how to ensure independent judiciary in pakistan
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
1/10
How to ensure
Independence of
Judiciary in PakistanPresented to: Sir Ahmad Raza Khan
Presented by Hassan Nasir -------738 B.A.
(Hons.) GCU Lahore.
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
2/10
Table of Contents:
I. IntroductionII. Meanings of Independence of Judiciary
III. The rationale behind independence of judiciaryIV. Pakistans Judiciary and its establishmentV. Judicial independence under the Pakistan Constitution
VI. Safeguards stemming from independence of judiciaryVII. Judicial activism and Ways to ensure independence of Judiciary in
Pakistan
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
3/10
I. Introduction:There are certain basic institutions within every state which need to function properly and
independently in order to ensure the stability of the state. One of the most important of such
institutions is an independent Judicial System.
In my opinion, the independence of judiciary poses the notion that the judicature organ of a
state is free to adjudicate upon the matters placed before it and to deliver its judgments and
decisions without fear and bias and be in accordance with the law of the land and dictates of
the constitution.
The commonly floated phrase independence of judiciary itself is such a point on which I would
like to duel or argue as lots of questions regarding it arise in my mind. The first thought that
comes to my mind is that whether judiciary in Pakistan is really not independent? If so, what
are the forces, institutions or elements in the socio-political setup and power structure of
Pakistan which curtail and enslave this organ?
The independence of the judiciary was promised since the early days of Pakistan when the
constituent assembly passed the Objectives Resolution in 1949, which was moved by Liaquat Ali
Khan, the then Prime Minister of Pakistan. The documented resolution clearly stated that the
independence of thejudiciary shall be fully secured.
I will propose an all-round view of the judicial system prevalent within Pakistan, the
establishment of courts, meanings of independence of Judiciary, ways to ensure its
independence as well as comment on Judicial Activism in Pakistan.
II. Meanings of Independence of Judiciary:One of the cardinal principles of a democracy is the concept of an Independent Judiciary. An
ideal and independent judiciary would mean that all the components of a judicial system,
including the Supreme Court, would be free from any sort of external and exertive pressures,
undue intervention and compulsion either direct or indirect i.e. brought about by other
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
4/10
institutions, colleagues, superiors or any third parties outside the judicial system. The judges
would not be bound or compelled by any external factor to give a judgment against the law and
would be free to decide the cases brought before them on the basis of law and their
conscience.
A number of legal instruments elaborate the importance of judicial independence such as: The
universal declaration of human rights (article 10), the international covenant on civil and
political rights (article 14), the Vienna declaration and program for Action (1993: paragraph 27),
the International Bar Association Code of Minimum Standards of Judicial Independence (New
Delhi: 1982), the Universal Declaration on the Independence of Justice (Montreal: 1983) and so
forth.
III. The rationale behind independence of Judiciary:The concept of Independence of Judiciary within a Federal state emerges from the logic of
federalism. Ever since the beginning of the history of legality, the courts are bound to act as
interpreters of the law and the arbiters between not only citizen and citizen but also between
State and citizen. All the rights guaranteed by the constitution are rights against the State and
thus the judiciary has been assigned by the Constitution very important and delicate role to
play, namely, to ensure that none of the organs of the State or the Government functionaries
acts in violation of any provision of the Constitution or of any other law and because of the
above nature of work entrusted to judiciary it was envisaged in the Constitution that the shall
be independent. Therefore, judicial independence is necessary within a State to give the
citizens a chance to fight, on right, against the mighty State.
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
5/10
IV. Pakistans Judiciary and its establishment:The System:
There are distinctively two components of the Judiciary in Pakistan which are as following:
a) The Superior Judiciaryb) The Subordinate Judiciary
The Superior Judiciary of Pakistan comprises of two courts, the Supreme Court and the High
Courts. The Supreme Court comprise of a 17 judge panel which hears appeals from the High
Courts, though the Supreme Court has no administrative supervision over the High Courts. The
High Courts are located in each provincial capital of Pakistan and they cater to the appeals
forwarded by District & Sessions Judges, members of the Subordinate Judiciary.
The Subordinate Judiciary within Pakistan comprises of Civil Judges and Judicial Magistrates,
lying at the base of the hierarchy. These judges are supervised by the Additional District &
Sessions Judges or the District & Sessions Judges. The most superior of the Subordinate
Judiciary are the District & Sessions Judges, located in each District of a province, who also
supervise the Additional District & Sessions Judges, though the Additional District & Sessions
judges are at the same hierarchical level.
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
6/10
A hierarchical depiction of the Judicial Systems is given above to clarify the structure of the
system. In addition to these two basic Courts, there are a series of other courts such as the
Federal Shariat Court, Labour Courts, Anti-Terrorism Courts, Accountability Courts and the
special courts & tribunals.
Establishment & Jurisdiction of Courts:
It has been provided under article 175 of the constitution of Pakistan that there shall be a
Supreme Court of Pakistan, a High Court for each province and a court for the Islamabad Capital
territory and such other courts as may be established by law. Courts of Law mean the courts
The Judicial System of
Pakistan
The Superior
Courts
The District
Courts
A hierarchical depiction of
the Judicial System of
Pakistan
Supreme Courts
High Courts
Addl./District &
Sessions Judges
Special Courts &
Tribunals
Civil Judges/Judicial
Magistrates
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
7/10
which have been established by the virtue of statutes, which are known as District Courts or
Subordinate Judiciary.
V. Judicial independence under the Pakistan Constitution:One of the basic principles of the Constitution of Pakistan is the independence of judiciary. The
constitution states that it is the will of the people of Pakistan to establish an order and the
independence of the judiciary shall be fully secured, as is seen in the part of the Constitution in
Article 2A and in the provisions of the Part VII of the Constitution which elaborates the principle
of independence of judiciary and in such a manner so as to ensure the independence of
judiciary.
The judiciary is, therefore, independent of the executive and legislature and has jurisdiction,
directly or by way of review, over all issues of a judicial nature.
Judicial independence, itself, is status-oriented as it focuses on the status of the court as well as
the relation between the courts and the others, particularly the executive branch of the
government. There are three core and distinctive characteristics of the judicial independence,
which are as following:
Security of Tenure Financial Security Administrative Security
Article 175 clearly denotes that the judiciary, including the lower or subordinate judiciary as it is
a part of the judicial hierarchy, is to be independent and separate.
VI. Safeguards stemming from Independence of Judiciary:This is in light of the independence of judiciary which provides the judges with a safe haven to
exercise their judicial acts, within their jurisdiction or capacity, in the best interest of justice,
even if the judge may have to commit an unlawful act, and he would not be liable to any
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
8/10
damages. The reason is not that judge has any privilege over others to make mistakes but that
the judge should be able to do his duties with complete independence and freedom from fear.
The Superior and the lower judiciary enjoy same level of immunity and protection and the
reason for this protection is to ensure that the judiciary may be free in thought and would act
judicially, for the sake of justice and law. The only condition in which a judge may be liable to
any damages is that he would be acting unlawfully outside his jurisdiction but until and unless
he is acting within his jurisdiction, he would not be liable to any damages.
VII. Judicial Activism and Ways to ensure independence of judiciary inPakistan:
With increased independence of the courts comes Judicial Activism which is essential and
quite beneficial. The concept of Judicial Activism is that the courts start exercising more of their
power and authority to review and adjudicate. We have seen in Pakistan that the Supreme
Courts, after the independence of the Judiciary, have inclined more towards Judicial Activism,
helped by the media reports regarding several issues like the issue of IPPs (Independent Power
Producers) or that of the tariff of sugar or such cases of corruption against powerful politicians,etc. This would not have been possible if the judiciary had not been independent or judicially
active. All that glitters is not gold and judicial activism, despite being good itself, has lead to
judicial adventurism, which is not good as the judges exercise their powers more to gain fame
from the masses and not in the interest of justice.
The threat to complete independence lies within an independent system itself and the threat is
none other than the lust for power and undue exercise of power to gain dominance and
absolute power is a negation of rule of law and will lead to judicial despotism.
Independence of judiciary can be ensured by avoiding such acts which conform to judicial
adventurism and despotism in order to avoid any sort of confrontation with the other executive
bodies of a State and judicial self-restraint methods should be adopted so as to avoid undue
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
9/10
interference with proceedings of the other bodies of a State. Unbridled judicial power and
delayed dispatching of justice would render judiciary as dependent rather than being
independent. Mechanisms, such as self-restraint and focusing on the real issues like dispatching
of speedy and fluent justice to everyone under the rule of law, should be adopted as soon as
possible and the only way to adopt these mechanisms successfully is to have an active
participation of the Bar, the Civil Society and the Media as they have the ability to criticize the
judgments by being vocal, without any fear of contempt. This is the only way that the judiciarys
true independence will be achieved.
-
7/31/2019 How to Ensure Independent Judiciary in Pakistan
10/10
References:
Access to Justice in Pakistan by Justice (R) Fazal Karim.
Building Judicial Independence in Pakistan a report by International Crisis Group (ICG),
10 Nov. 2004.
Independence of the judiciary, Indonesian Experience A joint address by Prof. Dr. Bagir
Manan, Chief Justice of the Republic of Indonesia and Mr. Iftikhar Chaudry, Chief Justice of the
Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
A special interview I conducted with Mr. Asad Imran, Civil Judge, Family Courts, Lahore
How true judicial independence can be achieved by Ali Zafar, an article in the Express
Tribune, published on 1st
of May, 2012.