how to help pupils to build up scientific problems in

17
HAL Id: hal-02555541 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02555541 Submitted on 27 Apr 2020 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. How to help pupils to build up scientific problems in biology lessons Patricia Schneeberger, Yann Lhoste, Brigitte Peterfalvi To cite this version: Patricia Schneeberger, Yann Lhoste, Brigitte Peterfalvi. How to help pupils to build up scientific problems in biology lessons. European Science Education Research Association. In C. Bruguière, A. Tiberghien & P. Clément (éd.). EBOOK PROCEEDINGS OF THE ESERA 2011 CONFERENCE: Science learning and Citizenship, 3, pp.170-178, 2012, 978-9963-700-44-8. hal-02555541

Upload: others

Post on 28-Nov-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

HAL Id: hal-02555541https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02555541

Submitted on 27 Apr 2020

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

How to help pupils to build up scientific problems inbiology lessons

Patricia Schneeberger, Yann Lhoste, Brigitte Peterfalvi

To cite this version:Patricia Schneeberger, Yann Lhoste, Brigitte Peterfalvi. How to help pupils to build up scientificproblems in biology lessons. European Science Education Research Association. In C. Bruguière, A.Tiberghien & P. Clément (éd.). EBOOK PROCEEDINGS OF THE ESERA 2011 CONFERENCE:Science learning and Citizenship, 3, pp.170-178, 2012, 978-9963-700-44-8. �hal-02555541�

EBOOK PROCEEDINGS OF

THE ESERA 2011 CONFERENCE: Science learning and Citizenship

General Editors: Catherine  Bruguière,  Andrée  Tiberghien,  Pierre  Clément

Co-editors:  Virginie  Albe,  Silvia  Caravita,  Graça  Carvalho,  Costas  Constantinou, Digna Couso, Jens Dolin, Reiners Duit, Bob Evans, Jane Johnston, Jari Lavonen, Conxita Marquez, Patricia Marzin, Laurence Maurines, Marisa Michelini, Robin Millar, Kai Niebert, Miriam Ossevoort, Roser  Pinto,  Dimitris  Psillos,  Miia  Rannikmâe,  Andreas  Redfors,  Helene  Sorensen, Rosa Maria Sperandeo, Jouni Viiri, Manuela Welzel-Breuer, Abert Zeyer

ISBN: 978-9963-700-44-8

EA  4148,  Université  Lyon  1  - ENSL,  Université  de  Lyon

This ebook contains fourteen parts according to the strands of the ESERA 2011 conference. Each part is co-edited by one or two persons, most of them were strand chairs. All papers in this ebook correspond to accepted communications during the ESERA conference that were reviewed by two referees. Moreover the co- editors carried out a global reviewing of the papers.

ESERA or the editors and co-editors do not necessarily endorse or share the ideas and views presented or implied included in this book. Moreover, the respect of the guidelines concerning the layout of each chapter is under the responsibility of the authors.

The goal of this electronic book is to publish an improved version of the proposal taking into account the discussion during the presentation.

The three formats of presentations during the conference are published in this ebook. The length for the single oral presentation and posters is between 4 and 7 pages. For the symposium there are two possibilities: The whole symposium is presented as a single paper of 15 pages or each contribution can be considered as a single oral presentation (4-7 pages).

This e-book should be referenced as follows:

Bruguière,   C.,   Tiberghien,   A.,   &   Clément,   P.   (Eds.). (2012). E-Book Proceedings of the ESERA 2011 Conference: Science learning and Citizenship. Lyon, France: European Science Education Research Association. ISBN:  978-9963-700-44-8  

Individual articles in the e-book should be referenced as follows:

[Author(s)]. (2012). [Title of article], In   C.   Bruguière,   A.   Tiberghien   &   P.   Clément (Eds.), E-Book Proceedings of the ESERA 2011 Conference: Science learning and Citizenship. Part [strand number] (co-ed. Editors of the strand chapter), (pp.[page numbers]) Lyon, France: European Science Education Research Association. ISBN:  978-9963-700-44-8  

TABLE  OF  CONTENTS  OF  THE  EBOOK

Part 1: Learning science - conceptual understanding Co-editors: Roser Pinto and Kai Niebert

Part 2: Learning science - cognitive, affective, and social factors Co-editors: Silvia Caravita and Albert Zeyer

Part 3: Teaching and learning science

Co-editors: Marisa Michelini and Reiners Duit

Part 4: ICT and other resources for teaching/learning science Co-editors: Patricia Marzin and Jari Lavonen

Part 5: Nature of science, History, Philosophy, Sociology of Science Co-editors: Laurence Maurines and Andreas Redfors

Part 6: Discourse and argumentation in science education Co-editors: Manuela Welzel-Breuer and Conxita Marquez

Part 7: Scientific literacy and socio scientific issues Co-editors: Virginie Albe and Bob Evans

Part 8: Environmental, health and Informal-Outdoor Science education Co-editors: Miriam Ossevoort and Graça Carvalho

Part 9: Science curriculum, educational policy Co-editors: Jens Dolin and Miia Rannikmâe

Part 10: Evaluation and assessment of student learning Editor: Robin Millar

Part 11: Cultural, Social and Gender Issues Editor: Helene Sorensen

Part 12: Pre-service science teacher education Co-editors: Dimitris Psillos and Rosa Maria Sperandeo

Part 13: In-service science teacher education Co-editors: Jouni Viiri and Digna Couso

Part 14: Early years science education Co-editors: Costas Constantinou and Jane Johnston

PART 3: TEACHING AND LEARNING SCIENCE Co-editors: Marisa Michelini and Reiners Duit

Relations between teaching practices and student cognitive and affective development, planning teaching/learning intervention. Research based intervention and its role for curricula planning, instructional paths and learning outcomes, monitoring learning and its role in teaching practices, laboratory-based practice.

This part corresponds to strand 3. It contains 39 papers.

TABLE OF CONTENTS OF PART 3 TEACHING AND LEARNING SCIENCE

Investigating classroom activities: what kind of information do we get – and what do we miss ? 1 Claudia Von Aufschnaiter

Learning about greenhouse effect: framing thermal phenomena and optics in a challenging context 7 Ugo Besson, Anna De Ambrosis, Pasquale Onorato

Which standards should textbooks meet to support competence oriented teaching ? 14 Katrin Bölsterli, Markus Rehm, Markus Wilhelm

Study of the approach of electrical concepts in teaching physics at college (proposals for the syrian educational system compared with the french system) 19 Chaza Cheikh

Multi-theoretic approaches to understanding the science classroom 26 David Clarke, Li Hua Xu, Jenny Arnold, Lay Hoon Seah, Christina Hart, Russell Tytler, Vaughan Prain

The impact of physical explanations   on   secondary   students’   knowledge   acquisition   in  thermodynamics 41 Antony Crossley, Erich Starauschek

A sustainable teacher training: approaching more science content and inquiry 49 Margareta Enghag, Birgitta Norberg Brorsson

Watching the sky -new realizations, new meanings, and surprizing aspects in university level astronomy 57 U. Eriksson, C. Linder, J. Airey

The effects of aim-gapped experimentation on concept learning and gaining scientific process skills 64 İlknur  Güven,  Ayla  Gürdal

The influence of content and language integrated learning on content performance in magnetism 72 Claudia Haagen, Martin Hopf

Graphs in upper secondary school chemistry education 77 Marja Happonen, Maija Aksela

The effect of brain based learning on academic success, attitude and retrieval of information in science and technology classes 82 Nuray  İnci,  Hilmi  Erten

Teachers’   conceptions:   interaction   between   self-epistemology / didactical skills / professional identity.  “mixtures  and  solutions”  course  design  – analysis  of  french  school  teachers’  practices  in the last elementary grades 90 Frédéric  Kapala

Promoting student-active and inquiry-based science learning by the project salis 97 Marika Kapanadze, Ingo Eilks, Simon Janashia, Malkhaz Makashvili, Marc Stuckey, Silvija Markic

Toward a theoretical explanation of the interplay between the collective and the individual dynamics in physics learning 102 Olivia Levrini, Paola Fantini, Marta Gagliardi, Giulia Tasquier, Barbara Pecori

Teaching and learning sequences for the study of electric energy at primary school 109 Dulce María López-valentín, María Teresa Guerra-ramos, Carmen Mayela Rojo-camarillo

Lesson plans for student language  heterogeneity  for  the  topic  “matter  and  its  properties” 115 Silvija Markic

The development and validation of a tool for measuring topic specific pck in chemical equilibrium 122 M.e. Mavhunga, M. Rollnick

Education to scientific images through chat-supported collaboration to design functional brain images 129 Réjane  Monod-ansaldi,  Grégoire  Molinatti,  Eric  Sanchez

Pedagogical link making: a methodology of analysis of teaching and learning scientific conceptual knowledge 136 Eduardo F. Mortimer, Phil Scott

An intervention for using multiple representations of mechanics in upper secondary school courses 140 Pasi Nieminen, Antti Savinainen, Niina Nurkka, Jouni Viiri

Genetic engineering education and citizenship in tunisia 148 Wided Oueslati, Laurence Simonneaux, Atf Azzouna

Using communication patterns for analysing classroom activities in chemistry 153 Tobias Pollender, Oliver Tepner

Acting with pendulum – the process matters where the object also should 159 Oleg Popov, Thongloon Vilaythong

Comments on the results of a teaching intervention on evolution. Which pupils benefited ? 163 Lucia Prinou, Lia Halkia, Constantine Skordoulis

How to help pupils to build up scientific problems in biology lessons 170 Patricia Schneeberger, Yann Lhoste, Brigitte Peterfalvi

Greek teachers' attitudes, beliefs, knowledge and context, concerning evolution teaching 179 Panagiotis Stasinakis, Kyriacos Athanasiou

Designing virtual experiments in electric circuits by high school students 186 Athanasios Taramopoulos, Euripides Hatzikraniotis, Dimitrios Psillos

How secondary school students design, perform and explain experiments on the rate of reaction 191 Montserrat Tortosa Moreno

Types of intra- and intermolecular bonding: the case of general chemistry textbooks 196 Georgios Tsaparlis , Eleni T. Pappa

Learning science through engaging with its epistemic representational practices 203 Russell Tytler, Peter Hubber, Annie Maj Johansson, Per-olof Wickman, Vaughan Prain, Jim Carolan, Bruce Waldrip, Richard Duschl

Mathematics in physics: analysis of students' difficulties 218 Olaf Uhden, Gesche Pospiech

Pupils’  views  about  experiments  in  science 223 Stefan Uhlmann, Burkhard Priemer

Students ideas about diagrams of a flower and a plant cell 228 Unsal Umdu Topsakal, John Oversby

Using kitchen stories as starting point for chemical instruction in high school 232 Jenni Vartiainen, Maija Aksela, Anu Hopia

The use of thought experiments in teaching physics. the case of the principle of equivalence 239 Athanasios Velentzas, Krystallia Halkia

The effect of lesson duration (45 vs. 60 minutes) on quality of physics instruction 244 Rainer Wackermann, Burkhard Priemer

Researching experimental phases in chemistry education using video analysis 248 Maik Walpuski, Alexandra Schulz

Learning physics in daily life contexts: a concept for effective learning and teaching 252 Bianca Watzka, Raimund Girwidz

��$�"��������#���!�"���#����#��!����"����

� �����!����������% ��!!��!

��)'��������#����'��'�����##���$()�� �#���'���))����)�'��!+���,?:G��@C562FI��#���*��������������������@C562FI���C2?46

,?:G�%2?E6D���)�%����� �������������%2?E6D���C2?46

�()'��) &FC� C6D62C49�2:>D�2E�9:89=:89E:?8� E96�4@?5:E:@?D� E92E�2==@H� E96�AFA:=D� E@�3F:=5�FAD4:6?E:7:4� AC@3=6>D� 5FC:?8� D6DD:@?D� :?4=F5:?8� >@>6?ED� @7 5632E6� :?� 3:@=@8J� =6DD@?D� &FC

AC@;64E� :D� :?�=:?6�H:E9�E96�C6D62C496D�4@?5F4E65�:?�3:@=@8J�5:524E:4D�@?�E96�C@=6�@7� =:?8F:DE:4

:?E6C24E:@?D� :?� D4:6?E:7:4� =62C?:?8� !?� E9:D� DEF5J�� H6� ECJ� E@� 4=62C� FA� E96� DEC2E68:6D� FD65� 3J

E62496CD� E@� 492?86� AFA:=DY� F?56CDE2?5:?8� @7� 3:@=@8:42=� A96?@>6?2� 2?5� 6?4@FC286� E96:C

:?G@=G6>6?E :?�E96�3F:=5:?8�FA�@7�2�D4:6?E:7:4�AC@3=6>�&FC�C6D62C49�52E2�H6C6�4@==64E65�:?�2

�E98C256�4=2DD�2?5�:?�2���

E98C256�4=2DD�+9C@F89�6I2>A=6D�@3D6CG65�:?�E96D6�4=2DD6D��H6�92G6

6I2>:?65� E96� H2J� E62496CD� >2?286� 2� 5:D4FDD:@?� 23@FE� AFA:=DY� 5:776C6?E� 2EE6>AED� 2E

6IA=2?2E:@?D�2?5�9@H�E96J�=625�E96>�E@�492?86�E96:C�A@:?ED�@7�G:6H�!?�E9:D�4@?EC:3FE:@?��EH@

3:@=@8:42=� E@A:4D� 2C6� 4@?46C?65�� E96� C64J4=:?8�@7� E96@C82?:4�>2EE6C� :?�64@DJDE6>D� ��E98C256

4=2DD���E96 DFAA=J @7�5:@IJ86?�:?�E96�3@5J����E98C256�4=2DD�

��.,$'�( =:?8F:DE:4�:?E6C24E:@?D��AC@3=6>�3F:=5:?8��6?F?4:2E:G6�A@DEFC6��AC@76DD:@?2=�86DEFC6�:?5F46C @7 AC@3=6>2E:K2E:@?

����" ��#�"���

&FC�C6D62C49�2:>D�2E�9:89=:89E:?8�E96�4@?5:E:@?D� E92E�2==@H�E96�AFA:=D� E@�3F:=5�FA�3:@=@8:42=

AC@3=6>D�5FC:?8�D6DD:@?D�:?4=F5:?8�>@>6?ED�@7�5632E6�:?�E96�4=2DDC@@>

.6� ECJ� E@� 4=62C� FA� E96� DEC2E68:6D� FD65� 3J� E62496CD� E@� 492?86� AFA:=DY� F?56CDE2?5:?8� @7� 2

3:@=@8:42=� A96?@>6?@?� 2?5� 6?4@FC286� E96:C� :?G@=G6>6?E� :?� E96� 3F:=5:?8� FA� @7� 2� D4:6?E:7:4

AC@3=6>

!?� @FC� 2?2=JD:D� @7� E96� E62496CYD� 24E:G:EJ��H6� 92G6� E6DE65� �23C6YD� 2?5�$FDBF6CYD� 9JA@E96D:D

� ���2�� ���3��� 6DA64:2==J� E96:C� :562� @7� Z�#�*��'� $�� %'$�!�"�)�/�)�$#[� !? DA:E6 @7 E96 H:56G2C:6EJ� @7 :?5F46CD @7 AC@3=6>2E:K2E:@? :>A=6>6?E65 3J E96 E62496CD� H6� 7@F?5 D:>:=2C:E:6D

36EH66? E96�EH@�2?2=JD65 D6BF6?46D !?�E9:D�A2A6C��H6 DEF5J�D@>6�@7�E9@D6�D:>:=2C:E:6D�+9:D

DEF5J�2==@HD 2�36EE6C F?56CDE2?5:?8�@7 E96 AC@46DD�@7�AC@3=6>2E:K2E:@?

�� �"������������# ��!�

!?��C6?49�D64@?52CJ�D49@@=��D4:6?46�E62496CD�2C6�6?4@FC2865��3J C64@>>6?52E:@?D�7C@>�E96:C

9:6C2C49J� E@�@C82?:K6�E96:C E6249:?8�2C@F?5�2�D4:6?E:7:4�AC@3=6>�3FE�>@DE�@7E6?�E96J�AC6D6?E

E96�AC@3=6>�E@�E96�4=2DD�2?5�E96�AFA:=D�92G6�E@�ECJ�E@�D@=G6�:E !?�E9:D�42D6��E96�BF6DE:@?�@7�E96

4@?DECF4E:@?�@7�E96�AC@3=6>�:D�2G@:565�2?5�:ED�C@=6�:D�@7E6?�F?56C6DE:>2E65

� DA64:7:4:EJ @7�@FC�2AAC@249�:D�C6=2E65�E@�E96�2CE:4F=2E:@?�36EH66?�E96�E96@C6E:42=�7C2>6H@C<

@7�AC@3=6>�3F:=5:?8 � 6=23@C2E65�3J��23C6�2?5�&C2?86����������)�%�=23@C2E@CJ��F?:G6CD:EJ�@7

%2?E6D � 2?5�2�D@4:@�9:DE@C:42=�2AAC@249�@7�=62C?:?8��H9:49�4@?D:56CD�E92E�D49@@=�>FDE�2==@H

AFA:=D�E@�C63F:=5�<?@H=6586�2G2:=23=6�:?�4F=EFC6�2?5�E96�H2JD�@7�E9:?<:?8��DA62<:?8�2?5�24E:?8

2DD@4:2E65� H:E9� E9:D� <?@H=6586� �#���*� =23@C2E@CJ�� ,?:G6CD:EJ� @7� �@C562FI�� '@?46� �

*49?6636C86C�� �� ���#9@DE6�� �����)63:QC6��*49?6636C86C���"2F36CE�� �����*49?6636C86C��

Teaching and learning science

Page 170

-RC:?�� �����$@C6�AC64:D6=J��H6�2DD:8?�2�564:D:G6�C@=6�E@�E96�AFA:=DY�AC@3=6>�3F:=5:?8�:?�E96

4@?DECF4E:@?�@7�3:@=@8:42=�<?@H=6586

+96� E62496CYD� C@=6� :D� 4@>A=6I� 3642FD6� 96� @C� D96� >FDE� 6?4@FC286� AFA:=D E@� >@G6� 7C@>� 2

A@D:E:@?� C@@E65� :? 6G6CJ52J� =:76� E@� 2� D4:6?E:7:4� 2AAC@249��E� E96� D2>6� E:>6 96� @C� D96 >FDE

6?DFC6�2�ADJ49@=@8:42=�4@?E:?F:EJ�2?5�96�@C�D96�>FDE�2=D@�:>AF=D6�2?�6A:DE6>@=@8:42=�CFAEFC6

36EH66?� E96� 7:CDE� BF6DE:@?D� 2?5� E96� 3:@=@8:42=� AC@3=6> $2?J� DEF5:6D� 4@?5F4E65� 3J

C6D62C496CD� :?� 3:@=@8J� 5:524E:4D� ECJ� E@� F?56CDE2?5� 9@H� E96� E62496C�>2?286D� E@� :?EC@5F46� 2

D4:6?E:7:4�AC@3=6>�E@�E96�4=2DD 2?5�E@�H92E�6IE6?E�:E�:D�A@DD:3=6 E@�2DD@4:2E6�E96�AFA:=D�:?�E96

AC@46DD�@7�AC@3=6>�3F:=5:?8�:?�3:@=@8J

.:E9�C676C6?46�E@�2�C2E:@?2=:DE�2AAC@249��H6�2C8F6�E92E�E96�>2:?�8@2=�@7�D4:6?46�E6249:?8�:D�E@

6?23=6�AFA:=D�E@�232?5@? 4@>>@?�D6?D6�C62D@?:?8�2?5�E@�56G6=@A�2�D4:6?E:7:4�2AAC@249�@7�E96

F?56CDE2?5:?8�@7�3:@=@8:42=�A96?@>6?2�*F49�2?�:>AC@G6>6?E�:D�A@DD:3=6�@?=J�:7�E62496CD�D6E

FA�256BF2E6�E6249:?8�D:EF2E:@?D��H9:49�:>A=:6D�@36J:?8�DA64:7:4�4@?5:E:@?D H9:49 492C24E6C:K6

E96� D4:6?E:7:4� 24E:G:EJ� .6� AC@A@D6� E@� :?G6DE:82E6� E96D6� 4@?5:E:@?D�� A2CE:4F=2C=J� E9@D6� E92E

AC@>@E6�E96�AFA:=DY :?G@=G6>6?E :?�2�D4:6?E:7:4�AC@3=6>�3F:=5:?8

���"��� �"���� ����� �#��

�FC:?8� @FC� C6D62C49�� H6� FD65� E96� 4@?46AE� @7� Z:?5F46C� @7� AC@3=6>2E:D2E:@?[�� 56G6=@A65� 3J

�23C6� 2?5�$FDBF6C� � ���2�� ���3� +96D6� 2FE9@CD� 2DDF>6� E92E�G2C:@FD�<:?5D�@7� Z:?5F46CD[

42?� 24E� E@� DE:>F=2E6 DA64:7:42==J� 5:776C6?E� 4@8?:E:G6� @A6C2E:@?D� :?G@=G65� :? 2� AC@46DD� @7

AC@3=6>2E:K2E:@?

�:8FC6���:D�2�>@56=�@7�E96�AC@46DD�@7�AC@3=6>2E:D2E:@?�244@C5:?8�E@��23C6�� �����4@>A=6E65

H:E9�:?5F46C�@7�AC@3=6>2E:D2E:@?���23C6���$FDBF6C�� ���2�� ���3�

-2C:@FD� <:?5D� @7� Z:?5F46CD[� 42?� 24E� E@� DE:>F=2E6� DA64:7:42==J� 5:776C6?E� 4@8?:E:G6� @A6C2E:@?D

:?G@=G65�:?�2�AC@46DD�@7�AC@3=6>2E:D2E:@?

$24C@:?5F46CD� 2C6� 5:C64E=J� 4@??64E65� E@� E96� D:EF2E:@?D� 2?5� E@� E96� E2D<D� AC@A@D65� 3J� E96

E6249:?8�56G:46D �

� ���:?5F46C���=625D�E@�3F:=5:?8�A@E6?E:2=�D@=FE:@?D

� ���:?5F46C���=625D�E@�4@?D:56C�D@=FE:@?D��H96E96C�A@DD:3=6�@C�?@E��:?�2�4C:E:42=�H2J��3J

C64@?D:56C:?8�E96�AC@3=6>

&E96C�:?5F46CD��=6DD�@3G:@FD��2C6�=:?<65�E@�E96�E62496CYD�@C2=�:?E6CG6?E:@?D�5FC:?8�E96�5632E6 �

� :?5F46CD�96=A:?8�E@�A@D6�E96�AC@3=6>� H:E9�>@C6�@C�=6DD�DA64:7:42E:@?�@7�E96�4@?5:E:@?D

�EJA6�2��@C�E96�52E2��EJA6�3�

� :?5F46CD� 2:>:?8� 2E E96� 6IAC6DD:@?� @7� 9JA@E96D6D� @C� 4C:E:42=� 2?2=JD6D� @7� D@=FE:@?D

244@C5:?8�E@�E96�4@?5:E:@?D��EJA6�5��@C�E96�52E2��EJA6�6�

� :?5F46CD�2:>:?8�2E�4@??64E:?8�E96�4@?5:E:@?D�2?5�E96�52E2�@7�E96�AC@3=6>

Teaching and learning science

Page 171

�.,96*� � �3)*0� 3+� > .2)9(*6� 3+� 463'0*1&8.7&8.32 ?� �&((36).2,� 83� �&'6*� ���9759*6�

���&�����'�

�����"������"���!

,D:?8�6I2>A=6D�@3D6CG65�:?�4=2DD6D�@7�5:776C6?E� =6G6=D�@?�G2C:@FD�3:@=@8:42=� E@A:4D�H6�92G6

6I2>:?65�E96�H2J�E62496CD�>2?286�5632E6�7C@>�5:776C6?E�AFA:=DY�2EE6>AED�2E�6IA=2?2E:@?�2?5

9@H�E96J�=625�E96>�E@�492?86�E96:C�A@:?ED�@7�G:6H��*49?6636C86C�6E�2=�� �����*49?6636C86C��

#9@DE6�� ���� $@C6� AC64:D6=J��H6� DEF5J� 9@H� E96� E62496C� 24ED� :?� @C56C� E@�>2<6� E96� AFA:=D

4@?D:56C� E96� AC@3=6>� 2D� E96:C� @H?� �@C� E9:D� AFCA@D6��H6� 6I2>:?6� 9@H� E96� AC@3=6>�� 2D� E96

E62496C� 7@C>F=2E65� :E� :?� 9:D� @C� 96C� AC6A2C2E:@?� A2A6CD�� :D� :?EC@5F465� E@� E96� 4=2DD�� 9@H� E96

5:D4FDD:@?�367@C6�2?5�27E6C�:ED�7@C>F=2E:@?�4@?EC:3FE6D�E@�>2<6�AFA:=D�F?56CDE2?5�:ED�>62?:?8

2D�2�C62=�AC@3=6>�.6�D62C49�H92E�4@?5:E:@?D�E96�AFA:=D�92G6�E@�3F:=5�FA�367@C6�F?56CDE2?5:?8

E96�>62?:?8�@7�E96�BF6DE:@?�2?5�9@H�E96�E62496C�24ED�E@�>2<6�:E�67764E:G6

&FC�C6D62C49�52E2�H6C6�4@==64E65�:?�2�4=2DD�@7����� �J62C�@=5�AFA:=D���E98C256��2?5�:?�2�4=2DD

@7� ������J62C�@=5� AFA:=D� ���E98C256�� H9@D6� E62496CD� 2C6� 2DD@4:2E65� H:E9� E96� C6D62C496D

4@?5F4E65�3J�@FC�E62>D�+96�52E2�4@==64E:@?�E@@<�A=246�5FC:?8�D6DD:@?D�:?4=F5:?8�>@>6?ED�@7

D4:6?E:7:4�5632E6 :?�4=2DD

+96�4@CAFD�:?4=F56D�G2C:@FD�52E2

� E96�E62496CDY�AC6A2C2E@CJ�H@C<�

� E96�EC2?D4C:AED�@7�E96�G:56@�C64@C5:?8D�@7�E96�D6DD:@?�

� E96�EC2?D4C:AED�@7�E96�E62496CDY�:?E6CG:6HD��D6=7�2?2=JD:D�

� E96�AFA:=DY�HC:EE6?�E2D<D

+H@�E@A:4D�H6C6�DEF5:65�5FC:?8�E96�D6DD:@?D

� +96 �E98C256 AFA:=D ����� � J62CD� @=5� DEF5J E96� C64J4=:?8� @7� @C82?:4� >2EE6C� :?

64@DJDE6>D�+9:D�=6DD@?�2:>D�2E�6IA=2:?:?8�E96�@C:8:?�@7�>:?6C2=�D2=ED�:?�E96�D@:=�:?�@C56C

E@� 6?23=6� E96� AFA:=D� E@� 4@??64E� E96� AC6D6?46� @7� >:?6C2=� >2EE6C� :?� E96� D@:=� H:E9� E96

564@>A@D:E:@? @7�@C82?:4�>2EE6C�E92?<D�E@�E96�24E:@?�@7�E96�564@>A@D6CD

� +96� ��E98C256� AFA:=D� ������� J62CD� @=5� DEF5J� E96� DFAA=J @7� 5:@IJ86?� :?� E96� 3@5J

5FC:?8�A9JD:42=�677@CE�+9:D�=6DD@?�6?E:E=65�Z+96�7F?4E:@?:?8�@7�E96�9F>2?�3@5J[�2:>D�2E

:?:E:2E:?8�E96�AFA:=D�E@�E96�4@?46AE�@7�:?E68C2E:@?�@7�E96�7F?4E:@?D�@7�E96�9F>2?�3@5J��2D

E96 @77:4:2=� �C6?49� 65F42E:@?� 4FCC:4F=F> DA64:7:6D�� ZE96� 4@?E6?ED� @7� E9:D� 492AE6C

4@?DE:EFE6�2�7:CDE�2AAC@249�@7�E96�4@?46AE�@7�C68F=2E:@?[

Teaching and learning science

Page 172

�����<86&(87�+631�8-*��6*2(-�(966.(9091

"&'0*���"-*�(328*28�3+�8-*��6*2(-�(966.(9091

�8-�,6&)* �8-�,6&)*

@�6.,.2�3+�8-*�1&88*6�3+�0.:.2,

'*.2,7A������

+9:D�=6DD@?�2:>D�2E�:?EC@5F4:?8

E96�AFA:=D�E@�E96�C64J4=:?8�@7�E96

@C82?:4�>2EE6C�:?�64@DJDE6>D� D@

2D�E@�E2<6�:E�:?E@�244@F?E�H:E9�E96

@3;64E:G6�@7�DFDE2:?23=6

56G6=@A>6?E

@"-*�+92(8.32.2,�3+�8-*�-91&2�'3)=A�����

+9:D�=6DD@?�2:>D�2E�:?EC@5F4:?8�E96�AFA:=D�E@�E96 �������

������������� @7�E96�7F?4E:@?D�@7�E96�9F>2?�3@5J�+96

4@?E6?ED�@7�E9:D�492AE6C�4@?DE:EFE6�2�7:CDE�2AAC@249�@7�E96

4@?46AE�@7 ���������������������

������$(�#�)$%����(�)���()*�.�$��)���+�'��)�$#(�$��)����'��$+�(�*!�'�%�'�"�)�'(��#�)����*"�#��$�.��*'�#�%�.(���!��-�')�$#�

&FC� DEF5J� :D� 2� BF2=:E2E:G6� DEF5J +96� EC2?D4C:AED� @7� E96� EH@� D6BF6?46D� H6C6� 2?2=JD65� 3J

7@4FD:?8�@? H92E 4@F=5�492C24E6C:K6 AC@3=6>�7@C>F=2E:@?�:?�3:@=@8J�E6249:?8

"&'0*���"-*�8;3�789).*)�(0&77*7

�E98C256�4=2DD ��

E98C256�4=2DD

���� �J62CD�@=5�����DEF56?ED

����"�$� !��+�(���)��'�$#�)���($�!��+�'.�.��'��*)���)�'�����.��'(�,���$#7)�,�! �$# ���" $�!��+�(�<40&.2�;-&8�-&44*27�83�8-*�)*&)�0*&:*7�

������J62CD�@=5�����DEF56?ED

�*'�#�� �� %�.(���!� ���$')� "$'� $-.��# �(%'$+����� )$� )��� "*(�!�(� ,��'��()�� $-.��# '�)�� �#��')�'��!��!$$� '�"��#( )��(�"���<40&.2�-3; 8-*�197(0*7 &6*�79440.*) ;.8-

).3<=,*2�;-*2�8-*�(3279148.32�.2(6*&7*7�

&FC�2?2=JD6D�>2:?=J�7@4FD�@?�@?6�=6DD@?�:?�6249�4=2DD

�����*8-3)303,=

&FC�>6E9@5@=@8J�:?4=F56D�EH@�DE6AD �

��� Z>:4C@D4@A:4[ 2?2=JD:D�@7�6G6CJ�D4C:AE �

� !56?E:7:42E:@?�@7�>@>6?ED�4@?D:56C65�2D�:>A@CE2?E�H:E9�C682C5 E@�2?�6A:DE6>@=@8:42=

A@:?E�@7�G:6H

� �@5:?8�@7�AC6G:@FD�:?E6CG6?E:@?D�H:E9�2?�:56?E:7:42E:@?�@7�E96�5:776C6?E�:?5F46CD

��� 4@>A2C:D@?� 36EH66?� 5:776C6?E� D6BF6?46D� 23@FE� 5:776C6?E� E@A:4D� @3D6CG65� :?� 4=2DD6D� @7

5:776C6?E�=6G6=D

Teaching and learning science

Page 173

�� �!#�"!

�����(31132 (-&6&(8*6.78.(

+96�2?2=JD:D @7�E96�EC2?D4C:AED�@7�E96�EH@�D6BF6?46D�92D�2==@H65�FD E@ :56?E:7J 4@>>@?�A@:?ED

H9:49 4@F=5�492C24E6C:K6 AC@3=6>�7@C>F=2E:@?�:?�3:@=@8J�E6249:?8

+96�2?2=JD:D @7�E96�EC2?D4C:AED�@7�E96�EH@�D6BF6?46D�92D�2==@H65�FD E@ :56?E:7J 4@>>@?�A@:?ED

H9:49 4@F=5�492C24E6C:K6 AC@3=6>�7@C>F=2E:@?�:?�3:@=@8J�E6249:?8�!?5665��:?�3@E9 42D6D� E96

7@C>F=2E:@?�@7�E96 A2C25@I �H96C6�E96�AC@3=6>�:D� 5@6D�?@E�2AA62C�:>>65:2E6=J� 4@?EC2CJ�E@

H92E :D :>A=:65 :? E96 6I2>A=6D�@7 AC@3=6>�D:EF2E:@?D 8:G6? 3J� D@>6�2FE9@CD� ��6�-6449:�

!?DE625��:E�C6BF:C6D�E96 4@?DECF4E:@? @7 :562D H:E9@FE H9:49�E96�AC@3=6> 5@6D ?@E >2<6�D6?D6

7@C�AFA:=D

����� ���

!? E96�D6BF6?46 @7 E96�D:IE9�8C256�4=2DD��C64J4=:?8�@7�@C82?:4�>2EE6C�:?�64@DJDE6>D�� :?�@C56C

E@�7@C>F=2E6 E96 A2C25@I�2D�DF49 � �4>�@7�=62G6D�72==�5@H?�6G6CJ�J62C��3FE�27E6C�����J62CD�H6

5@?YE�H2=<� @?� �>�@7� � =62G6D�� E96� AFA:=D�>FDE 92G6� D@>6� :562 @7 E96 4@?D6CG2E:@?� @7 E96

BF2?E:EJ @7�>2EE6C

�8-�,6&)*

�7E6C�����J62CD�@7�56A@D:ED�@7� ��4>�@7�=62G6D�2�J62C� E96�E9:4<?6DD�@7�E96�8C@F?5�92D�?@E

:?4C62D65�H9:=6�:E�D9@F=5�36� ��>�E9:4<6C

�@?5:E:@?�E@�C2:D6�E96�AC@3=6>�� E96�:562�@7�4@?D6CG2E:@?�:D�2446AE65�3J�E96�AFA:=D

�67@C6� 7@C>F=2E:?8� E96� AC@3=6>� E@� 562=� H:E9�� 2?5� ;FDE� 27E6C� 92G:?8� 5@?6� :E� E96� E62496C

��@C:??6�� 5@6D� ?@E� AC@>AE� AFA:=D� E@� 6?F?4:2E6� E9:D� 4@?5:E:@?� @7� E96� 4@?D6CG2E:@?� @7� E96

BF2?E:EJ�@7�>2EE6C�DEC2:89E�2H2J��3FE�D96�=625D�E96>�E@�C62D@?�:?�2�H2J�E92E�:?4=F56D�E9:D�:562

+9:D�H2J��E96�AFA:=D�2C6�6?23=65�E@�F?56CDE2?5�E96�A2C25@I�2D�DF49�������� .96?�E96�DA64:7:4

AC@3=6>�:D�7@C>F=2E65��E96�C62D@?:?8�E96�E62496C�2:>D�2E�6?4@FC28:?8�:>A=:6D�E92E�E96�:562�@7

4@?D6CG2E:@?�:D�2446AE65�3J�E96�AFA:=D

�����+62496C� /6D��3FE�@?46�E96J�C6�@?�E96�8C@F?5�:E�D�?@�=@?86C�=:G:?8�>2EE6C��2==�E92E�42?�364@>6

5625� @C82?:4� >2EE6C� :?� E96� 6?5� � E96� BF6DE:@?� :D� H92E� H92E� 364@>6D� @7� E92E� 5625

@C82?:4�>2EE6C�@?46�:E�D�E96C6��AFE�E96�L 5625�$& N�=236=�@?�E96�A@DE6C�

�����'FA:=� !E�5642JD

�]�

� ����+62496C� /6D��H6�D9@F=5�H2=<�@? 5625�=62G6D� �>�566A

������'FA:=� �9�

������+62496C� �625�=62G6D� �>�9:89�� E92E�D�?62C=J�2D�9:89�2D�E92E�3F:=5:?8��D@�H96?�J@F�8@�7@C�2

H2=<�:?�E96�7@C6DE�5@�J@F�C62==J�H2=<�@?�5625�=62G6D� �>�566A��

������'FA:=� .6==�?@��IIII� :E�D�EC2?D7@C>65�IIII

�]�

�����'FA:=� �2AE:DE6 D2JD�:E�D�3642FD6�@7�2?:>2=D��2?:>2=D�>2<6�:E�86E�D>2==6C

�]�

�����'FA:=� *@��2AE:DE6�J@F�D2:5�2�H9:=6�28@ H92E�2?:>2=D�5@

�����'FA:=� +96J�62E�E96>

�]�

Teaching and learning science

Page 174

�����'FA:=� �FE�E96J�==�5642J�2?JH2J IIII

�]�

�����+62496C� .92E�D@CE�@7�62CE9�5@6D�:E�364@>6

�����'FA:=� $2J36�D@>6�D@CE�@7�2�76CE:=:K6C

�]�

�����+62496C� *E@A� DE@A� DE@A� !�==�HC:E6� E92EE@�96=A�A=2?ED� 8C@H� � :7� J@FC� 76CE:=:K6C� 96=AD�A=2?ED� E@

8C@H��H92E�5@6D�:E�>62?����.92E�>2<6D�A=2?ED�8C@H����/@F�<?@H�E92E

�����'FA:=� !E��D�>:?6C2=�>2EE6C

�� ��+62496C� 6C6�H6�2C6 ��2AE:DE6 D2JD�:E�D�>:?6C2=�>2EE6C 8@@5��3FE�H92E�2C6�5625�=62G6D��

�]�

�����'FA:=� .6==��H96?�E96J�5642J��E96J�364@>6��E96J�364@>6��2D�!�D2:5�367@C6��E96J�364@>6

2?@E96C��2?@E96C�>2EE6C �2?5�E92E�>:ID�H:E9�E96�2:C

�����+62496C� .6==���HR?2T= D2JD�H96?�E96J�5642J��E96J�364@>6�2?@E96C�>2EE6C 2==�C:89E��D@�:E��D

?@E�E96�D2>6��:D�:E��:E�EFC?D�:?E@�2?@E96C��2�2?@E96C�>2EE6C��3642FD6� F8@�D2:5�2�H9:=6

28@��96�D2:5�:E�D42EE6CD� �HR?2T= D2JD�:E�86ED�G6CJ�D>2==��3FE�5@6D�:E�5:D2AA62C�

�� ��'FA:=� .6==��?@

!E�H2D�@?=J�=2E6C��H96?�D96�2D<65�E96�AFA:=D�E@�=@@<�7@C�D@=FE:@?D��E92E�E96�E62496C�2EE6>AE65�E@

>2<6�E96 AFA:=D�4=2C:7J E96�:562�@7�E96�4@?D6CG2E:@?�@7�E96�BF2?E:EJ�@7�>2EE6C������

+9FD� E96� E62496C�96=AD� E96�AFA:=D� E@�E9:?< :?�2�H2J� E92E� :>A=:6D� E9:D� :562�+96?� E96�A2C25@I

364@>6D�2�A2C25@I�7@C�E96> �FCE96C>@C6�E96�E62496C�D�:?E6CG6?E:@?D�2:>65�2E�<6JH@C5D�DF49

2D� �@C82?:4��� �>:?6C2=��� �5625� >2EE6C�� :?� @C56C E@� :?:E:2E6� E96� :562� @7� C64J4=:?8 .92E� :D

3C@F89E�FA� :D�?@E�5:C64E=J� E96� :562�@7� E96�4@?D6CG2E:@?�@7�BF2?E:EJ�@7�>2EE6C��3FE�2?� :562�@7

Z364@>:?8� FD67F=[�� H9:49� 2?E:4:A2E6D� E96� 6IA64E65� D@=FE:@?� +96� 42E68@CJ� Z0@C82?:41� 5625

>2EE6C[�� 3C@F89E� 3J� E96� E62496C� =65� E@� E96� ?@E:@?� @7� 2� 4@?E:?FF>� 36EH66?� @C82?:4� 2?5

:?@C82?:4� >2EE6C� :?� E96� 7@C6D925@H:?8� @7� E96� 4J4=6� D96� H2?E65� E96� AFA:=D� E@� 3F:=5

'2C25@I:42==J�� H6� 42?� D66� E92E� H96?� E96� AFA:=D� EC:65� E@� 7@C>F=2E6� E96� A2C25@I� FD:?8� 2?

6I2>A=6� 4=@D6� E@� 6G6CJ52J� =:76�� E96:C� @C2=� :?E6CG6?E:@?D� :?G@=G65� 2?� 23DEC24E� >@56=� @7� E96

EC2?D76C�@7�>2EE6C�36EH66?�A=2?ED��2?:>2=D��D@:=��FD:?8�D4:6?E:7:4�E6C>D��>:?6C2=�>2EE6C��@C82?:4

>2EE6C���2�>@56=�E92E�E96J�925�366?�E2F89E�367@C6�+9FD��E96�?@E:@?�@7�5:D4@?E:?F:EJ�H9:49�:D

E96�4@C6�@7� E96�D4:6?E:7:4�AC@3=6>�3642>6�2�46?EC2=� :562�:?�E96�5:D4FDD:@?�+96�A2C25@I�H2D

?@E� 7@C>F=2E65� H:E9� D4:6?E:7:4� H@C5D� �5625� =62G6D�� 6E4� ��� 3FE� H:E9� 2C8F>6?ED� :?G@=G:?8

BF2?E:7:42E:@?�� 2?5� E96� AFA:=D� 2EE6>AE65� E@� >2E49� E96� EH@� =2?8F286D� �5625� =62G6D�� 5625

@C82?:4�>2EE6C�

������ ���

!?�E96�42D6�@7�E96�@E96C�D6BF6?46����E98C256���:?�@C56C�E@�6IA=2:?�E96�A2C25@I��"$'����$-.��#

�(� %'$+����� )$� )��� "*(�!�(� ,��'��(� )��� ��$-.��#� '�)�� �#� �')�'��!� �!$$�� '�"��#(� )��� (�"��*'�#����%�.(���!����$')�� D@>6�4@?5:E:@?D 2C6�2=D@�C6BF:C65�:?�@C56C�E@�36�23=6�E@�7@C>F=2E6E96�AC@3=6> +96�E62496C�>2?2865�E@�7@C>F=2E6�E96�D4:6?E:7:4�AC@3=6>��E96�A2C25@I�567:?65�:?

D64E:@?� ��� H96?� E96� AFA:=D� D66>65� E@� C64@8?:K6� :E� 2D� DF49�� 3642FD6� 5:776C6?E� 4@?5:E:@?D

4@?46C?:?8�E96�2AAC@2496D�@7�E96�C6=2E:@?D9:AD�36EH66?�52E2��:?4=F5:?8�@A6C2E:?8 4@?5:E:@?D�

H6C6�:56?E:7:65�3J�E96>�!?�E96�AC@A@D65�D:EF2E:@?��AC@465FC2=�@A6C2E:@?D�2C6�C6BF:C65�3642FD6

E96� C6=6G2?E� 52E2� E@� E2<6� :?E@� 244@F?E� :?� E96� 3:@=@8:42=� AC@3=6>� DEF5:65� �5:@IJ86?

4@?DF>AE:@?� 5:@IJ86?�DFAA=J��2C6�?@E�5:C64E�52E2��:?�@C56C�E@�>62DFC6�E96>��@?6�>FDE�92G6

E96�4@?46?EC2E:@?D�@7�5:@IJ86?�2?5�FD6 2�>F=E:A=:42E:G6�724E@C��5:@IJ86? 4@?DF>AE:@?����C2E6

@7�5:@IJ86? :?�2CE6C:2=�3=@@5 X C2E6�@7�5:@IJ86? :?�G6?@FD�3=@@5��I�3=@@5�7=@H

Teaching and learning science

Page 175

�8-�,6&)*

"$'����$-.��#��(�%'$+�����)$�)���"*(�!�(�,��'��(�)�����$-.��#�'�)���#��')�'��!��!$$��'�"��#()���(�"���*'�#����%�.(���!����$')

�@?5:E:@?���5:776C6?E�4@?5:E:@?D�4@?46C?:?8�E96�2AAC@2496D�@7�E96�C6=2E:@?D9:AD�36EH66?�52E2

�5:@IJ86?�DFAA=J��5:@IJ86?�4@?DF>AE:@?�

�.,96*���"-*�6*0&8.327-.47�'*8;**2 ).3<=,*2�(3279148.32�&2)�).3<=,*2�79440= .2�8-*

'3)=

*@��=62C?:?8�5@6D�?@E�4@?D:DE�:?�2�D:>A=6�H2J��7C@>�E96�AFA:=DY�6IA6C:6?46�E@�>@C6��D4:6?E:7:4�

7@C>F=2E:@?D�!?DE625��E@�>2<6�E96�AC@3=6>�>62?:?87F=�7@C�AFA:=D��=:?<D�2C6�C6BF:C65�36EH66?

6IA6C:6?46D�2?5�>@56=D��H:E9�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�3F:=5:?8�2�D4:6?E:7:4�A@:?E�@7�G:6H

����&(63 &2) 1.(63�.2)9(*67

!? E96�D:IE9�8C256�D6BF6?46��H6 4@F=5 D2J E92E��2E�2�>24C@�=6G6=� 2== E96 E62496CYD�:?E6CG6?E:@?D

C6AC6D6?E 2 >24C@�:?5F46C�@7 A@D:E:@? @7�E96�AC@3=6>�H9:49�@44FCD�H96?�D96�DA62<D @7 5625

=62G6D :? 7@C6DED +92E� :D� H92E� D96� HC@E6� :?� 96C� AC6A2C2E:@?� A2A6C�� 367@C6� E96� =6DD@? �FE

367@C6�5@:?8�D@� :? 6249 :?E6CG6?E:@? �>:4C@�:?5F46CD���D96 EC:65�E@�>2<6�DFC6�E92E�E96 AFA:=D

3F:=5�FA E96 4@?5:E:@?D D@ E92E�E96�AC@3=6>�3642>6�2�AC@3=6>�7@C�E96>

!? E96�E6?E9�8C256�D6BF6?46��E96�AFA:=D�>FDE�4@?D:56C�EH@�4FCG6D�2E�E96�D2>6�E:>6��D9@H:?8

E96>�E96�5:776C6?46�36EH66?�E96�C2E6�@7�5:@IJ86? :?�2CE6C:2=�3=@@5�2?5�E96�C2E6�@7�5:@IJ86? :?

G6?@FD� 3=@@5� 3FE� E96J� 5@� ?@E� 5@� :E� DA@?E2?6@FD=J�,DF2==J�� E96J� 7:CDE� 7@4FD65� @?� 2� D:?8=6

4FCG6 +96�>:4C@� :?5F46CD� @7� E96� E62496C� E9:D� E:>6� 2:>D� 2E� =625:?8� E96� AFA:=D� E@� E2<6� :?E@

244@F?E�E96�EH@�4FCG6D��2?5�2E�7@4FD:?8�@?�E96:C�5:DE2?46

�92,7�97(0*7

5:@IJ86?

4@?DF>AE:@?5:@IJ86?

DFAA=J

�*&68�!$$���!$,

C2E6�@7�5:@IJ86? :?�2CE6C:2=�3=@@5(3278&28 � ���>##�

C2E6�@7�5:@IJ86? :?�G6?@FD�3=@@5

4:C4F=2E:@? @7

3=@@5

Teaching and learning science

Page 176

�.,96*��� �63)9(8.32�3+�32* 8-*�,6394�3+�789)*287

'FA:=� !�5@?�E�F?56CDE2?5�9@H�E96C6�42?�36�>@C6�5:@IJ86?�2E�E96�6?5 E92?�2E�E96�368:??:?8

+62496C� .92E� >2EE6CD� :D� ?@E� 6249� D6A2C2E6� 4FCG6�� 3FE� 3@E9� 4@?D:56C65� 2E� E96� D2>6� E:>6�

E@86E96C� :E�D� E96� 82A�D�� � 5:776C6?46�D�� 36EH66?� E96>

+96�D2>6�3=@@5�C2?�E9C@F89�E96�>FD4=6D

*@�E96C6�D66>D�E@�36 2�=:?<�36EH66?�>24C@�:?5F46CD�@7 E96�7@C>F=2E:@?�@7� E96 AC@3=6> H:E9

>:4C@�:?5F46CD� :?G@=G65� :?� E96 3F:=5:?8� FA @7� E96� 4@?5:E:@?D H9:49�>2<6� E9:D� 7@C>F=2E:@?

A@DD:3=6 +96D6�4@?5:E:@?D >2J 2=D@�36�4@?5:E:@?D @7�D@=FE:@?D�@7�E96�AC@3=6>

!?� 3@E9� 42D6D�� E96� 7@C>F=2E:@?� @7� E96� A2C25@I� :D� A@DD:3=6� E92?<D� E@� 2?� 2CE:4F=2E:@?� 36EH66?

>24C@:?5F46CD�2?5�>:4C@:?5F46CD��

� $24C@:?5F4E6FCD��� �:?�4@??64E:@?�H:E9� E96�86?6C2=�@C82?:K2E:@?�@7� E96� D6BF6?46�� :?

E9:D�42D6�2�4C:E:4:D>�@7�AFA:=DY�2?DH6CD

� $:4C@:?5F46CD��2��3���:?�4@??64E:@?�H:E9�=:?8F:DE:4�:?E6C24E:@?D�

��������#!���������������"���!

!?� E9:D� DEF5J�� E96�>6E9@5@=@8J� 32D65� @?� E96� 4@>A2C:D@?� 36EH66?� EH@� D6BF6?46D� FD:?8� E96

>@56=�@7�:?5F46CD @7�AC@3=6>�3F:=5:?8�=625D�FD�E@�7:?5�D:>:=2C:E:6D�2?5�5:776C6?46D

+96� 7@C>F=2E:@?� @7� E96� AC@3=6>� :D� A@DD:3=6� @?=J� :7� D@>6� ?646DD2CJ� 4@?5:E:@?D� 92G6� 366?

4@?DECF4E65� 367@C692?5� *@�� ?@E� @?=J� E96� AC@3=6>YD� D@=FE:@?� 92D� E@� 36� 3F:=E�� 3FE� 2=D@� :ED

7@C>F=2E:@? &FC�Z>:4C@D4@A:4[�2?2=JD:D�D9@HD�2?�2CE:4F=2E:@?�36EH66?�E96D6�4@?5:E:@?D�2?5

E96�:56?E:7:42E:@?�@7�52E2�E@�2==@H�E96�AFA:=D� E@�3F:=5�FA�E96�AC@3=6>��E96@C6E:42=�52E2�:?�E96

�E9�8C256��6>A:C:42=�52E2�:?�E96���E9�8C256�

.6�3C:?8�E@�=:89E�D@>6�5:776C6?46D

!?� E96� �E98C256�� E96� AFA:=DY� A9C2D:?8� :D� ?@E� :?� 244@C52?46� H:E9� D4:6?E:7:4� 5:D4FCD:G6

4@>>F?:EJ�� E96J� FD6 D4:6?E:7:4� E6C>D� 2?5� 6G6CJ52J� E6C>D� H:E9@FE� >2<:?8� 2?J� 5:776C6?46

36EH66?�E96>

!?�E96 ��E98C256��AFA:=DY�A9C2D:?8�:D�:?�244@C52?46�H:E9�D4:6?E:7:4�5:D4FCD:G6�4@>>F?:EJ��3FE

E96J�92G6�E@�:>AC@G6�E96:C�4@?46AEF2=�2AAC696?D:@?�@7�6IA6C:>6?E2=�52E2

�IA6C:6?465�E62496CD�<?@H�E92E�2?5�5@�?@E�DE2CE�H:E9�8:G:?8�E96�AC@3=6>�E@�36�D@=G65�DEC2:89E

2H2J��3FE�7:CDE�FD6�>24C@�:?5F46C�@7�AC@3=6>�7@C>F=2E:@?�2CE:4F=2E65�H:E9�>:4C@�:?5F46CD�D@

2D�E@�>2<6�E96�AC@3=6>�2AAC@AC:2E23=6�3J�AFA:=D .96?�EC2:?:?8�E62496CD� :E�4@F=5�36�FD67F=�E@

6IA=2:?�E96D6�2CE:4F=2E:@?D

&FC�C6D62C49�92D�:>A=:42E:@?�:?�EH@�5:776C6?E�7:6=5D�

�@?46?EC2E:@? 6? & 6?

>#=:EC6 56 D2?8

+6>AD 6? >?

C2E6�@7�5:@IJ86? :?�2CE6C:2=�3=@@5

C2E6�@7�5:@IJ86? :?�G6?@FD�3=@@5

Teaching and learning science

Page 177

�@?46C?:?8� C6D62C49� 7:6=5�� @FC� C6DF=ED� =625� E@ 2� 4C:E:4:D>� @7� E96@C:42=� >@56=D� @7� AC@3=6>

3F:=5:?8�2?5�:?5F46CD�@7�AC@3=6>2E:D2E:@?

�@?46C?:?8� E62496CDY� EC2:?:?8�� @FC� C6DF=ED� =625� E@� :56?E:7J� 5:524E:42=� D<:==D� E62496CD� >FDE

56G6=@A�:?�@C56C�E@�96=A�AFA:=D�E@�3F:=5�FA�D4:6?E:7:4�AC@3=6>D

�(/23;0*),*1*287

.6Y5 =:<6� E@� E92?< "62?�#@F:D� -6C?�� E62496C @7� �?8=:D9� 7@C� 9:D� 96=A7F==� EC2?D=2E:@?� @7� E96

�C6?49�G6CD:@?

��� ����!

�23C6��$���&C2?86���� ��������@?DECF4E:@?� 56D� AC@3=Q>6D� 6E� 7C2?49:DD6>6?E� 5Y@3DE24=6D

()�'������AA������

�23C6��$�� �����(FY6DE�46�BF6�AC@3=R>2E:D6C ��#6D�86?QD6D�5YF?�A2C25:8>6 �����'���(��#6�*��)�$#�����AA� ��

�23C6��$���$FDBF6C����� ������@>>6?E�2:56C�=YR=QG6�O�AC@3=R>2E:D6C ��#6D�:?5F4E6FCD�56

AC@3=R>2E:D2E:@? ��(�����#��(����!72�*��)�$#�%$*'�!70'���$*+�!!���� � ���AA������ �

�23C6��$���$FDBF6C����� �����-6CD�F?�CRA6CE@:C6�5Y:?5F4E6FCD�56�AC@3=R>2E:D2E:@?

�?2=JD6�5YF?6�32?BF6�56�D:EF2E:@?D�AC@3=Q>6D �%�'�!� ��?M�����A��������:DA@?:3=6�DFC!?E6C?6E � 9EEA�DA:C2=6�65F�C6GF67CDA:AA9A�2CE:4=6�� �4@?DF=ER�=6���D6AE6>3C6� ����

#9@DE6��/�� ���� �'$�!6"�)�(�)�$#����)�+�)6(�!�#����5'�(��)��%%'�#)�((������#(�!�(�(���#��(��� !�� +��� +9QD6� 56� 5@4E@C2E� 6?� D4:6?46D� 56� =YR5F42E:@?� ?@?� AF3=:R6�� F?:G6CD:ER� 56� %2?E6D�%2?E6D

'@?46�����*49?6636C86C� '� � �� �� !?E6C24E:@?� 2>@?8� 49:=5C6?� :?� D49@=2DE:4� 4@?E6IED� 2?5

<?@H=6586�:?�3:@=@8J *'$%��#��$*'#�!�$���(.��$!$�.�$�� �*��)�$#���

)63:QC6�� $�� *49?6636C86C�� '� �� "2F36CE�� $� � ����� !?� �� �FEJ� �� �� '=2?E:?� �5:C�

'�*"�#)�'��#��!�((�����(���#��(���*��6��)�4�!7�%%'�#)�((����#J@?��!%)'��A� ���� �

*49?6636C86C��'��)@3:DD@?��'��#:86C�$2CE:?��"����2C=6J����� ������@?5F:C6�F?�5R32E�A@FC

72:C6�4@?DECF:C6�56D�4@??2:DD2?46D ()�'������A������

*49?6636C86C��'���-RC:?����� ���� �6+�!$%%�'���(�%'�)�&*�(��76�'�)��)��7$'�!��#�(���#��(#J@?��!%)'

*49?6636C86C�� '� �� #9@DE6�� /� � ����� #6� CV=6� 56� =Y6?D6:8?2?E� 52?D� =YRG@=FE:@?� 5F

BF6DE:@??6>6?E�56D�R=QG6D�6?�4=2DD6�56 (���#��(����!��+����)����!����''� �*-+��!? �23C6�$��:2D�56��2CG2=9@�����#9@DE6�/��R5� -%6'��#����)�%'$�!6"�)�(�)�$#��#�6�*��)�$#��(%��)(%��!$($%��&*�(��($��$!$��&*�(��)������)�&*�(�'@CE@����5 �7C@?E2>6?E@��A����� ��

Teaching and learning science

Page 178