8/2/2019 How to address the subnational actor threat and effective national participation in the biological non-proliferation re

1/9

gat` g52!55

@ i h { e g d ` G ` r a g

V`{`evkb C`iia|) Cagdethag ~apv

ie V`kb`vkb` [tvetlhup`

E g l ` i e \ a a d | e v d

^valvejj` Dhv`ktav) S@VTHK

Ba| ta eddv`{{ tb` {pfgethagei ektav

tbv`et egd `cc`kths` gethagei

~evthkh~ethag hg tb` fhaialhkei

gag*~vaihc`vethag v`lhj`"50 Gas`jf`v 6>55(

Ef{tvektTb` Fhaialhkei \`e~ag{ Kags`gthag "F\K( v`*jehg{ tb` kavg`v{tag` ac tb` fhaialhkei |`e~ag{gag~vaihc`vethag egd dh{evjej`gt v`lhj`) `j*fadxhgl tb` gavj elehg{t F\ ~vaihc`vethag egde kaj~v`b`g{hs` F\ dh{evjej`gt afihlethag'Ba|`s`v) tb` fhaialhkei |`e~ag{ tbv`et h{`saishgl dp` ta {kh`gthchk egd t`kbgaialhkei d`*s`ia~j`gt{ eiagl |htb hgkv`e{hgl {pfgethageiektav hgt`v`{t hg fhaialhkei jet`vhei{ cav p{` hgkvhjhgei egd t`vvavh{t ekthshth`{) v`uphvhgl ege{{`{{j`gt ac tb` kag{`up`gk`{ cav tb` F\Kegd ht{ cptpv`' [`s`vei t`vvavh{t lvap~{ av av*legh}ethag{ {pkb e{ Ei Ue`de egd ht{ ecchihet`{bes` dh{~iex`d e kajjhtj`gt ta ekuphv` |`e~*ag{ ac je{{ d`{tvpkthag) hgkipdhgl fhaialhkei

|`e~ag{' \bhi` `r~v`{{hag{ ac hgt`gt) {pkb e{A{eje Fhg Ied`g{ d`kievethag hg 5882 tbet ek*uphvhgl |`e~ag{ ac je{{ d`{tvpkthag |e{ e v`ih*lhap{ dptx) e{ |`ii e{ ett`j~t{ ta aftehg fha*ialhkei el`gt{ egd kagdpkt `r~`vhj`gt{ cavkvhjhgei ~pv~a{`{ `shd`gk` e {p{tehg`d hgt`v`{thg fhaialhkei kvhj`{) ht v`jehg{ dhcchkpit ta e{*{`{{ tb` ektpei ke~ekhtx ac gag*{tet` ektav{ takagdpkt e fhaialhkei etteko) `{~`kheiix ag eievl` {kei`' Tb` 6>>5 egtbver i`tt`v{ ohii`d 0~`a~i` egd hgc`kt`d 6; atb`v{) fpt kep{`d |hd`*{~v`ed dh{vp~thag egd ~eghk) fipgtix bhlbihlbt*

hgl tb` v`eihtx ac tb` tbv`et'

Eddv`{{hgl tb` kbeii`gl`{ evh{hgl cvaj tb` {pf*gethagei ektav tbv`et be{ i`d ta up`{thag{ efapttb` {ka~` egd vai` ac tb` Kags`gthag' F\K

8/2/2019 How to address the subnational actor threat and effective national participation in the biological non-proliferation re

2/9

6

[tet`{ ^evth`{ `ccavt{ tbvaplb tb` Kags`gthag ta{tv`gltb`g gethagei j`e{pv`{ ta ~vabhfht egd~v`s`gt fhaialhkei |`e~ag{ ev` lvedpeiix v`e~*hgl v`tpvg{) |bhi` v`iet`d hgt`vlas`vgj`gteiavlegh}ethag{ hg tb` ch`id{ ac bpjeg) eghjeiegd ~iegt b`eitb egd kp{taj{ bes` eg hgdhv`kt~a{hths` hj~ekt ag F\K hj~i`j`gtethag {hj~ix

fx cpichiihgl tb`hv a|g jegdet`{' Eddhthagei)ievl`ix kaj~i`j`gtevx) hghtheths`{ bes` ei{af``g d`s`ia~`d ta cakp{ ag tb` {pfgethagei ek*tav tbv`et) ~evthkpievix fhat`vvavh{j' Tb` hg*sais`j`gt ac khshi {akh`tx hg ~v`s`gthag h{ ei{a eo`x h{{p`' Tb` F\K [`s`gtb V`sh`| Kagc`v`gk`cvaj 0*66 D`k`jf`v 6>55 h{ eg a~~avtpghtx tav`sh`| tb` {tet` ac tb` fhaialhkei |`e~ag{ v`*lhj`) ht{ gethagei hj~i`j`gtethag fx {tet`{egd) kvpkheiix) |bet vai` tb` F\K {bapid ~iexhg tb` g`ev*) jhd* egd iagl*t`vj hg dvhshgl tb`F\ gag~vaihc`vethag egd dh{evjej`gt el`gde'

HgtvadpkthagTb` t`kbgaialhkei v`saipthag hg tb` ihc` {kh`gk`{be{ l`g`vet`d gas`i a~~avtpghth`{ cav fhaialhkei|`e~ag{ "F\( ~vaihc`vethag fx fatb {tet` egd{pfgethagei ektav{' Tb` tbv`et ac {pfgethageiektav{ `glelhgl hg ~vabhfht`d ekthshth`{ hgsaishglfhaialhkei el`gt{ egd tarhg{fhaialhkei |`e~ag{ekthshth`{h{ k`vtehgix gat g`|) x`t [tet`{ ^evth`{ta tb` 58"6>>4(jav` kaj~`thths`) av dp~ihkeths`) tbegkaj~i`j`gtevx1

Tb` kagk`~t{ ac {pfgethagei av gag*{tet` ektavl`g`vet` d`chghthagei ~vafi`j{ |b`g e~~ih`d hgtb` F\ ch`id) e{ tb` evj{ kagtvai dh{kapv{` kaj*jagix edd{ e g`leths` kaggatethag e{ e kag{`*up`gk` ac ht{ cakp{ ag tb` tbv`et{ ac evjej`gt)~vaihc`vethag egd p{`' Ht vev`ix p{`{ tb`j hg tb`hvfvaed`v) g`ptvei j`eghgl ta hj~ix egx `gthtx hghgt`vgethagei v`iethag{ |bhkb h{ gat e {as`v`hlg{tet`5) hgkipdhgl eked`j`) gag*las`vgj`gteiavlegh}ethag{ egd cehtb lvap~{ |htbhg khshi {akh*`tx) tb` ~vhset` {`ktav av `kagajhk egd {akhei~evtg`v{' X`t jegx ac tb`{` `gthth`{ ~`vcavj shteicpgkthag{ hg p~baidhgl evj{ kagtvai) eiagl{hd`{tet` egd hgt`vlas`vgj`gtei ektav{) egd aplbt taf` f`tt`v hgt`lvet`d hgta tb` v`{~`kths` v`lhj`{)`{~`kheiix tb`hv hj~i`j`gtethag) jaghtavhgl egdas`v{hlbt cpgkthag{'

Pghs`v{eiix v`kalgh}`d e{ tb` kavg`v{tag` ac tb`

fhaialhkei |`e~ag{ v`lhj`) tb` Fhaialhkei \`e~*ag{ Kags`gthag be{ e uphgup`gghei a~~avtpghtxta dvhs` tb` F\ dh{evjej`gt egd gag~vaihc`ve*thag el`gde cav tb` g`rt chs`*x`ev ~`vhad egd f`*xagd) egd ta v`kag{hd`v ba| ht keg hj~vas` `c*c`kths` gethagei ~evthkh~ethag hg tb` Kags`gthagegd `cc`kths`ix v`{~agd ta tb` {pfgethagei ektavtbv`et) hgkipdhgl hgt`v eihe) fhat`vvavh{j) et ht{[`s`gtb V`sh`| Kagc`v`gk` cvaj 0 ta 66 D`k`j*f`v 6>55'

Tb` v`saipthag hg tb` ihc` {kh`gk`{egd ht{ hj~ekt ag gethagei hj~i`*j`gtethag ac tb` F\K[kh`gthchk egd t`kbghkei d`s`ia~j`gt{ hg ihc` {kh*`gk`{ hg ev`e{ {pkb e{ fhahgcavjethk{) l`gajhk{)~vat`ajhk{) egd {xgtb`thk egd {x{t`j{ fhaialxkagtvhfpt` ta hggasethag{ egd acc`v lv`et ~`v*{~`kths`{) cav `rej~i` cav tb` ~vadpkthag ac~bevjek`pthkei ~vadpkt{ av ac v`g`|efi` `g`v*lx6' Ba|`s`v tb` vh{o ac jh{p{`) |bhi` dhcchkpit tae{{`{{) ~`v{h{t{;'

DGE {bpccihgl) v`ixhgl ag hg shtva v`kajfhgethagac bajaialap{ l`g`{) h{ e ~a|`vcpi ~vak`{{ cavdhv`kt`d `saipthag tbet l`g`vet`{ ce{t`v gpj`v*ap{ v`kajfhgegt{) |bhkb keg tb`g f` tveg{iet`d

8/2/2019 How to address the subnational actor threat and effective national participation in the biological non-proliferation re

3/9

;

hgta ~vat`hg{' Ht kapid kagtvhfpt` ta tb` d`{hlg acbevjcpi el`gt{) `{~`kheiix hc kap~i`d |htb{kv``ghgl t`kbghup`{ `gefihgl tb` {`i`kthag acjai`kpi`{ |htb {~`khchk ~va~`vth`{' J`dhe kas`v*el` ei{a v`lpievix cakp{`{ ag tb` v`{pit{ aftehg`dhg tb` ch`id ac {xgtb`thk l`gajhk{ egd {xgtb`thkfhaialx) e{ tbv`et l`g`{ av `s`g l`gaj`{ kapid

f` ~vadpk`d fx DGE {xgtb`{h{ cav jei`sai`gt~pv~a{`{' Ekbh`s`j`gt{ iho` {xgtb`{h{ ac e shvp{|htb tb` fhakb`jhkei egd ~etbal`ghk kbevekt`v*h{thk{ ac e ~aihashvp{) v`kag{tvpkthag ac tb` 5852[~egh{b hgcip`g}e ~egd`jhk shvp{ av {xgtb`{h{ aceJxka~ie{jel`ghteihpj l`gaj` bes` {~evo`dkagtvas`v{h`{' [xgtb`thk fhaialx keg f` d`{kvhf`de{ tb` `glhg``vhgl ac g`| kaj~ag`gt{ egd {x{*t`j{ tbet da gat `rh{t hg getpv`) e{ |`ii e{ tb`v`d`{hlg ac `rh{thgl getpvei fhaialhkei {x{t`j{' Hthgkav~avet`{ `i`j`gt{ cvaj atb`v dh{kh~ihg`{)`r~iaht{ t`kbgaialh`{ hg fhahgcavjethk{) v`s`v{`

l`g`thk `glhg``vhgl egd DGE {xgtb`{h{' Ht bhlb*ihlbt{ {aj` ac tb` jehg kbeii`gl`{ tb` F\K be{ta cek`' Tb`{` g`| tv`gd{ hg ihc` {kh`gk`{) e{ |`iie{ hg v`iet`d t`kbgaialh`{ egd hgdp{tvhei e~~ihke*thag{) |htb tb`hv dpei*p{` ~at`gthei cav f`ghlgegd |`e~ag ~pv~a{ {) bes` dhv`kt hj~ihkethag{cav tb` F\K4'

Ag` ac tb`j h{ tb` lva|hgl kags`vl`gk` f`t|``gsevhap{ dh{kh~ihg`{) egd `{~`kheiix f`t|``g fhai*alx egd kb`jh{tvx' Tbh{ keii{ cav hgkv`e{hgl ihgo*el`{ f`t|``g tb` F\K egd K\K v`lhj`{ egd

tb` v`{~`kths` ekthshth`{ teo`g ta hj~i`j`gttb`j et tb` daj`{thk i`s`i' Tb`{` Kags`gthag{~a{` {hjhiev gethagei hj~i`j`gtethag kbei*i`gl`{) ~evthkpievix |htb v`{~`kt ta {pfgethageiektav{' ^vac`{{hagei{ cvaj sevhap{ dh{kh~ihg`{keg f` hgsais`d) j`eghgl ~`a~i` |ba jex f``s`g i`{{ e|ev` ac tb` ~at`gthei cav jh{p{` kegf` `glel`d hg dpei*p{` {kh`gk` v`i`segt ta tb`{`Kags`gthag{0'

Jav`as`v) jh{p{` kapid akkpv hg sevhap{ tx~`{ accekhihth`{) hgkipdhgl ~bevjek`pthkei egd fhat`kb*gaialx kaj~egh`{) ~vhset` v`{`evkb iefavetavh`{)

e{ |`ii e{ pghs`v{htx egd ba{~htei iefavetavh`{'Tb` ~bevjek`pthkei {`ktav h{ e bhlbix dxgejhkegd `r~egdhgl hgdp{tvx e{ e v`{pit ac tb` kaj~`*ththag |htb l`g`vhk jegpcektpv`v{) tb` d`s`ia~*j`gt ac fhat`kbgaialh`{) tb` ~at`gthei jevo`t{v`{pithgl cvaj gethagei egd hgt`vgethagei fhad`*c`g{` ~valvej{ av ~v`~ev`dg`{{ elehg{t `j`vl*hgl dh{`e{`{' E{ e kag{`up`gk`) jav` hgdhshdpei{ev` ekuphvhgl tb` {ohii{ egd `r~`vth{` ta begdi`bhlbix ~etbal`ghk jet`vhei{) egd tb` vh{o ac ejh{kv`egt {kh`gth{t av ~vac`{{hagei hgkv`e{`{ ek*kavdhglix'

Tb` F\K kajjpghtx be{ iepgkb`d e d`fet`efapt {phtefi` las`vgegk` jad`i{ cav tb` dpei*p{` t`kbgaialh`{ egd e~~ihkethag{3= v`lpietavxcvej`|avo{? {`ic*las`vgegk` e~~vaekb`{ hgsais*

hgl `dpkethag egd e|ev`g`{{*veh{hgl ejaglv`i`segt {kh`gthchk egd ~vac`{{hagei lvap~hgl{ takv`et` e kpitpv` ac v`{~ag{hfhihtx? egd bxfvhdjad`i{ kajfhghgl tb`{` dhcc`v`gt e~~vaekb`{'Tb`{` jad`i{ t`gd ta ~v`{pj` {aj` {tvpktpveiavlegh}ethag |htbhg tb` tevl`t lvap~{ |bhkb kegf` `r~iaht`d ta kb`ko tb`hv f`beshav'

Fpt e g`| ket`lavx ac gag*{tet` ektav) kajjagixoga|g e{ fha*beko`v{) ~pv{p` l`g`thk `glh*g``vhgl apt{hd` tvedhthagei ~vac`{{hagei {`t*thgl{ tbet {p~~avt las`vgegk` egd as`v{hlbt'Tb`x ev` ejet`pv{ |ba {``o ta ~vekthk` fhaialx|htbapt jeihlgegt hgt`gt' Hg tb` Pght`d [tet`{)cav `rej~i`) tb` j`jf`v{ ac L`g{~ek` kag{hd`vtb`j{`is`{ tb` chv{t gag*ipkveths` kajjpghtxfhaialhkei iefavetavx egd |h{b ta ~vajat` {kh*`gk` e{ e i`h{pv` ekthshtx cav fatb edpit{ egd kbhi*dv`g' Tb` fha*beko`v{ keg chgd hgcavjethag agd`dhket`d |`f{ht`{ {pkb e{ A~`g\`t\ev`'avlegd dh{kp{{ tb`hv ekthshth`{ ag cavpj{ {pkb e{DHXfha'avl' D`{~ht` tb`hv {aj`thj`{ edsegk`doga|i`dl` ac fhaialx) ja{t j`jf`v{ ac tb` fha*bekohgl kajjpghtx ieko {pcchkh`gt e|ev`g`{{ actb` vh{o{ tb`x jex ~a{` ta tb`j{`is`{ av tb` `g*shvagj`gt) egd kag{`up`gtix ac tb` fha{ec`txegd fha{`kpvhtx hj~ihkethag{ ac tb`hv ekthshth`{'Tb`{` ekthshth`{ ~v`{`gtix v`jehg pgd`v*v`lpiet`d egd |htbapt ed`upet` as`v{hlbt hg shv*tpeiix eii kapgtvh`{' Cpvtb`vjav`) lhs`g tb`hv `{*{`gtheiix egevkbhk avlegh}ethagei {tvpktpv`) atb*

`v{ |htb jeihlgegt hgt`gt kapid `e{hix `r~iahttb`hv g`t|avo) v`{pit{ egd j`tbad{' Tb`{` hghthe*ths`{ bes` tbp{ kep{`d pg`e{hg`{{ egd c`ev acekkhd`gtei v`i`e{` av jh{p{` ac ~etbal`ghkel`gt{ av tarhg{) eitbaplb `ccavt{ ev` pgd`v|exta jhthlet` {pkb vh{o{' Cav `rej~i`) tb` CFH{`h}`d tb` a~~avtpghtx ta d`s`ia~ kia{`v ihgo{f`t|``g {kh`gk` egd {`kpvhtx kajjpghth`{tbvaplb aptv`ekb ekthshth`{) avlegh}hgl j``thgl{letb`vhgl ~pfihk egd ~vhset` {`ktav v`{`evkb`v{|htb v`~v`{`gteths { cvaj tb` {`kpvhtx kajjp*ghtx' Ht h{ ba~`d tbet veh{hgl e|ev`g`{{ efapt tb`

vh{o{ hgsais`d) |hii f`tt`v hgcavj ~evthkh~egt{ ac|bet ekthag ta teo` hc tb`x `gkapgt`v {p{~hkhap{ekthshth`{

8/2/2019 How to address the subnational actor threat and effective national participation in the biological non-proliferation re

4/9

4

vhag) Evthki` H ac tb` kags`gthag kas`v{ eii kpv*v`gt egd cptpv` tbv`et{ ~a{`d fx fhaialhkeiel`gt{ egd tarhg{) hvv`{~`kths` ac |b`tb`v tb`xakkpv getpveiix av ev` kv`et`d evthchkheiix hg iefa*vetavh`{' [tet`{ ^evth`{ ev` kalgh}egt ac tb` ve~hdedsegk`{ hg tb` ihc` {kh`gk`{ egd p~det` tb`hvpgd`v{tegdhgl ac tb` {ka~` ac tb` Evthki` H ~vabh*

fhthag hg ihlbt ac tb`{` d`s`ia~j`gt{ et Kags`g*thag v`sh`| kagc`v`gk`{= tb` g`rt hgt`v{`{{hagei~vak`{{ h{ `r~`kt`d ta kag{hd`v {pkb d`s`ia~*j`gt{ jav` cv`up`gtix' Evthki` HHH cpvtb`v `sh*d`gk`{ tbet tb` F\K feg ag F\ ~vaihc`vethagkas`v{ {pfgethagei ektav{) fx ~vabhfhthgl [tet`{^evth`{ cvaj tveg{c`vvhgl fhaialhkei egd tarhgel`gt{) |`e~ag{ egd d`ihs`vx {x{t`j{ ta egxv`kh~h`gt |bet{a`s`v) e kiep{` pgd`v{taad ta`gkaj~e{{ gag*{tet` ektav{'

Tb` fhat`vvavh{j dh{kapv{` ~a{ht{ tbet |bhi` tb`F\K kas`v{ tbh{ ~evthkpiev tbv`et) ht ieko{ ed`*upet` taai{ ta eddv`{{ ht hg e bhlb tbv`et `gshvag*j`gt egd da`{ gat d`jegd {pcchkh`gtix d`tehi`dgethagei hj~i`j`gtethag ta cc`kths`ix ~v`s`gt ht'Kag{`up`gtix) jpkb ~aihthkei `ccavt be{ f``g hg*s`{t`d hg ~eveii`i hg{tvpj`gt{ egd hghtheths { taf``c p~ tb` v`lhj` elehg{t F\) {pkb e{) cav `r*ej~i`) PG [`kpvhtx Kapgkhi V`{aipthag 504>'\bhi` {pkb eddhthagei iex`v{ pgdapft`dix kag*tvhfpt` ta tb` liafei kas`vel` ac k`vtehg F\ ~va*bhfhthag{ "tb` F\K {thii ieko{ pghs`v{eihtx() tb`up`{thag evh{`{ |b`tb`v tb`{` v`iet`d hghtheths`{

da gat pgd`vjhg` tb` vai` ac tb` F\K e{ kavg`v*{tag` ac tb` fhaialhkei |`e~ag{ v`lhj` av|b`tb`v) ag tb` kagtvevx) tb`x ektpeiix v`hgcavk`tb` v`lhj` fx `r~ihkethgl {aj` afihlethag{ egdhgt`vgethagei `r~`ktethag{ ta ~v`s`gt fhaialhkei|`e~ag{' Tba{` ~eveii`i hghtheths`{ cakp{ eija{t`rkip{hs`ix ag {pfgethagei F\ tbv`et{) ~evthkp*ievix fhat`vvavh{j) {``jhglix ta tb` `rkip{hag acteglhfi` {tet`*fe{`d F\ tbv`et{'

X`t tb` F\K{ {tv`gltb ih`{ hg ht{ {hj~ihkhtx egdkaj~v`b`g{hs` {ka~`' Evthki` H) |htb tb` {a*keii`d l`g`vei ~pv~a{` kvht`vhag) d`chg`{ tb`

{ka~` ac ~vabhfhthag{? hg `{{`gk`) g`s`v pgd`vegx khvkpj{tegk`{ ta ekuphv` av v`tehg fhaialhkei|`e~ag{' E v`iet`d ~evelve~b hg tb` Chgei D`kie*vethag ac tb` [hrtb V`sh`| Kagc`v`gk` "6>>3({tet`{ tbet tb` Kagc`v`gk` v`ecchvj{ tbet Evthki`H e~~ih`{ ta eii {kh`gthchk egd t`kbgaialhkei d`s`i*a~j`gt{ hg tb` ihc` {kh`gk`{ egd hg atb`v ch`id{ ac{kh`gk` v`i`segt ta tb` Kags`gthag8'

E{ gat`d `evih`v) Evthki` HHH eddv`{{`{ tb` tbv`etcvaj {pfgethagei ektav{' Tb` chgei d`kievethag ettb` Capvtb V`sh`| Kagc`v`gk` "5883( pvl`{{tet`{ ~evth`{ ta kag{hd`v |ex{ egd j`eg{ ta`g{pv` tbet hgdhshdpei av {pfgethagei lvap~{ ev``cc`kths`ix ~v`s`gt`d cvaj ekuphvhgl) tbvaplbtveg{c`v{) fhaialhkei el`gt{ egd tarhg{ cav atb`vtbeg ~`ek`cpi ~pv~a{`{5>'

Evthki` HS afihl` {tet`{ ta teo` egx g`k`{{evxj`e{pv`{ ta ~vabhfht egd ~v`s`gt ~vaihc`vethagac fhaialhkei |`e~ag{) |htbhg _tb`hvZ t`vvhtavx)pgd`v _tb`hvZ mpvh{dhkthag av pgd`v _tb`hvZ kagtvaiegx|b`v`) |bhkb hj~ih`{ i`lh{iethag egd v`lpie*thag "ta lhs` `cc`kt ta ~vabhfhthag{() fpt ei{aatb`v j`e{pv`{ {pkb e{ gethagei ~aihkh`{) ~bx{h*

kei ~vat`kthag ekthshth`{) tvehghgl ac ~`v{agg`iegd ie| `gcavk`j`gt' Tb` {ka~` ac {pkb gethageij`e{pv`{ ki`evix hgt`gd{ ta kas`v {tet`{ e{ |`iie{ {pfgethagei ektav{' Ba|`s`v) lv`et dh{~evhth`{{thii kbevekt`vh}` tb` hj~i`j`gtethag ac tb`{`afihlethag{) e {htpethag tbet tb` {p~~i`j`gtevx{`t ac afihlethag{ hg PG[K V`{aipthag 504> be{gat f``g efi` ta ej`ihavet` lhs`g ht{ ~etkbx `c*c`ktpethag egd tb` g``d ta `dpket` egd `glel`F\K gag*[tet`{ ^evth`{ hg F\ gag*~vaihc`vethagdh{kapv{`' Edjhtt`dix) ieko ac F\K pghs`v{eihtxg`leths`ix ecc`kt{ tb` upeihteths` egd upegthte*

ths` getpv` ac F\*v`i`segt ie|{ |avid|hd`' Tbh{h{ e kep{` cav kagk`vg) f`kep{` jegx kaj~egh`{hgsais`d hg fhat`kbgaialx v`{`evkb egd DGE{xgtb`{h{ a~`vet` hg kapgtvh`{ tbet ev` gat ~evtxta tb` F\K av bes` e i`{{ tbeg {eth{cektavx i`lh{*ieths` egd v`lpietavx cvej`|avo'

Gethagei hj~i`j`gtethag tveg{~a{`{ tb` chv{tcapv evthki`{ ac tb` F\K hgta tb` gethagei i`lh{ie*ths` egd v`lpietavx cvej`|avo{ egd cekhihtet`{atb`v afihlethag{) {pkb e{ hgt`vgethagei kaa~`ve*thag egd e{{h{tegk` hg tb` `s`gt ac F\ p{`

"Evthki` SHH( egd tb` kaiiethag egd {pfjh{{hag achgcavjethag pgd`v tb` KFJ dete*`rkbegl`j`kbegh{j Tb` j`e{pv`{ {``o ta ~`geih}` ~va*bhfht`d ekthshth`{) `{tefih{b v`uphv`j`gt{ ta kag*tvai tb` tveg{c`v "hj~avt) `r~avt) tveg{ht egdtveg{{bh~j`gt( ac dpei*p{` fhaialhkei jet`vhei{egd t`kbgaialh`{) e{ |`ii e{ {~`khcx v`uphv`j`gt{cav tb` {ec` egd {`kpv` begdihgl) tveg{~avtethagegd p{` ac ~evthkpievix degl`vap{ fhaialhkeiel`gt{ egd tarhg{) egd `{tefih{b ~`v{agg`i v`ih*efhihtx kb`ko{ ta v`dpk` {pfgethagei tbv`et{'[pkb fha{`kpvhtx i`lh{iethag ~vhjevhix v`lpiet`{

ke~efhihth`{ dp` ta tb` t`kbghkei dhcchkpith`{ hgd`t`vjhghgl hgt`gt |b`g dpei*p{` fhaialhkeiel`gt{) `uph~j`gt egd t`kbgaialh`{ ev` hg*sais`d' Ba|`s`v) {aj` kapgtvh`{ bes` kvhjhgei*h}`d {tet`j`gt ac t`vvavh{t hgt`gt) hgkht`j`gt)v`kvphtj`gt) av tvehghgl) e{ |`ii e{ ac chgegkhglt`vvavh{j) hgkipdhgl fhaialhkei t`vvavh{j55' [tet`{jex ei{a `{tefih{b {tvhkt ihefhihtx acc`gk`{ cav tb`~a{{`{{hag ac k`vtehg degl`vap{ ~etbal`g{ egdtarhg{ |htbapt eptbavh}ethag) cav |bhkb hgt`gtg``d gat f` ~vas`d' Tb` p{` ac tb` hgt`vg`t e{ ej`eg{ ac ~va~elegde) cav {~v`edhgl bet`

{~``kb`{) kajjpghkethgl) {bevhgl oga|i`dl` avveh{hgl cpgd{ ~a{`{ g`| tx~`{ ac kbeii`gl`{) egdhghtheths`{ ta `htb`v {bpt da|g av jaghtav |`f*{ht`{ ac ~evthkpiev kagk`vg bes` f``g iepgkb`d56'

8/2/2019 How to address the subnational actor threat and effective national participation in the biological non-proliferation re

5/9

0

[tet`{ ^evth`{ keg p{`cpiix `gbegk` gethagei egdkaii`kths` ~vak`dpv`{ ta v`sh`| tb` `cc`kths`g`{{ac tb`hv gethagei j`e{pv`{ ta hj~i`j`gt tb`Kags`gthag) cav `rej~i` fx d`{hlgethgl e ge*thagei el`gkx |htb F\K hj~i`j`gtethag egd`gcavk`j`gt v`{~ag{hfhihth`{ egd dh{kp{{hgl ge*thagei hj~i`j`gtethag h{{p`{ eggpeiix dpvhgl

tb` hgt`v{`{{hagei ~vak`{{' @{tefih{bhgl e ge*thagei F\K cakei ~ahgt) e{ v`kajj`gd`d fx tb`[hrtb V`sh`| Kagc`v`gk`) |hii ei{a hj~vas` hg*t`vekthag f`t|``g [tet`{ ^evth`{ egd ejagl tb`|hd`v F\K g`t|avo) ta ~vajat` hj~vas`d ge*thagei hj~i`j`gtethag egd ta cekhihtet` hj~i`*j`gtethag e{{h{tegk`' Tb` F\K Hj~i`j`gtethag[p~~avt Pght "H[P( be{ hghthet`d aptv`ekb ekthsh*th`{) hgkipdhgl pthih}hgl `i`ktvaghk j`dhe cav ka{t`cchkh`gkh`{) fpt tb` gethagei cakei ~ahgt{ |hiibes` e kvpkhei vai` hg teohgl tb` F\K apt ac L`*g`se) tb` iakp{ ac ht{ hgt`v{`{{hagei egd v`sh`|

kagc`v`gk` j``thgl{) ta [tet` ke~htei{ egd v`*lhagei bpf{ cav aglahgl) d`tehi`d dh{kp{{hag aghj~i`j`gtethag h{{p`{) hgkipdhgl v`lhagei e~*~vaekb`{ egd bevjagh}ethag) egd e{{h{tegk`~vash{hag' Khshi {akh`tx lvap~{ ev` |`ii*~iek`d tab`i~ fvhdl` tb` l`alve~bhk le~ f`t|``g L`g`seegd [tet` ke~htei{ egd tb` kajjpghkethagdh{kapv{` le~ f`t|``g acchkhei{ egd atb`v F\K{teo`baid`v lvap~{' Hg tbh{ |ex) {pfgethagei ek*tav{ ev` ei{a e g`k`{{evx ~evt ac tb` {aipthag tatb` jad`vg F\ ~vaihc`vethag kbeii`gl`{'

E gpjf`v ac gag*las`vgj`gtei avlegh}ethag{egd eked`jhk lvap~{ ev` ekths`ix `glel`d |htb[tet`{ ^evth`{) tb` F\K H[P egd atb`v e{{h{tegk`kaavdhgetav{ hg ~vashdhgl ~vekthkei) t`kbghkei{p~~avt ekva{{ tb` gethagei hj~i`j`gtethag afih*lethag{ egd hg veh{hgl e|ev`g`{{ ac tb` vegl` achj~i`j`gtethag afihlethag{) v`{pithgl hg ~vadpk*ths` ka*a~`veths` evvegl`j`gt{' Cav `rej~i`)Fvedcavd Pghs`v{htx hg tb` Pght`d Ohgldaj kag*dpkt{ tvehghgl hg fha`tbhk{ egd be{ d`s`ia~`d ekaj~v`b`g{hs` `dpkethagei jadpi` ag fha{`kp*vhtx egd dpei*p{` h{{p`{5;' S@VTHK) e Iagdag*

fe{`d gag*las`vgj`gtei avlegh}ethag) ~vashd`{t`kbghkei i`lh{ieths` e{{h{tegk` cav F\K vethchke*thag egd ekk`{{hag egd dvecthgl hj~i`j`gthglie|{ egd v`lpiethag{' Ht be{ d`s`ia~`d e kaj~v`*b`g{hs` F\K i`lh{iethag taaioht kaj~vh{hgl {ej*~i` ekt{) v`lpietavx lphd`ihg`{ egd e vegl` ac cekt{b``t{ hg e vegl` ac ieglpel`{ egd ht jehgtehg{ ecv`` agihg` detefe{` ac F\*v`iet`d ie|{ e{ `r*`j~iev e~~vaekb`{ cav atb`v {tet`{ egd ta `g*begk` tveg{~ev`gkx as`v gethagei hj~i`j`gte*thag54' Ht{ ie|x`v{ bes` |avo`d |htb kapgtvh`{ hg`ekb l`alve~bhk v`lhag) et tb`hv v`up`{t) ta d`*

s`ia~ F\K hj~i`j`gthgl ie|{ egd kaa~`vet`d|htb hgt`vgethagei egd v`lhagei avlegh}ethag~evtg`v{ ta ~vajat` i`lh{ieths` afihlethag{ egd~vashd` e tehiav`d i`lh{ieths` e{{h{tegk` ~ekoel`'

S@VTHK{ t`kbghkei) ~vac`{{hagei egd kagchd`g*thei e~~vaekb be{ `e{`d ht{ hgt`lvethag hgta tb`F\K v`lhj` egd h{ e ~a{{hfi` jad`i cav cpvtb`vkaiiefaveths` ~evtg`v{bh~{ ta {tv`gltb`g F\Kv`lhj` d`s`ia~j`gt hg tb` cptpv`'

[tet`{ ^evth`{ bes` ekoga|i`dl`d tb` seip` ackhshi {akh`tx hgsais`j`gt hg tb` Kags`gthag{ a~*`vethag agix v`ieths`ix v`k`gtix) e{ `shd`gk`d fxhgshtethag{ ta ~evthkh~et` hg gethagei egd v`*lhagei F\K*v`iet`d |avo{ba~{) tb`hv hgkv`e{hglett`gdegk` et khshi {akh`tx {hd` `s`gt{ et F\Kj``thgl{ egd) ja{t gatefix) tb`hv ekk`~tegk` ackhshi {akh`tx fedl`*baid`v{ hg |avohgl {`{{hag{dpvhgl Kags`gthag j``thgl{ hg L`g`se) eg `r*~ihkht v`kalghthag tbet tb`x taa ev` ~evtg`v{ hgF\K hj~i`j`gtethag' Gat|htb{tegdhgl tb`{`~a{hths`) eif`ht hgkv`j`gtei d`s`ia~j`gt{) ed*dv`{{hgl tb` fhaialhkei tbv`et ~a{`d fx {pf*{tet`ektav{ |avid|hd` |hii v`uphv` {p{tehg`d i`s`i{ achgt`v`{t egd ~aihthkei `glel`j`gt hg tb` F\Kegd chgegkhei egd jet`vhei {p~~avt cav gethageihj~i`j`gtethag hg kapgtvh`{ {pcc`vhgl cvaj e~epkhtx ac ch{kei egd bpjeg v`{apvk`{ hg k`vtehgl`alve~bhk v`lhag{'

Kagk`~tpei kbeii`gl`{ cav tb` F\Khg eddv`{{hgl tb` {pfgethagei ektavtbv`etTb` F\K cek`{ e tv`j`gdap{ kbeii`gl` dp` ta

tb` dpei*p{` dhi`jje' Tb`v` ev` jegx i`lhth*jet` e~~ihkethag{ cav dpei*p{` fhaialhkei jet`vh*ei{ egd tb` dh{thgkthag f`t|``g ~vabhfht`d egdi`lhthjet` ekthshth`{ jex f` fipvv`d' Ht h{ cevjav` dhcchkpit ta kagtvai ~pv~a{`{ tbeg ta kagtvaiel`gt{ egd `uph~j`gt' Cpvtb`vjav`) fhat`vvav*h{j tbv`et e{{`{{j`gt ei{a hgsais`{ e{k`vtehghglke~efhihtx egd hgt`gt' E{{`{{hgl ke~efhihtx h{tb`av`thkeiix tb` `e{h`v ac fatb e{ baidhgl{ acdegl`vap{ ~etbal`g{) ~a{{`{{hag ac kvhthkei`uph~j`gt egd ~`v{agg`i |htb v`uphv`d oga|i*`dl` egd `r~`vth{` keg f` afm`kths`ix `{tef*

ih{b`d' Hg ~vekthk`) ba|`s`v) ht ~a{`{ {hlghchkegtbpvdi`{ f`kep{` jehgtehghgl d`tehi`d as`v{hlbtas`v el`gt kaii`kthag{ egd ekk`{{ ta tb`j h{ `r*tv`j`ix dhcchkpit egd) et e gethagei i`s`i) d`~`gd*`gt ag tb` vhlavap{ `gcavk`j`gt ac e vegl` acfha{ec`tx egd fha{`kpvhtx j`e{pv`{' E{{`{{hgltb` "jeihkhap{( hgt`gt ac {pfgethagei ektav{ h{{pf{tegtheiix jav` kaj~i`r' Gag*ka`vkhs` e~*~vaekb`{ d`s`ia~`d elehg{t t`vvavh{j {``o taf`tt`v pgd`v{tegd jathsethag egd hgt`gthag hgavd`v ta d`sh{` `cc`kths` ~aihkh`{ egd ~vekthk`{cav ~v`s`gthag) cav `rej~i`) fx j`eg{ ac d`*

vedhkeih}ethag ~valvej{50' Tb`x v`ix hg ~evt ag edheialp` p{hgl hd`aialhkei egd tb`aialhkei evlp*j`gt{) |htb tb` afm`kths` ac d`*i`lhthjh}hgl tb`p{` ac shai`gk` egd kapgt`vhgl `rtv`jh{t hd`aia*

8/2/2019 How to address the subnational actor threat and effective national participation in the biological non-proliferation re

6/9

3

lh`{53' \bhi` tb`x da gat cakp{ ag j`eg{ ac et*teko t`vvavh{t{ bes` av |apid bes` p{`d) {aj`evlpj`gt{ elehg{t fhat`vvavh{j kapid d`vhs` dh*v`ktix cvaj tb` {~`khchk getpv` ac fhaialhkei|`e~ag{' Ba|`s`v tb` F\K h{ gat tb` v`i`segtcvej`|avo ta d`s`ia~ {pkb ~valvej{'

\`{t`vg {tet`{ sh`|`d tb` tvedhthagei e~~vaekbta gag*~vaihc`vethag e{ taa gevva|) lhs`g tb`dpei*p{` dhj`g{hag ac tb` el`gt{ egd `uph~j`gthg v`iethag ta tb` {pfgethagei ektav{ tbv`et) egdtb`x d`sh{`d e jad`i v`ixhgl ag e g`t|avo acj`e{pv`{5 tevl`t{ tb`t`vvavh{t tbv`et ja{t {~`khchkeiix'

Tb` PG [`kpvhtx Kapgkhi eda~t`d V`{aipthag504> ag E~vhi 62) 6>>4) pgd`v Kbe~t`v SHH ac tb`Pght`d Gethag{ Kbevt`v egd `rt`gd`d tb` jeg*det` ac ht{ jaghtavhgl fadx) tb` 504> Kajjht*t``) cav chr`d ~`vhad{ tbvaplb V`{aipthag{ 53>2( egd 58 |b`g ht v`kalgh}`d tb` kagtvhfpthag ac cpiiegd `cc`kths` hj~i`j`gtethag ac Pght`d Gethag{[`kpvhtx Kapgkhi V`{aipthag 504> fx eii {tet`{ tae{{h{t hg ekbh`shgl tb` afm`kths`{ ac tbh{ Kags`g*thag58) |bhi` tb` V`{aipthag ~vajat`{ tb` pgh*s`v{ei eda~thag egd cpii hj~i`j`gtethag) egd)

|b`v` g`k`{{evx) {tv`gltb`ghgl ac jpithiet`veitv`eth`{ ta |bhkb tb`x ev` ~evth`{6>' Ht h{ tbp{g`k`{{evx ta `g{pv` kaa~`vethag egd kaavdhge*thag f`t|``g tb` t|a hgt`vgethagei i`lei hg{tvp*j`gt{) e{ tb`x fatb {p~~avt ke~ekhtx*fphidhgl)kagtvhfpt` ta `dpkethag egd e|ev`g`{{*veh{hgltbvaplb aptv`ekb ekthshth`{ egd v`uphv` egeia*lap{ i`lh{ieths` d`s`ia~j`gt'

Eg eit`vgeths` e~~vaekb kag{hd`v{ vh{o jegel`*j`gt ~vhgkh~i`{ ta kapgt`v tb` tbv`et ~a{`d fxgag*{tet` ektav{ evj`d |htb F\' Tb` 6>>8 P[Gethagei [tvet`lx cav Kapgt`vhgl FhaialhkeiTbv`et) cav `rej~i`) {tet`{ tbet e kaj~v`b`g*{hs` egd hgt`lvet`d e~~vaekb h{ g``d`d ta ~v`*s`gt tb` cpii {~`ktvpj ac fhaialhkei tbv`et{ e{ekthag{ |hii sevx hg tb`hv `cc`kths`g`{{ elehg{t{~`khchk tbv`et65' V`levdhgl dh{`e{` {pvs`hiiegk`)d`t`kthag) dhelga{h{ egd kagtehgj`gt) tb` ~ev*th`{ ta tb` F\K kag{hd`v`d dpvhgl tb` 6>>55 hgt`v{`{{hagei ~vak`{{ tb` kagtvhfpthag achgt`vgethagei avlegh}ethag{ {pkb e{ tb` \avidB`eitb Avlegh}ethag "\BA() tb` Caad egd Elvh*kpitpv` Avlegh}ethag "CEA() egd tb` \avid Av*

legh{ethag cav Eghjei B`eitb "AH@( ta `gbegkhgltb` ~vabhfhthag elehg{t F\ egd tbv`et ~v`s`g*thag' \bhi` tb` dex*ta*dex ekthshth`{ ac tb`{` av*legh}ethag{ ev` ~`vh~b`vei ta tb` F\K) tb`hvliafei `ccavt{ et ke~ekhtx*fphidhgl hg dh{`e{` ~v`*s`gthag ev` v`i`segt hc tb` vegl` ac fhaialhkeiaptfv`eo{ cvaj getpvei dh{`e{` ta d`ihf`vet` v`*i`e{` ac ~etbal`g{ h{ kag{hd`v`d e{ e {hgli` vh{o{~`ktvpj' Hg tbh{ v`levd) tb` Hgt`vgethageiB`eitb V`lpiethag{ "HBV 6>>0() i`lei elv``j`gtfhgdhgl 584 kapgtvh`{) hgkipdhgl eii 58; j`jf`v{tet`{ ac tb` \BA ~ip{ tb` Baix [``66) d`chg`{

kav` ke~ekhtx v`uphv`j`gt{ cav {pvs`hiiegk` egdv`{~ag{` egd v`uphv`{ gathchkethag ac eii ~pfihkb`eitb `s`gt{ |bhkb jex kag{thtpt` e ~pfihkb`eitb j`vl`gkx ac hgt`vgethagei kagk`vg'

^v`{`gtix tb` `gbegk`j`gt ac dh{`e{` {pvs`hi*iegk` j`kbegh{j{ egd v`{~ag{` ke~ekhtx ta ed*dv`{{ hgc`kthap{ dh{`e{`{ aptfv`eo{ ei{a dvhs` tb`d`fet` efapt Evthki` R ac tb` Kags`gthag' Cavjegx d`ked`{ tbh{ evthki` v`~v`{`gt`d e cepit ihg`f`t|``g tb` hgdp{tvheih}`d) |ba `j~be{h}`d dh{*evjej`gt egd gag*~vaihc`vethag "e{ kagtehg`dhg Evthki`{ H egd HHH() egd jegx d`s`ia~hgl kapg*

tvh`{) |ba |egt`d ta {`` tb` d`s`ia~j`gt ~vaj*h{` cpichii`d' Ht {th~piet`{ tbet j`jf`v {tet`{) hg*t`v eihe) bes` ta cekhihtet` egd bes` tb` vhlbt ta~evthkh~et` hg) tb` cpii`{t `rkbegl` ac `uph~j`gt)

8/2/2019 How to address the subnational actor threat and effective national participation in the biological non-proliferation re

7/9

5>() ~~' 63>>3' ~ 2'

6>' ^evelve~b 2' V`{aipthag "504>( eda~t`d fx tb` [`kpvhtxKapgkhi et ht{ 4803tb j``thgl) ag 62 E~vhi 6>>4' [!V@[!504> "6>>4('

65' Gethagei [tvet`lx cav kapgt`vhgl fhaialhkei tbv`et{"Gas`jf`v 6>>8() ~' ;'

bt t ~=!!|||' |bht `bap { `' las!{ h t `{!d`ce p i t ! c h i `{ !GethageiQ[tvet`lxQcavQKapgt`vhglQFhaTbv`et{'~dc

66' [tet` ^evth`{ ta tb` Hgt`vgethagei B`eitb V`lpiethag{"6>>0('

btt~=!!|||'|ba'hgt!hbv!i`leiQh{{p`{!{tet`{Q~evth`{!`g!

hgd`r'btji6;' Ohvo Feg{eo) H{{p`{ D`s`ia~ e{ F\K V`sh`| E~*~vaekb`{)Evj{ Kagtvai Tadex "Megpevx ! C`fvpevx 6>55('

64' Kbvh{theg @g`jevo) Tb` Vai` ac tb` Fhaialhkei \`e~*ag{ Kags`gthag hg Dh{`e{` [pvs`hiiegk` egd V`{~ag{`)

B`eitb ^aihkx egd iegghgl 60 "6>5>() ~' 423'

60' Levx Fpvg{) Oev`g Fx`v{) T`ko J`eg Kbpe) B`etb`v[b``i`x egd Fved Lafi`) Fha{ec`tx ~vac`{{hagei{ e{ {teo`*baid`v{ hg tb` FT\K) Dh{evjej`gt Cavpj 5 "6>55() ~~' 655() ~~ 5;;*5455() ~~' 06>8*5555'

2' [kh`gk`) Ie| @gcavk`j`gt Fphid Fvhdl`{) [kh`gk` ;;>"6>5>(' ' 5' Capvtb V`sh`| Kagc`v`gk` ac tb` [tet`{ ^evth`{ ta tb`

Kags`gthag ag tb` ^vabhfhthag ac tb` D`s`ia~j`gt) ^va*dpkthag egd [tako~hihgl ac Fekt`vhaialhkei "Fhaialhkei(egd Tarhg \`e~ag{ egd ag Tb`hv D`{tvpkthag= ChgeiDakpj`gt "F\K!KAGC'S!5>6'

55' Ei`k \ei`g) Kvhjhgeih}hgl [tet`j`gt{ ac T`vvavh{tHgt`gt= Ba| ta Pgd`v{tegd tb` Ie| Las`vghgl T`vvavh{tTbv`et{) egd \bx ht [bapid f` P{`d hg{t`ed ac Iagl*T`vj ^v`s`gths` D`t`gthag) Mapvgei ac Kvhjhgei Ie|egd Kvhjhgaialx "6>55) cavtbkajhgl('

56' KTHTC \avohgl Lvap~ ag Vedhkeih{ethag egd @rtv`j*h{j tbet I`ed ta T`vvavh{j) Chv{t V`~avt ac tb` \avohglLvap~ ag Vedhkeih}ethag egd `rtv`jh{j tbet i`ed ta t`v*vavh{j= Hgs`gtavx ac [tet` ~valvejj`{) 6>>2'

5;' Fvedcavd Dh{evjej`gt V`{`evkb K`gtv`) FvedcavdPghs`v{htx) Pght`d Ohgldaj @dpkethagei V`{apvk` Jad*pi`'

54' S`vhchkethag V`{`evkb) Tvehghgl egd Hgcavjethag K`g*tv` "S@VTHK() F\K Gethagei Hj~i`j`gthgl J`e{pv`{Detefe{`) |||'s`vthk'avl' S@VTHK ei{a ~vashd`{ i`lh{ie*

Gat`{

V`tvaps`} tapt` iektpeiht `t i`{ ~pfihkethag{ d` ie Cagdethag ~apv ie V`kb`vkb` [tvetlhup` {pv =

\ \ \ ' C V [ T V E T @ L H @ ' A V L

http://www.who.int/ihr/legal_issues/states_parties/en/index.htmlhttp://www.who.int/ihr/legal_issues/states_parties/en/index.htmlhttp://www.vertic.org/http://www.vertic.org/http://www.frstrategie.org/http://www.frstrategie.org/http://www.frstrategie.org/http://www.frstrategie.org/http://www.frstrategie.org/http://www.frstrategie.org/http://www.vertic.org/http://www.who.int/ihr/legal_issues/states_parties/en/index.htmlhttp://www.who.int/ihr/legal_issues/states_parties/en/index.htmlhttp://www.who.int/ihr/legal_issues/states_parties/en/index.htmlhttp://www.who.int/ihr/legal_issues/states_parties/en/index.html