how to be object of desire in the “war for talent” in ... event uploads/s… · “war for...

31
How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in Procurement Presentation to CIPs London event 27 September 2011

Upload: vudang

Post on 01-Apr-2018

235 views

Category:

Documents


7 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in Procurement

Presentation to CIPs London event

27 September 2011

Page 2: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 2© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

This document is exclusively intended for an agreed audience presentation.

Distribution, quotations and duplications – even in the form of extracts – for

third parties is only permitted upon prior written consent of A.T. Kearney.

A.T. Kearney used the text and graphs compiled in this report

in a presentation; they do not represent

a complete documentation of the presentation.

Page 3: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 3© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Robyn WrightPrincipalA.T. Kearney

• A member of A.T. Kearney‟s “Operations” Practice in London, which provides cross industry functional support to clients

• 22 years of consulting and industry experience, including Procurement strategy, Procurement Excellence, Category Management, Procurement Transformation, Supply Chain Organization and Change Management

• Sector work has included, Global Financial Institutions Chemicals, Oil and Gas, UK Military, Central Government Departments, Telecommunications, Retail and FMCG

• Previously worked at ICI Chemicals and Polymers as both a Sales Manager and as Commercial Services Director

• Robyn now focuses on supporting large organisations in managing their operating models to deliver the results they want, especially focused on human resource management. This involves finding out what the business requires of its supply chain and procurement functions, and what needs to be done to deliver on those requirements. The organisational redesign is often simply about making sure there are enough of the best people, with the right skills, focused on the right tasks, who can then be managed and rewarded in a logical way.

• Robyn is married to a Farmer, lives in rural Leicestershire and has twin sons now aged 12

Mobile: +44 7967 168075E:mail [email protected]

Page 4: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 4© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Contents

1. Hot skills at different levels in the procurement department

2. Behind the scenes in procurement re-organisations and what that means to individuals

3. Why stakeholder management is at the top of the list

4. What competencies that entails

5. Tips on gaining the experience you need in stakeholder management

Page 5: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 5© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Procurement skills come in many forms, and must support all Rooms in the House

A.T. Kearney‟s House of Procurement and SupplySM

Source: A.T. Kearney

Section 1 – Hot Skills

Page 6: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 6© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Integrate

Operations

with

Suppliers

Supplier Performance/Development Management (On-going Activities)

Strategic Sourcing (Periodic Events)

Day-to-day Purchasing (Daily Activities)

PayReceiveOrderRequest

Profile Category

and Supply

Market

Evaluate

Market

Dynamics

Improve

Customer

Respon-

siveness

Monitor

Usage and

Demand

Improve

Supplier

Performance

Perform

Continuous

Benchmarking

Category Management

Discovery Negotiation Execution

Monitor/Evaluation/Execution

Execution

Procurement

Strategy

Development

(Periodic

Event)

Identify

Potential

Strategies

Generate

Supplier

Portfolio

Select

Implemen-

tation Path

Select

Suppliers

Traditionally focus of the sourcing team has been in

strategic sourcing, but great value can be gained from

working closely with key suppliers

Strategy development, sourcing and post award contract management are the focus for Value Creation

Value Adding Processes

Section 1 – Hot Skills

Page 7: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 7© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Purchasing Chessboard® – Strategic supply management framework

4 basic strategies

16 approaches

64 methods

Key advantages

• Provides a structured approach for all spend categories

• Defines 64 unique methodologies, from quick win opportunities to highly sophisticated sourcing approaches

• Takes into account the market fundamentals (supply and demand power)

• Goes beyond the scope of traditional purchasing

• Is supported by comprehensive training material and backed up by sanitized benchmarks from 500+ purchasing projects in the past 3 years

• See www.purchasingchessboard.com for more details

... where strategic skills are paramount (and we think there are at least 64 strategies on the Purchasing Chessboard®)

Sourcing & Category Management

Section 1 – Hot Skills

Page 8: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 8© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Collaborative Cost Reduction

Invention on Demand

Cost Regression Analysis

Negotiation skills are a given, always required to manage the balance of power of the parties…

The Purchasing Chessboard®

Low HighDemand powerA B C D E F G H

Low

High

Supply power

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

Invention on demand

Core cost analysis

Vertical integration

Bottleneck management

Sourcing community

Procurement outsourcing

Compliance management

Leverage innovation

network

Design for sourcing

Intelligent deal structure

Political framework

management

Buying consortia

Mega supplier strategy

Closed loop spend

management

Functionality assessment

Product teardown

Composite benchmark

Product benchmark

Cost data mining

Master data management

Supplier consolidation

Specification assessment

Design for manufacture

Process benchmark

Complexity reduction

Standardi-zation

Spend transparency

Bundling across

generations

Value chain reconfigu-

ration

Supplier tiering

Collaborative capacity

management

Visible process

organization

RFI/RFP process

Supplier market

intelligence

Make or buy

Revenue sharing

Sustainability management

Virtual inventory

management

Vendor managed inventory

Expressive bidding

Reverse auctions

Best shoring

Profit sharing

Project based partnership

Total life cycle concept

Supplier development

Total cost of ownership

Price benchmark

Cost regression

analysis

Strategic alliance

Value based sourcing

Collaborative cost reduction

Supplier fitness

program

Leverage market

imbalances

Unbundled prices

Factor cost analysis

Demand reduction

Contract management

Bundling across

product lines

Bundling across sites

Global sourcing

LCC sourcingCost based

price modeling

Linear performance

pricing

The Purchasing Chessboard TM

• Simplify specification of products

• Employ product value analysis and engineering

• Substitute materials

• Optimize lifecycle costs

• Reengineer joint processes

• Share productivity gains

• Integrate logistics

• Support supplier operations improvement

• Employ strategic links with key suppliers

• Develop integrated supply chain

• Improve partnership with suppliers

Focus of CCR

Jointprocessimprove-

ment

Productspecificationimprovement

Relationshiprestructuring

Globalsourcing

Bestprice

evaluation

Volumeconcentration

TRIZ (Theory of Inventive Problem Solving) originated in 1940s/1950s work of Genrich Altshuller in the USSR

Over 200,000 world-wide patents analyzed

23% (inventive patents) were studied in detail

Key discoveries:

• Technical problems are best described as contradictions

• Problems and solutions across industries & sciences are governed by the same objective laws

• Inventions used scientific effects outside the field where they were developed

Price from regression function (based on technical

parameters)

Spread

Currentprice Regression

line

Deep understanding of supply-demand power balance is key in the definition of effective negotiation strategies in long term relationships

Sourcing & Category Management

Section 1 – Hot Skills

Page 9: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 9© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Cost Modelling / Parametric Bidding

...but advanced sourcing needs the ability to understand tools like Parametric Bidding & Collaborative Optimisation

Fix

ed

C

osts

Generic

# Silkscreen passes

Va

ria

ble

Co

sts

Masterbatch

Production loss

Stamping

Base Material

Finishing Coating

Handling & Packaging

%

Admin, Margin, etc

Storage

Unit

EXW

Price

Material

Set-Up

Production

Admin,

Margin, etc

Handling &

Packaging

Storage

Decoration

Product Specs

Material

Shape/Dim

Volume

Decoration

Decoration

Shape/Dim

Material

Su

pp

lier

Inpu

t

Input

Production Costs

Cost Model

Collaborative Optimisation

Optimi-

sation

Engine

Scenarios

AnalysisBaselineOptimal

Solution

Optimizing

Engine

Enables parametric biddingEnables collaboration & scenario

analysis

External Collaboration with Suppliers

• Alternative Bids

• Conditional Discounts / Bundles

• Supplier constraints

Internal Collaboration with Stakeholders

• Business/Manufacturing constraints

• Customer/Marketing constraints

• Cost of constraints

Collaborative Optimization often delivers savings of 12% - 35% of spend

Sourcing & Category Management

Sourcing & Category Management

Section 1 – Hot Skills

Page 10: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 10© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Supplier Management

Deep Sourcing/Integration

Supplier

• Joint market

development

• Product Innovation

Supply chain

• Collaborative Forecasting,

Inventory Planning,

• Integrated work planning

• Logistics management

Scope

• Outsourcing

• Backward integration

Basic Procurement

Volume

• Consolidation

• Supplier rationalization

Price

• Benchmarking

• Negotiations

• Contracting

Strategic Sourcing

Requirements

• Complexity reduction

• Standardization

Consumption

• Rationalization/

reduction

• Compliance

• Total cost of

ownership

Added value

• Performance metrics

• Value engineering

• Early involvement

Economics

• Volume commitment

• Forecasting/demand

planning/visibility

• Supplier / market

economic cycles

Users Suppliers

3 to 7% of purchase price

5 to12% of total cost of ownership

10+% improvement on cost

and revenue

Degree of Development

Economic Gain

When competitive bidding is not the highest “value-generating” strategy, supply chain skills come to the fore

Supplier Relationship Management

Section 1 – Hot Skills

Page 11: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 11© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Whilst at the other end of the spectrum, procurement still provides a service ....

Operating Process Management

Customer/supplier query routing

Knowledge and Data Mgmnt

Assisted Requisitioning

• Routing of query to category lead, manage order, supplier enquiry

• Incoming order issues, problems and supplier communications

Functions - customer service & P2P

operations

Communication/ Reporting

Procurement Services – example support organisation

Key activities

Ordering and expediting service where BUs do not have resource or capability to self

serve their buying

• Expedite orders/respond to order enquiries

• Creating Requisitions, Approvals, Change / Cancel Orders

• Releasing/R2P (Self-service tools: Pcard, catalogue, etc.)

• Track Response rates and report on helpdesk service attainment

• Build content and enact communication of activities, support and performance

• Contribute & Retrieve Information to /from Knowledge Base

• Compliance monitoring

• Maintain Databases/catalogue management

• Upkeep Supplier Data Technical Setup and ongoing Supplier master data

maintenance

• Maintain Local System information

Resourcesrequired

Section 1 – Hot Skills

Page 12: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 12© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

…and infrastructure and enablement teams need to gather best practices and use project management skills

Source: A.T. Kearney PPM Methodology

Performance Management

Section 1 – Hot Skills

Client Example

Page 13: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 13© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Contents

1. Hot skills at different levels in the procurement department

2. Behind the scenes in procurement re-organisations and what that means to individuals

3. Why stakeholder management is at the top of the list

4. What competencies that entails

5. Tips on gaining the experience you need in stakeholder management

Page 14: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 14© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Organisational Change in procurement is often a very structured process

Baseline„As-is‟

Organisation Principles

„To-be‟ alignments Design HR ArchitectureDevelop

Roadmap

2 31 4 5

Systems review

BaseliningOperating

modelResource profiling

Impact Analysis

RoadmapKey

Competency mapping

New Job profilingPotential

Changes to role/job focus

Best In Class Procurement Processes

Voice of the Supplier

Internal interviews

Voice of the Customer

Division Procurement Transformation

Divisional Procurement Leadership

StakeholdersSuppliers

Group Procurement

Category

and Tactical Support

Supply Market

SegmentSourcing

Group Procurement Enablement

Procurement

Hub Manager

Category

Procurement

Lead

Category

Procurement

Lead

Category

Procurement

Lead

Operational

Support

Transformati

onal Support

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Category

Procurement

Specialist

Head of

Market

Segment

Sourcing

Head of

Market

Segment

Sourcing

Head of

Market

Segment

Sourcing

Head of

Market

Segment

Sourcing

Head of

Market

Segment

Sourcing

Procurement

Director

Impact analysisFinance HR

RATEX

Org options

Procurement

Director

Heads of Market

Segment Sourcing

VP Supply Chain

Procurement

Transformation

Manager

Regional

Procurement Hub

Managers

SLAs Scenarios Governance

Org. charts

Non-procreports activity

Job descriptions

Competency maps

Performance management

Volumetrics

Section 2 – Proc Re-organisations

Page 15: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 15© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Key Activities

Design principles

Design principles (example)

Leverage full buying power and procurement experience of the organisation through category management

Separation of strategic and tactical sourcing from transactional purchasing activity

Ensure dedicated leads for implementing strategic activities (incl. performance management) with existing suppliers for key

categories

Establish and maintain collaborative, long -term relationships with strategic suppliers

Share best practices, emerging technologies and analytical techniques across the organisation

Drive consistent procurement policies and procedures across the organisation

Foster leadership and enhance capability of procurement human capital

Org. options Org. structure Role definitions Resource profiling

CXX

Division Division Subsidiary

Occasional

Buyers

Occasional

Buyers

Occasional

Buyers

Purchasing

Field… …

Purchasing

Division

CXX

Division Division Subsidiary

Occasional

Buyers

Occasional

Buyers

Occasional

Buyers

Operational

DivisionSubsidiary

Purchasing

Structure

Purchasing

Structure

Central

Purchasing

Department

Head, Sourcing Operations

Head,Centre ofExcellence

Chief Procurement

Officer (CPO)

Head,

Process

Improve-

ment

Head,

Perform-

ance Mgt

Head,

Knowledge

Mgt

Head,CategoryManagement

Category

Manager

Head,

Supplier

Relation-

ship Mgt.

Head,

Tactical

Sourcing -

Region A

Process

improve-

ment team

Perform-

ance mgt

analysits

Knowledge

managers

Supply

Market

Analysts

Local

sourcing

support

Role title Category Manager

Reports to Head, Category Management

Grade D

Key Responsibilities

• Develops and implements the most appropriate category management

strategies and policies for the improvement

of the business at all levels, in collaboration with business users

• Provides advice, leadership and support on all sourcing matters

• Communicates internal and external

category expectations, tracks internal compliance

• Takes primary accountability for delivering results (e.g., savings targets and

performance improvements)

Education/ experience

• Substantial experience in conducting RFI/RFP process and negotiations;

negotiation aptitude

• 5+ years in category specific background

Skills needed • Leadership• Problem Solving/ Resolution

• Technical expertise in spend category

• Relationship Management

Function Top-down

benchmark

– spend per

FTE ($M)

Spend

($M)

Calculated

FTE

FTE

(reviewed

with client)

Category mgt,

chemicals

70 300 4.3 4

Category mgt,

engineering

100 590 5.9 7

Category mgt,

IT and

telecoms

45 70 1.6 2

Procurement design aligns to the strategic objectives of the organisation ... But beware it‟s a future focused profile

The number of staff required for each role in the new organisation structure is profiled based on expected workload .. Not YOUR current skills...

Section 2 – Proc Re-organisations

Page 16: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 16© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Role: Strategic Buyer

Role Definition (Key activities)

• Develops and executes supply strategies for local categories

in line with corporate/regional category managers

• Applies sourcing approaches (RFPs, etc.)

• Conducts Negotiations with suppliers and stakeholders

• Manages supplier relationships ongoing (performance

measurement, improvement programs)

Skill Profile

Role Characterization: Strategic Buyer ExampleClient Example

Analytical skills

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

Procurement process skills

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

Management skills

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

Personal qualifications

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

1 2 3 4

Analytical skills

1. Data gathering (process, tools)

2. Analysis and modeling

Procurement process skills

1. Strategic thinking

2. Category Expertise (market, demand)

3. Commercial levers expertise

4. Technical / design capabilities

5. Negotiation

6. Contracting / legal

7. Manufacturing and Quality expertise

8. New Part Readiness (e.g. PPAP)

9. Ordering Requisition to Pay (ERP, eProc)

10. ERP planning / configuration

Management skills

1. People management

2. Project management

3. Stakeholder management

Personal qualifications

1. Presentation skills

2. Communication skills

3. Leadership skills

SkillNecessary Skill Level for Role

None Basic Advanced Expert

Allocation to Training Modules Based on Training Needs

But the good news is – if you survive there is generally a will to invest - accurate roles and skills assessment …

Course Participants

Trainees per levelGrand

TotalCorporate Ger UK China Nord EE Cn/ NZ

General

Procurement

• Entire procurement community

• Selected non procurement staf f

10 80 18 20 tbd tbd 21 239

Negotiation

Management

• Category Mngrs

• Strategic Buyers

• Operational Buyers

10 80 18 20 tbd tbd 21 239

Productd

Development

• Product

performance test

labs

• Primary

technologies

/ 6 4 3

Non

Procurement

Staff

• Non Procurement stakeholders

4 tbd tbd tbd tbd tbd tbd tbd

Grand Total 22 166 40 43 42 478

Section 2 – Proc Re-organisations

Page 17: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 17© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

…help to define the right training needs for each individual and role and the leadership want to invest to succeed with their plan

Procurement/Core Skills Competency Grids

GovernanceRACI/Service Agreements

Common Organisational

Backbone

Personal Objectives/MBOTeam Structure

Business Annual Plan

Targets by grade/stage level

Competency needs by role

Formalised Training Needs Reviews• Gap Analysis• Tailored Learning Higher

Performance & Retention

Direction

MeansMotivation

Ability

Procurement War on Talent

• Delivering high returns/sourcing value• Procurement perceived as exciting place to work• Decreased employee turnover and cost of

recruitment / onboarding time• Increased knowledge and sharing of best

practices

• Tailored Role Profiles • Clear Career Progression

• Structured Performance Incentives • Clear Strategic Imperative

Illustrative

Section 2 – Proc Re-organisations

Page 18: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 18© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Contents

1. Hot skills at different levels in the procurement department

2. Behind the scenes in procurement re-organisations and what that means to individuals

3. Why stakeholder management is at the top of the list

4. What competencies that entails

5. Tips on gaining the experience you need in stakeholder management

Page 19: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 19© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

1.5x

1.3x

1.6x

1.4x

Expanded

technical skills

And the skill set requirements of professionals are recognised as broader, including interpersonal skills

55%

58%

49%

39%

40%

25%

58%

44%

69%

73%

79%

70%

56%

41%

77%

67%

2011 2008

1.8x

1.6x

1.2x

1.2x

Deeper

interpersonal skills

Use of IT Tools

Spend Analysis

Supplier Development

Programs

Team Building

Risk Management

Project Management

Change Management

Communication/

Presentation Skills

The AEP in 2011 shows that as Procurement‟s involvement in cross-functional efforts increases so does the need for “business savvy” skillsSkills/Capabilities required from procurement personnel(% Companies selecting „Required‟)

Source A.T.Kearney‟s Assessment of Excellence in Procurement (AEP) 2011

Section 3 – Importance of Stakeholder Mgmnt

Page 20: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 20© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Folks it is about the CUSTOMER; you have to create ownership with key business leaders

GATE A

The Board is initially shown:

• potential areas of category focus

• spend numbers and consumption

The Board approves:• Give operational views on usage

patterns and a future forecast

• Agree to further investigations and

staff engagements

GATE B

The Board is shown:• Internal and external research and

conclusions

• Options on approaching the supply

market /managing demand

• Business Case (benefits, risks),

timelines and next steps

The Board approves:• the sourcing strategy and

contractual approach

• the supplier selection criteria and

the benefit measurement approach

GATE C

The Board is shown: • Comparative attractiveness of offers

• Estimated savings

• Implications of supplier choice – cost

of contractual change

• A proposed way forward

• Clear implementation plans

The Board approves:• Supplier selection decision

• The implementation plan

Gate BStrategy Defined

Gate CImplementation Planned

Gate DSavings

Approved

Gate ALaunch

Sustain Results / Manage Suppliers

OperationalizeNew

Agreements

Execute Strategy

Develop Category Strategy

Assess Supply Markets

Determine Business

Needs

Analyze Category

SpendMobilize

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

We would like to

investigate…..

We have some potential

sourcing options…..

We have the tender

responses…

We have completed

benefits calculations…

Section 3 – Importance of Stakeholder Mgmnt

Client Example

Page 21: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 21© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Procurement capability framework

Required skills

Leadership &

core skills

Purchasing

process

management

Strategic

sourcing

• Strategic influencing• Facilitation / coaching

• Change management

• Team working

• Conflict resolution

• Time management

• Communication

• Policy compliance

• Demand management

• Sourcing strategy develop.

• Negotiation & contracting

• New supplier selection

• Supp. Rel. Management

• Risk management

• Commercial skills

• Basic Knowledge of intra-

departmental activities

• Specification definition

• Supplier performance

management

• Transaction management

• Warranty management

• Catalogue management

• Inbound logistics

• Order expediting

• Process excellence

• Project management

• Cross-cultural awareness

• Managing for sustainability

• Costing and pricing

• e-sourcing

• Supply market analysis

Behavioral

capabilities

• Knowledge sharing

• Innovation focus

• Adaptability

• External focus

• Openness to feedback

• Response to feedback

• Going the extra mile

• Learning openness

• Learning focus

• Risk affinity

• Volunteering

Category skills are a given...key capabilities /selection criteria which make you stand out are about soft skills

Section 3 – Importance of Stakeholder Mgmnt

Page 22: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 22© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Contents

1. Hot skills at different levels in the procurement department

2. Behind the scenes in procurement re-organisations and what that means to individuals

3. Why stakeholder management is at the top of the list

4. What competencies that entails

5. Tips on gaining the experience you need in stakeholder management

Page 23: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 23© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

• The case for change: Is the Category Strategic Agenda and benefits case clear enough?

• Sponsorship Visibility: Are there clear supporting and vocal sponsors?

Transformation Figurehead

Category Business Leads

• Dynamic Engagement: Do you communicate based on stakeholder interests?

Undertake category initiatives which are business driven

Communicate

Communicate

Communicate

Drive decisions on sourcing strategies with options and data facts

Identify and pursue opportunities or quick wins

Balance empowerment with the need to integrate and give focus

Develop the plan

consistent

and achievable

Create ownership of

the way forward from

all the key stakeholder

groups

Develop pull by

passing responsibility

out and down as fast

as possible

Align the top

team around the

need, the

approach

and style of

change

Make sure there

is enough

resource (time,

energy, skill and

money) to embark

on the journey

Ensure the

business case

for a new proc

operating

model is

clear and

compelling

Pro-active Stakeholder Mgmnt

Excellence in influencing /stakeholder mgmnt means planning, thinking like your receiver, and receiving like you‟re thinking

Section 4 – Stakeholder Mgmnt Skills

Page 24: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 24© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Contents

1. Hot skills at different levels in the procurement department

2. Behind the scenes in procurement re-organisations and what that means to individuals

3. Why stakeholder management is at the top of the list

4. What competencies that entails

5. Tips on gaining the experience you need in stakeholder management

Page 25: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 25© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

Most survey respondents do not include cross functional team members outside procurement in training on procurement topics

Leaders in procurement provide a broader range of training topics to employees … is yours?

Procurement topics(% participants selecting “Training available to procurement employees”)

Business leadership skills topics(% participants selecting “Training available to procurement employees”)

66%

69%

68%

80%

69%

72%

69%

77%

85%

85%

92%

92%

Supply Market Analysis

Use of Procurement IT

tools

Spend Analysis

Negotiation and Contracting

Sourcing strategy Developmant

Sourcing Methodology

59%

45%

46%

48%

53%

61%

69%

77%

77%

77%

77%

85%

Project Management

Stakeholder Engagement

Balance sheet Literacy

Change Management

Building and motivating teams

Communication/ Presentation Skills

Leaders

Followers

Source A.T.Kearney‟s Assessment of Excellence in Procurement (AEP) 2011

Section 5 – Tips and Learning Strategies

Page 26: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 26© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

You should seek out opportunities to learn but more importantly PRACTICENever stop learning …

Strategy Description

Self Instruction

• One person learning completely on their own in a very informal manner

Self-Directed Learning

• Learners are given carefully prepared materials

• Questions are included to keep learners engaged and answers provided to allow for self-evaluation

Computer Based Training CBT

• Self-directed learning presented by computer

• A computer program acts as instructor and information source

Web-Based Training

• Can be used to disseminate self-directed or CBT courses

• Can also provide opportunity for learners to locate their own chat groups where they learn from other participants in an unstructured self instructional way

On-the-Job

• Training happens at the actual job site

• A supervisor/coach delivers and monitors highly structured training program complete with guides, application sessions and formal performance test

Stand Alone Job Aids

• Tools that guide performance as the learner performs the ability

• Usually used in combination with other strategies to enhance training effectiveness

Choose training sessions that take into account

your perceptual learning style …

Visual

Learners

Auditory

Learners

Kinesthetic

Learners

Description

Training Implications

• Learn by seeing

• Pictures and images are

important

• “I see what you mean…”

• Learn by listening

• Verbal instructions

are important

• “I hear you…”

• Learn by doing

• Games and practical

exercises are

important

• “That makes sense

to me…”

• Include visual

reinforcement (e.g.

projectors, videos)

• Have discussions

during training

• Use nuances of

speech (e.g. varying

pitch, speed of

presentation) to

deliver key messages

• Organize and

allow enough time

for practical

assignments

And seek out opportunities on the job, at conferences, and best of all – watch and

then do....building up your role

Section 5 – Tips and Learning Strategies

Page 27: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 27© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

About A.T. Kearney

Page 28: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 28© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

A.T. Kearney – Company Profile

A.T. Kearney is one of the world‟s leading strategic management consulting

• Atlanta

• Cambridge

• Chicago

• Dallas

• Mexico City

• New York

• San Francisco

• São Paulo

• Southfield

• Toronto

• Washington, DC

• Abu Dhabi

• Dubai

• Manama

• Riyadh

• Amsterdam

• Berlin

• Brussels

• Bucharest

• Copenhagen

• Düsseldorf

• Frankfurt

• Helsinki

• Istanbul

• Kiev

• Lisbon

• Ljubljana

• London

• Madrid

• Milan

• Moscow

• Munich

• Oslo

• Paris

• Prague

• Rome

• Stockholm

• Stuttgart

• Vienna

• Warsaw

• Zurich

• Bangkok

• Beijing

• Hong Kong

• Jakarta

• Kuala Lumpur

• Melbourne

• Mumbai

• New Delhi

• Seoul

• Shanghai

• Singapore

• Sydney

• Tokyo

Americas Europe

Asia Pacific

Middle East

Immediate Impact &

Growing Advantage

Founded in 1926

2,500 employees worldwide

58 cities in 38 countries

Private, 100% Partner-owned

Collaborative Working Style

Credentials

Page 29: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 29© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

We are the recognized market leader in supply management, accredited with the original “invention of 7 Step” sourcing

1990 1995 2000

Automotive

Engineering

Financialservices

Retail, cons. goods

Pharma

Process

Telecom

SourcingBPO

Consortia

AT&T, Bell South, CeskyTelecom, DT, FT, NTT

BP, Arcelor, Chevron, Elf, Esso, HKM, Lafarge, RAG, Saint Gobain, Shell, ...

Abbott, Astra Zeneca, Bayer HealthCare, BMS, Merck, Novartis, Pfizer, Quintiles, Viatris, Wyeth, …

Campbell, Carrefour, M&S, Sara Lee, Sears, Unilever, …

ABN Amro, AXA, Barclays, Citigroup, Daito Bank, Deutsche Bank, Groupama, HSBC, JP Morgan, Prudential, Royal Bank of Scotland, …

Babcock & Wilcox, Camargo Correa, Fluor Daniel, Grundfos, Hochtief, Impregilo, Lenze, MacGregor, Mettler Toledo, NCC, Rolls-Royce, Schindler, …

Caterpillar, DaimlerChrysler, Ferrari, Fiat, Ford, GM, Jaguar, Land Rover, Nissan, Volvo, VW,ArvinMeritor, Delphi, Faurecia, Federal Mogul, Getrag, Knorr Bremse, Magna, TRW, Visteon, …

Development of A.T. Kearney‟s supply management consulting expertise

Extension to

Strategic Sourcing

Enabling of Supply

Management"Invention“ of

Global Sourcing

"S-Teams"

500 projects during

past 3 years

850 consultants on

sourcing projects

Analysis of $ 400 bn

spend so far

Typical saving range

of 8-15% on

addressed spend

$ 68 bn cumu-lated

savings

$ 15 mln annual

investment in in-

tellectual capital

Thought leader

in sourcing since

more than 15 years

Facts

LSN, …

Tra

dit

ion

al

So

urc

ing

Ne

xt

Ge

ne

ra

tio

nS

ou

rc

ing

Se

rv

ice

P

ro

vis

ion

ing

Pro

ce

ss

E

na

ble

me

nt

Supply Management

Tra

dit

ion

al

So

urc

ing

Ne

xt

Ge

ne

ra

tio

nS

ou

rc

ing

Se

rv

ice

P

ro

vis

ion

ing

Pro

ce

ss

E

na

ble

me

nt

Tra

dit

ion

al

So

urc

ing

Ne

xt

Ge

ne

ra

tio

nS

ou

rc

ing

Se

rv

ice

P

ro

vis

ion

ing

Pro

ce

ss

E

na

ble

me

nt

Supply Management

Selection

Credentials

Page 30: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 30© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

A.T. Kearney's Assessment of Excellence in Procurement (AEP) 2011 is the seventh in the series

History of A.T. Kearney's Assessment of Excellence

in Procurement (AEP)

19921996

25 Total Participants

77 Total Participants

1999

2002

2004162 Total Participants

147 Total Participants

281 Initial Participants,

638 total participants

2008

295 Initial Participants, 650+ total

participants

2011*

162 Initial Participants, 201+ total

participants to date

(1) Over 1,000 elements benchmarked across 33 leadership practices covering 8 dimensions of Procurement

Overview

* The Survey is still open in 2011 and companies can receive full assessments against peers on an ongoing basis

Page 31: How to be object of desire in the “War for Talent” in ... Event uploads/S… · “War for Talent” in Procurement ... sourcing Intelligent deal structure ... Process benchmark

A.T. Kearney 27/09/2011 Ver 1.0 31© Copyright 2011 A.T. Kearney, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form without written permission.

The AEP in its 19th year, and is the most comprehensive benchmarking of Procurement practices

Highlights

• 201 companies have submitted responses

• Participants from Asia (22%), Americas (27%) and EMEA (51%)

• All industries are represented: Information Intensive Services (30%), Asset Intensive Services(14%), Non-Durable Consumer Products (17%), others (39%)

• Survey remains open; tracking to 500+ participation

• Average participant is US$12.5 B in revenues

• Survey remains open

Overview