how to create stream smart crossings - maine audubon...2018/03/03  · bottomless box culvert...

46
How to Create Stream Smart Crossings The Golden Rule: Let the stream act like a stream

Upload: others

Post on 01-Nov-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

How to Create

Stream Smart Crossings

The Golden Rule:

Let the stream act like a stream

Page 2: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Stream Smart Options

1) Avoid creating a crossing

2) Remove the crossing

3) Open bottom structure that spans or exceeds channel

– Abutments for temporary bridge

– Bridge or 3-sided box culvert

– Arch culvert

4) Embedded culvert

5) Hydraulic designs

Page 3: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Open bottom structures

Bridge

Arch Culvert

Temporary Bridge Deck

Bottomless Box Culvert

Page 4: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Embedded pipes

Photo: John Gilbert

Page 5: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Embedded box culvert

Page 6: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Liners don’t achieve

Stream Smart outcomes!

Page 7: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Rules of Thumb (4 S’s)

Span the stream

Set elevation right

Slope and skew match

stream

Substrate in the crossing

Page 8: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Don’t pinch the stream

Page 9: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

9

Span the stream

(and exceed it where possible)

Page 10: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

How undersized culverts constrict

stream flow and become perched

Turbulence

scours at

end of

culvert

Culvert that does not span the channel

set at stream grade

Plunge pool created

Low flow

barrier

Free Fall

(perch)

Water backs

up at inlet

Page 11: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Real World – Blanchard

2008 2010

Page 12: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Rules of Thumb (4 S’s)

Span the stream

Set elevation right

Slope and skew match

stream

Substrate in the crossing

Page 13: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Downstream (Outlet)

What is Upstream?

Set elevation right

Page 14: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Upstream

Page 15: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Indicators of elevation problems

Looking downstream Looking upstream

Inlet Outlet

Page 16: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

A stream channel rediscovered!

Page 17: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Indicators of

correct elevation

Looking downstream Looking upstream

Page 18: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Seamless inlets and outlets

Page 19: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Stream ProfileUsed to find correct elevation and slope

Water Level

Stream Bottom

Culvert Road Surface

Stream Slope Pool Bottom ElevationsNew, Larger, Lower

Culvert

Survey Stations

Page 20: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Existing 2.5' diameter

culvert

Cross-Section

1

Cross-Section

4

Wood

Step

Road

Surface

Cross-Section

2

Cross-Section

3

Accumulated

Sediment Upstream

Stream Profile Example 1

Page 21: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

“Berm”

Road Surface

Stream Profile Example 2

9 ft

Page 22: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Rules of Thumb (4 S’s)

Span the stream

Set elevation right

Slope and skew match

stream

Substrate in the crossing

Page 23: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Substrate in the crossing

Page 24: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Stream Smart Sizing

Step 1: Field Assessment

• Stream profile

• Stream cross-section

Step 2: Project Design

• Structure Choice

• Elevations

• Hydrology

• Hydraulics

Page 25: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

What volume of flow are we allowing for?

50-, 100- or 500-year storm event?

What species are we concerned about?

Fish, amphibians, mammals, invertebrates?

Step 1: Field Assessment

Page 26: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

• Geomorphic Map

• Stream Profile• Bed elevation

• Slope

• Scour potential

• Footer depth

• Road /structure height

• Cross Section• Structure span width

• Bed characterization• Stream bed material size

• Bank material size

Grace Levergood / NHDES

Step 1: Field Assessment

Page 27: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Determine the stream profile

to determine elevation and slope

Measure well upstream and

downstream from existing

crossing structure - 20-30 times

the width of the stream in distance

Step 1: Field Assessment

Page 28: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Stream Profile

Step 1: Field Assessment

Existing 4' culverts (3)

Cross-Section1

Bedrockat bank

Road Surface (464.5')

Cross-Section3

Page 29: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Determine the stream cross-section

to set the opening area of the crossing

6’

Average Stream Width = 6’

Average Depth = 1’

Measure both upstream and downstream of crossing in an undisturbed

location, and average measurements

Step 1: Field Assessment

Page 30: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Cross-section

Step 1: Field Assessment

Bankfull Width

Bankfull Width = 16.7'

Bankfull Depth = 2.5'

Bankfull XS Area = 42 sq ft

Floodprone Width

Page 31: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Step 2: Structure Choice

Page 32: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream
Page 33: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Structure Comparison

Embedded PipeBridge

Open Bottom Arch Traditional Pipe

Cost $$$

Lifespan 50-75 (yrs)

Pros AOP, Durable

Cons High cost

Cost $$

Lifespan 50-75 (yrs)

Pros AOP

Cons Assembly

Cost $

Lifespan 20-75 (yrs)

Pros Low cost

Cons Poor AOP

Only for small

crossings

Cost $

Lifespan 20-75 (yrs)

Pros Low cost

Cons Only for small

crossings

Page 34: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream
Page 35: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

35

New channel cross section

20’

pre-restoration

post-restoration

2009 site

Photo by K. Mueller

Stream-Smart: Open Arch

Page 36: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Stream-Smart:

Small bridge on low volume road

Before After

Page 37: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Stream-Smart:

Embedded Box Culvert

Before After

Page 38: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Stream-Smart:

3-Sided Box Culvert

Before After

Page 39: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Stream-Smart:

Concrete Arch Culvert

Before After

Page 40: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Step 2: Elevations

Page 41: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Step 2: Hydrology

USGS StreamStats

Page 42: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Step 2: Hydraulics

Page 43: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

43

Photo by Bill

• Permits

• In stream work window

(July 15 - Sept 30)

• Controlling water during construction

• Sediment & erosion control

• Embedding – building bed and banks

• Bedrock & unstable soils

Design & Installation Considerations

Page 44: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Controlling Water

Page 45: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

When might you seek help?

• Complicated legacy effects

• When you can’t find natural channel

• Tidal streams

• Safety or traffic issues

Page 46: How to Create Stream Smart Crossings - Maine Audubon...2018/03/03  · Bottomless Box Culvert Embedded pipes Photo: John Gilbert Embedded box culvert Liners don’t achieve Stream

Rules of Thumb (4 S’s)

Span the stream

Set elevation right

Slope and skew match

stream

Substrate in the crossing

The Golden Rule:

Let the stream act like a stream