plane of focus flat or curved? How soft are the corners wideopen and at what aperture to they get sharp? Does it have barrel or pincushion distortion? These are things

a bit of testing will show us about the lens. And they are good things to know that will let us use the lensmore effectively.

The manufacturer goes to great lengths to show the aspherical and low dispersion

elements, but dont show you w hich ones zoom or focus.

Step 1: Examining the Lens

But before we start optical t esting, we need to do some basic hands-on, touchy-feely examining. Some of

this is to make sure the lens is in good shape, some to make sure we know how it is going to work. Morenew lenses fail my touch-and-feel tests than actually fail optical testing.

The Barrel

If the lens is poorly assembled now, its not going to be better after a year of use. The lens barrel is made of

several different cylinders assembled together. Theres usually a joint under the rubber zoom and focusingrings and often another near the end of the lens just under the filter ring. Gently move, rock or extend each

segment of the lens and ask yourself the following questions:

Are any sections loose from the next?

Can you rock the filter ring?Do all the screw holes (including the ones at the lens mount) have screws in them?

If theres an extending internal barrel does it slide back and forth easily when you zoom and focus?

Does the front ring accept a filter easily (more important to check in a used lens, but weve seen afew new ones with defective threads).

While were here, gently shake the lens and make sure theres not a loose screw rattling around
http://www.google.com/url?ct=abg&q=https://www.google.com/adsense/support/bin/request.py%3Fcontact%3Dabg_afc%26url%3Dhttp://www.canonrumors.com/tech-articles/how-to-test-a-lens/%26gl%3DOM%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dca-pub-4883675891742296%26ai0%3DC88UkhvDGUcQKzc6KB6mEgKgOlvejpgPOxq20W8CNtwEQASCfgYgOUL2L6dD7_____wFggQSgAZKyyNkDyAEB4AIAqAMByAOfBKoEuQFP0ILv_jlRGps8erNctcQMIy6QKI8ueyUPTXc-Yq68bnGYd4PfYuIL-WK0dS2ShDoVs85YnI3wA3lT8OnIQravFF6NKnFu3V1jzaOnc-oUN56AiTw2wisNWaPv5neBjzVDaGFXP4G6PxYjUPPPY1u21doPGF5vO9pjL-SDNOdRHrQxR2sxayegza2q8BOP4xwSU968esxxzKl0QNggP-yuj96V-NL6i0YcoZ2KOviTCtbioOeaNl6o0uAEAYgGAYAH1s23Jg&usg=AFQjCNGzct83ue8EPIKifhInWKIS8wmwBghttp://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=C88UkhvDGUcQKzc6KB6mEgKgOlvejpgPOxq20W8CNtwEQASCfgYgOUL2L6dD7_____wFggQSgAZKyyNkDyAEB4AIAqAMByAOfBKoEuQFP0ILv_jlRGps8erNctcQMIy6QKI8ueyUPTXc-Yq68bnGYd4PfYuIL-WK0dS2ShDoVs85YnI3wA3lT8OnIQravFF6NKnFu3V1jzaOnc-oUN56AiTw2wisNWaPv5neBjzVDaGFXP4G6PxYjUPPPY1u21doPGF5vO9pjL-SDNOdRHrQxR2sxayegza2q8BOP4xwSU968esxxzKl0QNggP-yuj96V-NL6i0YcoZ2KOviTCtbioOeaNl6o0uAEAYgGAYAH1s23Jg&num=1&cid=5Ggi8uLG6t8OYVndbqFNmLAu&sig=AOD64_0l8mrwSI1GWn8oypACdNDIhP42mA&client=ca-pub-4883675891742296&adurl=http://markavip.com/customer/account/directcreate/invite_code/AWALL%3F___store%3Denglish%26___from_s&nm=1


3/12

inside. Yes it happens. (If the lens has an image stabilizing/vibration reducing mechanism, this may

rattle a bit when you shake the barrel. Dont freak.)

The Focusing Mechanism

This isnt for accuracy. That comes later. Set the lens on manual focus and run the ring back and forth a

few times (even if youll never use manual focus).

Does it move smoothly with no catches or gritty sensation? This is also the time to note what part

of the lens moves when focusing: front element, rear element, or internal group (neither the front orrear elements move when focusing).

If its a zoom lens, check the focusing at both extremes of the zoom. On the Canon 70-200 f2.8 IS

II lens for example, the rear element doesnt move during focusing when the lens is at 70mm, but

moves a great deal with the lens at 200mm.If the front element moves, does it also rotate (makes it very hard to use polarizing filters) or is it

nonrotating?

Does the distance scale rotate properly when you move the focus ring?

Is there a clutch for manual focus, a switch, or is the manual focus ring always active?

Then switch to autofocus, mount the lens to your camera, and repeat.

Does it autofocus smoothly?

Does the focus motor sound like your other lenses?Finally, autofocus on something close and then immediately on something at infinity. Then reverse

the process. How long did it take?

A slow autofocus system doesnt matter when youre shooting Macros or portraits, but it can makea lens useless for sports or s treet shooting.

(For those of you with too much time on your hands, if you want to quantify focus speed do the near-farautofocus test right next to a microphone plugged into your computer. You can open file in an audio editing

program and see exactly how long the lens motor was buzzing.)

Zoom Mechanism

Of course you want to test to see if the zoom mechanism is smooth, both going out and coming back. Ifthe lens zooms by extending the front element (or extending an internal barrel) make sure there are no

sharp, sudden catches or areas of high resistance. If there is an extending barrel, make sure the internal

barrel is clean with no scratches that might indicate rubbing when zooming. Also check that the barrel isntloose when extended, it shouldnt rock back and forth.

If the front element doesnt extend, look at the rear element during zooming. If the rear element is part of

the zoom mechanism it will move into and out of the barrel during zooming. Why is that important? Rear

element zooms tend to have shorter than advertised focal lengths when focusing on near subjects. It maybe 300mm at infinity, but only 240mm when focused 9 feet away.

Glass and internals

Look at (not through) the front and rear elements for scratches, coating defects, etc. Front element flaws

are of minimal importance, but anything wrong with the rear element (scratch, coating flaw) may have agreat impact. Then look through the lens while moving the focus and zoom rings. A bit of internal dust,

even straight from the factory, isnt unusual and is of no consequence. Things like a loose screw, piece ofcloth, scrap of metal, or a broken internal element (yes, weve seen all of those in brand new lenses)

probably are.

Mounting Ring

Mount and dismount the lens several times on the cameras and ask yourself the following questions:

Does it go on easily but firmly?

When seated is it firm with no looseness?Does the locking pin catch properly and then release easily when you push the cameras dismount

button?

Principles of Optical Testing

There are several principles to testing that are all too often ignored, but each is true (and obvious if youthink about it a bit).

1. If the fixed elements or mount of a lens are out of spec the lens wil l be bad at all parts of its zoomrange and when focusing both near and far distances.

2. With some lens designs an element 1mm too far forward or back will cause the lens to never focussharply.

3. An element tilted as little as 3 degrees from the plane of the lens can cause side-to-side or top-to-

bottom issues sharpness differences.4. An element just a bit off center can cause chromatic aberration, astigmatism, coma and edge

softness.

5. Modern lenses may have 15 or 17 elements, each of which could possibly be out of spec.6. If the zoom elements are out of spec the lens may be excellent in one portion of its zoom range and


4/12

horrid at another focal length. (But every zoom is usually slightly better at one end of its range than

the other. Im not talking about that, Im talking about really bad in one part of the zoom range.)

7. If the focusing elements are out of spec the lens may work fine on close objects but not at infinity, or

vice versa.8. If the autofocus electronics and algorithms arent accurate or camera-lens communication isnt good

the lens may front or back focus.

The primary point of this is that you must test zoom lenses at least at both ends of the zoom range (and

probably in the middle too), and test all lenses focusing on both close and distant targets. And a key pointin testing your lens is comparing each quadrant to the other quadrants, not just is it sharp. In fact, center

sharpness is probably the least important thing to consider when testing a lens.

Step 2: Front- and Back-Focus TestingWe start by testing autofocus accuracy because if the lens is not focusing accurately the other tests aremeaningless. Even a manual focus lens should be tested for focus accuracy on an SLR the viewfinder

and sensor may not be exactly calibrated in the camera, and if the lens has focus confirmation

electronics, that is, in our experience, more likely to be inaccurate than standard autofocus.

Set Up for Depth of Field and Focus Testing

This requires regularly marked surface set up at angles to a focusing object. We use a LensAlign Pro

because its quick and very accurate, but its not necessary. The marked surface can be a ruler or

yardstick set at angles to a focusing target for near testing and a fence (board, chain link, brick, doesntmatter) with some obvious focusing target for the far testing.

A lot of people use computer generated moire targets for autofocus microadjustment, and they are fine for

that, but they dont give all the information we need for lens testing so I dont recommend them for this

purpose.

Focus accuracy

Focus accuracy testing is done with a single focus point selected (center point unless you have some very

odd reason to do otherwise). We begin with the lens at widest aperture and then repeat with the aperture

stopped down a bit.

The process is quite simple: we autofocus the center point at the test target and then check to see wherethe sharpest focus actually is on the ruler or marked diagonal line. They should be very close. There are

several things that need to be taken into consideration:

Every lens can focus differently at near and far distances. Test at several distances.

A zoom lens usually focuses sl ightly differently at the minimum and maximum zoom ranges (andsometimes in between too).

This 24-70 f 2.8 focuses perfectly at 24mm (left) but backfocuses s lightly at 70mm

(right).

Some wide aperture prime lenses exhibit focus shift: they may focus accurately wide open, but

then backfocus or frontfocus slightly as the lens is stopped down.

A w ide aperture lens w ith no focus shift: note that the lens is a bit backfocused w ide open (f1.2) and remains that way as the aperture is decreased.

Autofocus accuracy is an interaction between the camera (every copy of which is slightly different)

and the lens (every copy of which is slightly different). Get over the fact that your camera is perfect

because it is perfect with some other lens. Below are 5 focus checks done with the same Canon 85


5/12

f1.2 on 5 different 5D Mk II bodies, for example (look at the number 4s to see that no two are exactly

the same).

The same 85mm f1.2 lens tested on 5 diff erent copies of the s ame camera body. Notice there are slight differences in front / backfocus w ith each body.

The summary of all this is we first have to check the lens at widest aperture and at least at both ends of

the zoom scale and several different distances from the test target.

If our camera has autofocus microadjustment we then adjust it for the best compromise, getting it perfect

where we want to use the lens. If Im going to use my 24-70 zoom usually near 70mm for portrait shots 15to 20 feet away, Ill zero the adjustment there. If Ill be shooting my 300mm prime lens on distant wildlife, Ill

zero it there.

If the lens is a wide aperture (f1.8 or lower) Ill also do some sequential shots at various apertures to checkfor focus shift. When a lens has focus shift, the point of focus changes slightly as the aperture is s toppeddown from wide open. Eventually the larger depth of field from reducing aperture overcomes the focus shift,

almost always by f2.2 or f2.8. This isnt something I can correct, but its good to know that I can shoot my

Sigma 50mm f1.4 either wide open, or at f2.2 or higher, but in between because it wont focus accurately.

GoAir Special Offer

GoAir.in

Early Birds Discounts. Upto 50% Off on 30 Day

Advance Booking. Book Now

One other thing to check with a wide aperture lens is spherochromatism (also called secondary

longitudinal chromatic aberration or longitudinal color shift). Spherochromatism occurs in many wide

aperture lenses because while the lens is corrected for for chromatic aberration in the in-focus area, theout-of-focus areas in front of and behind the plane of focus cant be corrected and will have magenta or

green tints. Theres nothing to be done about it, but its good to know how severe it is. In problem lensesyou can avoid large white areas if the foreground or background when framing your shot.
http://www.google.com/url?ct=abg&q=https://www.google.com/adsense/support/bin/request.py%3Fcontact%3Dabg_afc%26url%3Dhttp://www.canonrumors.com/tech-articles/how-to-test-a-lens/%26gl%3DOM%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dca-pub-4883675891742296%26ai0%3DCyTQwhvDGUesLqrqKB6npgZAPtpyelAOu7JfBSvaW49u4ARABIJ-BiA5Q2ennLWCBBKAB_MDR8QPIAQGpAhZDHV65HVI-4AIAqAMByAOfBKoEwQFP0ARI47rr7i3jVYRXaLFDzKlS5OazPAxlLeF0_DGZO0GjESfGzKxgTxVp2mpFl96J4d5pEboDGgUx2li478d3ukYywbCKw_cGOxDEq-Mpslbhrgu6eeh8GcZ6I6_FF0_uxeQHrhz1kN0ScvNjIqzWLc9g4Xt-HM3O98ODo_nQ34Hu01qd75r8-Gcvf7gHP6JhJUMQwP6aoiliAhrsZinls4oS31O5qLZhaZyFH6d2EXLxCHet5__63PncHiTKcFH84AQBiAYBgAfsvq4O&usg=AFQjCNEJwcXKsVuhGCtElxvIYAGsuivNHghttp://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=CyTQwhvDGUesLqrqKB6npgZAPtpyelAOu7JfBSvaW49u4ARABIJ-BiA5Q2ennLWCBBKAB_MDR8QPIAQGpAhZDHV65HVI-4AIAqAMByAOfBKoEwQFP0ARI47rr7i3jVYRXaLFDzKlS5OazPAxlLeF0_DGZO0GjESfGzKxgTxVp2mpFl96J4d5pEboDGgUx2li478d3ukYywbCKw_cGOxDEq-Mpslbhrgu6eeh8GcZ6I6_FF0_uxeQHrhz1kN0ScvNjIqzWLc9g4Xt-HM3O98ODo_nQ34Hu01qd75r8-Gcvf7gHP6JhJUMQwP6aoiliAhrsZinls4oS31O5qLZhaZyFH6d2EXLxCHet5__63PncHiTKcFH84AQBiAYBgAfsvq4O&num=1&cid=5GjU5TEOBrUkBegiYhCkvD5w&sig=AOD64_2gz7QC_aar2eNYDuT4iN_u736qvg&client=ca-pub-4883675891742296&adurl=http://goair.in&nm=2


6/12

Example of a w ide aperture lens w ith significant spherochromatism.

Note the purple tinge in the forground and green tinge in the

background.

Example of a wide aperture lens with significant spherochromatism. Note the purple tinge in the forground

and green tinge in the background.

Once we have the lens focusing as accurately as we can, we move on to Flat Field testing. Of course there

is an occasional lens that needs so much autofocus adjustment that you dont have to test further: if you

have to set your camera to +/- 15 or more, it may be better to exchange for another lens. And of course ifyour camera doesnt have microadjustment you have to decide what is, or is not, acceptable.

Flat Field Testing

This is the part of testing that will give you the most information about your lens, so its important to set it

up correctly. The key to flat-field testing is that everything is flat (duh) and lined up accurately. How flat andaccurate depends on depth of field of the lens, which changes with the aperture and the distance from the

target. If youre testing an f/1.4 prime lens at near distance it has to be very accurate. An f/5.6 lens at fardistance, not quite so much.

Flat Field Set Up

A fairly large building (windows are great for detail) makes a superb far-distance target. You can assumethe building side is perfectly vertical so using a bubble level to set the camera on tripod to vertical is verystraightforward.

Any wall can be used for near-distance testing. I recommend downloading and printing some USAF 1951test charts (they can be found online, including here ) You want one in the center of your image and at

least one in each corner. A few pieces of cut up newspaper will work too.

If you want to be more complex, I recommend the simple Resolving Power chart from Edmund Optics that

you can buy for less than $20. It may not be worthwhile to test one lens a year, but is certainly not a badinvestment for a camera club. There are lots of other test targets available online and most do the job just

fine.

Edmund Optics Resolving Power Test Chart

Setting up the Near Distance Flat Field


7/12

Camera centered on tripod for testing

1. Assuming your wall is vertical and straight make sure your test targets are placed smoothly andtightly on the wall. If theyre lumpy and bumpy, they arent accurate.

2. Place your camera on tripod so the center of the lens is level with the center of the test target. A laser

pointer held along the lens barrel can be used for targeting and to confirm centering. A bubble level(built into the tripod or a more accurate hardware level) confirms the lens is lined up vertically.

3. Make sure the camera is not pointed at an angle right or left: this could make one side of the targetout of focus compared to the other. The simplest and fairly accurate way is to measure an appropriate

distance from the wall (say 15 feet, but whatever is appropriate for the lens focal length) from either

side of the test target. Then draw a chalk line between those two points. That line should be parallelto the wall. You can line up the camera with that line using a yardstick and drop string if you want to

be a bit obsessive.

4. But lets be honest: most ofus are going to line up thelens so its centered on the

tripod, use the bubble level

on our tripod and eyeballjudge the rest of it. And that

will work just fine 95% ofthe time. If your results look

bad, then you can always

go back and measurecarefully to make sure its

the lens with the problem,not your setup.

Flat Field Optical Testing

Most people want to jump in andsee how much resolution the

lens provides at its center point, but unless the lens is horribly soft that isnt going to tell us much.Photographing a centered resolution chart gives you almost no information about the lens.

Center resolution is pretty good and fairly comparable on most lenses. A more expensive lensusually gets you more aperture or better resolution away from center.

A wide angle lens wont resolve as well as a standard or telephoto.

A wide aperture prime doesnt necessarily resolve better than a good zoom, although most do, atleast when you close the aperture a stop or so.

By f5.6 most lenses resolve well, by f8 some actually are losing resolution to diffraction(depends onyour camera) and by f11 most are losing resolution.

But I realize everyone wants to know how well their new lens resolves. The AF1951 target you can

find online and print for free, or whatever you are shooting, should give you a decent idea of how wellthe lens resolves.

AF1951 Test Chart

If you want more detail, Norman Koren has posted some downloadable test charts along with detailed

instructions for using them. Or you can buy detailed (and pricey) multiple test charts like the Edmund

58940.
http://www.normankoren.com/Tutorials/MTF5.html


8/12

Edmund Optics 58940 Test Chart

The only real necessity is to have an idea what you expect from the other lenses you shoot and compareyour new lens to them. Be reasonable, though: if you think your new f1.4 prime is going to be as sharp at

f1.4 as your old lens is at f5.6 you may be rudely surprised. And that new f2.8 zoom may not be anysharper in the center than your old variable aperture zoom, but it will probably toast the old one on the

edges and corners. If all you are interested in is how sharp the center of the lens is then just buy Macro

lenses and dont worry about it anymore.

The bottom line, though, is checking center sharpness doesnt help too much with testing a lens. Whatreally helps is comparing the quadrants of the image to each other. If they elements are all aligned and

centered properly the different quadrants should be similar. If the corners are soft wide open, they should

all be equally soft and begin softening a similar distance from center in every direction. Similarly anychromatic aberration should be equal on all sides, not worse on one than the other (assuming your target

is equally lighted).

If you look at the 4 corner targets from the lens test below, its obvious that the right hand targets are softer

than the left. If you look more carefully youll see that the right upper is even softer than the right lower andhas a bit more chromatic aberration. This is the kind of thing that will show up if the lens has an element

out of center or at a slight angle. The center sharpness on the lens, though, was excellent.

The four corner quadrants of a misassembled lens. Note how much sof ter the

upper right quadrant is than the lower left.

When you see an image like this you want to make sure the effect isnt caused by the camera not beingsquare to the test target, which could cause some of this effect (probably not the CA). You might try

shooting the camera in portrait mode: if its alignment the quadrant in the lower left will now be in the lowerright and less sharp, the upper right quadrant will now be in the upper left and more sharp. If the imagelooks the same in both portrait and landscape mode, its probably the lens.

Once weve determined that all 4 quadrants look equivalent on our fist test shots its time to run the lens

through a battery of fairly quick tests:

Near distance widest aperture. Zooms should be checked at their widest, middle, and longest focal

length.If your zoom is variable aperture, be sure to mark down at what distance the aperture changes. You

know your f4-5.6 zoom is f4 at the wide end and f5.6 at the long end, but do you know when it

changes? Its good to know that shooting at 160mm instead of 170mm will give you f4.At each location the lens should be checked with aperture wide open, and stopped down in

incremental (1/2 or 1 stop) steps to f8. You can assume the lens has reached maximal sharpness byf8. Some may sharpen further in the corners at f11, but theyll usually s tart sacrificing center

sharpness there.


9/12

The same tests should be repeated at far distance.Testing distances will vary depending on the lens, but I find it logical to test at the distances Im

likely to shoot at. I dont shoot the 16-35 f2.8 at 4 feet away so near testing may be 10 or 12 feet for

it.Unless youre going to really shoot at the minimum focusing distance, dont test there. The lens will

usually be sharper a few feet away.

Vignetting

Is really part of flat field testing but can be more obvious when the target is a smooth, evenly lit lightcolored wall. It doesnt require critical line up like the other parts of flat field testing, and you simply take

exposures at various parts of the zoom range and several apertures. Any vignetting should be even in allfour quadrants, of course. It is often more severe at one end of the zoom range than the other, and usually

less severe when as you decrease the aperture.

Distortion Testing

You can buy accurate optical distortion targets, but theyre pretty expensive ($200-$300) and for all but

quantitative work there are plenty of square things you can take pictures of to detect distortion. Squarelylaid brick walls work (although most arent as square as youd like), big windows or doors, basically

anything that gives you parallel vertical and horizontal lines. You want it to be at your level, though: angling

the shot up or down (or side-to-side) will cause its own distortion. You need the camera lined up near thecenter of the object youre using to check distortion.

Barrel distortion is most common at the wide end of zooms and pincushion at the long end. More complex

moustache distortion may be less evident, and is less common.

The common types of distortion (above) and an example of barr el distortion

(below )

More Advanced Testing

Flare Testing

Flare testing simply requires some bright sunlight. You dont shoot directly into the sun, but have it shining

at an angle from one corner of the field of view. Examine the image for ghosts and flare, and to see howbadly contrast is reduced. There are no standards here, but its good to know how the lens performs with

the sun in the field.

Star Test

This one requires no more than a tripod and a clear night sky. Basically you simply take a long exposure

of the sky in an area with fairly uniform stars. A few seconds exposure should give you fairly pinpoint stars

and several minutes to an hour will give you star trails. Observing these you can see very quickly if the lensexhibits coma or severe astigmatism, which will show as blurry stars or star t rails that fatten in the

corners. With such a long exposure camera sensors and noise will play a part but you can get somesimple information you might not otherwise.

Image Stabilization

This is difficult to standardize for a lens reviewer, but its a good thing to test with your own hands and

shooting style. Simply shoot a test target using different shutter speeds (making sure some of the speeds

should be sharp and some blurry when handheld) with the stabilization system on and off. See how manystops YOU get with your hands. Remember IS does not work equally well on every shot so repeat several

shots at each range and speed with the IS on.


10/12

Dont try to hold the lens to a made-up standard like if its 4 stops of stabilization I should be able to handhold a 1/20 second exposure. Just see if it helps and how much. Every person gets slightly different

results from the same IS system. The important thing is to see how much YOU get.

What Did We Learn Today?

When buying a new or used lens, its worth an hour of time to make sure its a good copy and to find out alittle about how it works.

My absolute requirements for an acceptable lens are:

1. Construct ion and function pass look and feel test ing.2. Front / backfocus can be corrected with microadjustment of 2/3 of the cameras range or less (leaving

a bit of margin of error for future adjustment).3. Front / backfocus is s imilar throughout zoom range and at near and far focusing. How similar is a

judgement call, but if it changes less than +/- 3 for a 4x zoom and +/- 5 for a 10x zoom throughout

the zoom range, then Im pretty happy.4. All 4 quadrants of the lens are equally sharp, vignette equally, and have similar chromatic aberration

at maximum and minimum zoom, near and far focus.

5. The lens doesnt have severe loss of sharpness at one end of the zoom range or one end of thefocusing range (20% decrease in resolution isnt too unusual from the sharpest to softest part of a

zoom, but 50% certainly suggests something is wrong.)

Most other things are going to be characteristics of the lens, not evidence of a good or bad copy. When

you go examine your testing pictures on a monitor (no you cant use the cameras LCD) make yourselfsome notes on that lens. My notes for a made-up zoom might look like this:

1. Maximally sharp at f/5.6 in center at wide end, f8 at long end

2. Corners maximally sharp at f8 throughout the zoom range3. Wide open sharpness falls off at 1/2 of the distance to the corner in most of the range, but 1/3 atextreme telephoto end.

4. Zoom is sharpest at wide end, begins to loose sharpness at the last 1/4 of its range.

5. There is barrel distortion wide open, gone by 24mm. Slight pincushion at maximum zoom.6. The lens vignettes mildly wide open at the wide end of the zoom range, but not the long end. It

disappears at f5.6.

7. Image stabilization lets me handhold at 2 times the shutter speed expected from 1/focal length Xcrop.

The notes are specific for each lens. A wide aperture prime lens may have notes about whenspherocromatism disappears. Wi th a Macro lens, writing down at what aperture diffraction s tarts to cause

softening may be the most important note I make, since Im often shooting at high apertures to increasedepth of field. If you only have a couple of lenses, youll probably throw the notes away after a few sessions

with the lens, but if you shoot with a lot of different lenses like I do, its nice to have that note card to refer

back to on a shoot.

Good photographers take advantages of these lens characteristics or learn work around them. They alsoare the fuel that feeds so many online arguments about lenses. For example, I love wide aperture primes

and expect to see spherochromatism or soft corners wide open. I use them for center compositions and

have learned to compose my shots to large light colored areas out of the foreground and background. Butabout once a week I get my feelings hurt when a renter tells me my recommendation of that lens stinks

because the foreground looks magenta and the corners are soft.

Oh, and one last note. Youll notice that nowhere in my testing do I say how to calculate is my copy

sharp. Its a meaningless calculation unless you have dozens of copies of the same lens like we do andare using some standard measurement of sharpness. I know, for example that on our test charts, at our

standard distance of shooting, on the 5D II bodies we test with, that the 70-200 f2.8 IS II Canon lens shouldresolve about 20 lines/mm. The 16-35 f2.8 will resolve about 16 and the 300 f2.8 about 22 or 24. But these

numbers are meaningless to your testing unless you had exactly t he same set up as we do.

I also know that one copy of a lens may resolve slightly differently on one camera than another. My onlypoint in all this is instead of worrying about sharpest poss ible just make certain its sharp enough. Andyou do that by examining your prints, not 100% magnification on your monitor. No one ever won a photo

contest or award for owning the sharpest possible lens.

The copy is sharp if it resolves the detail you want to see in the prints you make. After youve tested the

lens and know that its not defective and what its characteristics are, go take some pictures. That will tellyou if the lens is sharp enough for you.


11/12

THEME AND WEB DEVELOPMENT BYTHEME AND WEB DEVELOPMENT BY WEPTILEWEPTILE | MANAGED XENSERVER WEB HOSTING BY| MANAGED XENSERVER WEB HOSTING BY HOST DUPLEXHOST DUPLEX..

COPYRIGHT 2013 CANON RUMORS.| CANON RUMORS IS NOT AFFILIATED WITHCOPYRIGHT 2013 CANON RUMORS.| CANON RUMORS IS NOT AFFILIATED WITH CANON INC.CANON INC. OR ANY OF ITS SUBSIDIARIESOR ANY OF ITS SUBSIDIARIESGRAB OUR RSS FEEDGRAB OUR RSS FEED FOLLOW US ON TWITTEFOLLOW US ON TWITTE

PAGES:PAGES:

HOMEHOME ADVERTISEADVERTISE CONTACTCONTACT

BROWSE CATEGORIES:BROWSE CATEGORIES:

ARTICLE POSTARTICLE POST CANON RUMORS SITE INFORMATIONCANON RUMORS SITE INFORMATION PHOTOGRAPHER PROFILESPHOTOGRAPHER PROFILES WEEKLY ROUNDUPWEEKLY ROUNDUP
http://www.canonrumors.com/category/weekly-roundup/http://www.canonrumors.com/category/photographer-profiles/http://www.canonrumors.com/category/canon-rumors-site-information/http://www.canonrumors.com/category/article-post/http://www.canonrumors.com/contact-form/http://www.canonrumors.com/advertise/http://www.canonrumors.com/http://twitter.com/canonrumorsguyhttp://www.canonrumors.com/feed/http://www.canonrumors.com/tech-articles/how-to-test-a-lens/www.canon.comhttp://www.hostduplex.com/http://weptile.com/


12/12

how to test a lens « canon rumors.pdf

Documents